Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / The Hollywood Revue (1929)
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome
- 0:03to once upon a time at the Oscars Hello, everyone,
- 0:38and welcome to Once Upon a Time at the Oscars.
- 0:41Oh, you want me to do it? Yes, please. Okay.
- 0:43The podcast show. I already butchered it. It's
- 0:47okay. The show where we take you through every
- 0:49Best Picture nomination from 1928 through today.
- 0:531927 to today. That's okay. 1920s. Yes. Through
- 0:57today. We'll fix it in post. I'm not fixing it.
- 0:59Will we? Nope. Yep. I'm your host, Kyle. And
- 1:01I'm your co -host, Ryan. And welcome back to
- 1:04the final film. of the 1929 Academy year. I noticed
- 1:10when I went back and listened to how we talked
- 1:12about the previous year that there's some overlap
- 1:15that we already kind of have run into where we
- 1:18talk about the 1927 year as 1928 or talk about
- 1:20the 1928 year as 1929. So it's important to note
- 1:23that this movie did come out in 1929. Cool. And
- 1:26this is going to contribute to the 1929 ceremony.
- 1:30Is that correct? Yes, that is correct. I have
- 1:34gone back and forth so many times, and I even
- 1:36noticed I just put out the calendar for this
- 1:40year. For November. And it says 1930 ceremony.
- 1:43Yes. Which is totally fine. That is correct.
- 1:46But I thought the ceremony was in 29. Isn't that
- 1:50what we just said? For the ceremony this year?
- 1:52Yeah. Yes. Okay, sorry, I thought you meant for
- 1:54next year. For like when we talk about Alkwine
- 1:57and the Western Front. Oh, yeah, yeah. Yeah.
- 1:59Yeah, but we haven't done that calendar yet.
- 2:00No, we have not. Okay. So our calendar has one
- 2:03little typo. Yeah. Which, you know, again, confusing
- 2:06to know, like, is it for when it aired or for
- 2:10the movies that it's talking about? Right. So
- 2:12this is, in fact, the year of 1929. Perfect.
- 2:16That the ceremony is happening. Clarified. You
- 2:18know, we're just going to leave that typo as
- 2:20well, because I think it's like when people say,
- 2:23hey, have you been to New York City? And it just
- 2:27brings in, like, engagement. Yeah, I think it's
- 2:31a similar situation, like Black Eyed Peas. If
- 2:34we put something out, we're just going to leave
- 2:35it. You know, opposite of Black Eyed Peas. We're
- 2:37not going to make another version. Oh, yeah.
- 2:39Hey, we talked about that with the Lost Media
- 2:42episode. We did. So you leave it. You live and
- 2:44you learn. You get what you get. Yeah. Yeah.
- 2:46But also, listen to the show so you know what
- 2:49year we're actually talking about. I feel like
- 2:51if we did this six or seven years into it, that's
- 2:54one thing. Right. With it being like the second
- 2:56year and like the first year is so weird because
- 2:58it like goes over an amalgamation of like two
- 3:00years, maybe even three in some cases. I think
- 3:03that's okay. Yeah, we're just getting our feet
- 3:04wet. That's right. And by the time we get to
- 3:07the point where it's like, hey, we shouldn't
- 3:08be making mistakes, the Oscars correct themselves
- 3:10and only exist in one year. Hey, look, if we're
- 3:13covering something that makes plenty of mistakes
- 3:15itself, aren't we entitled to those same mistakes?
- 3:17We're just keeping up tradition at that point.
- 3:19That's right. Best Picture winner is La La Land.
- 3:22Uh, um, so I'm excited to talk about this movie
- 3:27today. I am too. It's super unique. It is. Way
- 3:30different from anything we have covered and probably
- 3:33will cover. Which is interesting because it's
- 3:35not even the first musical that we talk about,
- 3:38right? So Broadway Melody would be the first
- 3:40musical that was actually nominated. So, you
- 3:42know, along with this that we've talked about.
- 3:45So we're talking about a musical, but it kind
- 3:47of varies in a very different way because it's
- 3:49not exactly just a musical. It's more of a variety
- 3:53show. Yeah. And one thing I wasn't prepared for,
- 3:56and of course, I should say, we're talking about
- 3:58the Hollywood Review, also known as the Hollywood
- 4:00Review of 1929, is a variety show. But it's not
- 4:05even a variety show in the sense that it's recorded
- 4:09in front of a live audience. Right. You are the
- 4:11live audience. So watching this variety show,
- 4:15it's almost as if it was just taped as a variety
- 4:17show and then made into a movie. Yeah. Or not
- 4:20even made to a movie, put into theaters and then
- 4:22nominated for an Oscar. So was this your, this
- 4:26was not the first time you've watched this movie
- 4:27because you covered it for previous. Correct.
- 4:29Okay. So this is number two for me. So think
- 4:32back to when you first watched it. Yeah. How
- 4:34did, there's a scenario, did you know going in
- 4:37that this is a variety show? I always do a little
- 4:40bit of research before the movies. So I didn't
- 4:43know that's what it would be. I didn't know to
- 4:46what extent. I didn't know if there'd be. like
- 4:48an underlying story or anything. Behind the scenes.
- 4:52Yeah. Right. Watching it the first time, I remember
- 4:55being very critical of it because I was like,
- 4:58who is this for? Why are they doing this? This
- 5:01is the year of me just completely changing my
- 5:03opinions on everything, I think. Wow. That's
- 5:06great. Oh. Well, you got to remember that was
- 5:09your first year watching those movies, right?
- 5:11Right. So now I'm, you get to watch me be in
- 5:13the similar position you were in. Totally. And
- 5:15you get to be in the higher. than thou position
- 5:18of like, well, you know what? Maybe I take myself
- 5:20out of it. And I look at the movie how it is.
- 5:22And I'm very much in the, what is this? I'll
- 5:25just come out. This isn't a movie. Okay. It's
- 5:28a movie. Yeah. But it's not a movie. Sure. And
- 5:31there's a little bit of narrative, just a tiny
- 5:34little bit of narrative with some of how the
- 5:35characters enact or react to each other and interact
- 5:39with each other. But outside of that, there's
- 5:42no forward momentum. to this. It's performance
- 5:45after performance after performance with a host
- 5:48or two or three who comes out to announce it.
- 5:51And that is very different than anything I have
- 5:55seen before, which isn't always bad, but it does
- 5:57lend itself to be more like when you go to the
- 6:00theater and you watch Hamilton in theaters, where
- 6:03you're like, yeah, this isn't a movie, but it's
- 6:04like a production that I'm watching. Like an
- 6:06event. An event, exactly. This is more of an
- 6:09event, but it's so dated. In that the names and
- 6:13the characters that they're bringing out where
- 6:14they're like, can you believe that we got Abbott
- 6:18and Costello? You're like, sure. It's just, I
- 6:22know Abbott and Costello, but then they even
- 6:23bring out like, you know, who's the best singer?
- 6:25Who are the best actors? And you don't even know
- 6:28if like, am I supposed to know these names back
- 6:30then? Or these like characters they've introduced
- 6:32in the world of the Hollywood Review? Sure. And
- 6:35I very much get the feeling, especially with
- 6:37Adam Costello being involved. Laurel and Hardy.
- 6:40Oh my gosh, you're so right. I'm so sorry. It's
- 6:42Laurel and Hardy. So Laurel and Hardy, my apologies,
- 6:44are introduced, which introduces the idea to
- 6:47me that everything else is, for lack of a better
- 6:49word, canon. So the characters that you're supposed
- 6:52to meet and the ones they bring in, they're like,
- 6:54can you believe we got this guy or the best singer
- 6:56in the world? You think that they're real, you
- 6:59know, people based on real people, at least.
- 7:01So that was my perspective of it. Not terrible.
- 7:05And I did finish it. There's a segment that I'm
- 7:08very excited to talk to you about, and I won't
- 7:10get ahead of myself. But let's just say if it's
- 7:13not Laurel and Hardy, then it's got to be something
- 7:14pretty fun. And I thought it was. Yeah, I think
- 7:18I know what it is. Yeah, I have a feeling you
- 7:19do. Let's lay out the details before we get into
- 7:23the movie. Hollywood Review, 1929. This is an
- 7:26MGM production, which is kind of cool because
- 7:28Broadway Melody was also MGM. It was. So they're
- 7:31pumping out some musicals. Yep. This was directed
- 7:33by Charles Reznor. And then your, what do they
- 7:37call him? Interlocker? The host, basically. Correct,
- 7:40the host. Yeah. Is Conrad Nagel. And you also
- 7:42have Jack Benny, Norma Shearer, Joan Crawford,
- 7:45Laurel and Hardy, Buster Keaton. The list goes
- 7:49on and on and on and on. It does. And just from
- 7:52the starring credit given to Conrad Nagel, that
- 7:56is very much the name. that that character is
- 7:58introduced as. So there's another scenario of
- 8:01exactly what I was saying, where someone is playing
- 8:02themselves. Yes. Maybe it's a heightened version.
- 8:05I'm not very well aware with Conrad Nagel. To
- 8:08you, did this feel, and with your research, did
- 8:10this turn into be like an accentuated version
- 8:13of himself? Or was it very much just himself
- 8:15on screen? No, I think there are a few characters
- 8:19in this that play personifications of characters
- 8:23they're known for. Interesting. Buster Keaton's
- 8:25a good example. Laurel and Hardy obviously are
- 8:29doing their bit the whole time. But Conrad Nagel
- 8:31is just supposed to be Conrad Nagel. They're
- 8:34all doing performances and things and comedy
- 8:37bits. So there is the scripted nature of it.
- 8:41But this really is a movie MGM put together to
- 8:46showcase all of their stars. So if your star
- 8:49was supposed to be known for comedy bits, Laurel
- 8:52and Hardy, that's how they would show up in this.
- 8:56I think those are the biggest ones, your Laurel
- 8:58and Hardy, your Buster Keaton, and then the mystery
- 9:00one that I think is what you were referring to
- 9:04earlier. We'll talk about that soon. But the
- 9:07concept is cool to me. It's not something that
- 9:11you could do now because this entire concept
- 9:14exists due to the studio system that existed
- 9:19back in the 20s and 30s. These were all contract
- 9:21players for MGM. So it wasn't like they had to
- 9:24send out and see, oh, is Buster Keaton available?
- 9:27Is Jack Benny available? They were all contract
- 9:29players with MGM Studios. Right. So it was pretty
- 9:32much just, hey, call everybody. They work tomorrow.
- 9:36Right. And I guess my concern with it, my frustration
- 9:42with it, is that this is something that existed
- 9:44well before, you know, the talkies, right? This
- 9:47is a... production that would be put on at Broadway
- 9:50or, you know, on stage in general. So the concept
- 9:54of this review is not new. The idea of it being
- 9:58filmed and put into theaters is what made this,
- 10:01you know, well, hey, now it's super accessible
- 10:03and we don't have to like go to a production
- 10:05or to a theater to go see it. We can actually
- 10:07see it at home or at least close to home in the
- 10:10theater closest to us. So that's interesting.
- 10:13To me, it's very different than what I would
- 10:16have expected anything from 1929 being, which
- 10:18isn't a bad thing, right? But it also makes it
- 10:21very difficult for you to be super invested when
- 10:24it is two hours. So it is a lengthy production
- 10:28at the time, too. It doesn't feel like it grabs
- 10:30you the entire time through these musicals and
- 10:33plays that are put on. There's interesting ideas.
- 10:36There's some that work a little bit better for
- 10:37me than others. But also... inherently a variety
- 10:41show in review at that point is going to be a
- 10:44little more reliant on current topics right sure
- 10:49there's going to be a lot of you know names that
- 10:51are dropped or like references that are made
- 10:53that are very timely and going back and watching
- 10:56that that's lost on you a little bit yeah right
- 10:58sure whereas with a narrative there's something
- 11:00you can get into and follow throughout the whole
- 11:02thing so it makes it a little more difficult
- 11:04to grab onto Again, that doesn't make it a bad
- 11:07movie. I think there's just bad experiences you
- 11:09can have with it. And, you know, for the record,
- 11:13I did watch this on YouTube. So correct score
- 11:15and everything. Great. No issues there. So the
- 11:19bad experience is solely just my own mindset
- 11:22going into it. But also, it's technically not
- 11:25a movie. In that sense, where there isn't that
- 11:27narrative, there isn't anything going through
- 11:29it. There's no behind the scenes where Conrad
- 11:31Nagel is kind of like talking with someone else.
- 11:33There's a couple of moments, and forgive me,
- 11:35I'm forgetting his name. There's another individual
- 11:38who talks with Conrad a lot. He's a singer. He
- 11:41does a lot of other things, too. He plays ukulele.
- 11:44Ukulele Ike, I believe, is his name. There was
- 11:46another name that he had where it was like Little
- 11:48something. It's the voice of Jiminy Cricket.
- 11:52It is. Cliff Edwards. Little Cliffy. Yes. Or
- 11:56something cliffy. Yeah. Yeah. So he, first off,
- 11:59the good, insanely expressive face. Yeah. He
- 12:03just absolutely cracked me up with some of the
- 12:06faces he's making. And there's a couple of recurring
- 12:09bits throughout the movie where people will be
- 12:11hyping up someone. And you'll see Cliff in the
- 12:14corner just being like, stop it. Just so excited
- 12:16that they're talking about him. Right. Very humble.
- 12:19And then they'll be talking about someone else.
- 12:20And the faces he makes in that are just the gestures.
- 12:24Dynamite. So good. But that is the reason I bring
- 12:26him up is that there's a little bit of narrative
- 12:28there where you kind of hear the way he talks
- 12:29to Conrad and you're kind of like piecing together
- 12:31relationships, motivation, like a couple things.
- 12:35But outside of that, it really is just, did you
- 12:38like that? Here's another. Yeah. And I just move
- 12:40on for the next two hours. So a couple things
- 12:43break that up. We'll talk about it. But that's
- 12:45the layout of this specifically. So you're correct
- 12:49with who stars in that. Now, specifically, what
- 12:51was this nominated for? So this was just nominated
- 12:53for Outstanding Picture. That's it. Does that
- 12:56surprise you, given the performances, not just
- 12:59individual of the acting, but the songs? No,
- 13:02it doesn't surprise me, because like you said,
- 13:04there's no narrative here. There's not a whole
- 13:06lot of opportunity for a dramatic performance
- 13:11or anything that could compete with any of the
- 13:14other movies that were nominated as far as acting
- 13:15goes. So it's really just the... How good was
- 13:18the overall compilation of everything that was
- 13:21pumped into this movie? Right. Well, and of course,
- 13:24this being the first year with Talkies, there
- 13:27hasn't been an opportunity for there to be a
- 13:29best song, right? Sure. That hasn't existed previously.
- 13:33And what's interesting is it hasn't existed for
- 13:34this, because if it did, even with a Broadway
- 13:37melody existing, you know, historically our take
- 13:40on the Broadway melody song being absolutely
- 13:42mid. I just didn't. I saw the jazz hands were
- 13:46out. I think we can both agree that this would
- 13:48have taken the best song for a very unique reason.
- 13:51Yeah. Interesting reason, I should say. Oh, wow.
- 13:56My mind went blank. Yeah. I thought about the
- 13:58the unmentioned moment that we. Yeah. I don't
- 14:01even know if we're talking about the same. We
- 14:03are. We are for sure. Yeah. This this has a huge
- 14:05finale not to get ahead of us. That kind of changed.
- 14:09I don't know. Film history forever. Like it led
- 14:12to. one of the biggest musicals of all time.
- 14:15And it's definitely the... There's a reason it's
- 14:19the finale. It's the climax of the movie. It's
- 14:21pretty impressive to me. Do you... I agree. No,
- 14:24it is. I think that even the song itself hasn't
- 14:28changed much. We're dancing around this for a
- 14:29specific reason. The production that's put on,
- 14:33there's a very good... foreground background
- 14:36trick that's done where people are climbing up
- 14:40on stairs like to a higher platform that is very
- 14:43impressive right and that's kind of what you're
- 14:45looking for for me if we're going to watch something
- 14:47that is very you know supposed to be visually
- 14:51appealing i'm looking for that visual nature
- 14:53and that performance did give me a lot of that
- 14:56visual nature What we're dancing around here
- 14:58is the fact that this movie, the Hollywood Review
- 15:01of 1929, depending on which Hollywood Review
- 15:03you're looking at, does feature music by Gus
- 15:06Edwards, Arthur Freed, and Nachio Herb Brown.
- 15:09Now, those last two names of Arthur Freed and
- 15:13Herb Brown might be familiar if you're familiar
- 15:15with the movie Singing in the Rain. Right. Or
- 15:18the Broadway melody, actually. Arthur Freed did
- 15:20the music for that as well. Oh, really? Yeah.
- 15:22Interesting. But yeah, Singing in the Rain. Huge,
- 15:24huge musical. And that is the song that was actually
- 15:28introduced in the Hollywood Review of 1929. Which
- 15:31is so cool. Very interesting. To a point where
- 15:33when you hear it, you're like, hold on. Yeah.
- 15:36Wait, I know this one. Right. So I was unaware
- 15:40that this song existed well before the movie
- 15:44Singing in the Rain. Right. So imagine my surprise
- 15:47when the song does exist here. And with the exception
- 15:50of like a few notes and moments, basically the
- 15:53same exact song. Right, yeah. So, very interesting,
- 15:57but the way that it's performed here is great.
- 16:01The problem is that, especially now in hindsight,
- 16:052025 lens, we're comparing it to the movie, and
- 16:09we're comparing it to the Sing in the Rain performance,
- 16:13and there's something that just can't be beaten
- 16:15about the iconic nature. of swinging on the telephone
- 16:18or the light pole with the yellow umbrella. There's
- 16:21just things that you can't beat about it. So
- 16:23when you're watching this, you're like, well,
- 16:25that's admirable. Like, it's still good, right?
- 16:27But it doesn't, like, hold a candle to what it
- 16:30becomes later on. Right. Which is the theme that
- 16:33we've kind of toyed around with this entire show.
- 16:36Correct. Oh, this is a good gangster movie, but
- 16:39doesn't beat The Godfather, you know? Right.
- 16:42It's... hard to kind of set your mind to to not
- 16:45think that way it is tough but also at the same
- 16:48time like this wasn't like two years later gene
- 16:51kelly stars in singing in the rain right right
- 16:53this is like 23 years later something like that
- 16:56yeah uh yeah 23 uh 1952 to 1929 so 23 years later
- 17:01the movie is made based on this now my knowledge
- 17:05on singing in the rain beyond before this movie
- 17:08was the movie right, was the 1952 Gene Kelly
- 17:12movie. So to have anything introduced to that
- 17:16now, my mind is open. Were there any other iterations
- 17:20of Singing in the Rain that existed beyond 1929
- 17:23before 1952? Is that something you know? That
- 17:26is not something I know. I would imagine that
- 17:28it showed up all the time, even if it's just
- 17:31like a brief little ditty. Yeah, but like almost
- 17:34like a nursery rhyme. It exists, but there's
- 17:36no production behind it or score put out after
- 17:40that. It's just in your head. Right. Interesting.
- 17:43That's probably something we'll dive real deep
- 17:46into when we get to Singing in the Rain. Right.
- 17:48But at this time, I have no idea. My understanding
- 17:52is that it's not. From the little research that
- 17:54I was able to do to find this, I've not found
- 17:56any other iterations that have existed. So to
- 17:59me, again, if this was two to three years, sure.
- 18:02They're like, hey, that song blew up. We should
- 18:04do something with that. Yeah. 23 years. That's
- 18:06what's interesting. But, funny enough, as we'll
- 18:09talk about here shortly, not the song that I
- 18:12walked out of this movie referring to the most.
- 18:15Okay, good. We were talking about this song.
- 18:17I had a feeling we were. So, this was released
- 18:20in June 20th, 1929. Pretty, you know, sizable
- 18:25budget at the time. $400 ,000. $426 ,000 to be
- 18:28exact. Box office, this made north of $2 million.
- 18:33So, made bad production pretty well. But again,
- 18:36you know, you gotta think. You gotta imagine.
- 18:38With the talkies now being such a movement, having
- 18:41a review like this, a variety show, that everyone
- 18:44knows of at the time, but now can be played in
- 18:46theaters, that's the Taylor Swift Eros tour of,
- 18:49you know, movies back in 1929. She's back, folks.
- 18:53There's Taylor Swift's around for anyone with
- 18:55eyes. So it's interesting because as a production,
- 19:01you mentioned that this wasn't even the first
- 19:04musical that MGM had put out this year, let alone
- 19:07nominated for Best Picture. Right. So how do
- 19:11you think this held up to Broadway Melody in
- 19:13relation to a musical? In relation to... Well,
- 19:17that's the thing. The feeling that was lacking
- 19:21for you and me of being able to go, oh, wow,
- 19:23it's Jack Benny or oh, look, it's Joan Crawford.
- 19:26People were having that when they were going
- 19:28to the movies. So when when could you imagine
- 19:30now? I mean, it happens. A movie trailer comes
- 19:33out and there is a list of like 40 people. Yeah.
- 19:37And you're just like, oh, my God, what a stacked
- 19:40cast. I'm going to see that. That's exactly what
- 19:42this was. So people must have been flooding to
- 19:45the theaters to go check this out. Right. And
- 19:47which clearly they did. Right. For them, it's
- 19:50probably not that far -fetched, like the concept,
- 19:54because they were going to stage shows, probably,
- 19:57you know, to catch variety acts and things like
- 20:00this. And if not, they're familiar with the characters
- 20:02or actors that are in that review. Right, right.
- 20:06Some of them could have just been like, oh, wow,
- 20:08I love Laurel and Hardy. Yeah. Let me go check
- 20:10this movie out. And then they get a three -minute
- 20:12skit with them, and I don't know, maybe they
- 20:14go home sad, singing in the rain. But... Among
- 20:18other songs. Among other songs. I don't want
- 20:22to go bit by bit through each segment. I want
- 20:26to talk about the highlights. But before we do,
- 20:28to me, movies like this or just movies from this
- 20:31era in general that feel like they were built
- 20:34for the stage, I'm always looking for what ways
- 20:37they utilize the film technology. What separates
- 20:42this from, oh, I could have saw this on stage
- 20:44live or... You really have to see it as a movie.
- 20:48And this movie has a few moments like that where
- 20:51they do some fun things with the camera. I think
- 20:53most notably it's the making miniatures out of
- 20:57people. Yeah. That happens a handful of times.
- 21:00I will say that that was the standout cinematography
- 21:04for me. In which someone is depicted as much
- 21:07smaller and fitting on the hands of Conrad Nagel,
- 21:10correct? Right. Yeah. So in the hands of Conrad
- 21:14and a conversation is had between them, even
- 21:16to where he puts her on the ground and you see
- 21:18her step off of his palm. I thought that was
- 21:21very interesting. And that to me felt like, okay,
- 21:23well, that's, you know, what can we do in a movie
- 21:25that we can't do on stage? That was very cool.
- 21:28Yeah. And there's a few other things early on
- 21:30in the movie. I believe there's some like dissolving
- 21:33effects. when the movie first opens, or some
- 21:37overlapping of film. And there is, or there are,
- 21:41rather, a couple of color scenes that must have
- 21:45been a big deal going to see this movie in theaters.
- 21:48Correct. Those are most of the standouts of,
- 21:52hey, wow, look at the movies, not just the stage
- 21:55performance. Beyond the miniature people, did
- 21:58you feel like there was enough of that to make
- 22:01this feel like, oh, I get why it's a movie? No.
- 22:04So there are only two things that I thought noticed.
- 22:08The color aspect, sure. But again, when you see
- 22:11it in person, you mentioned seeing this in theaters
- 22:14versus seeing this in person. Seeing this in
- 22:16person, obviously the full color element is all
- 22:18there. In theaters, not so much because we weren't
- 22:21there at the time. So that's one. Two, you mentioned
- 22:25the trickery with a person on your hand. Very
- 22:29well done. To a point where... It's kind of amazing
- 22:32that we're in the same year that we talked about
- 22:34in Arizona, where there's moments that you're
- 22:37not underneath the exact position of the microphone,
- 22:39so we just can't make out anything that you're
- 22:42saying. A similar thing happens at Broadway Melody
- 22:44when people are walking out of rooms or into
- 22:46rooms, you really can't hear them at certain
- 22:48points. So it's kind of amazing that in those
- 22:51moments, in the same year where those moments
- 22:54exist, you also have an entire Broadway production
- 22:57where everything is pretty, for the most part,
- 22:59legible. And you have great camera work like
- 23:04that. So it's very cool to see that. Credit where
- 23:06it's due. On the flip side, you talked about
- 23:09the differences of seeing this in a theater versus
- 23:11the actual stage production. I would say the
- 23:13only thing is it saves you a little bit of time,
- 23:15just because obviously there's a little bit of
- 23:16setup that comes into these stages and productions.
- 23:19And that would take some time on stage. In the
- 23:23movie, it's very easy to just kind of black out
- 23:25and then black back in or come back into the
- 23:27movie with... everything's set up and Conrad
- 23:30is introducing, you know, the next bit. So I
- 23:33would say that there's some time -saving elements
- 23:35with the movie itself, just in terms of, you
- 23:37know, allowing the fade in and fade out to the
- 23:41next production. But otherwise, I did not feel
- 23:44that there was anything camera work wise that
- 23:46was like justification of this movie. Right.
- 23:49Now, the Singing in the Rain performance is fun.
- 23:51You know, it's very memorable. Because again,
- 23:54that song is just, you can tell that they realize
- 23:56they landed into something. Because then once
- 23:58that musical aspect happens, you hear the song
- 24:02about two more times. Right. Especially over
- 24:04the credits. So they know what they have. And
- 24:06they're definitely playing that up. But otherwise,
- 24:09no, I wasn't very impressed with like the camera
- 24:11work just because it did very much feel like,
- 24:13OK, now we want the camera over here and now
- 24:15focus on this person. Right. And it didn't feel
- 24:17very artistic vision. It was just more we got
- 24:20to record these performances. Yeah. There's a
- 24:23concept where I almost to me, it feels like your
- 24:26parents showed up at your stage play and they
- 24:28were like, hey, honey, you go on on the left
- 24:31side. I'll cover right. And I don't know. Grandma,
- 24:33good luck from down center. Yeah. And that's
- 24:36it. It's always interesting to me, too. I wonder,
- 24:39you're a big fan of Trip to the Moon. Yeah. Movies
- 24:43from that era specifically, they did so much
- 24:45with like smoke bombs and like apparitions on
- 24:49and off set and just like cuts where people will
- 24:52vanish and all kinds of things like that. Right.
- 24:53Do you think that that by this point, 1929, those
- 24:57tricks were like cliche and just overused? Probably
- 25:02because now with the microphone, it's going to
- 25:05pick up so much. So the cutting of the camera
- 25:09and lined up with the audio. has to be in a way
- 25:12to where if you have any kind of differences
- 25:14there, it's going to be so much more noticeable.
- 25:16Back then, it was just the visual aspect. You
- 25:19didn't have to worry about the microphone, any
- 25:23bleed over in that. Now you kind of do, which
- 25:26makes the moments like pulling the little woman
- 25:30out of your pocket and putting her on the palm
- 25:31of your hand so much more impressive because
- 25:34it does feel like the movie overall is like,
- 25:36look, isn't it amazing that we're even getting
- 25:38like... the audio captured of this, let alone
- 25:41a color sequence. Like, we're good. Like, that's
- 25:44really all we're focusing on, right? And to your
- 25:46point, with the musical of Broadway Melody and
- 25:49with, you know, the dialogue of the other movies,
- 25:52so much more importance was being put on getting
- 25:55the audio captured of these that I don't think
- 25:58they were really thinking through, like, well,
- 26:00what can we do that's great camera work as well?
- 26:01Much like they did in Trip to the Moon. So...
- 26:04That's why to me, it was kind of like I leaned
- 26:06up in my seat a little bit more when that sequence
- 26:08happened where you're like, oh, even in 2025,
- 26:11I'm looking back and being like, how did you
- 26:12do that? Because it looks like not perfect, but
- 26:15like a lot better than I would have expected
- 26:16anything like that to show in 1929. So it did
- 26:20feel a little bit like a variety show in the
- 26:23sense of like, yeah, we have this and we have
- 26:24that. But isn't it like a little interesting
- 26:26that now we're introducing this to you? Yeah.
- 26:28So I liked that aspect. And I was like, oh, cool.
- 26:30There's gonna be a few more of that. It really
- 26:32is the only of its kind. So it does hit at just
- 26:35about the midway mark, just a little bit. So
- 26:37it does pick you back up into it. But then I
- 26:40was kind of like, okay, cool. We're just outside
- 26:42of one song and singing in the rain, just more
- 26:45performances. Sure. Yeah. That's fair. That's
- 26:48fair. But still, I mean, not to take any discredit
- 26:51away from like what they did on this or even
- 26:52that sequence with like the hand, the woman in
- 26:55the palm, very well done. And very interesting.
- 26:58I'm sure that was, you know, mind blowing at
- 27:00the time to be able to do something like that.
- 27:02But it's also the only time in the production
- 27:06that it kind of like asks you to subvert reality,
- 27:10right? Otherwise, it's a very like, you know,
- 27:12hey, this is, I'm Conrad Nagel. I actually am
- 27:14Conrad Nagel. And I'm going to introduce this
- 27:16next act, which is an actual act. Like, it does
- 27:19feel very based in reality. That's the only fantastical
- 27:22moment. Yeah. And that's always the bummer. In
- 27:25any of these movies, when you're like, hey, you're
- 27:27a movie, like, do movie things. Yeah, exactly.
- 27:31That's where my frustration was, where it's like,
- 27:32you could do so many more things like this. Yeah.
- 27:35We don't have to just be like the front page
- 27:37news of like, hey, you know this person, you
- 27:39know that person. Sure. Which has its place.
- 27:41But it's not necessarily, it's, I would be reacting
- 27:44the same way if the Heiress Tour was nominated
- 27:45for Best Picture. Right? Where it's like, you're
- 27:47not really a movie, though. Right, right. That's
- 27:50fair. So, going down the line of all the different
- 27:53acts, I mean. When it first starts, you've got
- 27:56your introduction by Conrad Nagel, and Charles
- 27:58King shows up, Jack Benny, Cliff Edwards. You
- 28:00remember Charles King from the Broadway melody,
- 28:02of course. The first memorable moment, I would
- 28:05say, is a song by Joan Crawford. She does Got
- 28:09a Feeling for You. Do you remember that? I say
- 28:12it's memorable. Do you remember it? No, off the
- 28:14top of my head. Yeah. A lot of the opening bits
- 28:17are just songs sang by celebrity. Mm -hmm. Well,
- 28:23by the way. Right. Yeah, it's great. And I will
- 28:26say, I think you can understand the audio a lot
- 28:28better than you could in Broadway melody. But
- 28:30it's still, it takes a little while before you
- 28:33get to something that is more interesting than
- 28:36just a song and dance. 100%. And another reason,
- 28:40you know, go back and listen to our Patriot episode
- 28:43where we talked about lost media. Another reason
- 28:45that it's very important to have lost media in
- 28:48as many formats as you can is thank God for closed
- 28:50captionings. Right? Sure. So that's how I was
- 28:53able to pick up a lot of this. I mean, you know,
- 28:56credit to closed captioning abilities now, not
- 29:00100 % on some of these movies, just because how
- 29:02can you make out some of the, you know, things
- 29:04that are being said on the microphone when they're,
- 29:06like, not really underneath it. But otherwise,
- 29:08there's just moments that you're not going to
- 29:10be able to pick it up. Because this is the first
- 29:11year where this technology existed. So there
- 29:14are going to be some, like, you know, hiccups
- 29:16here and there. Thank God for closed captioning
- 29:18to kind of pick it up and let us know. Something
- 29:21was said. We watched a movie last week together
- 29:23in person, and someone said something. I don't
- 29:26know if you caught it. They said, I can't hear
- 29:29without my captions. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, and I
- 29:31felt that so much. I was like, yeah, I need my
- 29:33captions. It is crazy how, as I've gotten older,
- 29:37I'm like, turn on the read sound, please. It's
- 29:42moments like if I put on captions on Fast Five,
- 29:44where I'm like, okay, well, I don't really need
- 29:46that. But for narrative purposes, and especially
- 29:49research doing this, I want to make sure I'm
- 29:51hearing everything, so I need my words in front
- 29:53of me. Yes. It's like a read -along. Yeah, exactly.
- 29:56I love those books. Yeah, they're books. Can
- 29:59you imagine doing a sing -along, but it's a read
- 30:01-along, so they have the closed captioning on
- 30:03the theaters, and everyone's just reciting the
- 30:05movie back at you? You know what they should
- 30:06do at theaters? Movies with captions, and then
- 30:09make it popcorn reading. So everyone in the crowd
- 30:12has to read it. All right, E1, it's your turn.
- 30:14Yeah. And they're just like, uh. That sounds
- 30:16miserable. I am your mother. Especially with
- 30:22how often I'm in the movie theaters and how little
- 30:27my theaters are packed out. I just imagine being
- 30:29like, well, I'm just not going to hear five minutes
- 30:32of this movie because the entire row H isn't
- 30:34filled. Yeah. But yeah, true. That's an interesting
- 30:37concept, though. Please no one do that. Yeah,
- 30:39don't do it. It's interesting, but awful. So
- 30:41for me, the first bit or sketch, I guess, that
- 30:47I really enjoyed, and this is because I'm such
- 30:50a huge fan of her. I never knew I could do a
- 30:53thing like that, sung by Bessie Love. True. I
- 30:57just think she's adorable. I love her. And there's
- 31:01a bit where all of the... male dancers like grab
- 31:05her by the waist and cartwheel her yes repeatedly
- 31:08this poor woman this was the segment where there's
- 31:12three individuals right this is just her okay
- 31:16the one where there's three is towards the end
- 31:18correct and that's the story i'm something i'm
- 31:21bessie yeah that's so cute wait no so i'm getting
- 31:25these confused there's a segment i think you're
- 31:27correct it is still towards the end where there's
- 31:29a story being told about three individuals who
- 31:31are interested in one person And they then take
- 31:34turns of like dancing with her and take like,
- 31:37okay, so it's not the same with, it might be
- 31:39Bessie, but it's not this number. I don't think
- 31:41it's this number. Okay, copy. Yeah. But honestly,
- 31:44all I remember from this one is them spinning
- 31:47her around like she's a pinwheel over and over.
- 31:49And I'm just like, Bessie, my girl, are you okay?
- 31:52What they did to my child. She just tore up.
- 31:55That's the first skit that I really enjoyed.
- 31:59And it's because. My girl, Bessie. What was the
- 32:02first moment that you were like, okay, this is
- 32:04unique. This is interesting. I'm kind of cool
- 32:07with this. Or was it just the end? It really
- 32:11was about halfway through, and we can get into
- 32:13it here if you want. But one thing that did stick
- 32:15out to me was the way that Cliff was kind of
- 32:19introduced. It felt kind of like, for the first
- 32:23couple numbers, we just have this stage production
- 32:25of these stairs built in. There's a moment where
- 32:28there's a production stage of just stairs, right,
- 32:32from the very beginning. And then the majority
- 32:34of the B crew is kind of sitting on the stairs
- 32:36and reacting to everyone, like, singing songs.
- 32:39And I kind of liked the aspect of, like, you
- 32:41know, well, let's do kind of a roster check of
- 32:45who we have to perform here and, like, little
- 32:47performances. And I liked Little Cliffy the most.
- 32:51Yes, you're right. He's introduced later on as
- 32:53Ukulele Ike. But he actually calls himself Little
- 32:56Cliffy. And for some reasons, that stuck out
- 32:58to me the most. And I was just like, cool, that's
- 33:00just who you are to me now. So I liked whenever
- 33:02he was on screen. To your point, you brought
- 33:04up, you know, there's like a moment later on
- 33:06towards the end of, you know, I'm whoever, I'm
- 33:09whoever, I'm whoever. It's a three -piece act.
- 33:11He's part of that, too. So he is throughout the
- 33:14movie. But whenever he's on screen, you're just
- 33:17kind of like... What's the Simpsons bit with
- 33:19Poochie? Whenever Poochie's not on screen, someone
- 33:21should be asking, where's Poochie at all times?
- 33:23That was me with Little Cliffy. I was like, where's
- 33:28Little Cliffy, though? He's great. Hey, Joan,
- 33:30you're doing great. Where's Little Cliffy? Yeah,
- 33:32bring him back. I love it, too, when he does
- 33:34the falsetto singing. Yes. He's a highlight.
- 33:38Well, that's the thing is that he's very funny
- 33:40and he has like, this is exactly who you're looking
- 33:42for in 1929, right? Like, are you very funny?
- 33:45Are you very theatrical in your faces? Like,
- 33:48can you, could you have done very well prior
- 33:51to 1929, but also could you really thrive in
- 33:541929 and beyond? And Cliff was very much that
- 33:58kind of person. So Cliff Edwards, MVP for this
- 34:01for me, just because he did kind of stand out
- 34:03as like, hey, I could do a lot of face acting,
- 34:06but also. Very great at singing. Great voice.
- 34:11I don't know how to put that. Your acting is
- 34:13great even with your voice and not just your
- 34:15facial reactions. So audibly, you're great. Yeah,
- 34:18that was really it for me. Now, there is a song
- 34:21that is a production, rather, that is put on
- 34:24a little later that I was just absolutely enamored
- 34:28with. And you and I have kind of been talking
- 34:30about this. Yes. Off and on. And we danced around
- 34:34it, so to speak. Do you want to talk about that
- 34:36now? Let me throw out the Laurel. It does fall
- 34:39into act two. Right. So real quick, the Laurel
- 34:43and Hardy act. I just want to touch on that real
- 34:45quickly. Yeah. That's a big deal. Those guys
- 34:48were huge. This was their first time in a sound
- 34:51production. So this was like their opportunity
- 34:54to break into the new Hollywood, if you will.
- 34:57Right. So they do a magic act. And if you're
- 34:59unfamiliar with them, you mentioned Abbott and
- 35:01Costello earlier. Mistakenly, yes. Sure, but
- 35:04very much that type of act. Even, what are the
- 35:08two magicians now? Penn and Teller. Yes, Penn
- 35:10and Teller. They're like the early version of
- 35:13that, even the amount of comedy they do. That's
- 35:15correct. So I was super excited the first time
- 35:18I watched this movie to see like, oh, this is
- 35:21my first experience with Laurel and Hardy. The
- 35:23comedy bit is not great, if I'm being honest.
- 35:27It's not. Not their best work. No, and I've since
- 35:30gone back and watched An early talkie with Laurel
- 35:34and Hardy. And my biggest problem with them is
- 35:36that they sell a joke and then they continue
- 35:40to oversell that joke. Yes. I think they linger
- 35:43too long. One call out though from this act and
- 35:47then we can move on to act two. They do a banana
- 35:49peel bit. And I think this is one of the earliest
- 35:53banana peel bits of all time. Correct me if I'm
- 35:56wrong, but I think this like exploded banana
- 35:59sales after this. It was really influential.
- 36:04Okay. Well, I appreciate you, Hollywood Review,
- 36:08because otherwise without you, we wouldn't have
- 36:10Mario Kart. Yeah. So thanks for that, I suppose.
- 36:13Isn't that crazy? That's nuts. You joke, but
- 36:16that's true. Yeah, that is interesting. Wow.
- 36:19I do wonder. I mean, here's the thing. I haven't
- 36:21done my research on when was banana peel jokes.
- 36:24originally introduced sure and when were they
- 36:26funny answer is always for the last part but
- 36:29for the first part i mean laurel and hardy have
- 36:31been doing this well before the movie right not
- 36:33not the banana peel but like comedy and magic
- 36:35in general yeah so this made a bit of sense to
- 36:39me uh that they would be involved and i was like
- 36:41oh cool very cool to see still uh however i share
- 36:45your sentiment where i was kind of like oh i
- 36:47mean You guys are like very big names, even to
- 36:49now, right? You know, unfortunately, I've never
- 36:52heard of Conrad Nake. Unfortunately, I never
- 36:53heard of Cliff Edwards before this. So seeing
- 36:57these two, I kind of expected a little bit more.
- 36:59And it was surprising to me that there are moments
- 37:01in this movie that kind of make you like, you
- 37:02know, lean forward in your seat a little bit.
- 37:05This wasn't one of them. No. In terms of recognition,
- 37:08it was. But in terms of the actual performance
- 37:11they put on, it was fine. Yeah, yeah. It's very,
- 37:15very like base. comedy yeah in fact to where
- 37:19i believe when this is introduced this uh act
- 37:23is actually introduced as magic act yep they
- 37:26get real uh real creative with it yeah one other
- 37:29once we move into act two there's one other number
- 37:33there's an intermission that falls in between
- 37:34but i mean it's not even super worth mentioning
- 37:37because it is just like three songs that are
- 37:38played by the orchestra so just mostly as you
- 37:42know at least they recognized you know Brutalist
- 37:44in 2024. We need an intermission. Yeah. In 1929,
- 37:49they're like, this is two hours. Let's put an
- 37:50intermission in. Yeah. And thank goodness, right?
- 37:53Yeah. I went and I got my snack. I never left
- 37:55my seat. I didn't either, but I wanted them to
- 37:58think that I did. Yeah. I listened. I appreciated
- 38:01it though. It was a nice little break to be like,
- 38:02all right, cool. Let me stretch. Yeah. Act two,
- 38:04before we get into that big number, you do have
- 38:07a dance by Buster Keaton. How did you feel about
- 38:10that? Good. I mean, you know. Real sensual. Pretty
- 38:13sensual. The dance of the sea is what you're
- 38:16referring to. That's right. So I liked the idea
- 38:19that this tried to capture the underwater nature.
- 38:21It wasn't super effective. No. So it didn't make
- 38:25me do the howdy do that of it all. Sure. So good.
- 38:29Yeah. Moved well. Yeah. I mean, that's the highlight
- 38:33is, hey, look at this man, like. belly dancing,
- 38:37basically. Yeah, basically. That's it. It's done
- 38:40for laughs. It's Buster Keaton. When is it not?
- 38:42But it was a fun time. I mean, it's Buster. The
- 38:45thing is, is that like, it's important to note
- 38:48that what we're about to talk about directly
- 38:50follows this dance that Buster Keaton has done.
- 38:53Yes. So if you're like, wow, that was probably
- 38:55the highlight of the moment for me, then the
- 38:57next thing happens and you forget about the previous.
- 38:59Right. So not a ton of memory of Buster Keaton's
- 39:02dance there, but was kind of interesting to be
- 39:04like, let's Buster Keaton. Yeah, I know him.
- 39:07But again, after the Laurel and Hardy of it all,
- 39:09you're kind of now primed to be like, oh, look,
- 39:12that person. But nothing really happens. Yeah.
- 39:15So unfortunately, he kind of caught astray from
- 39:18the Laurel and Hardy of it all. Buster did. Poor
- 39:20Buster. I know. Okay, this is the moment that
- 39:23we both enjoyed the most, I think. I have a feeling
- 39:27that if you had told me that this existed before
- 39:31I watched this, I would have been like... Okay,
- 39:34so he wants to make sure I'm watching these movies.
- 39:36Because now he's going to expect me to come back
- 39:38and be like, hey, man, that would never happen
- 39:40because that's such a weird thing that you said.
- 39:42Yeah. So what were you doing? I just lied. I
- 39:44wanted you to watch it. This is one of the funniest
- 39:47things I think I've ever seen, just in terms
- 39:49of expectations. Yeah. What the movie has given
- 39:52you. Again, we're in Act 2, second performance
- 39:55of Act 2. So we're about an hour and some change
- 39:58into this production. Sure. Right? And they introduced
- 40:01kind of like almost in a very serious tone to
- 40:05try and scare you. Yeah. To be like, what scares
- 40:08you? And people are like, I just, I'm afraid
- 40:11of what Lon Chaney could do if he got my hands
- 40:12on me. And they proceed to put on a production.
- 40:15And the title is As Says. I'm not making this
- 40:19up. The title, just for reference, this movie
- 40:23has consisted of songs such as For I'm the Queen
- 40:26or You Were Meant for Me. Low down rhythm. Like
- 40:30you mentioned previously, the Buster Keaton was
- 40:33the dance of the sea. Yeah. This number is called
- 40:36Lon Chaney's Gonna Get You If You Don't Watch
- 40:39Out. It's so cool. I cannot believe that this
- 40:42is real. It's so cool. And not only is this an
- 40:45entire production theorizing about what Lon Chaney's
- 40:49gonna do if he gets his hands on you, they include
- 40:52Lon Chaney. To an extent, they include Lon Chaney.
- 40:56That's correct. Yeah. So this is super exciting.
- 41:00you just hosted your horror gore lore movie marathon
- 41:03more gore lore correct or lore and we're both
- 41:07big horror fans we are there's always the discussion
- 41:10of there's not enough horror recognized at the
- 41:12academy awards and blah blah totally agree with
- 41:15that um this is the first little taste of like
- 41:19straight horror that has dazzled the academy
- 41:23Correct. And it wasn't just like, you know, they
- 41:25put a black curtain behind them and kind of do
- 41:28this like little funny number. There's a production
- 41:30element behind it. Yes. Where there's like smoking,
- 41:32like smoke coming through doors and like bedrooms
- 41:34and supposed to be like a very vulnerable position
- 41:37that's then compromised by these monsters. And
- 41:40we should clarify, for anyone who's unaware,
- 41:42Lon Chaney is the actor who performed in multiple,
- 41:45multiple films, but is mostly known as the Wolfman
- 41:49and other universal monsters. His son was the
- 41:51Wolfman. Lon Chaney Jr. Oh, really? Yeah. Lon
- 41:55Chaney himself at this point was probably best
- 41:57known. You're absolutely right. Hunchback of
- 41:58Notre Dame. Yes. I heard Lon Chaney and just
- 42:01immediately went for it. But yeah, he's the man
- 42:03of, what is it, a thousand faces? Correct. So
- 42:06he is what horror movies are up to this point.
- 42:10Correct. So it's so cool that they're recognizing
- 42:13him for that and bringing him into this production
- 42:16and saying, listen, this guy's super scary. Let's
- 42:20celebrate him. I'm trying to think of the most
- 42:24one -to -one comparison we can make if the Hollywood
- 42:27review of 2025 existed, and we had the Lon Chaney's
- 42:31gonna get you if you don't watch out, what that
- 42:35would be in 2025. I guess it would have to be
- 42:38Jordan Peele, right? Because not enough people
- 42:40know Ari Aster, so it's not like Ari Aster's
- 42:42gonna get you if you don't watch out. Well, it's
- 42:45interesting that you go towards a director. Well,
- 42:47because otherwise, I mean, no one's gonna know...
- 42:51David Thornton, who plays Art from Terrifier.
- 42:54So I'm trying to think of who plays a specific
- 42:57character and how everyone would know. I could
- 42:59say Brad Dourif is going to get you if you don't
- 43:01watch out. But no one's going to know that's
- 43:03the voice of Chucky. Not everyone, rather. See,
- 43:05interestingly enough, my brain goes either to
- 43:09Bill Skarsgård, currently, or Doug Jones. Okay,
- 43:14you know what? In terms of accuracy... Doug Jones
- 43:17is going to get you if you don't watch out, is
- 43:19the 2025 version of this, because Doug Jones
- 43:22has done so much. But unfortunately, I think
- 43:25Doug Jones doesn't get his flowers as much as
- 43:28he should. By the way, incredible performance
- 43:30in what we do in the Shadows TV series. Oh, I
- 43:33haven't seen that yet. You should. He reprises
- 43:36his character of that throughout the series.
- 43:39We'll get into it. But great show, great performance.
- 43:42But otherwise, you're absolutely right. I mean,
- 43:43Guillermo del Toro is a boy. brought him in for
- 43:46multiple productions. He was the fish man in
- 43:49Shape of Water. Sure, yeah. He was the faun,
- 43:52and I believe he was also the... The pale man.
- 43:55The pale man as well, correct. So he was multiple
- 43:58characters. I mean, the list doesn't end there,
- 44:00but multiple Guillermo del Toro productions.
- 44:02You can... Oh, he was... Billy in Hocus Pocus.
- 44:06Yep. He goes way back. Way back. So a lot of
- 44:09work in horror, specifically. Yes. So great call.
- 44:12It's going to be Doug Jones. Unfortunately, I
- 44:14think where Lon Chaney and Lon Chaney Jr., very
- 44:16recognizable names, Doug Jones isn't going to
- 44:19stand out as much to people, which is unfortunate.
- 44:21He should. Right. Yeah. No, I agree. But just
- 44:23sheer numbers alone, you're right. Oh, yeah.
- 44:25He's carrying a big weight on his back. Yeah.
- 44:28I think you're in a band. You should write. I
- 44:31am. Doug Jones. It's going to get you. Doug Jones
- 44:34is going to get you. I feel like a good way for
- 44:36me to get checked into a facility is if I come
- 44:39to my bandmates and I'm like, hey, guys, I wrote
- 44:41a number called Doug Jones is going to get you
- 44:43if you don't watch out. I think there's a very
- 44:45good chance that there's a wellness check done
- 44:47on my household. Worth it. You know what? Chase
- 44:50would understand. And he'd be like, oh, Doug
- 44:52Jones, sure, yeah, but what are you going for
- 44:54here? The other three would be like, is he okay?
- 44:57Like, what's going on? I'm just saying, when
- 45:00a gamble comes to you and he's like, Hey, I need
- 45:03a song for my boy. Then he'll be getting a wellness
- 45:08check. I'll tell you this. If the Oscars want
- 45:10to bring me on when Guillermo... And it sucks
- 45:13to do this because Doug Jones isn't a part of...
- 45:15I would have loved to have seen Doug Jones' version
- 45:17of Frankenstein, but it was Jacob Elordi in the
- 45:20new Guillermo del Toro movie. If the Oscars come
- 45:24to me and they're like, hey, obviously, Frankenstein
- 45:26is nominated for Best Picture. Let's hope. We
- 45:29want to do a number for Guillermo. And they want
- 45:31me to write, Doug Jones is going to get you if
- 45:33you don't watch out. Gladly. Yeah. $1 free. I
- 45:37don't care. I'm doing it. I will write that number.
- 45:40I would love to see that. Because think about
- 45:41it. It'd be so great to see the Pale Man and
- 45:43the Fawn come out. Yeah. And Billy. A number
- 45:47of characters he's played. The Fish Man. See
- 45:49them come out and terrify people would be fantastic.
- 45:51So good. So good. And that brings us back to
- 45:54the actual performance in this movie. Yes. Essentially
- 45:58what it is, is... All of these monster characters
- 46:01with their masks and their creepy faces and things
- 46:04come out and terrorize this, I don't know if
- 46:08it's like an orphanage kind of setup. It may
- 46:12not initially intend to be that, but it does
- 46:14very much look like that because they're trying
- 46:16to fit as many beds as they can on the stage.
- 46:18Yes. It's like an all -girls school or something.
- 46:20A bunch of girls sleeping in bed while this guy
- 46:22sings about, listen, you gotta go to sleep. Because
- 46:27Lon Chaney's out there, and he's going to get
- 46:30you. What I love about this is it's not Dr. Jekyll
- 46:34and Mr. Hyde are going to get you. And it's not,
- 46:36you know, Hunchback of Notre Dame is going to
- 46:38come and get you. Yeah. It's that Lon Chaney
- 46:40the man is going to come and get you if you don't
- 46:43watch that one. He's going to show up. Who knows
- 46:45what he's going to be wearing, but he's going
- 46:47to get you. And it's really a cool dance. It
- 46:50is. I mean, it's such a cool tribute to his character
- 46:53and horror in general. There's like trap doors
- 46:56and smoke coming up from under the stage as he...
- 47:01kidnaps these girls and takes them away. Just
- 47:04such a cool little moment in history for horror.
- 47:07At such an early time in cinema history. I just,
- 47:11I cannot explain to you, if you're listening
- 47:14to this podcast, I assume you have some film
- 47:16knowledge. So you are probably aware of the Leo
- 47:19meme from Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. Almost
- 47:24quoted the podcast here. And him pointing at
- 47:28the screen and leaning forward. And I just need
- 47:30you to know the reaction that I had going into
- 47:33Act Two and hearing the Pearl Ballet. And then
- 47:35the dance of the sea. And just being like, okay,
- 47:37we're doing more of the same. Got it. Yeah. And
- 47:39then this song comes on, just being like, what?
- 47:41Like, was almost like, oh, I'm asleep right now,
- 47:44and I'm dreaming this, like, weird sequence.
- 47:47So happy. It's so cool, man. So happy that this
- 47:50exists, and so weird. And just an immediate bummer
- 47:53that, like, everything that follows was not a
- 47:55direct sequel of Lon Chaney's Gonna Get You If
- 47:58You Don't Watch Out. Still some cool stuff. Right?
- 48:01I think Act 2, let's just go ahead and get this
- 48:04controversial take out of the way. I think Act
- 48:062 absolutely blows Act 1 out of the water. Totally.
- 48:09Totally does. There's way more happening in Act
- 48:112 to where you're more interested there. But
- 48:13again, we're an hour and 10 minutes in. to this
- 48:15production yeah so it's a big ask for like you
- 48:18know 2025 audiences to go back and watch this
- 48:21knowing that there's more to come i think they
- 48:23could have spread this out a little bit better
- 48:25with like the numbers yeah because it's not every
- 48:27single one in act two is phenomenal it's just
- 48:30there are way better performances and ideas in
- 48:34two than in one totally as we move on to those
- 48:37one last thing i want to bring you up about long
- 48:39chain he's going to get you if you don't watch
- 48:40out We can talk about that exclusively if you
- 48:42want. I don't mind. The big bummer is that you
- 48:44have all of this massive tribute and this. It's
- 48:49so cool. It really is. That song needs to come
- 48:51back for Halloween every year, I feel. I played
- 48:53it on Friday. Oh, that's awesome. No, I mean,
- 48:56absolutely. I think my dad was like, what is
- 48:58this? It's awesome. No one caught on to it. The
- 49:01big bummer that you find out about it, though,
- 49:03is that Lon Chaney is one of like three MGM stars
- 49:06that didn't actually show up for this. Yeah.
- 49:09He was busy. So he's not even on stage for it.
- 49:12It's just a tribute to the guy. And then when
- 49:15you really look at the monsters on set, they're
- 49:18kind of like the Lon Chaney costumes you would
- 49:21buy at Walmart. Yeah. It's not the stage production
- 49:25of them. Yeah. Which makes sense because Lon
- 49:27Chaney never revealed his secrets, so you're
- 49:29not going to get a Lon Chaney accurate costume.
- 49:32Right. But that bummer aside, this is the highlight
- 49:35of the entire movie for me personally. Easily.
- 49:40I mean, in a movie that features the very first
- 49:42recording of Singing in the Rain, kind of unreal
- 49:45that anything is going to... If anything, I kind
- 49:47of think we're in the wrong timeline. I love
- 49:50Gene Kelly's Singing in the Rain so much. It's
- 49:52one of my favorite films of all time. But if
- 49:54this introduces the idea that there is an alternate
- 49:56reality where instead in 1952, we got Gene Kelly's
- 50:00Lon Chaney's Gonna Get You If You Don't Watch
- 50:02Out. I kind of want to live in that timeline.
- 50:04That'd be so cool. I would love to do that. In
- 50:07fact, I think this is a really good time for
- 50:09us to introduce the idea that now that it is
- 50:11public domain, that we are actually making the
- 50:13Hollywood Review of 2025. Yes. Or better yet,
- 50:17maybe we call it the Hollywood Review of 1929
- 50:19parentheses 2025 to differentiate the two. Yeah,
- 50:22not confusing. Not confusing. And then we just
- 50:25exclusively do two hours of launching. He's going
- 50:27to get you if you don't watch it. Yeah. It opens
- 50:29up with Buster Keaton dancing a little bit. And
- 50:33then Lon Chaney gets him. Immediately. Oh, yes.
- 50:35You know why? Why? Because he didn't watch out.
- 50:37Man, I love this. This is so good. So moving
- 50:41on with the rest of the show. Unfortunately moving
- 50:43on. Yeah, that's true. So immediately follows
- 50:46with the adagio. Adagio. Adagio. Thank you so
- 50:50much. The adagio dance. Following that, because
- 50:54it really just didn't super impress me much,
- 50:57the next thing that really stood out to me was
- 50:59Romeo and Juliet. Yes. Romeo and Juliet's a lot
- 51:02of fun. Very interesting. The concept of this
- 51:04is that a performance is being done of Romeo
- 51:06and Juliet, and the director then informs the
- 51:09cast, well, unfortunately, the producers want
- 51:13to go in a different direction. The studio actually
- 51:15wants to make it much more relevant. So we're
- 51:18going to keep the name, but we're going to change...
- 51:20No, I'm sorry. We're going to keep the... The
- 51:24character names. Yes. Keep the character names,
- 51:26but the dialogue should be more hip and now.
- 51:28Yeah. In 1929. This feels like an SNL skit. It
- 51:32does. And it's not the best skit. or sketch of
- 51:36this in this movie, but it is kind of refreshing
- 51:39to be like, Oh, okay. Like I see what you're
- 51:42doing here and it's funny and you're poking fun
- 51:43at yourselves and studios. Like it makes more
- 51:46sense. There's a little more commentary in this
- 51:48back half of this movie. Yeah. Quote unquote,
- 51:51then there is in the first half. So. I appreciated
- 51:55that. I don't think it's like, you know, I would
- 51:56tell people, hey, you should watch it just for
- 51:57this. But it was very fun. Yeah. And just to
- 52:01throw this out, that's John Gilbert playing Romeo,
- 52:03Norma Shearer playing Juliet. Norma Shearer shows
- 52:05up next year in a couple, well, in one movie
- 52:08that we're talking about. She's fantastic. So
- 52:11look forward to her. And then playing the director
- 52:13is Lionel Barrymore. Correct. Who also is a big
- 52:16director we'll talk about a lot in the future.
- 52:18And then this is the first moment where there
- 52:20is color on screen. Correct. Which is interesting
- 52:24because it really doesn't need it. No, it doesn't.
- 52:26But it does add that little bit of like, oh,
- 52:28okay, my eyes are now paying attention because,
- 52:30you know, there's color. Would have much preferred
- 52:33it for Lon Chaney's Gonna Get You If You Don't
- 52:35Watch Out. Yeah, but that black and white kind
- 52:38of adds to it. Yeah, I mean, it does add to it.
- 52:39That's true. It's just like, the problem is that
- 52:42if I was a producer in 1929, that I would just
- 52:45be like, yeah, yeah, this is all good. What if
- 52:47the big final number is the Lon Chaney number?
- 52:51I wish he would have been there. But maybe that
- 52:53would ruin a little bit. Maybe it adds to Lon
- 52:56Chaney lore that he's just like, I'm not dancing.
- 52:59I'm Lon Chaney. What kind of kills me, though,
- 53:02is that having his name mentioned so many times,
- 53:06because they do say quite often, Lon Chaney's
- 53:09going to get you if you don't watch out, is that
- 53:11Lon Chaney just isn't there. So it's not like
- 53:15when you hear his name mentioned that many times
- 53:17and suggesting that he's going to kill you. right
- 53:20so so to speak or at least kidnap you at the
- 53:22very least it's kind of insane that they didn't
- 53:24get his like rights or like him there yeah i
- 53:28i really think that adds to the lore though because
- 53:30you're just like oh which one's lon chaney and
- 53:32he's just at home like i don't know if it adds
- 53:35to the lore but it definitely adds to how funny
- 53:37it is sure in that like it's just oh cool so
- 53:40you guys got his approval what he belongs to
- 53:44us MGM is like, just make a song where he just
- 53:49kidnaps people. I don't know. Whatever. It's
- 53:51just so unheard of and absolutely funny. And
- 53:54I have a feeling it's not the last time we'll
- 53:55mention it. A, this episode. B, for the entirety
- 53:58of this run. For the rest of my life. So immediately
- 54:01following Romeo and Juliet is where you start
- 54:03kind of like hitting your like dingers territory,
- 54:05right? Like it's just like nothing but like hits.
- 54:08Yes. And not the best ones, but like still just
- 54:10like very memorable. Singing in the Rain. Yeah,
- 54:13you've got the introduction of that. The introduction
- 54:15of Singing in the Rain. And it's interesting
- 54:17because it is introduced by Cliff Edwards, and
- 54:19it's sang by sisters, specifically the Brock's
- 54:23sisters. Right. Right? So this is where it got
- 54:26confusing to me, where I was like, oh, okay.
- 54:28Like, this isn't like the headliner. Like, it's
- 54:30just in there. So this must have been like, they
- 54:32didn't know what they had. It's very clear that
- 54:34they did, because it comes back around. Sure.
- 54:36We'll get to that. But this is a very, like,
- 54:38this is, again. Leo DiCaprio pointing at the
- 54:42screen, snapping, is just me being like, is that
- 54:45Singing in the Rain? What's going on right now?
- 54:48So it is just very small, like, hey, while things
- 54:51change in the background, let's just get these
- 54:52three sisters to sing this song that we have.
- 54:55Feels very minimal. Immediately after that, we
- 54:58referenced previously that there is a segment
- 55:01where there are three individuals who say, I'm
- 55:04this, I'm this, I'm that. So this is going to
- 55:06be Charlie, Gus, and Ike, right? I'm Charlie,
- 55:08I'm Gus, I'm Ike. And it's cute. I think I like
- 55:12the set more than I like the idea of them having
- 55:15specific, almost like changing rooms that they
- 55:19step in and out of. Different costumes. They
- 55:22have their little songs saying, I'm Charlie,
- 55:24I'm Gus, I'm Mike. When I say memorable, I don't
- 55:27necessarily mean that in a good way. I remember
- 55:30that little ditty of that song. I don't remember
- 55:32anything else. It's kind of an earworm. A little
- 55:35bit of an earworm, but the song itself was not
- 55:38catchy beyond that. It's just that one little
- 55:40part of it. And there's just really not much
- 55:43to it. There's a second part where we bring your
- 55:47girl Bessie back. Yes. Right? You want to speak
- 55:49on that? Yeah. So the three gentlemen are Charles
- 55:51King, who we know from Broadway Melody, Gus Edwards,
- 55:54and then Cliff Edwards. Wow, I didn't realize
- 55:57I had the same last name. Yeah. And then you
- 55:59do the women. Marie Dressler, Polly Moran, and
- 56:02my girl Bessie Love. I'm Mary. I'm Polly. I'm
- 56:05Bessie. Yeah. Bessie's so cute. She is. Anyway,
- 56:09I linger on that. I like this half much more
- 56:11than the three gents. And probably because of
- 56:14Bessie or whatever. It's probably Bessie. Yeah.
- 56:16Which is funny because I think your Bessie is
- 56:18my Cliff. Oh, okay. Yeah. So I'm like, oh, I
- 56:21like the guy one better because it's Cliff. But
- 56:23that's it. I do like... cliff edwards and i do
- 56:26like bessie i mean jiminy crickets i thought
- 56:28that would be appropriate to not say anything
- 56:29to kind of put crickets in there but yeah sure
- 56:31i'll leave that in and you can post put some
- 56:33crickets yeah for sure so i'm i'm with you though
- 56:36this isn't super memorable it's it's catchy and
- 56:39uh if not for bessie love for me personally it
- 56:43probably wouldn't stick around sure but i'd probably
- 56:46go back and watch this just just for that yeah
- 56:49this is what's weird is that like i i mentioned
- 56:51that singing in the rain charlie gus and ike
- 56:53and uh Marie, Polly, and Bess. I guess she called
- 56:58herself Bess, which is interesting. Anyways,
- 57:00those are memorable. They kind of are, but not
- 57:04in, like... I don't know. We're definitely feeling
- 57:06the aftermath of, like, Lon Chaney's Gonna Get
- 57:08You If You Don't Watch Out and Romeo and Juliet,
- 57:10where we're kind of, like, winding down a little
- 57:12bit. Like, those are still memorable, and, like,
- 57:14I remember they happened, but they're not supremely
- 57:17great on their own. Signal of the Rain is, of
- 57:19course, fantastic, but the way it's introduced
- 57:21is just kind of like... almost like Broadway
- 57:23melody, like the idea of the Broadway melody,
- 57:26where like, look at this song we found. Yeah.
- 57:27Why don't we just put you in front of it or put
- 57:29it in front of you? Then you have orange blossom
- 57:31time. And this feels kind of like, okay, the
- 57:34pulse of this thing is dying a little bit. I
- 57:36mean, like it looks fascinating because it is
- 57:39introduced in the Technicolor. It does have the
- 57:42color. The second sequence of which, this makes
- 57:45more sense for it to be color than Romeo and
- 57:47Juliet did for me. Right. Because it is more
- 57:49of like a production that's being put on. Specifically,
- 57:52this would be your Charles King when he's singing
- 57:55specifically. And it's to Myrtle McLaughlin,
- 57:57right? Right, right. That he's singing this song
- 57:59specifically. So there's ballet happening in
- 58:02the background. It is a very large production.
- 58:05And it's memorable in that sense, but nothing
- 58:08really stuck out to me. I mean, how did you feel
- 58:10about this performance? Yeah, this is, if this
- 58:13would have been the finale, I would have been
- 58:15pretty disappointed. Sure. I think this has one
- 58:17of the more impressive sets, but that might just
- 58:21be because there were the color elements. Sure.
- 58:23Well, and scope, like just the size of it all.
- 58:26Yeah, it is pretty massive and impressive. To
- 58:29me, I think at this point in the movie, I was
- 58:31kind of tallying up. who had appeared the most.
- 58:35And I think it's really interesting that beyond
- 58:38your announcer, Conrad Nagel and Jack Benny and
- 58:41all of that, it kind of either shows you who
- 58:44is having their moment in Hollywood right now
- 58:48or who they're setting up to be big. Bessie Love
- 58:52appears so often in this. Charles King, huge.
- 58:55Both of them in the Broadway melody that came
- 58:57out just a few months prior. You can tell that
- 59:00they are kind of MGM's big stars right now in
- 59:04this moment. So that is kind of like the whole
- 59:08time I'm watching Orange Blossom Time, I'm just
- 59:10thinking, okay, who am I going to see next year?
- 59:13I got to keep an eye on Joan Crawford. Got it.
- 59:16Cool. All right. Moving on. That's high remarks
- 59:22of it, is that who all is in here right now?
- 59:24Yes. And that brings us to our finale, right?
- 59:27The finale then brings us to Singing in the Rain.
- 59:29So it's interesting. Because obviously at the
- 59:33time, they didn't know the longevity that this
- 59:35song would have, right? They know how catchy
- 59:37it is. So they assume, you know, hey, let's,
- 59:39you know, put it in here. It's interesting to
- 59:42me that it appears three times ultimately. Yeah.
- 59:45One, quite honestly, the most underwhelming,
- 59:49right? Three sisters just singing this song.
- 59:51Introduced by Cliff, little Cliffy, my boy. But
- 59:53then we do the finale. And the finale is a very
- 59:56large production, similar to that of Orange Blossom
- 59:59Time. Not quite the scope and scale of that,
- 1:00:02but it's still the entire stage. And we have
- 1:00:04the performance of everyone, you know, in the
- 1:00:06rain singing, singing in the rain. Yeah. And
- 1:00:09then I mentioned earlier, there's a background
- 1:00:11piece in the, in the background, there's like
- 1:00:13a stair case that like goes up almost like a
- 1:00:16bridge. I think it's supposed to be a bridge
- 1:00:18in the context. And you have a moment where.
- 1:00:22Everyone is on screen singing this song. And
- 1:00:24you even have a really great close -up. And this
- 1:00:26is one of the only other moments where I was
- 1:00:28like, okay, good camera work, where they zoom
- 1:00:30in on the front line of the main cast and kind
- 1:00:34of pan through them singing Singing in the Rain.
- 1:00:36Right, yeah. So I thought this was good, right?
- 1:00:40It isn't the movie. Right, right. And it doesn't
- 1:00:43make the movie. But specifically, to see the
- 1:00:46first large production number of this song makes
- 1:00:50it seem semi -worth it. Yeah, no, this is kind
- 1:00:54of iconic at this point. Right. The backdrop
- 1:00:56has, I guess, Noah's Ark. Correct. There's a
- 1:01:00rainbow. The idea is, I don't know, it's done
- 1:01:03raining, or it's still raining, and the world's
- 1:01:06flooding, but we're happy again. Yes. Everybody's
- 1:01:09wearing these big yellow raincoats. They look
- 1:01:11like they're all about to get pulled down into
- 1:01:13the sewers. You have a great moment as they're
- 1:01:15panning across the actor's face. Took me a second
- 1:01:18on that. I was like, it's definitely not, you
- 1:01:19can't tell it's yellow. What are you talking
- 1:01:21about? But yeah, I'm with you. Yeah, it's in
- 1:01:22color. Is it? Yeah, this part's in color. Is
- 1:01:25it? I don't remember it being in color. Uh -oh.
- 1:01:26Did you watch the wrong one? Yeah. Uh -oh, Tubi.
- 1:01:29Yeah, no. I just remember mostly the black bridge
- 1:01:32in the background, so that must have been my
- 1:01:34focus. Gotcha. As you're panning across the actors,
- 1:01:36you have a great moment where Buster Keaton really
- 1:01:37stays true to his character, and he is not singing
- 1:01:40in the rain. Yeah. He's just kind of looking
- 1:01:42around. I thought that was weird. Yeah, I think
- 1:01:45that is him just being like, I'm Buster Keaton.
- 1:01:47It's what I imagine Lon Chaney would be doing.
- 1:01:49He'd just have like the most grotesque mask,
- 1:01:52just like kidnapping Marie Dressler or something
- 1:01:55in the background. But truly, truly iconic. And
- 1:01:59even though this movie is not referenced very
- 1:02:02often, very often or talked about very often
- 1:02:05now, what it led to with Singing in the Rain
- 1:02:09and just like this. shot, almost, is something
- 1:02:13that I think pops up a lot. Babylon. Sure. This
- 1:02:16is a moment in Babylon. Yeah. It's really cool.
- 1:02:20And because I did the podcast before that movie
- 1:02:23came out, when I was watching Babylon and I saw
- 1:02:26that in the background, I was like, I may be
- 1:02:29the only person in this theater right now that
- 1:02:33has seen this moment. I have to give Damien Chazelle
- 1:02:37a massive amount of credit, though, for this
- 1:02:40being, only the second year that we've covered
- 1:02:42on this iteration of the podcast, right? But
- 1:02:45Damien Chazelle is coming up twice in two years.
- 1:02:48That's true. Because we talked about his love
- 1:02:50for Seventh Heaven and how that directly inspired
- 1:02:52the ending of La La Land. And to see him then
- 1:02:55follow up La La Land, is that correct, with Babylon
- 1:02:58and then First Man? Or First Man and then Babylon?
- 1:03:00First Man and then Babylon. Correct. So then
- 1:03:02follow up First Man with then more love of like...
- 1:03:05old hollywood and how hollywood came to be and
- 1:03:08that final sequence you're talking about paying
- 1:03:10tribute to movies in the past including hollywood
- 1:03:13review of 1929 yeah is very cool and whether
- 1:03:16those movies are super effective or not it's
- 1:03:18very interesting and admirable to see someone
- 1:03:20reaching across history like that and directly
- 1:03:23influence or citing influences yeah i didn't
- 1:03:26think about that he has been brought up quite
- 1:03:28a bit can't wait to see what he brings up in
- 1:03:30all quiet in the western front next year I wouldn't
- 1:03:32be surprised if there was something in there.
- 1:03:34I don't know what it would be, but I mean, let's
- 1:03:36start wrapping it up. Overall, I think we've
- 1:03:40come to understand that you're not the biggest
- 1:03:43Hollywood Review fan. I think that the Hollywood
- 1:03:47Review has introduced some things that will live
- 1:03:49with me forever, i .e. Lon Chaney terrorizing
- 1:03:52an entire production without being there. But
- 1:03:55it... did stand out as probably the most fitting
- 1:04:00slash most inappropriate movie at the same time
- 1:04:02to finalize this year, right? Because it is the
- 1:04:07standout. Not in a great way, but it does stand
- 1:04:09out the most in terms of it's not like the other
- 1:04:11movies. Right. In that there is no narrative.
- 1:04:13There is no direct pulse in this movie. And it
- 1:04:17is kind of that of a variety show, which means
- 1:04:20that it's a roller coaster of... Are we super
- 1:04:23into it? Are we out of it? So very different.
- 1:04:26Again, not abysmal. It's just not really a movie
- 1:04:29in that sense. Yeah. And that's not to say, you
- 1:04:31know, terrible. Don't watch it. It's out there.
- 1:04:34And this is exactly what we talk about when we
- 1:04:36say preservation, right? This was put on Laserdisc
- 1:04:38in the 90s and then released on DVD. So it is
- 1:04:41accessible. Very well so. So thank you. Or very
- 1:04:44much so. So thank you specifically, Warner Archive
- 1:04:47Collection, for doing that. But... This is what
- 1:04:50we want is we want to be able to go back and
- 1:04:51watch these things. And I think it's fitting
- 1:04:53to end this year before we talk about the ceremony
- 1:04:56to kind of like start at the beginning when we
- 1:04:58talk about lost media. So regardless of these
- 1:05:01are hits or not, it's important that we do these
- 1:05:03things and that we have things like, you know,
- 1:05:05whether it's not super effective, like the Laurel
- 1:05:08and Hardy of it all, or it's an absolute now.
- 1:05:12staple and totem of my personality, like Lon
- 1:05:14Chaney is going to get you if you don't watch
- 1:05:15out. It's important that we preserve these things
- 1:05:17and have the confidence in our art that we're
- 1:05:22putting out and preserve it the best that we
- 1:05:24can, because we don't know if it's going to be
- 1:05:25lost to fires or not being able to be put out
- 1:05:29in the future and not something that we can recite.
- 1:05:31Thank God for people like Damien Chazelle who
- 1:05:34are going back and referencing these things from
- 1:05:361927, 1929, respectively. Right, yeah. I hope
- 1:05:40Seventh Heaven was from 1927, 1928. We'll see.
- 1:05:43Yeah, yeah, it was. Hey, cool. You nailed it.
- 1:05:45So it's very cool that we have people like that
- 1:05:48who are directly reciting and, you know, the
- 1:05:50work that we're doing here. But regardless how
- 1:05:52we feel about these movies, that's my best way
- 1:05:54to spin it, it's imperative that we preserve
- 1:05:58these and the memory of these things. So very
- 1:06:00cool to do. Also a very interesting one to end
- 1:06:03on for this year. Yeah. I think that this is
- 1:06:06a cool movie to go back and watch. You're not
- 1:06:08going to have... the time of your life watching
- 1:06:11this one but this is cool if you want to explore
- 1:06:14more old hollywood itself because the way mgm
- 1:06:18intended it's an introduction to a lot of its
- 1:06:20stars it also felt very similar to like the the
- 1:06:24rat pack roasts that would uh go on to take over
- 1:06:27media in the future uh where it did just feel
- 1:06:30kind of like almost like the oscars themselves
- 1:06:33a celebration of Hollywood in different ways.
- 1:06:36So very cool to see them make fun of themselves,
- 1:06:38but also very much, okay, well, we just have
- 1:06:41to have musical productions put on that vary
- 1:06:44in terms of their effectiveness. A celebration
- 1:06:46of Hollywood, but mostly MGM Studios. You have
- 1:06:50two minutes. Yeah. If only that was told of this
- 1:06:54movie, but then we wouldn't have Lon Chaney.
- 1:06:55No. So that's okay. I'll take it. You take the
- 1:06:58good with the... So -so. Yeah. Again, not a bad
- 1:07:01movie. Well, it's not a movie, but it's not a
- 1:07:03bad time that's being spent on it. Sure. It's
- 1:07:06worth watching. That's what I say. So hit me
- 1:07:09with a ranking, or not a ranking, a rating. So
- 1:07:12on Letterboxd, I did rate this at a two. Okay.
- 1:07:17Now, with the Lon Chaney of it all, I would be
- 1:07:21interested in moving that up a little higher.
- 1:07:24We'll peel back the curtain a little bit here.
- 1:07:27I watched House of Dynamite. And I ranked that
- 1:07:30at two and a half on Letterboxd. To be quite
- 1:07:33honest, that's me mostly holding the last 15
- 1:07:36minutes or so of that movie against itself. Sure.
- 1:07:39I saw that you rated it a little bit higher than
- 1:07:41that. I have a feeling we might be talking about
- 1:07:43that in the months to come. Sure. So we'll hold
- 1:07:45on to that. This is where I say that the skewing
- 1:07:47of like a five star system is tough. But I think
- 1:07:51I'm pretty comfortable at like a two, two and
- 1:07:53a half. Yeah. And that half is probably Lon Chaney.
- 1:07:56Yeah. Yeah, I'm sitting at a two and a half as
- 1:07:58well. Great. Lon Chaney, Singing in the Rain
- 1:08:01and the importance of that. It's a big deal.
- 1:08:03And I do, I think I have a little bit more fun
- 1:08:06with some of the other segments than you do,
- 1:08:09maybe. Sure. And vice versa. Yeah. But yeah,
- 1:08:12I mean, that's where I'm sitting with it. I think
- 1:08:14that's fair. And again, that's not to say terrible,
- 1:08:17right? Like I would have rated it a half a star
- 1:08:18if I was just like, I hated my whole experience
- 1:08:20with this. It's just not what I would have expected.
- 1:08:23And I think I've catered myself at this point.
- 1:08:26in 1929 with, okay, well, what can we do with
- 1:08:29musicals? What can we do with the narrative of
- 1:08:33this? And I was really impressed with the majority
- 1:08:35of them. And with this, it's impressive, but
- 1:08:37on a different scale. It's the same way that
- 1:08:39you can't compare watching Citizen Kane to going
- 1:08:43and seeing Hamilton. You can't compare those
- 1:08:45two because they're just so different in style.
- 1:08:47Yeah, absolutely. It makes sense. We're running
- 1:08:49a little bit long, so let's jump into our double
- 1:08:52feature segment. Yeah. And then we'll wrap. Do
- 1:08:55you want to start on this? Sure, I'll start.
- 1:08:57I think you'll like this one. My pairing is going
- 1:09:01to be not a movie, but you should go online and
- 1:09:04you should watch the Muppet Show that was at
- 1:09:08Hollywood Studios. Just watch that. It's not
- 1:09:11a movie. Oh, Muppet Vision. Yes, Muppet Vision.
- 1:09:13Yes. Go and watch Muppet Vision. It's not a movie.
- 1:09:16It's a segment show. variety show, if you will,
- 1:09:19but it has that underlying narrative that you're
- 1:09:21looking for so much. I think it's a perfect representation.
- 1:09:25The Muppets really have always been a variety
- 1:09:27show. That's the whole... Mentioned two or three
- 1:09:29times on this podcast alone. Yeah. That's going
- 1:09:32to be my double feature pairing. I love that.
- 1:09:34I also love that you said that it's not a movie
- 1:09:36because now there's Hollywood Review. So in a
- 1:09:40similar sense, I'm going to do the same thing.
- 1:09:41I'm a double feature, but I'm going to say that
- 1:09:43you should watch Lon Chaney's Gonna Get You If
- 1:09:45You Don't Watch Out separately. And then immediately
- 1:09:47follow that with the You're Invited, Mary -Kate
- 1:09:51and Ashley Olsen sleepover series. They had a
- 1:09:53series called You're Invited, and there's one
- 1:09:55specifically of a sleepover, where you're invited
- 1:09:57to their sleepover. And there's a segment of
- 1:09:59the sleepover where they try to scare each other
- 1:10:02with spooky stories of monsters. And the entire
- 1:10:06segment of that... I mean, also watch Pizza Time,
- 1:10:09because that's iconic. But that whole segment
- 1:10:13very much feels like... in the same vein as Lon
- 1:10:17Chaney's gonna get you if you don't watch out,
- 1:10:18where it is just trying to, like, friendly, spooky
- 1:10:21stuff, right? Like, not very scary, and not very
- 1:10:25serious, but, like, very fun. I would probably
- 1:10:28suggest those two things, because when that stood
- 1:10:30out, very much I was like, did they just, like,
- 1:10:33you're invited me, like, to this, like, 1929
- 1:10:36production? What's going on? I love it. Mary
- 1:10:38Kate and Ashley referenced. Look, you never know
- 1:10:41what you're gonna get in this podcast. Never.
- 1:10:43It's a mixed bag. Never. Especially with your
- 1:10:45double features. They've been pretty wild. I'm
- 1:10:48trying to keep it like, you know. Out of the
- 1:10:51box, but also you see where the tether is. Right.
- 1:10:54It's not just like, you should see the stupids.
- 1:10:56No. And watch this with it. Every time I do my
- 1:10:58double feature, I'm like, oh, I'm going to do
- 1:11:00the Muppet show at MGM. This will be wild. No,
- 1:11:03that's a great one. And then you're like, Mary
- 1:11:04Kate and Ashley. No, that's a wild one. And I
- 1:11:08love what you did with it. Because again, you
- 1:11:10referenced it. I see the vision. It is the variety
- 1:11:12of it. It is very much a variety show. So I love
- 1:11:15that. But no, I had to stay true to my heart.
- 1:11:18And the Lon Chaney of it all just reminded me
- 1:11:19of the You're Invited video. So that's going
- 1:11:23to do it for this episode. Just to throw it out
- 1:11:25real quick, send us any thoughts you have on
- 1:11:27this entire year. Next episode, we're going to
- 1:11:29do the 1929 Oscar ceremony episode. So if you
- 1:11:33have thoughts on the movies, thoughts on the
- 1:11:35show, anything like that, email us at outaopodcast
- 1:11:38at gmail .com. Subscribe to the Patreon if you'd
- 1:11:41like to support us financially. That's patreon
- 1:11:44.com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast. All of the
- 1:11:48links to everything, including our social media,
- 1:11:50will be in the show notes. And one thing we haven't
- 1:11:53promoted at all so far in the show, leave us.
- 1:11:55reviews and and rate us on spotify has ratings
- 1:11:59now you can comment directly on episodes on spotify
- 1:12:02and look forward to if it's not already out the
- 1:12:06once upon a time at the oscars letterboxd page
- 1:12:08it'll have all of our double features listed
- 1:12:11the combined scores of our ratings of these films
- 1:12:15and that'll be a great place to get info on the
- 1:12:17show i realize now that it's probably not the
- 1:12:20best time for us to make the double features
- 1:12:23that we did For Letterboxd, because I don't know
- 1:12:25if Muppet Vision or You're Invited to Mary -Kate
- 1:12:27and Ashley Olsen's sleepover is going to be cited
- 1:12:30on Letterboxd. Sure. But much like life, we will
- 1:12:34find a way. Perfect. That's what we'll do. That's
- 1:12:38going to do it for this episode. Thank you so
- 1:12:40much for listening. As always, I'm your host,
- 1:12:43Kyle. And I'm your co -host, Ryan. And we'll
- 1:12:45see you at the movies.