Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP333: How The Latest Technology Trends Are Reshaping Ecommerce Team Structures & Skills
Transcript
- 0:03You listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:06and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:09and re platform specialist James Get and Paul Rogers.
- 0:12Get insights into ecom strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:14industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:16practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:22This podcast is sponsored by Worldpay.
- 0:24So Paul and I today are diving into a topic that we think is
- 0:27really interesting and really important.
- 0:29And this is about how the current trends around
- 0:35e-commerce, customer and technology are things like agent
- 0:39ecommerce for example, and AI products discovery are reshaping
- 0:42ecom strategy, team structures and also the demand for skills
- 0:46within in teams and the balance between those teams.
- 0:49Because the reality is that we all have to, as businesses react
- 0:52to market changes, customer changes and evolution of
- 0:54technology. So this, this is important
- 0:57because it's about understanding what you need to keep an eye on
- 1:01in the future and also thinking about your team and how it needs
- 1:04to evolve potentially differently to existing resource
- 1:08plans. So this is going to be about our
- 1:12observation and insights, what we're seeing, what we're
- 1:14hearing, where we're seeing other companies evolving to and
- 1:17decisions they're making. So if I pull out four key
- 1:20highlights and we dropped a newsletter from inside commerce
- 1:23on LinkedIn yesterday about this and this is going to be I like
- 1:26exploring this in great detail. So the the top level highlights
- 1:29about product data is a growth channel and this links into AI
- 1:33discovery and agentic commerce, AI native products and
- 1:37engineering leadership is going to become more and more
- 1:39important within businesses, not just in your external partners.
- 1:43The, the enhancements in AI tool in the capabilities alone and no
- 1:49code is going to increase demands on the expectation of
- 1:52things like continuous experimentation, for example.
- 1:56And the instead of being data-driven, it's being data
- 2:00lead and data smart. So the tooling is there now and
- 2:04it's about properly integrating marketing data tech for smarter
- 2:08decision making, but also probably ripping up our older
- 2:10playbooks about what KPIs and success criteria people should
- 2:14be using. And we had, we had ecom ID on
- 2:19the pod recently and they were talking about retained all the
- 2:22value, not average all the value.
- 2:24And this is a great example of altered the measurement, better
- 2:27tools and more accurate measurement equals better KPIs
- 2:32and measures. So that's my rambling set up.
- 2:35Paul, is that a good, do you reckon that's a good enough
- 2:37position for what we're going to talk about?
- 2:39Yeah, absolutely. Yeah.
- 2:39I think we'll probably end up covering quite a lot, like just
- 2:43One way. Obviously a second ago when we
- 2:45started framing the episode, I feel like we went off on a few
- 2:48tangents. So yeah, I'm sure we'll cover
- 2:50loads of different areas around all this stuff.
- 2:54Well, tangents are good. We know that's what we like
- 2:56doing. But let's start with what's
- 2:58changing. This is not just conceptual,
- 3:01this is actual. It's based on what is happening,
- 3:04the ecom teams we work and the technology we're seeing people
- 3:07invest in and how we're also using technology ourselves as
- 3:09service providers to a range of brands.
- 3:11So it's a step change from humans basically going onto a
- 3:17standard search engine, clicking on ads somewhere and browsing
- 3:21websites and buying from that website without any other tools
- 3:27enhancing that. So they are using the website as
- 3:30the purchase funnel too. Multi agent systems influence
- 3:33discovery, comparison and then to a lesser extent check out.
- 3:36And you know, there's a lot of evangelism around agentic
- 3:40commerce as in agents like the L NS chat chat CPTS are going to
- 3:45take away all the e-commerce and people are going to buy directly
- 3:47from them. And it's just not happening at
- 3:48volume. And you've seen open a roll back
- 3:50on their checkout ambitions. But from a from a product
- 3:54discovery point of view, the traffic is there growing.
- 3:56So more and more there are additional systems that are
- 4:01consuming information from your site, from other systems that
- 4:06helps them to decide what's relevant, what's not, what
- 4:08information show and when to influence how people find which
- 4:12sites they come to what, what even how far down the decision
- 4:15making process they are and what their intent to purchase is when
- 4:18they get there. And some elements of commerce
- 4:21might happen to a great extent out of the site, but it's more
- 4:24about those agents and how they influence what people do.
- 4:28So that's the key thing. How do you think this is
- 4:31impacting like ECOM strategy, Paul?
- 4:34So right now I don't think so in terms of like optimized and for
- 4:40visibility within the LLMS. I feel like all the
- 4:44conversations I've had around this is there's like a different
- 4:48levels of in a business, everyone's kind of panicking and
- 4:52essentially seeing a world where a lot of demand is, is coming
- 4:59from the LLMS and they're kind of thinking how do we get ahead
- 5:03of it. I think in my opinion, there's
- 5:06not that much that can be done right now to actually get ahead
- 5:09of it. So I think our average client
- 5:11has probably done some level of audit and paid someone to do
- 5:16some level of presentation on like what's happening right now
- 5:21in like relative to their brand and like what they can be doing
- 5:25to just, yeah, be better informed as their head.
- 5:28But I think the difficulty at the minute is the biggest
- 5:31challenge is that you can't measure anything properly.
- 5:33And I think, you know, these tools, I was actually at dinner
- 5:36yesterday and someone from a really big brand was saying that
- 5:41they're paying a fortune for Profound.
- 5:44And I think Profound's great. And it's obviously first market
- 5:48and it can obviously give you good insights and good
- 5:51suggestions. But I think I just think it's
- 5:55really difficult. I mean, all of the best
- 5:57practices, great, like try and build those into your strategy
- 6:00and like, you know, optimise your PDPS, etcetera, if you
- 6:03think it's the right thing to do as a brand.
- 6:05But I think the difficulty at the minute is like you can't
- 6:08measure what's happening in Google.
- 6:10Like there's no way of differentiating kind of traffic
- 6:13coming from AI mode or kind of any of the kind of AI
- 6:18interfaces. And then with ChatGPT, you can
- 6:22only measure referral traffic, which is going to be a minute
- 6:26percentage of the demand being created there.
- 6:29So like I, I don't know if you're the same.
- 6:32I think the majority of people that I speak to, if I find
- 6:35something by ChatGPT, I immediately go to Google and had
- 6:38search for the brand or the product.
- 6:41And I think that'll get easier to measure over time.
- 6:45And I think experiences will get better.
- 6:47But I think my view on it is I think open AI, open AI caused
- 6:53the speed and like shifts and like they caused Google to
- 6:58essentially move way faster than I think they would have liked to
- 7:02with how they're approaching like the agentic experience and
- 7:07agentic commerce. But now I think they will slow
- 7:12down. And I think because Claude,
- 7:14essentially, I think that, you know, so many companies, you
- 7:17know, perform like really clawing back market share from
- 7:21open AII feel like they won't focus on this as much.
- 7:25And I think that will help to slow things down a little bit.
- 7:32And then, yeah, I think that will like give us all a bit more
- 7:35time. But I think where we'll go to
- 7:37is, I think from a demand perspective, it'll get easier to
- 7:42track. All these tools will give you
- 7:44better reporting. And then you can like properly
- 7:47invest in it as you would with SEO and actually measure impact.
- 7:50I think that's the difficulty at the minute.
- 7:52So many people I know are investing money in this, but you
- 7:55can't actually see any level of impact because all the tools
- 7:58they're doing is like query and ChatGPT millions of times and
- 8:02seeing how often you're indexed and this.
- 8:04But there's so many variables and yeah, so I think the second
- 8:08that you can see the impact, it will help.
- 8:11And then I think the next thing will be just automate some level
- 8:13of automation around the transaction.
- 8:16But I still see that as like the bottom 10% of commerce.
- 8:19Ready to grow your business online?
- 8:21With World Pay E-commerce you can deliver fast, secure
- 8:25payments your customers love, backed by global reach and real
- 8:29people powered support. Scale with confidence and
- 8:33enhance your customers experience with World Pay
- 8:35E-commerce. Yeah, I mean, interestingly when
- 8:40I put that post out yesterday, so Joel Smith who's a well
- 8:43respected and highly experienced EE com digital technology
- 8:47leader, his his comment was about just not buying into the
- 8:53the hype around the commerce element of how much of this
- 8:57behaviour is, is then actually transactional in in these agents
- 9:03that are external to your ECOM infrastructure.
- 9:06I'm fully on board with that because there, there isn't the
- 9:09evidence there to suggest that this is happening on mass.
- 9:11I can see some areas where agent through agentic commerce
- 9:15external to websites could grow things around ticketing.
- 9:20I could see that definitely working well because it's
- 9:23actually solving a problem, which is like shit user
- 9:26experience by automating and and speeding up and taking away
- 9:29pain. But for so much discovery, just
- 9:32where when you get into complexity of ecom where it's
- 9:35right. OK, well, I actually, I've got
- 9:37an item on a collector from store and or I've got to, I've
- 9:42got to go through a more complex checkout logic because I'm going
- 9:46to I'm got using a local collection network and I've got
- 9:48to be able to find a local collection place that's near to
- 9:51my post code. And and you've got all these all
- 9:53these complexities and a check out with all the management
- 9:55rules. But Jesus Christ, how would you
- 9:57replicate that with an agent it commerce and without creating
- 10:01potential fraud exposure? So that I that I'm in tune with.
- 10:04And I don't think that's going to dramatically change E com
- 10:07strategy at all in the short term.
- 10:10Where I think it's really interesting as a bit you talked
- 10:12about the start of the product discovery and we we have moved
- 10:16from it just being about SEO and I don't believe that answer
- 10:20engine optimization is any different to SEO.
- 10:22It's a part of, but it's a growing part the, the demands of
- 10:25this. Where I'm seeing the shift is if
- 10:28I go back several years, when and semantic search first became
- 10:33like the terminology in, in Google about more structured
- 10:36data, more intelligent capability, passing micro
- 10:39snippets of content, not just whole pages and bringing
- 10:42structured data into the results.
- 10:44Then people got obsessed. All right, well, let's add loads
- 10:46of FAQs. But it became it's I, I don't
- 10:49know whether you've seen it. I saw it slowly morphing.
- 10:51So basically we've added FAQ blocks and our pages.
- 10:53Job done. But it was it was no more than
- 10:56let's look at what questions have been asked, let's add FAQ
- 10:59content. Where I'm seeing it shift a bit
- 11:02is people thinking more about the intent of what people are
- 11:05doing on pages and why, what type of information they might
- 11:08want. And FAQ is part of their
- 11:10fundamentally, but it's other data to answer other shopper
- 11:14questions or potential barriers to purchase where people are
- 11:17thinking about what else they should build into their pages,
- 11:20how those pages need to be structured and how that content
- 11:22needs to be atomized to make it indexable for SEO, but also then
- 11:26for these LLMS to be able to pick.
- 11:28Up. Yeah, I think what's really
- 11:29interesting my view on this because I completely agree with
- 11:31everything you just said. And I was having quite a long
- 11:34conversation about this last night.
- 11:36I think right now I completely agree with everything you just
- 11:39said. And I think you look at Google
- 11:41or like 7 maybe like even 10 years ago to be fair, like you
- 11:46know, everything was around how you structure data and it was
- 11:51very like not basic interpretation that data.
- 11:55But there wasn't that kind of like additional like they
- 11:59weren't as strong with like the natural language processing and
- 12:02everything else versus today like you know, in my opinion,
- 12:06when you if you look at like the correlation of the brand's
- 12:09ranking and the level of on page optimization they do, a lot of
- 12:15the time those brands aren't optimizing for SEO tool and you
- 12:19know, they're still ranking really well because of all the
- 12:21brand signals and everything else.
- 12:22So I think the two variables here, I think because
- 12:25everyone's, you know, optimizing and as they should be, I guess
- 12:29to what's working or what they know about the algorithm right
- 12:32now, I think open it. I think all of the LLMS will get
- 12:35so much more sophisticated in how they approach rankings.
- 12:41Plus, you know, they're going to have like more data than yeah,
- 12:45ever before on, on. It's on me as a user because of
- 12:49all the different queries I'm putting through that LLM and,
- 12:52you know, especially if we start shopping and they've got context
- 12:55around where I live and everything caters.
- 12:59Yeah, I just feel like it'll vary.
- 13:00I think in a year's time, 18 months time, it'll be a lot less
- 13:04around the things because right now everyone's trying to build a
- 13:08Reddit strategy and get Wikipedia page and everything
- 13:10cars, and I just think it'll move really quickly.
- 13:14Which is SEO, there's I mean that's always been SEO.
- 13:16There's zero difference, right. This is why I think is there is
- 13:20a conflation in the market of and there are there's always
- 13:23there's self-interest in every new technology trend where
- 13:26people go, we can make, we can make somehow we can position
- 13:29this as something completely different.
- 13:30Emperor's New clothes and AEO is just basically polishing
- 13:35something that's already existed, but it's been executed
- 13:37in different ways now because you've got you haven't just got
- 13:40search engines where people aren't asking slightly more
- 13:43smart questions like mobile device in the advent of like,
- 13:47you know, speech to speech to phone searching when you're on
- 13:51the move, help to expand query types.
- 13:53That's been there for years. This is just now the, you're
- 13:56right, it's the volume and, and, and it's the, it's the
- 13:59unstructured nature. I think actually, because when
- 14:02you're talking to somebody, you are still quite structured
- 14:06because it's your natural way of talking.
- 14:07But when you're in a chat, you know, like in a Chachi BT or
- 14:10whatever interface and you're going through like multiple
- 14:13prompts and commands and iteratives, you get quite lazy
- 14:16sometimes in can you just do this?
- 14:18What about? And it's, it's not a structured
- 14:20language. So I think that's that's
- 14:22probably the big shift in terms of understanding how people
- 14:25interact. I think, and so this is a
- 14:27tangent, but it is relevant to one of the topics that we were
- 14:30going to talk about anyway and we were talking about it a bit
- 14:32earlier. So I was saying to James, I've
- 14:35been working a bit with swap on their newer genetic product,
- 14:40which is really interesting. There's obviously a few players
- 14:42in the market at the minute and a lot of people are trying to
- 14:45kind of build that experience like of a really strong, yeah,
- 14:49kind of dialogue, conversational commerce experience where
- 14:54essentially you're gradually providing more context and then
- 14:57it's providing super relevant results and you can do virtual
- 15:01try on and you can like refine really easily, etcetera.
- 15:04But the thing that I've found really interesting actually to
- 15:07the point of, you know, these LLMS, no loads about us.
- 15:11So one of the big things the essentially what big part of
- 15:15swaps strategy and one of the big benefits to the brand around
- 15:20this experience is and you can see it happening like kind of
- 15:24when you're when someones using it.
- 15:26So you're kind of just constantly giving information
- 15:30and essentially like as I'm going through and I'm saying,
- 15:33no, I prefer this, I'm going to wear it here.
- 15:36And then it's saying, oh, what size are you just so I can
- 15:39refine. And then it's stored your size.
- 15:40And then it's like, how quickly do you need it to come like
- 15:43blah, blah, blah. And it's just constantly asking
- 15:45questions and then essentially against that user, like the
- 15:49level of data that they're collecting that is essentially
- 15:54stored against that user. And if they've provided an
- 15:57e-mail like like, it's like the ultimate like data collection
- 16:03journey for a brand, then that can all be pushed into your CRM
- 16:06or CDP. And if there's certain data
- 16:09points that are more valuable, you can just ask the agent to
- 16:12proactively ask for that and you're just much more likely to
- 16:15give it. And I, yeah, I think I found it
- 16:18quite interesting, like seeing as they've developed the product
- 16:21one how, because I think I was super sceptical at the start,
- 16:25like really sceptical. And then I think I gradually
- 16:28started to see how in the right use case, it's a much better
- 16:32experience. Then I started to see how you're
- 16:35building up all that knowledge. And I think, yeah, I think it'll
- 16:37be really interesting to see where it goes.
- 16:41Yeah, I think this is a point I wanted to tease out today is
- 16:47there's a lot of rightful scepticism about the growth of
- 16:49agentic commerce, the commerce element to it.
- 16:52So who's going to go in and actually like start searching in
- 16:56a chat TVT and end up making a purchase directly within there
- 17:00and hand their details over and be comfortable that the check
- 17:02out is everything's fine and that companies can surface all
- 17:06of the logic via an API to make those journeys work across all
- 17:10of the product versus owned agentic commerce.
- 17:14So that's my that's my shit terminology.
- 17:16I'm introducing owned agentic commerce, which is within your
- 17:20ecosystem, your website app, whatever you offering people,
- 17:25you are using agents to automate tasks to increase self-service.
- 17:30And a great example would be customer service chat bots.
- 17:34Loads of businesses already use these agents.
- 17:37They enable the agents to solve, you know, hundreds if not
- 17:41thousands of daily queries related to things like all the
- 17:45status tracking it, but you name it.
- 17:47I've seen brands who've reported a 80% plus reduction in customer
- 17:51tickets as a result of introducing smart agents.
- 17:54And it is case by case, depending on the nature of the,
- 17:57the enquiry, on how complex the enquiries are.
- 18:00But but then it's the, I think the, the, the big change is
- 18:04going to be using those more effectively through site
- 18:07journeys, not just as a, oh, I've got to click on it for you
- 18:11to help me. Is, is proactive prompting to
- 18:13go, hey, can we help you with this?
- 18:16But it's also the intelligence of the handover point.
- 18:20When does an agent have to hand over to a real person?
- 18:24What is that process? How smooth and efficient is it?
- 18:26What's the wait time for somebody does that, then lose
- 18:29them in in whatever journey they're in?
- 18:31Because it it's jarring. And that, to me, is an area
- 18:34where ECOM teams have got to spend more time thinking.
- 18:37Yeah. I think it's going to be so
- 18:38interesting. So where this ends up because I
- 18:41think right now, so there's a quite a few brands that have
- 18:44introduced an agentic experience where as you say, you can go and
- 18:52kind of navigate the catalog, but you could also ask about
- 18:56service stores, whatever else. And I think you can already,
- 19:00there's already brands that are starting to introduce the option
- 19:03where essentially the real estate that was live chat is
- 19:06moving into like a broader alternative way to browse.
- 19:10So on I've just introduced, it's not very good and it's not very
- 19:13broad, but I can see where they're probably looking to
- 19:16taste it. And essentially it's like a
- 19:18hybrid live chat and product discovery piece where I think it
- 19:23will go because essentially, and you mentioned in 10 earlier,
- 19:26which I think is really key because if I've just discovered
- 19:30a brand on Instagram and you know, I've seen a bit of
- 19:33creative and it's made me think this brand's great.
- 19:36The most performant journey is going to be showing that user a
- 19:40bit about the brand and the catalog.
- 19:43And in a lot of cases, people will want to see APLP or like
- 19:47they'll want to browse the catalog visually to see what
- 19:50they like. However, there are then other
- 19:53types of users that you know, need a different way of
- 19:56navigating. And I think they would prefer to
- 19:58have a conversation essentially be like, look, I'm going out
- 20:00tonight. Can you just show me 4 dresses
- 20:03And I want to do virtual try on and then you can give me a
- 20:05feedback and tell me some stuff. And then that's the better
- 20:08experience. But I think where it'll get to
- 20:10is exactly what you just said with the I think it'll start
- 20:14with a fight for the chat bot piece.
- 20:17And I think someone is going to need to.
- 20:20Create a solution where different companies can feed
- 20:24into that, where you could integrate gorgeous, you could
- 20:27pull in product results, you could yeah, pull in alternative
- 20:31information, etcetera. And then I think where it will
- 20:34get to you and I don't know which vendor's going to drive
- 20:36this. And in theory, it could be swap,
- 20:38it could be Shopify, it could be someone else is like, I think
- 20:43we'll get to a Copilot experience.
- 20:46And I think essentially you'll land on the site and then you'll
- 20:50have the option of, you know, you'll have both options.
- 20:54And then I think as you're browsing the site, if you're on
- 20:56APDP at any point, you would like open your Copilot
- 20:59interface. And then you might ask questions
- 21:00about that PDP that you might equally be like, let's show me
- 21:0420 more products like this. And then if you wanted to, you
- 21:07could essentially continue your journey in the like kind of chat
- 21:12experience. But yeah, I think I think it'll
- 21:15quite quickly get to that point. That's where I kind of see it.
- 21:19Headache. Yeah, it's interesting to say I
- 21:21was, I sat there thinking the other day and part of me the the
- 21:25big, the big challenge I'm going to put to that point is because
- 21:27I don't disagree with it, but it's, I think in the industry,
- 21:30we can foresee something because of our knowledge of the
- 21:33technology that doesn't necessarily have the demand from
- 21:35a customer point of view. And I think conflating the 2 is
- 21:38always a risk when you're in tech, working in tech day in,
- 21:40day out, because I think I, I can see that work for some
- 21:43people. I was working in shop find
- 21:45psychic and one on a complex store building.
- 21:48I've constantly got sidekick open next to me.
- 21:51And in the same way with ChatGPT with the, the business licence
- 21:53version where my, my chats are stored and I can go back any
- 21:57point and go, oh, I was doing that piece.
- 22:00I was trying to sort out those Python scripts on that, right.
- 22:02What was, what was that? Come on, I forgot what that
- 22:04prompt was. I've got that history.
- 22:06The problem with chat at the moment on a site is I'm in a
- 22:10query with a customer. I've got one at the moment with
- 22:11a bedding mattress company because the mattress keeps
- 22:15coming and it's shit. And I'm on the chat, but there's
- 22:19no history. There's no recognition that I've
- 22:21already had this chat and that was a week ago and you've sent
- 22:23me another one. So I'm redoing everything.
- 22:26And as a customer, it's really bloody annoying.
- 22:28If you approach that pilot chat, that psychic thing is, well,
- 22:33actually I can, I can have a history I can see.
- 22:36And therefore, even if it's just, I can refer people out or
- 22:38I can copy and paste, but I can track my history.
- 22:41And it might be, Oh, you recommended a product the other
- 22:43day And I can say, oh, you, you, you know, on Thursday you
- 22:46recommended this really cool product.
- 22:48Where is it? But I think that that that is a
- 22:51future option. I, I don't know how many
- 22:53customers demand that. That will be my question.
- 22:56And to be honest, I think it is really open, isn't it?
- 22:59So I think where I think we'll get to that copilot way of
- 23:02browsing, but what I don't know is how that's going to who's
- 23:07going to play a key part and how it's going to work.
- 23:09The other side of this, realistically the browser,
- 23:12because I've started using the, so I use Claude a lot and I've
- 23:16like really doubled down on trying to give Claude enough
- 23:20context and enough integration into all the tools that I use to
- 23:24like automate proportions of what I do.
- 23:29And then I use a Chrome extension and essentially like,
- 23:32if I'm actually like, you know, if I'm on a web page and I want
- 23:35to extract information or I want to go and find similar things, I
- 23:39used extension and actually does I, I don't think it'll be a
- 23:43browser extension, but it does the browser.
- 23:46Like if I'm Google, I feel like, or if I'm Apple or Safari, I
- 23:51feel like, yeah, I would be seriously thinking about how do
- 23:54I play a major part in this? How do I collect all the data?
- 23:59Yeah, how do I potentially at some point make some money
- 24:01through payments or something? And I think, you know, Apple,
- 24:05Apple are really, I think everyone's talking about Google
- 24:09and open AI, which I think makes sense because that's like the
- 24:12short term major change area. I think Apple are in a really
- 24:18interesting like macro position with Safari being the dominant
- 24:23browser and Siri having so much potential to play a major part
- 24:30as like a sidekick or as like in the agentic space.
- 24:34And I think that is something that people aren't really
- 24:36thinking about because it's not happening or it's not live.
- 24:40But I think they're, you know, you just need to look at who
- 24:42they're hiring around commerce and in the AI space, like
- 24:47they're deaf. They're definitely a play.
- 24:49And then I think the other one, the other side to this would be
- 24:52like matter. So for our brand, matters by far
- 24:56the biggest Discovery Channel. And like, that's how people, you
- 25:00know, first come across the brand in a lot of cases for a
- 25:02high proportion of users. And it's like, what role do they
- 25:05play in this? And they're certainly not just
- 25:08going to watch people, you know, replace the website and try and
- 25:13take, yeah, all of all that try and steal demand or market share
- 25:19from the awareness and discovery side.
- 25:24So yeah. And I think it's going to be
- 25:25really, it's going to be really interesting to see, yeah, which
- 25:29players are in what position in like 2 years.
- 25:34Link to the point I want to move on to before we get down that
- 25:38rabbit hole because it is it is interesting it is interesting to
- 25:41watch what big players are doing, but it's the impact that
- 25:44that these the evolution of tech and how customers are using the
- 25:48technology is having on team structure and skill needs.
- 25:51So if I give a, if I talk about what I'm seeing and then you can
- 25:55refer and we've probably seen slightly different, similar but
- 25:58slightly different things. So there's what I see for ECOM
- 26:02recruiting is a massive competition for specialised
- 26:04skills to get senior people and people who have experience
- 26:09across, I guess the areas that are converging now.
- 26:11So the way that tech is enabling you to improve like Omni channel
- 26:17customer experience, the way that data connectivity is
- 26:21increasing, the ability to drive intelligence and automation and
- 26:26AI is a constant theme and all of that.
- 26:28And I'm seeing more, I'm seeing more businesses where the boards
- 26:32are aware of and talking about what what their overall AI
- 26:37strategy is, what role it plays, what they need and how people
- 26:41need to use technology and what the benefits will be.
- 26:44And looking at internally what that means, not just to what
- 26:47someone does from an execution point of view on ecom.
- 26:49Like, you know, we've got a search much tool with AI
- 26:51testing, AB testing, or we've got this AI tool to do X.
- 26:56But it's the internal day-to-day team management, improving
- 26:59efficiency, stripping out cars. And there are two skills that I
- 27:04think senior ecom hires now need to demonstrate, not just having
- 27:08an awareness of, but demonstrate that they know what to do with
- 27:10it. And there's AI product
- 27:11management, so understanding what agentic pathways are, so
- 27:15how shoppers are using AI interfaces, what impact that
- 27:17has, what they need to do on their site, how they need to
- 27:21improve structures around product data, content to drive
- 27:24visibility to, to drive to future proof for it.
- 27:29And then it's also the internal bit like knowing how, whether
- 27:32they're using a cloud, a ChatGPT, whatever the AI tools
- 27:36are, what that role is in their team, how their team should be
- 27:39using it, what license versions they need to support here, what
- 27:43the expectations are and how that can improve speed of
- 27:46execution, Chao inefficiency, help them focus on value adds.
- 27:51And then linked to that is conversation design.
- 27:54So this is understanding and the two parts again is on a site
- 27:58where you have agentic tools, what is that conversational
- 28:01interface? What is that user experience and
- 28:03flow? What are the prompts and how did
- 28:04customers react and respond to them?
- 28:07And then within the business, if you're expecting somebody to use
- 28:11a, an AI tool for like product data cleansing and improvement
- 28:14or content generation, what's their fluency and understanding
- 28:17in terms of like prompt writing and engineering?
- 28:19And do we know that they're going to get the best out of the
- 28:21tool and not compromise output? So this to me is really tangibly
- 28:25happening right now. Yeah.
- 28:27I think, I think this is really interesting and I think it's
- 28:31super inconsistent across our clients.
- 28:34And I think so every year before Pulse, I do another survey and
- 28:38this year's about 70 econ directors and there's a couple
- 28:41of questions found AI. And I would say what's quite
- 28:45interesting is you've essentially got maybe 15% of
- 28:49people doing absolutely shit loads.
- 28:52And I'll come on to like what they're doing and how they're
- 28:54benefiting. You've got that 15% of people
- 28:57doing literally nothing and they're not thinking quite at
- 29:00all. And then you've got the middle
- 29:03who are essentially buying based on AI capabilities and using for
- 29:08like the basic use cases around kind of customer experience and
- 29:12content generation. But I think it's really
- 29:16interesting because like the way that, and I think I look at our
- 29:20clients and like I'd say, you know, represent or at one end of
- 29:24the scale where they've now built, you know, but in their
- 29:26internal team, they have two public Shopify apps that have
- 29:29been built via, you know, AI and no code that are now on the
- 29:34Shopify App Store. You know, they were super early
- 29:37to translations. You know, they've done a lot of
- 29:39stuff around like visual content, everything else.
- 29:41And they're constantly like experimenting and they've kind
- 29:45of moved to like data structures and reporting tools that allow
- 29:50them to kind of, yeah, interface via prompting and like generate
- 29:57via prompting. And I think for us as a
- 29:59business, that's been like the one that we've invested the most
- 30:01time in. But I think when I look at some
- 30:05of the other ones that are not particularly AI literate,
- 30:09essentially they're outsourcing. So they're still, I still think
- 30:13they're doing some of the same stuff they're outsourcing.
- 30:16So they might have I think consultants kind of making
- 30:23suggestions around how they use AI, how they approach the
- 30:27visibility on their LLLLMS. And then I think they're then
- 30:31relying on vendors like Shopify and Clavio to drive some of the
- 30:38other stuff. But yeah, I mean, I actually, I
- 30:40feel like I love this topic and I'm actually super interested in
- 30:44it, but I feel like it's just so varied.
- 30:48And I don't know if you follow the CTO of Hew on LinkedIn, a
- 30:52guy called Ollie, but like you only need to look at.
- 30:57So like he, I think he is essentially like just someone
- 31:00that is super into like no code very kind of he's clearly stayed
- 31:06very hands on and he's investing a lot of time into looking at
- 31:12the stack across the business in fuel.
- 31:14And he's quite open about what he's kind of built in the
- 31:18business. And I've seen the head of
- 31:19engineering talk about it. I've seen someone in a date row
- 31:23talk about it and it's like, it's incredible what they're
- 31:26doing. But I think the, the interesting
- 31:28thing is so far, like you look at that business and some of our
- 31:32clients that have really built amazing stuff with AI so far,
- 31:38they're just more effective and they're probably not saving
- 31:43money or they're definitely not saving money on outsourcing and
- 31:47they're probably approaching things that they wouldn't have
- 31:48done before. But I think every like the whole
- 31:51narrative around this is like the econ team will be a team of
- 31:55one in like 3 years. And so far, I think my view on
- 32:01it is that people are just more effective at the minute.
- 32:04I don't think there's like, I guess like teams probably will
- 32:07get leaner and more efficient. But I think one thing that I
- 32:10would say at the minute is like, after observing this for months,
- 32:15February was like the worst month we've seen in like 2 years
- 32:18from a trade perspective. And I feel like half the people
- 32:21that were like, absolutely flying on AI and like investing
- 32:24all their time there and now like desperately going back to
- 32:27the basics and like, yeah, trying to, you know, have the
- 32:31conversations with the people in the business to figure out how
- 32:34to like trade better and like recover revenue and, yeah,
- 32:38figure out profitability. And obviously, like, yeah, I
- 32:40think, I mean, again, I'm kind of rambling, but I think it's
- 32:43just really hard to have an opinion on like, what is right
- 32:47right now because the brands, Vars that are doing the best
- 32:50from a growth perspective and not actually doing that much of
- 32:53AI. They're just outsourcing
- 32:55opinions and buying technology. So yeah.
- 32:59But I think that's, it's such an interesting discussion.
- 33:02But I don't, yeah, I think there's a massive advantage for
- 33:06upskilling internally and externally and building
- 33:09capability. But I don't think it's the be
- 33:11all and end all. And I don't think right now
- 33:14you're falling that behind if you're not putting all your time
- 33:18into it. I don't think you should put all
- 33:20your time into it, but I, I fundamentally be, I believe
- 33:23anything that can be a critical competitive advantage should
- 33:25have ownership in house, even if you outsource elements of it
- 33:28externally. It's always been the same, yeah,
- 33:31throughout the history of, of ecom SEO.
- 33:34If you don't have somebody in house who understands anything
- 33:36to have SEO and you've outsourced an agency, you have
- 33:38no idea how to hold the agency to task, how to measure it,
- 33:42whether the strategy is right in supporting your business goals.
- 33:45With the advent of AI tech and its impact on custody drainage
- 33:48habit and also internal efficiency.
- 33:52To have no ownership of that in house to me is a big risk.
- 33:55It's a big risk and I would never advise.
- 33:57But equally, I don't buy into this.
- 34:00This is just in future if you get rid of everyone there's
- 34:03there's a couple of people meet on LinkedIn pedal in this and it
- 34:06depresses the shit out of me every week is I can show you how
- 34:09to get rid of your entire team and be Oh my God, mate, go go,
- 34:13go, go into the matrix and never speak to another human being.
- 34:17We need people. For me.
- 34:19This is about why would you want your team constantly going?
- 34:24Oh, I can't get that done because I've got to do this.
- 34:26There's a problem with this spreadsheet or this date is
- 34:28wrong. If you can put in smart tech
- 34:32that can automate and clean and sort things out and take away
- 34:35the craps tasks that people hate and spend 50% of their time
- 34:38doing, you've now got teams focused on value add.
- 34:41You can ship the road map items that you can't ship.
- 34:44You can do those value add things on the site that you
- 34:46couldn't previously execute, those additional categories that
- 34:48you wanted to set, all that stuff.
- 34:50So you take away the barriers to execute things that the business
- 34:53knows takes it forward. And that to me is where
- 34:56strategic ownership has to happen in house.
- 34:58I I completely agree. And I think realistically right
- 35:01now is the time where every single business probably needs a
- 35:06view on which technology they're going to back, how they're going
- 35:10to structure data most effectively to make it work, how
- 35:14they're going to share Claude skills or whatever and how
- 35:17they're going to like govern it. But I feel like that's the point
- 35:19we're at. I think the bit that I find
- 35:21really difficult because I think that the thing that's hard is
- 35:25like, and again, like, I mean, there's just so much benefit and
- 35:28like you say, competitive advantage.
- 35:29I mean, the CRO space is one that I think is really
- 35:31interesting, like watching how quickly you're able to build
- 35:36sophisticated tests without the need of a developer.
- 35:39And I think like seeing all that stuff is just mad.
- 35:42But I think what's really interesting is that I look at
- 35:46how big teams are because some of our clients, they'll have
- 35:50people that are technical and they'll have time versus some of
- 35:54our clients just won't. And I think like it's, it's
- 35:58where like there's just, I just think that's a massive variable
- 36:02and how much time people should invest in AI.
- 36:05It's like the Holy Grail is you invest money into bringing
- 36:10people into your team to get the most out of AI.
- 36:13But it's like some team, some businesses have that money and
- 36:16the time to think about it and some don't.
- 36:19And yeah, I think overall, I think we're both saying everyone
- 36:22should be investing in this and building capability, but it's
- 36:26like it's just difficult to say when a brand should go deep and
- 36:31not go deep versus buy and outsource.
- 36:33And yeah. Yeah, that, that I get I, but
- 36:37for me it's a mindset shifting. I know I've had to go through
- 36:39this myself because my tendency, if I've got something where this
- 36:43is complex, I've got to get this done and I start my RAM at all
- 36:46and it can't do it straight away.
- 36:47My tendency to go, shit, I know I can do this myself, I can do
- 36:50that on Google Sheet, but I've had to force myself on a current
- 36:53project and product data go no, don't.
- 36:55And I spent time. So I spent about half a day in
- 36:58chat chi PT and managed to fix and resolve the issues I had and
- 37:02got it to about 90% of where I needed.
- 37:04And actually, that would probably take me about two days
- 37:05worth of work if I'd done it myself by creating formulas,
- 37:11look UPS, manipulating data, etcetera.
- 37:13And so I've saved myself a day and a half, but I had to stop
- 37:17and go, right? No, trust it, trust in the tech
- 37:19and user. And even if you don't, the
- 37:21learning of what the boundaries or what you can and cannot do
- 37:24will help you to make smarter decisions you go forward.
- 37:26So I mean, I personally, if I was the owner of an E Comm
- 37:29business or I was the director recruiting and I wanted a senior
- 37:33E Comm manager. If they didn't have skills and
- 37:36knowledge and understanding of the AI elements of tech and how
- 37:39it can be used internally but also within the ECOM tech stack
- 37:43that they would be managing or demand investment in, that
- 37:47wouldn't be enough for me to take the box and go, right.
- 37:49I think you're strong enough candidate.
- 37:51I I think one of the things that, and I guess we probably
- 37:54had loads of time now, but I'll just say this lastly.
- 37:57So I think what I found really interesting because I completely
- 38:00agree with what you just said. And this is a slightly different
- 38:03topic, but so you know, my wife has, so she left Clayview four
- 38:08or five months ago and she's been really careful looking for
- 38:11a new role. But essentially she wanted an
- 38:13implementation or like kind of product strategy role in an E
- 38:18com SAS business. She's seen about 8 jobs she
- 38:20liked and all of them have been super competitive.
- 38:23And quite early on, I think she realised, and this applies to us
- 38:27I guess as well and lots of companies that the only thing
- 38:32that can give you a competitive advantage now is being able to
- 38:35demonstrate your experience and knowledge of AI.
- 38:41So it is basically spent the last however long just learning
- 38:44Chord and like various different courses, which I think is also
- 38:48amazing what's available to like learn all this stuff.
- 38:52And I think now because also AI and the economy and shall find
- 39:00anything else has really impacted the competitiveness for
- 39:04roles. So like every role we put out,
- 39:06we have hundreds of applicants that unemployment is not great
- 39:09and it's going to get worse. And actually now I think you're,
- 39:14it is critical to have working knowledge as a candidate of AI
- 39:20unless it's a very specific role and you have a very specific set
- 39:24of skills or backgrounds that makes you a perfect candidate.
- 39:27I actually, yeah, I basically I'm just completely agreeing
- 39:31that I think, yeah, anyone looking at moving into a role
- 39:34that isn't director level now should be thinking how can I
- 39:39demonstrate that I am extremely capable from an AI perspective
- 39:44and yeah, I can input into the best way for the business of my
- 39:48role to use AI to be more effective.
- 39:51Yeah, I, I think that's it. It's I'm not saying that AI
- 39:54should take over. I definitely am not advocating
- 39:57AI should replace people unless you have yeah, tell you what it
- 40:01can replace and I know for a fact it can is where some people
- 40:05in projects go. Oh would you like We need a temp
- 40:07for a couple of weeks to to to sort this data out on a
- 40:10spreadsheet Is I. Well, actually there are times
- 40:13I've been in projects, people go, oh, I just need do you know
- 40:15what, we'll we'll pay the agency a bit extra and they can sort
- 40:17this copy is like, well, actually you don't need to
- 40:19anymore for a lot of these tasks.
- 40:21So if it is, we need to resort all the data and we need to
- 40:25format and normalise and that's got being sentence case.
- 40:28We need that lower. There are no hyphens or we got
- 40:30all these weird characters as well.
- 40:32Actually, you need someone to spend a couple of hours writing
- 40:35really precise prompts and numerated commands into an AI
- 40:40model that will do it all for you.
- 40:42And then you just need to spot check and validate it.
- 40:44So there are, I think there are tasks that can be removed, not
- 40:47people. And I don't I hate the prospect
- 40:50of remove people. It's let people have better,
- 40:54more enjoyable jobs and be smarter and, you know, value
- 40:56add. But what it will change, in my
- 40:58opinion, is the Nate, the type of person that people recruit in
- 41:02the future. Yeah.
- 41:05But the the other thing, so I'm interested in whether you see
- 41:07this now and I think I think maybe the type of project I work
- 41:10on is probably more biased towards this is AI think linked
- 41:13to this and linked to the point of this isn't a bad game really
- 41:16people, but it's the skill set is I for I foresee a a more and
- 41:20I've seen it in some some businesses recruiting econ
- 41:23product managers to sit underneath a head of ecom.
- 41:27The head of Ecom is the more traditional strategic trading,
- 41:32you know, PNL numbers, the whole piece that whole how E com fits
- 41:37within the business and delivers against business objectives,
- 41:39budgeting, you name it. Whereas a shop, Shopify, an E
- 41:43com product manager, whether it's e-commerce or Shopify,
- 41:46Adobe, whatever stack your arm is more in this tech space more.
- 41:51And therefore that that product knowledge, the technology
- 41:54knowledge, the AI capability knowledge within platform or
- 41:56within other tools and understands things like the
- 41:59product data model, which impacts the AI discovery piece.
- 42:04They understand like check out logics, app ecosystems, the
- 42:08discount capabilities, the the automation and flows and built
- 42:12that you can build out of it and run Rd. maps.
- 42:15That, to me is the role that's going to grow because that
- 42:17person can then execute on and use the tools more effectively.
- 42:23I think, yeah, we've already seen that, to be honest.
- 42:25And I think those there's people that are in those roles that can
- 42:28build landing pages, they can draw.
- 42:32They just essentially everything we've talked about, they're just
- 42:34very hands on and scrappy and able to do what would have taken
- 42:39days and required multiple third parties and people in minutes.
- 42:44And yeah, I think I completely agree.
- 42:46And the value of those people is getting so high as well.
- 42:50But yeah, I completely agree. Yeah, amusingly, I have a client
- 42:54I've just helped. I gave a bit of advice on
- 42:56recruiting a new econ manager and they're on Magento.
- 43:00They've under nerd about moving away from an open source to like
- 43:04modern SAS look at Shopify big commerce.
- 43:07But they they just don't have the the revenue to justify the
- 43:10re platform it and they were looking at new econ managers and
- 43:15none of them had any Magento experience.
- 43:17And my big flag to them was you need someone with Magento
- 43:19experience because you've got A1A one person team and you want
- 43:23them to be hands on. They're not going to know how to
- 43:25use Magenta. They're not going to understand
- 43:26category management, they're not going to understand the
- 43:28limitations. They're not understand how it
- 43:30works day-to-day. So I think I, I personally think
- 43:33this is exactly the right way to be going because you're right, I
- 43:36lied the way you've used Scrappy a lot over the years.
- 43:38But I like that because I've got one of my main clients, they've
- 43:41just bought a new Shopify project manager and she's really
- 43:44structured and really smart, but she has that Scrappy element
- 43:47where she can just get shit done and go right.
- 43:49Well, I know I can do this or I could use a flow for that.
- 43:51Or actually I can just create a meta field and do this and that
- 43:54will now drive that. And if you don't have the
- 43:57ecosystem centre not or even, oh, this app will do this best
- 44:00and it's cheaper than those ones.
- 44:02If you don't have that knowledge, decision making takes
- 44:04longer and you can also spend money really poorly, right?
- 44:10So let's wrap this up in summary, because you're right,
- 44:12we can ramble on for hours. So I've got a couple of key
- 44:15points. What will be yours?
- 44:16And my summary is that AI and agenda commas are reshaping
- 44:21discoverability, not just product but your brand as well.
- 44:24So some focus is shifting from traditional channels, not all to
- 44:28machine readable data. e-commerce streams are need to
- 44:32restructure and are in terms of core structures, the roles and
- 44:36the skills they need to stay in touch with evolutions in shopper
- 44:40behaviour in tech and the demand for hybrid AI illiterate talent
- 44:44is rising. Those are my core takeaways.
- 44:46Yeah, I mean, I think to be honest, I didn't really add
- 44:48anything. I think you covered everything
- 44:50there. I think.
- 44:50Yeah, just the more time you can invest in learning this stuff.
- 44:54I mean, I've seen a number. I mean, I've seen some pretty
- 44:57successful tech companies recently that don't have any
- 45:00developers and it's just no code.
- 45:02And I'm. Yeah, one of my friends has
- 45:04built something pretty smart in the shop fire world, again
- 45:07without developers. And yeah, I mean, the stuff that
- 45:10I'm seeing, some of the newer tools design as well, it's just
- 45:14crazy like. And I think the more time you
- 45:16can invest in it, the more you'll be able to achieve.
- 45:19And yeah. OK, there we go.
- 45:24That is our our unstructured ramblings on the topic of how
- 45:28current E com tech trends are influencing E com strategy and
- 45:32team structures. Feel free to disagree with us.
- 45:35Feel free to point out glaring gaps in what we've talked about.
- 45:38Do reach out, do add comments to the posts we put on LinkedIn.
- 45:41But thanks as always for listening.
- 45:44You're listening to the Insidecommerce podcast hosted by
- 45:47experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 45:50Insidecommerce is your fast tracked additional knowledge
- 45:52feature in interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 45:55industry thought leads and the C-Suite key tech companies to
- 45:58explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 46:00and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 46:03really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 46:06to help fine tune your ecom strategy and taste.
- 46:09Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 46:12like to discuss an Ecom's project.
- 46:14We hope you enjoy the latest episode.