Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 467. Bone Loss, Thyroid and Hormones: How to prevent Osteoporosis with Dr Doug Lucas
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the thyroid fixer podcast where I'm all about helping you lose that stubborn weight that won't come off no matter what you do. Get off your couch at 2pm and get through your day with energy and stop counting the hairs that come out of your head.
- 0:16I'm your host, Dr. Amy, and I'm here to help you get optimized with your thyroid and your hormones. It's all part of living our mantra. Better thyroid, better hormones equals a better life. So let's get you back to being the badass human that you're meant to be. Let's approach it from a thyroid and hormone optimization standpoint.
- 0:38Between myself and my guests, you will be loaded down with information to take control of your health and get back to being you. So let's get started.
- 0:50Dr. Dove, welcome to the show. I'm so happy to have you on because this is a topic, bones, osteoporosis, bones, that obviously my entire audience needs. If you're female, if you're male, if you're young, if you're old, we should all be thinking about our bone health. And especially if you are perimenopausal, menopausal,
- 1:10have a thyroid condition, which is 99.9% of my audience, then this is a topic that you should be paying attention to. So I try to bring on people that know way more than me in areas that I don't claim to be an expert in. And osteoporosis and bone health is one of them. So I'm super excited to have you on the show to really dive deep into this topic. Well, thank you so much for having me. This is the topic I like talking about the most.
- 1:35So how'd you get into specializing in bone health? Is there a backstory? Yeah, so I'm an orthopedic surgeon by training. So I was the traditional orthopedic surgeon doing the operating room thing, practice like that for about a decade.
- 1:52During my practice, I was always in the mindset where I wanted to help prevent the things that were causing the things that I needed to operate on. It's just, I think, how I'm wired. I don't know if I wasn't supposed to go into orthopedics, but I like talking to people about nutrition. I like educating my patients. My wife runs a nutrition business, and as I watched her really heal people through nutrition, I realized, oh, my gosh, there's some really powerful tools that I'm missing out on.
- 2:17And then through the course of some challenging, we'll call it hospital political issues that occurred in my practice, I found an out that allowed me to get some additional training and then start the practice ultimately that I'm in now, which is really in the functional integrative space.
- 2:32Yeah, that's enough of a story to force you one way or another. So when we're talking about osteoporosis, and then I hear osteopenia. So I hear those words used almost interchangeably from my patients and from my audience. Can you break that down and explain what each one is? I hear this a lot in just any of the osteoporosis.
- 2:54really strikes fear in people. And it's really important that we understand the difference between osteoporosis and osteopenia because osteoporosis is an actual diagnosis whereas osteopenia is just the transition into the diagnosis like prediabetes and diabetes. Although I think prediabetes actually has an ICD code but osteopenia does not.
- 3:14It doesn't mean that it's not necessarily bad, but it might not be. So let me explain what I mean by that. So both of those terms are simply based off of imaging, meaning that on the DEXA scan, which is the traditional imaging modality, although not the best imaging modality for bone health,
- 3:30you get a score called a T-score. We can dig into what that means. But basically that T-score is essentially a standard deviation, a statistical measure of how your bone density compares to that of your sex and race at your peak bone density age, which would be like mid-20s, early 30s. It comes across this chart. And so if you are one standard deviation below or a T-score of negative one,
- 3:55to down to negative 2.5 or two and a half standard deviations below. That's called osteopenia. And anything less than that, so less than negative 2.5 is osteoporosis. So really what that's telling you is that you might be at risk for a fracture, but it's only looking at one aspect of bone. But the short answer is osteoporosis is worse bone density according to that scale. And osteopenia is worse than average, but not as bad as osteoporosis.
- 4:21So how do people move along that path of, okay, your bones are starting to look a little bit funky, and now you're moving full on into osteoporosis? Like, how do we move down that path and what are the causes of it? Yeah. So this is the interesting thing about the diagnosis is I hear people say, like I said, people will get a diagnosis, let's say of osteopenia.
- 4:43and they'll say, oh my gosh, I got a DEXA scan for whatever reason and I have osteopenia, I'm freaking out. But the thing to remember is that osteopenia doesn't necessarily mean that your bone is that bad.
- 4:54So you could have osteopenia be one standard deviation below the average and have great bone quality and not really be at risk for fracture. Additionally, like myself, like I have osteopenia, I've had it since my mid 20s. And I know this because I went through my wife's Ph.D. thesis when I was in college and I got a DEXA scan and I had a T score of negative one five in my 20s. Right. So I never had good bone density to begin with. I didn't have good peak bone density.
- 5:19It's been the same my entire adult life. So is my bone getting worse? No, I'm not losing any bone. Arguably, the average is going down and I'm staying the same. I hope with all the work that I've done since I started teaching people about bone health, it's probably going up. I haven't retested it yet. But that's an example where I have osteopenia. Am I worried about fracture? No.
- 5:39But if you have osteopenia and then you get retested again, let's call it a year later, and you have worse osteopenia or now you have osteoporosis, like that is a problem. So osteopenia could be an issue depending on the trajectory and your bone quality. We're going to talk about how to measure that.
- 5:57The causes, though, are many, many, many. There's some really common ones. But when we look at a patient in our program, what we're trying to do is to find the underlying causes. There's a lot of things to consider. I would say probably the top, let's call it three, would be when women go through menopause, whether it be natural or surgical or therapeutic.
- 6:18You know, they have hormone dysfunction and perimenopause, but for whatever reason, when estrogen drops, then you lose bone. It's predictable. It happens to everyone. The question is, is how good was your bone to begin with? And so that's probably number one progesterone dysfunction in that same group. So for women who are ovulating, who have a progesterone or luteal defect of progesterone, they're going to be losing bone because progesterone is important.
- 6:42Women with adrenal function that are going to have low testosterone naturally, they're going to have bone loss as well. So all three of those sex hormones are super important. I'd say the other two main ones would be gut health, which is related to just about everything, right? But if you have poor gut health, then you're not going to be able to absorb nutrients. You're not going to be able to build your bone. And then the other one I would put in the top three would just be poor nutrition, whether it be.
- 7:05chronic dieting, choices that are not going to be good for muscle and bone, just undernourished in general, all of those things are going to lead to eventually probably bone loss.
- 7:16So if you were a woman with your already iffy T-score, but it's staying the same, chances are we would see that T-score change because of that drop off in estrogen, progesterone and testosterone that occurs as women move through perimenopause and menopause.
- 7:36Yeah, it's absolutely predictable. And what's scary is that I don't think we know because we don't screen young women. I think that there is a wave of or a tidal wave, rather, probably a tsunami of women that have that had low peak bone mineral density, excuse me, that had low peak bone mineral density in their 20s and 30s.
- 7:58that as they go through menopause, especially if they are not offered or discuss HRT, then they're going to have osteoporosis in their 50s. I think because I see it all the time. We have patients in their 30s and 40s with osteoporosis. A lot of times there's multiple reasons, but I think we're going to see a lot of women come into menopause already severely osteopenic and into osteoporosis.
- 8:19So if we're in that, well, I guess this question is for both states. If we're in that osteopenic state, is it reversible? If we're in the osteoporosis state, is it reversible? Yeah, this is probably, I would say if there was an underpinning to my mission of being on social media and creating content and doing all the work that we do is to get this point across, which is that osteoporosis as a disease probably shouldn't exist in general. I think maybe for rare circumstances.
- 8:47But really, we should have good peak bone marrow density as a young adult, and we should be able to maintain it as we age, regardless of our lifespan, if we live to 130.
- 8:56because it is easy to maintain if you're doing all the right things. Can you reverse it? A lot of doctors would say no. I say absolutely, that's wrong. We can absolutely reverse it. We're doing it all day, every day, and we're collecting a ton of data on this. So yes, the vast majority of people that come into our program are improving their bone turnover markers and then subsequently improving imaging metrics. So yes, it doesn't matter. Really, your starting point, as long as you have the capacity to actually do the interventions, which we can talk about, then you can improve your bone health.
- 9:25Oh my gosh. Well, that just gives hope because I think, you know, people think of osteoporosis as not a death sentence, but a sentence. This is it. This is how you're going to be the rest of your life. You're just going to have to deal with it. I think death sentence is accurate. I really see so much fear around this diagnosis. People will come in and they really feel like they're going to die. Oh, wow. Okay. They do not need to have that much fear around the diagnosis.
- 9:49And is that, do you think that that's because, you know, we hear so much about grandma and ma falling, breaking a hip, they land in the hospital bed, they're done. Like we hear those stories over and over again. Yeah. I mean, the statistics are really nasty, right? So if you look at hip fracture in particular, which is really what I was treating when I was practicing orthopedics, I treated a lot of hip fractures.
- 10:10Statistically, a third of patients with a hip fracture will die within 12 months. A third lose their dependence. They become dependent and require full-time care. And then a third regain independence. I'm doing that in quotes for those that can't see me because their independence is not the same as it was. So it's a pretty crummy injury.
- 10:28And it can happen relatively young. So it is a big deal. But the reason why I think the fear happens is because they get the diagnosis, their doctor says, you have to go on this drug, they Google it on their way home, and they see horror story after horror story of the drugs. So they're scared of the drugs, they don't know what else to do, they see conflicting information online,
- 10:48And they start pulling their hair out because they're frightened of having this hip fracture or spine fracture or having the deformity or losing their independence or all of it. So it's a really big wake-up call and is associated with such unnecessary fear.
- 11:03Now, I'm going to come back to the importance of hormones because I really want to drive that point home that you mentioned earlier. But since you're talking about the drugs, I was calling the Sally Field drugs because I just remember her on a TV commercial touting this bone loss drug. I couldn't even tell you the name of it. But what about it? Because I'm in the same boat, not the same boat that I have osteoporosis, but I have seen and heard and read those side effects of the...
- 11:27anti-bone loss drugs or the Sally Field drugs. And oh my gosh, it is scary. So what is the truth around those osteoporosis bone drugs? Yeah. So I never want to, I try not to disparage doctors. I try not even disparage drugs, which gets hard sometimes, but there's a time and a place for these drugs. The problem with the drugs, I'll go into the individual drugs, but the problem with the drugs as a class is that there's no long-term solution here.
- 11:53So if you are a 90-year-old with a diagnosis of osteoporosis and you're trying to prevent a hip fracture, that's a very different patient case than is, say, our 51-year-old woman who just went through menopause, got her first DEXA early because she wanted it and she demanded it, has severe osteopenia, osteoporosis, and then is told to take a drug
- 12:14that she can't take for the rest of her life. So what is her long-term plan with this drug if she's 50 and plans to live to 90? That's 40 more years, right? So the drugs don't have a good long-term approach. They have a particular mechanism that might work in some cases, but it is the first line, of course, because that's our system, it's the first line of defense for osteoporosis, but there is not a good long-term plan with any of them.
- 12:38Also, the drugs are kind of divided into two classes. So there's sort of the anti-resorptive drugs. So that would be your bisphosphonate, your Fosamax, you know, like those drugs. Reclast is a really popular one now. Those drugs are going to slow down bone loss. And they do that in a way that is pretty, it's not permanent, but it's pretty significant, which is essentially either poisoning the cells that break down bone, the osteoclasts, or preventing osteoclasts from sort of being brought up from the progenitor cells or the stem cells.
- 13:07So you're essentially shutting down that side of bone metabolism. The problem is when you do that, there are implications to that, right? Like you can't mess with metabolism of a specific organ for the long term and have good outcome. And so when you shut down the breakdown, the bones can't build up either. And if you look at the research, the bone density does climb, but they become more dense, but then more fragile.
- 13:33So then you have dense, fragile bones, you end up with these atypical fractures, or the other side effect is osteonecrosis of the jaw, which is also a really nasty complication from those drugs.
- 13:43Oh, that sounds like a very nasty complication. Oh my gosh, what does that even mean? Like your jaw is basically disintegrating? Yeah, that's the way to look at it. So I would not encourage anybody to Google this and look at images. It's really terrible. So what happens is the jaw bone, the mandible and maxilla, those bones of your face, the ones that we chew that our teeth are in, those bones go through really pretty rapid bone turnover because you imagine the stress that we put on the teeth
- 14:11the bone sockets that are holding those teeth are constantly remodeling because we're putting all this stress through our teeth if you shut down bone metabolism then they can't do their remodeling and then if you ended up needing you know dental work or you had a problem like a root canal or whatever that bone's not going to heal and then you end up with osteonecrosis of the jaw which is dead bone in the jaw you can have fractures it can be
- 14:35absolutely debilitating and terrible. And so that I think is unfortunately really underreported because we're taking patients out of the traditional medical system. And we're talking about now in the dental system, right? There should be good reporting between the two, but there's not. So I think we see a lot of stuff happening on the dental side that isn't reported to the doctors that are prescribing the drugs. And so they say, oh, it's rare. It's the 0.0, whatever percent.
- 15:01But what I hear from dentists and from people in our YouTube channel and our communities is that it is really common. So I don't know what the real number is. I don't think it's actually common. I think we just have a biased perspective. But I think it's more common than is reported.
- 15:16Yeah. Yeah. I mean, that just doesn't even sound like a dice I would want to roll. Unless you had to. Unless you had to. Right. To your point, like if you're 90 and you have to take that, absolutely. But I think with all of the answers and all of the...
- 15:32the different options that we have right now to implement early for prevention or even to implement now, if you're in that osteopenic or even osteoporosis state, because you even said this absolutely can be reversed. Let's go over some of those. I realize, I mean, it's wide, vast, and you have specific protocols for patients, but just some of them. So I want to go back to the hormone piece.
- 15:57I talk about the importance of hormones ad nauseum. And yet still there is this fear that has been embedded in women's minds from the Women's Health Initiative study that hormones are going to cause cancer. And some conventional doctors are still perpetuating that message, even though it's been debunked, even though we know the benefits are wide and vast. Now, since talking to you,
- 16:23I am also going to add to my repertoire. Now, of course, I say bone, brain, breast, and heart protection. And I kind of, you know, do it like that, like a brush over. But to really emphasize the point and what you're saying, not doing bioidentical hormone replacement therapy can literally lead to you dying early
- 16:43from a hip fracture can literally lead to being bent over having multiple breaks what else comes with osteoporosis what else are we'll say the kind of day-to-day things that people deal with when they have it yeah the funny thing about osteoporosis is that it's really they call it the silent disease it's not it's not silent in my opinion because of the fear associated with it so what i see is that when people have the diagnosis they have they go through this fear
- 17:13And so it's not so much that you have symptoms of it until you have a fracture because then you do hip fracture, whatever forearm, wrist, spine. There's all of those things are relevant and can be debilitating. But for me, what I ask every time we do a master class and I'm talking to people that have osteoporosis, I always ask them, what are you not doing that you want to be doing because of your diagnosis?
- 17:33And the list is it's forever, right? Skiing, horseback riding, lifting weights, playing with my kids, lifting my grandchildren, like all of those things. I think that's what's so debilitating and so loud about the disease. And then once you have a fracture, of course, there's the debilitation that goes along with that. But yeah, those are the biggest things that the people aren't doing what they want to do because of the diagnosis, even though they don't actually feel it.
- 17:55Right, so there's the case for hormones right there and everything that you said in the beginning, they just make such a difference at prevention that, oh my gosh, why not do it? And it's not even just prevention. Can I, let me just dig into this because I know you're gonna love this research.
- 18:13I just did a talk at the A4M BHRT Symposium in LA that was this last month. And the reason why they asked me to speak is that I've talked with them before. I've done presentations on osteoporosis. When I talk about hormones, it's a different perspective because the hormone literature in the bone health space isn't really talked about in the traditional hormone space.
- 18:36some fantastic speakers in the hormone space, especially in the A4M space. And like such good speakers, I learn so much every time I go. But the research that I see, because I'm looking at bone hell, I'm looking at, you know, the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, right? Like this isn't where you're going to spend your time if you're a hormone specialist. And it's really compelling to look at the power of the studies, the power of the hormones themselves on the bones.
- 19:00and compared to the pharmaceuticals. So I did a deep dive for this talk that I did because I had a 90 minute block, which is a really long stage block. And so at a 90 minute block, I really wanted to go into the research on this. And what I pulled is all these studies from the kind of late 90s, 2000s. This was sort of like, they all started before the WHA, right? So like there was a different, totally different mode of using hormones, the different types of replacement, which I want to go into.
- 19:29But what really stuck out to me is the power of hormone replacement, even with crappy synthetic commercial versions, still powerful, especially when you compare it to the bisphosphonate drugs. So there were some studies that really stuck out to me where if you use an adequate amount, because some of them measured serum levels, not all.
- 19:49But if you use an adequate amount of estradiol and you kind of breach this 60, 80 picogram per ml threshold of serum estradiol, then you really see most of the bone mineral density outcomes. We're looking for like 4% improvement in a year. Like that would be really good, right? That's sort of a drug number, 4 or 6%. You can not only see that in hormones, but you can see double that. There were studies that have over the course of 24 months,
- 20:13but 9%, 10% improvement in bone mineral density with estradiol and progestin, again, like crappy commercial synthetic, which actually causes bone loss. But still, it was so impactful because of the power of hormones compared to even the pharmaceuticals. What people don't take away from this, because even the authors and the studies would say, well, they're about the same.
- 20:35I'm like, no, they're not because hormone you can keep doing the bisphosphine. You have to stop after three years. So like they're not the same, even if they were the same, the hormones still outperformed them. But even if they didn't, the fact that you can keep going is so much more powerful. This is a solution you can use long term.
- 20:52So I love presenting these studies because it shows the power of hormones because bones leave biomarkers, the imaging modalities. We can see what is the dose and then what is the different forms? You can see differences between using estradiol versus there's so many studies on Premarin, right? And so you see all this different information from the different hormones. And then what really stuck out to me too is static versus cyclic. And I don't know if you talked to your audience about the difference here, but cycling progesterone
- 21:22in having either different doses or even the same dose of estradiol, but cycling progesterone is a much more powerful tool than is static hormones alone. And by static, I mean same dose of both progesterone and estrogen every day throughout the month. And that cycling has really gone away in the post-WHI era, because if you're using the lowest dose for the shortest term.
- 21:46Why cycle progesterone, right? You're not even taking enough of it for it to matter. And so looking back at some of these old data points and demonstrating, wow, cyclic matters, dose matters. We need to follow these biomarkers and make sure that we're actually saturating our estrogen receptors and progesterone receptors. Bones are such a powerful tool there because we can see what's happening with our metabolism.
- 22:07My gosh, this is gold. This is absolute gold. I'm so glad you brought this up. So let me ask you, do you see a difference with estradiol and estriol? Like, will you ever use a bi-est for the estradiol component? Or do you always use estradiol? Yeah. I was trained to use bi-est, and I used it early in practice because that's what we do as doctors, right? We're like, well, I'm just going to do what my trainers told me.
- 22:33I had heard early on in my practice, you know, don't use bias. We don't know what the estriol is doing. It's not as well studied. So I kind of looked into it. And early on, I was like, yeah, this doesn't really make a lot of sense. Because physiologically, there's not a lot in a woman's system unless she's pregnant. Pregnant.
- 22:49That's not the state I'm trying to reproduce here. So this doesn't really make sense. And so I went away and I started using just topical estradiol alone. But one of the studies that I pulled for this talk, and it just like shocked me. I must've read it like 20 times. It's like, are you serious?
- 23:06is that they they used estriol as a control group and they had estradiol and other forms and other groups and they even said the author said in the study we we chose estriol in the control group because we knew that it wouldn't protect bone and that was it was such a like i was like i can't believe i just read that you know because i see so many people using bias 80 20 bias right it's 80 estriol
- 23:31And they're using it because they want to improve their bone, heart, and brain. I'm like, well, I don't think you're improving the bone with an 80-20 bias. And so that really, that sealed the deal for me. Because you saw in that study that group lost BMD. I don't know if it was a 12 or 24-month study. But it was 2%, which is what you would expect to see in a postmenopausal woman, not on HRT. Right? So it was an adequate placebo, even though it was estriol. So yeah, I don't use it anymore really for anything. Okay.
- 24:00Yeah, I'm right there with you. I just rather go straight up estradiol with women. Now, what about testosterone? I love testosterone. I love talking about testosterone's importance for women because so many people, doctors included, think that testosterone is just a dude hormone. So of course, I talk about the motivation, libido, the drive, the brain function, the heart protection. Where does it come in for bones? Yeah.
- 24:25The literature is not great for bones. There are a couple of studies. And what I would say is that testosterone, because it's androgenic, meaning that it's going to promote things to grow. So like muscle and bone because it's androgenic, I think it's a very valuable tool. There's not a lot of evidence to say that as a standalone
- 24:46instrument, a standalone intervention, you're going to see great outcomes. It just hasn't been studied that way in women. It's been studied in men, but obviously at a different dose, although arguably, I think all those studies underdosed them then too. Testosterone is such a, it's such an interesting hormone.
- 25:02And I've kind of gone not full circle on this, but I was very pro-testosterone early in my, in the practice where we started prescribing hormones because I personally had been on it. I, you know, it's in my ecosystem. A lot of people were testosterone deficient, both men and women on it, doing fantastic, right? So it is a very powerful hormone. What I found though, in our patient population is that as women get 10 years, 20 years out from menopause,
- 25:29If we start to use testosterone as a standalone tool, they don't tolerate very significant doses. They had a really hard time getting their levels, their serum levels up because they would start to experience side effects. You mean without estradiol and progesterone, like standalone without the other hormones? Right.
- 25:45Correct. So for example, let's use an example. I have plenty of these patients. So let's say a 70-year-old woman who's over 20 years out from menopause who has significant cardiovascular risk. We're not comfortable starting estrogen potentially in that person. We do in some, but not at all. So then we say, hey, well, we can sort of cheat around this and we can use testosterone off-label.
- 26:07And we're going to try to help build muscle mass, which of course the menopause society says not to do that. But these patients have osteoporosis. They're desperate. So we do it. It has worked for some. But again, I've struggled in the 60 to 70 year old age group getting enough testosterone on board to have an impact. So that really forced us to look heavier. Like let's optimize estradiol and progesterone first because they can absolutely tolerate those two and they feel so good.
- 26:31But for our younger audience, especially our perimenopausal women with stress, adrenal dysfunction, low testosterone, and call it sputtering estradiol,
- 26:41they do really well on testosterone. And in fact, it's actually sometimes hard to keep them at a low enough dose because they feel fantastic. They're like, I want more. And so, yeah, it's just interesting the different groups and how our treatment has changed over the course of the last several years to pull back a little bit on testosterone, potentially use something like DHEA in that population because the side effects aren't as significant. And then we do find that their testosterone rebounds.
- 27:08So we'll see their free and total testosterone come up on DHEA, especially if we've optimized estradiol and progesterone. That makes sense. Now, tying this in, how important is keeping your muscle as you age to protect your skeletal system? So important. I'm sure you've heard people talk about that muscle is the organ of longevity. Yes. Gabrielle Lyon, she's coined that. Yep. Absolutely.
- 27:35So I absolutely love that phrase and I think she's right. When I look at our patients, they're all sarcopenic, right? They've all lost their muscle mass. Chicken or the egg, I don't know which one came first, but osteoporosis and sarcopenia almost always come together. So when we build it back, even though resistance training actually isn't a great tool for building bone, it's a good, obviously, the tool for building muscle, we have to build the muscle back if we're gonna keep the bone that we're building back.
- 28:05When we train people, we are training them to eat adequate protein. You've gotta build your muscle. We've gotta get you into an anabolic state. Again, there's the power of anabolic hormones. But we've gotta get you into an anabolic state. We've gotta get you building muscle and then doing the things that will stimulate bone.
- 28:21So we're really taking this population of, again, mostly women that have never exercised, and we are pushing them as hard as we can or as hard as they'll let us, into this anabolic, let's lift weights, let's totally change the way we look at our lives state. And it's really fun to watch.
- 28:37That's so cool. Okay, now we want to build the muscle, protect the bone. How important, I always talk about protein first as well. You have to get your protein in. How important is amino acids and protein specifically for bone remodeling? Or is that more of an action on the muscle like we were talking about?
- 28:56No, it's bone. And so this is an area where even when I'm standing on stage at A4M, I'm definitely going against the grain here. Because in the bone health space, I'd love to hear your thoughts on this. In the bone health space, there's such a mindset around the alkaline theory of diet where people are avoiding potentially, quote unquote, acid forming foods, which, of course, includes animal protein and dairy.
- 29:19So I see a massive movement in the bone health community to eat a plant-based diet, exclusively plant-based vegan, whatever, because they think that these alkaline foods are going to benefit their bones. And I've gone into this in depth. I love looking at pH research on food because I watch these authors talk themselves in circles and prove themselves wrong over and over again. And it's really fun to just point this out on videos on YouTube. So I have a bunch of content on this.
- 29:45But what I need to do with these patients is to help them understand that protein is the most important thing. Getting amino acids in the form in which your body recognizes it, which is going to come from other animals primarily. That's what you have to do because most of the vast majority of people coming in are under eating in general. They're under eating protein. And when they are eating protein, they're generally getting it from plant sources. And this is one of the reasons why they can't build bone, right? Their body doesn't...
- 30:08have the building blocks for bone. Bones are 50% protein by, I believe it's by weight, but 50% protein. We have to have bone. We have to have protein to build bone. You need the mineralization as well, but you have to have protein to build bone.
- 30:24Oh my gosh, 50%. Oh my gosh. And no, I love that you go against the grain. I'm 100% in agreement with you. I think vegans and vegetarians and all this plant-based fad, I think it's destroying health. I really do. I mean, that lack of protein is just, it's crazy. You can see it in a person. Like you said, you can't really see the symptoms of osteoporosis unless they break something.
- 30:50But man, you can see protein deficiency, the hair, the skin, the lack of muscle. I will say, you know, I've been, I try not to be too hard on the plant-based community because there are people who are eating a vegan diet doing it for what they think are the right reasons. And I'm totally supportive of that. I love freedom. And if you want to eat that way, that's fine. But what I really struggle with is when people go into eating a plant-based diet and they
- 31:15And then they end up eating highly processed foods because it's really hard to eat a whole foods plant based exclusive diet. It's really hard to do. I have patients. I have a couple of patients that do it really well. Right. So they're really focused on getting adequate protein. They're mixing and matching their plant sources of protein and make sure you get all the amino acids. They're supplementing, of course.
- 31:35In addition to that, and they are adamant about doing it and they're doing it great. They track all their food. They're getting adequate protein. It's amazing. But that is the exception. And most people that become vegans end up eating highly processed plant-based garbage. And it's just a terrible diet.
- 31:51And so then they come in and they're like, oh, my gut doesn't work. I'm inflamed. I keep putting on weight. Like, I feel terrible. And I'm like, yeah, this is not working for you. Yeah. No, I agree. There's two and far between that really, like, they are dedicated and they do it the right way. But I would say the majority of people are eating the fake meat and the impossible burgers and the soy and the, oh, geez, we won't even, that's another podcast. Okay. So-
- 32:16So you had mentioned minerals. Now we're going to get to minerals and mag and D and all that, but oh, the pressing question that I've wanted to ask for so long. What about calcium? Should people be taking a calcium supplement or not? We've also gone full circle on this. I came out of, again, the traditional medical model, right? Where when I would fix a hip fracture on somebody and they would say, well, what do I do about my bone health?
- 32:42And I would say, I don't know, go follow up with, I guess I didn't have anywhere to send them. And, you know, here's a handout that says take vitamin D and calcium. And that's all I got for you, right? And probably it said on there, like, don't lift more than five pounds, you're going to have a fracture. This is the terrible advice that doctors give patients with a hip fracture or osteoporosis diagnosis.
- 33:02And so the traditional recommendations are to consume calcium and vitamin D. I don't know what the vitamin D recommendations are anymore, but the calcium recommendations have stuck to be around either 1,200 milligrams or 1,000 milligrams of calcium.
- 33:14as a supplement, which is really high. And the way that my understanding of the way that they came up with those numbers is pretty suspect in general. It's not based off of good research. It's just sort of like you have a bone problem. You need calcium to make bones. So we're just going to give you a crap ton of calcium and we're going to call it a day. But when you look at the studies on the calcium supplementation, two really important things pop up. Number one, it doesn't actually fix your bones. But number two, it increases your risk of heart attack and stroke.
- 33:43So calcium alone is not a good idea. The form of calcium though matters. What you take it with matters. And we do need minerals to build bone. So early on in practice, we were not using calcium supplementation at all. We had people track their food. We were seeing how much they were getting from food and we would manipulate their diet because we have coaches and fantastic dietitians and we can do that, right? So that was our approach. We made sure they were getting at least 700 to 800 milligrams of calcium, if not more,
- 34:13and if they weren't then we would talk about some kind of a supplement but we weren't even using calcium out of the gate and we were seeing results so i don't think they need to take calcium to improve their bone because we were getting results without it but what changed for me is i did a talk for uh one of the bone health franchise groups and i was i was on a panel with the company i don't know if you want to name brand new companies but let's call it a company that makes products for bone
- 34:40And they have a whole food form of calcium coming from algae. And what I was saying, what they were saying totally didn't match up. So after we had that panel, I sat down with the speaker and she said, hey, why don't you meet with our CEO? I would love for you to air your concerns about the products. So I did and I went through their research and I spent a lot of time looking at
- 35:03what they've pulled and some of the other studies, and I did a whole bunch of videos on this. And what I learned is that if you look at calcium as a supplement and the association with heart disease, cardiovascular disease, heart attack stroke, it's there, it exists. But if you take calcium, even in crappy forms like calcium, citrate carbonate,
- 35:22If you take those crappy forms with vitamin D3 and vitamin K2, then that risk goes away. Additionally, if you consume calcium from whole food forms, either from food or from food products like algae, then the risk is actually inversely associated, meaning that the more calcium you consume, the lower your heart attack risk and association status. And so I think what's happening is that when you, and you can see this in some of the studies,
- 35:51When you consume calcium carbonate or citrate, you get this massive spike in serum calcium. It goes up, it comes back down, because you would die if it stayed up. But it goes up, it comes back down. To get it back down, I think your body just puts it wherever it can. It just wants it out of your bloodstream, because we have all these calcium channel gates in our cells, and you would die if you had too much calcium. And so it just puts it everywhere, which again, in the arteries, to me in the coronary arteries, everywhere.
- 36:18And so we don't want that spike when you consume either an algae form of calcium, or there's some, a product that's made from ground, like whole round bones. So it has all like the proteins and the other stuff that's in the bones. When you consume those products, you don't get that spike in calcium. It's like consuming it from food. Like when you drink a glass of milk, you don't get a spike of, of syrup calcium. So I think it's a totally different mineral when you consume it that way.
- 36:44So the way that we do it is we use an algae form of calcium that has a lot of other minerals in it. And I look at it more of like I'm giving you a multi-mineral that's kind of heavy on calcium, but it's coming from a whole food source. So I don't really care if you have too much because extra calcium in your gut is actually good for your microbiome. So we've sort of come full circle where now we actually recommend...
- 37:04for the most part, everybody is on some form of an algae form of calcium as a multimeteral. That makes sense because these people that were popping, you know, hard calcetrex or something from like Walgreens, I always thought to myself, this can't be good. And I do know that calcium will bind to thyroid medication. So for all of my patients and my peeps, they're taking...
- 37:26T3 twice a day or NP twice a day. It's really hard to time that calcium supplement. Now, I would assume even with the algae-based one, you would probably still want to put it at dinner, take it away from your thyroid medication. Yeah, it's pretty heavy in calcium. Yeah, I would. I would avoid that with any of the thyroid preparations.
- 37:45Yeah. Now I will get to thyroid questions as well, but I want to ask you about magnesium since we're kind of on the supplementation route. What about magnesium? And I know there's so many different forms, but how does that relate to bone? If you were to ask me what is the most important mineral for bone, I would say magnesium. Okay. Because magnesium is required for you to utilize calcium. Plus it's required for, you know, whatever, how many hundreds of enzymatic reactions, right? Like we need magnesium to make bone and to live.
- 38:13Plus, we're mostly magnesium deficient as a population. We are not mostly calcium deficient. So if you told me I can only use one mineral for my patient, they would get magnesium. I think it's probably in a ratio of like at least two to one. Sometimes people would say three to one. That's a lot of magnesium. But basically, as much as you can tolerate is how much I want you to have.
- 38:35Any specific forms that you prefer over others? I was actually just doing an interesting podcast earlier today, but right now our current practice is using any kind of a chelated form.
- 38:47magnesium glycinate or bis glycinate. They're really well tolerated. They're well absorbed. They don't give GI side effects unless you take really big doses for the most part. So that's sort of our go-to for the vast majority of it. For people that have sleep issues, we might use a MAG-3 and 8. For people that have some constipation or challenges with their gut, we might use other forms that could help with motility. So you can kind of play with the different forms of magnesium depending on someone's particular situation.
- 39:15Yeah, that's fair. Yeah, they all do different things. Okay, the big question that I kind of let you know beforehand, because I wanted to make sure you were comfortable with it. In my community, so, so many people are running into the rhetoric of if you have a low TSH,
- 39:36then you are at risk for osteoporosis. And I shared with you before we started that, and my audience knows this, I've repeated this over and over again. I tell my patients to use me as an example to their doctor if they're working with someone that's freaking out about a low TSH. I have been on...
- 39:52150 micrograms of T3, which is a little bit larger dose. I'm a non-converter. So I do 75 and 75. Been on that for at least 16, 17 years. I've had two DEXAs back to back. They give me a thumbs up every time. I couldn't tell you. I have to look up my T score. I couldn't tell you off the top of my head.
- 40:09But two DEXAs back to back the last two years at Hacker Health. And they're like, this is awesome. So to me, suppressed TSH does not have a correlation with, oh my gosh, if you, and the way these doctors are putting it, if you have a low TSH, you will get osteoporosis and let's throw in some AFib as well. So can you break that down for us?
- 40:32Just a little sprinkle of AFib on top. Just a little sprinkle, yeah. Yeah, so I looked at this because we see thyroid dysfunction. I mean, of course, we see it everywhere, right? I mean, we do an extensive lab panel because we're looking for all potential causes of bone health. And we built the bone health system
- 40:47company on top of our health optimization company. So we basically just took all the stuff we were doing and then we added all the bone health flare. So our lab panel is massive. It's as big as LabCorp will let us make it. If we add anything else, we have to take something out because they're not comfortable drawing any more blood. Right. 17 vials that are coming. Right. Yeah. It's like a claim to fame, right? It's like, we're going to treat your osteoporosis through a phlebotomy.
- 41:09But we get a lot of data and we look at the thyroid in depth and I see dysfunctional thyroid in, I would say probably 90% of our patients, right? Like it is almost everyone. So we treat it and I had to look at the literature because I was kind of taught the same thing. Like you don't want to over suppress TSA, it's just going to cause the bone to get worse.
- 41:29But that didn't really jive clinically because I saw patients who were being treated that had a really low TSH and their bone was fine. So it's like, well, this doesn't really make sense. But I went and looked at the literature and it is there. So when you look at the studies on thyroid treatment, you will find studies that show that if you over, quote unquote, and I know you might disagree with what they're saying here, but these aren't my words. If you over treat hypothyroidism and you over suppress TSH, these are the terms they use.
- 41:57and your TSH is, you know, of course, less than 0.01, so it's 0.0001, then you have an association with lower bone mineral density and an increased risk of fracture. So that side of it is true from an association perspective. That doesn't mean it's causative. It just means that those things are associated. The same thing if you have an overactive thyroid cancer.
- 42:20So these are totally different situations, obviously, but if you have an overactive thyroid and you have hyperthyroidism, you are also at increased risk for the lower bone mineral density and a higher fracture risk. And so they're totally different situations. So most relevant to your audience probably is the low thyroid. Right. So I early on in my practice, when I was getting into the functional integrative space and I was getting.
- 42:44I was very comfortable treating thyroid and I struggled with some patients to find that sweet spot. Right. So like I was afraid to use T3 early on, like all like the normal stuff. And I did find that there were some patients where we really had to pull the lever really hard.
- 42:59If you pull the thyroid lever really hard, you're going to suppress TSH down to 0.001. I tried to find other reasons, but there are, for some people, that's just what you have to do in order for them to be quote unquote uthyroid. So then for those patients, if we had to do that, then I just said, we need to monitor your bone because we know that there's an association here, but it's not necessarily causative. So we have, like I said, early on, bones leave biomarkers.
- 43:25So I can do your bone turnover markers and I can tell you, are your bones getting worse at this, at this dose of your thyroid medication? And of course, imaging takes, you know, six, 12, 18 months to change, but we can verify on imaging that your bone is not getting worse and likely continuing to get better. So there's an association of quote unquote over treatment, but it is definitely not positive. And I think that if you are doing, if you're living an otherwise healthy life and doing all the nutrition and the exercise and impact all that stuff.
- 43:55It's probably not an important factor of a factor at all. I think the reason why that association exists, if you imagine if you're doing a big population study and you're looking at who is on thyroid medication, who has a low TSH, who is being treated by a doctor who's pulling that lever really hard, what's going on with them.
- 44:13you're dealing with a population likely of sick people, right? People with SIRS, people with mold exposure, people with fibromyalgia, all the things that go along with a really dysfunctional thyroid. And yeah, those people are gonna have lower bone mineral density and increased fracture risk, right? So it just, you have to understand at the patient level, at the customized patient level, like what is Dr. Amy's risk of having a TSH of 0.0001? And from a bone health perspective, it's probably nothing.
- 44:41what is the exact mechanism that happens in the body, the feedback, the mechanism where, okay, we're giving thyroid hormone and let's take that, like you said, that hypothyroid patient, not the hyper where everything is off, just that hypothyroid patient, we're working on getting their,
- 44:58free t3 free t4 and reverse t3 optimized and in doing that whoops that tsh just got suppressed because of the natural hpt access feedback loop now what is the mechanism where that would start leaching bone i mean i can't even put the piece no i don't
- 45:19I don't know. You know, actually, I think of it more the other way, which is if you look at hypothyroidism as a disease and the association of bone marrow density, it's actually associated with lower bone marrow density and increased fracture risk. Right. So it's sort of like a double edged sword. Like you don't want an you don't want an underactive thyroid because that physiology does actually make sense to me.
- 45:39So if you slow down all of your metabolism, consider the thyroid as your master conductor of all the things, if you just slow everything down, you slow down your gut motility, all your detox, all this stuff, your bone is not going to turn over well. So I think that you would potentially lose bone in a hypothyroid state. But a treated, adequately treated hypothyroid person who requires larger doses than, let's say, the average bear, what is the mechanism there?
- 46:05I don't know. Yeah. Well, no, thank you for exploring that with me because I couldn't think of the mechanism either. I've been trying, but yeah, I just don't know. Oh my gosh, that's like gold right there. My people will be so happy to hear you say that.
- 46:21Now they're going to take this information. So replay this everyone and then take notes and then you can take that back to your doctor that's freaking out over your low TSH. And you can have that doctor go watch Dr. Doug and subscribe to his YouTube channel. And maybe they'll learn something. So they'll chill out. Right. Well, I just, just tell them like, look, we don't have to guess about bones because we can do like, if their doctor really wants to look at your bones, they can do the bone turnover markers. How to do that's on my YouTube channel.
- 46:47They can do the bone turnover markers and they can repeat your imaging. It's not going to kill you for a year to be on the dose that you're on or your thyroid and then recheck your DEXA. If it goes down, then try to figure out why. It might not be from your thyroid. But hopefully if all the other things, all the other boxes are checked, it's not going to go down. It's going to stay flat and maybe even go up.
- 47:06Right. Right. I love that. I love that. So last question I have to ask, because you mentioned something earlier and you said about lifting and that's not necessarily going to help you with your bone density. Now I've always heard weight bearing exercise, but what exactly is weight bearing exercise? So if I'm doing a bicep curl or squat, I'm,
- 47:30Is that weight bearing or do I have to do like squat jumps and actually pound the ground or go for a run? Can you break down the exercise piece?
- 47:38Yeah, I don't like the term weight-bearing. We were talking about that today in our, we have a community called the Osteocollective, a bunch of people that are trying to improve their bone health on their own. And so that came up today because you're asking that same question, like, what does weight-bearing even mean? And I'm like, like from an exercise perspective, like everything's weight-bearing, right? So like it doesn't, it's not a specific enough term for me to say, this is something you should do for your bone health.
- 48:02I think if you're like a couch potato and you never get off the couch and all you do is watch Netflix and eat Fritos, then like, yeah, weight bearing, like just get up and walk is good. But if you are motivated to improve your bone health, reverse osteoporosis naturally, we need to just not worry about the term weight bearing. Let's talk about the terms of resistance and let's talk about the term impact.
- 48:21So resistance is obviously anything where you're applying a force and you're pulling, pushing, whatever. Resistance is what we want to do for our muscles. The reason why I say resistance doesn't build bone is that the research has been done for, especially like in the franchise, you know, bone building space, they have these machines that do this thing called osteogenic loading. And in the research to create these machines, they prove that you need over 4.2 multiples of your body weight to stimulate bone turnover.
- 48:494.2 multiples of your body weight and resistance training. There is not a power lever on the planet that's lifting 4.2 multiples of their body weight in any specific exercise. Right. Right. Right. So like, I mean, I just use me. My numbers are simple, right? So I weigh 200 pounds. I cannot bench press 800 pounds or squat 800 pounds. Right. And so we're not going to generate four multiples of body weight by doing any kind of resistance training. That doesn't mean resistance training isn't good.
- 49:16We don't need to do 4.2 multiples of body weight to build muscle. That's a totally different conversation. But if we want to stimulate the bone to turn over and grow, we have to breach that 4.2 multiples in the way that you do that is by using impact.
- 49:30And so if you like go back in the research again, that they created some of these machines, the research looked at what athletes have the best bone mineral density in its gymnasts. So gymnasts, even though there is an abundance of eating disorders, there's all kinds of challenges in the space because they're doing that impact over and over and over again, their bones are rock hard.
- 49:52And so then the question is, OK, well, how do I take my 80 year old grandmother and have her become a gymnast? And obviously that's not going to work. And so can we apply the stimulus in a controlled manner? And that's anywhere from doing something as simple as a heel drop to a box jump. You can use something like whole body vibration or even those osteogenic loading devices.
- 50:14all ways to impact the bone and stimulate the bone to grow because you're doing it quickly as opposed to slowly with a barbell.
- 50:23Okay. So I should continue doing my squat jumps because that impact, in addition to squatting, do my squat jumps, because that impact is going to strengthen my bone. Exactly. All right. Well, you clarified that. Thank you. That's gold. That's gold. This whole conversation has been amazing. It really has because these are questions that really have come up a lot more so recently, it seems, and, and this topic and talk around bone and bone loss. So yeah,
- 50:51I greatly appreciate you coming on and sharing your wisdom and sharing your knowledge. And if you can tell people where they can find you, and I know that we have a little something, something for them that we're going to put in the show notes as well, but let people know where they can find you. And if they are interested in going deeper, joining your community, working with you on their bone health, because they have that death sentence of osteoporosis, please share. Yeah.
- 51:18Yeah, so if you're totally new to our information, YouTube is the place where we put all the content. We have our YouTube channel is called The Dr. Doug Show.
- 51:27and it is all about bones, hormones, and health spans. So we talk about bones and hormones all day long, every day on the Dr. Doug show. So that's probably your first stopping point. If you're interested in the community, it's called the Osteo Collective. We'll give Dr. Amy the links to that. And then we also have our practice called Optimal Human Health, where all we do is bone health now. We've just stopped doing anything else. All we do is build a team to help people reverse osteoporosis naturally. And it's a lot of fun. We have an incredible team.
- 51:54And we do have a special offer for your listeners. And so we'll just give you all the details we've been talking about in the show. Beautiful. Well, thank you, Dr. Doug. I appreciate your time today and all of your wisdom and everyone listening appreciates it as well. Yeah, absolutely. Pleasure to do it.