Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Tech IPOs Are Pivoting to Direct Listings
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot on this show about the IPO window—when it's open, when it's slammed shut, who gets through. But there's a quieter structural shift happening underneath all of that, and it's the fact that more and more tech companies are simply bypassing the traditional IPO altogether. Luna: You mean direct listings. It's not a new concept—Spotify did it back in 2018, Slack in 2019—but it feels like the conversation has really accelerated in the last couple of years. Lucas: Right. And the data backs that up. According to a recent report from the law firm Fenwick, about 15 percent of all tech IPOs in 2025 were direct listings—up from basically zero a decade ago. And that number is expected to grow in 2026. Luna: Fifteen percent doesn't sound huge, but it's a meaningful shift. And it's not just small companies either. Spotify was a household name. Coinbase went public via direct listing in 2021, valued at nearly $100 billion. Lucas: Exactly. So let's be concrete about what a direct listing actually is. In a traditional IPO, a company hires investment banks to underwrite the offering—they buy shares from the company and sell them to institutional investors at a set price. In a direct listing, the company just lists its existing shares on an exchange, and the market sets the price from day one. Luna: No underwriters, no lock-up period, no price-setting by bankers. Which sounds great in theory—but why don't more companies do it? Lucas: The big reason is uncertainty. In a traditional IPO, the underwriters guarantee a certain amount of capital—they buy the shares, so the company knows exactly how much it's raising. In a direct listing, there's no guarantee. You're at the mercy of whatever price the market decides on day one. Luna: And that's a big risk for a company that needs to raise a specific amount of capital to fund growth or pay down debt. Lucas: Exactly. But here's the thing—many of the companies choosing direct listings don't actually need to raise new capital. They're already profitable or have plenty of cash. For them, the goal is liquidity for existing shareholders—employees and early investors who want to cash out. Luna: Right, which is exactly why Spotify did it. They didn't need the money. They just wanted to give their employees a path to sell shares without the artificial price support that banks provide. Lucas: And that's a big part of the appeal. In a traditional IPO, there's typically a lock-up period of 180 days where employees can't sell. With a direct listing, there's no lock-up—employees can sell immediately. Which is huge when you've been holding illiquid stock for years. Luna: But doesn't that also create a risk of a flood of supply hitting the market on day one? If every employee tries to sell at once, the price could crater. Lucas: It's a real concern. And we've seen it happen. When Slack debuted via direct listing, the stock opened at $38.50 but quickly dipped as sellers came in. It recovered, but the volatility was real. What a lot of companies now do is work with a financial advisor to coordinate a 'sell to cover' program—basically, employees sell just enough shares to cover their tax obligations from the listing, which reduces the supply shock. Luna: So it's not quite the wild west that people imagine. There is some structure, just not the traditional banker-led kind. Lucas: Right. And the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq have both changed their rules in the last few years to make direct listings easier. For example, the NYSE now allows companies to raise primary capital in a direct listing—so they can issue new shares and sell them directly to the public, not just let existing shareholders sell. That's a game changer. Luna: I remember when the SEC approved that in 2022. It basically removed the biggest objection—that you couldn't raise money in a direct listing. Lucas: Exactly. And we're seeing the effects. In 2025, companies like Arm and Reddit—which had originally planned traditional IPOs—reportedly considered direct listings at the last minute. They ultimately went the traditional route, but the fact that it was even on the table shows how much the landscape has shifted. Luna: So who benefits most from direct listings? Is it the company, the employees, or the investors? Lucas: It's complicated. For companies, the big benefit is avoiding the massive underwriting fees—usually 3.5 to 7 percent of the money raised. For a $10 billion IPO, that's $350 to $700 million in fees that go to banks instead of the company. In a direct listing, those fees are much lower—more like 1 to 2 percent for advisory services. Luna: That's a huge savings. And for employees, obviously, the liquidity and no lock-up is a big plus. Lucas: For retail investors, the picture is mixed. In a traditional IPO, retail investors often get shut out—the shares are allocated to big institutional clients. In a direct listing, anyone can buy on the open market from day one. But the flip side is that there's no 'IPO pop'—the stock doesn't get priced artificially low to generate first-day gains, so you might not get that instant profit. Luna: Although some would argue that the IPO pop is actually a sign that the company left money on the table. If the stock jumps 20 percent on day one, the company could have priced it higher and raised more capital. Lucas: Right. And that's the classic argument against the traditional IPO model—that banks intentionally underprice to reward their institutional clients. Direct listings eliminate that. The market finds the true price. Luna: But not everyone is convinced. Some critics say direct listings favor insiders—because if there's no lock-up, insiders can sell first while retail investors are still figuring out the valuation. Lucas: That's a fair concern. And it's why the SEC has been looking at additional disclosures for direct listings. But overall, the trend is clear. More companies are choosing this path, especially in tech, where the notion of disrupting Wall Street is part of the culture. Luna: And speaking of culture, this is a business and technology show—where operators and builders meet. If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, we'd love to keep them coming. Lucas: Totally. And a quick honest thing—we don't run ads on this show. It's listener-supported. A small group of listeners already chips in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what makes it possible to produce episodes like this. Luna: Yeah, it's a simple way to keep the show ad-free and independent. No pressure at all—just if it's added value for you. Lucas: Alright, back to direct listings. So one of the interesting developments is the rise of secondary market IPOs—where a company's shares already trade on private markets before the direct listing. That creates a price history and reduces the uncertainty. Luna: Like what we saw with Coinbase. Their shares were trading on the private secondary market at around $350 before the direct listing, and they opened at $381. The price discovery was already happening. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a big advantage for direct listings. If a company has a robust secondary market, the 'gaping hole' of price discovery is much smaller. Investors have a reference point. Luna: So for a company like SpaceX, which has a very active secondary market, a direct listing would be a natural fit if they ever decide to go public. Lucas: Absolutely. And you can see why the traditional IPO is starting to feel like a legacy product for a certain type of company. Not every company fits that mold—if you need to raise a lot of capital and you want the marketing support of a big bank roadshow, the traditional IPO still makes sense. Luna: But for a mature, cash-rich tech company that just wants to give its employees liquidity? The direct listing is hard to beat. Lucas: Right. And I think we'll continue to see a bifurcation. The companies that raise large amounts of capital—say, over $500 million—will likely still go the traditional route. But for companies raising less, or raising no capital at all, direct listings will become the default. Luna: And that's a shift that changes the dynamics for everyone—banks, employees, and investors alike. It's one of those structural changes that doesn't make big headlines, but it quietly reshapes how capital gets allocated. Lucas: For sure. And it's worth watching how the regulatory environment evolves. The SEC is still working on rules around direct listings, and there's debate about whether they should require more disclosures about insider selling plans. Luna: Because if insiders can sell immediately without any transparency, that could undermine investor confidence. Lucas: Exactly. But so far, the market seems to be handling it well. Direct listings have lower volatility on average than traditional IPOs, according to some studies. And the companies that choose them tend to be higher quality—more profitable, more established. Luna: So it's a self-selecting group. And that might be the real story here—the companies that choose direct listings are the ones that don't need to rely on the banks' stamp of approval. Lucas: Right. And that's a powerful signal in itself. When a company says, 'We're confident enough in our story that we'll let the market decide the price from day one,' that says something about their conviction. Luna: It also puts more pressure on investment banks to justify their fees. If the direct listing model works well for a growing number of companies, the traditional IPO underwriting business could shrink. Lucas: And we're already seeing that. Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley have both launched advisory services for direct listings—they're adapting because they see the writing on the wall. Luna: So the banks are still involved, just in a different role. They're advisors rather than underwriters. Lucas: Exactly. And they charge lower fees for that advice, but it's still a lucrative business if you're doing a lot of it. The question is whether the volume of direct listings will grow enough to offset the loss of traditional underwriting revenue. Luna: And that depends on the IPO market overall. If the window stays mostly closed for unprofitable tech companies, as it has been for much of 2025 and into 2026, then the number of IPOs—traditional or direct—might stay low. Lucas: But within that smaller pool, the share of direct listings could keep rising. And that's the trend to watch. It's not that IPOs are dying—it's that the model is evolving.