Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E014: Flash & the Future of Payment Gateways with Pierre Corbin
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes. Down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless,
- 0:14artificial. Gold.
- 0:16Is it still rat poison? Probably rat poison squared.
- 0:19We need to get into the world of OK, this is actually
- 0:22foundational. Technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:29which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 0:41the roller gun. The one thing that's missing
- 0:44that that will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 0:51Welcome back to Final Settlement.
- 0:54It is Wednesday, October 9th, and today we're joined by a
- 0:58fascinating guest, Pierre Corbin.
- 1:01Pierre is the founder and CEO of a Bitcoin payments company, more
- 1:05specifically a Bitcoin payment gateway platform called Flash.
- 1:10And Michael and I have had the opportunity to get to know
- 1:13Pierre over the past few months and quickly became eager, eager
- 1:18to get him on the pod and and share a little bit more about
- 1:21what he's been building. So we have plenty of topics to
- 1:24get into today with Pierre, but welcome to the show.
- 1:27How are you doing today, Pierre? Thanks.
- 1:30Thanks, Brian. Good to be here and I'm doing
- 1:34great. Yeah, I think, you know, we,
- 1:37we've had a number of conversations in recent months,
- 1:40in recent weeks and just really getting excited about what you
- 1:43guys are building. But maybe a, a logical place to
- 1:46start would be a little bit more about yourself and, and your
- 1:49background, your, your journey to Bitcoin, if you will.
- 1:53You know, having started more in sort of the traditional world of
- 1:57consulting and then even doing some, some filmmaking and then
- 2:01ultimately deciding to, to build in Bitcoin and build flash.
- 2:04So maybe a little bit of color around your journey and and sort
- 2:07of past influences and and work and study.
- 2:11Yeah, Peter, before before jumping into it, I just thought
- 2:13of, I didn't see it, I don't know if anybody watched, but
- 2:15it'll be interesting to hear your take as a Bitcoin
- 2:18filmmaker, how you would contrast that as compared to
- 2:22whatever was shown last night on SBF.
- 2:26Yeah, I didn't watch it actually.
- 2:27I've just seen Twitter, all of all of that.
- 2:29And I believe Peter Todd is actually Satoshi, right?
- 2:32I think that's what, yeah, that's that's.
- 2:34That's where they landed. I I watched it.
- 2:35It was it was flimsy at best, at best.
- 2:40Like it was there was no like hard evidence, no smoking gun.
- 2:44And I think for for people who who know who Peter Todd is, like
- 2:48there's a lot of reasons why he isn't Satoshi that I think just
- 2:52weren't covered in the film. And he sort of left left those
- 2:55out. So, yeah.
- 2:57But curious once you do get to wash it, what what your thoughts
- 3:00would be? Yeah, but there is one film.
- 3:03So I also organized Bitcoin Film Fest and we screened at this
- 3:07year's edition, we screened a film Searching for Satoshi that
- 3:11is a Canadian film. And this, this one is really
- 3:14good when it comes to investigating who could be
- 3:16Satoshi. And it doesn't really come to a
- 3:19conclusion, which I think is is also good about it.
- 3:23But yeah, I don't think Peter Todd is the one I have more
- 3:28another idea based on, based on that film that I recommend
- 3:31everyone to go to go check out searching for censorship.
- 3:35Yeah. But OK, so a bit about myself.
- 3:38So I'm Pierre Corbin. I'm I'm French and Spanish.
- 3:42I live in in Poland. Just kind of lived all my life
- 3:45going back and forth. I studied finance and during my
- 3:50degree I just picked up programming because I thought it
- 3:53would be, you know, just a good skill to have.
- 3:56And I completely got into, I mean, I was studying at night, I
- 4:02was working also restaurants and evenings and I would spend 8
- 4:05hours a day just programming. So it was, yeah, a crazy time.
- 4:10But you know, this led me to starting my first job after
- 4:14after my, my studies and I, it was just programming a lot and
- 4:20trying to get as much programming as possible into my
- 4:22daily work. And I just started automating a
- 4:25bunch of tasks for everyone in the teams.
- 4:27And little by little this got me into working in financial
- 4:31information systems of different companies.
- 4:33I was consultant at Accenture and most year round financial
- 4:37information systems as well. But of course, it all depends on
- 4:40the project and such. And in that time, I was just
- 4:44studying Bitcoin a lot. I started with, you know, crypto
- 4:49in 2017, I guess. You know, many people started
- 4:52their the. Hero's Journey.
- 4:54You're right exactly and made a bunch of money that I then lost
- 4:57a bunch because that was all crypto stuff.
- 5:00But then, you know, during the bear market, that's when I
- 5:03actually, you know, no one cares about crypto during a bear
- 5:06market. No one talks about that anymore.
- 5:07And so the only thing that there was reads talked about was
- 5:09Bitcoin. And so I started studying a lot
- 5:12more just Bitcoin, Bitcoin, Bitcoin and yeah.
- 5:15And in in 2021, I was just so obsessed about it that I was
- 5:21just getting tired of my job. There was no going back to the
- 5:24office or anything. I just, you know, wanted to
- 5:26change. And I thought it's the time to
- 5:29quit my job and focus on Bitcoin because I think that's the, you
- 5:34know, greatest technology, the greatest invention in my
- 5:37lifetime. So, you know, that's what I
- 5:38should focus my time on. But the first thing I did was,
- 5:42yeah, not in programming. Actually, it was in film making.
- 5:45Filmmaking was just something I really always enjoyed.
- 5:48I also did a filmmaking course when I was a student.
- 5:51It was just a storytelling is something I'm attracted to and I
- 5:56always wanted to do something in that.
- 5:57And you know when you quit your job and you say I'm going to
- 6:01work in Bitcoin, it doesn't really mean anything.
- 6:04So I was just trying to figure out what I wanted to, what I
- 6:07wanted to do, and I watched the documentary that really inspired
- 6:12me and I thought I can do the same thing.
- 6:14It's just about storytelling and and good research.
- 6:17So yeah, so, so I did The Great Resets and the Rise of Bitcoin.
- 6:22If anyone hasn't watched it, I recommend it.
- 6:25And yeah, multiple things happened along the way.
- 6:29Bitcoin Film Fest was the first initiative, you know, trying to
- 6:32bring a bit more of Bitcoin only culture and community here in
- 6:37Poland as well. We did the second edition this
- 6:40year, but last year I was also just contacted friend of mine
- 6:49reached out saying, look, let's meet let's talk because he knew
- 6:52I was of course very technical. We had very similar backgrounds
- 6:54when it came to the the corporate work that we did, but
- 6:57completely separately. And and he told me about, you
- 7:00know, what we can do with, with AI, how easy it is to build
- 7:03things now and there's a big opportunity.
- 7:05Maybe we should do something about it.
- 7:07And and so, you know, he told me everything about how how this
- 7:11works. And I thought, OK, that's,
- 7:12that's very interesting. I'm happy to do something in it.
- 7:15Let's try and find some ideas. But it has to be Bitcoin focused
- 7:20because of course I want to dedicate myself to Bitcoin.
- 7:22So if I was going to spend my time on something that was even
- 7:26AI related, it had to be around around.
- 7:28And so we created a talk to Satoshi, which was an AI chatbot
- 7:33that was taking just different books for each of the answers
- 7:38and it would answer as if it was Satoshi.
- 7:40And we released this in May, I believe, of last year.
- 7:45And it was, it was a really good success.
- 7:47There was, you know, over 300 articles written in a week.
- 7:49We were, it was very exciting. And yeah.
- 7:53And that's when you know, with, with so with my friend, we just
- 7:57realized that working on this was was really good.
- 7:59We had similar ideas with the similar kind of things.
- 8:01We're driving us forward. And so we decided to do more out
- 8:05of this. And that's when he became my Co
- 8:07founder at Flash. And we, I mean, we didn't start
- 8:11with what Flash is right now. I think that's what happens to
- 8:14most businesses. At first we were trying to
- 8:17figure out, OK, is there really opportunity in AI and what can
- 8:21be done with it? And it's quite tough.
- 8:25We don't, I mean, we can go there if you want to, but, but
- 8:27essentially it's, it's, I think it's a tough place to make money
- 8:30because you're just always chasing for the next new thing.
- 8:33And I think it's not a great way to build business over the, the
- 8:36long term because you end up always competing against the big
- 8:39ones, I think. But what we decided to do was,
- 8:43OK, well, maybe there's a way to use the Lightning Network for
- 8:47microtransactions and Noster for messaging, so everything is
- 8:52private and encrypted. And this way we could create the
- 8:55marketplace of APIs and of data storage.
- 8:59They're called vector stores that then developers would be
- 9:03able to just, you know, plug and play essentially in their own
- 9:05applications. And for each API request, there
- 9:08would be this microtransaction that happens before the response
- 9:11is, is given, which is great, super cool, but very, very, very
- 9:15niche. And we, we kind of realised that
- 9:18and we thought maybe that's, that's not really the way to go.
- 9:20But, but while working on that, we stumbled upon Noster wall
- 9:26connect and generally just using Noster more for user management
- 9:32and so on. And, and in, in, you know,
- 9:35building that we had, we called it Noster X.
- 9:37That was the name of that project.
- 9:39And in building that we realized that actually the power in all
- 9:42of this is Nostril Wallet Connect because there's so many
- 9:46complicated tools out there even today or, or things that are
- 9:51added to, you know, certain protocols that are being created
- 9:55and that I think are complicated.
- 9:58And Nostril Wallet Connect really simplifies that while
- 10:02making sure there's always self custody and that it's integrated
- 10:07and interoperable with with all of the wallets that use nostril
- 10:11wall connected. And that's when we thought, OK,
- 10:13maybe that's that's why we need to actually push further.
- 10:16That's because if we can trigger payments for people, well then
- 10:19we can change how applications are being built.
- 10:23And that's what Nostril Wall Connect does.
- 10:26We're just trying to find a way where we could fit in that and
- 10:30where would there be the strongest need for that because
- 10:33there's a lot of applications that can be built that leverage
- 10:37this. I mean, you can think of a
- 10:39Noster client that allows direct payments and so on without ever
- 10:42holding custody of users funds thanks to Noster Walk Connect.
- 10:45And that's a great use case. But I think it's difficult to
- 10:48build a Noster client. And if what it really changes is
- 10:52how payments are made, how Bitcoin payments are made, One,
- 10:55in that case, we should go for the payments market because this
- 10:58is where a lot of tools are going to be needed and Noster
- 11:00Walk Connect can leverage, I mean can be leveraged for this.
- 11:05At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 11:08asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 11:12right. There are shortcomings with
- 11:14keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 11:17up your own self custody arrangement.
- 11:19Onramp solves for these concerns.
- 11:22Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 11:25minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 11:28remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 11:32inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 11:34well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 11:37for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 11:40for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 11:43setup. For more information, check us
- 11:46out at on rampbitcoin.com. Yeah, I know.
- 11:49It's it's fascinating because I think the the vast majority of
- 11:53people who have gotten interested in Noster, even like
- 11:57a cursory interest, I think most of them have been focused on,
- 12:01you know, Twitter clones like the social media aspect of what
- 12:04Nosfer can do. And I think the a real key
- 12:07inside of what you found with Nostra wallet connect in
- 12:10particular is like this is extremely applicable to the
- 12:13payments world and actually making Bitcoin payments more
- 12:17reliable, more usable and, and just more efficient generally.
- 12:21Could you drill down a little bit more on, you know, we, we've
- 12:23talked about Nostra on the show a few times, but just a, a bit
- 12:27of an overview of how you view Noster as this open
- 12:31interoperable protocol that is very complementary to, to
- 12:34Bitcoin and Lightning. And then more specifically, what
- 12:38Noster Wallet Connect actually does and what it unlocks.
- 12:43So essentially, you know, the Noster protocol is just a set of
- 12:46rules just like e-mail SMTP is and anyone can create a client
- 12:50for that. And of course the the features
- 12:53that are added into Noster for the first features that were
- 12:57added at least were really social network features.
- 12:59The idea being that we could have decentralized kind of
- 13:02Internet with decentralized social network.
- 13:04So you can just, you know, have your own personal profile
- 13:08information, you can post things, you can send DMS and so
- 13:11on. But then Bitcoin was added on to
- 13:14it, right? And this is this is great
- 13:17because we see a lot of really, really good use cases around it.
- 13:21And the first use cases that everyone has been looking around
- 13:24looking at, as you mentioned, is a client that just interfaces
- 13:28like a Twitter or other platforms like that.
- 13:32But I think that's really just the very first use case because
- 13:35I think the, and even that's already a layer 2A kind of use
- 13:40case, because the first part of it that is very interesting for
- 13:43everyone is the fact that I have my profile and I can just jump
- 13:47from one client to the other and just experience the same network
- 13:52differently. So the, the thing that people
- 13:55find really cool is not the social network side of it is the
- 13:59the user management side of it. And that's something that that
- 14:02we really want to be able to leverage at Flash because so
- 14:07when you create an account in Flash, even if you log in by
- 14:09e-mail, we create Noster keys for you.
- 14:12And this is everything that we use in our back end.
- 14:15And this is how we also allow for communications on Noster
- 14:19through the profiles that are created on Flash, because Flash
- 14:23is essentially also a Noster client.
- 14:26The only thing is that we don't look at posts.
- 14:28We don't, Yeah, none of that. We just take care of user
- 14:31profile information, some encryption things to Noster, and
- 14:36then Noster Wallet. And Noster Wallet connect is it
- 14:41allows for wallets and relays. So it allows for a wallet to
- 14:47know to be connected to a relay and it allows for wallets to
- 14:51communicate via Noster. So it solves a bunch of
- 14:55problems. One of them is the always on
- 14:58server kind of thing. There's just technical necessity
- 15:01and difficulty in the space. But generally speaking, the main
- 15:06feature that it brings to the table is that it is a a shared
- 15:11API among every single nostril wallet connect participant.
- 15:16So if you're a wallet owner, company, startup or whatever it
- 15:22is, it takes an afternoon or such to integrate Noster Wallet,
- 15:28connect to your wallet. And the moment you do that, well
- 15:30then developers, they can use one function and it'll be the
- 15:34same function for all of the different walls that are there.
- 15:37So me as an application developer, I do not care what
- 15:41wallet the user is using. I don't need to create the
- 15:45individual integrations with all of these wallets, look at their
- 15:48API documentation and I don't need that, I just need one.
- 15:53And this is pretty powerful because it allows to bring
- 15:58wallets together in one interface.
- 16:01And wallets essentially become backends to any of the
- 16:04applications that are being built.
- 16:06And each application can recreate their own interface of
- 16:09a wallet because you have access to all of these functionalities,
- 16:12which I think is just in terms of breaking down the concept of
- 16:16what a wallet is. It's pretty interesting, I think
- 16:19can bring a lot of change. Yeah, it's hard to comprehend
- 16:22it. Like even the the Twitter
- 16:25instance, it's the notion of user management and having salt
- 16:29silent gardens with Twitter, Facebook and and then being able
- 16:32to port over the public key and then manage that profile is one
- 16:38thing. But then when you start thinking
- 16:39about like the Venmo's, the cash apps and every financial
- 16:42institution has its own user management login and they don't
- 16:46speak to each other. And so effectively, you can
- 16:49still have the you can have the Bitcoin layer that's
- 16:51interoperable. So from like strike to cash app,
- 16:53you can send Bitcoin, but they still don't allow for any kind
- 16:57of payment infrastructure because bitcoins naturally push
- 16:59protocol. So you need an intermediary like
- 17:02protocol, which is noster to manage or noster plus wallet
- 17:04connect. But then the 2nd order effects
- 17:07are still like mind bending on like what that entails from a
- 17:11Bitcoin that we haven't seen. But then B just the traditional
- 17:13financial architecture that is historically bit this like
- 17:16siloed garden. It's fast.
- 17:18It's it's a fascinating. Did did I summarize at least
- 17:21part of the like innovation or or things that are changing here
- 17:25with that? Yeah, at the at the high level
- 17:28that that's exactly what it is. Because then we we could enter
- 17:31in in the granular and there's like, and I mentioned this a few
- 17:35minutes ago as well. There's this new feature
- 17:37essentially that is brought to thanks enough to work and that
- 17:40is generally brought to Bitcoin. Generally, whether it is on
- 17:44chain lightning liquid E cash, it doesn't matter is the fact
- 17:47that Nostril Wallet connect allows for direct debit.
- 17:52So essentially as if I have a wallet that is installed on my
- 17:57phone or I mean whatever kind of thing that is Nostril Wallet
- 18:00compatible, I can connect my wallet to an application and
- 18:04give a limited control over my wallet by this application.
- 18:11Yeah. And then the developers of this
- 18:14application, they can just create different interactions
- 18:16and they can trigger payments even if I'm not on my wallet.
- 18:21I don't need to sign a transaction manually myself.
- 18:25I gave this power to the wallet developer and that's sorry to
- 18:29the app developer and that's thanks to Noster Wall Connect.
- 18:33So I can be on a run, but I have my monthly payment for Netflix
- 18:39that has to happen. Well, it's it's the same
- 18:43experience as with a debit card. I can be on my rent.
- 18:45The payment tool anyway happen in Bitcoin and that was
- 18:48impossible until master walk connect.
- 18:51And what's also fascinating in that is that it's what we need
- 18:56to be able to at scale, bring microtransaction into lightning
- 19:01as well. Because you know, if you think
- 19:03of, so there's this protocol L4O2 that was developed by
- 19:08Lightning Labs that allows to pay for API requests.
- 19:13It's it's, I mean, my understanding of it is that it's
- 19:18not very efficient. There's a lot of there's issue
- 19:20in terms of authentication and in terms of it's not really one
- 19:26time payment for the API request.
- 19:28You kind of have to set a budget aside.
- 19:30So you do not have access to this Bitcoin, and it's just for
- 19:35every request that you do, it's automatically taken from that
- 19:38budget that you already set aside.
- 19:40And after wallet connect changes that, because I can connect my
- 19:44wallet and it will just take payments whenever they're
- 19:47needed. There's no need to set aside a
- 19:49budget. I can just manage my finances
- 19:51the way I would normally do in the Fiat world, which if we want
- 19:54to bring people to Bitcoin, that's the kind of user
- 19:56experiences that we have to be able to bring and create.
- 20:00The right tools that leverage these technologies because
- 20:03that's what people are used to. I think it's going to be tough
- 20:05to bring people onto Bitcoin if the user experience is just not
- 20:10on par with what they're used to.
- 20:13And I think that's that's yeah, pretty big and very exciting for
- 20:17the future of self custody because a lot of these things
- 20:20are doable in custodial solutions.
- 20:23There's so much easier if you control people's funds, you can
- 20:25do all of these things. But you know, when I, when I
- 20:28talk all of this, it's all with self custody in mind.
- 20:32And I think this is this is what's pretty amazing.
- 20:35Gotcha. Maybe maybe it's a good, good
- 20:38transition to talking a bit more about Flash specifically.
- 20:42Maybe you could provide sort of a, an overview of business, you
- 20:45know, where it is currently, where it's headed, different
- 20:48features and, and functionality and, and real use cases that are
- 20:52leveraging that infrastructure that we kind of just walked
- 20:54through. Yeah.
- 20:56And so as I mentioned earlier, the moment you enter Flash while
- 21:02you create an account, you'll have a Noster account directly
- 21:05and you can use it to log into other Noster applications as
- 21:07well. And the purpose of Flash is
- 21:12really to bring solutions for businesses to monetize and
- 21:17monetize whatever their business model.
- 21:18That's really what we're trying to, to be able to, to provide
- 21:21here. And so we started off with the
- 21:23simple use cases. You know, the first one was a
- 21:25paywall. So you can go into Flash, you
- 21:28can create a paywall, it'll generate a script and this
- 21:31script then you can just load it into any website builder or
- 21:34whatever it is. And when the pages is, you know,
- 21:38the website is opened and then the paywall appears and pretty
- 21:42simple. We've done the same thing for a
- 21:43video, which I think is pretty innovative, but a very
- 21:47interesting one as well where you can just set the budget
- 21:49because again, since we can do micro transactions and we can
- 21:52trigger these payments, well, then it's very easy for us to be
- 21:56able to create new experiences around pay per minute watch and
- 22:00so on. So that's that's another thing
- 22:02that anyone can create. And it's as simple as filling in
- 22:04a form with five points. It generates a script and it can
- 22:08be added to any website. So we also have payment links.
- 22:11We also have widget that is that is also pretty nice filling the
- 22:16gaps after such solutions kind of disappeared.
- 22:20A simple widget again, you add a script onto your website and
- 22:23there'll be a small little icon bottom right of the screen.
- 22:26That's, you know, you can have a call out for users and just, you
- 22:30know, buy me a coffee is what I added on my website.
- 22:33And, and people can just easily donate some Satoshi's through
- 22:37such, through such tools. And so these are the the first
- 22:41things that we started building. But then again, we realized that
- 22:44while we have user management with Noster, even though we
- 22:47don't know our users and we have the direct debit payments.
- 22:53So we thought, well, maybe actually we can do something
- 22:56that no one else has done so far because it was technically
- 22:58impossible, which is subscriptions.
- 23:00So automatic recurring payments and that was the the next big
- 23:05thing that that we that we really built, that was truly
- 23:08innovative and that we're still continuing to build because of
- 23:11course we need to make it, you know, breach the standards of
- 23:15other platforms like Stripe. That is the standard for
- 23:18subscriptions in the Fiat world. Well, you know, it has to be
- 23:22about developer improvements for a developer experience and so
- 23:26on. So there's, there's a lot of
- 23:27work going on there. And essentially this allows to
- 23:31schedule payments. So you can do it once a month,
- 23:33once a week, once a year. There's really many options
- 23:37there. And it allows to manage for
- 23:40subscriptions. So any user can using an Oster
- 23:44wallet connect enabled wallet can just connect his wallet to
- 23:48any subscription for any business and they can start
- 23:52accepting these payments in in Bitcoin and every month
- 23:55automatically these payments are going to happen.
- 23:58And as an app developer, you can of course, you're notified about
- 24:00that. You can arrange your entire back
- 24:03end to handle these subscriptions and be able to,
- 24:06you know, manage features, hide features and create your your
- 24:10own things in your applications or or websites.
- 24:13And the subscription is as simple as even a no code
- 24:16solution just to get monthly donations to whatever you want.
- 24:21And so from there, of course, you know, we're thinking, OK, so
- 24:23what's the next thing that could be needed?
- 24:24What, what, how else do people monetize?
- 24:26And of course, the big one is, is e-commerce.
- 24:29And we started off by, you know, well, we need to create first
- 24:32our back end for that. So let's take things one step at
- 24:35a time. If we want to provide solutions
- 24:37for e-commerce, well then people need to be able to have
- 24:39products, they need to have a check out page, right?
- 24:42And the moment they have products already added onto the
- 24:46platform, well then we can display these products in many
- 24:50different ways, right? So we added a point of sale
- 24:52where directly from flash you can see all of your products in
- 24:55a point of sale and you could directly in person on your phone
- 24:59or through a tablet or website, you'd be able to manage your
- 25:01store. When customers come in, you
- 25:03just, you know, select what are the products that should go.
- 25:06The price is automatically for summed up, calculated, it
- 25:09generates an invoice and once it's paid, all of this gets
- 25:12added to your reporting, including inventory management,
- 25:17you know, trying to think kind of big as to what the needs
- 25:20could could be there. And so once we create to the
- 25:23point of sale, well, great. So some more people come out and
- 25:26reach out to us. They say, well, great phone, can
- 25:28I have some kind of store? Well, sure.
- 25:30Well, again, the same thing you know, we have products already
- 25:33has just changed the interface and now users can have a store
- 25:36And the next thing that we're working on now that will be
- 25:39released in just a few weeks will be plugins for Shopify and
- 25:43for WooCommerce that will take us further down the path of
- 25:49integrating with other platforms that are out there and soon
- 25:52after that be able to also bring subscriptions in Bitcoin onto
- 25:56these platforms. I mean, WooCommerce, there's
- 25:59hundreds of thousands, there's millions of websites built in
- 26:02WooCommerce around the world. It's the number one platform to
- 26:06do it. And yeah, if we can integrate
- 26:09with these, including for our innovative products that are the
- 26:12subscriptions, I think we can. Yeah, there's big opportunity
- 26:16there. Yeah, you're on mute.
- 26:20I think you're on mute. It's super exciting and I think
- 26:24you mentioned it, but it's worth calling out again is everything
- 26:27you're describing is in a non custodial fashion.
- 26:30And I think why that's ultimately important is because
- 26:34if it pushes to the end user corporate client, their Flash is
- 26:39agnostic to it in the same way that Stripe is agnostic to the
- 26:43bank account that funds are getting swept to.
- 26:45It is just providing a utility, a service in the middle ground
- 26:48and the tooling around it for, for payments and the additional,
- 26:51you know, services that are attached to it.
- 26:54And I think there's been a, there's been a gap in the market
- 26:59because traditionally you have existing lightning or payment
- 27:02services, but then they all have their own bespoke or custom
- 27:06custodial situation. And that comes with, I want to
- 27:09say significant trade-offs, but it comes with trade-offs
- 27:12superior. I don't know if you want to
- 27:13speak to that. And just like how you know was
- 27:15that designed for the very beginning to be interoperable
- 27:18and agnostic to the end point of where funds were delivered?
- 27:21Or was that something that the market like kind of pulled from
- 27:24you as far as looking for something that was they had
- 27:27their own kind of like bring their own custody service?
- 27:30So for us, you know, what really matters is to make sure that we
- 27:36make these transactions peer-to-peer, right?
- 27:38So they're in the more traditional finance, it's
- 27:41account to account transactions. Because anyway, this is on the
- 27:44rise, right? Like I think this is something
- 27:46that can also allow us to position ourselves nicely
- 27:49because the traditional finance world is also pushing for direct
- 27:54account to account transactions. And it's gaining.
- 27:57I mean, I'm based in Poland right now 70% of digital
- 28:00payments are direct account to account transactions because
- 28:03they're just this great tool in Poland for that.
- 28:05In other countries it's much lower.
- 28:07I think France we're at a 7% penetration, right.
- 28:10But so I think it's, you know, Sir.
- 28:12Yeah. Can you describe it?
- 28:13Can you describe that? I'm not as familiar with that.
- 28:16Term so like this actually it's it's like a peer-to-peer
- 28:19transaction but directly from my account to another user's bank
- 28:26account Yeah, it's bank account yeah.
- 28:27So it's not because self custodial, obviously the bank
- 28:30holds the funds, but the payments are just more
- 28:32efficient, faster, instant. And is that like?
- 28:36Like top down like to like all banks in Poland to utilize this.
- 28:41Interesting. Yeah, exactly.
- 28:43Yeah. And and I mean you're definitely
- 28:45familiar with this. So is it because like European
- 28:48and Latin American markets have less of the like red tape
- 28:51between financial institutions that can do that?
- 28:55Because I think like in the US, it gets harder to do the direct
- 28:59to direct, right. So that's where you have like
- 29:00the silos of the Venmo's and sales and the cash apps of the
- 29:03world. Yeah.
- 29:05So I mean, I think obviously a lot of it is just it comes down
- 29:08to regulation and choices that are made, right.
- 29:11I know in Europe in general, these account to account
- 29:13transfers and used payment standards to allow for instant
- 29:17payments, they're getting more and more popular.
- 29:20But it, you know, this the solution that I mentioned that
- 29:23exists in Poland has been here for already a few years.
- 29:26It was ahead of other countries in in the region and and so
- 29:29it's, it's gained a lot of popularity.
- 29:31And I think Finland was another one that came up with a similar
- 29:34solution. And they're also at about 60% of
- 29:36their digital payment transactions that are using this
- 29:40direct account to account. So essentially the payment
- 29:43doesn't go through all the steps and intermediaries of yeah,
- 29:48banking route. They can go directly from one
- 29:51account to the other and and that's the concept of
- 29:55peer-to-peer. But peer-to-peer is for me only
- 29:57applies when there's custody involved.
- 30:00Otherwise, I mean, you're not a peer in the transaction, right?
- 30:03Yeah. And so generally speaking, it's,
- 30:06it's a general trend that that is coming that is these account
- 30:10to account payments, which makes so much sense obviously.
- 30:13And being able to show and be part of that I think is is
- 30:18pretty important because we'll be able to he'll speak to people
- 30:20more as we can, as we can, you know, just follow the trend that
- 30:24is also happening in the traditional finance world.
- 30:27Now of course, we're doing it all in self custody, which is
- 30:30just the the beauty of it. And generally speaking, I think
- 30:34the aspects that of self custody are more important than we
- 30:40realize for a business. It just makes things more
- 30:43complicated because the moment you want to be able to offer any
- 30:48kind of solution that allows for direct payments within an
- 30:53application, including some micro transactions, while then
- 30:57the only solution that exists today is taking custody of user
- 31:01funds in one form or another. And this means that you need to
- 31:04KYC your users and no one wants to KYC users.
- 31:07I mean, it's risks for security, but on top of that, it's also
- 31:13expensive. No one really wants to do it and
- 31:16no user likes being KYC, right? Of course you do it because you
- 31:20need to do it in order to be able to, to use a particular
- 31:22service. But no one likes it.
- 31:24And there's a lot of people I even know personally that
- 31:27wouldn't go for a certain solution or an application
- 31:30because it requires KYC and they want to remain private.
- 31:33And, and I think that's that's what self custody unlocks and
- 31:39it's pretty great. Yeah.
- 31:41And I think it's, I think just from a business perspective
- 31:43building, it's very like there's this notion of you want to have
- 31:48a large, the largest total addressable market.
- 31:50You want to do everything in the terms of like what the market
- 31:54presents, IE you know regular regulations and onboarding the
- 31:59things that are presented. But at the same point you want
- 32:01to have redundancy and fault tolerance in case that that
- 32:04doesn't isn't always there. So we heard of 2.1 point O was
- 32:09like late 2009 10s when it came to firearms and other, you know,
- 32:13I think gambling websites where you couldn't accept payments.
- 32:15We, we know what's happening with the banking situation in
- 32:18the US. It's two point O.
- 32:20And so this notion of like a gateway stripes of the world not
- 32:26being able to let clients or customers accept payments for
- 32:30their services. You always want to kind of build
- 32:33in a Bitcoin world this notion of censorship resistance,
- 32:36interoperability that you you're not worried about that.
- 32:39And so if you have the right tooling and what you're
- 32:42providing and others where you have the intermedi, the
- 32:45intermediary, it's agnostic, it's a, it's a technology
- 32:48doesn't know what's being sold or bought, it's just
- 32:50facilitating. But then to your point, if you
- 32:52get onboarded from a micro transaction or needing any kind
- 32:55of financial services in the traditional world, you need to
- 32:58do the KYC onboarding and that presents a lot of risk for the
- 33:02funds are deposited. And it's not to say we don't
- 33:04participate in that world. It's like it's just from a pure,
- 33:07I like to joke like we're in a bull market for overreach,
- 33:10right? Like for and because of that,
- 33:13you always want, if you're being prudent and pragmatic, you want
- 33:16to build with the notion that your business isn't knocked out
- 33:20because somebody doesn't like it.
- 33:22And so at On Ramp, it's very similar in the sense that we
- 33:25partner and facilitate and do all the things required from a
- 33:28regulated entity. But at the end of the day, like
- 33:30our endpoints are the keys and somebody can deposit Bitcoin for
- 33:35custody, for custody services. They pay in Bitcoin, they can
- 33:39pay in, you know, Stripe as well.
- 33:41But then ultimately, if for some reason banking relationships
- 33:44sour aren't available, you could still custody the Bitcoin with
- 33:47the private keys and you can still take your fees in BTC and
- 33:50your business is operating fine. Probably takes a hit because
- 33:53some people need to pay. And if that's happening, there's
- 33:55probably like a hit to the industry from a short term
- 33:57perspective. But you're not knocked out of
- 33:59the game where we saw six months ago with all the stuff with
- 34:02samurai. People just get knocked out of
- 34:03the game. They leave the the countries and
- 34:05all that. So anyway, it's just more of a
- 34:07nod to, I think it's really commendable and also like
- 34:10forward thinking that we're only going to see more and more
- 34:13people get deep platform just because that's just the nature
- 34:16of and that it's important to build the tools that can play
- 34:19within the existing system, but also outside of that system.
- 34:22Yeah. And you know, I have a personal
- 34:25story also around such intermediaries and platforms
- 34:29that I think we have the opportunity to change
- 34:32completely, which which I'm very excited about.
- 34:36So I mentioned I made a documentary, The Great Reset in
- 34:38the Rise of Bitcoin. It's on YouTube, so I have a
- 34:40YouTube channel and I reached over 700,000 views just on my
- 34:45channel. So very quickly I was able to
- 34:47start monetizing and, and that the, you know, that was cool.
- 34:52Some money just started accumulating on the Google
- 34:54account and, and after a certain amount of time, I was able to
- 34:58withdraw these funds. Well, it turned out I couldn't.
- 35:02I went, it was over two months of process going back and forth
- 35:06with Google because there was one problem with Google Pay, but
- 35:09actually, no, it was YouTube and they were just sending me back
- 35:12and forth back and forth. And it took over two months for
- 35:15me to resolve that. When I mean in a world where we
- 35:18can build applications where there are direct peer-to-peer
- 35:21payments, like I understand that Google could remain an
- 35:25intermediary for because this is how can I explain that today
- 35:31when it comes to YouTube, Google is has two roles as
- 35:35intermediary. There is one that is the
- 35:37platform and the content and you know how you experience YouTube.
- 35:40But the other one is the payments and the fact that
- 35:43people can earn, people can spend and so on, right?
- 35:46And if if you remove completely the the payments part from from
- 35:50their control or rather remove them as an intermediary for the
- 35:55payments part, well, then such issues would never happen
- 35:58because you could be paid directly.
- 36:01It's not waiting on an account. You can be paid directly.
- 36:05And we have a bunch of ideas on how we can try and, you know,
- 36:10change a bunch of Google products particularly, but you
- 36:14know, generally Internet products and the payments that
- 36:17they have because we can do it. Subscriptions are great, but I
- 36:20think down the road Bitcoin microtransactions, instant
- 36:25scheduled payments, etcetera. Automatically triggered payments
- 36:29I think are are the the future of how payments will happen
- 36:32between applications. So that's insanely exciting.
- 36:36Like I would love to drill a little bit more into that
- 36:38because we, so we, we mixed up. We were initially going to have
- 36:43you a few weeks from now and Roy from from breeze.
- 36:45And then he had some stuff going on with the situation in the
- 36:49Middle East. So he'll be on.
- 36:50And one of the things we were going to bring up was his recent
- 36:53article about I'm going to butcher the title, but it was
- 36:56about like orange fillings kind of over like we need to find use
- 36:59cases, right? We need to find like products
- 37:02and services that are actually matter to to the end user, not
- 37:05just Bitcoin, because like that will happen by its own thing
- 37:07from an ideological perspective, But we just need better
- 37:10products. And what you just described is
- 37:12just a better product. If you're a content creator and
- 37:15you have T + 30 or 60 days to get paid or you can get paid
- 37:18same day and not have counterparty risk people are
- 37:20increasing. It doesn't even have to matter
- 37:21about getting D platform. It's just if you could take the
- 37:23asset and then stream it to wherever your endpoint exchanges
- 37:28to get into dollars or local currency.
- 37:30That is just like 10 to 100 X better than what you just
- 37:33described. And so like those things are
- 37:36really, so I guess drilling into that though, and we kind of
- 37:43jumped in and I wanted to to bring this up in the beginning,
- 37:45you referenced having like a traditional finance slash
- 37:49consult, like a management consulting background, right?
- 37:52Kind of there's one pocket in my mind of like a stereo, like an
- 37:55archetype. And then you like to engineer or
- 37:59you you're technical, which is another archetype.
- 38:01You generally don't see those together.
- 38:03And then the third is that you're creative in that you, you
- 38:06know, produce a, a video content series.
- 38:09And there's some other rougher points that you said you you
- 38:12enjoy creating. Those are like 3 generally.
- 38:15Again, this is direct or generalizing, but different
- 38:17archetypes that usually don't like inter inter twined together
- 38:21and curious like what would you say if you had to is you either
- 38:25feel your strongest suit or your most interest vent because I
- 38:28feel like that's an important function of what you're building
- 38:31here is like when you start to tie those things together,
- 38:34that's when you recognize, Oh, maybe AI is too niche because
- 38:37other people don't didn't think that at the time.
- 38:39It's like, oh, AI and lightning, It makes all the sense.
- 38:40And then we've kind of seen how that sputtered out.
- 38:42And that's what we've seen in Bitcoin is generally somebody
- 38:44has one version of the world and they kind of go down this path
- 38:47and then they're still working on they're not seeing the full
- 38:50360 view of like, wait, there's not commercialization here,
- 38:52here, let's figure out the things that are needed from a
- 38:54mass market. And I think those three
- 38:56different components, and there's probably more are what's
- 38:59like allowing you to see this like opportunity that we're most
- 39:02are kind of missing. So just curious, like how you
- 39:05think about yourself in that respect?
- 39:06It's kind of a weird question, but it's but I think it ties in,
- 39:11I think it ties in a bunch to like what you're building and
- 39:14the exciting opportunity ahead and where people have kind of
- 39:17missed what's right in front of us.
- 39:19Yeah. So I think really it's, I mean,
- 39:23all of these are, are skills that can be used.
- 39:26That's always why I train to, you know, and that's why I
- 39:28always, I tell everyone it's, you know, try and build on the
- 39:31skills you already have. Because these three points, you
- 39:34know, like being a technical person, being a business person
- 39:37and liking filmmaking. Like these are things that I was
- 39:41kind of always into just at different levels, right?
- 39:44And I think it all comes in waves.
- 39:46It's there's a moment I want to, you know, I have the time and I
- 39:50have the idea and the energy to go and do more of some
- 39:53filmmaking work. Well, then I'm just going to
- 39:55pursue that and I'm going to obsess over it.
- 39:59And, you know, so this, these are just all skills that, that,
- 40:02that you learn. And when it comes to the
- 40:04filmmaking side, it also, especially as a Bitcoin
- 40:06filmmaker, because I'm not a general filmmaker, it's really,
- 40:09again, I focus on Bitcoin. It's the storytelling side of
- 40:12it. I think it teaches a lot when it
- 40:14comes to just storytelling. How do you position yourself?
- 40:18How do you position a story that you're trying to bring forward
- 40:21to make sure that every. Anything fits in a story that
- 40:24there's the right, you know, points and the right tempo.
- 40:28I think these are these are a lot of things that I can then
- 40:30use in business as well, right, The technical stuff.
- 40:34I mean, obviously it's just I mean, I can build things, right.
- 40:38So if I wasn't a technical Co founder, we wouldn't have flash
- 40:43the way it works now, because a lot of it, even though I don't
- 40:47think I'm the best coder, right. So I think I like when I, when I
- 40:50see my developers, when they go over my code, there's always a
- 40:52lot of changes that need to happen.
- 40:54But but I can prototype, I can make it work and it works right.
- 40:57And and to that, I think what we're also really trying to tap
- 41:01into flash is we want to be able to attract every type of
- 41:06business. We think that there is no
- 41:07solution out there that uses the Bitcoin Lightning network,
- 41:12particularly that fits big companies.
- 41:16A lot of the user experience that there is this, you know,
- 41:18some wallets that are, you know, like not great kind of
- 41:22experience or they're not very well integrated with other, with
- 41:25other tools. It's hard to really find a
- 41:27wallet and a platform that we're allowed to do all of this
- 41:31properly. And so that we're that's what
- 41:33we're trying to to, to bring as well.
- 41:35And you know, the technical side is needed for that.
- 41:38But having worked for big corporations just gives a, a
- 41:42very good understanding standing of where we need to meet them
- 41:46because of course it's going to take some time, right?
- 41:48There's there's levels of which we're going to be able to reach,
- 41:51you know, different kinds of of companies and and corporations,
- 41:55but we have the right way of thinking about it.
- 42:00We know that it should just be a new system for them.
- 42:04And what do such systems work like?
- 42:07I've built them for corporations.
- 42:08I know what they'll be looking for.
- 42:10So I think all of this just lines up properly to be able to
- 42:15yeah, to build things that work and that can bring value in
- 42:18Bitcoin. There's a lot of opportunity in
- 42:20Bitcoin still. There's always new technologies
- 42:22in Bitcoin. And so I think, you know,
- 42:25there's a huge opportunity for us to disrupt things and be
- 42:29ahead of of everyone else. Yeah, that that reminded me of
- 42:32of something that, you know, I wanted to drill into a little
- 42:35bit deeper around. You know, you mentioned, you
- 42:39know, a lot of companies have have thought about ways to
- 42:42catalyze Bitcoin payments right over the past, you know, several
- 42:46years even. And I think the, the default,
- 42:51you know, most common solution was using some form of
- 42:54lightning. But I'm curious your thoughts on
- 42:57sort of how that landscape has evolved in terms of, let's call
- 43:01it broadly like the the layers of Bitcoin, whether they're
- 43:04layer twos or threes. You know, basically what is your
- 43:09perception and view of all of these different, you know,
- 43:13basically methodologies for scaling Bitcoin, but
- 43:17importantly, like how they can be complementary?
- 43:20Because I think that's the thing that you've really keyed into
- 43:23here with what you're building at flash is it's not just using
- 43:27lightning, it's using lightning, it's using nostril, it's using
- 43:30something like liquid. It's it's, you know, really
- 43:33opening the aperture of how all these things can actually
- 43:36function together. So curious your thoughts there
- 43:39on, on sort of how that's evolved over the past, you know,
- 43:42call it 12 to 24 months and what your, what your general view is
- 43:46on, on how people should be thinking about building, you
- 43:49know, more usable Bitcoin payments.
- 43:51Because I think part of the part of catalyzing that, you know,
- 43:55increased usage of Bitcoin as as a payment rail is just people
- 43:59being willing to spend their Bitcoin, right?
- 44:01Like that. That's sort of part of it.
- 44:02And I think that will happen slowly.
- 44:04But the other component is just the usability of it, right?
- 44:08Like the UX itself, the ease of use, the lack of friction, like
- 44:12all of that is is critical to catalyzing that.
- 44:14So curious your your views or thoughts on any of that.
- 44:18Yeah. So you know what, the way I look
- 44:22at it and, and generally how we look at it at Flash is the fact
- 44:27that, you know, what matters, what people want is Bitcoin,
- 44:30right? Like when I look at my wallet,
- 44:31what I want to know is that I have Bitcoin and that it's safe
- 44:34and that I hold my own keys and no one will take it away from
- 44:38me, right? That's the important part.
- 44:42Then of course you need to be able to send and receive
- 44:44Bitcoin. But sending and receiving
- 44:46Bitcoin, this is where I think we enter more of the category of
- 44:49there's just different technologies and the way we look
- 44:53at it is that it shouldn't really matter to the user what's
- 44:57happening in the background. What matters is that he is
- 45:00receiving the payment. If we can have our own back end,
- 45:05because actually we didn't mention, but we, we're releasing
- 45:07our wallet, right? If we can have our, our own back
- 45:11end for our wallet that accepts and communicates all the
- 45:16different methods of payment that are available, which would
- 45:19be on chain, which would be lightning liquid, all of these
- 45:23within the same QR code that you sign essentially within the same
- 45:27invoice information. Like, you know, what's other
- 45:31wallet developers receive to be able to actually process the the
- 45:34transaction. But then I think we can gain so
- 45:38much in terms of user experience.
- 45:40I think that it means, you know, that new standards need to be
- 45:42also put together. We have a bunch of ideas on that
- 45:45and you know, and we'll see, I think what, what guides
- 45:48standards are use cases. So if we have the right use
- 45:52case, then we'll be able to, to leverage all of that.
- 45:54But it just, you know, it doesn't really make sense for me
- 45:57that all of this information cannot be shared and to be able
- 46:02to accept all of these payments methods because multiple
- 46:04wallets. I mean, if you think the Aqua
- 46:06wallets wall, they support liquid lightning Bitcoin on
- 46:09chain, right? There's other wallets that
- 46:10support just on chain and lightning and you know, there's
- 46:14just different technologies out there like E cash as well,
- 46:17right? There's gaining popularity and
- 46:20all of these things. I mean, they're just tech
- 46:23developers should be able to choose what they want to build
- 46:26their tech on. And they can, of course, but
- 46:29what if all of this information could be in the same place?
- 46:32And I think this is where Noster Wall Connect also brings a lot
- 46:35of opportunity because Noster Wall Connect right now is
- 46:38focused on the Lightning Network.
- 46:40So you can there's one function of the library that is called
- 46:44make invoice, which allows to create an invoice now by
- 46:47default. So the way it works is you know
- 46:49this information is transferred to the wallets by Noster and
- 46:53then in their back end the wallets can see, OK, they called
- 46:57make invoice. What do we allow them to do with
- 46:59that? And so of course they create a
- 47:01lightning invoice and they send back the lightning hash.
- 47:04But there's more information that comes with Noster wall
- 47:07connect. You can add some metadata, you
- 47:08can add some extra fields there, which again, since it's just
- 47:14information that is organized in a way that we choose to
- 47:17following certain standards. Well, then I could choose as a
- 47:21wild developer. That's when I make an invoice.
- 47:24I make an invoice that is both liquid lightning and even E
- 47:28cash. Why not, right?
- 47:29And all of this information is sent back and then the other
- 47:32side can just choose which one they're they're picking up.
- 47:35And I think that's that's what is that's what's pretty
- 47:37interesting here is that it can just bring a lot of
- 47:40interoperability and all of these technologies, it'll be a
- 47:46matter of app developers, you know, integrating all of them,
- 47:50select few, whatever works for them, right?
- 47:52But within this shared protocol to communicate about it because
- 47:56they'd be able to exchange funds with water that has completely
- 48:01different features. They don't even know about it.
- 48:03And it can happen. And that's thanks to Master
- 48:05Walk. So yeah, I think there was two
- 48:07parts to your question, but but I think that that answer is part
- 48:10of it, I guess. Because your Bitcoin custody
- 48:12setup keep you up at night. Maybe you still have coins
- 48:15sitting on an exchange worried about hackers, or maybe you've
- 48:18set up your own self custody. But don't feel safe with your
- 48:21Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic device in your
- 48:23desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 48:27and our multi institution custody solution.
- 48:30Here's how it works. On Ramp creates a dedicated
- 48:33multi sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 48:37a key on ramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 48:42unilaterally. Instead, only you have control
- 48:45over your coins with on ramps multi institution custody.
- 48:49You'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is stored
- 48:51with best in class security on chain with fault tolerant multi
- 48:55sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 48:57going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 49:01exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench of tax
- 49:05in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 49:08you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 49:11custody set up on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 49:15eliminates single points of failure, reduces your personal
- 49:18attack surface and technical burden, and provides access to
- 49:21financial services that allow you to confidently secure your
- 49:24Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance backed
- 49:28warranties for all balances and transactions, low cost trading,
- 49:31and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 49:34asset, secure it right. Learn more at on
- 49:37rentbitcoin.com. Yeah.
- 49:39And I think I think it's worth reinforcing we've historically
- 49:42seen kind of AI think there's two parts to this.
- 49:46You guys may disagree, so be curious your thoughts.
- 49:48But like historically we haven't seen a lot of use cases for like
- 49:51payments in Bitcoin. And I, I tend to believe because
- 49:56like spend and replace can obviously be done, but I tend to
- 49:59believe it's just because of the lack of adoption.
- 50:03Like there's not, there's only so many Bitcoin holders that
- 50:05exist. And then the cost basis.
- 50:08So if you buy Bitcoin at 50,000, you don't really spend it at
- 50:1160,000 like for a number of reasons, because you wanted to
- 50:14appreciate. But as the cost basis grows,
- 50:17right? So somebody that bought it 2 is
- 50:192000s more likely to spend it at 50,000 in the same way that
- 50:21somebody bought it 2 hundreds likely to spend at 2000.
- 50:24You grow the adoption coupled with the cost basis.
- 50:27So now you just have more people willing and then the the so like
- 50:30that's one component. I think we're at a really
- 50:32exciting time with what we all feel on the precipice of the
- 50:35price appreciation is a proxy for awareness and more users.
- 50:40But then the other side, which you just referenced is I never
- 50:43thought of it in that way, is that most of the Lightning or
- 50:46most of the payment companies have tried to enforce the use
- 50:50case on the end client, which you you can't because that's
- 50:54just how markets work. It's like the market has to come
- 50:57up with the use case and pull what it's being used.
- 50:59And So what Flash is doing is my understanding is providing the
- 51:02middleware to provide that same like Strike can't go and say use
- 51:06Stripe for this. It's like the market says, oh, I
- 51:08needed Stripe for this type of service to accept payments.
- 51:11And so by pushing that to the edges and giving the best tools,
- 51:14the markets going to pull forward.
- 51:16What are the ways to pay? And because pulling forward is
- 51:19the other side of like providing the service that somebody wants
- 51:22to use their Bitcoin for versus trying to say, this is what you
- 51:25use it for. Because we all know that without
- 51:27naming any names like the, the vendors and the, you know, what
- 51:30is it like the, the terminals and saying, Oh, we have
- 51:33partnerships here. But it's like, that's not how
- 51:34consumer behavior goes. And like you can't, you can't
- 51:38make assumptions that somebody's going to download an application
- 51:40And instead of going like, we have the best applications,
- 51:42Apple Pay and tap with our credit cards to switch that
- 51:47there's no way we can forecast that.
- 51:48It's just the market pulls it because they have the use cases.
- 51:51So it's just an interesting thing that you kind of
- 51:54reference. I just thought of.
- 51:57Yeah. And you know, I think generally
- 51:59speaking, the what what we try and do also at Flash is and
- 52:05that's why we focus on on AB to B product first is because, you
- 52:10know, why would people come to Bitcoin?
- 52:13They're either D Jens as they like to call them people that
- 52:17kind of, you know, the same path that I took towards Bitcoin,
- 52:20which was just kind of digging deep into finance, the economy
- 52:24and like, yeah, all all this, you know, big Bitcoin rabbit
- 52:28hole that there is. But I think that there's
- 52:30literally billions of people out there that won't ever care about
- 52:34that. And I think that the great
- 52:37solution with self custody is the fact that there is no
- 52:43requirement and no new risk that we present to our users, right?
- 52:49So because they always hold custody of their own funds.
- 52:51So we can easily go to different places.
- 52:53We can right now. We just saw this the, the number
- 52:58one country from where people can visit our website, our
- 53:03landing pages Nigeria, which is pretty interesting.
- 53:07And you know, in Nigeria, it's very difficult for people to be
- 53:10able to use solutions like Stripe cash app or whatever it
- 53:13is to be able to manage their businesses.
- 53:16It's just, I mean, all the entire KYC processes are, are a
- 53:20nightmare. We can talk about this forever.
- 53:22I, you know, I did two years of research for another Bitcoin
- 53:26documentary that talks about the monetary system and what
- 53:31institutions control it and how and so on.
- 53:33So we could really go there for a long time.
- 53:35But if you think of countries in in Africa, I mean, there's
- 53:38people that just cannot do KYC, like literally cannot do KYC
- 53:43because they cannot get I DS right.
- 53:45There's places where there's no address.
- 53:47And if you don't have an address, you can't do KYC,
- 53:49right, Because KYC has to follow standards that are set in
- 53:53Switzerland, right? By someone that lives in a
- 53:55completely different world, right?
- 53:56And so these people, we can bring the right modern payment
- 54:04solutions that they should have because thanks to self custody,
- 54:10well, it's easy for us to go into these markets because
- 54:14again, we never touch their funds.
- 54:16We're just this intermediary. We present no new risk for them
- 54:20and there's no requirement for KYC.
- 54:22And, and, and for them, I think they're the opportunity there is
- 54:26huge and, and all of these people, all of these potential
- 54:31users, if they come in from this B to B aspect, well then they
- 54:36can bring in some end users as well, right.
- 54:39And the use cases that we'll be able to build through direct
- 54:43application integrations with instance payments without
- 54:46custody, while allowing every single intermediary and
- 54:51application developers to still get paid a fee per transaction,
- 54:54right? Because in the end, this is how
- 54:55Flash works, right? Without custody, we can still
- 55:00trigger fee payments and get paid this way and we can add
- 55:03more individuals to these payments.
- 55:06And so I think the use cases we'll be able to bring there are
- 55:10just going to completely innovate.
- 55:13I think the Internet and how we interact online the same way we
- 55:18do it with steps on Noster, but just at a greater scale because
- 55:23it can be more directly integrated.
- 55:25Yeah. And it's embedded and implied
- 55:27that with the B to B, you're pushing the solution from like
- 55:33their clients, their users, so that the C and that the B to B
- 55:37to C, they have their own angle, whether it's peer-to-peer.
- 55:40We had Abu Baker on and talking about his interests or early
- 55:45getting Bitcoin exposure and how he had to go and figure out how
- 55:48to get BTC. So they will figure it out and
- 55:50then they will spend that Bitcoin with a tool like that.
- 55:53And so you don't have to understand or figure that out.
- 55:58And then the other thing that's super fascinating that most
- 56:01people don't talk about is because Bitcoins money, the
- 56:03financial services are localized.
- 56:04At the end of the day, people want to work with the local
- 56:07merchants. They don't want to work across
- 56:08the the state, country world with the counterparty.
- 56:12And so by pushing and providing the tooling, it just opens up
- 56:15that topography of use cases versus having like a silent
- 56:19focus where they have to come to you for that that product or
- 56:21service. Yeah, exactly.
- 56:24Exactly. One, one thing you said in there
- 56:27Pierre was around just your monetization model.
- 56:30If you could provide a little bit more color there in terms
- 56:33of, you know, transaction fees and and how Flash is, is
- 56:37monetizing its products and services relative to you know
- 56:41some other models that we've seen out there which are more
- 56:44sort of subscription based and how your, your thought process
- 56:47went into that decision. And so essentially out there,
- 56:53you know, there's a bunch of solutions that also allow to
- 56:56make accept payments, particularly for e-commerce,
- 56:59right? I think that's the number one
- 57:01use case that that people get get into because it's much
- 57:05easier to it's, it's much easier to generate invoices and allow
- 57:11people to receive money than it is to make outgoing invoices.
- 57:15You can automate the generation of invoices much more easily
- 57:19than you can automate to the payments.
- 57:23And so that's what everyone goes for, you know, because it's
- 57:24pretty simple. You've got a store, you've got a
- 57:26product, and the moment someone wants to pay, there has to be a
- 57:30check out and there has to be an invoice for it.
- 57:33And, and it's fine, you know, but I think it works great.
- 57:35But at the same time, that's just not the standard model for
- 57:41payment gateways and payment processors in the Fiat world,
- 57:44right? They all moved on to percentage
- 57:49based fee and I think it's for a bunch of different reasons.
- 57:52It's to simplify user onboarding, right, because it's
- 57:56free until you earn like what a great deal that is, right?
- 58:00Of course, it's a no brainer rather than paying for something
- 58:03that you're uncertain how much is going to cost you and even
- 58:06such solutions people pay for, right?
- 58:08People will have Shopify stores that earn them zero and it's
- 58:11just a cost month by month. But they still, they still, you
- 58:14know, choose to cover this cost. And there are companies out
- 58:17there that follow a model like that in the Bitcoin space,
- 58:20including in the South custodial Bitcoin space like Zaprist,
- 58:23which I think, I mean, they're great guys and I think they have
- 58:26a great approach to all of that. But it's complicated for them
- 58:30because every single wallet that is compatible with them is an
- 58:36individual connection. So they have to do a separate
- 58:40integration for all of the functionalities that.
- 58:42So it's it's an entire back end section that they need to build
- 58:46for each of the wallets. And they need to, of course, you
- 58:49know, always stay up to date when updates come into this or
- 58:52that API or SDK and they need to like, you know, change their
- 58:56code. It's I think it's pretty
- 58:58complicated. Noster Wall Connect resolves
- 59:01that. And so again, because they don't
- 59:03use Noster Wall Connect, well, they cannot trigger payments,
- 59:05They essentially cannot make subscriptions.
- 59:08Literally before Noster Wall Connect subscriptions and
- 59:10Bitcoin in a self custodial manner was impossible.
- 59:14And there's other Bitcoin and including lightning focused
- 59:20payment gateways like open nodes speed.
- 59:24They're out there and they do have a per so a fee per
- 59:29transaction revenue model, but they are custodial solutions.
- 59:34So right, they get paid and then you can withdraw to your own
- 59:37account, which again, in this world of empowering peer-to-peer
- 59:42transactions and not adding new risk to your users, they're not
- 59:46aligned with with that vision. And so you know, there's a real
- 59:50gap there. And essentially we're the only
- 59:52ones that allow for self custody while taking a transaction fee
- 59:57for that. And for those that are that are
- 1:00:00wondering, the way we can take a transaction fee without taking
- 1:00:04custody of users funds, even if it's for a split second, is that
- 1:00:07we trigger multiple transactions.
- 1:00:09So if a user gets paid through our store because he has, I
- 1:00:16don't know, he's selling shoes on a flash store, well then the
- 1:00:20payment will go from the end user.
- 1:00:22That is scanning the QR code on his screen, for example,
- 1:00:25directly to that merchant's wallet.
- 1:00:27And we know when the merchant gets paid and after he's
- 1:00:31received payment, we trigger the fee that gets paid to our wallet
- 1:00:35directly. So rather than holding the, the
- 1:00:39amount for a certain, for, you know, even a split second and
- 1:00:42then send part of that, well, then we make sure that the
- 1:00:45payment goes straight to that. Because there's different
- 1:00:48platforms that have tried to essentially do what Flash is
- 1:00:52doing, but they were holding even if it was a split second,
- 1:00:56like literally one second. And I forgot what's the name of
- 1:00:59this platform? It was Canadian, I believe.
- 1:01:01And that's from around November last year or December last year,
- 1:01:05they had to shut down because they got a cease and desist note
- 1:01:09because they were holding custody of their users funds,
- 1:01:12but they weren't KYC ING them or anything, right?
- 1:01:14And seeing this for me, it was instant signal.
- 1:01:17I mean, it's OK. I'm like, we have to get away
- 1:01:19from that. We have to be able to find a way
- 1:01:20to trigger payments and get paid without ever touching users
- 1:01:24funds because that's the best way to have a target on on our
- 1:01:27head. Yeah, bottle pay was fantastic
- 1:01:31back in the day and they ran into the similar issue where
- 1:01:34they had these like nice embeddable things on like skins
- 1:01:36on Twitter and you could pay and because of that fee structure,
- 1:01:40they kind of had to slow down and then the the kind of rest is
- 1:01:42history there. One thing that I I think is
- 1:01:46worth calling out is the the fee structure.
- 1:01:50I think it's, it's a very polarizing thing in the Bitcoin
- 1:01:52space on a, on a fee because when people think about credit
- 1:01:56cards and they have like this assumption or 3% and all the
- 1:01:59things embedded in there and that Bitcoin payments fees,
- 1:02:03whether it's custody and this isn't everyone, but I think it's
- 1:02:05worth calling it like whether it's custody or or payments
- 1:02:08should be flat and it makes zero sense.
- 1:02:12It's, it's it, it, it makes sense.
- 1:02:15Like at a face value, I should be flat because you're sending
- 1:02:18it and you send a Bitcoin transaction.
- 1:02:20There's a fees you pay there. The the, the protocol doesn't
- 1:02:22know how much you send. But when you think about goods
- 1:02:25and services of business, it doesn't make sense because
- 1:02:27ultimately, let's say something like flash, if you don't send
- 1:02:30much money, will you pay any zero fees?
- 1:02:32But if you're sending an insane amount of capital through, well,
- 1:02:36you should pay for that because if you're sending that amount of
- 1:02:39money through, you want that business to provide a goods and
- 1:02:41services and to exist into the future.
- 1:02:43And if they're, if they are, if you're paying a flat fee and
- 1:02:46everybody's paying a fat a flat fee and flash ends up sending,
- 1:02:50you know, 10s of millions, hundreds of 1,000,000 billions
- 1:02:53of dollars. Well, the services in the
- 1:02:57additional financial services on top of that, you want them to be
- 1:02:59best in class in the security profile.
- 1:03:01And that doesn't come with a flat fee in the same way with
- 1:03:04like custody, custody, most people have kind of been lulled
- 1:03:07asleep with paying zero. You pay for it somewhere,
- 1:03:09whether it's self custody, you pay for it or somebody can break
- 1:03:11in your house. You have to deal figure that
- 1:03:12out. In the same way if you pay for
- 1:03:15it with the Peace of Mind, like a multi institution that onramp
- 1:03:17provides, well, you pay for that because you have 3 institutions
- 1:03:21safeguarding that and it comes up a lot.
- 1:03:23Well, it should be flat. It's like, well, what we'd love
- 1:03:26to do at flat is if we're securing 10 tens of billions, if
- 1:03:29not hundreds of billions, well, you want us to be your financial
- 1:03:32partner in the future and you want to think about all the
- 1:03:34different financial services that are required and also the
- 1:03:36proportional security that comes along with it.
- 1:03:40So it's just a, it's an interesting balancing.
- 1:03:42I think it's more of how early we are that people just assume
- 1:03:44it all needs to be flat, but they're not thinking about like
- 1:03:47the financial counterparty in the future.
- 1:03:48They don't really want them to be a flat fee if they actually
- 1:03:50work with them deeply embedded in their life because they want
- 1:03:53them to be alive and then also provide best in class services
- 1:03:56and that can't come with a flash structure.
- 1:03:59Yeah, yeah. And I think essentially, you
- 1:04:01know, that's that's where the distinguish the like we have to
- 1:04:06make a distinction. It's that there's a difference
- 1:04:09between a transaction fee and a service fee, right.
- 1:04:13In our case, it like transaction fees are from our wallets,
- 1:04:17they'll be whatever the network requires, right And whatever
- 1:04:21other wallets anyone uses. It just, you know, depends,
- 1:04:23depends on that, but and the end user, I mean the customer.
- 1:04:28So again, if there's a flash merchant, so then there's a
- 1:04:32customer that is buying from him, well then this customer
- 1:04:36never pays more than whatever his wallet is going to charge
- 1:04:39him. We we don't charge the the end
- 1:04:40customer. What we will charge is the
- 1:04:42merchant because the merchant is monetizing through US, right?
- 1:04:46And so he's using our tools to be able to do that.
- 1:04:49And that's where it's a, a service fee essentially.
- 1:04:52And yeah, I know that bitcoiners sometimes have a bit of a
- 1:04:55problem with that, but at the same time, I think it's hard for
- 1:04:58them to argue on a service fee that is, you know, instant
- 1:05:01settlement among multiple parties.
- 1:05:03I think that's that's if there's a way of making fees, I think
- 1:05:06that that that's the right way of doing it.
- 1:05:08But it's just like, you know, some, some individuals weren't a
- 1:05:13big fan of the subscriptions when we we released them in
- 1:05:19yeah, late March because that's Bitcoin allows us to move away
- 1:05:25from subscriptions because you can have these per interaction
- 1:05:28payments and the value for value kind of models and all of these
- 1:05:32things, which which are great. I mean, we want to be able to
- 1:05:34support again, anyone and however they choose to monetize.
- 1:05:39If you want to be a value for a value person and just want to be
- 1:05:42able to, you know, monetize easily different some of the
- 1:05:47content you put out there, just being able to receive payments
- 1:05:50through a payment button or something like that.
- 1:05:52Well, you can do it with flash. But if you want to be, you know,
- 1:05:56someone that wants to have a predictable planned income and
- 1:06:04organize yourself through, through subscriptions, that is,
- 1:06:07I mean, it's huge industry. There's billions of dollars that
- 1:06:12are spent through subscriptions. And I'm pretty, I mean, I know
- 1:06:17I'm subscribed to more services than I could list right now if
- 1:06:21you asked me to, right? And that's part of the reason
- 1:06:25why it is such a popular way of monetizing because it'll ask to
- 1:06:28manage churn very easily and it'll ask to just predict the
- 1:06:32earnings that you're going to have as a company better.
- 1:06:36So it just makes sense that it's out there and if it's something
- 1:06:40that is, you know, trending in the Fiat payment space, I think
- 1:06:49it's the kind of payment that everyone is looking for.
- 1:06:51And so we should be able to provide these solutions as well
- 1:06:55as long as it's always self custodial, right and instant
- 1:06:58settlement. That's I think the rest is just
- 1:07:03talk. I think what matters is that
- 1:07:05people get what they want and it remains non custodial.
- 1:07:10Yeah, that optionality is key. What are you gonna say, Michael?
- 1:07:14A final settlement, not instant settlement.
- 1:07:17Which is exactly, exactly 1. You mentioned you leaked a
- 1:07:23little bit of alpha that you guys have a wallet coming out.
- 1:07:26Anything else you want to talk about around that and sort of,
- 1:07:29you know, the sort of strategic vision for the wallet as part of
- 1:07:32the business and then also sort of anything else looking ahead
- 1:07:36on the road map for Flash? Yeah.
- 1:07:39So, you know, we, the decision to build a wallet came from the
- 1:07:46fact that we wanted to simplify user onboarding and so and of
- 1:07:52course make sure that we have the right solution for our users
- 1:07:54that is that is free. So they can just, you know, get
- 1:07:57on board and have a wallet they can use for their personal use
- 1:08:01if they want to put is it is automatically connected to a
- 1:08:05flash account. So the Flash wallet will be a
- 1:08:08mobile wallet in in its first version, completely self
- 1:08:12custodial. We're actually using the Breeze
- 1:08:13SDK and it'll come out in the next coming weeks for the 1st of
- 1:08:21November for sure. But we want to really some, you
- 1:08:24know, alpha version before that maybe to get some, some testing
- 1:08:27going. And, and essentially we focus on
- 1:08:32user experience. We focus on making sure that it
- 1:08:35is simple to use, it is clear. So this is what the world is
- 1:08:38going to be focused around really.
- 1:08:40We want to make it look nice, look and feel like a modern
- 1:08:44fintech banking application. But on top of that, it will be
- 1:08:50directly linked to the user's Flash account, It'll be linked
- 1:08:55to Noster, and it'll be linked to with Noster Wall Connect.
- 1:09:00So you'll be able to use it everywhere.
- 1:09:02And not only that, but the wallet will be connected to
- 1:09:07everything that you do in Flash as well.
- 1:09:10So any kind of monetization that you do through these tools will
- 1:09:13be received on the wallet directly, but you will also be
- 1:09:17able to see all of your reporting, get notifications
- 1:09:19about any kind of incoming revenue and so on directly on
- 1:09:22your on your phone and be able to see this see this nicely.
- 1:09:27Yeah. So I think that's something to
- 1:09:29look forward to because it's going to be the first, the first
- 1:09:31wallet of its kind that is directly, you know, linked to
- 1:09:36all the business solutions that we have.
- 1:09:38We hope to be able to bring, of course, a lot of B to C people
- 1:09:41just so you know, regular consumers to use it because we
- 1:09:45think it's going to be a great wallet experience.
- 1:09:48And hopefully, you know, we can also redirect them to using a
- 1:09:52flash to monetize because this is the moment we get paid, first
- 1:09:55of all, of course. But on top of that, again, these
- 1:09:59solutions are so easy. Anyone can implement them for
- 1:10:02anything that they're working on.
- 1:10:04So might as well try and increase your revenue if it's
- 1:10:08just as easy as owning a wallet. So that's gonna be the focus
- 1:10:14now. But early next year we wanna be
- 1:10:16able to release also business wallet, so more targeted towards
- 1:10:20enterprise. And this wallet, we'd want it to
- 1:10:23be a desktop wallet rather so accessible through the browser,
- 1:10:28simply because again, this is where enterprise will be doing
- 1:10:31their work. It's not going to be the CEO or
- 1:10:35head accountant that holds a mobile phone and all of the
- 1:10:38funds are there like that's not how such clients are going to
- 1:10:42use such technology. So we need to be able to, you
- 1:10:46know, meet them where where they are.
- 1:10:47So browser will be the first thing we want to be able to add
- 1:10:50extra features that increase security, making sure that you
- 1:10:54know the keys, the custody of the keys can be shared among
- 1:10:57different individuals in the company.
- 1:10:59So simplifying that, simplifying some multi sig as well on the
- 1:11:02Lightning network and being able to just better serve bigger
- 1:11:08types of clients with the wallet that today doesn't exist and
- 1:11:11isn't in the market that yeah, there's no good option for for
- 1:11:17Business Today when it comes to the Lightning Network.
- 1:11:19And yeah, and then I have the the the original one more for
- 1:11:23the B2C people as well that maybe, you know, don't have a
- 1:11:26enterprise profile, but still want to have a great user
- 1:11:31experience and even monetize directly just with always on
- 1:11:36device. That'll be their mobile phone.
- 1:11:38Yeah, that's that's super exciting.
- 1:11:40I think we all kind of feel it on the consumer side.
- 1:11:43You kind of play hot potato with the wallet, right?
- 1:11:44There's like moon, there's mutiny and everybody kind of
- 1:11:47moves around given the the complexities of building a
- 1:11:50wallet that's easy to use when it comes to on chain and then
- 1:11:54like lightning or second layers. And so I will, you know, you
- 1:11:59guys have a lot planned there so you could share it kind of the
- 1:12:01future, but there's a lot of interesting stuff I know you
- 1:12:04guys are working on to simplify that experience.
- 1:12:06And when somebody downloads it, they won't have to deal with the
- 1:12:07complexity of figuring out how they're getting paid and they'll
- 1:12:10just be able to net settle and then move it out in a non
- 1:12:13custodial fashion. I mean, the way it's going to
- 1:12:16work in, in its first version is that a user that comes onto our
- 1:12:20website creates a Flash account. He goes through the onboarding,
- 1:12:23we get him to create the Flash wallet.
- 1:12:26So directly, you know, he'll take his phone out, scan the QR
- 1:12:29code, install the wallet. And the moment he does that, his
- 1:12:33wallet will be connected with the Flash account directly and
- 1:12:37he'll be able to make payments even on the Internet through the
- 1:12:40Flash web application. And when he creates any one of
- 1:12:45our gateways, subscriptions, products, whatever it is, well,
- 1:12:49his wallet will be there as the default option.
- 1:12:51So he doesn't even need to think about making a connection.
- 1:12:55We want to make it so that the user doesn't even realize where
- 1:12:59his wallet truly lies. Is it in his pocket or is it on
- 1:13:04the browser? We can mix these experiences so
- 1:13:07it just feels extremely easy and without all of the complexity
- 1:13:12that usually comes with having a bit point light while it's at
- 1:13:15the beginning. Yeah, that's that's super
- 1:13:18exciting. Very eager to to test that out
- 1:13:21once it's once it's live in the marketplace.
- 1:13:23So thanks for walking through that.
- 1:13:26Maybe this is a good, good spot to wrap.
- 1:13:28I mean, this has been a fantastic conversation, Pierre
- 1:13:31and and, you know, learned a lot about what what Flash is doing
- 1:13:34and, and super excited for you guys and I'm sure we'll we'll
- 1:13:37have you on again and in the near future.
- 1:13:39But anything else you wanted to to get out there or where could
- 1:13:44people learn more about Flash or yourself?
- 1:13:48Yeah, I think it's what we're working on is definitely
- 1:13:52interesting, innovative, and we need people to test it out, to
- 1:13:57work with it, to help us in building it, share ideas.
- 1:14:01There's just a lot of things that that can be done so anyone
- 1:14:04can reach out to us. Of course, our website is Pay
- 1:14:07with flash.com and there's all the information there.
- 1:14:11You can directly access the web app.
- 1:14:12It's free. The only moment you pay
- 1:14:14something is the moment you earn anything.
- 1:14:17So it's a net positive for you as a user.
- 1:14:19So go check out the app as well. We're trying to put a lot of
- 1:14:21effort on user experience and making it feel nice, just like
- 1:14:25what people are are used to. So Pay with flash.com.
- 1:14:29Yeah. If you can find me on Twitter at
- 1:14:32Seer Corbin. Well, just Pierre Corbin, I
- 1:14:35think you'll find me as well. And yeah, yeah, I think that
- 1:14:39that's it. But thanks a lot for having me
- 1:14:40on, guys. It was really, really good
- 1:14:42conversation. Always good to be able to go so
- 1:14:44deep into these topics that, you know, I think about all day but
- 1:14:47I don't talk about so. Yeah, absolutely appreciate you
- 1:14:51making the time. Thanks for joining, Pierre.
- 1:14:54Thank you. All right.
- 1:14:56And that's that'll do it for this episode of Final
- 1:14:58Settlement. Thanks everybody.
- 1:15:00Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:15:02If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:15:04episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:15:07app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:15:09today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:15:12Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Rat Media is
- 1:15:14for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:15:17nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:15:20Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:15:23to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:15:26to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:15:29advisors.