Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Reopening In Absentia Orders Following Expedited "Mega Master" Calendar Hearings
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to today's program, reopening in absentia
- 0:06orders following expedited mega master calendar
- 0:10hearings. I'm Alla Policastro, Director of Education
- 0:13and Professional Development at Beverly Hills
- 0:15Bar Association. And today I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:17our speakers, Michelle Mendez and Rebecca Chavez.
- 0:20Michelle is the legal director of the National
- 0:23Immigration Project, having previously led clinics
- 0:26defending vulnerable population program, and
- 0:29served as senior managing attorney at Catholic
- 0:32Charities of the Archdiocese of Washington, where
- 0:35she represented immigrants before immigration
- 0:37court, USCIS, and on appeals to the Board of
- 0:41Immigration Appeals and the Fourth Circuit. Her
- 0:44career includes serving as counsel on numerous
- 0:47notable federal litigation matters, co -authoring
- 0:50two AILA publications on immigration court practice
- 0:54and trial skills, and teaching at Yale Law School,
- 0:57Catholic University, and the University of Baltimore.
- 1:00She began her legal career on Equal Justice Works
- 1:03fellow sponsored by DLA Piper and currently serves
- 1:07as program director for the National Institute
- 1:10for Trial Advocacy's immigration public programs.
- 1:14Joining her is Rebecca Chavez, who is staff attorney
- 1:17at the National Immigration Project. Before joining
- 1:20the organization, she spent over four years at
- 1:22the Galveston Houston Immigration. Immigrant
- 1:25Representation Project, where she represented
- 1:27detained immigrant clients in removal proceedings
- 1:30and litigated before federal districts and appellate
- 1:32courts, including the Fifth Circuit Court of
- 1:34Appeals and the Board of Immigration Appeals.
- 1:37Throughout her career in immigration law, Rebecca
- 1:39has handled a broad range of immigration matters,
- 1:42including asylum, VAWA, self -petitions, U visas,
- 1:46and DACA applications. We're so excited to hear
- 1:48what they have to share with us today, so I'm
- 1:50now going to turn it over to them. Thank you
- 1:53so much. I really appreciate that introduction.
- 1:55So thanks everybody for joining us today for
- 1:57this webinar. As was mentioned, my name is Michelle
- 2:00Mendez. I'll go ahead and get us started before
- 2:02I turn it over to my colleague here at the National
- 2:04Immigration Project, Rebecca Chavez. So we'll
- 2:07be discussing in absentia orders recently issued
- 2:10by immigration judges during. a master calendar
- 2:14hearing known as a mega master calendar hearing.
- 2:17We'll talk about why that is and the arguments
- 2:20for reopening these in absentia orders. So if
- 2:22you have any questions, do remember to use that
- 2:25Q &A feature on Zoom. And just note that we're
- 2:28gonna be using some common immigration acronyms.
- 2:30So if you're not sure what the acronyms mean
- 2:32or stand for, do not be shy, ask us what they
- 2:35are, but we're just kind of very used to this
- 2:37immigration lingo. Next slide. All right, so
- 2:43what will we discuss during this presentation?
- 2:46So first we're gonna start by providing insight
- 2:48into the current immigration court context and
- 2:52why this context is so prejudicial when we add
- 2:56a mega master hearing and the need to reopen
- 3:00those removal proceedings. And then we're gonna
- 3:03explain what we mean by mega master. Next, we're
- 3:07gonna discuss the requirements for reopening
- 3:10an in absentia order. and the potential statutory
- 3:13constitutional and regulatory arguments for reopening.
- 3:17We're going to end that section with a couple
- 3:19of hypothetical scenarios that will allow us
- 3:21to apply these potential arguments and then finally
- 3:25we'll have some slides on practical considerations
- 3:29that we likely will not be able to cover given
- 3:31the time that we have but we did include so that
- 3:33you have them as a reference and note that our
- 3:37slides are intentionally text -heavy so that
- 3:40you can have them as a reference tool moving
- 3:42forward. But be sure to confirm that the content
- 3:46in the slides is still relevant, is still accurate,
- 3:50because the changes to immigration law are fast
- 3:53and furious. Right. Next slide. OK. So under
- 3:58this presidential administration, the immigration
- 4:01court context is ripe for in absentia orders
- 4:05of removal. and very difficult to achieve reopening
- 4:09of those removal proceedings. So this slide includes
- 4:12some of the main reasons for this, but there
- 4:15are honestly too many reasons to list for this
- 4:18one slide and for the time that we have. But
- 4:21really quickly, as you have the information before
- 4:24you, when we're talking about an in absentia
- 4:27order of removal, it means that the person did
- 4:29not appear at the hearing. And when somebody
- 4:31doesn't appear at the hearing, they're going
- 4:33to likely, if not definitively get an in absentia
- 4:38order of removal. That's what that denotes in
- 4:39case you're unfamiliar with that term. So the
- 4:43immigration court context, we are seeing where
- 4:46fair and seasoned immigration judges have been
- 4:49fired, where those who have been hired to replace
- 4:53those fired immigration judges are those that
- 4:56fit a kind of deportation immigration judge profile.
- 5:00The BIA has issued precedents signaling that
- 5:03immigration judges must issue in absentia orders
- 5:06where the respondents fail to appear. So for
- 5:09example, in the case that's listed here, a matter
- 5:11of Orozco Becerra and Orozco Becerra both. The
- 5:16BIA held that when respondents, including minor
- 5:19respondents, children, fail to appear for their
- 5:22hearing and DHS has established that the non
- 5:25-citizen who's a minor received proper notice
- 5:28of the hearing and are removable as charged that
- 5:31the immigration judge actually lacks authority
- 5:34to administratively close removal proceedings
- 5:36and must instead proceed with an in absentia
- 5:40order of removal. So what we've seen in the past
- 5:43especially under prior administrations is that
- 5:45if somebody did not show up for the hearing judges
- 5:48have been willing to use other mechanisms like
- 5:50administrative closure or a continuance to avoid
- 5:53issuing an in absentia order given how prejudicial
- 5:55it is for somebody to have one of these orders.
- 5:58The BIA has also issued president rendering suesponte
- 6:03reopening more difficult. So for example, Matter
- 6:06of Yadav is a recent case where the non -citizen
- 6:09married a U .S. citizen and was eligible to adjust
- 6:13status. Adjustment of status means that they
- 6:15became a lawful or they can become a lawful permanent
- 6:17resident in the United States without having
- 6:19to leave the country first and go through a consular
- 6:22processing. And the BIA held that post -order
- 6:26removal equities such as marriage or an approved
- 6:29I -130 family petition carry minimal weight in
- 6:33discretionary reopening requests. So that was
- 6:37a key feature of that decision. And then the
- 6:40BIA has issued precedent requiring non -citizens
- 6:42to seek a stay of removal with ICE as a prerequisite
- 6:47to filing a stay of removal with an EOIR adjudicator.
- 6:52with jurisdiction over the case. So this extra
- 6:55step of having to file a stay of removal with
- 6:58ICE is futile because ICE is not generally granting
- 7:03stays of removal and the wasted time actually
- 7:05helps ICE prepare and remove the non -citizen
- 7:08before the non -citizen is able to seek a stay
- 7:10of removal from an immigration judge or from
- 7:13the Board of Immigration Appeals. So those are
- 7:16some of the issues that we are seeing and that's
- 7:19part of the context of what's happening in immigration
- 7:22court and why the context is so ripe unfortunately
- 7:26for in absentia orders and making it so difficult
- 7:29for people to reopen any in absentia order. Let's
- 7:33go on to the next slide. All right, what are
- 7:37mega masters? So in this context that I just
- 7:41talked about, EOIR which stands for Executive
- 7:44Office for Immigration Review, decided that it
- 7:47was a good idea to schedule dozens of people
- 7:49for master calendar hearings, which are the preliminary
- 7:52hearings in immigration court. And EOIR also
- 7:55thought that it would be a good idea to include
- 7:57non -citizens with scheduled final hearings in
- 8:01this process. So this means that non -citizens
- 8:04who had already had their master calendar hearing
- 8:08in the past and were scheduled for a final hearing
- 8:11were suddenly and out of nowhere being taken
- 8:14back, a step back. out of nowhere being scheduled
- 8:17for master calendar hearings again. So of course
- 8:22scheduling a master calendar hearing out of nowhere
- 8:24especially when you have a final hearing already
- 8:27set into 2027, 2028, 2029 that presents significant
- 8:33notice problems and other problems that we're
- 8:35going to talk about. It's as if EYR is trying
- 8:39to force in absentia orders knowing how difficult
- 8:42it is to undo or to reopen that in absentia order.
- 8:47Next slide. So mobile pathways and backlog are
- 8:52two platforms that analyze complex federal databases,
- 8:57such as those from EOIR, to track system trends,
- 9:01support practitioners like yourselves, and bring
- 9:03transparency to immigration law. So they basically
- 9:06collect data. and then issue the data in these
- 9:09really great graphics, which is the one on this
- 9:11slide. And so both have been tracking megamasters
- 9:14and the in -absentia orders that have resulted
- 9:16from this practice. And so here's that graphic
- 9:19from Mobile Pathways to put it into perspective
- 9:23as to the in -absentia orders that have been
- 9:26issued since these megamasters started. So in
- 9:29-absentia orders have more than doubled since
- 9:31EOIR started using this megamaster model. And
- 9:35it suffices to say that MegaMasters is definitely
- 9:38one way that the administration is able to reach
- 9:42its mass deportation goal. With that, I'm going
- 9:45to turn it over to Rebecca. Thank you, Michelle.
- 9:51So as you've seen, it's resulted in a lot of
- 9:54in absentia removal orders. And the remedy that
- 9:58we need to seek is a reopening of these removal
- 10:01orders. So it's great to understand first, What
- 10:06the immigration judge, when they are required
- 10:09to issue an absentia removal order. So the statute
- 10:13provides when and the board of immigration appeals.
- 10:17Views this as a mandatory duty of the immigration
- 10:20judge that they must issue an absentia removal
- 10:23order when when the criteria are met, which is
- 10:27written notice is given to the non citizen or
- 10:29their attorney. They do not attend the proceeding.
- 10:34And the Department of Homeland Security Service
- 10:37has established by clear and convincing evidence
- 10:40that the written notice was provided and the
- 10:43non -citizen is removable. So these is a situation
- 10:46in which the immigration judge would issue an
- 10:48absentia removal order. And we're going to come
- 10:50back to these, but it's important to have that
- 10:52in mind. And then the statute also provides when
- 10:57a removal order can be rescinded and the case
- 11:00can be reopened. And one of those will be an
- 11:03exceptional circumstance, which we'll talk about
- 11:06in more detail. And that would need to be filed
- 11:08within 180 days of the in absentia removal order,
- 11:13or if they did not receive notice, or if they
- 11:18were in a federal or state custody. And that
- 11:22was the reason where they failed to appear. When
- 11:25we're talking about these motions to reopen,
- 11:27it's really important to know that under the
- 11:32statute, you only have right to one motion to
- 11:36reopen. And this was actually something that
- 11:40the Board of Immigration Appeals recently ruled
- 11:43on as of two days ago in a matter of MMLJ in
- 11:49which they say that you cannot get another motion
- 11:53reopened. It's not subject to equitable tolling.
- 11:56So this is why it's very important. to raise
- 11:59all the arguments that you can with this one
- 12:01motion reopen because you this person may not
- 12:04have another opportunity to do so and this has
- 12:08been the case in the fifth circuit but in the
- 12:10ninth circuit there is still case law that allows
- 12:12for equitable tolling of that one motion reopen
- 12:15so if if the person is removed in the ninth circuit
- 12:19it's very important to cite to that ninth circuit
- 12:21president even though we have this new board
- 12:23of immigration appeals decision that just came
- 12:25out two days ago. And with that, I will turn
- 12:31it back to Michelle. Great. Thank you so much,
- 12:35Rebecca. So now that we know what the statute
- 12:38says about when the judge can issue an in absentia
- 12:42order removal and what is needed in order to
- 12:46reopen, we want to break it down. And so we've
- 12:51broken it down into six arguments for you. We're
- 12:54going to take each at a time. cover them. So
- 12:57the first one is late arrival is not a failure
- 13:00to appear. There is not no deadline for that.
- 13:04The second one is DHS did not establish a movability
- 13:07during the in absentia hearing. There's no deadline
- 13:10for that either technically. The respondent did
- 13:14not have notice of the hearing. There's also
- 13:16no deadline for that. There's an exceptional
- 13:19circumstances argument where the non -citizen
- 13:22can argue that exceptional circumstances prevented
- 13:25them from appearing at the hearing, there is
- 13:28a deadline for that and that's 180 days from
- 13:31the date of the in absentia order, the date that
- 13:33it was issued. There's also in this specific
- 13:36context we think a really important due process
- 13:41argument, a procedural due process argument regarding
- 13:44notice that is different from the statutory notice
- 13:49provision. We'll talk about that. And then finally,
- 13:51there's a sua sponte reopening argument that's
- 13:55embedded in the regulation, which is not as strong
- 13:58as the statute, obviously. So this is what we
- 14:00mean by statutory constitutional and regulatory
- 14:03basis for reopening. So let's go to the next
- 14:06slide. Okay. So the first potential argument
- 14:11is that the person did not fail to appear. So
- 14:15if a person arrived late at the hearing, we would
- 14:18argue that they did not actually fail to appear.
- 14:22Remember that the statute at 240B5A says that
- 14:26a non -citizen who does not attend a proceeding
- 14:30under this section will receive an in -absentia
- 14:33order. So we're basically just going back to
- 14:36the statute and saying does my particular client's
- 14:40case fit each piece of this statute? And this
- 14:42should only actually apply if somebody does not
- 14:45attend a proceeding. Well, if my client arrived
- 14:47late, well, then they were there. They did attend.
- 14:51It's just that they were late. And so in matter
- 14:53of SLH and LBL, the BIA examined a case where
- 14:58the family arrived late at the hearing. And the
- 15:01attorney included adequate documentary evidence
- 15:04for the late arrival that had to do, I believe,
- 15:07with traffic conditions and weather, et cetera.
- 15:11So kind of unforeseen situation. And they did
- 15:15take adequate precautions in leaving early. So
- 15:18the BIA ultimately reopened the case based on
- 15:21exceptional circumstances, which we're going
- 15:23to talk about, and expressly stated that it did
- 15:26not decide whether slight tardiness constituted
- 15:29a failure to appear. In footnote two of that
- 15:32decision, the BIA noted that while the Sixth
- 15:35Circuit, where the case arose, has not issued
- 15:38a precedential decision on the issue of whether
- 15:40a late arrival constitutes a failure to appear,
- 15:43the Sixth Circuit had discussed via dicta the
- 15:47other circuit court's decisions doing so. So
- 15:50indeed, some US courts of appeals and the BIA
- 15:54and unpublished decisions have concluded that
- 15:56a late arrival is not a failure to appear. So
- 15:59this argument would be particularly strong where
- 16:02your client arrived at the hearing while the
- 16:05immigration judge was still on the bench or shortly
- 16:07after the hearing concluded. And we're going
- 16:09to actually have a scenario at the end of the
- 16:13presentation where this might come into play
- 16:15in a mega master situation. All right, but think
- 16:19about how makeup masters are being scheduled
- 16:21kind of with like not foreseen scheduling and
- 16:27so a lot of that leads to kind of late notice
- 16:30to the person that they have to appear and which
- 16:33can lead the person to kind of rushing to a hearing
- 16:36unfortunately. So if you have a case where the
- 16:40person arrived late at the hearing here are some
- 16:42tips to consider. when making a late arrival
- 16:46is not a failure to appear argument and so you
- 16:49can argue that late arrival is not a failure
- 16:51to appear and we also suggest that you alternatively
- 16:54argue exceptional circumstances which Rebecca
- 16:57is going to cover later. The evidence is crucial.
- 17:00I mean as I mentioned that decision from the
- 17:03board where you know they didn't reopen based
- 17:06on this argument but based on exceptional circumstances
- 17:10either way the evidence was is crucial so you
- 17:12want to file evidence that includes as always
- 17:15i think this isn't just for this argument but
- 17:18you always want to file as much accurate documentary
- 17:22evidence with your motion To reopen it. You're
- 17:25not going to get a hearing on it So everything
- 17:27is based on the documents that you submit with
- 17:29the motion and so but this particular argument
- 17:32though You'll want a declaration from the client
- 17:35and for other people with personal knowledge
- 17:37Describing the efforts that they took to arrive
- 17:39timely with some unforeseen obstacles that they
- 17:42faced and getting there timely the time of the
- 17:45arrival at the court and any communication with
- 17:49you IR at the hearing or at the court thereafter
- 17:54meteorology reports, if it was an uncommon kind
- 17:57of weather event, traffic reports to substantiate
- 18:01that the person did hit some kind of unusual
- 18:04traffic that day. We really want you to think
- 18:06about being detectives here when you are collecting
- 18:09evidence. And you cannot take anything for granted,
- 18:11especially under this administration's executive
- 18:14office for immigration review. All right, next
- 18:18slide, please. So the next slide here. has that
- 18:23second argument that I previewed, which is that
- 18:26you want to argue that removability was not established.
- 18:30And so this argument requires us to understand
- 18:33the mechanics of an in -absentia hearing. So
- 18:37here's what happens. If a non -citizen is not
- 18:41present at a hearing, the immigration judge is
- 18:43going to note that on the record. I mean, everything's
- 18:45on the record here should be, and then ask DHS
- 18:48for their position. and so DHS at that point
- 18:51will move her in an absentia order and then the
- 18:54judge then should be requiring DHS to prove by
- 18:59clear unequivocal and convincing evidence that
- 19:03the respondent the non -citizen received written
- 19:06notice in compliance with the statute which Rebecca
- 19:10showed us and is removable as charged so it's
- 19:14a very high burden and I see that oftentimes
- 19:17judges and the BIA get this wrong where they'll
- 19:20go a shortcut and they'll say clear and convincing
- 19:22evidence but it's clear unequivocal and convincing
- 19:26evidence and the last circuit to speak about
- 19:28the importance of this standard the actual standard
- 19:31as opposed to this shortcut standard of clear
- 19:33and convincing evidence is the first circuit
- 19:36very important cases our yeah case out of the
- 19:39first circuit as to the importance of this standard
- 19:43and its high threshold and so That's what the
- 19:47judge must require DHS to prove. And then DHS
- 19:50will usually present an I -213. What is an I
- 19:54-213? It's a record of deportable alien. That's
- 19:58what it's called. And it's kind of like the equivalent
- 20:00of like a police record, right? So a police report.
- 20:07And so they will probably use that. They often
- 20:11do. That's the most common thing I would say.
- 20:13to prove that the non -citizen is removable as
- 20:17charged. Regarding notice, there should be some
- 20:19other stuff in the record and the judge will
- 20:21have proof of that more handily than the I -213
- 20:25because the I -213 is DHS's document. So while
- 20:29the judge will usually be able to look at the
- 20:31notice stuff and if DHS rose to the high threshold
- 20:35for notice, when it comes to removable as charged,
- 20:38DHS will have to present that I -213 or some
- 20:42other evidence of the person being removable
- 20:45as charged. So the judge then needs to inspect
- 20:48DHS's evidence and determine if DHS met the high,
- 20:53clear, unequivocal, and convincing standard.
- 20:55And if the evidence submitted by DHS at that
- 20:58in absentia hearing does not rise to that level,
- 21:01that clear, unequivocal, and convincing evidence
- 21:03standard, Because of errors or other indicia
- 21:06of unreliability, you're going to want to argue
- 21:09that the in absentia order was not properly issued
- 21:12and therefore must be rescinded. How do you know
- 21:15if DHS failed to meet that very high threshold?
- 21:19Well, If you were not there and your client was
- 21:21also not there, you're going to want to obtain
- 21:25and listen to the digital audio recording known
- 21:27as the DAR. Once you enter your appearance in
- 21:30the case, you'll be able to access the DAR. And
- 21:32if you want to review the DAR before you accept
- 21:34the case, you can request it from the immigration
- 21:37court. There's a particular process. And the
- 21:4015 steps resource that we included in your materials
- 21:43includes some of this information. So we're here
- 21:46at this next slide that has some of the tips.
- 21:49for making a really good argument that removability
- 21:53was not properly established. So you want to
- 21:56review the EOIR record of proceedings. That's
- 21:59what the ROP stands for. To compare the notice
- 22:02to appear charged with the evidence of removability
- 22:05that DHS submitted, maybe DHS failed to submit
- 22:08any evidence. I've seen that before where They
- 22:11just don't submit anything. The judge didn't
- 22:13ask for anything and DHS didn't ask for anything.
- 22:14Well, he definitely didn't meet that high threshold,
- 22:17if that's the case. Maybe DHS submitted an I
- 22:19-213, but it wasn't properly authenticated. It
- 22:23was error -ridden or otherwise unreliable. Perhaps
- 22:27the charge does not match the facts. You want
- 22:30to then listen to the DAR. And as you're listening
- 22:32to the DAR, ask yourself whether the IJ put DHS
- 22:36to its burden. whether the IJ applied the correct
- 22:38standard like I said get this wrong often whether
- 22:42the immigration judge applied or rather what
- 22:47record evidence the IJ relied on to conclude
- 22:49removability was established. Okay so those are
- 22:54some tips for figuring out did DHS actually present
- 22:59clear unequivocal and convincing evidence that
- 23:02written notice was received by the person and
- 23:05that the person is removable as charged. Next
- 23:08slide. And if you have a client who received
- 23:16an I -213 when they were minors, it's especially
- 23:19important to look closely at the I -213 and scrutinize
- 23:23it for reliability concerns. I -213's issue to
- 23:27minors usually will rely on statements from minors
- 23:31themselves. or third parties that increase the
- 23:34chances of errors or inaccuracies, right? It's
- 23:37like that game of telephone. So you're getting
- 23:39it from like all these different people that
- 23:42definitely decreases the reliability factor.
- 23:47And with that, let me turn it over to Rebecca
- 23:49to take us through the next two arguments that
- 23:52you can use. So we're still on the statutory
- 23:56arguments, right? So now we're going to turn
- 23:58to written notice, and it's the same standard
- 24:02that Michelle has already talked about, that
- 24:04clear, unequivocal, and convincing evidence standard.
- 24:07So the argument being that the immigration judge
- 24:10did not properly enter the in absentia removal
- 24:13order. So when we think of notice, the languages
- 24:17did not receive notice, right? So when we think
- 24:21of notice, there's a... Substantive part of it
- 24:24and receive is a procedural part so the notice
- 24:28would be. What are the statutory requirements
- 24:32for notice and that's typically what's involved
- 24:34in the the notice to appear the notice to appear
- 24:36is the document that initiates removal proceedings.
- 24:41And then, when we think of receive did they actually
- 24:44receive that notice did they receive that notice
- 24:47to appear did they receive the notice of hearing.
- 24:50And. We talked a little bit about timing, right?
- 24:54This exceptional circumstance, if you're gonna
- 24:57argue exceptional circumstance, it has to be
- 24:59filed within 180 days. When you're making a no
- 25:02notice argument and the client did not receive
- 25:05notice, that motion to reopen can be filed at
- 25:08any time. There is no time limit and it can be
- 25:11even filed after the person has departed the
- 25:15United States. When I'm talking about the notice
- 25:21to appear, which is the initiating document,
- 25:25there are certain things that have to be included
- 25:27in the notice to appear. The nature of the proceedings,
- 25:30the legal authority, the allegations of charges,
- 25:35and the time and place of the next hearing. So
- 25:38in the past, a lot of the times, the government
- 25:40would not include a time and place in the notice
- 25:43to appear. So it's not uncommon to see a notice
- 25:46to appear that does not have a date and time.
- 25:49or place for the first hearing however recently
- 25:53they have been typically including this now um
- 25:57given like a supreme court decision that came
- 25:59out but you should still always check the notice
- 26:03to appear to see whether it has that time and
- 26:06place um included in there um and if it was not
- 26:11um if the notice to appear was not properly served
- 26:15there's an argument that there was no notice
- 26:18here. So it's really important to look both at
- 26:19the notice to appear and any other notice of
- 26:23hearings that the person might get afterwards.
- 26:28So when we talk about looking at the notice to
- 26:32appear and whether the service was proper, there's
- 26:35a part in the bottom of the notice to appear
- 26:37that you should have your, you should look at,
- 26:39which is a certificate of service, which is usually
- 26:42on the second. page of the Notice to Appear.
- 26:44And we have a screenshot here. So when you're
- 26:48reviewing the Notice to Appear, you're going
- 26:49to want to see which way it was sent. Was it
- 26:52sent through mail? Was it delivered in person?
- 26:57Was it certified mail? You're going to want to
- 27:00know who served it and who was it served upon.
- 27:03And this is going to be really important as well
- 27:05whenever we're going to talk about minors. and
- 27:08how they can be served. And you want to look
- 27:11at the language that they receive the notice.
- 27:14Because oftentimes I see that left blank or maybe
- 27:18someone speaks an indigenous language and they
- 27:20use a Spanish interpreter. So it's very important
- 27:22to look to the notice to appear to see what was
- 27:26happening if the proper person served. And also
- 27:29at the top, what address the notice to appear
- 27:32was sent to. Typically it has the address along
- 27:34with their name. and their A number, what address
- 27:38it was sent to, if it was mailed. And that's
- 27:40usually going to be the case that they mail it.
- 27:44So when we're talking about the notice to appear
- 27:46and mail, it can be sent through personal. It
- 27:52can be sent through regular mail. It does not
- 27:54have to be sent through certified mail to be
- 27:56sufficient service. But it must be served on
- 28:00the individual. and it can be allowed to be mailed
- 28:05when personal service is not practicable. Sometimes
- 28:08there's an argument that it could have been served
- 28:12in person and mail shouldn't have been the way
- 28:15to do that, but I don't usually see that being
- 28:19the immigration court agreeing with that position.
- 28:23And if they can also serve the attorney of record,
- 28:27So it's really important if that did happen and
- 28:30the attorney did not notify the client of the
- 28:34hearing that there might be an avenue to raise
- 28:38ineffective assistance of counsel claim against
- 28:41that attorney. And we're going to talk about
- 28:42that later when we get to the exceptional circumstances
- 28:44too, but it still should be raised here in the
- 28:48notice part of the statutory argument because
- 28:52that would support that they did not receive.
- 28:56the notice, that procedural argument. And like
- 29:00I said, the Board of Immigration Appeals has
- 29:03found that regular mail is sufficient under a
- 29:07matter of MRA. However, that can be rebutted.
- 29:11So it doesn't mean that just because they sent
- 29:14it through regular mail that that means we cannot
- 29:17contest proper service. And it's important to
- 29:23note that there are, when it comes to children,
- 29:29there are heightened service requirements for
- 29:32children. And this is recognizing that children
- 29:35are vulnerable and we want to make sure that
- 29:37they have proper notice and extra protections.
- 29:42And they need more rather than less service.
- 29:46So these heightened service requirements are
- 29:49found in the regulations. And in the regulations,
- 29:54any minor who is under 14, the person with whom
- 29:58the child resides should be served whenever possible.
- 30:03So that would be the near relative guardian or
- 30:06whoever they reside with. However, in the Ninth
- 30:11Circuit, there is extra protection here for children
- 30:14under the age of 18. So if there was a minor
- 30:18who was under the age of 18 within the Ninth
- 30:21Circuit and they were released from immigration
- 30:22custody to an adult guardian, the DHS has to
- 30:27serve that adult guardian for it to be proper
- 30:31service. And that was in this decision, Flores
- 30:34Chavez v. Ashcroft. And so how does this, again,
- 30:39support that argument that if the notice to appear
- 30:45wasn't properly served, then they could not have
- 30:48been found to have received proper notice in
- 30:54this case. This is similar to what Michelle said
- 31:01this is when we have to go into your detective
- 31:03mode and you're going to have to get all the
- 31:06records you can and you're going to have to look
- 31:08at the notice to appear any notice of hearing
- 31:10and look to see if there's any inaccuracies within
- 31:15the record because I've seen You're going to
- 31:18want to see where the notice of hearing was mailed
- 31:20to, where the notice to appear was mailed to,
- 31:22if there's any typos. Sometimes it's been the
- 31:25case that there's an apartment number missing
- 31:27on the notice or maybe they just transposed two
- 31:31different addresses. I've seen that before where
- 31:33they had an address, the street address from
- 31:36an old place and then they had the city in a
- 31:38different place so it never got to the person.
- 31:41So this is when it's important to look at your
- 31:44record. and figure out what happened. And also,
- 31:50when we're talking about that presumption of
- 31:53mail, maybe the record shows that it was delivered
- 31:56to the right address, but the person never received
- 31:59it. If that happened, you want to investigate
- 32:02to see what could have happened to the mail.
- 32:04Is there issues in the post office? Has there
- 32:07been issues in the apartment complex? Has mail
- 32:09been misplaced? Is this a recurring problem?
- 32:11You're going to want to gather as much evidence
- 32:14as possible to support that that person did not
- 32:17receive the notice. And like Michelle said, this
- 32:23is all on the paper, so you need to submit everything
- 32:26at once and try to get... all the evidence. So,
- 32:34and then one of the most important things that
- 32:35you're going to submit is a declaration, right?
- 32:38Because on some cases, you're not going to have
- 32:41physical corroborating evidence. It's not always
- 32:45the case. So you are going to have to work with
- 32:47your client or other people to get as much details
- 32:51as possible. It's also important to get the big
- 32:56picture. Did this person, would they have wanted
- 33:00to go if they knew about the hearing? Have they
- 33:02gone in the past? Did they go to past hearings?
- 33:05Did they have a relief application already pending?
- 33:07And if they don't have a relief application already
- 33:10pending, are they eligible for relief? And oftentimes
- 33:14it's best to present that relief application
- 33:16with the motion to reopen itself to show that
- 33:19they had. an incentive to appear, that they have
- 33:22this meritorious claim that they wanted to present
- 33:25before the immigration judge. So you're going
- 33:28to want to look at all the facts and present
- 33:29them to show that they would have had an incentive
- 33:32to appear based on past behavior also. I mean,
- 33:36have they gone to ICE check -ins? Have they been
- 33:38complying with other responsibilities? Had they
- 33:42previously submitted a change of address? Things
- 33:44like that would help bolster the argument that
- 33:47they had an incentive to appear. But we do run
- 33:52into a problem oftentimes when clients don't
- 33:55change their address. And it happens quite often
- 33:58that, you know, people move, life gets in the
- 34:01way, maybe they move around a lot and they sometimes
- 34:04don't know how to do the change of address. And
- 34:08unfortunately, whenever, if they don't submit
- 34:11the change of address and the government is not
- 34:18They do not have to send the notice to appear
- 34:21I mean the notice of hearing to their last their
- 34:23address or new address because they don't know
- 34:25it right the the non -citizen has a duty to present
- 34:29a change of address so when that happens though
- 34:35the timing of of it is very important like when
- 34:39did that notice of address when did that move
- 34:42happen right, so if If they updated their address
- 34:48with ICE before they were put in removal proceedings
- 34:50and ICE used the wrong address, they fulfilled
- 34:53their obligations and that was ICE's issue. So
- 34:56that is something to look at. If they did do
- 35:00a change of address, when did they do it? If
- 35:03they never received the notice to appear, because
- 35:07it was sent to the wrong address to begin with
- 35:09and they never got the advisals to change their
- 35:11address, that's a reasonable way to challenge
- 35:14that why they didn't submit a change of address.
- 35:17However, if they did get the notice to appear
- 35:19and they never changed their address, it's going
- 35:21to be much more challenging. We still think there
- 35:23are arguments and that we'll cover later in these
- 35:28mega master situations as to why someone might
- 35:31not change their address. For the procedural
- 35:36due process that we'll talk about, but when it
- 35:38comes to the notice argument, it's very difficult
- 35:41to overcome when they do not change their address.
- 35:44But you can also think about exceptional circumstances
- 35:48to hear what if what if they. They couldn't change
- 35:53their address because they were suffering from
- 35:55such significant housing instability and they
- 35:58didn't have an address to change it to. That
- 36:00might be something to raise and raise both in
- 36:03the notice and exceptional circumstances argument.
- 36:08But so here it's really important to look at
- 36:09the timing, see when the change of address happened,
- 36:16and look at the documents for that. So here we
- 36:23have some tips. So listen to the DAR to find
- 36:28out what happened. Always look for competency
- 36:32issues, because if there's competency issues
- 36:34similar to the children, there are other notice
- 36:41requirements and service requirements for anyone
- 36:43with competency issues, interpretation problems
- 36:46that might have led. So we included two. unpublished
- 36:51VIA cases here. The first one was where the respondent
- 36:54was personally served with a hearing notice,
- 36:56but it was not in their native language. And
- 36:59that's why I talked about looking at the notice
- 37:00to appear to see what language was used. And
- 37:04so they didn't receive proper notice for that
- 37:06reason. The second one where the immigration
- 37:11judge the oral notice was incorrectly interpreted
- 37:15in Spanish. So you want to get all the facts,
- 37:17listen to the DAR, if they were given these notice
- 37:19of visals in the hearing to see if there was
- 37:24any issues there. And as always, include as much
- 37:27arguments as possible. And these often overlap
- 37:29with exceptional circumstance arguments. And
- 37:34now we'll get to the exceptional circumstances.
- 37:36So for exceptional circumstances, you have 180
- 37:40days to file them. Don't think of the exceptional
- 37:44circumstance as exhaustive, like what constitutes
- 37:48an exceptional circumstance. The statute does
- 37:52provide list examples of what could constitute
- 37:57an exceptional circumstance being battery or
- 37:59extreme cruelty to self -child parent, serious
- 38:03illness to the non -citizen, or serious illness
- 38:08or death to their spouse, child or parent. And
- 38:12then also this less compelling circumstances.
- 38:15So you might just end up being in that less compelling
- 38:18circumstances, but still keep in mind the other
- 38:22ones that are listed as well, battery and then
- 38:25the serious illness. And we've talked about service
- 38:32and that also includes when does that 180 days
- 38:37start? And that's a good question, right? So
- 38:40if you think about the removal order and when
- 38:44they received that removal order and notice of
- 38:47that removal order. So if they never received
- 38:50that, maybe there's an argument that the 180
- 38:53days has not started because they never received
- 38:57that removal order. And for equitable... These
- 39:04exceptional circumstances you want to think of
- 39:07it in the totality of the circumstances So you're
- 39:09going to want to fact -gather and look at as
- 39:12much facts as possible in the case. So we've
- 39:15listed Some factors to think about again. These
- 39:19are not exhaustive. So there might be more in
- 39:22any given case so it can be the age minority
- 39:26can Sometimes constitute as an exceptional circumstance
- 39:29that we'll talk about I will give some examples
- 39:32to reliance on adult caretaker that again goes
- 39:35to that minority health related issues. I mentioned
- 39:39like housing instability, domestic violence in
- 39:43the home. Prior we talked about that incentive
- 39:48to appear prior attendance at other immigration
- 39:52prior immigration hearings or ice check ins misinformation.
- 39:57Maybe they they got. wrong information from the
- 40:00immigration court or they were they are illiterate
- 40:03and they asked someone for Assistance in reading
- 40:05a hearing notice and that person provided them
- 40:08with the wrong date their eligibility for relief
- 40:12Showing that they were diligent they were keeping
- 40:15up they might have been checking the case status
- 40:18System every so often they might have been calling
- 40:20the court every few months to make sure they
- 40:22didn't miss a court hearing And then having counsel,
- 40:27trying to find counsel, how quickly they filed
- 40:29the motion, all of this is going to build the
- 40:32picture to show that it was but for these exceptional
- 40:38circumstances, they would have appeared at their
- 40:40hearing. And again, when you're looking for some
- 40:45of the forms of relief that you might screen
- 40:48for and include in the relief application would
- 40:52be a special immigrant juvenile status, which
- 40:55is for minors who do not have a parent or one
- 41:00or both parents here in the United States to
- 41:01provide care and it's not in their best interest
- 41:04to return their country. That might be something
- 41:06they may be eligible for. There's humanitarian
- 41:09forms of relief, a U visa, a T visa, and protection
- 41:13under the Violence Against Women Act. Maybe they
- 41:16have a relative who can petition for them, a
- 41:19family -based relief adjustment. if they're a
- 41:22Cuban asylum or they have a citizenship claim.
- 41:26So those are things to screen for as well as
- 41:28when you're looking to see if there's notice
- 41:31in these. One of the most common exceptional
- 41:35circumstances that come up a lot in practice
- 41:38is ineffective assistance of counsel. Oftentimes
- 41:42it can come up that they didn't notify the client
- 41:45or Like the attorney did get a notice, but they
- 41:52never told the client. Maybe the attorney was
- 41:55hired, they never entered an appearance, and
- 41:57just never kept up with the case. So when you're
- 42:02raising an ineffective assistant of counsel,
- 42:03it's going to be really important to follow all
- 42:06the... procedural requirements and substantive
- 42:10requirements. So the case you're going to want
- 42:12to look to is Matter of Lasada, which is a Board
- 42:14of Immigration Appeals case from 1988, which
- 42:18sets out exactly what needs to be included to
- 42:21raise an effective assistive counsel claim against
- 42:24another practitioner. You have to prove, obviously,
- 42:29that the person provided ineffective assistance
- 42:31of counsel and also that the non -citizen was
- 42:34prejudiced. Generally, it's assumed that they're
- 42:38prejudiced when they have it in absentia removal
- 42:40order, but it's also recommended that you show
- 42:44prejudice in order to meet that standard. When
- 42:47you're raising this claim, you're going to have
- 42:49to provide a detailed declaration of what was
- 42:54the agreement between that client and that attorney.
- 42:57as well as notice to that prior counsel and generally
- 43:03a bar complaint or a UIR complaint against that
- 43:07attorney. And these are very strict requirements
- 43:09generally, so you should abide by them if you
- 43:13are going to raise an ineffective assistance
- 43:15of counsel claim. There are instances where an
- 43:19individual maybe was working with a notario and
- 43:24not an attorney. In those instances, it may not
- 43:30be considered. I think recently the Board of
- 43:32Immigration Appeals said that that wouldn't be
- 43:34an effective assistance of counsel unless they
- 43:36carried themselves out as an attorney, but I
- 43:39would still raise that argument and most likely
- 43:42report that notary for unauthorized practice
- 43:45of law if that was the case in any situation.
- 43:49But I don't see that coming up here as much because
- 43:52it's generally a hearing. So a notary might not
- 43:55be involved, but something to keep in mind if
- 43:58that is the case. And then we, so for a child,
- 44:05this is the EACA v. Rosen is a case out of the
- 44:09sixth circuit. That's really important to think
- 44:11about when you're thinking of children's cases.
- 44:14In that case, it was a 13 -year -old minor. His
- 44:19mom was unable to file a change of venue, was
- 44:24unable to file counsel, and she was also unable
- 44:27to take the child to the hearing because she
- 44:29had recently given birth. So the court did find
- 44:33that that was exceptional circumstances. And
- 44:37so this is a good case to cite too, whenever
- 44:39you're dealing with a similar issue, which is
- 44:41often gonna come up with minors who are dependent
- 44:43on their parents and their guardian or adult.
- 44:48And that adult is unable to take them to the
- 44:50hearing or the adult didn't even communicate
- 44:53to the minor that they had a hearing. So they
- 44:56were unaware. In those cases, it's also recommended
- 45:01to look at this Department of State Office of
- 45:04Inspector General Ports, even if it's generally
- 45:07prejudicial, because there's some language in
- 45:10there that supports that. Even in there's cases
- 45:15where the sponsors are not providing complete
- 45:17address or ICE is not able to get them to appear
- 45:21in court, so that might help. show the complete
- 45:25picture and the reliance that they have on these
- 45:27adults in these situations. And you're also going
- 45:31to want to look and see what the sponsor did
- 45:34do. If they were in immigration custody, whether
- 45:36a sponsor filed a change of address, maybe the
- 45:39sponsor filed it incorrectly, again, you're really
- 45:42going to investigate to see and show that the
- 45:47child was relying on that sponsor and the sponsor
- 45:49did not. properly assist and provide that correct
- 45:53information. And then here's another good example.
- 45:57And this is for a family case example. And I
- 46:01think it really highlights that you want to look
- 46:03at the bigger picture and see all the actors
- 46:05involved and see what's going on. So in this
- 46:08case, they did appear at their master calendar
- 46:14hearing a mom and her minor son. And the judge
- 46:17had given oral instructions, given given the
- 46:20next date as well as a notice of hearing. And
- 46:24in this case, the mother could not remember the
- 46:29date because she had suffered from a traumatic
- 46:31brain injury, which prevented her from remembering
- 46:33what date the immigration judge gave. She was
- 46:35also illiterate. And when she asked someone for
- 46:38assistance in reading the hearing notice, which
- 46:42is in English, the person who gave it to her
- 46:47Read it and told her the date had transposed
- 46:50the month and day as is general They were reading
- 46:53it like everyone else in the world does and they
- 46:56gave her the wrong date. And so that was the
- 46:58basis So this is a great example of an exceptional
- 47:01circumstance and like just looking beyond like
- 47:03assuming you were only representing the minor
- 47:06looking to the the parent and seeing what was
- 47:08happening in her life and You would you know
- 47:12present? evidence of the traumatic brain injury,
- 47:15a declaration from her, a declaration from the
- 47:17child if they were there. I mean, and sometimes
- 47:20the child's not in the hearing. So those things
- 47:23to look at and listen to the DAR to get more
- 47:26details. And so here we're going to, again, we're
- 47:30talking about declarations are very, very important
- 47:32for these cases. So you're going to want to have
- 47:35a detailed declaration that gives a great explanation
- 47:38as why they could, they fell to appear. and other
- 47:43declarations again if there's relief applications
- 47:45available and if you are in some cases getting
- 47:49all the records is going to take much longer
- 47:52than you have to be able to file the motion and
- 47:55in that case it's really important just drop
- 47:57a footnote say that you'll supplement as soon
- 47:59as you receive the documents and evidence that
- 48:01you have requested the documents and for whatever
- 48:04reason you have not received them yet and I will
- 48:08turn it to Michelle. Great. So let's talk now
- 48:11about that constitutional basis that we have
- 48:15been alluding to. So the procedural due process
- 48:18argument. And so I think we all know that procedural
- 48:22due process is a constitutional rule that requires
- 48:25the government to do certain things for fairness
- 48:28to the person. And so what are they supposed
- 48:30to do? They're supposed to follow fair established
- 48:33procedures before taking away a person's life,
- 48:36liberty and property. They also need to guarantee,
- 48:39the government also needs to guarantee proper
- 48:42notice, a fair chance to be heard, and a decision
- 48:44from an impartial judge or neutral decision maker.
- 48:48And so here we have a situation in these mega
- 48:51masters, where as I mentioned before, we have
- 48:54folks who, for example, had been scheduled for
- 48:57that final hearing, that individual hearing way
- 49:00into the future. They thought they were done.
- 49:02They just needed to show up at that hearing.
- 49:04And so maybe that's why they didn't change their
- 49:07address. And they just knew that, you know, needed
- 49:09to be there. And so that's it. Like that's nothing
- 49:12else is going to change that. So that's it. I'll
- 49:16just keep checking the system to see if if maybe
- 49:19the case gets pushed into the future. But surely
- 49:22it's not going to get pushed back. Like it's
- 49:25not going to get. advanced too much but if it
- 49:28is advanced which you tell people always check
- 49:30it's not going to become some master calendar
- 49:32hearing right there and there has to be like
- 49:34a reason for the change if you will for it to
- 49:36be a master calendar hearing so coming back to
- 49:40due process due process requires notice reasonably
- 49:43calculated to provide a meaningful opportunity
- 49:46to be heard so these advanced hearings may violate
- 49:50due process if the respondent received only,
- 49:53for example, day's notice of the hearing change
- 49:56and they could not reasonably appear or prepare
- 49:59to appear. So consider like how far the hearing
- 50:02was advanced, the reliance on that original day.
- 50:06Like I said, there was going to be some strong
- 50:08reliance if that hearing that they had scheduled
- 50:11was a final hearing was in 2027, 2028, 2029,
- 50:15and then it gets advanced and then it becomes
- 50:18its master calendar hearing. And so think about
- 50:22in that context and then appearance does not
- 50:26necessarily cure inadequate notice if the respondent
- 50:28is still unable to meaningfully participate because
- 50:32at these hearings where there are dozens of people.
- 50:35respondents, there's going to be crowding, confusion,
- 50:39rushed proceedings. They may not have an interpreter
- 50:41for their best language. There may be some language
- 50:45communication problems, which is one of the unpublished
- 50:47decisions that Rebecca mentioned earlier. And
- 50:51so ultimately, you want to argue procedural due
- 50:54process, even though We normally wouldn't do
- 50:57this, I think, in a regular reopening case that's
- 51:01not a mega master type of case, because we're
- 51:03really beholden to the statute or to the Suis
- 51:06Ponte regulatory reopening authority, which I'll
- 51:09mention in a second. But here, I think we need
- 51:12to go outside of the statute, which is pretty
- 51:14narrow in many ways with regards to notice and
- 51:18what proper notice is, and go outside of the
- 51:22statute and think more about, okay, was this
- 51:24procedurally aligned with what due process requires.
- 51:30And I don't think it is. So I leave it for you
- 51:33to consider further and to decide if you're gonna
- 51:35include it. We did help one of our members at
- 51:37the National Immigration Project with a motion
- 51:40recently and we did include this argument and
- 51:43not really sure what basis the immigration judge
- 51:45reopened on, but maybe this helped push that
- 51:48judge to reopen that particular case. All right,
- 51:51next slide. And so the final basis is going to
- 51:57be on a Suez -Bonte reopening. And so the regulations,
- 52:02not the statute, the regulations say that an
- 52:05immigration judge may upon the immigration judges
- 52:08motion at any time or upon motion of DHS or the
- 52:11person. reopen or reconsider any case in which
- 52:14the judge has rendered a decision unless jurisdiction
- 52:18is vested with the Board of Immigration Appeals.
- 52:19And just by the way, if it's an in absentia order,
- 52:22you would be going to reopen with the judge always.
- 52:27We'll be always seeking that motion to reopen
- 52:29from the judge who issued that order. You can
- 52:31appeal that to the board, but there is no world
- 52:34in which you're going to be filing a motion to
- 52:36reopen with the board in the first instance in
- 52:38an absentia case. And so here, This suesponte
- 52:42reopening ground has been narrowed considerably,
- 52:44as I mentioned before, at the onset of this presentation
- 52:47by a case called Matter of Yadav. However, even
- 52:52though it's been really narrowed because of that
- 52:55case, you still need to deal with it. If you're
- 52:57going to include a suesponte argument, you're
- 52:59going to want to distinguish your case from Matter
- 53:01of Yadav. And why would you still include a suesponte
- 53:04argument even though it's going to be unlikely
- 53:05that the judge is going to grant on that suesponte
- 53:08reopening basis? because it's an opportunity
- 53:11to humanize your client. It's all based on discretion.
- 53:14And so it's the weighing of the positive and
- 53:17the negative factors. And so you want to put
- 53:19out there how amazing your client is, what they
- 53:23do in the community, what they do at work, what
- 53:25they do for their family, how they contribute
- 53:27to the economy, all of these factors that have
- 53:29nothing to do with the statutory reopening grounds
- 53:32or with this constitutional procedural due process
- 53:35argument that we're giving you. You want to include
- 53:37all of this to really humanize them as much as
- 53:39possible. And it's just really a vehicle to do
- 53:41that. It's a vehicle for you to include carefully
- 53:44chosen photos, which again, this is all in the
- 53:46papers. So how can you humanize your client?
- 53:48Include a photo, include a visual of them and
- 53:50their family. It may work. Charitable donations
- 53:54or the work that they do. That's volunteer service,
- 53:58letters from neighbors, teachers, coaches, bosses,
- 54:01et cetera. All right, now let's go on to our
- 54:04hypos. that we've learned the six reopening bases
- 54:07that we think are available in this mega master
- 54:09context. Should I read this to you, Rebecca?
- 54:12Does that sound good to everybody? Yeah. All
- 54:16right. So Julia's, well, I don't know if it's
- 54:18Julia or Julia in our hypo. Julia's individual
- 54:22hearing was scheduled for May 5th, 2028. Since
- 54:26her last hearing, Julia moved from her residence,
- 54:29but did not update the Los Angeles immigration
- 54:31court. Knowing that her May 5th, 2028 hearing
- 54:34would be her last hearing, at which point the
- 54:37immigration judge would decide her asylum case,
- 54:40she had this date engraved in her mind and on
- 54:43every calendar. Julia decided to show her friend
- 54:46how to check one's immigration court hearing
- 54:49date and time on the EOIR automated case information
- 54:51webpage when she saw that the immigration judge
- 54:54ordered her removed in absentia on June 24, 2026.
- 54:58You obtained the record of proceeding and the
- 55:01digital audio recording and observed that the
- 55:04immigration judge did not request any evidence
- 55:06of alienage from DHS. So what arguments are available
- 55:10to Julia? Yeah, so right off the bat, we're seeing
- 55:14that there was not evidence of alienage. So it's
- 55:19going to go to that statutory argument that the
- 55:23DHS had the burden of showing by clear unequivocal
- 55:26evidence that she was removable as charged. And
- 55:30if there's no evidence of alienage, it's not
- 55:34proper that the immigration judge issued that
- 55:36in absentia removal order. So that's like the
- 55:38one we're seeing right off the bat. But remember,
- 55:40we gotta include all the ones that we're gonna
- 55:43see. I'm also seeing, we talked about this procedural
- 55:46due process. It looks like her hearing was moved
- 55:49up by almost two years and she was relying on
- 55:52that date. So this might be a one where you would
- 55:54raise that procedural due process argument. potentially
- 55:58even exceptional circumstance. We might need
- 56:00more facts about what was going on. Maybe there
- 56:03was something else going on in her life. But
- 56:05again, not changing her address because of that
- 56:08reliance could be an exceptional circumstance
- 56:10argument as well. And then we're always going
- 56:13to throw in that Suiz Fonte, humanize Julia,
- 56:17humanize what you know, she's been going to all
- 56:19of these, I don't know how many hearings she's
- 56:21gone to. We'll assume she's gone to some other
- 56:23hearings in the past. She's already scheduled
- 56:25for a hearing, individual hearings, so she's
- 56:28bound to have gone to other hearings. How many
- 56:31years she's been in proceedings, she has applications
- 56:33pending, has she already submitted evidence in
- 56:36support of her application? All of that would
- 56:38show and support an exceptional circumstance
- 56:40argument. All right, let's go to the next typo.
- 56:46All right, so Leo was waiting for the immigration
- 56:49court to schedule his first hearing and he hired
- 56:52absent -minded attorney who entered their appearance
- 56:55with the immigration court. The immigration court
- 56:57sent absent -minded attorney Leo's hearing notice
- 57:00for July 20th, 2026. On July 20th, absent -minded
- 57:04attorney called Leo in a panic telling him to
- 57:07rush to the immigration court because his hearing
- 57:09was happening that morning at 10 a .m. Leo arrived
- 57:12at the immigration court at 1030 a .m. while
- 57:16the immigration judge was still on the bench,
- 57:18but there were so many people inside the courtroom
- 57:19that the guard instructed him to wait outside.
- 57:22Once inside the courtroom, Leo waited for his
- 57:25name to be called, but the immigration judge
- 57:27left the bench without calling his name. The
- 57:30immigration judge's legal assistant said that
- 57:33Leo had received an in absentia order. What arguments
- 57:37are available to Leo? Yeah, so we're we're seeing
- 57:41here that index exceptional circumstance based
- 57:44on an ineffective assistant of the council here
- 57:46They had the attorney absent -minded attorney
- 57:49Notified them day of they rushed right? So they
- 57:54would have to follow the procedure requirements
- 57:56that are under matter of lasada to raise that
- 57:59claim and we also have this That it wasn't really
- 58:03a failure to appear because he appeared he was
- 58:05there the judge was on the bench He was in the
- 58:08courtroom um and but for i don't know the chaos
- 58:14which would also potentially be that procedural
- 58:16due process argument um he would have been in
- 58:19attendance and as always like a suiz fonte argument
- 58:23as well yeah and he definitely got noticed because
- 58:28he got noticed through his attorney so that's
- 58:31constructive notice so that's going to be not
- 58:33really an argument that he has available to him
- 58:36but Again, like the fact that the attorney got
- 58:39the notice and that he did not share that information
- 58:41with Leo until the very last minute brings up
- 58:44that ineffective assistance of counsel, which
- 58:46technically can bring in under exceptional circumstances.
- 58:49All right, next slide. So here are the practical
- 58:53consideration slides, which I mentioned I was
- 58:55not going to go over orally because of time and
- 58:58surely here we are with time being an issue.
- 59:00So this slide is about reopening filing fees.
- 59:03This has changed quite a bit since July 4, 2025.
- 59:07Next slide. The automatic stay of removal, some
- 59:11considerations there. I want you just to know
- 59:14that there are some statutory automatic stays
- 59:17over removal that do apply, for example, in absentia
- 59:21motions to reopen that are based on both the
- 59:28notice and for exceptional circumstances. There's
- 59:32some others too. And then we have a couple of
- 59:35settlement agreements that have a kind of like
- 59:37state provision or an aspect of it, for example,
- 59:41in the missile litigation. Next slide. have a
- 59:46detention plan or strategy for your client because
- 59:49it's likely that detention is in their future
- 59:51and so you'll want to be sure that they are well
- 59:56protected and prepared for a detention by ICE
- 1:00:00and then you'll want to be able to move quickly
- 1:00:02if that happens for sure. Next slide. And then
- 1:00:08what if the immigration judge denies a motion
- 1:00:10to rescind and reopen? Well, you're going to
- 1:00:13appeal that to the Board of Immigration Appeals.
- 1:00:15And then if denied, you want to file the petition
- 1:00:17for review for all of you in the Ninth Circuit.
- 1:00:21That's great. So Ninth Circuit, you're usually
- 1:00:23in pretty good place there. But this is this
- 1:00:27is going to be a long game. So you have to include
- 1:00:29all the available arguments in your motion from
- 1:00:32the onset and then be sure that you go ahead
- 1:00:35and appeal it all the way up to the petition
- 1:00:38for review to the Court of Appeals because you're
- 1:00:40probably not going to get real justice for your
- 1:00:42client until you reach the petition for review
- 1:00:45level, given how things are right now with the
- 1:00:48EOIR adjudicators. All right, and to wrap up,
- 1:00:52we have a couple of slides to share with you
- 1:00:55regarding the National Immigration Project. Oh,
- 1:00:58I think that, yeah, I think this might not be
- 1:01:01the most updated slide deck, actually. So I think
- 1:01:06you have the most up -to -date slide decking
- 1:01:08your materials. I just noticed that because this
- 1:01:12slide in particular, it has an update and that
- 1:01:15is not reflected here, but become a National
- 1:01:18Immigration Project member. So we do not use
- 1:01:23the acronym anymore because it's very difficult
- 1:01:25to remember an acronym. It's just yet another
- 1:01:26acronym. So NIP &LG means National Immigration
- 1:01:29Project. And think about becoming a member of
- 1:01:32the National Immigration Project. Next slide.
- 1:01:36These are some upcoming National Immigration
- 1:01:39Project CLEs that we have coming up that we'd
- 1:01:44love for you to check us out on and come learn
- 1:01:47with us as well. And there was a slide here that
- 1:01:51we intended to include, but it's not showing
- 1:01:53up. There is a donation slide, so you're always
- 1:01:56also welcome to donate if you're thinking about
- 1:02:00nonprofits that you want to support in this fight.
- 1:02:02Yeah, you can find that information on how to
- 1:02:05donate at our website in any case. So I think
- 1:02:09we're pretty much on time and thank you all for
- 1:02:11this opportunity. We hope that this has been
- 1:02:14helpful. I guess I should also just quickly flag
- 1:02:16the resources and the materials you should have
- 1:02:19received. You should have received a practice
- 1:02:25advisor or practice alert on 15 steps to dealing
- 1:02:28with removal orders. And then you should also
- 1:02:31have received a list of cases that may be helpful
- 1:02:34in support of that due process argument that
- 1:02:36we mentioned. All right, thank you so much. This
- 1:02:42concludes today's presentation. Thank you so
- 1:02:44much, Michelle and Rebecca, for an excellent
- 1:02:45presentation today, and thank you so much to
- 1:02:47our audience for joining us. Have a great day,
- 1:02:49everyone.