Latest / In God We Trusted / American vs French Revolution: Who Got Liberty Right?
Transcript
- 0:11Welcome to God We Trusted. I'm your
- 0:13host, Will. I'm here alongside Sam. Sam,
- 0:14what are we talking about today? So,
- 0:16today we're going to be talking about a
- 0:17tale of two revolutions. And we're going
- 0:19to pit the American Revolution up
- 0:21against the French Revolution because I
- 0:23think there's some really important
- 0:25things to mine about worldview and how
- 0:28we approach the world from a biblical
- 0:30perspective or an atheist perspective.
- 0:32And these experiments, right, the French
- 0:34Revolution which was trying to to pursue
- 0:36the object of liberty and the American
- 0:39Revolution that was trying to do the
- 0:40same thing across the ocean. Both of
- 0:43these start at the same time coming at
- 0:47the goal from two entirely different uh
- 0:50foundations and you see how they play
- 0:52out and I think there's a lot to learn
- 0:54from it. Yeah, it's really fascinating
- 0:55to put them up against each other
- 0:56because like same time, same hope, very
- 1:00different ways of going about it and
- 1:01very different outcomes which is
- 1:03blatantly clear about why what happened
- 1:06happened. That's right. So if if you're
- 1:09walking around in France at this
- 1:11particular time in the late 1700s
- 1:13through the mid700s,
- 1:15you live in a culture where the church
- 1:18authentically is pretty oppressive. Like
- 1:20if you publish things that are against
- 1:22the church, there's huge consequences.
- 1:24It stifles free speech. It it is going
- 1:27after those things. And so if you're in
- 1:29the French libertarian mindset, you
- 1:31immediately have this idea that the
- 1:33church is bad for freedom. It's it's bad
- 1:35for liberty. And so everything that
- 1:37you're going to see come out of the
- 1:38French Revolution is like, okay, if we
- 1:40want liberty, what do we have to get rid
- 1:41of? The church, God, religion, it all
- 1:45has to go. But over in America, they
- 1:48have a different understanding where
- 1:49it's like, okay, well, we have the whole
- 1:51point of the reason why we started in
- 1:53large part at least was the pursuit of
- 1:55religious freedom. So people are free to
- 1:57worship as they choose. But we are going
- 2:00to base our entire system of liberty,
- 2:02our entire system of government on the
- 2:04idea that our rights come from God.
- 2:06We're doubling down on the idea of
- 2:09religion. And so you see one experiment
- 2:13entirely built upon the idea that your
- 2:16rights come from God and the other
- 2:19experiment saying in order for us to get
- 2:21liberty, we have to tear down all of the
- 2:23vestigages of God and get rid of him
- 2:24entirely. How do they play out? That's
- 2:27that's what I want to look at. Okay. So
- 2:29you talked about the French Revolution
- 2:30and the whole idea of get rid of God. So
- 2:32who are the guys behind it? Who are the
- 2:33thought provokers are saying, "Okay,
- 2:34let's go this route." Well, well, you
- 2:36have the guys that actually lead the
- 2:38French Revolution, but before them, you
- 2:40have some names that are laying the
- 2:42foundation in France for this kind of
- 2:44revulsion against the idea of religion.
- 2:47So, let's look at a few of them. One of
- 2:48them's name is Rouso. You could learn a
- 2:51lot about Rouso. I think he's a terrible
- 2:53philosopher. Um, he's he's essentially
- 2:57like feelings become important. He
- 2:59believes that man is basically good and
- 3:00institutions and society corrupts us,
- 3:03which is totally unbiblical. He would
- 3:05deny the idea that you're born with
- 3:07original sin and those things. But he
- 3:09also has a lot of animosity toward
- 3:11Christianity growing up in that world.
- 3:13He's listen I'll give you some of his
- 3:14quotes, right? He says, "I had been
- 3:16brought up in a church which decides
- 3:18everything and permits no doubts. So
- 3:21that having rejected one article of
- 3:23faith, I was forced to reject the rest."
- 3:26And so he's growing up again. And what
- 3:28is what does religion represent for him?
- 3:31>> Oppression. Ah, it's stifling. It's too
- 3:33much. You can't you can't have your own
- 3:35opinions. And he goes on and he says,
- 3:37"Christianity preaches only servitude
- 3:40and dependence. Its spirit is so
- 3:43favorable to tyranny that it always
- 3:46profits by such a regime." And so he
- 3:50goes on and talks about how religion
- 3:52presents these laws and it's only these
- 3:54laws like it invents this morality. Why
- 3:56do we accept it? We should have our own
- 3:58morality. Each person should kind of
- 4:00have their own thing, right? like why do
- 4:01we accept this oppressive thing that
- 4:03comes over us and makes us feel bad? Um
- 4:07and he says we should do well to inquire
- 4:10if these evils did not spring up with
- 4:13the laws themselves. In other words, all
- 4:14these things that we consider wrong are
- 4:16only wrong because we said the Bible has
- 4:18said they're wrong. Like there's no
- 4:20basis to call that wrong. We should make
- 4:22up our own morality as we go and we
- 4:24should do it together. We should all be
- 4:26free. We should overthrow religion
- 4:28because it breeds oppression and all
- 4:29these things. And so one of the big
- 4:31things that you find in Rouso's writings
- 4:34is talking about the general will. In
- 4:37other words, truth is not fixed and
- 4:38absolute. It is on the whims of what the
- 4:41general will is like the populace.
- 4:43>> Yeah. Today if if we feel like doing
- 4:45this, that's morality. And if we feel
- 4:47like doing this, that's morality. And we
- 4:49all have to covenant together to bring
- 4:51this about. Now, here's another
- 4:53interesting thing about Rouso. He hates
- 4:55religion, right?
- 4:56>> Yeah. So he's probably the dominant
- 4:58French philosopher that's going to pave
- 4:59the way toward the French Revolution.
- 5:02But he recognizes and he says this, no
- 5:04state has ever been founded without
- 5:06religion at its base. So he's looking
- 5:08back and he's like everything, you know,
- 5:10Rome, Greece, Babylon, all of them,
- 5:12they've all had Egypt, they've all had
- 5:14religion at the base. Like the the
- 5:16leaders appeal to the gods. He's like,
- 5:19"So we do need to have a religion." So
- 5:23he offers and creates something called a
- 5:25civil religion where there's no god by
- 5:27name. It's just yeah there's there's
- 5:29something out there. We'll we'll you
- 5:31know not give it a name but it'll just
- 5:33be something and we'll all have our
- 5:35rituals because people kind of need
- 5:36those but it's not Christianity. It's
- 5:38not Islam. It's nothing that's by name.
- 5:40It all centers around the state. And
- 5:43then he defines it right. This is this
- 5:46is what our chief mantra you know our
- 5:48dogma is. He says, "As for the negative
- 5:51dogmas, I would limit them to one single
- 5:54doctrine." You ready for it?
- 5:56>> Yeah.
- 5:57>> No intolerance.
- 6:00>> Does that Does that sound familiar?
- 6:01>> Yeah.
- 6:02>> Like
- 6:02>> thought that was a modern idea, not
- 6:04Rouso.
- 6:04>> That's Rouso. That's what sparks the
- 6:07French Revolution. Like you can't tell
- 6:09me I can't do anything. Like I'm getting
- 6:12rid of the oppressive structures that's
- 6:14around me. The only thing that's not
- 6:16tolerable is intolerance. Right.
- 6:19>> Yeah.
- 6:20>> Which is ironic. He says intolerance is
- 6:22something which belongs to the religions
- 6:24which we have rejected. It is impossible
- 6:26to live in peace with people one
- 6:28believes to be damned. And so he goes on
- 6:31this crusade of saying we got to get rid
- 6:34of religion and absolutes and the
- 6:37structures above us. Man is basically
- 6:39good. Let him run. Let him run. Get rid
- 6:41of all these things. He's basically the
- 6:43protocommunist essentially. And the the
- 6:46idea of the French Revolution was very
- 6:48much built on three words, liberty,
- 6:50equality, and fraternity. And they that
- 6:54would be their mottos all the time. Then
- 6:56you had a guy named Voltater. Voltater's
- 6:59famous French philosopher. We're not
- 7:01going to get into much of what he said,
- 7:03but I I want you to understand
- 7:06um why Voltier hated religion because I
- 7:09think there's something for us to learn
- 7:10in this. Um we don't want to create more
- 7:14volts. But listen to this. In Voltier's
- 7:16day, the French monarchy and the
- 7:18Catholic Church didn't just target
- 7:20Protestants. They targeted all religious
- 7:23minorities, including atheists. So in
- 7:251766, three decades before the
- 7:27revolution, Jean Francois de Labar, an
- 7:30atheist, was accused of showing
- 7:32disrespect toward Catholicism by singing
- 7:34blasphemous songs and defecating on a
- 7:37crucifix. So he sounds like a pleasant
- 7:38guy, right? I wasn't ready for
- 7:40defecated, right? Weird thing. Well, the
- 7:44court forced him to confess his crimes,
- 7:46then had his tongue cut out. All right,
- 7:48that seems like an overstep. Whoa. then
- 7:50ordered that he have his head cut off on
- 7:52a scaffold. His body and head will then
- 7:54be thrown on a p to be destroyed, burnt,
- 7:57reduced to ashes, and then these will be
- 7:59thrown to the wind. And then as a
- 8:01warning to Voltater and other atheists,
- 8:03the court order ordered Voltater's
- 8:06philosophical dictionary to be thrown by
- 8:08the executor on the same P as the body,
- 8:10which sent a message to Voltater, you
- 8:13come back where we can arrest you. Guess
- 8:15what's going to happen to you?
- 8:16>> Yeah,
- 8:17>> it's all these same things. So Voltater
- 8:19is like, "Whoa, the church and the
- 8:21government working together. This is not
- 8:23good. This is oppressive. This is not
- 8:25conducive to liberty." And he comes and
- 8:27says this, "Christianity is the most
- 8:30ridiculous, the most absurd and bloody
- 8:32religion that has ever infected the
- 8:35world."
- 8:36>> So he had strong feelings.
- 8:37>> Yeah. He's he's not a fan. He's he's
- 8:40definitely not a fan. And to be honest,
- 8:42if I lived in the under this brand of
- 8:45religion, I don't think I'd be a fan
- 8:48either.
- 8:48>> Fairly understandable,
- 8:49>> right? Like I'd be like, whoa, this is
- 8:50this is oppressive. It is gross. It is,
- 8:53you know, uh it's certainly not
- 8:56conducive to liberty. Um so, so we hit
- 8:59two. We hit Rouso, we hit Voltater.
- 9:01Here's another one. And I'm only
- 9:02throwing him in because his line is so
- 9:05rabid that it's like, holy smokes. But
- 9:07this guy's Denise Dero, another thinker
- 9:11right before the French Revolution. I
- 9:13mean, he died in 1784, 5 years before
- 9:15the French Revolution. But he said this,
- 9:18"Man will never be free until the last
- 9:22king is strangled with the endrails of
- 9:25the last priest."
- 9:28Dang. In other words, we need to stamp
- 9:31out the monarchy and
- 9:33>> by stamping out religion,
- 9:35>> the religion, right? So, this is the
- 9:38this is the ethos that's brewing in
- 9:40France. You have an oppressive church
- 9:42that's done some bad things that
- 9:43oversteps that is not conducive to
- 9:46liberty. And you have these people
- 9:47going, "God is the problem
- 9:49>> and we need to stomp it out ourselves.
- 9:51>> We're going to crush it." And so then
- 9:54you get the guy who's usually considered
- 9:56the most responsible for the French
- 9:58Revolution, Maxmillian Robes. And he
- 10:01says this, if the basis of popular
- 10:03government and peace time is virtue,
- 10:06then the basis of popular government
- 10:07during a revolution is virtue and
- 10:10terror. Virtue without which terror is
- 10:12baneful, terror without which virtue is
- 10:15powerless. What in the world did he just
- 10:17say? He's saying normally, like in
- 10:19America, let me give the contrast. In
- 10:21America, where did they think virtue
- 10:23came from?
- 10:24>> Religion. Like what you believe about
- 10:26ultimate things ultimately fashions the
- 10:29way that you live, right? Our founders
- 10:32said things like man will either be
- 10:34governed by a p power within or a power
- 10:37without like talking about the
- 10:38government either by the Bible or the
- 10:40bayonet. Our founder said so in French
- 10:43culture it was like no it's not
- 10:45religion. Morality does not come from
- 10:47religion. Morality comes from terror.
- 10:50This is actually the word he uses,
- 10:52right? You know, the French word, but
- 10:54it's actually the word he uses. Like,
- 10:55why are people going to be virtuous? Why
- 10:57are they going to comply with this?
- 10:58Because if they don't, they're going to
- 11:00die.
- 11:00>> Yeah.
- 11:01>> They're going to die. And so,
- 11:02everybody's going to come kumbaya into
- 11:04this new system of liberty or we'll kill
- 11:07them. Like that's they will be compelled
- 11:10to this. And that's exactly the way the
- 11:13French Revolution started. Because
- 11:14otherwise, how do you compel them? This
- 11:16is this is like going back to communism.
- 11:18When Markx writes about communist
- 11:20revolutions and get rid getting rid of
- 11:22God because he's an obstacle to the what
- 11:24we're trying to accomplish,
- 11:26he's like, "It's going to require
- 11:28revolution. It's going to be violent.
- 11:29Like, there's going to be some broken
- 11:30eggs here. Like, we're going to have to
- 11:32kill some people to bring this about."
- 11:34Like, nobody hides that. At the
- 11:35beginning of the French Revolution, you
- 11:37have its founder being like, "Yeah,
- 11:38terror is coming. We're going to bring
- 11:40this and if you stand in our way, you
- 11:42should be terrorized." It's like, "Oh,
- 11:44boy. Can't wait for liberty." You know,
- 11:46cuz like if you have somebody who's
- 11:48holding presenting that like I'm going
- 11:50to get my way or you're going to be
- 11:52terrorized. Do you feel like they're
- 11:53doing the same thing that the Catholic
- 11:56Church was doing? You either
- 11:58>> abide by what we say or we're going to
- 12:00tongue and
- 12:01>> chop off your head then burn you for
- 12:03some reason,
- 12:04>> which is virtue by terror. And then he
- 12:06comes and goes, "No, I got a better
- 12:07idea. How about virtue by terror?
- 12:08>> I'm just going to be in charge of it,
- 12:10>> right? I get to determine who's
- 12:11terrorized." And so one of the things
- 12:13that is is not taught enough when we
- 12:16learn about the French Revolution, if we
- 12:19learn about the French Revolution in
- 12:20school, I don't know if you were taught
- 12:21that.
- 12:21>> I don't think I did.
- 12:22>> But they began a very systematic program
- 12:26of dchristianizing France.
- 12:28>> That's the first step.
- 12:29>> First step. I mean, and they went all
- 12:31in. So like like I'm just going to walk
- 12:32through some things and we'll see like,
- 12:35okay, great. This is the atheistic
- 12:38experiment. You know, we're going to see
- 12:39how this works out. 1790, one year after
- 12:42it starts, the civil constitution of the
- 12:44clergy um comes along and it made it
- 12:48made all clergy employees of the
- 12:50government's new civil religion. So if
- 12:52you were a priest of the Catholic
- 12:53Church, if you were a minister in a
- 12:55Protestant religion, if you still want
- 12:56to be clergy, guess what religion you're
- 12:58going to advocate for?
- 13:00>> The government's
- 13:00>> the government's civil religion. And if
- 13:03not, you're going to be arrested,
- 13:05jailed, murdered. It outlawed the
- 13:07collections of tithes by the church. So
- 13:10the Catholic Church, you know, 10% of
- 13:12income given to support the works of
- 13:13ministry outlawed. The church is no
- 13:16longer allowed to collect money. They
- 13:17seized and sold all the properties owned
- 13:20by the Catholic Church, which at this
- 13:22time 6.5% of all of France was owned by
- 13:25the Catholic Church. They took it. All
- 13:27the schools, all the seminaries, all the
- 13:29churches now became government property.
- 13:32their hospitals, their monasteries,
- 13:34their convents, public services gone and
- 13:37seized by the church or by the state.
- 13:40Then they start persecuting the church.
- 13:42Death sentences on any defiant
- 13:44clergymen. They forced churches to close
- 13:47that wouldn't go along. They outlawed
- 13:49religious education in the schools
- 13:51except for the new civil religion. And
- 13:53they had statues throughout France that
- 13:55were religious of saints or Jesus or
- 13:58they're all decapitated to remind them
- 14:00of Marie Antuinette's fate who was
- 14:02beheaded, right? And so it was like
- 14:05warning, if you go down this road,
- 14:07you're going to lose your head. So two
- 14:09dozen statues outside Notre Dame
- 14:11Cathedral destroyed. and the goddess
- 14:14reason. They had a statue for the
- 14:16goddess reason enthroned inside notre
- 14:19Dame Cathedral as like a a provocative
- 14:22dancers all around it and everything
- 14:24else.
- 14:24>> So it's like this is our god now.
- 14:26>> Yeah. We don't believe in your stupid
- 14:28fairy tale god. We're we've got reason,
- 14:31right? And that's going to be a big word
- 14:32in the French Revolution. We've got
- 14:34reason now. We know things. We don't
- 14:37need religion. And so the new French
- 14:39government abolished the Gregorian
- 14:41calendar,
- 14:43imposed a 10-day week instead of seven.
- 14:45Why? What's where's the seven-day week
- 14:47come from?
- 14:48>> Creation. It's creation. It's a biblical
- 14:50thing. Well, no, we're not doing that
- 14:51anymore. 10day week. We're getting rid
- 14:52of everything biblical. They create this
- 14:56absurd. It's literally called the
- 14:58festival of the supreme being. It's like
- 15:01no name to it or anything, but we
- 15:03acknowledge there has to be. It's like
- 15:04an agnostic thing. Like there's
- 15:06something out there. We'll just call it
- 15:08a generic. And so they have a festival
- 15:10of the supreme being which sounds like
- 15:12>> North a North Korean holiday
- 15:15>> really like it's true. So they launched
- 15:19the reign of terror which was the plan
- 15:21all along and there was such an extreme
- 15:24bloodlust and you had the guillotine
- 15:26which became famous during this where
- 15:28they would and chop off heads. Estimated
- 15:3116,594
- 15:33people were officially put to death. At
- 15:36least 12,000 people were murdered
- 15:38without a trial. 10,000 people were left
- 15:40to die in prison. And in 1794, the guy
- 15:43that was like considered the leader of
- 15:45the French Revolution, guess what
- 15:46happened to him? He lost his head in the
- 15:49guillotine. And that's the way that
- 15:51these godless revolutions always work.
- 15:53Like they eventually turn and they eat
- 15:55their master
- 15:56>> and then it just continue like it's a
- 15:58continual cycle of devouring everything.
- 16:00And so the the hilarious tragic part of
- 16:04this French Revolution is you have a
- 16:05bunch of people who come together and
- 16:06they're like, "We feel oppressed, right?
- 16:08We feel oppressed by the monarchy. We
- 16:10feel oppressed by the church. So we're
- 16:12going to overthrow it so that we can get
- 16:14real liberty." And it results in
- 16:16bloodshed, revolution after revolution
- 16:19after revolution that ends with
- 16:22Napoleon.
- 16:24So it's like yeah we we don't want we
- 16:25don't want a tyrant you know we don't
- 16:27want someone who singularly holds all
- 16:29the power and where does it end it ends
- 16:32with Napoleon who seizes power in a coup
- 16:36da and then launches on all of Europe
- 16:40one of the greatest invasions that ends
- 16:42up with three and a half million
- 16:44Europeans dead
- 16:46>> and the Napoleonic wars that he brings
- 16:48it about which makes it almost the same
- 16:51casualty rate if you adjust for
- 16:52populations that you saw in World War I.
- 16:55This is all because of the instability
- 16:57of France which rejected God and
- 17:00launched all these bloody revolutions
- 17:02thinking I can get liberty if I just get
- 17:05rid of God and his absolute truths that
- 17:08will bring about this wonderful utopia
- 17:10of brotherhood and equality and liberty
- 17:14and they got none of them. There was no
- 17:16brotherhood. There was no equality.
- 17:18There was no liberty. When they expelled
- 17:20God, the nation became
- 17:24just an upheaval, convulsing from one
- 17:27bloody movement to the next. So that's
- 17:29the French Revolution. No matter what we
- 17:31remember about it, no matter what we
- 17:32look back, it's bloody. It's one filled
- 17:34with terror. And the cause is that it
- 17:37was one without God specifically.
- 17:40>> And the funny thing is there's another
- 17:41revolution going on in America around
- 17:43the same time that is very different in
- 17:46almost all aspects.
- 17:47>> Yeah, that's right. George Washington's
- 17:49first year as president was the year the
- 17:51French Revolution started.
- 17:53>> Okay?
- 17:53>> He he's president for eight years and
- 17:55when he leaves he takes a shot at the
- 17:57French in his farewell address. Remember
- 17:59remember what was enthroned in Notre
- 18:01Dame Cathedral?
- 18:02>> The goddess of reason.
- 18:04>> Reason that's their word. They love
- 18:05reason.
- 18:06>> And this is what Washington says. He
- 18:08says reason and experience both forbid
- 18:11us to expect that national morality can
- 18:14prevail and exclusion of religious
- 18:17principle. So what is Washington saying?
- 18:19He's like never in America do we want to
- 18:22get rid of religion. That's the basis of
- 18:24morality. In France they want virtue by
- 18:26terror. In America we want virtue by
- 18:29religion. We want to promote that.
- 18:31Right? You have guys like Alexander
- 18:33Hamilton that's looking at the French
- 18:34Revolution and he calls it a disgusting
- 18:37spectacle and listen to what he writes.
- 18:39Like when he when he's condemning it,
- 18:41this is what he says.
- 18:42>> The attempt by the rulers of a nation to
- 18:45destroy all religious opinion and to
- 18:48pervert a whole nation to atheism is a
- 18:51phenomenon of wickedness. To establish
- 18:54atheism on the ruins of Christianity is
- 18:56to deprive mankind of its best
- 18:58consolations and most animating hopes
- 19:01and to make a gloomy desert of the
- 19:03universe. Like all of the founders that
- 19:06were speaking up against the French
- 19:08Revolution, they were like it you can't
- 19:10do that. Like this is going to be
- 19:12bloody. It's going to be awful. We can
- 19:13never do that in America. We always have
- 19:15to have God as our core. Like he is the
- 19:18basis of everything we're building here.
- 19:20He's the source of our morality. He's
- 19:21the source of our liberty. Everything we
- 19:24do is based on that. Like everything.
- 19:27And you have a guy, a French historian
- 19:29who comes over in 1835 to write about
- 19:32our prison system. Very famous author
- 19:34named Alexis Detoqueville. And he comes
- 19:37over from France. So he's witnessed all
- 19:39this stuff. He's witnessed what they've
- 19:40done. And he's seen like the animosity
- 19:43toward religion. And listen to what he
- 19:44says when he comes to America and
- 19:46writes. He's he writes a book called
- 19:48Democracy in America. And he says,
- 19:50quote, "The Americans combine the
- 19:53notions of Christianity and of liberty
- 19:56so intimately in their minds that it is
- 19:59impossible to make them conceive of the
- 20:01one without the other." And with them,
- 20:04this conviction does not spring from
- 20:06that barren traditionary faith which
- 20:10seems to vegetate rather than to live in
- 20:12the soul. So what is he looking at? He's
- 20:14leaving France with all of its
- 20:15Catholicism and rituals and smells and
- 20:17bells and all that other stuff. And he's
- 20:19like, "Nobody believes it. Nobody loves
- 20:20Jesus. There's no personal relationship
- 20:22over there." And what does it result in?
- 20:24It results in oppression. It's just used
- 20:26for power grabs. But over here in
- 20:28America, like it doesn't just vegetate.
- 20:30It lives in the soul. Like it is
- 20:33powerful. And they can't imagine liberty
- 20:36without this idea of a God who loves
- 20:38them, that watches over them, that
- 20:40provides their liberties, that they owe
- 20:42a duty to. It animates everything about
- 20:45them over here. And it's he's aed by it
- 20:48because he's leaving France. He's never
- 20:50seen that there. But now he's like, "No,
- 20:52no, no." Like liberty really does need
- 20:55this, but it needs to be a healthy
- 20:58faith. It cannot be this oppressive
- 21:00theocratic, you know, power grab kind of
- 21:02faith. It's got to be like, I love
- 21:05Jesus. I want to follow after Jesus.
- 21:07What would he have for us kind of devout
- 21:10thing? But without religion,
- 21:12absolute catastrophes happen. And so
- 21:15like I want to close I guess with just
- 21:17kind of the four main ideas that you
- 21:19find in America that you don't find in
- 21:22France. And I think we can learn from
- 21:24this, right? So the first one, the most
- 21:25obvious is, and I use the acronym rail,
- 21:28R A I L. And it's a helpful way to
- 21:31remember these, but in America, you had
- 21:32an absolute dependence on religious
- 21:35principles. Yeah.
- 21:36>> We believe that our rights come from
- 21:37God. We that's the basis of it.
- 21:40Government exists to secure the
- 21:41blessings of liberty. God is the source
- 21:44of the liberties. We're endowed by our
- 21:45creator with certain inalienable rights.
- 21:48The declaration says so it's built on
- 21:50our religion, right? Francis like get
- 21:53rid of it. The next one is absolutes.
- 21:57The Americans believed that there was a
- 21:59truth beyond man's opinion, right? And
- 22:02that it was the duty of good governance
- 22:04to chase after to find what's true and
- 22:07then bless the people by conforming to
- 22:10the design of the creator. Right? There
- 22:12are absolutes. What is Rouso saying? Oh,
- 22:15it's all just so oppressive. Anything
- 22:16that's absolute, it needs to be the
- 22:18general will. We'll figure it out as we
- 22:19go.
- 22:20>> No. America was like, absolutely not.
- 22:23There are absolutes. There is such a
- 22:25thing as truth. That's number two. The
- 22:27third one is an I. And it's the
- 22:29individual, the rights of the
- 22:30individual. Right.
- 22:31>> The general will.
- 22:32>> That's right. the general will where
- 22:34where they would say like uh you know
- 22:37here's the group and if you're against
- 22:38it if you're against where we're going,
- 22:40you know, we're going to terrorize you
- 22:41or decapitate you or if you stand
- 22:43against what we're trying to do, you're
- 22:44dead. Like this is like no no the
- 22:46individual has protections from the mob,
- 22:49right? That's that's where our bill of
- 22:51rights comes from. It's not a permission
- 22:53of, hey, you're allowed the government's
- 22:55going to allow you to speak. It's like
- 22:56no, Congress is not allowed to make a
- 22:58law that would impede on your right to
- 23:01worship or to speak or to publish things
- 23:03and to press or to own weapons or you
- 23:05know, you go down the line. The
- 23:07individual matters in America. In
- 23:10France, it was the general will like
- 23:12under the guise of liberty. But here
- 23:14it's like no, no, no, the individual
- 23:15matters because every single person is
- 23:17made in the image of God. They cannot
- 23:19have their rights taken away without due
- 23:21process. You have a absolute right to
- 23:23life, liberty, and due process. Like all
- 23:26of that was absolutely foundational in
- 23:29America. France not so much. And then
- 23:31the last one is limited government. The
- 23:35whole basis of the constitution was not
- 23:38to like give a government that can be
- 23:40big enough to build this utopian society
- 23:42that the French were looking at like,
- 23:44oh, we're going to be this great
- 23:45brotherhood and the government's going
- 23:46to make it happen and it's going to be
- 23:48so empowered that it can just oppress
- 23:50whoever stands in its way. the
- 23:51Leviathan, you know, they used to say,
- 23:53is going to be so big and powerful and
- 23:55unrestrained that we it'll be able to do
- 23:57whatever it wants. In America, they were
- 23:59like, "Oh, dear Lord, no." Like, we do
- 24:03not want a Leviathan that's unrestrained
- 24:06that can go and oppress people and have
- 24:08the power to do whatever it wants. So,
- 24:10they wrote a constitution that said,
- 24:12"We're going to limit it in a million
- 24:13different ways. We're to pass a law, you
- 24:15need to have these people and these
- 24:16people and checks and balances and
- 24:18separation of powers and so many other
- 24:20things." I mean, and a constitution that
- 24:23says government may not do this. You
- 24:24read the Bill of Rights, it's government
- 24:26may not do this, government may not do
- 24:28this, government may not do this,
- 24:29government may not do this. Where the
- 24:31French were like, let's build something
- 24:32and set it free to go do all these
- 24:35things. Our founders were like, protect
- 24:37the individual and restrain the
- 24:40government.
- 24:41>> That was the path to liberty. When you
- 24:42put those together, a dependence on
- 24:45religious ideals, God is the source of
- 24:47liberty. God is the source of truth. We
- 24:50have a duty to God, right? Not the
- 24:52government. Government's not giving you
- 24:54your liberties. God is. Next one. A
- 24:57absolutes. There is a truth beyond our
- 24:59opinions. We don't just go find it and
- 25:02whims and everything else. Like there is
- 25:05a designer behind all this and we our
- 25:08job is to conform to the designer's
- 25:11will, right?
- 25:12>> Which is biblical ideas, natural law.
- 25:15The next one, rights of the individual.
- 25:18Like the mob doesn't have sway over the
- 25:20individual. And then lastly, we're going
- 25:23to restrain the government. When you
- 25:25look at those two experiments running
- 25:27side by side on train tracks right next
- 25:29to each other, the French said, "We
- 25:31don't need any of those rail. We're
- 25:34going off the rails.
- 25:34>> We're going on terror.
- 25:36>> We're going off the rails. We're
- 25:39rejecting God. It's gonna But that same
- 25:42all those same ethics are behind Marxism
- 25:45and communism and socialism and they
- 25:47always end the same way. Every time
- 25:49they're tried in humanity's history, it
- 25:52always ends with the marginalized being
- 25:53exploited,
- 25:55run down, starved.
- 25:58And America saying, "No, no, no. We're
- 26:00going to build a society that's based on
- 26:02biblical truths. We recognize the fallen
- 26:05nature of humanity, that no one can be
- 26:06trusted with power, that our rights come
- 26:08from God." Like when that was tried, it
- 26:11unleashed the most successful
- 26:13constitutional republic in the history
- 26:15of the world.
- 26:17>> And I would say for the last 60 years or
- 26:19so, we have been veering away from it
- 26:23like, well, let's remove God as the
- 26:25basis of things. Well, you know, the
- 26:27individual h that's kind of
- 26:29uncomfortable. So, let's take those
- 26:31rights away. Let's unleash the
- 26:33government to do more and to grow its
- 26:35budget. Everything that made America
- 26:38wonderful and set apart in the history
- 26:40of the world, we're now looking at and
- 26:42being like, maybe we should be a little
- 26:43bit more like the French.
- 26:45>> Mhm.
- 26:46>> And I just want to say no.
- 26:50Learn from history and get back to the
- 26:52ideals
- 26:54that made the nation flourish.
- 26:58If you love your neighbor, you want your
- 27:01neighbor to live in a government that's
- 27:04going to allow for his flourishing. That
- 27:08doesn't happen in these oppressive
- 27:10regimes. It happens in a regime. Whereas
- 27:13Dtoqueville said, there's a faith that's
- 27:16not just vegetative,
- 27:17>> it lives. And liberty is so intertwined
- 27:21with that that you can't see one without
- 27:23the other. That's what I would love to
- 27:25see, you know, and I think one of the
- 27:26things that that we're going to do in a
- 27:28lot of these episodes is look back at
- 27:30historical examples to show that
- 27:32biblical wisdom works, right?
- 27:35>> It's wisdom for a reason.
- 27:37>> It's wisdom for a reason. There's a
- 27:38great uh historian, Greek historian
- 27:41whose name was Thusidities. And one of
- 27:43his lines, it's one of my very favorite
- 27:45ways of of seeing history and philosophy
- 27:47all tied together. But he says history
- 27:51is philosophy teaching by example,
- 27:54right?
- 27:54>> So when you come across an idea and
- 27:56you're like, "Hey, what if we tried
- 27:58this?" The best thing you can do is to
- 28:00go back in history and and say like,
- 28:02"Did someone try this before us?" how it
- 28:03work because right if you don't learn
- 28:06from history what's the line those who
- 28:08don't learn from history are doomed to
- 28:10repeat it so let's go back in history
- 28:13have we tried this before like have we
- 28:15tried a society that walks away from God
- 28:17we tried all these things how did it
- 28:18work out have we have we seen societies
- 28:21that draw near to the Lord with vibrant
- 28:22faith like how did that work out
- 28:24>> and then map our course forward by
- 28:27looking at what has been before and
- 28:29that's what I wanted to do today let's
- 28:31not go to the French Revolution Let's
- 28:33renew the beautiful things about the
- 28:36American Revolution. And I think that's
- 28:37where we will end for today. All right.
- 28:41I want to thank you so much for
- 28:42watching. Join us next time on In God We
- 28:45Trust.