Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 222. Discussing Through Discomfort: Why the Conversations You Avoid Cost You the Most
Transcript
- 0:02Matt Abrahams: Often the things we really want are on the other
- 0:05side of a difficult conversation.
- 0:07My name's Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:10Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:12Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:16Today I'm really looking forward to speaking with Jennifer Wynn.
- 0:19Jenn is a professor at NYU Stern School of Business, where she's
- 0:23taught a class on difficult conversations for nearly ten years.
- 0:27Previously she was the Director of Education at the Obama Foundation.
- 0:30Additionally, Jenn hosts The H.I. Note Podcast and runs a consultancy focused
- 0:35on organizational transformation, change leadership and repair.
- 0:39Welcome, Jenn.
- 0:40I'm really excited for our conversation.
- 0:42Thanks for being here.
- 0:43Jenn Wynn: Thanks for having me, Matt.
- 0:44I'm excited to be here with you and the listeners, which include
- 0:47my executive MBA students.
- 0:49Matt Abrahams: Yes, absolutely.
- 0:50Well, shall we get started?
- 0:51Jenn Wynn: Yes.
- 0:52Matt Abrahams: So you teach a course on difficult conversations, and I'm curious
- 0:55what makes conversations so difficult?
- 0:58Is it the topic, the emotions, the circumstances?
- 1:01Where's the difficulty come from?
- 1:02Jenn Wynn: I wanna say all of the above, but at the core it's the emotions.
- 1:06It's the emotional reactivity.
- 1:09So, a quick way to think about this, in my first class of the Difficult Conversations
- 1:13course that I teach, I ask folks to call out topics that are difficult for them to
- 1:18discuss, and while they're calling it out, I'm typing the list into the slide deck.
- 1:23And we very quickly, not only fill the page with topics, but then you come to
- 1:28see that what's really difficult for one person is not that difficult for someone
- 1:33else, and in fact, some people enjoy it.
- 1:36So a topic like negotiations will terrify someone.
- 1:40I don't wanna negotiate my salary or getting a promotion or a negotiating
- 1:44fees with a client, and someone else will say, oh, I love a good negotiation.
- 1:48Let me take your negotiation on for you.
- 1:50Or saying No when a team member or a direct report wants extra
- 1:55resources, or a loved one asks you for help, and you've gotta say no.
- 1:59And it's so interesting because not only are people really unique, even
- 2:04idiosyncratic, it shows you that what makes a conversation difficult is much
- 2:10less the topic and much more the inner experience that each person is having.
- 2:15And so effective communicators, effective leaders know that they've gotta be
- 2:20self-aware of that inner experience that they're having in the moment.
- 2:23When I say inner experience, I mean what you're thinking and
- 2:26feeling, but not saying out loud.
- 2:29And what that makes you realize is, if I can be aware in the moment that
- 2:34I'm triggered, then I can pause.
- 2:36I can recenter, I can regulate my nervous system, and that way I'll
- 2:40be able to choose a better response.
- 2:43And I say to my students, your nervous system goes with you into
- 2:47every single difficult conversation.
- 2:49So if you can pause and regulate your nervous system, then you're
- 2:53gonna be a better version of yourself at the time when you most need to
- 2:56be the best version of yourself.
- 2:58So the implication of all of that is self-awareness and emotional intelligence
- 3:04are essential for leading difficult conversations to productive outcomes.
- 3:09Matt Abrahams: So we really have to reflect on our own experience
- 3:12before we can actually be present and engage in the conversation.
- 3:16And I think the point you made about difficult conversations
- 3:20aren't the same for everyone, and in fact, we need to appreciate that.
- 3:24So it's really appreciating your own experience and the emotions you're
- 3:28feeling and finding a way to get yourself grounded and be centered
- 3:32and prepared before you go in.
- 3:34Jenn Wynn: Yes, and open to hearing and understanding the other person's
- 3:39inner experience because if I happen to be the one who loves negotiations,
- 3:43but I'm sitting across from the person who's terrified by negotiations,
- 3:47I need to have the emotional intelligence to be aware of their
- 3:50inner state and help them manage that.
- 3:52And at the end of the day, the goal is for all members of the dialogue to move away
- 3:58from emotional reactivity towards choice.
- 4:01I wanna choose the better, more strategic path, not the reaction that
- 4:06came out of an emotional trigger.
- 4:08It's more choicefulness.
- 4:09Matt Abrahams: So it sounds to me like one of the key elements, or
- 4:13a couple of the key elements, of managing difficult conversations
- 4:17first starts with self-awareness.
- 4:19Being other aware and accepting doesn't mean agreeing, but accepting.
- 4:23And it sounds almost like there's an invitation involved where you're
- 4:27inviting the other person to share their inner experience so that you
- 4:30can meet them and then ultimately make choices in a choiceful way.
- 4:35Are there particular strategies or tactics people can use to help bring
- 4:41out that information in someone?
- 4:44Jenn Wynn: Yes.
- 4:45So we'll start with that self-awareness piece, since it is the foundation.
- 4:49I tell my students, if you only remember one framework from this
- 4:52entire course, please remember self-awareness, pause, reframe, okay?
- 4:57Self-awareness, pause, reframe.
- 4:59So what does that mean?
- 5:00In the moment am I aware of my physical cues, my cognitive and emotional
- 5:07cues that let me know i'm triggered, I'm heated up in this moment, right?
- 5:11So for me, I get a lump in my throat or like a tightness in my chest.
- 5:15Some people get, uh, butterflies in their stomach.
- 5:18I'm curious, what is it for you, Matt?
- 5:20Matt Abrahams: So I, I resonate totally with a tight chest.
- 5:22When I'm ready for battle or feel like battles coming I,
- 5:25my whole chest gets tight.
- 5:26Jenn Wynn: Yes.
- 5:27So each one of us think in advance, what's my tell sign, right?
- 5:30And once I know that, the moment I see it, I know I've gotta pause.
- 5:35And then here's the best thing.
- 5:36If I know my pause techniques, if I know what helps me metabolize my hormones,
- 5:42get that adrenaline out of my system, really regulate my nervous system,
- 5:46then I can be back to my centered self.
- 5:48So a go-to pause technique for me is to imagine myself with my best friend, Carla.
- 5:54Then I'm at ease, I'm centered, and that is our goal.
- 5:58That we lead these conversations to a productive outcome, both
- 6:01for the content, the matter at hand, and for the relationship.
- 6:05So that last step, reframe, is where I actually shift away from viewing
- 6:11this conversation as a threat to something I care about, and instead
- 6:15perceiving it as a learning opportunity.
- 6:17What good information can I get out of this?
- 6:19So self-awareness, pause, reframe is a framework I always
- 6:23ask my students to remember.
- 6:24Matt Abrahams: I really like the taking the time to check in with yourself.
- 6:28Both how am I feeling emotionally but physically and use the
- 6:31physical as a trigger to help you.
- 6:33Pausing is wonderful.
- 6:34I love that you rely on a friend.
- 6:36I have a place I go to in my mind.
- 6:38There is a particular tree in Sydney, Australia that faces the Opera House and
- 6:43the Harbor Bridge, and when I get worked up, if I just envision that in what I
- 6:47felt like when I saw it, it's my place of zen that really helps calm me down.
- 6:52And then this notion of reframing from one of threat to one of learning, one
- 6:57of collaboration, one of invitation.
- 6:59One of my colleagues, Michele Gelfand, likes to say, mind your metaphors, and
- 7:03the metaphor you bring to the interaction helps determine how it's going to be.
- 7:06So if I see it as a learning opportunity, this difficult conversation
- 7:10is going to go very differently than if I see it as a battle.
- 7:12So I really appreciate that.
- 7:14Share with us some of the other tips you have, especially if
- 7:16there are particular barriers that get in the way to doing this.
- 7:19Jenn Wynn: Some of the most common barriers I see are not
- 7:22having the conversation at all.
- 7:24I'd say a second one, not having a goal.
- 7:26And a third, I'd say not listening enough.
- 7:29Often when we don't have the conversation, it's because we assume it will go poorly,
- 7:34so we give up before we've even started.
- 7:36But here's the thing.
- 7:37Most things that we want in life are on the other side
- 7:41of a difficult conversation.
- 7:42Sometimes it's a difficult conversation with myself.
- 7:45Sometimes it's a difficult conversation with a loved one, a colleague, a boss.
- 7:50But a lot of those things that we really want and we've been longing
- 7:53for and haven't gotten yet, are gonna require us to get to the other
- 7:56side of a difficult conversation.
- 7:57So are you just going to give up on your biggest dreams in life because you weren't
- 8:03willing to take the time to step outta your comfort zone and practice a skill?
- 8:07Because that's the thing.
- 8:08You know this Matt.
- 8:09Communication is a set of skills, learnable, growable skills, and
- 8:14difficult communication is a set of hard, but worth it skills.
- 8:20Matt Abrahams: It is important to remember that these difficult conversations
- 8:24are one of many conversations that we will likely have with these
- 8:27people or in this environment.
- 8:29So we're not only trying to come to a mutually agreed to resolution, in
- 8:34the short term, for this situation, but we're setting ourselves up
- 8:37for the future, and the next one.
- 8:39You mentioned listening, and that's a skill that my wife is
- 8:42still encouraging me to work on.
- 8:44I'm curious, how do you help your students to be better listeners
- 8:47in these difficult conversations?
- 8:50Jenn Wynn: Yes.
- 8:51So sometimes the issue is not listening enough and sometimes it's
- 8:55not showing that we are listening.
- 8:58So those are two distinct skill sets.
- 9:00At the end of the day, I think about dialogue as the free flow of meaning.
- 9:03And so if I've done it well, effective dialogue grows the shared
- 9:08pool of understanding between us.
- 9:10I understand how you made meaning of a situation and you understand
- 9:14how I made meaning of a situation.
- 9:16So that means that I've gotta inquire, I've gotta ask enough questions to
- 9:20understand how you experienced that, that client meeting, that argument
- 9:25my husband and I may have had.
- 9:26And then once I've listened, internalized, the meaning you
- 9:31made, I've gotta paraphrase it back as a check for my understanding.
- 9:35A real humble attempt to say, this is my summary of what I think you experienced.
- 9:41But is that right?
- 9:42Fix what I'm missing?
- 9:43Is it half right and I miss the other half?
- 9:45And once we can paraphrase, this is a skill that, honestly, I think it's
- 9:50like punching above its weight, right?
- 9:53After I've taken all this time to really ask these open, thoughtful questions,
- 9:57get curious, understand your perspective, make sure you show the person that
- 10:02you are internalizing what they said.
- 10:04And like you said, it's not agreeing, it's just acknowledging.
- 10:07And when they finally say yes, that's it.
- 10:10Then you've grown the shared pool of understanding, at
- 10:13least from their perspective.
- 10:14And then you can go share yours, and that's where you move into advocacy.
- 10:18But at the end of the day, the balance you're looking for is
- 10:20inquiry, paraphrasing and advocacy.
- 10:24And inquiry and paraphrasing are listening skills, both to understand
- 10:28what the other person experienced and confirm with them that my understanding
- 10:32was correct of their experience.
- 10:34And the advocacy skills, the talking one, right?
- 10:36That's essentially a two thirds, one third ratio, and I don't mean it as
- 10:40an exact science, but I did have a student say to me one time, oh, so
- 10:44that's why my parents said you have two ears and one mouth for a reason.
- 10:49A lot more listening and confirming that I understood you
- 10:53correctly from your perspective before I dive into sharing mine,
- 10:57Matt Abrahams: I like your definition of listening as seeking shared understanding.
- 11:02And when you take that approach, it definitely puts you in a place of being
- 11:08present, of being humble, because you're checking, maybe I didn't get it right.
- 11:14And leveraging, what I think is one of the most powerful communication
- 11:17skills, which is paraphrasing because it does so much for us.
- 11:20I really appreciate that approach.
- 11:23I'd like to turn our conversation to a different topic.
- 11:26I know you are likely getting similar questions to me with artificial
- 11:29intelligence, AI, coming into things.
- 11:32How do you envision that AI could actually help us with some of these
- 11:35tricky communication situations?
- 11:37Jenn Wynn: Yes, I have seen several of my students find some really great uses
- 11:42for AI, so I'll give some examples.
- 11:45Sometimes I have a student who wants to work on their tone.
- 11:48They've received feedback that their tone is getting in the way of their
- 11:51message being received, and so they'll type in what they wanna say and
- 11:56say, make that tone more friendly, or make that tone more respectful.
- 12:02And get a sense for what some other language, some other word choice might be
- 12:06to help them still deliver an authentic message, but in a way that can be heard.
- 12:11So that's one interesting way.
- 12:13I think another is coming up with perspectives that I
- 12:16haven't considered, right?
- 12:17Here's the problem I'm dealing with.
- 12:19What other perspectives could there be?
- 12:20Or here's my take.
- 12:22And then recently I had a student really enjoy the role plays that we
- 12:26did in class, but not have someone back in her apartment to role play with.
- 12:31And she actually asked ChatGPT to role play with her, uh, which
- 12:35I thought was such a cool idea.
- 12:37And I just think at the end of the day, we have to keep in mind that this
- 12:39is one perspective based on whatever data this particular LLM has been
- 12:45trained on, and not take it as the final word, but just more options.
- 12:49Matt Abrahams: Practice for these situations can be so important,
- 12:52as with any communication, and using a tool to do that.
- 12:55And I really like this idea of having a tool help you see what
- 12:58other wording can affect tone in a way that you might not see.
- 13:02I like that a lot.
- 13:03Like me, you host a podcast, one that I've enjoyed very much.
- 13:06I'm curious to learn how you balance your inquiry to challenge your guests
- 13:10without turning your interviews into challenging conversations.
- 13:14In other words, how do you put your audience at ease enough to have the deep,
- 13:19meaningful conversations that you have?
- 13:21Jenn Wynn: So on The H.I. Note podcast we're talking about how people
- 13:26healed from some really tough stuff.
- 13:29You know, childhood trauma, loss of loved ones, disease, goodness,
- 13:34toxic relationships, you name it.
- 13:36And so before I asked them to share about some of the toughest moments in their
- 13:41lives, I start by surprising them with three things that I love about them.
- 13:46And so this is not in the agenda that I send them ahead of time.
- 13:51But when we sit down to chat, I let them know three elements of who
- 13:56they are that I absolutely love.
- 13:58And it's amazing to see how, not only pleasantly surprised they are, which
- 14:05is just a nice moment of pure joy and connection, but also to see how once
- 14:10they feel seen as a whole person, and in a strengths based and affirming way,
- 14:16they become more generous in what they share and the conversations go deeper.
- 14:22And I learn such amazing insights because they've really let down any walls or any
- 14:28pretense and just shared from the heart.
- 14:30And it's been a beautiful gift to see how powerful asset-based framing is, and
- 14:36I've brought that over into my classes.
- 14:38So for Difficult Conversations, and for the other courses I teach, in the very
- 14:43beginning, in the first session, I'll ask folks to gather up in trios and do
- 14:47an exercise that I call at your best.
- 14:49And so they'll share in trios times they were at their best
- 14:53during a difficult conversation.
- 14:54And then the feedback that they give one another is strengths based.
- 14:58So, this action that you took had a tremendously positive
- 15:01impact, do that again.
- 15:03Or, wow, I'm really impressed how you shifted your mindset right there
- 15:07in the middle of being triggered and now I'm gonna go do that as well.
- 15:12And students say that they not only feel seen after that exercise, but
- 15:17that the classroom environment is more psychologically safe and enables them to
- 15:22be more brave in the rest of the course.
- 15:25Matt Abrahams: I love that as an opening activity.
- 15:27I'm going to borrow it, if you don't mind, to have people think about in my course,
- 15:31a time where they were able to communicate strategically in a way that was successful
- 15:35and then to get that positive affirmation.
- 15:37I really like this idea of leading with connection.
- 15:41You sharing the three things that you really appreciate about the person is
- 15:45a way of connecting and saying, I see you, I know you and I respect you.
- 15:50And that opens up the door to perhaps more challenging or, or deeper conversations.
- 15:55Thank you for that.
- 15:57Well, as you know, as someone who listens to the podcast, I end
- 16:00every episode with three questions.
- 16:02One I make up just for you, and two, I ask everybody, are you ready for that?
- 16:05Jenn Wynn: I think so.
- 16:06Matt Abrahams: Yes, you're gonna do great.
- 16:07I'm going to ask you the unfair question that I always get asked, 'cause
- 16:10I'll be curious about your answer.
- 16:12So people will often ask me, what's the one thing I can do
- 16:16to improve my communication, as if there is one magic key.
- 16:20But I'm asking you this question because I hope it gives you an opportunity to
- 16:23talk about something that we haven't talked about, because we've talked
- 16:25about a lot of really deep, meaningful communication bits of advice, know your
- 16:30audience, know yourself, paraphrase.
- 16:32Is there something that we haven't covered that you think is important?
- 16:35Jenn Wynn: Practice.
- 16:36At the end of the day, the goal is not perfection.
- 16:39It doesn't exist.
- 16:41The goal is continual improvement.
- 16:44I wanna keep getting better and better.
- 16:46And so the way to do that, of course, like any muscle building activity is practice.
- 16:52And so I really do, not only create a lot of practice opportunities for
- 16:56my students in class, but I give them ideas of how they might continue
- 17:00practicing after the class is over.
- 17:03And my suggestion is to make it a little more challenging each time.
- 17:08So start with the low stakes day to day stuff.
- 17:11When you're chatting with your roommate, ask a few more questions
- 17:13than you might have otherwise asked so that you build that inquiry muscle.
- 17:16But then when you have a disagreement with a colleague, if you think, this
- 17:21might actually make a difference if I shared this one perspective, try out
- 17:25stating your intention, sharing your perspective, and then asking for a greater
- 17:30understanding on their perspective.
- 17:32And as we continue to have more and more repetition, right, as we build in the
- 17:36reps, we're not only gonna build the muscle, which feels good, but then it's
- 17:40gonna be ready for us to flex when the moment counts, when we're in the most
- 17:45consequential conversation, we will have already built up those great question
- 17:50asking muscles, those great paraphrasing muscles, those great intention stating
- 17:54muscles, and so on and so forth.
- 17:56So practice, practice, practice, and make it a little more
- 17:59challenging each time along the way.
- 18:01Matt Abrahams: And I think that's absolutely dead on.
- 18:03We have to practice.
- 18:04I'll be curious to hear your answer, who's a communicator you admire and why?
- 18:08Jenn Wynn: Michelle Obama.
- 18:09Her authenticity is palpable.
- 18:13When she's sharing, it's not only real and true for her and others in the
- 18:18room, it's the heart of the matter.
- 18:21She's not being authentic about things on the fringe.
- 18:25She's getting to that piece that lands in the pit of my stomach that I may
- 18:29not have had the courage to share.
- 18:31And she has so many great quotes, one of which is, courage is contagious.
- 18:35And I feel that in her presence or when I'm watching a speech of hers.
- 18:39And then of course her ability to connect, but she's fantastic at connection
- 18:43through relatable storytelling and humor.
- 18:46And I've seen that in her most casual and impromptu moments
- 18:50and in her prepared speeches.
- 18:52It's just a part of who she is.
- 18:54Matt Abrahams: Courage is contagious.
- 18:56Really profound actually.
- 18:58And connection, and the ability to connect.
- 19:01Storytelling is a key tool for that.
- 19:04Alright, what are the first three ingredients that go into a
- 19:07successful communication recipe?
- 19:10Jenn Wynn: Audience, intent or goal, and listening.
- 19:15Uh, we've already spoken about the importance of knowing where the
- 19:19other person is at and how to meet them where they are at, right?
- 19:22Emotionally, during that time of day or in their schedule, what matters most to them.
- 19:28Understanding how to create a shared goal, right, which goes into the second piece.
- 19:34And then the last piece, you might've thought it'd be something around
- 19:38know what your message is, or be clear on what your message is.
- 19:42But the reason I think it's listening is because if I'm really growing
- 19:46the shared pool of understanding, if I'm really hearing your perspective
- 19:50and understanding it to a level that I didn't understand before, I may
- 19:55actually have a new idea, right?
- 19:58I've heard the quote, dialogue is the birthplace of synergy.
- 20:02Your information and the way you made meaning of that information might
- 20:07create, not just a new perspective within me, but a new meaning making, a new
- 20:12understanding of what matters most and therefore, what I'm most wanna drive home.
- 20:16So, audience, intent or goal, and listening.
- 20:21Matt Abrahams: So audience and intent and listening.
- 20:23Jenn, this has been a fantastic conversation.
- 20:25You have equipped me, and hopefully our listeners, with many tools they can
- 20:29use, and you have certainly increased our shared understanding and meaning.
- 20:33Thank you for joining us and thank you for your time.
- 20:35Jenn Wynn: Thank you for having me.
- 20:36This was fun.
- 20:39Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 20:41Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 20:44To learn more about difficult conversations listen to episode
- 20:4722 with David Demarest.
- 20:49This episode was produced by Ryan Campos, Katherine Reed, and me, Matt Abrahams,
- 20:54at the Spotify Studios in New York City.
- 20:57Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 20:59With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 21:01Find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 21:04Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 21:07Also, follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram.
- 21:09And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 21:13learning content, and our newsletter.