Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Constantly Interrupts
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I want to start with something I bet every manager in our audience has dealt with: the employee who constantly interrupts. Not just once in a while — I mean the person who cuts people off in every meeting, finishes sentences, jumps in before someone else is done. Luna: Oh, that's a tough one. Because on one hand, you want people to be engaged and contributing. But on the other, it can really damage team dynamics if it goes unchecked. Lucas: Exactly. And the reason I want to dig into this today is that most advice I see is either too aggressive — like 'call them out in the moment' — or too passive — like 'just let it slide.' Neither really works. So I want to look at a specific case: a marketing manager at a 200-person software company I'll call Jenna. Luna: What was Jenna's situation? Lucas: Jenna managed a team of four. One of her direct reports, a guy named Derek, was brilliant — really sharp, great ideas — but he interrupted constantly. In team meetings, in client calls, even in one-on-ones with Jenna. Other team members started to withdraw. One person told Jenna privately: 'I just stop talking when Derek's in the room because he'll take over anyway.' Luna: That's a red flag. If people are disengaging, you've got a real problem. Lucas: Right. So Jenna came to me and said, 'I need to fix this, but I don't want to squash his enthusiasm.' And that's the key tension, isn't it? You want to preserve the person's drive — but you also need to protect the team's ability to contribute. Luna: So what did she do? Lucas: She started by trying to understand why Derek interrupted. She observed for a week and noticed a pattern: he mainly interrupted when there was a pause or a moment of hesitation. It wasn't malicious — it seemed like he was trying to fill the silence, or he was afraid his idea would be forgotten if he didn't say it immediately. Luna: That makes sense. A lot of interrupters are actually anxious, not arrogant. Lucas: Exactly. So Jenna scheduled a one-on-one with Derek and used a framework I first heard from executive coach Elena Ramirez. It's three steps: name the pattern without judgment, explain the impact on others, and offer a specific alternative behavior. Luna: Can you walk us through how that sounded in practice? Lucas: Sure. Jenna said something like: 'Derek, I want to talk about something I've noticed in our team meetings. When someone's speaking and there's a brief pause, you often jump in right away. I know your intention is to move things forward, but the effect is that other people feel cut off. Some have told me they stop sharing ideas because they don't feel heard.' Then she paused. Luna: That's a brave thing to say. How did Derek react? Lucas: He was surprised — he honestly didn't realize he was doing it. That's common. Most interrupters are oblivious, not defiant. So Jenna moved to step three: the alternative. She said, 'Here's what I'd like you to try: in our next team meeting, wait three full seconds after someone finishes speaking before you say anything. Count in your head if you need to. And if you're worried you'll forget an idea, jot it down. Can we try that for a week?' Luna: Three seconds feels like an eternity in a meeting. But I can see how it rewires the habit. Lucas: It does. And Derek agreed to try. The next week, Jenna noticed a small improvement — he still interrupted a few times, but less often. She followed up and said, 'I noticed you caught yourself a couple of times. That's progress. Let's keep going.' The key is reinforcement, not reprimand. Luna: Right. Because you're coaching a new behavior, not punishing an old one. Lucas: Exactly. Now, there's another layer here. Jenna also realized she might be accidentally enabling the behavior. She had a habit of looking at Derek when she asked a question — because he always had an answer. So she started deliberately making eye contact with other team members first, giving them a nonverbal cue that she wanted to hear from them. Luna: That's smart. You're changing the environment, not just the person. Lucas: And it worked. Over about a month, the team dynamic shifted. Derek still contributed plenty, but other voices started coming through. The team's output actually improved because they were getting more diverse ideas. Luna: I think a lot of managers worry that addressing this will cause resentment. But if you do it with empathy and a clear alternative, it usually strengthens the relationship. Lucas: That's the paradox. People who interrupt often want to be seen as valuable. By coaching them, you're actually saying, 'Your input matters — and so does everyone else's.' That's a far more respectful message than silently stewing or snapping at them in a meeting. Luna: What about the person who interrupts not out of anxiety but out of genuine arrogance? Does the same approach work? Lucas: That's harder. If the root cause is a belief that their time is more valuable than others', then the three-step framework still applies — but you need to be more direct about the impact. You might say, 'When you interrupt, it signals that you don't value what others are saying. That erodes trust.' And you may need to set a firmer boundary, like, 'If it happens again in a meeting, I'll ask you to hold your thoughts until the end.' Luna: So you escalate only if the coaching doesn't take. Lucas: Right. But in my experience, the anxious interrupter is far more common than the arrogant one. Most people want to be good team players — they just need the awareness and the tools. Luna: Speaking of tools, I love that 'pause and pass' technique you mentioned. Can you describe it for someone who might want to try it with their team? Lucas: Sure. The pause and pass is a meeting norm where after someone speaks, the facilitator — or anyone — explicitly says, 'Let's pause for a moment and let that sink in, then I'd like to hear from someone who hasn't spoken yet.' It's a way to create space without singling anyone out. You can even make it a team practice: everyone agrees that after a comment, you'll count to three before the next person speaks. Luna: That's a low-stakes way to change the culture without calling anyone out. Lucas: Exactly. And if you have a team that's open to it, you can even do a fun experiment: in one meeting, ask everyone to be extra aware of pauses and let the silence breathe. Then debrief at the end. People are often surprised by how much more thoughtful the conversation becomes. Luna: I want to circle back to something you said earlier about the manager's own role. You mentioned Jenna making eye contact differently. What other self-checks should a manager do? Lucas: Great question. First, ask yourself: do I give this person more airtime because they're quick to answer? If so, you're inadvertently reinforcing the interruption. Second, check your own interrupting habits. If you cut people off, your team will mirror that. And third, notice whether you're rewarding interrupters by acknowledging their points immediately while letting quieter voices fade. Luna: So it's not just about fixing the employee — it's about fixing the system around them. Lucas: Exactly. And that's actually good news, because you have more control over the system than over someone's personality. Luna: One thing I've seen work in practice is using a talking stick or a physical object. I know it sounds silly, but in some tech teams, they literally pass a small toy around. Only the person holding it can speak. Lucas: That can work for certain teams, especially if the culture is playful. But I'd caution against imposing it without buy-in. If you just plunk a rubber chicken on the table, people might roll their eyes. Better to start with a conversation: 'Hey, I've noticed we sometimes talk over each other. Would anyone be open to trying a speaking token for our next brainstorming session?' Luna: Fair point. The key is co-creation, not top-down rules. Lucas: Right. And that brings me to a final thought: the goal isn't to eliminate interruptions entirely. Some interruptions are constructive — a quick clarification, a supportive 'yes, and' — but the chronic ones that shut people down need to be addressed. If you can reduce those by 80 percent, you've transformed your meeting culture. Luna: I think that's a realistic and encouraging target for managers. Lucas: If we've helped you think through a tricky management situation like this one, it's worth mentioning that these episodes stay ad-free because of listeners who chip in a couple of dollars a month at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It genuinely makes a difference in keeping the conversation going. Luna: Yeah, and it's a small way to support the show if it's been useful to you. Lucas: So to wrap up: if you've got a Derek on your team, try the three-step framework — name it, explain the impact, offer an alternative. And don't forget to look in the mirror. Your own meeting habits might be part of the pattern. Luna: And give it time. Changing a habit takes weeks, not one conversation. Lucas: Exactly. Thanks for listening, and we'll see you next week.