Latest / Public Health Review Morning Edition / 1126: Leadership, Trust, and the Future of Rural Health Investment
Transcript
- 0:01This is Public Health Review Morning Edition for Thursday,
- 0:03May 14th, 2026. I'm John Sheehan with news from
- 0:07the. Association of State.
- 0:08And territorial health officials.
- 0:10From leadership shakeups at the federal level to one of the
- 0:13largest investments in rural health in decades, public health
- 0:16is navigating a moment of uncertainty and opportunity.
- 0:19Today, ASTO Senior Analyst for Government Affairs Catherine
- 0:22Murphy unpacks the ripple effects of ongoing changes at
- 0:25the Department of Health and Human Services and CDC.
- 0:29Later, ASTO Chief Medical Officer Doctor Susan Conzagra
- 0:32takes things to the state level, where leaders are racing to
- 0:35deploy Rural Health Transformation Program funds
- 0:37under tight timelines and complex compliance requirements.
- 0:41We'll hear comments Doctor Conzagra made at a recent EY
- 0:44educational webinar titled Now, Next and Beyond Understanding
- 0:49the Rural Health Transformation Program.
- 0:51First, here's Catherine Murphy. Catherine Murphy, welcome back
- 0:55to the show. Thanks so much for having me,
- 0:57it's really great to be here. So, Catherine, let's talk about
- 1:00the flux, we'll call it at HHS. There's been leadership
- 1:06turnover, workforce reductions. What has been the impact on CDC?
- 1:12Yes. So in the first year of the
- 1:13Trump administration, the Department of Health and Human
- 1:15Services, which I'll shorten to HHS from now on, underwent
- 1:19considerable changes in the form of proposed reorganization,
- 1:22budget cuts, reductions in force, which I will call riffs,
- 1:26and changes to leadership within the department's agencies,
- 1:28including CDC. This is as the new
- 1:31administration worked to form the department and its agencies
- 1:35kind of in the image of Make America Healthy Again, the Maha
- 1:38movement, and really work towards their priorities in the
- 1:42public health space within CDC. Specifically, riffs have altered
- 1:47the agency's ability to provide public health guidance and
- 1:49technical assistance as offices that state and territorial
- 1:53public health partners usually contact have lost some or all
- 1:57employees. One example of this is that
- 2:00Milwaukee Public Schools reached out to CDC's Lead Poisoning
- 2:03Prevention Surveillance Branch for assistance and were
- 2:06initially denied because the entire branch had been let go as
- 2:10career staff leaders with decades of experience and others
- 2:14were riffed from the organization or left via
- 2:17voluntary termination incentives.
- 2:19The organization CDC lost a wealth of institutional
- 2:22knowledge, and ongoing changes to leadership like the CDC
- 2:26director may slow the agency's output of guidance, approval of
- 2:30ASIC recommendations and more. So this variability in CDC
- 2:36leadership has raised concerns. How important is consistent
- 2:40Senate confirmed leadership for for maintaining trust in CDC's
- 2:44recommendations? Yeah, absolutely.
- 2:47Federal law dictates that Senate confirmed positions, including
- 2:50the CDC director, can only be filled by an acting director for
- 2:53210 days. The purpose of a Senate
- 2:55confirmed appointment is to appropriately vet candidates and
- 2:59ensure that leaders possess appropriate qualifications for
- 3:01the role. The action serves as a checked
- 3:04presidential power, so the president can't just appoint
- 3:06anyone he or she wants to a role running an agency.
- 3:11The CDC director became a Senate confirmed position due to a 2022
- 3:15law, the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023,
- 3:18which was the fiscal year 23 appropriations omnibus.
- 3:22The provision to make the director a Senate confirmed
- 3:24position became effective in 2025.
- 3:26S President Trump's first appointment for CDC Director.
- 3:29Susan Monares was the first CDC director to require approval by
- 3:33Congress. In her confirmation hearings,
- 3:35senators asked Doctor Monarez about childhood vaccinations and
- 3:39insurance coverage, ASIP vaccine policy, chronic disease, Make
- 3:43America Healthy Again priorities, cancer screening,
- 3:46and recent measles outbreaks, among other things,
- 3:49demonstrating these as public health priorities for the Senate
- 3:53panel who questioned her. So the Senate HELP Committee.
- 3:55The confirmation process provides an opportunity for
- 3:58transparency and creates public knowledge and understanding for
- 4:01the public health community to know more about the priorities
- 4:03of the nominated candidate, ideally in this case, instilling
- 4:07trust in the knowledge and decision making capacity of the
- 4:09leader of the nation's foremost public health agency.
- 4:13Some public health thought leaders have commented on
- 4:15changes to CDC's leadership with concerns about the ability of
- 4:18the agency to promote well researched, evidence based
- 4:21recommendations for public health.
- 4:23After this blog was published, President Trump nominated Dr.
- 4:27Erica Schwartz to be the next CDC Director, and she will
- 4:30appear before the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions,
- 4:34or Health Committee soon. OK.
- 4:37And you mentioned changes to ASIP, which have included
- 4:40dismissal of its members, alteration of the childhood
- 4:44vaccine schedule, and it's all had ripple effects.
- 4:47What challenge does this pose for immunization programs, for
- 4:51clinicians, for state? Level implementation.
- 4:55CDC's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, or ACIP,
- 4:59is a group of independent medical and public health
- 5:01experts who make recommendations on vaccines, which becomes CDC
- 5:04policy once adopted by the director.
- 5:07The recommendations bear on immunization schedules, the
- 5:10vaccines for children program and clinical decision making,
- 5:13and have downstream effects on whether insurance providers
- 5:15cover vaccines and the context in which those vaccines can be
- 5:18administered. So in a pharmacy versus in an
- 5:21office visit. In June of 2025, HHS removed all
- 5:2517. Biden appointed members of ASIP
- 5:28and in a press release, the department noted the goal to re
- 5:31establish public confidence in vaccine science.
- 5:33In January of 2026, HHS announced an overhaul of the
- 5:37childhood vaccine schedule outside of the ASIP
- 5:40recommendation process. The announcement included
- 5:42changes to recommendations for hepatitis A, rotavirus,
- 5:45influenza vaccines, and more. And in March of 2026, a federal
- 5:49judge pleased to stay on all of Secretary Kennedy's appointments
- 5:52to ASIP, the panel's recommendations, and the 2026
- 5:56schedule change. The administration's changes to
- 5:58ASIP have garnered bipartisan response from congressional
- 6:01leaders, especially those on the Senate Health Committee, who
- 6:03specifically questioned Secretary Kennedy on his
- 6:06potential revisions to CDC's vaccine recommendations during
- 6:09his confirmation hearing. And.
- 6:11With all these. HHS staff departures and
- 6:15continuing restructuring what is now the relationship between
- 6:19federal agencies and state health departments.
- 6:22This loss of expertise bears on the work of CDC in multiple
- 6:27areas in outbreak response, SLOB surveillance and capacity, data
- 6:31sharing, and all of the topical public health priorities.
- 6:36So one example is the laboratory leadership Service. 16 out of 24
- 6:41fellows were terminated. These lab service members are
- 6:44often dispatched to States and territories to help identify
- 6:46what's causing an outbreak. In one example, service members
- 6:49expanded testing for dengue when the mosquito borne illness hit
- 6:53American Samoa and the US Virgin Islands and they rebuilt testing
- 6:56capacity in Puerto Rico after hurricanes.
- 6:59They evaluate tests for state health labs and trains staff on
- 7:02how to use them for public health topics like, you know,
- 7:06chronic disease or maternal and child health or really for any
- 7:10public health topic you can think of.
- 7:12CDC lost a wealth of expertise and the staff who distribute and
- 7:16oversee grants that fund that work at the state level.
- 7:19There's also a loss of ability to provide technical assistance
- 7:22for issue areas with offices impacted by riffs or staff loss.
- 7:26So like I mentioned above, when Milwaukee Public Schools reached
- 7:29out to ask for help with lead poisoning prevention, they
- 7:34initially weren't able to get help from CDC.
- 7:38So as these reforms continue and leadership roles stay open or
- 7:45undetermined, what should public health leaders do and
- 7:49policymakers do to prioritize stabilization while this is
- 7:53shaking out? To be clear, public health needs
- 7:56stability. The best outcomes occur when the
- 7:58field is staffed with trusted subject matter experts who know
- 8:01and understand the communities where they work and decisions
- 8:04are made carefully and with robust evidence based backing.
- 8:07The field needs consistent and full funding to support the work
- 8:10of the public health system. So this is a field where funding
- 8:14typically spikes during emergencies and drops during
- 8:16times where the work of the public health system is less
- 8:18visible. So less visibility equals less
- 8:20funding or not in a pandemic. So we're funding public health a
- 8:23bit less. Consistency in what public
- 8:27health does for us in times where we're not in an emergency,
- 8:30and also in showing how public health prevents emergencies,
- 8:34help builds trust in the work of public health, the research base
- 8:38and the expertise of our public health leaders, and can also
- 8:41help us advocate for that funding and ensuring that we
- 8:44have strong foundational public health infrastructure.
- 8:48Factors like workforce and data sharing also factor into this.
- 8:52So when public health is consistently funded, we can have
- 8:54a strong workforce and continue to upgrade the methods by which
- 8:58we share data and information. Consistent funding and
- 9:01consistent efforts to build our public health system ensure that
- 9:04our health departments are resilient, adaptive and
- 9:07responsive to ongoing and emerging threats to public
- 9:09health. Katherine Murphy, thanks so
- 9:11much. Thank you so much for having me.
- 9:14Katherine Murphy is a senior analyst for government affairs
- 9:17at ASTO. Find a link to the blog and the
- 9:19show notes. Now let's hear from ASTO chief
- 9:22medical officer Doctor Susan Kensagra.
- 9:24She recently spoke at an educational webinar hosted by
- 9:27Ernst and Young's health policy team, Washington Council, EY, as
- 9:31part of a series to help educate private sector rural hospitals,
- 9:34providers, Med tech, and other rural health ecosystem
- 9:37stakeholders on the realities of the Rural Health Transformation
- 9:41Program grant process. The webinar was titled Now, Next
- 9:45and Beyond Understanding the Rural Health Transformation
- 9:48Program. Doctor Kinsagra, I'd like to
- 9:52start this conversation by better understanding your hopes
- 9:54and concerns for the program. Well, thanks so much, Kip, for
- 9:58having me. Really appreciate being on.
- 10:00And yeah, you know, this program has a tremendous opportunity for
- 10:04states, and there's a lot of hope built into the future
- 10:07outcomes that this program can help deliver.
- 10:09It's one of the largest investments that we have seen in
- 10:12rural health for quite some time.
- 10:14And it's also designed in a way to be really flexible for
- 10:17states. And so there's an opportunity
- 10:19for states in partnership with their community organizations,
- 10:23their providers, health systems and public health agencies to
- 10:26design this in a way that works for the needs of their state.
- 10:30So there's a lot of opportunity through this program.
- 10:33Of course, the risks of this are that, you know, the timeline is
- 10:36short, relatively short for the amount of funding that is going
- 10:40out to states to implement the program.
- 10:42Particularly in this first year, states are have about 6 months
- 10:46to implement about a year's worth of work in that initial
- 10:49start up phase. You know, the other important
- 10:51piece of this program is how states can leverage this funding
- 10:55in a way to ensure sustainability.
- 10:57And some of the programs that they are putting in place live
- 11:00beyond the five years of the grant while it's just kicking
- 11:03off. Sustainability is always top of
- 11:05mind, especially when you're not clear of the funding that might
- 11:07come afterwards. So that's another thing that
- 11:10states will be watching carefully.
- 11:12And and lastly, I will say, of course, states want to be able
- 11:14to implement the program in a way that really relies on
- 11:18community feedback input. And doing so in a way that also
- 11:23watches out for the procurement processes and compliance issues
- 11:27at a state level is also something that they're going to
- 11:29have to balance over the next several years.
- 11:31So again, lots of hope, lots of opportunity through this program
- 11:34and of course lots of things that states will have to prepare
- 11:38and launch carefully as they work through the next several
- 11:41months especially, but for the five years throughout.
- 11:45Doctor Consagra lots been going on at the state level Revised
- 11:48budgets were due to CMS by January 30th.
- 11:51There's been a lot going on and the to scope out and with budget
- 11:55revisions and ongoing state specific legislative processes
- 11:59to appropriate funding. Can you provide a little more
- 12:02context than what you spoke about before and some of the
- 12:05challenges that state agencies are facing and really getting
- 12:07the money out the door in this first year?
- 12:10Well, you're right, Kip. There's definitely a lot of work
- 12:13that is happening now both at the federal level and at the
- 12:15state level to ensure that the money gets out the door to
- 12:18states. And then of course, states are
- 12:20working hard to think about how they can get the money back out
- 12:22to their communities. So as I mentioned before, this
- 12:25first year is a pretty compressed timeline.
- 12:27It's looking more like 6 months by the time states get the
- 12:30funding in their hands. There's been a lot of back and
- 12:32forth, of course, with the CMS to make sure that they
- 12:35understand what states are planning through their work
- 12:39plans that they have submitted. And then as this money comes
- 12:42into the state, thinking about what governance structures and
- 12:45what systems that the state needs to put into place to
- 12:49ensure that this money is being thoughtfully rolled out in a way
- 12:53that gets the input of providers on the ground, gets the input of
- 12:56community organizations and rural communities, of course,
- 13:00and doing that in a thoughtful, strategic way.
- 13:02So states right now are balancing the creation of those
- 13:05systems that they need to fully implement on these funds with,
- 13:10with all the other things that come with actually implementing
- 13:12the work plan and deliverables within the funding.
- 13:15So lots happening right now at a state level.
- 13:17Doctor Kasagra, What innovative models and partnerships are you
- 13:21seeing across the states that you know to help meet this
- 13:23ambition of the rural health transformation and what
- 13:27opportunities exist in your in your view?
- 13:30Well, we're seeing lots of innovative partnerships being
- 13:33proposed through this funding opportunity.
- 13:35So to give you an example, many states are looking at creating
- 13:38regional partnerships within the state.
- 13:41So giving money to organizations that can bring together
- 13:44providers, healthcare systems, public health agencies,
- 13:47community based organizations to help provide a comprehensive and
- 13:52thoughtful approach to the funding at a regional geographic
- 13:55level within the state. So that's certainly one of the
- 13:57things that we're seeing planned through these funds.
- 13:59You know, the other is of course, as you think about some
- 14:01of the major challenges that rural communities are facing
- 14:04from behavioral health to chronic disease to ensuring
- 14:08maternal and infant health and healthy outcomes.
- 14:11States are proposing program models that help utilize hub and
- 14:16spoke models to deliver care more effectively and to make
- 14:19sure that that is integrated in with broader community of
- 14:22resources as well. So we're seeing a few different
- 14:25models. And then certainly even, you
- 14:27know, for some states who have rural populations also seeing
- 14:31some cross state collaboration. You know, we know providers and
- 14:35organizations often times serve folks across state lines,
- 14:38particularly if they're a community that lives on the
- 14:40border of a state. And so we're even seeing some
- 14:42innovative models of collaboration and thinking about
- 14:45what systems they can put in place that really benefit the
- 14:48population, you know, other state, but that those benefits
- 14:50might be felt by other states too, which is great.
- 14:53Susan, just one last question while we have you and I'll go
- 14:56back to where we started. If you think about this five
- 15:00year program and all the great work you did and the outcomes
- 15:02that you achieved in North Carolina and and NYC, what do
- 15:07you, what do you hope for? Again, just the hope.
- 15:09What does this, what does rural health look like in five years
- 15:12as a result of this great program and great opportunity?
- 15:16Well, you know, my hope would be that states are able to
- 15:19implement programs and systems that ultimately deliver real
- 15:24outcomes for the communities they serve, including outcomes
- 15:27on behavioral health, reducing, for example, what we're seeing
- 15:31around the opioid epidemic and overdoses, improving maternal
- 15:35and infant health outcomes, having healthy babies at and of
- 15:38course, supporting health throughout the life course and
- 15:41preventing chronic disease. We know that's one of the most
- 15:44costly impacts to our health system in the US.
- 15:47So being able to prevent those things from happening in the 1st
- 15:50place is, is such an opportunity with these funds.
- 15:53And so I hope at the end of the day, these programs, these
- 15:56structures that we implement support those things.
- 15:58And then there's some foundational things too,
- 16:00supporting workforce in rural areas.
- 16:02That is a real specific focus of this opportunity.
- 16:06And I hope that we are able to do more as a country in
- 16:09supporting that workforce pipeline in rural areas so that
- 16:13we can, you know, again, support delivery of these outcomes at
- 16:16the end of the day for the communities that are impacted.
- 16:19So, you know, lots of hope through this program, lots of
- 16:22opportunity, and looking forward to seeing the successes in five
- 16:26years. Doctor Susan Kinsagra is ASTO
- 16:29chief medical officer. Her comments were recorded as
- 16:32part of the webinar Now Next and Beyond Understanding the Rural
- 16:36Health Transformation Program, part of the series hosted by
- 16:39Ernst and Young's health policy team, Washington Council, EY.
- 16:42Find a link to the webinar in the show notes.
- 16:47On Friday, May 8th, CDC issued a Health Alert Network health
- 16:51advisory about a new cluster of antivirus disease cases caused
- 16:54by infection with Andy's virus. Antivirus disease can cause
- 16:58severe illness and can be fatal. Clinicians should be aware of
- 17:01the potential for imported cases, although the risk of
- 17:04broad spread to the United States is considered extremely
- 17:07unlikely at this time. Read the full advisory when you
- 17:10click the link in the show notes.
- 17:14Join ASTO for a webinar May 20th to explore how to build
- 17:17resilient dialysis systems and teams.
- 17:20Understanding the structures, processes, and practices that
- 17:23influence patient safety during times of stress is essential to
- 17:26informing priorities and targeting interventions that
- 17:29strengthen resilience. This one hour session convenes
- 17:32frontline clinicians, workforce leaders and public health
- 17:35partners to examine practical evidence, informed strategies
- 17:39that enhance both system and worker resilience in the
- 17:41outpatient dialysis setting. The link to register is in the
- 17:45show notes. This has been public health
- 17:47review morning edition. I'm John Sheehan for the
- 17:49Association of State and Territorial Health Officials.