Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Insider Sales to Time the Market
Transcript
- Lucas: Last week, the CEO of a well-known post ipo software company filed to sell nearly 15 percent of his personal stake. The stock dropped 4 percent that day. And I remember thinking — this is exactly the kind of signal that gets misinterpreted. Luna: Because investors automatically assume insider selling means the executive thinks the stock is overvalued. Lucas: Right. And sometimes that's true. But for post ipo companies especially, the timing of insider sales is often about something else entirely: managing tax liabilities, diversifying concentrated wealth, or — and this is the angle I want to drill into — actually taking advantage of the market's rhythm to get the best possible price before a downturn. Luna: So you're saying insiders are trying to time the market, not necessarily flee it. Lucas: Exactly. And the data we're seeing in Q2 2026 bears that out. According to filings aggregated by InsightMetrics, insider sales at companies that went public in the last three years are up about 40 percent compared to Q1. That's not panic selling — that's deliberate execution. Luna: Forty percent is a big jump. What's driving it? The broader market has been under pressure — the S&P 500 is down about 18 percent from its high, and the Renaissance IPO Index is off even more, around 22 percent year to date. Lucas: Right. And that's exactly the context. When a stock is still trading at a relatively high multiple — say, 8 or 9 times revenue for some of the ai adjacent names — but the macro outlook is deteriorating, insiders have a strong incentive to sell sooner rather than later. They're basically front-running potential further declines. Luna: But don't they have to use Rule 10b5-1 plans? Those are supposed to prevent exactly this kind of market timing. Lucas: That's the key nuance. Rule 10b5-1 plans allow insiders to set up a predetermined selling schedule. They can't change it based on material non-public information. But here's the thing — they can decide to set up a plan when they have a strong view on the market. And they can cancel a plan, though that comes with scrutiny. So the timing of when you initiate the plan is still a choice. Luna: So it's not illegal, but it's definitely strategic. And investors are trying to read into it. Lucas: Yes. And what's interesting is that we're seeing a lot of these plans being initiated in the last 60 to 90 days — exactly when the market started its most recent leg down. Take Palantir, for example. The stock is down about 6 percent in just the past five days, but earlier this quarter, several insiders filed 10b5-1 plans. Now, Palantir's stock had run up a lot in 2025 and early 2026, so some profit-taking is natural. But the concentration of plans around a peak is telling. Luna: I looked at the Palantir filings too. One of their co-founders set up a plan in April to sell up to 500,000 shares over the next six months. At the time, the stock was around $140. Now it's $127. So even if they haven't sold yet, the plan was initiated near a local high. Lucas: And that's the pattern. It's not just Palantir. We're seeing it across the post ipo universe. And it contrasts sharply with the buyback narrative we've covered in earlier episodes. When a company does a buyback, it's usually a signal of confidence. When insiders sell into that same period, it can create a mixed message. But I'd argue that in many cases, the insider sales are more about personal balance sheets than company fundamentals. Luna: Speaking of the show's own balance sheet — or lack thereof — we don't run ads here. We keep these conversations ad-free because we think that's the right way to have a real discussion about capital markets and company strategy. If you find value in that, and you want to support the show staying independent, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, that's exactly it. No pressure, no pitch — just a way for listeners who get something out of these episodes to help us keep going. And we really appreciate it. Luna: Alright, back to insider sales. So we've got insiders selling more, but not necessarily because they think the company is doomed. What about the actual mechanics of how they execute? Is it all through the open market, or are we seeing more block trades and secondary offerings? Lucas: That's a great question. In Q2, we've seen a noticeable uptick in secondary offerings — where the company itself facilitates a sale of shares from existing holders. That's different from an insider selling on the open market. In a secondary, the company often underwrites the sale, which can help minimize the price impact. And it sends a different signal: the company is helping insiders get liquidity in a controlled way. Luna: So the company is essentially endorsing the sale. That's a bit more reassuring to the market than a sudden Form 4 filing. Lucas: Exactly. And we've seen that with a few of the larger post ipo tech names this quarter. They've done secondary offerings where the proceeds go entirely to selling shareholders — not the company. That's a way to let insiders cash out without the stock tanking. But it also gives the company a chance to buy back shares at the same time, which we've seen in a couple of cases. Luna: So the company might buy back stock to offset the dilution from the secondary. That's a sophisticated strategy. Lucas: It is. And it shows that management is thinking about the optics. But I want to circle back to the timing point. The SEC's new guidance on 10b5-1 plans, which went into effect earlier this year, requires a mandatory cooling-off period before trades can start — 90 days for officers and directors. That's actually making the timing even more critical. If you want to sell in a certain window, you have to set up your plan months in advance. Luna: So the plans we're seeing now were probably set up back in March or April. That means insiders were already anticipating the market weakening. Lucas: Right. And that's the information signal that investors can use. It's not a perfect tell — plans can be cancelled — but it's one of the few forward-looking data points we have from insiders that isn't just words on an earnings call. Luna: Let's talk about the other side: insider buying. Are we seeing any insiders buying the dip in their own stocks? Lucas: Not much. According to the same dataset, insider buying among post ipo companies is actually at a two-year low in Q2. That's notable. If insiders thought the selloff was overdone, you'd expect them to be buying. The fact that they're not — and that selling is accelerating — suggests they see more downside risk. Luna: That's a sobering data point. Especially when you consider that many of these companies are still growing revenue at 20 or 30 percent. But the market is pricing in a lot of uncertainty — interest rates, regulatory risks, AI model disruptions. Lucas: Exactly. And insiders are closer to the business. They know if the sales pipeline is softening or if a big customer is churning. So their selling pattern isn't just about market timing — it's about their own visibility into the next six months. Luna: I want to go back to the example you mentioned at the top. The CEO who sold 15 percent of his stake — was that a secondary offering or open market sales? Lucas: It was a combination. He had a 10b5-1 plan that was set up last quarter, and then he also participated in a secondary offering that the company announced. So it was a two-pronged approach. The stock dropped initially, but it recovered within a few days — which suggests the market did differentiate between a planned diversification and a panic. Luna: That's a useful lesson for investors. Not all insider sales are created equal. The context — the plan, the size, the method — matters a lot. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's why we're spending an episode on it. For listeners who are tracking post ipo stocks, I'd say: don't just look at the headline 'insider sells shares.' Look at the filing. Was it a pre-arranged plan? Was it a secondary? What's the company doing on the buyback side? The combination tells you far more than any single data point. Luna: And with the SEC's new rules, we're actually getting more transparency. Plans have to be disclosed earlier, and there's more detail about the terms. So it's a good time to be paying attention. Lucas: Yeah, the disclosure has improved. But it also means the signals are more nuanced. The old heuristic — insider sells equals bad — doesn't hold anymore. You have to dig into the 'why'. Luna: So what should a retail investor do if they see a big insider sale at a company they own? Lucas: First, check if it's part of a 10b5-1 plan. If it is, note the date the plan was adopted. If the plan was set up months ago, the sale is less informative about current sentiment. Second, look at the size relative to the insider's total holdings. Selling 5 percent of a position is very different from selling 50 percent. And third, check if the company is buying back shares at the same time. That's a classic signal of confidence. Luna: And what about the case where there's no plan — just an open market sale? Lucas: That's rarer now because of the 10b5-1 rules. Most large insiders use plans. But if you see an open market sale without a plan, and it's a significant amount, that's worth paying attention to. It could mean the insider needed liquidity urgently, or it could be a red flag. Either way, it's a stronger signal than a planned sale. Luna: Makes sense. So as we wrap up, what's the one takeaway for someone listening to this on their commute? Lucas: Insider selling is up sharply among post ipo companies in Q2 2026. It's not necessarily a sign of doom — much of it is strategic diversification using 10b5-1 plans. But the fact that buying is at a two-year low suggests that the people closest to these businesses are bracing for more turbulence. As an investor, use the filing details to distinguish between noise and signal. Luna: And that's the kind of conversation we like to have here — no ads, just analysis. Thanks for joining us for episode 50. Lucas: Next time, we'll look at how some post ipo companies are using their cash reserves to make strategic acquisitions while their stock prices are down. See you then.