Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 9)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. This is chapter nine in our deep dive on the
- 0:04Duggers and the Christian religious cult IBLP and other topics that are related. Let's
- 0:12get into it. What do you say, Berto, Let's do it.
- 0:14This is the Psychology and Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkanda.
- 0:18I'm a therapist and a professor. Who are you Berto? My name is
- 0:22and I'm a master lens crafter. So one of the benefits about having so
- 0:27many chapters in this series is that it gives a chance for the listeners to
- 0:31email us, and a lot of patrons actually commented and gave us more information.
- 0:38Because, of course, even though we spent a month or so deep
- 0:41diving on this topic, we didn't find all the corners of the data.
- 0:46So there's some really good data. And I can't confirm whether or not these
- 0:51points are accurate or not, but they have the feeling of accuracy anyway.
- 0:57So we have patron Raquel commented on Patreon and said the following thing. They
- 1:04say when Josh was a teenager, he was caught looking at pornography. During
- 1:10that time, he was working on a campaign and the politician who was not
- 1:14his father, the politician lost, and they believed the family and the community
- 1:19believed that the politician, the politician lost as a punishment from God because Josh
- 1:25was looking at porn. Wow, okay, have you ever heard of those
- 1:29kinds of perspectives? Yes, certainly about like punishments like that based on bad
- 1:34be here, what I think is a little novel is the transference of punishment
- 1:38someone on your campaign, a teenager on your campaign, right, caused your
- 1:42loss? Yeah, Like if anyone working on your on your campaign out of
- 1:48you know, a hundred people, I wonder if like this was born out
- 1:51of literally the dude the politician going back to Josh yelling at him, like
- 1:56you lost me my campaign. Yeah. But from my understanding I've worked with
- 2:02clients, you don't have to be in a cult to believe this notion.
- 2:07It's also normal for humans to draw causation when there's correlation, right, And
- 2:13I have you known people who aren't even problematic necessarily about it where they see
- 2:19the world. Because if you believe that God is in charge of everything,
- 2:24right, and you are of the belief system that God takes a personal interest
- 2:30in you, you know, because some religions and some cultures they believe in
- 2:34God, and they believe that God is in charge of everything. But they
- 2:36also believe that God doesn't really care about you as a person. You don't
- 2:42have a personal you know, there's a contemporary sense of Christianity where when you're
- 2:47praying, it's like God or Jesus is sitting right there paying attention to you
- 2:53and is literally with always watching you as always helping you along. Yeah,
- 2:57it is very interested in you and us. If something bad happens to you,
- 3:01then they punish, they must the ones that are not you, but
- 3:06that are related to right and and especially if you're an a cult that's talking
- 3:09about how the secular world and all of their aids and there, you know,
- 3:15their riots, it's because God's punishing them. Right, So you know,
- 3:21you don't have to be in a cult to believe that negative things happening
- 3:24to you might be related to something bad that you did. You know,
- 3:29certainly there's folks that believe that the sports team lost because they didn't do this,
- 3:34that or the other thing, exactly. Especial religious sometimes not religious,
- 3:38right, especially when you're in an anxious you know, like with I always
- 3:43marvel at with football, American football, there's not a lot of superstition.
- 3:47I almost occasionally, but with baseball it's it's a constant thing. Even when
- 3:53I was a kid and I played baseball and football, I noticed that I
- 3:57remember that like with baseball, I would have all these superstitions about trying to
- 4:03get the picture on my team to strike the guy out. And in football
- 4:10I don't ever remember. In fact, as a fielder, as a shortstop,
- 4:14I remember I had this routine where I would use my fears. I
- 4:17don't know if I've ever said this out loud. I would take my fingers
- 4:19and I would sort of draw a box around the picture, thinking that sometimes
- 4:27sometimes that helps, Yeah, sometimes that does. Hell. So I think
- 4:30the factors are that with baseball it's so much more random. Well, but
- 4:33it's also boring as hell because there's so much just standing around when you're playing
- 4:40baseball, particularly when you're in the dugout right, But with football there's no
- 4:44time for that, right you're in a constant state or soccer, for example,
- 4:47you know you're in a constant state of activity. You don't have time
- 4:50to think about superstitions. That's probably a factor. And like I would say,
- 4:55like with football, when there's definitely obviously random chance and stuff, but
- 5:00like the action is such that you're gonna a person is going to pass to
- 5:04that person and then they're gonna run. In baseball, I'm gonna throw a
- 5:08ball and it may or may not land in this area, right, and
- 5:11then you may or may not hit it, and if it does hit,
- 5:13it may or may not right exactly. I thought the same thing that a
- 5:16picture can try to throw the same ball ten times and ten different things will
- 5:23happen. The same hitter will go up against the same picture and try to
- 5:29get a base hit, and only a third of the time that'll happen,
- 5:31So it feels a lot more random. So I think that there's a tendency
- 5:39for people to start drawing those those kinds of connections. And if you're anxious,
- 5:44as another thing, if you're very anxious about the outcome, I think
- 5:47that and research shows that increases your likelihood of seeing magic where their where it
- 5:53does well. And if you don't draw the box, I mean, yeah,
- 5:56yeah, it supposed to work. So they believed that the politician loss
- 6:00because Josh was looking at porn. Because of this, this is this is
- 6:03a patron raquel. Because of this, they sent Josh away to live in
- 6:09solitude to dig a pond. They used an analogy that the weight of the
- 6:13pond would symbolize his sins. They shaved his head and he was not allowed
- 6:17any contact with anybody except for when he had meals delivered. Jim Bob,
- 6:24the father, and Jim Bob's brother John David would occasionally visit him. But
- 6:29that was it. Wait, you're telling me is that when teenage Josh looked
- 6:34at porn he was remanded to essentially a little prison with hard labor and almost
- 6:41no contact. But when he repeatedly violated people we just liked, had him
- 6:48talk to the priest or something. Yeah, yeah, wow. I could
- 6:53see looking at pornography too in their twisted world, being a bigger and sexually
- 7:00abusing younger younger siblings, you know, because pornography is probably something they talk
- 7:08about outwardly and frequently, right, because it's something when I was growing up
- 7:15in the seventies and eighties and the Christian church that I was in, I
- 7:17don't remember pornography being talked about. I think mostly because the church that I
- 7:23was in wasn't that type of church. It didn't condemn groups of people.
- 7:27It didn't go into politics. It was just about love and relationships and dealing
- 7:32with your anxiety and trying to provide comfort and community and wisdom. Occasionally there
- 7:41were little things. But well, anyway, so I met camp and we're
- 7:45having this lesson, and the teacher was telling us that John Denver was devil
- 7:50music because there's sunshine on my shoulder makes me high, which is clear,
- 7:56which is clearly a reference to drugs, which is level, which is also
- 8:01a high in Rocky Mountain high. You know, yeah, and uh,
- 8:05you know, maybe it was you could see John Denver like liking the weed.
- 8:09But but I remember thinking, at the age of seven, I'm thinking,
- 8:16I don't know about this ship here, like no one talks shit about
- 8:20the Denver like you know. So well, you're saying about how different churches
- 8:26have different levels of what they consider bad in pornography sometimes is really bad in
- 8:31those churches, but you didn't hear a lot about pornography being bad in your
- 8:37church anyway. I think what I was saying is that in some churches,
- 8:41that's all that they talk about. And you could also imagine that in the
- 8:46church they wouldn't talk about sexually abusing and your siblings very often, not because
- 8:50they're not because they're trying to avoid it necessarily, but like they're trying to
- 8:54support it or something. But it'd be very taboo. How would they even
- 8:58write in society? A lot more of a taboo topic. Okay, so
- 9:03they sent Josh away, they shaved his head, and also it's possible that
- 9:09some congregant wanted a pond and you know, two birds with one stone,
- 9:16and not to mention, since young Josh was already tormented in whatever ways,
- 9:20I'm sure this helped his mental development, right, making it more busted up
- 9:28inside of him, regarding his very normal impulse to engage in sexuality, right
- 9:33going out with the email or the comment. In addition, every Sunday at
- 9:37church they would give a Josh update about how his punishment was doing. Oh
- 9:41my gosh, what I mean, it's a church sanctioned intervention. So but
- 9:48why was it so public? Well, I mean, I don't think there's
- 9:52a lot of things that aren't public when you're in a cult like that,
- 9:56you know, a small group like that. This took place the time around
- 10:00the time special the special fourteen Kids Im Pregnant Again was filmed. This is
- 10:03their first special Okay, you can even see Josh's shaven head in one of
- 10:07the scenes. This was not a one time behavior or incident for Josh.
- 10:13This was a chronic behavior that happened over and over again that the family continue
- 10:16to ignore, and they worsened it by their approach to it. Yeah.
- 10:20I mean, it's hard to know if they worsened it, but it wouldn't
- 10:24be hard to hypothesize that. I believe there was even an instance of molestation
- 10:28that happened in front of other family members where one of the sisters was sitting
- 10:31on his lap and he molested them. Oh my god. So that's a
- 10:35very common story that I've heard from people who will molest children, is that
- 10:41they will get more and more bold. Oh well, when I also think
- 10:45that there's something about being abused destroys your sense of boundaries, proper boundaries.
- 10:52Like when I got back to Columbia when I was seven, this is after
- 10:56I had experienced abuse. I was in a car ride with a little friend
- 11:01of mine who was eight, and she was like, we were kind of
- 11:03liking each other a little bit, but at that age, what you expect
- 11:07is maybe you hold hands or at most, right we're in the car,
- 11:11right, and I started putting my hand down the back of her pants like
- 11:13with adults and other people, like it was dark because it was nighttime,
- 11:16and she sho it made it looked at me like what are you doing?
- 11:22And I stopped and I was like, oh, I don't know, and
- 11:24then that was the end of that interaction. But I literally didn't know what
- 11:28I was doing, and also I didn't care we were in a car with
- 11:30other people, well, right, because this is what was modeled to you,
- 11:35that when you have feelings for someone, you just invade and you touch
- 11:43right, and that's okay and might even be what even you your abuser might
- 11:50have wanted you to do things like that along those signs, And then you
- 11:54can imagine that for you because you had this normal impulse to connect with the
- 12:01seven year old girl, you had this proto romantic feeling, if you will,
- 12:05and because of the influence from the abuse you went through, you took
- 12:09action upon it, and you got chastised, and you probably felt really bad
- 12:16and weird and mostly confused. Like certainly I'm sure I felt bad, but
- 12:20in my head I was like, oh, I thought, wait what and
- 12:22no one was there to guide you with it. And that could really set
- 12:28things in motion depending right, Like you could imagine Josh might have had something
- 12:33similar to that where he was influenced in some way. When he's younger,
- 12:37he starts to act on some minor impulses. Maybe again, maybe with his
- 12:41sisters, as we've talked about before, because he is not allowed to talk
- 12:46with peers girls and he's homeschooled so he doesn't see many of them anyway.
- 12:50But maybe at church, and you know there's all the Nike and the eye
- 12:54traps and stuff. Oh by the way, oh yeah, someone explained what
- 13:00Nike was about. Yeah, that's like look at your shoes. Look at
- 13:01your shoes, right, So patron Jessica pointed out that on Patreon that Nike
- 13:07meant to look down at your shoes, so you look down at your the
- 13:11Nike. So in my head, because Nike is a ancient Greek figure,
- 13:16right that, I thought maybe it has something to do with the Bible because
- 13:22the Bible was written in around the same time. But nope, it's just
- 13:26the fucking It's just shoes. But like I'm trying to figure out, so
- 13:31are they saying if you're in public and you see someone, But when I
- 13:33like check your laces or something like, oh, your laces aren't. But
- 13:37when would they say Nike. Okay, so if they're in public and someone
- 13:41wearing attractive or revealing clothing, so a non cult member right when a woman
- 13:46walks by, Because it's all about not tempting the guys. Women don't matter
- 13:50if a woman wearing attractive or revealing clothing walks by or is visible the women.
- 13:54It was the women's responsibility to yell Nike, Nike, to alert the
- 13:58men, to let them give my heads up. It's the women's responsibility.
- 14:03I wonder if I wonder how Nike feels about that, you know, just
- 14:05like free advertising. And then patron Ed, good old patron Ed said,
- 14:13reminded us that the phrase was eye trap. Oh right, I also saw
- 14:18that. Yeah, eye trap right there, eye traps. Yeah, that's
- 14:22really great detail that patron mcil gave us. We could imagine a lot of
- 14:26other things happening along these lines with Josh, but we would never know about
- 14:30it because all right, let's take a break and we get back. Let's
- 14:33continue with these emails that are providing more information that we didn't pick up on.
- 14:37What do you say, let's do it all right, we're back from
- 14:45the break. So another email that I received recently is a very serious email,
- 14:52so I want us to take it really seriously. Anonymous email, just
- 14:56one sentence, no no punctuation. You and your friend are obnoxious? Oh
- 15:03sorry? What was the most obnoxious? Laugh like it? Yeah, I
- 15:11love you too. And this was sent to my personal email address. But
- 15:15to be fair, so I guess it might not be podcasts related, but
- 15:18it's got to be podcast related. They called us friends. That's got to
- 15:22count for something. Yeah, you know, it could have been like you
- 15:26and your because a lot of times like you and your guest are or who
- 15:31is that guy? Yeah, exactly, this was good. It's like you
- 15:33and your gut. And they grouped us together. We have we are simpatico.
- 15:37Doesn't simpatico mean annoying? And I often I've said this. I think
- 15:41to you that I love obnoxious, obnoxious people like my friends are some of
- 15:48the most My closest friends are some of the most obnoxious people I know.
- 15:52A Berto is one of the most you know, in a good way obnoxious.
- 15:56But some people don't think of you as being anxious in a good way.
- 16:00I think less so these days but you know, it's always been an
- 16:03acquired taste ten fifteen years ago, right, Bob. Might it might surprise
- 16:08the listeners the viewers that Bob is also pretty obnoxious in a good way,
- 16:15meaning that loud laughter, you know, lots of silly jokes and wise cracks,
- 16:21and lots of you know, when Bob is in the room, you
- 16:26know, when Ambarto is in the room. And I've had other close friends
- 16:29that were like that too, And I found this pattern that I like to
- 16:34have obnoxious people with me, maybe to make me feel less obnoxious because I'm
- 16:38also in that direction, but also that the other phrase that I would use
- 16:45is that other than obnoxiousness, is that you're not boring, like you do
- 16:49things, you say things. That's the key is. I think my behavior
- 16:53that is polarizing might also be a defense tactic for me to not spend time
- 16:59with people that are boring. Yeah, right, because it pushes them away.
- 17:03Yeah, It's like, well, okay, then cool, we probably
- 17:04weren't meant to Yeah, yeah, because you know, the opposite of obnoxious.
- 17:10Along my lines for this dimension is someone who is very blank and bland
- 17:15and never says or does anything that is challenging or interesting or risk taking or
- 17:22anything. And I want to live life and a part of that is having
- 17:29super obnoxious friends like you, such that it's accurate when a random person somehow
- 17:34finds my personal email address and emails. They got many things right. You
- 17:38and your friend are obnoxious. Yeah, so I'll take it as a compliment.
- 17:42But now I feel hurt. So now I'm going to be very mild
- 17:45and bland. Oh God, patron Steff Stefan says regarding the letter that Kayley
- 17:52wrote and was discovered in the book, there was a detail that I think
- 17:56is interesting. Kaylee released a video regarding the letter after Josh was convicted that
- 18:02was earlier this year, right or maybe last year, depending on what he's
- 18:06talking about. Kayley said, as a writing exercise, she wrote the letter
- 18:11to her favorite author, a Christian writer, so she wasn't a meaning to
- 18:15ever send it. It was just a writing exercise. The letter was a
- 18:19topic, right. The letter was meant more as a composition practice, and
- 18:25it wasn't intended to be sent. So she was very forthcoming in it in
- 18:27a way she probably wouldn't have been otherwise. It sounds like it was written
- 18:30right after they cut off the betrothal between her and Josh. So it was
- 18:34probably a reaction to the explanation she had been given as to why the patrothal
- 18:40had been broken off, and Josh may have confessed to her to some degree
- 18:45as part of his punishment, which you could imagine her she stuck it in
- 18:49the book and forgot about it. Then the book was put in a bunch
- 18:52of other books as part of a church book swap where they would borrow books
- 18:56from each other, knowing that they would be appropriate to read. Oh,
- 19:00so they've already been vetted by other members, and that's how the letter was
- 19:06leap. Yeah, I mean so that. I mean, it's essentially what
- 19:08we were saying. But yeah, it's it's a little more detail, I
- 19:11gotta say, I mean, more power to the fact that she wrote the
- 19:15letter. However, I don't. I mean, there there must have been,
- 19:19at least subconsciously, some additional parts of it, because, first of
- 19:23all, you know, a writing exercise like, oh, I wonder what
- 19:27I should write about. Oh, I just witnessed those two double murders yesterday.
- 19:30Maybe i'll that's a good topic for me. And then but i'll I'll
- 19:37keep the letter and I don't know, I'll put it over here. No
- 19:40one can find a letter in a book. Yeah, so I feel like
- 19:42again and I'm good that she did. It's just it must have been more
- 19:47to it. I mean, unless she's generally a flakey like that. Yeah,
- 19:52it's essentially a really whiz bang of a journal entry, you know,
- 19:56and to just put it in a random family book in the family library and
- 20:03forget about it. You know, that's not a typical thing that you would
- 20:07do. But patron Patricia wrote in and said Bill Gothard specifically taught the cult
- 20:15leader. Bill Gothard specifically taught that women should gaze adoringly at their husband so
- 20:21that others who see it would think highly of the husband, right, like
- 20:26psychological imprinting. Yeah, if it's you know, without words, if this
- 20:30person is looking at him like that, there's something worthwhile about this person.
- 20:33And you know, I could see it working on people actually, right,
- 20:38but not working on you and me because it has the opposite effect, Right,
- 20:44It's like, what is happening? I'm scared? You know, I
- 20:47feel I feel like you would only be doing that if you felt forced,
- 20:52right, questions that come up? Is he a monster? Yeah? Right?
- 20:55Like the opposite of right, say, that's why Michelle and other IBLP
- 21:00women do that gay similarlyly, Similarly, women are trained to have a soft
- 21:06and pleasing voice. That's why she speaks that way. Other IBLP women do
- 21:11that too. You can see it in other episodes that Anna, Josh's current
- 21:15wife does that gaze and that voice with Josh. It's mandated, and they
- 21:21can get in trouble for not going along with it. Wow. Yeah,
- 21:26I mean we've already talked about the total control over women in a variety of
- 21:30ways, but we'll just add this to the list. I mean, just
- 21:33think about that, that that you'd get in trouble. Yeah, that it's
- 21:41I mean, it's bad for everyone in this cult. But can you imagine
- 21:44being a woman. I mean, you're basically a slave, and you're you
- 21:48can't be yourself. You're this constant state of acting and brainwashing yourself, right,
- 21:56because if you give into it, you're like, Okay, I'll comply
- 22:00because I don't want to be punished, so I'll gaze at him and you
- 22:04know, like acting it helps to be method. So eventually you just convince
- 22:08yourself he is awesome, it is, and I am nothing, and he's
- 22:15so smart and well, and the umbrella is protecting you, right, So
- 22:18it's real. It's like, that's right. If I'm under the umbrella,
- 22:22i am safe. Yeah, so I need to prop up the umbrella.
- 22:26Yeah. Now, I will say that sexism is a live and you know
- 22:30a lot of these cults are exaggerations of our society, and sexism is alive
- 22:37and well and has been in our society for a long time. And you
- 22:40don't have to be in this cult to experience this. As a woman in
- 22:44a heterosexual marriage, there can be pressure from the outside and internally that you
- 22:48know, you're not supposed to talk if he's talking, you know, if
- 22:52you're at a dinner party and he's saying things like it's your job to deal
- 22:56with him or to praise him, or to manage him. And so you
- 23:02know, you don't have to be in a cult to be in this direction.
- 23:04Patroon Nicole wrote a comment the term quiverful comes from Psalm one twenty seven
- 23:11quote, like arrows in the hands of a warrior, our sons born in
- 23:18one's youth, Blessed is the man whose quiver is full of them. They
- 23:22will not be put to shame when they contend with their enemies in the gate.
- 23:27So what do you think about that? Again? I think I mentioned
- 23:32this in one of the early episodes. Great great tactic for humanity to imbue
- 23:37a sense of urgency around having children. I think that was very clever for
- 23:42early humans. And then putting it in a religious text I think is very
- 23:48powerful because it means that they will, you know, humans will take it
- 23:52seriously and they will say, oh, well, yeah, I mean it's
- 23:53not just something I heard, like, it's the law, the religious law
- 23:56I should do. I think that's very powerful for manity as it was growing
- 24:00up, because you need more people. People are dying left and rived from
- 24:03plagues and everything. And if you're a father and you only have like one
- 24:08child and they die, you have no legacy. I totally get it.
- 24:11I just think that applying it to the modern context, unless you're trying to
- 24:15hostile takeover of culture, I do think it's not great because we don't need
- 24:21twenty people per family, you know. Yeah. It also should be pointed
- 24:26out that it's talking about having boys having sons and doesn't say anything about the
- 24:32girls. And you know, I imagine that a lot of Seattle Christians would
- 24:37say well, you know there will will apply it to children of all genders,
- 24:42but for the cult, you can imagine that they would take this literally
- 24:47as well. Bible says that the boys are the real arrows in the quiver.
- 24:52Away patron Stafun wrote a comment, Michelle Dugger typically weaned her babies,
- 25:00so this is really interesting. If this is true, it sounds credible.
- 25:03But ChIL Dugger typically weaned her babies between six and nine months old, because
- 25:07remember that they had the buddy system, and the infants were given to an
- 25:11older sibling, and that older sibling was in charge of in my head,
- 25:15you know, since the average was eighteen months of having kids. You know,
- 25:19sometimes it'd be a year, sometimes it'd be two years. That I
- 25:22was thinking, well, maybe it's around eighteen months, but it wasn't.
- 25:26It was six to nine months old, six months old, so the babies
- 25:30were given I mean eighteen months old, but still six months old, So
- 25:34the babies were given to the older sisters around then. On Reddit they referred
- 25:40to it as teated and yeated. Oh my gosh. It's a very damaging
- 25:45process practice all around, and it bothers me when some creators will hand wave
- 25:49this practice as something natural that happens in large families. Yeah, that's not
- 25:53natural. That's not a natural thing. I mean, it's okay if older
- 25:57siblings are helping around, you know, well, which I mean, I'll
- 26:03tell you what's natural. It's natural for horses to come out walking and for
- 26:10you know, turtles to have to make their way to like there's lots of
- 26:12quote natural things. Again one hundred thousand years ago, Yeah, I mean,
- 26:15what are you gonna do. We have a modern society with lots of
- 26:18complexity. Kids need to be properly have proper secure attachment. They need to
- 26:23be properly raised and educated because they can't thrive in our current, current modern
- 26:27society otherwise. Yeah, and we don't know. But one hundred thousand years
- 26:33ago, the what I think to be likely is that you didn't have this
- 26:37prantification of children. Children would have responsibilities that we don't give children today,
- 26:42like gathering berries and doing more important chores around the village, if you will,
- 26:48or the you know, whatever they called it. But when you see
- 26:52other primates, there's a lot of contact twenty four seven between infant and mother
- 26:59for any significant amount of time, you know. And yeah, but then
- 27:03they get attacked and they have to go do this and the other thing.
- 27:06Yeah, time there's you are able as a mother to have your young child
- 27:14with you pretty much all the time. You can work with the child,
- 27:18you can sleep with the child, you can travel with the child. You
- 27:21know, it's because the tribe is generally hanging out together in the same area,
- 27:26and the tasks involve in hunter gatherer societies are actually lesser than in industrial
- 27:33and agricultural society, So there's a lot of just hanging around, you know
- 27:37what. I sure, but I'll throw up to you. What you often
- 27:40throw to me is like, you don't know, yeah, And I said,
- 27:42we don't know when you look at their primarial But the notion that somehow
- 27:48older siblings one hundred thousand years ago were necessarily taking care of younger siblings and
- 27:55parents were off somewhere else, it just doesn't fit with my general sense of
- 27:59how anthropologists. And that's fair, but also things that were happening maybe even
- 28:03a thousand years ago, even a hundred years ago, even fifty years ago,
- 28:06even now, is tribes killing each other and taking over each other's lands
- 28:10and murdering and raping everyone. I don't want to hear what's natural. What
- 28:12I want to hear is like what works for humans today? Right? Yeah,
- 28:17Yeah, The sisters were responsible for almost every part of running the household,
- 28:22including raising the children. So it wasn't just raising the children. They
- 28:26were responsible for cleaning and cooking and all. There's also an issue in my
- 28:30opinion, of the sisters bonding with their siblings as their mother would to a
- 28:33child. So this is interesting. They love that child and care for that
- 28:38child entirely. Then they're grown, when they're grown as a as the you
- 28:44know, the buddy, and they might want to consider leaving the religious belief
- 28:48system. They're terrified of being cut off from their siblings. There the children's
- 28:55right, which would be like being cut off from young child. It creates
- 28:57an environment where these people will continue to be manipulated to feel trapped. Because
- 29:02they can't bear the thought of being separated from the children they love, they
- 29:04will sacrifice themselves to maintain that relationship. Also, the girls were responsible for
- 29:10responsible for disciplining the siblings, which you know stands for reason and due to
- 29:15the abusive child disciplinary methods within this culture, siblings are being made to abuse
- 29:22each other. And then yeah, and in my experience, siblings don't really
- 29:27have a dimmer switch on that kind of thing. I mean, even when
- 29:32you're not prentified and totally you're tasked with, you know, Like a common
- 29:37thing in my family would be like dinner time and my mom would say maybe
- 29:45to me, would say like, it's it's dinner time. Where's Kevin,
- 29:48my younger brother, And she's like, you know, dinner Kevin. And
- 29:52then she would turn to me and she'd be like, go get Kevin.
- 29:56Well, I don't. Again, I don't have a dimmer switch, so
- 30:00I would yeah. And if and if I you know, if he was
- 30:06annoying, yeah, if it took a while to find him, I just
- 30:08be like, you know, what are you doing? In ourself? I
- 30:12was the same with my brother, look so ill. I'll often observe this
- 30:17behavior between my twelve year old and my seven year old, not even about
- 30:21like parentification or anything, just literally the seven year old will say something and
- 30:25my twelve year old will be overly harsh or overly critical, and I'll have
- 30:29to remind her like, listen, remember when you were seven, did we
- 30:33overly you know? Like as as example, today, the seven year old
- 30:37was giving a spa treatment to the twelve year old, you know, spa
- 30:40treatment stuff, and the twelve year old was going like they wouldn't do this
- 30:45at a real spot or you know, like she was just complaining about things.
- 30:47And I'm like, all right, but keep in mind, like,
- 30:48imagine you were giving me a spot treatment when you were seven. What would
- 30:52you want me to say? She's like, all right, you know,
- 30:56said stuff like that. Where they don't really they don't have the awareness of
- 31:00how to treat a child proper well. And their children who have insecurities and
- 31:04lack experience and emotional regulation and are frequently seeking any evidence that they are smarter
- 31:15or more capable than other people and younger siblings are very easy targets for that
- 31:21comparison. Right. So one thing I can't even imagine how they would handle
- 31:26it is when these little kids are in that sixth to nine months then one
- 31:32year even, they have unexplainable tantrums in the middle of the night. They
- 31:36have like really hard moments that as an adult is so trying, so nerve
- 31:41wracking, so like I don't know what to do. What is a twelve
- 31:47year old that eight year old supposed to do? Right? I mean,
- 31:49I didn't get a sense of exactly what age, But yeah, I think
- 31:53eight to twelve would be a good guest. Maybe younger, I don't know.
- 31:57Also, the girls are responsible for discipline and siblings. Due to the
- 32:00abusive child discipline of that culture, siblings are being made to abuse each other.
- 32:07Jana Dugger, I think that's the oldest sister. I think she's just
- 32:09below Josh was known as the disciplinarian in the family, to the point that
- 32:15if children were misbehaving, they would threaten do you want me to get Janna?
- 32:21It is so harmful? Yeah, So thank you patron Stefan for alerting
- 32:27us to that, because you know, I had the broad strokes on that,
- 32:30but to hear it laid out like that is it really just drives home
- 32:36because I remember thinking and maybe saying, it's like, well, you know,
- 32:39there's nothing inherently dysfunctional or harmful if an older sibling is helping out.
- 32:45But it sounded to me as if it was way too much responsibility. But
- 32:47I didn't have a sense of the specifics, and I think now we kind
- 32:52of do. Anonymous patron wrote in and said, I grew up in the
- 32:55Quiverful movement. I was homeschooled, I was one of nine children, etc.
- 33:00I feel like what people don't understand is the complete control that is exerted
- 33:05over the grown daughters in this community. I helped raise my younger siblings,
- 33:10and from a young age, I was mistaken for being way older than I
- 33:15was. I've never actually made that connection until I listened to the podcast where
- 33:19you talk about practification right. I had friends who were also printified when we
- 33:22were ten years old. I remember talking to my friends about how we were
- 33:25mistaken for being eighteen years old by people, by people outside the cult.
- 33:30We thought the crazy outsiders didn't know how children should be acting, you know,
- 33:37because it's like, how come all the outsiders think were so old and
- 33:39mature they must be raising their kids wrong? Instead of ten is young,
- 33:45you know, like you should be ten. Childhood was downplayed in my community.
- 33:52We were supposed to act we weren't supposed to act like a kid.
- 33:54So that's interesting that we've heard things along these lines. But from this it
- 34:00sounds like it was all encompassing. Like if you just had a childish interest
- 34:06or an impulse, you know, think about your seven year old or maybe
- 34:09you're twelve year old, is probably a better you know, what does she
- 34:14do that is very twelve years you know, you see her friends, you
- 34:16know, what are the things that they do? You're like, oh,
- 34:20you're twelve, what are those things? One example would be so because okay,
- 34:25so first I'll say the things that And this was very frustrating when she
- 34:29was first turning twelve because she was just what they don't do is a lot
- 34:32of imagination play, Like they are no longer playing with barbies. My daughter
- 34:38plays with barbies with my seven year old, but when she gets together with
- 34:42their twelve year old friends, they're not playing barbies, they're not pretending to
- 34:45be in magical school, but they are doing things like they want to start
- 34:50a business together. So like her and one of her friends that they're starting
- 34:53a business together. And the twelve year old thing is like they have no
- 34:58conception of what the complex it easier, and when I try to kind of
- 35:01explain, it's like I don't want to hear it. Like we're doing our
- 35:04thing right. That's pretty typical. Another thing is like the irresponsibility what kind
- 35:08of businesses Like she wants to start well, I mean, and I totally
- 35:12supportive of course she her and her friend want to do a business where they
- 35:15draw pets for people, Like the people send him a photo and they draw
- 35:17the pets. Great idea. I mean they could literally and they could totally
- 35:22do it right, But I was just explaining because they want to go and
- 35:24sell it at like the farmer's marketing stuff. I'm like, cool, So
- 35:28here's what you might have to do, Like I will get there later,
- 35:30you know, I don't want to. You gotta start at LLC. The
- 35:34other thing is like irresponsibility, where you know, I'll be like, okay,
- 35:37so here's what you need to do. You need to you know,
- 35:40get dressed, unload the dishes, feed the dog. Right, okay,
- 35:45just a minute, a little later, like, hey, you're still in
- 35:47your Jammy's. You didn't unload the dishes, you didn't feed the dog.
- 35:52Oh, I totally forgot. I was I was reading. I thought you
- 35:54meant later. You know. That's like so typical, and I was the
- 35:58same way. You know, it's like just to an age thing where you
- 36:00can count on them for things, but you gotta remind them. You gotta
- 36:04like you can't fully depend on right because they're children. So if you're like,
- 36:08take care of the baby, Wait, did you take care of the
- 36:10baby. Right, So imagine the punishments that would be, you know,
- 36:15brought forth not only from parents, but even from Janna, the older sibling.
- 36:20Right. And also imagine if you went to you know, her and
- 36:22her friends say they're all in this cult, and you said, you know,
- 36:28this is childish. You should be doing your chores. Stop acting like
- 36:32you're twelve, and or how you actually try to involve yourself. You try
- 36:38to encourage it a little bit, right, You go like, well,
- 36:40maybe this, or you might say things that are just like, wow,
- 36:45that's a really great idea, even though you're thinking, well it's not.
- 36:49But you know they're twelve. Well, imagine if you're in this community.
- 36:52It sounds like if your daughter was doing this, they would they would have
- 36:57shut that down years ago. Hey, no, grow up, you don't
- 37:00understand things work. Plus, you have to do your torch right now,
- 37:02right, I don't want to hear any things about blah blah blah, no
- 37:06imagination. Right. We were taught that adolescence was made up by the world,
- 37:13you know, secular world. Teenagers were expected to get married and have
- 37:16kids and were providing childcare and household help. From early on. Many of
- 37:21my friends and I also helped our families financially from an early age. And
- 37:25this is what I mean by like, because you could easily make an argument
- 37:29I'm like, hey, you know if you can have reproductive capability at twelve
- 37:32or thirteen, well you know, yeah, it slots into the overall philosophies
- 37:39of these cults. One, it's very traditional, so it helps in that
- 37:45way. But also it's absolute control over the women in the society because if
- 37:51you never allow them to have an independent thought or freedom, or creativity or
- 37:58fun, then and they never learn that they have any rights, they never
- 38:04learn what they want. They are in a constant state of trying to avoid
- 38:07punishment. And so you just have total control. And since it's a patriarch
- 38:14a hyper patriarchal society going on, I feel like I'm making connections I've never
- 38:19made before listening to your podcast. Any tips on how to not prentify your
- 38:22children. I have an eleven year old, an eight year old, and
- 38:24a three month old, and I'm struggling with letting my eleven year old help
- 38:29even when she offers, because I'm scared of this dynamic being repeated. I
- 38:34have an eleven year old, an eight year old and a three month old
- 38:37child, So three kids, and I'm struggling with letting my eleven year old
- 38:40help even when she offers, because I'm scared of this dynamic being repeated,
- 38:45you know, prentifying the eleven year old. Well, so I'm going to
- 38:49answer. I have a lot to say about this, because there are a
- 38:51lot of questions along design. It's like, how do I not prentify my
- 38:54child? But let's go to the patron zone. So if you want to
- 38:58hear the rest of this episode, we're also gonna go eventually into the the
- 39:04news story about Ruby Frankie, which is a breaking story that just came out
- 39:10yesterday and in our time and you know, meaning that we're recording it's it's
- 39:15it's September first right now, and it was a YouTuber who was found to
- 39:21be abusing very related, yeah, so very very related to what we were
- 39:24talking about in terms of the laws and the problems with YouTube vloggers and the
- 39:32lack of regulations and oversight. So so if you want to listen to that
- 39:37portion of this episode, this chapter, become a patron of the podcast.
- 39:40Otherwise, please take care of yourself because you deserve it.