Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 285. Think Inside the Box: How Constraints Spark Creativity and Communication
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: Constraints catalyze communication.
- 0:06My name's Matt Abrahams and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 0:09Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:11Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:15Today I look forward to chatting with David Epstein.
- 0:17David is a science writer and investigative journalist, best known
- 0:20for his number one New York Times bestseller range and the Sports
- 0:25Gene in his latest book Inside The Box, how Constraints Make Us Better.
- 0:29He explores the counterintuitive cognitive science showing that the limits we have.
- 0:34Free us up to be more creative.
- 0:37Well, welcome David.
- 0:39Thanks for being here.
- 0:40I really look forward to learning from you today.
- 0:42David Epstein: It's a pleasure to be here.
- 0:43Thanks for having me.
- 0:44Matt Abrahams: Okay.
- 0:44Shall we get started?
- 0:45David Epstein: Let's do it.
- 0:46Matt Abrahams: In reading Inside the box, I really resonated with,
- 0:49when you talk about the Christmas tree effect or featuritis.
- 0:53Can you share what these ideas mean and how can we prevent when we communicate in
- 0:58our core ideas from being drowned in just the unnecessary complexity of so many of
- 1:03the things we end up communicating about?
- 1:05David Epstein: That's a great question because those are phrases that come from
- 1:08designers primarily, featuritis and the Christmas tree effect, that essentially
- 1:12mean the same thing, adding more.
- 1:14So featuritis is like you get carried away by always adding features to things.
- 1:17The Christmas tree effect is similar, meaning you just keep putting ornaments
- 1:22on the tree over and over and over.
- 1:24And humans have a hardwired what's called additive bias to always solve
- 1:29problems by putting more and more on.
- 1:31In a related bias, the flip side called subtractive neglect bias,
- 1:35we tend to overlook solutions that involve taking things away.
- 1:38I think when it comes to communication, and I've been guilty of this for sure,
- 1:44I'm curious about a lot of things and I have a desire to impart everything
- 1:48that I think is interesting to someone.
- 1:51And I think that shows in my first book, which did well, but in retrospect, going
- 1:55back, there are things in here that I would take out looking at it now.
- 1:58So I feel like an antidote to featuritis when it comes to communication
- 2:02would be something like, assuming the other person's gonna forget
- 2:06everything except one thing you said.
- 2:08Now decide what that one thing is before you're opening your mouth.
- 2:11That doesn't mean you can't add other things.
- 2:14But that one thing you wanna make sure that you get across.
- 2:17And I think that's an approach, like many good constraints do, can help
- 2:22you clarify priorities when you're trying to communicate clearly.
- 2:25Matt Abrahams: Yeah.
- 2:25One of the things that I coach the people I coach and the students
- 2:29I teach is to really think of the bottom line first before you speak.
- 2:33And I like how you said, what's the most important thing?
- 2:35And then build the message from there rather than thinking of
- 2:39everything you have to say and hoping that some of it sticks.
- 2:43Growing up, one of my favorite books as a kid was Green Eggs and Ham.
- 2:47I love Dr. Seuss.
- 2:48Can you tell the story of Dr. Seuss, Theodor Geisel, and The Cat in the
- 2:52Hat, and how that was written with vocabulary restriction in mind?
- 2:57And how can that type of restriction lead to new and novel input and output?
- 3:04And have you thought about that in the way you do your communication, and perhaps
- 3:08all of us could do our communication?
- 3:10David Epstein: So Dr. Seuss, we take for granted now that there's a lot of
- 3:15interesting children's literature, but at the time he was working, it was boring.
- 3:19Like I went back and read some of the stuff and it was just super
- 3:22literal stuff, very pedantic.
- 3:25And Dr. Seuss was asked to create a children's book using only 200 words from
- 3:32a kid's vocabulary list that he was given.
- 3:35And so what does he do?
- 3:36First he starts complaining to his wife.
- 3:37'Cause he looks through and he says, there's basically no adjectives.
- 3:40And in fine Seussian form, he compares it to trying to make a strudel without
- 3:44any strudels, which I love because it's like he was the same person
- 3:48in private as he was in public.
- 3:50But then he gets exasperated and decides he's just gonna take the
- 3:53first two rhyming words on the list and write a book around them.
- 3:56And the first two rhyming words are cat and hat, and the rest is history.
- 3:59But that restriction forced him to experiment with rhythm because
- 4:04he couldn't experiment vocabulary.
- 4:05And after he did that, his famous publisher bet him that he couldn't
- 4:09do it again using only 50 words.
- 4:12And he did that for Green Eggs and Ham where he had to experiment
- 4:14with rhythm even more because what can you do with 50 words?
- 4:19And it became this rollicking tale, of course, that spawned imitators
- 4:22and changed children's literature.
- 4:24And gave rise to psychological effect known as the Green Eggs and
- 4:28Ham effect, which is the idea that the quickest path to creativity
- 4:32is by blocking familiar solutions.
- 4:35So our brains are actually lazy.
- 4:37You know, you may think your brain is made for thinking, but it's actually
- 4:39made for preventing you from having to think whenever possible because
- 4:42thinking is energetically costly.
- 4:44So if you're given complete freedom, you'll just go down
- 4:48what cognitive scientists call the path of least resistance.
- 4:50You'll just do the thing that feels convenient or that you've done before.
- 4:53And so the best way to become creative or have new ideas is to take that away.
- 4:56So in a communication perspective, one thing I would think of is, let's say
- 5:01you're going into a client meeting or something and you say, if we were not
- 5:06allowed to pitch or recommend or say the usual thing, what would we do instead?
- 5:12And I think that can be a fruitful thought exercise for thinking of what are other
- 5:15ways we could frame this, or what are other ways we could propose this, or maybe
- 5:19even directly in the communication medium, if we were not allowed to communicate this
- 5:24using PowerPoint slides or whatever it is that we're used to, how would we do it?
- 5:27I'm not saying you necessarily have to do that, but it tends to be a
- 5:30very generative exercise in figuring out what is the core of this thing
- 5:34and what are ways to communicate it.
- 5:36Matt Abrahams: I love the backstory on Dr. Seuss's initial successes and this idea
- 5:42of putting constraints into communication to get you to think differently about it.
- 5:48I have a colleague who when they do an activity in class and they're
- 5:52teaching conflict resolution, they ask the students to have a conflict,
- 5:56they create a simulated conflict, and the students can only ask questions.
- 6:00They can't make declarations.
- 6:02And you can see how it would change the dynamic, right?
- 6:05And again, she's not advocating that every conflict should be resolved
- 6:09through questioning exclusively, but it changes your mindset
- 6:13and it changes how you listen.
- 6:15David Epstein: When I'm in my mode as a journalist, I think I'm legitimately a
- 6:18better person because it's not that I'm only asking questions, but it's that I go
- 6:23into every conversation with the mindset of trying to understand, not to be right.
- 6:30And that frame just makes so much difference in how the conversation goes.
- 6:35Matt Abrahams: Yeah, absolutely.
- 6:36And I think the challenge for all of us, you first have to recognize the habits
- 6:41and patterns, heuristics, that you have to then begin to challenge them and
- 6:44say, okay, now we're not gonna do this.
- 6:46But I think there are a lot of possibilities and another reframe you
- 6:49could use, go into any situation as a journalist, what would a journalist
- 6:53do here could be really helpful.
- 6:55What is chunking and how can it help us in our communication?
- 6:59David Epstein: Chunking is in the sense that psychologists
- 7:02use, it means essentially the grouping together of information.
- 7:07So maybe I can give you an example, would be an easy way to explain the phenomenon.
- 7:11If I said 20 random words to you right now and asked you to repeat them
- 7:15back, you'd have trouble doing that.
- 7:17If I gave you 20 words in a sentence, you may well be able to repeat that
- 7:21back to me, or at least most of it, and they could be the same 20 words
- 7:25just in the first case mixed up.
- 7:26But it will make your memory seem so much better because you've learned a
- 7:30system of grammar and groups and phrases of words that are chunked or collected
- 7:34into groups in your brain, so you're not actually remembering 20 different things.
- 7:38You're remembering just a few different chunks that fit together in some
- 7:41coherent scheme, and that's how humans are able to remember and access as much
- 7:46information as we can because we chunk information into related, meaningful
- 7:52groups and then into these broader networks or templates of knowledge.
- 7:56Matt Abrahams: So how does this lead to novelty?
- 7:58How does it lead to creativity and new ideas when you're attaching to
- 8:01previous existing old information?
- 8:04David Epstein: Our older ideas or familiar ideas are actually the jumping
- 8:08off point for new ideas typically.
- 8:09In fact, as I was doing the research for the book, one of the things I learned
- 8:12was that the idea that creativity and originality are synonymous was not even
- 8:17a thing until the late 18th century and this group of people that wanted
- 8:21to say not everything is logical, like creative inspiration comes in
- 8:25these lightning strikes out of the blue and there's no rhyme or reason
- 8:29to it, and that's not really true.
- 8:31It actually typically comes from modifying ideas that are already very familiar.
- 8:37And I think if we're thinking about this in a communication frame, one of
- 8:40the important things is that if you want to get people to come along with
- 8:43creative or radical ideas, a really important thing you have to do is ground
- 8:48it in things that are very familiar to them, and then layer the more radical
- 8:53thing on top of it so that this vision of change also comes along with it
- 8:56an embedded vision of continuity.
- 8:58Matt Abrahams: Demonstrating consistency and showing how what you're talking about
- 9:02is familiar, it makes it easier for people to one, buy into it and to follow through.
- 9:08Anybody listening to this show knows that I am a huge advocate for frameworks
- 9:12and structure and communication for the very reasons you've just talked about.
- 9:16They allow us to understand and predict what's coming so we can dedicate
- 9:20and focus more information on it.
- 9:22We're not good at remembering just list after list, item after item.
- 9:26When you package it in a structure like problem, solution, benefit, past, present,
- 9:31future, all of a sudden that chunking allows us to have a framework that we can
- 9:36attach to and it makes it more memorable.
- 9:39So I definitely appreciate you defining that term that helps us see something
- 9:43that we often talk about on the show.
- 9:45In your book, you talk about the podcast, This American
- 9:48Life, one of my favorite shows.
- 9:50Can you share with us what you learned from your interviewing of them?
- 9:54David Epstein: I did a piece for This American Life and I had never
- 9:57written anything for radio or narrative podcasts essentially.
- 10:00And this was like a 35 minute piece that I'm writing.
- 10:03I know nothing about what I'm doing, and I'm a science writer, so I was used to
- 10:06putting a lot of technical information in articles, or reasonably technical,
- 10:10and that's okay when people can stop and reread it or slow down, not so
- 10:14okay when it's flying by them in audio.
- 10:17And so This American Life had this system where you do these
- 10:20read-throughs where it's like Ira Glass sitting there holding a stopwatch.
- 10:23You're reading the narration, your producer hits play when you
- 10:25wanna play some interview audio.
- 10:27And then people say what confused them.
- 10:28They don't tell you how to solve it.
- 10:30You have to do something, you can't ignore, but they don't tell you how.
- 10:33And then you keep redoing that.
- 10:34And every time you do it, there'd be at least one new person who had
- 10:38never heard it before, every time.
- 10:39And that person gets to say what confused them.
- 10:41Then you just do that over and over until the new person comes
- 10:44in and says, nothing confused me.
- 10:46I got everything.
- 10:47And so the process titrated out confusion, and it's a brutal process, but the
- 10:53greatest editing process I've ever been through because it just relentlessly
- 10:58exposes all the assumptions you are making about things that you know really well,
- 11:03and that you've even lost track of the fact that not everybody knows this stuff.
- 11:07And even though I'm sensitive to that as a professional science communicator,
- 11:11I'm thinking about that all the time.
- 11:12And yet there's still stuff that just becomes so routine or, or so obvious
- 11:17to you once you know about it, but it's not obvious to people who don't.
- 11:20So it's a great system in that way that people can really lose track of
- 11:23what the other party doesn't understand if they start taking for granted the
- 11:27meaning of things in their world.
- 11:29Matt Abrahams: The American Life story highlights the importance of
- 11:32making sure your audience understands.
- 11:34But what I really like about it is the question they asked,
- 11:36they said, what is confusing?
- 11:38Many of us will say, did you understand everything?
- 11:41Were things clear, et cetera.
- 11:43But when you put it in, hey, what was confusing?
- 11:46That helps people be more specific, and I really like that they
- 11:50don't then give suggestions for how to make it less confusing.
- 11:54They leave that to you.
- 11:55So that, I think, is where that creativity comes in.
- 11:58And I think you learn more when you're not given direction on how to fix it.
- 12:01And I'm really gonna take this lesson to heart as a parent, as a teacher, as
- 12:05a coach, because often it's my reaction to then immediately give, here's
- 12:10what I think you could do to fix it.
- 12:12David Epstein: I thought it was fantastic because just wrote a book obviously about
- 12:16useful constraints, but there is clearly such thing as too much constraint, right?
- 12:19If you're telling someone what they have to do and how they have to
- 12:22do it, if the person says, there's no room for me to surprise myself,
- 12:25then it's too much constraint.
- 12:27But in this case, it really impressed upon me the power of having someone define
- 12:32the problem for you really well, and instantly you're fired up about solutions.
- 12:36They'd say, I just did not understand this beat in the story, whatever it was.
- 12:40And if they could define it really well, it feels very empowering for
- 12:43then doing the problem solving.
- 12:44I, I see the problem clearly.
- 12:46In many cases, I think a clear definition of the problem is the
- 12:49best tool for getting it solved.
- 12:51Matt Abrahams: Right, it helps to distill that down.
- 12:53Very good.
- 12:54Another term I need you to define for our listeners, what is
- 12:57precluding and how does it work?
- 13:00David Epstein: Yeah.
- 13:00Precluding is, in this context, blocking the most familiar solutions.
- 13:06So, in the history of innovation, preclude constraints are basically ever
- 13:13present, where either by someone's choice.
- 13:17In artistic innovation, it was often the case that people did this by choice,
- 13:21in order to innovate, in technological innovation, in many cases, it was more
- 13:24necessity, but that a preclude constraint means it precludes the previous solution.
- 13:29It blocks the path that has been taken most regularly, and once that's
- 13:36gone it's maybe the most generative creative prompt you can possibly have.
- 13:42The thing you're used to, the thing everyone's always done,
- 13:44you're not allowed to do it.
- 13:45So what now?
- 13:46How can you get this done?
- 13:48It kind of reminded me, actually, one of the early readers of the book was
- 13:50a guy named Ed Hoffman, who was the first chief knowledge officer at NASA,
- 13:53basically like the head psychologist, he stopped partway through and said, I
- 13:56gotta tell you about this mission called LCROSS, where the team ended up with
- 14:00half the time in budget they expected.
- 14:02And so what did they do?
- 14:04First they complained and then they said, well, if we were gonna get
- 14:06this done anyway, how would we do it?
- 14:08And it led them to repurpose things.
- 14:10So they took imaging equipment from army tanks and engine temperature
- 14:13sensors from NASCAR and created a probe that confirmed water on the moon.
- 14:19It was incredibly innovative and it led to other missions where they
- 14:23realized they could repurpose lots of technology, but they just never would've
- 14:26done this if they hadn't been forced off of the convenient path basically.
- 14:31Matt Abrahams: And we can challenge ourselves to do that.
- 14:34We don't have to have some external thing or people tell us that we can
- 14:38say, what if this weren't possible or this were taken away so we can actually
- 14:42leverage this as a tool ourselves.
- 14:45Before we end, I like to ask everybody three questions, one I make up just
- 14:49for you and two I've been asking everybody I've interviewed in the past.
- 14:52Are you up for that?
- 14:53David Epstein: Absolutely.
- 14:54Matt Abrahams: Alright.
- 14:54I'm gonna give you a constraint.
- 14:56If you were to give our listeners one boundary that could help them in their
- 15:02communication, what would that advice be?
- 15:06David Epstein: Make the other person's argument first.
- 15:09I realize there's no rule that applies to every situation, but I found this
- 15:13when I critiqued Malcolm Gladwell pretty stridently in my first book, and we ended
- 15:17up, we first met for a public debate, and then we became really good friends.
- 15:21So this was a very generative relationship based on disagreement.
- 15:24One of the things that really helped was at that initial debate, we decided
- 15:28to start, he and I together, by stating what we thought the other person's
- 15:33argument was, and I think one, that gave you some first empathy for the other
- 15:38person's argument, but it also gave the other person a chance to decide if
- 15:42they were actually being misunderstood.
- 15:44So you both had an understanding of if the other person heard you and then you
- 15:48could know what you were talking about when you were having this discussion.
- 15:52And so because of that, he and I then became running buddies and all this stuff,
- 15:55I started taking that forward to other situations where I thought I might have
- 15:59a different perspective than someone to start off, even if it's just to myself.
- 16:03Like that was a formal debate with him.
- 16:05But even to myself, what do I think the other person's point of view is?
- 16:08And, and I will, if I think it's appropriate, try to work
- 16:11that in early in a conversation.
- 16:12So what I'm hearing you say is, and then you're basically fact checking
- 16:15in real time and they'll correct it if you're wrong, and that's useful.
- 16:19So I think that idea of going in with making the other person's argument
- 16:22first, even if it's just to yourself, is a really useful constraint to enter
- 16:26certain types of conversations with.
- 16:28Matt Abrahams: I really, really like that.
- 16:29If nothing else, it puts you in service of the audience.
- 16:32It makes you focus on what's going on for them.
- 16:35Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 16:39David Epstein: Not to be redundant here, but I do wanna say it's Malcolm
- 16:42Gladwell because in those series of disagreements that led to us becoming
- 16:46good friends, he was very open-minded.
- 16:48So we had a debate at the same forum, 5 years apart, and the second time around,
- 16:53he started saying the things that I had convinced him of, and I didn't have
- 16:57nearly as much professional capital the first time we met for a debate.
- 16:59You could have just crushed me just because of who you
- 17:01are, and you're very clever.
- 17:03And he said, yeah, but I have the luxury of learning from my critics.
- 17:07And that stuck with me so much.
- 17:08The idea that an earnest critic, you have the luxury of learning from
- 17:12them instead of becoming defensive.
- 17:14And now I've seen that in his writing where he has decided some things that
- 17:19he wrote that became very famous, are not right, and has changed direction.
- 17:24And I think that's an amazing thing to do when you've been so successful with
- 17:28a certain idea, because I've definitely seen the opposite of other writers
- 17:31who, once they've become successful with an idea, they are not changing
- 17:35their mind, no matter the evidence.
- 17:37So his ability to acknowledge that and address it even directly, I think is
- 17:43rare and amazing and quite frankly, became really a role model for me.
- 17:47Matt Abrahams: That notion of there's something to be learned from the criticism
- 17:50and just the openness there, I think we could all learn something from.
- 17:54Final question for you, David.
- 17:56What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 18:01David Epstein: I think identifying the type of conversation you're having.
- 18:05We've all probably had this issue at some point where you are saying
- 18:09something or someone else is saying something you're upset about and one
- 18:12party offers solutions and really it's a I need to be heard conversation.
- 18:16And I think that can be a very upsetting disconnect for both sides.
- 18:20So identifying the conversation type.
- 18:22I think keeping in mind what psychologists call the peak end rule, which is that the
- 18:27way your brain remembers an experience is more or less an average of the moment
- 18:31of peak intensity and the last moment.
- 18:34You may not be able to do much about the moment of peak intensity,
- 18:36but you can end on a good note.
- 18:38That end moment has more weight than just an average moment.
- 18:41And the third I would say, and this is more group focused, would be relatively
- 18:46equal conversational turn taking.
- 18:48So, not that everyone has to have a turn in every case, but there is a body of
- 18:52research that I write about in the new book that shows that one of the hallmarks
- 18:56of teams that are good at solving problems together is that over the course of a
- 19:00day, for example, if they're working together, there will be relatively
- 19:03equal conversational turn taking.
- 19:05When I was writing about Pixar, where Ed Catmull, the co-founder, told
- 19:09me that they banned Steve Jobs from certain feedback meetings specifically
- 19:13because as he became this larger than life personality they felt his voice
- 19:18would take up too much space and crowd out other people who might have a lot
- 19:22to add but not be quite as eloquent.
- 19:25Or there's this colloquial term, HIPPO, highest paid person's opinion,
- 19:29where if that person speaks, everyone will start to gravitate around them.
- 19:32So I think putting boundaries in place that facilitate more
- 19:36equal conversational turn taking.
- 19:38Matt Abrahams: I really appreciate the three ingredients.
- 19:41They're very specific and they're all science-based.
- 19:44Be aware of what type of conversation you're having, what's needed in this
- 19:48conversation, what's your role in it?
- 19:50Think about how they end and can you end it in a way that increases the
- 19:54likelihood that people will remember it and have the experience you want them
- 19:57to, and then to really consider the turn taking that takes place because
- 20:01that does impact how people feel about it and the quality of the interactions.
- 20:05David, this has been fantastic.
- 20:07In many ways you've unconstrained my thinking and hopefully that
- 20:12of our listeners, even though the book was all about constraints.
- 20:15Thank you so much.
- 20:16Good success on Inside the Box, and I appreciate learning from
- 20:19you and having our conversation.
- 20:22David Epstein: I enjoyed this very much.
- 20:23Thank you.
- 20:25Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 20:26Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 20:29To learn more about constraints, please listen to episode 108 with Dan Klein,
- 20:34Adam Tobin, and Patricia Ryan Madsen.
- 20:36This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 20:42Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 20:43With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 20:46Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 20:50Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 20:52Also follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram.
- 20:55And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 21:00learning content, and our newsletter.
- 21:02Please also consider joining the Think Fast Talk Smart Learning Community
- 21:06at fastersmarter.io/learning.
- 21:09You'll find video lessons, learning quests, discussion boards, my
- 21:13AI coach, and our book club.
- 21:15Again, that's fastersmarter.io/learning to become part of the Think Fast
- 21:20Talk Smart Learning Community.