Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Jodi Arias - (Chapter 3)
Transcript
- 0:00So Berto, there's a chapter three in our deep dive on the psychology of
- 0:03Jodi Arius, three out of ninety nine. Yeah, there's so many things
- 0:07to talk about, and we're barely into my notes. We've had a number
- 0:10of different tangents, if you will, into love bombing and borderline and other
- 0:14kinds of things that I want to continue talking about in this deep dive,
- 0:17which is partially for everyone to listen to and partially just for patrons. But
- 0:22in this chapter, I want to start just by kind of launching into the
- 0:27next part of the story between Jody Airis and Travis Alexander. What do you
- 0:31say, Berto, Let's do it. This is the Psychology in Seattle podcast.
- 0:34I'm your host, Doctor kirkand I'm a therapist and a professor. My
- 0:37name is Umber. I step on cracks, which I think might hurt my
- 0:42mom, but I'm not sure. So. At this point of their relationship,
- 0:46they basically just met, and they had been seemingly a part of love
- 0:52bombing. She might have been love bombing him. It's unclear if he was
- 0:56doing it to her. At the very least he was receptive to it,
- 1:00maybe because of his own attachment disruption growing up and they begin to have a
- 1:04serious relationship, seemingly exclusive long distance between Arizona and California, travel to see
- 1:11each other. They'd also travel to a city in between because they had a
- 1:17friend that lived right in between close. They would talk on the phone.
- 1:21She would post pictures of them on her my space because it was two thousand
- 1:25and six and they fell deeply in love with each other and couldn't think,
- 1:30you know, about anything else, and email each other eighty two thousand times
- 1:34and just a regular old relationship. And he was a devout Mormon though,
- 1:40and she wasn't. And in his blog he wrote that around this time,
- 1:45he says he's thirty one, and he says that he loved being a bachelor,
- 1:49but he was lonely. And this is another tick in the column possibly
- 1:53of avoiding an attachment. That he probably was getting a lot of pressure to
- 1:59get married and have kids because fundamentalist traditional Mormons. That's actually pretty late for
- 2:05those types of communities, I'm guessing on average. Yet, and from the
- 2:08sound of it, he didn't really have any really deep long term relationships with
- 2:13women. He liked being a flirt, he liked having casual relationships. Now
- 2:19he would claim I think, and a lot of people around him would claim
- 2:22he wasn't having sexual relationships casual sexual relationships. But it's hard to know because
- 2:27there's a lot of Mormons who will have workarounds, if you will, who
- 2:32will engage in other kinds of sexual activity that doesn't involve intercourse and is considered
- 2:38by many within the church to be not a sin. I had a ten
- 2:42hour debate with an ex friend of mine, probably in the year two thousand
- 2:46or two thousand and one or something. That ten hour debate all night.
- 2:50We were up all night till the next morning, and it was because I
- 2:53was trying to convince this person probably shouldn't have but I was trying to convince
- 2:55them that it would be okay if they had premarital sex. And my rationale
- 3:00was because they engaged in a whole bunch of other sexual acts and thought it
- 3:04was okay. And anyways, this was just went around around, So I
- 3:07am familiar with the workarounds, logic and the yeah. So he tried to
- 3:15convert her to be a Mormon, and she converted happily. Now, on
- 3:20one hand, you could say she was inspired by the teachings of Latter day
- 3:23Saints On the other hand, you could say this was further evidence of her
- 3:28chameleonizing herself, that she doesn't really know who she is, not because she's
- 3:31a Dirk face and she wakes up in the morning and says, I don't
- 3:34want to know who I am. But because she wasn't given a chance to
- 3:38know who she was when she was young, because she wasn't a tune to
- 3:40another, which is likely the factor there. And she converted and Travis baptized
- 3:46her, which is interesting. I don't know if that says he was a
- 3:51leader of the church or it's just a common thing. Like my dad baptized
- 3:54me when I was a kid. Sometimes congregations like to keep it more in
- 4:00the family, if you will. Yeah, that not the pastor doesn't necessarily
- 4:03baptize everyone, you know what I mean. As in more formal churches like
- 4:08Catholics, dads don't baptize. That's very official. Yeah, So he baptized
- 4:14her, and he was trying to be a good Mormon, and they were,
- 4:18according to her and her journal and her testimony, they were having a
- 4:23lot of workarounds having anal sex for example, probably oral sex, this kind
- 4:27of thing. There's also this thing I think called floating that I've heard Mormons
- 4:30talk about sometimes where you put it in P and V and heterosexual sex but
- 4:36you don't move, and so technically, according to them, it's not really
- 4:41intercourse because you're just putting, You're just placing it in there. Oh my
- 4:44gosh. Okay, by the way, like the one that blows my mind
- 4:49the most is of course, like anal sex, right, because I mean
- 4:54really like but when you hear the teaching, yeah, they will talk about
- 4:59how creation is sacred. Yeah, you know, in the past, say
- 5:03fifty or even thirty years ago, the implication was, well, really anything
- 5:09in that ballpark is in the ballpark and thus a sin. But as more
- 5:14sex positivity and we wouldn't call the Mormon Church being sex positive, but as
- 5:18more sex positive notions get spread by advocates through our society, notions of liberation
- 5:27sexually are, you know, especially for younger people, more and more prevalent.
- 5:30So the idea of like, yeah, it's okay to have oral sex,
- 5:32okay to have you know, sex, if that's what you want to
- 5:34do. You know, there are precautions that you take. Plenty of online
- 5:38tutorials and doctor Drew giving advice and that kind of thing, and it starts
- 5:43to open up stores. So you have a lot of questions. You have
- 5:45a lot of youth saying like, well, so why can't you have sex?
- 5:48You know, because a lot of horny kids that are prevented from heavy
- 5:51petting it. So what's you know? So there would be there would be
- 5:55conversations like so it's kissing okay, Like, yeah, kissing's okay, So
- 6:00French kissing okay? Well, French kissing. Actually, it depends on the
- 6:02because when I was involved with some of my friends who were on the more
- 6:08extreme reborn Christian side of things, they heavily discouraged passionate kissing like pex on
- 6:15the cheek. Okay, anything that led to greater excitement its name right.
- 6:18Because the idea the threshold often is anything that causes you to even think about
- 6:26out of wedlock sex as a sin. You're not supposed to even think about
- 6:31it. But for others there could be like and certainly you can argue,
- 6:34like kissing doesn't necessarily cause you to think about sex. I mean, just
- 6:40you could argue just looking at your partner could make you think about sex.
- 6:44So you're not supposed to look at your Okay, so within a certain framework
- 6:47of thinking, he starts, Okay, well, kissing is okay. What
- 6:50about heavy petting? You know it is that? Okay? Well it's like,
- 6:54well, yeah, I mean it's it's not you're not having sex.
- 6:58I mean, that's that's what it says in the Bible. Okay, what
- 7:00about oral sex like sixty nineteen doesn't get you thinking about your partner sexually?
- 7:04Well, maybe the idea of thinking about your sexual your partner sexually isn't really
- 7:09the issue at that point. And then it's not a stretch if you will
- 7:14to you start saying, well, anal sex isn't a stretch, but it's
- 7:20you know, not, it's not intercourse, it's not procreation. So thus
- 7:26it's not the sex that they're talking about. The bou is a lot of
- 7:30lube with that logic. I mean, hey, you can shove anything in
- 7:33anywhere if you give it enough practice. You know, you start small and
- 7:38you work your way up. So with them, the two of them,
- 7:43according to Jody, which who knows, but it sounds credible because it's a
- 7:46common story that her and Travis started with these things and eventually we're having you
- 7:53know, P and V R intercourse. Now here's another factor I want to
- 7:57throw out there about why this all happened, because you can make an argument
- 8:03that Travis was involved with her well beyond the expiration date, right, maybe
- 8:07even during those first five months. And it's possible that if even if you
- 8:13just take Jody out of the equation and her issues and her love bombing and
- 8:20her pressuring and stalking and eventual murder of Travis, if we just think about
- 8:24factors that we can all think about for ourselves. Is when you take a
- 8:28human being a group of humans, and you artificially deny them their needs sexual
- 8:35needs for example, and you put you back them into a corner, you
- 8:39paint them into a corner where they have very few good choices to get out
- 8:45of that corner, then some wonky things are going to happen. For example,
- 8:48you could argue there's I don't know the statistics, but there's probably a
- 8:52lot of more women, young women who are walking around with some anal injuries
- 8:58because of some you know, you can have anal sex and have it,
- 9:01you know, if you take precautions and make sure, but you probably have
- 9:03to go to the doctor a couple of times kind of check up on things,
- 9:07make sure everything's going okay, because it's not meant for that, you
- 9:09know, And so you can have consequences to people. And one of the
- 9:15consequences that you can have is you can create a situation for someone like Travis
- 9:20where they would if they were left alone to their own devices and the other
- 9:26the fellow Mormon women were left to their own devices, then there would be
- 9:31occasional sexual gratification through consensual sex with either short term partners or casual sex long
- 9:39term partners. And thus you would have Travis walking around with the ability to
- 9:46make flexible choices that were in his own interest, Like like at some point,
- 9:50say with Jody one, he could have been really compelled towards her because
- 9:56I believe she might have been one of the few non Mormon women that he
- 10:00dated, maybe because she was so love bombing with him. Yeah, but
- 10:03also when things started to go a little wonky with Jody, he might have
- 10:07who knows, been more easily flexible away from Jody if he had someone else
- 10:13to have sex with that or he least predicted because what he was facing was
- 10:20so if I give up Jody, it's we're probably looking at a few years
- 10:24of trying to find my soulmate, and so I have to return to the
- 10:31desert. Yeah, that's no fun. So that's another factor that I think
- 10:35we should wait a minute though, When in history has grabbing a whole bunch
- 10:39of dudes and preventing them from having any sex for for a long time created
- 10:43any problems Catholics. So she has a diary, and she wrote a lot
- 10:50about her life not only as a teen regular life, but also wrote a
- 10:54lot about Travis and her feelings about Travis and her reactions to Travis, and
- 10:58a lot about their sexual life. So there's there's a lot of data that
- 11:01we have to go off of, and the courts had to go off of,
- 11:05and the public had to go off of, which really just you know,
- 11:07hey, people out there, if you have a diary or you got
- 11:11some private pictures on your computer, Like I'm not saying you're supposed to cover
- 11:16up a crime that you commit or something, but you know, just like
- 11:18or a tip that I'll say to everyone is if you're using work email,
- 11:24know that at any time those things can be pulled. Those are not pride.
- 11:28You have a password to that email, but you do not own that
- 11:31account. So where I ran into this early in my career at the university
- 11:37was when we decided to kick out a student. Occasionally we would get sued
- 11:43by that student, and all emails pertaining to that student and peripheral emails would
- 11:48get pulled and read in court, and you're just like, wait, So
- 11:52I emailed a fellow professor about a rent and one of the things I talked
- 11:56about was this student, and now we're reading this email, and you know,
- 12:00you're just like, yeah, you have to be kind of careful about
- 12:03what you talk about. That's the guidance. Like, so at work,
- 12:07we were told, listen, you're gonna be stepping on a lot of cracks
- 12:09and you're gonna write emails about it all the time. Expect anything you write
- 12:13an email to be in like hundred point font on the New York Times cover.
- 12:20That's how you should think about these emails. Yeah. Yeah, So
- 12:24friends start to observe their relationship between Jody and Travis, and you know,
- 12:31we talked about the hot tub scene. The friends were saying that she was
- 12:33all over him in this really weird way, very clingy. They would also
- 12:37say that Jody was very possessive, very jealous, wanted everyone to know that
- 12:43she was with him, and that he was not single. She didn't like
- 12:46him talking to other women. And one one friend gave this account. I
- 12:50don't know if you came across this, Burtle, but you know, there
- 12:52were a lot of jealous, clingy behaviors where I was like, okay,
- 12:56yeah, that's definitely you know, in the realm of cleanness. But then
- 12:58this, and who knows this was accurate, but it fits the profile,
- 13:01fits the story of Jody. They would be hanging out with all this friends,
- 13:05all their friends, you know, because they're in their twenties and they're
- 13:07hanging out all together, and they would meet at that one friend's house and
- 13:09so there's a lot of time around his friends, so a lot of observation,
- 13:15watching TV and that kind of thing. Well, he gets up to
- 13:18go to the bathroom and she goes with him. She doesn't stay in the
- 13:22couch. I didn't hear this one. And the woman giving this account said
- 13:28that Jody would sometimes stand outside the door of the bathroom what without him even
- 13:35knowing that she was out there. Okay, yeah, that's next level of
- 13:39cling right, because a lot of the things, you know, someone being
- 13:43very affectionate publicly not liking it if he talks to other women. You know,
- 13:48these aren't good, but they're things we've heard of before. But not
- 13:52even wanting to be a separate from each other. She didn't want to be
- 13:58separated from him when he went to the bathroom, just to temporarily and let's
- 14:01follow him to the bathroom. She would go through his cell phone and his
- 14:05email. She forwarded any email from a woman to herself, so she would
- 14:09go through his email and then quickly forward all these emails to herself so she
- 14:13would have an account of these situations. And to be clear, this is
- 14:18not only clinging, but this is abusive. Yeah, you know this is
- 14:22Yeah, this is controlling and not okay. Yeah, she showed him an
- 14:28email claiming that a man was stalking her, and the friend was claiming that
- 14:33she just made up. So the friends gives us account of like, yeah,
- 14:37this one time Travis comes to me and he's like, oh my god,
- 14:41someone is stalking Jody because they lived in different towns. Oh my god,
- 14:46someone is stalking Jody. And they read the email and this friend,
- 14:52this woman says like, Travis, she made up the email to make you
- 14:56jealous. Who knows. But given everything we find out about Jody, it
- 15:03seems highly likely. Yeah, so it's like time jealous or uh, you
- 15:07know, be worried, So he pays more attention to her right right,
- 15:13or wants her to move to his town or wants to move to her town
- 15:16or something. So hoping, you know, trying throwing a lot of darts
- 15:22at the board, hoping to get a bull's eye, trying to get him
- 15:26to respond, trying to get him to dedicate himself to her. In my
- 15:30experience, brief experience with this kind of thing, there would always be some
- 15:35sort of emergency. Whenever I was trying to back out of things, like
- 15:39if you know, like if I'm like, well, I'm gonna be kind
- 15:43of busier, some emergency would Oh my god, I have cancer. You're
- 15:46joking, but that actually happened one time. What do you mean, what
- 15:50happened? This person claimed that they might have cancer. It's a very young
- 15:52person. Now they might have but maybe they did, Maybe they did,
- 15:58but this was this was a romantic partner. Yeah, yeah, and there's
- 16:02always some sort of a young young person. You mean you were both young,
- 16:04yeah, you were both young adults. Yes, And I see you're
- 16:08saying yeah, yeah, no, no, no, no, No,
- 16:11we were both adults, and we were both uh involved romantically for a brief
- 16:15This wasn't a long period of time. This was like a few months and
- 16:18and it went there. There were a few times it went into the zone
- 16:22where I was like, uh, you know, I was kind of trying
- 16:23to pull back a bit, and it was like some emergency would happen.
- 16:26What else would she do? Uh, you know, basically like um accidents,
- 16:32like there was a car wreck or there was uh, I don't remember
- 16:36a stalker thing, but there was definitely like a big fight with someone.
- 16:40Uh, there was you know, problems with one family members. There was
- 16:42a health concern as possible. Those things really could have all been real,
- 16:47but in just coincidences. Yeah. Also, why if you're pulling away,
- 16:52would she maybe utilize that event as a way of trying you know, It'd
- 16:59be one thing if she was like, hey, you know what, I
- 17:00know you're kind of busy with things, but I just want to let you
- 17:03know I got in a car accident, but I'm okay, you don't need
- 17:04to worry about it, right. That's not how she probably did it right
- 17:07well, And I to be clear, I initially believed all of the instances.
- 17:11But after a while I started kind of noticing the pattern, and that's
- 17:12when I started getting a little suspicious, Like I'm like, well, that's
- 17:15kind of odd. Yeah. So with some of them meeting evidence that she
- 17:19had cancer, there was a car accident, well I never had evidence for
- 17:22any of it. Okay, it was always just so you didn't see a
- 17:25no, a smashed car. Okay. Yeah, so Jodiarius seems like she
- 17:30was doing this, and to be clear, this wasn't. I'm not this
- 17:34is a micro version of this. I'm just saying I've seen that kind of
- 17:38thing, and it's always tricky because at first, of course, you want
- 17:42to be like, oh my gosh, what happened? Let me help you?
- 17:45Like what can I do? Yeah, I mean it works right,
- 17:48Yeah, I mean you're just like I'm a bad person if I plus,
- 17:52they will have a way of, you know, expressing dependency. They're like,
- 17:55you're the only person that could help me. Oh. And I've also
- 17:59experienced this with an on rotic actually more than one non romantic person like friend
- 18:03in my life, where similar things happened, where there was a points where
- 18:10dramatic things were sort of used. In this case, I'm talking about a
- 18:14family member where dramatic things were used as a and they know or and it
- 18:19could be subconscious as well, depending that the pressure that you'll be under to
- 18:25actually rise to the occasion and bridge the gap is so large, you know,
- 18:29because you're a compassionate, good, responsible, loving human being that would
- 18:33not that would deny someone help when they need it. Okay, So I
- 18:37want to talk a little bit about just a briefly, because we'll you know,
- 18:41occasionally talk about borderline. She was eventually diagnosed with borderline during the trial,
- 18:45but another psychologist said she didn't have borderline. I don't know. If
- 18:48I were to assess her, I would say that she has borderline, but
- 18:52she has a lot of the signs. And I was quite convinced by the
- 18:55testimony during the trial, or at least mostly convinced. It sounded believable to
- 19:00me because that person actually did have several days to assess her and talk to
- 19:03other people. And my recollection is that the defenses psychologists or the person that
- 19:10assessor the prosecutor pointed out several like mistruths or yeah, we'll get to that.
- 19:15Yeah, that's a whole episode right there, The whole chapter of me
- 19:18there's so many details of the psychological testimony that are interesting. Let's just say,
- 19:25but to check in with this now, I want to be clear.
- 19:27People with borderline, you know, they don't kill people typically, So I
- 19:32don't want to say that she killed because she had borderline or people with borderline
- 19:36kill people. That's just not the case. And also that not all people
- 19:41with borderline present as she does. There's plenty of different types. And also
- 19:45there are plenty of listeners right now to this who I know because they'll tell
- 19:48me that they have borderline. They self identify or have been diagnosed with borderline
- 19:53and have a lot of self awareness, and they've been through a lot of
- 19:56treatment, a lot of therapy, and thus although they have a tendency towards
- 20:00borderline personality and the distortions and the behaviors, they manage it well enough that
- 20:06they would never do this. But with Jodie, pre awareness, pre treatment,
- 20:11possibly with what I'm arguing is moderate borderline. And my contention is that
- 20:15if she does have borderline, it's not severe because severe borderline individuals would have
- 20:22had a lot more global behaviors across a lot of different relationships. That would
- 20:26be a lot more obvious. Seemingly, she did have the underlying foundation of
- 20:30borderline, the terrifying feelings of abandonment and betrayal, the desperation for closeness at
- 20:37all costs, the idealization versus devaluation. You know, she idealized him and
- 20:45then got to the point where she was all batting him and devaluing him to
- 20:48the point where she killed him. Also, people with borderline tend to be
- 20:53very dependent on others because they desperately want Now there's a types. You know,
- 21:00you can actually have borderline people who are very dominant and might come across
- 21:03as very independent and don't really express their vulnerability. So there's different kinds.
- 21:07But she exhibits the kind that the way that she gains attachment security is through
- 21:15expressing dependence and cleanness. I need you, I want you, I can't
- 21:18live without you, and you can't leave me because I don't know what I
- 21:22would do without you. That that kind of stuff obsessed with him. Also,
- 21:26she would have a very childlike demeanor, and I think she might have
- 21:30even had a childlike demeanor with him, And that also gets into the discussion
- 21:34of possible pedophilia, which we'll talk about later. There's extremely low evidence of
- 21:40him being attracted to children. But there are some details that we can get
- 21:45into, and most of the details that we can discard in this category were
- 21:51put forth by her when she's trying to defend herself. But she did have
- 21:53a very you know, when she's being interviewed by the cops, if you
- 21:56didn't know any better, you would think she was like a tenure old or
- 22:00something. She acted very young. Yeah, yeah, the cadence, the
- 22:03sweetness, the naivete, the purity, the pleasantness of a ten year old,
- 22:11if you will, just kind of like, I'm gonna I'm here,
- 22:12I'm gonna tell you a story, the rambliness of a ten year old,
- 22:15comparing it with Casey Anthony, the same weird lack of reaction when confronted with
- 22:22direct accusations, which is always like because you know, if if you or
- 22:26anyone accuses me of something, I'll be like what No, that's what it.
- 22:30Right. In these cases, you see them accuse these people directly and
- 22:34they're just like, oh yeah, well, I just you know, change
- 22:37subject, going to this long, rambling thing, tangent thing, and it's
- 22:41so odd to watch. And she does that in those in those interviews,
- 22:45where it's like again as kind of as a child, like, oh,
- 22:48almost like I didn't get what you just meant. But anyways, there's this
- 22:51other thing that I was thinking about it. Yeah, this is not necessarily
- 22:53a part of borderline, but it is a part of early childhood difficulties.
- 22:57Yeah, you can imagine it's child learning and maybe even for parents out there,
- 23:03maybe even for yourself, Burdo, you will see your children regress at
- 23:07times under stress, where you will see them adopt a younger persona where they
- 23:11might even talk in a syntax that's young. I've definitely seen that vocabulary that's
- 23:17younger though, wine like they were younger. They might even claim I can't
- 23:21do that because they couldn't when they were younger. And it's a normal thing.
- 23:25We all do this. Kids are very obvious with it. Adults will
- 23:27do this as well. When we're unsafe, we want to eschew responsibility.
- 23:33We want to return to a place where we were given much more accommodations.
- 23:37You know, where people accommodated us. They didn't require things of us,
- 23:41right, and they loved us regardless, right, And I didn't have to
- 23:45do this stupid math problem. Yeah, you could argue nicer to us.
- 23:52You know, when you're four, you don't have to do homework, you
- 23:55don't have to do chores, or you have very limited chores, you don't
- 23:59have to be able to go to school, these kinds of things. You
- 24:02don't have to take care of younger sister when you're four, And when you're
- 24:06pressured and you're stressed out and you want sympathy included in this, you'll you
- 24:12just subconsciously or consciously will kind of go back there. And sometimes it works,
- 24:17you know, because it will elicit the sympathy from the parent. You
- 24:22know, either consciously or unconsciously. The parent will see the big anime eyes
- 24:29and will say, oh, you cute little kid. Can't we can't let
- 24:33you off like that. I mean, we can't let you suffer like this.
- 24:37Our pets, dogs and cats do this too us. You know,
- 24:40they will beg in a very well It's like we were recently on a fairy
- 24:45a faery, right, and my twelve year old wanted to go outside where
- 24:52it was very windy, and neither of us wanted to go in that moment.
- 24:55We did go, but not in that moment, and I will just
- 24:56go out and regression happened, like I don't I don't want to go out,
- 25:00Like we're right here, we see it, like we we see the
- 25:03way, like we know where you're gonna be standing. There's no problem.
- 25:07Eventually she did. But it was really odd. It was like, well,
- 25:11there's a difference between not regressing as a twelve year old and just being
- 25:15uncomfortable. Did she give off a younger vibe? Yes, like basically like
- 25:19I'm like, I don't know an eight year old, and I can't be
- 25:22alone by myself outside. Like it was just very maybe the facial expression and
- 25:26the body language. Yeah, this is a person that goes riding her bike
- 25:30outside alone all the time. Yeah, and for some reason in this moment,
- 25:34Well it's it's new, right, Yeah, she doesn't know she's in
- 25:38a crowd of stranger. I'm not saying it's not battering. It was just
- 25:41fun. It was odd. You know, it happens all the time.
- 25:44Regression happens all the time. We do it all the time. That's why
- 25:45when we crawl into a fetal position, that's why when we put our head
- 25:49and our partners lap and they you know, play with our hair, we're
- 25:55regressing to a place that is why are you bringing that up? I was
- 25:57scared during the movie. What was I'm supposed to do? You know,
- 26:00like, that's okay, but you know I regretted a little bit to stop
- 26:04drooling. I just told you so for her, who knows. But an
- 26:10hypothesis is that when she is afraid and uncomfortable, and has been frequently in
- 26:15that position growing up, she goes to that place not only as a way
- 26:21of getting out of trouble and getting people to think, oh, what a
- 26:25sweet little girl next door, yeah, but also as a way to elicit
- 26:30people loving her. Right, it's hard not to love an innocent, naive
- 26:37child, and adults will sometimes go to this place as a way of trying
- 26:41to tap into that instinct. Right, because you don't feel threatened by an
- 26:47innocent, naive woman who comes across like she's just you know, because the
- 26:52way she and you have If you haven't watched the interviews of her being integrated,
- 26:55she's literally being interrogated for the murder, for the brutal murder of us,
- 27:00and she is acting like she's the sweetest, most positive, and she's
- 27:06talking about how she loves God and that she has all these plans. Do
- 27:11you remember the tangent. When she was apologizing to the dog, she lightly
- 27:15tapped with her foot one time. Yeah, I mean it is a little
- 27:18kid. That is a little kid, Like I could see a little kid
- 27:22going like, oh my gosh, I feel terrible. The dog was licking
- 27:25the thing and I kind of went like this and I now my dog,
- 27:27and I like, you're being interviewed for murder of your like what are you
- 27:30talking about? And the facial expressions when she's being interviewed by the press during
- 27:36this time like very disarming, right. You see the footage of the like
- 27:41the behind the scenes footage of one of the famous interviews, the one where
- 27:47at the end, towards the end of the interview, she starts like creating
- 27:49this new story of what actually happened. But there was footage like behind the
- 27:53scenes of before that interview started, she was applying makeup. Yeah did you
- 27:59see that? And it's like all kind of I wouldn't call it flirty.
- 28:02It's almost like on Janue like, oh hi, almost like Marilyn Monroe,
- 28:07but Monroe Monroe, Monroe, Monroe, thank you, the Monroe doctrine.
- 28:11But she's like, oh, I'm just oh, look, that's like acting
- 28:15very innocence. She asked the interview to hold her her compact. Yeah,
- 28:19so she can, and you know, she's apologized. She's like, I'm
- 28:22so sorry, so sorry. She's like, oh, yeah, and tell
- 28:25me if I get if I get shiny up, put on makeup. And
- 28:27on one level, yeah, you want to look good on the camera.
- 28:30It's fine, especially when you want America to like you and you don't want
- 28:34to be canceled and you want to be set free. On the other hand,
- 28:37the way she goes about it is so denying the situation context. Yeah,
- 28:44there's a way, there's a way to do. She'd be like,
- 28:45hey, um, you know this is a real serious situation. You know,
- 28:49my life is on the line here, But do you mind if I
- 28:52put some makeup on? I know it's kind of you know, there's a
- 28:55way of coming across while you're ignoying, like there's nothing wrong with putting makeup
- 28:59on. I feel like people focus on that, like can you just like
- 29:02the interviewer probably put a lot of makeup on, you know, like,
- 29:04what's the big deal. But the manner, the demeanor, I think she
- 29:08actually used it as a way to try She thinks as a way because I
- 29:12think it worked when she was growing up. I think I think it worked
- 29:15in life. I think when she regressed when she child eyed herself. I
- 29:19think it did work a lot when she was growing up and in subsequent relationships.
- 29:25But this situation was so bizarre, so different from her other moments in
- 29:30life. She resorted to that and was confused when it wasn't working. I
- 29:33know what I'm like when I am accused of a crime I didn't commit.
- 29:37And by crime I mean like you know, you said you were going to
- 29:41call at seven and at seven thirty, and I'm like no, actually,
- 29:44like you know me, I get into a full on debate, will debate
- 29:48for hours. I will not have my name besmirched. Can you imagine me
- 29:52sitting before an interview when I've been accused of murder that I didn't commit,
- 29:56and I'm sitting there going cracking my usual bar too, jugs, okay,
- 30:00oh, you know, puns and little funny little things. In what world?
- 30:04I would be like so focused, I can't focus on anything else then
- 30:08getting the heck out of this crazy hell that I've been thrust into. What
- 30:14are you talking about? My make like, get the hell out of here.
- 30:17Yeah, I wonder if you somehow could measure her brain. Of course
- 30:22we don't have that ability, but if consciously she literally wasn't aware of the
- 30:26context, or she very much was, and she was resorting to subconsciously or
- 30:33at least somewhat subconsciously or even consciously this demeanor, most people will say she's
- 30:37purposely manipulative. It's possible, and purposely putting on this act. It's possible,
- 30:42But it's also possible it's just a habit that she would fall into,
- 30:48because there's a possibility that again, if you measured her brain in that moment,
- 30:52you literally would see no signal that she was in trouble in the way
- 30:56that she was, or that someone actually died, and even someone died brutally
- 31:00by her hand, like she had compartmentalized it so greatly that it just left
- 31:07no other room than for this very sweet person to come forward. You know,
- 31:11that is the feeling I get and some of these types of people and
- 31:15when you see them that I feel like parts of their ability to feel are
- 31:19not there, at least in those moments, because you're like, how are
- 31:22you doing this? No one can keep it like this, keep it cool
- 31:26and good, because because if because she's not a dumb person. Her IQ
- 31:30was higher than average, and if she was aware of the context and she
- 31:36was trying to convince people, I think she would have come across very differently,
- 31:41right, yeah, you know the way that maybe you know, like
- 31:45Casey Anthony actually came across that way sometimes, like Casey Anthony was not correct
- 31:48me if I'm wrong, right, Like Casey Anthony wasn't weird the way.
- 31:52So in the cop interviews she was Casey Anthony was, yeah, but not
- 31:57in the press interviews. And now you and I had a different reaction to
- 32:02that mockumentary we watched. I always felt a cringe. You actually didn't quiet.
- 32:08So people I think might have seen it from both sides. But I
- 32:12think everyone, well I don't shouldn't say everyone. I think more people than
- 32:15not would see this, this one, the the Jody one, and be
- 32:19like, Okay, that's not right. Yeah there's something. So it's almost
- 32:22like, if you're scoring their ability to play for the context of the situation,
- 32:29I would score Casey slightly higher because Casey to more people can come across
- 32:36as doing the right thing in the right CONTEXTU. Yeah, like Casey to
- 32:40me in her lies, I think she was a sort of person that would
- 32:45convince herself temporarily of the lies, but at the end of the day she
- 32:51is like, well, I know that's a lie. But with Jodiarius,
- 32:54sometimes I wonder the way it looked is that she just complained, letely compartmentalizes
- 33:00things that have happened in her life such that that might not be very accessible
- 33:05to her for a long period of time. You know, she like really
- 33:09convinces herself of a particular story, although I don't know, I get the
- 33:15more I think, and then I think about her being interrogated by the police.
- 33:16In a order for her to lie, she would have to have the
- 33:20real story in her head. So maybe she's just really good at lying or
- 33:24don't. But there's still an inability to feel right. And what I mean
- 33:29by feel is like just get under pressure, starts sweating, start stuttering a
- 33:34bit, start like none of that is there, right, It's completely like,
- 33:37oh I don't know, right, Yeah, that's weird. Okay,
- 33:39So that brings up other questions like is their fear underneath it and she's covering
- 33:44it up with a face, or she literally just doesn't even feel it,
- 33:49you know what I mean? Yeah, it's weird. It is something to
- 33:52think about, and I don't know there's evidence for the latter, definitely could
- 33:57be. One thing is when you hear like one of the things I brought
- 34:00up during the Casey thing was when she calls the first call she makes back
- 34:05to the house where her family's ad she sounds fairly urgent and desperate. Now
- 34:10she's completely unfeeling about everyone's feelings. She just wants to talk to her brother
- 34:15and get someone the boyfriend's number and blow. But she sounds desperate, like
- 34:20there's a desperation there, urgency right now. Maybe I didn't see those,
- 34:23but like almost in every single interaction, no, every interaction I can think
- 34:29of that I saw the Jodie once. She's kind of like not right,
- 34:32she's just more almost sedated. Yeah, like even in the trial, Like
- 34:37if you think of the trial, there's no like, God, damn it,
- 34:39I told you, I don't remember. Yeah, it's always like I
- 34:43don't know what did you mean by that word? Well, I can't tell.
- 34:45Well, I'm being well, mine is shutting down because you're kind of
- 34:47talking a lot. Well, you're portraying it robotic, But I would say
- 34:52it was like that sweet little girl, fair enough, an innocent little girl.
- 34:57Although I'd say in the trial it's almost like almost like she's graduated to
- 35:00a teenage, like a moody teenager. Yeah, where she's like, I
- 35:05don't know, because she's being as you have a little more attitude with the
- 35:07prosecutor, yeah, whereas with the cops there's no attitude. Yeah, a
- 35:10little bit of just like I can't believe. The vibe is I can't believe
- 35:15I'm being accused of this. Well, you haven't been treating me very nice.
- 35:17Yeah, this is really awful. I'm being I don't know, you're
- 35:20using a lot of words, but like that's kind of almost like this teenager
- 35:22thing, like yeah, yeah. So anyway, but my guess is that
- 35:27that is you could argue a part of the development of the personality kind of
- 35:32related to borderline, or at least both of these aspects come from the same
- 35:37place of abandonment, worry of attachment, loss, assumptions of betrayal happening around
- 35:44every corner, and out of not knowing who you are. That's so that's
- 35:50another Actually, that's another aspect to this that let's talk about, and then
- 35:52we'll go to the break that when you are raised in a way that doesn't
- 35:57have a lot of a tunement. You can feel lot of a band and
- 36:00you can have the schemes and the pain and the emotional problems related to borderline
- 36:06later in life, but you also are not given the ability to know who
- 36:09you are and know your emotions. So the individual will both lack an identity,
- 36:15as they say, but the way I frame it is they don't know
- 36:17who they are because they have never been given the chance to explore that within
- 36:22a caring relationship, a safe caring relationship. They also don't know how they
- 36:25feel, and they actually have a hard time interpreting the emotions because a big
- 36:29part of early childhood is parents actually reflecting the child's emotions, saying, oh
- 36:32my god, you're so happy right now, yes, oh my god,
- 36:36you're so sad, Oh my god, does that hurt? And if they
- 36:37don't have that, then they don't really understand it. They understand they're having
- 36:40the emotions, and they have a very childish understanding their emotions and thus have
- 36:46very little ability to know what they need because emotions also and you have very
- 36:51little ability to regulate your emotions because you don't even know the emotions till they're
- 36:54at ten. I think you're nailing that on the head, because that is
- 36:58I think what I've actually been trying to kind of pinned down about her behavior
- 37:01is she is clearly smart enough to be argumentative with the prosecutor about words and
- 37:07kind of in some cases maybe look make him look argumentative and dumb or whatever.
- 37:10But she doesn't get the things she's supposed to be portraying to elicit the
- 37:16right emotion from the jury of empathy for her. She doesn't get that part,
- 37:22which is that's not going to win them. What you want if you
- 37:25were being really evil and aware of it would be like that desperation, that
- 37:30the pain, that the struggle, and that there isn't that's not there.
- 37:35Yeah. In fact, when I was watching the trial footage, and the
- 37:39prosecutor would at times, I think, kind of lose his mind. I
- 37:44mean there were times when yeah, he really had, he became he became
- 37:50an abusive bully. I'm just gonna call it. I mean, is anyone
- 37:52asking you that question? No one asked you that question. No one wants
- 37:55to know that anyone asks you at points where he didn't need to. No,
- 38:00he looked ridiculous and of course I knew the end result of the trial,
- 38:05but as I'm watching it, I, in this weird way, started
- 38:07worrying that the jury was gonna was gonna have sympathy for Jody because of the
- 38:12way the prosecutor was talking to her. But two things worked against that worry.
- 38:15One, she didn't let them have that because she could have played it
- 38:20up. That's what I'm saying, she right, if she had was in
- 38:22connection with her emotions and could use them. Now want to get started down
- 38:27because because like literally I was like, if she broke down and started crying,
- 38:30it would be actually it would be emotionally congruent because the way he was
- 38:36bullying, because he was screaming at her at point. I mean, I
- 38:38would say nine to tie in with their story. Yeah, her story is
- 38:43she freaked out because that the views and he was very seeing i think,
- 38:46overtly creating scenarios in the courtroom, trying to abuse her verbally so he could
- 38:53demonstrate how her argument and her self defense didn't work. But I'm like,
- 38:59dude, that that's like for some movie about the courtroom, that's not for
- 39:04the actual court. Well, so a it's like you have a blind person
- 39:07and you throw a book at their face trying to prove you know, it's
- 39:09like, that's great for the movies, but you don't do that in real
- 39:12life. So I don't disagree with you that he was purposely trying to goad
- 39:15her, That's true. At the same time, I only watched a small
- 39:20percentage of of her eight days of testimony, eight or eighteen days, right,
- 39:25I only watched a very small portion, and I was getting sick and
- 39:29tired of her argumentativeness. So yeah, I could totally understand how he got
- 39:35to that point. Totally. But he's a professional, right, But I
- 39:37also could see the jury. That was the second thing I would say would
- 39:39work against her is that the jury saw the whole thing and also was sitting
- 39:44through the bullshit from both sides. So they're probably like, oh, these
- 39:47two, well, holy craft. Well, what I will say is ninety
- 39:52five percent of the tactics and the behavior from the prosecutor I thought was not
- 39:58only fine, also very effective. I mean the way he would break people
- 40:05down in a very when he was calm, well well, because what was
- 40:08fair is a lot of times when he was losing his shit. It's because
- 40:12earlier he had asked a question. She had given a clear answer, and
- 40:16later when he quoted that answer, she just pretended it never happened. Yeah,
- 40:20but there's a way, you know, I'm not a litigator, but
- 40:22there's a way to get frustrated that will highlight to the jury the problem with
- 40:30the witness. And there's a way of you know, getting hot under the
- 40:34collar that almost derails the jury from what you want them to be paying attention
- 40:39to. You know. So anyway, we're kind of rambling, But let's
- 40:45take a break and let's have the rest of the episode just for patrons of
- 40:49the podcast. You know, when we go over this outline that I that
- 40:52I've been taking for the past number of days, we end up rambling.
- 40:54But where we're gonna pick up again after the break during the patrons is when
- 40:59we're going to talk about the stalking. And I want to talk about her
- 41:01stalking, and I want to talk about stalking in general. What do you
- 41:05say, brutal, Let's do it, and everyone out there please take care
- 41:07of yourself because you deserve it.