Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Sexual Assault Litigation in Entertainment and Fashion
Transcript
- 0:03Let's get started. Welcome, everyone, to the
- 0:06Sexual Assault Litigation in Entertainment and
- 0:09Fashion. Thank you so much, everyone, for taking
- 0:11time to be with us today. I'm Uduak Awduak, fashion
- 0:16and entertainment lawyer, former fashion model,
- 0:19and founder of Fashion ENT Law. I bring both
- 0:22industry experience and civil and criminal litigation
- 0:24experience, including juvenile dependency. and
- 0:29juvenile delinquency and dependency matters involved
- 0:34in sexual misconduct and exploitation, which
- 0:37informs how I approach legal issues in fashion
- 0:40and entertainment. And I am truly delighted to
- 0:43introduce today's speakers who will be joining
- 0:46me for this program. First up is Neda Sagafi.
- 0:49Joshua Kushner and Professor Victoria Burke.
- 0:53A little bit about Neda. Neda Sagafi is an attorney
- 0:56at Panish Shay and Rafi Pudi LLP, and she's a
- 1:00key member of the firm's sexual abuse litigation
- 1:03team advocating for adult and child survivors
- 1:05through a compassionate, client -centered approach.
- 1:09Neda is also the vice chair of BHBA's litigation
- 1:12section, a board member with the Women's Law
- 1:15Association of Los Angeles. And she's barred
- 1:17in multiple jurisdictions, including California,
- 1:20New York, DC, and Maryland. Joshua Kushner is
- 1:25a founder and managing partner of the Kushner
- 1:27firm and a former sexual crimes and homicide
- 1:30prosecutor and big law trial attorney. Joshua's
- 1:34nationwide plaintiff's practice focuses on the
- 1:36representation of survivors of sexual assault,
- 1:40human trafficking, child abuse, and catastrophic
- 1:43injury. an active member of the National Crime
- 1:46Victims Bar Association. Joshua was also recognized
- 1:50in 2024 by the National Institute of Trial Advocacy
- 1:54as one of the nation's leading trial advocacy
- 1:57instructors for practicing attorneys and law
- 1:59students. Congratulations, Joshua. All right.
- 2:02And then finally, we've got Professor Victoria
- 2:05Burke, who's an adjunct associate professor at
- 2:08Southwestern Law School and an experienced attorney
- 2:11with nationally recognized expertise in intellectual
- 2:14property and privacy law. Since 2016, she has
- 2:18practiced at Scott and Scott Attorneys at Law,
- 2:21focusing on class action litigation involving
- 2:24privacy, data breaches, and antitrust matters
- 2:27in the financial services sector. We'll begin
- 2:30with each panelist presenting their selected
- 2:32case study, focusing on key legal claims and
- 2:35overall structure of the lawsuits. After all
- 2:38presentations, we'll return to the stage to discuss
- 2:40the broader issues raised, and then open the
- 2:43floor for you, our audience, for your Q &A. So
- 2:46with that, let's get started with our first presentation
- 2:49by Netta Zagafi. Hi, all. Thank you, Uduak, for
- 2:55that introduction. Again, my name is Netta. I
- 2:59am a plaintiff's sexual assault civil attorney
- 3:03at Panache Raviputi in Los Angeles. I am passionate
- 3:07about this work, about survivors' rights and
- 3:09voice, and I'm so pleased to be here with you
- 3:13today. So thank you for taking the time out of
- 3:15your day. So we're all working on various case
- 3:18studies and the industries that we've pointed
- 3:21out and highlighted entertainment fashion. In
- 3:25this particular case, sports have these power
- 3:29dynamics where there is the possibility for sexual
- 3:33assault to thrive and a lot of concealment to
- 3:36occur. So the first case study that I'm going
- 3:38to be looking at is a civil suit against Larry
- 3:43Nassar and affiliated entities. If we could actually
- 3:46go back to the very first slide. For those of
- 3:48you who don't remember, Lawrence Nasser is a
- 3:51former osteopathic physician. He was a sports
- 3:54medicine doctor who worked in elite gymnastics
- 3:57in the United States and also worked with a number
- 4:00of athletes at Michigan State University. So
- 4:04he faced state and federal criminal charges and
- 4:08a number of civil suits. And again, the one that
- 4:11I'm highlighting today is Rachel Denhollander
- 4:14et al. versus Michigan State University et al.
- 4:16This was a federal civil lawsuit out of the Western
- 4:19District of Michigan. It was a multi plaintiff
- 4:22suit and it was filed January 2017 and plaintiffs
- 4:26in the action included former patients, gymnasts,
- 4:30and minor athletes. So now we can go to the second
- 4:32slide and just break down the case a little bit.
- 4:34Now just to let you guys know in your materials
- 4:37the entire complaint is available. I'm not going
- 4:40to go through each component of the complaint,
- 4:43but I want to highlight several big factors.
- 4:45If we could go to the second slide. So who were
- 4:49the named defendants? First and foremost, we
- 4:52had Nassar in his individual capacity. Now, when
- 4:55I file a civil lawsuit and sexual abuse, I'm
- 4:59considering One, is this a high profile case?
- 5:02And or two, does the individual perpetrator have
- 5:05deep pockets? If neither, it may not make sense
- 5:08to name the individual perpetrator. In this particular
- 5:12case, we have someone who is high profile who
- 5:16worked with worked with elite athletes and U
- 5:19.S. Olympians. So he is named in his individual
- 5:22capacity. Then you will have Michigan State University
- 5:25and the board. Now the board is the governing
- 5:28body of the university. and therefore they are
- 5:31named together. Nassar, having worked at Michigan
- 5:33State University and seen many survivor plaintiffs
- 5:37in his office there. You also have USA Gymnastics
- 5:40and also Twice Stars USA, which was an elite
- 5:42gym where Nassar frequently volunteered and also
- 5:46worked to treat athletes. So then we ask ourselves,
- 5:49what are common causes of actions in these kind
- 5:52of civil sexual abuse cases and in particular,
- 5:56in this matter? Again, I'm not going to go through
- 5:58all of them, but I want to highlight a few. And
- 6:01we note that there are state tort actions, and
- 6:05there are also federal causes of action. And
- 6:08one I want to hone in on is the tort action of
- 6:12negligent supervision. And I'm going to talk
- 6:14about negligent supervision as against a minor.
- 6:19So negligent supervision of a minor, which is
- 6:21essentially a cause of action that states that
- 6:24the entity failed to adequately supervise the
- 6:28minor when it had a duty to do so. And in California,
- 6:32minor being someone who is younger than 18 years
- 6:35old. And the way that I personally established
- 6:38this cause of action is through asserting a special
- 6:41relationship, either between the entity and you
- 6:46know, we're seeing these entities, MSU, the Board
- 6:49of Trustees, USA Gymnastics, Twice Stars, so
- 6:52either between the entity and the plaintiff and
- 6:54the plaintiff's guardians and or the entity and
- 6:56the third party tortfeasor, which in this case
- 6:59was Nassar. As we know, there is generally no
- 7:04affirmative duty of care. But the special relationship
- 7:07doctrine creates an affirmative duty of care
- 7:10because, one, the plaintiff was in a particularly
- 7:14vulnerable position for which the defendant entity
- 7:17we claim assumed care over the plaintiff. So
- 7:20we are essentially saying, and you'll see this
- 7:22in many civil complaints for sexual abuse, we're
- 7:25saying, well, what you did entity defendant is
- 7:30you took care of my minor child and you represented
- 7:35that they would be in your care and well taken
- 7:37for essentially stepping into the shoes of a
- 7:40parent such that there was an affirmative duty
- 7:43of care. There was an affirmative duty for you
- 7:45to supervise my child. And so then you create
- 7:48that affirmative duty in the negligence context.
- 7:51Alternatively, for the special relationship to
- 7:54arise, you can say the defendant entity was in
- 7:57the best position to control the actions of the
- 8:00third party tortfeasor. So in this case what
- 8:02that would look like is you would be saying,
- 8:05hey USA Gymnastics, you are in the best position
- 8:10to control the actions of Nassar by watching
- 8:13him, by overseeing him, by having direct control
- 8:17of him and promulgating policies in which he
- 8:19should not have been able to do this. So that's
- 8:22really the cause of action that I want to go
- 8:24over and to preserve some time I'm going to go
- 8:27to the next slide. Now in 2022, we had several
- 8:34athletes, we actually had 90 athletes bring a
- 8:38Federal Tort Claims Act as against the FBI. And
- 8:43those athletes included Simone Biles, Ali Reitzman,
- 8:46and the FTCA or the Federal Tort Claims Act has
- 8:51a procedural mechanism for filing. you have to
- 8:55present the administrative claim before filing
- 8:58a tort suit against the governmental entity.
- 9:02And then that has to be done within two years
- 9:05after accrual of the cause of action. Now what
- 9:08is the FTCA? The FTCA basically says that when
- 9:13an individual is injured due to the negligence
- 9:16of any employee of the United States, who is
- 9:19acting in their capacity as a government employee
- 9:22and negligence occurs, then there can be a viable
- 9:25cause of action against the US government. It's
- 9:29generally against the US government. And in this
- 9:31case, what people were saying or survivor plaintiffs
- 9:35were saying was hey FBI we gave you notice that
- 9:39something was amiss that this quote -unquote
- 9:42treatment that Nassar was giving us didn't feel
- 9:45right and we told you what was happening and
- 9:47you didn't investigate this properly allowing
- 9:49this injury and this harm to continue. And so
- 9:53I wanna go to the next slide and kind of summarize
- 9:56what happened in the Nassar cases. Eventually,
- 10:00as against MSU or Michigan State University and
- 10:03the board, there was a settlement of $500 million
- 10:05in May, 2018. As against the FBI, there was a
- 10:09settlement of nearly $139 million in April, 2024.
- 10:14And as against the U .S. gymnastics, USA Gymnastics,
- 10:21they filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy and they
- 10:24negotiated a settlement of $380 million. And
- 10:28if we go to the next slide, what's kind of the
- 10:31takeaway here? Institutional reform and accountability
- 10:36is possible. So not only did USA Gymnastics settle
- 10:41in terms of monetary amount, but they also agreed
- 10:45to set up a restorative justice program and under
- 10:49those terms survivors would have a say in the
- 10:52future about how USAG deals with future allegations
- 10:56of sexual abuse and because there was so much
- 11:00notice there were so many complaints about what
- 11:03was going on with Nassar before anything was
- 11:05done allegations around a cover -up around an
- 11:08adequacy of investigation creates a higher damages
- 11:12story of liability. And the law is not the end
- 11:17all be all. It does create reforms, but we have
- 11:19to consider survivors and what they have to live
- 11:22with and the mistakes that were made in the process
- 11:25such that harm was done upon survivors. And I
- 11:28think Rachel Denhollander said it best. And she
- 11:31wrote, justice has been done in so far as it
- 11:34can be. And it is good that we rejoice in that.
- 11:36But remember that tomorrow everyone wakes up
- 11:40still living the consequences. Don't lose that
- 11:43reality in the midst of sober rejoicing in the
- 11:46truth. So thank you all and I'm going to go ahead
- 11:50and hand it over to Josh who's going to present
- 11:53on Diddy. Thank you so much, Neda. Thank you
- 12:03all so much for taking the time. This is such
- 12:05an important topic and very topical today. So
- 12:11anybody who takes the time to educate themselves
- 12:13on the state of law in this country that has
- 12:16the ability to benefit survivors, hats off to
- 12:21you and thank you. So I want to talk today about
- 12:25a pretty well -known case in the last year and
- 12:29a half. Sean Diddy Combs, if you don't have a
- 12:33television, you may have missed it. But if you
- 12:35do, you probably have quite a good sense of what
- 12:37the nature of the claims are. So Sean Diddy Combs,
- 12:42of course, is a music icon whose career has spanned
- 12:48decades, who ultimately was caught up in a major
- 12:53scandal charged federally with multiple crimes,
- 12:57which we'll review on the second slide here.
- 13:03So United States of America versus Sean Combs.
- 13:07This is the case style of the federal charges
- 13:11that Sean Combs faced in the Southern District
- 13:13of New York, criminally. But I think before we
- 13:18get into the charges, I do think that this is
- 13:20an important comment regarding civil liability
- 13:23and the importance of civil lawyers in the criminal
- 13:27arena. This criminal case was spawned by the
- 13:33civil claims of Cassie Ventura. It was spawned
- 13:37by a survivor who had the courage to come forward,
- 13:39tell her story and shake the trees and of the
- 13:43FBI and the Department of Justice. And she ultimately
- 13:46was the factor behind these charges. So what
- 13:52we're looking at is we're looking at ultimately
- 13:54as the case developed, we're talking about multiple
- 13:56survivors reporting a span of abuse that nearly
- 14:01did his entire career, decades, 30 years. And
- 14:04it was a complex network. We're talking about
- 14:07employees transporting individuals. We're talking
- 14:10about interstate travel. We're talking about
- 14:13corporate funded events, parties, the freak offs
- 14:17that were in the news so often. And ultimately
- 14:19what that resulted in is it resulted in five
- 14:23federal criminal charges against Sean Combs,
- 14:27racketeering conspiracy, two counts of sex trafficking,
- 14:30and two counts of transportation prostitution.
- 14:33Ultimately, again, if you have the television,
- 14:36you know that the guilty counts were on counts
- 14:39four and counts five. He was found not guilty
- 14:41on counts one through three, sentenced to 50
- 14:44months in federal prison. If we could pop over
- 14:48to the next slide. The nature of the conduct
- 14:54and the reason he ultimately was charged with
- 14:57sex trafficking is because a lot of the stories
- 14:59and whether this is No comment on on whether
- 15:02you believe this was an overcharge or an overreach
- 15:04by the Department of Justice the reports wrong
- 15:08true of Widespread we'll call it trafficking
- 15:11conduct. So we talk about significant coercion
- 15:15and control. We'll talk about the the nature
- 15:18of federal trafficking law right now. Coercion
- 15:22control, organized encounters, extreme violence,
- 15:26retaliation, threats, escalating behavior. And
- 15:31ultimately, I think one of the things that we
- 15:33see in fashion and entertainment in Hollywood,
- 15:37this open secret culture. There's a lot of people
- 15:40who claim to have known that this was happening,
- 15:43but didn't respond. which you'll see implicates
- 15:47civil liability in just a moment. So understanding
- 15:50that this is the conduct, here's where we're
- 15:53at on the next slide. We're gonna break down
- 15:57the Trafficking Victims Protection and Reauthorization
- 16:01Act. It's section 1591 of the federal code, covers
- 16:05sex and labor trafficking. The key words in federal
- 16:11trafficking analysis and critically, The civil
- 16:14elements of federal trafficking and of labor
- 16:19trafficking and sex trafficking, the civil elements
- 16:21and the criminal elements are identical. The
- 16:23statues track each other. So the first element
- 16:26and the key words that we see in any trafficking
- 16:28analysis are these words force, fraud, or coercion.
- 16:34What constitutes force, fraud, and coercion,
- 16:36I can tell you, is the case law has been developing
- 16:40over the last probably decade, 15 years. And
- 16:43it is whatever you think it is, it's wider than
- 16:46what you think it is, which is why it's important
- 16:48to consult with an experienced lawyer in this.
- 16:53For each element, you'll see that I am going
- 16:55to apply it to both Sean Combs and corporate
- 16:59actors, because in this case, the civil claims
- 17:02that have trailed Sean Combs, in addition to
- 17:06the criminal charges that plagued him, have not
- 17:09just been against him personally. In addition
- 17:11to other individual actors, Other music stars.
- 17:15At one point, Jay -Z was named in a suit. We're
- 17:18talking about a lot of corporate actors. Companies
- 17:21as large as Epic Records and Arista Records,
- 17:24Bad Boy Entertainment, a lot of LLCs associated
- 17:27with Diddy. Those individuals are also going
- 17:32to be implicated here. You'll see why in the
- 17:36next two... in the next two slides. But ultimately,
- 17:40the first question is force threats, frauds,
- 17:43or coercion. Physical assaults, threats to careers,
- 17:46doesn't have to be I'm going to break your legs.
- 17:48It can be any type of, it can be financial, it
- 17:51can be psychological, it can be physical. There's
- 17:54a wide array of what can constitute force fraud
- 17:57or coercion. So the next element is on our next
- 18:00slide. And we're talking here, we're going to
- 18:05be talking about sexual trafficking in particular.
- 18:08So you're looking at a commercial sex act or
- 18:10anything of value. Again, the question is, well,
- 18:13what do we define as commercial? And what is
- 18:16anything of value? The answer to anything of
- 18:19value, which is the catch -all in this situation,
- 18:22is literally anything of value. Money, opportunities.
- 18:27I'm going to make you a star. I'll put you in
- 18:29a movie. You'll be on my next album. I'll get
- 18:32you into these parties. I'll get you drugs. There's
- 18:36a very wide range, but anything of value, it's
- 18:39a trade one for the other, a quid pro quo scenario.
- 18:45And this, by the way, this applies to adults.
- 18:49When we're talking about children, the age alone
- 18:53is going to be a factor of child sex trafficking,
- 18:57which is its own subsection of the TVPRA. Application
- 19:01to combs, application to corporate actors. How
- 19:05are these corporate actors benefiting? I'd say
- 19:07anything that's directly tied to the success
- 19:11of a star is benefiting and receiving the same
- 19:17value that that star would be receiving. I think
- 19:19that's particularly critical in this situation
- 19:23because when we're dealing in fashion, when we're
- 19:26dealing in entertainment, very rarely do we see
- 19:29these individual high profile actors who are
- 19:32just existing on their own. in this world. They
- 19:36are propped up by LLCs, they're propped up by
- 19:38record companies, by agents, by large organizations,
- 19:44all of whom are receiving the same benefits that
- 19:47that star is receiving. Which brings us to our
- 19:50third element on our next page, which is the
- 19:55knowing participation or critically, check out
- 19:59that arrow, benefiting from knowing or should
- 20:03have known that they were benefiting from trafficking.
- 20:06So civil liability is going to attach to any
- 20:09person or entity that benefits from participation
- 20:12in a trafficking venture. If anybody has seen
- 20:16the uptick, for example, in human trafficking
- 20:19litigation against motels and hotels, this is
- 20:25their knowing benefit. When they turn a blind
- 20:27eye to what's happening in these rooms, when
- 20:29they see these girls coming in and out, They
- 20:32are benefiting from it, even if it's just by
- 20:34receiving $50 for the room rental that evening.
- 20:40That's knowing benefiting. Same concept. So obviously
- 20:44the argument would be that Combs is, he's an
- 20:47active participant. He doesn't need to be a knowing
- 20:50beneficiary. He is the trafficker in this situation.
- 20:53Arguably other individuals are the traffickers.
- 20:55But when you apply to corporate actors, you're
- 20:58talking about any individual who's Providing
- 21:01and these are the allegations in these civil
- 21:03suits providing transportation housing security
- 21:06event coordination Travel people who are providing
- 21:09drugs and alcohol people who are moving people
- 21:12from one location to another Arguably the failure
- 21:17to intervene despite your long -standing knowledge
- 21:20Knowing that this is happening knowing this is
- 21:22happening for 30 years doing nothing But taking
- 21:25your paycheck or or taking your tax benefits
- 21:28as a as a corporate entity ultimately, arguably
- 21:32benefiting from trafficking ventures. Which brings
- 21:35us to our final slide, I believe. So our lessons
- 21:41in civil liability is this. Where conduct fits
- 21:46a federal trafficking framework, you can bring
- 21:49these claims federally in any jurisdiction. A
- 21:54couple of just general comments. While punitive
- 21:57damages are not included, In the statute itself,
- 22:01there is not a federal court in this country
- 22:03that has not found, I believe every circuit at
- 22:07this point has found in at least one case that
- 22:09punitive damages are available under the statute.
- 22:15In these situations, there's usually a strong
- 22:18basis for vicarious liability when we're talking
- 22:20about these additional corporate actors. you
- 22:23are not limited to your trafficking claims. There
- 22:26are definitely claims that trail these and most
- 22:29trafficking claims are brought alongside vicarious
- 22:33liability claims, negligent supervision, negligent
- 22:35hiring, negligent retention, aiding and abetting
- 22:38claims. And when you're dealing with these larger
- 22:41actors or these sort of complicit parties, That
- 22:45comes along with a lot of evidence, travel logs,
- 22:48communications, contracts, NDAs. It also often,
- 22:52if you can shake the trees like Cassie Ventura
- 22:56did, it also often comes with the benefit of
- 22:59trailing behind an FBI investigation or a state
- 23:02trafficking investigation. But ultimately what
- 23:04I think it shows is that these organizations,
- 23:08these LLCs, these entities exist alongside and
- 23:11behind these actors in the fashion and entertainment
- 23:15and sports and music industries, they are going
- 23:19to be held responsible as they should be, and
- 23:23the TVPRA provides a good opportunity for them
- 23:26to do that. With that, I will turn it over to
- 23:30Victoria Burke. Thank you so much. Okay, I'm
- 23:36going to be covering the case days of Bruce Weber
- 23:39and Mario Testino. These are two highly regarded
- 23:43fashion photographers. Anna Wintour, editor of
- 23:47Vogue, had said these were some of her best friends.
- 23:52What happened was, first of all, we had the Me
- 23:54Too movement that really caught fire around 2016
- 23:58of Harvey Weinstein. came about in 2018 when
- 24:03numerous male models are saying, hey, you know,
- 24:06I was like sexually harassed, sexually assaulted,
- 24:09touched inappropriately by these two very esteemed
- 24:13photographers. And you have to realize when you're
- 24:16in modeling. You could be in very vulnerable
- 24:19positions and a lot of times are young and they
- 24:22may or may not know what is appropriate, such
- 24:25as they might be touching you to adjust you,
- 24:28or like you with Bruce Webber, if you could advance
- 24:32the slide. With Bruce Weber, he would engage
- 24:37and say, we're going to do some of these breathing
- 24:40exercises together. He would use it as a way
- 24:43to inappropriately touch the models. At one point
- 24:48in, I believe it was 2018, a whole bunch of people
- 24:52came forward and in 2020, Bruce was actually
- 24:57sued in court. Next slide. He was brought forward
- 25:05by Jason Boyce and then 10 non -party accusers.
- 25:10The causes of action in New York were New York
- 25:13State Human Rights Law, New York City Human Rights
- 25:17Law for sex trafficking under the Trafficking
- 25:21Victims Protection Act. Now, a lot of times you'll
- 25:24see with these cases, they do not go forward.
- 25:27They usually end in a settlement. And especially
- 25:30when they get a lot of press, a lot of times
- 25:32someone wants them to go away. And so you never
- 25:35really see how these laws play out. And can you
- 25:39advance one more? With Mauro Testino, I don't
- 25:43believe there was a case brought against him,
- 25:45but there were accusations. The ramifications
- 25:48of these actions were no one wanted to work with
- 25:50these photographers anymore. Anna Wintour had
- 25:53said that Conde Nast would no longer be employing
- 25:55them, even though she said these are some of
- 25:58my good friends, but we have to be cautious and
- 26:02believe survivors. this is how it was for a while.
- 26:07But as we're noticing now with a lot of the effects
- 26:10of the Me Too movement is it didn't always stick
- 26:15and they're starting to make a comeback, such
- 26:18as Bruce Webber. If you could advance it one
- 26:21more. He's having a quiet return. He's offering
- 26:26to work for free. A lot of places are like, wow,
- 26:29he's such an expert photographer and he's willing
- 26:31to work for free. That sounds pretty good to
- 26:35us. What you'll see here is you're having to
- 26:39inform models before that they go to assignments
- 26:43with Bruce Weber of these allegations. probably
- 26:47make a model feel very unsure how to say yes
- 26:51or no to this because as a photographer, if your
- 26:56agency is sending you out there saying, are you
- 26:57comfortable with it? Are you in a position to
- 26:59say no? Unfortunately, a lot of people are put
- 27:03in these positions without something to feel
- 27:08secure. There's no telling them to have someone
- 27:12else present to make sure everything is fine.
- 27:15Next slide. So I was curious about how would
- 27:20this play out in today's legal landscape? And
- 27:23what's interesting is what we saw in the Me Too
- 27:26movement is the press covered how great it was
- 27:30when so many survivors came forward and they
- 27:32told their story. We saw people like Harvey Weinstein
- 27:35and other people be taken down. We're like, yes,
- 27:36this is good. People are speaking out. But what
- 27:39the press didn't cover as much is what came after
- 27:43it. And what came after it was a wave of defamation
- 27:47lawsuits used to silence people speaking out,
- 27:51the survivors. And usually with the survivors,
- 27:54oftentimes there's an imbalance of power and
- 27:56money. And what happened with these lawsuits
- 27:59is that It's very hard to prove defamation these
- 28:03cases because, you know, a lot of times are many
- 28:06years ago, there was no evidence remaining, no
- 28:09one else was there. It's he said, she said, you
- 28:11know, two people go in a room, two people exit.
- 28:14They both have two different versions about what
- 28:16happened. So these cases usually are not winnable,
- 28:19but they're used to intimidate and bully and
- 28:22to just shut down the survivor speak out because
- 28:24it's cheaper. to go silent because these defamation
- 28:28lawsuits oftentimes cost five, six, even seven
- 28:33figures and they often take like five years to
- 28:36resolve. And it's so much cheaper to go silent.
- 28:40And I had something that happened to me years
- 28:43ago. And when I was in this position of I wanted
- 28:46to speak out, I remember a friend of mine from
- 28:48law school had said to me, don't speak out, don't
- 28:52use your abuser's name, any identifiers, you
- 28:55could be sued for defamation. And I remember
- 28:58thinking like, that's crazy. Like, what? And
- 29:01she said, please just look it up in the wake
- 29:03of me to what happened. So I did start doing
- 29:06all this research and I was outraged by this
- 29:09huge wave that was happening. So I decided to
- 29:13change the law. And so I came up with AB 933,
- 29:18which basically is called the Speaker Truth Act.
- 29:22It was made into law and acted in 2023 in California.
- 29:28It's now four states have adopted it and it's
- 29:30moving nationwide. What it does is if a survivor
- 29:34is sued for defamation, it ensures that if it
- 29:39cannot be shown that the survivor spoke of malice,
- 29:42that the survivor can recover attorney fees.
- 29:45and in California, trouble damages and potentially
- 29:48punitive damages. And you're seeing this bill,
- 29:53which is starting to catch fire this year. Blake
- 29:58Lively used it as a defense with Justin Baldoni
- 30:01in the defamation case. And so I've had to see
- 30:05my bill. be misspoke about all of our social
- 30:09media and people not quite understanding the
- 30:12mechanics of how it works because even now, although
- 30:14the defamation claim has ended, she still is
- 30:17able to claim damages of attorney fees. and possible
- 30:22trouble damages and potentially punitive damages
- 30:25because of my bill. And that still needs to be
- 30:27adjudicated. So I'm seeing my bill is being applied
- 30:31quite often now. I was speaking to attorney Alison
- 30:35Anderson, who represented the victims of Danny
- 30:37Masterson. And she said she's been applying my
- 30:40bill since March. And what she's seen is there's
- 30:44coming in the threat. to a client of hers, a
- 30:47survivor speaking out, of like, well, we're going
- 30:49to sue for defamation if they don't stop talking.
- 30:52She's like, well, go ahead. If you can't prove
- 30:54malice, you're going to have to pay the attorney
- 30:56fees and any of their actual damages, which would
- 30:59be... triple and potential punitive. If you're
- 31:03willing to do that, let's go. Also, these cases
- 31:06are going away. It's having a chilling effect
- 31:09on those who want to bully while still preserving
- 31:13the ability of someone who's falsely accused
- 31:16to bring forward a defamation claim so long as
- 31:19they can prove malice. That is Currently moving
- 31:24nationwide. Last year was introduced in 16 states.
- 31:28Certain states take several years to get it passed.
- 31:32It's been introduced in New York. It was mentioned
- 31:34with articles about. Cuomo was brought up oftentimes
- 31:38that how would that bill affect him with his
- 31:42suing his survivor, threatening to sue his survivors,
- 31:45speaking out for defamation. So it's having quite
- 31:48an impact in significant places across the nation.
- 31:52Because if you think about it, with the Blake
- 31:54Lively trial, originally Justin Baldoni responded
- 31:57Blake Lively wanted New York law. And he said,
- 32:01no, no, no, I want California laws. The contrast
- 32:03stayed. She was like, OK, well, then we're going
- 32:06to apply this bill, which was just recently passed
- 32:08in California. So you have to think about your
- 32:11client about what choice of law that they might
- 32:14want to use in a case like this, because in this
- 32:17state, this law is available. So depending on
- 32:19which side your client's on might impact which
- 32:22state you wishes the law to be applied. So that
- 32:26is right now how we see what the landscape would
- 32:28apply is that maybe nowadays the photographers
- 32:32would have tried to sue for defamation the models
- 32:35But now we're seeing that many people are able
- 32:38to use my bill which at AB 933 or CA 47 .1 To
- 32:43say okay to counter any threat of a defamation
- 32:47lawsuit that's being weaponized They could say
- 32:49like that's fine. Here are the consequences if
- 32:52you can't show malice. So that's the landscape.
- 32:56Thank you so much. Thank you so much, Victoria.
- 33:03And before I get into my own discussion and presentation,
- 33:07I first have to highlight a few things that really
- 33:09stuck out to me of what everyone said. And I'll
- 33:12start with Victoria. In a different conversation
- 33:15just yesterday, I was... Excuse me, Uduak. It
- 33:19looks like your camera's not on. Oh, my apologies.
- 33:22Can everybody see me now? Yes. Yeah. Okay. Thank
- 33:27you so much, Susie. So in a different conversation
- 33:29yesterday, I was saying and lamenting the plight
- 33:32of the legal industry as a whole, legal profession
- 33:35and attorneys. When you look at the current climate
- 33:39that we have and the media narrative and the
- 33:42public's distrust of who we are as attorneys.
- 33:44And the idea that it's funny how we are responsible
- 33:48for giving voices to the voiceless, but when
- 33:50you really peel the layers behind, you really
- 33:53see that we don't really have a voice. I find
- 33:56that that applies in the entertainment industry
- 33:58as well, or we think we don't have a voice. And
- 34:01what Victoria has done is underscore that not
- 34:03only do we have a voice, we have a duty and obligation
- 34:06to do something about it through the notes I
- 34:09took that she was just talking about, Speak Your
- 34:11Truth Act, right? So, and you're gonna see as
- 34:14I present that you can no longer sort of take
- 34:16an arm's length approach and say, oh, let me
- 34:19sit back. I see all this toxicity as Josh highlighted
- 34:22so well. open secret culture that's occurring
- 34:25and do nothing about it. You actually could potentially
- 34:29be pulled into having to deal with legal liability.
- 34:33I also liked what Netta said about negligent
- 34:36supervision of a minor that is rampant in the
- 34:38entire entertainment industry and of course,
- 34:41and fashion. And of course, as you see these
- 34:42cases, they're going way back. when people were
- 34:45minor. So let me actually use my experience,
- 34:48industry experience. I studied modeling at 14
- 34:51years old. And the sexual harassment that I experienced
- 34:56in modeling, it was so commonplace, open secret,
- 35:00not only me, my colleagues. And often, particularly
- 35:03when you look at the fashion industry, there's
- 35:05an emphasis on women and also the entertainment
- 35:08culture as a whole. Boys and men are really suffering.
- 35:12And I appreciate that Victoria. underscored that
- 35:15sexual harassment that did not stop and of course
- 35:19in that space also you hear about sexual assault
- 35:22towards other colleagues in the film and if you're
- 35:26working in fashion necessarily at some point
- 35:28all of the creative arts are gonna intersect
- 35:31so I got into film and I got into music it never
- 35:34stopped right until I really started to obviously
- 35:39assert myself as I grew older in the industry
- 35:43because everybody, that culture of silence, are
- 35:46you going to lose the opportunity? What's going
- 35:48to happen to you? Is anyone going to believe
- 35:49you? It's really, really, really rampant and
- 35:52also quite strong. Having said that, let me transition
- 35:57to my actual presentation. We'll start with the
- 36:00first slide. So one of the reasons I emphasize
- 36:05my personal experiences, often I'm asked, is
- 36:08it really true what everyone is saying? It is
- 36:11so true and beyond. Film industry experience,
- 36:15as I said, sexual harassment, music industry,
- 36:17same thing. And to underscore that, we're looking
- 36:20at the McGowan versus Weinstein case, et al,
- 36:24the anatomy of a Me Too era racketeering lawsuit.
- 36:28Remember when this case broke, everybody started
- 36:30to say, Me too, me too. And it seemed like, wow,
- 36:35this was really going on. Yes, it is. Let's start
- 36:37first with the parties, with the McGowan versus
- 36:40Weinstein case. First thing to note is that the
- 36:45plaintiff here is Rose McGowan. She is an actor.
- 36:48She's the author of Brave, which tells her story
- 36:51of allegedly being raped by the defendant Weinstein,
- 36:57and she's also a big advocate for industry reform
- 37:00on sexual harassment and sexual assault. The
- 37:03defendants here, as played in the original complaint
- 37:06with Harvey Weinstein, David Boyce and Boyce
- 37:09Sheila Flexner LLP, David Boyce as a lawyer,
- 37:14Lisa Bloom and the Bloom firm, BC Strategies
- 37:17Limited doing business as Black Cube, which was
- 37:19a security agency hired allegedly by the attorneys.
- 37:23in order to supposedly track Rose McGowan among
- 37:28other things that she mentioned that they did
- 37:30that was even more egregious. What I want to
- 37:32underscore particularly with this slide is that
- 37:34David Boyce is sued in his individual capacity
- 37:37and as an agent acting on behalf of his law firm.
- 37:42And his law firm is also pulled into the litigation.
- 37:44The same holds for Lisa Bloom. And if you're
- 37:46not familiar maybe with Lisa Bloom, she's Gloria
- 37:49Allred's daughter. And she, along with her mother,
- 37:53are known as advocates for sexual assault victims,
- 37:57especially women. To court from page 16 of the
- 38:00complaint, the plaintiff said, Bloom primarily
- 38:03represented women who accused celebrities and
- 38:06other prominent men of sexual harassment and
- 38:08assault, including President Donald Trump and
- 38:12then Fox News anchor Bill O 'Reilly. As a lawyer,
- 38:17you may be exposed to legal liability, disciplinary
- 38:20consequences, and one of the ways to assess that
- 38:23is to look at whether you knew or had a strong
- 38:25reason to believe that, for example, minors were
- 38:28being abused or placed in danger, women were
- 38:31experiencing sexual harassment or assault, or
- 38:33that there were ongoing violations of employment
- 38:36or safety laws. Again, you can no longer sort
- 38:38of take an arm's length to these realities. Let's
- 38:41move on to the next slide. of where we talk about
- 38:45the civil litigation landscape against Harvey
- 38:48Weinstein. Dozens of lawsuits were filed across
- 38:51multiple jurisdictions. However, what I could
- 38:54find in terms of well -documented suits include
- 38:56the Doe versus Weinstein matter that you see
- 38:59here on your screen, the Ashley Judd versus Weinstein,
- 39:04and then the McGowan versus Weinstein et al.,
- 39:06which is what we're focusing on. There were also
- 39:09criminal prosecutions in New York City and Los
- 39:11Angeles that occurred separately. that's not
- 39:13part of the analysis. The focus here is more
- 39:15on the civil. All right. We already covered the
- 39:19parties, I believe. Let's get into the case theory.
- 39:23For the case theory, McGowan's point was that
- 39:27she claimed under the RICO statute that defendants
- 39:30formed and operated a Weinstein protection enterprise
- 39:34to spy on her and deceive her, to obtain and
- 39:38exploit her brave manuscript, which was sort
- 39:40of this tell all included of what had happened
- 39:43to her, and also interfered with the publication
- 39:46to discredit her rape allegations. So lawyers
- 39:49are sometimes named in lawsuits, even if they
- 39:52were not abusers. and because why so it's because
- 39:56they allegedly are helping with creating the
- 39:59system that allows abuse to continue. So ask
- 40:02yourself, are you drafting several settlement
- 40:04agreements to hide abuse? Are you threatening
- 40:07or pressuring victims into silence? Are you helping
- 40:10to destroy or hide evidence? Are you transferring
- 40:13abusers or protecting them from internal consequences?
- 40:16If you are doing such thing, there might be a
- 40:19time of reckoning. So let's go to the pleading
- 40:22strategy for this particular matter. First, as
- 40:25with any other complaint you file, you want to
- 40:28ensure that the proper caption is there. jury
- 40:31demand in this instance. There's a jurisdictional
- 40:34and venue question, of course, that you must
- 40:36address. In this instance, federal question addressed
- 40:39Rico wiretap, the wiretap act, the supplemental
- 40:42state claims that also should be addressed in
- 40:45that complaint. The parties, I loved how Neda
- 40:48talked about Evaluating deep pockets we all know
- 40:51that's sort of a standard important thing to
- 40:53evaluate But for newer attorneys if you're getting
- 40:56into it and filing such complaint be aware of
- 40:58that to to know where the deep pockets are Detailed
- 41:02factual background always important and if you
- 41:04look at the complaint in your packet that you
- 41:07should have received It should be about 72 pages
- 41:10of very detailed facts on what happened how it
- 41:13happened among other things next you look at
- 41:17Specifically, if you have a RICO claim, you have
- 41:19to have it played with very, very detailed facts.
- 41:24And part of that is establishing RICO enterprise
- 41:28and the Predicate Act section. Also, the causes
- 41:30of action that was addressed here with the multi
- 41:33-counts of RICO, YATAP Act, the fraud, the Bain
- 41:37Act, the computer crimes, the conversion, the
- 41:39intentional infliction of emotional distress,
- 41:42the negligence and the prayer for relief. Essentially,
- 41:47McGowan was saying Weinstein and his associates
- 41:49orchestrated efforts through their legal counsel
- 41:52and their investigators to prevent her from publishing
- 41:56her book, to leak damaging information about
- 41:59her, including drug -related charges, to silence
- 42:03and intimidate her, all to protect Weinstein's
- 42:06interests. And she claims that those actions
- 42:10constituted an enterprise and the Weinstein enterprise,
- 42:14the Weinstein protection enterprise and that
- 42:17the defendants committed multiple predicate acts,
- 42:19which was the fraud, the white top acts that
- 42:21had already addressed over a period of time.
- 42:24Next slide please on the litigation outcome.
- 42:26So the litigation outcome of what happened in
- 42:29this case was there was the motion to dismiss
- 42:31granite in part and denied in part. The fraud
- 42:35based claims survived and several statutory claims
- 42:37including the Rico claim was dismissed with leave
- 42:40to amend. That was in 2020. Subsequently in 2021,
- 42:44there was an amended Rico allegations that was
- 42:47still insufficient because of how high that threshold
- 42:50is to meet for Rico claims and the elements that
- 42:53must be satisfied. And after that, McGowan proceeded
- 42:57pro se because her attorneys withdrew and she
- 43:00missed a supplemental briefing deadline. And
- 43:03ultimately, the court dismissed the action. The
- 43:06Rico claims were also dismissed with prejudice,
- 43:08meaning that she can't come back and refile those
- 43:11matters. The emphasis for us is really to unpack
- 43:15a lot of conversation here. And so on the ethics
- 43:19and industry implications. So next slide, please,
- 43:22as we begin to get ready to have even further
- 43:24discussions. What are the ethics and industry
- 43:28implications here? I think for me, the central
- 43:32thing here is highlighting what responsibilities
- 43:35do lawyers have when protecting powerful clients.
- 43:38It doesn't even have to be powerful nationwide
- 43:40clients when protecting clients that might be
- 43:44really inflicting harm on victims that we become
- 43:48aware of. And where is that ethical line? So
- 43:52how the allegations were used in this particular
- 43:54matter. use of private intelligence firms and
- 43:57convert surveillance directed by lawyers or allegedly
- 44:00directed by lawyers, blending of legal strategy,
- 44:03PR and undercover operations, litigation tactics
- 44:06functioning as intimidation rather than advocacy.
- 44:10That was part of the allegation. Non -disclosure
- 44:12agreements and settlements discusses potential
- 44:14silences of accusers and the resulting impact
- 44:17on the public trust in lawyers and the justice
- 44:20system. So on that note, I will make a transition
- 44:23and pose my first question to Josh, actually.
- 44:27Josh, what responsibilities do lawyers have when
- 44:30protecting powerful clients? So I'll say this.
- 44:36Most of my practice is going to focus on, we'll
- 44:39say, the underdog, the survivor. But that's not
- 44:42saying that there aren't powerful individuals
- 44:46who are also victimized. I think a lot of times
- 44:47that's overlooked. But I think the Duty owed
- 44:52is the duty owed to any client, right? It's zealous
- 44:55representation, zealous advocacy within the ethics
- 44:59of our profession. And as soon as you, this goes,
- 45:03I guess, particularly for any new lawyers, young
- 45:06lawyers on this meeting. As soon as you start
- 45:12questioning, if something's a close call, should
- 45:14I do this? Should I not? I'll save you the call
- 45:17to the bar hotline and say, don't do it. Right?
- 45:21We're human beings. We have a duty. But ultimately,
- 45:25there's a lot of gray. This is sort of, I guess,
- 45:29the lesson. There's a lot of gray in our profession.
- 45:33There's also a lot of black and white. And I
- 45:35think that one of the critical things to do is
- 45:38when you see the black and white, make the right
- 45:41decision and make the right call. And then when
- 45:44there's gray, you you deal with it and you you
- 45:47speak to uh to colleagues that you have but your
- 45:50moral compass is is something that you just can't
- 45:52lose in this type of litigation okay so let me
- 45:56go to Victoria, then the question Josh, you said,
- 46:00when there's gray. So Victoria, when there's
- 46:02gray, how do you handle that? Particularly, I
- 46:06would say, what effective counter strategies
- 46:09can you, you know, create for a culture of silence
- 46:13that normalizes internal and external reporting?
- 46:16And then one of the reasons I asked also, you
- 46:18talk about how in the modeling industry, which
- 46:20is so true, you know, you're being touched for
- 46:23feedings, among other things. And so You're not
- 46:26even connecting the dots that that is happening
- 46:29per se, even though it might feel uncomfortable
- 46:31for you. So what counter strategies would you
- 46:34say that lawyers should be thinking about and
- 46:37employing? I think maybe urge different industries
- 46:42to start educating what are the boundaries and
- 46:44what can be, and maybe have chaperones urge something
- 46:48like that in different industries that have intimate
- 46:52actors, like you're modeling and touching people,
- 46:56because we're starting to see, are they called
- 46:59intimate coordinators for movies? So we're starting
- 47:02to see where actors used to just have to tolerate
- 47:05it. Some of them, I could think of the movies
- 47:09in the past where they were really bad to different
- 47:13women and stuff like that. Now, I have an intimacy
- 47:16coordinator. If you have any issues, you can
- 47:19consult them and be like, I'm not comfortable.
- 47:22I think that's really good. I think that should
- 47:24be spread throughout the industry. I think people
- 47:28should have an environment where they're encouraged
- 47:30to come forward. However, I do feel that if you
- 47:33have a story to tell, it would be beneficial
- 47:35to pause and consult an attorney because not
- 47:39every state has like my bill like the Speaker
- 47:42Truth Act and so you can be hit with a defamation
- 47:44suit that takes long so you have to think about
- 47:47is there another way I could speak about it without
- 47:49being sued so I would take a pause if I was counseling
- 47:54a client and just say you know just you know
- 47:56this these are the consequences if you name the
- 47:59person or give any identifiers and you're not
- 48:02protecting this in this particular area, but
- 48:05this is how you can still tell your story in
- 48:08this way. So maybe like... if some people had
- 48:11a redo when they did hashtag me too and told
- 48:13their story on Twitter, that maybe they would
- 48:16have left out some identifying details and said
- 48:18that if they were not prepared to handle a defamation
- 48:20suit that came afterwards. But I've seen more
- 48:23and more where people are having a network where,
- 48:27I forgot what it's called, shoot, I'll have to
- 48:32remember it, where if we're on college campuses
- 48:36that you can now sign up if you have been sexually
- 48:41assaulted. And if someone else has been sexually
- 48:43assaulted by your abuser, you're connected. And
- 48:46it's anonymous until then. So then only at that
- 48:49point would you guys connect to discuss if there's
- 48:52an abuse case. So people are finding ways where
- 48:54they can come forward, where it is in a somewhat
- 48:57protected environment. Wow. Very, very interesting.
- 49:00Let me transition to Neda. That's interesting
- 49:03what's happening on college campuses. Victoria
- 49:07brought a very important point about how you're
- 49:09counseling your clients. So two last questions
- 49:12before we go to the audience, and then we can
- 49:14always come back and answer more, discuss some
- 49:16more and unpack some more. Where, Neda, would
- 49:19you say you draw the line between confidentiality
- 49:22versus being complicit? That's a hard line that
- 49:25a lot of attorneys are always trying to figure
- 49:27out, all of us included. So what would you recommend
- 49:30would be the approach? Sure. So when I think
- 49:33about I'm thinking about our ethical duties and
- 49:38responsibilities of confidentiality to our clients.
- 49:41And so the question that I ask myself is, is
- 49:45the confidentiality serving a legitimate client
- 49:48interest or is it primarily serving to silence
- 49:53disclosure of wrongdoing and protect the wrongdoer
- 49:56rather than protecting the victim? So in thinking
- 49:59about confidentiality versus complicity, the
- 50:03question becomes, are we enabling misconduct
- 50:05in a manner that doesn't actually abide by our
- 50:09responsibilities of confidentiality per our ethical
- 50:13requirements as attorneys? And confidentiality
- 50:17is essential as well, but it doesn't override
- 50:22all other ethical concerns. So a few points I
- 50:27want to add here. If you represent, let's say,
- 50:29a studio, a brand, a team, and you become aware
- 50:33of patterns of misconduct, our responsibility
- 50:36is to ensure that we're not simply enabling the
- 50:40concealment of abuse. It's our responsibility
- 50:43to consider whether we need to advise the organization
- 50:47to adopt independent and impartial outside external
- 50:52investigations, disclosure obligations, and systemic
- 50:55reforms. And if you find that your role is becoming
- 51:01a participant in concealment of wrongdoing, there
- 51:06are mechanisms of withdrawing under our ethical
- 51:09rules. In California, rule 1 .16. And another
- 51:14thing that I want to bring up is reviewing settlements,
- 51:17particularly in civil lawsuits. In thinking about
- 51:22NDAs, nondisclosure agreements, You have to make
- 51:26sure that the confidentiality clauses don't run
- 51:29afoul of statutory prohibitions. civil procedures
- 51:361001 and 1002 essentially say that a settlement
- 51:41agreement in a civil lawsuit cannot prohibit
- 51:45a survivor from providing the factual claims
- 51:48of sexual assault or harassment. So being really
- 51:52careful that you as an attorney are reviewing
- 51:54those settlement agreements as well. Okay, I
- 51:57want to come back to you Neda on AB 250 that's
- 52:02just been recently enacted and have you sort
- 52:05of spell that out. But before I do, you mentioned
- 52:08something that maybe Josh, it'd be interesting
- 52:10to see your perspective on it. You know, sort
- 52:13of like we have a duty to report, etc. I know
- 52:16most of my colleagues in the entertainment music
- 52:18space are going to say easier said than done.
- 52:21Depending on the genre. And the clients you're
- 52:24representing, it truly is a very toxic culture
- 52:28at the core. I've talked to colleagues that say
- 52:30they just feel not only so uncomfortable, they
- 52:33don't sleep well at night and they can't wait
- 52:35to just get out of that space. But they've got
- 52:37to worry about bills. They've got to worry about
- 52:39all those other things. And beyond that, they
- 52:42almost feel like, yes, it's happening, but it's
- 52:45not my place. to move forward with, you know,
- 52:49particularly out in my client, if you will. So,
- 52:52Josh, you have extensive experience more on the
- 52:55prosecuting side. Now you're doing the civil
- 52:57plaintiff side. How do we handle all of this?
- 53:00Still trying to do the right thing, but then
- 53:03sometimes depending on the culture of the industry
- 53:07we're representing and the clients we're representing
- 53:09is just a different ball game from a practical
- 53:12standpoint. Yeah, you know, I'll say this, I'll
- 53:17fall back and I might be oversimplifying this
- 53:20a little bit. I'll fall back on my first answer
- 53:24a little bit here. If you feel that you can't
- 53:27navigate sort of the moral complexities of this
- 53:30and this is just an industry that you feel like
- 53:35your hands are tied or you're not sure that you
- 53:37can navigate sort of the... the practical or
- 53:41professional balances of reporting, of dealing
- 53:44with clients, of sort of working in a space where
- 53:47this type of abuse exists and you know it and
- 53:51you see it, if you can't do that sort of personally,
- 53:55professionally, I'd say go ahead and just go
- 53:57into transactional work. And that's that. And
- 54:02not saying that transactional lawyers aren't
- 54:03around this and don't see it and don't have the
- 54:05same responsibilities. Now, when we're talking
- 54:07about Obviously, when we're talking about client
- 54:10confidentialities and things like that, we're
- 54:13lawyers. We're bound by certain rules and certain
- 54:17ethics and things like that. So I guess the way
- 54:20that you tie those two things together is to
- 54:22say, there's a reason that this is a panel. right
- 54:28that exists in 2025 right because we we know
- 54:31what's happening the the the light has been shown
- 54:34it continues to be shown um you know we're gonna
- 54:37see in whatever's gonna happen in the next few
- 54:40weeks i think we're gonna see a lot of a lot
- 54:43of things exposed and a lot of names out there
- 54:45and a lot of uh you know people spiraling and
- 54:50and world spinning and i think one of the things
- 54:53that you're gonna find is you're gonna find that
- 54:55those people didn't operate in a vacuum There
- 54:57were people out there, they have lawyers, they
- 54:59have representatives, they have like Sean Diddy
- 55:01Combs, like Bad Boy Entertainment, they have
- 55:03LLCs, they have people propping them up. These
- 55:06people don't exist in the ether. The next time
- 55:09I see a multi -millionaire, high fashion entertainment
- 55:13powerhouse who doesn't have a massive team behind
- 55:17him or strategic agency or strategic corporation,
- 55:20that will be the first. So if you have the ability,
- 55:25To operate in that world and and and you can
- 55:28walk that moral line and go to go to sleep at
- 55:32night and sleep And as long as you're acting
- 55:34ethically, I say, you know go for it but again
- 55:38to the younger lawyers your reputation is everything
- 55:41in the law as soon as you as soon as you take
- 55:45a take a make a misstep It will follow you forever.
- 55:48I promise so if you can do it do it If you can
- 55:52do it with and if you have client confidences,
- 55:54which you will have, I promise you there are
- 55:57client confidences that I have that I wish I
- 55:59didn't. And I've been representing plaintiffs
- 56:03and survivors and victims my whole life, and
- 56:05I still have those. If you don't think that you
- 56:07can operate with those on your conscience, go
- 56:11into it for your own mental health, go into a
- 56:13different industry. But outside of that, again,
- 56:17there are certain things that are just black
- 56:19and white in your own moral compass is going
- 56:20to be your guide. Excellent. Thank you so much.
- 56:23We've got a few questions that I see, which is
- 56:27why I'm knowingly continuing with the panel to
- 56:29unpack a little bit. But I'll wrap it up with
- 56:31this final question with Neda. And then we'll
- 56:35go into the two questions posed by Nicole Sass.
- 56:38So over to you, Neda, specifically. AB 250, Assembly
- 56:43Bill 250 is now being passed, and it supposedly
- 56:46will have an impact on sexual abuse litigation.
- 56:49Could you just give us the key features or any
- 56:52additional information that would be helpful
- 56:53to our audience? Yeah, I'll break it down really
- 56:56quickly. So Assembly Bill 250 basically amends
- 57:00the statute of limitations in 340 .16, CCP 340
- 57:05.16 to revive claims for adult sexual assault.
- 57:10for survivors whose claims were previously time
- 57:13barred in the civil context. So the revival period
- 57:18is effective January 1st, 2026 through December
- 57:2331st, 2027. So basically for adult sexual abuse
- 57:29matters in the civil context that were previously
- 57:33time barred, this basically creates a window
- 57:36in which you can bring the claim. It does not
- 57:40include public entities. So if one of your defendants,
- 57:45for instance, is a public school district, that
- 57:48would not be able to be named in this look back
- 57:50period. So you can name an individual perpetrator.
- 57:55You can name a private institution. But a cover
- 57:59up should be alleged as to the entity. So that's
- 58:02AB 250, which excitingly is coming into place
- 58:06in effective January 1st, 2026. Thank you so
- 58:10much for that. Let's go to the questions posed.
- 58:14I think I'll start with the one from Giacomo,
- 58:18Jack Russo, and then we'll go to the longer one
- 58:21from Nicole. So, is Boyes and his firm doing
- 58:24the same pattern as in the Terrano's Elizabeth
- 58:26Holmes case, or is this just all zealous advice?
- 58:30That's the trick, Jack. That's the challenge
- 58:33of that case. And the fact that it ultimately
- 58:35got dismissed, the McGowan case, one could argue,
- 58:38whether it's Lisa Bloom's firm or Boyd's firm,
- 58:42that it's in fact David Boyd's firm, that it's
- 58:44in fact legal advice. We're doing what any other
- 58:47attorney would do. The first thing you do is
- 58:49obviously consult with your client. Your client
- 58:53is saying, this is truthfully, I didn't do those
- 58:55things. They're false, etc. You conduct an investigation.
- 58:59Of course, you have to conduct an investigation
- 59:01as part of your duty, among other things. But
- 59:04it appears that that matter never went to trial.
- 59:07So in terms, a lot of it would be speculating,
- 59:09right? But if it did, and then we would obviously
- 59:12find something more tangible that we can hang
- 59:15on to. But with the Tarantos Elizabeth Holmes
- 59:18case, actually a very close friend of mine of
- 59:20over 20 years was one of the part of the prosecuting
- 59:25team for that Elizabeth Holmes matter. And it
- 59:29appeared, well, depending on the industry, but
- 59:32it appeared based on what we see. When I say
- 59:34depending on the industry, some feel that it
- 59:36wasn't any different because she was a woman.
- 59:38She was claiming that's why she ended up having
- 59:40to deal with this. But if it was a man who convinced
- 59:43investors to invest this sum of money for this
- 59:46potential solution that could really stabilize,
- 59:49it'd be a different story. But to your point
- 59:51again, I think that that's what we won't per
- 59:55se know. I think David Boyce could argue convincingly
- 59:58and persuasively. And I think that's why the
- 1:00:00court on the recall claims that you haven't really
- 1:00:02showed true connection in establishing those
- 1:00:05elements to show that, in fact, that was a racketeering
- 1:00:09enterprise that you're claiming. Let's go to
- 1:00:12Nicole's question. She says, how about digital
- 1:00:15sexual abuse via AI and revenge porn? Oh, sure.
- 1:00:20You want to take this one? Yes. Let me read it
- 1:00:24out for anyone else that hasn't seen it. How
- 1:00:26about digital sexual abuse via AI and revenge
- 1:00:29porn? When police department refused investigation,
- 1:00:32when organizations protect the abuser and the
- 1:00:34victim is labeled crazy and her fake deep photos
- 1:00:38and fake revenge porn videos spread all over
- 1:00:40the internet. Please mention the President's
- 1:00:43Take It Down Act that went into effect May 2025.
- 1:00:45Over to you, Victoria. It's interesting because
- 1:00:48I remember with the organization RAINN, who's
- 1:00:51a very big advocate of victims of sexual assault
- 1:00:55and abuse, when I was asking them to vet my bill
- 1:00:58in 2022, an early draft of it, they had asked
- 1:01:02me, what do you think about revenge porn? How
- 1:01:04would you go about fixing this? I said, maybe
- 1:01:09say copyright that you participate in so you
- 1:01:13have rights. I said, but you're probably just
- 1:01:14going to have to just write a bill. So they did.
- 1:01:17They ended up working with other people to get
- 1:01:20this built. past. What it does is you can now
- 1:01:25go to different social media platforms that have
- 1:01:28posted any revenge porn or AI porn, and they
- 1:01:31have 48 hours to take it down. They also have
- 1:01:35federal penalties for anyone who has done this,
- 1:01:38which is you could be put in jail for two years,
- 1:01:41and if it's a child, three years, and it's the
- 1:01:44FTC that is the one who enforces this. Thank
- 1:01:47you. I'll now chime in from Josh and Netta, and
- 1:01:50then we'll wrap it up with our next question.
- 1:01:53I'll follow up on that. Not so much on the AI,
- 1:01:56but I do maintain a niche practice in digital
- 1:02:00voyeurism. Obviously, our terms are changing
- 1:02:06all that. I think it's non -consensual sharing
- 1:02:08of private imagery as opposed to revenge born,
- 1:02:11whatever the term is. Critically, one thing that
- 1:02:15I think people overlook, and it's not a claim
- 1:02:17that's often held, but the Violence Against Women
- 1:02:21Reauthorization Act of 2022 actually set statutory
- 1:02:26damages of $150 ,000 per image for the distribution
- 1:02:33of non -consensual private imagery. So your ex
- 1:02:37-boyfriend goes out and sends three pictures
- 1:02:40that were meant for your ex -boyfriend at the
- 1:02:42time because you split $450 ,000. Does he have
- 1:02:46it? I don't know. That being said, did I have
- 1:02:50a case against a hotel chain recently where a
- 1:02:54nasty boyfriend sent private pictures of his
- 1:02:56girlfriend to the boss and then the boss forwarded
- 1:02:59them to another person in the company? and ultimately
- 1:03:04put his hotel on the hook for transmission of
- 1:03:07private imagery at $150 ,000 a pop? Yes, it did.
- 1:03:12There's an argument that the posting of those
- 1:03:17images, for example, to any cloud -based sharing
- 1:03:22site is the sharing of the imagery, and the movement
- 1:03:26of those images by any cloud -based server is
- 1:03:30the sharing of the imagery. So the law is very
- 1:03:34much developing in that area, but the Violence
- 1:03:37Against Women Act of 2022 actually did quite
- 1:03:40a bit for civil victims of revenge porn. That
- 1:03:43is so interesting when you talk about the sharing
- 1:03:46through the cloud, because down the line, you
- 1:03:48could see potential liability pulling in the
- 1:03:50tech companies. So that's fascinating. They continue
- 1:03:53to go under the Communications Distancy Section
- 1:03:56230 Act kind of situation. OK, so let's close
- 1:03:59it out. Yeah, from the 90s. Yeah, right? Before
- 1:04:02the internet was the internet, but who are we?
- 1:04:04Okay, thank you so much for that. Let's answer
- 1:04:08Annette's final question. She says, could anyone
- 1:04:11explain why McGowan could not find substitute
- 1:04:14counsel? Seems like she had a very strong case.
- 1:04:16I'll let my colleagues start off and then I'll
- 1:04:18close it out since I brought up that case. Anyone?
- 1:04:22OK, then let me go since I delved into it. You
- 1:04:27know, that's a fascinating question. I was also
- 1:04:30curious as I researched it why they even, you
- 1:04:32know, we drew in the first place because I couldn't
- 1:04:34necessarily find any information about it. It
- 1:04:37does appear that she has a pretty strong case.
- 1:04:41Usually, I mean, the finances involved in litigation,
- 1:04:44as we already know, is just humongous. And with
- 1:04:48such, you know, such detailed pleading and the
- 1:04:53factual statement, it seemed like her attorneys
- 1:04:55were very invested in the first place. When you
- 1:04:58now lose those attorneys, sometimes it's very
- 1:05:01hard to find another one to take on your matter,
- 1:05:03especially if you don't have a budget for it.
- 1:05:05And if you're going against very, very powerful
- 1:05:08people who will bombard you in the discovery
- 1:05:11process with all kinds of paperwork and, and
- 1:05:15really try to just make your life miserable.
- 1:05:18I would also add that It's one thing to go against
- 1:05:21Weinstein, but then you also want you're now
- 1:05:24adding law firms to it where their reputation
- 1:05:26matters their license matters It's definitely
- 1:05:30an uphill battle. So I'm thinking, I don't know
- 1:05:34that it's really from a reality of just a budget
- 1:05:37issue on the part of the plaintiff. And secondly,
- 1:05:41on the part of the defendants taking on the business,
- 1:05:44right? You're not going to run your law firm
- 1:05:45out of business just because you're trying to
- 1:05:47represent one client. And it doesn't matter the
- 1:05:49size. Sometimes even the larger the size of the
- 1:05:52firm, the more expenses you deal with plus media
- 1:05:56scrutiny, et cetera. So I think I'm guessing
- 1:05:58from a practical standpoint, budget issue both
- 1:06:01on our end and then potential counsel looking
- 1:06:03at the cost benefit and just say, no, it's not
- 1:06:05worth getting entangled in all of that. With
- 1:06:08that, we conclude this wonderful panel. I would
- 1:06:11say to my knowledge, and I've attended a lot
- 1:06:13of panels, within and outside of BHBA. I think
- 1:06:17this is the first I've ever seen in the industry
- 1:06:19and I've been in the industry now for about 30
- 1:06:21years that I've ever seen anything on this topic.
- 1:06:25I want to Thank Netta and the entire BHBA litigation
- 1:06:30section, Rachel included, myself included, as
- 1:06:34we came up with this to say, you know what, let's
- 1:06:36start changing this narrative. Thank you to our
- 1:06:38entertainment and fashion colleagues also that
- 1:06:41are joining on this. And we really appreciate
- 1:06:43you. Thank you, Josh, Victoria, Netta. Everybody
- 1:06:45was excellent. Until next time, we'll see you
- 1:06:48and thank you so much for joining us. Meeting
- 1:06:51is over. Thank you.