Latest / The Philanthropists / Are We Making Philanthropy Too Complicated? | One More Thing with Quanda and Meredith
Transcript
- Quanda: Welcome to The Philanthropist Personal Journeys of Giving with Purpose. I'm Quanda Allen. After our guest conversations, we come back together for a reflection episode, a space where Meredith and I unpack some of the ideas, tensions, and questions that stayed with us long after the interview ended. Because these conversations are about much more than charitable giving. They're about identity, responsibility, grief, families, systems, joy, and what actually moves people to stay engaged in the lives of others. So today's episode is a reflection on our conversation with Craig Newmark, the founder of Craigslist, and a philanthropist whose giving is far more expansive than the simple website most of us first knew him for. Craig started Craigslist in 1995 as an email list sharing arts and technology events with friends in San Francisco. What began as a useful community service grew into one of the Internet's most recognizable platforms. But Craig chose not to maximize every possible dollar from it. He kept the site minimally monetized, stepped away from its daily management, and and has since committed the large majority of what he earned to philanthropy. meredith: In our full conversation, Craig took us through a remarkably wide portfolio: fighting scams and cyber attacks, trustworthy journalism, supporting veterans, military families, expanding opportunities for women and girls in technology, and yes, rescuing pigeons. But beneath that range was a very consistent philosophy. Craig tries to identify people who are genuinely good at their jobs, give them meaningful resources. Keeping the process simple and of and avoids getting in their way. He also spoke candidly about gifts that did not work as well as he had hoped, and the importance of checking whether an organization can actually execute on what they say and the limits of prestige as a substitute for performance. Quanda: So, this reflection is not simply about the causes Craig funds. It's about the architecture of his giving, how simplicity can become a discipline, how trust should follow real diligence, how donors can use intermediaries and networks instead of building everything themselves, and why a serious philanthropic strategy can still leave room for delight and personal affection. And if you have not yet heard the full Craig Newmark episode, this conversation will give you the essential story, but we hope that you will go back and listen. His humor makes the conversation light, but the convictions underneath it are anything but casual. This is the Philanthropists. meredith: Hello, Quanda, how are you? Quanda: I am well, hello, Meredith. meredith: I am really looking forward to talking about our conversation with Craig Newmark, who is one of my favorite people. Craig's portfolio looks wide-ranging at first, from cyber defense to journalism to veterans, women in technology, and then of course his beloved pigeon rescue. But as I listened, I kept hearing the same moral instinct underneath all of it. He's talked often about his his North stars and his values. he notices when people are can be harmed, identifies who's already doing something useful and then helps them actually do it. So Kwanda, when you step back from the individual grants he talked about, what do you think the conversation was really about with Craig? Quanda: Yeah, there are a couple of things that I felt really rose to the surface. The first is personal accountability at scale. So Craig talks about the creation of Craigslist and the unfortunate amount of like scams that happen on this platform. And and he does feel like that number is overblown, by the way. It's very clear. about that, meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: but he created this environment for people to come together as a means of exchange. And the fact that there are scams that happen on this platform, I think was an early catalyst for him to combat cybercrime. And I thought that was so interesting that, the personal responsibility that he feels towards Craigslist, even though he sold it many, many years ago, the fact that it bears his name has really been a through line through his philanthropy to make sure that there are organizations and programs that help people to avoid being victims of of cybercrime. I think another kind of big takeaway for for me as it relates to this particular conversation is just the importance of some of the early formative lessons that Craig benefited from. He talked a lot about Sunday school. And, meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: I love that that like the lessons that he learned in Sunday school as a child really created a lifelong moral framework for him. And I think that so many people identify with that, but the way he articulated it, I felt like was also an important through line for for his philanthropy. He had a a phrase that he shared with us, a saying that he holds really dear. And that's the only wealth you keep forever is the wealth that you you give away. I found that so telling and I found that so prevalent in his perspective and ultimately meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: his approach to giving. meredith: Agreed, agreed. He he he is an incredibly principled philanthropist. And and I think having known him for several years, I feel like many people come to him with lots of other things, but he is his North Stars are set in the sky and he's always keeping an eye on them for sure. Quanda: Yeah, and and he also is a distinct personality and meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: he knows who he is. I mean, meredith: Mm. Quanda: he calls himself a nerd. He says, hey, I'm an engineer at heart. and and you see that echoed not just in like the simplicity of Craigslist, but in the simplicity of of his giving. And one of the things that I thought was so interesting about Craig's approach to philanthropy is, how he talked about, 1999 investors were really encouraging him to monetize Craigslist aggressively because we've all used Craigslist. We know how simple the interface is. And, they're not a lot of like, they're not ads popping up. You don't have to pay a huge subscription, to access it. And he was getting a lot of pressure to implement some of those things. And, he made the decision to have a very limited business model. meredith: Right. Quanda: And that was like personally important to him and aligned with his values. And you see that as well in the lack of complexity around his philanthropy, which we'll talk about in a minute. But like what do you think donors and family foundations can learn from the fact that like Craig really concentrated his his giving, he concentrated his approach to business really before there was anything to prune. meredith: That is yeah, absolutely. I I think it's really interesting that he was he's just incredibly focused, right? And it's easy and he started off, like you said, he used the word simple, simplification, right? He starts off with core values and it's easy to be concentrated or focused when you adhere to your values and you get real clear about what impact or or ambition you wanna or impact you wanna see in the world. So before Quanda: Mm-hmm. meredith: you d design, you know, all of these structures around staffing and leadership and legacy commitments and habits Quanda: Right. meredith: and beneficiaries and all these different things, he was just really clear. And I think a lot of bigger foundations often change their strategy frequently, you know. Every few years, I think family foundations sometimes inherit, you know, second and third generations inherit programs that they are perhaps are no longer as impactful or that they don't represent the the wishes of the the next generation, you know, phase two, phase three of a foundation. And and Craig was very clear about the beginning that he was gonna focus on on North Star issues and they were gonna be focused. And and he stuck with them for years. And I give him tremendous credit for knowing who like you said, knowing who he is, knowing what what change he wants to see in the world, identifying the people that he thinks are best to make that change, and then giving them the money that they need to do so. It really he it's refreshing to talk with him in around the o you know the ideas of. you know, monetization, which is such a, you know, investment and all, you know, that whole world and like make sure you go through series A, series B, and then, you know, accumulate, accumulate, accumulate. And he has he's just has a different philosophy and he's incredibly streamlined and efficient. And it's pretty impressive the amount of money that he gives away working like by himself with his financial advisor and Quanda: Right. meredith: his comms person. And And that's it. It's it's unreal how efficiently Quanda: It is. meredith: he he worked. And and that's his full-time job, right? Like that Craig Newmark Philanthropies Quanda: Right. meredith: is his full-time job. so he's again, so he's focused. Like I just think his focus is really what sets him apart. And and I think, like we've said, that's unusual because it's, you know, he doesn't have a traditional board or a family council or big professional staff. You know, he he relies on that. very core circle of people that help him implement his grants he has folks or stakeholders that have influenced the way that he thinks about these things he talked about learning from Jim Buckmaster who took over for him at Craigslist. He talks about his big investment in Blue Star families and how he relies on that leadership to help guide him. And I've worked with them before amazing, amazing organization. The Got Six Network that's run with Aspen and Betsy, like these are tremendous forces of nature. And then all of his technical partners in cybersecurity. And I guess my question to you is, you know, is radical delegation functioning as Craig's substitute for formal governance? And like, what do you think the strengths and risks of that model are? Quanda: Yeah, I think to answer that, we first have to talk a little bit about a more traditional model, right? So meredith: Mm. Quanda: if you have a family foundation or, a private foundation, there's typically a North Star as well, but there are formal governance bodies that typically take the form of, officers who would form the equivalent of like a a board of directors for that particular foundation. and they would have specific roles to to play and they also in a lot of ways serve as checks and balances for the entire organization and and even sometimes for the original the original donor and so that's typically on the governance side and depending on the size of the foundation there are Oftentimes staff members who perform a wide variety of functions as well. you may have someone who is a grants administrator. and then, depending on the size, maybe even a comms person or a programs person, right? For the level meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: of philanthropy that Craig is engaging in, you would not at all be surprised to see. an organization with two or three staff and a full board. But that is not how Craig Newmark is operating Craig Newmark Philanthropies, as you articulated, he is at the center of decision making and he does have, a group of individuals and organizations that he has outsourced a variety of roles to. And so, I mean, I do think that there's some strength there, right? So the strength would be ease to act, quick decision making, lots of meredith: Right. Quanda: transparency, and and the ability to impact specific causes, in the way that you want, and and the ability to do that really, really fast. and the way that Craig is being able to realize all of those benefits is that he does invest a lot of time. As you said, this is his full-time job. He invests a lot meredith: Right. Quanda: of time in due diligence, right? Like making sure that he understands, the organization, making sure that he understands the people. he's really focused on the impact that. the organization has ultimately made. And so that is really the accountability model. It's from like selection, it's from due diligence. It's from observation. And that is how he reduces the risk that ultimately his philanthropic intent is not going to meet his objectives. Now, meredith: Mm. Quanda: I do think that, you know, There are some risks inherent in this type of structure and we talk we're gonna talk a little bit about that, later. But succession planning, right? It's very difficult to replace Craig Newmark. And so, he he doesn't a bot meredith: Right. Even with a bot. Quanda: or or or a chat version or all kinds of wonderful things that we might have in the future. This isn't so much of an issue for him because he does want to spin down. you know, during his lifetime. But for others, if you operate like this and you want your giving to endure, it is challenging to not be at the center of that of that giving. And so that could create some level of risk if everything kind of begins and and ultimately ends with you. So, if if you take away formal governance, you kind of need something to perform that that essential work. Yeah, meredith: Yeah. Quanda: for sure. and it's interesting to me, like one of the clearest through lines in Craig's story is really all about his commitment to keep things simple. And we talked about that like a moment ago. I mean Craigslist today looks very similar to Craigslist, meredith: Yeah. Quanda: in nineteen ninety nine, right? I mean he wanted this platform where users, could have fast and easy access to the resources that they need. And it's philanthropy, as we've discussed, is similarly lean. Small core operation, outsource operations for a wide variety of support functions. And then a a very clear and easy process for how to move money without like surrounding every single gift with a necessary machinery and and in people. And so I really wanted your perspective on like what do you think serious donors might misunderstand about simplicity and like why can a streamlined process actually be a mark of rigor rather than the lack of it? meredith: I these are great questions and Craig, it's in like there's a he optimizes for efficiency. And the reason he can do that is because he knows the organizations because of this due diligence and because he engages with the organization. And, you know, what he didn't talk about is that he's created a network. Well, actually he did talk about about how he he likes I mean that actually is What Craigslist began as is a mechanism to create a network of people who all were interested in something similar. and he and he still does that today through with his grantees and through his grantees. So that's part of his due diligence process. So what looks like simple from the outside is actually super thoughtful. and the other thing I think is really important is that because he's focused on a sh on a core number of issues, you know, no more than five. That he is able to become the content expert too in those Quanda: Right. meredith: areas and he knows the players in those particular ecosystems. So he he develops the sense of trust through building relationships with those organizations and those people. And then he's very deliberate about bringing all those people together. And because there's only five big issues. I those people that he supports get to know each other and then they create connections and and they can leverage those connections in support of the work that they're doing. So it's actually a more complicated he's created more complicated ecosystem than what exists on the surface, but I think at the core it's it's It's trust based philanthropy and I and I don't know if he's gonna ever write a book someday, but like I would love that book to be written by him about how you can be very clear about your goals, the issues you wanna tackle, and Quanda: Right. meredith: and be clear and develop trust with the people that you are going to invest in to to meet to meet those goals. I I just think it's it's pretty fascinating. And then the other thing is, you know, the more that you know, some of these bigger foundations, you know, Gates and and Omidiar and and well, Omidiar's focused has focused their work, but like at OSF or other these these big philanthropies, Ford, you know, they they tackle so many different issues that they have to have program officers to be the Quanda: Right. meredith: experts on these things, you know. So Craig is an expert on on on issues that he cares deeply about. And so he doesn't need to have Like a thousand people helping execute against his vision. So what's really interesting is a few years ago, I think it was twenty twenty four, there was a report on the state of nonprofits from the Center for Effective Philanthropy. And it found that, you know, sixty five percent of nonprofit leaders reported that funders were continuing or newly committing to streamlining applications, which is amazing. And and Craig has one of the most streamlined, like efficient applications you could possibly imagine. It's gorgeous as a fundraiser. You I wish everyone would take a page from his book that he hasn't yet written, though I hope he does. And then like a 65% 66% reported that there was like similar movement on reporting requirements. So the interesting thing away about Craig operates is that, you know, he, yeah, sure, you he wants to see an annual reflection about what do you think you accomplished and what kind of impact do you think you had, but you're contacting him and communicating with him and all of his other grantees in the areas that y'all share alignment with. Constantly, like all throughout the year, every week. So he's created this wonderful feedback mechanism that that is built into his Quanda: Right. meredith: philanthropic community, which at first you think, wow, that's so simplistic, but i it's not really. It's actually he's very it's really smart and he uses that network as a as a mirror, feedback loop, addis additional opportunities to identify opportunities to make greater impact. And it actually puts some of the due diligence on like it brings it front and center for all of his grantees, right? Like it's it's not just that he's gonna do it, but we all should be thinking about the impact we're having constantly together. so I guess yeah the key takeaway there is like simplify the burden, you know, on your Quanda: Right. meredith: grantees, not the thinking or the networking. I don't know. I was just he's he really is a different sort of philanthropist and it's refreshing. and he admits he's quirky, right? And he's a nerd and he professes that and I his in his humor is refreshing and and funny and sometimes you know you're not so sure how to take it. But what's also embedded in there is like this self-awareness about Quanda: Right. meredith: about his own operating. model and then his philanthropic operating model. Like he knows what he's really good at. and he knows where he thinks other people can benefit from. So he hasn't doesn't have to build like a huge internal department really because a foundation of his size is expected to have one. So you know I I wonder, how do you think donors should think about the difference between, you know, building their own philanthropic apparatus and then buying and borrowing and trusting the expertise of others. I mean, like this is kind of your this is your world. This is your business, you Quanda: Ha ha ha meredith: know, and your and your day job. I I'd love to hear your thoughts on that. Quanda: Yeah, I mean, I think it all begins with self-awareness, which you alluded to. I mean, Craig knows his strengths and his weaknesses. And that has led him to kind of pull the through line of simplicity from his business through his philanthropy and operate it efficiently and effectively because that's what he does. if you recall our first conversation on the podcast with Norman Ornstein and Judy Harris, they reflected on where they were as meredith: Right. Quanda: a couple and as a family and decided to create an operating foundation, which is kind of like the opposite of, what we're talking about here with Craig, where they did staff up and they did commit to spending a lot of their personal time and energy and effort developing. a debate institute and a series of documentaries, right? And so meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: I think it really just begins with self awareness in who you are as an individual or family, what your strengths and weaknesses are, and then what type of organization supports ultimately how you want to to deliver the impact in the area of your choice. And and I think that, starting this endeavor with an emphasis on, an MVP, right? A minimally meredith: Right. Quanda: viable product. Like what is the least amount of infrastructure meredith: Right. Quanda: I need? I think that is the question that meredith: Yeah. Quanda: that it it would be great for donors to kind of begin, their their journey when they're thinking about developing an actual vehicle. Like do you meredith: Right. Quanda: actually need to stand up a full, private foundation? Do you need to stand up an operating foundation? Could you, function with a donor advice fund or, you meredith: Right. Quanda: know, some other vehicle that could be a little simpler and less to maintain from an administrative and a legal and a tax perspective. So I think that those are all the questions that donors should ask themselves and they should also be thinking about the fact that like delegation is not disengagement, right? So nowhere meredith: Right. Quanda: have we discussed, don't volunteer or don't, be on the board or, or or don't, go and and visit institutions or programs. Like the structure that you stand up to deliver your philanthropy, does not mean that it dictates a level of engagement. So I I think that ultimately that is what I would love for like donors to take away from this part of the conversation meredith: Right. Quanda: is like start with a level of self self awareness, and think about what you can do and then look around at the many options available to you and start simple. meredith: Right. I love that. I love love that you're pulling from our Georgetown MBA program minimal viable product. I love that. Yeah, I think lots Quanda: Yes. We did lots of those, yeah. meredith: of those, right? No, it's simple. Yeah, I'd like keep it my mom used to say, Keep it simple, stupid. You know, I didn't really like the stupid part of that phrase, but Quanda: Right. No. meredith: but I do, you know, like start start simple, you know, trust people and then test performance, you know, Craig Repeatedly talks about his successes like finding people who are better at their jobs than he could ever be. Quanda: Mm-hmm. meredith: and then he also was like really honest diplomatically about like some of his gifts didn't perform as well as he expected, Quanda: Yeah. meredith: including gifts to institutions where the press the the prestigious reputation initially made them appear like they were a safe investment or safe choice for making a philanthropic gift. But ultimately like didn't live up to Craig's expectations. So what do you think his experience teaches us about the difference between informed trust and then simply being impressed by a name? Quanda: Yeah, I thought that if you kinda go back to his support of journalism in particular, right? So there are a number meredith: Mm. Right. Quanda: of schools of journalism that he has supported and he did not name names, but when you support similar organizations during similar work, you can kind of compare them a little meredith: Right. Quanda: more objectively. And the big message was like, hey, prestige doesn't necessarily Equal execution, just because an organization has a great reputation or has name recognition that doesn't necessarily translate into results. And I think that that is a hard lesson that any donor learns when trying to identify potential partnerships. But I think that was a really important one. But I think the flip side of that when you start thinking about informed trust is that. because Craig trusts himself and he trusts his own judgment, meredith: Mm. Quanda: he he he puts a lot of trust in the people who he surrounds himself with. And I meredith: Right. Quanda: think that is really important, so he doesn't have to be impressed by a name because he's gotten to know the people and organizations really well. He's done all the due diligence that remove, some of those other criteria. So I think that's really important is like thinking about, when you're choosing people and organizations to align with, just making sure that they're good at their job and that they, you meredith: Right. Quanda: know, have the ability to execute on what it is that they have said that they can do. I mean, look at their track record, look at the financial health of like an organization and the evidence that they've been able to produce from the programs that they've implemented. so I think that, it's it's it's important that, we kind of think about the role that Craig places on his trust in other people as like an a really integral part of his broader approach to philanthropy. And I think that there, is a lot that's instructive there. And if you kind of fast forward and think about the work that McKinsey Scott, has has done, I mean, we all have been incredibly impressed by her large, unrestricted gifts, to organizations. And the Center for Effective Philanthropy has done some research on the impact of those gifts. And they just continue to come back to like, These gifts have made these transformative gifts have made positive impacts on the organizations that have received them and very little harm has been done. meredith: Right. Quanda: Like very, very few situations can you actually point to where, the original intent of the gift was not was not lived out. So I mean, I think that's the important part of it. Like if you do your due diligence on people and institutions, you can be pretty confident that your donor intent will be met for for the most part. meredith: Agreed, agreed. Yeah. It trust. Simple trust. Quanda: Absolutely. and so when we start to kind of look at Craig's actual giving, right? So you talked a lot about how he gives. and meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: we've we've alluded to some of the areas that he supported, but some of his largest commitments have been toward like cybersecurity, scam prevention, journalism and veterans, really areas that some people might assume would be handled by the government. or potentially even markets, but like his approach is that hey, these systems are responsible for protecting people. And, if we're in a situation where there is lack of funding or lack of coordination or these institutions don't have technical capacity or they can't move quick enough, then people and institutions need to kind of step into that. So I mean from your perspective, what is Craig's cyber giving reveal about the role of like philanthropy in relationship to some of these larger public problems, you know, that feel kind of fragmented, maybe even too fragmented for any one individual to solve. meredith: Yeah, and cyber's like really tricky. well, actually cyber philanthropy, cybersecurity philanthropy has had a bumpy road over the last 10 years, and I'll talk about that in a little bit. But he's I will say Craig, again, being very clear and very focused for for the long haul here. and I think at some point democracy is gonna wake up in like 15, 20 years and thank God that Craig Newmark stayed on this course because it really is about like the backbone of trust in institutions and trust in people and the media. And so he's he really I love it. Like trust based philanthropy, you know, i is is his the name of the game for him. And cybersecurity in his investments, the philanthropic investments in that particular issue is about is about trust, right? So Quanda: Right. meredith: You know, cybersecurity for those who are not yet been touched by that that that that issue in your personal life, but probably have heard about it on the news. You know, there's you know, over a million complaints the FBI has been tracking in their ri re crime report in like a twenty twenty-five last year. You know, over twenty of was it twenty billion dollars in reported losses, and that's like A 26% increase in the year before as a result of Quanda: Wow, that's amazing. meredith: cybersecurity. You know, we're walking into a new election season here in America, and you know, cybersecurity is gonna be top of mind during the election. people over 60 years old often report more losses than than others, 7.7 billion dollars, underscoring that like humans are still vulnerable and will continue to be so, in a way that it sounds like a technical issue, like cybersecurity, that's not gonna affect me, right? But we've all been part of our our I our identities or our information has all been part of some cybersecurity breach. You know, if you own a bank card or a credit card. I mean you work in banks, you have Quanda: Yeah, for sure. Yeah. meredith: dealt with this. So Craig is, you know, he's focused on the issue in a way that he thinks is most important, which is elevating the level of awareness in across, you know, in the public sector and and educating people, investing in research and pilots and convenings and and so forth. and then the networks that can help have a you know have a greater impact around cybersecurity. So And I will say that is a particularly important because about 10 years ago the Hewlett Foundation tried to create a funding collaborative to focus on cybersecurity at a policy level, at a technical level, anywhere in between. And they got a number of big philanthropies, Craig being one of them, to support those efforts and commit to making investments across The ecosystem at various levels, you know, high level, big policy things, but then also Quanda: Right. meredith: ground level. And they they worked, you know, but they largely went away. It was like it felt like a fad in philanthropy that it shouldn't have been a fad. It should be a it could be a constant. And so what's really unique about Craig's philanthropy is that he he's maintained the focus where others have not. And I think I think we'll all benefit like society will benefit from us from it and and that he strengthened the connective tissue between his donors who are focused on this in a way that is really important to the field, right? So when a whole bunch of philanthropy gets dumped into a particular field, right, nonprofits. Meet the moment, they they sometimes either create programs or expand programs that didn't exist before. And then when that funding goes away, those nonprofits who are doing, you know, God's work and whatever issues it is are kind of left in the lurch a little bit, you know, whether the need Quanda: Right. meredith: is still there or not. And so Craig has been consistent throughout. And I really think that's made a difference. And and the work that he's done in with his philanthropy. you know, complements government efforts and complements market efforts and complements advocacy efforts and civil society efforts. So, you know, one of the principles I think that his philanthropy teaches us, those of us in the in the nonprofit world, but then philanthropists and in their own work is that, you know, philanthropy can build, it can test, it can connect people, and it can it can strengthen whatever existing systems can't yet do so well. So I I really think you know he's an outlier in this field and I hope more people come back into the into this field in with their philanthropic priorities. another issue, I think, Quanda that exemplifies this focus is his investments in journalism. Sort of fit the same framework, you know. Quanda: Right. Agreed. meredith: Trustworthy press is the immune system of democracy. You need to support institutions as well as infrastructure. He supports journalism schools. He has supported reporting organizations. He's actually been a first mover. And many of those newer fact-based reporting institutions pro publica. He talked a lot about Wikipedia and how important that was to him and the value that he believes that organization plays, not only in creating an editor community, but also, you know, a correction process, a feedback loop, and recognizing that it's, you know, iterative. So I was gonna ask you like, what do you think donors should learn? From the fact that Craig often funds the information systems and networks underneath public life rather than only the most visible programs. Quanda: Yeah, I mean, I think that the average donor is most familiar with direct service programs that, meredith: Right. Quanda: organizations deliver. And it's tangible, it's visible, it's easier to assess and evaluate. And so traditionally, the majority of philanthropy, goes to those types of programs. But I I think that, you don't you don't miss the infrastructure until it's not there, right? So the type of funding that Craig provides, I I think is so incredibly fundamental. he is a truly a visionary in in this space because he's able to see what a lot of others, can't see. And that is the importance of having kind of the underpinning of healthy institutions in tax. So I really feel like, if if there is an essential function that everybody is is relying on, then don't we also need to fund it? so when you think about meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: journalism, you think about cybersecurity. I mean, in a lot of ways, he's really ahead of the curve in making sure that from a foundational perspective, he can preserve, institutions and programs and and provide the the underpinnings of so many aspects of of life. meredith: Yes, and and if with all of that seriousness, right, and focus, he's incredibly funny. one of the most memorable moments of the episode is when he talks about pigeons and I've known him, Craig, for over fifteen years, so I know about the pigeon love, but you know, especially he talked about like ghost face killa, the backyard visitor who apparently has several wives and left behind a family. You know, I just Quanda: Yeah. meredith: love the story, it was so funny. Quanda: It was. meredith: but I also think it carries, you know, an important message about philanthropy, you know, disciplined strategy, you know, for giving can still include causes that are deeply personal and joyful and even eccentric, right? So, you know, why is that useful, do you think, for other donors to see that? Quanda: Yeah, I mean, Craig has really concentrated his giving in alignment with the core areas that he's focused meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: on, but leaving room like for pigeons, meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: it's like leaving room for joy, right? It's, meredith: Yeah. Quanda: it's it is I think so instructive to donors to feel like they have some flexibility and freedom in their giving and that every gift doesn't have to have a theory of change. every gift doesn't have to, impact a huge swath of people or, a major, major cause. I mean, there is meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: room in your philanthropy to express a wide variety of values. And that's meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: what I love about Craig's commitment to to pigeons. It, it meredith: Right. Quanda: it just demonstrates to all of us that, yeah, strategy is important. It gives us focus, it gives us intent. But it doesn't necessarily remove humanity from the equation. So I think that like a donor should take away from this that you can have a portfolio of organizations or causes or programs that you serve. And there's room for multiple areas of focus, but there's also room for simply giving to something that, you're interested in that, may not align with. all of those areas. And and the other thing too that I love about Craig's approach to this is that like he doesn't apologize, about it. meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: And he's very clear, he's given hundreds of thousands of dollars to pigeons. And so and meredith: Yeah. Yeah. Quanda: and he's he's confident, that he made the right choice for him. And I meredith: Right. Quanda: just I just love that he doesn't feel like every single thing that he does has to like bear the weight of his overall philanthropic strategy. And there is just some room, right, for you to give to things that are of interest to you or just things that reflect what you love. meredith: Right. No, I I I do. And it he he lights up in a different way, you know, when he talked about Quanda: He does. meredith: how he and his wife, you know, like look at the birds together and then when they're on the West Coast, what they look at, you know, in the backyard in San Francisco versus the backyard in New York and you know, it really does. And I like talking about it with them because it it does bring it does seem like a joyful topic. I mean Cybersecurity and veterans and, you know, the state of journalism and democracy. These are like really heavy issues. Quanda: Journalism, yeah. meredith: Then you're like, let's talk about pigeons. Yes, I'd love to do that. Quanda: Let's talk about pigeons. And it's interesting too because like we've talked about the wide range of giving that Craig has participated in, along the lines of various causes. But he's also given away not hundreds of thousands of dollars. He's given away hundreds of millions of of dollars. And but but relatively recently signed meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: the giving pledge. meredith: Right. Quanda: and he'd already been giving at this substantial level. And it was interesting because, like, what mattered most to him was not simply just appearing on a list of wealthy donors, but what mattered to him was the proportion of his resources that he was giving. He wanted people to know and he wanted to lead by example to say, I may not be a billionaire, but I'm giving at a super substantial level. for my personal level of wealth, and and I'm I'm curious, I mean, from your perspective, like what does this suggest about how donors should think about like enough and about the proportion of giving to their own capacity? meredith: Yeah. and that's like a tough conversation, right? At a time when there's great disparity between the haves and the have nots. And you see the haves with like accumulation not only and concentration of wealth, but of things, you know. and toys and assets and a different outwardly exemplary, artifacts that showcase their wealth, right? You know, and it's hard not to see that when you're on if you're on social media, right? And Quanda: Right. meredith: Craig's Craig's focus on his and on how he's choosing to spend his money is not in comparison to anyone else's. He's really not focused on that, you know, and he's not telling people what to do with their money. But what's the example that he provides is and the way he's talked about, you know, what is enough enough? Right and Quanda: Right. meredith: and you know, modesty and living with what you need and maybe not excessively more is is what's what's what's important to him. You know, he he's really humble. you know, going back to the themes that you and I have talked about over the years together, about humility and curiosity. I think he's he is he's humble about his beginnings and the opportunities. You know, we go back to the beginning of conversation, minimize, not monetize is just his framework for the world, like how he views the world, like the lens through which he views his actions and his modest giving can be meaningful for sure. And it represents like intention and consistency and I think Again, he's not in competition with anyone else and he's not judgmental about other people, but for him, giving away, like he he he's comfortable, right? And he knows he doesn't need a lot more. He's not in the business of monetization or accumulation. He's in the business of giving back and helping others. Again, we always talk about philanthropy and the root cause root word is, you know, love of humanity. it's not a it's not a moral competition, right? It's about Making giving a planned part of your of your resources and then, Quanda: Right. meredith: you know, using your resources in a way to make sure that you can survive and you can thrive and you can live your best life. but also whatever remains after you're personally satisfied, like can be given away. You know, what's enough for me and what becomes possible for others once I once I give that, give the excess away, you know, like that to me is like that is the most the loveliest intention, right? That is humility personified. Quanda: Yeah, it it is in Meredith, I think you're touching on so many important elements of like how Craig gives. And so meredith: Mm-hmm. Quanda: like give us the Craig Newmark donor framework. Like if you had to call out a handful of just like key concepts, what would those key concepts be? meredith: Absolutely. let's see. I would I mentioned a little bit before about giving across the continuum, and I'll I'll come back to that. So he's been very clear, clarify clarity about the values that you have. He talks about them in every interview. Quanda: Right, clarity. meredith: clarity about the problems that genuinely matter to you or that you see in the world that you think you can solve. Investigate again, that's like curiosity. Determine if there are people and organizations that are capable of meeting that challenge, of solving those problems. and if not alone, together. And he thinks Quanda: Right. meredith: you know that is part of his of his plan is bringing people together to tackle problems along the continuum of that problem, you know, and simplify, keep the process simple. You don't need fancy applications that are really in depth and like you know, accumulate all the things you could possibly do and give me fifty million examples of what the impact you're gonna have in the world and project out 30 years and then write me a report about what you did and what you didn't do wrong and make sure it's 12 pages long, you know. Yeah, he's keeping it simple. Process is proportionate to the gift and to the ability of the organization. He protects nonprofits' time. Go do the work. And then he creates a feedback mechanism, you know, as part of that simplification process. Delegate. Use intermediaries. Use Quanda: Yes. meredith: collaboratives, expert leaders, bring people together, to do some of the back-end things that you don't want to do yourself. And then I will say like this, he's a lifelong learner, right? And I don't think he would use those phrases him, that phrase himself, but he is he's he's curious. And so if you're curious, then you're naturally a lifelong learner. And he's created mechanisms to continually learn about the issues that he cares about. And he brings his grantees together to constantly talk about. About that, acknowledge good things, bad things, what worked, what didn't work, how you change course. and he's, you know, he's open to hearing all of it. And Quanda: Right. meredith: then, you know, create a mechanism, and he's done this that goes back to the learning part of like getting the feedback, governance, you know, testing assumptions, Quanda: Yeah. meredith: what works, what didn't work. and then, you know, deciding what you should do, you know, when you're gone. You know, when you're no longer the person who can be in charge, whether you create a bot in his case, you know, he hopes, you know, the Craig Chat bot maybe Craig I. version does something, or where it's something else, or that you truly like a Craig like a like Charles Feeney, you know, like where you really spend down everything you you you created with your wealth. You know, Charles Feeney was the founder of Atlantic Philanthropies and probably one of the greatest. examples of, you know, you can't take it with you. So let's make sure it does good work. And then the last thing I'll say, Quando, I think it's Craig does give along the continuum of a particular issue. And I'm really grateful for Quanda: Yes. meredith: that. personally and the work that we've that we've done together when we were at New America, where you it was like a he funded, you know, the incubator of ideas, of policy ideas, and the funding that he supports And directs to the McCourt School of Public Policy at Georgetown with, you know, aligns with his passion for supporting and advancing veterans and military families, right? So he supports Blue Star families, which helps veterans and military families across the continuum. He supports vets and tech. So when they come out of the military service, they can be upskilled and connected with the right places to get to get new jobs or new experiences. He supports the McCord School and veterans in public policy, right? Who are going to be the policymakers of the future. You know, the best way Quanda: That's great. Right. meredith: that you protect veterans and military in the future is you educate, you educate the future policymakers who will be making decisions that support them, right? So he does this with journalism. He funds journalism schools, students learning it, but then he also funds the journalists and the the the media organizations that those journalists end up at later on Wikipedia ProPublica so forth and so on. Quanda: Right. meredith: It's just he's again super focused, but he does diversify his philanthropy across the continuum of an issue. And I I just think it's super, super smart. Quanda: I agree with that. And I think that anyone listening can just take so much from the framework that you just articulated. And, they should simply know that like no due diligence process is gonna eliminate all of the uncertainty. But if you go into your philanthropy with intent, a a clear view of what it is that you wanna accomplish and vetted individuals and organizations. you can test and learn and ultimately achieve the impact that that you hope for. So it's it's been so exciting to have an opportunity to just sit back and think about all that we've discussed as it relates to the lessons that came out of the conversation with Craig Newmark. meredith: For sure. Quanda: Yeah. meredith: Absolutely. And and the one lesson that, you know, I didn't mention that you and I talked about before was leaving room for joy, you know, preserving some space Quanda: Yes, that was good. meredith: in your philanthropy that is a cause that like really delights you or like speaks to a part of your identity that is, you know, not part of your public persona, but is, you know, is curious and delightful. Like I I love that. I love that part and that Quanda: Great. meredith: lesson. What stays with me is that Craig made his most consequential strategic choice very early on. Minimize, monetize was not only a business decision, it was a decision about what is enough, what is concentration, what is the focus, and the kind of complexity he was willing to create. He did not wait for a future board to unwind an overbuilt institution, because he didn't overbuild it. I'm also struck by how much of his model depends on radical delegation and personal humility. He trusts a small number of capable people to do the work that formal governance performs elsewhere, and he uses humor to keep himself from becoming the central character in every story. Craig also referenced an unresolved question beneath many of his jokes. Who carries a deeply personal giving philosophy forward when there is no family or institution built to inherit it? Quanda: And what stays with me is the consistency between how Craig built and how he gives. Craigslist began because he wanted to be useful. He kept it simple because that served the people using it. And now his philanthropy follows the same logic. Understand the problem, reduce friction, support capable people, and keep it moving. But he also leaves room for humor, affection, and pigeons, and that matters. Philanthropy should be disciplined, but it should still sound and feel like the person doing the giving. meredith: If this reflection resonated with you, we encourage you to listen to our full conversation with Craig Newmark. You will hear much more about the origins of Craigslist, Craig Newmark Philanthropies, his commitments to cybersecurity, journalism, veterans and military families, women in technology, and the unforgettable ghost faced killer. Quanda: Thank you for joining us for this reflection episode of The Philanthropist: Personal Journeys of Giving with Purpose. You can also watch full episodes and exclusive content on our YouTube channel and follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram for behind-the-scenes reflections and upcoming conversations. And if this podcast is meaningful to you, please subscribe, review, and share. It really does help us grow this community. We would like to extend a special thanks to Lumina Foundation for their support and our good friends Jack Pompey and Connor Ellis of Goodpoint NYC for producing this episode. Meredith Hanley: To continue the conversation with us directly, email us at hello at the philanthropistpodcast.org. We generally want to hear what these stories are stirring in you. You can also watch full episodes and exclusive content on our YouTube channel and follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram for behind the scenes reflections and upcoming conversations. Quanda: I'm Quanda Allen. Meredith Hanley: And I'm Meredith Hanley. Until next time, give with purpose, give with joy, and give in a way that changes you too.