Latest / Quantum Potential / Securing the 21st Century with Ret. Gen. Paul Nakasone
Transcript
- 0:00I think academia has a huge role here to assist because, you know, we can take a step back and look a little further in terms of, "Hey, what are the emerging threats in the future?" Or, "What do we have to do to bring partnerships to a greater degree of capability?" Or, "What do we need to do in terms of training the next generation of young people that are gonna be able to address some of these really thorny issues?" Today I'm honored to welcome our guest Gen. Paul M. Nakasone, a transformational leader in national security and cybersecurity.
- 0:29General Nakasone is a retired four- star general who had dedicated nearly 40 years to military service, culminating as the director of the National Security Agency and commander of U.S. Cyber Command.
- 0:40During his time in uniform, he led some of the most consequential efforts in modern digital defense.
- 0:46He pioneered the now widely adopted strategy of persistent engagement— the idea of a more active approach to defending cyberspace while also strengthening public-private partnerships to defend against rapidly evolving cyber adversaries.
- 1:12Welcome to 'Quantum Potential,' a podcast dedicated to curiosity and discovery.
- 1:18My name is Cybele Raver, and I serve as the provost of Vanderbilt University.
- 1:22As a leader in higher education and as a social scientist, I believe that we can transform higher education for the 21st century.
- 1:28At my core, I am wildly curious about other people's work, whether it's in science, the social sciences, the humanities or the arts.
- 1:37This podcast gives us the opportunity to break open new ideas through discovery and creative expression.
- 1:50Since retiring, General Nakasone has turned his attention to shaping the future. We're so incredibly fortunate that he came to Vanderbilt to found the Vanderbilt Institute of National Security, where he's developing the next generation of national security professionals who are fluent in both policy and technology.
- 2:08He also serves on the board of directors for OpenAI, contributing his expertise to questions of AI, safety, security and governance, as well as on the boards of Neuberger Berman Mutual Funds and WitnessAI.
- 2:21A lifelong leader and learner, he holds degrees from St. John's University, USC, the National Defense Intelligence College and the U.S. Army War College.
- 2:30General Nakasone is widely regarded as one of the most foremost voices on cybersecurity, digital warfare and leadership in an age of emerging threats.
- 2:39We're so grateful to have him with us here today, especially given that he's launching today's Vanderbilt Summit on Modern Conflict and Emerging Threats, which now has, I believe, General, over 700 uh, folks?
- 2:53This is the first we've had a sellout, Provost.
- 2:55It's really exciting.
- 2:57So I'm gonna jump in after welcoming you with this amazing, uh, sort of moment, uh, where we are celebrating and, uh, learning so much, just to first ask, can I call you Paul?
- 3:08Please?
- 3:08And can I call you Cybele?
- 3:09Please.
- 3:10Fantastic.
- 3:11Okay.
- 3:11What a relief, right?
- 3:12It's so nice.
- 3:12We've, we've had success already here.
- 3:15Great.
- 3:16Today I'm so honored to speak with you about, um, all of the ways in which your leadership has really transformed the way that we think about national security.
- 3:25You know, I think we often imagine war with boots on the ground, but you've really helped us to understand cybersecurity— the way that in a digital age threats look completely different.
- 3:36And I'd like to get soon to the things that drove you into this field or led you into this field or inspired you into this field, but first, I thought it would be great for you to just set the stage a bit to help us understand this completely new way of thinking about threat and, uh, ways in which that might come from cyber attack rather than from, uh, necessarily people standing at a border with weapons in hand.
- 4:01Yeah, it's interesting because I entered the United States Army at the end of the Cold War, and we were pretty much a thought process of national security— you're either at peace or you're at war. And over a period of time, really, uh, 10 or 15 years, whether or not it's activities in the Balkans, whether it's 9/11, whether or not it's the discovery of Russian malware in our classified systems— the definition of national security has changed, and so it's no longer just this idea of "How do you form international partnerships?
- 4:28How do you protect your borders?
- 4:29How do you have a very, very powerful military?" It's this idea that there are borderless challenges.
- 4:33Mm-hmm.
- 4:34We've seen this.
- 4:34Yeah.
- 4:34Think about five years ago we were dealing with the challenge of a global pandemic. Right.
- 4:39This is the world in which we live today.
- 4:41Fascinating.
- 4:42And in that regard, it immediately makes me flash on having to do my annual cybersecurity training for Vanderbilt last night, right at 9 p.m.
- 4:50It also seems to span across corporate as well as government institutions, right?
- 4:55We're not only thinking about cities, we're thinking about hospitals, or we're thinking about, um, you know, utilities or we're thinking about our railroads.
- 5:03Can you help us also understand that kind of span?
- 5:06Think about, you know, these bright lines that we once had between peace and war that now are, like, you know, this line that's between public and private.
- 5:14Yeah.
- 5:14Or the line that's between academic and, you know, public corporations. Or it's a line between civilian and military.
- 5:21These lines are getting much, much more gray.
- 5:24And so as we think about this, whether or not it's, you know, being able to deal with our cybersecurity.
- 5:28Whether or not it's thinking about the ideas of a global pandemic or even climate change—we have to think differently about this, and we have to have critical thinkers that really understand the change of what's going on.
- 5:39Amazing.
- 5:40I mean, clearly it's this huge cognitive reframe, right?
- 5:43This big mental rotation where we don't outsource or think about, uh, the military taking care of one world and, you know, the private sector taking care of another world—commodities versus safety.
- 5:55But instead, uh, you're helping me to understand at least the ways in which they're deeply, deeply overlapping, if not integrated.
- 6:00I think that's one of the real appeals of 'Quantum Potential' is you use the word curiosity.
- 6:04Yeah.
- 6:05So curiosity is one of the things that we've gotta do much different approach to thinking of these problems.
- 6:11How do we bring together radical partnerships?
- 6:12How do we think about our competitive advantages?
- 6:14How do we actually, you know, bring the power of academia to address some of these really challenging issues?
- 6:19That's great.
- 6:20So let's step back for a minute to ask you a little bit about how you ended up in this particularly incredibly important, uh, role in terms of your leadership, in terms of your transformational approach.
- 6:31Your parents immigrated to the U.S. from Japan.
- 6:34You know, I think we share something in common— my mom immigrated here from Germany right after World War II.
- 6:39Tell me a little bit about what led you to this point in your life.
- 6:42So my grandparents actually come from Okinawa, Japan, to the United States in Hawai'i, uh, at the turn of the century convinced that they were gonna make a million dollars.
- 6:51And, like many immigrants, they find out that it's much more challenging.
- 6:54My father, born in Hawai'i, raised in Hawai'i, actually watches the attack on December 7th on Pearl Harbor.
- 7:01And then four years later finds himself an interpreter in the United States Army because he had spoken Japanese in the home. And so he's there at the, uh, at the reconstruction of Japan.
- 7:11He's an educator.
- 7:11My mother's an educator.
- 7:12Mm-hmm.
- 7:13And so I have this great, deep appreciation for education as I'm growing up.
- 7:18But here's so interesting to inter to just interject there, to think that his dual language proficiency and capability, that that notion of dual cultural identity and, and language was actually really important for national security in that moment, right?
- 7:30And I think that's one of the things that we should always remember, that we have competitive advantages as a people, as a nation that we should always be able to leverage.
- 7:38I think the interesting epilogue of the story, if I might, is last fall at the, at the invitation of the emperor of Japan, uh, I was invited to, uh, an award ceremony at the Imperial Palace in Tokyo.
- 7:50And I thought to myself, as I met the emperor of Japan, "I wonder what my grandparents would've thought three generations ago being peasants coming to Hawai'i.
- 7:57Their grandson now was meeting the emperor." Pretty amazing.
- 8:00Amazing.
- 8:01And also that as educators and as an interpreter dealing with information and, and correct information, right?
- 8:08I'm just imagining your father translating and that idea of getting, getting the translation right.
- 8:13Or the, their role as educators getting the transmission of information and the inspiration of, you know, factual correctness, but also trust in information, um, that I'm, I'm curious about those themes.
- 8:25Yeah, I, I think, you know, the really interesting thing, Cybele, is that there was a culture growing up that, you know, education was always revered.
- 8:33That you know, your idea of being able to look at a problem, understand the problem, talk about the problem—those were things that were very, very valuable.
- 8:40And so when I decided to make a career choice, when I went to college, uh, and I graduated from college, joining the Army, that was one of the things that I think really helped me, was that curiosity.
- 8:49Amazing.
- 8:50And when you think about the image of your grandparents, you know, looking upon you as you're, uh, meeting the emperor of, of Japan, what, what is the thought that you think they would've had in addition to just huge, massive amounts of pride?
- 9:03Uh, I think confirming their decision to, to come to the United States.
- 9:06Yeah.
- 9:06The fact that education matters.
- 9:07The fact that, you know, this really is a land of opportunity.
- 9:10You know, those things were always kind of, uh, present and present growing up.
- 9:14But it certainly came back to me as I was thinking about, uh, thinking about that day.
- 9:17Yeah.
- 9:17Amazing.
- 9:18Well, and congratulations on that moment.
- 9:20Thank you.
- 9:20It must have been really, truly mind blowing in this sense of "how, how could this possibly be that I'm here," and yet of course, this makes complete sense in some interesting way. In terms of thinking about being here.
- 9:33Obviously, you know, that moment, uh, also coincided with the culmination of your 30 years of military service, where your next move was often decided for you, I think in, as I understand life in the military.
- 9:46You then actually get this big moment of making a decision about where next, what next?
- 9:52And you decide to join us at Vanderbilt to help us in this endeavor of supporting students and thinking about national service and about cybersecurity, about, you know, all the things that you are, are leading us in terms of thinking about national security by launching the Institute of National Security.
- 10:07So, of course, you know why Vanderbilt, why now?
- 10:10Well, I visited Vanderbilt twice during my last, uh, couple years in service, and I always enjoyed coming here to, to speak at the summit.
- 10:18But I have to be really honest here.
- 10:19Uh, when I retired from the Army, I was like, oh my gosh, I have some time off now.
- 10:23Fantastic.
- 10:24And a couple months into it, I received a call from the chancellor and my thought was, "Oh, chancellor, I'm really enjoying retirement." He's like, "Just come to Nashville." And so Just see.
- 10:33I would just, just, right.
- 10:34And, and you know.
- 10:35That's how he gets us all...
- 10:36That's right.
- 10:36It's Just visit.
- 10:37Just visit.
- 10:38And, uh, and so I brought my wife along, and we had just a wonderful week in Nashville. And I could see that I knew that I wanted to give back in the next phase of my life, and what a better place than here?
- 10:49Uh, the appreciation for education, the freedom of expression, uh, the city that's growing so rapidly—and just a history of being part of education and research.
- 10:59I wanted to be associated with that.
- 11:00It's amazing, and I think the spirit that you communicated during those visits is was so aligned, is so aligned with my excitement about, um, transforming higher education in the 21st century, for real clear evidence for action.
- 11:15You know, you talk about trying to solve wicked problems rather than simply writing white papers and storing that white paper in a journal somewhere.
- 11:24And not that that isn't a laudable goal, but it's not the one that I think is the most pressing or inspiring from my vantage as provost.
- 11:31And I just love that you are so committed to that action component— the way in which, if the work isn't relevant right now, we may be less inspired to do it.
- 11:42Do you wanna say a little bit about the...
- 11:43I do.
- 11:44I think, you know, one of the questions I often get is, "Hey, Paul, why Vanderbilt?" Yeah, yeah.
- 11:48"Why did you go to Vanderbilt?" Yeah.
- 11:49And I would, I would say that the equation looks something like this.
- 11:52First of all, world-class university that's well known for its education and research.
- 11:56Second piece.
- 11:58You know, a true commitment to freedom of expression, what is called here institutional neutrality.
- 12:03The third thing is this idea of, hey, let's be able to look at problems in the lens with different partners.
- 12:10What the chancellor calls radical partnerships is alive and well.
- 12:13It's something I'm very, very familiar given my career.
- 12:16And the last part is, "Hey, let's have pragmatic or practical solutions.
- 12:19Let's show something for our work." That was one of the things I think that always defined the organizations that I was, uh, that I was able to be a part of.
- 12:26And so that was an appeal to me is I, I looked at Vanderbilt as I looked at a brand new institution.
- 12:31I described it to one of my friends, it's like, it's like having a huge whiteboard and I get the markers.
- 12:36Yeah.
- 12:36And I get to color, and it doesn't matter in terms of what the history of the place was or preconceived notions.
- 12:42It's all new, and that's really appealing.
- 12:44And so less siloed.
- 12:44Right.
- 12:45It is.
- 12:46And one of those great examples, I learned that you are, uh, currently collaborating with another 'Quantum Potential' podcast interviewee, Erin Calipari, the wonderful neuroscientist that was just on a few episodes ago.
- 12:57I was, uh, really thrilled to hear about, um, the ways in which you're working with her.
- 13:01Do you wanna talk a little bit about that?
- 13:02You, you know, Erin's new institute, uh, her work with regards to taking a look at drug addiction.
- 13:07Uh, the challenge that we have coming back to this idea of borderless challenges with, uh, the flow of fentanyl and other drugs into uh, our nation and how do we look at it, both from the idea of supply and demand. And the work that she and her institute have done really are very, very interesting.
- 13:22And the idea of, oh my goodness, we have different departments really kind of talking here and trying to get solutions.
- 13:27Where do you see that?
- 13:28Uh, well, you don't necessarily see that everywhere in academia, but you see it here in Vanderbilt.
- 13:32Yeah, very much, very much.
- 13:34I think a lot too about, um, our launch of the new College of Connected Computing, our recent hire of Matt Johnson- Roberson from CMU for as the new dean.
- 13:44I would imagine that the launch of the new college is a really great opportunity in terms of thinking about, um, cyber warfare and thinking about, um, some of the key issues that you really wanted to tackle, like ransomware.
- 13:56How does that look from your vantage?
- 13:57It is, Cybele, and lemme just take a, a step back and just, you know, uh, just pay thanks to Dean Krish, and really the deans of Peabody and A&S and Business just because they were so welcoming to me.
- 14:09Great.
- 14:10Uh, I think that one of the things as we look to the, we look to the future is, you know, how do we bring this new college into the fold of what we know are really significant issues?
- 14:20And so having Matt coming from CMU, really looking at different problem sets. You know, the folks that he's gonna be able to bring and the ideas, I think will really work well— not only within Vanderbilt what, but with what our institute wants to do in the future.
- 14:32Yeah.
- 14:32I mean, I think in a recent podcast you were talking about autonomous systems actually being at a point with large language learning models, essentially being at a point of, uh, being able to make decisions without the human involved, right?
- 14:45And I think that that immediately raised such a fascinating set of questions in terms of what our future looks like as we continue to develop AI in ways that increasingly need us less, um, not at the, uh, workforce level of manufacture, for example, but at the decision-making level.
- 15:04And I just thought maybe you, you might wanna talk a little bit about that.
- 15:07I think that's an important question because it comes to this idea of really who are the players.
- 15:12Yeah.
- 15:12Uh, and I look at a, a Venn diagram, if I was gonna draw it for you, there'd be a circle that says private.
- 15:19And that could be private companies, private citizens.
- 15:21It's just private.
- 15:22Yeah.
- 15:22The next circle I draw would be government.
- 15:24And it doesn't necessarily mean just U.S. government.
- 15:26It means government.
- 15:27And the third circle, well that's third circle is academia.
- 15:31Yeah.
- 15:31And so bringing those three together, I wanna see the intersection and make that intersection as large as possible.
- 15:36Yeah.
- 15:36Because for someone who had served, uh, for over 30 years in the United States military, I was always looking for people that could make that circle bigger.
- 15:45I think academia has a huge role here to assist.
- 15:47Because you know, we can take a step back and look a little further in terms of, "Hey, what are the emerging threats in the future?" Or, "What do we have to do to bring partnerships to a greater degree of capability?" Or, "What do we need to do in terms of training the next generation of young people that are gonna be able to address some of these really thorny issues?" No, it's great.
- 16:06And I think that intersection really speaks to institutions, um, like this one that ... where collaboration is, is really the touchstone, right?
- 16:14Is really the coin of the realm.
- 16:15We love being able to have those conversations across those disciplines, across those different sectors.
- 16:20So that makes ex, you know, complete sense to me.
- 16:23And when you think about training the next generation, I love your commitment to working with undergraduates and our graduate students.
- 16:29Do you think that the largest portion of the work with our students is really informational and technical?
- 16:36Or do you think it's something deeper about building trust and really helping them to understand service and public service?
- 16:43Is it really a kind of core value, or is it intellectual, or is it both?
- 16:48One of the things I, I would share with you is that, first of all, our number one customer at the institute is the undergraduate student.
- 16:54Great.
- 16:54Uh, it's, it for me was like so refreshing to be able to go back into a campus, going to classes I was in, you know, Dr. Tom Sullivan's class this week on the intelligence community.
- 17:03You know, I've been in Brett Benson's class and, and others just to, to be able to share ideas.
- 17:08You've read the textbook, hey, let me tell you how this really works in...
- 17:11In real time.
- 17:11...in real time, right?
- 17:12Yeah.
- 17:13And so as we look at it from an institute, you know, our vision is the premier national security institute that trains the next generation of national security professionals with the technical capabilities, the policy background and the critical thinking skills to solve the toughest challenges that our nation faces.
- 17:30And so it comes back to this idea of it's not just the fact that we need to have you smart in policy.
- 17:35Yeah.
- 17:35It's not just the fact that you need to be really good technically.
- 17:38It's the fact that you have to be a critical thinker.
- 17:41One of the things that that I like to say is in the future, I really want policymakers who code and coders who understand policy.
- 17:47Yeah.
- 17:47It's that, you know, generation, this, uh, generation that's gonna really be able to take on those two disciplines with really good critical thinking skills to be effective in this world.
- 17:56Yeah.
- 17:56The connected.
- 17:57Right.
- 17:57As the connected computing, right.
- 17:59The connected between the ways in which students double major all the time here, right?
- 18:04Correct.
- 18:05Yeah.
- 18:05Fascinating.
- 18:06You know, I would imagine you see students who are phenomenal at being student-athletes who have an incredible level of discipline on the field and who really wanna commit that kind of, uh, level of, of discipline and focus, um, on, you know, in, in terms of service.
- 18:21Uh.
- 18:21There might be students from ROTC, there might be students who are really fascinated by politics and debate, but who find themselves really interested in foreign relations.
- 18:31Is there one constituency that really sort of rises to the fore as they come knocking on your door?
- 18:36I don't think so.
- 18:37I, I think the constituency that we're looking for is just interest, right?
- 18:40Yeah.
- 18:40Curiosity.
- 18:41Yeah.
- 18:41I was struck by, you had asked me about, uh, a constituency, and I remember meeting Candice Lee among the first people that I met at the, at the university.
- 18:48And, and just her passion to talk about intercollegiate athletics and the discipline that it takes.
- 18:53And not only her experience, but also now her leadership role here—really impressed upon me, there are so many different constituencies here at Vanderbilt, and I wanna touch a lot of 'em.
- 19:01And even if you're not, even if you're not gonna be a national security professional, to leave this university with an understanding of, hey, this is a little bit about how the world works, and this is how I find myself within this world.
- 19:11Yeah, more sophisticated citizens with a greater sense of both the threats and the, and, and the solutions.
- 19:18Right.
- 19:18Amazing.
- 19:19And how about that sense of trust in information more broadly, right?
- 19:23Increasingly, you know, I think of old- style civics as something that students feel, um, is, is really not, um, very relevant to the way in which information travels through their phones, through TikTok, through various other media.
- 19:38So that it becomes so high, a volume of messaging and information that none of it is actually salient, right?
- 19:47It's all really, really epiphenomenal.
- 19:49How do you move students and faculty and professionals in the private sector to being able to trust information and to think about information in a way that really can vet that information for its value?
- 20:02So I've had a little bit of experience with regards to trust.
- 20:05When I, when I ran the National Security Agency, one of the things that I committed to was this idea of, the American people had to have trust in conference in this agency that had such tremendous surveillance powers...
- 20:15Yeah.
- 20:15...and the leaders that led it.
- 20:17And one of the things that, that I found out was the way that you build trust is through transparency, is through communication, is through understanding not only what is of concern to obviously your constituents, but also, uh, what is concern to you.
- 20:31And so being able to talk about what we did, being able to say, "This was the benefit, and oh, by the way, this is how we protect your civil liberties and privacy," was inherent in being able to build that trust.
- 20:41And so as I think about just talking about information, one of the things is being able to understand where the information comes from.
- 20:47Comes from, yeah.
- 20:48And that's why it's so important to be in a place where free expression is valued.
- 20:52Yeah.
- 20:52Have civil discourse, being able to talk about it in a manner that isn't, you know, isn't sharp or, or isn't, uh, shut down is one of the things that I think Vanderbilt should be incredibly proud of.
- 21:02Yeah, the Dialogue Vanderbilt certainly, um, under Darren Reisberg and led by of course, the chancellor.
- 21:07But also, um, I'm thinking a lot about Amanda Little and the work that she's doing in terms of, um, civic engagement through, uh, student newspapers, right?
- 21:15How to create, uh, and, and leverage student, um, journalism as an opportunity to be more engaged in creating, uh, really robust information channels.
- 21:25You know, spoiler alert here.
- 21:27This is, uh, the, uh, institute's, uh, summit as you'd indicated.
- 21:30And tomorrow we're going to hear from Sam Altman, who is the CEO of OpenAI.
- 21:35Obviously one of the, uh, most important, uh, you know, visionaries on artificial intelligence that, uh, is in the world today.
- 21:41But one of the things that we're gonna do afterwards is have a bit of a press engagement.
- 21:45And one of the folks that gets to talk to Sam Little or Sam Altman is, obviously, the reporter from 'The Hustler,' so we're excited about that.
- 21:52Great.
- 21:52Yeah.
- 21:52Great.
- 21:52Wonderful.
- 21:53Yeah, I mean, I think just that idea that, you know, how tech works and how information works, um, often get treated as separable, but then you see absolutely that issues around privacy, issues around the transmission of information and disinformation are absolutely integrated.
- 22:09Correct.
- 22:10Amazing.
- 22:11And in terms of threats on the horizon in that space, do you have a sense of, um, looking around a corner to see what we are most concerned about?
- 22:18We talked about elections, um, in a past conversation, I know Josh Clinton was on 'Quantum Potential' talking about building trust in elections.
- 22:26Is that continuing to be the, the burning issue in the spaces?
- 22:30Well, obviously a little, little less so now that we're out of the election cycle, but it will come back with the midterms.
- 22:33It'll come back with the, obviously the the 2028 presidential election.
- 22:38But I think taking a step back, as you talked about really the, you know, the most, uh, uh, I think powerful technology in the, the present and in the future is artificial intelligence.
- 22:48And so I think this idea of how do we develop artificial intelligence safely and securely, how is it, uh, ensured that the United States and its, and its allies and democratic free, uh, free peoples are able to do this is one of the things that I think is really pressing.
- 23:01And, and how do we ensure that we have not only the data, uh, the semiconductors, the energy and the talent to do this is one of the things I suspect Sam will talk about tomorrow.
- 23:11That's, I think, really the, the early-term piece of, of what we have to be able to focus on.
- 23:16But let me also tell you that, uh, as we think about threats, I do think about, uh, the threats that we can't even envision now.
- 23:23I don't ever remember, uh, before March of 2020, someone saying to me is, "Hey, get ready for the global pandemic.
- 23:29Right?
- 23:29Right.
- 23:30And, and so the global pandemic came at us and so we had to be able to, to figure out how we were gonna deal with that.
- 23:35Absolutely.
- 23:36And I think that's, again, a little part of the critical thinking that's so important for us to be able to develop in our students here and be able to develop for those that that work with the institute, because those are the skills that are gonna allow you to address the next challenges and national security.
- 23:48Yes.
- 23:49I think you spoke about the preparing, uh, for the unknowns, right, the unknowable unknowns.
- 23:56And I'd love to come back to that.
- 23:58I think let's take a little break and we'll, we'll be back.
- 24:15Welcome back.
- 24:16We are here at 'Quantum Potential' and having an amazing conversation about national security— particularly in an age of AI, and, uh, digital integration of both the public and the private sector.
- 24:29And we're speaking with General Paul Nakasone, and we're really thrilled to have you and really excited to continue the conversation.
- 24:38So, Paul, would you tell us a little bit about the Wicked Problems Lab?
- 24:41I, I am very fascinated by this idea of really tackling a problem and wrestling it to the ground in, in vivo rather than a model that might yield a, an outcome or solution 10 years or 15 years hence.
- 24:55And again, I think this speaks to the, the power of Vanderbilt University of being able to, to realize that you have to take radical partnerships with new curious ideas to be able to get after outcomes.
- 25:05Our thought here is, "Let's bring together a series of people that are looking at a challenge," whether or not they're from government or they're private sector, whether or not they're from academia and say, "Hey, what can we do collectively to be able to get after this?" We're very interested in ransomware.
- 25:18We're very, very interested in being able to secure our critical infrastructure.
- 25:21And tell everybody a little bit about how ransomware works.
- 25:24I know it.
- 25:24Yeah.
- 25:24I mean, just think about a criminal.
- 25:26Let, let's return to, you know, the, the spring of 2021.
- 25:30Uh, and we find that Colonial Pipeline has been hit by, you know, ransomware attack from someplace in Russia.
- 25:37And this ransomware, while it wasn't really that effective, made the company shut down their entire operations for a series of days.
- 25:45Now, Colonial Pipeline, many of us had no idea that it controls 43% of the petroleum products on the East Coast.
- 25:51Wow.
- 25:51Think about the impact that has on our economy, our daily life, uh, normal citizens.
- 25:57And it is this idea here that we've gotta be able to have a way of being able to prevent this.
- 26:03And so the way, yeah.
- 26:04I mean that's such a fascinating example, just to interject, because I think of ransomware affecting data systems in hospitals or at universities because that's, those are closer to my own, you know, working life as a leader.
- 26:16I can't even imagine the level of huge, huge challenge that it would pose to those cities and to those residents to suddenly not have access to fuel.
- 26:27So think about, you know, the fact that this nation has a number of people that operate in cyberspace, and they see what's going on.
- 26:33And if there was some way that they saw what was going on, and if they could anonymously and securely provide that information back to some central point of the government, and the government could then warn people before ransomware hit?
- 26:45Think about what a difference that would make.
- 26:47And you've called these people white hats, right?
- 26:48White hat hackers, white hat hackers.
- 26:50It's, it's fantastic.
- 26:51And I would tell you that, you know, we wanna be able to, to leverage that community that is interested in helping, but want to do it in a manner that doesn't necessarily shine an attention on them.
- 27:01And do white hat hackers sit happily trying to, um, chase down the bad guys because it's fun?
- 27:08Or because they feel a sense of duty? Or because they're just really good at what they do?
- 27:12What's the?
- 27:12So I think a, a little bit of all of those, right?
- 27:14Yeah.
- 27:14I think that that is a, a really good description of, you know, the DNA, that makes up a very, very good white hat hacker.
- 27:20And my thought is, "Hey, if you're really good at that and if you really see it, and if you could provide us warning, why wouldn't we wanna work with you?
- 27:26And so let's figure out how we do that." And that's a little bit of, you know, the, the work that we've done at the Wicked Problems Lab and being able to then say, "Okay, who in government should get this and how should we do it in a manner that can do this securely?" And then being able to transmit this very rapidly to a series of different potential victims.
- 27:41That's the idea of taking...
- 27:43Amazing.
- 27:44...a really hard problem, having some type of pragmatic solution and then getting to an outcome.
- 27:48And is there a way for people to be recognized as quiet heroes and for the that problem to be solved and no one knows that it's happened, right?
- 27:57You've essentially solved a crisis before it's become a crisis.
- 28:01How does that work in terms of morale or in terms of being able to motivate and mobilize people?
- 28:06So I think there's just a general sense, you know, within the internet community that the government just hasn't done enough.
- 28:13Yeah.
- 28:13And, and it's not gonna be able to do everything we need to.
- 28:15And so I think being part of that is in many times rewarding in and of itself, and being able to do that in a manner that you see, "Hey, this really is contributing to an open and free internet" is one of the things that I think is also part of the DNA of white hat hackers.
- 28:29Yeah.
- 28:29"I stepped up.
- 28:30And I'm continuing to maintain this as a system that's open and fair." That's right.
- 28:35Fascinating.
- 28:36I mean, I think that's...
- 28:37And then you have to have a really cool name, right?
- 28:38I mean, Yeah.
- 28:39How about Wicked Problems Lab, and then being able to, to be able to shine that and brand that and, and being able to say, "Oh, we're part of Vanderbilt University Institute of National Security." That gives us great pride.
- 28:48Amazing.
- 28:49And the, and and is it also strangely circuitous in terms of you're not contracting with a, a trusted provider of those services ... you're using somewhat, uh, you know what I would think of as sort of the irregular troops, right?
- 29:04Like a group of, of, of individuals who don't follow in the standard, you know, you will NDA, you will follow the nondisclosure agreement of your corporate hire, you know, employer.
- 29:14How does you know that sense of building a system or a solution?
- 29:18So I'm an economist at heart, and uh, I look at it as, as saying,"Oh my gosh, we're doing this at a fraction of the cost." Yeah.
- 29:24Almost no cost.
- 29:25Fascinating.
- 29:25And it's, if we provide just the seed corn here, think about how popular this could be and doing this in a manner that I think not only, uh, ensures a free and open internet, but also provides a degree of security for those of us that really have to rely on these goods and services.
- 29:40You mentioned rural hospitals.
- 29:42I mean, think about a rural hospital to getting hit by a ransomware attack and you know, the impact that it has with a hospital that probably has very, very small margins.
- 29:50Margins, right?
- 29:50A hospital that probably doesn't have the information technology staff that can be able to address this.
- 29:55Uh, this gives me great joy in terms of thinking about how powerful this can be in the future.
- 29:59Yeah.
- 29:59I mean, breaking open the fear that threats like that are only going to lead to pessimistic or scary outcomes, right?
- 30:07And very hopeful in the sense of, or at least optimistic in sense...
- 30:11in the sense of seeing a solution and then actually demonstrating that that solution is not just possible, but actually implementable, feasible, can be done soon.
- 30:20Any other of those, uh, wicked problems that you wish to share or do you want to keep them all close to the vest?
- 30:23We're at, we're at critical infrastructure, not only, but we're looking at, as, you know, Cybele, 16 different elements of critical infrastructure in our country.
- 30:30One of the things that we're looking at is how do we take one of those elements of critical infrastructure and then apply, uh, some very, very basic technology to be able to drive higher standards in terms of how they secure their networks and data.
- 30:44But also this idea of...
- 30:45And when you're talking critical infrastructure, I'm sorry to interrupt.
- 30:48Think about, think about water.
- 30:49Water.
- 30:49Think about power.
- 30:50Electricity.
- 30:50Think about, you know, our financial industry.
- 30:52Yep.
- 30:52Think about our transportation industry.
- 30:53Yep.
- 30:54Our defense.
- 30:54Electronic banking.
- 30:55Defense, industrial base.
- 30:56Exactly.
- 30:56And, and these 16 different sectors—some of them are well resourced and some of them are not.
- 31:02Yeah.
- 31:02And so if we can provide this advantage, you know, this competitive advantage, that "Hey, we're being able to really eliminate this concern about, you know, basic threats to your network and data," think how different that could be.
- 31:15And so, uh, I'll look forward to coming back hopefully in the future and talking about some of the successes that we've had at the Wicked Problems Lab.
- 31:20That's great.
- 31:21And I think our minds often jump in sort of standard sort of sci-fi way to technology meaning machines.
- 31:30And we don't often think about technology, meaning bio, you know, bioterrorism or biopharma or things pertaining to, you know, food supply or our, you know, health.
- 31:42How do we think about that in sort of soft systems?
- 31:45Do we only really think about security in terms of hardware or do and, and software, but, um, what do we do with security in sort of the more ... in the natural world?
- 31:56And I, it's a great question, and I was just, you know, thinking about really the, the critical component across all of those descriptions is the fact that you have to have talent.
- 32:05That's the biggest thing.
- 32:06Yeah.
- 32:06I ran an agency, the National Security Agency, that has incredible technology, really fascinating trade craft, but at the end of the day, the most important thing was talent.
- 32:14And so, coming back to the Wicked Problems Lab— let me talk about the talent, whether or not it's faculty...
- 32:19Who do you have there? How does it work?
- 32:19You have faculty here at Vanderbilt, whether or not it's, you know, people from the private sector that we've been able to recruit to come in, whether or not it's students.
- 32:27Yeah, and, and interesting, we have one of our best computer science majors who shared with us the other day,"Every single day I go in there, I feel like I am the ... the least capable person of them all." Mm-hmm.
- 32:36And you know, you know, one of the things we talk about is the fact that this is exactly the power of being able to work in radical partnerships because you learn so much from others.
- 32:45Yeah.
- 32:45Leaving this institution...
- 32:47And what was the computer science major telling you about?
- 32:49And she was just telling about working with these people that, you know, had spent, you know, a career looking at information technology and the way that you secure systems.
- 32:56And thinking about, "Oh my gosh, I'm just in my third year at Vanderbilt...
- 32:59And I'm just scratching the surface.
- 32:59...and I've just had this many computer science classes.
- 33:02Right.
- 33:02But I, I think the, the point of it here is that you leave an institution with that experience and that ability to have worked with people that have that type of talent.
- 33:11Yeah.
- 33:11This is nothing but really goodness for you.
- 33:14Yeah.
- 33:14Who mentor you...
- 33:15Exactly.
- 33:15...and support you and figure out with you what you wanna do next.
- 33:17You know, we learn from education, we learn from, you know, operational experiences, we learn from self-development.
- 33:22All of those three are really important.
- 33:24But I would tell you just coming out and having seen it and done it— there's nothing that replaces that.
- 33:28No, that's great.
- 33:29Totally great.
- 33:30In terms of this year's summit, focusing on AI and national security, what opportunities and risks do you see emerging from quantum computing, for example, from AI?
- 33:39What are some of the topics that you're most excited about, um, in this year's conference?
- 33:43Couple things that we're obviously very excited about— first of all is to, to hear really thought leaders, like first of all, Sam Altman.
- 33:50And then at lunchtime tomorrow we're gonna have Chris Miller, who wrote the book 'Chip War,' talk about the semiconductor industry and, and just the importance of semiconductors to everything we do in our life.
- 34:00But the other piece that's interesting is being able to listen to the panels, the six different panels that will take place throughout the two days.
- 34:06One panel that talks about,"Hey, what's AI's impact on the world and our national security?" One that talks about, "Hey, what's AI's impact on biopharma?" Yeah.
- 34:15You know, what is it going to be in terms of this disruptive technology— being able to bring such huge advancements in drug discovery or being able to understand really disease prevention?
- 34:24We have a panel that I'm gonna lead with our Indo Paycom partners.
- 34:27Mm-hmm.
- 34:27So our Indo-Pacific partners from both Japan and Singapore to talk about,"Hey, Japan, Singapore, Australia, how do you see artificial intelligence in your region of the world?" And then the one that I would share with you that I'm really looking forward to is Lt. Gen. (retired) "Tuna" Moore is gonna tomorrow conclude the last panel and talk about predictions for the future.
- 34:45Mm-hmm.
- 34:45Great.
- 34:46So tell us what's gonna happen in 2025 and guess what?
- 34:49In a degree of transparency, next year we'll say hey, "Here's what the panel said.
- 34:52How well did they do?" So we're very, very excited.
- 34:55And not to mention not only Senator Marsha Blackburn, but also Chairman and Congressman Mark Green gonna be able to appear on day two.
- 35:00It's a fantastic two days.
- 35:02Amazing lineup.
- 35:02Amazing.
- 35:04And in terms of predicting the future, you know, back to those unknown unknowns, right, the unknowable unknowns, would you think that you're gonna hit that about 40% correctly in terms of prediction? or 90% correctly?
- 35:17You know, how much do you feel that you can actually see around the corner?
- 35:20Yeah, I think that, you know, again, one of the things that, that we have to do, and we just are releasing a paper today on red teaming and being able to, you know, end the, the echo chamber of, of what happens in, in some of the efforts that we try to do to get after problems.
- 35:34I think we need to have these type of discussions, right?
- 35:36What are the different experts really thinking about as they look to both the opportunities and challenges of this really important technology?
- 35:43But also what are the opportunities and challenges that we have to do here in academia, and also we have to do as a broader nation to ensure we have the positives and minimize the negatives.
- 35:53Yeah, I mean, I think you consistently, um, really hit this point about being nimble, right?
- 35:59Being cognitively and, uh, technically nimble to address whatever that threat is or whatever that challenge is.
- 36:06And I find that really inspiring.
- 36:08I think often people think of academia as very, uh, slow-moving or very, um, committed to going deep and not necessarily to pivoting.
- 36:17And, you know, that's clearly a, a key feature of so much of what you've just discussed.
- 36:22In the aftermath of COVID-19, one of the things that I asked all of the leaders within the National Security Agency was,"Okay, so how many crises can we handle?" Great question.
- 36:32How many crises can we handle?
- 36:33Can, and did you come?
- 36:35And so "Well, we can handle one." Yeah.
- 36:36Why can't, why can't we handle six?
- 36:38Yeah.
- 36:38Why can't we handle eight?
- 36:39And I, it comes back to your point, I used the word agility.
- 36:42I, I wanna think about how do we become much more agile?
- 36:45Much more agile as an institute, much more agile as a university.
- 36:48And one of the ways we become much more agile is the fact that, first of all, we have really good technology that allows us to, to think and, and take in data much differently.
- 36:56Secondly, we have a series of partners that we've been able to say, "Hey, what are you seeing out there?
- 37:01What's going on here?
- 37:02What do, what do we compare notes here in terms of being able to end this echo chamber?" And the third part, the third part always comes back to education and training.
- 37:09Yeah.
- 37:09How do you ensure the people that you're working with are at the top of their game, and they really understand how to do critical thinking well, they're very, very good communicators and they have a strong degree of curiosity.
- 37:20Those are things that allow us to have greater agility.
- 37:23But I would tell you that in the world in which we live today, there's gonna be much more information tomorrow than there was yesterday.
- 37:29And I think that's...
- 37:29So so exactly right.
- 37:29...one of the things that we're gonna have to be able to do, is to figure out how we're gonna process that...
- 37:33Yeah.
- 37:33...and find the critical information that we need to be able to act on.
- 37:36Yeah.
- 37:36I see that even with using gen AI, for example, with my own team, it's taking us a lot longer to read the output than it does to write the prompt, right?
- 37:47And so how do we build in the patience to actually really take in and critically evaluate the output, right?
- 37:54And I think that notion of when to go fast and when to slow down enough to actually interpret the content is gonna be a challenge for us—getting used to things moving fast, right?
- 38:05Perhaps you can, uh, identify with this.
- 38:07Uh, when I was in college, I remember spending an inordinate amount of time on thinking about what I needed to major in.
- 38:13Do I major in this?
- 38:14Do I major in that?
- 38:14Do I minor in this?
- 38:15Do I double major?
- 38:16These were all questions that were just like, you know, coming at me...
- 38:19Bouncing around, right?
- 38:19Yeah, exactly.
- 38:20My mind.
- 38:20And then it was really interesting— I graduated and no one ever asked me, "Hey, Paul, what'd you major in?" But what they did want is they did want someone that could think critically.
- 38:28Yes.
- 38:29They did want someone that had an ability to communicate, and they did want someone that had a curiosity.
- 38:33To be able to approach that problem creatively.
- 38:35Exactly.
- 38:35Right.
- 38:35And see it from a different perspective.
- 38:37And so it didn't matter what I majored in.
- 38:38Yeah.
- 38:38It was the fact that I was able to think critically and I was able to communicate and I had a degree of curiosity that that was really important.
- 38:44Yeah.
- 38:44Amazing.
- 38:46I'm so excited for you for this, um, next few days and I really wanna wish you the best in, um...
- 38:51Thank you.
- 38:51...that level of creativity and that level of productivity and that level of inspiring problem solving.
- 38:57I think it's just an amazing lineup, and I'm thanking you so much for bringing that kind of leadership, um, here to Vanderbilt.
- 39:03But also together in the world for that kind of conversation.
- 39:06So that's a little bit about, you know, bringing the world to Vanderbilt.
- 39:09Yeah, yeah.
- 39:09But also us being able to, you know, in the future bring Vanderbilt to the world.
- 39:13To the world.
- 39:13Absolutely.
- 39:13I think that's an important piece of what we do.
- 39:15Yeah.
- 39:15Fascinating, too, to think about, you know—Singapore was not in my mental map as a a partner, and that's just great to expand that.
- 39:23Looking ahead in terms of the next five to 10 years, what does success look like for you, for the institute, for Vanderbilt and for this area of national security?
- 39:32Well, I think as we take a look at our four pillars, whether or not it's educate, innovate, convene, or advise, the next five years really is, you know, in terms of how we educate, we educate across both the undergraduate, the graduate and the executive ed program.
- 39:46Yeah.
- 39:46So I think within the next year or two, you're gonna see programs and all that.
- 39:49In the past six months, we were able to develop a minor.
- 39:52Now, I'm not sure how that's done in other universities, but I was a little surprised we could do that very quick.
- 39:56Oh, it's super fast.
- 39:57And so I was very proud of that.
- 39:58I'm very grateful to everyone that worked with you and to you for really leading it.
- 40:03And I think that as we take a look at innovate, I think, I mean, this is gonna be the signature issue of bringing Vanderbilt to the world.
- 40:09This is the Wicked Problems Lab.
- 40:10Yeah.
- 40:10This is being able to take a look and saying, "Hey, what's going on?" and then convene.
- 40:14I think it's not only convening here in Nashville, but I would see convening in our nation's capital, convening overseas.
- 40:19I, I think there's an opportunity for us to be able to, to bring what we've been able to do in this two-day summit to different places to be able to talk about it.
- 40:26And then the advise piece, uh, really two parts to that.
- 40:29I see in the next five years, it's not only the fact that we are really being able to satisfy our number one customer, the undergraduate student here, and being able to advise and assist them and being able to educate them in a manner that provides success in their futures.
- 40:42But it's also this idea that, hey, in the future, you know, maybe there's someone in D.C. that's gonna pick up the phone and say, "Hey, wonder what Vanderbilt's thinking today on this issue?" That's gonna be the success, and I think that that will come as well.
- 40:52Amazing.
- 40:54And just to take a minute on that point, I, you know, I think a lot about how much, um, so many of our faculty play a key role in that advising capacity.
- 41:03That in having conversations with people on the Hill, whether it's congressional leaders, whether it's policy leaders.
- 41:10Is it the case that you find mid-career professionals in policy and politics excited about AI?
- 41:16Or, uh, feeling, uh, beleaguered and stressed that they didn't catch up enough in computer science back in the day when they were undergrads?
- 41:24So I think there's really one of three ways that I see folks as they look at artificial intelligence.
- 41:28I look at any new technology, you know, it's either adapt or adopt or it's avoid.
- 41:34Yeah.
- 41:34We wanna make sure it's adapt...
- 41:36Yeah.
- 41:36...or adopt.
- 41:36I mean, think about, you know, 2007 when Steve Jobs launches, you know, the iPhone, how much that has changed exactly what we do in our lives today.
- 41:45Yeah.
- 41:45And the companies and the folks that adapted and adopted to it?
- 41:49They're huge today.
- 41:50Yeah.
- 41:50It's crazy to think that was less than 20 years ago.
- 41:52That's right.
- 41:52Yeah.
- 41:53That's right.
- 41:53And so that's, that's what I look for.
- 41:55Yeah.
- 41:55And that's what we're trying to enhance is that adapt, uh, and adopt.
- 41:59Yeah.
- 41:59I think that's really important.
- 42:00And I think, you know, many times the public perception of a university is very undergraduate-focused.
- 42:06And it's not as focused on the ways in which we can really promote lifelong learning, the ways that we can really support and advise, um, senior leaders as well as mid-career professionals.
- 42:15So I I, I'm very grateful for you carrying that message to the Hill and to other places around the world.
- 42:20It's really great.
- 42:21Um, in terms of one message you'd like to list, have listeners take away from this conversation, Paul, what is that call to action that you would really like to place out into the stratosphere, out into the world?
- 42:31Yeah.
- 42:31I mean, I come back to, Cybele, this idea of the world in which we live today has, you know, incredible amount of opportunities and a lot of challenges, and the way that we get after the challenges is through a series of partnerships.
- 42:42Remember the three circles that I talked about, whether or not it's government, whether that's the private, or whether or not it's academia.
- 42:47Hey, this is our circle.
- 42:48Let's make sure that we're part of that solution, because those problems aren't gonna go away, and these opportunities are here for us to be able to leverage today.
- 42:56Thanks to our listeners for tuning in.
- 42:58Remember to stay curious and keep exploring new ideas.
- 43:02We'll be back next time with another guest who's pushing the boundaries of discovery.
- 43:06Until then, I'm Cybele Raver, and this is 'Quantum Potential.' The 'Quantum Potential' podcast comes from Vanderbilt University.
- 43:23Your host is C. Cybele Raver.
- 43:26Thank you to our guest retired Gen. Paul Nakasone.
- 43:30Production by Matriarch Digital Media.
- 43:33For more information about'Quantum Potential,' go to vanderbilt.edu/quantum potential.
- 43:42Stay curious.