Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #74🎙️ |Public Inquiry Review of the week 2nd June 2026 |
Transcript
- 0:04Unknown: This week public inquiry appeared to be
- 0:06discussing roads heritage and planning policy, but as I sat
- 0:10listening to the evidence, it struck me that something much
- 0:14bigger was unfolding beneath the surface. What we were watching
- 0:19is a system designed to assess categories, trying to come to
- 0:22terms with things that simply do not fit neatly into categories
- 0:27at all, things like memory, faith, community, belonging, and
- 0:32the invisible ties that bind people to a place and to each
- 0:35other. What happens when a system designed to assess
- 0:40categories, is asked to understand people, memory,
- 0:44faith, community, and belonging, and perhaps even more
- 0:47importantly, what happens when the people inside that system
- 0:51simply don't care. Many people listening to this podcast have
- 0:56reached the conclusion that the decision has already been made.
- 1:01They believe the outcome is predetermined. They believe the
- 1:05public inquiry is little more than a stage managed exercise
- 1:09designated to create the appearance of due process before
- 1:13political decision is delivered. That is certainly how many
- 1:17people are feeling now. Before anyone accuses me of being
- 1:22cynical, let me explain. Over the last few days, I found
- 1:28myself looking at that question from a completely different
- 1:31angle. What if we've been asking the wrong question all along?
- 1:36What if the opposite was true? What if our task was never to
- 1:40persuade the planning appeals commission. What if our task was
- 1:45never to convince a government department? Because when I think
- 1:49back over this week, that is not actually what stands out for me.
- 1:54What stands out for me is I see local people standing up and
- 1:58explaining why a mass rock matters. I see academics
- 2:02travelling from across Ireland to speak about heritage. I see
- 2:06retired clergy speaking quietly and eloquently about community
- 2:10division and belonging. I see ordinary people discovering what
- 2:15they thought was a local issue is actually part of a much
- 2:18bigger story, a story about how communities respond when
- 2:23powerful institutions stop listening. History is littered
- 2:28with examples where communities did not prevail because they
- 2:31convinced those in power. More often they prevailed because
- 2:37they convinced each other, they deepened their understanding of
- 2:41who they were and what they valued and what they were
- 2:44prepared to stand for. Our communities win by convincing
- 2:49each other, we win by building relationships, we win by telling
- 2:54stories, and we win by preserving memory. We win by
- 3:00refusing to surrender our understanding of what is
- 3:02valuable simply because someone with authority says it has no
- 3:06value, because every time one of us stands up and gives evidence,
- 3:12we're doing something bigger than contributing to a planning
- 3:16process, we're creating a public record, we are preserving a
- 3:20memory, we are saying we were here, we saw this, we spoke, and
- 3:26that matters. It matters whether the decision goes our way or
- 3:30not. Because when institutions stop listening, our communities
- 3:35still have a choice. We can become cynical or we can become
- 3:40stronger, we can become divided, or we can become even more
- 3:45connected. We can accept somebody else's definition of
- 3:49what is important, or we can continue defining it for
- 3:54ourselves. And perhaps that's why these conversations at the
- 3:58public inquiry matter so much, because even if every fear about
- 4:03predetermination turned out to be true, even if the outcome had
- 4:09somehow already been decided, something important has happened
- 4:13here over the course of these hearings, stories have been
- 4:17told, knowledge has been shared and accumulated, and people who
- 4:23may never have met one another have discovered common ground.
- 4:28In short, a community has become more conscious of itself. For
- 4:34me, that may be one of the most important things to emerge from
- 4:38this entire process. The question then is not whether the
- 4:43outcome is predetermined. The deeper question is how
- 4:46communities respond when they believe they are facing a
- 4:50predetermined outcome. Do we become cynical and disengage, or
- 4:55do we become even more connected to one another? Do we retreat
- 5:01into frustration or do we strengthen the relationships
- 5:05that brought us here in the first place? Do we allow others
- 5:09to define what matters or do we continue to tell our own story
- 5:14and defend our understanding of what is valuable?
- 5:18Because if this week reminded me of anything, it is that
- 5:22institutions can approve projects, issue rulings, and
- 5:26sign decisions, but they cannot manufacture legitimacy that
- 5:32comes from the people, it comes from communities, and when
- 5:36communities remain connected to each other and clear about what
- 5:39they stand for, they possess a form of power that no
- 5:43institution can simply erase with the stroke of a pen, and
- 5:48communities that remain connected to their history,
- 5:51their values, and each other have a remarkable habit of
- 5:55outlasting the decisions of any particular commission,
- 5:58department, or government. So, if you come across negativity,
- 6:03hopelessness, or the belief that the public inquiry is nothing
- 6:06more than a foregone conclusion, then don't argue about the
- 6:10outcome. Instead, do something far more powerful, strengthen
- 6:16our community, have the conversations, share the
- 6:19knowledge, support our local people, bring others with you.
- 6:24Because if this week has taught us anything, it is that our
- 6:28greatest strength was never in the hands of institutions. It
- 6:31has always been in our ability to stand together. Whatever
- 6:35decisions eventually emerge from this process, one thing remains
- 6:40true. We're still here, we still know what this place means, and
- 6:45we're not finished telling its story. Thanks very much for
- 6:48listening, and see you all again soon. And the final request, if
- 6:53you're listening to podcasts on Spotify or on Apple, do give us
- 6:57a follow and review, and hit the star button as well, it really
- 7:01makes a difference and helps us to get our story out even
- 7:04further, so.