Latest / Journey to the Fringe / The Bigfoot DNA Paper and Dr. Melba Ketchum
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:12Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe, where we put the fringe in fringe.
- 0:17I didn't have anything today, I thought that was good enough.
- 0:20We are here, host, who I swear we haven't written off the whole episode, the rest of
- 0:24the episode is good.
- 0:25I just didn't have time for the opener, guys.
- 0:29We are your pop-chess host, Taylor and Chelsea.
- 0:32Here today, we're talking about whether or not there's DNA of Bigfoot out there.
- 0:36Nice, there is.
- 0:38And specifically, if we have studied it and written it down in papers.
- 0:41I bet you we have.
- 0:43Chelsea, I think you know a bit about the story.
- 0:45I'm going to dish on this whole thing with all the sass and whatnot that comes with it.
- 0:49This story turned out a lot more interesting than I thought it was going to be, because
- 0:53when I first did it, I couldn't find anything, including the paper that's supposed to be
- 0:57on this subject.
- 0:58I've got a lot to go over.
- 1:00It's going to take a while, so let's just get right down to the start.
- 1:03Now, Chelsea, this story is predominantly about one person, Dr. Melba Ketchum.
- 1:08Have you ever heard of her?
- 1:10Yes, I have.
- 1:11And I'm sure you've heard her talk before, too.
- 1:13We covered this briefly in David Polatis.
- 1:16Yes, and he's going to come up at some point in this episode.
- 1:19Thank God.
- 1:20I was really feeling like we were missing him in this episode.
- 1:24That's all I've heard her from, to be honest.
- 1:27You're going to know her for a few things after this.
- 1:29Okay, turning to the French for what?
- 1:31So you all know she is not only the most famous relative of Ash Ketchum.
- 1:36She is also a vet.
- 1:38You know what?
- 1:39Let's just go over the coast to coast AM biography.
- 1:41Those of you who grew up in the 90s or later probably got that Pokemon joke.
- 1:46The rest of you, I do apologize for that.
- 1:48Is Ash still existing Pokemon?
- 1:50I think he does.
- 1:51He might have just retired, but he went a long time.
- 1:54Now, here's Dr. Melba Ketchum's coast to coast by geography, as we always start these
- 1:59episodes.
- 2:00She grew up in Texas City, Texas, and attended Texas AMM University, where she received her
- 2:05doctorate in veterinary medicine after five years at the university.
- 2:09She had a mixed veterinary practice until she founded DNA diagnostics.
- 2:14And Dr. Ketchum is the president and founder of DNA Diagnostics, Inc., doing business as
- 2:19Shelterwood Laboratories.
- 2:20Established in 1985, DNA Diagnostics has become a leader in all types of DNA testing, including
- 2:25human and animal forensics, human and animal paternity and parentage testing, disease diagnostics,
- 2:32trait tests, animal and human identity testing, species identification, and sex determination.
- 2:38Most common species of animal are tested at DNA diagnostics.
- 2:41Ketchum initially says that she never believed in Bigfoot, and it's due to a friend's chilling
- 2:47encounter with the creature in 1995 that was relayed to her that really made her a believer
- 2:52and brought her into this world.
- 2:53She was approached to get involved in the testing of collection samples from Bigfoot
- 2:58sightings, and that's how she got brought onto the scene.
- 3:02She got approached in, I believe it was 2008, and I can actually write that down, but it
- 3:05was some years before this all actually happened.
- 3:08And in November of 2013, after studying this stuff that they were given for five years,
- 3:13finally got to a point of publishing a scientific paper in a scientific journal.
- 3:17This was released in November of 2013.
- 3:19The research appears in the DeNovo Journal of Science, which seemed to confirm Ketchum's
- 3:24research about the reality of Bigfoot, and damn it, I forgot to include my joke about
- 3:29her having to catch them all, which is what brought her into the study of this.
- 3:33It can go here.
- 3:34That's fine, you guys will get the joke.
- 3:36From that time when this article came out, I found a live science article on it.
- 3:41It can tell us what's in it.
- 3:43The testing confirms the legendary Bigfoot is a human relative that arose some 15,000
- 3:49years ago, at least according to a press release issued by a company called DNA Diagnostics,
- 3:54detailing supposed work by a Texas veterinarian.
- 3:56The release and alleged study by Melba Ketchum also suggests such cryptids had sex with modern
- 4:02human females that resulted in hairy, hominin hybrids, but the scientific community is dubious
- 4:07about her claims.
- 4:08Quote, a team of scientists can verify that their five-year-long DNA study currently
- 4:12under peer review confirms the existence of a novel hominin hybrid species commonly called
- 4:17Bigfoot or Sasquatch living in North America.
- 4:20The researchers' extensive DNA sequencing suggests that the legendary Sasquatch is a
- 4:24human relative that arose approximately 15,000 years ago.
- 4:29For her study, Ketchum obtained three, quote, whole nuclear genomes from purported Sasquatch
- 4:34samples.
- 4:35The genome sequencing shows that Sasquatch MT DNA is identical to modern Homo sapiens,
- 4:40MT DNA's mitochondrial DNA.
- 4:42What Sasquatch Nikolai DNA is a novel unknown hominin related to Homo sapiens and other
- 4:47primate species, end quote.
- 4:50Quote, our data indicates that the North American Sasquatch is a hybrid species the
- 4:54result of males of an unknown hominin species crossing with female Homo sapiens, end quote
- 5:00the statement reads.
- 5:02So that's what came from the story.
- 5:04I should also state that on Ketchum's website at this time, Sasquatch genome project, she
- 5:09writes quote, has been a long and tedious battle to prove that Sasquatch exists.
- 5:14Trying to publish that had taken almost two years.
- 5:17It seems mainstream science just can't seem to tolerate something controversial, especially
- 5:21from a group of primarily forensic scientists and not quote famous academia and quote, still
- 5:27inside her quote, aligned with our universities, even though most of our sequencing analysis
- 5:33was performed at just such facilities, end quote.
- 5:36That's all I got to read of her scientific paper.
- 5:39It was published in DeNovo, Chelsea, I want you to go to DeNovo scientific journal, just
- 5:45type it in.
- 5:46You find it anything big foot DNA discovered the last.
- 5:49Oh, no, no, that's not the website.
- 5:51Novo Sciences dot AI.
- 5:53Nope.
- 5:54That's not it.
- 5:55It doesn't exist anymore.
- 5:57DeNovo Journal published one journal volume one issue one and it had one scientific paper
- 6:03in it.
- 6:04Do you want to guess which one?
- 6:06The exact one you're talking about.
- 6:08Yes.
- 6:09And that's it.
- 6:10And the website doesn't exist anymore.
- 6:11Well, of course, why would you have it still running?
- 6:15If you weren't publishing papers for the life of me, it is referenced in multiple places
- 6:21on the web.
- 6:22Can't find the journal entry anywhere because they all say back to the DeNovo website.
- 6:27So it doesn't exist.
- 6:28Isn't that convenient?
- 6:29I mean, it probably does exist somewhere.
- 6:31It has to because somebody wrote it.
- 6:33It's not easy to find.
- 6:35That is for sure.
- 6:36I spent a long time trying to actually find it because I wanted to read this paper.
- 6:39Instead, Chelsea, what we have to rely on is reading a critique of Ketchum's process
- 6:45and paper that was written around the time of its publish by a skeptic.
- 6:51This is titled The Ketchum Project, What to Believe About Bigfoot DNA Science Article.
- 6:55It was uploaded by Sharon Hale on February 16, 2015.
- 7:00Sharon Hale, this is all from, let me just find it really quick.
- 7:04I'm sure that's what they were going for when they took the website down.
- 7:08Please read the summary by a skeptic.
- 7:11Honestly, the best thing you can find, you can find everything about Sharon Hale and
- 7:15her background on here.
- 7:17She's written six publications on here and has 19 citations.
- 7:21It's the best thing we got.
- 7:22And that's what we're going with from here.
- 7:23And we're going to learn, Chelsea, all about the Bigfoot paper, proving that Bigfoot exists
- 7:28through DNA sampling from this perspective.
- 7:31In 2008, when her lab was picked to analyze the suspected Bigfoot Yeti hair from Bhutan,
- 7:37collected as part of Josh Gates' adventure show Destination Truth, which airs on the
- 7:40Discovery Channel in the US, Ketchum appeared twice on the show in 2009 and 2010 as a forensic
- 7:45analyst.
- 7:46She then became one of the go-to people for those who had collected DNA samples that they
- 7:50thought might be from a Bigfoot.
- 7:52Ketchum was affiliated with various corporations registered in the state of Texas, including
- 7:56one called Science Alive LLC.
- 7:58This partnership included Robert Schmalsbach, better known as Java Bob, who was previously
- 8:03an officer under Tim Biscardi's group searching for Bigfoot, and Richard Stubstead, an engineer
- 8:08who became interested in Bigfoot DNA and was a funder of Ketchum's work.
- 8:12According to Stubstead, some sort of dispute occurred in fall of 2010 as lawyers eventually
- 8:17managed to cut Schmalsbach and Stubstead out of this corporation venture, leaving Ketchum
- 8:21with the entire control of any media from publicizing Bigfoot DNA findings.
- 8:26This was not the first or last of legal dealings where Ketchum was involved.
- 8:31Ketchum had been sued and lost a claim for patent infringement that required her lab
- 8:36to stop using certain tests.
- 8:38In addition, the lab itself was not in good standing with the public, having an F rating
- 8:42by the Better Business Bureau due to complaints for delivering results, a possible problem
- 8:47with the state of Texas regarding payment to franchise taxes, and some lost client contracts.
- 8:52Ketchum responded to these issues by admitting she was naive regarding the people involved
- 8:55in Bigfootery, which is the first time I've ever heard that term.
- 8:59Some of whom she described as turning out to be unethical.
- 9:02She did not know of their reputation but wanted them removed from the study to protect its
- 9:07integrity.
- 9:08Ketchum had been associated with several other individuals and projects throughout the years
- 9:12of Bigfoot DNA collection and analyses, including the following, an Olympic project, a group
- 9:16of researchers studying habitat and attempting to obtain trail cam photos of Bigfoot, Tom
- 9:21Biscardi of Searching for Bigfoot Inc, involved with the infamous, and we'll cover this at
- 9:25some point, 2008 Georgia Bigfoot in a Freezer story.
- 9:30Chelsea, do you remember that?
- 9:31I do, yep.
- 9:32Who collected DNA samples for her project, so he's involved getting the DNA samples.
- 9:37Oh, God, I was hoping he would be.
- 9:41Wally Hursam, a generous contributor to several Bigfoot research projects, who funded at least
- 9:45some of Ketchum's work.
- 9:47Patriot Erickson of Sastwatch the Quest, who stated he has high-quality pictures and videos
- 9:51of the creature, and David Politis of North American Bigfoot Survey, who is a Ketchum
- 9:55supporter.
- 9:56Politis, an ex-police officer and author of books about missing persons and tribe of
- 10:00Bigfoot, has been particularly outspoken about Ketchum, placing the responsibility and scientific
- 10:05study of Bigfoot DNA all on her, saying each of the samples used had its own specific story.
- 10:11Ketchum alone had all the data, he says, and deserves the praise.
- 10:15NDAs were signed among participants of the project so that information would not be leaked
- 10:19prior to the reveal, but it was anyways.
- 10:21A source of these samples supposedly included a toenail tamed by Biscardi from Larry Johnson,
- 10:26blood from a smashed PVC pipe, and flesh from the remains of a Bigfoot body.
- 10:31But it's not clear that all the samples were collected properly.
- 10:35They also may have been exposed to contamination or degradation.
- 10:39With the destination true samples of 2008, apparently, the primer for her interest in
- 10:43the subject in August of 2010, Dr. Ketchum disclosed on the Coast to Coast AM radio program
- 10:48that she had a scientific paper in the works.
- 10:51The forthcoming paper provided an excuse for her to avoid discussing the results at the
- 10:56time.
- 10:57However, in the fall of 2010, Ketchum was doing additional interviews about her work.
- 11:02Ideas about Bigfoot being a type of human were already formed by other Bigfoot researchers.
- 11:06A copyright filing in her name dated September 2010 described a media project related to
- 11:12quote a new tribe of living humans, end quote.
- 11:15The theme of a book or video was to be quote Sasquatch as a modern human with some genetic
- 11:20mutations accounting for their physical appearance, end quote.
- 11:24This copyright notice foreshadowed the results of her DNA study, stating that the project
- 11:28would describe quote complete Sasquatch mitochondrial genome sequence and nuclear DNA deviations,
- 11:34end quote.
- 11:35Ketchum later brushed aside the notice saying it never came to fruition.
- 11:39This idea also corresponded to hypotheses proposed by Damon Politis and his book Tribal
- 11:43Bigfoot published in 2009.
- 11:46So weird that she's coming to the same conclusion that Politis had in 2009 and is in fact trying
- 11:51to copyright said thing.
- 11:53News about Ketchum and the various Bigfoot projects was fed by rumors, speculation, and
- 11:57opinions that appeared unsourced on the internet.
- 11:59The social media aspect, especially personal weblogs, sites, and the Facebook network have
- 12:04provided a near steady stream of both clear and dubious information.
- 12:08Melba herself became active on her own Facebook page in 2009, providing information directly
- 12:13to the public.
- 12:14In June 2012, the public page went away and only the private friend page existed.
- 12:18Several Bigfoot themed blogs dutifully reproduced any news she posted on Facebook verbatim.
- 12:23She occasionally did address questions about the study on her page but often referred questions
- 12:28to her publicist, Sally Raimi, who possibly also posted updates on this page.
- 12:33Therefore it was not clear who was actually supplying the content for her Facebook page.
- 12:37In late 2011, Ketchum provided an update on Facebook that results were complete and the
- 12:41paper was being submitted for publication.
- 12:43She told her followers to be patient, good science takes time.
- 12:47Citing the famous skeptical mantra, quote, extraordinary claims require extraordinary
- 12:51proof.
- 12:52This is what we are doing, she added.
- 12:54She appeared confident that her data would stand up to scrutiny.
- 12:57However, Ketchum herself avoided opportunities for appearing in public.
- 13:01She was a no show at two conferences in which she was scheduled to speak about Bigfoot DNA,
- 13:05a Bigfoot conference in Hanobia, Oklahoma in October 2011 and in Richland, Washington,
- 13:11Bigfoot conference in May 2012.
- 13:13For the latter, she completed a DNA 101 presentation via Skype peer connection.
- 13:18These observers in attendance reported their disappointment to interested Bigfoot bloggers.
- 13:22The community of Bigfooters expressed their concerns that she was avoiding questioning
- 13:27by not appearing in public and completely controlling the discussion while everyone waited, hopeful
- 13:31for concrete results.
- 13:32However, Ketchum has alleged that she chose not to attend because there was a threat against
- 13:36her person at one of these events.
- 13:39Every week, a diligent few searched for the embargoed papers awaiting publication.
- 13:44There are many false alarms.
- 13:45A prolific blogger named Robert Lindsay was a major informant who published inside information
- 13:50and leaks from the various Bigfoot projects and activities for several years.
- 13:54Throughout 2012, he sparked interest in multiple occasions that the Ketchum paper would be
- 13:58published very soon.
- 13:59It wasn't.
- 14:00There were rumors that the paper had been submitted to the prestigious journal Nature,
- 14:04but it had been sent back due to a lack of qualified authors or testable hypothesis.
- 14:09In February 2012, Ketchum implored her followers to have patients saying, quote, our data is
- 14:14amazing and beautiful and all cutting edge.
- 14:17End quote.
- 14:18That sounds like a Trump quote right there.
- 14:21Our data is amazing and beautiful and all cutting edge.
- 14:24It actually really does.
- 14:25Now that you say it again after you said it sounds like Trump, it absolutely does.
- 14:30She also noted she was creating a website for non-scientists to be able to access the
- 14:34paper and understand what it means.
- 14:36This was seen to be in the works in December 2012 on the DNA Diagnostics website.
- 14:41Ketchum continued to hurry up and wait by suggesting that revisions were requested for
- 14:45the paper, but it was never made clear if it was actually accepted anywhere for publication.
- 14:50She bragged that the paper had double digit co-authors, many with PhDs and some university
- 14:55heads of departments.
- 14:57In July, she assured followers that the basis were covered and quote, it will be worth the
- 15:01wait.
- 15:02End quote.
- 15:03Throughout 2012, her supporters in the Bigfoot community grew frustrated by the secrecy and
- 15:07delays, confidence in the Ketchum project and in Melba herself eroded.
- 15:11The red flags noted commentators include rumors of infighting among the project members, the
- 15:16fractioning of the original group of participants, the ever-moving release date for the data,
- 15:22and concerns over the sample origins and the ability to result to withstand scrutiny of
- 15:26the scientific community.
- 15:28To be clear, many scientific papers do take months of waiting and back and forth exchanges
- 15:33to revise the manuscript prior to publication.
- 15:35So this frustration by spectators was unfounded and should, in fairness, not have been attributed
- 15:39to Ketchum creating delays.
- 15:41Ketchum threw many observers for a loop when she disclosed that she had actually seen the
- 15:45creatures herself and described them as quote, peaceful and gentle.
- 15:50This was the whole thing.
- 15:51She was a neutral bystander in this, like just a scientist.
- 15:55And then she started talking about how she'd actually seen them and she fully believes
- 15:59in them.
- 16:00This is going off the rails here quickly.
- 16:02And the paper hasn't even come out yet.
- 16:04In April of 2012, she made public a photo she said she took with her mobile phone of
- 16:09an array of sticks in the forest with the suggestion that it was made by the creatures.
- 16:13This blurry sticks picture incited nasty comments on forums and blogs by a discouraged
- 16:18audience who bemoaned this unprofessional behavior.
- 16:21Ketchum claimed to have additional evidence to support the claim that a family of five
- 16:25playful Sasquatch repeatedly visited a site known as habituation site.
- 16:30But she did not reveal the location or further details.
- 16:33Her comments stated that her personal experiences were not meant to convince the non-believers.
- 16:38The DNA study would do that.
- 16:40Meanwhile, a parallel Bigfoot DNA project was launched by Brian Sykes, professor of
- 16:44human genetics at University of Oxford and Dr. Michelle Sartori, director, Musee de Zoology
- 16:51in Switzerland.
- 16:52This Oxford project invited submissions of indeterminate DNA samples as part of a larger
- 16:57inquiry into the genetic relationship between our human species and other hominids.
- 17:02According to the published schedule for this project, samples were to be collected from
- 17:05May to September 2012, analyzed from September through November with a paper to be prepared
- 17:10for publication before the end of 2012.
- 17:12Because the peer review process does indeed take months and perhaps up to a year, we should
- 17:15not expect to see the results published until possibly well into 2013.
- 17:19Dr. Sykes attained a copy of Ketchum's paper to analyze and told me through personal
- 17:23communications that he has no comment on it, as of the time that this piece was released,
- 17:28nor any updates on his own project to share.
- 17:30That is a different tactic from the parade of social leaks Ketchum provided Dr. Meldrum.
- 17:35of Idaho State University as a well-known academic involved in big research, has also
- 17:39steered clear of the Ketchum project and instead backs the Sykes study, perhaps even by submitting
- 17:43a sample towards it.
- 17:45Meldrum was also critical in semi-public of the Ketchum, quote, science by press release
- 17:50approach, end quote.
- 17:52It surely did not help Ketchum's reputation that she was associated with Igor Bertsev,
- 17:57a Russian Yeti researcher.
- 17:59In recent past, Meldrum expressed a noise with the approach of Bertsev and the Russian
- 18:03scientists eager about the study of Bigfoot and the native lands.
- 18:07When fall 2012 came and no paper had yet appeared, things started to turn sour for the Ketchum
- 18:12camp.
- 18:13In September, Ketchum's public relations person, Sally Raimi, was gone.
- 18:17She was replaced by Robin Lynn Pfeffer, a woman who claimed a family of Bigfoot lived
- 18:22on her land in Michigan.
- 18:24She refers to them as the forest people.
- 18:26She is known in the Bigfoot community for her wildly publicized comments that her Bigfoot's
- 18:31like blueberry bagels.
- 18:33Pfeffer's however does not appear to have any experience in either science or in public
- 18:37relations.
- 18:38It is not clear why or how Pfeffer was named as Ketchum's spokesperson.
- 18:43Observers noted in October that Ketchum's lab building in Timson, Texas was closed
- 18:47and up for lease.
- 18:48The phone had been disconnected.
- 18:50One blogger followed up and discovered a backstory of Ketchum's missing payments and her neglect
- 18:54of the business itself.
- 18:56The business nevertheless still exists, but at a different mailing address.
- 19:01Ketchum's key to gaining acceptance for her Bigfoot DNA claims was published in a respective
- 19:05peer-reviewed scientific journal.
- 19:06But the plan went awry.
- 19:08The complicated bicks of people, secrecy, delays, and promises boiled over in late November
- 19:13when news of the study was outed by Igor Bertsev.
- 19:16The self-appointed head of the Russian-based International Center of Hominology, Bertsev
- 19:20issued this urgent announcement on his Facebook page on November 23rd.
- 19:24Quote, the DNA analysis of the Bigfoot Sasquatch specimen conducted by Dr. Melba Ketchum, the
- 19:30head of DNA diagnostics, Timson, Texas, has been over.
- 19:34End quote.
- 19:35That doesn't really make any sense.
- 19:36Oh well.
- 19:37He stated that the team of Americans 90s led by Ketchum analyzed 109 purported samples
- 19:41of the creature.
- 19:42Ketchum sounded somewhat dismayed when responding to the leak saying, quote, it is unfortunate
- 19:46that the partial summary of our data was released in this manner.
- 19:49However, I will be making a formal response in the next few days.
- 19:53Even though Igor Bertsev released this, it was not Dr. Bertsev's fault, end quote.
- 19:58She later admitted that possibly misunderstanding due to language and eagerness was why the
- 20:02Don disclosure agreement was breached.
- 20:04At this point, she felt that the study must be addressed instead of ignoring the leak,
- 20:08and that might cause further damage if left unattended.
- 20:11After the official announcement of the results in November, Ketchum appeared in a few media
- 20:15interviews.
- 20:16In one, she mentioned that the paper of the study would be accompanied by high-definition
- 20:20video footage of the creature.
- 20:21The origin of his video is the Ericsson project.
- 20:24On its website, Ericsson mentions the video and the many samples they collected that were
- 20:28analyzed for DNA.
- 20:29Back in February 2012, Ketchum had thanked Ericsson for funding support for DNA testing.
- 20:35None of the footage has been released except for one still shot of a hairy, indeterminate
- 20:39shape on the forest floor, and here say that the images were all either wonderful or not
- 20:44convincing.
- 20:45The Ericsson project website went down for a while in November of 2011 when it rumored
- 20:49that Ericsson had run out of money for it.
- 20:52In resurface in 2012, a few scientists have spoken out showing enthusiasm and interest
- 20:57in the Ketchum results.
- 20:58Others were scathing in their criticism against her and the entire concept of the study.
- 21:02To fuel further ridicule, the quote, unknown novel and quote, DNA was publicized as angel
- 21:08DNA by blogger Lindsay.
- 21:10A few press release outlets included this mention in their pieces Dr. Ketchum denies
- 21:14ever using such a label.
- 21:16David Politis, the director of the North American Bigfoot Research, once again threw support
- 21:21behind the results and Ketchum saying quote, Dr. Ketchum originally found the combination
- 21:25to unlock Bigfoot DNA and utilized top scientists in various fields to validate the results.
- 21:31The results were independently verified with the group silently sitting on these findings
- 21:34for months as the results were validated a third and fourth time and quote, if true,
- 21:40that may explain the delays exhibited through 2010 to 2011.
- 21:43Politis had more commentary to add regarding the DNA.
- 21:46In the press, his quoted as saying that quote, it falls in the realm of human end quote experts
- 21:52in the field of human DNA study may wonder why they weren't consulted for her publication.
- 21:56The worldwide media coverage over the press release from Ketchum on November had not quite
- 22:01died down when on December 6 Igor Bircev was spilling more news on Facebook saying the paper
- 22:07was rejected by the US journals but is now under review in a Russian journal.
- 22:11Bircev issued a scathing review of what he considers the closed-minded American science
- 22:16establishment and the rejection of Bigfoot noting that the creature's existence is accepted
- 22:20by the public as if scientific truth is somehow based on popular vote.
- 22:24Response from the Ketchum camp was incoherent with Robin Lynn remarking contrary to Bircev
- 22:29that the paper was still under review and quote, extremely scientific end quote.
- 22:34Again we are left wondering what role Bircev was playing with this drama.
- 22:38There may be some truth in the allegations that reputable science journals could not
- 22:42touch the study due to its association with Bigfoot.
- 22:45Because there is no type specimen or any corroborate incredible physical evidence, there is no
- 22:50justification for mentioning a creature known only for folklore in the study.
- 22:56Scientifically all of this results could say is that the DNA is unidentified.
- 23:00Which yes, if you're writing it scientifically, you should remain neutral like that.
- 23:05Yeah, that sounds like a rubber thing to do.
- 23:08Then the paper finally appears.
- 23:10On February 12, 2013, Ketchum commented on Facebook media outlets.
- 23:14Buckle up and the next day the paper appeared along with a press release.
- 23:18The study, quote, North American hominins next generation sequencing of three whole
- 23:23genomes and associated studies, end quote, which analyzed DNA from a total of 111 high
- 23:28quality samples submitted from across the continent appeared in the inaugural issue
- 23:32of DeNovo Journal of Science.
- 23:35The co-authors were Ketchum, Wojcowicz, Watts, Spence, Holdzenberg, Toller, Pritchettko,
- 23:43Zhang, Bollinger, Scholders, and Smith.
- 23:46The paper describes the conclusion stated earlier in the November pre-paper press release
- 23:51that both the mitochondrial and nuclear DNA were sequenced.
- 23:54The mitochondrial DNA inherited from the maternal side was human, but the nuclear DNA was not.
- 24:00This consisted of a structural mosaic of, quote, human and novel non-human DNA, end quote.
- 24:06Upon attempting to access the paper the morning it appeared, I encountered the next huge misstep
- 24:11by Ketchum.
- 24:12The journal DeNovo is a brand new online outlet that consists of one issue with only this
- 24:18one paper.
- 24:20The website is clunky and amateurishly designed with stock, sciency photos of animals and test
- 24:26tubes.
- 24:27The strangely placed by now button was in the center, yet on one page the words DeNovo
- 24:31Open Access floats in a blank box.
- 24:34For a moment I did think the paper was freely available.
- 24:37Not so.
- 24:38Clicking on the by now button I was taking to the checkout page that charged $30 to access
- 24:43it.
- 24:44What?
- 24:45Backing out of the site to look for other reactions I noticed that several bigfoot bloggers
- 24:49had already obtained complimentary copies, or they had managed to download the paper for
- 24:54free of a slight glitch.
- 24:56I requested through email to the address in the press release a complimentary press copy
- 25:00as well.
- 25:01The inquiry was not answered.
- 25:02I was provided two review versions of the paper later in the day via other means.
- 25:06Regarding the origin of DeNovo, Ketchum said on the day of the paper release that an unnamed
- 25:11journal had accepted the paper after peer review was completed, but their lawyer advised them
- 25:15not to publish due to the disreputable topic.
- 25:18Instead of continuing to shop the paper to other sources, she decided to acquire the rights
- 25:22to this unnamed journal.
- 25:24Suspected to be the journal of advanced and multidisciplinary exploration and zoology.
- 25:29Looking into the history of that journal, investigators found it was registered under
- 25:32Ketchum's name on January 9th, 2013.
- 25:35This led to serious ethical questions about the publishing.
- 25:38The DeNovo website was created on February 4th, 2013, just nine days prior to the release
- 25:43of the paper.
- 25:44Ketchum claims to have documentation of the prior reviews and from the acquisition of
- 25:48the new journal.
- 25:50These and any information on which journals previously rejected the paper have not used
- 25:54yet been released.
- 25:55In the announcement of the paper, Ketchum mentioned two associated websites, the Sasquatch
- 26:00Genome Project and the Global Sasquatch Foundation.
- 26:03Both were produced with what appeared to be the very basic web tools hosted on low volume
- 26:08servers.
- 26:09Both sites failed the first day possibly due to the traffic.
- 26:12Prior to their inaccessibility, I captured some information published on them.
- 26:16On the Sasquatch Genome Project, Ketchum denied she self-published and took a dig at the scientific
- 26:21community.
- 26:22We encountered the worst scientific bias in the peer review process in recent history.
- 26:27End quote.
- 26:28Again, sounds like a Trump quote.
- 26:29What's her deal?
- 26:31I guess Trump wouldn't have said recent history.
- 26:33He called it the Galileo effect and suggested that she was treated unfairly.
- 26:36Ketchum's explanation for publishing in DeNovo was that she was eager to get the data out
- 26:41there and not have to deal with further rejections, hinting that all the previous reviewers were
- 26:45less than decent or open-minded seemingly because they rejected her work.
- 26:49On the Global Sasquatch Foundation site, the statement appeared, quote,
- 26:53Due to the efforts of our founder, Dr. Melba Ketchum, it has been proven that Sasquatch
- 26:57are a human hybrid.
- 26:59Here at GSF, we have made it a priority to protect these indigenous peoples from being
- 27:03hunted, harassed, or even killed, end quote.
- 27:07One could assert that this statement was premature considering the scientific community had not
- 27:10assessed her conclusion.
- 27:11Regardless, she had extreme confidence in her results.
- 27:14The Foundation site also included pictures of stick structures supposedly constructed
- 27:18by the creatures and a photo of a matted horse mane.
- 27:21An example of what Ketchum had alleged is Sasquatch's braids is in the horse manes.
- 27:26As for the paper itself, it was incomprehensible to those without specialized training in genomics
- 27:31or forensics.
- 27:32It began with the premise that Sasquatch exists and this study helps to confirm that.
- 27:36Two days later, Ketchum announced through social media that unnamed, quote,
- 27:40Top Level Scientist, end quote, volunteered to assess her data.
- 27:44A few days after that, a statement appeared on the Danova website from David Swenson,
- 27:49a biochemist, who said he reviewed the manuscript and agrees with the conclusion.
- 27:53The statement, as well as Ketchum's own statement, and those of her spokesperson,
- 27:57were all riddled with grammatical and typographical errors.
- 28:00The few experienced geneticists who viewed the paper reported a dismal opinion of it,
- 28:05noting it made little sense.
- 28:07The DNA sequences did indeed contain matches to a human chromosome, 11.
- 28:11A lot of the undetermined DNA and some that in part matched to other animals.
- 28:16Thus, the whole sequences do not resemble any known animal and are contradictory with
- 28:21evolutionary biology.
- 28:23In a curious side note, the term Danovo is used in bioinformatics to designate the absence
- 28:29of a reference genome.
- 28:30Next generation sequencing technology was used in the study to read the whole genome,
- 28:34a process that used to be far more time and labor intensive.
- 28:38There are problems with NGS, Danovo protocols that can lead to poor quality data.
- 28:43We do not know if the results were properly evaluated prior to concluding that the genome
- 28:47data could be used and if the interpretation of the results is reasonable.
- 28:51These factors will likely come into play during the external review of the paper.
- 28:55Some critics have stated that the DNA may have been contaminated.
- 28:59Ketchum assures everyone that she fully accounted for contamination issues and dismisses its
- 29:03allegations citing her own lab's experience with handling forensic crime samples.
- 29:07The samples have not been made available to others, so there is currently no way for anyone
- 29:12to run a test to compare results.
- 29:15There appears to be multiple places where the data quality could have been compromised
- 29:18regardless of how confident Ketchum is in her results.
- 29:22Accompanying the official version of the paper was Ericsson's video which supposedly showed
- 29:25a sleeping Sasquatch.
- 29:27Made public a day later showed a brown furry mass sleeping on a woodland floor.
- 29:32Ericsson project claimed that the DNA was obtained from this individual named Matilda,
- 29:36which was analyzed as part of the Ketchum study providing a link to a real creature.
- 29:40The promised high definition video evidence was not made available.
- 29:44Within a week, researcher Bill Munns claimed that he had acquired still shots of Matilda
- 29:48whereby the face strongly resembled Chewbacca, a tall, hairy, bigfoot assed creature from
- 29:53the Star Wars movies.
- 29:55If that wasn't enough to increase the derision of Ketchum's work, what may be the most
- 29:59feeling fine came from careful readers on a skeptical forum.
- 30:03Three of the references cited in Ketchum's paper as prior published research on the creatures
- 30:08were discovered to be questionable in validity.
- 30:10One was an openly stated April Fools prank that concluded the Yeti was actually an ungulate,
- 30:16hooved mammal, in that its resemblance to apes was due to convergent evolution.
- 30:21When confronted with this information, Ketchum denied responsibility saying she was told
- 30:25to include all references by one reviewer.
- 30:28She had not conceded that she knew they weren't reputable scientific works.
- 30:32So what does Ketchum have?
- 30:33Is it human DNA with an undocumented variation?
- 30:36Is it an animal sample contaminated with human DNA or vice versa?
- 30:40Is it a concocted hoax?
- 30:41Or is it actual unique DNA that may point to the existence of an unknown hominin?
- 30:47In a revealing interview on Coast to Coast AM, she told the public she is not after glory,
- 30:52would rather avoid the publicity and has turned down money making offers.
- 30:56She admitted that she wouldn't tackle this project if given another chance due to the
- 31:00trouble it created for her.
- 31:02She admits she was not privy to the culture of Sasquatchery that exists where many players
- 31:06try to either one up or discredit the other person.
- 31:09She is solidly convinced that she has enough data to unquestionably make the case for the
- 31:14existence of Bigfoot even without a type specimen.
- 31:18In the Coast to Coast AM conversation, she likened them to special forces soldiers who
- 31:22cannot be seen unless they want to be.
- 31:24She has completely accepted that they exist across North American, wishes them to be
- 31:28protected as a tribe of people.
- 31:30In the presentation of this potentially urshaking discovery, Ketchum lost every shred of scientific
- 31:36credibility through her short circuiting genetic experts and the process of peer review.
- 31:42Instead she attempted to appeal to the popular Bigfoot enthusiast crowd as their savior who
- 31:46has the goods.
- 31:47Even that backfired.
- 31:48She continued to make excuses instead of admitting her errors in poor judgment.
- 31:52She censors those who point out these serious problems or ask questions about them.
- 31:56She has not exhibited cooperation with geneticists who are experts in human DNA.
- 32:01The people supporting her are not usually helpful to her cause.
- 32:04Her disclosures about her own personal sightings and obvious missteps in the process have done
- 32:09much to sabotage her own credibility.
- 32:11It's not a pleasant picture.
- 32:13For now, Ketchum's chapter in the saga of Bigfoot remains unresolved.
- 32:16There's one thing we can be certain of.
- 32:18This is not the end of the Bigfoot story.
- 32:20The legend will live on in the hearts.
- 32:22That's the end of the article.
- 32:25What do you think of it?
- 32:26Having not been able to read it in any way, even the abstract and only hearing critique?
- 32:32The guy that wrote The Guy or Girl did a great job, I think.
- 32:38Way better than it seems she did at putting out this information.
- 32:43It really felt like she was open to actually seeing it and it being Bigfoot.
- 32:48This is a terrible story.
- 32:50There was no way this is coming out good.
- 32:53What business does she have doing DNA?
- 32:56Sharon or Melba?
- 32:58Melba.
- 32:59Melba does have a DNA lab.
- 33:01We're actually going to talk about that a bit.
- 33:02She does have a background in veterinary studies.
- 33:04She has her doctor.
- 33:05Veterinary medicine.
- 33:07Why would that lead her to DNA diagnostics?
- 33:10I think she found an opening with it.
- 33:12She does have specialization in it.
- 33:15She has worked with courts in the past and provided expert opinions on DNA analysis.
- 33:20We're going to get that to DNA.
- 33:24It's all over the map and I'm really not sure if we could say it's non-human, human.
- 33:30Exactly what she's done.
- 33:31She's done countless, but that will come up in a minute here.
- 33:34I mean, I know I'm reading her biography.
- 33:36It says she does DNA diagnostics, but what makes her an expert in that?
- 33:41I believe she does have training in it and courses, but I couldn't actually point to
- 33:46the specific courses because all I know is she has a veterinary doctorate.
- 33:50That's all I'm looking at here.
- 33:51I can't find anything else.
- 33:53I also see here that he did a big foot and giant discoveries with George Knapp for four
- 34:00hours to full coast AM.
- 34:04He's also planned at that point on sampling giants and elongated skulls for DNA.
- 34:11So I'm surprised that George Knapp spent that much time with her.
- 34:15At that point, she's a DNA expert.
- 34:18And I will say I've listened to a couple of the podcasts she's been on in the last three
- 34:23years, I would say.
- 34:24She still asserts that this paper shows exactly what she wants it to show.
- 34:28She receives no pushback from anybody.
- 34:30That's the thing about this freaking community.
- 34:33Like they're just giving the people what they want to hear because it's so fringe.
- 34:38Well that and the broadcaster as well, they don't want to lose access to these people
- 34:42so they don't do pushback.
- 34:43I think it's as simple as saying that.
- 34:45Or they don't want to do the work because if you're hosting a daily show, like it's
- 34:49really hard to actually critically analyze everything that you're going to be talking
- 34:52about.
- 34:53That's true.
- 34:54That's true.
- 34:55But I don't know, they don't critically analyze anything.
- 34:57You think if you're doing a daily show, at least like maybe once in a while, you'd have
- 35:00the time to do it?
- 35:01Well, I'm surprised at George Knapp because George Knapp is pretty good.
- 35:06I usually pretty good.
- 35:07I listened to one today where she was on, oh, what was it?
- 35:11Spaced out radio.
- 35:12I've never heard them before I was listening to it.
- 35:14Clearly enough, he was posting from Central British Columbia, so he's somewhere near me.
- 35:19She brought up that she saw Bigfoot's out of fence mind communicating with something.
- 35:25And then also that the Kandahar giant is real, which we've covered in the past.
- 35:29It is that story is so made up.
- 35:32And I realized that every single link that I can find to get to her is also deadwind.
- 35:38Yeah, everything's down.
- 35:39She still does shows.
- 35:40She goes on very select shows.
- 35:42She maybe does for interviews a year now, I think somewhere in that range of like two
- 35:46to seven.
- 35:47She thinks she would exist somewhere.
- 35:49Oh, she does, Chelsea.
- 35:50I'm going to send you to her.
- 35:53Which one am I on here?
- 35:54Sorry, I have way too many links open.
- 35:56Her GoFundMe page.
- 35:59Looks like the Sasquatch genome project website.
- 36:02Well, there's the picture.
- 36:03So she has asked for $20,000 to help fun.
- 36:07Augman.
- 36:08She has Bigfoot, Dogvan, Giant and others DNA that she now wants to study and she made
- 36:14$20,000.
- 36:15And good news, everybody.
- 36:16She has $26,000 as of reading a podcast.
- 36:21So she still does have a following out there.
- 36:23This is crazy.
- 36:25The even crazier thing I found out about her, Chelsea.
- 36:29If you search her name on Amazon, she has a couple books that she wrote that I don't
- 36:36know how to describe them.
- 36:37They're either young adult fiction about a family of Bigfoot's living in the forest
- 36:42or their romance erotic Bigfoot novels.
- 36:45I can't tell.
- 36:46But she was writing these just after her DNA scientific paper came out because they start
- 36:52in 2014.
- 36:53Let me take a look.
- 36:54But I also have to say about this GoFundMe.
- 36:56At least David Wilcock is on YouTube working for his donation.
- 37:01He has a grandma.
- 37:05He will whore himself out there for every dollar.
- 37:11Why can't I find this?
- 37:13I'm an Ascendant.
- 37:14I'm sad I miss that life.
- 37:16Stick for his memories.
- 37:17Oh, they're holding hands.
- 37:19Yeah, I can't tell if it's supposed to be young adult or if it's supposed to be romance.
- 37:22Is that a Bigfoot?
- 37:23Is that supposed to be a Bigfoot?
- 37:25Chelsea, do you want to read the quote from the book?
- 37:28Oh, I was going to read the review.
- 37:30They're all five stars.
- 37:32Please just read that.
- 37:33Okay, quote.
- 37:34If only I hadn't gotten lost.
- 37:36If I hadn't strayed into the woods, none of this would be happening.
- 37:40I wouldn't break Garrett's heart.
- 37:42I wouldn't have hurt my parents and my brother.
- 37:45Sorry, I wouldn't have.
- 37:47It's all my fault.
- 37:50If only I hadn't been so foolish.
- 37:53She shided herself as tears ran down and a torrent down her face.
- 37:57What have I done?
- 37:58Lucy McKay has decisions to make that will change her life forever.
- 38:03The form between the mystical and oftentimes dangerous world of the forest people and her
- 38:09normal teenage life with her family, she must choose.
- 38:13But how can she, when she longs for both, only Gracie can decide the forest people?
- 38:19Yeah, that's the Bigfoot.
- 38:20That's what she calls them.
- 38:21That's their tribe she wants to protect.
- 38:23That's fucking weird.
- 38:24Exactly.
- 38:25Now, imagine you want to be taken seriously as a scientific author of a very serious
- 38:32Bigfoot paper and within the year you write, I can't tell Chelsea.
- 38:37Young adult or romance novel?
- 38:39Which one is it?
- 38:40Young adult for sure.
- 38:41Look at the picture on the back.
- 38:42Oh, and their teeth?
- 38:43Yeah.
- 38:44Do you think this is AI?
- 38:45No, this is before AI.
- 38:46And Chelsea, there's another one called Mystic Forest Wishes and it has the same picture
- 38:50on the back.
- 38:51Yeah, do you want to read some of the reviews?
- 38:53They're all five star.
- 38:55Gracie and Zari's adventures continue.
- 38:58Great sequel.
- 38:59The stories of Gracie and Zari continue in this book.
- 39:02Gracie struggles with teenage angst as she tries to try Slyman Balsari's words and her
- 39:09own at the same time.
- 39:11Learning to live in two worlds opens up news perspectives and makes bought her and Zari
- 39:17better people.
- 39:18That's thirsty for truth that reviewed that.
- 39:21Booty, love, love, love this book.
- 39:23Next book, please.
- 39:24Love this one.
- 39:25Amazon customer.
- 39:26Fantastic book.
- 39:27It's just me wishing I didn't have to wait for the next in the series.
- 39:30Can I mark it helpful?
- 39:32That's it.
- 39:33Well, I guess they're-
- 39:34Someone's getting it for their birthday.
- 39:37But yeah, like I said, Chelsea, like everything to do with this journal and this paper disappeared.
- 39:42As far as I can tell immediately upon it being released, it's still touted to this day as
- 39:49a very real scientific journal paper that needs to be taken seriously.
- 39:53That is so bizarre and it's nowhere to be found.
- 39:56David Politis, June 24th, 2019 on Coast to Coast AM, quote from this episode.
- 40:00No, well, yes, I get it.
- 40:01In the second hour, Politis talked about various types of evidence for Bigfoot, including
- 40:05Melba Ketchum's DNA testing, which indicated that the creature is actually a type of human
- 40:10hybrid.
- 40:11This was six years after that debacle of it being released.
- 40:16That is messed up.
- 40:17She knows that is not real.
- 40:20I also just say, I have to say this quick, this is going back a little bit.
- 40:23I tried to find the book myself on Amazon and I'm looking at a bunch of Ketchum and
- 40:29it turns out I spelled your name wrong.
- 40:31Okay.
- 40:32There's some Melinda's Ketchum.
- 40:35It looks pretty good.
- 40:37That's probably more reputable.
- 40:38I will say that.
- 40:39Probably.
- 40:40It looks pretty nice.
- 40:42I don't really know what Melba's doing outside of this Bigfoot and was I cryptid DNA study
- 40:49because I have to redo this other article I found.
- 40:52In June 2021, Dr. Ketchum was accused by the Harris County Public Defender's Office of
- 40:57professional misconduct related to her forensic analysis in a criminal trial.
- 41:01Well, Ketchum committed misconduct when she testified about the forensic analysis of canine
- 41:05DNA while knowing her laboratory was not accredited under Texas law.
- 41:09The complaint also alleged Ketchum presented incomplete and misleading testimony regarding
- 41:14the DNA analysis in the case by failing to explain the limitation of her opinion.
- 41:19The commission finds the testimony of Ketchum in the trial was incomplete and poses substantial
- 41:23risk of misleading the trial of fact.
- 41:25The commission also found Ketchum was aware of and consciously disregarded the accepted
- 41:30standard of practice as set forth in purviewed articles she co-authored.
- 41:34Ketchum's testimony constitute professional misconduct because she was aware of and consciously
- 41:39disregarded any accepted standard of practice.
- 41:42Oh shit.
- 41:43Through Dr. Ketchum's testimony in the trial, though Dr. Ketchum's testimony in the trial
- 41:47was separate from her Bigfoot research, they are closely related.
- 41:50For example, her analysis in both cases involved misidentification of mitochondrial sequencing
- 41:55of non-human hairs overstating the certainty of her conclusion.
- 41:59And just regarding accepted standards of practice in her field, her expert testimony misconduct
- 42:03is in some ways more serious than that of her Bigfoot research as it occurred in the
- 42:07context of a criminal trial and could have contributed to an innocent person being wrongly
- 42:11convicted or a guilty person's going free.
- 42:14And I will end it there.
- 42:16Turns out she's not that good at it and it was funny because in some of the interviews
- 42:21I was listening to she said that the Bigfoot paper impacted her work with the court because
- 42:25she gets discredited for working on the Bigfoot case when really they're pointing to it as
- 42:30very shitty genetic analysis.
- 42:33Not because you did Bigfoot work.
- 42:35People are probably pretty quick to accept that as an answer who we're looking for, who
- 42:40are really heated about stuff like this coming up.
- 42:44That's pretty damning.
- 42:46This is a court that saying, you know, you're not properly doing your work as a professional.
- 42:51And particularly in the exact same way that you're claiming you've done your work in the
- 42:55Bigfoot project, not claiming it in there, just kind of being able to cross reference
- 42:59it that way.
- 43:00Just right there.
- 43:01You can tell right away that she doesn't do her work as a professional.
- 43:05She's able to get 26 grand from people to continue on.
- 43:08So I guess we may have a follow up episode on Dr. Melba Ketchum at some time in the near
- 43:12future.
- 43:13I hope she keeps putting out books.
- 43:16See, it's been 10 years since the last one.
- 43:18I think this might be the conclusion of the Mystic Forest, unfortunately.
- 43:23She has some people that are waiting.
- 43:26Well, that's crazy.
- 43:28Thank you to the person who did the fricking.
- 43:31Yeah, Sharon, you know what?
- 43:32Sharon Hill, your life's end to the skeptic community.
- 43:36That was a fantastic breakdown of something that had to be done at the time because you
- 43:39can't find it anymore.
- 43:41Better listen to the podcast for free for the rest of her life.
- 43:44We'll send her a free copy in the email.
- 43:46Yeah, but if floppy disk.
- 43:49I gotta say, a comment, of course, spring came in the latest.
- 43:53It's six years later and he comes saying that this is credible work.
- 43:57God, I love that.
- 43:58I'm sure you could find it other places.
- 44:00I just, I always check coast to coast because I know he's on there and they actually do
- 44:03a fairly good job of working down what's discussed.
- 44:06So I was like, I bet it's in here and Sharon out.
- 44:08What's the point in him?
- 44:10He's going to call him out on it.
- 44:12Like these guys only go on shows that don't call him out.
- 44:15He's so hard pressed to give an answer of what's missing for when one is, which I think
- 44:20he's now saying is UFOs.
- 44:22I'm really behind on him.
- 44:24But why specifically if you're so cautious to not be discredited by saying something,
- 44:32why would you get behind someone like that doesn't make sense?
- 44:35But he's he's an asshole.
- 44:37So he's on the list.
- 44:39The show that's coming, we know it.
- 44:41We did an episode on him at the asshole episode, but the asshole episode on David Blatis was
- 44:46one of the episodes we got pushed back on to.
- 44:49That's where the was that the in a nap.
- 44:50Yeah, that was the in a laughter episode.
- 44:53Oh yeah, it was.
- 44:54I love a name laughter, but in any event, I have been Taylor here with Chelsea.
- 44:58We are journey to the fringe.
- 45:00Thank you all for listening and we'll see you next week.
- 45:05Thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe.
- 45:07If you have liked what you have listened to, please like, share, subscribe or follow,
- 45:13depending on what venue you are listening to us through.
- 45:17Also please, if possible, leave a five star review as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 45:23Should you wish to interact with us, please check us out on your social media of choice.
- 45:28I bet you we are there.
- 45:29And if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas for new episodes or tell
- 45:34us that we're wrong and terrible either way, please send us an email.
- 45:37At Journey to the Fringe at gmail.com.
- 45:41For now, I'll see you in the next episode.