Latest / Partnered with a Survivor: David Mandel and Ruth Reymundo Mandel / Season 7 Episode 6: Domestic Abuse in Queer Relationships
Transcript
- 0:16Ruth Reymundo: And we're back.
- 0:17David Mandel: And we're back.
- 0:17David Mandel: Hello.
- 0:18David Mandel: Good morning.
- 0:19David Mandel: Good afternoon.
- 0:20Ruth Reymundo: Good afternoon on this blustery, blizzardy day.
- 0:23David Mandel: Yeah.
- 0:24Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 0:24David Mandel: How are you feeling here in cold, snowy, New England?
- 0:28Ruth Reymundo: It's quite beautiful.
- 0:29Ruth Reymundo: And I've got the birds of Northern California.
- 0:30Ruth Reymundo: And the birds are like the birds are very grateful to me because everything is covered in snow.
- 0:35Ruth Reymundo: So they seem pretty happy.
- 0:37Ruth Reymundo: But I am Ruth Reymundo of the Safe and Together Institute and Safety Nexus.
- 0:41Ruth Reymundo: And who are you into?
- 0:43David Mandel: Dave Mandel of all those things as well.
- 0:45David Mandel: And you're listening to Partner with Survivor.
- 0:47David Mandel: And welcome back to the show, which very excited about.
- 0:51David Mandel: But before we even dive into that, two things.
- 0:52David Mandel: One is if you're listening and a regular listener, and I'm going to make a request.
- 0:57David Mandel: If you haven't shared this with somebody and you really like the show, if you don't like the show, why are you listening?
- 1:02David Mandel: Why are you listening?
- 1:03David Mandel: Why are you listening?
- 1:04David Mandel: But it you know, but it assuming that, assuming that he's worried about my wires.
- 1:11Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, he's he's tending to the wires.
- 1:13David Mandel: That's right.
- 1:13David Mandel: I'm the tech support.
- 1:14David Mandel: So if you you're listening to the the show and you like it and you haven't shared it with somebody, please share it with somebody.
- 1:20David Mandel: Yeah.
- 1:21David Mandel: If you haven't thought about using it for professional development, you know, think about that because we know that's what's being done around the world.
- 1:26David Mandel: If you haven't written a review, uh we don't do this very often.
- 1:29David Mandel: I don't make these direct requests, but it's you know, it's really love it.
- 1:32David Mandel: If you're on a platform, Apple Music or Spotify or somewhere else, and you can write a review, write a review because that means more people will listen.
- 1:38Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 1:39David Mandel: And the algorithm will bump it up.
- 1:41David Mandel: If you want to share this on your socials, please do that.
- 1:44David Mandel: But anyway, so but with that, uh, I'll turn over to Ruth to do land acknowledgement.
- 1:49Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 1:50Ruth Reymundo: So we are coming to you from Tunxsiss, Masako, land in the Farmington Valley near the Farmington River.
- 1:58Ruth Reymundo: And it is extremely blizzardy and snowy, and the wind is howling.
- 2:02Ruth Reymundo: And we are acknowledging any indigenous custodians of the land, past, present, and emerging, and that wisdom that that keeps us connected and keeps us in relationship, in healthy relationship with each other.
- 2:20Ruth Reymundo: So that is our land acknowledgement for the day.
- 2:23Ruth Reymundo: And I'm gonna turn it over to you to introduce our guests.
- 2:27David Mandel: Yeah.
- 2:28David Mandel: I am really excited to introduce Luke Martin in a moment, and where we're gonna talk about topics that are, I think, are really critical across communities across the world.
- 2:39David Mandel: Yeah.
- 2:39David Mandel: Male victims, domestic abuse, and queer relationships, same-sex relationships, being the two big ones that we brought Luke on to talk about.
- 2:47David Mandel: Luke has a tremendous amount of experience working with female survivors as a trainer, as an independent victim advocate.
- 2:55David Mandel: But I just want to say this, put this in context, you know, that the safety of the model, while we spend a tremendous amount of time talking about the gendered responses to domestic abuse and men as parents and survivors as mothers, and the model, and we've written about this and talked about it, was designed from the beginning to be one behavioral and look at patterns across different configurations of relationships.
- 3:23David Mandel: Yeah.
- 3:23David Mandel: Very explicitly, including same-sex relationships.
- 3:26David Mandel: And then the other thing is also really because we focus on coercive control as a framework for the patterns, intersectionalities is really central to that.
- 3:37David Mandel: That's one of the things I talk about, which is which is that one of the differences between a physically violent incident-based approach and a course control-based approach, is with physical violence, you're going to be very focused on individual dynamics, injuries, behaviors, you know, sort of and and serious things like lethality and dangerousness and physical harm.
- 3:57David Mandel: But once you kind of become more pattern-based and look at course control and you're focused on entrapment, it really becomes clear that entrapment has so much to do, not just with the behaviors of the individual who chooses to act that way, but also of systems.
- 4:10David Mandel: If I can't trust a system, if a system is dangerous to me because of who I am or what I look like or how I behave or who I love or any of those things, then I'm less likely to reach out.
- 4:24David Mandel: If I think the system is dangerous to my partner, even though they're being abusive to me, I may be less likely to call and help for those systems.
- 4:31David Mandel: I want the violence and abuse to stop, but I don't want them to be harmed by the system or I don't want my children taken away because I'm in a queer relationship.
- 4:40R: Yeah.
- 4:40David Mandel: You think about places like Texas now that are green.
- 4:43Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, totally.
- 4:43David Mandel: You know, parents who are.
- 4:45Ruth Reymundo: I mean, even when I was going through, you know, separation and those custody, I like that was an actual thing.
- 4:51Ruth Reymundo: You know, being out as a queer person could get your children taken away from you if you encountered the wrong divorce mediator or the wrong, you know, lawyer.
- 5:02Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 5:02Ruth Reymundo: So that's a real that's a real thing.
- 5:04Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 5:05David Mandel: So just want to give that for our audience a backdrop.
- 5:07David Mandel: And so with that, I want to welcome Luke Martin onto the show.
- 5:11David Mandel: He's coming to us from the UK.
- 5:12David Mandel: And Luke, welcome to partner with a survivor.
- 5:15David Mandel: Thank you very much for Anthony.
- 5:17Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 5:17Ruth Reymundo: And so, Luke, why don't you tell everybody about yourself a little bit in your own words, and then we'll just kind of dive in.
- 5:24Luke Martin: Yeah, most definitely.
- 5:25Luke Martin: So I'm a trainer consultant on domestic abuse.
- 5:27Luke Martin: Been working in the violence against women and girls sector for 20 years now in various roles.
- 5:33Luke Martin: And I've covered domestic abuse in my law degree and was fascinated because as a very naive law student, I thought, well, why is nobody doing anything about this?
- 5:43Luke Martin: And left university and moved down to work for an organization called the Dean Project, which was one of the first male domestic abuse services in the UK.
- 5:52Luke Martin: So I went from there on to do my master's in law, gender, sexuality, and human rights and focused that specifically on violence against women and girls, crime types, and then went on to work with male and female victims, survivors, and then over to work with children and young people who were growing up in homes where abuse was taking place, and then on to do some work with those who harm or perpetrators, and then have sort of floated about more recently a lot of policy work within that, and most recently have published two recovery programs, one specifically for LGBT UIA or queer survivors, and one for heterosexual male victim survivors, because there was a massive gap in the UK for those client groups.
- 6:38Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, there are massive gaps, and that's so real globally.
- 6:43Ruth Reymundo: So I really thank you for stepping into that space, Luke, because the in that gap uh represents immense danger and immense vulnerability.
- 6:54Ruth Reymundo: So, you know, I'd love to hear a little bit more about what's contributing to those gaps, but also how we can all collaborate to provide better and more appropriate care for populations that often fall outside the binary narrative about domestic abuse and the need for interventions and supports.
- 7:22Ruth Reymundo: So can you can you tell me, can we start a little bit in how the system and the binary narrative is set up in a way that fundamentally challenges appropriate services for LGBTQ and queer people as well?
- 7:39Ruth Reymundo: I really want to hone in on that topic.
- 7:42Luke Martin: Yeah, so I think one of the biggest challenges that we see is that if we're focusing on a binary model, there's a huge amount of invisibility of the queer community.
- 7:51Luke Martin: And I'll probably use queer instead of LGBTQ.
- 7:54Luke Martin: We used LGBTQ in the UK and they use different acronyms in the States, but there's a huge lack of visibility.
- 8:02Luke Martin: And I think one of the biggest challenges that we see is a lack of proportionality in services.
- 8:08Luke Martin: That there's this notion that you're either funding one or the other.
- 8:13Luke Martin: And I see it quite a lot when I look at men's services more generally, that if we're funding support for male victims, then we're taking money away from female victims.
- 8:22Luke Martin: And actually, that that's not commonly the case.
- 8:25Luke Martin: And I think it's very similar when we look at queer people's experiences.
- 8:29Luke Martin: This when we look at our data in the UK, one in three LGBTQ people report experiencing domestic abuse in their lifetime.
- 8:37Luke Martin: A huge amount of that from family members and often as well as intimate partners.
- 8:44Luke Martin: But there isn't those conversations taking place necessarily.
- 8:48Luke Martin: And actually, when we look at familial abuse, that dynamic often looks very different to intimate partner abuse and is much easier to hide.
- 8:56Luke Martin: Um we've seen a bit of a shift in the UK recently with lots more conversations around banning of conversion practices and conversion
- 9:05Speaker: therapy.
- 9:05Speaker: We've got governments that have been promising to ban conversion practices for decades, and they're still very much there.
- 9:13Ruth Reymundo: So I I I wanna I want to kind of hone in on this because I think that there are people who will have a hard time understanding how that familial abuse, which often manifests early in life for queer people, and the child maltreatment study in Australia really showed this devastating fact that children who identify as being queer or who may also have other differences like gender diverse gender diversity, or they are also you know neurodivergent, they're not they're not that binary, that they experience some of the highest rates of child maltreatment, child sexual abuse, and child abuse, and that that actually increases exponentially when that child is a girl.
- 10:11Ruth Reymundo: And so you can guarantee that if a child has different identity or they are queer or they are non-binary, that there's probably a high likelihood that they are experiencing some form of child maltreatment.
- 10:26Ruth Reymundo: And that child maltreatment then sets that child up for life for the vulnerability of intimate partner violence.
- 10:34Ruth Reymundo: So they are not non-related, though our services and the way that we assess these things are often not linked together.
- 10:43Ruth Reymundo: So that's what I wanted to kind of show you just in your narrative, Luke, that some people won't see those two things as being linked, but they are very deeply linked.
- 10:54Ruth Reymundo: I don't know if you have some thought about that, David, because that's yeah.
- 10:59David Mandel: No, I would love, you know, Luke to talk because we're often talking on the show about about partner violence, we're often talking it to child maltreatment.
- 11:06David Mandel: And I'd love you to talk about that, that aspect of familial abuse.
- 11:12David Mandel: Because I think it is such a tough spot and doesn't get enough attention.
- 11:16David Mandel: So can you discuss that a little bit?
- 11:18Luke Martin: Yeah, most definitely.
- 11:19Luke Martin: So I think one of the biggest challenges that I see is effectively privilege that comes into play with this.
- 11:26Luke Martin: And as a heterosexual, cisgender person, you hold more privilege and anything else being perceived as less than.
- 11:33Luke Martin: So what we'll often see with parents is this notion that their children are less than because they are queer, and whether that's in their sexual orientation, their gender identity, or both.
- 11:43Luke Martin: And actually, what comes with that is the vulnerability.
- 11:46Luke Martin: And we know all of this from all the research that we have on experiences of trauma, that if you're experiencing harm in the home, actually we're likely to see somebody use predatory behavior to be able to identify that and monopolize on that and then use harmful behaviours towards you in your intimate relationship.
- 12:05Luke Martin: And actually, if you're experiencing modelling of harmful behavior growing up, it may not seem so uncomfortable.
- 12:14Luke Martin: It may feel that something's something that's very normal for you when you go into an intimate relationship and you're also experiencing that harm.
- 12:22Luke Martin: So I think the challenges are really around parents not feeling able to recognize experiences of queer identity.
- 12:31Luke Martin: We quite often see children sort of ostracized.
- 12:35Luke Martin: Again, we we see lots of conversation in the UK at the moment and thinking about the comment on sexual harm.
- 12:42Luke Martin: We work with lots of clients who have experienced things like collective rape, corrective rape to try and alter their sexual orientation
- 12:50Speaker: or gender identity and how some of this is somewhat normalized, and especially when it's not being criminalized or banned in the UK.
- 12:58Ruth Reymundo: So I just want to I'm I'm gonna put a little pin in this because this is a very emotional conversation for me.
- 13:06Ruth Reymundo: I grew up in conversion therapy.
- 13:08Ruth Reymundo: I witnessed violence against gay people as a tactic.
- 13:12Ruth Reymundo: It's a real thing, and a lot of people are extremely unaware of the prevalence of it.
- 13:18Ruth Reymundo: And though that does also occur in homes, right, this is also a system problem because those types of abuses are rarely just limited to a familial setting.
- 13:33Ruth Reymundo: They're often also in other settings like counseling settings, spiritual advisement settings, church settings, you know.
- 13:43Ruth Reymundo: So this is not just an issue of children who are being abused by their parents.
- 13:49Ruth Reymundo: That often leads them directly into an institutional pipeline where then they are made more vulnerable and they are and they are trafficked in a they are their labor is used, they are sexually exploited, and they're predated upon.
- 14:08Ruth Reymundo: So so this in this day and age where we're really starting to become aware of the prevalence of abuse towards vulnerable and racialized and minoritized children, this is really pertinent both to the way that we provide services to those people, how we can make them safe, how we can prevent systems from abusing and exploiting them further, because that is happening.
- 14:44Ruth Reymundo: So I want to I want to pivot a little bit over to this to the system itself, because that's where you work in.
- 14:53Ruth Reymundo: And and I want you to just talk to our listeners about your efforts inside that system to provide this safe, appropriate, and effective care to people from these populations.
- 15:11Luke Martin: Yeah, most certainly.
- 15:12Luke Martin: And there's been such a huge change in the 20 years that I've been doing this work.
- 15:16Luke Martin: We've I would like to think we've come on leaps and bounds in how we support LGBT survivors of domestic abuse.
- 15:24Luke Martin: We think about changes in law and the recognition of LGBTQ people and how that's been more supportive.
- 15:33Luke Martin: When we look at our data around things like reporting in the criminal justice system, we know that for any survivor it's really, really low.
- 15:42Luke Martin: Across the board in the UK, only one in five victims will ever report their experiences to the police.
- 15:47Luke Martin: So what we've seen with regards to systems change is although our criminal justice system, I would suggest, is more knowledgeable now around queer people's experiences, we've got far more frontline offer of support.
- 16:02Luke Martin: So I do lots of work with independent domestic violence advisors who are frontline practitioners here in the UK to upskill them.
- 16:10Luke Martin: We've got some incredible Bion 4 services.
- 16:13Luke Martin: So we've got Gallup, which is our national service worker with LGBTQ survivors.
- 16:19Luke Martin: Um, I'm currently working with Switchboard, which is my local provision.
- 16:23Luke Martin: We've got organizations like Loving Me and Trans Without Abuse, which are specific Bioinforce services for trans and non-binary survivors.
- 16:31Luke Martin: Our shift in offer is massive.
- 16:34Luke Martin: We've got some really incredible recovery provision.
- 16:38Luke Martin: And whether that's for LGBTQ, whether that's specifically for trans and non-binary people, it just wasn't there 20 years ago.
- 16:46Luke Martin: It was perceived as something that happened behind closed doors, and it's because it was two people of the same gender that there wasn't a power imbalance.
- 16:54Luke Martin: And we've recognized now that actually we need to explore this a little bit more.
- 16:59Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, that's the key, is that we've really placed that power imbalance inside a specific gender.
- 17:05Ruth Reymundo: And in in same-sex relationships and in gender career relationships, it is so much more about the pattern of behavior, the dominance thinking, the entitlement thinking, and that the behavioral reactivity and violence, oftentimes born out of trauma, right?
- 17:23Ruth Reymundo: That that we can all point to that as having empathy for that while also being very clear that those behaviors are unacceptable in intimate partnership and in consensual relationships.
- 17:36Ruth Reymundo: So, you know, I I I I want to kind of land in some of that because there's some real confusion when it comes to assessing same-sex relationships.
- 17:49Ruth Reymundo: But also I just want to, I wanna I want to throw out a couple of statistics that that I feel are really important for this framing.
- 17:57Ruth Reymundo: Because we do know, and and and you know, maybe you have further information that you want to share with people, that transgender and bisexual people experience some of the highest rates of intimate partner violence because they're experiencing violence often from both genders.
- 18:19Ruth Reymundo: That's a real thing.
- 18:21Ruth Reymundo: Intimate partner violence in female, same-sex relationships, coercive control is a real thing.
- 18:28Ruth Reymundo: And what's kind of scary is that I've seen recently some conservative groups trying to use the statistics about that type of violence to argue that same-sex people are just just as violent as heterosexual men as a way to dismiss the narrative that men's violence is a prevalent problem.
- 18:51Ruth Reymundo: So I don't know if if you want to kind of dive into the the nut of that conversation.
- 18:56Ruth Reymundo: And I think David may have some things to say about the pattern itself and the behavior, but yeah.
- 19:01David Mandel: But I'd love to hear from Luke first.
- 19:02David Mandel: Yeah.
- 19:03Luke Martin: Yeah.
- 19:04Luke Martin: So I think by women, especially hugely invisible in services.
- 19:09Luke Martin: I think they're hugely invisible with regards to support that's available.
- 19:13Luke Martin: And I remember speaking to a survivor on one of the recovery programs that I was running, who had said that she had previously had a relationship with a man that had been hugely violent.
- 19:23Luke Martin: She was now in a relationship with a woman and that had also been violent.
- 19:27Luke Martin: And she had said, I went to a local women's service and they put me on a recovery program, but all they talked about was him as harmful and her as the victim.
- 19:36Luke Martin: And it just didn't gel with my identity.
- 19:39Luke Martin: And I had to keep correcting the facilitators and saying that's not my experience.
- 19:43Luke Martin: And I think that arras was huge in people's recovery, when you've got to try and reinsert yourself into the narrative.
- 19:51Luke Martin: It's really harmful when actually, when she came on to a queer inclusive program, what she found was she didn't have to explain her identity.
- 19:59Luke Martin: And I think when we look at by women's experiences and by men's, I guess in that as well, often there's an assumption around the gender somebody's presenting as and the gender they talk about their partner as.
- 20:12Luke Martin: So I've worked with lots of women who have presented as female and talked about their male partner, and people have just assumed that they were heterosexual rather than asking them.
- 20:21Luke Martin: And it's a huge challenge because it just shuts down an offer of support, and actually you can't bring your whole identity to that space.
- 20:28David Mandel: Yeah.
- 20:28David Mandel: It reminds me, I haven't thought about this in for ages.
- 20:31David Mandel: You know, when I started doing men's behavior change work, we had some, you know, this was for people who were arrested, and we were running same-sex groups for men.
- 20:42David Mandel: And occasionally we'd have men come in who usually pulled me aside or was in the paperwork that said that they were in a same-sex relationship.
- 20:52David Mandel: And we would give them the option, and I feel really mixed about this, looking back on it now.
- 21:01David Mandel: I think I felt mixed about it at the time, saying you're here, you're court-ordered to be here.
- 21:06David Mandel: You don't need to out yourself.
- 21:08David Mandel: If you want to refer to your partner as female, and that's and you want to do that, that's uh we're we'll support you and keep that.
- 21:14David Mandel: You know, and it's it was an imperfect solution.
- 21:18David Mandel: Prioritizing safety, there wasn't, you know, and but giving them the choice to say this you can you can get something from this.
- 21:25David Mandel: You're ordered by the court to be here, but we don't want to put you in danger, you know, from the other other people in the group who have a history of violence, who, you know, who you don't know.
- 21:36David Mandel: And looking back now, also what we know about uh men using violence, they're more likely to have very rigid gender role expectations, right?
- 21:44David Mandel: And around that goes out to sexual orientation.
- 21:48David Mandel: So it you know, I you know, that was one of my early experiences with that on the other side, which was sort of navigating or or or or being asked by systems to create a screening.
- 21:59David Mandel: Tools in systems that weren't sophisticated already about same-sex relationships.
- 22:06David Mandel: And we're missing, you know, the majority of the cases that they just number wise would be heterosexual relationships, male perpetrators, and female victims.
- 22:14David Mandel: So they really weren't set up to sort of do both ends, say this is the biggest chunk, and we need to be nuanced here.
- 22:22David Mandel: So we were pushing gender neutral language at that point, but I felt it was going to push into a gender symmetry issue in in heterosexual couples that wasn't, you know.
- 22:36David Mandel: So I think there's interesting navigations because the system is not and culturally we're not set up this way.
- 22:43Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 22:44David Mandel: What I do want to go back to, if if you don't mind, Ruth, and and Luke, you don't mind going back to is I really would love to tease out.
- 22:50David Mandel: You're talking about the systems and the differences and the, you know.
- 22:54David Mandel: Look, if you can tease out a little bit, you know, some of the course of control, patterns of course of control are the nature of this history, whether it's same-sex relationship, queer relationship, no matter the gender identities, you know, of the folks who are involved on any side.
- 23:12David Mandel: And there's there's there are differences.
- 23:16David Mandel: And I'm thinking about queer people who come from homophobic, maybe religious homophobic background, who can't go back to their family.
- 23:26David Mandel: Don't feel like I'm being victimized here.
- 23:29David Mandel: And I I I I fell I came out, I fell in love with my partner, same sex.
- 23:33David Mandel: It was a huge risk with my family.
- 23:35David Mandel: I, you know, I thought for my identity.
- 23:38David Mandel: And now, and they've been telling me I'm broken and my family's told me I'm broken that's something wrong with me.
- 23:43Ruth Reymundo: Or my family's dangerous.
- 23:44David Mandel: Or they're dangerous, right?
- 23:45David Mandel: I mean, that's dangerous.
- 23:46David Mandel: And and now I'm being abused by my partner.
- 23:48David Mandel: How do I go back to I can't go back, like I don't feel safe going back to my family.
- 23:52David Mandel: So there are distinct dynamics, at least.
- 23:55David Mandel: I won't say difference, dynamics, both on the side of entrapment and also, but also unique strengths.
- 24:01David Mandel: If I don't go to my family, I don't feel safe calling the police, I am doing things to manage my safety.
- 24:06David Mandel: So can you talk about both what's what you notice is unique on the entrapment side and also on the strength side?
- 24:14Luke Martin: Yeah, so I think isolation is huge when I work with queer survivors.
- 24:19Luke Martin: And even if they do have a good relationship with their family, they've often moved to somewhere that's more inclusive.
- 24:25Luke Martin: So it's either a train or a plane or something to be able to get back to that place of safety.
- 24:31Luke Martin: And actually, those sort of check-ins aren't necessarily happening.
- 24:35Luke Martin: I'm, I mean, I I know it's different in the UK.
- 24:38Luke Martin: We're much smaller, but I'm sort of three hours and a boat away from my parents.
- 24:42Luke Martin: If I were in crisis, it would be really difficult for me to physically get there.
- 24:46Luke Martin: And actually, the size of the states, you've got clusters of queer people that are going to move to your bigger cities where there's a bigger network.
- 24:55Luke Martin: There's also this misconception that queer communities are huge.
- 24:59Luke Martin: And actually, what we see with survivors and their partners is that often they're sharing in a friendship group.
- 25:06Luke Martin: So not only do they then lose the support of their family potentially, but they also have this chosen family that often you've got a perpetrator saying, if you end the relationship, they're not going to want to talk to you.
- 25:18Luke Martin: They were my friends first, or you're going to have to move somewhere else and isolate yourself further because nobody in this town city is going to want to be there for you.
- 25:28Luke Martin: So I think that's really challenging.
- 25:30Luke Martin: And I think we see it especially with trans and non-binary survivors as well, that actually you these communities get smaller and smaller and smaller.
- 25:39Luke Martin: And then when you look at trans people, that division between trans men and trans women, and actually you're looking at tiny numbers of people that if that relationship ends, how easy it is for someone using harm to isolate that person further ostracize them from a community.
- 25:57Ruth Reymundo: And this really puts into context suicide in queer communities because of the dislocation and isolation, lack of support, lack of safe housing.
- 26:12Ruth Reymundo: Often a tremendous amount of financial vulnerability as well.
- 26:17Ruth Reymundo: If you are if you so I'm gonna, I'm gonna I'm gonna I'm gonna just say I think of it as you know, the the the queers who've got their family and their roots and their community, and then there's the rest of us, you know, and that's a very very vulnerable position to be in if you're a person who has none of that and has had to fully relocate themselves to a different country sometimes for safety, yeah, or to a different region or area just to be able to live freely and mostly safely as you are.
- 26:55Luke Martin: And that's I guess on that what we think about is access to resource.
- 26:59Luke Martin: Actually, I've got a really supportive family, they were really supportive when I came out, but actually what that meant was that I felt safe to go off for further education and was supported in accessing university.
- 27:10Luke Martin: A majority, well, a quarter of homeless people in the UK under the age of 25 are LGBTQ people.
- 27:20Luke Martin: So we've got a hugely disproportionate number of young people who have been kicked out of home or not felt safe at home.
- 27:27Luke Martin: And then what that impacts is their access to education, which then impacts their employment opportunities.
- 27:34Luke Martin: And actually, we've got this really polarized uh, I guess, a disparity of wealth within the queer community, that we've got a number of people that have got access to a huge amount of resource, and then the other end those that most certainly don't.
- 27:48Luke Martin: And actually, I see that in services because if you're working full-time and you've got access to resource, you're far less likely to access the charities that I work with because they offer support Monday to Friday, nine to five.
- 28:01Luke Martin: If that's your working hours, it's not going to be suitable.
- 28:04Luke Martin: But actually, I see lots of queer people that are accessing private therapy and things like that because they've got the finances to do so.
- 28:12Luke Martin: But also that impacts, as you say, things like housing provision and access to we've got a handful of LGBTQ specific refuges in the UK, but it's not representative of how many queer people are experiencing domestic abuse.
- 28:28Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 28:29Luke Martin: Yeah.
- 28:29Luke Martin: So there's some real challenges around that.
- 28:31Ruth Reymundo: So you never got to the strengths part I'm aware of, and I want to hear strengths because that's really important.
- 28:36David Mandel: Yeah.
- 28:36David Mandel: Yeah.
- 28:37David Mandel: Yeah.
- 28:37David Mandel: I would love, I'd love to help professionals know, because I think a lot of times they judge people who won't.
- 28:44David Mandel: And I'll say this and kind of flip it over to you.
- 28:46David Mandel: Because actually I'm sitting here with a little bit of vibration going on.
- 28:49David Mandel: Because I I want to say to my colleagues, as I'm listening to this conversation and participating in it, you know, which is just how much the domestic violence community can sort of ignore these things that we're talking about, sort of family, identity, connection, community, place, and sort of insist on these ideas of separation, equal safety, call the police and and have this very myopic, limited view of safety and what is important to people.
- 29:21David Mandel: And, you know, and I've worked on cases like this where people are like, you know, no, that my identity as being queer is who I am.
- 29:32David Mandel: And I I won't lose that.
- 29:34David Mandel: I won't have that taken away from me.
- 29:35David Mandel: And so yeah, I'm willing to stay with it and be supportive.
- 29:38David Mandel: I feel like people are going to try to define me away from that or tell me there's something wrong with that.
- 29:41David Mandel: And just so, or I know I'll lose my community.
- 29:44David Mandel: And I think people kind of like they dismiss it.
- 29:46David Mandel: I mean, I'm I've seen professionals over my career be like, well, they could die.
- 29:53David Mandel: Well, the the person's experience may be that they're gonna die without their oxygen, without their people, without their community.
- 30:01David Mandel: They're gonna be out there alone, they're gonna be vulnerable, and they'd rather, and I've heard this from survivors of all backgrounds, I'd rather be at risk connected to people I know in places I know that are familiar to me than be alone someplace and feel like I'm not safe.
- 30:16David Mandel: So uh this is a just so this is my little rant about to my professional colleagues, which is don't like, don't collap, don't, don't poo-poo these things.
- 30:25David Mandel: Don't kind of push them off as sort of secondary to your definition of safety.
- 30:30David Mandel: So anyway, I needed to say that.
- 30:32David Mandel: So I thought I was sitting on the page.
- 30:33Ruth Reymundo: Okay, now we're getting to the strength.
- 30:34Ruth Reymundo: So that's not true.
- 30:35David Mandel: But this is the flip side of it, that you know, which is what should people look for?
- 30:39David Mandel: Because you're saying value and see when they're staying connected to community.
- 30:44David Mandel: In fact, they may be staying connected to somebody who's close to both them and the perpetrator.
- 30:50Ruth Reymundo: For a reason.
- 30:51David Mandel: For a reason for lots of reasons, right?
- 30:52David Mandel: But can you tell me if if you were talking to professionals and say this person is actively trying to keep themselves safe, mentally as healed as possible, mentally as together as possible, economically together as possible?
- 31:08David Mandel: What might they miss if they weren't really tuned in?
- 31:12Luke Martin: I think it's the same when we think about any survivor.
- 31:16Luke Martin: Any survivor is has already safety planned for themselves.
- 31:20Luke Martin: They know the risk better than anybody else.
- 31:22Luke Martin: And we need to be having those conversations with the survivor.
- 31:26Luke Martin: What does this look like for you?
- 31:28Luke Martin: Where does that risk sit?
- 31:29Luke Martin: What is it that you're worried about?
- 31:31Luke Martin: And it was interesting, David, when you talk about coercion control earlier and men's experiences, this notion that men don't talk about being afraid.
- 31:41Luke Martin: But what I often see when I'm working with men is this notion of worry.
- 31:44Luke Martin: I'm not afraid that I'm going to be killed.
- 31:46Luke Martin: I'm not afraid that I'm going to be seriously injured, but I'm worried about certain things.
- 31:51Luke Martin: And sometimes that worry is around things like being ostracized from a community.
- 31:55Luke Martin: But actually, often it's when I reflect back when I say, I'd be quite afraid if my partner had done that to me.
- 32:02Luke Martin: And I think there's a sense of safety in that, in having a professional that recognises that what you're experiencing is scary or is abusive.
- 32:11Luke Martin: And actually, what I see when I work with queer clients is often that abuse is dismissed or it's minimized in the risk level.
- 32:20Luke Martin: So being able to name it as something that's harmful, but also drawing out those patterns of behaviour.
- 32:26Luke Martin: I think when I work with queer survivors, it's very incident-led rather than exploring that pattern of behaviour.
- 32:34Luke Martin: And I think that's quite common when I see counter allegations.
- 32:37Luke Martin: So thinking about what professionals need to be more skilled in is identifying that who's doing what to whom, where that power does it, what that pattern of behaviour looks like.
- 32:48Luke Martin: And when we think about, you know, we've got the power threat meaning framework that looks at what have you had to do to stay alive?
- 32:56Luke Martin: And actually, that's often the starting point when we think about career survivors.
- 33:00Luke Martin: What have you had to do to keep you alive, to be able to sit in front of me today and have this conversation around the abuse that you've experienced?
- 33:08Luke Martin: And I think a lot of it's around managing any kind of shock.
- 33:14Luke Martin: That I've worked with lots of clients that have had to do things that are fairly shocking to be able to stay alive.
- 33:22Luke Martin: And whether that's in their relationship, whether it's in wider communities or wider society, actually it's worked for them.
- 33:30Luke Martin: But often what that looks like when it comes into service is complex or compound needs, multiple compound needs for survivors.
- 33:37Luke Martin: So thinking about the importance of that multi-agency work as well, that no single agency should be holding risk.
- 33:45Luke Martin: And actually, when we're thinking about what this looks like, we're thinking about those who harm.
- 33:50Luke Martin: And what we need to reflect on is what's our offer with regards to behavioural change.
- 33:56Luke Martin: Because literally, you know, given the example you've shared, David, that do you have to suppress a part of your identity to be able to engage in behavioural change?
- 34:07Luke Martin: We've got very few LGBTQ behaviour change programs in the UK.
- 34:13Luke Martin: And actually, you know, when what we see is this one size fits all model, and this is the programme that we've got.
- 34:20Luke Martin: Either you come on it and engage with it as best you can, otherwise, you can't have support.
- 34:26Luke Martin: And we see it with women who use harm as well, that actually we don't necessarily have anything bespoke and comes down to intersectionality.
- 34:34Luke Martin: There are so many different parts to somebody's identity.
- 34:37Luke Martin: Which part is their priority?
- 34:39Luke Martin: Is their career this their priority?
- 34:41Luke Martin: Or do they want a service that works with black and brown communities or older people or looks at Eurodiversity or disability?
- 34:49Luke Martin: But you might identify with all of those characteristics, and what do you want from a service?
- 34:55Luke Martin: And we won't know that without speaking to the survivor, speaking to the person using harm, and finding out what's going to be the best fit.
- 35:03Ruth Reymundo: And this is really where partnering is so important.
- 35:07Ruth Reymundo: And, you know, one of the reasons why I was so captured by the Safe and Together model was because of the concept of partnering, which really put squarely back on the responsibility shoulders of the practitioner to be curious, to uncover the needs and the context of the victim, and to meet them in where they were, not overlay onto them their beliefs about how to achieve safety or what the appropriate relationship was for them, but to really listen to that victim survivor and hear what safety meant to them, what relationship means to them, what the patterns of behaviors are that were causing danger and harm and removing liberties.
- 36:05Ruth Reymundo: And and I really want to go back to the fact that there really is no appropriate resource for behavior change for queer women.
- 36:18Ruth Reymundo: There is none really globally.
- 36:22Ruth Reymundo: And and and I I really feel like the roots of that are in our failure to understand power dynamics, live in every relationship, and that women are capable of violence and coercive control.
- 36:38Ruth Reymundo: But also deeply in that is this belief that uh violence out of men is purely a dominance thing instead of a fear thing and a shame thing and a desperation thing to maintain a connection and to have that that glue, that cement with a person.
- 37:05Ruth Reymundo: I I really feel like we would need to get much better at understanding violence and its behaviors and its energies in a way that can acknowledge that it lives in every single body that is human.
- 37:20Ruth Reymundo: It doesn't matter how it's dressed or how it identifies or what its gender expression is or who it loves or what it believes, it lives in every single one of us.
- 37:29David Mandel: So I I would love to explore this, the three of us together for a moment, because I agree with what you just said a thousand percent.
- 37:37David Mandel: And you and I know you think about this a lot because we talk about it sometimes ad nauseum, about men's violence and how it shapes wider society and how it's tied to patriarchy.
- 37:52Ruth Reymundo: Society depends on men's violence.
- 37:54Ruth Reymundo: So there's a difference in that there's a real systemic support for men's violence, not as much for women's violence, but you know, it depends on power and control of the, you know, so yeah, can we talk about this?
- 38:06David Mandel: Luke, I'll be interested in hearing your episode because you just kind of made the nuance I wanted to kind of bring out for the audience, but just sort of you you the first statement was about is about any of us could be, and I believe this, and I've always said this both men and women could be violent.
- 38:19David Mandel: Violence can exist in people in queer relationships, doesn't really, it's a human challenge.
- 38:23David Mandel: And I always say you say control is uh is a human challenge.
- 38:27David Mandel: It's a you how you deal with things you can't control, right?
- 38:30David Mandel: And you just had the other one of the other pieces I wanted to hear, which was there's societal structural support for male violence.
- 38:39David Mandel: For male violence towards anyone.
- 38:41David Mandel: To anyone, man, boys, boys, women, girls.
- 38:44David Mandel: So anyway, so that's so Luke, what do you want to add to that?
- 38:47David Mandel: Because I think you you obviously must spend a lot of time thinking and talking about this.
- 38:51Luke Martin: Yeah, most definitely.
- 38:52Luke Martin: And the reality is we all look for control because it gives us a sense of safety.
- 38:57Luke Martin: And it comes back to again, uh we're moving towards the more trauma-informed work way of working with those who harm.
- 39:04Luke Martin: I think the challenge that we see is that when we see women especially using harm, is it's deemed so different to the norb that we perceive men as sort of strong and physical and emotionless, and women as kind and caring and nurturing.
- 39:22Luke Martin: And when we do see women using harmful behaviours, it sits so far outside of that woman box that it's hugely demonized.
- 39:30Luke Martin: When I look at our convictions in the UK for women who use the same level of violence or harm as a male perpetrator, they're often given much longer sentences because it's seen as so unwomanly.
- 39:43Luke Martin: And actually, that brings in some of the challenges around behavior change when we're working with women and whether they're they're heterosexual or they're queer.
- 39:52Luke Martin: It's something that sits outside of that norm, and people don't feel comfortable with it.
- 39:58Luke Martin: And it's fascinating when I talk about women who have used harm.
- 40:02Luke Martin: Commonly the first question I get asked was, Well, what happened to them?
- 40:06Luke Martin: And I don't get asked that when I'm talking about men who have used harm.
- 40:11Luke Martin: That we often look at almost at whether it's mental health or whether there's trauma, this want to diagnose and almost excuse away women's use of harmful behavior that I don't necessarily see when I'm talking about men's experiences.
- 40:25Luke Martin: And there's a real challenge in that.
- 40:27Luke Martin: I feel like we're moving a little bit more.
- 40:29Luke Martin: Again, it comes back to that notion of well, what happened to you?
- 40:33Luke Martin: And we're seeing that more now with men who are using harmful behavior, and not that it's a justification, but it gives us an understanding as to where somebody's at, and as you say, working with them, where they're at on that sense.
- 40:47Ruth Reymundo: You know, the the only an effective way to really ask that question and not collude with someone is to ask the next question.
- 40:56Ruth Reymundo: And that is, is how is that showing up in your relationships right now?
- 41:02Ruth Reymundo: And what do you need to change?
- 41:05Ruth Reymundo: And are you willing to do it?
- 41:07Ruth Reymundo: Can we support you in doing it?
- 41:10Ruth Reymundo: We cannot support you in doing it if you cannot admit that it's a problem.
- 41:15Ruth Reymundo: You know, so so for me, uh, I'm always as a person who's experienced violence from both men and women, and physical injury from both men and women, and sexual harm from both men and women, I can say squarely that it's very dangerous for us to stay in that trauma-based question.
- 41:35Ruth Reymundo: And the assumption behind it is that men are innately violent.
- 41:40Ruth Reymundo: And that women need to be not violent in order to counteract that.
- 41:46Ruth Reymundo: That's our job.
- 41:47Ruth Reymundo: And so we're endlessly locked in this binary violence, not violent.
- 41:52Ruth Reymundo: You're a nurturer, you're a violent, you're violent, that's your function.
- 41:55Ruth Reymundo: And it's terrible because it's not real and it increases the likelihood that people will be violent.
- 42:02Ruth Reymundo: And it is so wrong.
- 42:04Ruth Reymundo: It's so wrong.
- 42:06David Mandel: You know, I'm sitting here, you know, with two thoughts.
- 42:08David Mandel: One is what you're saying, it's sort of like the visibility of domestic abuse in, and I'm saying visibility from both systems in lesbian relationships, and the dismissive and expect expectation of it in men and in men's relationships with each other.
- 42:25David Mandel: And, you know, you hear boys will be boys, you know, and then or miss stereotyping around kink.
- 42:33David Mandel: And then unfortunately, and like these things, we do these conversations, things I haven't thought about in a long time.
- 42:38David Mandel: The horrible example, and I think I'm getting it right.
- 42:41David Mandel: Unfortunately, there's more than one of these, Jeffrey, Jeffrey Dahmer.
- 42:45Ruth Reymundo: Dahmer.
- 42:46David Mandel: Dahmer, you know, one of his last victims, I believe, escaped and was returned to him by the police.
- 42:56David Mandel: Yes.
- 42:57Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 42:57David Mandel: Am I getting this right?
- 42:58Ruth Reymundo: Yes.
- 42:58Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 42:59David Mandel: And the police attitude was this was just, you know, kink, gay men, violent, you know, and and it just I get sick to my stomach with the idea that the police, that this man ran to some to help.
- 43:14David Mandel: And the people who very should have helped him returned him.
- 43:18David Mandel: How horrific to the person who ended up killing him.
- 43:23Ruth Reymundo: And but that's how much the experience of so many people who are not entitled and who live squarely in that vulnerable place, that actually we are returned to our perpetrators often by those systems.
- 43:41Ruth Reymundo: We are forced back into contact with them.
- 43:44Ruth Reymundo: We are sent back to them as children, as adults, that is a real experience.
- 43:49Ruth Reymundo: And this is where the system needs a little mirror to hold up to itself.
- 43:53Ruth Reymundo: And we need to hold that mirror up and we need to demand better.
- 43:56David Mandel: Yeah.
- 43:56David Mandel: That's a real time.
- 43:57David Mandel: So what what what's your experience?
- 43:59David Mandel: With hopefully nothing that extreme.
- 44:02David Mandel: But so that boys will be boys.
- 44:04David Mandel: This is boys, men being violent with each other, just what you expect.
- 44:08David Mandel: It's kink and that, you know, and and so stereotyping about communities.
- 44:12David Mandel: What's your what's your experience about that?
- 44:14David Mandel: And even about the con, you know, people will talk, and I think more openly.
- 44:17David Mandel: This is actually this isn't this whole other topic.
- 44:20David Mandel: Think more openly to its credit.
- 44:22David Mandel: We'll talk more openly about kink and the difference between kink and violence, you know, sort of non-consensual behavior in the queer community.
- 44:31David Mandel: I think that's actually a conversation that was more there than some other places.
- 44:34David Mandel: But can you talk about some of this?
- 44:36David Mandel: Pick pick any one of those threads you want.
- 44:38Luke Martin: Yeah, most definitely.
- 44:40Luke Martin: So thinking about, I'm gonna start at the end and work my way back.
- 44:43Luke Martin: Thinking about what you were saying, Ruth, about being taken back to the people causing you harm and see it loads with the young people that are coming through into services, whether actually it's their parents or siblings or both that are causing harm to them, especially if they're even 18, 19 parental home is considered the safe place for them.
- 45:06Luke Martin: So whether it's housing that are returning them back to their family of origin or whether it's police taking them back there, that it's a huge risk.
- 45:15Luke Martin: Parents often not being perceived as a risk factor for LGBTQ people and that vulnerability that's there.
- 45:23Luke Martin: The other challenge that you see with that return to family is parents contacting services.
- 45:30Luke Martin: My child's missing, do you know where they are?
- 45:32Luke Martin: Have you seen them?
- 45:33Luke Martin: Have they presented to you as homeless?
- 45:36Luke Martin: Plays a huge factor.
- 45:37Luke Martin: Thinking about some of the other elements that you're talking about, David, things like the pink element, especially when we think about men in same-sex relationships.
- 45:48Luke Martin: We've had a huge increase in the use of chem sex in the UK, especially with gay buying men who have sex with men, and the vulnerability of that.
- 45:57Luke Martin: So a lack of understanding around consent.
- 46:01Luke Martin: Our education system is awful in teaching young people what consent is, and this belief that even if you're under the influence, you're able to consent.
- 46:13Luke Martin: And I worked on a case where we had some reports of people who were signing what they perceived to be legally binding contracts on what other people could do to them whilst they were under the influence of these substances, and in some cases, if they were unconscious, and that lack of understanding that if you don't, if you're not able to withdraw your consent, you're not able to consent.
- 46:38Luke Martin: We've had some quite significant changes in the UK recently.
- 46:42Luke Martin: So things like the banning of strangulation in pornography.
- 46:47Luke Martin: We've got our legislation now around non-fatal strangulation, non-fatal suffocation, and it puts an end to the rough sex defense in our criminal cases where there's been a death, but actually it doesn't really go far enough.
- 47:01Luke Martin: The other challenge, as you say, is around that perception of men and masculinity.
- 47:07Luke Martin: What I probably see most is an assumption from professionals that regardless of the gender of the person, the person deemed to be more masculine is automatically assumed to be the perpetrator or the person using harm.
- 47:22Luke Martin: And often it isn't the case, but actually it becomes much easier to frame it that way when we think about a heteronormative model of what domestic abuse looks like.
- 47:31Luke Martin: And I remember working on a case about a decade ago where a professional police officer had said to the victim, You look like the man we're going to arrest you.
- 47:40Luke Martin: And they were both men.
- 47:42Luke Martin: So those assumptions, those biases, whether it's conscious or unconscious, that people hold around this.
- 47:48Ruth Reymundo: Whoa, you know, you just opened up that mask, that mask on the victim pipeline, because that's a real thing.
- 47:56David Mandel: I'm laughing because it's just it's just so ludicrous.
- 47:59David Mandel: And unfortunately, it's easy to imagine at the same time that somebody would do that and say, oh, you look like a man.
- 48:08David Mandel: And uh and again, it goes back to it's terrible.
- 48:10Ruth Reymundo: It's terrible because it the way it shows up in in in in female gay culture is just absolutely terrible.
- 48:17Ruth Reymundo: You know, just that that way of thinking that that just makes people blind to the realities of human behavior is so dangerous, it's so wounding too.
- 48:31Ruth Reymundo: And on a level, you know, what it does is it supports that belief that if you were truly a masculine person, you would never be abused or dominated.
- 48:44Ruth Reymundo: And that is such shame.
- 48:46Ruth Reymundo: That is such loads of bullshit shame, excuse me, uh cranky Latina survivors coming out right now.
- 48:53Ruth Reymundo: Of course, cranky bisexual Latino survivors coming out.
- 48:56David Mandel: I I just it makes me think about going to a workshop where we were years ago, where I was a you know with a group of people where we were exploring sort of masculine and feminine energy, you know, put it that way.
- 49:06David Mandel: And going back to you, this how much built in this expectation of men collapsing of masculinity and man and masculinity, masculine presenting, right?
- 49:17David Mandel: All this stuff with violence.
- 49:20David Mandel: And so people were asked to kind of model movement through what they perceived as masculine energy.
- 49:27David Mandel: And almost everybody to a person stomped around the room.
- 49:30Ruth Reymundo: As a man?
- 49:31David Mandel: Yeah, well, exactly.
- 49:32David Mandel: But there was one guy, and he happened to be gay, and he skipped across the room because we were talking about sort of forward momentum.
- 49:40David Mandel: And and the idea was sort of masculine energy in this case was being framed as sort of how do you, you know, for you know, forward, because the the one extreme of this is this idea of aggression, or you have to be assertive and or, but it can be also exploration or curiosity, let's say.
- 49:54David Mandel: And so ever but almost everybody was like stomping forward across the room.
- 49:58David Mandel: And this one guy was just skipping, and all of us were like, oh my God, we interpreted forward momentum, male forward momentum as angry aggressive.
- 50:07David Mandel: And and I was it it stuck with me.
- 50:11David Mandel: Yeah.
- 50:11David Mandel: I mean, it's another example just coming through all this.
- 50:14David Mandel: I think this theme that sort of this these stereotypes and these expectations of men have such broad and deep implications.
- 50:24David Mandel: You know, it's why we don't reach out to men of any sexual orientation who are perpetrating and saying you can help.
- 50:32David Mandel: It's why we're more kind of kind, quote unquote, to women, more understanding around women who use violence.
- 50:38David Mandel: You know, it's all these things.
- 50:40Ruth Reymundo: It's also why we don't we don't see women who are violent.
- 50:43Ruth Reymundo: It's also why we work so hard to push away the the different variations of violence that don't show up in the the really rigid way we've talked about, you know, through services or through funding, right, right, pathways or through service delivery.
- 51:03Ruth Reymundo: You know, I feel like we could talk forever with you, Luke.
- 51:07Ruth Reymundo: Seriously.
- 51:08Ruth Reymundo: I'm very grateful for this conversation.
- 51:10Ruth Reymundo: I really hope our listeners are learning a lot.
- 51:14Ruth Reymundo: And and, you know, there's one more challenge that I would really love to bring up, and that is that a lot of people assume that queer people know exactly how their own identities show up and are comfortable reaching out via their identity for services.
- 51:37Ruth Reymundo: And that's not actually real.
- 51:40Ruth Reymundo: A lot of people who have diverse identities and sexuality are still very much frightened, don't have the language to describe their own experience, or are resistant to using that language because it feels dangerous.
- 51:59Ruth Reymundo: And so, how do you support people who are deeply vulnerable in that way and may not even have their own ability to articulate their relationship of what's happening?
- 52:14Ruth Reymundo: Perhaps that relationship is secret because they're still living in a community where they have to be closeted deeply and they don't use the same language as services.
- 52:24Ruth Reymundo: They're not as comfortable describing their identity, but they are in same-sex relationships.
- 52:32Ruth Reymundo: Can you talk a little bit about that?
- 52:34Luke Martin: Yeah, so I think the the simplest thing to do is to ask somebody, how do you describe?
- 52:39Luke Martin: How do you describe your relationship?
- 52:41Luke Martin: How do you describe your gender?
- 52:42Luke Martin: How do you describe your sexual orientation?
- 52:44Luke Martin: And actually, we know the reality is people might not feel able to answer those questions.
- 52:50Luke Martin: But if you're proposing that as a question, you're instantly signifying this is a safe space.
- 52:57Luke Martin: I know that you might identify as something other than heterosexual, I know that you might be in a relationship with somebody of the same gender, or you might identify as non-binary.
- 53:06Luke Martin: But it's continuing to ask that question.
- 53:10Luke Martin: We think about sort of routine questioning.
- 53:12Luke Martin: If we can just say to somebody, I'm just going to check.
- 53:15Luke Martin: Last time we met, you said you weren't sure how you described your sexual orientation.
- 53:21Luke Martin: And that's okay, but I just want to check if you've had any more thoughts on that or if you'd like to explore that a little bit more.
- 53:26Luke Martin: Again, in the UK, we've been talking about men who have sex with men, and it's a really sort of sexual health model way of working, that we work with lots of men who identify as heterosexual straight, but are having sexual relationships with men to the point where we've just categorized it as something else.
- 53:45Luke Martin: And actually, because we need to be considerate of it when we're thinking about sexual health, it started to sort of seep into other areas of society.
- 53:54Luke Martin: And actually, that self-identifying is huge.
- 53:57Luke Martin: How would you describe it?
- 53:59Luke Martin: How would you describe your partner?
- 54:00Luke Martin: That it's the flexibility in that.
- 54:05Luke Martin: And I guess that validating, am I right in saying?
- 54:09Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 54:09Luke Martin: Am I right in defining this for you?
- 54:12Luke Martin: Because quite often we make these assumptions where we assume what somebody's gender is or their sexual orientation, and then we try and impose what we know onto somebody else rather than giving them the space to explore that themselves.
- 54:24Ruth Reymundo: And I just want to say that it's really important for people to have that curiosity and that open door because it may be that the person who is abusing that person is coercing them and that person is closeted, or they may identify as heterosexual.
- 54:45Ruth Reymundo: And you need to be able to hear that information in a different way in order to identify things like coercion, blackmail, and stalking.
- 54:55David Mandel: Right.
- 54:55David Mandel: These are real vulnerabilities.
- 54:57David Mandel: We're also identifying and mapping vulnerabilities in an intersectional lens that can be really, you know, specific versions of course of control.
- 55:05David Mandel: You know, you're you're not real.
- 55:07David Mandel: I mean, the statement, you're not really, is can be filled in with you're not really black, you're not really this, you're not really this, you're really gay, you're not really black, you're not really, you know, and it's a way to one-up somebody and say, I get to define you.
- 55:20David Mandel: And and the truth is, unfortunately, we see that behavior in professionals as well as perpetrators, you know, where professionals like, well, this is what this looks like.
- 55:31David Mandel: This is what this is supposed to be.
- 55:32David Mandel: You don't seem to fit that pattern, you know, and versus doing Luke what you're saying, which is really kind of an educated, curious partnership where you may hold information about a diversity of experiences and how other people have done it, which is one of the great things I found that you can make room for as a professional.
- 55:50David Mandel: You may be like, oh, I talked to this person, this is the way they thought about it.
- 55:53David Mandel: And I talked to this person, and I saw this person go through this, and they were where you were, which doesn't mean you're going to go down the same path.
- 55:59David Mandel: But I can share those with you because you're living in your, you may be living in your little isolated bubble.
- 56:05David Mandel: And and I I just, I just again also, again, always speaking to the professionals of the audience, as you say, you know, your experience isn't when it's not used with arrogance, it's not used with you know dominance or defining other people's experience.
- 56:21David Mandel: Your wide range, you may have a wider education than somebody who comes from maybe a highly controlled background.
- 56:30David Mandel: And so your knowledge may be a huge asset to them.
- 56:35Ruth Reymundo: Right, right.
- 56:36Ruth Reymundo: So I know we need to move to wrapping up, and I'm I'm actually really sad about that.
- 56:41Ruth Reymundo: This is a very meaningful conversation.
- 56:44Ruth Reymundo: These are deeply vulnerable populations that have a lot of vulnerability behind them.
- 56:51Ruth Reymundo: You know, when we speak about um the vulnerability of queer people, we're often speaking about people who have been highly abused and coerced in their families of origin, maybe stripped of resources and made extremely vulnerable.
- 57:07Ruth Reymundo: Perhaps they are people who have been system, you know, intervened in multiple times because their family has claimed they're mentally ill or that they've run away.
- 57:19Ruth Reymundo: And so they may have system interactions which make them look like they're unstable, right?
- 57:26Ruth Reymundo: And so this curiosity about this person's experience is really key to their safety.
- 57:32Ruth Reymundo: And and I would love to hear Luke, just as we move to wrapping up, what you would say to professionals in this space about working with those diverse and vulnerable populations.
- 57:48Luke Martin: So I would start by saying be professionally curious.
- 57:52Luke Martin: We are always learning.
- 57:55Luke Martin: We're learning more about domestic abuse, we're learning more about queer identity.
- 57:59Luke Martin: So ask lots of questions and actually take the onus on yourself to go and learn elsewhere.
- 58:05Luke Martin: Think about how you can work collaboratively with other professionals.
- 58:09Luke Martin: You probably have got LGBTQ services in your area, in your states, where you can do some joint working.
- 58:17Luke Martin: Maybe you're all domestic abuse practitioners, then going over there and educating them on what domestic abuse might look like, and sort of that that knowledge of exchange is vital.
- 58:27Luke Martin: I think knowing that you won't have all of the answers for survivors that you're supporting, but there's so much information out there now.
- 58:35Luke Martin: There's a wealth of resources to be able to go to.
- 58:38Luke Martin: And there's also something in being vulnerable and saying, I've not heard that before, or I don't know.
- 58:45Luke Martin: I think what I quite often see with professionals is that if they don't know the answer to something, they make things up and it's somewhat dangerous rather than going to you know what, actually, I've not heard that before.
- 58:57Luke Martin: Let me go away and have a look at what that means or what resources, or even asking survivors what that means.
- 59:03Luke Martin: I've seen it quite a lot recently with polyamory, and I guess more so because we see it more frequently within queer communities, not that it's something that's queer specific.
- 59:14Luke Martin: But going to somebody, okay, well, explain what that means for you, um, what that relationship dynamic looks like, who's safe for you, who might feel less safe.
- 59:24Luke Martin: How can we map this when we're thinking about risk?
- 59:28Luke Martin: But lean on other professionals with more knowledge, maybe with lived experience, and help shape services through that lived experience.
- 59:38Ruth Reymundo: And what would you say to victim survivors as well, Luke?
- 59:45Luke Martin: That there's support out there.
- 59:46Luke Martin: There are professionals who are highly skilled.
- 59:50Luke Martin: But even if you're accessing more generic services that aren't LGBTQ specific, they will have resources and hopefully have knowledge that are able to support you.
- 1:00:00Luke Martin: That you don't have to go to an LGBTQ specific service if you don't feel like it's the right fit for you.
- 1:00:07Luke Martin: If you're in a small community and you're worried that you're going to know workers that might be there, then actually think about what mainstream support might be available.
- 1:00:15Luke Martin: Think about if you're not sure of the dynamic of your relationship, there are helplines that you can call and say, this is happening and I'm not sure if it's right, I'm not sure if it's harmful, but can I explore it with you?
- 1:00:29Luke Martin: Take that first step.
- 1:00:30Luke Martin: And if you need to take that first step anonymously, then take that first step anonymously.
- 1:00:35Luke Martin: And if you're concerned about your own behavior, there is support provisions for that behavior change.
- 1:00:42David Mandel: Right.
- 1:00:42David Mandel: That's great.
- 1:00:43David Mandel: Really appreciate that.
- 1:00:44David Mandel: And we'll we'll be including whatever you want in our show notes for anybody who's listening to check out the show notes below the you know, where the episode is playing.
- 1:00:52David Mandel: So, Luke, thank you so much for your time.
- 1:00:55Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 1:00:56David Mandel: And your your expertise and your commitment to to the queer community, to male victims, you know, to victims of all backgrounds.
- 1:01:04David Mandel: Uh I just we can't be talking about this enough.
- 1:01:07David Mandel: So thank you for for coming on partner with Survivor.
- 1:01:10Ruth Reymundo: So thank you, Luke, for joining us.
- 1:01:11Ruth Reymundo: So you've been listening to Partnered with a Survivor, and I'm still Ruth Reymundo Mandel, and you.
- 1:01:18David Mandel: I'm still David Mandel.
- 1:01:19David Mandel: And please again still, if you you're listening and you came to the end of the podcast.
- 1:01:23Ruth Reymundo: You're a winner.
- 1:01:24David Mandel: You're a winner.
- 1:01:25David Mandel: Please share this link.
- 1:01:26David Mandel: Yeah, you hung in there.
- 1:01:27David Mandel: Yeah, you got to the end and you get the little prize at the bottom of the Cheerios box, whatever.
- 1:01:32David Mandel: I don't know.
- 1:01:33Ruth Reymundo: But there's no prize at the end.
- 1:01:34Ruth Reymundo: There's no prize at the end.
- 1:01:35Ruth Reymundo: We're the prize.
- 1:01:36David Mandel: Our guests are the prize.
- 1:01:37David Mandel: But again, check us out at safetyinstitute.com, check out our virtual academy at Academy.safety Institute.com.
- 1:01:46David Mandel: Follow us on all sorts of media that we're out there on LinkedIn and social media.
- 1:01:51David Mandel: So and we out of the way, we're not going to be able to do that.