Latest / Her Life: Real stories of women, courage & change / Leaving the Church That Raised Me Behind Forever | Her Life
Transcript
- The door clicked shut, and for the first time in twenty years, I didn’t feel like I was being watched. It wasn’t a dramatic exit; it was just quiet, heavy, and entirely mine. I want you to picture the feeling of wool. Not the soft, cashmere kind that feels like a hug, but the scratchy, itchy wool of a stiff Sunday suit or a heavy coat you wore because that’s what good girls wore. For most of my life, that itch was part of the landscape. It was the texture of expectation. I grew up in a church where love was conditional on performance. You performed your faith, you performed your politeness, you performed your silence when things felt wrong, and in return, you got belonging. Or so we were told. Leaving isn’t usually a single moment. We think of it as a movie scene—music swelling, doors bursting open, someone shouting a truth. But real leaving is slow. It’s a series of small surrenders. It’s deciding not to answer the phone from the deacon board. It’s stopping the tithe before you can explain why. It’s letting the guilt sit in your chest like a stone and realizing you can still breathe around it. I spent decades trying to smooth out the wrinkles in my soul to fit into the pews. And then, one Tuesday, after a particularly exhausting service where I smiled until my cheeks hurt, I realized I couldn’t do it anymore. Not because I hated God, but because I loved myself enough to stop performing for an audience that never truly saw me. There are ghosts in every place that raised us. In my case, they were the whispers. The subtle comments about who married whom, who lost weight, who seemed too loud or too quiet. The church was a community, yes, but it was also a panopticon. Everyone was watching everyone else, judging the alignment of their lives against some invisible standard of holiness. When I started pulling away, the silence was louder than any sermon. I remember sitting in my car in the parking lot after one last service, gripping the steering wheel. My hands were shaking. I felt like I was betraying my grandmother, who had knitted my blankets with prayers stitched into the edges. I felt like I was abandoning the women who had held me when my father left, when my mother cried, when the world felt too big and scary. Leaving felt like cutting off a limb. It felt selfish. But here is what I learned in the stillness: staying out of fear is not loyalty; it’s self-betrayal. And self-betrayal is a much heavier burden to carry than loneliness ever was. I had to mourn the community I lost while grieving the person I was forced to be within it. That grief is real. It’s okay to miss the warmth even if the fire burned you. One of the hardest parts of leaving isn’t the theology; it’s the language. When you grow up in a specific spiritual ecosystem, you learn a dialect. You speak in phrases like 'God has a plan' or 'trust the process' or 'let it go.' These phrases become comfort mechanisms. They are the tools we use to soothe our anxiety, to make sense of suffering. When you leave, those words start to taste like ash. You hear them in your head, and instead of peace, you feel a flash of irritation. You realize how often those phrases were used to dismiss pain rather than honor it. 'Just pray harder' when you were depressed. 'Be grateful' when you were grieving. I had to relearn how to talk to myself. I had to find new words. Instead of 'it’s all for a reason,' I started saying, 'This hurts, and that’s valid.' Instead of 'God will provide,' I said, 'I am capable, and I will figure this out.' It took months to rebuild my internal vocabulary. I had to learn that discomfort doesn’t always have a divine purpose. Sometimes, it’s just pain. And acknowledging pain without wrapping it in religious cellophane is a radical act of honesty. It’s terrifying at first. You feel exposed, unanchored. But eventually, you realize that your own voice is a stronger anchor than any dogma. People ask me, 'Do you believe in God now?' And I smile, because the question assumes that God lives only in buildings or under certain doctrinal umbrellas. The truth is, leaving the church helped me find the sacred again. I started noticing it in the way light hits the floorboards in the morning. I found it in the deep, resonant silence of a forest hike. I found it in the messy, imperfect conversations with friends who don’t quote scripture but know how to hold space. I realized that the divine isn’t contained by walls. It’s in the breath between heartbeats. It’s in the courage it takes to be vulnerable. It’s in the kindness we show strangers. I don’t need a roof to feel connected to something larger than myself. In fact, having a roof sometimes made me forget to look up. This journey wasn’t about rejecting spirituality; it was about reclaiming it from the people who tried to monetize it or control it. I wanted a faith that was expansive, not restrictive. A faith that invited questions instead of demanding answers. I’m still building that. Some days it feels like constructing a cathedral from thin air. Other days, it feels like simply breathing. Both are holy. Now, let’s talk about the loneliness. Because it exists. There are weeks when I walk through town and see the church steeple, and I feel a pang of missing the routine. The predictability of Sunday. The knowing nod from the greeter. The structure. But then I meet my new people. They aren’t perfect. They don’t sing hymns. They argue about politics and cry over bad movies and show up with soup when I’m sick without asking if I’ve prayed about it. They see the cracks in my armor and don’t try to fix them. They just sit with me in the rubble. This is what I missed most. Not the rituals, but the radical acceptance. The understanding that I don’t have to earn my place at the table. I belong here because I am here. My presence is enough. This kind of community doesn’t demand your perfection; it celebrates your authenticity. It’s slower to form, yes. It requires more vulnerability. But it lasts. It’s built on truth, not tradition. And there is no greater foundation for a life well-lived. If I could go back and sit down with the girl in the scratchy wool suit, hiding in the back pew, afraid to raise her hand... I would tell her this: You are allowed to outgrow the containers that were meant to hold you for a season, not a lifetime. Your faith is yours. Your body is yours. Your story is yours. No one gets to write the ending for you. I would tell her that the gatekeepers of heaven are not the ones holding the keys. She is. She always has been. The power she thought was external was always internal. She just forgot how to access it. Leaving was hard. It was messy. I lost friends. I faced judgment. I had moments of profound doubt. But I gained myself. I gained the ability to say 'no' without apology. I gained the freedom to explore. I gained a relationship with the divine that is intimate, personal, and unmediated by bureaucracy. So if you are standing at the door right now, hand on the knob, heart pounding... take a breath. Feel the wood against your palm. Know that behind that door is not darkness, but possibility. And on the other side, there is a whole world waiting for the real you. The one who doesn’t need to perform. The one who just needs to be. You are seen. You are known. And you are exactly where you need to be. Until next time, I’ll be right here, listening. Bye for now.