Latest / Columbus' Morning News / Are the Intel delays old news?
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: I wanted to spend some time talking to our next guest.
- 0:02I saw an op ed in the Dispatch and it
- 0:04caught my eye. I thought it was really well done.
- 0:06Let's welcome in Phil Daryll on a Legacy Retirement Group
- 0:09dot com phone line. Phil is a guy who started
- 0:13a business and in the New Albany area industrial distribution business,
- 0:16served time on the New Albany Plain Local Board of Education.
- 0:20And this op ed piece or opinion piece in the
- 0:23Dispatch on the Intel, which I'm now Phil affectionately calling
- 0:27the world's largest and most expensive concrete slab in Licking County.
- 0:31Speaker 2: Good morning, how are you, sir?
- 0:33Speaker 3: I'm doing well? Thank you? How about you?
- 0:35Speaker 2: Great?
- 0:36Speaker 1: Thanks for spending a couple of times a time with
- 0:38moments with us this morning, so we know the story.
- 0:41Last week there's another announcement from Intel announcing a delay
- 0:46in their operation and getting the semiconductor plant up and running.
- 0:51That plant, by the way, was supposed to be up
- 0:53and running like now, like this year. As we speak,
- 0:56it's now twenty thirty one, maybe even longer. And this
- 1:00CEO even said we may have to pull the plug
- 1:02all together if we can't get customers set up before
- 1:05I think twenty twenty seven, twenty twenty eight.
- 1:08Speaker 2: So it's kind of gotten sideways. Phil.
- 1:11Speaker 1: You live in the area, you deal with that, you
- 1:13talk to people, You're seeing what's going on out there,
- 1:16what's your read.
- 1:18Speaker 4: Well, as I wrote in my column, I think the
- 1:20plant will eventually get built. I'm not as confident that
- 1:25Intel will be the one to finish building it. Intel
- 1:28has quite a few of their own challenges. They really
- 1:32lost their market leadership over the last decade or so
- 1:37and they're trying to play catchup.
- 1:40Speaker 3: And the biggest challenge.
- 1:41Speaker 4: With them building and running this plant is that they
- 1:46need external customers. They need other chip makers to want
- 1:50to use this fabrication facility.
- 1:54Speaker 3: To build their chips.
- 1:56Speaker 4: And I'm not sure that Intel is going to be
- 1:59successful in that bench. They might be, but I still
- 2:02think the project goes forward because of all of the
- 2:06work that's already been done does lend itself to building
- 2:10a chip plant, and so even if Intel doesn't do it,
- 2:13somebody else probably will.
- 2:16Speaker 1: So they've got what about seven billion already literally in
- 2:21the ground there and in poured concrete and some of
- 2:23these very specific uh you know, slabs, and they've got
- 2:29to put these pads in and that that's the hard part, right,
- 2:32that they already have done that lends itself to being
- 2:34a semiconductor plant.
- 2:37Speaker 4: Yeah, I mean, sixty foot thick concrete slabs is a
- 2:41pretty big deal. But frankly that could be covered up.
- 2:45You know they can. They can cover it up, build
- 2:47something else there. And you know, businesses are aware of
- 2:51the sunk cost fallacy that just because Intel spent seven
- 2:54billion dollars doesn't mean they should spend another twenty one
- 2:57billion dollars to finish the plant and and not have
- 3:01any customers for it. So I think just as much
- 3:05as those slabs, I think that an even bigger issue
- 3:08is the environmental control systems that are already on site.
- 3:13Those are really purpose built for this sort of operation.
- 3:17So I think the plant gets built and will be
- 3:20making chips.
- 3:21Speaker 3: I just don't know exactly.
- 3:22Speaker 2: When, when, or and who will ultimately be running that.
- 3:25Speaker 1: Speaking with Phil Daryl, he's got an op ed piece
- 3:28in the Dispatch and his column there on the future
- 3:30of Intel. So you know, I've heard that a company
- 3:34like Oracle, who does similar work, could come in and
- 3:39take over the facility. They I've heard that they may
- 3:42even just come in and just take over Intel, and
- 3:44Intel goes away as we know it.
- 3:46Speaker 2: If you've heard anything like that, I.
- 3:48Speaker 4: Don't have any specifics on that.
- 3:51Speaker 3: You know, it's a wide open field.
- 3:53Speaker 4: There are other chip makers in the world that you know,
- 3:56probably wouldn't mind having a presence here, especially with the
- 4:00push of this administration, and I think a correct push
- 4:04to assure that we have advanced chip making capability in
- 4:10our in the continental US. As I wrote in the
- 4:14column during COVID, it really exposed our vulnerabilities there. You know,
- 4:18we couldn't we couldn't ship cars. We our military depends
- 4:23on chips that we get from Taiwan. You know, if
- 4:27if things go badly in Taiwan, we're in trouble.
- 4:31Speaker 1: Have have they received any of the chips Act money?
- 4:35Maybe a portion of it, or any of it at all?
- 4:38Speaker 4: Okay, now a small portion. I don't know the exact number.
- 4:40I think it's you know, as I started the column,
- 4:44it says, you know, a billion here, seven billion there.
- 4:47Pretty soon we're talking real money. I think Intel has
- 4:50gotten from the from taxpayers, you know, a billion or two.
- 4:55It's a lot of money, but yeah, it's some of
- 4:59the money has been spent.
- 5:00Speaker 1: I'd be curious if there's any any clawback clauses, if
- 5:04this thing continues to just stutter along, if there's people
- 5:08going to go, I want my money back, because if
- 5:10we've got two point two billion already invested from the
- 5:14taxpayer dollars, it's like, hey, what's going on here?
- 5:17Speaker 4: There are clawback provisions there. You know, it's a pretty
- 5:20good in MS in terms of government support for private industry.
- 5:25I think the agreements are pretty solid.
- 5:27Speaker 3: But if things go.
- 5:28Speaker 4: Really badly for Intel, who you're going to get.
- 5:30Speaker 3: The money from.
- 5:30Speaker 2: Yeah, well it's a good point.
- 5:33Speaker 4: But you know, look, this isn't This is hardly the
- 5:35first time this has happened. There was, you know, over
- 5:38a decade ago, there was you know, a big hoopla
- 5:40over hundreds of millions of dollars given to Celindra for
- 5:45you know, I think of solar energy, right, and there's
- 5:48half a dozen other green energy projects that have gone
- 5:51belly up that were funded by the government.
- 5:53Speaker 3: So this is hardly this is hardly news.
- 5:56Speaker 4: It's one of the reasons I'm not a big fan
- 5:58of government support for such things.
- 6:00Speaker 1: Phil What are you hearing from folks in the area
- 6:03You know, a lot of people came in and they
- 6:05snapped up land and just to be a part of
- 6:07the intel orbit, if you will. Other secondary tertiary type businesses.
- 6:14Are these people sort of sitting on these plots of
- 6:16land not knowing quite what.
- 6:17Speaker 2: To do with it.
- 6:19Speaker 4: Sure, that's you know, private business. Private investors take risks.
- 6:25They don't all pan out, they don't all pan out
- 6:27in the time they want, and that's how it goes.
- 6:31But again, I think the plant will get built five
- 6:34years later.
- 6:35Speaker 3: Yeah, Look, the.
- 6:36Speaker 4: Twenty twenty five timeline was never reasonable when you saw
- 6:39how complex the plants were going to be, that was
- 6:42never gonna happen. Twenty twenty eight was the doable from
- 6:47a reality point of view. And you know, I know
- 6:50it's in the news as new news, but these delays
- 6:54really were announced back in February, and all of the
- 6:59press that we're seeing now is really related to the
- 7:01February announcement. There's some details about needing external customers and blah.
- 7:06Speaker 3: Blah blah, but really it is it's old news. It's
- 7:10just it's back in the news.