Latest / Why the Mongol Empire Split Apart So Quickly — Fexingo History / The Mongol Siege of Baghdad and Its Aftermath
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about the Mongol Empire's collapse from the inside — the succession crises, the tax reforms, the religious shifts. But there's one event that stands out as both a high point of Mongol power and a crack in the foundation: the siege of Baghdad in 1258. Luna: That's the one where they ended the Abbasid Caliphate, right? Lucas: Exactly. Hulegu Khan, grandson of Chinggis, led the invasion that brought down the caliphate and smashed the cultural heart of the Islamic Golden Age. And it's often seen as a triumph, but it also fueled the resentment that split the empire wide open. Lucas: So let's set the stage. In the 1250s, the Mongols had already conquered most of Persia and were pushing west. Hulegu was tasked by Möngke Khan with dealing with the remaining Muslim powers, especially the Abbasid Caliphate, which was a shadow of its former self but still held symbolic authority across the Sunni world. Luna: Right, the caliph in Baghdad was still seen as the leader of Sunni Islam. Lucas: Yes, and Hulegu was determined to crush that authority. He assembled a massive army, including Chinese siege engineers with their trebuchets and gunpowder weapons, and he made alliances with local Christian and Shia leaders who were hostile to the Sunni caliph. One of those allies was Nasir al-Din al-Tusi, the famous Shia scholar and astronomer, who served as Hulegu's vizier and helped with the siege. Luna: Interesting — so the Mongols used local divisions to their advantage. Lucas: Absolutely. And for the siege itself, the Mongols surrounded Baghdad in January 1258. The caliph, al-Musta'sim, was a weak ruler, more interested in his books and his harem than in defense. He made a series of blunders — underestimating the Mongol threat, failing to mobilize his army, and even refusing to submit when Hulegu offered terms. Lucas: The city fell within a couple of weeks. The Mongols breached the walls and then carried out a massive massacre. The official histories say perhaps 80,000 people died; later chroniclers talked about the Tigris running black with ink from all the manuscripts thrown into the water. The destruction of the House of Wisdom and all its libraries is one of the great cultural catastrophes of the medieval world. Luna: Wow. And what happened to the caliph? Lucas: There are different stories. Some say he was wrapped in a carpet and trampled to death by horses, because shedding royal blood would bring bad luck. Others say he was starved to death with his treasures. The Mongols themselves didn't boast about it. But the caliphate was gone, and that created a power vacuum in the Islamic world. Lucas: Now, here's where it gets interesting for our broader story. Hulegu was a Toluid — grandson of Tolui, brother of Möngke and Khubilai. A few years after Baghdad, his cousin Berke, who ruled the Golden Horde in the north, had converted to Islam and was furious about the sack of the caliphate. Berke's anger set off the first major war between Mongol khanates. Luna: So the Baghdad conquest basically alienated the Muslim Mongols. Lucas: Exactly. That, and the fact that Hulegu didn't share the spoils or the territory with the Jochids, who saw themselves as rightful heirs to the western conquests. So the siege of Baghdad deepened the Jochid-Toluid rift and eventually led to the Toluid Civil War between Hulegu and Berke's armies. Lucas: But there's a really important counterfactual here. If Hulegu had not turned back after Baghdad to handle matters in the east, he might have pushed all the way into Egypt and destroyed the Mamluks. Instead, he took most of his army back, leaving a smaller force under Kitbuqa, who was defeated at Ayn Jalut in 1260. That victory made the Mamluks the first people to stop a Mongol advance, and it probably saved the Islamic world from full conquest. Luna: That's a huge 'what if'. Lucas: It is. And the aftermath of Baghdad also shows how the Mongols treated their conquests. Hulegu set up the Ilkhanate, which ruled over Persia and Iraq for nearly a century, but it was always distant from the Yuan court in China. And while Hulegu himself was a shamanist, his successors gradually adopted Islam, partly to gain legitimacy among their subjects. Ghazan Khan, who converted in 1295, even tried to repair relations with the Mamluks, but the damage was done. Lucas: So when we think about why the Mongol Empire split apart, the siege of Baghdad is a perfect example of how a conquest that looked like a victory actually accelerated the empire's fragmentation. It wasn't just a religious or cultural catastrophe; it was a political turning point that made the unity of the empire nearly impossible. Luna: You know, this episode about Baghdad and its fallout is exactly why I love this show. We get these big events and then we dig into the consequences that ripple for generations. Lucas: And that's why I keep doing it. And honestly, if today's conversation was worth a coffee to you, there's a link to support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It keeps the show ad-free and lets us keep going deep. No pressure at all. Luna: Yeah, we're just glad you're here. Lucas: Now, let's get back to the siege itself, because there's a detail that often gets overlooked: the role of the Shi'a vizier Nasir al-Din al-Tusi. He was one of the greatest scholars of his age — he built the Maragheh Observatory, which became a major center for astronomy. But he also advised Hulegu during the siege, and some later sources accused him of persuading the Mongols to destroy the caliphate because of his own sectarian grievances. Luna: So he used the Mongols to settle an old score? Lucas: Possibly. But it's also worth noting that al-Tusi likely saved many scholars and texts by encouraging Hulegu to spare certain libraries. So his legacy is mixed. And then there's the question of the caliph's death — we have to be careful with the stories. Ibn al-Athir, who wrote just a generation before, gives a very different account of the Mongols' cruelty than Rashid al-Din, who was writing under the Ilkhans and had his own agenda. So we have to weigh those sources carefully. Lucas: One thing that's sometimes lost is that the Mongols didn't just destroy — they also built. Hulegu founded a new capital at Maragheh and later at Tabriz, and he surrounded himself with scholars and artists. So the Ilkhanate became a patron of Persian culture, even as it was built on the ruins of Baghdad. That paradox is part of the story of the Mongol Empire's fragmentation. Luna: I hadn't thought of it that way. They built new centers of learning, but on top of ash. Lucas: Exactly. And that's part of why the Mongols are still so debated. Some see them as mindless destroyers; others point to the cultural exchanges they fostered. The truth is somewhere in between, but the destruction of Baghdad was undeniable. It ended the Abbasid line and shifted the center of Islamic learning eastward to places like Tabriz and later to the Ottoman capital, Istanbul. Lucas: So next time you think about the Mongol Empire breaking apart, remember that it wasn't just about succession disputes or religious differences. It was also about a single, brutal siege that changed the course of history and deepened the divisions that already existed. The empire didn't collapse in one day, but moments like Baghdad made it inevitable. Luna: Thanks for diving into this with me, Lucas. It really puts the empire's fall into perspective. Lucas: Always a pleasure. And to our listeners, if you want more on this, we'll be looking at the Mamluks next time, and how they held the line against the Mongols. Until then, keep exploring.