Latest / Braver New Worlds / What We Get Wrong About Environmentalism with Anne Middleton of WILDCOAST
Transcript
- Nathan: being able to do this podcast and have these conversations with my guests. But there's another part of all of this that I'm excited about too. And I wanna share that with you now. Hello, welcome back to Braver New Worlds, a podcast about the stories we need to tell for the future that we want to see. My name is Nathan Young. I am your host Alongside these podcast conversations, I'm also building out a set of live gatherings a way of bringing people together in person have conversations similar to the one that we're having with each other here. been excited about today's interview because I am talking to Anne Middleton. She is the Director at Wild Coast and we get to geek out together on nature and ⁓ and conservation. ⁓ She much more about all of these things than I am. I am like a hobbyist, she has a master's degree, The event series I'm putting together, it's called Big Idea Night. I'm bringing together smart and thoughtful people own community to share what they know and what they is at different venues all around my hometown of San Diego. She has a background in all of this working internationally in Cameroon, sustainable ebony sourcing and supply chain transparency for Taylor guitars. She also worked with the Environmental Agency in Washington, DC. at these events. They'll be giving a presentation and sharing stories about the big ideas that they have to share, returning to the audience and inviting people in attendance to have a conversation amongst themselves about the big idea as it's being presented too. And in that role, she was able to contribute to landmark wildlife crime investigations, such ivory and wood markets. and management from UC Santa Barbara's Bren School. about creating opportunities for people to meet each other, engage with the ideas that we think are important, and think collectively about how we can live and lead into a changing world. now of course she does conservation ecosystem in San Diego and Mexico with Wild Coast. Over time, I envision this growing into a community for thoughtful people to come together and share the stories and ideas that could potentially make our world a better place. so if you're in San Diego and this sounds interesting to you, check it out. It's called Big Idea Night. You can go to bigideanight.com or find us on social media. And I'll include a link in the show notes here too. And you're not in San Diego, but you're interested or interested in bringing this to your city, let's talk. Maybe there's a way that that could be done. I know a lot of the projects that she works on are these lagoons here in San Diego, which I love. They're beautiful places to go walk around, especially this time of year, springtime. There's a lot of migrating birds that are showing up there. I became a bird nerd during the pandemic. So I'm out there with binoculars and a little chart, checking to see what birds I see. Right. Thanks for listening to my little spiel and now back to the show. in this episode, we dig into We talk about restoration ecology, why conservation isn't just like a nice to have and basically everything the products we buy to the way our cities are built shapes the world we in. We also get into some bigger questions about and about hope and about what it would actually look like to live a city and our own lifestyles that are like more aligned with natural systems that we depend on so much. And so you've ever wondered what actually matters it comes to saving the environment or overwhelmed by where even or like all the different things that you could or should do, think you'll get a lot out of episode. let's get into it. thanks so much to Anne for coming on the show with us here and I really appreciate just the conversation and the work that she's doing. as I said in the intro, I'm big fan of our natural world. want it exist and continue to exist and thrive and get better and improve and to like have more of it available. we need too, right? Couple things I'm taking away from this conversation is just how foundational this all is. Like the environment some ⁓ project, nice to have type of thing. It's like the thing that everything else depends on and the contradictions that creates here in San Diego where I live. know I have some, ⁓ viewers and listeners in other of world. if you care to share how it works in your city, love to hear that too. But then also like, yeah, these tensions we talked about between action and the larger systems and what can we actually do and how much we should be guilting ourselves over that one extra coffee cup that we throw away or whatever it is. Because it's actually really hard for us as individuals to live sustainably in this world that we have set up. the day-to-day of the lifestyle that we've all ⁓ more or inherited but ⁓ also been to. requires us to, little bit more of a consumer-centric life. welcome to the podcast. Anne Middleton: I am so excited to be here. I've really been looking forward to this for pretty much since you invited me. So thanks for having me. Nathan: I try to minimize it, but I am constantly buying stuff. even now, I'm looking around like, oh, it's like in this room here, there's just stuff, more stuff than I actually want. At the time, I bought it all thinking like, oh, this is an important piece of stuff to have. now that I'm looking around, like, well, it's stuff. Alright, cool cool. Just to start things off, just in your own words, can you tell us a little bit about who you are and what you do? Anne Middleton: Yeah, it's always a struggle to find the right words for that. My name is Anne Middleton. grew up in Montana. I love being outside, which led me to a career in conservation. I am also a musician. I play in a couple bands and I like to make cakes. Nathan: Anyways, you can find links to Anne's work and Wild Coast and all the different projects. She's in even her band down in the show notes. And if you got something out of this episode that you care to share, we would love to hear it. You can send us a message or find us on social media, at Braver New Worlds on everything I always post a lot of clips from each episode on social media. You like to make cakes? This is new. Tell me about these cakes. Anne Middleton: Yeah, ⁓ my gosh, if I could do my life over, would start a bakery. It's like my Zen happy place. So if you ever need any baked goods, just because you want to eat your feelings or you're going to an let me know because it's art for me. But I don't actually like to eat sweets very much. So I ⁓ end giving away everything that I make. ⁓ Nathan: If you haven't already, like and subscribe, go find us on social media, share with friends, thank you for listening to Braver New Worlds. Okay. Okay, is there like a certain kind of cake you specialize in? I don't want to be like too much of an attention, but now I'm curious about this. Anne Middleton: Yeah, well, I mean, because baking is science, right? ⁓ cooking is more art. I think baking is science. I have this recipe for a sour cream chocolate cake that has cream cheese, peanut butter, whipped frosting with chocolate ganache on top. And it is insanely delicious. It's the richest thing you'll ever eat. And so that's my go to if I'm trying to impress somebody. Nathan: Hmm? Okay. Okay. All right, okay. I get on my Instagram, I get these like hyper realistic cakes where it like looks like anything. Yes. And like just the most random stuff. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And it's like who like, to me it seems so strange that they have the skill to make something like that and they make it in something ephemeral as Anne Middleton: I love those. It looks like a cell phone or like a bowl of ramen. Yeah, wow. Well, very telling, I guess. Create art, it disappears. mean, such is life, right? ⁓ Nathan: I so, Yeah, yeah, exactly. But okay, so we're not here to talk about cake though. We are here to talk about restoration, mean, we can, we'll get, we can, but restoration, conservation and restoration ecology. That was like the original premise of what we're gonna talk about. And I was excited to have you on here too, because as I've shared with you, I'm a little bit of an ecology nerd on a hobby level, so. Anne Middleton: Darn. Ha My people, yes, I knew we had so much in common. Nathan: Yes. Yes, right? like, if you ever go for a hike with me, I mean, probably you won't get this, or maybe you will, but I'll be like, you know, can I tell you about fire ecology? Do you want to hear about fire ecology? I'll talk about it. Okay. And also, I geek out on kind of maybe what the habitats around here, especially around San Diego, like what they looked like before the white man came and paved everything over and... Anne Middleton: Always, always. Nathan: what it looked like is for the people that lived here before us and how they interacted with the land. I'm like always very curious about all of that. So I don't know if these are things that you know much about or. Anne Middleton: Poof. Yes. Well, we're in a good spot for someone with your level of curiosity because San Diego County is one of the most biodiverse places on the planet. Not just in California, not just in the United States. With our of ecosystems from to desert, we have more biodiversity than almost anywhere else the world. So ideally, we will keep and some of that Nathan: Yeah, yeah. Anne Middleton: ⁓ which is kind of what I do in my day job. Nathan: Yeah. Okay. so yeah, tell me, What is the day in the life of a restoration ecologist and conservationist in your role, at least? Anne Middleton: you want the technical side or the existential crisis side? I think I'll tell you both if that's okay. ⁓ so, the day in the of a conservationist, on the technical end is are biologists. Well, I'll speak on my own behalf. I view the world through a different lens. We all view the world through several different lenses, For me, I'm always looking at a landscape level, but also at a molecular level. Like how are things interacting? How are pollutants being transported? How is development impacting biodiversity and species richness? Does this bumblebee actually belong here? Did it come from somewhere else? Are these plants being pollinated according to their natural cycles, et cetera? I could go down many, many nerd rabbit holes there, but Nathan: Yeah. Anne Middleton: the ⁓ end, it's a tough time to be in the environmental space. It's always been tough. We're always fighting a battle that we feel like shouldn't be a battle in the first place and that is and overlooked. However, it's critically to all of humanity that we have functioning ecosystems and living in Nathan: Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: a world in which we have an administration that blatantly disregards of these natural systems ⁓ the name of profit. ⁓ a very hard to be doing anything in which you are working with and trying to conserve nature. But it's one of my favorite things about this space too, is you find extremely passionate, outspoken, grounded, Nathan: Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: aggressive, crazy people. So I like that. In a good way. Yeah, yeah. Nathan: Okay. Like in a good way. Crazy in a good way. Okay. I'm of what the the kind of challenges are that you run up against and like, obviously, there's the big ones of you know, policy and money. But I'm also like curious about the more the emotional challenges of getting people invested, too, because I know it's the type of thing that like we all sort of nominally want this. But then We're not necessarily making the day to day decisions that lead to it. And I don't know if that, you how much that comes up on a personal level a larger, you city or county or statewide policy level or country level or ⁓ what. Anne Middleton: Mm-hmm. Yeah, very good question. I have a lot of different ways to answer that. First of all, say that I go through my life day to day thinking that our relationship with our environment and the way we treat our natural resources is arguably the number one most important thing. to say that all of the socioeconomic issues that we all care about so deeply are not important, because they very much are. But if we don't have clean air and access to drinking water, global wars won't matter, ⁓ you know, affordable housing won't matter. Access to arts won't matter. And so I think one of the ways that the quote unquote environmental movement has failed over the last 50, 60, 70 years is that the environment has become this wedge issue, this this politically left thing, this afterthought where we think, OK, it's it's almost reserved for Nathan: Yeah. Anne Middleton: people of a higher socioeconomic class or know, only white rich people can afford to buy organic vegetables, for example, and being dramatic to make a point. But instead, in for us all to be successful biologically, ecologically, and then financially and politically the road, we have to be making decisions about environment from the very beginning. And I think that this is something that ecological knowledge knows and has been trying to say for a long time indigenous groups have been saying this forever. And we have been getting it wrong. as a result, seeing human health issues, depression. Things like autism could be caused by environmental pollutants that we just don't know about yet or all of the forever chemicals in our water. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Anne Middleton: I kind of went on a different tangent there, but I think that if we treat our environment and our natural resources a person, as an entity in the conversation from the beginning, we'd all be so much better off. And then to answer the second part of your question, it's to go about life thinking about this because as a consumer, as a lay person, as ⁓ someone, example, who isn't in my career field. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: It is incredibly difficult ⁓ environmentally conscious decisions part of the time, let alone most of the time and all the time. ⁓ economy is based on we throw away, things that are convenient, things that are extractive, ⁓ the line, the cheapest, way to get you to spend more money. ⁓ And that antithetical to conservation. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, that's where I was curious to ask about too, because when you said like, it needs to be the conversation from the beginning, but that is a sort of intention with like, like, which conversation, who's having that conversation? And where is the beginning of that conversation? Because for so many of us, as much as we might want to really like about this, even you and me, I'm sure we're both guilty of this. We're like, but we're still going to work. We're still driving to work every day. We're still Anne Middleton: Do you this? Nathan: going on freeways, I'm buying coffees and stuff and I'm trying to like keep my impact to the minimum, but there's still, probably producing way more trash on a daily basis than people did in a year, a hundred years ago. it's just a tough situation to, to deal with and sort of make sense of when the way that our society flows doesn't really, like, it just almost can't do it. Anne Middleton: It really is. Yeah, well, I'm sure you to many experts who are much more eloquent than I in explaining why this is a top down problem and how the people making the decisions At the top are not really concerned about health and well-being and environmental conservation initiatives. However, I be able to do my job if I didn't believe that even small daily decisions by everyone up make big difference. on the flip side of that, individuals and organizations pulled out or gave up their sustainability initiatives, we would get to a much worse space a more quickly. ⁓ Before I moved to San Diego, I was living ⁓ in Cameroon in West Africa, working Taylor guitars, helping them create Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Anne Middleton: sustainable forest initiatives for of the species, ebony, that goes in their guitars. And became wonderfully obsessed with global supply chains, specifically as it relates to wood products. ⁓ And the that we buy at IKEA that's cheap and convenient and it falls apart and then you ⁓ buy another next time you move could be made from wood fibers from Nathan: Okay. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: Habitat in Siberia and we don't know that as consumers and you have Intentionally seek out companies like Taylor guitars who are doing their best to do the right thing and that's only one tiny piece of their supply chain, which is also incredibly expensive and politically complicated to clarify and to create transparency. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Anne Middleton: With our plastics and our electronics and we live in Southern California where unless you have all the free time in the world and are extremely fit and prefer to cycle everywhere, you can't get anywhere ⁓ our public transit system. You always have to have a car. we quit believing that the things we're doing for the environment or anything a difference, then we may as well give up now. And I am not giving up. Nathan: Yeah. Anne Middleton: I'm not giving up and I do not surround myself with people who give up. And I think that's how we became friends too. We kind of run in the same circles of people who are really trying hard to make our communities better places to live for everybody. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. That resonates so much. I think, it is inconceivable give up on this. Not that I'm necessarily doing a whole hell of a lot, like, every little piece of land that I see, I'm like, please don't develop that. Please don't develop that. Please don't develop that. Anne Middleton: Yeah. I mean, this is like super crass, but we're friends, so can tell you this. When people ask me what can I do to save the environment? And I try not to roll my eyes when they say things like, recycle, which is like a whole nother podcast. I won't get into that. Like, good. Okay, cool. The two most impactful things any person in the United States or anywhere really can do for the environment is not reproduce and to vote Nathan: Yeah. Anne Middleton: for people who care about environmental initiatives. So in that regard, Nathan, I think we're both doing pretty well. ⁓ Not that I'm ⁓ kids, I love kids and we need responsible people to continue to raise responsible humans, there are too many people on this planet, right? ⁓ In biology we say we've exceeded our carrying capacity and we probably exceeded it a long time ago, but that's why you're seeing all of these global ills Nathan: Hahaha Yeah, yeah, right. Yeah. Anne Middleton: such as global warming, for example, while we're sitting here in Southern California in early March and it's 90 degrees, that's not normal. ⁓ Nathan: Yes, it's been a very creepy winter in that regard. Yeah, you're right, and there's plenty of room for aunties and uncles out there. people in your life that have kids, they need aunties and uncles for those kids, so you can just play that role. And like the great part about that is you just get to show up, have fun, and leave, and that's it. Anne Middleton: Mm-hmm. yeah, yeah. This morning was speaking at a high school and it was environmental studies and social class. I was like, yes, people, this is great. And just hearing the ideas that these students had, it's like, my gosh, this is like college level thinking. It's kind of embarrassing that now you're at that age where we're saying, yeah, when I was your age, people were telling me your generation gets it. You're going to get it right. And now I'm standing up in front of all these students saying, well, we tried and we didn't really get very far. So now it's your problem. Nathan: Ugh. Yeah, now it's you. Yeah, yeah, we recycled ⁓ and made recycling normal. Whether or not that stuff we put in the bin actually ends up getting recycled. Anne Middleton: But, But Yeah, exactly. But know, there is a lot of good news. I don't want people to think of the environment as there's nothing I can do and it's all doom and gloom. We've made a lot of strides in the last several decades and there's something that we all can do and we don't have to and we cannot lose hope. So for example, the organization we're in now, Wild Coast, what we do is in our name, we're preserving wild coasts and we tell people if there's a natural space as defined as like not having been developed yet. We want to keep it that way. And there's biological and economic and intrinsic value in keeping open spaces open full of biodiversity and not full of marinas and industry and highways. even in San Diego County, people live here because of the amazing recreational opportunities we have. We have hiking, we have the beach, we... Nathan: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: can go paddle boarding on the bay. And these beautiful spaces continue to exist because organizations like Wild Coast are working hard to continue to keep them protected in that way. And when people like you and I go and visit them and whether you're paying a park fee or supporting other nonprofit organizations or just telling your friends about these beautiful spaces where we recreate, that also has value it helps us Nathan: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: to continue to do the work that we're doing. So everybody can do something ⁓ ⁓ die that because ⁓ if I think that then I'd have to open a bakery. Nathan: You're good. I'm not gonna take the bakery bait again, we're gonna stay on topic. So what is some of the work that goes into restoration nowadays? I know when we first met, I live up in North County and there's all these lagoons up here. And I know these lagoons are sort of a big spot where lot of restoration work is happening. And at least from my perspective, definitely looks like these lagoons are amazing. I them. I love San Elijo Lagoon and Bataquitos Lagoon. And able to walk along the edge there and you see all these different birds that are migrating and hanging out. there. especially at San Elijo, there's osprey and guess there eagles there not too long ago. So it's just such a cool opportunity to able to walk around in those environments. Anne Middleton: Yay! Yeah. ⁓ Nathan: And I know that these a lot of restoration work has happened in all these places over the years too. I don't know if that's overlapping with the type of work you do or what is, but tell us more about like what restoration is and how it works. Anne Middleton: Yeah, no, good question. So we, if you've been to Badaquitos Lagoon recently, we have an active project there, we Wild Coast. And restoration really is removing invasive species, meaning species that don't ⁓ naturally there, such as ⁓ eucalyptus, example, or ice plant, and then planting native species, meaning species that biologically evolved to exist there. And why that is important is that evolved together. Like the species in ecosystems co-evolved to have these beautiful biological synergies so that birds, bees, bats, carnivores, plants all serve a purpose for one another. They're either pollinating each other or one's eating the other or one is serving as the food for the other. when you start to replace native species with non-native species, that it doesn't create space for the natural ecosystem to thrive. And so the example of Bataquitos ⁓ been removing eucalyptus trees ⁓ ice plants ⁓ ⁓ native species that belong there. Some tree species might include like coast live oak for example, or native milkweeds for the butterflies. Because if we don't do that, then we'll start to see little by little kind of a house of ecological cards collapsing. I mean, you know all this, you love ecology. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. But not every, yeah, not every realistic does. So keep going. But you can go a little more in depth if you want. Anne Middleton: Yeah, so especially in urban areas, we have these islands ⁓ native biodiversity such as the lagoons in San Diego County, because the rest of the county is either paved over for highways or parking lots or lawns where they're bringing in grasses or palm trees that don't belong here. There's really only one palm tree that is native to California, the fan palm. big tall trees that you see in Hollywood Boulevard, those are actually not native to California. And so these ⁓ biodiversity these pockets that we have all over county are critically valuable to the wildlife, especially migratory wildlife like birds and butterflies. don't have many carnivores anymore, although I'm also on the board for the Escondido Creek Conservancy. And we're setting up cammon traps in some of our parcels of land in North County and working with some scientists to try to trap and collar one of the mountain lions that we've seen on our property. So carnivores are a critical part, again, of ecosystems as well, either as keystone species, meaning that they kind of connect to all the other species. And if one disappears, then one takes over or one doesn't take over. Nathan: Yeah. Anne Middleton: yeah, in the United States, most of our wide migratory carnivores have been extirpated or off, decimated off their land, grizzly bears, wolves, sharks. Another good example, but yeah, It's literally impossible restore any ecosystem now to what it quote unquote was naturally for two reasons. One, climate change. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: Because as it gets warmer, disturbs the blooming or the circadian rhythms or the migratory patterns of plants and animals. So what once used to in a circle, for example, if you had plants and animals coexisting in a specific geographic area, as it gets warmer, the plants might migrate northward or to a different area where it's not as hot, whereas... Nathan: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: the birds and butterflies are not used to that and they come back and there's not enough plants to eat. So that's the number one reason. The second reason is that humans are and have been parts of these ecosystems for a very long time. we've done a great job in the United States of dispossessing people of their lands and to have a natural space, a conserved area with no people in it is not really quote unquote Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Anne Middleton: natural either. So that's also a whole other topic for discussion. we can do to support native of place is ⁓ worth the and because also as scientists, we'll be the first to admit that we don't fully understand what happens when these systems totally break down. I mean, have a lot of Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Anne Middleton: predictions and they're not great, but it could be worse. If we, for destroy all of our pollinators, what happens to our agricultural system? ⁓ So are lots of human impacts of neglecting nature. Nathan: Yeah, yeah, yeah, Yeah. Diego is such an interesting contradiction around these things on some level too, I always think, so I lived in Portland for a while and people in Portland, talk like, there's just like a whole city full of tree huggers there. ⁓ They drove me bonkers, I'm gonna be honest with you, drove me bonkers. It but I think was interesting because I visited a lot of cities. Anne Middleton: Yeah! Nathan: And one of things I've always noticed about San Diego is I've lived in so many different parts of San Diego and any part of San Diego I lived, there was like a natural space within walking distance of it, like, or like a biking distance. And I don't know that a lot of other cities have this. So like, yeah, we have all this sprawl, but also like amidst all that sprawl, there's all these fingers of natural spaces that follow these canyons and stuff. ⁓ And the same time, you don't hear conversations about conservation Anne Middleton: Mm-hmm. Nathan: as to why those canyons exist. It seemed like they sort of exist accidentally because it just wasn't really profitable to like pave over those sections and somehow, cool, we got this canyon, you know? Anne Middleton: Yeah. Bingo. Yeah, that's actually why a lot of natural spaces exist. It didn't really make sense to develop on ⁓ And lucky the wildlife here in San Diego, a lot of the canyons, the canyon lands migratory habitats and it's where ephemeral streams. so there's lots interesting plant life and you see the coyotes coming going and the birds and things like that. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: Usually in an urban area, if something isn't developed, it's either because we had something like the 1915 World Fair here in San Diego and created Balboa Park, which is also not natural, but at least it's an open green space. The canyon areas are because, yeah, we just got lucky. It's too hard to build a house in the realm of the canyon. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. point there that contradiction that came up. You mentioned something about how we can't talk about like food security and water security or affordable housing if we're not caring about the environment. But sometimes those are things like affordable housing and like job creation stuff. Those the things that get brought up this be like, well, that's why we got to pave over this because we need the housing there and we need the jobs doing that and that kind of inherent contradiction in our environmental stuff too. Anne Middleton: Okay. my gosh, you're so right. ⁓ a lot of interesting laws in any urban area in the United States, but particularly in San Diego about building height. And that's where public policy comes in and city council is so important because really what we should be doing, this is my ecological point of view, is we should be building in and up, not out, right? More density, taller buildings, ⁓ people Nathan: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: in the areas that are already developed so we can reserve our quote unquote open space outside of our urban areas for nature agriculture in some cases, although even agriculture can be done on rooftops and inside. So a policy issue and see that come up regularly on ballots and the NIMBYism, the not in my backyard and even people in... ⁓ particularly in historic neighborhoods or like anti-ADU. We don't want more construction here. We like it how it is. I just think, yeah, I'm sure that the wildlife is probably saying that too. We like it how it is. And you came in and built a neighborhood. So ⁓ lot of competing interests, some of whom don't voices or can't make it to city council meetings. And so it is a public policy issue. And when you have Nathan: Yeah, yeah, totally. Anne Middleton: powerful lobbyists for development, oil and gas, water, SDG &E, whatever it may pushing these things, they often win. I spent five years of my career early on living and working in Washington, DC for an organization that did environmental lobbying on the Hill. I worked for a group called the Environmental Investigation Agency. It was so fun. We did undercover trade crime investigations on environmentally sensitive species of wood animals. So like ivory, tortoise shell, tiger skins, illegal wood, which is how I got involved with Taylor guitars. And we would document illegal supply chains ⁓ undercover footage and then lobby legislative solutions. So our whole thing you have to shut down demand. It's not necessarily a supply issue. It's a demand issue. If you shut down the legal demand for these things, you're helping on the supply end. So if ivory is completely illegal to trade around the world, which it is, in theory, it should help the elephants. Of course, there's a big black market. And at the time we were working to shut that down too. am saying all this? a It's a political quagmire. It's a dance. It's a fight that isn't as simple as understanding the science. have a saying at Wild Coast that ⁓ science is the easy part. We all know how to do the science. That's why I science in school because I like knowing that there's an answer. I like getting from point A to point B in a logical manner and saying, okay, we did it. This is how it goes. Nathan: Yeah Yeah. Anne Middleton: And it turns out that when you're doing conservation work or almost anything anymore, you have to take account the socioeconomics, the politics. you may say, I have the answer, which we do for public transit, for climate change, for sustainable water use, for feeding the world. We have all of these answers. exist technologically. We have the intellectual capacity to solve these problems. What we don't have is the Nathan: Yeah. Anne Middleton: political will, which leads to the funding. So in San Diego, back to San Diego, ⁓ if aren't willing and able legally to ⁓ house ⁓ in way ⁓ that continue to destroy open space, then we're going to keep destroying open space. We're going to keep destroying natural spaces and biological diversity will suffer ⁓ and Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Anne Middleton: People suffer too, because you have to travel farther and farther to get to your jobs and that's more expensive and it's this like downward spiral of ⁓ doing things in a way that really just don't make sense. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, totally. What? It's interesting too because yeah, lot of it too isn't necessarily. Because always that weird demand also, right? There's always gonna be somebody that wants their house right on the edge of civilization, right on the edge of development, or like kinda out in a different place. And you're there's like a sort of demand thing, there's a cultural thing behind all of that also that's always gonna be a challenge to put out there too. What do you think, ⁓ go ahead. ⁓ Anne Middleton: Excuse me. Yeah, well... I was gonna say, One of the most interesting classes I ever took was in undergrad. I went to Oberlin College in Ohio and I took a class on the history of the American environment. It's interesting to think about how as society, we started viewing ⁓ wilderness other, as out there, right? And it's, Nathan: Mmm. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: civilization and wilderness. And civilization has order and predictability and it's profitable. Wilderness is scary and wild and dark you go there and you get eaten by bears and things like that. And this is portrayed a lot of art too in the early 19th century and even before that. And it's ⁓ deeply in our culture that nature is something that is outside of us. Whereas really, we're all living and functioning in an ecosystem. And there are inputs and outputs and different layers of bacterial and animal plant biodiversity that all impact the air that we breathe, the water that we drink, the flavor of our food, the availability of our food. And I honestly don't know how to... Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: rebuild that concept, right? I mean, again, if you have millions of dollars and lots of time, there are ways to build truly sustainable societies where we grow your own food, you filter your own water. But, in today's world and economy, that's like, you may as well say, like, let's build a colony on the moon or something like that. So ⁓ I don't know, if Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Anne Middleton: kind of gets at what you're thinking about. it's the way that we view and treat nature and even like think about it next time you watch a movie or a cartoon or even the stuff we grew up on like Bambi for example and you've got hunters and deer and wildfires and is separate. There's society and there's nature. Nathan: Yeah. Anne Middleton: And they're two completely different things that are to be managed differently and they don't interact with one another. It's nature is somewhere where we go visit if we're lucky, if we have access and time that we don't have the time and the space to keep thinking about nature in way. It is all around us. Even if you are native species in your garden at home, even if it's just a four by four plot or if you have Nathan: Yeah. Anne Middleton: native milkweed on your patio because you don't have a yard because you live in San Diego, that is creating food for a monarch butterfly that might not survive if it weren't there. So even these, going back to these micro decisions that we can all make on a small scale, really add up to be something big that is the very least we can be doing as society right now, I think. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, because now you're getting at like, this is like my little realm, like that's a narrative, basically. It's a narrative, like nature and civilizations being separate. We've got that narrative ingrained in our society. And yeah, it's got to change on like a narrative level. That'd be my, one of my hypotheses. So Here's where I'm curious to ask you though, like kind of going in that direction. and I want you to think like, pie in the sky of like, what would it look like if we, Anne Middleton: Mm hmm. Nathan: we're able to take the vision you have in your head for what a very ecologically sustainable San Diego would look like. And like, be willing to be like kind of, yeah. But be like, you pie in the sky and like, like your, your thoughts on that too, that don't necessarily have to like adhere to some kind of like realistic science thing. Like just you get a magic wand to do this. What does it, how does it look? Anne Middleton: That is a big question. I love that. Yeah. Okay, I'm going to start with the problems, but I think I have solutions to it. I don't want to just load you up with problems. So from this is just my personal opinion, but I think the two biggest problems we have with regard to sustainability in San Diego County are transit and water. So anyone who's even visited here for five minutes know that we have a poorly functioning, inadequate public transit system. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: I'm a cyclist and so I'm a little bit biased, but we live in a place where you really could ride your bike every day. You know, it doesn't snow, the roads aren't icy. It's not super hilly, most neighborhoods. So if we had really well public transit, including cycling and pedestrian access within neighborhoods, that would go a very, very long way to helping us be quote unquote ⁓ Again, a money thing, right? I mean, we don't, ⁓ it has to be a system that works for people. ⁓ do have trolleys and we do have buses, but ⁓ they go where people need to go at the frequency they need to go? Are they safe? Are they reliable? Are they affordable? So I think public transit needs a massive, massive Nathan: Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: And that could include policies like allowing people to work from home more. We saw that during COVID, know, like air quality dramatically improved, people weren't driving and flying around all the time. And then the second big thing is water. So whether we like to admit it or not, we live in a desert. The average rainfall in San Diego is less than 10 inches a year. we import over 85 % of our water. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah, totally. Anne Middleton: here in San Diego County. So when you turn on a tap or water your yard, that water is either likely either coming from Northern California or it's coming from the Colorado River, depending on the rain year and depending on the water makeup and water policy in California is fascinating and depressing at the same time. I spent a little while working for the San Diego County Water Authority. So I got to see some of that firsthand ⁓ and Nathan: Mm. Anne Middleton: we need to use less water. There again, there are technological solutions to this that don't have to involve you only showering every other day. Right So a really good example of this is last year, I think was measure E didn't pass on ballot and it included a small increase Nathan: Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: for the voters, but it was going to pay for stormwater infrastructure. It just rained again, was it this last January where Mission Valley was flooding again, Pacific Highway was flooding. The gym that I go to flooded twice, like big disruptions to business because our stormwater infrastructure has not been updated since the 1970s. So it's not meant to the level of floods that these atmospheric rivers are bringing. So that's one piece of it, but that is Nathan: Mm-hmm. Wow. Yeah. Anne Middleton: fresh water that could be reused and turned into potable water. And there's like the Pure Water Project in San Diego, which ⁓ was unfortunately coined like toilet to tap and that kind of grosses people out. that's what we're drinking anyway. We're drinking. ⁓ Yeah. And I know whoever thought of that. ⁓ great. ⁓ Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. It's terrible branding. You know what though? think was that like Was that like the attack though? Anne Middleton: But that's what we're drinking anyway. We're already drinking Vegas's toilet water. If you think about it, it's coming through the Colorado River aqueduct. And like we clean it and drink it. So potable reuse is what we call it in the industry. And because here in San Diego, we don't have a lot of groundwater ⁓ just of the geography and it does rain a lot. there are creative technological solutions to providing enough water for us. Nathan: ⁓ great. Anne Middleton: to live, have a vibrant economy for businesses to run, for us to shower, and even in some cases water our lawns if that's what we choose to do. But it's many things there. It's a lack of education and voting ⁓ political will and the money in the right places at the right time. So San Diego could put a little bit of thought and elbow grease and money into infrastructure for public transit, and infrastructure and portable reuse, we'd be in a much, much better place in terms of sustainability. End rant Nathan: And what? And rent? Oh, oh, and rent. OK, got it. You can. Well, I want to propose something to you, too. I'm curious to hear your thoughts on this. Because at one point during the pandemic, my girlfriend and I, the time, we were living together and we were just driving each other crazy. Or I was driving her crazy. So I had to get out. I had to live somewhere. Yeah, yeah. And so. Anne Middleton: End rant. I mean, I could keep ranting if you want. We all did that during the pandemic, My marriage ended during the pandemic. Nathan: Yeah, okay, yeah. so I ended up moving into this house out in La Mesa and woman who owned it, she was just renting out the room ⁓ and I this house. I thought it was so amazing. And what she had done is basically she had like made it into a little like oasis in the suburbs out in La Mesa. And she had redone the landscaping. So was all native plants, taken out everything, like no lawn, it all native plants. There a lot of just sagebrush. degree that she didn't have native plants, had fruit trees growing, like a vegetable garden, and that was back there. So she had almost like a little food forest in her backyard. She had, ⁓ the springtime, she had wildflowers that had all like... grown in and taken over. And so her whole yard just blew up with wildflowers in the springtime. It was amazing. She had a setup with like solar power. She was collecting rainwater. And then she also had a pond pool. She had that pool in the backyard that she converted into a pond. And so she had like plants growing outside of the pool and everything. So all these birds were coming to visit all like there's bats around the house all the time. There's bees around the house. There were dragonflies and what called mayflies or all the different cool bugs that fly around ponds. Anne Middleton: Cool. Wow. Nathan: All this stuff was happening just in this little oasis that she had set up in the middle of the suburbs. And all these bugs and birds and animals all found their way to her little ⁓ pool oasis somehow, even though it was completely disconnected from any real canyons or anything. ⁓ I just thought that was so amazing. I just wondered. Obviously this is like a huge thing, but this is like my magic wand is that we would just do that to our backyard. it would just be the way that we'd do it. We'd have native plants in our yards. We'd make a little pond in our yard or something. We'd collect our rainwater. Each one of our houses would be a little more self-sustaining, environmentally, environmental space. You know, growing a little bit of food, bit of room for birds to stop by and check it out. And it was like, it was just pleasant too. It was like the most pleasant ⁓ I'd ever been in my life. Yeah. Yes, exactly. Anne Middleton: Yeah, like calming, good for the mental health. Yeah. No, I'm glad you brought that up because that is absolutely one of the solutions that many like sustainable community advocates fight for or advocate for is we can do that if you have the space that is something you absolutely can and should be doing if you have the resources to do. And it makes a huge difference to the local wildlife. They can smell the water, they can smell the food and the flowers and they'll figure it out. bring up growing own food, which is not easy, right? And for anyone who's tried to keep a house plant alive, I mean, I'm a biologist and I can't keep my plants alive. Our global food system is Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Anne Middleton: absolutely backwards as well. And I just feel like it's just a few handfuls or a few wrong decisions away from total collapse. saw that during COVID too, right? I mean, you can get containers in and out or you can't access supply chains. Everything is global and ⁓ a commodity that we can... Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: eat avocados year round, even when you live in Minnesota. You can have blueberries from Chile anytime you want. a result of that, it's created massive carbon for one thing. It's a huge contributor to climate change. Destroying native, Cutting down rainforests in so that we can grow soy and beef for American markets ⁓ is bad for biodiversity. ⁓ Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: More importantly for people who maybe aren't necessarily ecologists, is the flavor and nutrition is being out of all of our food. You know, There's a reason people don't like to eat tomatoes because they don't taste like anything. They're mushy and they're pale. And it's because ⁓ soil they're grown in is depleted of nutrients if they're even grown in soil at all. And it's the way that we eat. And it goes back to like the fast, cheap, convenient Nathan: Yeah. Anne Middleton: is obviously bad for the planet, it's bad for us. This is not the way that humans evolved. I don't know if you've ever read Omnivore's Dilemma. Oh, highly recommend. I have an obsession with food nonfiction, so I could go on and on about that too. But yeah, it's a... Nathan: I haven't read that one, no. Okay. Anne Middleton: You know, we're not meant to eat ultra processed foods. It's bad for our physical and mental health. It's bad for the planet. What it's not bad for is the pockets of a handful of executives. And the decisions that money and politics are making is impacting human and biological health around the world. And it's just... Again, it kind of goes back to what I've been talking about, that disconnect between we live in and with our natural resources. It's like nothing in a bag of Doritos was something that you evolved to eat, right? And in fact, it's been scientifically modified that your dopamine systems are activated and you will definitely want to eat more. And I'm kind a picky eater. I try not to be, but I mean, we've been at meetings together, right? There's like a box of donuts on the table and I'm like, I'm not going to eat that. And it's not, it's not because I don't love donuts and because I'm trying to be ultra fit or something. It's because the chemicals in our food me. And I think that there are so many environmental toxins in our lives because ⁓ again, our lack of respect for our environment, our lack of respect for Nathan: Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: how we grow, obtain, distribute natural resources. And it's like, if I have any control over some sort of poison that's going into my body, I'm gonna try to it out. And it's just so, so overwhelmingly difficult. again, back to like regular consumers who are just trying to Nathan: Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: get through life and pay the bills and send their kids to school and like making decisions about supply chains when don't have time or money or ⁓ shouldn't be up to consumers to changing the tide of things. This is a corporate issue. This is a political issue. And these are top-down decisions that are impacting all of us. And Nathan: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: It's so frustrating and infuriating to think that what it results in in my field is just a lot of people saying, well, I don't know what to do. It's too much. It's too heavy. So I'm just not going to do anything. I can relate to that, right? I mean, it's very to be a conscious consumer. And I realized that I am very privileged to even be having this ⁓ argument with you and with myself, shouldn't be up to us. ⁓ gotta be a top-down thing. And we have the right people and the right pressures making the right decisions, the little decisions to add up and they have. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, well, because yeah, at the same time, like, even though it's a top down issue, like, there needs to be pressure on those people, or like getting the right people into that, those positions of the corporate leadership and political leadership to want to make the decisions that we would like in this regard. Anne Middleton: Yes, exactly. Yeah. Yep. So pay attention to who we're putting in office, pay attention to what's on the ballot. And get made fun of ⁓ some of my friends and family members, but every time it's election season, I get together with a handful of friends for several hours and go through every single ballot measure. And I'll get together people who ⁓ work the government or not, or who are subject matter experts or not and be like, what do we think about this? What really are the downstream impacts of this decision? Nathan: ⁓ wow. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Anne Middleton: How should we be voting on this? And I just think voting is so, ⁓ so important, especially now in a world where it's easy just to disengage and just be frustrated and pissed off and angry and hoping that someone dies. ⁓ have to, we have to, ⁓ is the time to like get engaged. And I think that's one of the reasons why I love like Business for Good, for example, is a place where you find the people who are Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah, someone, someone. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: making these ground level decisions and running for office and putting things on the ballot because they ⁓ for our environment, they matter for our health, they matter for education and housing and all the things that are all parts of the puzzle that have ⁓ either direct indirect impacts on the environment. So I think that you know, thinking of conservation and the environment as a separate issue as its own thing is impossible now. And I think that maybe when we were younger, it was easier to think of, save the rainforests oh, you know, like I kind of grew up in the save the rainforest era before climate change was like the big doom and gloom issue of our time. Or even simple like save the whales. That was a big great piece thing for a while. And I literally am doing that right now. That is my job. When people ask what I do, sometimes I say I save the whales. But in order to save the whales, we have to think about oil and gas policy. We have to think about development. We have to think about shipping. We have to think about ecotourism. We have to think about... Nathan: I say the whales. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: El Nino and Super El Nino and all of these things that go into saving a whale. It's like quite complicated, Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. takes a civilization. Anne Middleton: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, yeah. Nathan: So let me ask you this then, what, if anything, what if anything gives you hope right now? Anne Middleton: You know, I think that to you and people like you gives me a lot of, no, cause I think ⁓ lot of people are pissed off right now. A lot of people are mad. I feel like there's a lot of activation happening right now. ⁓ you're, you're seeing that in marches. You're seeing that in who's running for office. You're seeing that on social media and the might have to break before we can rebuild it. But. Nathan: Ha ha. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: Good. Maybe it does. ⁓ I saw something on social media the other day that was like, if every single politician named in the Epstein files was fired, we wouldn't have anyone running the country. we're like, okay, good, cool, good. They should be fucking fired. Women take over. But ⁓ what gives me hope is that Nathan: Yeah. It's little bit, yeah. Yeah, yeah, perfect. Yep, let's do it. That's Anne Middleton: we have the solutions. We are smart enough to fix the problems that we have created because because we created the problems, smart enough to fix them. ⁓ I think that there's enough frustration and energy, especially from from younger to that. This is an unacceptable way to move forward as humanity. that. I think a better future is in store. for example, someone asked me the other day what my favorite environmental policy was. And I said, the Montreal Protocol, which was the global policy that the ozone layer from Nathan: Okay. ⁓ yeah, yeah, yeah, right, yeah, yeah, Anne Middleton: disappearing forever and shrinking the hole in the ozone layer. So was like early 90s it was about eliminating SOX and NOx and the atmosphere and acid rain and things like that. And we globally decided, oh shit, we don't want a bigger hole in the ozone layer because we're all going to die. We should do something about this. And so we have recent examples of Nathan: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, yeah, yeah, totally. Anne Middleton: people coming together and making the right decisions. And there are examples of that all over the world of restoration, of reforestation, of sustainability. it's out there. ⁓ just have to keep going. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah, it does seem like we're at a moment where enough people are aware and care. And it's just like, and the younger generation's like motivated by this, but there's a sort of like, and we've been disillusioned that like capitalism is gonna fix any of this, right? So there's a sort of like detaching from that, that is the sort of hurdle. Anne Middleton: Mm-hmm. Ha, yeah. Nathan: And you're seeing people trying, at least, to find ways to detach from that. But that's where I was going to come back to, is just that notion of how we've all got to either pay our bills or keep up with what the Joneses keeps us on that trajectory. Anne Middleton: Thank you. Yeah, yeah. When we're redefining what the Jones's looks like, right? I mean, I think most people in San Diego can't afford to own a home. I am among those people and I have a good job. And so it's to have to redefine what success means, what it looks like. And you know, social media is helping and hurting that at the same time. But I think that Nathan: Yeah, yeah, right? Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Anne Middleton: there's not a lot of places for corporations to hide anymore as well. mean, Of course there's a lot of corruption and a lot of deals happening behind closed doors, but consumers have more information now than they've ever had. And we to support companies who are doing reforestation, for example, or organic farming, ⁓ or Nathan: Yeah, yeah, totally, totally. Anne Middleton: chain transparency or giving to communities or all those that consumers, think millennials and younger really supporting that are doing the right thing. So at least that seemed to be trending upward quickly before COVID happened. So hopefully come back to that. Nathan: Yeah. Anne Middleton: We vote with our dollars too. So how you spend your money, what you support, how much clothes you buy, know, like fast fashion is a huge problem for the planet. Everything that you ever need probably exists in a thrift store down the road. ⁓ we need to reuse, recycle and fix the things that are broken rather than going to buy new things. And you know, this is all stuff that we've all Nathan: Totally, totally. Yes. ⁓ Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: probably been beaten over the head with at this point, but it totally matters. you throw something away, what does that mean? It doesn't just disappear. Landfills filling up. In one of our initiatives at Wild Coast is we've installed a couple of trash retention devices in urban Tijuana they don't have centralized waste collection, either or trash. Nathan: No, just because of a landfill, yeah. Yeah. Anne Middleton: And so people get used to just throwing their trash. And by trash, mean the stuff in your kitchen tires, to sofas and baby cribs in concrete canals in Tijuana. then when it rains, all of that gets flushed out to the ocean. And because of the currents, it ends up in San Diego in the Tijuana estuary, which is a marine protected area. And so a very simple, elegant, effective, cheap solution to that is we've installed these trash booms in these concrete channels and to date we've already collected over a quarter million pounds of trash and debris in just a couple of years and then we pay community members once the water subsides to sort through it, recycle it, upcycle it. We have multiple recycle collection points across the city that weren't there before because the meantime Nathan: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: someone needs to society that we need to quit creating so much trash in the first place. But now that we have it, we're trying to figure out a way to keep it from getting into the ocean. yeah, just ⁓ the we have with our stuff needs to change and we ⁓ all control over what we buy. Nathan: Hmm? Yeah, yeah, yeah, totally. Yeah, yeah totally. Anne Middleton: So I chat like if anyone needs any takeaway from this, I hope that they just think before they buy something, whether it's a latte in a paper cup or it's a new cell phone or it's a new outfit, just say, do I really need this? What does need mean to me? And if the answer is no, then don't buy it. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. even just like, just, even just put it off for a while. Just like, just... Anne Middleton: Yeah, we just don't need so much stuff. We have too much stuff. And then we have more people who need more stuff. And it's this never-ending cycle of stuff that is piling up in our ecosystems and gonna cause humanity's collapse if we don't start to take it seriously. Nathan: Procrastinate on it. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. So we should probably wrap up. I did want to make one comment about your TED Talk because I thought it was super interesting that I had experience with as well. Your TED... Yeah, of course. So your TED Talk was about eucalyptus trees, about how they're causing like a fire danger, right? Because they're out there, they're just like more flammable than our native species. Anne Middleton: Thanks for watching! Nathan: That they're also a lot more like on the urban interface. So they're usually catching on fire and then that fire spreads to houses, right? Neighborhoods and everything, right? I think I told you on the phone that I used to be a forest service firefighter way back in the day in the previous life. I mention? Yeah. And so I'm always curious about fires the perverse kind of way too. And I was up in LA about a year ago and I went to the spot where the neighborhood north of Pasadena, Altadena. Anne Middleton: Mm-hmm. Yes. ⁓ yeah! Cool. Nathan: I went up there, just like, I was just curious. I wanted to drive through and look at it. And the wildest thing was how many trees survived the fire. I thought it was so fascinating. And not eucalyptus trees, but it was trees like sycamore trees and oak trees and some decorative trees that, and didn't know exactly what species they were, but there was a lot, there's a street of these big towering sycamores that were all just Anne Middleton: ⁓ gosh. ⁓ Mmm. Is it nice? That's awesome. Yeah. Nathan: fine. The houses were gone, but the sycamores were doing great. so get to one that kind of like gets your point of like these native trees can survive these fires a lot better. But it's also trying to think of like, here's the here's the twisted part about that too. The reason why one of those trees survive. I know live oaks are like very good at surviving fires. But also like Anne Middleton: you You Nathan: That fire happened in January, so the trees probably didn't have a lot of leaves. Anne Middleton: ⁓ yeah, that's a good point. I didn't ever think I didn't think of that. Yeah, well, I Nathan: So that's a little bit kind of messed up though, that the fire happened in January. Anne Middleton: Well, no, but I mean, you bring up a lot of other other good points that you know, fires are a natural part of every ecosystem and, and the plants that evolve in fire prone areas, evolve to withstand fire and a lot of trees, their reproduction cycle depends on fire. And yeah. Nathan: Yeah. Yep. Yep. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Anne Middleton: oils in eucalyptus are like particularly flammable. They're just like firecrackers. ⁓ the fact that eucalyptus is ubiquitous in Southern California is not good ⁓ fire. But a really interesting point. I'm gonna have to look into that because you're right. Because it was there weren't a lot of leaves, hence not a lot of fuel. ⁓ Nathan: Yes. Yeah, totally. Yeah, let's get them out. Get them out. Yeah, think my kind of hypothesis there is that you had the live oaks and the sycamores like they're again they they they're built to like survive these these But also, they were tall, but also the fire was in the houses and stuff. So it could get the leaves of the sycamores, right? But a lot of the decorative plants that survived, that was my sort of theory on a lot of those. There's a lot of deciduous plants that are more like decorative variety of deciduous plants. Like these maple gums, the gum maples that are real popular. There's a lot of those that were, popping off and stuff like that. I ⁓ that was my theory on how they all survived. Anne Middleton: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. ⁓ yeah, yeah. ⁓ that's really interesting. I'm totally going to look into that. I was, another reason why a lot of the homes leveled is you know, in our, in our furniture, in our paint, in our carving, in our glues, we've got like much of what we surround ourselves with. These chemicals are highly, highly flammable, ⁓ volatile organic compounds are also not great for breathing and not great for lying. and we just Nathan: Yeah. Okay. No, no. Anne Middleton: don't think of these things. And this why things like the EPA are really important and they can't do everything and they can't cover everything. But when we dismantle and underfund or quit funding our government institutions that are fundamentally in place to protect us in a lot of ways, and I know that kind of sounds naive coming out, at my core, do believe that there are good, smart people building institutions to protect. ⁓ Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Anne Middleton: and support the rest of us. And we can't always just ⁓ and blame Sacramento for everything that's going on because without the EPA, we wouldn't have the Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act. And I have lived in places where those things don't exist. And believe me, if we didn't have the Clean Water Act, a lot more people would be dying from cancer. A lot more people would not have access to potable water. I wouldn't be able to afford food. So Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Anne Middleton: It's important that we continue to uphold these crumbling institutions that help keep us safe. I say that, you know, yeah, yeah, ⁓ ⁓ Nathan: last messages of whatever they are that we've got. Well, okay. We should probably wrap it up there though. Any thoughts, anything else you want to add at all? ⁓ I how do we get this on the high notes? Go back to cakes? Anne Middleton: Okay. Yeah, well, you know, I think that like, we can only do so much and our mental and physical health has to be intact for us to be able to fight for the people and animals and things that can't fight for themselves. So I say just surround yourself with good, positive people. Use one less to-go cup this week. Buy one less outfit this month. Try to upcycle, recycle, reuse as much as you can because collectively, have power, our voices matter, our choices matter, our vote matters. And we all back out or give up, then it'll be worse. ⁓ And it be a lot better. A better future is right in front of us. And there are hardworking people and organizations out there who are fighting the fight every single day, myself included, so that we have livable, breathable walkable, edible ecosystems. can't beat yourself up for the little things, but the little things matter at the same time. So, you know, just go outside. Enjoy it. You know, go to the beach, go on a hike. Yeah, because we got this. We do. I really do believe that we've got this. Like there are more Nathan: Touch native grass. Anne Middleton: good people in humanity than not. And it's easy to get overwhelmed with the doom and gloom, but there are a lot of really good people doing really cool things, of whom are on this podcast. So when I need a little like positivity boost in my week, I see like, I wonder what I listened to yet on Nathan's podcast. So that's what I'd say. Nathan: Cool, right on, thank you. So, all right, so how people that wanna get in touch with you, what's the best way for people to follow up with you or find out about other things you're doing? Anne Middleton: Yeah, Wild Coast, our website is wildcoast.org and we're on social media as Wild Coast, Costa Salvaje, which is Wild Coast in Spanish. if you want to come to one of my band's shows, we are at The Good Good Music ⁓ Instagram, funk band, all women, we have a lot of fun. And you can find me on LinkedIn as well. Nathan: Cool, cool, right on. Well, thanks so much for joining and do this again one of these days. ⁓ Anne Middleton: Yay! I hope so. Thanks, Nathan. That was fun.