Latest / Bloomberg Law / SBF, Trump Immunity, Google Loss & Clean Beauty
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:11Speaker 2: I've been gathering the greatest hunters across all realities, and
- 0:14Speaker 2: I started with the best cost a lot of credits
- 0:18Speaker 2: to convince Mando.
- 0:19Speaker 1: But this is the way.
- 0:23Speaker 2: The plan, pure chaos and no one will sew it
- 0:26Speaker 2: better than them.
- 0:29Speaker 3: Fortnite is an online video game where players collaborate to
- 0:33Speaker 3: survive in an open world environment, and the winner is
- 0:37Speaker 3: really Epic Games, which makes billions of dollars every year
- 0:40Speaker 3: from it. And this week Epic won its years long
- 0:44Speaker 3: real world battle with Google over its app store, where
- 0:47Speaker 3: it charges companies' fees when users make purchases.
- 0:51Speaker 4: For games like Fortnite.
- 0:53Speaker 3: In a major blow to the tech giant, a San
- 0:55Speaker 3: Francisco jury found that Google's app store constitutes an illegal
- 1:00Speaker 3: monopoly in violation of the anti trust laws. Google is
- 1:04Speaker 3: vowing to appeal. Joining me is anti trust expert Harry First,
- 1:09Speaker 3: a professor at NYU Law School.
- 1:12Speaker 4: What did the jury decide exactly?
- 1:14Speaker 3: Here?
- 1:15Speaker 5: So, the jury decided basically that in a number of
- 1:19Speaker 5: different ways, Google abused its power to keep its monopoly
- 1:24Speaker 5: in the Google app stores or the distribution of Google
- 1:30Speaker 5: apps and that they did a number of different ways,
- 1:33Speaker 5: Agreements with the handset makers, agreements with developers, you know,
- 1:38Speaker 5: making sure that Google Play appears on every Android phone,
- 1:43Speaker 5: keeping developers from going off and developing their own app stores,
- 1:48Speaker 5: and basically requiring everyone to sort of go through this funnel.
- 1:52Speaker 6: You know.
- 1:52Speaker 5: It's sort of like the old hourglasses. You know, it
- 1:55Speaker 5: goes down into the middle and everything goes through. Google
- 2:00Speaker 5: will play if you want to reach someone with an
- 2:01Speaker 5: Android phone in their hands. So those little grains of sand,
- 2:06Speaker 5: thirty percent of them go into Google's pocket.
- 2:09Speaker 3: Yes, those are the commissions as high as thirty percent
- 2:12Speaker 3: that Google takes from software developers. The jury deliberated for
- 2:16Speaker 3: a little over three hours after a month long trial,
- 2:20Speaker 3: and came back with the unanimous verdict.
- 2:22Speaker 4: Was the evidence against Google. That's strong.
- 2:25Speaker 5: Jurors take these cases very seriously. Jurors pay attention. They
- 2:30Speaker 5: sit there and they listen hard. This is new to
- 2:34Speaker 5: them in a sense. I mean maybe some of them
- 2:37Speaker 5: have played video games on their phone, but they listen hard.
- 2:41Speaker 5: And I took a look at the sheep with their findings,
- 2:44Speaker 5: and it said, you're supposed to define what the market is,
- 2:48Speaker 5: and instead of the sheet having a list of things
- 2:52Speaker 5: with a checkbox. You know what it might be. It
- 2:54Speaker 5: just had a box and you had to write it in.
- 2:56Speaker 5: So they wrote in the exact right product market definition
- 3:00Speaker 5: that the plaintiffs wanted. And to me, it's sort of
- 3:03Speaker 5: a little tell that they're paying attention. I mean, this
- 3:07Speaker 5: is a little bit technical language, and they were paying
- 3:10Speaker 5: attention to what was going on. There were atmospherics in
- 3:13Speaker 5: the case, of course, there always are, you know, testimony
- 3:17Speaker 5: of how apparently Google made an offer to Epic to
- 3:23Speaker 5: come back on board, We'll give you a lot of money.
- 3:26Speaker 5: There was some question about how Google was dealing with
- 3:29Speaker 5: its internal chats and whether they were trying to, you know,
- 3:33Speaker 5: erase the evidence as they were making it. So those
- 3:36Speaker 5: may have played a role. But I think that's a
- 3:38Speaker 5: real indication of non technical experts saying, Okay, we understand
- 3:45Speaker 5: what power is. You know what a monopoly is. We're
- 3:49Speaker 5: not economists, but we can understand this evidence.
- 3:52Speaker 3: And Google's it Epic, which seems to be on a mission,
- 3:57Speaker 3: lost a similar challenge to Apple's Appstor two years ago,
- 4:01Speaker 3: and both companies have asked the Supreme Court to review that.
- 4:04Speaker 3: Does the judges verdict there contradict the jury's verdict here,
- 4:08Speaker 3: or are the cases and the facts different.
- 4:12Speaker 5: Yes, maybe or maybe yes. It depends, So you're doing.
- 4:17Speaker 4: It again, Harry, you got me in one of those.
- 4:20Speaker 6: I mean, this.
- 4:21Speaker 5: Certainly is going to be one of Google's arguments when
- 4:24Speaker 5: Google appeals this case to the Court of Appeals in
- 4:26Speaker 5: the Ninth Circuit, saying, you know, you just affirmed this
- 4:30Speaker 5: decision finding a very different statement of what the product
- 4:34Speaker 5: market is, finding that Apple and Google compete in the
- 4:39Speaker 5: distribution of gaming apps, and you were right in the
- 4:44Speaker 5: Apple case, and this case can't stand. The jury made
- 4:48Speaker 5: an error of law, you know, reflected no doubt the
- 4:51Speaker 5: instructions that it was given, and the verdict can't stand.
- 4:55Speaker 5: So I think that's going to be a key part.
- 4:57Speaker 5: Now what did I say? Maybe yes, yes, maybe. Epic
- 5:02Speaker 5: is still arguing, of course that the judge was wrong
- 5:04Speaker 5: in the Apple case, but putting that to the side,
- 5:07Speaker 5: we'll argue there's differences between what Google's doing and what
- 5:11Speaker 5: Apple's doing, and the product market definition is different because
- 5:16Speaker 5: other companies actually do distribute Android compatible applications, so it's
- 5:23Speaker 5: not a product market definition constructed for one seller as
- 5:27Speaker 5: it seems for Apple, since no one else can distribute
- 5:31Speaker 5: applications that will work with the Apple operating system because
- 5:35Speaker 5: Apple controls that, but Google doesn't quite control Android in
- 5:40Speaker 5: the same way, although there are probably arguments over that.
- 5:43Speaker 5: So they'll try to distinguish the facts of the case
- 5:46Speaker 5: a little bit. But at heart it seems like a problem.
- 5:50Speaker 3: The case isn't over because the judge has to decide
- 5:53Speaker 3: what the remedy will be. Yet Epic didn't seek monetary
- 5:57Speaker 3: damages from Google, only a change in app store policies.
- 6:01Speaker 3: I mean, what's the range that the judge can order here?
- 6:05Speaker 5: Well, you're being more specific about what Epic seeking than
- 6:09Speaker 5: Epic was in its complaint. The remedy was stated very
- 6:14Speaker 5: generally about adjunctive relief. So it's not one hundred percent
- 6:18Speaker 5: clear what Epic wants, except to say that apparently whatever
- 6:24Speaker 5: match was offered Match dot Com was offered and agreed
- 6:27Speaker 5: to in its settlement. Presumably Google would have been glad
- 6:31Speaker 5: for Epic to take the same settlement it didn't, so
- 6:36Speaker 5: presumably it wants more than just that. Now, I'm not
- 6:41Speaker 5: one hundred percent clear about exactly what it wants, except
- 6:45Speaker 5: it certainly wants to be able to free itself from
- 6:49Speaker 5: the Google payment system. It wants to be able to
- 6:51Speaker 5: sell things in Fortnite through its own Fortnite app and
- 6:56Speaker 5: not have to pay a commission to Google. But exactly
- 7:00Speaker 5: how they want to achieve that technically, they don't seem
- 7:04Speaker 5: to want to have some sort of a choice thing
- 7:06Speaker 5: that's within Google's control. So it's not one hundred percent clear,
- 7:12Speaker 5: But I would say this Epic did not invest so
- 7:15Speaker 5: much money in this litigation without thinking that it could
- 7:19Speaker 5: get something worth more. So whatever it wants, they must
- 7:23Speaker 5: think it will be worth a lot of money to
- 7:25Speaker 5: them going forward. Because Fortnite's big business, some.
- 7:29Speaker 3: Analysts have been saying that the business model in apps
- 7:33Speaker 3: that generates for Google and Apple close to two hundred
- 7:37Speaker 3: billion dollars a year is in jeopardy. Jim Sweeney, the
- 7:40Speaker 3: chief executive officer of Epic, said, the dominoes are going
- 7:44Speaker 3: to start falling here. The end of thirty percent is
- 7:47Speaker 3: in sight.
- 7:48Speaker 4: Do you think it's as big as all that?
- 7:50Speaker 5: Well? Maybe, I mean it's certainly Epic wants to argue
- 7:55Speaker 5: that your business is about to end. You know, this
- 7:58Speaker 5: may just be a dance towards the settlement. Hard to say,
- 8:01Speaker 5: but you know, whatever it is. Apple and Google have
- 8:05Speaker 5: already moderated some of their pricing for smaller developers, but
- 8:09Speaker 5: the big money appears to be particularly with the games,
- 8:12Speaker 5: which offers subscriptions and things that can be bought within
- 8:15Speaker 5: the app itself, and there's a lot of money in that.
- 8:18Speaker 5: So no doubt that's thirty percent is going to stick.
- 8:21Speaker 5: But what it's going to be and who's going to
- 8:24Speaker 5: control the payment I don't know. And part of the
- 8:26Speaker 5: question is is this a settlement that's only sort of
- 8:29Speaker 5: a one off for them or is it going to
- 8:33Speaker 5: help other developers? And I guess that's yet to be seen.
- 8:37Speaker 3: Google is defending two other anti trust cases by the
- 8:40Speaker 3: Justice Department, one in DC over its search engine and
- 8:43Speaker 3: another in Virginia over its ad tech business, and the
- 8:47Speaker 3: Justice Department has been investigating Apple's app store practices since
- 8:52Speaker 3: around twenty nineteen. So is it like an antitrust revolution
- 8:57Speaker 3: against big tech? Looking at it from the viewpoint of
- 9:01Speaker 3: a professor of antitrust.
- 9:03Speaker 5: Well, from professor of antitrust, I think, gee, what took
- 9:08Speaker 5: everyone so long catched up?
- 9:10Speaker 6: You know?
- 9:10Speaker 5: If you think about using anti trust against major economic powerhouses,
- 9:14Speaker 5: and particularly in the tech space, it took two decades
- 9:18Speaker 5: between Microsoft and filing cases against the major tech platforms.
- 9:23Speaker 5: So in that sense, it's a revolution not taking place
- 9:27Speaker 5: in the streets, it's taking place in courtrooms. So it's
- 9:32Speaker 5: pretty amazing in that sense. And the ad tech case
- 9:36Speaker 5: against Google that will also be tried before a jury
- 9:39Speaker 5: because the Justice Department is asking for money damages because
- 9:44Speaker 5: the federal government is an advertiser. So it's a way
- 9:47Speaker 5: both to get money back for taxpayers, but also a
- 9:52Speaker 5: way to have a case try before a jury instead
- 9:55Speaker 5: of a judge. And this may be a little cautionary
- 9:58Speaker 5: tale for Google.
- 9:59Speaker 3: About that sort of a test of whether a jury
- 10:02Speaker 3: makes a difference rather than a judge. Thanks so much, Harry.
- 10:05Speaker 3: That's Professor Harry First of NYU Law School. This is Bloomberg.
- 10:12Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 10:19Speaker 7: Look, I screwed up, like I would CEO. I had
- 10:22Speaker 7: a responsibility here. I had a responsibility to be on
- 10:25Speaker 7: top of what was going on on the exchange. I
- 10:29Speaker 7: wish I had done much better at that.
- 10:31Speaker 3: Sam Bankman Freed accepted responsibility for ftx's collapse in his
- 10:36Speaker 3: so called apology tour after its bankruptcy in November of
- 10:40Speaker 3: twenty twenty two. But fast forward to a year later
- 10:43Speaker 3: when he took the stand at his front trial, and
- 10:45Speaker 3: it was a completely different story. Bankman Freed danced around
- 10:49Speaker 3: the questions and appeared vague and evasive in a painstaking
- 10:53Speaker 3: cross examination, so much so that his own lawyer says
- 10:57Speaker 3: he was the worst witness he's ever seen. Joining me
- 11:01Speaker 3: is Bloomberg Legal reporter Ava Benni Morrison, who spoke to
- 11:04Speaker 3: attorney David Mills behind the scenes. Architect of Bankman Freed's
- 11:08Speaker 3: defense at trial, Ava tell us about David Mills, who
- 11:12Speaker 3: is he for.
- 11:13Speaker 8: David Mills is a Stamford law professor, a longtime White
- 11:18Speaker 8: Cole lawyer who is also best friends with Sam Bateman,
- 11:20Speaker 8: Fred's parents, Barbara and Joe. They're also Stanford Lall professors,
- 11:25Speaker 8: and he came into SBF case to be the legal strategist,
- 11:30Speaker 8: though he was sort of directing the approach that trial
- 11:32Speaker 8: attorney should take, suggesting different strategies in terms of dealing
- 11:36Speaker 8: with the chargers, the defense, the kind of case that
- 11:38Speaker 8: they would make at the trial.
- 11:40Speaker 4: Law isn't his only career. He has quite an expansive resume.
- 11:45Speaker 3: The's riot.
- 11:45Speaker 8: He's a very interesting guy. On top of being an attorney,
- 11:49Speaker 8: he's also a managing director at Fortress. He's also a
- 11:52Speaker 8: general counsel at a quite reputable Silicon Valley design firm
- 11:57Speaker 8: run by the very well known former chief designer Apple,
- 12:00Speaker 8: Johnny Ives. He's also been advisor to the VC firm Benchmark,
- 12:05Speaker 8: when it was trying to out the Uber CEO Travis
- 12:09Speaker 8: Kalenick a few years ago. So he has his things
- 12:13Speaker 8: in a lot of different pies, but he is relatively unknown.
- 12:16Speaker 8: Most people outside of the industry don't really know who
- 12:19Speaker 8: he is. People that I spoke to for this story
- 12:21Speaker 8: that he's very humble. He likes to keep his head
- 12:23Speaker 8: down and just do the work. He doesn't really seek
- 12:25Speaker 8: the limeline at all.
- 12:27Speaker 3: And he's done very well, although he won't talk about
- 12:29Speaker 3: just how well. He donated at least ten million dollars
- 12:33Speaker 3: to stand for law school, millions more to the NAACP
- 12:36Speaker 3: Legal Defense Fund, and when SBF was jailed in the Bahamas,
- 12:40Speaker 3: he flew there on his own private jet.
- 12:42Speaker 4: But he's also been involved in a lot of pro.
- 12:45Speaker 3: Bono efforts for criminal defendants, and when you interviewed him,
- 12:49Speaker 3: he had a cap on with the number three, four,
- 12:51Speaker 3: one nine representing the number of people he's helped to
- 12:55Speaker 3: get out of prison.
- 12:56Speaker 8: This is something he's probably most proud of. Was a
- 13:00Speaker 8: major financial backer and driver of the effort to overturn
- 13:04Speaker 8: California's three strikes law. That was a law that put
- 13:08Speaker 8: people in prison for life on their third conviction, no
- 13:10Speaker 8: matter how big or small that third conviction was. So
- 13:13Speaker 8: he worked with students at Stanford Law in twenty twelve
- 13:18Speaker 8: to change that law, which ended up getting thousands of
- 13:20Speaker 8: people released from prison.
- 13:22Speaker 3: He told you that he realized right away that it
- 13:26Speaker 3: would be an uphill battle defending bankman freed because lawyers
- 13:31Speaker 3: turned him down.
- 13:32Speaker 8: He'd had a bit of an idea about FTX from
- 13:36Speaker 8: Joe's and Beamon Fred's barber. They had informal conversations about
- 13:40Speaker 8: how the crypto exchange was going. Joe thinking about going
- 13:44Speaker 8: over and working for FDx full time, but when there
- 13:47Speaker 8: was a run of a bank at FTX in November
- 13:51Speaker 8: twenty twenty two, so called David essentially for advice. David's
- 13:55Speaker 8: response was, Sam needs a lawyer right away. So David
- 13:59Speaker 8: started calling around on different firms looking for someone to
- 14:02Speaker 8: try and represent Sam Bankman Freeze, but he said a
- 14:05Speaker 8: lot of people didn't want to touch the case. He
- 14:06Speaker 8: described Sam a most hated person in America behind Donald Trump.
- 14:11Speaker 8: He finally set it on two trial attorneys in New York,
- 14:14Speaker 8: Mark Cohen and Christian Evidel, who ended up taking the
- 14:17Speaker 8: case right through a trial.
- 14:18Speaker 3: He doesn't believe the trial was fair. Tell us why.
- 14:22Speaker 8: He said he believed that Sam is innocent because he
- 14:26Speaker 8: didn't form the intent to do anything wrong, which is
- 14:28Speaker 8: obviously a key element of proving fraud. He said that
- 14:33Speaker 8: the pre trial motions, though the orders that the judge
- 14:36Speaker 8: handed down before the trial even got started, really put
- 14:40Speaker 8: the defense at had disadvantaged. They weren't allowed to haul
- 14:43Speaker 8: a number of expert witnesses, so they couldn't really rely
- 14:46Speaker 8: on the defense that Sam was acting on the advice
- 14:49Speaker 8: of lawyers and doing a lot of the things that
- 14:51Speaker 8: the prosecution said was wrong. He said, from that point
- 14:54Speaker 8: on he realized the case was essentially unwinnable.
- 14:58Speaker 3: And you and I have discussed Sam bekman Fried's decision
- 15:01Speaker 3: to take the witness down. He said that after the
- 15:05Speaker 3: prosecution's case, SBF really had no choice but to testify.
- 15:11Speaker 8: He said, after those profile motions and hearing the damning
- 15:14Speaker 8: testimony from some of Sam mcman fried's former friends and
- 15:19Speaker 8: fellow executives that Sam really had no other choice but
- 15:22Speaker 8: to testify himself. Mill said it was his idea and
- 15:26Speaker 8: his strategy for Sam to get up there and say, yes,
- 15:30Speaker 8: I did everything that you said I did, and I
- 15:32Speaker 8: made all of these statements that yes, they were conflicting
- 15:36Speaker 8: after FTX Pubs bankruptcy last year, but I was doing
- 15:38Speaker 8: my best to look after customers and I was trying
- 15:41Speaker 8: to save their money. But he didn't do that. He
- 15:44Speaker 8: seemed to be okay and coherent and clear on direct examination,
- 15:48Speaker 8: but when he was under cross examination, he came across
- 15:52Speaker 8: as a little bit of basive. He was quibbling with
- 15:54Speaker 8: the prosecutors questioning. It seemed like he wouldn't answer sort
- 15:58Speaker 8: of simple questions about whether he says or he didn't.
- 16:01Speaker 8: And Mills was pretty candid in his assessment of Sam
- 16:04Speaker 8: under cross examination, saying he was probably the worst witness
- 16:08Speaker 8: he's ever seen under.
- 16:09Speaker 3: Cross I assume they prepped him, but did he talk
- 16:11Speaker 3: about how they prepped him at all?
- 16:13Speaker 8: I asked that question. I said, well, isn't it your
- 16:15Speaker 8: job to Sam ahead of his trial for this very situation.
- 16:21Speaker 8: He said that while there was a lot of preparation
- 16:23Speaker 8: done for his direct examination, it was really difficult to
- 16:27Speaker 8: prepare him adequately because he was in prison. His battle
- 16:31Speaker 8: was revoked just before trial. There were a lot of
- 16:34Speaker 8: issues around his lawyers getting proper access to him, and
- 16:37Speaker 8: Mill also said that if he had all of the
- 16:39Speaker 8: resources and money in the world, he would have hired
- 16:42Speaker 8: a different lawyer who wasn't involved in the case to
- 16:45Speaker 8: go through a mock cross examination with Sam, but they
- 16:47Speaker 8: didn't do that. So he put it down to the
- 16:50Speaker 8: lack of access to Sam in prison and the lack
- 16:53Speaker 8: of money.
- 16:54Speaker 3: Essentially, he told you that SBF went off script when
- 16:58Speaker 3: he took the stand.
- 17:00Speaker 4: What did he mean by that?
- 17:01Speaker 8: Mills said that it was his strategy and he wanted
- 17:04Speaker 8: Sam to get up there and admit to everything that
- 17:07Speaker 8: the prosecution and the witnesses said that he did. They
- 17:10Speaker 8: wanted him to just admit to all of the public
- 17:12Speaker 8: statements for the tweets and the media interviews and all
- 17:16Speaker 8: of those different things that were on the public record
- 17:18Speaker 8: in the context of yes, I said these things, but
- 17:21Speaker 8: I was trying the best in really difficult circumstances to
- 17:24Speaker 8: do the best for customers, but he didn't do that. Instead,
- 17:28Speaker 8: Sam got up there and said, time and time again,
- 17:31Speaker 8: he couldn't recall things that the prosecution said that he
- 17:34Speaker 8: had said that he couldn't recall certain conversations with witnesses.
- 17:38Speaker 8: So there was a disconnect there between what Mills wanted
- 17:42Speaker 8: him to do and what his strategy was and what
- 17:44Speaker 8: Sam did.
- 17:45Speaker 3: But Mills thinks that even if bankman Freed had performed
- 17:48Speaker 3: better on the stand, the jury still would have found
- 17:51Speaker 3: him guilty.
- 17:52Speaker 8: Yes, Mills said that he thought a guilty verdict was inevitable,
- 17:56Speaker 8: but the trial wasn't there. This circles back to Mills
- 18:00Speaker 8: referring to the pretrial motions that essentially whittled down the
- 18:04Speaker 8: defense case to a case that was very thin. He
- 18:07Speaker 8: also thought that the testimony from Sam Batemanfried's former friends
- 18:12Speaker 8: Gary Wong, Caroline Ellison, and the Shad Seeing were pretty
- 18:15Speaker 8: powerful and it was difficult to go up against those.
- 18:19Speaker 3: This really struck me, he said, I'm not going to
- 18:22Speaker 3: get myself emotionally involved on a very deep personal level
- 18:25Speaker 3: in a case like this again, And he's rethinking taking
- 18:29Speaker 3: criminal law.
- 18:30Speaker 8: Cases exactly He seems like someone who just throws absolutely
- 18:35Speaker 8: everything into a case once he signs onto it.
- 18:38Speaker 9: You know.
- 18:38Speaker 8: He told us he often talks to his wife to
- 18:40Speaker 8: almost get her permission and her support to take on
- 18:44Speaker 8: a client because he just gives his entire life to it.
- 18:47Speaker 8: So that's what he did in this case. And I
- 18:49Speaker 8: think it had the added complexity of a friendship there.
- 18:52Speaker 8: And he found the whole experience very demanding, very exhausting,
- 18:57Speaker 8: and he just doesn't want to do another criminal law
- 18:59Speaker 8: case like it again.
- 19:00Speaker 4: So he's not going to be involved in the appeal.
- 19:03Speaker 8: Then, that's what he said. He doesn't want to be
- 19:05Speaker 8: involved in the appeal. He feels like he's done his
- 19:08Speaker 8: bit and he's ready to just take it down a
- 19:10Speaker 8: few notches and spend a bit more time with his family.
- 19:13Speaker 3: Did the trial cause a breach in his friendship with
- 19:17Speaker 3: Sam bankman Fried's parents.
- 19:18Speaker 2: Yes.
- 19:19Speaker 8: Mill thinks that this case and the verdict against Sam
- 19:22Speaker 8: bankman Fred has certainly had an impact on his friendship
- 19:25Speaker 8: with Barbara and Joe. Neil said that he took on
- 19:28Speaker 8: this case out of the favor to Sam bankman Free's parents,
- 19:31Speaker 8: as well as an interest in being involved in a
- 19:34Speaker 8: really novel and high profile case. Mills said that he
- 19:37Speaker 8: was concerned that parents who think that their child hasn't
- 19:41Speaker 8: done anything wrong will look for someone to blame, and
- 19:45Speaker 8: that he was in their line of sight. He also
- 19:47Speaker 8: said that he didn't think their friendship would recover. He
- 19:50Speaker 8: actually went to Barbara and Joe and asked them what
- 19:53Speaker 8: they thought of Mills and his comments. They responded and
- 19:56Speaker 8: said we loved David Mills and were eternally grateful for
- 19:59Speaker 8: everything that he has done.
- 20:00Speaker 3: For There are often fallouts from trials that the public
- 20:04Speaker 3: doesn't see. Fascinating interview. Thank you so much, Ava. That's
- 20:07Speaker 3: Bloomberg Legal reporter Ava, Benny Morrison. I'm June Grosso. When
- 20:11Speaker 3: you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 20:15Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 20:21Speaker 10: Adherence to the rule of law is a bedrock principle
- 20:24Speaker 10: of the Department of Justice, and our nation's commitment to
- 20:28Speaker 10: the rule of law sets an example for the world.
- 20:33Speaker 10: We have one set of laws in this country and
- 20:35Speaker 10: they apply to everyone.
- 20:37Speaker 3: In announcing one of the two federal criminal cases against
- 20:40Speaker 3: Donald Trump, special counsel Jack Smith said that no one
- 20:44Speaker 3: is above the law. It applies equally to everyone. However,
- 20:49Speaker 3: the former president is claiming the law doesn't apply to him.
- 20:53Speaker 3: Trump says he's entitled to absolute presidential immunity against criminal
- 20:58Speaker 3: charges over his efforts to overturn earn the twenty twenty
- 21:01Speaker 3: presidential election. The trial judge rejected Trump's claims of immunity,
- 21:06Speaker 3: refusing to toss out the charges, and Trump has appealed
- 21:09Speaker 3: to the DC Appellate Court, But in an effort to
- 21:12Speaker 3: prevent delays in the case, the special counsel is trying
- 21:16Speaker 3: to leapfrog the appellate court by asking the Supreme Court
- 21:20Speaker 3: to step in to decide the issue. Joining me is
- 21:23Speaker 3: Derek Muller, a professor at Notre Dame Law School. Derek
- 21:26Speaker 3: tell us about this untested claim of absolute presidential immunity
- 21:31Speaker 3: against criminal charges that Trump is making.
- 21:34Speaker 6: Think about, you know, immunity from your actions as president.
- 21:38Speaker 6: That is, you are engaged in your official capacity, you
- 21:41Speaker 6: are engaged in executive functions, and the notion that you
- 21:45Speaker 6: can be criminally prosecuted for that behavior, for the things
- 21:49Speaker 6: that you're doing while you're conducting your job, and should
- 21:53Speaker 6: be exempt from criminal prosecution as a result, and get
- 21:56Speaker 6: a lot of turns on at what point does your
- 21:59Speaker 6: behavior sort of flip from official executive behavior too unofficial behavior,
- 22:03Speaker 6: political or individual behavior. Is there an immunity for crimes
- 22:07Speaker 6: committed if you're purporting to them in your official capacity?
- 22:10Speaker 6: How could that possibly be the case? And so on?
- 22:12Speaker 3: The Special Council is asking the Supreme Court to step
- 22:15Speaker 3: in using Scherai before judgment, which is essentially skipping the
- 22:20Speaker 3: appellate court. It's unusual, But how unusual is it for
- 22:24Speaker 3: the court to grant that kind of review?
- 22:26Speaker 6: Pretty unusual, I mean, so I think you can think
- 22:28Speaker 6: about it this as some layers. If you're asking the
- 22:31Speaker 6: Supreme Court to have a petition for corcerari before judgment,
- 22:34Speaker 6: you know, sometimes that might arise if there's just a
- 22:37Speaker 6: sort of preliminary injunction or preliminary posture of the case
- 22:40Speaker 6: where maybe you want the court to step in, and
- 22:42Speaker 6: so that happens. It's not common, but it's not uncommon.
- 22:46Speaker 6: It's a relatively infrequent occurrence for the Court to step in,
- 22:49Speaker 6: but to sort of ask them to skip the Court
- 22:51Speaker 6: of Appeals and go straight to the United States Supreme
- 22:54Speaker 6: Court to resolve this matter before the DC Circuit has
- 22:58Speaker 6: weighed in is more unusual.
- 23:00Speaker 1: Now.
- 23:00Speaker 6: On the one hand, you could say, well, I think
- 23:03Speaker 6: this is a matter of presidential executive power. What has
- 23:06Speaker 6: happened in some of the cases involving Richard Nixon. If
- 23:09Speaker 6: we're dealing with executive power and criminal investigations and so on,
- 23:13Speaker 6: and these are major issues that we expect the Supreme
- 23:16Speaker 6: Court is going to have to weigh in on some point.
- 23:18Speaker 6: So there's this notion up front that they'll weigh in,
- 23:21Speaker 6: and so maybe we should just skip that stepping at
- 23:23Speaker 6: the United States Supreme Court involved. It's extraordinary, true, but
- 23:25Speaker 6: these are extraordinary circumstances. On the other hand, you have
- 23:28Speaker 6: to think from the justices perspective about their willingness to
- 23:31Speaker 6: sort of step in here and say, well, can we
- 23:32Speaker 6: just let the process play out? Maybe if the DC
- 23:35Speaker 6: Circuit is a good job, we don't really have to
- 23:37Speaker 6: weigh in. We can just kind of agree with what
- 23:38Speaker 6: they've said and just, you know, passively let the case
- 23:42Speaker 6: kind of continue below without us having to weigh in.
- 23:44Speaker 6: So there's just some questions about what the court might do.
- 23:49Speaker 6: But again, it's understandable why the prosecution wants to move
- 23:52Speaker 6: this as quickly as possible, and the.
- 23:53Speaker 3: Trial judge has paused the case pending this appeal, although
- 23:57Speaker 3: she said she wasn't throwing out all the dates.
- 24:00Speaker 4: I did want to ask.
- 24:01Speaker 3: You about the political overtones in the Special Council's request
- 24:06Speaker 3: to the Supreme Court, because trials are delayed all the time,
- 24:10Speaker 3: but if it's delayed in this case and he wins
- 24:12Speaker 3: the presidency, then it'll never happen.
- 24:16Speaker 6: I think the concern is if we have to go
- 24:18Speaker 6: through a level of briefing in oral argument and waiting
- 24:21Speaker 6: for an opinion at the DC Circuit, and then wait
- 24:23Speaker 6: for another round of appeals to the United States Supreme Court,
- 24:26Speaker 6: and do the same thing all over again, which we
- 24:29Speaker 6: feel like is inevitable, that can really start to press
- 24:32Speaker 6: upon that March fourth date. And so there is this
- 24:34Speaker 6: effort to move things along as quickly as possible. And yeah,
- 24:38Speaker 6: I figure right that we have this concern if you're
- 24:41Speaker 6: the prosecutor, that if there's any delay, this thing gets
- 24:44Speaker 6: pushed back, and then there's all kinds of additional complexities.
- 24:47Speaker 6: You know, what happens if he's the nominee for the party,
- 24:49Speaker 6: You know, can we realistically expect him to be facing
- 24:52Speaker 6: criminal charges or sitting in a court room while he's
- 24:55Speaker 6: supposed to be campaigning for president. That raises all kinds
- 24:58Speaker 6: of unique and additional class. And so we want this
- 25:01Speaker 6: to be resolved as early as possible. If he's guilty,
- 25:04Speaker 6: something the voters ought to know. If it's not guilty,
- 25:06Speaker 6: also something the voters want to know. So there is
- 25:08Speaker 6: this effort to resolve as early as possible. But there's
- 25:11Speaker 6: no question it has some political avalance to it. There's
- 25:14Speaker 6: some political charge because whenever you're dealing with in the
- 25:17Speaker 6: front running candidate for presidential nomination for major political party,
- 25:21Speaker 6: whatever you do in any direction is going to have
- 25:24Speaker 6: some kind of political ramifications and definitely some risks that
- 25:27Speaker 6: we're going to see play out about how we balance
- 25:30Speaker 6: those things.
- 25:31Speaker 3: You mentioned US v. Nixon in nineteen seventy four. In
- 25:35Speaker 3: that case, I believe it was sixty one days from
- 25:38Speaker 3: start to finish.
- 25:40Speaker 6: Yeah, So I mean, we can move things quickly, and
- 25:42Speaker 6: it's no question that we can move things quickly in
- 25:45Speaker 6: these processes for the United States Supreme Court. I think
- 25:48Speaker 6: about bushfee Gore where they granted certain on December ninth,
- 25:52Speaker 6: or argument December eleventh, decision December twelfth. I mean that's
- 25:55Speaker 6: record pace to move it in three days, right at.
- 25:58Speaker 3: The Special Council's request. If the DC Appellate Court has
- 26:01Speaker 3: agreed to expedite its consideration of Trump's appeal, setting deadlines
- 26:06Speaker 3: for briefs to be filed between December twenty third and
- 26:08Speaker 3: January second, how does that play in here?
- 26:11Speaker 6: But even then you then have to schedule oral argument,
- 26:14Speaker 6: And while you have that as a firm date, you
- 26:16Speaker 6: don't know how long it will take after oral argument
- 26:19Speaker 6: to issue a decision. You can say that you'd like
- 26:21Speaker 6: it as quickly as possible, and the DC Circuit can try,
- 26:24Speaker 6: but you know it might take a couple of weeks,
- 26:26Speaker 6: even working under the fastest of circumstances. So just looking
- 26:30Speaker 6: at the calendar, it might not be teed up for
- 26:32Speaker 6: Supreme Court review until mid to late January. And again,
- 26:35Speaker 6: if you're looking at a March fourth trial date, that
- 26:37Speaker 6: adds a tremendous amount of uncertainty and tremendous pressure on
- 26:40Speaker 6: the Supreme Court to weigh in get on a truncated timeline. So,
- 26:43Speaker 6: and it's the reason why you say it's an extraordinary
- 26:45Speaker 6: request from Smith's team here to seek the Supreme Court review,
- 26:49Speaker 6: But totally understandable when you're looking at the calendar and
- 26:51Speaker 6: what it looks like, and that this is a major
- 26:54Speaker 6: barrier to getting to that judgment. And if Trump is immune,
- 26:58Speaker 6: the case goes away. And if he's not, then probably
- 27:01Speaker 6: his strongest defense is gone and we're going to a
- 27:03Speaker 6: jury trial.
- 27:04Speaker 3: Normally, our responding gets a month to file a brief
- 27:08Speaker 3: opposing an appeal, but on Monday, the Supreme Court agreed
- 27:12Speaker 3: to speed up the part of the process where it
- 27:15Speaker 3: decides whether to take the case. It's only giving Trump
- 27:19Speaker 3: until December twentieth to respond to the Special Council's request.
- 27:23Speaker 3: Does that indicate that the Justices are aware of the
- 27:27Speaker 3: seriousness of the case, or that they're inclined to grant
- 27:32Speaker 3: the Special Counsel's request?
- 27:34Speaker 4: I mean, does it indicate anything at all?
- 27:36Speaker 6: So I don't know if they're inclined to grant, but
- 27:38Speaker 6: I think it certainly means they are not disinclined. I mean,
- 27:42Speaker 6: this is a small but important victory for Smith's team here,
- 27:45Speaker 6: because if the Court just says, no, we're just going
- 27:48Speaker 6: to give you a month to respond, well, that pretty
- 27:51Speaker 6: much settles it, right, It pretty much makes the decision
- 27:54Speaker 6: for you. But by allowing expedited response to the petition
- 27:58Speaker 6: for it a sacherari. All of the court's options open
- 28:02Speaker 6: right whether to grant and then have it on a
- 28:04Speaker 6: expedita basis, or to deny send it back to the
- 28:06Speaker 6: DC Circuit allowed to proceed on the normal track. So
- 28:09Speaker 6: this was sort of a necessary win for a Smith's team,
- 28:11Speaker 6: But it certainly I don't think suggests a whole lot
- 28:14Speaker 6: about the merits except that the Court is kind of
- 28:16Speaker 6: keeping it to options open.
- 28:17Speaker 3: The Supreme Court, of course, has a six to three
- 28:20Speaker 3: conservative majority, but it has not been especially receptive to
- 28:24Speaker 3: the cases that Trump has brought since he left the presidency.
- 28:28Speaker 3: I mean, does a conservative majority lean toward no presidents
- 28:33Speaker 3: above the law or does it lean in another direction.
- 28:35Speaker 6: Whenever you're justice in the court, you realize that you
- 28:38Speaker 6: are setting major precedents for presidential power executive authority immunities,
- 28:44Speaker 6: not just for Donald Trump, but also for Joe Biden,
- 28:47Speaker 6: whoever the next president is. Right, So there is I
- 28:50Speaker 6: think this institutional concern from the Court, and that's a
- 28:52Speaker 6: major question.
- 28:53Speaker 3: Right.
- 28:53Speaker 6: Once we've established that precedent about when former presidents can
- 28:58Speaker 6: be prosecuted, it's going to have a lot of sway
- 29:01Speaker 6: in the future. So I think the court's view, regardless
- 29:04Speaker 6: of whether you're a conservative or more liberal, justice is
- 29:07Speaker 6: going to be thinking about these issues from other kinds
- 29:10Speaker 6: of hallmarks of executive power and what kinds of behavior
- 29:14Speaker 6: conduct in office immunize you from future prosecutions. Where that
- 29:18Speaker 6: immunity attaches and arises and where it doesn't.
- 29:21Speaker 3: It would be a landmark decision. Thanks so much, Derek.
- 29:23Speaker 3: That's Professor Derek Muller of Notre Dame Law School. I'm
- 29:27Speaker 3: June Grosso and this is Bloomberg.
- 29:32Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 29:42Speaker 10: Hey everyone, it's Helen and I'm here with my beautiful
- 29:44Speaker 10: model Lucy, and today we're creating an everyday makeup look
- 29:48Speaker 10: using all.
- 29:49Speaker 2: Clean its for our products.
- 29:51Speaker 6: I'm Ayisha and I'm Melinda, and today we're going to
- 29:53Speaker 6: be talking about five clean beauty brands you need to know.
- 29:56Speaker 3: Hi. I'm Danil and today I'm going to share with
- 29:59Speaker 3: you some of my top picks from my lipstick wardrobe
- 30:02Speaker 3: and they're all clean. Sephora is just one of the
- 30:06Speaker 3: companies promoting clean beauty products. How much does that matter
- 30:10Speaker 3: to consumers like climate conscious gen zers and millennials well,
- 30:15Speaker 3: the clean beauty market has grown from its roots in
- 30:17Speaker 3: luxury and independent brands to take over shelves at mass
- 30:21Speaker 3: market retailers like Target, and it's forecast to expand to
- 30:25Speaker 3: fifteen point three billion dollars by twenty twenty eight. But
- 30:30Speaker 3: just what is a clean beauty product? That's the question
- 30:34Speaker 3: that's driving consumer led class actions against Sephora and Target
- 30:38Speaker 3: and raising the legal risk for companies trying to capitalize
- 30:42Speaker 3: on the demand for clean beauty. Joining me is Sean Collins,
- 30:46Speaker 3: and attorney at Straddling. He advises companies on consumer litigation.
- 30:51Speaker 3: What is a clean beauty product? Are there any parameters
- 30:54Speaker 3: the public can rely on?
- 30:57Speaker 9: No, there are, And that's probably the most first strading
- 31:00Speaker 9: part about it. And this is not abnormal. I mean,
- 31:03Speaker 9: the FTC and the regulatory bodies are always five to
- 31:07Speaker 9: ten years behind where the marketplace is. But you know
- 31:10Speaker 9: that is everybody's great frustration is that there is no
- 31:13Speaker 9: legal definition for beauty. And so the FTC releases what
- 31:16Speaker 9: they call guidelines, so you'll see if you google it
- 31:19Speaker 9: FTC guidance on what it means to have a clean
- 31:22Speaker 9: beauty product. And that guidance is not law. They are
- 31:25Speaker 9: trying to create guardrails or boundaries that kind of give
- 31:29Speaker 9: guidance to the skincare and beauty product lines out there
- 31:33Speaker 9: in the world, so that they at least have an
- 31:35Speaker 9: idea of what is permissible and what's not permissible. But
- 31:39Speaker 9: it's not very helpful because if you're a skincare cosmetics company,
- 31:44Speaker 9: you're just really kind of crossing your fingers and hoping
- 31:47Speaker 9: that you don't do anything that will get the FTC's
- 31:50Speaker 9: attention or maybe a state attorney general's attention.
- 31:52Speaker 3: There are now consumer led class action lawsuits.
- 31:57Speaker 4: Tell us a little bit about the lawsuit.
- 31:59Speaker 9: Against the form the reality of lossuit against the Four,
- 32:02Speaker 9: and the reason why you're seeing so many plaintiffs attorneys
- 32:05Speaker 9: go after them is it's like anything in life, tall
- 32:07Speaker 9: trees attract the most wins. The four is one of
- 32:10Speaker 9: the most recognized beauty and skincare companies in the world.
- 32:15Speaker 9: You know, you walk into any mall and even online
- 32:18Speaker 9: they have huge e commerce present and so Planet's attorneys
- 32:21Speaker 9: are coming after them and saying, you know, this is
- 32:23Speaker 9: what the FTC guidance says, and you didn't do that,
- 32:25Speaker 9: therefore you're in violation of the law. Now, what is
- 32:28Speaker 9: the law. The law of Section five of the FTC Act,
- 32:31Speaker 9: which is very broad and vague. It says you cannot
- 32:35Speaker 9: advertise a product in an unfair, deceptive, or misleading mass.
- 32:40Speaker 9: And so the question becomes, well, what does that mean?
- 32:42Speaker 9: The FTC views it as well. If a consumer is
- 32:45Speaker 9: looking at your label and they don't quite understand what
- 32:47Speaker 9: you're saying to them on that label, that's unfair, deceptives leading.
- 32:51Speaker 9: That's kind of the impetus for these lossits like the
- 32:53Speaker 9: one you're saying against the four.
- 32:55Speaker 3: So what do you tell your clients about promoting clean
- 32:58Speaker 3: beauty products?
- 33:00Speaker 9: I tell my clients, if you're advertising here in California
- 33:03Speaker 9: and you're going to use that word clean or all natural,
- 33:05Speaker 9: and you know that there might be an ingredient or
- 33:08Speaker 9: more that could potentially not be classified as clean or
- 33:12Speaker 9: all natural by the California Attorney General, you need to
- 33:15Speaker 9: do to one or two things you have. They need
- 33:16Speaker 9: a hedge with your language. Meaning most people like say
- 33:19Speaker 9: one hundred percent natural. I always tell them, well, if
- 33:22Speaker 9: it's not one hundred percent natural, you could say mostly natural,
- 33:26Speaker 9: you know, something to that effect. And obviously you know
- 33:28Speaker 9: the clients don't like that, especially the advertising department because
- 33:31Speaker 9: they're like, no, we want to use all natural. And
- 33:34Speaker 9: I say, look, I'm not going to tell you that
- 33:35Speaker 9: you can't use all natural, but if you don't put
- 33:39Speaker 9: an asterisk next to it or soften that language a
- 33:42Speaker 9: little bit, there is the potential that a plant attorney
- 33:45Speaker 9: could come after you.
- 33:46Speaker 3: Well, as these cases proceed, we'll find out more about
- 33:49Speaker 3: what courts consider to be clean beauty. Thanks so much, Sean.
- 33:54Speaker 3: That's Sean Collins, a shareholder at Straddling And that's it
- 33:58Speaker 3: for this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you
- 34:00Speaker 3: can always get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg
- 34:03Speaker 3: Law podcasts. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 34:07Speaker 3: and at www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast slash Law,
- 34:12Speaker 3: and remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every
- 34:15Speaker 3: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso
- 34:19Speaker 3: and you're listening to Bloomberg