Latest / UK Column Radio / Jerm and Carl Zha Laugh about Their Trip to China
Transcript
- 0:35None. Carl Zha, thank you for joining
- 0:40me in the Drenches. As always, my pleasure germs.
- 0:46Dude, the last time we spoke we were in China.
- 0:50Yes, we were. It was good times.
- 0:53It was good times. Have you recovered?
- 0:55Have you recovered? I, I have, it took me a while,
- 0:58but I have, but I'm going back there in two weeks.
- 1:02I'm actually going back to China in two weeks, wait back to my
- 1:07hometown, Chongqing. So we're going to just before
- 1:12the Chinese New Year, the Chinese New Year, I think it's
- 1:16February 14th or something. So I'll be there just before
- 1:19that. My recovery was not ready so
- 1:23much the China trip but more Ethiopian Airlines flight home.
- 1:32Was it really that bad? You know, it depends on it
- 1:39depends on how you're coming at this, OK.
- 1:43I mean, I'm home, right? So I'm safe.
- 1:45I guess That's, that's OK. You know, the first prize.
- 1:48But it's the process, it's the journey that that could do with
- 1:52a bit of work. You make it sound like you're
- 1:57packed. You're like packing the plane
- 2:00with like goats and stuff. What's going on, man?
- 2:03But what? Happened.
- 2:03All the luggage was sitting on top of the plane, you know.
- 2:07No, I'm kidding. Yeah, I know you're kidding.
- 2:10Yeah. Having said that, the airport in
- 2:14Addis Ababa is very impressive, and I suppose that's also
- 2:17because it was built by the Chinese.
- 2:19Yeah, yeah. Much of infrastructure in
- 2:23Ethiopian capital is built by the Chinese, actually.
- 2:26Yeah, they built the African Union building over there, I
- 2:29believe. You and I spent almost a month
- 2:33traveling China, and it was, for you, probably just, you know,
- 2:38Wednesday. But for me, it was enlightening
- 2:41and it turned a lot of what I thought I knew upside down.
- 2:45Yeah, I mean, it wasn't Wednesday for me.
- 2:48I actually was my first time back after six years, you know,
- 2:52like I that was my first time back after COVID.
- 2:55And but, but, but I, you know, we should really turn this
- 2:59around because I should really be interviewing you about your
- 3:02experience because I bet you know, you have more eye opening
- 3:06moments in this. Well, I mean, look, coming from
- 3:11Africa, everything in China is amazing.
- 3:15You know, like, you know, roads and you know, stuff that works.
- 3:22My ball is very low. Call although you did you did
- 3:26say the the the the traffic was chaotic when we were rode our
- 3:31bicycle. Was mind blowing, really.
- 3:33OK, So, yeah, well, hold on, hold on.
- 3:36OK. So when I arrived in Shanghai,
- 3:37it was, I think it was in the evening and I remember messaging
- 3:42you and you were out and about already and I was so tired and,
- 3:47you know, jet lag, etcetera. And when you and I met up the
- 3:52next day and we decided to attempt the bicycles around
- 3:56Shanghai, I thought I was going to die.
- 3:59I've never seen such bad driving.
- 4:04Well, there are a lot of new drivers in China because, you
- 4:07know, a lot of people, a lot of Chinese drivers, this is their
- 4:10first time being a car owner, right, That they just move from
- 4:15bicycles to car. And so, yeah, that's
- 4:18understandable. But I for me, I've come from a
- 4:22different perspective. I go from Indonesia to China.
- 4:25For me, that was orderly. That was heavenly.
- 4:28Like, like, like everybody is staying there.
- 4:31Lame mostly. And that was pretty impressive
- 4:34also. What you're saying is that there
- 4:36are levels? I mean Africa is pretty chaotic
- 4:39so Indonesia must be next level. Indonesia is definitely the next
- 4:44level cause 'cause you know, like there's a lot of scooters
- 4:48in Indonesia and they all compete with the cars and the,
- 4:51the zigzag. So after I start, I, I bought a
- 4:55car recently, this last year and after I started driving, I, no,
- 5:01I really got me. If you thinking these Indonesian
- 5:03people are very, no, they're very trustful.
- 5:06They're, they're very, they really have a lot of faith that
- 5:10I am a good driver, right? Because they were like cut right
- 5:13in front of me at the last minute.
- 5:15I'm like, whoa, that was a big test of my driving skills.
- 5:19And they really have just very have a lot of trust that
- 5:24everybody behind the wheels is a good driver.
- 5:28The other problem, though, is at least here in South Africa, you
- 5:33know where the cars are. In Shanghai, you don't.
- 5:38It's too quiet. Yeah, because it's mostly
- 5:42electric. There's a lot of electric cars
- 5:44in Shanghai. That that is something actually
- 5:49different for me as well because again, I, I came from Indonesia,
- 5:53so certainly I'd go for like a very nosy, noisy, very chaotic
- 5:58environment to like a relatively orderly and quiet place.
- 6:03And and for me that that was a change of scenery as well.
- 6:06But it just also goes to show that this apparent social credit
- 6:11score that's in China doesn't apply to the drivers, clearly.
- 6:16No, because we saw on many occasions those scooters just go
- 6:21right, turn right illegally. We follow the red light, you
- 6:26know, like more than one, one location.
- 6:28Yeah. And I didn't see any of these
- 6:30digital billboards with their pictures appearing on the screen
- 6:33because that's what Western media says.
- 6:36Then they should be. I think there should be.
- 6:40They should be. In actual fact, I remember
- 6:43thinking, well, when in sorry, when in Rome, do as the Romans
- 6:48do and we just, we're jaywalking.
- 6:50I just rode anyway. I remember just riding into
- 6:52oncoming traffic because, you know, it didn't really matter at
- 6:54this stage. We all got out alive, you know,
- 7:01thanks to our amazing bicycling skills.
- 7:05But I mean, I think, I hope like you kind of got a glimpse of
- 7:10China as like this completely different civilizational space
- 7:16because it's almost like a different planet compared to
- 7:19like a lot of the Western countries, right?
- 7:22It's completely different call. It's very much not what you
- 7:27would see on social media. Yeah, and also like for because
- 7:33I think they're such a that the Americans had do have a lot of
- 7:38soft power. So I, I don't think people will
- 7:41be as shocked as much say they go to travel to US or even
- 7:46Europe, because a lot of, you know, at least we received by
- 7:51osmosis what kind of Western society to expect, you know,
- 7:56but, but, but China is very different because there's very
- 7:59little information coming from it.
- 8:01And so when you go there, you it's like you're going there
- 8:04blind, you know, like, you know, I'm, I'm obviously not going
- 8:08there blind, but you were. Well, I mean, Shanghai also,
- 8:11just to be fair, does look like any other major city in the
- 8:15world. It's just very clean and very
- 8:18organized other than the traffic.
- 8:21Yeah, yeah, yeah, definitely. I that was actually that was the
- 8:25case even I would say 20 years ago, because I remember right
- 8:30after September 11th, I was in the summer of 2000 O one, I was
- 8:37working Hamburg, Germany. And then I went to China just
- 8:42one month after September 11th and I was in Shanghai and I was
- 8:46like, wow, this street is cleaner than Hamburg.
- 8:50Because in Hamburg, Germany, you have people bring their dogs
- 8:53everywhere to the restaurant and there's dog poops everywhere on
- 8:56the street. That wasn't the case in
- 8:58Shanghai. Well, although I did when that
- 9:02time in two in 2000, the time I went to Shanghai was a time when
- 9:05George W Bush was coming to town.
- 9:07So it's, it's possible to clean it up for him.
- 9:10But you know, I already had that impression.
- 9:13Shanghai was cleaner than a lot of Western cities back in 2001.
- 9:18George W Bush, the US president, who said is our children
- 9:23learning. Well, he has been.
- 9:28His reputation has been rehabilitated now, you know,
- 9:32like this is with American presidents, you know, no matter
- 9:36how bad you think they are just going to the future, Fast
- 9:40forward to the future, you'll realize they're going to always
- 9:43convince the worst candidates. You know, like, like, like
- 9:46George W Bush, they are now rehabilitating him because he's
- 9:53not Trump. So here we are.
- 9:56The day that we met up and decided to attempt Chinese
- 10:01traffic with bicycles. The thing with the with the
- 10:05system, they I don't to this day know what Chinese money looks
- 10:09like because all we ever used was WeChat and Alipay.
- 10:14Yeah, Most people, you know, I, I was so, so spoiled in 2019
- 10:20when I went to China with all the mobile payment.
- 10:24I remember, you know, I was on my way flying to Bali.
- 10:28I made a stop in Hong Kong. And then I wanted to explore the
- 10:32city in Hong Kong. And so I want to take the metro
- 10:35from the airport and they have these coins, coins.
- 10:40I'm like, what, who carries coins?
- 10:43How am I going to get coins? I have to go to like a finer ATM
- 10:47machine, get the cash out and then get the cash converted into
- 10:51coins to use in coins slots. If it feels like I was stepping
- 10:55from 21st century back to the 20th century.
- 10:59I mean, that's how I fell back in 2019 and, and, and, and, and
- 11:03even the time we went to China, you know, I was, I was so
- 11:07confident. I know how things work.
- 11:10I remember like I show you how we could take the subway, right?
- 11:14The Metro. Yeah, we're using the.
- 11:15Yeah, we're using the Metro. Yeah, yeah, we're using the
- 11:18Metro. I was like showing.
- 11:19I was like acting like the expert.
- 11:21Oh, like you go to the ticketing machine and then you select your
- 11:25destination and then you will tell you how much it costs.
- 11:28And then you just scan with your WeChat and then you just pay the
- 11:32exact amount and spit out the plastic car with that value and
- 11:37you scan in. So that is the way that I knew
- 11:40how it worked back in 2019. So that's how I did it when we
- 11:44were there in 2025. And I was actually complaining
- 11:48that it was not very intuitive because they had two machines,
- 11:52one machine just show you the, the, the, the, the, the route
- 11:55and, and how much it, it, it will cost.
- 11:58And then you have to go to the machine next door to actually,
- 12:01you know, pay. So I thought that was, that was,
- 12:04yeah, exactly why. So later after our trip was
- 12:09over, I went to my hometown Song Ching and I met up with a bunch
- 12:14of expat friend of mine who have been living in China for like 20
- 12:17years. And they saw me doing that.
- 12:19And they're like to Carl, what are you doing man?
- 12:21What are you doing? So he's like, give me your
- 12:24phone. I give them phone.
- 12:25He's like, look, go to your WeChat.
- 12:27There's a mini app here called metro Click on it and then put
- 12:32in this your current city, Chongqing, you will generate a
- 12:35QR code And once you have that QR code, you just use that QR
- 12:39code to scan yourself in and automatically deducts a month.
- 12:43I was like, oh, see, I didn't know that I I would still doing
- 12:48the way I was back in 2019. That's how I knew how to
- 12:52navigate. But apparently China already
- 12:55moved down in the last six years.
- 12:59What is more stereotypical than a Chinese guy on a bicycle?
- 13:05I feel like that this is the this is the image, the image
- 13:09that most people have of China, you know, like the China back in
- 13:13the 1970s, nineteen 80s, when the main mode of transportation
- 13:18is still bicycle. But but, but it's actually
- 13:22quite, quite different today, of course, because you know, like,
- 13:25like I said, a lot of people are now moving into cars, which
- 13:29caused whole set of new problems because, you know, they're new
- 13:32drivers and there you go. Well, I'm one of the I'm one of
- 13:36the new drivers, a white African riding a bicycle in China.
- 13:41For the first time, yeah. One of the questions that will
- 13:46obviously come up is you're in a we're in a city day of what,
- 13:4926,000,000 people? There are no people in this
- 13:52photograph. Well, the day we were out, there
- 13:56was still some, well, we, we were there in like late
- 14:00September, but it was unusually hot heat, hot heat wave hit
- 14:06Shanghai because when we weren't there, like you will be drenched
- 14:10just walking like 10 minutes. And it was so hot.
- 14:15People are trying to stay in the shade.
- 14:17You know, there's, you're not going to have many people
- 14:19standing in the, in the sun in the middle of the day because,
- 14:23you know, you would just pass out.
- 14:25That I think that's one reason also we went at the time we, we
- 14:29were like, we're tourists, man. Like people, real people in
- 14:33Shanghai that have to go to work.
- 14:34We were there on a weekday. We're also there on a weekday.
- 14:37So there's that. On the one hand, you have this
- 14:41very advanced city that Shanghai is, and then you showed me this
- 14:46street. Yeah, we took some back alleys
- 14:52because we're navigating by bicycles.
- 14:54And this is a lot of this kind of juxtaposition in China, the
- 15:00old and new. And Shanghai, obviously, you
- 15:04know, he has been the wrong for more than 100 years.
- 15:07You know, Shanghai was the, the city of Shanghai really came to
- 15:11being back, back in like 18 sixties, you know, after the
- 15:17Second Opium War. So so you know, you still have a
- 15:21lot of old buildings, like a lot of these buildings you see like
- 15:25the in the foreground. Those those are probably from
- 15:29dates from like 19 thirties, 1940s, you know, like almost 100
- 15:36years old. And of course, the the the
- 15:39building in the background, those are a lot, lot newer.
- 15:43I just want to at this point say call that this conversation has
- 15:48been sponsored by the CCP. And President Xi, if you're
- 15:53watching this, please, I'm still waiting for my check to clear in
- 15:58the mail. You know, send them anytime.
- 16:01I mean, we only spent a few days in Shanghai and then a real
- 16:06because. So this was the funny part.
- 16:08So I was in Hong Kong a few months earlier and that it is
- 16:13China, but as many Chinese say, it's not really China.
- 16:17Then you go to Shanghai and it's more Chinese, but the Chinese
- 16:22will say, Nah, that's not really China.
- 16:26Remember that. Shanghai is the most westernized
- 16:30Chinese city on mainland China, right?
- 16:32Of course, Hong Kong is even more Westernized because by the
- 16:35virtue of being a British colony for, for for 100, more than 100
- 16:39years. But yeah, there are different
- 16:41levels of being Chinese, as you find out, because, you know, you
- 16:45didn't understand that because you when you're in Shanghai, you
- 16:48said to you everything just look very Chinese.
- 16:51And I assure you there's there's different levels.
- 16:55Well, I mean, I didn't really understand anything because very
- 16:58few people speak English. I mean I had to use a translator
- 17:03app or you? Yeah, or me.
- 17:07Well, that's the thing. Because China is so large and it
- 17:11has a large population. So in a way, unlike a lot of the
- 17:17smaller country that cater to foreign tourists, you know, a
- 17:22lot of locals didn't have to pick up English, right?
- 17:27The expectations that you will make the effort try to try to
- 17:31fit in, not not vice versa. And you know, like I said, China
- 17:35is a whole complete different civilizational space.
- 17:39You know, once you're in China, you're like, you know, a new
- 17:42world. When I came back, I received a
- 17:46huge amount of pushback because I didn't trash China.
- 17:50I didn't say that was some some totalitarian hellhole and we
- 17:55knew this was coming. I still told you when we were in
- 17:57China. I said, wait, wait until I get
- 18:00back and and watch and watch the the backlash.
- 18:04So I also want to point out that when you and I rode around on
- 18:07bicycles, we had a security guard who was taking us
- 18:12everywhere and making sure that we were only looking in the
- 18:14direction that he was pointing. We were completely controlled.
- 18:19Yeah, our head can only like sit in One Direction.
- 18:22We can't even like slight movement of the head was not
- 18:25allowed, you know. Otherwise a laser will ZAP our
- 18:29face to put us on the right track.
- 18:34So then we went on our real trip, which was joining up with
- 18:40Pepe Escobar to kind of follow his Silk Road journey and you
- 18:46know, part of the documentary that was being made.
- 18:50And we did a whole bunch of cities and we rent.
- 18:52We went right across to the western side and we really saw a
- 18:57very different side of, of China.
- 19:00And firstly, the food in my opinion was better on the on the
- 19:05western side. I.
- 19:07Agree but but it was a lot more rural and people forget that
- 19:12they when they think of China they just think of mega cities
- 19:15like Shanghai. Yeah, there's, I mean, China is
- 19:19huge. So there, there will be like
- 19:22mega cities like Shanghai, like Beijing, like Guangzhou on the
- 19:26coast. But there's plenty of other
- 19:29parts of China that's not mega city.
- 19:32And we actually traveled like, let's see, we spend almost like
- 19:37a month, maybe like 2-3 weeks. And we drove.
- 19:41I asked our driver, he said we drove 3500 square, 3500
- 19:48kilometers in those two weeks. Yeah, like I, I develop butt of
- 19:54iron. It still hurts.
- 19:55But I, you know, I think, yeah. Well, we met up with with
- 20:03obviously oppressed Uyghurs and as you can see in this
- 20:05photograph, the sad thing is that there was a firing squad
- 20:09waiting for these two Uyghurs after this photograph.
- 20:12So may that rest in peace. Right.
- 20:18Yeah. So we, we that was in Uluchi,
- 20:20the capital when we first arrived.
- 20:24That's the day when we met up with my Twitter follower, Luke.
- 20:29He's a very nice British chap who is who is teaching English
- 20:35in Urumqi. He actually got his PhD in
- 20:39Shanghai. But while he was waiting for his
- 20:42graduation ceremony, he was just bumming around in Xinjiang
- 20:45because he loved it so much. And, you know, and apparently he
- 20:48has a local girlfriend. And so he was, he didn't speak a
- 20:51little bit Uyghur. So he, he was taking us to all
- 20:54the, you know, the Uyghur part of the tongue to sample the
- 20:57authentic Uyghur food. And then he took us to the
- 21:01touristy area where all the tourists go, where you bought
- 21:04some souvenir for your wife, I believe.
- 21:08Yes, that was actually very that, that was a pleasant
- 21:13surprise because we were there because he was, you know,
- 21:17touristy place. We were, we were just traveling
- 21:21through the, the, the, the itinerary our tour guide set out
- 21:26for us, but these two Uyghur girl just came up to us because
- 21:30you and Pepe Escobar stood out because there are very few
- 21:34foreigners there. So they came up there and wanted
- 21:37to practice English. And so I think Pepe actually
- 21:40took that photo of me and you. And, and so we actually have a
- 21:45spontaneous conversation. They're not, you know, you know,
- 21:49they're, I, I, I, they're not CCP agents who are tracking, who
- 21:55are tracking us, right? They're just like 8-8 year old
- 21:59girls. Because there were bored, There
- 22:01were not many tourists in that area.
- 22:03So they were like bored at their parents shop.
- 22:06So they just decided to follow us around.
- 22:09But their mother got nervous about.
- 22:12Us. Yeah, Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 22:14They're holding back. Yeah.
- 22:17The parents called him back after a while.
- 22:19Yeah. We also traveled through the
- 22:25desert and the Taktamakan desert.
- 22:30It's a huge desert that very few people know about.
- 22:32It's the second largest moving desert in the world if I'm
- 22:36correct. Call.
- 22:37Yeah, second largest moving sand desert after Sahara.
- 22:41It was huge. And we, we travel right across
- 22:44it. We, we drove on the highway that
- 22:46went straight across the desert itself, which is pretty
- 22:50impressive. We actually went inside the
- 22:53desert, which I don't recommend We spend about the entire day
- 22:58off the road. We.
- 23:00Went to that village, we went to that, we went to that village of
- 23:03like 110 people and it took us 3 hours driving through sand
- 23:08dunes. Yeah, and then three hours back
- 23:12through the same sand dunes. That was a rough day.
- 23:17Thank goodness we had the, the, the we had what?
- 23:19A Toyota. It was a Toyota Highlight.
- 23:21No, no. Fortunate.
- 23:22What did we have? Land Cruiser.
- 23:24Land, land, land. Land Cruiser, I think, yeah.
- 23:27Yeah, we weren't driving Chinese, we were driving
- 23:28Japanese. That would have made the locals
- 23:30feel a little bit more aggro. Well, we did see a lot of other
- 23:35other people driving the Chinese tanks not, not tanks, not tanks.
- 23:41The brand of SUV called tanks. Not not literal tanks, but the
- 23:47but the. Tank 300.
- 23:48The Tank 300. Yeah, Tank 300.
- 23:51Yeah, Tank 300. There were, there were all the
- 23:54one tank 300 failed to clamp climb that sand dune challenge.
- 23:59We saw them trying to go up a sand dune.
- 24:04You you slide backward at the last moment.
- 24:07So. So yeah.
- 24:09I might have a photograph of us when we were in that, in that
- 24:13desert, exactly where that Tank 300 was.
- 24:17But I mean, that is also an entirely different experience.
- 24:22No cell phone signal at all. Yeah, that was unusual.
- 24:27For China. Yeah, that was actually first
- 24:29time in China, though we didn't have any cell phone signals.
- 24:33So yeah, but, but, but The thing is, once we arrive at our
- 24:37destination in that quote UN quote, isolated village with 100
- 24:42people, we see this giant signal tower, cell phone signal tower
- 24:47right there, right? Yeah.
- 24:50So here's a photograph of you, Carl.
- 24:52Nice. Would you mind telling us what
- 24:54you were doing? No.
- 24:58Did you? Did you?
- 25:00Did you feel me peeing in the desert?
- 25:05That's not a very. That's a.
- 25:06Water. I was giving water.
- 25:09No, I. One of the other fascinating
- 25:13things about the drive through the desert was how they kept the
- 25:17sand off the road. Yeah, Yeah.
- 25:21So that was key because it's it is a moving sand desert because
- 25:26the, the the wind will just blow the sand everywhere.
- 25:29So in order for the road not to be buried as soon as he was
- 25:33being built, they had to find a way to fix the sand on both
- 25:36sides of the road. And they come up with this thing
- 25:39what Pepe calls the Chinese Magic Square.
- 25:42It's a, it's a, a grid made of straws and they have a series of
- 25:49straw grids that just enough to block to, to kind of slow down
- 25:54the sand moving in. And they also have some
- 25:58shrubberies and, and, and fences as well on the either side of
- 26:03the road. So that keeps the sand from
- 26:05encroaching on the road itself. I mean, it's apparently very
- 26:08effective because we drove through the whole thing.
- 26:13This was the tank 300 that got stuck on the sand dune.
- 26:19Almost. It's so close.
- 26:20He almost made it, but at the last moment it's just started.
- 26:25He slid back. Yeah, he slid back.
- 26:28That is a great car. By the way.
- 26:29I nearly bought a Tank 300. I'm so impressed with it.
- 26:33But I did buy a Chinese car, but not.
- 26:35But not the tank. Oh.
- 26:37What did you buy? Have you heard of Jetwa?
- 26:42No, I have not. Well, that's what I got.
- 26:46Great vehicle. It's owned by the Cherry Group,
- 26:49which is one of the competitors to GW, Yeah.
- 26:52Yeah, Cherry is pretty good. It's a pretty good brand.
- 26:54Yeah, you're doing good. But that I remember how driving
- 27:00through that desert really, really got to us.
- 27:03By the end of the day, we were like, if we can just get onto
- 27:06Tar Rd. I remember you were you were
- 27:09just, you were taking a serious knock in the car.
- 27:11I remember. That was rough man.
- 27:15I almost got seasick. I also got motion sickness.
- 27:18It's like I think one hour of off roading in sand dune will be
- 27:24fun. It will be fun.
- 27:26It was fun the first hour, but after that I was just trying to.
- 27:30Six hours to get a bit much. I just tried to survive.
- 27:34After that, I was just trying to survive, yeah.
- 27:38But that was us driving to that, to that village of 100 people.
- 27:44I mean, it's natural. We're.
- 27:46Driving on a dried we're driving on a dry lake bed, so it was
- 27:51relatively flat instead of us going up and down the sand
- 27:55dunes. And you know that that actually
- 27:58was nice shy. It looks like a car commercial.
- 28:01You know this. That was a literal and free
- 28:04endorsement for Toyota right there.
- 28:09There was a funny moment. I remember I've got the photo
- 28:12here when we were when, when we stopped in the desert to to take
- 28:16a photo, you and me. And just before this photograph,
- 28:22I, I was, I was standing barefoot and I told you call be
- 28:25a man, take off your shoes. And I couldn't stand in that
- 28:30sand for for more than 10 seconds.
- 28:32I had to run back to the car. It was way.
- 28:37Too hot. It can get pretty hot.
- 28:40Like people fry eggs on those sand, you know, in the
- 28:44summertime. The locals think that actually
- 28:46one of the that's what they sell the tourists, you know, the sand
- 28:50fry eggs. It just it just like eggs, they
- 28:53put in the sand for like 30 minutes and it's done.
- 28:59You were talking about buying my wife something and what I bought
- 29:03for her was this. I think we were in Kashgar.
- 29:08Yes, yes, we were in Kashkar. So what's the history of Kashkar
- 29:14very quickly, and why do these dresses matter?
- 29:17Oh, so these are actually the it's made from the type of silk
- 29:22that's with a traditional pattern local to Xinjiang area.
- 29:26It's called Atlas silk. And so they're they're pretty
- 29:31famous. I mean, at least in China, that
- 29:34like this is very characteristic of the Uyghur silk patterning.
- 29:40It's it's a type of tie dying process.
- 29:43They use like natural herbs to to, to to bring out the color.
- 29:48We we went to the factory, you know, where they have the whole
- 29:51silk production from cocoon to actually make weaving them into,
- 29:57into clothes. Yeah.
- 29:59So they're, they're handmade and it's pretty impressive, like.
- 30:03Yeah, I'm just handmade. Yeah, yeah.
- 30:06I mean, there you can see they're literally making it by
- 30:09hand. Yeah.
- 30:12And you can see another piece of fabric hanging on the wall that
- 30:16is a pattern that's just like the local traditional Uyghur
- 30:19silk pattern. So the, the, when the silk
- 30:24travel W, you know, the Xinjiang was the first stop.
- 30:28You know that that's there's, there's actually a, a myth about
- 30:32the, the whole story. Supposedly the they, the there
- 30:37was a Chinese Princess was on her way to be married to the
- 30:42Prince of Persia, to the King of Persia.
- 30:44And when they're traveled to the border area, they realize she's
- 30:49pregnant. They realized, oh, crap, we
- 30:53cannot complete the mission. Abort, abort, abort the mission,
- 30:57abort the mission. So they had the baby was not
- 30:59aborted, that the baby was born locally.
- 31:02And he, they, they founded their own Kingdom in the region.
- 31:05And the Princess also smuggled the silkworm eggs in her hair.
- 31:12So that's how the silk cultivation spread in the
- 31:16region. That that was a local legend.
- 31:18And. Yeah.
- 31:21Call. What's going on here?
- 31:23We are, I think we're in the carpet factory this in Kashgar
- 31:27and and behind us. Those are like hand woven
- 31:30traditional carpet. You know, these just like the
- 31:34those Persian carpet or you know, carpet from Afghanistan,
- 31:38the in Xinjiang, they also have a local tradition of weaving
- 31:42carpet. You know, it's very Central
- 31:44Asian and the worst sitting in one of the large, larger, you
- 31:49know, carpet pieces. This is what makes China very
- 31:53interesting. It's sheer size means that
- 31:57you're going to end up with a vastly different Chinese people
- 32:03on the left hand side to the right hand side.
- 32:07That's correct. I mean, China traditionally had
- 32:09been an empire for thousands of years and you Corp incorporated
- 32:14a lot of different people and and different group.
- 32:18So you know people, you know peeps, a lot of people go to
- 32:22Xinjiang. Their first remark is like, oh,
- 32:25this doesn't feel like China because they usually have a
- 32:29strong stereotypical, the idea of what China should be, should
- 32:33be like water buffaloes and people in like pointed straw
- 32:37hats and stuff like that. But Xinjiang is very Central
- 32:39Asian because you know, it's, it is part of Central Asia and you
- 32:44know, it has a deep cultural ties to, to the neighboring
- 32:48countries like Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan,
- 32:52Tajikistan, etcetera. And, and in fact, in fact, it is
- 32:56the hub of the Silk Road. You know all the Silk Road that
- 32:59link China to the West, It all goes through Xinjiang.
- 33:04And now the belt and Rd. Now the belt, I mean if in fact
- 33:08the Belt and Road, Belt and Road is a short for Silk Road,
- 33:14Economic Belt and Marine time Silk Road.
- 33:18So So this is Belt and Road is China's attempt to revive
- 33:23ancient Silk Road links. You mentioned Tajikistan.
- 33:28Wasn't it funny how they thought I was a Tajik?
- 33:33So okay, so for our audience, we went through the border, so
- 33:38there's a lot of security checks in Xinjiang, but most of them we
- 33:41just got waved through. They just asked to lower our
- 33:45windows, look through the camera where they do AI facial
- 33:50recognition, I'm sure. And then then they just send us
- 33:53on our way. You know, they just tell us,
- 33:54okay, buckle your safety belt, please.
- 33:57And so so, but when we got closer to the border, there's
- 34:01much tighter security. So Pepe and our our Russian
- 34:08photographer, who is very blonde and blue eyed, they got stopped
- 34:12at almost every checkpoint to show their passport.
- 34:16You know why they're there. And whereas you and me, we were
- 34:21sitting in the same car, we just got way through.
- 34:23So after a while we're like, what do they think?
- 34:29Who do they think you are? Like how come they didn't ask
- 34:33you for your passport? So we figured they must thought
- 34:36you are local. You're you're low.
- 34:39Maybe they thought you are local Tajik.
- 34:43And then you asked our driver and he said yes, they thought I
- 34:46was Tajik. Yeah, yeah.
- 34:51My people need me call. You want to see your people, you
- 34:55want to connect with your roots in China.
- 35:00But of course, China's not all, you know, technological
- 35:04advancement. I mean, we, we had to endure
- 35:09this, ah. Yes, yeah.
- 35:13So, so that's, that's very typical.
- 35:15I mean, most of the places that they have squat toilet, you
- 35:19know, like a lot of Chinese people prefer squat toilet
- 35:22because then they're they their their butts don't have to touch
- 35:25the same surface many other people's butts have touched.
- 35:29So it it's a it's a, it's a matter of preference, you know,
- 35:33a matter of preference. But I, I.
- 35:34Understand squatting and the squatting keeps you fit.
- 35:37Yes, I understand it can be difficult for Westerners
- 35:41because, you know, Westerners are not used to squatting like
- 35:43where, where's the Asians? We're used to the Asian squad
- 35:47from, from a very young age. So, so it's natural for us.
- 35:50But I can understand, you know, maybe, maybe people, Western
- 35:53people need to do more yoga, you know, like so you can, so you
- 35:57can squat down and and be the on your flat of your feet.
- 36:02Another thing that I really loved about China is how based
- 36:10they are. You know, they don't, they don't
- 36:13mess around when they show you a lady's toilet.
- 36:16I mean, yeah, we have a ballerina.
- 36:22And then, gentlemen, China is also very diverse.
- 36:36I mean, OK, look, so it's got a huge Han population, but on the
- 36:41Western side, it has multiple other populations.
- 36:43And this leads to geopolitical conflict.
- 36:47I mean, like, like I said, right?
- 36:52The The thing is, I don't know why people expect China to be a
- 36:58ethnic state. China is not a ethnic state.
- 37:00You know, even in Chinese constitution, it says it's a
- 37:04multi ethnic country and it has always been a multi ethnic
- 37:09empire throughout the thousands of years of history.
- 37:13And it and, and the whole idea of, you know, like a nation
- 37:18state should be like a monolithic like ethanol state.
- 37:22I mean that that itself is pretty new.
- 37:25You know, that that only started like with World War One in
- 37:28Europe when they, you know, start doing like ethnic
- 37:31cleansing. So to make nice knee borders
- 37:33with like one single ethnic group.
- 37:37Most of the human society, I think in most, most places live
- 37:41in a kind of, you know, multi ethnic empire or one way or
- 37:47another. Then there was a very
- 37:54informative part of the trip and that was driving up to almost 4
- 37:591/2 thousand meters above sea level and sitting on a yak.
- 38:05Yeah, so we were. This is the White Sand Lake in
- 38:09Xinjiang. We it was really cold because
- 38:12because it's high elevations, it was, the wind was blowing.
- 38:17It was really, really cold. But the, the local, so a lot of
- 38:22tourists will stop by at that spot because from that spot you
- 38:25have the, the, the entire view of the lake.
- 38:28And so a lot of people stop by, take pictures and the local
- 38:32Kirgis Herdzman, you know, being enterprise pricing
- 38:37entrepreneurs, they just set up their camps there.
- 38:40You know, they brought their yurts to and their yaks and they
- 38:43rent out their yaks for tourists for photographs and that.
- 38:47And they they take photo for you.
- 38:49You know, they charge a little bit extra.
- 38:50But so, yeah, we all got our photos taken.
- 38:53It was. It was a fun experience.
- 38:56Yeah, but I mean, another beautiful part of that is the
- 39:01color of that water. Yeah, because there's a lot of
- 39:05minerals that came from the glacial melt from the Tansa
- 39:09Mountains. That's what gave that very
- 39:13intense green color. And because also we are at high
- 39:17elevation, the sun is a lot stronger.
- 39:21I didn't even realize that until, like, I sent my pictures
- 39:24back to my wife and my wife's like, oh, did you apply
- 39:27sunscreen? Your glasses already turned
- 39:30dark? You know, the UV must be really
- 39:32strong. It was true.
- 39:34Like, the sun is quite intense. That's why we saw a lot of solar
- 39:39farms. When we're there, we travel
- 39:42through like miles and miles or kilometers and kilometers of
- 39:45solar farms because there's a lot of solar energy in Xinjiang.
- 39:50Now keep in mind, again, we were almost 4 1/2 thousand meters
- 39:53above sea level. That's more than double the
- 39:56height of Janesburg. And Janesburg is considered
- 39:58quite high, you know, in South African terms.
- 40:01And that's very. Yeah, Remember they gave us,
- 40:03they gave us oxygen tanks in case.
- 40:06Yes, yes. And they have entrepreneurs who
- 40:10at 4000m sea level selling tourist oxygen tanks because,
- 40:16you know, being Chinese, they, they never missed a chance to,
- 40:19to make some money. And, and it was, it was nice.
- 40:22It was nice like, because I was Pepe decided to challenge
- 40:27himself to, to walk to the lookout point at 4200 meter
- 40:34above sea level. And I was about to follow his
- 40:38footsteps. But you know, I think it was
- 40:40you. Was it you that you told me you
- 40:42got to breathe in deeply? So when I tried to breathe in
- 40:45deeply and suddenly I was like having a little panic attack
- 40:49because I was like, feel like I wasn't getting enough oxygen.
- 40:52So I grabbed the oxygen canister.
- 40:54That's the only time I used it. But it was quite nice to have it
- 40:57to have that option. I didn't, yeah, I didn't use the
- 40:59oxygen, but I remember feeling a bit light headed.
- 41:03Yeah, yeah. Because I was happy to be done.
- 41:07Yeah, I was happy to be at the bottom.
- 41:09At that level, the the the oxygen level in the air is only
- 41:12like 50% of the air at the sea level.
- 41:17So yeah. Call One of the greatest moments
- 41:21One of the greatest moments in China was this.
- 41:28Oh, you guys were you guys were starving for some hamburgers
- 41:33like we were. I, I remember when we're
- 41:37travelling in Xinjiang, you know, like you and both you and
- 41:41Pepe, you're like, we'll be dying for some hamburger.
- 41:44And then next thing we know, we drove through, we drove through
- 41:49like a roadside restaurant. They serve Jack burgers.
- 41:53And it was good. And it was good.
- 41:54It was good, right? Yeah, it was very good.
- 41:58I think we bought like 3 or 4 of different different kinds.
- 42:03We bought, we bought a whole bunch.
- 42:05Yeah, we both. Sides of the drive, Yeah, we got
- 42:07into. The road.
- 42:12Where was that though? I'm trying to remember now.
- 42:14That that's the Tashkurgan, that's when we when we went,
- 42:19when we start climbing toward the Pakistan border.
- 42:22So, so our way back, our way back from Tashkurgan back to
- 42:26Kashkar. But yeah, we're in some mountain
- 42:29Rd. And there was on the side of the
- 42:31road there's a burger joint. So that was great.
- 42:38Yes, you call with a Uyghur Hai or Tajik.
- 42:43Yeah, yeah, she's, she's, she's a Uyghur.
- 42:45So we, this is a night we spend in Tajikurgan.
- 42:48And so the hotel we stay, they have these like little cultural
- 42:53introduction, right? They, there's a Uyghur host and
- 42:56there's like a bunch of Tajik dancers and they all invite us
- 43:02to do the dance. And then this is our picture
- 43:04afterwards. So I was wearing a, a Tajik hat,
- 43:08like made Fung sheep wool, I think.
- 43:12Yeah. Again, sadly, I think she was,
- 43:17you know, put in front of the firing squad later that night.
- 43:20Yes, yes, that was her last performance.
- 43:25Where does this idea come from that Uyghurs are being killed by
- 43:30the Chinese government? Well, I think there's a lot of
- 43:33projection when people talk about China, right when, when
- 43:37people because they they feel like, OK, if because US was
- 43:44founded on genocide of Native Americans, on slavery of
- 43:50imported Africans. So China must also been doing
- 43:55some shady stuff, right? Like this is kind of a why talk
- 43:59to a our black American Muslim friend Dana, who took us around
- 44:05Shanghai. He calls it the universalization
- 44:09of oppression. So they think, OK, they, the
- 44:14Chinese, if we know the US government is bad, doing bad
- 44:18things, but the Chinese must be must be worse, if not as bad,
- 44:25right. So I think it's that assumption
- 44:27and the fact that there were some security crackdown in
- 44:31Xinjiang because the tourism incident that that happened.
- 44:35And and so a lot of the, and the fact that they're just not many
- 44:41information coming out of coming out of China in general.
- 44:44I think that allowed created this informational vacuum where
- 44:49people can easily wage disinformation campaigns, you
- 44:53know, against China, you know, to say there's a Uyghur
- 44:57genocide, which is completely bogus, you know, given what's
- 45:00actually happening in Gaza right now and what we saw Xin Xin
- 45:04Jiang in our trip, you know, this that that claim is does not
- 45:08hold any water, you know, like because we were walking through.
- 45:12Yeah, exactly. Like all all these people down
- 45:15there, they're Uyghurs. This is we actually went to a
- 45:18Uyghur wedding in Kashgar. This is one of their last night
- 45:22there. So.
- 45:23So it was interesting to have like the the man and the women,
- 45:29they have the separate dance circle.
- 45:31So that was a groom that's been surrounded by friends and
- 45:34relatives and they all, you know, go up to him and
- 45:38challenging him to a dance off. And during the dance off, they
- 45:42will give him stuffed money into his pocket.
- 45:45So my question is, what if the his pocket is not big enough?
- 45:50You know, what if what if he like there's more money than
- 45:54than the how much he pocket could hold?
- 45:57But somehow they made it work. Dude that was a party of night
- 46:02that Uyghur wedding. I don't know how those people
- 46:07got in there. I think.
- 46:10I think those two were shot after or executed right after
- 46:14the wedding. But I mean, that was a serious
- 46:18party. I've never seen a wedding like
- 46:20that. That was something that was, you
- 46:25know, it's the the restaurant owner actually figured out a
- 46:29really good scheme. So he apparently he allowed the
- 46:33first floor to be, to be used for wedding venue, but he must,
- 46:39you know, got the, the the wedding couple to agree.
- 46:42Maybe give them a discount or something to, to allow the
- 46:46restaurant patrons on the 2nd floor to be spectators, you
- 46:51know, so we could be there and participate and, and take
- 46:55photos. And so it was great.
- 46:57It was a great atmosphere. We, this is the second wedding
- 47:01we went to. We, we, we, we ran into because
- 47:04in, in Turpan, I don't know if you were there cuz we got back
- 47:10to Turpan really late. And then we, we noticed there's
- 47:14loud music in the lobby and we saw some women like dressed very
- 47:18nice. And then we, we, we, we, we saw
- 47:21in one the hotel like they're. No, I went.
- 47:26I went upstairs to call my wife. Yeah, yeah, cuz we, we, so we
- 47:30did, we start, just start peeking in and we realized it's
- 47:33a wedding reception. And then, yeah, I was with Pepe
- 47:37Escobar and the hotel receptionist saw what we're
- 47:41doing. They're like just go in.
- 47:42We're like, really? Yeah.
- 47:44They're like going, we're like, can we take photos and shoot?
- 47:47They're like, yeah, yeah, yeah, just go in.
- 47:48And we went in. It was great.
- 47:50And we just got to the dance off part where the, the former
- 47:53circle around the groom and it's another circle around the bride.
- 47:57You know, all the groomsmen are dancing with the groom and the
- 47:59bridesmaid dancing with the bride.
- 48:01I got that all on video. It was great.
- 48:03And, and so after that, our tour guide said, OK, we'll find a
- 48:09traditional Uyghur wedding for you to go.
- 48:12And they found on Chinese social media, you know, this restaurant
- 48:16in Kashgar that does this kind of thing.
- 48:18They, they host weddings and they allow the restaurant guest
- 48:22to, to, to, to, to, to spectate from the 2nd floor.
- 48:27So that's where we went to and it was great time.
- 48:30And just as a reminder, they are Uyghur police in Uyghur
- 48:35territory. Yeah, The thing is all the
- 48:38reporting, right? They always try to create this
- 48:42false dichotomy, like the Chinese police are oppressing
- 48:46the Uyghur people. Well, when you go travel there,
- 48:50you realize most of the local police are also Uyghur and
- 48:53they're very professional. They're very, very polite.
- 48:55We because there's one time in Jharkhand on our way to cash
- 48:59card, we did get pulled off for passport checks because, you
- 49:04know, Pepe Escobar and, and our rushing for that.
- 49:09Yeah, yeah, yeah. Give blow our cover.
- 49:11So, so at that time, we they did check our passport, but they
- 49:15were very apologetic. They're sorry we have to do
- 49:17this, you know, like, like we really apologize and they sent
- 49:22us on our way. They're very, very nice.
- 49:24And even according to Stan, our Russian photographer, he said
- 49:28the the Xinjiang police were nicer and more polite than the
- 49:32Shanghai police. So, but yeah, that was our
- 49:36experience. But we were in the desert.
- 49:39I just remembered now we saw a very interesting rock.
- 49:48Yes, yes. I mean, it's, yeah, it's kind of
- 49:51firm, isn't it? It rises up.
- 49:54It's very erect, yes. Yes, and everybody was taking
- 49:59photographs in front of this rock.
- 50:02Yeah, me. Yours truly included.
- 50:09I mean, I mean, look at that. That was where the police
- 50:16actually came to inspect our our footage.
- 50:20Yeah, yeah. Because we went in a
- 50:23particularly sensitive time because we the time we went was
- 50:28right around the National Day. And also you just so happened
- 50:33that on the national day, that was like the 50th anniversary of
- 50:37the founding of the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region.
- 50:40So Xi Jinping was in town to visit.
- 50:43And because of that, as part of the security measure, they had a
- 50:46blanket drone butt band across most of the Xinjiang.
- 50:52And so we thought, we thought we're out here in the middle of
- 50:55nowhere in a Canyon of the desert.
- 50:58You know, who is going to know? And then so we, we, we had our
- 51:02Russian photographer flew the Jones and then 23rd half hour
- 51:06later, the police can't find us. Like whatever you guys doing
- 51:11that didn't you know there's a Jones van?
- 51:14We're like, oh shit. So I, I think what according to
- 51:19the, our, our photographer theory stand is that the all
- 51:23these drones, they all have to send their coordinates, right?
- 51:27And so they, they would know instant a drone has taken off.
- 51:31And so, so we got smart we later.
- 51:35So instead of using our own drones, we saw these Chinese
- 51:39tourists who are flying their drone.
- 51:42So we asked them to take a video of us and and and send to us on
- 51:46WeChat. Yeah.
- 51:50And then while we were driving through the desert call, in the
- 51:54middle of nowhere there are these statues of horses.
- 52:00Yeah, yeah, yeah. This was like a high, almost
- 52:03like a highway rest stop or like a lookout point where you can,
- 52:07you know, park your car on the side of the road and go to the
- 52:10restroom. I I don't, I don't know what the
- 52:13statue of the horses are, you know, like what their
- 52:16significance. But it was just, that's where we
- 52:18stop. This is where we stop in the
- 52:20right in the dead center of Takamakan Desert.
- 52:23And. Yeah.
- 52:26And just to be clear, we drove for 11 hours on that road
- 52:30through sand. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 52:33That that. That was tiring.
- 52:36It is, I mean, it is, is I asked our, our driver, he said that's
- 52:41what travelling in Xinjiang is like.
- 52:43Because Xinjiang is such a huge place.
- 52:45It's basically the size of Alaska.
- 52:48A lot of time you are, you're just going from point A to point
- 52:52B, you know from 1-1 tourist spot to the next and there's
- 52:56like hours of driving in between.
- 52:57It is just what it is. Automated people mover, which is
- 53:02just another way of saying a train.
- 53:06Right. I think it's like a, it's a,
- 53:11it's someone use probably use like a not Google Translate, but
- 53:16this Chinese equivalent to do like a machine translation.
- 53:19This is what you get right? But yes, what's funny, it's
- 53:22actually logical. I mean, it was automated in the
- 53:26sense that it had no driver and it, you know, was moving people.
- 53:30Yeah, I mean, that's what it literally means in Chinese.
- 53:36That's why it literally means in Chinese.
- 53:37They just literally translate into English.
- 53:41By the way, I hear this competition now for the most
- 53:44advanced city not being Shanghai but actually being Chengdu.
- 53:50I mean it's a tier one city now. Oh, well, OK, there these are
- 53:54so-called the new tier one cities.
- 53:56I mean, basically they just upgraded all the tier, formerly
- 54:00Tier 2 cities and they call them new tier one cities now it's
- 54:04kind of tourism promotion. I, I think.
- 54:07I mean, Chengdu is very nice. I, I have travelled to Chengdu
- 54:11after you, you know, you, you, you made stop by at the airport,
- 54:14but I actually did a day trip to Chengdu afterwards.
- 54:18It's, it's very nice. It's a very nice city and the
- 54:22price is a lot cheaper than Shanghai because Chengdu is much
- 54:25more inland. But you know what Chengdu is
- 54:27most famous for in, in, in China, it's known as the gay
- 54:33capital of China. That's.
- 54:38What Chen? What?
- 54:39I don't know that. Yeah, it's it's gay friendly
- 54:44city, that's what it is. Where will we?
- 54:47When we were at that coffee shop where we we saw that that that
- 54:51flaming gay guy, the flaming gay Uyghur.
- 54:54We were in Kucha, which is a small today by Chinese standard,
- 54:59a small city, you know, like like now, but like a, like a
- 55:03tourist stop on the Xinjiang tourism circuit.
- 55:07And we found this very nice, a coffee shop that's serving
- 55:13coffee and playing jazz music. And as we were relaxing on the
- 55:18lawn chairs and you point out to me, it's like, Carl, did you see
- 55:23that flaming guy? I was like, oh, yeah, he's,
- 55:26he's, he's definitely flaming. But, you know, he's, it's he he
- 55:34probably he was able to, you know, present himself in such a
- 55:39way only in more recent years because Xinjiang in the old
- 55:45times was like a very, how do I say, like a traditional
- 55:50conservative Muslim place, Right.
- 55:54I mean, that he will look very out of place.
- 55:56But I guess today it's OK. You know, he was just out in the
- 56:00open, you know, like people just look at him and know he's gay
- 56:04and. Yeah.
- 56:06We will probably get accused of painting China with rose tinted
- 56:12glasses in this discussion, but I think it is true to say that
- 56:16China is like, from my experience, most other
- 56:20countries. It's a country with nuance.
- 56:23It has lots of good things and it has lots of bad things.
- 56:26It absolutely has a dark underbelly.
- 56:28What country doesn't? And it's got its own problems
- 56:33for sure. And I am from Africa and I do
- 56:35prefer living in Africa. I'm used to what I have.
- 56:40I, I, I, all I know is a broken infrastructure.
- 56:43But there is a sense of freedom that comes with, without chaos.
- 56:46But at the same time, there is something incredible about the
- 56:49order and the hierarchy that you see in China.
- 56:53And I'd be very happy to import some of that here.
- 56:58I'm not wild about all those cameras, and I'm not certain
- 57:02either a call how effective they are because London has millions
- 57:08of cameras too, and it has a huge crime problem.
- 57:11So I'm not entirely certain if cameras are just theater.
- 57:16Well, that's a good question. Now you got to ask the question
- 57:20is, you know, so, so, so in China, the, the rationale for
- 57:23the camera is public safety, right?
- 57:26And, and people say, well, Cam because the camera now people
- 57:30are actually lining up. They're not jaywalking and
- 57:33stuff. They're still working on that.
- 57:35But long, like you said, London has just as many cameras and
- 57:41there's still, it's still a very crime written city.
- 57:44Why is that? Well, I think it has to also
- 57:47come down to enforcement. You know, if you have cameras
- 57:50and you don't do Jack shit about actually enforcing the law and,
- 57:57and, and then then what's the point?
- 57:59And I think you know that this is the difference between China
- 58:02and and, and London or, or, or New York is it's not just the
- 58:08cameras you actually need a effective law enforcement.
- 58:14But my point was that I don't think China is somehow more
- 58:21totalitarian and hellhole ish than other countries.
- 58:25I would. I mean, I would say that it's on
- 58:28par with its pros and it's cons and it and it has beautiful
- 58:32things and it has bad things and there's nothing wrong in
- 58:35celebrating the beautiful things either.
- 58:38China is just a normal country. It's just different.
- 58:41It's a normal country like any other country, but it's just
- 58:43very different because it's they have a very different culture,
- 58:47very different history. So and, and, and you know, you
- 58:51different language, obviously. So that's why when people you go
- 58:55there, you feel like you are in another world, in another
- 58:58civilizational space. But fundamentally, just like any
- 59:02other country, you know, it has it has problems, it also has
- 59:06it's good, good sides. And you know, for for us
- 59:10tourists who who travel to China, you know, we are just
- 59:14reporting what we saw, you know, on the limited time that we
- 59:18spent there. I mean, everything works.
- 59:22Mostly everything works train run on time.
- 59:25And you know, so whatever you think about Chinese government
- 59:30policies, that primarily effects Chinese citizens living in
- 59:36China. Me because I have AUS passport I
- 59:42could care less what China do in China and and and and for me I
- 59:49have more I'm more concerned by my own government for the US
- 59:54government reading through my emails and and and because they
- 59:58actually have jurisdiction over me you know they they have I
- 1:00:02have I'm obligated to pay taxes to Uncle Sammy every year so I
- 1:00:05would be more worried about US and China just.
- 1:00:09For the simple fact that Chinese government have no jurisdiction
- 1:00:12over me. So I don't understand why people
- 1:00:14outside of China would be, you know, somehow scared of the big
- 1:00:18bad China an. American economist, friend of
- 1:00:22ours whose name we won't mention because he asked to remain
- 1:00:25anonymous. But we went and had supper with
- 1:00:27him in Shanghai and he's lived in China for almost three years.
- 1:00:32And and he was saying that his kid has been asked by the US
- 1:00:37government to to get a, an American passport.
- 1:00:41And he's like, no, no, I want him to have a Chinese passport
- 1:00:44because despite Xi Jinping having his problems, he'd rather
- 1:00:50have those problems than the American problems.
- 1:00:53Yeah, he he, he, he's was very clear with us.
- 1:00:57He didn't like Xi Jinping. He hates Xi Jinping.
- 1:00:59But Even so, he rather that his kid only have Chinese passport
- 1:01:05than have, you know, have American passport.
- 1:01:07So I think that that that speaks volumes.
- 1:01:11I haven't met, in my personal experience, anybody who's been
- 1:01:15to China and has come back and said, man, that is a terrible
- 1:01:18country. Nobody.
- 1:01:21Yeah. There is a dude now I.
- 1:01:27Was going to say there is a dude on YouTube who's who's called
- 1:01:29serpent ZA but but I mean he's he's funded I think to to to
- 1:01:33push out anti China propaganda. He had a bad experience a few
- 1:01:36years ago and now he hates China.
- 1:01:39I, I think, you know, he figured out what get him most money for,
- 1:01:43you know, how, how, how to best monetize his YouTube channels.
- 1:01:47Because if you, if he figured out if you make China bad
- 1:01:50videos, he will get more views. His videos are more promoted,
- 1:01:54you know, and, and it's kind of positive reinforcement, right?
- 1:01:58I mean, so, so, so you then you make more, more China bad videos
- 1:02:01because that's what your audience want to see.
- 1:02:04But it's, it's, it's doesn't mean it's rooted in reality
- 1:02:07because he himself haven't been in China for many years.
- 1:02:11He moved to United States. So all this time he's like
- 1:02:15talking to you from like a basement somewhere and and, and,
- 1:02:19and and and talking about this China that exists in people's
- 1:02:22imaginations. I also didn't mind using WeChat.
- 1:02:28I know that it has a lot of criticism, but I don't need it
- 1:02:32outside of China, so I only used it when I was inside China.
- 1:02:36My only criticism on WeChat is, you know, I, I do think they
- 1:02:41have, they must have some security loopholes because
- 1:02:45somehow these Chinese scamming telescam groups got hold of my
- 1:02:50number. I mean, I only think way I could
- 1:02:52think they could got hold of my number is probably through some
- 1:02:55kind of WeChat lead because I keep on getting calls.
- 1:02:58They in Chinese, I have package waiting for me at the Chinese
- 1:03:03consulate. Like what?
- 1:03:05Why would I have a package waiting for me in the Chinese
- 1:03:08consulate, right? Because apparently they, they,
- 1:03:11they somehow knew I was Chinese, but they didn't know that I
- 1:03:14don't have a Chinese passport and so I have no reason to go to
- 1:03:18the Chinese consulate. But anyway, go ahead.
- 1:03:21It was really funny that you're Chinese and in China you
- 1:03:24couldn't use WeChat, but I'm Tajik, so I could use WeChat.
- 1:03:30That's right. That was quite funny.
- 1:03:33I mean, you couldn't get your WeChat working.
- 1:03:36Well, my WeChat is working. Is the WeChat payment is
- 1:03:41sometimes sometimes is janky because because my WeChat isn't
- 1:03:47it's, it's complicated because my WeChat or only in the last
- 1:03:53few years, China have made it that you can link your foreign
- 1:03:56bank cards with WeChat and Alipay, you know which that you,
- 1:04:00you were able to use. But when I was in China in 2019,
- 1:04:04that was not the case. So what I did was I asked my
- 1:04:07auntie to open a bank account for me, but under her name that
- 1:04:12was linked to my WeChat. It's a Chinese bank.
- 1:04:15It's a Chinese bank. So it was linked to my WeChat.
- 1:04:18But what happened is then there's other apps.
- 1:04:21Sometimes they need identity verification.
- 1:04:23So when I try to use the DD app, which calls a taxi from WeChat,
- 1:04:29he wants to take, he wants me to take a picture to do facial,
- 1:04:34facial recognition to make sure I'm, I am what I said, who I was
- 1:04:38and I don't look exactly like my auntie.
- 1:04:41That's why you. Look nothing like it.
- 1:04:47It's like 2 different people. But yeah.
- 1:04:55How can my audience follow you? Well, I now have my own show on
- 1:05:00UK column. You know, like I have a show
- 1:05:04every Monday, Monday, Wednesday and Friday about I think they're
- 1:05:11push out around 9:00 PM UK time. And and I also have my own
- 1:05:17YouTube channel as well. You know, people can just search
- 1:05:19my name Carl Zah. And I'm also a very prolific
- 1:05:23shit poster on Twitter. Just look for my handle Carl
- 1:05:26Zah. So I don't take Twitter
- 1:05:28seriously. So you shouldn't use it unless
- 1:05:31what I tweeted is true, then do take it serious.
- 1:05:36Carl Zah, thank you for joining me in the trenches.
- 1:05:40Anytime Germs.