Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E049: Invert, Always Invert with Fidelity’s Chris Kuiper
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company on ramps. Multi institution custody is a
- 0:35segregated institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:39institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:43unique permissions have been met at on RAMP we understand that
- 0:47your Bitcoin journey is a multi generational pursuit catalyzed
- 0:50by the ideals of perseverance, aspiration and legacy.
- 0:54That's why we're proud to introduce on RAMP Heritage, a
- 0:57suite of private client services dedicated to ensuring your
- 1:00Bitcoin legacy is preserved and passed on, embodying the true
- 1:04essence of wealth that goes beyond mere numbers.
- 1:07If you would like to learn more, please schedule a consultation.
- 1:10What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 1:14we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous
- 1:18excrement ever assembled in the history of Darkness. 1974,
- 1:25198792972000, and whatever we're going to call this, it's all
- 1:29just the same thing over and over.
- 1:31We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 1:37when we sell. And we're live back with Chris
- 1:44Kuiper from Fidelity. Welcome back.
- 1:49Now thank you. Great to be back.
- 1:51Feels like it's been an eternity since we last had you on.
- 1:55Wasn't that long ago September 15th, 2023 lead up to the end of
- 2:00last year, lead up to the ETF approvals and launch earlier
- 2:06this year. A lot is going on.
- 2:08We've had the price ripped to all time highs fall 20% below
- 2:13that. We're settling a little above
- 2:16where where it fell last month. We had the halving.
- 2:23It's not going on in six months, seven months, however long it's
- 2:26been what what, what are your thoughts generally over the last
- 2:33three months of 2023, the first four months of 2024?
- 2:38Yeah. So we we had the the 2023 bull
- 2:41market 155%, which seems like in traditional finance people
- 2:46weren't even paying attention to it's.
- 2:47It's just funny how we get so accustomed to the large swings
- 2:51in numbers that it just doesn't even feel that much.
- 2:53But I have to remind myself, if this was an asset class that I
- 2:56was looking at or a stock back in my former traditional finance
- 3:00days, 155% rally in one year, one calendar year would just be
- 3:05absolutely phenomenal. But it seems like people weren't
- 3:08even really picking up on it and in the traditional finance world
- 3:11until the very end of the year and then going into 2024 with
- 3:15obviously all the chatter around the the exchange trade products
- 3:18being approved. And so we got the approval price
- 3:21pulled back at least 10% there and everyone said see classic by
- 3:27the rumor, sell the news, Wall Street adage.
- 3:29And I was, I was in that camp, I was kind of expecting it as
- 3:32well. You saw this in the data, you
- 3:33saw things like open interest moving up, you saw perpetual
- 3:37futures, the funding rate spiked to 30% on an annualized basis.
- 3:41So a lot of speculators obviously anticipating the
- 3:45exchange traded products and then when it happened it all
- 3:47that kind of unwound what I was not expecting and I think a lot
- 3:51of people were not expecting happily I I can say is the flows
- 3:55we saw into these products weeks after so end of February,
- 3:58beginning of March of this year, absolutely phenomenal flows of
- 4:02of hundreds of millions of dollars per day even on some
- 4:05days. And the the big question, of
- 4:07course was where is this all coming from?
- 4:10Who's who's buying it? And it was a bit of a head
- 4:13scratcher for me as well because I thought if anyone's really
- 4:16invested into Bitcoin and they've done the homework and
- 4:19they've they're they've come around to the idea that this
- 4:21deserves a core allocation, they're on the investment
- 4:25thesis. They've already made their
- 4:27allocation there. There's plenty of ways before
- 4:29these products to get exposure. It was not that hard.
- 4:32And obviously Fidelity and others like yourself had been
- 4:35offering these services and so I had to believe that a lot of it
- 4:41was speculative money just flowing into it.
- 4:44They saw the rally last year they they finally said it's it's
- 4:47easy to get exposure, their finger was on the buy button and
- 4:50and they kind of plowed in. And so then the question now
- 4:53that we're faced with was how many people are going to stay in
- 4:55if they were just in it for a trade as the price has now
- 4:58pulled back a little bit again. We've digested some of those big
- 5:01gains. You know at one point we're up
- 5:03almost 70% just this year alone and this is on the rally of of
- 5:07last year. And so we've we've seen
- 5:09definitely some outflows now the dust, the dust has settled.
- 5:13We we had about 3 weeks of net outflows.
- 5:16But interestingly, I do think there is a pretty good cohort of
- 5:20people who are buying it for the longer term and it's the people
- 5:23who maybe already had an allocation but now they can also
- 5:27allocate in accounts they couldn't before, namely the IR
- 5:31as the four O1 KS, that sort of thing.
- 5:33And you know I can't say too much on it, but even our
- 5:36internal data supports this. One of the largest types of
- 5:39accounts that have bought these products are IR as.
- 5:44So it'd be people like you and I who we've maybe already gotten
- 5:47our exposure, but now we want to unlock a new, a new Ave. or new
- 5:50account where we can get exposure to to Bitcoin through
- 5:53these products. So we've also seen this in the
- 5:56data with the outflows. The outflows haven't been as
- 5:58much as you would anticipate with the price being down.
- 6:01So I do think there's still still a coat full cohort of
- 6:05people who have made that core allocation.
- 6:07There's going to be a lot of traders too.
- 6:09You see that in the the volume, the trading volume.
- 6:12And then the final thing I'll say here before continue to just
- 6:14ramble on is, is the under appreciated story.
- 6:18I think that people aren't aren't fully grasping.
- 6:21They they conceptually know this, but I don't think they're
- 6:23fully grasping the numbers is that this is going to be a long
- 6:26slow burn. I think of demand all these
- 6:29products, they're still going through compliance procedures,
- 6:33they're going through the due diligence.
- 6:35A lot of them aren't even on the major platforms yet and it just
- 6:38takes time and anecdotally this is what we're hearing.
- 6:40We're hearing from advisors and others that we're not soliciting
- 6:43it. It's only clients coming to us.
- 6:45So that's another unlock that has to happen.
- 6:47And when they're doing it, they're not talking about let's
- 6:50do 510%, they're saying let's dip our toes in at half a
- 6:54percent and even that is still a huge number with this 10s of
- 6:58trillions of dollars of of advisor and RIA market.
- 7:02So I think that's the bigger story over the next 12 to 24
- 7:05months and I don't think people are fully grasping how big those
- 7:08numbers can be and how steady of a bid that could create under
- 7:13this whole market going forward. Yeah, I think it's very
- 7:18underappreciated. I actually got dinner with my
- 7:20neighbor on Tuesday night. He's a wealth manager at Morgan
- 7:23Stanley and he was explaining to me that they're going through
- 7:27the process at Morgan Stanley to make it so it they don't, they
- 7:32can only allocate right now. They can only allocate if their
- 7:35client solicit it. But they're going through the
- 7:37process to get educated internally so that they can
- 7:42actually go sell these products and talking about that slow
- 7:45burn. I think people are curious like
- 7:48how how much demand you alluded to it, but how much inflows
- 7:53could these unlocks for these wealth managers bring to these
- 7:58ETF products? Yeah, absolutely.
- 8:03I mean you can do kind of the the back of the napkin math of
- 8:06what's what's the market 10s of trillions.
- 8:09If at least half of those people or 25% of those people want an
- 8:12allocation then they do whatever you want to say one 2% you're
- 8:16talking, you're talking about a lot of a lot of money here and
- 8:21critically that's money that's not just trading in and out of
- 8:24of the do it yourself, the self-directed brokerage people,
- 8:28it's it's the advised clients. So they're only checking their
- 8:32portfolio with their advisor quarterly or semi annually or
- 8:35annually and so they're making changes at the margins, they're
- 8:38rebalancing every year. I I do think that's the bigger
- 8:41demand story and again people we all know that conceptually.
- 8:45But then if you think about the actual numbers in the math and
- 8:48then how many coins are on exchanges that continues to go
- 8:51down, How many coins are are being put away for for cold
- 8:55storage long term. I I I think it could be a pretty
- 8:59interesting dynamic in the in the next say 12 months plus and
- 9:04then you add in all the other macro stuff on top of that and
- 9:06it could get really interesting. We talked about dampening
- 9:10volatility in the individual retirement accounts are funny
- 9:13because they're it helps in the counter cyclical bid in the
- 9:16sense of people buy out of those accounts on both sides either
- 9:19their net new position because they don't think of those assets
- 9:22as being available or long term savings.
- 9:25And then what I've seen in previous firms is general and I
- 9:29think to your point Chris is that individuals that had
- 9:32exposure either when the market starts to correct, they look for
- 9:36liquidity to buy more Bitcoin or when the market is in its
- 9:40natural down cycle and they're you know, education is you know
- 9:44proceeding or growing and their convictions growing, they're
- 9:46also looking for more liquidity. And then those individual
- 9:49retirement accounts are a natural place to tap into.
- 9:52And so I think that also helps like this, this the natural bid,
- 9:55but then also from a volatility perspective, you know moving
- 9:59forward. Yeah, absolutely.
- 10:02And especially if they they put these things on autopilot like a
- 10:05lot of people do and they they create rules that, you know,
- 10:07good advisor usually creates some of these rules with the
- 10:10plan and as long as they follow it, of course they're all
- 10:12humans, but as long as they follow it, they should be adding
- 10:15more when their position's down. So if they said I'm going to do
- 10:185% market has a 50% drawdown, they're going to add more into
- 10:23that down market. And then of course when it goes
- 10:25up, they're going to take some off the table.
- 10:27So it will will be interesting to see as not only this whole
- 10:30asset class just gets bigger and that dampens the volatility, but
- 10:34then also as you get these other players that we haven't had
- 10:37before, these other types or investor personas if you will,
- 10:42that we haven't had before, I think that's going to be really
- 10:44interesting. Yeah.
- 10:47So, So what you mentioned it in the start of that was you sort
- 10:50of talked about the different cohorts of who would be buyers
- 10:53of these ETF products. And the the key bit in there to
- 10:57me was that from what you guys are seeing or hearing, you think
- 11:03it may be largely people who have already adopted Bitcoin or
- 11:07crypto maybe who are now allocating their IRA funds into
- 11:13these ETFs. Which is to say that, that
- 11:17there's been nobody new yet, right?
- 11:19There's there's there hasn't been.
- 11:20You know on the whole not a lot of fresh new interest new
- 11:25eyeballs arriving yet which sort of lines up with what you'd
- 11:29expect from a market cycle point of view of traditionally we've
- 11:33seen a lot more interest when Bitcoin is at new highs and
- 11:38still running hot, right. And and that's when people can't
- 11:41resist showing up who have who have not participated before.
- 11:46So is is that what you know I guess that that's news to me and
- 11:51it's exciting to hear because it's would potentially mean that
- 11:55if the halving does what it has done historically and we start
- 12:00to have another rally here into new all time highs that only
- 12:05then especially as these Rias start to clear these ETF
- 12:10products for inclusion in in in in how they're operating.
- 12:15We could start to see a whole new cohort of of new investors
- 12:19arriving to Bitcoin via the ETFs that have yet to partake at all.
- 12:24Is is that kind of your your sense or perspective there?
- 12:29Yeah, I think that's definitely part of it.
- 12:31So if you kind of think of how this this works out, you know
- 12:34like I said we don't know exactly.
- 12:36There's obviously clearly a bunch of retail traders given
- 12:39the volume and some of the stuff we've seen on our side with our
- 12:41data. But like I said before one of
- 12:43the largest accounts is IRA. So you could probably presume
- 12:46like you just said those are people who are already on board
- 12:50the the net new will either be driven by just the price which
- 12:55is the greatest advertiser for for Bitcoin.
- 12:57And of course people are going to be looking at that and and
- 13:00realizing it very soon especially if we go back and
- 13:03break the all time high once again.
- 13:05And historically that's been a really interesting period when
- 13:07you you hit and barely break the last all time high of years ago
- 13:11and then you you can pull back and then you come back and you
- 13:13you blast through it the second time.
- 13:15But, but I think the bigger story is once these products get
- 13:19turned on on all these platforms, so as you were all
- 13:23just saying earlier, a lot of advisors, they can't, they can't
- 13:27initiate the conversation, they can't quote sell it that it has
- 13:30to be client led, the client has to come to them and then they
- 13:33might be able to say, OK, I can accommodate that.
- 13:36Some firms still won't even do that.
- 13:39But once they're on platform they're fully vetted then
- 13:41they've got the green light to actually go and proactively
- 13:44market this to their clients or educate them.
- 13:48And that's when you could get a whole new cohort because now
- 13:51we're to the point where put aside all the stuff about the
- 13:55the politics and the even the investment thesis and store of
- 13:58value and and all of that. And if people just start to look
- 14:02at this, especially advisors, through an objective lens of the
- 14:05statistics of it, it's going to be very hard to ignore.
- 14:08You know, 1 by 1, all these dominoes keep going down.
- 14:11Before it was, well, there's no way I can support it.
- 14:14There's not a exchange traded product or it's too young, it's
- 14:17too small, it's too volatile. All of these things have now
- 14:21been dismantled 1 by 1. And so as an advisor, they have
- 14:24very few excuses to not at least look at this.
- 14:27Now that's not to say it's, it's still might not be right for
- 14:30some people of course, but the they're, they're running out of
- 14:33excuses to push this aside and not deal with it.
- 14:35And now they have to deal with it.
- 14:37They can deal with it. It's not at all a burden anymore
- 14:40with these these products in terms of opening new accounts
- 14:43and paperwork and tracking the cost basis and all that kind of
- 14:46stuff. And so I think that's where
- 14:48where we're at now, where they've got a fiduciary duty, a
- 14:52lot of these, and they should be looking at this.
- 14:54I always like to invert it. Where before I would say here's
- 14:59all the cases for Bitcoin and here's the investment thesis.
- 15:02And I, I say not to to take Charlie Munger, who I respect in
- 15:07many ways, but of course he absolutely hated Bitcoin.
- 15:10So hopefully he's not rolling over in his grave, but his
- 15:13famous phrase is invert, always invert.
- 15:16And so that's the thing I'm trying to push now just invert
- 15:18it and say why don't you own this, I mean on paper this is
- 15:22the best performing asset. It's not correlated to other
- 15:25stuff in your portfolio. And as as you know as finance
- 15:27people, that's the Holy Grail. The only free lunch in finance
- 15:30is to add something that's not correlated to increase your risk
- 15:33adjusted returns. And you can just go go through
- 15:36all that, the tics of this and say why you tell me why you
- 15:40don't own this anymore, you're running out of excuses and
- 15:43volatility is still the big one. We can talk about that, but I
- 15:46think that's just a convenient excuse because they all own
- 15:49stuff that's just as volatile or even more volatile than Bitcoin.
- 15:52So it's their job as a risk manager to handle the
- 15:55volatility, not just say it's off the table entirely.
- 15:59Yeah, I I love it. I love the the, the image of the
- 16:02future that that that paints and and I think I would love to get
- 16:07your thoughts on this. I think one of the things that
- 16:09has surprised me about the first 3-4 months of the ETFs has been
- 16:14the the extent of reflexivity, let's let's call it that, in in
- 16:20the flows behavior from demand in a sense that when the price
- 16:26was running pretty hot in March, February, March, there was a ton
- 16:33of demand. There was $500 million per
- 16:35trading day coming in, you know 9000 Bitcoin per day for a while
- 16:39there 10X. But we were mining at the time
- 16:41per day and then it slowed down, right.
- 16:45And then you had these net outflows as the price went down,
- 16:48suddenly the ETF, net ETF behavior was was outflows.
- 16:54And of course GBTC is a big part of that story both in January
- 16:58and in, in April. But I was a little surprised, I
- 17:04think, about the extent of how ETF flows, sort of acted a lot
- 17:10like we see with retail Bitcoin buyers on on exchanges of, you
- 17:15know, they pile in when the price is going up and then they
- 17:18they sell when the price is going down.
- 17:20And then that reflexivity reinforces itself.
- 17:24But what you're talking about here with the slow methodical
- 17:29burn and increasing rate of burn towards, you know, managed
- 17:34wealth moving into these ETF products in Bitcoin in general
- 17:39that would be that would replace that reflexivity with a a more
- 17:45passive consistent bid, Is that I guess would love to get your
- 17:50thoughts on on was the reflexivity over the last 3-4
- 17:53months surprising to you guys And then do you think that that
- 17:57will continue or be replaced by a different trend?
- 18:02No, I I agree with most of that. I I do think there is the
- 18:05reflexivity like you talked about it, it amplifies it
- 18:08especially because these have the the cash create structure
- 18:11rather than in kind. They have to go out and buy and
- 18:13sell all all of these coins. And so that kind of adds to it
- 18:16as well I think. But over time we'll see more
- 18:20products built on top of it. We don't have options on these
- 18:24yet. So that will help.
- 18:26You know, historically academic research has shown derivatives
- 18:29markets over time to help dampen volatility because you can move
- 18:33some of that speculative behavior to those and then over
- 18:36time to like you're saying you're going to get a bigger
- 18:38cohort owning these for the longer term rather than just
- 18:41trading them. Of course, once they launched,
- 18:43it was the traders, the speculators that have that
- 18:45really want to get out of the gate and start trading with
- 18:47these, right. I don't think there was a lot of
- 18:48people who who were just dying to, to put it into their
- 18:51accounts right away if if they hadn't already, as we talked
- 18:54about before. So I think that will definitely
- 18:56dampen the volatility over time. And then just going through the
- 19:00financialization process of all of this and we don't have a lot
- 19:04of corollaries, but we've seen some, for example, gold, we
- 19:08mentioned this in our recent volatility piece.
- 19:11Gold had to go through a price discovery process once it was
- 19:14open for basically all investors.
- 19:17Not only did we sever the ties to gold, the dollar to gold in
- 19:211971 with the Nixon Shock, but shortly after that it was also
- 19:24finally legal for U.S. citizens to own gold.
- 19:27They couldn't even own gold as an investment.
- 19:29And so gold went through a price discovery process.
- 19:32Its volatility spiked, went from $35.00 an ounce to over 800 back
- 19:36in 1970s dollars. And then we saw another kind of
- 19:40rediscovery and price discovery process with gold in 2008 and
- 19:45and people coming around to it. So but of course now it's a $15
- 19:48trillion asset class. It's in many portfolios for
- 19:52various reasons. People do and can still
- 19:55speculate it with with futures and other derivatives.
- 19:57But overall it's it's much more stable.
- 20:00And so while obviously Bitcoin is very different than gold, if
- 20:03you look at just the financialization track COVID, I
- 20:07see a lot of. A lot of similarities where it's
- 20:09it's got to go through this process and it's going to follow
- 20:12some of the same, some of the same track.
- 20:15We haven't even talked about what happens when people learn
- 20:18that they they don't have to rebalance.
- 20:20I'm pretty confident everybody on this call, I can speak for at
- 20:22least three people don't rebalance their Bitcoin
- 20:24positions when they get to, you know, waiting there, you know,
- 20:27whatever their targets are. So you mentioned there's the
- 20:29automated stuff. But once people get to a certain
- 20:32track, they're like, wait, what am I rebalancing to?
- 20:35Yeah, that will be very interesting.
- 20:38I still think for the average person, if you just think of
- 20:41like a financial advisor, it's just so ingrained to rebalance,
- 20:44diversify, hold a hold a portfolio.
- 20:48The interesting thing about Bitcoin though is it has a very
- 20:51unique characteristic where rebalancing can actually be very
- 20:56good. Obviously not if if, if you're
- 20:58just you know kind of the crazies like us that might just
- 21:01want to let it run. But if you're in that vein of of
- 21:05of the regular kind of academic research and and what financial
- 21:10advisors are trained to do, because bitcoins returns and we
- 21:14have this in our latest piece as well, are are asymmetric.
- 21:17They're skewed to the right. So if you look at a histogram of
- 21:20monthly returns for Bitcoin versus the S&P 500, the S&P 500
- 21:24has monthly returns that look very normal, the normal
- 21:26distribution. It's got a mean of like 1.11
- 21:29point 2% per month. So it's positive, but it's very
- 21:32normally distributed and Bitcoin doesn't have much in the middle.
- 21:36There's very few months where it does nothing.
- 21:38It's either going up a lot or going down a lot, which of
- 21:42course scares people. But if you look really closely,
- 21:44there's more occurrences that the tail is fatter on the right,
- 21:48the positive side. So if you're constantly
- 21:51rebalancing, you're you're in effect harvesting that
- 21:54volatility and as long as that remains that that relationship
- 21:58remains a positive skew to the right, you're going to do better
- 22:02rebalancing Bitcoin regularly and harvesting that volatility
- 22:07compared to any other asset class.
- 22:09So even if people do do this and they don't, and they do follow
- 22:12the general practice of rebalancing, they're going to be
- 22:15much better off than doing the regular rebalancing and a lot of
- 22:18the other asset classes. Which is an awesome thing to see
- 22:23as we as we think about you know nominal versus real returns and
- 22:26being able to you know impact your portfolio as you think
- 22:29about long term savings. I do think that'll be that'll
- 22:33become part of the like winning strategy around Rias in
- 22:38particular like why you shouldn't, why you wouldn't want
- 22:40to would want to incorporate Bitcoin into all of your clients
- 22:43portfolios is because you get this sort of free yield.
- 22:46If you're following that that methodology of like of trimming
- 22:52your position when it's had a really good year which happens
- 22:56three years out of four and then adding to your position on that
- 22:59on that down year whenever when there's blood in the streets.
- 23:04If RA as actually managed to to do what most humans can't do.
- 23:10And so that was a big of of actually lean into that
- 23:13methodology when it feels like the corn is dying when you know
- 23:16the next FTX blows up or whatever happens, then it's
- 23:20possible for that to be the winning strategy for how RI as
- 23:23can get a little extra juice for their clients and and and
- 23:27differentiate themselves versus their peers by by using you know
- 23:33by having Bitcoin in a portfolio and adding to it when when
- 23:37blood's in the streets. Well, luckily for these RI as
- 23:41they have people like the, the research team at Fidelity diving
- 23:45into the data, so they're better equipped to actually make these
- 23:48decisions. So I think this is a good time
- 23:50to jump into the recent report you guys did on Bitcoin's
- 23:53volatility and sort of walk through the mechanics of how
- 23:56this has worked historically and what you guys are seeing in the
- 23:59data. So, Logan, Yeah, absolutely.
- 24:03So, so this report was written by the one of the researchers on
- 24:06my team, Zach Wain. Excuse me, Zach Wainwright.
- 24:09And he has two parts to this, this report.
- 24:12The first part is kind of just the facts of volatility, you
- 24:17know is is what you've heard actually true if we run the
- 24:20numbers And from a research perspective, I'll be honest when
- 24:23I kind of thought of this, I was like well maybe we'll look into
- 24:26it, but we probably won't use it because that's just really basic
- 24:29table stakes of research. It's not very interesting or
- 24:32ground breaking. But even I was surprised when I
- 24:34ran the numbers as to where we are now.
- 24:37To be fair, we're we're maybe in a anomalous low for bitcoin's
- 24:41volatility right now. Overall, if you take an average,
- 24:44it's still there. You can see it's 73% annualized
- 24:48Vol, so multiple multiples higher than the riskiest thing
- 24:52in most people's portfolio, which is equities, right, Or or
- 24:56surprisingly even commodities might be a little more volatile.
- 24:59So on average it's still very volatile.
- 25:01But if you zoom out, you have to remember we actually went from a
- 25:04200 Vol asset in Bitcoin down to an average of 73.
- 25:09And more recently we're actually at around 4045.
- 25:13We even hit a low on on the 90 day ball of 33.
- 25:16And so bitcoins actually currently less volatile than
- 25:20almost half of the magnificent 7 stocks that you can see there
- 25:23Meta, NVIDIA, Tesla and these are just examples to to name a
- 25:27few. You know this is what the stats
- 25:28saying. We're not saying anything about
- 25:30these stocks as investments obviously, but many people own
- 25:34these stocks because these are the absolute mega cap stocks and
- 25:38they've no qualms about owning them because it's it comes down
- 25:40to again, your risk management and usually your position size
- 25:44is the best way to handle that. And so that's why I I'm
- 25:46increasingly running out of patience when people say it's
- 25:49too volatile. I don't know if it's if it's
- 25:51ignorance which is what we're trying to combat with research
- 25:54like this or if it's just a convenience excuse because they
- 25:57don't want to deal with it and that resonates with people like
- 25:59yeah, I don't want to own anything that's volatile.
- 26:01The other thing we show in the paper is, well, I'll make one
- 26:04point quick on the on the where it ranks.
- 26:07Currently 33 S&P 500 stocks are more volatile than Bitcoin, or
- 26:12at least when we wrote this paper a few weeks ago.
- 26:14Back in October, there were over 90 S&P 500 stocks more volatile
- 26:19than Bitcoin when Bitcoin was at a real low.
- 26:21So almost 20% or 1/5 of the entire S&P 500.
- 26:25And again, those are the largest companies.
- 26:29So again, this gets gets you, gives you an idea that there's
- 26:31there's fewer and fewer excuses for this and I don't think
- 26:34people realize how far this asset class has matured.
- 26:38And then to your second point of RI as using this to get a little
- 26:41more yield, you are more than compensated or a little more
- 26:45returns, I should say you're more than compensated for taking
- 26:49on that volatility. And you can see this in the
- 26:51sharp ratio which is is of course your your unit of or how
- 26:56much return are you getting for each unit of risk.
- 26:59But in finance, as you know, risk is just standard deviation.
- 27:04Well, standard deviation is just a statistical measure of how far
- 27:07something moves across from its mean, how far away it is from
- 27:10its mean. So you can actually have good
- 27:13volatility, or you can have bad volatility.
- 27:15Nobody cares that bitcoins volatile when it's going up
- 27:18again, that right tail, that distribution.
- 27:21So you can do something like the Sortino ratio, which only looks
- 27:24at downside volatility, bad volatility.
- 27:27And here Bitcoin blows everything else out of the water
- 27:30and when you compare it to the SP500 or or basically any other
- 27:33asset class, so again you're as a as someone who's looking to
- 27:38increase the risk adjusted returns, you shouldn't be
- 27:41looking at just the risk. The question, the pertinent
- 27:43question is, well, I'm taking on risk, but how much am I getting
- 27:47in return And you're getting way more in return for taking on
- 27:50that risk than any other asset class out there or at least
- 27:53historically. Of course this is not
- 27:55predictive, but just saying historically this is what's been
- 27:57true. And so that's that's half of the
- 28:00paper of what we want to get through.
- 28:02And the second-half, I won't get all into it right now just cause
- 28:05it's a lot, but we can get into it later if you want.
- 28:07It proposes, Zach proposes a model of looking at historical
- 28:13periods when volatility is very low, but looking at on chain
- 28:16indicators like the percentages of addresses in profit is high.
- 28:21It's a very rare time and we're in a time right now.
- 28:24We've only been in this period two other times when you have
- 28:27low volatility, but the price is moving up and and a lot of
- 28:30addresses in profits. So it's that time right before
- 28:33historically a big bull run has occurred because if you think of
- 28:36market psychology, it's when everyone's kind of thrown in the
- 28:39towel, but then the price is going up kind of more subtly.
- 28:44And so volatility gets compressed, compressed,
- 28:47compressed kind of like a spring and then all of a sudden it
- 28:49explodes as the price explodes to the upside.
- 28:52So again, that's not a a prediction, but just an
- 28:54environment that we currently could be in if the past is is
- 28:58any at all the prelude to the future here.
- 29:02Fascinating and and to add to that, I think it's notable that
- 29:07it you know, while it feels like we've been going sideways or
- 29:09down forever, it has only been what like 7-8 weeks and in 2016
- 29:17it took us 15 weeks once we bumped up against the prior all
- 29:20time high before we decisively blew through that and then in
- 29:252020 it took five weeks. So you know we're we're par for
- 29:30the course right now and it and yet as you point out Chris, it
- 29:34feels like people have thrown in the towel.
- 29:37Yeah, There's another chart in there that gets at that of or a
- 29:40table I should say where it shows when we hit the last all
- 29:44time high and then broke through it where how far in percentage
- 29:49terms were we up only one year later.
- 29:51And then also I think we look at how quickly it double S after
- 29:56these events as well. And so again things happen in
- 30:00Bitcoin world very, very much at the extremes and very much
- 30:04lopsidedly, right. You can just be sitting.
- 30:06Grind around for a long time and then all of a sudden within a
- 30:09few weeks, it's like years have passed by in terms of of price,
- 30:12action and appreciation. Yeah, this, this report has a
- 30:16ton of great data while we're on it.
- 30:19And Chris, where can everybody find this data so they can look
- 30:22through? The report themselves Fidelity
- 30:25Digital assets.com and then you can either do forward slash
- 30:29research or just click on the research tab at the top.
- 30:33Yeah, there's a a few other reports, the Q 12024 signals and
- 30:37then the Bitcoin having. We'll we'll link to those two
- 30:40and then this one in the show notes for for folks to view as
- 30:43well. Great.
- 30:44Since you mentioned it Michael too, I think that's another
- 30:47important topic to bring up for where we stand today.
- 30:52We just had to having a few weeks ago here.
- 30:55And again I wonder if it is that we're in this anomalous period
- 31:02that you described Chris, because we have the halving and
- 31:06typically you have a bunch of hash rate come off the price
- 31:09either dumps before or goes sideways after.
- 31:12But we have had this catalyst of the ETFs leading up to the
- 31:15halving, which is a massive catalyst before this massive
- 31:20quadrennial event within Bitcoin, which is a halving of
- 31:26the the block reward subsidy, which certainly has an effect on
- 31:32the supply of Bitcoin on the market, an effect on the mining
- 31:35industry specifically in their economics.
- 31:40Yes, one thing that's we we've been following closely because
- 31:43it only happens every four years.
- 31:44On one hand it's like well it happened just as we predict.
- 31:48You know the code predicted not any any of us obviously, but as
- 31:51the code stated in TikTok next block we go on and kind of a
- 31:55shrug. But on the other hand it only
- 31:56happens every four years. So there's always something new
- 31:59or a little more interesting wrinkle each time.
- 32:02And so we've since we've only had a few of these so far.
- 32:05The big wrinkle this time as you mentioned was the exchange
- 32:08traded products. I think that clearly helped
- 32:11propel us to new highs before the having.
- 32:14So this time was clearly different in that regard.
- 32:18But of course the big question we get from everyone is, well,
- 32:21if we're hitting a new all time high before the having, this
- 32:23time is the having getting priced in, are more people aware
- 32:27of it? And there's a little bit of
- 32:29that. One area I've noticed some
- 32:31reflexivity like we talked about before was if you look at Google
- 32:35search trends, the past havings were nothing, nothing, nothing
- 32:39searching for the term Bitcoin having and then a huge spike on
- 32:43the week of and then down and then nothing again.
- 32:46This time we actually had a lot of movement weeks and even a
- 32:49couple months prior to it. And then of course it moved up
- 32:52during the halving as well and we got way more search volume.
- 32:55So as more people become aware of Bitcoin because of the all
- 33:00time high in price, I think they were Googling Bitcoin and then
- 33:04the halving came up as something that was going to happen soon.
- 33:07And then they would maybe research the halving and that
- 33:09might give them more confidence in Bitcoin and it's fixed supply
- 33:13and wide supply is actually going down and lending to that
- 33:19investment case. And then so you get that
- 33:21reflexivity over and over that pushes up price again.
- 33:24So I think that was different this time and of course whether
- 33:27or not it can be priced in, I'm still in the camp that it it
- 33:30wasn't and isn't still fully priced in just because basic
- 33:34economics, you've got supply and demand.
- 33:36If you're cutting your incoming supply in half, that has to have
- 33:39an effect. Now of course the question is
- 33:41how much, but I don't think anyone can say that there's no
- 33:44effect there. And one of the charts I've been
- 33:46seeing circulating around in favor of this isn't really going
- 33:51to affect it. Is the the chart showing or data
- 33:54showing that 450 coins per day, that's her new level other than
- 33:59900, that's less than 1% of the global trading volume.
- 34:04And I I'd be curious your thoughts on this as well because
- 34:06I haven't fully fleshed this out, but I'm, I'm just thinking,
- 34:09well, that's true. We have to acknowledge that
- 34:12that's a very small percent. So it's not like we're having a
- 34:15major supply shock like we did in the past, but that's also
- 34:19just trading volume, people just trading back and forth some of
- 34:21the same coins to me and I'm not exactly sure how you measure
- 34:24this. To me, what's more important is
- 34:26you've got less supply coming in and you've got more and more
- 34:28people taking supply off the market off of the exchanges.
- 34:32That's just fewer and fewer coins to to go around and and be
- 34:36put into cold storage. So eventually that has to
- 34:38trickle into into the markets as well.
- 34:42The other reason I don't think it's fully priced in is is you
- 34:45now have a very large and robust publicly traded miner industry
- 34:50now. And so as a thought experiment,
- 34:53if the price of Bitcoin were to, you know, price in the halving
- 34:57and it would go from 50K to 200K or whatever people's number is,
- 35:02that would blow out the margins of these miners.
- 35:05They would have such incredible margins that if you're a capital
- 35:08allocator you're going to say why would I buy spot Bitcoin
- 35:10when I can take advantage of these miners that are doing
- 35:13amazing work here with really, really good good margins here.
- 35:16And so the capital would naturally flow and find an
- 35:19equilibrium between people allocating the spot versus
- 35:22allocating to the miners. But those are just some of the
- 35:24reasons I'm I'm still a little more in the camp of it can't
- 35:28fully be priced in and then you just have the whole demand side
- 35:31on top of it and and these cycles have followed the
- 35:34liquidity cycles we seem to be ticking up on, on liquidity as
- 35:37well. So it's really hard to say.
- 35:39It's hard to disentangle these two things.
- 35:42Yeah, I think, I think everybody on this call doesn't, you know,
- 35:44fully buy in either it's a efficient market hypothesis or
- 35:47specifically for Bitcoin. And the easiest example is like
- 35:50you can't price in reflexivity, like when the market starts
- 35:53running, like you can't price in where it goes.
- 35:55And the demand and all the things that are associated with
- 35:57that supply constraint and the price skyrocketing with it, like
- 36:01what, how that further propels the price and then the demand
- 36:06like you can't, you can't predict that.
- 36:09No, but the school of thought that none of this is priced in,
- 36:12you don't even have to focus solely on the halving, you just
- 36:15zoom out. People don't understand Bitcoin,
- 36:16People don't understand money. Most people don't understand the
- 36:20systemic nature of the incumbent, the systemic
- 36:22fragility within the incumbent system.
- 36:26And most people still think, whether we like it or not, that
- 36:30Bitcoin is just some Ponzi scheme Tulla bubble, and they
- 36:33don't really understand what it is.
- 36:35And so that fundamentally cannot be priced in.
- 36:39I feel like micro strategy, a great example of this, like I
- 36:42think people forget in 2020 where that like weird little it
- 36:45was like 8 to 12 for months at a time and we know that there's
- 36:48been this constant bit. It's like how do you price in
- 36:50micro strategies demand in the market like single entity then
- 36:56yeah. Yeah that was actually an
- 36:59example. I've I've seen some people give
- 37:01as well. We we kind of had a having you
- 37:03had an A buyer of X amount of Bitcoin a large publicly traded
- 37:07company buying kind of indiscriminate of price.
- 37:11So again they didn't move the market in a massive way, at
- 37:15least as we can tell. But of course nobody knows these
- 37:18things. The the market is a complex
- 37:20almost like Organism that nobody knows what all of these things
- 37:24have an effect on. But all the same basic economics
- 37:28101 says well that that has to have, that has to have an
- 37:31effect, it's just how much an effect or what were some of the
- 37:34other competing factors against it.
- 37:36And so with this having we we're only a few weeks in.
- 37:39So we we don't know exactly, but one of the data points we're
- 37:42seeing of this diminished supply entering the market, it's being
- 37:46filled by these long term holders.
- 37:49So the one stat we were watching very closely because this time
- 37:53was different once again was things like the number or
- 37:57percentage of coins not moved in over a year.
- 38:00That hit an all time high of 70% at the beginning of this year or
- 38:05late last year. And going into the exchange
- 38:07trade products and approval and then also into the halving as we
- 38:11rallied this year that finally started to move down.
- 38:14So these these holders held all through twenty 23155% rally
- 38:18didn't cause him to budget at all and now we're finally seeing
- 38:21that start to take down. It's still high I think around
- 38:2364% but that's natural and that's natural of the cycle and
- 38:27our you mentioned our signals report, we've we did move our
- 38:30midterm rating to neutral because we are kind of in the
- 38:33middle in terms of these cyclical indicators.
- 38:37But I think that's where some of the supply is coming in to fill
- 38:40the reduced supply and the having side, it's these long
- 38:42term holders that are now finally unlocking that and and
- 38:45giving the new demand the supply that they want.
- 38:51Yeah, that's right. That's the only way that the the
- 38:54supply demand price equilibrium can be reestablished.
- 38:57When you cut supply creation is for the price to drift upwards
- 39:01to a point where holders bring their coins to market, you know
- 39:06they become sellers and then that supply fills that gap.
- 39:09But back to your earlier point of, I feel passionately about
- 39:13this, I think that the, the trading volume is one of the
- 39:17great red herrings about understanding the having and its
- 39:22impacts on the price of Bitcoin. And and you know, everybody
- 39:28always does that. And they look at the traded
- 39:30volume and see there's, oh, there's billions, billions and
- 39:33billions of of like $10 billion worth of Bitcoin traded every
- 39:37day. So what?
- 39:38What does it matter if we decrease the amount of Bitcoin
- 39:40being created every day from, you know, from 30 to 15,000,000
- 39:44or whatever, whatever tiny amount it is relative to that.
- 39:49But I think that's the wrong way to look at it because that
- 39:54trading counts buying and selling, right.
- 39:58So you can, you can it, it can be a game of musical chairs,
- 40:04really of of of of traders moving through supply and
- 40:08handing it over again and again. You could trade.
- 40:11You could trade $100 billion of of Bitcoin and half of it's
- 40:17buying and half of it's selling. And you you the net impact, the
- 40:21net demand for all of that activity is 0 and I think that's
- 40:25what people forget about when they look at trading volume is
- 40:28that by and large it's a lot of traders coming in and out of
- 40:33positions that net out to not much net activity.
- 40:37And then and then when you when if you're able to wipe away all
- 40:42of the hot potato musical chairs activity and just get the net
- 40:48activity, the net activity relative the impact of the
- 40:53halving relative to the net activity is significant.
- 40:56And especially if you layer in that the important additional
- 40:59element that you're talking about here like 70% of of supply
- 41:03is being held by long term holders.
- 41:06And So what what is the actual amount of supply that's
- 41:09available for sale and how does the the impact of the of the
- 41:13halving reduction, the halving's reduction of new supply creation
- 41:17interplay with the amount of supply that's available for
- 41:21sale. And you know when you when you
- 41:23take the relevant view in into mind the amount of trading
- 41:29volume doesn't really matter and the amount the the, the small
- 41:33size of the halving relative to the total circulating supply
- 41:36doesn't really matter. What matters is available for
- 41:38sale supply. What matters is net inflows.
- 41:41And you know, and then taking looking at it from the opposite,
- 41:46from a from a different point of view of on the day of the
- 41:49halving for the 30 months prior, 30 days prior, we had seen $1.8
- 41:54billion of Bitcoin created from mining and you know the price
- 42:00had gone well. It had been going up sideways,
- 42:03but going up left, up and to the right.
- 42:05But let's assume it had been going sideways.
- 42:09That means $1.8 billion of demand, all else equal.
- 42:12A ton of noise in there, but fine.
- 42:15And then of course the 30 days post having you have half as
- 42:19much new supply being created. So $900 million of supply,
- 42:23ostensibly $1.8 billion of net inflow and demand still.
- 42:27So that $900 million of missing supply becomes what's relevant
- 42:32as it goes out into the market to to find some willing supply
- 42:37some sellers from the available for sale contingent.
- 42:43And yeah basically all that to say that when people talk about
- 42:47trading volume with the halving, I think that they are focused on
- 42:52a metric that seems important but isn't important when you
- 42:55peel back the the inflows and outflows and how they have to be
- 42:59reduced to a net, a net amount of of flows.
- 43:04That's all that really matters in the trading numbers each day
- 43:07is are we is there net demand inflowing or or a net outflow of
- 43:12demand And yeah and. And when you look at it from
- 43:16that point of view, a reduction from $1.8 billion of supply
- 43:21being created every month and having to go out into the market
- 43:24and being met by demand in order for the price to go sideways,
- 43:27that dropping from eight, $1.8 billion every month to $900
- 43:32million every month, that's huge.
- 43:36And anyway, so I think that's I it frustrates me that in Bitcoin
- 43:40we we get caught up on some of the the top level numbers when
- 43:46it's the net numbers, the net flows that really matter.
- 43:51Now I think that's really well said.
- 43:52Like I said, I I had an inkling as to why this didn't quite work
- 43:56or make sense, even though to a lot of people that it does.
- 43:59They say, oh you, you're talking about a drop in the bucket.
- 44:01Look at all this liquidity, all this trading, but you you
- 44:06obviously have thought about this a lot more And so I
- 44:08appreciate the, the nuance there of what we actually have to look
- 44:11at. And so that makes a lot of sense
- 44:12to me as well. And then I'll just add to to
- 44:15layer on that. You've got a narrative shift now
- 44:18with a .83% inflation rate. We're well below the inflation
- 44:22rate of gold now. So of course people are looking
- 44:24at gold again as making all time highs and now you've got
- 44:28something out there that's less than half the inflation rate of
- 44:31gold and it's not going to change unlike gold with gold
- 44:35shoots up, you're going to get a lot more supply of gold coming
- 44:37online and that's just basic commodities, right.
- 44:41So that's that. I think that's another
- 44:42interesting thing that people are aware of but under
- 44:45appreciating. Thanks for tuning in.
- 44:48If you're interested in exploring any of these topics
- 44:50further, or want to learn more about how we can help you secure
- 44:53a new or existing Bitcoin allocation, get in touch with
- 44:57our team at on rampbitcoin.com. We look forward to supporting
- 45:00you on your Bitcoin journey. Totally.
- 45:03And on that point Andy Eidstrom has has been talking about a
- 45:07narrative that he's seeing develop in the RIAA space.
- 45:12The the the Bitcoin IRA space really of of gold is the new
- 45:18bonds and Bitcoin is the new gold.
- 45:23Which is an interesting sort of turn of like we we talk, we talk
- 45:26about how Bitcoin is better than gold and it is now and we'll
- 45:30talk about how gold is better than bonds and and Bitcoin sure
- 45:34as hell is better than bonds. But it's sort of an interesting
- 45:37shift of like we could see a behavioral shift of of gold
- 45:42starting to fulfil the role of a store of value, a relatively
- 45:46stable store of value that bonds historically has been.
- 45:49If we're entering an era where where inflation will be greater
- 45:54than the nominal yield of holding bonds and then therefore
- 45:58they're in real terms wealth destroying, that's you know
- 46:04based on a few assumptions and and we'll see if that does play
- 46:08out. But I think that's the world
- 46:09we're likely heading towards. But it's an interesting sort of
- 46:13thing that he's starting to see in the framing of how do you
- 46:15view these different asset classes from a portfolio
- 46:17creation point of view as an RA? It makes complete sense outside
- 46:23of RA. Like Jesse and I have had
- 46:24conversations and I think with Marty and others buying closed
- 46:27doors of what is the natural progression of adoption of
- 46:30Bitcoin and I think we would like it to be in.
- 46:32Most would assume that's looked at this asset class that
- 46:35somebody goes from their traditional portfolio mix to
- 46:37Bitcoin and bitcoins the end all be all or how they get there.
- 46:42But the reality is gold's been around for 5000 plus years.
- 46:46It has all the different attributes that somebody that
- 46:48was older has the capital knows and is trusted and so that would
- 46:53be the naturals like and also the volatility would be the
- 46:57natural like. I don't want to call it a
- 46:58stopgap, but transition point and to figure out what is that
- 47:01distribution of 9010. So 90% gold, 10% Bitcoin or
- 47:05whatever it looks like seem logical for a lot of different
- 47:09cohorts not just on the managed wealth but it makes sense like
- 47:12that is that segment that he's speaking about.
- 47:16So I think I think it's an interesting thing just to to
- 47:18follow and and probably talk with other folks, the
- 47:21Incrementum guys we've been chatting with and they they're
- 47:23an interesting cohort in Austria.
- 47:26I believe that I think they're most known for that.
- 47:29Zoltan after he left Credit Suisse that wrote a piece about
- 47:33outside money and and the growth of it.
- 47:34And they have an interesting product where I think they can't
- 47:39remember if it's segregated so they have gold and Bitcoin funds
- 47:42or or it's like a mix. But I've always thought that's
- 47:44very fascinating because you're generally going to a certain
- 47:47segment of the market and that may not want to deal with
- 47:49volatility for for a number of reasons.
- 47:51But gold can help dampen that, and it's also something they're
- 47:53more familiar with. I think there's another demand
- 47:59driver that's becoming more prevalent in the market that we
- 48:01should probably talk about because the ETF flows have
- 48:04obviously been material and we think that slow burn will
- 48:07continue. And we mentioned micro strategy
- 48:09earlier really led the way in terms of adding Bitcoin on your
- 48:13corporate treasury as a treasury asset.
- 48:15But we've seen in the last few months alone that block has come
- 48:19out in open source, their playbook.
- 48:22They've decided that they're not going to do lump sum buys every
- 48:25once in a while of Bitcoin to put on their balance sheet.
- 48:28They're now going to dollar cost average every month, taking 10%
- 48:33of the profits from their Bitcoin focused products and
- 48:36allocating that to Bitcoin. We had a coal miner come out
- 48:40last month, Alliance Resources and they basically said, yeah,
- 48:44we've been mining Bitcoin for the last four years and we're
- 48:49adding it to our balance sheet. I believe they have over 420
- 48:52Bitcoin on their balance sheet now at this point.
- 48:54Obviously we have Tether which has really began to normalize
- 48:57their quarterly buys of Bitcoin which are in the multi thousands
- 49:02I believe above 8000 was last quarter.
- 49:04And so I do think you could have to your point Michael of do
- 49:09individual investors decide to invest in gold or Bitcoin, what
- 49:14does that mix. I think we're seeing something
- 49:15on the corporate side begin to develop and I can see a FOMO
- 49:19like follow on effect in the corporate world happen where
- 49:23people look at block, they look at this coal miner, they look at
- 49:26tether micro strategy and they say hey maybe we should be
- 49:29putting some Bitcoin on our balance sheet as well.
- 49:32And what kind of demand does that put on on the network and
- 49:38the supply of Bitcoin, what kind of demand does that drive for
- 49:42Bitcoin? And then how are these companies
- 49:46getting exposure? Because I think that's another
- 49:48thing that people are looking at as well right now is the K1
- 49:51filings of who's actually buying these ETFs.
- 49:54Like are people going to buy spot Bitcoin like MicroStrategy,
- 49:57Square and Tether or or some company simply just gonna
- 50:03allocate some of their treasury to these ETFs?
- 50:07Yeah, it's, it's incredible because when you really break it
- 50:10down, it's like what is the point where this becomes not
- 50:12speculative and just math and what we've seen in the past 15
- 50:15years. And then this dynamic or angle
- 50:17of like you wouldn't build a business without using software,
- 50:19you wouldn't build a business without using some of the new
- 50:21tools that can help you leverage to do more with less.
- 50:24Why would you build a business using an analog dollar that
- 50:26loses X percent per year. You just use this other asset
- 50:29and then it's just baked into your capital raising efforts.
- 50:32You're built your, your forecasting that you're going to
- 50:34have this thing that preserves well like you didn't have to be
- 50:37about money, right. It doesn't have to be about all
- 50:38these things. It's just a different form of
- 50:40technology that you go and put on.
- 50:42And so it's like I think we're we're there, we see it with like
- 50:45you know micro strategy River put out the report we need to
- 50:48get Alex back on and see it was square.
- 50:50And it's just as it becomes more and more, I think it's less
- 50:54ingrained because I think there's like the a lot of people
- 50:56know this. I think there's the overhead
- 50:58from a investor perspective, our investors going to crush you, is
- 51:01the market going to crush you. But once like that gets de risk
- 51:05from the just risk of like the idea of nobody ever got fired
- 51:10for buying X, like once that's there then it just becomes a lot
- 51:13easier for people to allocate. I was just at the MicroStrategy
- 51:18conference, the big event they have every year, which is for
- 51:21their company, but then as you know, they tack on their have
- 51:24this separate track for Bitcoin for corporations.
- 51:27So there's a lot of talk of this that I just came out of thinking
- 51:31about this and I I think it's absolutely fascinating #1 just
- 51:34thinking of what you just said, the playbook of if you're if
- 51:37you're a corporate treasurer, what are your, what's your
- 51:40mandate? And that's to have capital ready
- 51:44to deploy for your company and you have to preserve that
- 51:47capital. So getting back to my point of
- 51:50all these excuses are slowly getting dismantled.
- 51:52And if people just put aside all their preconceived notions of
- 51:55Bitcoin and just purely look at it as an asset or a technology,
- 51:59like you're saying, it's very hard for them to say, wait, why
- 52:02aren't we putting at least X percent to defend ourselves?
- 52:05They don't even have to believe it.
- 52:07But it gets down to the the game theory that you're talking about
- 52:10here. Whereas if their competitors are
- 52:12doing it, they've got to do X percent to match it just in case
- 52:16it does work or catches on or grows more or preserves their
- 52:20power. They're not left behind.
- 52:22You know, someone said well, but are these companies going to be
- 52:27concerned that they're they're never going to catch up to
- 52:29something like a micro strategy? I said it's like the old adage,
- 52:32you don't have to run faster than the bear.
- 52:34You just have to run faster than the next person.
- 52:36And so you're going to see this reflexivity and game theory play
- 52:39out, at least in my opinion. And we did hear from one person
- 52:43on the panel saying there's another company that's going to
- 52:45announce that they're putting on their balance sheet.
- 52:47They of course didn't say who. So I'm very keen to see who that
- 52:51is or what that announcement is. But one of the things I ended my
- 52:54panel on was the question was where are we at?
- 52:58And I brought up the the old Ted Talk video.
- 53:01It's like a only a 3 minute video many years ago, and I'm
- 53:04sure I'm not. I'm not the first person to
- 53:06think of this, but I did come up with it organically.
- 53:09My wife and I were talking about this video.
- 53:10It's called How to Start a Movement and the light bulb just
- 53:14clicked. We were talking about something
- 53:15completely unrelated. And then I said, wait a minute,
- 53:17this directly applies to the what's going on here?
- 53:20And the the video is the the guy that's doing the Ted talk
- 53:24dissects another video, just a couple minute video of a young
- 53:28man dancing wildly on a grassy hill.
- 53:30I think they're at a music concert or something and he's
- 53:34the only person dancing and you think he's starting the
- 53:37movement, 'cause he's the one that's doing it first and and
- 53:40and obviously going out there. But as he dissects the video, he
- 53:43says no, Watch how this plays out.
- 53:45The most important person is the second person that joins them
- 53:50because that person now validates the first one.
- 53:53The first guy is not crazy and then he motions over his friends
- 53:56so he gets everyone else involved.
- 53:58And then within seconds you've got this whole raging crowd of
- 54:00people dancing and wildly and and on this grassy hill.
- 54:04And so I think that's the point we're at.
- 54:06We've got a couple of first movers that a lot of people are
- 54:10thinking are crazy and look silly, and we've got companies.
- 54:14We've got one country and I think we're getting close to the
- 54:17point where we're going to have the second person and that's the
- 54:20validator of it. And so again, if you just play
- 54:23this out the game theory you've you've got to at least take a
- 54:25defensive position where like you said, the career risk is now
- 54:30gone. You're not going to be fired for
- 54:32doing this. You were just playing it safe
- 54:35and being prudent with with the options that are out there.
- 54:40You know, you know what you just made me think of when you say
- 54:42game theory and removing money, but more of just like technology
- 54:45as AdWords. You people like Google and
- 54:48AdWords coming out and the this reality of like it comes out and
- 54:51the first person uses it and they like juice the shit out of
- 54:53their returns. I can't remember what some of
- 54:55the first companies that their whole like businesses were baked
- 54:58on the back of being first to to leveraging Google Adwords, but
- 55:01the reality of it being you and a little weird and then every
- 55:04net new person coming in their business incrementally grows
- 55:07from it till then it's just an absolute standard if you want to
- 55:10survive on the Internet, right? Or like having some kind of like
- 55:12formal exposure like that. It reminds me of that, like in
- 55:15in this respect, it's obviously not apples to apples, but it's
- 55:19this idea that this will become ubiquitous and the only way you
- 55:21actually can stay alive is to is to play.
- 55:26Yeah, another talking about being in an anonymous period.
- 55:31I mean outside of 2020 and right after 2008 when Bitcoin
- 55:35launched, like who knows what's going to happen in the macro
- 55:39world, but there's a lot going on behind the scenes.
- 55:42We had, I believe the Treasury or the Fed yesterday opened up a
- 55:46swap line with the Bank of Japan.
- 55:48And the tea leaves the people are reading are basically coming
- 55:51to the conclusion that the US government and the Federal
- 55:54Reserve did not want the Bank of Japan selling U.S.
- 55:57Treasuries to defend the yen as they try to do yield curve
- 56:02control, which they've completely lost control of.
- 56:04And I think if the macro headwinds become so strong that
- 56:10they they lead to a a decline in the stock market and a decline
- 56:16in overall markets, it'll be really interesting to see if you
- 56:20have that period where you have the 2nd person joining the party
- 56:24with Bitcoin, does it actually act as a risk off asset this
- 56:29time around? I mean I think the probability
- 56:32if we're looking historically is probably low, but there there
- 56:34may be that chance there where people finally wake up like holy
- 56:38crap, look at all this debt that the world is awash in.
- 56:41Look at the inability of the central banks to actually
- 56:44control the yield curves that they're trying to control.
- 56:48Maybe we should allocate the Bitcoin.
- 56:51Obviously we have tech stocks that are screaming still.
- 56:56I think I believe I saw Stan Druckenmiller sold 20% of his
- 57:00NVIDIA stake earlier today and announced he thinks AI is
- 57:04overhyped and we're going to havea.com bubble like crash at
- 57:08some point in the near future. So I think it will be really
- 57:12interesting to see what happens to Bitcoin in that environment
- 57:14cause historically when these risk off events do happen,
- 57:19people typically sell their Bitcoin to get liquidity and
- 57:22shore up their dollar balances. Our research shows Bitcoin is
- 57:28highly correlated to monetary conditions and you you all know
- 57:32this M2 central bank balance sheet changes however you want
- 57:34to measure it. One of our favorite charges is
- 57:37looking at real interest rates, and if you invert one of them so
- 57:41it tracks closely, you find that Bitcoin tracked the inverse real
- 57:45rate very closely for a long time.
- 57:46And this of course made sense to us, and we might have talked
- 57:49about this last time. But when real rates are going
- 57:53down, Bitcoin looks more attractive because even though
- 57:55you don't have a yield, it's like, well, I'd I'd rather get
- 57:58take my chances with Bitcoin than lock in a negative real
- 58:01yield with these bonds. And then of course it went up
- 58:04when the Fed raised rates at the fastest rate in 40 years and
- 58:07inflation came down a little bit.
- 58:09But then it completely decoupled.
- 58:10And so everyone was saying, OK, is Bitcoin just doing its own
- 58:13thing. It was anticipating the approval
- 58:15of the ETP products. Maybe I was in the camp of it's
- 58:19sniffing something else out on the macro front and that's
- 58:22because gold was doing the same thing.
- 58:24And so whether it's sniffing out having to do rate cuts in the
- 58:28future, it's staring down the structural fiscal deficits, I
- 58:32think is a big part of it or some of the things you're
- 58:34talking about. Bitcoin is very much a macro
- 58:38asset. It's one of the best macro
- 58:40assets in my opinion because it's it's homogeneous, it's
- 58:42traded globally 24/7 people and it can express all kinds of
- 58:46opinions at any hour of the day with Bitcoin.
- 58:49And we've seen this with geopolitical events happening
- 58:51over the weekend and everything like that.
- 58:53And so I agree with you that I think this could be its its
- 58:57moment as more people realize it's not just a tech stock on
- 59:01steroids or a lever tech stock, it's something fundamentally
- 59:04different. But in the very short term, I
- 59:06still think it's going to have that knee jerk reaction of of
- 59:09the old Wall Street adage. In crises all correlations go to
- 59:121. Meaning as you said, people will
- 59:14sell their Bitcoin for cash. There's just always a knee jerk
- 59:17reaction to the safest most liquid thing which historically
- 59:20been cash. And so we could see that again,
- 59:23but I think that will just be the short term and then we'll
- 59:26start to see how people realize, wait a minute, there is this
- 59:32pristine collateral, something that no one else controls and I
- 59:37can verify and there's absolutely no counter party
- 59:40risk. We don't have anything else out
- 59:42there in the financial world like this.
- 59:44And and there could be some massive reflexivity implications
- 59:47to that as well when people start to realize that.
- 59:53Yeah, there's there's a natural also like corporate sizing that
- 59:58requires because this asset's so volatile that we can say to size
- 1:00:02it appropriately. But then once animal spirits
- 1:00:04get, you know, that's that's a different story.
- 1:00:07And people will, like people naturally, still see this for
- 1:00:09cycles where people size it disproportionate or not
- 1:00:13appropriately, and then they get burned.
- 1:00:15Because we've seen that since bitcoins, you know?
- 1:00:18History and I don't think like corporates would change that and
- 1:00:21know how to appropriately manage their treasury like ideally you
- 1:00:24should as a fiduciary and to be prudent, but I don't know if we
- 1:00:27that just like absolve itself because we're in a, you know,
- 1:00:29ETF era. They're still humans.
- 1:00:32I've worked with many institutions.
- 1:00:33They're they're still humans. Yeah, they are.
- 1:00:36There's not some magic door you go through where you leave all
- 1:00:40of your psychological biases behind.
- 1:00:46And and in fact, if anything, committees are more prone to
- 1:00:50human psychology than than humans themselves.
- 1:00:52Because you can always have the maverick individuals to
- 1:00:54understand you should buy blood when when there's blood in the
- 1:00:57streets. But the committees are
- 1:01:00inherently slow and always like you know, are are going to
- 1:01:04exacerbate trends rather than counter trade and and so on.
- 1:01:09So yeah, the institutions tend to be at least as human, at
- 1:01:15least as prone to human psychology as as individuals.
- 1:01:21The one thing that's been really compelling, Chris, you brought
- 1:01:25up and we've had other individuals and it's always
- 1:01:27great to hear how you position in the market.
- 1:01:30Certain aspects you talk about, I think it was the monger
- 1:01:35Buffett, how to how to invert things and you brought up a few
- 1:01:39examples on the last podcast we did that I thought were really
- 1:01:43compelling on how we personally And then the market when they
- 1:01:46think about educating individuals on Bitcoin and those
- 1:01:49sometimes change but then they they often stay similar to like
- 1:01:52the themes are similar but the way they're positioned are
- 1:01:55different based on like the market, you know ETF being here.
- 1:01:58It would be curious you know any of your recent favourites or
- 1:02:02things that you've seen land and I asked that because I just
- 1:02:07thought of we've been discussing with an individual that's pretty
- 1:02:10was pretty senior in the managed wealth space and going to Ras
- 1:02:14and and how do you position Bitcoin and talk about it
- 1:02:17because you know Ras are generally or a lot of them are
- 1:02:20going to be managed segregated from like a traditional wire
- 1:02:23house where they can you know they have a more I don't know if
- 1:02:27the correct term is affinity for their client but like they're
- 1:02:30more looking at it from a decentralized view of governance
- 1:02:35and how they think about product services and protecting and
- 1:02:38preserving someone's wealth. And one of the angles was how do
- 1:02:41you go and speak to them? And and the kicker of the where
- 1:02:43he ended was basically telling them at what price do your
- 1:02:48clients deserve Bitcoin? And that was like this.
- 1:02:52That was like the thing. And it was just like it just
- 1:02:54landed so beautiful because like these individuals are supposed
- 1:02:56to care about their clients and generally most do.
- 1:02:58And their apprehension exists and rightly or wrongly so
- 1:03:02because of volatility and drug trafficking and all the crazy
- 1:03:05things that have happened the past 15 years.
- 1:03:07And then it's like, well, and they can say all of that, but
- 1:03:10then they haven't actually done it, the the diligence, right.
- 1:03:12And so it's like at what point or at what price do your clients
- 1:03:16deserve Bitcoin? And I just thought that like
- 1:03:18landed so beautifully with that segment.
- 1:03:20I'm curious like your thoughts on that and then other like
- 1:03:22cohorts and what you've seen kind of really be positioned and
- 1:03:26be successful in your in your team's kind of like approach?
- 1:03:30That's a great way to to put. I hadn't heard it quite that
- 1:03:34bluntly but it does make you think right and put the question
- 1:03:37back on them just like we were talking about with inverting it.
- 1:03:41I I've heard it all. I think broadly speaking the
- 1:03:46excuses get a little more sophisticated if you will.
- 1:03:50It's clearly gone past the only used on the dark web illegal
- 1:03:55nefarious purposes and even it's not real to today.
- 1:03:59Oh, regulatory concerns, volatility, like those are more
- 1:04:02of the the excuses or barriers du jour if you will that that
- 1:04:07people kind of latch onto. Although you you still hear it.
- 1:04:09I I was at a conference and there was a a large wealth
- 1:04:11manager and he was saying I can't feel it, I can't touch it,
- 1:04:15it's not real. And you try to get to them and
- 1:04:17say well is Microsoft real? It's software that's just code
- 1:04:21on a screen. Is that real to you?
- 1:04:22It's a trillion dollar company. But then he proceeded to say he,
- 1:04:25he owned a lot of art and was active in the art market.
- 1:04:27And I thought, sure you can see and touch your art, but the
- 1:04:32value there to me is even less real because it's it's very
- 1:04:34subjective of course and and can change and it's not a
- 1:04:38homogeneous market. So it's just interesting as you
- 1:04:41said how it hits with different people in different ways.
- 1:04:44I've been trying the more the invert approach like that.
- 1:04:48I think that's a good one. And I think for the RIA market
- 1:04:52or other people dealing with more the middle class mass
- 1:04:55affluent, the biggest thing hitting people right now and
- 1:04:58this shows up in all the polls is inflation.
- 1:05:00And even though we've obviously come way down from inflation on
- 1:05:04ACPI basis, it's still high. It's only slowing.
- 1:05:08So it's it's growing less rapidly, but it's still going up
- 1:05:12and people have lost at least 1/4 of their purchasing power of
- 1:05:15the last few years. We're now seeing companies like
- 1:05:19Starbucks, McDonald's, just to name a few in their quarterly
- 1:05:22earnings report confirm this. Their same store sales are down.
- 1:05:26They've had to hike prices, they're losing customers.
- 1:05:29That's the the mass affluent out there that is really struggling.
- 1:05:33And so somehow we got to get across a better narrative of you
- 1:05:38can store your hard earned work and wealth in this asset and
- 1:05:44still get them over the hump of yeah, but it's so volatile.
- 1:05:47I can see it go up and then I can see it it lose everything in
- 1:05:50a in a few weeks or or months. That's that's the hard part to
- 1:05:55get them to see that no, this is we're talking about the long
- 1:05:57term. This is what you need to survive
- 1:05:59over or you're going to keep going backwards in this current
- 1:06:02inflationary regime and we could be set up for another one.
- 1:06:06You touched on this a little bit, but I always talk about the
- 1:06:09inflation of the 70s and and we talked about how gold kind of
- 1:06:12discovered itself. People think oh the 70s, one
- 1:06:16homogeneous 10 year period, like high inflation during the entire
- 1:06:1970s period. Like it was just double digits
- 1:06:21for a decade. And of course not it was two
- 1:06:24major waves and even a first little wave.
- 1:06:27But then the second wave was big.
- 1:06:29It came down, looked like they had inflation whipped and then
- 1:06:31we got a major second wave and and we have to be honest that
- 1:06:35maybe we're facing a similar thing.
- 1:06:37History doesn't repeat, but it does rhyme.
- 1:06:39What if we're facing another wave?
- 1:06:42We've we've had at least three hot higher than expected CPI
- 1:06:45reports now. So I think maybe that's more of
- 1:06:49the the angle or pivot that I think could be useful, but I'm
- 1:06:52along with you I'm always. I'm always interested to hear
- 1:06:55more ways to to get the message across.
- 1:06:58Yeah, don't look now, but M2 is officially going up again.
- 1:07:02Logan. If you pull the chart up, after
- 1:07:05a little bit of a year and a half of of M2 falling, we've
- 1:07:10officially gone above the X axis again above 0.
- 1:07:15And that's year over year. But I agree with you Chris that
- 1:07:20it feels like inflation is human psychology.
- 1:07:25It's it's how we it's how policy reacts to to inflation that is I
- 1:07:32I think what rhymes and you know the bullwhip effect of inflation
- 1:07:36is what we saw in the 70s. And you know I I think as we're
- 1:07:42as you know as we're adding like a a trillion dollars of national
- 1:07:46debt every hundred days or so for right now and deficits are
- 1:07:51expanding to to 2 trillion. We're normalizing $2 trillion
- 1:07:54deficits and interest expense on the national debt is is now over
- 1:07:59a trillion dollars. Lynn Alden I think has been has
- 1:08:02been spot on about kind of sounding the alarm here that
- 1:08:06it's it's going to blow people's minds that this kind of high,
- 1:08:12high interest rates with our national debt scenario will be
- 1:08:18stimulative to inflation. And that's because of all the
- 1:08:21the debt that has to be printed in order to pay interest expense
- 1:08:24and other and other you know deficit spending that has to
- 1:08:27happen and how that could drive another wave of inflation in the
- 1:08:33coming years. It it does seem like it's
- 1:08:35setting up that way. You know, it could be.
- 1:08:38This reminds me of it's gonna be good report.
- 1:08:41Maybe it's more on brand for on ramp but just throwing it out
- 1:08:44there is if you guys saw on Twitter a couple of weeks ago
- 1:08:47where the person's family member passed away.
- 1:08:49Because I think talk about trillions and deficits goes from
- 1:08:52an ephemeral thing to more of like visceral feeling of just
- 1:08:55somebody's like personal wealth being stolen.
- 1:08:56And if you remember, somebody passed away and on Twitter they
- 1:08:59showed the like shoebox that their grandmother, I can't
- 1:09:01remember for the grandmother or grandfather had like say there
- 1:09:04wasn't a wealthy person they had saved that money away for their
- 1:09:07family or to pass it on or or from a for a rainy day.
- 1:09:11And you just kind of like broke down, you know what, let's call
- 1:09:13it $20,000 or whatever the number was and how much and how
- 1:09:16hard it was to save that and what that like buys you today.
- 1:09:19And that kind of hit me. And then but then recently on my
- 1:09:23wife's side, one of her grandparents had passed and that
- 1:09:26they found a shoebox. He kind of in his mind wasn't
- 1:09:29wasn't working at the at the very end properly.
- 1:09:31And they found money that he didn't even know he hid.
- 1:09:33And it was kind of like this sweet gesture and it wasn't a
- 1:09:35lot of money and they gave it to all the grandchildren.
- 1:09:38But it's just like so heartbreaking when you think
- 1:09:39about what was that amount and how hard was it to store it
- 1:09:42there then what does it mean in 2024?
- 1:09:45And I think like writing a report like showing maybe year,
- 1:09:47year after year, decade after decade and like just the joint
- 1:09:50lane purchasing power, what buys from what's called the 70s to
- 1:09:54now 50 year time frame. I think land such a bigger punch
- 1:09:59no matter how much money somebody has because it just
- 1:10:01makes it more like human versus the numbers and the amount of
- 1:10:04dollars we have to print because it just ends up on the margins
- 1:10:08versus like really hitting home anyway.
- 1:10:10It's something I've been thinking about.
- 1:10:11And then just as you're bringing that, you know, Chris of like
- 1:10:14how do you position this? It's like everybody has to deal
- 1:10:16with it at some at some level. And to to quantify that Michael,
- 1:10:26I I just put something in the the chat that we're gonna throw
- 1:10:29up here but this is a chart that's been going around on
- 1:10:33Twitter over the last couple days.
- 1:10:35But it is pretty stark when you look at it like the pre tax
- 1:10:39income of our grandparents, parents and the the younger
- 1:10:43generations today. And you juxtapose that to the
- 1:10:49percentage of the cost of college.
- 1:10:52Like our grandparents paid 14% of their income to go to
- 1:10:56college. Today kids are paying 42% in the
- 1:10:59house price to income ratio. For grandparents with 3X and out
- 1:11:03seven X, that is material. Yeah, there it is. 18 years
- 1:11:11after death. Two.
- 1:11:13Oh, yeah. I didn't even realize it was
- 1:11:14peso. Yeah.
- 1:11:19I mean, in this, it should go to credit to Fidelity in the
- 1:11:21financial institutions that are doing what they're supposed to
- 1:11:24do in the sense of like you're supposed to write value for the
- 1:11:27end client, help them. And Fidelity took the stance,
- 1:11:29you know, close to 10 years ago, I guess in saying, what are we
- 1:11:32going to disrupt ourselves and how do we think about it?
- 1:11:34And building custody, building those products and obviously, we
- 1:11:36don't have to name them. But there's other financial
- 1:11:39service firms that have said that we don't need to adopt
- 1:11:41this. And it's like at some point
- 1:11:43people are going to look at you and say like, well, what are,
- 1:11:45what are we doing here? Like this is how we protect
- 1:11:47ourselves. Like, you're supposed to protect
- 1:11:48our capital, our preserving of wealth.
- 1:11:51So it's always been awesome to to see Fidelity leading the way.
- 1:11:56Yeah, absolutely. Thank you that that's our
- 1:11:58mission statement that you learn when you on board the fidelity
- 1:12:00mission statements to increase the well-being, the financial
- 1:12:04well-being of our of our clients.
- 1:12:05So you have to explore all opportunities and possibilities.
- 1:12:09So definitely credit, credit to them for exploring this very
- 1:12:12early and recognizing the the potential here which is one of
- 1:12:16the most attractive things about about working there.
- 1:12:20They they truly get it and truly believe in it and we've we've
- 1:12:22got a lot of great people there to to help push that mission.
- 1:12:25And you guys built custody like I'd be curious your thoughts and
- 1:12:28it can be from an external perspective, the research side
- 1:12:31or fidelity, but just like how do you think about the market
- 1:12:34with 90%, you just from a market participant maybe however you
- 1:12:37can talk about it like 90% of ETFs sitting at Coinbase, this
- 1:12:41angle of like we understand you know money and centralization
- 1:12:44and thinking about the importance of fidelity and
- 1:12:46having their own custody solution.
- 1:12:47But how? We should just be looking at the
- 1:12:50market for the next 10 years as as more and more capital comes
- 1:12:53in, there's not really that many different qualified solutions to
- 1:12:57like house this amount of Bitcoin.
- 1:13:00You're correct that we built our own custody solution.
- 1:13:03That was the very first thing that we built and it's still one
- 1:13:05of our major products today and it's the major product for
- 1:13:09Fidelity digital assets where I work.
- 1:13:10But it's also the custody solution behind all the other
- 1:13:14Fidelity products you see. So the retail side and and all
- 1:13:17the other things out there, so that's that's us on the the back
- 1:13:20end and there was a real recognition that well first of
- 1:13:23all the reason they built is because no one else had it.
- 1:13:27They said we want to store some Bitcoin in the enterprise grade
- 1:13:31institutional level solution. Nobody else was really doing it.
- 1:13:34So they said well we got to build our own then and they
- 1:13:36brought all their expertise of being a 75 plus year financial
- 1:13:40services company with knowing how to custody regular financial
- 1:13:44assets, knowing cybersecurity, knowing the hardware, everything
- 1:13:48else about it. They brought all that expertise
- 1:13:50to create this enterprise grade solution and they really do
- 1:13:53believe, we really do believe that's that's the primitive that
- 1:13:57you need to start with. You have to have custody and as
- 1:14:00you know obviously you have to get custody right.
- 1:14:03It might be a boring business, but you don't want it to be an
- 1:14:06exciting business because then something probably went wrong.
- 1:14:09But you want it to be the bedrock for all of these other
- 1:14:12things that you can then build off of it.
- 1:14:14And of course we, we are one of the few that have custody for
- 1:14:17our exchange trade product and that allows us to have kind of
- 1:14:21that vertical integration. So not only does that save us on
- 1:14:24the cost side of things where we don't have to go out and pay
- 1:14:26someone else, but we have full visibility and control of that
- 1:14:29as well which I think is one of the the big differentiators.
- 1:14:32And then on the research side, you know not to to to brag too
- 1:14:35much or anything, but I have heard anecdotally from people
- 1:14:38that they've chosen our product because they see our research
- 1:14:42and they say you actually get it, you're invested in this
- 1:14:45space, you've been doing this a very long time.
- 1:14:47That gives me the comfort owning this.
- 1:14:49It's not just another financial product for you.
- 1:14:52You've obviously been here and believe in it and are committed
- 1:14:55to it and that the big thing I like to tell people is I I
- 1:14:58started not even three years ago Fidelity Digital assets had
- 1:15:02about 100, 120 people or so. Today we have around 700.
- 1:15:08So all during this bear market we've been building, we've been
- 1:15:10hiring, we haven't let off the gas because we've seen it as an
- 1:15:14opportunity given our long term vision in the space.
- 1:15:19Which is makes sense and it's so consistent like if you're
- 1:15:21educating the market and the market gets educated from the
- 1:15:24content, it's a natural extension to leverage the
- 1:15:27products because it's a signal of understanding and investment
- 1:15:30versus stepping in and putting laser eyes on, you know your
- 1:15:33Twitter picture. But it's just like it.
- 1:15:37This is why you know we focus on education and research and all
- 1:15:40the things the same respect. It's like you have you go
- 1:15:43educate the market and it's just a natural next step from the
- 1:15:46journey to go and ask what do you, what do you provide because
- 1:15:49you've built that trust. So yeah, it's awesome to see it.
- 1:15:55Is coming up on time. Want to be respectful of
- 1:15:59everybody's time here. I think this is a great check
- 1:16:02in. It's a it's literally a
- 1:16:05different world today than it was in September 15th.
- 1:16:10Tomorrow will be a different world too.
- 1:16:11But I think we're. Now better than gold.
- 1:16:13That's the big difference. Better than gold.
- 1:16:16We've got a lot of flows coming in the block subsidies.
- 1:16:20Only 3.125 Bitcoin per block. Japan is losing control of the
- 1:16:27yen and Bitcoin keeps producing blocks and Fidelity keeps
- 1:16:31pushing out. Good research and good products.
- 1:16:33So Chris, I wanna thank you for joining us and if we have
- 1:16:36anything we wanna end it on guys, now's the time to say your
- 1:16:40piece no. I appreciate you joining us.
- 1:16:45Yeah. Appreciate you joining it.
- 1:16:47All right. See you guys next week.
- 1:16:49Thank. You, Chris.