Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Multipolar Investing: Geopolitics, Risk, and the End of the 60/40 Portfolio
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity.
- 0:10Where the supply is unaffected by the demand.
- 0:15If you want to preserve your wealth, you have to convert.
- 0:18That. Currency into an asset that's
- 0:21scarce, desirable, portable, durable, and maintainable.
- 0:31Michael and I sat down with Rob Laerty, chief investment
- 0:33Officer, and Jacob Shapiro, director of research at Bespoke
- 0:36Group. They explained why the unipolar
- 0:39era is fading, how regional power blocks are reshaping
- 0:42global trade, and what it means when U.S.
- 0:44Treasuries are no longer risk free.
- 0:47In a world where trust in sovereign debt is eroding,
- 0:49scarce and liquid assets like gold and Bitcoin move to the
- 0:52front of the line. But the conversation was not
- 0:55only about what to own, it was about how and where to own it.
- 0:58If you hold Bitcoin, securing it for the long haul is mission
- 1:01critical. But how do you do that?
- 1:04That is exactly what On Ramps Multi Institution Custody
- 1:07Solution is built for. A secure custody solution built
- 1:10for 100K Bitcoin, where your Bitcoin is safeguarded by three
- 1:14independent institutions. While you retain control of your
- 1:17Bitcoin wealth, you can protect yourself against exchange
- 1:20failures, physical threats, lost seed phrases, inheritance gaps
- 1:24and more. With on ramp, you have seamless
- 1:26inheritance insurance through woods of London and access to
- 1:29trade loans, all included in your account.
- 1:33Are you ready to protect and grow your Bitcoin in a world
- 1:35that is rewriting the rules of risk?
- 1:38Get started in 10 minutes at on rampbitcoin.com or book a
- 1:42consultation with myself or someone else on the team and
- 1:45we'll make sure all of your questions are answered.
- 1:47Now enjoy the episode. All right, welcome back to
- 1:49scarce assets. This week will be a good one.
- 1:52I'm joined by my Co host, Michael Tanguma, and our guests
- 1:55of honor this week are Jacob Shapiro, Director of Research,
- 1:58and Rob Larity, Chief Investment Officer at the Spoke Group.
- 2:02Rob and Jacob, great to just meet you before we hit record
- 2:06here. Thanks for joining us.
- 2:07How are the two of you doing? Very good.
- 2:11It's. Another Tuesday in paradise
- 2:13here, but not all of us are in Paris like Rob, putting our feet
- 2:15up and eating croissants every day, so I think it's better for
- 2:17him. Does sound like a nice way to
- 2:21start the day, huh Rob? Yeah, I try to have at least
- 2:26three kilos of cheese before lunch, so it works pretty well.
- 2:33Nice. I'm, I'm on just black coffee to
- 2:36to kick things off here. So we're going to bring a lot of
- 2:38energy into this podcast. Really excited about sitting
- 2:41down with the two of you. Jacob, we discussed briefly
- 2:45before we hit record, but both Michael and I came across your
- 2:48podcast that you did a couple weeks back when you interviewed
- 2:51Matt Pines, kind of in preparation of having a
- 2:54conversation with Matt on our show.
- 2:56So really excited to speak with the two of you.
- 2:59You both have produced excellent research at Bespoke Group.
- 3:03But before getting into the details of any of that and
- 3:05discussing, you know, what's going on more broadly from a
- 3:09political, geopolitical policy perspective, could you just
- 3:13share your background, high level kind of what led you to
- 3:16Bespoke and what you're focusing on for the firm?
- 3:21I'll let you go first bro. Sure.
- 3:24So my role at Bespoke, so I'm Chief Investment Officer, which
- 3:30means really taking a charge. All of the direct investing that
- 3:33we do at the firm. We're a little bit unique in
- 3:38that sense in that we do a lot of our asset management in a
- 3:42vertically integrated way. So, you know, not only are we
- 3:45working with families at the very high level to do sort of
- 3:49strategic planning and, and everything around their needs,
- 3:53but all the way down to we're doing work on the individual
- 3:56companies that we're investing them in and doing that in house
- 3:59in a very deep and throw away. So that's my side of the house
- 4:04and and that's, you know, where Jacob and I work together.
- 4:06Obviously my background real quick, you know, I come from the
- 4:12buy side investment industry. I spent most of my career
- 4:16focused on the short side. So kind of interesting when you
- 4:21think about the kinds of families that we're helping, we
- 4:24like to think that it's, it's nice to have a, a cynical view
- 4:28of things to go in and kind of hammer them and make sure that
- 4:32they don't break. Because when you're dealing with
- 4:34generational wealth, you know, the first thing is to protect
- 4:38and then to focus on growth and gains.
- 4:41So you know, kind of that background has has put me in
- 4:45good stead for this sort of work.
- 4:48But yeah, I mean all of my career has been in macro and
- 4:52individual like very deep bottom up stocks and the confluence
- 4:56between those two things. And, and As for me, it's, it's
- 5:01funny you bring up Matt Pines. I find that it's actually a very
- 5:03small world, like the number of people who are actually doing
- 5:05deep research or deep insight around these topics.
- 5:08Like we all sort of know each other.
- 5:10And when you see others that are out there, like pretending like
- 5:12they do it, you can kind of separate people that way.
- 5:15My career is, is starts as a geopolitical strategist.
- 5:17So I've been doing geopolitical analysis for over 15 years now.
- 5:21When I started my career, nobody cared about geopolitics.
- 5:24I like to joke, I was in Austin, TX working at a company called
- 5:27Stratford. My grandmother thought, why,
- 5:30why, why don't you go to law school?
- 5:31Like, what is this job that you're doing?
- 5:33It wasn't interesting to anybody at the bar that I try to talk
- 5:36to. Like nobody wanted to talk about
- 5:37these things. And slowly over the course of my
- 5:39career, geopolitics has become more and more and more
- 5:42important. And my career has taken me from
- 5:45sort of direct consulting with multinational corporations, so
- 5:48companies that have international supply chains and
- 5:50are dealing with questions like, is China going to invade Taiwan?
- 5:54Is the US going to raise tariffs against Vietnam?
- 5:56Should I worry about drug cartels in Mexico if I'm
- 5:59establishing a factory there? Like that was sort of the sorts
- 6:02of questions that started my career.
- 6:04And about 10 years in Rob and I actually met at a different
- 6:07company that Rob started cognitive investments, and I
- 6:09started trying to tie my geopolitical research directly
- 6:12to matters that were related to investment.
- 6:15And we never really looked back from there.
- 6:17And I think one of the things that separates me from the small
- 6:20number of geopolitical analysts that are out there, and I've
- 6:22worked with most of them. I haven't worked with the in
- 6:25Bremer, but you go down the list like George Friedman, Peter
- 6:27Zion, Marco Pat, like we all worked together at different
- 6:30points in our career. It's a fairly small group, but
- 6:32for me, like it's all about applying the research in a way
- 6:36that actually has real tangible impact.
- 6:38So we're actually making decisions based on not just
- 6:41geopolitical risks, but on geopolitical opportunities
- 6:43because I think we are living, as we'll probably talk about in
- 6:46a huge international shift. We're in a huge technological
- 6:50shift, we're in an energy shift. And that means there's going to
- 6:52be creative destruction for entire industries and for nation
- 6:56states. It also means there's going to
- 6:57be incredible opportunity on the other side.
- 6:59So most of my job is to make sure that that geopolitical
- 7:02insight is embedded in the DNA of everything we do, from the
- 7:06where to own, from the how to own, the what to own.
- 7:08You need issues of geography and political risk and all those
- 7:12things embedded in those things. And then for particularly
- 7:14internationally minded clients, I'm usually their interface
- 7:17because, you know, sometimes people just want to talk about
- 7:19whatever's in the headlines and I'm a good person to shoot the
- 7:22shit with so. It's it's so fascinating.
- 7:25I'm really excited for this conversation because I didn't
- 7:29realize that about your side and like Peter Zahan and a lot of
- 7:32these groups coming from a, you know, having overlapping
- 7:35backgrounds, I think it's worth noting and we talked about it
- 7:39before recording Mcclintock and some of the group at Bespoke
- 7:43they're doing, they have been doing world class work for over
- 7:46half a decade now. And to see them kind of grow and
- 7:49take on the stance and have a more global presence makes
- 7:51complete sense. But then also I think I'm
- 7:56curious, like on your side, Jacob, when you referenced, you
- 8:00can kind of tell who knows what they're they're talking about
- 8:02and not like, I think one of the things that at least on the
- 8:06Austrians bottoms up side that maybe has a little difference of
- 8:11opinion or maybe the macro economist could get a bad rap is
- 8:15when they go to like high level or top level and put everyone
- 8:19into like lumps versus understanding emergence and
- 8:22decision making. And just like, you know, you
- 8:25talked about the interconnected interconnectedness of markets,
- 8:29but I think sometimes it gets to like, I don't wanna say top
- 8:33down, but just to like not like concrete in understanding of how
- 8:38independent actors, I guess human action at its core, right
- 8:41praxeology and that we're all independent actors and make
- 8:43independent decisions and that he ends up being too ephemeral
- 8:47and abstract and then you lose the interconnectedness and the
- 8:50actual give and take of human action.
- 8:53And so I don't know if you have any thoughts there, but I think
- 8:55that's probably one of the bigger things that like Luke,
- 8:57Roman and Zahan have picked up on where others maybe haven't
- 9:00made it through this great filter of who has signal and
- 9:03who's more of noise. Well, yeah, and I'm appreciative
- 9:06of everyone who's in the environment because I think they
- 9:09all serve a purpose. You know, I for me, one of the
- 9:13books that is like one of my Bibles is, is Philip Tetlock's
- 9:16work and his division of the world into thinkers, into foxes
- 9:20versus hedgehogs. I don't know if you guys are
- 9:21familiar with this, but for the listeners, Tetlock was doing
- 9:24analysis of people who were making political predictions.
- 9:28And he found that the only thing that was statistically there,
- 9:30statistically relevant for people who are making political,
- 9:34the forecast was, were they a fox or were they a hedgehog?
- 9:37And a hedgehog is somebody who knows one thing really, really
- 9:39well and bangs that square peg into the round hole over and
- 9:43over and over again. And the juxtaposition is the fox
- 9:46is somebody who will change his mind even while you're in
- 9:49conversation with him because he'll be open to new data.
- 9:51He'll be open to new ideas. And the crux of what Tetlock
- 9:55found was that it's the hedgehogs that get all of the
- 9:58media play time. Because it's really hard to
- 10:00change your mind constantly and engage with complex ideas and
- 10:03have people listen to a 2 minute sound bite.
- 10:05So the people that constantly get fed to you, the media diet
- 10:08that we get is all of the hedgehogs, no matter how wrong
- 10:10they are. And it was the foxes that were
- 10:12statistically better at predicting things than the
- 10:15hedgehogs. So I'm a fox in this space, and
- 10:18I think there is utility for hedgehogs.
- 10:19Like Peter was the one who said, yeah, Russia's probably going to
- 10:22invade Ukraine. I'll raise my hand right here
- 10:24and say I didn't think that was going to happen.
- 10:26Geopolitically, it didn't make sense to me.
- 10:28Now, the 10 things that happened after that Peter didn't get
- 10:30right because he was stillwell, you know, this is what's going
- 10:33to happen. It's the hedgehog thing.
- 10:34I had to really pivot very quickly and decide, OK, like I
- 10:37got this thing wrong. Let's get out of our Russian
- 10:39assets. Let's think about all the
- 10:40different ways that this is going to change the world.
- 10:42And I'm proud of the sort of track record since then.
- 10:44And I think, you know, sort of what you talked about that
- 10:46there's two things that I would say.
- 10:48The first is I reject the notion that there's a big crystal ball
- 10:52out there. Like my analysis is never
- 10:54deterministic. I will always overweight to the
- 10:56role of individuals because all economics and demographics and
- 11:00all of these highfalutin studies, it's all just trying to
- 11:04figure out what large groups of humans are going to do.
- 11:07I think sometimes we lose sight of the fact that, yeah, like you
- 11:09have to understand deeply what the individual is going to do
- 11:12and you have to have a fair degree of humility in
- 11:14understanding that. Like, let's take demographics is
- 11:17a great example. How are we supposed to know how
- 11:19many children the individual family is going to want to have
- 11:225-10 years from now? The hubris in predicting
- 11:25outwards demographic trends just based on a population pyramid,
- 11:28like blows my mind because you have to really get in the minds
- 11:31of families and what they want to do if you actually want to
- 11:33try and predict that. And then the second thing, you
- 11:35know, I talked about it being a small group of analysts who are
- 11:38out there in this space. You might have seen that JP
- 11:41Morgan is the latest to do this. They announced, they announced
- 11:43this new Center for geopolitics that they're building.
- 11:45And all of the big firms are doing this in the same way that
- 11:48they're, you know, being converted to Bitcoin and
- 11:50cryptocurrency. They're also being converted to
- 11:52geopolitics and rolling out these huge centers.
- 11:55But the way that they're rolling out these centers, and I'm not
- 11:57trying to throw shade at the people that they're hiring
- 11:59there, but they're getting people with impressive
- 12:01credentials who are high up in government or defense or
- 12:04intelligence, slapping them into their special center of
- 12:07geopolitics and saying, OK, now we do geopolitics.
- 12:10And The thing is, my form of analysis, it's not about what
- 12:13I've done. It's about how I think it's a
- 12:15discipline, It's a practice for how you think about the world.
- 12:17And just because you were assistant deputy to so and so at
- 12:20the department of yada, yada, yada, OK, it's a really nice
- 12:23title. Even if it's a five star general
- 12:25like that doesn't mean you actually know how to look at a
- 12:28piece of information and say, OK, I'm going to analyze it this
- 12:31way. It's going to mean this for this
- 12:32investment portfolio. It's going to mean this for this
- 12:35particular family based on their geography.
- 12:37Like that's a very, very different skill set than setting
- 12:40up a center and sort of having some names there.
- 12:42So that's that's what I mean when I say that it's it's out
- 12:44there and that there's a small group of us who actually do the
- 12:46work versus everybody knows they want geopolitics now and it's a
- 12:49fairly scarce commodity. And so they're trying to find
- 12:52all these different ways they can say they do geopolitics
- 12:54without actually doing the hard analytical work.
- 12:59I love that Jacob there. There's a lot that we can pull
- 13:01on there, But I think just as a foundational part of the
- 13:03conversation, I would really love to hear how you define
- 13:06geopolitics because it was in the report and it's now a
- 13:09buzzword to your point. When you started your career,
- 13:12nobody really paid attention to geopolitics.
- 13:14It was more a niche thing. But now you're making the case
- 13:17over the past couple of years and going forward, geopolitics
- 13:20is really a primary pillar and focus of capital allocation.
- 13:25So I'm hoping you could define geopolitics and then in addition
- 13:29to that, you know, what are the some of the core things that
- 13:31you're paying attention to today?
- 13:33And then Rob would love to get you looped into the kind of the
- 13:36back half of this segment or question to talk about how these
- 13:41themes that Jacob's speaking to from a geopolitical perspective
- 13:44are converging into the investment landscape and how you
- 13:47think about that? Yeah, it's a it's a devilishly
- 13:50hard word to define. And I reached a sort of crisis
- 13:55in my career 10 years in where it sort of a la Don Draper.
- 13:57I like wrote this piece to myself.
- 13:59That was why I'm quitting geopolitics because I hated the
- 14:02word and I really had to come to terms with it.
- 14:04I think there's 2 levels at which we can define geopolitics.
- 14:06The first is just the method and the discipline that I talked
- 14:09about around the time we're talking about late 19th century.
- 14:14So 18, seventies, 1880s, eighteen 90s.
- 14:16This is the same time that we're getting concepts of social
- 14:18Darwinism, of evolutionary biology.
- 14:21All these things are starting to come in and you get this class
- 14:24of social scientists largely based in Germany.
- 14:27There are some in the UK. Mckinder is the famous one that
- 14:30most people know, but it was actually a Swede who was the one
- 14:32who coined the word who start thinking about the nation state
- 14:35in an organic sense. I should also say you're going
- 14:38at this period from multi ethnic empires and monarchies to actual
- 14:42nation states defined by ethnicity and, and things like
- 14:44that. And so they start a theory of
- 14:47international politics basically that treats the nation state
- 14:49like it's an Organism. So what that means is the nation
- 14:53state has needs, it needs to eat, it needs to expand and have
- 14:57room to grow. It also has constraints.
- 14:59There are things which no matter what it wants to do, it
- 15:01absolutely cannot do. And so you have to assess all of
- 15:05these different needs and imperatives of.
- 15:07And when you do that, you will get some sense of how the world
- 15:10is going to work. This was a pretty attractive
- 15:13discipline in a popular discipline into the early 1900s.
- 15:16And it got a bad rap because the Nazis, as you can imagine, loved
- 15:20it. They could use a lot of these
- 15:23different geopolitical justifications to say, oh, the
- 15:25Germans need living space and the Slavs are lesser people than
- 15:29us and the Jews are lesser people than us.
- 15:30So let's just take the living space and expand.
- 15:33And this is all geopolitically justified because the science of
- 15:35geopolitics tells us that, you know, the Third Reich, blah blah
- 15:39blah blah blah. And so for decades after World
- 15:41War 2, geopolitics really goes into disrepute because nobody
- 15:45wants to be tied to something that the Nazis took off the
- 15:47shelf and then applied in their own way to to really bastardize
- 15:52in their way to justify some of the policies that they were
- 15:54doing. It started to make a comeback in
- 15:57the United States, ironically, from German intellectuals and
- 16:00scholars who brought it here, you know, folks that had left
- 16:02the Nazi regime early on. Hans Morgenthau was one of the
- 16:05the real godfathers of it. And in the US intelligence
- 16:09community in, you know, the, the thinkers that were thinking
- 16:12about the Cold War, they revive the initial practice of
- 16:15geopolitics to think about the relations between the Soviet
- 16:18Union and the United States and to try and model what relations
- 16:21are going to look like in a bipolar world.
- 16:23And, you know, basically ever since then, you get these
- 16:26updates to geopolitical practice and discipline as a result of
- 16:29that. So I say that because there's
- 16:31this discipline and practice thing, which is in a certain
- 16:33sense, geopolitics didn't exist for roughly 1880.
- 16:36Like it wasn't a thing. Now there's a second order level
- 16:39of geopolitics, which is to say the things that geopolitics is
- 16:42trying to understand, which is the relations between nations or
- 16:46between empires or different groups of people that has been
- 16:49going on for literally thousands of years.
- 16:51So you can go back in time and apply a geopolitical analysis to
- 16:56Sparta and Athens or to the Davidic monarchies in, in you
- 17:01know, in Israel and things like that.
- 17:02You get lots of scholars that start to do that.
- 17:04But I do think you start to go off the rails and get into
- 17:06crystal ball. And if you say, ah, like
- 17:08geopolitics has been there for thousands of years, like, no,
- 17:11it's a, it's a lens and a discipline for how to understand
- 17:14the world. I think it is ideally suited for
- 17:17understanding the world today because I think we're going back
- 17:19to a world like the 1890s. I think you're getting that
- 17:23level of volatility. I think you're getting changes
- 17:25in the international political system that are pitting States
- 17:28and nations and even non state actors against each other in the
- 17:30way that geopolitics was designed to understand.
- 17:33I think geopolitics was particularly boring from roughly
- 17:361990 to 2015 because geopolitics was easy.
- 17:40It was the United States is the top dog.
- 17:42The buck stops with the United States, you know, invest in the
- 17:45United States and its allies, go to lunch and play golf, and
- 17:47don't look at your portfolio too much.
- 17:49Like that would have been the geopolitically responsible thing
- 17:51to do. But now I think we're going back
- 17:53to this world where it's relevant again.
- 17:55And in terms of the core things I look at, honestly, it depends
- 18:00what the question is. It depends what the time horizon
- 18:02is. It depends who the client is.
- 18:04I mean, it really veers all over the place.
- 18:06I will tell you, I often joke that if you left me on a desert
- 18:09island and I had one statistical indicator that I could use to
- 18:13understand what was going on in the rest of the world, give me
- 18:16food prices. Because every single time food
- 18:19prices rise, you basically are guaranteed a major war or a
- 18:22major revolution or something like that.
- 18:24But it's really, really hard to just say, you know, here are the
- 18:27things that you have to watch for some clients who are exposed
- 18:30in certain geographies. You have to focus on those
- 18:33things. I can tell you that some of the
- 18:35things that we are particularly interested in and that I think
- 18:37we have contrarian viewpoints on and, and Rob might add some
- 18:39color here is, you know, we think that the future of China
- 18:42over the next 5-10 years is going to be critically
- 18:44important. That's maybe the biggest
- 18:46question you have to get right on a macro level because if
- 18:50China is going to collapse or if, you know, demographic
- 18:53decline is going to lead to breaks in the Communist Party's
- 18:55authority, well, that's one decision tree.
- 18:58And it will affect both investments in China and also
- 19:00the world globally versus, well, is China going to survive and
- 19:03thrive? They are the global
- 19:04manufacturing capital of the world.
- 19:06They are having huge advantages in innovation and technology,
- 19:09things that we were assured were not possible because there's no
- 19:12way that communists can be innovative, right?
- 19:14Well, you start to look under the hood, they're looking pretty
- 19:16innovative, more innovative in some ways than the United
- 19:19States. So we're constantly thinking
- 19:20about that. We've been bullish about the
- 19:22European Union and its prospects for as a sort of pole in the
- 19:25multi polar order for years now. And that's one that we're
- 19:28constantly checking in on at to Rob's point, sort of cynically
- 19:31asking ourselves, is this actually happened?
- 19:33Is Europe actually becoming something more than the sum of
- 19:35its sum of its parts? Or are Hungary and Poland and
- 19:38Germany going to keep arguing about stupid things so they're
- 19:41until they're blue in the face and the world has left them
- 19:43behind? And then, of course, thinking
- 19:46about the role of the United States, the mismatch between
- 19:48imperial US foreign policy in a multipolar world and how that
- 19:52affects emerging markets and then other things.
- 19:54But, you know, sometimes it's as down in the weeds.
- 19:57As you know, Rob and I have done projects before that required me
- 20:00to get really specific about Turkish.
- 20:04Gold legislation and and rules about mining rights inside of
- 20:07Turkey because we were looking at a particular particular
- 20:10investment opportunity around that.
- 20:11So it can be very, very high level with the crystal ball
- 20:13thing. It can also be very granular and
- 20:15like, OK, what is this law going to do to this investment in this
- 20:18geography and this time horizon, things like that, so.
- 20:24Just to take the baton a little bit and talk about how that gets
- 20:29implemented in terms of capital allocation.
- 20:33Just I would preface that by saying, you know, Jacob spoke
- 20:37about foxes and hedgehogs. And that's a really important
- 20:40thing to take away because as someone who comes from the
- 20:43investing side, who's worked with Jacob as a geopolitical
- 20:47analyst side by side and actually implementing for a
- 20:50number of years now, I can tell you it's very different from
- 20:53what most people are used to. Because most people who do what
- 20:56Jacob do, they're in the business of selling ideas or
- 20:59selling consulting. And that's all about
- 21:02storytelling and narratives. And a great macro investor once
- 21:06said that when it comes to investing, storytelling is 10%
- 21:10of it and 90% is implementation and flexibility.
- 21:14So if you were to see the actual, you know, the way the
- 21:17sausage gets made in terms of research process and how we're
- 21:20taking some of the things that Jacob is talking about and
- 21:23actually kicking the tires on them, it would be very boring
- 21:27and grey and probabilistic. And, you know, here are our
- 21:30theses and where's the new information?
- 21:32And is this disproving anything? What do we have to to check up
- 21:36on? And that doesn't make for good
- 21:38storytelling, but it makes for good investing.
- 21:41So I would preface it with that. And in terms of specifics, you
- 21:46know, I think, you know, the way that we're implementing right
- 21:49now kind of these core theses that Jacob just talked about.
- 21:53You know, I, I think if you take what, what he's saying and, and
- 21:57you know, boil it down to two investment theses, it really
- 22:01comes down to, you know, that if we're entering a period, you
- 22:06know, that's more multi polar, you're having something like a
- 22:10volatility spiral. You know, this is a term we use
- 22:12a lot where volatility in a lot of different dimensions is going
- 22:16up over the last 10-15 years. That's policy volatility, it's
- 22:21market volatility. It is the volatility within
- 22:25culture, within technology itself.
- 22:28And obviously that has a lot of negative implications, which you
- 22:31know your your listeners will be familiar with.
- 22:33It also has a lot of really positive implications because
- 22:36the same kind of volatility and Oh my God, did that just happen
- 22:40kind of feeling also opens the door to innovative thinking, to
- 22:44innovative technologies. So when you think about one of
- 22:47the core things that we do with families is first protect and
- 22:53how to really think carefully about the protection side.
- 22:57But then also where do you harvest that volatility and all
- 23:01the opportunities that are springing up out of it.
- 23:03And that's mostly about innovation and about
- 23:06technological change and growth coming out of new disruptive
- 23:11technologies. And those are the two things
- 23:13that we spend most of our time thinking about.
- 23:16And then from a geographic standpoint, I think one of the
- 23:18big, big things that we're super focused on that is that is quite
- 23:22different is in a multipolar world, creating portfolios that
- 23:27are truly global portfolios and not, you know, oh, you have your
- 23:30S&P 500, you know, sort of approach.
- 23:33And then you're going to throw some ETFs on the side, like
- 23:36truly starting from scratch with a global view.
- 23:40Where are the poles of power and value creation?
- 23:44What is the true, you know, way to get access to them?
- 23:46How are they interacting? How do you control for a sort of
- 23:50fragmenting supply chains across of those and, and diversify
- 23:54while protecting those are those are big things.
- 23:57But really having that, that global first approach and having
- 24:02the ability to go and to get access to to markets and to
- 24:08invest in markets where, you know, most US based families are
- 24:13currently not thinking about and, and are currently way over
- 24:17exposed to the US. That's a big it's a big part of
- 24:21what we do as well. Yeah.
- 24:24I mean, this is, it's unrelated but related that I can't help
- 24:29but think about investing in entrepreneurship are we're
- 24:34always meant to be artisanal and very bespoke.
- 24:37It's where the name of the firms is so great because these
- 24:41concepts that you're referencing were 100 years ago normal and
- 24:46standardized, but they've kind of been bastardized with the
- 24:48amount of liquidity in the system.
- 24:50And I know you guys feel it there's because there's no
- 24:51shorter to people that will say they do what you do, but there's
- 24:54a lot of ways you're describing what you do that signals from
- 24:57anybody that is a builder understands deeply like the
- 25:01notion that you referenced in, you know, the implementation and
- 25:06flexibility and eerily resembles entrepreneurship and like
- 25:10everyone can have an idea, but the execution is all is where
- 25:13all the devil in the details is that 90% And part of the
- 25:16execution is the flexibility because anybody that's ever
- 25:18started something ultimately knows that like your plans are
- 25:20going to change very quickly. And so you have to be able to
- 25:23navigate that. And it goes back to Jacob.
- 25:26In the beginning, you referenced nobody really understands the
- 25:30the market. You can only get as best as you
- 25:32can in understanding individuals and what will like the
- 25:34interconnected interconnectedness and it kind
- 25:38of titles back to like Steve Jobs and taste.
- 25:40There was something that that world class entrepreneurs and I
- 25:42think investors both have as a taste for the market.
- 25:45They have a taste for how individuals react, how what's
- 25:48happening around corners. And it goes back to, I think
- 25:51Jacob, would you were referencing about like the
- 25:54notion of in the dirt and in the clouds of getting in the weeds
- 25:57in the Turkish mining firm, but also looking at it, how it
- 26:00interconnects at the highest level.
- 26:02And so there's just a lot of like these ideas and how a free
- 26:04market forms is around entrepreneurs and then around
- 26:06investors that are able to see both sides.
- 26:08And you have to be able to understand that.
- 26:10And the majority of the market just fundamentally doesn't have
- 26:11this because they haven't been actually kind of tied back to
- 26:14the fundamentals. And we'll probably talk about
- 26:16like loose monetary policy, you know, has created this
- 26:20structure, but it helps in like really paint a picture.
- 26:22You guys have a deep understanding of what you're
- 26:23doing because this is just how economies have formed.
- 26:26But there's a very big dislocation from fundamentals to
- 26:29like noise in the system. Yeah, no, I mean, absolutely.
- 26:34I think the hardest part of, and this is not just geopolitical
- 26:37analysis, the hardest part of any analysis, whether it's
- 26:39investment analysis or political analysis or cultural analysis,
- 26:43like you name it, it's that you fall in love with your own ideas
- 26:47and you see things that comport with your narrative.
- 26:51You know, my job, I think sometimes sounds sexier than it
- 26:54is. Like the fun part of my job is
- 26:55thinking about the world that are making these predictions
- 26:57about where I think think things are going.
- 26:59But to Rob's point, like I spend 90% of my time looking for
- 27:02things that disprove my ideas. Like that is most of what I
- 27:05spend my time on to see the ways that I am wrong because I am
- 27:08constantly worried that I didn't understand everything because
- 27:11there's no possible way I could understand everything.
- 27:13Right. Like in that sense, it's really
- 27:14about learning more quickly than other people are learning and
- 27:18having my finger on the pulse so that when something happens, I'm
- 27:22going to be able to pivot really quickly.
- 27:24When I was, when I was still doing mostly in the consulting
- 27:26space, for example, I was working, I can't name the
- 27:29companies, but I was working for several different companies and
- 27:31COVID in 2020 happened to everyone.
- 27:35It destroyed supply chains before everyone.
- 27:37Nobody had a solution. But I can tell you there was a
- 27:39huge difference in the people that I worked with, some who had
- 27:42disaster pandemic plans and others who had never thought of
- 27:46it at all. And the ones that had plans and
- 27:49had thought through it and had been looking at these things
- 27:50very closely and took it very seriously when they were like,
- 27:53hey, there's a weird disease in China circulating.
- 27:55This was December 2019. You started to pick up media
- 27:58reports. So I had a couple people who are
- 28:00like, hey, this is this seems weird.
- 28:02Do we need to like think about this?
- 28:04Do we need to start thinking about like disaster plans and
- 28:06things like that versus those who like, no, everything's fine.
- 28:09Like there's going to be no problem. the US government says
- 28:11everything's fine. The World Health Organization
- 28:13says everything's fine. We're not worrying about this.
- 28:15And then like they have no plan when things get taken off the
- 28:18shelf. So yeah, it's, it's that
- 28:19constant push to, to your point of the 90% implementation,
- 28:23anybody can have good ideas, but can you change your mind?
- 28:26Can you take the L and move on and keep punching because you
- 28:29trust your method and your discipline rather than sort of
- 28:32shooting your shot at one thing and then getting really insecure
- 28:34when that one thing goes wrong? There's a lot of different
- 28:40directions we can go in. I'm curious like to try to my,
- 28:43my aim here is to try to wrap in a couple of different things
- 28:46both Jacob and Rob you spoke to in the past 10 minutes or so.
- 28:50So we talked about kind of the investment thesis and the idea
- 28:54of multipolarity global capital allocation, kind of starting
- 28:57from a neutral base and then building out that portfolio
- 29:01globally. We talked about long volatility.
- 29:03It really does sound like a lot of the themes that both of you
- 29:06are focused on and helping your clients preserve and then grow
- 29:09wealth are a lot different than what they were 5-10 years ago.
- 29:14And so I know there's still a lot of traditional finance
- 29:19that's unwilling to let go of how portfolios have been
- 29:23constructed for the past, call it 30 or 40 years, short
- 29:26volatility, 6040, mostly public equity, public fixed income
- 29:31exposure, very heavy concentration in the US.
- 29:33So what you're proposing is kind of vastly different than what
- 29:38mainstream portfolio construction has looked like
- 29:40over the past several decades. And I want to get into that.
- 29:44But I think before doing so just to get a little bit deeper on
- 29:47some of the themes that are actually driving the shift of
- 29:50capital allocation. We talked about again, multi
- 29:52polarity geopolitics, you define it, Jacob.
- 29:55These are themes that are critically important to pay
- 29:57attention to. And maybe a decade ago, to your
- 30:00point, the geopolitical move was to just be long US, right?
- 30:04And and now that's obviously changed.
- 30:07And the other thing too that you mentioned, I think it's really
- 30:09interesting and important to hone in on is the future of
- 30:12China. And so understanding what you
- 30:14said the next five years might look like that is really going
- 30:17to shape a lot of not only the investment thesis, but also I
- 30:21guess risk management I guess is the best way I'd categorize it.
- 30:26So I'm curious, there's a lot of things themes that we've already
- 30:29discussed, but I think before going forward on some of the
- 30:32investment policy or investment framework capital allocation
- 30:35decisions and why that's so different, it might be more
- 30:38helpful to understand what's happening with the two world
- 30:41superpowers right now, the United States and China.
- 30:44And so if we could talk about what you've paid attention to
- 30:47this year, what you're looking at going forward in the United
- 30:50States as it relates to fiscal and monetary policy.
- 30:54You know, there's the big beautiful bill, there's the
- 30:56credit downgrade, there's DOGE, which hasn't really lived up to
- 31:00what expectations were six months ago.
- 31:02I think probably some of us saw that coming just given the
- 31:04fiscal situation. And then you have China as well,
- 31:07which you said is incredibly important to figure out what the
- 31:10next five years might look like. So I'm curious to distill all
- 31:14that thoughts on US, China and where things stand currently in
- 31:19this kind of power competition. And then from there, we can get
- 31:22more into investment frameworks. Yeah, I mean, we could spend 2
- 31:26hours just talking about the things that you talked about.
- 31:28But I'll, I'll try to do it very succinctly and I'll let rob,
- 31:30I'll let the Rob lead the cavalry charge when it comes to
- 31:33US fiscal and and monetary, because it does relate to these
- 31:35things. I'll tell you that in some, in
- 31:37some sense, I think the damage that Doge had, some of this
- 31:40reckless cutting has done, the assault on American
- 31:43universities, which isn't to say that they didn't need, they
- 31:45weren't needed reform, but the assault on universities, on the
- 31:48assault on international students, like I think that's
- 31:50going to have huge impacts on US innovation and technology going
- 31:55forward. But I think in your question,
- 31:57actually, you just helped show unwittingly how hard it is to
- 32:00process some of these concepts because I reject the notion that
- 32:03there are two world superpowers. If that's true, we're in a
- 32:05bipolar world, then it's the United States and China, it's
- 32:07Cold War 2.0, and we just go back to that mental model and
- 32:11that is possible. That's like when I stay up at
- 32:14night and think, am I wrong about things?
- 32:15That's the scenario that I think could replace the multi polar
- 32:18scenario. But the true multi polar
- 32:21scenario is there are no world superpowers.
- 32:24There are just regional powers that are vying for spheres of
- 32:27influence and trying to make sure they have access to food or
- 32:30energy or the intellectual property or the capital inputs
- 32:33that they need in order for their economies to function.
- 32:38So I think, yes, the United States and China are the two
- 32:40largest economies, and in some ways they are the most
- 32:42important. But I don't think either one of
- 32:44them is at that dominant level of that world superpower level.
- 32:47And I think one of the reasons you see such volatility with
- 32:51U.S. policy is this Trump administration doesn't get that.
- 32:55They think the United States is still the top dog and they think
- 32:58they're making America even greater, that all the things
- 33:01that they're doing are just making America even more
- 33:03powerful and that everyone will bend the knee just because
- 33:06President Trump says so. And I think they're going to be
- 33:08in this short term bias where people will bend the knee in the
- 33:11short term because in the short term, yes, it would be very
- 33:14painful to pick a fight with the Trump administration, with the
- 33:17United States. But many, many countries, even
- 33:19US allies are looking in the mirror and saying this country
- 33:22is not dependable anymore. We're going to need to make 510
- 33:25year plans for a multi polar world where we can't rely on the
- 33:28US security guarantee or where the US might attack on tariffs
- 33:31to us next because we're starting to run afoul of
- 33:34something for policy there. I'm a good example of what I'm
- 33:37talking about. For me, the so far far this
- 33:40year, the two most important things that have happened in the
- 33:42world. Number one is the break between
- 33:45the United States and Europe. I think when historians look
- 33:48back at 2025, we won't necessarily be talking and we
- 33:51still have six months to go in the year.
- 33:52But if we just had these six months, you know, it would be
- 33:56all the things that the Trump administration did to break the
- 33:59transatlantic partnership, which has basically been in place
- 34:02since the end of World War 2. In 1945, if you had a German
- 34:06election and a chancellor appointed who has literally said
- 34:10we cannot trust the United States anymore, Germany must
- 34:13rearm itself. You have German auto companies
- 34:16that are selling facilities or, you know, signing contracts to
- 34:19produce weapons and tanks and artillery shells.
- 34:23Again, this always makes me nervous like, you know, you get
- 34:25some people in the United States say no, Germany should spend
- 34:27their fair share on defense. I don't know.
- 34:30I saw the movie where they spent a lot on defense.
- 34:32Do do we really want to relive that movie?
- 34:34Anyway, I'm I'm a little I'm rambling there a little.
- 34:36But the point being like, I think that's a huge thing.
- 34:39Also, I mean, I've been obsessed with this since over the
- 34:41weekend, as Rob can attest, what Ukraine did to Russia over the
- 34:45weekend. That might be the biggest thing
- 34:47that happens this decade. For all I know.
- 34:49It used to be that long stern, the ability to strike at an
- 34:53enemy target over long distances.
- 34:56That was a commodity only owned by great powers.
- 34:59And over the weekend, Ukraine with roughly 100 drones costing
- 35:03$600 a pop roughly. You could go buy the drones
- 35:06yourself if you want to, took out 1/3 of Russia's strategic
- 35:10bomber fleet, strategic bombers that cost $100 million per
- 35:14bomber. And when you start to put that
- 35:16in context, I think about some of the things that have happened
- 35:18geopolitically in the last 12 to 18 months.
- 35:21You've got a ragtag group of non state Houthi militants in Yemen
- 35:25firing off missiles and rockets in the Persian Gulf such that
- 35:28entire supply chains avoid the Persian Gulf.
- 35:30Now everybody's going around Africa and the United States
- 35:33under both Biden and Trump haven't been able to stop them.
- 35:37They've bombed them, they've warmed them, they've threatened
- 35:39them. The Houthis are still sitting
- 35:41there and shipping is still going around Africa.
- 35:43Not a very unipolar power. Think about what Israel did to
- 35:46Hezbollah with the pagers, where they hijacked international
- 35:49supply chains, input some explosives and some devices that
- 35:52they knew were going to this militia inside of Lebanon and
- 35:55decapitated them all. Cool if you don't like jihadist
- 35:58militias, but not so cool if you are an important human being or
- 36:02somebody that might be targeted for different things.
- 36:04And can somebody hijack a supply chain and put something into a
- 36:07device or something to spy on you or to hurt you or to hurt
- 36:11your different country? Like all these things are sort
- 36:14of in our face about that. So I think that's another thing
- 36:16to think about. And it gets to this, the
- 36:18intersection of technology and how that relates to governments
- 36:20and how things are working together.
- 36:22So we can delve into that too. And then the last one, I would
- 36:24just say, you know, sort of ask the things that I'm talking
- 36:27about. I don't want to Pooh Pooh China.
- 36:29But for me, the thing that keeps me up about China is not
- 36:31necessarily the economy. And I know that, I mean, Rob
- 36:35doesn't have any more hair to burn off of his head based on me
- 36:37saying that, but I'm sure inside he's like, stop it, Jacob.
- 36:39But at least geopolitically, the most important thing for me is
- 36:43the health of Xi Jinping, because as long as Xi Jinping is
- 36:46calling the shots, China's fairly predictable to me.
- 36:49It's fairly clear what they're trying to do, and I don't have a
- 36:52lot of doubt about what they're trying to do.
- 36:53The problem with China is the political structure, at least to
- 36:56the extent that we can analyze it, looks extremely brittle.
- 36:59If this guy has a heart attack or if he, you know, slips on a
- 37:02banana peel and has a stroke or something like that, there is no
- 37:05successor. That's by design.
- 37:07He got rid of all the successors.
- 37:08He's purged all of the rivals. And so if you get to a situation
- 37:11situation where Xi Jinping is not calling the shots and he's
- 37:14getting up there in age, then political stability in China
- 37:18starts to look very different. I think China has shown market
- 37:21resilience over the past couple of years, dealing with lots of
- 37:24structural economic problems. And I think that resilience will
- 37:26continue. And I think they have a lot of
- 37:28leverage in the multi polar world and in the trade war that
- 37:30the Trump administration is I think mistakenly picking with
- 37:34China. But the thing that keeps me up
- 37:35at night is, well, is Xi Jinping going to be around to follow
- 37:39through on some of these things? Because I don't see that that
- 37:41the system itself. And maybe I'm wrong about this,
- 37:43but it looks to me like the system is brittle.
- 37:45I'm in that very narrow sense. So those are the three things
- 37:48that I would say I'm looking at this year.
- 37:49And maybe Rob wants to weigh in on on some of the others that
- 37:53you talk about. Yeah, I can, I can run with
- 37:57that. And then ultimately take take us
- 37:59all the way back to 6040 and how we get to finance theory and and
- 38:04all the highfalutin stuff. I think, you know, in in a lot
- 38:09of different themes, what Jacob was describing as sort of the
- 38:13asymmetry of power is changing and, you know, whether it's
- 38:18military or economic or what have you.
- 38:22And that's sort of the recurring theme.
- 38:24And that is multipolarity, of course, in finance terms and
- 38:28how, you know, we think about that.
- 38:30I think the events of the last two months have really been a
- 38:35strong confirmation of our thesis.
- 38:38And what I mean is like, if you grow up, you know, being trained
- 38:42in finance, you get used to thinking of the US as the top
- 38:47dog just in theory terms, like the US Treasury bond is
- 38:50literally the risk free asset. That's what it's called, the
- 38:53risk free asset. We don't have a risk free asset
- 38:58anymore. And the realization of that is
- 39:01quite shocking. And it up ends a lot of the
- 39:03traditional models of how people allocate to assets and how they
- 39:07allocate internationally. And everyone's sort of familiar
- 39:10with what's going on and, and, and why that is.
- 39:12So I won't elaborate on that point, but that's the biggest
- 39:17earthquake of of the last 40 years in terms of how to think
- 39:22about investing, how to think about capital allocation is that
- 39:25pre pre eminent US position is, is, you know, wounded and it
- 39:32doesn't look like it's coming back.
- 39:34So that would be, you know, sort of the the very high level take
- 39:37away in terms of, you know, what we're actually doing in terms of
- 39:43implementation. And specifically with regard to
- 39:45China, I think as Jacob explains, we're quite bullish,
- 39:51but also quite cognizant that there are risks there
- 39:54geopolitically. And what we try to do, without
- 39:58getting too into the details is identify those areas of China
- 40:03that are extremely attractive from a growth standpoint to find
- 40:07these champions essentially. That are trading at tiny
- 40:10fractions of the multiples that you know similar companies in
- 40:13the US trade at. Just just to put some meat on
- 40:16the bone of that. If you were to look at the
- 40:18beginning of this year, BYD which has the same revenue as
- 40:23Tesla, they both at the at the end of last year did 100 billion
- 40:27of revenue. Byd's market valuation was $100
- 40:30million a $100 billion. Excuse me, Tesla's market
- 40:34valuation was $900 billion. So very similar businesses, same
- 40:38exact financials, 1 trades at 9 times the valuation as another.
- 40:42And obviously that's a little extreme example, but that's not
- 40:46an isolated case. When you look at sort of Chinese
- 40:48assets and how they've been basically left abandoned by
- 40:52people who are thinking emotionally and, and, and all,
- 40:56you know, the things that we know.
- 40:58So just seizing those opportunities itself is a is a
- 41:02big part of what we do along specific areas of technology, in
- 41:07particular where China is developing, you know, clear
- 41:11superiority and an ability to go into export markets and really
- 41:15drive growth in addition to domestic markets.
- 41:18So trying to hedge some of those risks that Jacob talked about
- 41:21politically and and sort of those tail risks of a Xi Jinping
- 41:26banana peel event. So so yeah, I mean, we can, we
- 41:31can get into specific areas if you if you guys want.
- 41:34But how this ties into, you know, the investment industry
- 41:39and conventional wisdom, so to speak.
- 41:42The one point I would make on that is we're a boutique and our
- 41:47job is to work for the families that we work with and to take
- 41:52care of them. That's very different from what
- 41:55most of the investment industry is.
- 41:57The investment industry is there to sell you products.
- 42:00And the term that I would use is institutional inertia, because
- 42:04most investment institutions emerge to fight the last war.
- 42:08They emerge to capture what is working and then sell that in
- 42:12whatever number of iterations over and over and stuff the
- 42:16goose full of product. And now we're sitting in a
- 42:20position where we just had a 40 year period where the big things
- 42:23were. Up until recently, stocks and
- 42:26bonds moved in opposite directions.
- 42:28So you could create everything around the notion that that's
- 42:31going to always be the case. That's number one.
- 42:34Number two, the US is going to outperform everybody.
- 42:38And, and that's all you really need to think about.
- 42:41And #3 private markets are, you know, the bee's knees, and
- 42:47that's superior to public equities.
- 42:49So the more private equity, the more venture capital you can do,
- 42:53the better. Everyone wants to be like David
- 42:55Swenson to the point where about a decade ago, the liquidity
- 43:00premium went negative. In other words, people were
- 43:03paying extra just to lock up their money.
- 43:06So the whole industry has grown up around those themes where
- 43:09it's US focused, you know, selling you private products
- 43:14and, and everything has revolved around that and around these
- 43:17asset allocation models that assume the 6040 framework where
- 43:20bonds are a hedge until they're not.
- 43:23And I only bring that up to say, you know, it's going to be very
- 43:26difficult to transition out of those institutions because all
- 43:30of these institutions have grown up around those ideas.
- 43:33And you don't change your stripes overnight.
- 43:36Whereas A boutique, you just do what works and you move.
- 43:40We're not selling products, we're just implementing
- 43:43solutions and figuring out what is happening and how do you
- 43:46respond. And that I think is our, that's
- 43:49our approach and why it's a nice place to work cuz you have that
- 43:53flexibility. Yeah, I mean, there's a lot
- 43:56there that really resonates. I know we have a core focus
- 43:59around Bitcoin and you guys have a component of that, but there's
- 44:01a lot of themes there. I love the institutional inertia
- 44:05component because it's something we talk about a lot when we
- 44:07reference these corporate treasuries adopting Bitcoin.
- 44:09It's like the it's the undefinition of alpha if
- 44:12everyone's doing it. And there there's, you know,
- 44:15it's that same framework that you're thinking about in the
- 44:176040 layered into this new asset class.
- 44:21And so it ultimately is discounting a lot of the
- 44:23counterparty risk and execution risk that nobody talks about.
- 44:27And I think to like summarize, at least in my mind, how I've
- 44:30always thought about because I didn't come from the traditional
- 44:32finance background. I came from the traditional tech
- 44:35world and then started to understand what money is.
- 44:37And then you start to just discern, well, if you're
- 44:39thinking at a micro ultimate boutique, right, the individual,
- 44:42it's like, well, I want the thing that has the properties
- 44:44that are going to reduce volatility, reduce counterparty
- 44:47risk, reduce the basement. Like these are natural things
- 44:50that the market has been short counterparty risk.
- 44:53And where we're going to, based on a lot of stuff Jacob and you
- 44:56shared is we're going to be long counter in our party risking
- 44:58long volatility over the next 10 to 20 years.
- 45:01And if you're in those positions, you have to start re
- 45:04underwriting all these assets. And so like anecdotes like the
- 45:07Russian Treasuries, debasement of bonds and just the currency
- 45:10and generally over multiple inflated equity multiples or
- 45:13private placement illiquidity. It's kind of how SUNY and I
- 45:16started chatting about this was just how crazy it is on the
- 45:18private placement side and people trying to get out of
- 45:20those positions at 50% discounts or whatever they are just so
- 45:23they can get back into liquid assets.
- 45:26That's kind of the core of like what we focus on.
- 45:28Why we see this like Bitcoin gold trade is so paramount is
- 45:31because you can start to really like chop at a lot of these
- 45:35things that exist in the market that historically people haven't
- 45:37really indexed as a problem. And they're going to wake up to
- 45:40a rude awakening and realizing, Oh my God, like I'm really long
- 45:45potential insolvency across the board.
- 45:47And that's a scary proposition. Yeah, well, you said it right
- 45:53there. And the term liquidity is
- 45:55unfortunately for many people, they are locked into the trend
- 46:00of the last war because they don't have liquidity.
- 46:02And that's, you know, the theme du jour, which you're seeing
- 46:06right now as all these vultures are raising, you know, fifteen
- 46:10$25 billion secondaries funds is, you know, it's the first
- 46:15step of trying to, you know, get your get your foot out of the
- 46:21trap. But that's not going to be an
- 46:23easy or a short process. And, you know, if, if you're
- 46:29listening to this and you're getting told by someone, hey,
- 46:31that you should really get into private assets, just be aware
- 46:35the way that they usually get out of these as they dump them
- 46:37on, you know, unsuspecting people.
- 46:40So be skeptical of of that pitch.
- 46:44Yeah, we talked about it. I mean Jackson had a background
- 46:47involved in when you think about like ALTS, like the notion of
- 46:52Alts alternative investments, right or private credit.
- 46:56Like when I hear that, it just sounds like further and further
- 47:00on the risk curve and speculative because people
- 47:02couldn't hit the hurdle rate of inflation or what the S&P.
- 47:05So they naturally had to be sold to go to these other products
- 47:08that are, you know, underperform when you look at it in
- 47:10aggregate. And it's pretty wild to know you
- 47:14guys have to feel this of like the market sentiments doesn't
- 47:16explain any of this or tell anybody that there's other
- 47:19viable solutions that provide more optionality, less alpha or
- 47:22just decay in general around the asset and they can maintain a
- 47:26liquid profile. And again, they don't have to
- 47:28have a boutique firm explain it. It's just not out there in the
- 47:31lexicon. And it, and I think that's part
- 47:33of like the the changing world is this information.
- 47:36If you can seek it out, can find podcasts like this and others
- 47:38and realize that they're you don't actually need to pay
- 47:41somebody 1% to just protect or or store your wealth.
- 47:45Just a quick break. I really like the framework that
- 47:47the Bespoke Group uses for evaluating investments.
- 47:50It's not only about what do you invest in, but it is how and
- 47:53where do you invest. And with Bitcoin, the question
- 47:57is how do you secure your Bitcoin for the long term?
- 48:00And that is why we started on ramp, because as the price moves
- 48:03from 1000 to 10,000 to 100,000 to 1,000,000, the landscape for
- 48:09risk and threat vectors is quite frankly changing.
- 48:12People are concerned about physical threats.
- 48:15They're concerned about exchange collapses.
- 48:17They're concerned about mismanaging their keys or their
- 48:20children not being able to access their Bitcoin
- 48:22inheritance. These are all things that need
- 48:24to be fleshed out sooner than later.
- 48:26And so at Onramp, that is exactly what we help our clients
- 48:29with. If you want to learn more about
- 48:31how we can work with you, head to onrampbitcoin.com.
- 48:34You can book a consultation. You can also shoot me a note
- 48:36directly jackson@onrampbitcoin.com.
- 48:39Be happy to have a conversation. Hope you enjoy the rest of the
- 48:41episode. Yeah, I mean, I would love to
- 48:44chat on. There's always so much you can
- 48:47cover in a podcast and especially when you have Rob and
- 48:51Jacob on, there's probably hours that we can go into.
- 48:54One thing that I think would be interesting and and impactful
- 48:57for the audience is just to Rob, maybe dig more into the
- 49:01statement that you made that may seem obvious to you.
- 49:04And it's probably somewhat obvious to a lot of our
- 49:06listeners given it is more of a, let's say, sound money focused
- 49:10capital allocation framework that they use personally or as a
- 49:14firm. But the US Treasury market is,
- 49:17to your point, the underpinning of the global financial system
- 49:20or was once the underpinning of the global financial system.
- 49:23But the US has been very fiscally irresponsible over the
- 49:28past several decades, continuing to run I think deficits 45 out
- 49:32of 50 years. And so it's both sides of the
- 49:36aisle, right. The basement deficit spending is
- 49:38just kind of baked into the system.
- 49:40And so I think it was last week or maybe the week prior with 30
- 49:44year bond yields hitting 5.1%, highest since 2007.
- 49:50That is alarming to me from the standpoint of how much debt
- 49:55there's actually been accumulated in the financial
- 49:57system because in 2007, I don't have the number off the top of
- 50:01my head, but it was a fraction of what the federal debt was
- 50:04today. And I think private debt has
- 50:06grown pretty dramatically as well.
- 50:08And so I'm curious just like digging more into just the RE
- 50:11underwriting of the US Treasury and how that ultimately impacts
- 50:16these capital allocation decisions that we're speaking
- 50:18about. We could also if you want, want
- 50:21to go there or feel the need to tie it in any way.
- 50:24Japan is interesting too, just JGB market and volatility there.
- 50:28So I'm curious just how you guys think it could be either for one
- 50:32of you, how you're thinking about the RE underwriting of the
- 50:34US Treasury and just volatility and bond yields there, just
- 50:38structural debasement baked into that?
- 50:41Yeah, I'll start with the treasuries and then maybe we can
- 50:43talk about Japan and and Jacob can get into the geopolitics of
- 50:47Japan too, because that's really relevant in that case.
- 50:52Jacob used the word constraints earlier, and I think that is
- 50:56really key. It's one thing to sit around and
- 51:00look at what's happened in the last few months and say, oh, you
- 51:02know, wow, if only I'd seen that coming.
- 51:06I think really what we try to focus on doing is anticipating
- 51:12and anticipating based on those constraints.
- 51:15And if you looked at where the United States was even six or
- 51:18seven years ago, I mean, in short, tax receipts have gone
- 51:26down as a percentage of GDP and spending has irrevocably gone up
- 51:32for reasons that politically are very, very, very difficult to
- 51:37change. Like those are.
- 51:39That's the Cliffs Notes version of the constraints.
- 51:42So unless you see some powerful force that's going to come in
- 51:46and change that and you know, there's all sorts of Speaking of
- 51:49probabilistic, you know, scenario analysis, like we don't
- 51:51even want to go down that, but you really have to just start
- 51:57with that is that that is the set up and that's what's playing
- 52:01out over time. And it's going to continue to
- 52:03play out over time. And you're monitoring for what
- 52:06are the signposts of how they're going to react and what are they
- 52:08going to do given those constraints that they have?
- 52:11What are the tools in their toolkit?
- 52:12Is it pegging yields? Well, that has implications.
- 52:15Is it, you know, is it actual, you know, a move toward physical
- 52:18consolidation that has major implications.
- 52:22So, you know, without going down all the rabbit holes of the
- 52:25different scenarios, I think really starting with that
- 52:27assumption and, and assuming that that's going to continue is
- 52:30where you have to begin. And there's no, there's no easy
- 52:34way out of that problem and it's going to be a major problem.
- 52:38So we, you know, we have not been involved in any sort of
- 52:42credit with our clients or, or duration risk quite, you know,
- 52:49deliberately. And that's, that is something
- 52:51that we that's is going to be part of the playbook unless
- 52:55something big changes and getting to some of the stuff
- 53:01that we shared, you know, on the resilient portfolio paper and,
- 53:05and Switzerland and Singapore. You know, a lot of what we do,
- 53:09like when you look at the constraints and sort of
- 53:10politically in the USA, lot of what we do for clients is
- 53:14identify, OK, where are the special places where those
- 53:16constraints are different? Where are the incentives
- 53:19different? And finding geographies that are
- 53:22unique in that sense that have a strong incentive not to debase,
- 53:26not to run deficits, not to peg yields, but to run, you know,
- 53:31policies that protect wealth and protect capital because their
- 53:35survival depends on doing that. You know, Singapore being a a
- 53:40very prominent example. And we do a lot in Singapore.
- 53:45That's a big part of it too. So, you know, that's kind of
- 53:47the, the big picture thing. Japan is is an interesting one
- 53:51in particular. And again, you have to look at
- 53:53each of these individually and have this sort of deep nuanced
- 53:58understanding that kind of geopolitical analysis plus macro
- 54:02and just history and all that stuff put together gives you the
- 54:05thing that's different about Japan.
- 54:07I mean, virtually everything is different between the Japan
- 54:10situation in the US, but one big thing I would highlight is that
- 54:14the net investment position of Japan is very different.
- 54:17Japan has a ton of debt, but they also have a ton of foreign
- 54:21held assets because they've been running a current account
- 54:24surplus, you know, since the the Second World War basically.
- 54:31And that is a very different situation when you're thinking
- 54:33about sustainability of that debt, what are their options
- 54:37that they have to get out of it? And we don't have to go through
- 54:40all the details of that. But Japan, I think, is, I don't
- 54:45want to say fundamentally healthier the United States,
- 54:48just to be clear, we're very positive on many aspects of the
- 54:51United States. But this is 1 aspect that's a
- 54:53particular problem. Japan has many problems of its
- 54:56own, but that's an aspect where I think they have more
- 54:59flexibility than maybe people assume who are taking the US,
- 55:03you know, context and trying to apply it to the Japan situation.
- 55:08Yeah, I'll chime in and say, you know, we were talking about
- 55:10rewriting value of assets and things like that.
- 55:13In some sense you have to re rate like what US power looks
- 55:17like. And I think this is actually a
- 55:18really difficult thing to do analytically because you have to
- 55:21say two things at the same time. You have to say the United
- 55:23States is not going to collapse. It's not like, you know, we're
- 55:25not headed towards civil War 2 point O and like run for the
- 55:29hills and everything's going to be terrible.
- 55:31All I'm saying with the with the multipolar world is that
- 55:34relative US power to other countries in the world is
- 55:37declining. So whereas 40 years ago when
- 55:42Iran itself was shooting missiles and rockets into the
- 55:44Persian Gulf and the US government said, that's enough
- 55:47of that, we're going to bomb you into the middle of the 14th
- 55:50century. If you keep doing that and they
- 55:51stopped versus to today where the Houthis are like, yeah, take
- 55:55your best shot. We're going to keep firing off
- 55:57the Rockets. There's like a there's a, a
- 55:59disparity that has opened up between what the United States
- 56:01can say and what other countries are going to do.
- 56:04But that doesn't mean that there aren't pockets of innovation.
- 56:06That doesn't mean that the United States is not still like
- 56:10one of the most powerful and richest countries in the world.
- 56:12It also is not to say that the US dollar is going to lose its
- 56:14status as a global reserve currency.
- 56:16Go look back at the history of reserve currencies.
- 56:19It took not just one but two world wars for the pound
- 56:22sterling to lose its status to the US dollar.
- 56:24So most people are not going to incur the costs to make major
- 56:28shifts like that unless you get a truly cataclysmic event.
- 56:31And I don't see that cataclysmic event necessarily on the horizon
- 56:35now. What I do think, though, has
- 56:37happened, and this goes back to our conversation about are you
- 56:40thinking about the individual person or are you thinking about
- 56:43economics and demographics, things like this?
- 56:45Even when it comes to Treasury yields, when you think about the
- 56:48yield rising or the value of the dollar falling, what you're
- 56:50really talking about there is a lack of confidence in the United
- 56:53States. And that's what's happened
- 56:55around the world. The policies of not just this
- 56:58Trump administration, but the Biden administration, the
- 57:00hairpin turn from the first Trump administration, the
- 57:03presence of populist in the system.
- 57:06You know, whether it's a Bernie Sanders or an AOC, like you
- 57:09start to look at the entire political environment.
- 57:11If you realize there's only populist here, there's no fiscal
- 57:15conservative anymore. There's nobody who wants to
- 57:17defend the international LED, you know, global order.
- 57:21It's all make America first, just disagreeing about which
- 57:23policies are going to make America first and make America
- 57:26great again. And so if you're a foreign
- 57:29country and you're looking at that, you're thinking, I don't
- 57:31have confidence in the United States anymore.
- 57:34And I think you're seeing that all over the world.
- 57:38One thing I think that is particularly interesting about
- 57:40the the Trump administration this time around, one of my
- 57:43favorite podcast is David McWilliams.
- 57:46He's a former central banker from the Bank of Ireland.
- 57:48He was, he made his name because he was a head on the 2008
- 57:51financial crisis. He was sitting there in Ireland,
- 57:54a banging on the table that something bad was coming.
- 57:56Nobody listened to him. And then turned out that he kind
- 57:58of got it right. But I was listening to a podcast
- 58:00of his about six months ago, and he talked about how, you know,
- 58:03as a central banker or as a political official, your job,
- 58:07you're not going to avert the crisis.
- 58:09Like, eventually the bug is going to hit the windshield.
- 58:11Like, eventually debt is going to go beyond the capacity of the
- 58:14US government to pay for it. That's what a loss of confidence
- 58:17means. But the job of the politician or
- 58:19the central banker or the bureaucrat is to kick the can as
- 58:21far down the road as possible. You're trying to buy yourself as
- 58:25much time as possible on the hope that something can save
- 58:28you, whether it's growth or technology or some change in the
- 58:31system, and at least let it be the next persons problem so you
- 58:34don't get blamed for it. I think the one thing we can say
- 58:36about this Trump administration is they're doing the opposite.
- 58:40They look like they're accelerating the crisis.
- 58:42So the trends that Rob just talked about, they've been going
- 58:44on for 10 years. They were going to happen for
- 58:46another 20. I think the most interesting
- 58:48thing about what's happened in the first six months here is
- 58:50that by doing what they've done, and I think because they have a
- 58:52mistaken sort of framework for how to think about the world,
- 58:55they're bringing the crisis forward.
- 58:57We don't even have a phrase for what is the opposite of kicking
- 59:00the can. They're like going fishing for
- 59:02the can and trying to bring the can as close as they possibly
- 59:05can as quickly as possible. And that's causing that lack of
- 59:08confidence in general. And the reason a country like
- 59:10Japan is so interesting to me is Japan is arguably the country in
- 59:14the world that is most dependent on the United States. the United
- 59:17States literally conquered Japan in World War 2 and remade and
- 59:21refashioned Japan in its image. And all of the economic growth
- 59:25and all of the things that happened in Japan were a result
- 59:27of the United States basically using Japan in that context, to
- 59:29the point that Japan doesn't even have really a military that
- 59:33is allowed to take offensive action to protect Japanese
- 59:36interests. That's something that, you know,
- 59:37hawkish Japanese politicians have been trying to change, but
- 59:40they can't do it. And one of the most interesting
- 59:43things that happened that has happened so far this year, right
- 59:45after Liberation Day and after all the tariffs, Japan, not
- 59:50China, not Turkey, not not Japan came out and said, we're not
- 59:54doing anything until the Trump administration takes tariffs
- 59:57back to where they were before. We're not, we're not going to
- 1:00:00disassociate from China. We're not going to, we're not
- 1:00:02going to like, no, terrorists need to go back to where they
- 1:00:04were before. We're not listening.
- 1:00:06And if even if you've lost, even Japan with all of the exposure
- 1:00:10that they have and all of the vulnerabilities that they have,
- 1:00:13like that really is a crisis of confidence in US leadership over
- 1:00:17time. We're talking about Japan.
- 1:00:18There's a election in South Korea today.
- 1:00:20It looks like the the left progressive candidate won.
- 1:00:25He's probably going to take South Korea in a direction that
- 1:00:27is away from alliance with the United States and is more
- 1:00:29engaging with ASEAN or with China, better relations with
- 1:00:33North Korea, trying to position South Korea in that way.
- 1:00:35I think you'll see the same thing with Japan.
- 1:00:37And one of the reasons Japan becomes a really interesting
- 1:00:40investment position, I mean, has been for a couple years, is
- 1:00:44because if you look at Japanese history, Japan is one of these
- 1:00:47countries that it can be. It can have a lot of infighting
- 1:00:49and a lot of bickering and things can be static, you know,
- 1:00:53for a long period of time. But when Japan wakes up and when
- 1:00:56it decides to make a change, it makes change with a level of
- 1:00:59political will and cohesion that very, very few countries can
- 1:01:03summon. And if you're Japan and you're
- 1:01:05seeing all these threats emerge around you, you know, you can
- 1:01:09say, yes, we could talk about Japanese debt.
- 1:01:10We can talk about the yield and Japanese government bonds, all
- 1:01:13these other things. The other thing to talk about
- 1:01:14with Japan is, OK, but are we getting to the point where the
- 1:01:17Japanese public is realizing there's a problem and they're
- 1:01:20going to do one of those hairpin turns like the Meiji Restoration
- 1:01:23or like the creation of the Japanese Empire in the 1930s?
- 1:01:27Not necessarily that they're going to do it, but history
- 1:01:29suggests that when Japan reaches this kind of inflection point,
- 1:01:31it's going to respond in a meaningful way.
- 1:01:34And fight against those constraints as much as possible.
- 1:01:36So I think ultimately, to boil down what I'm saying here, you
- 1:01:40know, when you think about Treasury yields, when you think
- 1:01:42about the value of the US dollar, for me it's about the
- 1:01:44world is re rating their confidence interval in the
- 1:01:47United States being a protector of the values, the international
- 1:01:51rules and standards that it's upheld for a period of 50 to 70
- 1:01:55years. And most countries in the world
- 1:01:57are reaching a sort of two-part conclusion #1 we can't afford to
- 1:02:01buck the United States today. We're just too exposed and we're
- 1:02:04too dependent. But damned if we're not going to
- 1:02:06fix that situation in the next 5 to 10 years.
- 1:02:09And here are the things that we need to do, even if it causes
- 1:02:11pain in the medium term, in order to get away from that
- 1:02:13dependence on the United States. And that is going to affect the
- 1:02:16United States like it's nice to say America first and make
- 1:02:19America great again. Let's see what happens 10 years
- 1:02:22from now when, OK, America's first and America's great again,
- 1:02:25but you don't have this global alliance network that was
- 1:02:28literally working to make your products cheaper and to grease
- 1:02:30the wheels of your economy. It's going to be a rude
- 1:02:32awaiting. Yeah, I have maybe a difficult
- 1:02:37proposition or ask and if you if you can't answer it, no worries,
- 1:02:40but I feel like you'll you'll accept or enjoy it is without
- 1:02:44having being transparent the knowledge and depth that you do.
- 1:02:48Maybe this is America first century question I'm asking, but
- 1:02:51also because we live here is if the bug was going to hit the
- 1:02:55windshield no matter what, And what would be like the opposite
- 1:03:00stance or the the angle where the Trump administration is
- 1:03:04accelerating that? Like what would be the reason
- 1:03:06for it or the positive outcome to accelerate it?
- 1:03:09Because I think we'd all agree they're not like they have some
- 1:03:13idea or some thesis or some strategy.
- 1:03:16I don't know if it's really apparent to anybody here, but we
- 1:03:18can only pontificate or theorize.
- 1:03:20But just curious, like what would be the other side of that
- 1:03:23token of they've accelerated for a particular reason that would
- 1:03:26be in America's best interest? Well, let me take the easy part
- 1:03:30of that first and then we'll we'll do the hard part and I
- 1:03:32accept your challenge. So this is fun and I'm sure Rob
- 1:03:35will want to weigh in as well. There's no 5th dimensional chest
- 1:03:39that's happening here. There is no grand strategy that
- 1:03:42one person is authoring and is pushing through this Trump
- 1:03:45administration. In this sense, look a bit looks
- 1:03:47very much like the first one, which is instead of a
- 1:03:50bureaucratic or executive presidency, it's a courtly
- 1:03:53presidency. Everybody must come and kiss the
- 1:03:55ring. And President Trump must decide
- 1:03:57what's going to happen and he'll decide or he won't decide.
- 1:03:59In addition to that, he has surrounded himself with people
- 1:04:01who disagree with each other. And if you read, like, you know,
- 1:04:05HR Mcmaster's book, you read the interviews of James and their
- 1:04:07experience of dealing with Trump in the first administration,
- 1:04:10they said things about him, like, first of all, he's a
- 1:04:12natural contrarian, which I relate to.
- 1:04:14I'm also a natural contrarian. But that means in a meeting,
- 1:04:17he'll just take the opposite point of view sometimes because
- 1:04:19he thinks that that makes him look smart.
- 1:04:21And sometimes the person who has his ear last is the one that
- 1:04:24gets him to push policy through. You saw this around the tariffs
- 1:04:27because, I mean, I'm sure you saw that Wall Street Journal
- 1:04:29reporting where Navarro was on the other end of the White
- 1:04:31House. And so Besson and Lutnick got in
- 1:04:34there and said, hey, like, you've caught too far.
- 1:04:35Do you see what Treasury yields are doing?
- 1:04:37You see what the dollar is doing?
- 1:04:38We're really in trouble. You need to walk back some of
- 1:04:40these things. Don't listen to Peter Navarro so
- 1:04:42much. And he walked it back.
- 1:04:44I think if you're looking though, for the positive outcome
- 1:04:46or why the Trump administration want might want to do this, the
- 1:04:49strategy, man, the man with the plan is Scott Besson.
- 1:04:53And I think Scott Besson was thinking, OK, we can use the
- 1:04:55threat of tariffs and we can maybe drive down interest rates
- 1:04:59and we can monetize the balance sheet of, you know, US physical
- 1:05:04assets and things like that. And together we can make the
- 1:05:07debts. And also, you know, they're also
- 1:05:09has to be fiscal conservatism as part of that.
- 1:05:11So get Elon in here. Let's remake the government.
- 1:05:13Let's make it more efficient. Again, if you put all of those
- 1:05:16pieces together, yes, you can make a compelling case that's
- 1:05:19out-of-the-box thinking that combines the best of Wall Street
- 1:05:22with the best of Silicon Valley with a politician who doesn't
- 1:05:26give a damn about his future or doesn't care about, you know,
- 1:05:28the conventions of power. He just wants to get things done
- 1:05:31and make things better for America.
- 1:05:33The problem is Trump cut the legs out from underneath Besant
- 1:05:36with Liberation Day and with the tariffs.
- 1:05:39The heavy-handed way in which he pushed through the tariffs and
- 1:05:41scared away US allies and other countries that might have
- 1:05:44cooperated with the United States to do this basically
- 1:05:47makes that plan impossible. So even if we grant that there
- 1:05:49was the strategic plan and that Besant was the holder of the
- 1:05:52plan, I think the way the Trump administration rolled things out
- 1:05:56here in the first six months, which was OK, today it's Besant,
- 1:05:59then it's Navarro, then it's Lutnick's plan, then it's Trump
- 1:06:01decided this, oh, then it's Besant again, Then, oh, we're
- 1:06:03doing tariffs. We're not doing tariffs.
- 1:06:05Tariffs again. You know, it was just sort of
- 1:06:06all over the place. You've got that confidence
- 1:06:08interval declining. So even if you got rid of all
- 1:06:11the noise and said, let's go back to the master plan, let's
- 1:06:14go back to best sense master plan, Trump is going to be
- 1:06:17disciplined and support the plan and do those things in order to
- 1:06:20make these fundamentals better. I still think you're going to
- 1:06:23have the problem where Japan is going to be like, OK, but we
- 1:06:25don't trust you anymore. And China's going to say, OK,
- 1:06:28but we refine all the rare earths and we have 35%
- 1:06:32manufacturing share. So unless you want to drive up,
- 1:06:35you know, the prices for all the things that you import from us,
- 1:06:39you're going to have to do what we want.
- 1:06:40We're not going to do what you want.
- 1:06:41Europe is not turning around. Germany is not going to say, OK,
- 1:06:44JK, we'll stop making tanks. Again.
- 1:06:46You've convinced us everything is fine.
- 1:06:48Like these are not genies that you, that you put back in the
- 1:06:51bottle. But I'm, I'm curious if Rob
- 1:06:54agrees with that or if I characterize that correctly.
- 1:06:56Because I, I do think in the mind of Scott Besson, there was
- 1:06:59a plan and that he thought that he could use the best parts of
- 1:07:02Trump in order to make some major structural changes to the
- 1:07:07United States. And I think Besson found out
- 1:07:09that dealing with Trump was harder than he thought, just
- 1:07:11like Elon found out that it's actually harder to reform the
- 1:07:15bureaucracy of the US government than it is to probably send
- 1:07:17someone to Mark. Yeah.
- 1:07:20And I, I think that that captures it best in thinking
- 1:07:24that there was a plan and, and getting to what you're asking,
- 1:07:27Michael, is there a scenario where it is good to, you know,
- 1:07:33go fishing for the can and bring it forward and, and deal with
- 1:07:36something in advance? And, and I think the answer is
- 1:07:40yes, because there are structural problems like
- 1:07:43obviously this is a structural, as we said, constraints.
- 1:07:46Constraints are what are leaving the United States to this
- 1:07:49growing wedge between expenditures and and income.
- 1:07:53If you want to reduce it to that one number, right, all the
- 1:07:56issues. But the problem is, as Jacob
- 1:08:00pointed out, is there is no plan.
- 1:08:02And you know, the, the methods of the Trump administration are,
- 1:08:09are like the methods of the Joker in The Dark Knight.
- 1:08:11I am an agent of chaos. There is, it's not a, an agent
- 1:08:14of structural reform and hard decisions and careful thinking
- 1:08:18about how do we get out of this mess and do the difficult things
- 1:08:21that we need to eventually do. If that were the case, I think
- 1:08:25it would be, it would be different.
- 1:08:28I, I think Trump is sort of a byproduct of, of the, the
- 1:08:32structural problems that have got us into this mess.
- 1:08:35And as that byproduct is not someone who's coming in to
- 1:08:39necessarily fix them or address them in any cogent way.
- 1:08:44So, you know, that's not particularly a good outlook.
- 1:08:50But one thing I would just follow it up with is like you
- 1:08:54have to always discriminate between the real assets in the
- 1:08:59economy, which are people who know how to do things, which are
- 1:09:02businesses that are excellent at what they like, all of these
- 1:09:05things that we are, we're aware of.
- 1:09:07And then the financial economy and a lot of the problems are on
- 1:09:11the financial side. And that's not to say that
- 1:09:15debasement, you know, financial issues, like the issue is we
- 1:09:20have this looming financial problem and dealing with it
- 1:09:23could have very real world effects.
- 1:09:25Like right now, the real world, you know, real asset side of the
- 1:09:29US economy is really good in, in many ways in, in many places.
- 1:09:34And obviously there's, there's, there's issues and, and things
- 1:09:38that we can talk about, but a restructuring could have
- 1:09:43implications that that feed into that and hurt that.
- 1:09:47And and that's sort of one of the key questions is if that's
- 1:09:50the crisis that we're bringing on like now yields are going
- 1:09:52like this now something is sooner going to have to be done
- 1:09:56or is going to, you know, is going to happen.
- 1:10:01You know, whether we like it or not.
- 1:10:03How does that impact the real economy?
- 1:10:06How does it impact human capital in the US?
- 1:10:09How does it impact organizational capital?
- 1:10:11Because that's the stuff that longer term really matters.
- 1:10:15And that's really, you know, the interrelation between those two
- 1:10:18things is, is kind of the tricky thing to to plan for and
- 1:10:22understand, but that's, that's where we're at.
- 1:10:24Yeah. I just want to piggyback on that
- 1:10:26and say one more thing too, which is to to supply a little
- 1:10:28bit of historical context because the United States has
- 1:10:31been here before. This is not the first time the
- 1:10:33United States is going through this kind of structural reset or
- 1:10:36the need for a structural reset like this.
- 1:10:39It's one of the pitfalls of democracy that it can't get
- 1:10:43itself organized to deal with problems.
- 1:10:46Usually things have to get bad enough so that you elect leaders
- 1:10:49who will make, who will make the economy take its medicine or who
- 1:10:52will make the hard decision. It's much easier for
- 1:10:54authoritarian regimes like, say, China to say we have major
- 1:10:58structural things we have to do. And I don't have time to brook
- 1:11:00dissent. That's why Xi Jinping has become
- 1:11:02a dictator. Chinese leaders for, you know,
- 1:11:05since Deng Xiaoping, it was you get 2 terms and then you're out
- 1:11:07and your successor is appointed in your second term and it's
- 1:11:09ruled by consensus. I'm not saying it's not a
- 1:11:11dictatorship, but there was a clear establishment of how power
- 1:11:14was supposed to pass from leader to leader.
- 1:11:16Xi Jinping has gotten rid of all that, and he's gotten rid of all
- 1:11:19that because China has many of the same structural problems
- 1:11:22that we're talking about. They will part of the globalized
- 1:11:24world. They also partied like it was
- 1:11:26crazy. They have incredible wealth
- 1:11:27disparity in that country and all sorts of structural issues
- 1:11:30related to debt and local government debt that we could
- 1:11:32spend a lot of time talking about.
- 1:11:34And so Xi Jinping says, OK, I need to be able to make the real
- 1:11:38estate companies suffer because they didn't listen to me.
- 1:11:41And I have to make sure that nobody's going to come and knife
- 1:11:43me in the back when I do some of these difficult things.
- 1:11:46That's not going to happen in a democracy.
- 1:11:49And I think for the United States, I think we're still
- 1:11:52very, very early in this. The United States economy, even
- 1:11:56with the things that have happened in the last six months,
- 1:11:58is doing great. We've been doing great relative
- 1:12:00for a couple of years. the Fed has been thinking about having
- 1:12:04to raise interest rates because inflation is running too hot,
- 1:12:06because things are going so well.
- 1:12:08And I think we're at an age of decadence.
- 1:12:10I think we're arguing about things that don't actually
- 1:12:13matter, like we're having arguments about what bathroom
- 1:12:15people should go to and all these other different issues.
- 1:12:18Like most Americans are not feeling the type of pain that
- 1:12:22they felt in the 1920s, in the early 1930s, or in the
- 1:12:25stagflation era of the late 1970s.
- 1:12:28And those are historical examples of where things got so
- 1:12:31bad in the economy that you did get a reset of the US
- 1:12:35government. The Great Depression gives us
- 1:12:37Franklin Delano Roosevelt and the refounding of the Republic
- 1:12:40and the New Deal. And you can disagree with the
- 1:12:41New Deal and you can say that wasn't the New Deal that saved
- 1:12:44America, okay? It was the confidence that FDR
- 1:12:46reinjected into the system with the combo World War 2 that
- 1:12:49allowed the United States to rise out of that.
- 1:12:52Same with Jimmy Carter and stagflation.
- 1:12:54I think Jimmy Carter had the unfortunate yet unfortunate
- 1:12:57timing. He got caught holding the bag,
- 1:12:59but it was Reagan who came in and ushers in deregulation and
- 1:13:02everything that goes afterwards. So I think that you're going to
- 1:13:06eventually get a point where things are going to get so bad
- 1:13:08in the US economy where you do get politicians who have to make
- 1:13:11a hard decision. But that's not this president.
- 1:13:13And I don't think it's really ever been this president.
- 1:13:16I don't I don't think he's sort of said about that.
- 1:13:17And I think the the cautionary tale is there was a third time
- 1:13:20in U.S. history where things got this bad or where you had a bug
- 1:13:24that was going to hit a windshield.
- 1:13:25This obviously, and that was the 1850s and we saw which path the
- 1:13:29United States chose sort of in that into the 1860s.
- 1:13:31In general, I think we can avoid that.
- 1:13:33I actually think once the United States metabolizes some of this,
- 1:13:36it will probably be stronger for it.
- 1:13:38But we've gone through these periods of history and time.
- 1:13:40The question I think you asked for, especially for, you know,
- 1:13:43folks that are in the US, is what flavor of ideology is going
- 1:13:47to bring the solution because right now it's up for grabs.
- 1:13:50It could come from the right. Maybe it's sort of a real
- 1:13:54deregulation and fiscal conservatism and unleashed
- 1:13:57growth and public private partnership and monetize the
- 1:13:59balance sheet of the United States.
- 1:14:00Like that's one path. Another path is the door of the
- 1:14:04left, which is raise taxes up to 50 and 60 and 70%.
- 1:14:08Balance the budget that way. Take it from the wealthy and
- 1:14:11make sure that you're going to, you know, the wealth
- 1:14:13inequalities rise in the United States.
- 1:14:15Make the rich pay their fair share.
- 1:14:16You can hear that populist rhetoric already on the left.
- 1:14:19I think whatever the solution is going to be, it's going to be up
- 1:14:21for grabs. And a lot of it will be about
- 1:14:23timing and personality and things like that.
- 1:14:25But this administration, I don't think it's actually bringing the
- 1:14:27can forward. If they wanted to bring the can
- 1:14:29forward, they would have had to combine protectionist trade
- 1:14:32policy with massive fiscal outlays to increase the training
- 1:14:36of human beings to go work in factories and build
- 1:14:39infrastructure and factories in the United States itself, along
- 1:14:42with very, very close partnerships with close allies
- 1:14:45that could fill in some of the gaps here.
- 1:14:47And then, you know, also getting rid of some of the fluff around
- 1:14:50the budget and the deficit instead of going after things
- 1:14:52like international students at Harvard University.
- 1:14:55Like, that's not the stuff you do if your economy is really in
- 1:14:58crisis and you're dealing with a serious issue.
- 1:15:01Yeah, it makes a lot of sense. I appreciate you running through
- 1:15:03that. I think we'd be remiss because I
- 1:15:04know we have about 10 minutes. I want to be conscious of time
- 1:15:07on scarce assets and hard assets and where they fit into kind of
- 1:15:10some of the portfolio theory. And also maybe piggybacking off
- 1:15:13of any of the playbook with Bescent, specifically around
- 1:15:16gold. And we saw some of the flows
- 1:15:19globally, you know, shift in the past six months and then BTC.
- 1:15:22How you guys think about either that in the toolkit and also
- 1:15:26we've seen China as a net buyer, but then also just Bitcoin and
- 1:15:30how you think about that in general in the geopolitical
- 1:15:32landscape, neutral assets? I could take that one.
- 1:15:39So the way that we think about this is sort of like a a barbell
- 1:15:46of sorts. If you want to think of it at
- 1:15:47the very high level, gold and Bitcoin are real assets, but
- 1:15:54they're also liquid. And that's a big difference from
- 1:15:57a lot of the other real assets that we're talking about,
- 1:16:00whether it's artworks or collectibles or real estate or
- 1:16:05you know, even private businesses.
- 1:16:09So they play a very special role in client portfolios as a, as a
- 1:16:13protector, A protector and debasement, A protector against
- 1:16:18inflation, which when you're dealing with the families that
- 1:16:22we work with really on that generational time frame, that's
- 1:16:26how you lose. You lose because of on the one
- 1:16:29hand, family conflict lawsuits like things like that, that are
- 1:16:33on the how to own side. When you look at the what to own
- 1:16:36side, it's it's currency debasement or it's, you know,
- 1:16:44just massive malinvestment or bad allocation that results in
- 1:16:50some huge problem. So Bitcoin and golds are sort of
- 1:16:55central port, central parts of that real asset side of the
- 1:16:58barbell, along with durable currencies, among which are
- 1:17:03things like the Singapore dollar, things like the Swiss
- 1:17:05franc. And the the common denominator
- 1:17:08among all those things is that they are liquid.
- 1:17:10And that is key because you need to retain that flexibility to,
- 1:17:14to move, to respond. So these things like we just
- 1:17:17described 8 different scenarios of key things that we don't know
- 1:17:20exactly what's going to happen, how's the US going to respond?
- 1:17:22What's going to happen in China? If you don't have liquidity to
- 1:17:26adjust and be the fox, then you're in trouble.
- 1:17:29And it doesn't matter what real assets you own, you're stuck.
- 1:17:33And it's, it's not optimal in that way.
- 1:17:36So, so yeah, Bitcoin and gold as a liquid real assets coupled
- 1:17:40with those currencies is a, a really, really big portion of
- 1:17:44what we do. And then on the other side, you
- 1:17:47know, the, the corollary is that real assets, they don't, they
- 1:17:51don't do anything. They just exist, right?
- 1:17:54Like, like why do, why is gold the precious asset?
- 1:17:58It's, it's because it's literally the only asset that
- 1:18:01won't degrade. It just, it just sits there and
- 1:18:04Bitcoin just exists. But they don't, they're not,
- 1:18:08they're not value accumulating assets.
- 1:18:10They are real assets against the backdrop of depreciating
- 1:18:13currencies. So the other side of the barbell
- 1:18:16has to be in this volatile environment, where are the
- 1:18:19opportunities being unleashed and particularly around
- 1:18:23innovation and certain areas of innovation and aligning your
- 1:18:27capital to those globally to, to organizations that have sort of
- 1:18:35that are squishy. They're resilient because
- 1:18:38they're squishy, not because they're hard, because they can
- 1:18:40flex and adapt and they're composed of people and
- 1:18:44intellectual property that can that can change and move to new
- 1:18:47markets. And but there's some resilient
- 1:18:50core to what they do that's very difficult to dislodge.
- 1:18:53So those are the two sides of in most cases, what we're building
- 1:18:57for client portfolios with, you know, certain niche things, you
- 1:19:01know, used to complement that. But really thinking in terms of
- 1:19:04that barbell, what indoors, you know, everything within the
- 1:19:08portfolio enjoys, but what is the, the real asset, the hard
- 1:19:11asset? And then on the other side, what
- 1:19:13is the innovation asset that's going to be your your offense?
- 1:19:19And I appreciate the question because it allows me to explore
- 1:19:21an idea that I'm working on that is not fully formed.
- 1:19:24So entering full Fox mode, which is that if geopolitics has many
- 1:19:28blind spots, as all disciplines and frameworks do, one of its
- 1:19:31biggest is that it over indexes on the power of the state.
- 1:19:34And that makes sense because it's literally, it was literally
- 1:19:36a tool that was created to understand how states deal with
- 1:19:39each other. That's like the geopolitical
- 1:19:41methodology from the late 1800s. But for a large part of my
- 1:19:44career, I would do that. I would over index on the power
- 1:19:46of the state. We mentioned Peter Zion earlier.
- 1:19:49You probably remember he went on Joe Rogan.
- 1:19:50And I forget what Bitcoin was at when he went on, but Rogan asked
- 1:19:53him like, all right, well, yeah. Where, where do you think, you
- 1:19:55know, it was when Bitcoin was in one of its troughs?
- 1:19:58And he asked Peter something like, you know, how far, how
- 1:20:00much more down do you think it's going to go?
- 1:20:01And Peter was like 0 and said it very flippantly.
- 1:20:04And I thought that that was very flippant.
- 1:20:07But also I think that spoke to a bias that most geopolitical
- 1:20:10analysts had a Bitcoin because there was this thing that was
- 1:20:13separate and it wasn't related to the power of the state.
- 1:20:15And of course the state was going to crush it.
- 1:20:17And I was talking actually with Matt Mcclintock about this just
- 1:20:21last week. And he, he shared with me this,
- 1:20:23this joke that everybody buys Bitcoin at the price that they
- 1:20:26deserve. And I, I sort of have to say
- 1:20:29that analytically, I've been reformulating how I think about
- 1:20:31this in just the last couple of months, in part because of that
- 1:20:34kicking the cans scenario. There was a certain level of
- 1:20:37complacency for me about the dollar in particular and about
- 1:20:40Fiat currency in general because I thought we had 20 or 30 years
- 1:20:44before the system was really going to, you know, have to
- 1:20:48reckon with itself. I thought we were going to be
- 1:20:49able to keep kicking the can. And that thinking, you know, too
- 1:20:52early about this. You were sort of ignoring what
- 1:20:54was in front of you for fears that were unwarranted about the
- 1:20:57future. And the way that things have
- 1:20:59developed really not just in the first term administration, but
- 1:21:02over the last 12 months and some of this volatility spiral that
- 1:21:05Rob has talked about has made me re evaluate that in a huge way.
- 1:21:10Because I see the crisis is accelerated and I see the
- 1:21:12debasement of currency is accelerated.
- 1:21:14And I see that populism is proliferating.
- 1:21:17And that the sort of velocity of populism and the things that are
- 1:21:20being talked about are accelerating in ways that for me
- 1:21:23are like 10 or 15 years ahead of where I thought they were going
- 1:21:26to be. So for me, like when you're
- 1:21:28thinking specifically about Bitcoin, that's one of the
- 1:21:32things that makes me sort of re evaluated it because I think
- 1:21:34you're going to get in a situation where individuals,
- 1:21:37even countries are going to think about reclaiming
- 1:21:39sovereignty for themselves and for a family.
- 1:21:41That might mean getting rid of currency risk and Bitcoin away
- 1:21:44is a way to do that. For countries, that might mean
- 1:21:46we don't want to have the dollar be our unit of currency anymore.
- 1:21:50Like think about how El Salvador has really been at the forefront
- 1:21:53here. There's a lot of nebulous,
- 1:21:55tricky moral issues when talking about the Buchele government.
- 1:21:58And are they good or are they bad?
- 1:21:59They bet big on Bitcoin apart because their economy got
- 1:22:02dollarized in the 90s and they didn't want to be exposed to the
- 1:22:04US dollar. And that looked sort of silly
- 1:22:07even five years ago. To a geopolitical analyst, it
- 1:22:09looks positively sort of genius when I'm sitting at the
- 1:22:13situation today, when you think about it.
- 1:22:15And then, you know, this is not a fully formed thought.
- 1:22:17The last thing I'll just say is as I'm thinking about this
- 1:22:19myself, watching the White House embrace Bitcoin and
- 1:22:24cryptocurrency to the extent that they have to me is also,
- 1:22:28it's sort of a cautionary tale here because you have the Trump
- 1:22:32family itself has sort of woken up to the possibility and
- 1:22:35potential of this. And I'm not sure that that
- 1:22:39affiliate, that that affinity is necessarily going to be good for
- 1:22:41Bitcoin in the long run. Because Bitcoin is supposed to
- 1:22:44be the apolitical thing. It's supposed to be the thing
- 1:22:46that gets you out of some of this political risk.
- 1:22:48And yet here is the US government saying, no, no, like
- 1:22:52the Trump administration and the Trump family is going to be
- 1:22:54running around making all sorts of deals with cryptocurrency.
- 1:22:57And this goes back to what I'm talking about with the bug with
- 1:22:59the windshield. Because I think you also can
- 1:23:00imagine scenarios where things get really bad in the US
- 1:23:03economy. And then do people remember,
- 1:23:06hey, do you remember that when they were doing tariffs and
- 1:23:08things like that, they were also cutting deals in the Gulf and
- 1:23:11making, you know, Trump coins and having dinner and talking
- 1:23:14about Bitcoin currency reserves and things like that?
- 1:23:16Is that tied into the nepotism that caused some of these
- 1:23:19problems? Like, I think there's a little,
- 1:23:21there's the shadow of some kind of political risk there with the
- 1:23:24way that Bitcoin has been mainstreamed so quickly by the
- 1:23:28White House, by the Trump family and, and by the US government.
- 1:23:31So I I don't have a fully formed thought there yet, But as you
- 1:23:33can tell it's all in flux. Two things I want to add to that
- 1:23:36because I think it'll help as you work through it.
- 1:23:38And then we'd be curious to see what the outputs are.
- 1:23:40One is it's basically the polar opposites of that.
- 1:23:44One is that is something I think about deeply and talk about.
- 1:23:47It's a contrarian take, but the deep political intersection
- 1:23:52across the globe, you hear bit bonds, you hear SBR, you hear
- 1:23:55corporate treasury. That notion will end up biting
- 1:24:00individuals that are buying these products because
- 1:24:02ultimately they're a product of leveraging the debt system to
- 1:24:05accumulate and they will be politicized and then captured.
- 1:24:08I think that's where that that ends.
- 1:24:10But the counter to that is it goes to what Mcclintock said.
- 1:24:13There's a common theme that we that that term, you know,
- 1:24:16everyone buys Bitcoin at the price they deserve.
- 1:24:18There's another one. It's it's more of a ego test,
- 1:24:20right, because people to re underwrite what they think value
- 1:24:22is. But I think that's the 2D
- 1:24:24version because that's assuming people like us.
- 1:24:27Let's go back to the 3D version, which Bitcoin is really a common
- 1:24:31sense test versus an IQ test, because if you go to a 5 year
- 1:24:33old, it would take a finite currency versus a infinite
- 1:24:37currency or currency that continue to be grown.
- 1:24:38So as individuals grow, because people grow up, well, what are
- 1:24:42they going to choose? And that's how you can
- 1:24:43understand the end state is because let's just forget about
- 1:24:45us because we won't live forever.
- 1:24:47And what are people for the past 13 years woken in or 15 years
- 1:24:51brought up into? And I think that's the thing
- 1:24:52people discount is in an age of obviously AI, but digital, you
- 1:24:57know, in a digital world, what will reign supreme?
- 1:25:00And then really from an IQ versus common sense test, what
- 1:25:03would somebody want? They're not going to have all
- 1:25:04this baggage. And that's the thing most people
- 1:25:07kind of discount when we build these mental models of the
- 1:25:09existing world. It's like, what is everyone else
- 1:25:11just going to know in the same way the Internet and e-mail and
- 1:25:14money will interact with. And that's kind of like, without
- 1:25:16saying what the end state is, that that is kind of the end
- 1:25:18state that most people aren't prepared for.
- 1:25:20Once that's understood that everything else can be
- 1:25:22underwritten in a different way. Yeah, this was fascinating.
- 1:25:28We probably have to do it again. I feel like every, you know, the
- 1:25:32way the world's moving, every three or six months there's a
- 1:25:34new view or a very drastic, like pivot point that's changing.
- 1:25:40I think since COVID it's been the case.
- 1:25:44It, it never stops. I sort of wish the world would
- 1:25:46slow down a little bit. It's it's, it's been
- 1:25:49overwhelming. Well, appreciate both of your
- 1:25:53times, Jacob and Rob, to Michael's point, maybe we'll do
- 1:25:57this again in the future. Really appreciate the insights
- 1:25:59you brought. Just a hand off.
- 1:26:01Where do you want people to find you online to get in touch,
- 1:26:05whether it's to follow your work or interested in what you're
- 1:26:08doing with Bespoke in the Family office?
- 1:26:14It's pretty simple, you know, our website is bespoke group dot
- 1:26:17IO. I'm a sadomasochist and I'm on
- 1:26:19all the social media for now. And you can find my podcast too
- 1:26:21if you want more stuff like that.
- 1:26:23Rob is lurking out there too. But we're we're not hard to
- 1:26:26find. Rob any place you want to direct
- 1:26:27people as well. No, just the bespoke site.
- 1:26:31I think that's the the best way to get in touch or to follow.
- 1:26:35Yeah, we'll try to include. I know there are PDFs, but I'm
- 1:26:38assuming they're on the website. Those two reports that we
- 1:26:41referenced in the show notes because they were really great
- 1:26:43kind of recaps or go deeper into what we talked about today.
- 1:26:49Well, thank you, gentlemen. Really appreciate the time.
- 1:26:51Cheers. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:26:53week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:26:56valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:26:58rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:27:00All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:27:02notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:27:05reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:27:08entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:27:11investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:27:14your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:27:16Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:27:20one of our private client advisors.