Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / The Spy in the Bag | The Impossible Death of Gareth Williams
Transcript
- CoffeeandCrimewithMom: No, absolutely not. There is no way someone just casually zips themselves into a locked bag in a bathtub. Say what you do. Zalle: That's exactly why we're talking about it today. Welcome back to Coffee and Crime with Mom. I'm Zayley. Are you playing it? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: ⁓ you can hear it? and I'm Nicole. Zalle: Today's case is one of the most baffling deaths in modern intelligence history. A man who worked for two of Britain's most secretive agencies, GCHQ and MI6, found dead in circumstances that experts have called physically impossible. This is a case of Gareth Williams, the man found in a bag in the mystery that 14 years later still has no definite answer. You probably have it on preview. You gotta put it on live so I can hear. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: That makes more sense. Okay. I'm not going to even stop recording because it's it. Where ever we go. You ready now? That we can, got my shit together. And I was like, say Liz, are you waiting for a certain part of the song? We know this tune. Okay. All right. Zalle: Hahahaha like I mean Okay? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: And this one frustrates me because the more you read about it, the less sense it makes. All right. Zalle: It really does. And what makes it so important beyond the intrigue of the intelligence ankle is what it represents about institutional failure, about the limits of forensic science and about what happens when the people who are supposed to protect us become the ones who obstruct the truth. So today we're going deep. We're talking about who Gareth was, what happened to him, the forensic contradictions that make this case almost impossible to solve and why his family is still fighting for answers. August 23, 2010, London, England. A police officer arrives at 36 Alderney Street in Pemlico, a quiet, upscale neighborhood not far from the Thames. He's there for a welfare check. Gareth Williams, a 31-year-old mathematician who works for British Intelligence, hasn't shown up to work in over a week. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Well, let's do it. Zalle: Okay. Sorry. I don't know if y'all saw that. Mosquito. His family is worried his employers are well, his employers finally noticed he was missing. The officer enters the flat. Nothing looks disturbed. No broken windows, no overturned furniture, no signs of a struggle, just stillness and heat. The heat is on full blast in the middle of August. He walks through the living room, past the table with a cell phone, two Sims cards and a woman's wig into the main bedroom. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Oh, I was like, one of the kids wake up? What's going on? Zalle: I don't know you, twenty feet. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: He's always wanted to podcast. Probably he said his, his opportunity, he can't let it pass. Zalle: ⁓ this was his dream. Okay. Well, I'm gonna need him not to do it over here near my eyebrow. All right, before we dive in all the way into the today's episode, what are we drinking today, CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Okay. Zalle: into the ensuite bathroom and there in the bathtub is a red sports bag. A North Face Holdall 81 centimeters by 48 centimeters zipped padlocked from the outside. The officer approaches he knows before he even touches it what he's going to find. Inside that bag is Gareth Williams naked curled in a fetal position decomposing. The key to the padlock CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Well, today I got fancy and I still did my whip coffee. Y'all just gonna have to let me get over this hyper fixation. But I had some like melting caramel that we bought because your dad wanted to try to do something that he still hasn't done. anyway, so I melted some of that and I kind of put it in the bottom of my pretty cup here and then just put my whip and all that on top of it. So I got a little caramel splash in there. Zalle: It's underneath his body, inside the bag with him. No one knows how he got in it. No one knows how the bag was locked from the outside. And 14 years later, no one can agree on whether this is a tragic accident, a calculated murder, or something else entirely. Mm, a little sweetened. Okay. Okay. Well, I am on like this weird, I don't really know where my taste buds are right now type thing. because I've, I've been drinking coffee for so long. Ain't no, I started with poo and poo is a black coffee type of gal. And so I feel like CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. We should explain who Pooh is because... Zalle: ⁓ Poo is my grandmother. She is obviously my mom's Coffee and crime with mom. Her mom. Yes. Her mom. And, ⁓ that is the white woman of our family. Yes. And she drinks. Yes. She drinks her coffee black. Well, she used to. Now she does with some creamer. Yeah. She got old. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yes. Mm-hmm, yes. Hello, hello. I'm mom. I'm mom, yeah. She's our white lady. She does. She switched it up. I got her hooked on it when I was in the hospital after I had the surgery. So she started buying them little cups and now she's addicted. Zalle: Right. Yeah. And now it's a whole thing. It's a whole thing. But so because I used to drink it black with her now, like I did switch it. Like once I got into like my 20s, I started doing all the creamers on all the extras and all that. And I'd be like, it'd be too much. It's too sweet. So what I have going on today as I have a dark roast with a dash of heavy whipping cream and some caramel macchiato creamer. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Okay. Zalle: And just mixed that up because I wanted to have like the thickness, but I don't want it to be like super sweet. It's no sugar or nothing else in here. It's just the coffee and those two. And that is what I'm drinking in my Nespresso cup that I found. Yes. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Okay. Okay. Okay. look you fancy. We got our fancy cups today. I got my love yourself, love yourself cup. Zalle: So my husband works for FedEx and he works on the north side of town where the rich people stay and they throw. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Some parts of the North that, some parts, let's be clear. Zalle: Right. No, but the part that he works at is where the rich people stay. Right. And so they'd be giving away stuff and he'd be like, y'all giving away this stuff? And they'd be giving out like, big old truffle things of like putting it in the trash of like coffee cups and dishes. And they had pots and, ⁓ with a deep fryer for a chicken and all kinds of stuff. He was like, can y'all get this stuff work? Y'all give me any. Yeah. He was like, you want it? He was like, ⁓ yeah. And he had like 30 coffee cups in there. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Yeah. I'm okay. Zalle: I got a whole bunch of coffee cups. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: That's right. Repurpose it. Repurpose it. Keep using it. Yeah. Zalle: Yes. Yes. Yes. So, but I definitely have to go with the dark roast today because as you know, I don't think any of our episodes are like, but it's definitely not like today. And then next week we're going to be covering, we're just going to, this is going to be a thing every, every episode. We're going to tease every episode. So y'all kind of know. We all have the suspense of like, Ooh, yeah. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: We're teasing it again. Okay, okay. prepare yourself for. Yeah. Zalle: Next week we're going to be covering the murder of John Benet Ramsey. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: What? We are dealing with some big cases. What's fun about this, doing this with you, is that a lot of times you've heard of these cases, but like you don't know all of the weird crazy details on some of the older ones. And it's fun when you first hear it and I get to see your face to be like, what in the actual are these people talking about? So I get to experience it again through you. Zalle: John Bonet Ramsey. Right. Hmm. Right. especially that's awesome. Cause especially for this one, like for anybody who doesn't know, John Benet Ramsey was a six year old beauty pageant queen founded in her family's Boulder, Colorado basement on December 26th in 1996, which is the year that I was born. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah. Mm-hmm. I didn't even put that together. The year you were born, okay. Zalle: Yes, the year that I was born. Okay. And the case has spawned decades of theories. It has documentaries, books, and investigations, which I know this case because of a documentary that I've seen. And if I'm not mistaken, I believe it was on Netflix. So, and I'm not going to lie to you, if I talk about documentaries most of the time, it's from Netflix. Netflix, HBO. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Okay. It's Netflix. I agree. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Zalle: That's where I'm at with it for the most part. But just recently there have been new developments with the advanced DNA testing and a fresh push by Boulder police to solve it. So. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Wow, 30 years, some people have been waiting for answers and we better go deep and heavy on this one. Zalle: Yeah, I mean 30 years is a long time and like the Gareth Williams case is a story where the technology keeps evolving where what was impossible in 1996 is not possible in 2026. So families keep hoping that one breakthrough will finally give them the truth and mark your calendars because that's what we'll be doing next week. Prepare yourself. If you have the time, go ahead and watch those documentaries. I'll, you know, get up on that a little bit. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: And if not, then just make sure that you make a full pot of coffee for next week. But today we're going to do Gareth Williams. And trust me, this one is just as complex, just as infuriating and just as heartbreaking. So Gareth Wine Williams was born in 1978 in Anglesley, Anglesley, Anglesley, Anglesley baby. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm. Anglesee, Anglesee. We again, we again, we're just sad Americans. We don't know how to say. Zalle: police. And I am not one of the Americans that is ashamed to admit I can be very ignorant. And it's not on purpose, but sometimes it is. But this particular time, it was not. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: some of the American words, so we're really testing our vocabulary. Yeah, that wasn't angles. We just don't say it how it looks and please anyone from this part of the country, this part of the world, just forgive us. We are trying our best. Zalle: Angles. Angles C. Yes, Anglesey North Wales. A small island off the Wales. What'd say? Walls. North Wales. Okay. He was born in 1978 in Ang... Say it again. Angsie. Anglesey North Wales. I'm gonna get that you guys. A small island off the North Wales. The North Wales. Look at this, see? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Wills. Wills. Wals. Wills. Angles C. You're gonna get it. Zalle: It's not just, it's not even, it's all the words you guys. A small island off the Northwest coast of Wales, known for its rugged beauty and tight-knit communities. He was a math prodigy. He finished university at the age of 17. And that kind of mind doesn't come along often. That kind of see, that sees patterns in like chaos and that breaks codes others can't even read. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Hmm. Uh-uh. Zalle: graduating university at 17. I mean, that's, doesn't happen often. No, a genius. I agree. A genius, genius, genuine genius. And that genius, yeah. And that genius is what brought him to the attention of the GCHQ, Britain's government communications headquarters. Their signals intelligence agents. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: universe. Yeah, that's a genius, genius, a genuine genius, genius. both is true. Zalle: Agency, baby, my mouth is not working with me. Okay. There's signals, right? There's signals. Intelligence Agency, the British equivalent of the NSA. He worked there for several years before being seconded to MI6, the secret intelligence service, Britain's foreign intelligence agency, the people who do the real spy work. And when... CoffeeandCrimewithMom: We're gonna get to it. Mm-hmm. Zalle: I don't know much about MI6, I just know that when they be doing like the James Bond movies, they be MI6 people. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Maybe jumping down. Yeah, they be doing that kind of stuff. So he was a spy is what you're saying. Zalle: I mean, he was a code breaker on assignment to the spies. So his work involved financial intelligence, cyber operations, hacking and tracking money flows linked to international crime and potentially hostile foreign powers. He wasn't James Bond. He was the person that James Bond's CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Okay. Okay. Zalle: agency calls when they need somebody to break an encryption or trace a financial transaction through 12 shell companies. He was CoffeeandCrimewithMom: ⁓ wow. So the brain behind the operation is what you're saying. Zalle: Yeah, exactly exactly that's what I'm getting at and I mean when I like think sit back and think about it I Wish I could do that stuff. I Wish my brain work like that I don't necessarily know if I want to be a spy but to be able to do what he was doing where he could like Do all that with the computers because you got to be able to like see the stuff. I cannot CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Be a spy. ⁓ I wish I could do that too. And then I could go and anonymous would recruit me. And I would happily be a part of it. Like all of that's exciting. Zalle: That's what I'm saying. I don't necessarily want to go to be like part of the government or whatever, because one way or the other, I would get fired because y'all are going to be on some BS and then I'm going be the person that's back door getting all the stuff like, oh, okay, that's how y'all handling it. Are we over here and this what we doing? And y'all think that people not supposed to know dropped it. So like that couldn't be me, you know, they would offer me, I would be in the bag, in the bath. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: No. No. ⁓ Mm-hmm. Yeah. You would be, you would be Gareth Williams in the bag with the key in the bath. That would be. Zalle: Yep. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Okay. So here's what matters about who he was. Gareth Williams was not a risk taker. His sister Sherry, say her last name, Subay. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: I'd go with it. So it looks right to me. Zalle: looks right. I apologize if that's not how you pronounce your last name. But she described him as the most scrupulous risk assessor she knew. Those are big. That's nice. Scrupulous. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Corrupulous Risk Assessor. Zalle: assessor. He disliked office culture. He didn't do post-work drinks. He didn't like the rat race of London. He had actually requested to return to GCHQ headquarters in Cheltenham. I believe that's what he said. Preferring the quieter country life to the intensity of London and MI6. So he was trying to leave London. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Yeah, so, right, he wasn't someone who sought out the danger. Zalle: No, not if you're trying to leave the city to go to the countryside. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: and And I think on some of the things that on the research, it was saying that he didn't like the. the red tape part of his move to this other part of the government, MI6, because it was a lot of red tape to get the information. He wanted to do the code cracking and stuff, and it was always a hassle. And he didn't enjoy that part, so he was ready to go back to where it came from. Mm-hmm. Zalle: ⁓ he just wanted to be able to do what he wanted to do. Okay. Yeah. So it seems like he was private, meticulous and structured, the kind of person who plans everything, who thinks three moves ahead. So sounds like me except for the thinking three moves ahead. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: You thought about it three moves ahead and that's why you got anxious and you just gave up the whole plan because you did too much. Zalle: Yeah, okay, yeah, three moves in. And then I just gave up on the plan, yeah. I thought too far in advance is too much, right? Okay, that personality profile becomes really important when we talk about how he died because what happened to Gareth Williams does not match who Gareth Williams was. So we're gonna go through exactly what happened because... CoffeeandCrimewithMom: You did, you overwhelmed yourself. You weren't even there yet. Zalle: Obviously details matter. Gareth Williams was last seen alive on August 14, 2010 on CCTV at Holland Park Tube station in London. He was returning from a shopping trip and he was carrying bags. In the early hours of August 16, his laptop logged onto a cycling website and that's the last known digital activity of his. He was supposed to attend an MI6 meeting on August 16, but he never showed up. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: and nobody noticed. Zalle: Nobody noticed for seven days, an MI6 agent who was, which, you know, the agency he was working for did not report him missing. They did not go check on him. And they did not seem to care that one of their cold breakers had vanished. Like his family was the one who finally raised the alarm and his sister Sherry, hadn't, um, who hadn't heard from him. She's the one who knew that something was wrong, but like, it's not like he's one of the agents out in the field. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: now. Zalle: Like they said, the code breaker disappears. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: So that makes it even more suspicious that it took seven days. So this is the guy who has the intelligence, both his intelligence, but he has all the information, all of this, I'm assuming serious information because he's breaking the codes to get the information. And then he don't show up to work because I've never worked for a government agency. I've worked for a bank or credit union, but if I don't show up on day one, Zalle: That's what I'm saying because he's not the one out there. on y'all as well. bright. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: somebody was going to be on my phone. Yeah, it's going to, somebody wants to know, yeah, why you didn't call us. But the people who keep up with all of the people everywhere in that country, they lost him for seven days in August. And you said with the heating on. Zalle: Somebody's gonna call. Yeah. Hey Eric Nicole, are you coming in today? What's happening? You sick? Yeah. Yeah, so when they found him or when the police went into his place, the heat was on full blast in August and that delay caused forensic evidence because of decomposition. The heating being on full blast in mid August accelerated everything. And by the time the police entered, any chance of finding DNA, fingerprints or trace evidence was severely compromised. The coroner would later call this delay extra anguish and suffering for the family but it was more than that it was the loss of evidence that might have solved the case. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: So what did they find when they finally got there? Zalle: And they found a flat that looked normal. No forced entry, no struggle, no sign of a break-in. In the living room on the table was a phone, two SIMS cards, a woman's wig, which... The two SIMS card, that's kind of weird, but the woman's wig is definitely weird. And then they go into the main bedroom's ensuite bathroom, and that's where they see the Red North face sports bag in the bathtub. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Right. Zalle: It was 81 centimeters by 48 centimeters. It wasn't long enough to hold a person, but barely. It was zip shut padlocked from the outside and inside. Obviously again, Gareth Williams was in there. He was naked and curled in a fetal position and the key to the padlock was underneath his body in the bed. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Okay. Zalle: This is where the case turns from like strange to almost, ⁓ it almost gives like alien-ish or like real conspiracy theory because it's so many contradictions. And so we're going to go through each carefully because this is the heart of the mystery. Okay. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: ⁓ huh. Right. Mm-hmm. Okay, so the lock bag. Zalle: We'll start with the lock bag. Let's start with the physics. The bag was padlocked from the outside, but the key was inside the bag, underneath the body. And there were no fingerprints on the bag, the padlock, the zipper, or on the bathtub, at least the rim of the bathtub where the bag was at. There were no footprints in the bathroom and no DNA evidence that definitively pointed to another person being there, though. There were no inconclusive fragments. I'm sorry, though there were inconclusive fragments from at least two other individuals. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: so someone wiped everything clean. Zalle: at least two other individuals because I mean though it didn't like point to anybody directly it was evidence it was at least two other people there so and then there's nothing anywhere like some CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Right. Mm-hmm. That doesn't make sense. Somebody wiped it down. There's no way, even if we say he got in this bag by himself, because he had the key under him, even if he did all of that, which doesn't make sense, even if he did all of that, then his fingerprints would be all over, not only the bag, but I would think everything around him, how you would have to maneuver your body and push. Zalle: Right. Right. Because that's that, right? But also, also this is your apartment. So why are there no traces of DNA anywhere in your apartment, including your evidence, like your DNA and stuff, where you stay? So either somebody was never there, like they're in a way that never left traces or they knew how to like move around. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: All right. Yeah. Zalle: and avoid leaving anything. But the crucial part is that the investigators tried to recreate that scenario with the bag and they had experts attempt to lock themselves inside an identical bag. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Okay. Zalle: from the inside of the bag. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: And? Zalle: And they tried over 400 times, 400 attempts by trained professionals, escaped artists, people who understand confinement and locks. And none of them succeeded. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Wow. None. Zalle: None of them. Peter Falding, he's a confined space rescue specialist. I say his name wrong? Falding? Not Falding, Falding. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. I think it's folding. It looks like folding, but there is a reference I'm remembering and I think it was said folding. Zalle: Okay, folding. He was a confined space rescue specialist and he tried 300 times out of the 400 times himself. And he called the idea of self confinement a physical impossibility and pointed out that even if somebody could get inside and somehow lock the padlock from within, there would be fingerprints and footprints all over the bathtub and the back. And there wasn't any of either. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: anywhere. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: So the official police theory is that he locked himself in and that theory is physically impossible according to experts, but also beyond being impossible, why would you do this? That's the next question. Zalle: OK. OK, so. We'll get there. We're going to come back to that because we have a, we're going to go over the theories. But okay. So according to the multiple experts who tried to prove it and failed, but like you were saying, um, the remains, the metropolitan, oh, sorry. According to multiple experts who tried to prove it and failed. And yet that remains the metropolitan police position that he did this by himself, which I don't understand how you have that position after 400 failed attempts. But okay. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Okay, okay, okay. All right, I'll slow down. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. the clip. Zalle: Pathologist Richard Shepherd, who examined the case noted that Williams body position suggested he was likely alive when he entered the bag. If he had been placed there after death, the position would likely be different. He wouldn't be in a fetal position like he put himself in the bag. It will probably look more stuffed. You know what saying? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah, yeah. So he was alive when he went in. That seems terrifying. Zalle: I mean, probably alive, which means that if the police theory is correct, he consciously chose to enter the bag that he couldn't escape from in a position that experts could not recreate and then what waited to die. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: That doesn't make any sense. None of this makes any sense. Zalle: It does not. does not. And hypercapnia, I believe that's how you say that, which is a CO2 buildup, would cause unconsciousness in two or three minutes in a sealed bag that size. So if he was alive and conscious when he entered, he would have passed out almost immediately because he could have, ⁓ before he could have any kind of like experience before he could test any kind of escape ability, he wouldn't have been able to do any of that. And remember who we're talking about? A risk. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: adverse mathematician who planned everything. That does not sound like somebody who would voluntarily enter a bag with no exit strategy. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: No, not at all, doesn't. No. Zalle: You're thinking three steps ahead. You plan everything out. I'm going to get in here and even let's he did do it and put the key in there with no way to get to the lock that I've locked from the outside. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Right. I mean, I can't even get there because you would have to tell me why he got in this bag. Even if he killed himself, he that's very elaborate. mean, like, Zalle: Maybe kink, you know, what is it called? That kink they have where, ⁓ like it's on the verge of like, you know, being unalive. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: The auto-asphyxia when they do like the string themselves Okay, I don't know much about that so Zalle: Yeah, maybe it was like that kind of thing. Yeah. Or maybe his hobby was trying to be an escape artist. And this was like, if I do this, then I can go. Or like he was trying to Chris Angel his way through this, you know? Right, maybe, maybe. I'm tired of doing the math and I'm trying to do math in a new way. Right. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: And he just dropped the key under himself. He just saw it as new hobby maybe. He was tired of decoding things. Yeah. Right. I'm trying to, I can see the lady in all the videos with the geometry and all the algebra. That's what my brain is doing right now because none of this makes sense. None of this makes any sense. Zalle: Yeah, in the doony. I don't, that's my, well, that's what I'm thinking. If that's what they're thinking is the thing, you know what saying? That's what I can come up with. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: you Well, I understand what you're saying. I don't even know. I feel like if I'm a cop and I walk into a bathroom and there's a dead man in a duffel bag in a bathtub, that would not be what I thought. Man, I wonder if he put himself in that bag in the bathtub that's clean and there's no evidence that he touched anything in here. His whole department has been wiped down. Zalle: I'm automatically gonna assume murder. Murder. that's clean. Clean bathroom, clean house. Nothing is disturbed. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: So he cleaned, he wiped all of his DNA, all of his fingerprints, and then he climbed in his bag without touching anything, dropped the key under himself. And he didn't know that just in two to three minutes, he would pass out from CO2. Okay, all right. Zalle: and then stuffed himself in the bag. would pass out. So maybe when he was on his way into the bag, had the key in like a pocket or something. And like on the way down, he fell and then the way he was positioned, he couldn't reach it. And so he was, you know, you know, if we got to make it fit. Yeah. Yeah. Right. So in May of 2012, CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Hmm. Maybe it's back pocket. Okay. Hmm. I feel like they're stretching really hard to cover something up. Zalle: Coroner Fiona Wilcox conducted an inquest. She heard from experts, from family, from police, from intelligence agencies, and she reached a conclusion that directly contradicted what the police would later say. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: What did she find? Zalle: Coroner Wilcox ruled that Gareth Williams' death was unnatural and likely to have been criminally mediated or meditated. Mediated? Mediated, okay. I had it right, I had it right. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Nope, mediate That's what you took from that. Okay. Zalle: Okay, so this is what happens when you have undiagnosed. What's the magic? What is it when the words go like this when you be reading? And I'm just trying to make it how I get it. That's what I got. I'm giving you what I got. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Dyslexia, dyslexia. Just trying to make it work. You still saying you got dyslexia. This is the same story. You just carrying that story over from the last episode. Zalle: because it's the truth somebody okay on the balance of probabilities she concluded he was killed unlawfully she believed a third party placed a bag in the bathtub and locked it that Williams was probably alive when this happened that the cause was likely co2 poisoning or suffocation or possibly A short acting poison that wouldn't show up on standard toxicology and she rejected several theories that had been floated in the tabloids like suicide, autoerotic activity, is what we were talking about, or bondage. Bondage interest, which I guess is another one. I didn't think about the bondage. I never would have thought that a duffel bag. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Be Bing! To me, that makes more sense than the autoerotic activity. That bondage makes more sense, but it still doesn't make sense. Zalle: No, that makes no, I wouldn't have thought Duff bondage, duffel bag bondage. That wouldn't have went for me. But she found no evidence to support any of those. Okay, that's true. She didn't. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: I mean, I'm bound up. So the coroner said murder. Zalle: she said murder or at least unlawful killing by a third party, which I'm not quite sure what the difference is, but. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: I guess maybe legally murder, manslaughter maybe. Yeah, maybe. Zalle: Purposefully, I don't know. Okay, but then in 2013, the Metropolitan Police conducted their own review, which I don't know why they did that because clearly all failed in the first place. And they reached the opposite conclusion twice. They said it was probably an accident and that William had locked himself inside the bag during some kind of scenario possibly related to private interests, possibly just experimentation because that's what we do as. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: the face that. Zalle: You know, MI6, mathematician, hacker. Let's just experiment with getting in the bags. I feel like everybody on the department. Fired. Fired. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah, I don't understand the steps that you got. So despite the experts who couldn't do it, they couldn't recreate what the police, they brought these experts in and the experts said no. And then they, the coordinator said, absolutely not. And then they said, well, let us try again. Okay. It's definitely was not murder. It definitely was not what you said. What? Zalle: ⁓ Absolutely not. Fuck what y'all said. I don't give a damn what y'all said. Who's an expert in where? What I said was, this is what happened. So we're going to go with what I said. Despite the experts, despite the physics, despite the complete absence of fingerprints, footprints, despite the personality profile of a risk adverse man who planned everything, the police still said accident. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: What I said was, that's what we're gonna go with. Zalle: And in 2021, they launched a CoffeeandCrimewithMom: That's not. That's not suspicious at all. Zalle: Right, right. I don't see anything wrong with that picture. Right, what's that? A bird. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Everybody look away. What's that? Zalle: They launched another forensic review in 2021 using modern technologies. They re-examined evidence. They found that DNA on a green tile in the kitchen was Williams, not a third party as initially thought. They found that DNA on Williams' hand, which had been identified as unknown was actually contamination from a forensic scientist. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: So, some mistakes were made in the original investigation, but let's just say this is a forensic scientist who is here to collect evidence, put it up and then take it to the lab. I'm assuming, I neither live in the UK nor am I a forensic scientist. But my assumptions would be that you probably put on gloves, you would cover up your hair, maybe put on those white suits where you Zalle: So. I would like to backpedal. That forensics. gloves. Cover up. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: all the stuff that you bring out from the world and no, no. Okay. We're going to call these mistakes. Zalle: Yeah. Yeah. ⁓ So in 2024, the police closed the review. Three years after they started it with no new DNA evidence, no new suspects, no new lines of inquiry, their position remained unchanged. Gareth Williams most likely died alone. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: So. But the coroner said that someone else was involved. Zalle: That's what she had said. She said that somebody was unlawfully involved. And 14 years later, those two conclusions still stand in direct opposition to each other. I don't understand. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yes. I mean, because, so I often wonder when we hear these stories about different governments and their coverups, like this is so obviously a coverup that it hurts you more because not only are you covering something up, but you keep trying to lie to me and tell me things that don't make sense. And that's just what you're going to go with. Beyond the people who you brought in, you brought in as experts. Zalle: Bye. Bye. You called them. I didn't have their number. That's not in my phone book. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah, no, no, I don't know. I was not there. No. Zalle: Okay, so we're gonna back up. One of the theories, right, is the intelligence angle, which is where we at with it. But what was he working on, right? Because I feel like that's important, because that is kind of what makes the case so tantalizing and so dangerous to speculate about, because we don't really know, at least yet, right? So. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Okay. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Right. Great. Zalle: Gareth Williams was not just a mathematician. He was a code breaker working on some sort of, or sorry, on some of the most sensitive operations in British intelligence. Like you said earlier, he knew they business and the other people business that he was hacking, right? His work involved tracking money flows linked to international crime networks, possible ties to Russian intelligence targets. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: You know where my business is. Zalle: financial operations that if exposed could have serious geopolitical consequences. This sounds like some shit that'll get you offed. That's what gets you offed in the movies. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: I'm just saying this is a lot. I mean just what you say right there it seems like because none of it makes sense. Wait. Zalle: I didn't see Russian, I didn't see financial, didn't see geopolitical. British intelligence. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: political. But my thing is this, what, has to be some type of, I don't know, message somebody is trying to get. This is just the weirdest. I mean, why, if it's the government trying to kill them, they just make them disappear. Why, why are we killing him or putting them in a bag alive? Zalle: Okay, so maybe, maybe it was the people, the government people, but something was happening and somebody like kind of interrupted. So they had to leave in the middle and they just put the body in the tub while it was cleaning all of the shit up and they was going to get his body and leave, but something happened. So they just had to dip. They ain't had time to go back and get the body. And maybe that's what's happened. Yeah, maybe they was going to come back. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Mmm. Mmm. And maybe they just thought they'd just leave them there for seven days and with the heat on in August. Zalle: And because it was the because it was probably the people he worked for. They was like, ain't worried about this shit because we the ones that's going to investigate the nigga. But then it didn't happen. Well, it did happen, but not how they thought that it was going to happen. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Right. Mm-mm. Okay. Zalle: Right? Or are you keeping up with me here? Okay. Yeah, okay. So that's where I'm getting at. But he knew things and he told his friend Elizabeth Gutierre. Baby. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yes, yes, I've got... Guthrie? Guthrie? Okay, we're gonna have a non-HR approved moment, okay? Because I have a question. So my question is why when your cousins, and my cousins, wrong, say words wrong, do they make them more difficult than the original way the word is said? Good theory. just you thought this is fancy because it's in the UK. So I'm not gonna say it like it reads. Okay, that's Zalle: Ain't nothing else been said how it read, so she... drag, okay? Guthrie, that he feared he was the target of hostile surveillance that he felt he was being watched. Now in the world of intelligence, paranoia can be a professional caution, but it can also be justified. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Okay. So yeah, it can, but was there any evidence of any foreign involvement? Zalle: So technically, no. There was no concrete evidence that was ever found linking any foreign power to his death. But here's what we do know about how the intelligence agencies behaved. So MI6 failed to report him missing for seven days. That in itself, a huge reflex. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: We starting off and you guilty in my mind. Zalle: But the head of MI6, Sir John Sawyers, he met with Britain's most senior police officer after the body was discovered to discuss the investigations remit, basically what they were allowed to look into. ⁓ The foreign secretary, William CoffeeandCrimewithMom: hate. Zalle: Hag, since I didn't say it I'm just pausing to you pronounce it. William Hague signed a public interest immunity certificate that withheld details of William's work from the inquest. Okay. Details of joint operations with the United States were never disclosed and perhaps most troubling nine memory sticks and a North face bag were found in Williams MI6 office. But SO15 Britain's counter terrorism command did not disclose these items to the murder detectives investigating his death. How you not involved, but you're involved, please explain. Because first of all, why is your foreign secretary, why is the foreign secretary signing a public interest immunity certificate that withheld details about William's work from the inquest for y'all to even be able to ask any questions about what he doing, that's cut off. And Howard is the head of MI6. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: You are withholding evidence. right. Zalle: meeting with the highest or oldest police officer right after the body is discovered to talk about what it is basically that you're allowed to look into. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. So that's the thing though. So like anytime any thing goes, know, anybody thinks like CIA or FBI is doing something, they just say, well, we can't give you that information because of state security or, you know, whatever. So nobody can ever really go in and investigate anything because everything is so secret and they just put it under that umbrella of state security, which to me, what is this? Zalle: Cause then they could just say they can't do that. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: The whole thing is crazy because you're saying, it's nothing. He was just playing around and tried, was trying stuff and got locked in the bag. But you're also at the same time withholding whatever he was working on that could clearly be a cause of this because that would make more sense. Right. Zalle: Right. Right. So you're a huge connection with the United States that was never disclosed. then maybe let me tell you as an American only in America. Okay. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: which then people is shifty. Then people are shifty. This is America. Zalle: this with the long grow. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: what you see right now, isn't it? Please just leave it, just put it down. Zalle: Okay, right there. We're just going to drop that. But then the nine memory sticks and then it was another North Face bag at his office, the MI6 office, which here's, here's the thing because he wasn't even, why did he have a bag at the office? You know what I'm saying? Like you are a CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: You're a hacker, a mathematician. What is in this bag? What is in the bag? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. And why do you have nine memory sticks? Because I'm assuming that that stuff is not supposed to leave the building. But not only do you have them, you have them in a bag. Plus there's another bag like that. I mean, this is, it feels like perhaps somebody saw him with the bag that he had, assumed maybe it was the bag that was in his office and they took their opportunity. I'm just saying, I don't know because I don't work for MI6. Zalle: So that's what I'm saying. Maybe somebody covered it up. Maybe somebody who knew about it was able to know he had that bag at the office. That's what they're going after. I know this is the bag. It's the same bag. North Face bag. So I'm going put his body in this bag. They're going to assume it's the same bag. It's empty. This one he keep at his office. We could just take that bag and then boom, won't nobody know about that. Right? But obviously somebody saw it at the point that we can know. Right? Right. Right. So and CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Somebody did something. I don't care what they said, this man didn't put himself in it. Zalle: SO-15 officer later claimed that intelligence agencies had assured him the items weren't relevant, but how could he know that without examining them? How can anybody know what was relevant without looking? And how can you be in the middle of an investigation and tell me, and tell me that it's not relevant? Right. And then the front door and the lock. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Bye. That's not your investigation. Decide what's relevant. You're not the investigator. Zalle: of Williams' flat were removed before police forensics could examine them. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Now that's obstruction. They're not even trying to be cool and charismatic and get these, it's nothing, it's nothing. They're just taking evidence. Zalle: It's been the Pterxshoot. If it looked like a duck and then quack like a duck, it's obstruction. Okay. Whether it was deliberate or them being incompetent, the effect was the same. Evidence was lost, compromised or never collected. And they blocked so much stuff. And the family has consistently believed that foul play was involved, that the scene was staged, that someone CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Good. Zalle: With professional skills, someone who knew how to avoid leaving traces were responsible, such as... James Bond, that's all I'm saying. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Ha! Zalle: Okay, because that's what it's giving. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: I mean, none of it makes sense to me. it's not, nothing makes me more angry than when someone lies to me in such a way that I believe that you believe I'm stupid. That's what mothers do. Zalle: Well, see, here's that part. And I feel like they feel like it's like, they're just like, oh, it's not that it couldn't possibly be that it's movies are believing stuff. That's not real. It's blah, blah, blah. It's just in the movies. Hmm. We know that y'all people is up to some shifty stuff. We already know y'all out here doing things you ain't actually supposed to be doing. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah. Right. And we know that a lot of stuff we see in movies ends up, we end up at least seeing is true. It could have always been true, but we finally see that it's true. Zalle: is The idea is coming from somewhere. Okay. Do your research. Anyways, we're going to look back at the psychology of Gareth Williams. Excuse me. Because I feel like that's going to help us understand what probably did not happen to him. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Okay. So the personality profile. Zalle: his personality profile. He was highly intelligent. He was private, structured, risk adverse, as we keep saying, very meticulous, a man who planned everything, who didn't like spontaneity, who preferred the quiet of the countryside to the chaos of London. And his sister called him the most scrupulous risk assessor she knew. This is not someone who takes unnecessary chances. This is not someone who experiments. with dangerous scenarios for thrills. Like getting in a bag. Right. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Right. I don't understand any of that. And so what about the tabloid theories? Zalle: Oh, the tabloids had a field day. They found that William had visited bondage websites on four separate days, which I don't think that that's a huge thing, but they found 20,000 euros or 20,000 to 25,000 euros worth of women's clothing, wigs and makeup in his flat. That is That's weird. They found that his landlady had once discovered him tied to bedpost, though he claimed he was testing his ability to escape. And then they ran with that. Which is where they got the auto-erratic accident and bondage gone wrong in the secret double life. But coroner Ruhelcox rejected this. She found that the website visits were CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Hmm. Zalle: too intermediate to indicate an active interest. Like it didn't, it wasn't a consistent thing too far in between. The clothing was consistent with his fashion interest. He attended fashion courses and with gift giving. So like him giving gifts or whatever. And the wigs were consistent with a manga cosplay, which he enjoyed. And if anybody is like me and y'all like the animes and the mangas, you understand. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Okay. Zalle: Okay. That's not far-fetched, but the land lady incident where she found him tied to the bedpost, that was also three years before, and it was just one time. And he did explain it as an escape test, but still. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. So this doesn't add up, because he, four times they saw him go on these websites. Okay. If I'm to the point where I'm going to try to put myself in a bag and lock myself in the bag from inside the bag, but the lock is on the outside and I'm going to try to do all of this. I've, I'm way more into this than for website searches. I'm, I'm, this is, I'm interested in this. Even if you take Zalle: Right, right. Like this is what I've been trying, yeah. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: If you take into account the landlady story, I mean, he probably was doing something with somebody. Maybe they scammed him and left, left him there tied up. It could be anything. So we don't know what that is. And that's a big leap from there to this situation. Zalle: and left and he was embarrassed to say what really happened. Yeah. The only thing that would catch me off guard is the women's clothing and the makeup. Because unless you're like a secret cross dresser, you know what I'm saying? You're not going undercover as a woman. Like that's not what you're doing as a code hacker. We're not sending you out there. So unless you had like a secret woman that you were with that lived with you and nobody knew that y'all was in like this relationship and that's where all that came from, that is weird. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Right, and they were saying exactly. Well, I he had a sister and if he was making money and he was single and he had this money, he was. Well, maybe he was. mean, when did this happen? Maybe it was almost Christmas time. We don't know, but I think it's a huge leap to go from. I mean, he could be into things in his personal life. That's nobody's business, but even that is a big leap from I have all these clothes and makeup and. Zalle: Maybe he was just stockpiling gifts, like buying things. Okay. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Was he in the bag in a wig with makeup on in women's clothes? Other than that, you can't put those two things together. It's just something else that doesn't really fit into a picture, but it doesn't add to that theory. Zalle: No. Okay. Right. none of it is holding up to any of the scrutiny. Okay. And more importantly, it really doesn't match his like psychology. Would this type of person with like such structured thinking voluntarily enter a bag and seal it up with no exit plan? Would he do so in a way that experts can't even replicate? Like how did you get to that level? CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-mm. Right. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Right. Zalle: of expertise where people can't replicate this awful for internet searches. Like that doesn't make sense. The psychological mismatch is astonishing. And it's one of the reasons the corner rejected the accident theory because it just doesn't make sense. Okay. So we're going to strip away the theories and focus on what we can say with certainty. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. That does it. Mm-hmm. So what do we know? Zalle: Okay, we know that Williams was last seen alive on August 14, 2010. He was found dead on August 23, 2010 inside a locked sports bag in his bathtub. The bag was padlocked from the outside, but the key was inside under his body. There were no fingerprints or footprints on the bag, padlock, zipper, or bathtub rim. ⁓ Experts tried over 400 times to recreate the situation and failed every time. A coroner ruled it unnatural and likely criminally mediated unlawful killing. The police still maintained probably an accident after all of that. There were no drugs, alcohol or poisons detected. No definitive DNA evidence of a third party was involved, though there were inconclusive fragments. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Yeah. Zalle: MI6 delayed reporting commencing for seven days. Intelligence agencies withheld evidence from the investigation. The case was reviewed again from 2021 to 2024 with no new evidence. And as of 2024, the case remains officially unresolved, so still open. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: That is just crazy. So we're left with a ⁓ lock bag, a missing explanation, and a whole lot of questions and no reasonable answers coming from the police. Zalle: I mean, yeah, we're just left with the log bag, the missing explanation, and then the two official conclusions that completely contradict each other. Okay. And then his family that still believes that their son and brother was murdered and intelligent agencies that at best were incompetent and at worst completely obstructed justice. So, I mean, I don't really know where to go here. I'm on the side. that this is a cover up. And they did such a poor job because they just felt like we could just blow this off and it's going to be like, yeah, whatever. Or it was done by, like, let's say another country and they wanted the people to know like what was going on. But this is his country's way of just saying, no, this isn't happening. So they don't have to like focus on what. Right. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: You'll probably tell some of their secrets. Right. So I don't know what happened. I don't know who did it, but I know Garris didn't do it. I can use my own common sense to know that he did not do that. And they, the lies and the cover up just make it, it makes it so clear that something was wrong. It makes it clear that you're hiding something. Zalle: No, that doesn't make sense. Right. And regardless to all of that, before we close, just want to make sure that we make sure we say his name to us. That's like one of the most important parts of every, every episode is making sure that their stories, the victims are the people stories are told from like their life, not just as being a victim or a case number and not just being known as the titles that go along with what happens to them. Like not just being known as a spy in the bag. or just a conspiracy theory. We want to see him as a whole person. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: because he was a whole person, whatever happened to him. Zalle: Yes, he was. Yes, Gareth Wine Williams, 31 years old, a mathematician, a cold breaker, a man who loved cycling and running and manga. manga, manga. I never know how to say it. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: manga manga we said them all at this point we'll just choose the right one Zalle: Manga, manga sounds right. Cycling and running in manga and fashion, a brother, a son, a friend. He was born in Anglesey, Anglesey, Anglesey, North Wales. I don't like that word, I'm sorry. Anglesey, North Wales. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Anglesy? don't even know if that's right. I'm just pronouncing it how it looks. So I don't, I don't know if that's right. Okay. Zalle: Okay, well that's what we're going with. He was a prodigy who finished university at 17. He chose a life of service, working for his country's intelligence agencies, using his extraordinary mind to protect others. He was private, meticulous, risk adverse, the kind of person who thinks before he acts, who plans, who considers consequences. He deserved to live a long life. He deserved to return to the countryside he loved as he asked, and he deserved to grow old with his family. Instead, he was found in a bag, in a bathtub, in a apartment that was not safe, a safe house that was not safe. And 14 years later, we still don't know what happened to him, but we do know his name. And we tried our best to say it out loud during this episode. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: We see you, Gareth Williams. Zalle: Yes, Gareth, we see you and we are sorry for what happened to you and the lack of competency in trying to solve your case. This was not a neat story and it doesn't have a tidy ending and it doesn't have a villain who was caught or a hero who saved the day. It was a dead man. It has a dead man and a locked bag and two completely contradictory officials. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Right. Zalle: conclusions and a family that is still waiting to know the truth and probably will never know. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Right. And what keeps me up at night is the institutional failure, but more so what seems like malice and, and dishonesty over, so, you know, protecting something over the truth about this man who served not, mean, whether he served his country or not, but he worked with these people and he was somebody's son, somebody's brother. People loved him and they, Zalle: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: totally ignored what happened to him or hid it. Zalle: Yeah, it just seems like a complete disregard for him as a personal, like a person period. The institutional failure was huge. And seven days before anyone noticed he was missing at your job, like that doesn't make sense. Evidence withheld, the scene compromised, the front door being removed before forensics could examine it. A forensic scientist DNA misidentified as evidence, which is crazy. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: No. Zalle: that caused the family additional pain. The coroner who said murder and a police force who said accident and never meeting in the middle to really try to figure out what happened. And through it all, the intelligence agencies, the very people Gareth Williams served, seem to have been more interested in protecting their own secrets than finding out the truth about his death, which they probably knew because was this a tragic accident, a calculated murder? A perfectly executed coverup is, we don't know, we may never know. But what the case proves is that when institutions fail to cooperate, when evidence is withheld, when investigations are compromised, the truth becomes impossible to find and families are left with questions that haunt them for decades. And Gareth Williams' family has been fighting for 14 years. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: His sister Sherry, his parents, they have refused to accept the accident theory, which I would not have accepted either. I would have demanded answers the same way that they are. And they have been met with silence, obstruction, and contradiction, which, you would not hear the last of me, okay? You will rue the day. Rue the day that you got this. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: I wouldn't either. through the day and they deserve so much better. All families deserve better than this. Zalle: Yes, they did. They deserve better. And so did Gareth. And if you do want to go deeper on the case, the 2024 documentary, The Spy in a Bag, New Revelations by Firecracker Films, explores the cover-up evidence in detail, which pretty juicy. The original inquest records are publicly available and make for sobering reading. if this case frustrates you, if... the institutional failures, why can I not talk if the institutional failure failures, my mouth is like, I literally am trying to get it to do what I'm telling it to do and it's doing what it wants. Like my tongue just relax when it goes to hers. If it angers you, good, it should anger you because only way these systems change is when enough people demand accountability. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: failures. He gave up. Zalle: All sources and links are in the show notes. Thank you for spending time with us and thank you for remembering Gareth Williams. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: and we'll see you next week. Zalle: Yes, we will see you next week and please if you guys enjoyed the show comment like review share Subscribe we do do all of this stuff do all this stuff ⁓ CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Subscribe, share, tell your friends, tell your families. Come interact with us on our socials. We are begging, we beg this every week. Please come interact with us. So we know people are listening. Yes. Zalle: Yes. Yes, it means so much. helps us grow. Yeah, and for all of you guys, I just want to say for those out in Thailand, Bangladesh, Austria, Hong Kong, all of the international Germany, all the international people listening to us, thank you guys so much. You have no idea. Even the one download that we have been getting in these other countries, it doesn't matter from anybody anywhere. We're just super excited. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Germany. Zalle: that people are listening and that it seems like you guys like what we're doing. And that means a lot to us, because this is like our baby. So we hope that y'all keep coming back. And if y'all would like to interact with us, like my mom said, reach out to us on the social medias, or you can reach out to us ⁓ via email on coffee and crime with mom at Gmail or at Outlook. We'll respond to either one of them. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Mm-hmm. Yes. Zalle: Let us know about ideas for the show or coffee ideas or whatever. If y'all have a weird story or some kind of personal mystery or whatever the case is, just hit us up and let us know. And until then, stay sweet you guys. CoffeeandCrimewithMom: Take care of yourselves.