Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Acorn support, Ocean Winds graduation, and Reform on reactors
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. This week, ACORN finally got
- 0:24funding. Or or did it?
- 0:26We'll find out. Then Erica went down to ocean
- 0:29winds to have a yap with Gillian Martin, our new cabinet
- 0:33secretary, long term cabinet secretary for Scotland.
- 0:36And finally, we're going to address that big white, blue
- 0:40elephant in the room reform. But first, I better introduce
- 0:43myself. I'm Aberdeen features lead Ryan
- 0:45Duff. And joining me this week is news
- 0:48reporter Matthew Perry. Good morning.
- 0:50How are we? Doing I'm not too bad.
- 0:51How's yourself, Matt? I know it's a week of spending
- 0:53review excitement, which I can't really say that with a straight
- 0:57face because there's not been much in there that's been all
- 0:59that exciting, but yeah, otherwise pretty good.
- 1:01Yeah, I think there was a, it was, it was quite a bit of a
- 1:04damp squib, but we'll find out a little bit more about that in
- 1:07just a minute. But I'm also joined by E Forward
- 1:10Editor Ed Reed. Do you know Editor Ed Reed is a
- 1:13difficult thing to say. I should, I should really
- 1:15rethink my title, I think, or possibly my name.
- 1:18Maybe maybe I should just change my name at this point.
- 1:20That would be like, you know, let's let's go to for the root
- 1:23cause of the problem and just really dig in.
- 1:25But yeah, it's it's lovely to be back guys.
- 1:26I mean, I feel like I have been away for a while doing other
- 1:30things, paternity leaving, etc. But now I'm really back where
- 1:34where my heart is obviously podcasting with the team.
- 1:37Exactly that. Exactly that.
- 1:39We've got a dream team together today and sorry, Erica, you're
- 1:42not involved in that this week but hey, I mean, virtually she
- 1:45would she is, I suppose. Yeah, we've we have we have the
- 1:48ultimate dream team. Erica's even joining us, but I
- 1:52alluded to it right at the top of the show.
- 1:53We should probably speak about the spending review.
- 1:56Matt, you've already dived into it.
- 1:58It wasn't too many details, but we did find out that ACORN had
- 2:02got, and I quote, support from the UK government.
- 2:06But we don't really know what that means, do we?
- 2:09No. And it seems as if what's really
- 2:12happened is that the Track One CC US cluster, so that's the
- 2:16East Coast cluster around Teesside and a little bit on the
- 2:19Humber and the high net cluster over in the Northwest.
- 2:22It looks as if their track One expansion program has gotten
- 2:25probably the bulk of that funding.
- 2:27But, you know, obviously there's been a lot of angst in Scotland
- 2:32from particularly the SNP and the the industry up in Aberdeen
- 2:35about the lack of support for for a Cohen over the past few
- 2:39months. And so I guess Chancellor Rachel
- 2:42Reeve getting up in the House of Commons and saying we're funding
- 2:46more carbon capture and storage in England wouldn't have been
- 2:49particularly popular north of the border.
- 2:51So they've made a big song and dance about support for the
- 2:54Track 2 project, which is obviously Acorn, which is
- 2:57Astrega, Harbour Energy, Shell and North Sea Midstream Partners
- 3:00in the Scottish cluster, and the Viking CCS, which is Harbor
- 3:05Energy and a lot of industrial firms down in the Humber region.
- 3:09They've gotten funding support in the spending review.
- 3:13That said, development support funding has not outlined exactly
- 3:16how that is, but overall we're seeing £9.4 billion going over
- 3:22the spending review period to carbon capture and storage.
- 3:26How that's been allocated it, it doesn't really say.
- 3:29So I mean, we've, we've seen probably I guess a bit of a
- 3:32muted response from from the industry.
- 3:35Normally when you get to one of these announcements and people
- 3:37are quite excited about it, the the press releases start
- 3:39flooding through quite quickly. It took a little bit of a time,
- 3:42I think for, you know, the likes of OE UK to I guess think
- 3:47through exactly how they wanted to respond because you know,
- 3:51it's, it's not nothing. They had to think about how we
- 3:53say, how they say, oh, the government's done a good thing,
- 3:56but maybe speak with us a little bit more is kind of.
- 3:59It a lot of that language of will work, continue working with
- 4:02the government to, you know, programs, blah, blah, blah.
- 4:05It's it's it's I guess depends in industry terms, you know,
- 4:09they often talk about signals of support from, you know, that
- 4:13investors can point to and say, look, you know, the government
- 4:15is supporting this. This is something that we can,
- 4:18you know, hold on to and then, you know, not pull out, tell our
- 4:22investment completely. So, you know, Rachel Reeves
- 4:25getting up and then, you know, speaking about Acorn and Viking
- 4:29in the midst of the spending review, Maybe that is enough of
- 4:31a signal for them to keep them encouraged.
- 4:33But it was certainly wasn't enough for the the SNP, which
- 4:36which you wrote about yesterday. Stephen Flynn wasn't
- 4:39particularly happy. Yeah, I think to get into
- 4:42details specifically what the spending review says about Acorn
- 4:45and Viking, it said that they'll be supported to FID this
- 4:49parliament. However, that is also subject to
- 4:53project readiness and affordability.
- 4:55So a nice little get out clause there for them as well if they
- 4:59if they decide that they can't allocate the funds later in in
- 5:03the government. So yeah, Stephen Flynn
- 5:05essentially said that the lack of details around how much
- 5:08funding is being delivered, when it's being delivered, how it's
- 5:11being delivered was a glaring omission from the spending
- 5:15review. And like you say, I think the
- 5:17industry up in Scotland probably aren't exactly delighted about,
- 5:21you know, track one are getting a lot of support.
- 5:24And you know, it was soon after the Labor government came in,
- 5:28they unlocked that funding for track one.
- 5:31Track 2 was still waiting for it.
- 5:33You could argue still is based on the lack of details here.
- 5:37And you know, at the time of the Track 1 announcement, we saw a
- 5:40lot of business leaders up in the northeast of Scotland sort
- 5:44of bemoaning the decision to go with not go with Acorn under
- 5:48track one, but rather it was it was sort of poised as being, oh,
- 5:53it's the, you know, most likely to get track to funding, but
- 5:57there was uncertainty there. And then eventually it did get
- 5:59track too. And now the funding still not
- 6:02here either. So yeah, I think there there is
- 6:05a lot of a lot of toing and froing around this.
- 6:07You know, I have seen people saying it's good news.
- 6:10You know, there's not a shortage of people from the NSTA to
- 6:15Global Underwater Hub or UK also are saying, you know, we welcome
- 6:20the the messages support and we welcome the sort of engagement
- 6:23with the Acorn and Viking project.
- 6:26However, you've also got folks like Stephen Flynn kind of
- 6:29saying, well, have you actually done anything?
- 6:32You know, there isn't much detail here, but.
- 6:35There I, I mean, like, obviously I think, you know, it's, it's,
- 6:37it's, it's absolutely fair to criticize the the lack of kind
- 6:40of clarity around ACORN, but I think there's also like there's
- 6:42an amount of politics going on there, right.
- 6:44I mean. Oh, 100%.
- 6:45Having just seen the by election result with with with Labour
- 6:48getting that sort of unexpected win, obviously the SNP sinking
- 6:51ahead to the election, like, I feel like obviously there's
- 6:55there's very much a need for the for the SNP to come out and say,
- 6:58hey, hey, how about Scotland? You know, what do we actually
- 7:00get? Which is totally legitimate, But
- 7:02I think, you know, it's it it these things don't happen in.
- 7:04Iraq. Oh, no, 100% no.
- 7:06And yeah, that we're, yeah, we can't, we can't say that Stephen
- 7:08Flynn is only doing this out of the the goodness of his heart
- 7:11and his passion for the ACORN project.
- 7:13Of course there is some political point scoring there.
- 7:16Labour have left a slightly open goal in the form of lack of
- 7:19details, so he's obviously going to take that.
- 7:23I think another thing I found quite interesting from
- 7:25businesses when within the CCS space was actually from a carbon
- 7:30clean, a carbon capture technology company who actually
- 7:34called for CFDS for CCS in in the wake of this, which was
- 7:39quite interesting because obviously in industry there's a
- 7:41lot of talk around how do we finance CCS projects.
- 7:45They can't always be, you know, that we can, we're not going to
- 7:47have a track 17. We're not going to have a round
- 7:51after round of track funding. It's just, you know, if they are
- 7:53going to have to be able to stand on their own 2 feet to a
- 7:56certain extent eventually some people would argue that CFDS
- 8:02isn't a project standing in its own 2 feet, but it's it's
- 8:04definitely a move away. It was quite an interesting
- 8:07call. Just in response to that.
- 8:09I was wondering what you guys had to think I had to say about
- 8:12that because like I say, there is a lot of chat around sort of
- 8:15how do we make CCS financially viable?
- 8:17Yeah, I mean, I think as you say, right, I think like it's,
- 8:19it's, it's, it's important to start thinking about what comes
- 8:22next, right? Like obviously the government
- 8:24doesn't have an infinite pot of money.
- 8:25Like they've got to make decisions.
- 8:27CFDS are quite, quite, quite an elegant way to sort of, maybe
- 8:30sort of solve the problem. Like in addition to obviously,
- 8:33you know, sort of higher carbon prices, which we might be seeing
- 8:36with the, the link up with the UKEUETS.
- 8:40So I think like there, there, there are all these ways in
- 8:43which we should be moving towards it.
- 8:46Obviously it's going to be a bit of a challenge to kind of get
- 8:49things going. But we, yeah, we need to be
- 8:51thinking ahead of Beyond Track too.
- 8:52Mr. Rega has been there, one of the partners in the Acorn
- 8:55project, They've been a big proponent of what is so-called
- 8:57merchant model, which is I guess the model that Norway and
- 9:01Denmark are pursuing, where you essentially take CO2 shipments
- 9:05from, from internationally or from areas even within the UK
- 9:08that have no real other options. They're not nearby, they can't
- 9:11do a via pipeline. And you can essentially charge
- 9:13more for that. You know, you not have maybe
- 9:15having to have the UK government Subs in that it might be the
- 9:18German government for some of their industrial producers that
- 9:20don't really have other options to, to send their, their carbon
- 9:24off. So could maybe I think Viking
- 9:26Harbour energy has talked about, you know, CO2 international
- 9:30shipments being a, a good revenue support for, for Viking
- 9:33as well. So yeah, I think in the future
- 9:35they'll have to be some work done to figure out what, what
- 9:38kind of model some of these because you've then got beyond
- 9:41track too. You've got a lot of other
- 9:42projects in the work, you know, Morecam net zero, you've got
- 9:45Poseidon and Orion that Perenko is working on.
- 9:47So the model that maybe sends those projects forward hasn't
- 9:52been nailed down just yet. I suppose, yeah, I mean, I
- 9:56totally agree. And I think, you know, obviously
- 9:58just looking even within the UK, right, you can see sort of South
- 10:01Wales, you know sort of sending sort of CO2 to Steregra or
- 10:05something. But I think there is, you know,
- 10:06maybe a question about the sort of the political sort of
- 10:10viability of sort of, you know, importing CO2.
- 10:13I think, you know, there is a degree of sort of public
- 10:16skepticism about about the industry.
- 10:18It's sort of seen as, you know, obviously kind of, you know,
- 10:20waste disposal in many ways, isn't it?
- 10:22And I feel like, yes, I can see that being like a like a viable
- 10:26industrial strategy, but I think it's going to be needed to be
- 10:29treated very carefully. I mean, yeah, that literally is
- 10:32classed as waste that I remember speaking to Project Greensand
- 10:35years ago and they were saying that to get CO2 into Denmark
- 10:39from overseas, they had to sort of finagle some EU law a little
- 10:43bit to make sure that. Yes, that's the London
- 10:45Convention. Yeah, exactly.
- 10:46You know, like because it is essentially the same as like,
- 10:50you know, all right, legally it's seen as sort of doing the
- 10:52same as having, you know, those big like New York trash barges
- 10:55kind of just floating across the border.
- 10:58It's kind of that's how the law, Aussies at least.
- 11:00So it's definitely an interesting, interesting talking
- 11:04point, but it kind of does round out our 10 minutes on it this
- 11:07week. There was a lot of news on
- 11:08nuclear as well. I know Matt was itching to speak
- 11:11about that, but maybe you're just going to have to read his
- 11:13coverage this week to find out what happened there.
- 11:53So up next, Erika Askel and our news editor has been over at
- 11:57Ocean Winds speaking to the now permanent energy Secretary up
- 12:02here in Scotland. She's taken over from Mary
- 12:05McAllen. It's Gillian Martin.
- 12:07Here with the acting Netzier secretary Gillian Martin, who's
- 12:11just been around Nest Call touring the facilities and
- 12:15meeting with the developers of the Caledonian Wind Farm Ocean
- 12:18Winds. So tell me a little bit about
- 12:20what you've seen here today. So this is the second time that
- 12:25I've met a cohort students that have been brought in in a hot
- 12:29housing one year course to get there.
- 12:31They're not 5 in welding and fabricating.
- 12:34I met them for the first time in the Fraserburgh campus and
- 12:36today's their graduation they've all gone through.
- 12:39And I think half of them at the moment are already looking at
- 12:42apprenticeships. They've been snapped up.
- 12:44The other half will be snapped up probably very soon as well.
- 12:48And it's just an example. We've worked with Ocean winds
- 12:50and we've worked with ESP training provider and Nescal to
- 12:54really hot house the types of young people that we need to be
- 12:58taking up the jobs that we're going to need.
- 13:01Multiple thousands of people doing welding and fabricating.
- 13:05So this is a pilot project, We've done it in this one year.
- 13:09We're then going to roll it out again for the second year.
- 13:12But because it's been so successful, there is a very real
- 13:16prospect that this sort of thing is going to be rolled out across
- 13:18the whole of Scotland. Because The thing is
- 13:21particularly realising our ambition and offshore wind is
- 13:24the one thing that I have absolutely in tattoos of my
- 13:27brain is we need more welders. We need welders at scale.
- 13:33So anyone young people thinking of I want to be part of the
- 13:36solution in terms of the energy transition, I want to be part of
- 13:40the solution in terms of tackling climate change, if
- 13:42that's your thing. You get in at the ground
- 13:45literally as a welder and you have got the skills for a really
- 13:49fabulous career, particularly in offshore wind.
- 13:52Sure. OK.
- 13:53Now everyone's really excited about offshore wind, floating
- 13:57offshore wind, but we're seeing some really massive hurdles.
- 14:00So depending on when this podcast goes out, we will have
- 14:05seen something emerge, you know, from the spending review or not.
- 14:10But there's a lot of ambition particular and needs from AR 7
- 14:16to make sure that this gets built out.
- 14:18There's worry that, you know, these people probably have jobs,
- 14:22but you know, is it going to achieve the levels of what
- 14:27people were expecting if we don't get all of the offshore
- 14:32wind gigawatts because of delays or they keep moving right there?
- 14:37There's a worry there. That has to work, we have to do
- 14:40this. It's not an option at all to not
- 14:45meet that ambition. We have to for a number of
- 14:47reasons. And it's not just the Scottish
- 14:48Government saying it's UK government, current UK
- 14:50government as well know this knows and, and they're very
- 14:54aware of some of the headwinds and, and barriers.
- 14:57We are all aware because industries speaking to them
- 14:59about the biggest barrier is uncertainty.
- 15:02So what has to happen in the spending review is certainty has
- 15:05to come back. What has to happen in the review
- 15:07of the the the market, the RIMA has to be certainty has to be
- 15:11restored because that is the biggest enemy in the way of any
- 15:16kind of investment that's happened.
- 15:18We need to do it in a way that is going to give certainty, the
- 15:21certainty to the industry. But there is also a wider thing
- 15:24for the public there. There needs to be acceptance of
- 15:26what's been done by the public beyond the Northeast and beyond
- 15:29Scotland as well. The people have to to know that
- 15:33what we're doing here is going to have a consequence for their
- 15:35everyday life, both in economic growth and the jobs for for
- 15:40people in the Northeast and particularly people working in
- 15:42oil and gas that wants to transition the wider Scotland as
- 15:45well for future jobs for young people, but also the economic
- 15:49prosperity of the country. So this is this is what's at
- 15:53stake if there is not certainty of direction now, I hope that
- 15:58the Scottish Government has provided that certainty of
- 16:00direction for many, many years. We've always had an ambition to
- 16:03be a renewables capital and we're doing everything in our
- 16:06powers to make sure that we do our bit in making sure that
- 16:10projects get built and that there is a support and the
- 16:14workforce there to sustain them. The UK government level, they
- 16:18have to give certainty around AR 7.
- 16:20They need to reform the energy electricity markets.
- 16:23They need to be making sure that all the option rounds are are
- 16:29are there's a support there for for companies to actually bid
- 16:33for those rounds and to have a success of all their.
- 16:36But the main thing is they have to give certainty on the build
- 16:41out of the grid capacity. And there's one other thing when
- 16:46people say we need welders, we need certainty, we need grid
- 16:51capacity. And so all of those things need
- 16:54to do in place and there's a lot in in there that are is coming
- 16:57into place in the spending review.
- 16:59I would say we also need certainty on carbon capture and
- 17:02storage. The Acorn project has to be
- 17:05given the funding and the green light to go ahead because it's
- 17:08not just an, an offshore wind that we've got the potential,
- 17:10we've got the potential to be a CCUS destination for, for the
- 17:16whole of Europe and the jobs that created.
- 17:18And these are the jobs that will minimise any gap that we have as
- 17:23we see oil and gas depletion in the, in the North Sea, which we
- 17:27know is happening and be needs to be have the, the certainty
- 17:31around things like where Rima's going to go in terms of zonal
- 17:36pricing or, or whatever. There needs to be certainty
- 17:38there because we have got oil and gas companies that are
- 17:42looking to decommission as well. So again, these are jobs for
- 17:46people for decades to happen. I mean, it's minimising that gap
- 17:49as much as possible before we have Scotland built out.
- 17:52There's a lot that needs to happen.
- 17:55A small fraction of it isn't the gift of the Scottish Government
- 17:58skills in particular. That's why we're doing.
- 18:00That's why we're here, absolutely.
- 18:02Our energy consent unit, we have doubled the capacity of the
- 18:05energy consent unit, more than doubled the capacity 'cause that
- 18:08was something that people were saying to me.
- 18:09Yeah, our applications are not going through in a time that we
- 18:13would like to see. We've now got the guarantees
- 18:15they're going through in a year. We've got streamlining of the
- 18:18process around that. We've got better communication
- 18:21with the energy consent units and developers as well.
- 18:24Well, there's a lot has to happen at UK level.
- 18:27Sure. We'd really like to see Berwick
- 18:28Bank for example go through. I think that would give a lot of
- 18:32certainty to the marketplace in order to kind of offer a offer,
- 18:37you know, people graduating here, certainty of certainly
- 18:40jobs, you know for that. Is there any?
- 18:43And so that isn't it. That is in the gift of the
- 18:46Scottish Government, though. Yeah, I think there are things I
- 18:49cannot. I know.
- 18:50Yeah, yeah, yeah. The wider ambition is when
- 18:52specie and projects get built in a sustainable way, need to get
- 18:56projects getting built in a, in a way that is have minimal
- 19:00impact on ecosystems and the environment.
- 19:03That's what we need to do. But in terms of like government
- 19:07policy, both governments have to be very, very focused on this
- 19:11the the direction they have in terms of renewables more
- 19:15generally. Yeah.
- 19:16And decarbonizing more generally, because that's where
- 19:19the jobs are going to be. That's where the future jobs are
- 19:22going to be for decades to come. Now I know you said certainty,
- 19:25but how do you square the two opposing forces between cheaper
- 19:31energy bills offered through local pricing of energy, zonal
- 19:37pricing versus the need for industry to invest and deliver
- 19:43the economic benefits to the company?
- 19:45How do you, how does the Scottish Government square that
- 19:49circle? What are you saying?
- 19:50You know, aside, to make that a reality?
- 19:53I don't see it as a binary choice.
- 19:55I think there was an awful lot more that could be done in the
- 19:57consumer space that is not just. Zonal pricing, I think that they
- 20:02have whittled down the process of RIMA, they have whittled down
- 20:05their options to this, but there actually was an awful lot more
- 20:08than the table even a couple of years ago.
- 20:10The decoupling of the price of electricity and gas is something
- 20:14that needs to be looked at again.
- 20:15A social tariff for those that are most vulnerable in terms of
- 20:19their cost of of their fuel supply has to be on the table.
- 20:23We need to be looking at all the different options on the table
- 20:27in order to make sure that we have a reduction in the fuel
- 20:31poverty that places like Scotland absolutely suffer from.
- 20:35And we need the jobs and the the investment in order to bring
- 20:40down the wholesale cost of electricity into the future.
- 20:45So there has to be some short term and medium term decisions
- 20:48to be making it easier for those that are the most vulnerable
- 20:51consumers. It's consumers that, you know,
- 20:54suppliers are seeing debt from and this is AI think the social
- 20:57tariff is a way to do that. But we also have to not
- 21:00jeopardize what we have in terms of the projects as well because
- 21:04the scale of what we are wanting to achieve in Scotland in
- 21:07particular is going to drive down electricity prices.
- 21:11And that is we've got to keep an eye on that future and keep an
- 21:13eye on the ball in that respect. Right, well thank you for
- 21:16keeping the eye on the ball for Scotland at least.
- 21:20Lovely to speak to you. Thank you very much.
- 21:22So that does it for a wind this week or does it?
- 21:25We've got to speak about reform. So we've skirted around the
- 22:25topic for for long enough. I think it's about time we speak
- 22:28about Farage and Co isn't that They've been making waves in the
- 22:32energy sector. This week we also saw an ex oil
- 22:36and gas worker take the LinkedIn and, you know, call for Farage's
- 22:40support. He wrote a letter to, to Reform
- 22:43UK and it got a decent amount of responses on on social media.
- 22:49So I guess it's about time. But the energy sector is talking
- 22:52about reform. Farage was just up in Aberdeen.
- 22:55Just what was it last week speaking about the the utter
- 22:59nonsense that is net zero? So who wants to jump on this
- 23:04particular hand grenade first? Well, I think it's, you know,
- 23:08not not credible really what what, you know, reform is, is
- 23:12putting forward in terms of its energy policies.
- 23:16But I think the interesting thing for me is that it's it's
- 23:18actually out of step with the people that are actually voting
- 23:21reform. You know, there's been a lot of
- 23:22polling done in the lead up to the local elections in the week
- 23:25after and and some polling for focal data for the Energy and
- 23:30Climate Intelligence Unit found that 54% of voters who plan to
- 23:34vote for reform UK at those local elections at the beginning
- 23:37of May, they wanted they support policies to stop climate change
- 23:41and put in place targets accordingly to keep the UK on
- 23:44track. I think it was out of, you know,
- 23:47the, the for, for reform voters, the most important issue for
- 23:51them voting in those elections, you know, had immigration and
- 23:54asylum up very high at 66%. That was their top, you know, a
- 23:57very important issue for them. Only 12% selected energy policy
- 24:02and and only 4% selected climate change.
- 24:05So, you know, I guess the polling kind of indicates that
- 24:08reform vote is, you know, broadly in line with the
- 24:11majority of the UK and that they, you know, believe that
- 24:13climate change is, is real and they, they want to see action
- 24:16towards, you know, cleaner energy systems.
- 24:18But it's not really a deciding factor in whether or not they're
- 24:24going to vote for reform. So I think there's potentially
- 24:26this risk that people see, you know, Nigel Farage and Richard
- 24:29Tice up, there's spouting off about net 0 being being madness,
- 24:34But that doesn't mean that every single person voting for reform
- 24:39necessarily agrees with those those views on on net 0.
- 24:42Well, I think I think that's the thing like, you know, if you
- 24:44look back to sort of UKIP and the Brexit Party and Farage is
- 24:49all there. Are they are they all the same
- 24:52party or they failed previous attempts?
- 24:55I can't argue that they're not the same.
- 24:57But they, you know, they were almost seen as being the the
- 25:02vote for the people who think the right weren't right enough,
- 25:05weren't they? They were kind of, you know, all
- 25:06Conservatives are to say, you know, coming too far central for
- 25:10me. I want to go further right.
- 25:11Whereas now the Tories have fallen abets.
- 25:15Labour aren't exactly the friend of the working class that, you
- 25:21know, they, they're traditionally seen as we've seen
- 25:23trade unions are lobby against them, which feels very, very
- 25:28interesting. So I guess for them it's a case
- 25:31of, you know, now they're able to sort of scoop up all these
- 25:34voters that were, you know, they're now going, well, we want
- 25:37something different, we want change.
- 25:38And so it's an interesting time. I think, I think like I
- 25:43obviously I don't really disagree with you guys.
- 25:45I don't think that reforms, energy policies are are much of
- 25:50A goer, right? But I think that there is that
- 25:52there are some very interesting things that they express.
- 25:54And I think that's really where Nigel Farage has his strength.
- 25:58I mean, I'm obviously we we're seeing some opinion polls that
- 26:01suggest, oh, maybe reform will get like a, you know, win the
- 26:052020 eleven election. I frankly think that's nonsense.
- 26:07I like to think so, but then I also thought that Trump getting
- 26:10elected a second time was. Nonsense.
- 26:13Yeah, but, but, but, but, so I, I, I think, look, I think
- 26:16that's, that's nonsense. But I think that's the
- 26:18essentially that the, the power of reform and the power of
- 26:21Ferraris does not lie in actually governing.
- 26:24I think it lies in channelling populist discontent, Right.
- 26:29And I think there is clearly a, you know, all this talk about
- 26:32energy security, they're tapping into that and they're saying,
- 26:35look, shale gas, we love that, you know, return to North Sea,
- 26:40you know, but they're also saying like, we don't like, we
- 26:43don't like new pylons. And they're also saying we love
- 26:46nuclear power, right? So, so just go through those
- 26:48kind of just quickly. Shale gas obviously feels like a
- 26:51non starter in this country. Obviously Scotland, big non
- 26:53starter North Sea. They're saying, look, we, we
- 26:57want, we want to, you know, kind of reopen the North Sea and we
- 27:00want to invest in it, right? And you're a bit like, why?
- 27:03That feels like an absolute highway to nothing.
- 27:07Like I, I think the idea of the UK state actually investing in
- 27:10North Sea, North Sea fields is, is an absolute nonsense which
- 27:15won't stand up to any scrutiny. And I suspect companies would be
- 27:17extremely skeptical about that as well.
- 27:19I think grid is really interesting, right?
- 27:21So they're saying, look, we don't want to build, you know,
- 27:22pylons through our beautiful landscape, which really, you
- 27:25know, taps into a lot of those kind of concerns that people are
- 27:28having around the country, right, in Scotland.
- 27:29But also, you know, where I am in the South of England, I see
- 27:32kind of, you know, big signs saying, you know, we don't want,
- 27:34you know, grid expansion, things like that.
- 27:36But that's not dissimilar, right?
- 27:37Like the Lib Dems, for instance, are saying very similar things,
- 27:41right? The Lib Dems obviously, you
- 27:42know, kind of, I guess in some ways kind of like quite soft
- 27:44Conservatives, Lib Dems, you know, and they're saying, look,
- 27:47we don't, we know we're going to be, you know, we want to, we
- 27:50like the idea of green energy, but we don't want actually to
- 27:53see the impact of it. And then finally nuclear.
- 27:56I think it's really interesting because you know, sort of seeing
- 27:58Farage and Richard Times talking about nuclear, obviously they
- 28:00keep breaking very keen on SMRS. What did we see in the spending
- 28:03review? We saw what, 14 billion for
- 28:06Sizewell and 2 1/2 billion taken from GB Energy and reallocated
- 28:10to SMRS. I mean, there's been a lot of discussion about, you
- 28:14know, is the Labour government too attuned to what reform is
- 28:18doing? And it feels like in some ways
- 28:20this is right. Like, I feel like taking money
- 28:23away from GB Energy and giving it to SMRS feels to me like,
- 28:27again, just like an absolute nonsense.
- 28:29Like I feel like GB Energy should be doing innovation.
- 28:32It should be doing community projects.
- 28:33It should be doing those things, right?
- 28:35It should be trying to, to move the needle in that way.
- 28:37Like we don't need GB Energy to give like Rolls Royce or, or
- 28:41whoever else 2 1/2 billion pounds to, to, to get into the
- 28:45SMR business. If we want to change nuclear, if
- 28:47we want to, you know, get those get those big nuclear projects
- 28:49going and those small nuclear projects going, we should be
- 28:52cutting cutting regulations. What was Sizewell had the what I
- 28:55think the most complicated application in all of history.
- 28:5844,000 pages. I think I read just absolutely
- 29:01do Chris and that and that would be the thing that that changed
- 29:04it right? Make it commercially viable and
- 29:06then say, look, if companies want to come and invest, come
- 29:08and invest. The idea that GB Energy needs to
- 29:11step in. I just feel like that is that is
- 29:13just sort of playing the the shadow of reform.
- 29:15It does also seem that Labour is, I guess on the political
- 29:20side with a view to the the Holy Rood elections coming up be
- 29:24pitching nuclear as or building that up as a potential
- 29:28battleground against the SNP in these holy rood elections.
- 29:30We've seen, you know, this week with the on the day of the
- 29:34announcement of the new golden age of nuclear, I think was the
- 29:37phrasing that Labour used. We had Michael Shanks, the
- 29:40energy minister, the rather Glenn and MP he writing an op-ed
- 29:45in the in the Scotsman talking about how A and a sawa LED
- 29:50Scottish Labour government would would bring all these nuclear
- 29:52benefits to to to Scotland. And obviously the SNP has had a
- 29:56long standing stance against new nuclear development.
- 29:59And with I guess Torness, the last kind of remaining nuclear
- 30:04power station in Scotland set to, you know, begin powering
- 30:06down in in 20-30. I guess you know, that that
- 30:09might be that Labour might be seen this as a way to tap into
- 30:12that kind of I guess in industrial nostalgia that a lot
- 30:15of the the UK has in the you know, there is, I guess you
- 30:18know, has been a lot of history of Scotland in in nuclear power
- 30:21up in. So it does seem that nuclear
- 30:26areas is potentially firming as a as a as a battleground for for
- 30:30holy rood elections next. Year.
- 30:31Yeah, it definitely feels like, Yeah, that industrial nostalgia
- 30:34you call that. I think that's exactly what they
- 30:36do, except we joked about this before, before recording.
- 30:39But yeah, I was scrolling on TikTok last night and Ed
- 30:42Miliband appeared on my screen and he.
- 30:45Yeah, he was touting that golden age of nuclear political slogan.
- 30:49You can tell how good a political slogan is by how
- 30:51quickly you get fed up of it. And I'm already kind of like,
- 30:54I've heard it enough now. But yeah, he was saying the same
- 30:58thing. I think he said, you know, back
- 31:00when Britain actually built things was like the thing that
- 31:03he said it. Feels very reformed language,
- 31:06right? That.
- 31:06Yeah, exactly. Yeah.
- 31:08Do you know what? I, I hadn't really hadn't really
- 31:11thought of it in that way until you were speaking earlier.
- 31:14And I was like, jeez, that is the exact.
- 31:15Same. Well, they haven't gone quite as
- 31:17far as advocating to the restart in the coal mines in Wales just
- 31:20yet. So they're not quite at the
- 31:22level. But I just want to also come
- 31:23back to something you were talking about before it and you
- 31:25talked about, you know, reforms real, I guess position of power
- 31:29is not being in in government, but it is, you know, as being
- 31:33this opposition voice in this, this voice of discontent.
- 31:35But it is interesting also seeing what I guess some of
- 31:39their members do when they do actually get into government
- 31:42positions. And we've seen, I guess they do
- 31:44Mayor of Holland, East Yorkshire, Luke Campbell, you
- 31:47know, see, in the lead up to the election, there was Nigel Farage
- 31:51has been on a big anti net 0 crusade.
- 31:53There's a lot of, you know, energy transition projects going
- 31:57on in the Humber region around Holland, East Yorkshire got a
- 31:59lot of offshore wind development.
- 32:00A lot of, you know, we've just been speaking about Viking and
- 32:04East Coast cluster. So a lot of people in that
- 32:05region, they're, they're aware that their jobs are, or, you
- 32:09know, potentially future jobs for their, for their kids and
- 32:11their families will be coming from a lot of these renewable
- 32:15energy and clean energy projects.
- 32:16And so he's sort of gone against the grain of the, the wider
- 32:19Reform Party. And he said he's going back net
- 32:22zero and green energy products if they create jobs and benefits
- 32:25for the, for the region. So I think we saw the same from
- 32:28the the new mayor of Greater Lincolnshire, not long after she
- 32:31took on the mayoral position, was at an investment forum
- 32:33talking about how, you know, companies should come and invest
- 32:36in offshore wind. So, you know, sometimes it seems
- 32:39that the things that they will say in opposition don't match up
- 32:42with what they then turn around and do once they they do win,
- 32:46win the seat of power. Exactly that it's it's an
- 32:48interesting talking point, Meg is one that we'll be cycling
- 32:51back to over the coming months and years, let's face it.
- 32:55And the build up to the Scottish election but probably also the
- 32:59UK election if polling's polling.
- 33:01Continues still having the same conversation in 2029.
- 33:04It's a bit like, hey, we're still asking what about ACORN
- 33:07after a for God support, But I guess that does it for this
- 33:11weeks episode of Energy Voice Out loud.
- 33:14Thank you very much chaps for joining me today and thank you
- 33:17very much for listening. But if you'd like to see Mr.
- 33:19Reed in person, he'll be in Liverpool in the coming weeks,
- 33:23Isn't that right? June the 26th there will be
- 33:25square. We'll be talking about high net,
- 33:27all things CCS. It's going to be a.
- 33:28Crack. Well, that's very topical, so
- 33:30make sure you get your tickets, make sure you sign up.
- 33:32And if you want to stay up to date with all the comings and
- 33:35goings from the energy sector, stay tuned to Energy Voice Out
- 33:38Loud.