Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / Why Marketplaces Sometimes Pay Suppliers to Show Up
Transcript
- Lucas: So we talk a lot about demand on this show — how marketplaces attract buyers, keep them coming back, spend on ads. But there's a quieter side of the equation that often decides whether a marketplace lives or dies, and it's the supply side. Luna: You mean getting enough sellers, drivers, hosts, or whatever to actually offer their stuff in the first place? Lucas: Exactly. And sometimes, the only way to get them is to pay them. Not just a listing fee waiver — literally hand them money to show up and transact. It sounds backwards, but it's a playbook that's been used by some of the biggest marketplaces out there, and it can be the difference between a network that never gets off the ground and one that becomes a verb. Luna: I'm already thinking about ride-hailing. The early days of Uber and Lyft were basically a subsidy war for drivers. Lucas: Right. And that's the classic example. But the playbook is broader. Think about Etsy, which in its early years actually ran seller referral programs that paid existing sellers to recruit new ones. All those handmade soap makers and vintage sellers were the supply side, and without them, buyers would have nothing to browse. Luna: So when does paying your suppliers make sense? Because it's not like you're just handing out money and hoping for the best — there has to be some structure to it. Lucas: The key is that you're not subsidizing the supply for its own sake. You're subsidizing it to create liquidity, which then attracts demand. And the trick is to set it up so that the subsidy is temporary — it's a bridge to a self-sustaining network. If you're still paying drivers three years in, you probably didn't design the incentive right. Luna: Or you're in a race with a competitor who's also paying, and you can't stop without losing market share. Lucas: That's the trap. But let's look at a specific number that makes the economics interesting. In the early days of ride-hailing, some markets offered drivers guarantees like twenty dollars an hour even if they got no rides. That's a pure supply-side subsidy. And the rationale was that if you have enough empty cars trolling the streets, wait times drop, reliability goes up, and riders start to trust the service. Once riders are hooked, you can dial back the guarantees. Luna: But doesn't that just attract drivers who game the system? They'd sign up, park somewhere, and collect the hourly guarantee without actually giving rides. Lucas: Yes, that's a real problem. So the smart marketplaces structured the guarantee around actual trips — you only get the top-up if you've accepted and completed a certain number of rides per hour. That forces drivers to be genuinely available. It's a performance-based subsidy, not a handout. Luna: That makes a lot of sense. So the subsidy has to be tied to behavior that actually builds liquidity, not just to showing up. Lucas: Exactly. And this is where it gets interesting for the listeners who are building their own marketplaces. You have to figure out what the equivalent of a 'completed ride' is in your niche. For Etsy, it was a seller listing at least ten items and making their first sale. For a freelance platform, it might be completing your first project. The behavior has to be the thing that creates value for the other side. Luna: But before we go deeper into the how — I want to pause on something. If you're getting value out of these episodes, whether you're an operator or a builder, a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Lucas: Really appreciate that, Luna. And it's because of that support that we can keep digging into these playbooks without any ads. So, back to the design of the subsidy. Lucas: One framework that helps is to think of the subsidy as an investment in learning. The marketplace is learning whether the supply side can actually deliver on the promise to demand. And the supplier is learning whether it's worth their time to stay. So the subsidy is essentially buying both sides' attention. Luna: But how do you decide how much to pay? Is there a formula? Lucas: The starting point is to calculate the lifetime value of a new supplier. What's the average commission you'll earn from them over, say, twelve months? If that lifetime value is three hundred dollars, then you can afford to spend up to that to acquire them, as long as the payback period is acceptable. It's the same logic as customer acquisition cost for buyers, but for sellers. Luna: So it's a classic unit economics exercise. But what about the network effects? If you subsidize a bunch of sellers in one city, that might attract more buyers, which then attracts more sellers organically. That's the multiplier effect. Lucas: Right, and that's the whole point. The subsidy is meant to trigger that flywheel. But you have to be careful not to over-subsidize in a way that you're just buying fake liquidity. If the supply disappears the moment you stop paying, you haven't built a network, you've built a rental. Luna: That's a great way to put it. A rental. I think of TaskRabbit, which we covered earlier, and they had to balance how many taskers to allow in each city to keep them busy enough. If they over-subsidized and had too many idle taskers, they'd leave. Lucas: Exactly. So the subsidy amount needs to be calibrated not just to attract suppliers, but to give them a realistic expectation of earnings. If you pay them a guaranteed twenty dollars an hour, but the market is only generating ten dollars an hour in actual earnings, then when the guarantee ends, they're gone. You need the subsidy to be a bridge to a real earning potential. Luna: So let's talk about a concrete example of a company that did this well. I'm thinking of Thumbtack, the home services marketplace. They actually started by charging pros to bid on jobs, which is a different model, but they also offered credits to new pros to get their first few jobs. Lucas: Thumbtack is a good example because it shows that the subsidy doesn't have to be cash. It can be free leads, discounted bids, or even a badge that gives you a temporary boost in search rankings. The point is to reduce the cost of trying for the supplier. Luna: And that's especially important for marketplaces where the supply side is small businesses or individual pros who are risk-averse. They're not going to invest a lot of time and money without some assurance they'll get work. Lucas: Right. So the subsidy is a risk transfer. The marketplace is absorbing some of the risk that the supplier would otherwise bear. And if the marketplace can measure that the supplier's first few jobs lead to repeat bookings and loyalty, then the subsidy is worth it. Luna: What about the dark side? When do subsidies become a crutch or even harmful? Lucas: The biggest danger is subsidy addiction. You start paying suppliers, they get used to it, and they demand more. You can't stop because they'll leave, taking your liquidity with them. That's what happened with some of the food delivery apps in certain markets — they were paying restaurants and drivers so much that the unit economics were never positive, and when they tried to cut back, they lost both sides. Luna: So how do you avoid that trap? How do you design a subsidy that has an exit ramp? Lucas: You need to set clear expectations from the start. Make it known that the subsidy is temporary and tied to specific milestones. And you need to continuously track whether the market is becoming self-sustaining. If the data shows that the network can survive without the subsidy, you taper it down gradually. If not, you might have to rethink your whole model. Luna: But even with an exit ramp, there's a risk that you're just creating a bunch of suppliers who are only there for the money and don't care about the quality. That could hurt the buyer experience. Lucas: Absolutely. That's why the subsidy has to be tied to quality metrics, not just activity. You could pay a supplier a bonus for maintaining a high rating or a low cancellation rate. That way, you're not just buying liquidity, you're buying good liquidity. Luna: And I imagine that's where a lot of marketplaces get it wrong. They subsidize anyone who signs up, and then they get flooded with low-quality suppliers who scare away buyers. Lucas: Exactly. So the art is to find the supplier who is likely to become a great long-term participant, and focus your subsidy on them. That means you need to have good data about supplier behavior even before they get the subsidy, or you need to do a small test period before you give them the full incentive. Luna: So it sounds like the key is to treat the subsidy as a targeted investment, not a blanket giveaway. And you have to be really disciplined about measuring the return on that investment. Lucas: Right. And that's the difference between a marketplace that uses subsidies to ignite a flywheel and one that just burns cash. The former is a strategic move; the latter is a disaster waiting to happen. Luna: So what's the one takeaway you want our listeners to remember today? Lucas: I'd say it's this: if you're building a marketplace, don't be afraid to pay your supply side to get started. But make sure you're paying for behavior that builds genuine liquidity, not just for showing up. Tie the subsidy to a milestone that benefits both sides, have a clear plan for when the training wheels come off, and measure everything. That's how you turn a temporary subsidy into a structural advantage. Luna: And if you want to keep getting these playbooks, you know where to find us. Thanks for listening.