Latest / Gabriel Ellis, PhD | The Curious Mind Podcast / Therapy Recording Sessions - "Anna", part 6/6
Transcript
- 0:01This is the cure is mine podcast.
- 0:03My name is Gabriel Ellis and welcome to the last episode of
- 0:07my therapy sessions with my client, Anna.
- 0:13In this last of six episodes, she summarizes the insights that
- 0:18you had about the family Dynamics, especially the
- 0:25individual needs of her siblings.
- 0:28And now also taking into account, the needs of her
- 0:32father, and her mother separately beyond that she
- 0:38approaches the question of how to interact with them and during
- 0:42the Conversation. We come to realize that there is
- 0:46a certain risk that you falls into the same role that you had
- 0:52previously, which is the caretaker, the connector the
- 0:56oldest sibling, which takes responsibility for keeping the
- 1:00family together, and I encouraged her to go beyond that
- 1:05more narrow. Self-definition as her as a
- 1:09family member and to contemplate.
- 1:13The question to whom she can also open up about her needs and
- 1:19what she needs from them. To show the vulnerability that
- 1:24she has from her position and to avoid the Trap of wanting to be
- 1:30perceived only as the giver and the strong one from the outside.
- 1:36We jump back into the conversation at a point where,
- 1:40and reflects the possibilities of her giving, something back to
- 1:45her family and specifically, to be a listener to her mother.
- 1:52Who might be involved too closely with her siblings at
- 1:56home and the possibility for Anna to be to her mother, the
- 2:01one who patiently listens, who understands her concerns and who
- 2:06can properly take into account. Her need is an agent woman who
- 2:11wants to be connected with her grandson.
- 2:16Yeah. Yeah.
- 2:19I think this is actually something that you might be good
- 2:21at because you moved away to be close to live in the same
- 2:27household or to, you know, constantly see each other
- 2:30constantly a weekend or something like this.
- 2:34It makes it so difficult to be emotionally, independent.
- 2:40It's so easy to Yeah, get into a weird mix of resentment and yet
- 2:48not being able to break away personally, you know, when you
- 2:53live in the same household, it's it's not easy to listen to a
- 2:57parent. Yeah, defend your position, you
- 2:59have to maintain your individuality.
- 3:02You cannot just give in like that's, you know, the kid
- 3:04anymore, right? But I think being more away and
- 3:09not being exposed to culture. Not being exposed to her talking
- 3:14constantly about politics in a way that you disagree with the
- 3:18eminently. Maybe not to list over here.
- 3:22Her conversation with friends and so on, which would might
- 3:24aggravate you more. I think you might be able to
- 3:29contribute that as a daughter. And as a as your part, in the
- 3:35family Dynamics, this is something we talked about last
- 3:38time. Yeah, able to provide from the
- 3:41distance. This is one thing that you could
- 3:45do give her comfort that your siblings are not able to.
- 3:50Yeah, yeah, that's what I was thinking, too.
- 3:53Like I can be here there for her, like, in that way.
- 3:56And at the same time, I'm also thinking about my dad, because
- 3:59poor dad has just been kind of like push to the side through
- 4:04all of this. And and it's not fair to him
- 4:07either because like, I'm sure he doesn't like that, I always tell
- 4:12Mom. Mom, all the news first and he
- 4:14doesn't get first dibs and stuff.
- 4:17So I have to think of that and he's such a good man like really
- 4:22good guy and but he's also very passive so he wouldn't complain.
- 4:28He wouldn't, you know, he would hold that in again you know, the
- 4:32lack of skill to express a need and then life might face a
- 4:38rejection of that need, right? So obviously is a very different
- 4:41style and your mom but But yeah, he wouldn't ask and yes, it's
- 4:46not fair that he's left aside just because he's not showing
- 4:51his pain so much or you get used to it, or he has a very
- 4:54different way of communicating. So taking that into account, how
- 5:00would you like to Have your dad close to bring him in.
- 5:10I want to like because he and I share an interest of music and
- 5:16stuff. So I think that I should just be
- 5:18a little more active like sending him songs or like check
- 5:22out this Dad or something like that.
- 5:24I think he would appreciate that.
- 5:26Sending him a picture of my son or whatever just he gets that,
- 5:32you know, from time to time, I should be more Active letting
- 5:36him see that because he's, you know, he's just one of those
- 5:40really caring guys like, and he helps my mom so much even though
- 5:46they bicker, but it's, they've known each other forever.
- 5:50Yes. And and he, he always lets her
- 5:56like, kind of take over and he's very passive with her, which
- 6:01maybe I learned a lot of my Relationship skills by watching
- 6:07mainly through my dad, because I'm also like him and so that's
- 6:15probably why. I know he probably gets hurt
- 6:18that. He's overlooked because, yeah,
- 6:23it's nice to follow up on that, it really is.
- 6:25Yeah, not to just support a dynamic that the one who screams
- 6:31the loudest or shows the most Indignation or the most whatever
- 6:37rejection is the one who gets fed basically emotion.
- 6:41Yeah, this definitely not fair. It's like, you know, a child who
- 6:48throws a big tantrum and then everyone gives attention to that
- 6:50child and the child was sitting there quietly, you know, gets
- 6:54overlooked. And it's not it's not fair.
- 6:58So I have to be mindful of that stuff.
- 7:02And at the same time thinking about my brother Brother and
- 7:04sister and and I wrote down some notes and thinking from last
- 7:10session, a bit more about my siblings because I hadn't really
- 7:14thought of that about our dynamic, as much as my parents.
- 7:20And this past week, I've been thinking more about them and
- 7:24stuff and just writing down, you know, like How I think my
- 7:30brother sees me how I'd like to see him like that.
- 7:36And it was inside because again also the way that we were
- 7:40discussing we were focused on today, it was your mom last
- 7:45time. It was more your sister and your
- 7:47brother. You know, if he took something
- 7:49from your dad, then you also doesn't know how to express.
- 7:54Maybe he's good in repressing and pushing.
- 7:58Yeah. Very, he's very much like quiet.
- 8:02Like he holds everything in. He's very private.
- 8:06Yes. Yeah.
- 8:09Very much. What would be important not to
- 8:11believe that? And to see that there is someone
- 8:14behind who is again, might not be skillful.
- 8:18I hope that he has found a way to express himself with his
- 8:23girlfriend that you mentioned, so that maybe there is a
- 8:27development and Improvement there.
- 8:29Because he has found the one person for him but even if you
- 8:36opened up with her and more, it's it will be work for him,
- 8:41you know, to be, oh yeah, ever really was yeah.
- 8:45So yes, maybe we can share a little bit of how you are you.
- 8:50That's what I'm afraid of with him because because he's so
- 8:53repressed and now he's in a relationship with the woman who
- 8:58I don't know, her Her personally, but from what I've
- 9:00heard, it's not she's quite controlling quite dominating.
- 9:05Yeah, I know is like, you know, you're watching a car crash in,
- 9:10slow motion. And there's nothing you can do
- 9:13to help. I feel like that, like, and I
- 9:15told my parents, like, maybe he should just leave, we go through
- 9:20it and just feel those mistakes and stuff because he's never
- 9:24really done that before. But at the same time, Time.
- 9:29I kind of want him to know that I'm there to help because I've
- 9:33been in a really, you know, a big relationship that was not
- 9:37healthy and I can see the signs and I understand, I can
- 9:43sympathize with him, it was us. So you just not getting sympathy
- 9:49from others, you know, in the family.
- 9:51But I could, yeah. Okay, there is yes, could you
- 9:58share some thoughts about your sister?
- 9:59Just to wrap up the yeah, well with my sister.
- 10:05I know that she yeah she does miss me and we had a nice
- 10:13relationship before and I think it can be re-established.
- 10:17And I'd like her to see me as someone who she can come to for
- 10:22support for dealing. Thing with all of this family
- 10:26stuff. And for being a mom because we
- 10:28both have children the same age, you know, and we could bond over
- 10:34this. It's just that I have to tell
- 10:37her that. Like she needs to be more
- 10:40present on online because I can't be the one always like,
- 10:44hey I'm here. You have to, you know, it takes
- 10:485 minutes, maybe to send a message once a week would be
- 10:53enough. Of that would be enough, but I
- 10:57think that she and I just need to have a heart-to-heart
- 11:00conversation and I know it could happen.
- 11:02Like we've opened up in ways to each other that are other family
- 11:07members have not. So we have that going for us.
- 11:13Good. So one suggestion to that is to
- 11:16establish a ritual. So this is a good help for
- 11:23avoiding. So if she's in a mode of
- 11:26managing, this is what it sounds like she has to manage for kids
- 11:29who are Parents emotional needs of other people and so on, then
- 11:34not to introduce another problem.
- 11:36And the problem would be, where can I take those five minutes to
- 11:41call to text to send a picture? Because another thing on her
- 11:45list and there's one thing that she has enough of I guess, has
- 11:48to do so, Yeah, I know and the ritual would be a possibility to
- 11:54take the minor. So every Thursday, 5:00 p.m. we
- 11:59talk time when she doesn't have to have another list or tasks on
- 12:06her mind. So I would strongly suggest to
- 12:11whatever she's capable off organizing but do not leave it
- 12:16to Individual decisions again, and again.
- 12:22Yeah, awesome. Okay.
- 12:24Those 10 things. When can I squeeze out time for
- 12:28picture to my sister? So make it more concrete, you're
- 12:33saying like make it more like, okay.
- 12:36If you could establish a ritual, every Second Friday for 20
- 12:42minutes we talk whatever it is that somehow suits your times
- 12:48because there's a time difference, right?
- 12:52The u.s. because that would just make it easier for her original.
- 12:58You could commit to that if not then somehow I feel I have to
- 13:01deal with that. But it would be more probable
- 13:04that if you don't find a ritual, that you would be, the one
- 13:07probably an issue that would be the unfortunate thing.
- 13:11Right? And I get frustrated.
- 13:14Yeah, I was thinking of starting a even a private like Facebook
- 13:18group for just my brother sister and I just eyes, no one else.
- 13:22And what we could post pictures or make comments and it's like
- 13:27shared with the three of us. Yes.
- 13:30That might be a nice first step for them because it's just,
- 13:33like, there's less pressure, you could post when you're ready,
- 13:38you know, and I'll just share some things with them.
- 13:42Did, show them how to how to do it because they're not there,
- 13:47they're younger than me and they're not as open to be online
- 13:51and to do things on social media.
- 13:54And it blows my mind like you guys are younger than me, kid.
- 13:59Well, are you sure that they're not doing stuff that you just
- 14:02don't know of? With your brother and
- 14:05specifically maybe they have a private thing.
- 14:09Maybe. But I do, I doubt it another not
- 14:13among each other will just tell you know, that he has his
- 14:17forums, he has his Facebook friends here as well, whatever
- 14:19they use. That is what I mean.
- 14:23No, they never post things. No, they don't.
- 14:27They're not into that stuff. They don't have Instagram
- 14:30accounts. They don't do.
- 14:32Like, they're very Minimally on online.
- 14:36Yes, yeah, well it's it's a possibility.
- 14:40You just have to be aware of again, your frustration level.
- 14:42When you set up a group and you feed some stuff and if they
- 14:46don't follow up that much, yeah, you know, it's something to keep
- 14:51in mind and those also skill to it and right, actually the
- 14:56beginning, that might be more necessary than just have a group
- 14:59and post pictures, but to ask somehow, you know, interesting.
- 15:04Kitchens, for example, to your brother is interested to
- 15:07respond, right? Something provocative or
- 15:12something funny or something that is not just an obligation
- 15:15of, okay. Now Family group or siblings?
- 15:18Yeah, yeah, exactly. It's got it.
- 15:22I think I have to make it seem like a neutral thing in the
- 15:26beginning, so he can let down his guard a bit, you know.
- 15:30Like I'm not even going to talk about his girlfriend stuff for a
- 15:33while. While until he and I feel more
- 15:38comfortable around each other. I think it's so that he knows
- 15:42that he then he can trust me to open up like I'm not going to
- 15:45just say stuff to Mom, you know. Yes that's always.
- 15:50I think the concern in oh yes. And for sure, I mean, if you
- 15:55want to be acknowledged by him and that position He obviously
- 16:01sees something in her. And to go with that, you know
- 16:06yeah like yeah controlling from the outside and looks like a
- 16:09pattern repeating itself and so on but he seizes sure.
- 16:14So if he likes her and then you don't ya you don't know her.
- 16:18So maybe yeah. But don't you go with his like
- 16:22of her then to bring in a rational voice of concern or
- 16:28something like that? Yeah, exactly.
- 16:30He hears that from my sister and my mom Mom, he's hearing that
- 16:35from them even my little niece is saying stuff and she's 2
- 16:39years old so he's isolated. He feels isolated with his
- 16:43choice of partner, right? And you know how feels like it's
- 16:47not a good position to be in. It's good to have someone who
- 16:49since she's something for you to tell me something nice about
- 16:53her. I like yes, your honor.
- 16:56What did you come to get together?
- 16:58How did you decide to be a couple, right?
- 17:03And that would be his point of view, right?
- 17:07That's right. Okay, now I'm interested to you
- 17:12your described. I think a nice range of
- 17:14possibilities of how to connect with them and it I hear through
- 17:19your words that there is something satisfying and this
- 17:22Prospect of connecting Your mom in a certain way and not
- 17:28forgetting your dad and including him and talk about the
- 17:32music and not just sending music.
- 17:34And then to approach a siblings, now, what I see is a, I would
- 17:40like to voice a question or concern that I have and to get
- 17:46your feedback from that. I see that, you know, how to
- 17:49navigate being You would go back to the older sibling position.
- 17:53Again, let me take care of people.
- 17:56This is how I know how to interact with them.
- 17:59So I fulfilling, what would be the good listener to my brother?
- 18:03I would be an emotional support for my sister.
- 18:06I would listen to my mom, so you would be that person again, the
- 18:10caretaker, where are you as the one in?
- 18:15Need the one, reaching out. And not just communicating look,
- 18:19I'm here for you. If you need someone to talk to
- 18:22I'm be the one. But I would like to be the one
- 18:25who is Listen to I've stuff to share that.
- 18:29I don't know how to express towards other people.
- 18:31I would like you to my sister to be there for me.
- 18:37So, the part that Arden you, where's that?
- 18:40And I'm being the advocate for that part and not just the
- 18:44convenient route of okay? Be the big sister again that you
- 18:48know how to do. Yeah it's so hard because like I
- 18:57I'm so independent that. It's so hard for me to to open
- 19:03up to them in that way to say hey like could you just listen
- 19:09to me you know, or I'm dealing with something?
- 19:13Can you help me with a problem? I mean well look what a
- 19:17difference is. You only need that you have to
- 19:20Words, your family is to be regarded as the caretaker then
- 19:25you know, that is the need that you have.
- 19:27You can go there and then you know the other needs you would
- 19:30have from your partner from your son to Annex.
- 19:34Yeah. Friends or yeah.
- 19:36Because that's the thing that I like my friend here.
- 19:38Yeah. My friends here have kind of
- 19:40taken over that just because of you know, the situation I live.
- 19:46I live closer to them. We hang out more, we talk more
- 19:48and I feel like Like I I've built such a nice personal life
- 19:55here that a nice support group here.
- 19:58I have a good partner and stuff that feel like it's okay.
- 20:02Like I'm if I have a problem, I'm dealing with something with
- 20:05work or whatever. I always have someone to talk to
- 20:09and at the end of that, I feel better.
- 20:11And so I don't need to like unload that on to my family.
- 20:15There are many things that they don't know about with me is here
- 20:19and stuff, and I don't know, I just feel like it's probably
- 20:24better for them to because they never, I don't think they like
- 20:29to be in a position where they have to take care of me.
- 20:32And yet, okay? So maybe taking care is too
- 20:35strong of a word and our previous two conversations.
- 20:38I heard comments where you were deeply hurt that, they're not
- 20:41know in your life. I know they don't want to do
- 20:44what I'm doing. They're not interested, I'm tree
- 20:47that I live in, they don't? Yeah, that that is painful.
- 20:51They not into that is. So that would be even if you
- 20:55took care of them. That would be still a part that
- 20:58is left unsatisfied know that you're right?
- 21:01Yeah, yeah. It's true.
- 21:05Yeah, I just I guess I just learned that I can only control
- 21:10my what I can do in life and my behavior.
- 21:14So I'm just thinking so much like what I can give them.
- 21:18In the hopes that maybe they'll then be interested in learning
- 21:23more about me personally and learning more about where I
- 21:27live. And what I actually do here and
- 21:29stuff, I'm just hoping that like, through all of this, like
- 21:33I'm giving and they'll, they'll reciprocate, okay?
- 21:37And now I will be the advocate for that part.
- 21:40Who wants to be a student. And as that part, I would say
- 21:44this is not enough as a strategy.
- 21:46Yeah. It could happen, right?
- 21:49I'm not saying that it isn't what where I'm coming from is.
- 21:55So now, I'm talking more as the expert of needs.
- 21:58And as a need, we want to have a viable path.
- 22:04And if I is in need, don't have that.
- 22:08I'm looking either anxiously into the future.
- 22:12For the anxious hope of fulfillment, or I'm frustrated.
- 22:17And if I have a path which is, for example, okay, let me try
- 22:22for a couple of months to do, you know, taking care roll.
- 22:29Let me try that. And if that doesn't work, I will
- 22:32open up more to my sister and say, look, I don't know.
- 22:35I know that I don't show this but it's so painful for me that
- 22:39I'm here for you and don't feel that you guys are interested or
- 22:45you personally, Not interested and how I am and what I do and
- 22:50what my life is, this for me is painful and I would hope that
- 22:54you show more interest. So if I have this kind of a plan
- 22:58just as an example, alright? Then I is a need would feel
- 23:02that, okay? There is a plan B.
- 23:04I'm not just limited to hoping that they read my mind or that
- 23:10they develop a natural interest in my life, something that they
- 23:14have simply not done in the past.
- 23:16Fast. Right.
- 23:19So what, what are some plan B's that you could provide that part
- 23:23in you? That is sad and frustrated for
- 23:25them not showing interest, you know, it's true.
- 23:31I shouldn't I shouldn't assume that they will understand the
- 23:38signals I'm sending out opening up and my doing all this stuff
- 23:43and my God, my grandmother used to say about the word assume
- 23:48that it's the way it's spelled. It makes an ass of you and me.
- 23:52Hmm, consider that. Don't forget.
- 23:57Also that you sending out other signals.
- 24:00It's the the signals that you Out a stronger and that they
- 24:05show. I'm self-sufficient.
- 24:06I'm strong, I'm independent. I don't need anyone.
- 24:11Don't underestimate how much you send out those signals when you
- 24:15provide support, when you are the one who listens because
- 24:19well, that's true. Even say anything right there
- 24:23for me. So kindly you have the emotional
- 24:25capacity on the time to do that. So yeah, why would I come to
- 24:30think that you might need something?
- 24:33It's a mixed message me. Yeah, I would, I'm hoping that
- 24:39I'll have enough confidence in myself to actually confront them
- 24:45verbally with it like conversation.
- 24:48Yes. I think, of course, like a
- 24:50letter, is a great idea. Maybe from Mom and Dad, they'll
- 24:56need the time. But my brother and sister, we
- 24:58can be a little more like in the moment and just react off of
- 25:02each other. We've done it before and I think
- 25:06that it's okay to do it again. Yeah, yes.
- 25:13I just want them to feel comfortable with with it.
- 25:16Like, I'm not like attacking them, like, you know, pointing
- 25:18fingers. Exactly.
- 25:20Not that. Exactly.
- 25:21And this is very important, right?
- 25:22When, yeah, there is a skill in that and it's good to keep that
- 25:27in mind and to practice that also just in daily life, right?
- 25:31The ability to express a need without the implication that
- 25:35it's blame. Right, so look, this is
- 25:42basically to understand how do we do that.
- 25:45Bye. Showing them that I understand
- 25:48their position. I know that I'm the most
- 25:51responsible for this because I have not communicated this in
- 25:54the past. All right.
- 25:58Yeah. Yes me that showed to be strong
- 26:02and to be independent. But over the time, I had to
- 26:07recognize that there is this part of me that doesn't know
- 26:11exactly how to express it. Where I would wish that you my
- 26:16brother. You are mostly you.
- 26:17My sister would reach out and show interest in me that is
- 26:22possible for you. I would love that.
- 26:24And if that's not possible for you, then I do understand, and
- 26:29to wrap it up in terms that don't make them defensive about
- 26:33it or all right? Yeah, yeah, that's it.
- 26:39So I'm, you know, after our sessions and and Doing some
- 26:44writing and and calm or contemplation and I have before.
- 26:48I feel like more confidence to go that route.
- 26:55Yeah. Like I put it in in words like I
- 27:00create this narrative in my head of this situation so that I can
- 27:05approach them. Whereas before I don't know I
- 27:10would I probably would have been a little more emotional if I
- 27:13talk to them. Yes.
- 27:16A little more like reactionary instead of like, let's, let's
- 27:20contemplate. And think first.
- 27:23So now I feel a little more prepared for that.
- 27:26A little more understanding with my mom.
- 27:30Just feeling more sympathetic for her, you know, she's never
- 27:35been in this situation before. So she's trying.
- 27:41And that's, you know, nowadays is, I guess trying is the most
- 27:44important thing, right? Yes, that's that means a lot
- 27:48because there's many people who don't even do that.
- 27:50So, yeah, trying. And what is important is that
- 27:54it's accompanied by skill and that comes by thinking it.
- 27:59Through right. There is an element that I think
- 28:02is from my side. I think it's important when you
- 28:06reflect on it, coming from a house, built off implicitness
- 28:10and avoidance to, to get rid of that as far as I can.
- 28:15Because my tendency is to do the same.
- 28:17Give small hints, hoping that they're picked up giving an idea
- 28:22being, you know, indirect about things.
- 28:27This would be the tendency of the Ali Dynamic, and from
- 28:31myself, to contemplate, in a different way where they applied
- 28:34to communication or not is a different thing.
- 28:36But from myself to know, this is what I need.
- 28:39This is who I want to be and to invest some time when you have
- 28:42in your favor that you are, have this writing kind of approach
- 28:47and I would I would use that more.
- 28:50Yeah, well we associate the right things often to compliment
- 28:54contemplate in this way. Yeah, exactly makes sense.
- 29:00Then yeah, I am thankful that I had these few sessions with you
- 29:06to kind of like you know what, that in order because I've never
- 29:10done that before. I've never, you know, it's
- 29:14little things come out here and there with conversations with
- 29:17friends or whatever or you sit by yourself, you think about
- 29:21something. But I've always been so
- 29:22distracted by other things in my life.
- 29:25And I never, Really just focused on it.
- 29:28Yes. So, so why don't you share with
- 29:30us a few impressions of the specific context that we have
- 29:35now leaving aside that it's recorded, and it's not 100% in
- 29:39Atlantic Therapy context still, so you didn't know me kind of
- 29:46face the challenge of opening up about things that you haven't in
- 29:51the past. You were not exposed to
- 29:53therapeutic context. At all.
- 29:56So what can you share with us of what it feels like to be in that
- 30:02position? It's hard as it is it what are
- 30:05the things that you actually work for you working?
- 30:09This is that. It makes you think in a
- 30:11different way and eventually act in a different way.
- 30:14I would be curious enough. I think that, you know, in the
- 30:18beginning, of course, it's uncomfortable because I've never
- 30:22had such a spotlight on me and, and getting used to just talking
- 30:27about yourself or 60 minutes. It's like, it's hard, especially
- 30:34with my job. I'm, I'm a teacher.
- 30:36I'm also asking questions other people and I'm always focused on
- 30:41others and I had to like really feel comfortable talking about
- 30:46myself. Elf.
- 30:47And I think it's good. I like everyone should have a
- 30:50moment where they feel that, you know, it gives you some clarity
- 30:57and puts things in perspective. Makes you feel that someone's
- 31:03actually listening to you like you summarize things.
- 31:06Even like a week later that we talked about and I'm like oh he
- 31:10remembered he was, I don't know why it well obviously it's what
- 31:15you're doing. But um, Just assume most people
- 31:19just taken and little bits and pieces.
- 31:21But when you hear it, that someone can actually summarize
- 31:24the whole thing and even add something else to it.
- 31:28It's really like eye-opening and encouraging like, okay, just
- 31:34keep talking because this person's listening and they're,
- 31:39they're making connections for you, and it's nice to have that
- 31:43feels good like this, this time, you know, I feel Feel more
- 31:47relaxed opening up about stuff with my family.
- 31:51Then I was the first time that's for sure.
- 31:55Okay, so I really appreciate it. This was the conclusion of our
- 32:01three sessions. I hope you found interest and
- 32:04our conversations and that it gave you an insight and idea of
- 32:09how therapeutic process with such a topic would look.
- 32:13Like, I would be glad if you joined us again.
- 32:16In future episodes, where we'll continue the therapy recording
- 32:20sessions.