Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Mapping the Anti-Rights Movement From the US to the UK" with Amnesty International UK
Transcript
- 0:02You are listening to a stage talk titled Mapping
- 0:04the Anti -Rights Movement from the US to the
- 0:07UK. This week Amnesty International, UK's gender
- 0:10justice director, came in to discuss their research
- 0:13on the UK's anti -rights movement. From pro -life
- 0:17arguments to anti -trans rhetoric, voices against
- 0:20rights that have long been established in the
- 0:21UK appear to be growing louder. Kiara explained
- 0:25why you might feel like the UK is following the
- 0:27footsteps of the US. and what that might mean
- 0:30over the next few years, as well as highlighting
- 0:32gaps researchers could cover when it comes to
- 0:35accountability for these groups. You can find
- 0:37links to all the resources mentioned in the talk
- 0:40in the podcast description. This talk was hosted
- 0:42by me, Charlotte Mar, on Thursday the 12th of
- 0:45February, 2026, in the Bell and Cap Discord server.
- 0:55Welcome to this week's Stage Talk. We are joined
- 0:58by Chiara Caprero, Gender Justice Director at
- 1:01Amnesty International UK. Last year, Amnesty
- 1:04shared a research report on the growing anti
- 1:06-rights movement in the UK, which I've just popped
- 1:08in the chat for your perusal. It mapped the nature
- 1:11and finances of 65 anti -rights groups operating
- 1:14across the UK. Over the next few minutes, Chiara
- 1:17will unpack the patterns they observed of American
- 1:19anti -rights rhetoric travelling overseas. and
- 1:22highlight how they found that the same key actors
- 1:24are driving the conversation in the UK. This
- 1:26is not a debate on political views, but a discussion
- 1:30on how political influence structures manifest
- 1:32across oceans. Whilst we talk, you can place
- 1:35your questions in the chat accessible on the
- 1:37right -hand corner of your screen. But please
- 1:39remember that this is being audio recorded for
- 1:41the podcast, so if you do not want me to mention
- 1:44your username, please add that as a note in your
- 1:47question and I will absolutely avoid doing that.
- 1:50Okay. Kiara, over to you. The floor is yours.
- 1:54Thank you so much, Charlie. Hi, everyone. I'm
- 1:57really excited to be here. I'm a big fan. So
- 1:59thanks so much for having me today. As Charlie
- 2:03said, I work at Amnesty International UK. So
- 2:05that's the UK branch of Amnesty International.
- 2:09I've been there for about eight years and my
- 2:12role focuses on bodily autonomy issues. So that
- 2:16means policy and advocacy on issues of abortion,
- 2:19trans rights and sex workers rights. 90 % of
- 2:23my work is domestic facing, so UK policies and
- 2:27load. And I've been working on these issues for
- 2:30about 12 years. So to start with, I wanted to
- 2:35set the context of where the research kind of
- 2:39comes from and how it fits in the current context
- 2:42of the worsening human rights situation in the
- 2:44UK, because we need to understand the erosion
- 2:47of LGBT rights, especially trans rights in this
- 2:51wider context. So if there are people from the
- 2:55UK, you would know that successive governments
- 2:58have eroded human rights protections. So we've
- 3:01had even ever more draconian legislation on asylum
- 3:05and regression of economic and social rights.
- 3:10severe restrictions to the right to protest,
- 3:13especially in the past three, four years, I would
- 3:15say. And then there is the sort of like ongoing
- 3:18narrative around taking the UK out of the European
- 3:22Convention on Human Rights. This kind of comes
- 3:25and goes. Right now is a time where it's very
- 3:28much present. So the erosion of LGBT rights and
- 3:32trans rights as a side needs to be seen in this
- 3:34context. So the UK used to be the first in the
- 3:38European ranking of LGBTI equality in 2015, and
- 3:42now it's 22nd. And the situation of trans people
- 3:45is one of the main causes of this. Over the past
- 3:50seven years or so, trans people have been dehumanized,
- 3:54have been portrayed as the other, a dangerous
- 3:57other in the media. And I think we're talking
- 4:02about that tiny, tiny minority who is already
- 4:05marginalized. There's also another tiny minority
- 4:09which is people seeking asylum that kind of has
- 4:12the same treatment in the media. So I'm gonna
- 4:14talk specifically about gender issues. We kind
- 4:18of need to see the demonization of minorities
- 4:21and the otherization of minorities as really
- 4:24like a very powerful force at play here. So I'm
- 4:29just going to whisk through a timeline that kind
- 4:32of again sets the context for the findings. So
- 4:36the starting point I would say was 2018 when
- 4:41the government at the time was Theresa May, Prime
- 4:44Minister, that feels like centuries ago. But
- 4:47she proposed a reform of the Gender Recognition
- 4:50Act, which is the law that kind of regulates
- 4:53how a trans person can have their gender. uh,
- 4:56slash sex legally recognized, uh, in law. So
- 5:00the first step to this was a consultation. And
- 5:03that was the first time that we saw organized
- 5:06opposition coming together. So you had your,
- 5:09you know, Christian groups that you would expect,
- 5:13but we also started to see in kind of like radical
- 5:16feminist groups or groups that right now we like,
- 5:20you know, now we would call gender critical,
- 5:22but sort of like kind of putting trans rights
- 5:25in opposition to women's rights. So this group
- 5:28also started to emerge and to converge, and I
- 5:30think Open Democracy reported on this that their
- 5:33views were basically the same, so that's quite
- 5:35interesting. So even though the public response
- 5:40to this consultation was in favor of reforming,
- 5:45at the end this reform was shelved because of
- 5:48the opposition and also then having you know,
- 5:52government was interested. Another issue that
- 5:55we've had ongoing is around the use and access
- 5:59to puberty blocker. So I can't go into detail
- 6:02on all that has happened since 2018, 2020, but
- 6:06know that they've been banned for use for gender
- 6:10dysphoria permanently at the end of 2024. And
- 6:14then we got to April 2025 with the Supreme Court
- 6:18judgment. I'm sure people have heard about this,
- 6:21but this was a judgment, an appeal of a case
- 6:24brought by a gender critical group against the
- 6:27Scottish government. And the case itself started
- 6:29in 2018. So the court ruled that the words sex,
- 6:34woman, and man must be understood as biological,
- 6:37by which they mean basically the sex marker that
- 6:40you have on your birth certificate. for the purposes
- 6:43of the Equality Act which is our equalities legislation.
- 6:47So this is a complete departure from how the
- 6:50law was understood for the past 20 years and
- 6:53Amnesty UK we intervened as a third party in
- 6:57the court and we made clear that you know legal
- 7:00gender recognition is a human rights and the
- 7:03legislation derives from European court case
- 7:06law. So from our perspective now with this judgment,
- 7:10the scope of legal gender recognition has reduced
- 7:13massively and we consider that we are in a sort
- 7:17of like pre -legal gender recognition situation.
- 7:21So the implementation of the judgment is still
- 7:24unclear, but the exclusion of trans people has
- 7:27already started on top of rising hate crime and
- 7:31vilification over the past seven years or so.
- 7:34So you have big organizations like the Football
- 7:36Association, for example, they decided, I think
- 7:39this was in the summer, to exclude the trans
- 7:42people. And recently we've had important women's
- 7:46organizations like the Guiding Women's Institute
- 7:48also decided to exclude trans women. And there
- 7:51is evidence that in all these cases, legal threat
- 7:54played a role in this organization making this
- 7:58decision. So all of this said, why we decided
- 8:01to do this research? I guess the starting point
- 8:05is that we find ourselves on the back foot. We've
- 8:08been firefighting for years and resources for
- 8:12human rights work are what they are. Definitely
- 8:16way less than what the anti -rights movement
- 8:19has. So we know that the opposition exists and
- 8:22is active, but we don't know exactly who they
- 8:24are, what they're up to, where do they come from.
- 8:27We also know that there's money coming in from
- 8:29the US. This happened during the first Trump
- 8:31term and is happening now as well. In 2022, I'm
- 8:36sure people are aware, Roe v. Wade was reversed
- 8:38in the US and this really galvanized the anti
- 8:42-abortion movement globally, including in the
- 8:44UK. And also across the movement, there is little
- 8:50understanding of how issues of bodily autonomy
- 8:52really are intersectional. So you have you know,
- 8:55abortion, reproductive rights, trans rights,
- 8:58these are all issues that are under the umbrella
- 9:01of bodily autonomy. So I wanted to look at like
- 9:04how the anti -rights movement targets these issues
- 9:06and how we can be better, you know, working together
- 9:09and fighting back. And another reason was that
- 9:13small organic face backlash and the action of
- 9:17anti -rights actors like directly, but they don't
- 9:20have the resources to do this kind of work. So
- 9:22we wanted to support the wider movement. So this
- 9:25was the first time really that amnesty, usually
- 9:29our research uses other kinds of methodology.
- 9:33So I work with Claire Provo who is an investigative
- 9:35journalist so you might know her. She has a lot
- 9:38of experience in this area. So how did we go
- 9:44about it? We had two phases of the research.
- 9:47The first was mapping and the second one was
- 9:50a follow the money exercise. So in terms of the
- 9:54mapping, we used a snowball methodology. So we
- 9:58looked at information available publicly, so
- 10:02websites, social media, responses to government
- 10:05consultations. And then we also had interviews
- 10:09with key actors in the movement that have been
- 10:13directly affected by these organizations. And
- 10:16then for the follow the money piece, we looked
- 10:18at accounts. We consider the expenditure and
- 10:23not income. This too was to avoid counting assets
- 10:26and reserves. It's a bit more straightforward.
- 10:30Other analysts use income, so there's a different
- 10:34way of going about it. We use expenditure. Looking
- 10:37at the accounts, the levels of detail was very
- 10:40variable. There isn't like one requirement to
- 10:43break down accounts in a specific way, which
- 10:45again is an issue per se. And levels of detail
- 10:50vary. So for example, Alliance Defending Freedom,
- 10:53which I'm going to talk about in a little bit,
- 10:55just has a lump sum for expenditure and for donations
- 10:59for income. And I have to say that the findings
- 11:02were limited to the capacity and budget that
- 11:06we had. So we certainly didn't cover everything.
- 11:10And also, ideally, this is an exercise that should
- 11:13be done on an ongoing basis. Yeah, just keep
- 11:17ourselves up to date with what the opposition
- 11:20is up to. So in terms of the findings, in terms
- 11:25of the mapping, we mapped 65 organisations, three
- 11:28quarters of which are charities and registered
- 11:31companies, which I found really shocking. When
- 11:35you're a charity, you can ask for institutional
- 11:38funding. So we found evidence that a few of the
- 11:41crisis pregnancy centres that we found received
- 11:46the government and national lottery funding,
- 11:49which shows that there is really either a misunderstanding
- 11:51or a complete ignorance of what these organizations
- 11:54actually are. I don't know if people know what
- 11:57crisis pregnancy centers are, but essentially
- 11:59they are either like clinics, like kind of brick
- 12:03and mortar like centers you can go into or helplines.
- 12:07that kind of market themselves as being neutral
- 12:10and providing advice, but actually they're run
- 12:13by anti -choice organizations and they want to
- 12:15dissuade women and pregnant people from having
- 12:18an abortion. So we divided the 65 in categories,
- 12:23but they must be understood as an ecosystem.
- 12:26So the categories are not watertight. So for
- 12:29example, anti -abortion groups and what we call
- 12:32ultra -conservative Christian groups often overlap.
- 12:36and they share strategies, they share tactics,
- 12:39they share staff or lawyers. So moving to the
- 12:44Follow the Money, we looked at five financial
- 12:47years, so 2019 to 2023, and we were able to look
- 12:51at the accounts of 32 organizations where there
- 12:55were accounts available that we could have a
- 12:58look at. And I'm sure other people with this
- 13:01methodology know that, of course, we're always
- 13:04kind of like one financial year behind, right?
- 13:07So it's always kind of like a retrospective look
- 13:10at the situation. So this 32 spent 106 million
- 13:14pounds in those five financial years and the
- 13:18expenditure grew by over a third. All categories
- 13:21have increased expenditure considerably. So,
- 13:24for example, the anti -abortion group by 34%.
- 13:28the UK branches of US organizations by 46%. And
- 13:33I just wanted to highlight organizations promoting
- 13:36so -called conversion therapy, which are 12 in
- 13:40the mapping, but only four in the follow the
- 13:43money exercise. So they account for only two
- 13:46million pounds out of the 160. So it's a very,
- 13:49very small share, but their expenditure has gone
- 13:53up by 167%. So this is important because We have
- 13:58been waiting for legislation to ban conversion
- 14:02therapy the first time it was announced in 2018.
- 14:06So successive governments have kept announcing
- 14:08that this was going to come. We're still waiting.
- 14:11And in the meantime, it appears that these organizations
- 14:14are thriving really. So the biggest spender in
- 14:18terms of the groups that spent more money are
- 14:22these UK branches of US organizations. So I'm
- 14:25going to talk about Alliance Defending Freedom,
- 14:27which I think people have heard of. So they are
- 14:32an American organization that was established
- 14:35in the mid 1990s and they're, I guess, infamous
- 14:39or most famous because they contributed to the
- 14:44overturn of Roe v Wade, as well as like many
- 14:47other different cases that are now perhaps that
- 14:49high profile. So they established in the UK in
- 14:532015 as a company, and then they registered as
- 14:56a charity in 2017. So their expenditure since
- 15:002015 has grown by 187%, sorry, since 2019. So
- 15:08they are investing in the UK more and more. So
- 15:12far, their main activity has been defending individuals
- 15:15that have been charged with breaching safe access
- 15:18zones around abortion clinics. And last summer,
- 15:22JD Vance commented on one of these cases, making
- 15:26it an example of how we don't have freedom of
- 15:29speech anymore in the UK, apparently. So quite
- 15:32like really extraordinary that a US vice president
- 15:35comments on like one legal case of one individual
- 15:39in the UK. So they are very close to the Trump
- 15:42administration. And recently, I don't know if
- 15:45people have seen, but the New York Times reported
- 15:48that ADF has also facilitated Nigel Farage going
- 15:52to the U .S. Congress to testify again around
- 15:56freedom of speech, apparently. So why freedom
- 16:00of speech? The UK context is different for what
- 16:05concerns abortion, how it is regulated. Here
- 16:08is parliament that decides. So it's not through
- 16:11the courts like in the US that you can make changes.
- 16:15So this organization needed another entry point
- 16:19and they have converged on freedom of speech.
- 16:23Another entry point where ADS is not as active
- 16:27so far, but others are. is France healthcare,
- 16:31especially for young people. So since 2020, we
- 16:35have seen a prominent anti -abortion solicitor
- 16:38by the name of Paul Conray taking, I think, at
- 16:43least five cases, five legal cases to try to
- 16:46meet the capacity of under 16 to consent to medical
- 16:51treatment. This is called the Gillick Principle
- 16:54in law. You know, if this was restricted, these
- 16:58outcomes would impact everyone. So not only trans
- 17:01youth, but also young people wanting to access
- 17:05abortion and contraception. And this is a wedge
- 17:09for this movement to get to abortion and contraception.
- 17:14So they have adopted this strategy, kind of using
- 17:17a wedge issue rather than going straight for
- 17:20abortion and contraception, given how different
- 17:22the political climate is in the UK compared to
- 17:25the US. The thing I find really frustrating is
- 17:29that these dots are basically never joined in
- 17:33mainstream coverage of these issues. So you see,
- 17:36for example, coverage of these trans health care
- 17:40cases with named, this solicitor is named, but
- 17:43nobody kind of joins the dots saying actually
- 17:45this person is being active trying to reduce
- 17:48access to abortion as well. And I think that
- 17:51The same, like lack of joining the dots, unfortunately,
- 17:55is also part of our movement. The sectors are
- 17:59very siloed. For example, the reproductive rights
- 18:02sector and the LGBTI sector in civil society
- 18:05are very siloed. And there is still disagreement
- 18:08on trans inclusion. So of course that doesn't
- 18:11help us fighting back. So I want to move on to
- 18:17another kind of key actor. a key player in anti
- 18:22-rights when it comes to the UK. So in the UK,
- 18:26many anti -rights organizations also called gender
- 18:29critical are women led. And this provides a really
- 18:33good kind of cover for legitimacy where you can
- 18:37say that, you know, this is about women's rights
- 18:40and protecting women and women and trans people's
- 18:44rights are incompatible. Of course, we also have
- 18:47the JK Rowling factor. I'm not going to go into
- 18:50that. I'm sure everyone is aware of her level
- 18:54of influence. We've seen this growing exponentially
- 18:58when we had the general election campaign last
- 19:01summer. And from looking at these issues for
- 19:05a few years now, I can say that in this case,
- 19:08it's the UK gender critical movement that has
- 19:12influenced the US rather than the other way around.
- 19:15And the key difference is that, as I said, here
- 19:18is women led organization, sometimes LGB people
- 19:21led organization, or, you know, that's what they
- 19:24say. So that provides more legitimacy, right,
- 19:29than being like, you know, your evangelical organizations
- 19:32that you might expect. So this is the key difference
- 19:34that their policies are the same, but they present
- 19:38themselves or they are different. So for example,
- 19:42one of the main gender critical organizations,
- 19:45Sex Matters, praised Trump's first executive
- 19:49order on biological truth. I can't remember exactly
- 19:55what it was called. And this is never kind of
- 19:59raised as a question that why an organization
- 20:02that says they support women are actually in
- 20:05agreement with Trump. So Sex Matters is the main
- 20:10gender critical charity. They registered in April
- 20:132024. So we're still waiting for them to file
- 20:17their accounts for the first time. They have
- 20:20a year's time because they're a new charity plus
- 20:2310 months as like a grace period. So we're still
- 20:26waiting. It would be really interesting to see
- 20:29what they look like and also to see the level
- 20:31of detail that they go to in their accounts.
- 20:36And sex matters also recently intervened in two
- 20:39cases around, again, freedom of speech, around
- 20:44issues of LGBT rights, where Christian Concern,
- 20:47which is a ultra conservative Christian organization,
- 20:50represented defendants. So from their perspective,
- 20:54because it's about freedom of speech, it really
- 20:57allows them to work with actors where it could
- 21:01raise questions why they work with these actors.
- 21:03But the freedom of speech framework really allows
- 21:06different actors to converge and work together.
- 21:09They also submitted just last week, I think,
- 21:13an amicus to the US Supreme Court on this case
- 21:15on trans inclusion in sports. So they are extremely,
- 21:19extremely active, even though there are, I think,
- 21:21three people who are spokespeople for these organizations.
- 21:26So I'm running a bit out of time, but I just
- 21:28wanted to conclude by saying that what we see
- 21:31that is coming up is a constituency of committed
- 21:35anti -abortion MPs or former MPs convening inside
- 21:39the reform. So you have people like Dan Hooger
- 21:42who defected from the Tories or people like Maria
- 21:46Caulfield who is an anti -choice former MP. She
- 21:49also joined the reform. And we also have this
- 21:53Professor James Orr. I didn't know about him.
- 21:56I haven't heard about him until this summer.
- 21:59I'm curious to see if people have heard. of him
- 22:01before, but he's a professor of divinity at Cambridge,
- 22:05very close to JD Vance. He's against abortion
- 22:08in any circumstance, and he's now a top advisor
- 22:11to reform. And it's been interesting to see Farage,
- 22:15how he positions himself around abortion. So
- 22:20he has been saying that he's pro -choice, but
- 22:23the abortion limits are ludicrous, so they should
- 22:27be lowered. Then a few months ago, he brought
- 22:31up the Child Benefit Cap, which is a restriction
- 22:34to social protection, which is responsible for
- 22:37keeping a lot of families and children in poverty.
- 22:40So he said, you know, we should lift this cap
- 22:42so that families can have more children. Of course,
- 22:45you know, he means white families. This is like
- 22:48an ethno -nationalist framing. But then two weeks
- 22:51ago, he said that we should reinstate the cap.
- 22:55so that we can use the money to provide subsidies
- 22:58for pubs. So there isn't a coherent ideology
- 23:02around these issues yet, but of course we're
- 23:07keeping an eye on what's going on. So I think
- 23:09I'm going to stop here and I'm looking forward
- 23:12to the questions. I'll give it back to you, Charlie.
- 23:16Thank you. Thank you, Chiara. We've already got
- 23:18a bunch of questions coming in. But I wanted
- 23:21to ask a question first and foremost, just to
- 23:25understand the research a little bit better.
- 23:27How does your team define an organisation as
- 23:31part of this movement? What kind of characteristics
- 23:33are important to kind of class an organisation
- 23:37as part of the anti -rights movement in the UK?
- 23:41Yeah, that's a really good question. Thank you.
- 23:44Yes, so by anti -rights actor we mean organizations,
- 23:49individuals, political parties or member states.
- 23:52When I mean member states, I mean at the UN level
- 23:54who actively advocate for the restriction of
- 23:59human rights. These ones that I've talked about
- 24:03are often called anti -gender. We call them anti
- 24:06-rights because they are really against the architecture
- 24:10of human rights and human rights are universal.
- 24:13So when you you know, you start clamping down
- 24:15on bodily autonomy that of course affects rights
- 24:18across the board. So that's how we define them.
- 24:24Brilliant. Thank you. We've got a few questions
- 24:29across the board that I'll ask Icares first.
- 24:33They said, I know your study is mainly descriptive,
- 24:35but would you say the motive of these anti -rights
- 24:37groups is mainly ideological or are there economic,
- 24:40political motives behind these efforts? Yeah,
- 24:44this is an excellent question because there are
- 24:47mixed motivations. So when I talked about the
- 24:51anti -abortion cool status inside reform, that's
- 24:54extremely concerning because you have people
- 24:57who are ideologically committed and then you
- 25:00have people who are trying to grab power. So
- 25:03that cocktail is pretty dangerous. So, you know,
- 25:07in many, for example, trans rights that become
- 25:10such a political football and been taken up by,
- 25:15you know, the issues being taken up by politicians
- 25:17who never said anything about LGBT rights. So
- 25:21that is clearly a wedge issue. It's something
- 25:23that they think is going to work with the public
- 25:25in terms of, you know, quote unquote culture
- 25:28wars. Instead for others is really they're ideologically
- 25:31committed on clamping down on LGBT rights. So
- 25:35there's mixed motivation. There's also, I didn't
- 25:37have time, but I think a very fascinating aspect
- 25:40of all of these is individuals. and how they
- 25:43monetize this kind of activity. So influencers
- 25:46who have cases of, for example, a couple of people
- 25:50who have become like, yeah, not famous, but let's
- 25:56say known in the public sphere because they took
- 25:59up cases where they argued that they were discriminated
- 26:03against because of their views. Out of that jumping
- 26:07point, now they have, you know, huge Twitter
- 26:10following, they go on GB News, they have their
- 26:13own blogs, their own podcasts. So this is a very
- 26:16interesting aspect of anti -rights grifters,
- 26:20I call them, that I hope to investigate more
- 26:24in the future. Seeing the same kind of patterns
- 26:27of those individuals also within the US. As we're
- 26:30talking about organisations though, Will D601
- 26:34ask an interesting question, does the legal structure
- 26:36within the UK compared to the US restrict what
- 26:40kind of advocacy these groups can perform, i
- 26:43.e. if they're a charity versus a private company
- 26:45and tax deductible, deductibility questions for
- 26:48donors? Is there any difference between the UK
- 26:50and the US funding that kind of restricts some
- 26:53of the advocacy that they can do in the UK? I
- 26:59think in terms, okay, I can't say that I can
- 27:03answer this in full. I can say how it looks like
- 27:07in the UK, which is there are different vehicles
- 27:10for influencing parliamentarians, for example.
- 27:14So as a charity, you can influence. We are also,
- 27:17you know, a charity and we try to influence.
- 27:20There are mechanisms like all party parliamentary
- 27:24groups with a sort of like interest groups of
- 27:27MPs. For example, there is a right -life one.
- 27:30which was chaired by an anti -choice organization.
- 27:34So that's a good vehicle to kind of like, you
- 27:36know, get into parliament and start talking to
- 27:38MPs. I think perhaps, and I'm no expert in this,
- 27:42but I think perhaps like a big difference is
- 27:45the level of like electoral funding and how parties
- 27:50can raise funds ahead of elections. I think the
- 27:53UK is stricter, but is also kind of seeing more
- 27:58and more money coming in. So just to give you
- 28:00an example, there is a donor to LGBT Alliance,
- 28:05which is an anti -trans LGBT organization, who
- 28:11is also a top donor to reform. And they provided,
- 28:15you know, it's not a big sum, it's like 20 ,000
- 28:17pounds to LGBT Alliance to run their, they have
- 28:21a helpline. to run the helpline. So it's not
- 28:25that much money, but you see them kind of coming
- 28:28together and the sort of, as I said, kind of
- 28:32like dynamic where you have ideologically committed
- 28:35people and people were just trying to get in
- 28:39power. Consider that we have elections in 2029,
- 28:43but the current government is not doing very
- 28:45well, so they could happen even sooner. So it's
- 28:48really prime time to influence right now. Yeah,
- 28:54and reform do appear to be gaining traction as
- 28:57well in the UK at the moment. As we're on funding,
- 29:02actually one of the first questions we got was
- 29:04you mentioned to follow the money exercise. How
- 29:07did you conduct that particular exercise? Is
- 29:10it just a series of web searches or are there
- 29:13specific tools that you use to look into the
- 29:17finances? I know you mentioned a few in the talk.
- 29:22Yeah, so this was essentially going through the
- 29:25accounts that were available. So that was Charity
- 29:29Commission and Companies House. So we just used
- 29:34what was available. As I said, we had limited
- 29:36capacity. So it was a lot of working with spreadsheets
- 29:39and tracking the expenditure over five years,
- 29:43as well as like, you know, increasing percentage.
- 29:46So it was really with publicly available information
- 29:49that you find on Charity. Commission website
- 29:52and Companies House website. We've spoken before
- 29:56in a stage talk about the nightmare that is Companies
- 30:00House in terms of finding information on there
- 30:02and how there's differing reporting on there
- 30:06and all sorts of things. If anybody fancies taking
- 30:09some time out to build a fantastic tool to use
- 30:14Companies House better for open source researchers,
- 30:17I'm sure that would be very well received. Bellingcat
- 30:21actually a couple of years ago built a tool for
- 30:26looking into US corporate data, which is also
- 30:30difficult to navigate. And I've just posted a
- 30:33link to that in the chat. So many more questions
- 30:38coming your way. Can I just add something on
- 30:42this? So as I said, we looked at 32 out of 65.
- 30:49three quarters of those mapped were registered
- 30:53charities or companies. So a lot of them are
- 30:56micro companies. So they're either completely
- 30:59exempt from accounts or they just have to file
- 31:02micro accounts. But I think it's interesting
- 31:06that you don't need that much money to be very,
- 31:09very influential. I'll give you an example. There
- 31:13is a registered company called The Lesbian Project,
- 31:17and this is to anti -trans. yeah, lesbian activists
- 31:21and they, you know, yeah, they don't appear to
- 31:25have a lot of money, but of course they have
- 31:27their own podcasts, you know, their own columns,
- 31:30et cetera. But they intervene also in the Supreme
- 31:34Court case, which is a very, very, you know,
- 31:38is a very big piece of influence that you can
- 31:40exercise. So sometimes, yeah, sometimes it's
- 31:44like particular individuals have a lot of influence,
- 31:48whether they have gained that recently or they
- 31:51have it because previously they were already
- 31:53journalists or lawyers. So I think the money
- 31:57is a really, really important aspect of it, but
- 32:00there is also the wider ecosystem of social media.
- 32:05For example, a lot of these individuals go on
- 32:08GB News, which as far as I understand, these
- 32:10are paid appearances. Again, money might not
- 32:15be that much, but it might be enough to be very,
- 32:19very influential. That's a really important point.
- 32:22Thank you for adding that. In terms of funding,
- 32:25as we're talking about it, Das Wickermann asked
- 32:27earlier, are there similarities between the overall
- 32:30structure of funding for these organizations,
- 32:32especially at the grassroots level, and far -right
- 32:35extremist groups? Has your organization ever
- 32:38looked into the comparisons there? We haven't
- 32:42looked into that. There is an organization in
- 32:45the UK called the Hope Not Hate and they track
- 32:49the far right. That's their main job. They have
- 32:57observed over the past few years that transphobia
- 33:01has become like a top talking point for the far
- 33:04right as well. And in their, they keep like Yeah,
- 33:10just like an index of individuals that they observe.
- 33:13And one of them is this campaigner called Posey
- 33:17Parker. That's not her real name, but that's
- 33:19how she's known. And she's a gender critical
- 33:23anti -rights activist who has been kind of like
- 33:26hanging out with what we would call sub -right
- 33:29more than the other ones who are more of like
- 33:33a sort of respectable kind of, yeah, veneer,
- 33:37I would say. But in terms of the funding, I wouldn't
- 33:41be able to say, but I recommend that you check
- 33:44out Hope Not Hate. Thanks for sharing that. Moonlight
- 33:49earlier asked, has Amway appeared anywhere when
- 33:53following the money? And also have any neurodivergent
- 33:56related E .G. autism or ADHD ableist organizations
- 34:00also appeared in your research? I think this
- 34:02is a question about the crossovers basically.
- 34:06Sorry, what was the first thing you mentioned?
- 34:09Amway. A -M -W -A -Y. Amway. And if you've not
- 34:14heard of them, then I'm guessing they haven't
- 34:16come across in your research. Okay. No, I haven't
- 34:19heard of them. In terms of, yeah, I mean, there
- 34:26are crossovers. It's a complex one because a
- 34:33lot of the anti -abortion organisations, one
- 34:35of their points is that basically abortion is
- 34:40detrimental to the rights of people with disabilities.
- 34:44This is absolutely not the case and has been
- 34:47said repeatedly by all human rights bodies. So
- 34:50I think in that sense, there is an instrumentalization
- 34:53of people with disabilities. But again, I think
- 34:58that one of the points here that is like an interesting
- 35:02angle to look at this from is the sort of economic
- 35:07policies that not necessarily these people that
- 35:11I've tracked, but others in this ecosystem promote,
- 35:15which are essentially small state. And small
- 35:19spending, of course, this is very detrimental
- 35:21to people, to disabled people. So, yeah, I wouldn't
- 35:28say that I found that more than as I just explained,
- 35:33but it's really interesting. And I just saw in
- 35:35the chapter that what Anwui is, and I didn't
- 35:38know, so I had to keep an eye on that. Yes, just
- 35:42for listeners at home, it means it's a multi
- 35:45-level marketing company. I think it's called
- 35:47American Way. But yeah, it's a multi -level marketing
- 35:51company. It would be interesting to know kind
- 35:54of, as mentioned, the marketing strands that
- 35:58come out of maybe some of the investments that
- 36:00these organizations or these individuals are
- 36:02taking. We've got quite a few questions to get
- 36:05through those. So in the interest of time, I'd
- 36:08like to... Move on. Somebody asked earlier, I
- 36:12was wondering if you come across any evidence
- 36:14of British groups operating in Ireland and any
- 36:17other links between the same? We've spoken a
- 36:20lot about the crossover between America and the
- 36:23UK, but is there any crossover closer overseas
- 36:27between the UK and Ireland? Yeah, that's a really
- 36:31interesting question. So I assume you're talking
- 36:36Republic of Ireland rather than Northern Ireland.
- 36:40So this is not as recent as a few years ago,
- 36:44but some gender critical British campaigners
- 36:49tried to organise a tour in Ireland and there
- 36:52was a very strong and united response from the
- 36:56feminist movement there. that was basically saying,
- 37:01you know, set home and don't come here. And it
- 37:03was framed in, you know, from a decolonial perspective
- 37:07as well. So the, yeah, the Irish feminist movement
- 37:11is definitely trans inclusive, but in Northern
- 37:15Ireland as well is more trans inclusive than
- 37:17the rest of the country. Really Scotland is...
- 37:22Yeah, I'm in Scotland and England, but especially
- 37:24Scotland is where we've seen like a lot of the
- 37:27big legal cases happening, including the one
- 37:30that then led to the Supreme Court judgment that
- 37:33was brought initially by a group called Four
- 37:35Women Scotland. That's really interesting to
- 37:40note. Somebody said, it's a pretty horrendous
- 37:43situation and we currently sat in the back of
- 37:45the bus as we are being driven off a cliff. My
- 37:47question is how do we get on the front foot?
- 37:50When you're thinking about counter strategies,
- 37:54bearing in mind that we're both from non -partisan
- 37:57organisations, what are effective long -term
- 37:59strategies for human rights advocates to counteract
- 38:02coordinated anti -rights efforts without amplifying
- 38:06their messages? What would be your advice in
- 38:08terms of trying to counteract the steps that
- 38:12these movements are taking? Yeah, that's a million
- 38:17-dollar question, right? I think that in terms
- 38:23of strategic long -term picture, for me, the
- 38:27key one is intersectionality. We're still very
- 38:31much divided. The crossover between these issues
- 38:34and, as I said, the demonization of certain groups
- 38:37is plain to see. is still hard for organizations
- 38:43kind of working, let's say, with different constituencies
- 38:47to come together. So that is really, is really
- 38:50key. I discuss about this a lot, you know, with
- 38:54colleagues and other people, and this is perhaps
- 38:57not, it's a more operational thing to do. But
- 39:02it's kind of somebody talked about leveraging
- 39:05bureaucracy. So kind of burying them in paperwork
- 39:10and procedures and try to kind of like slow down
- 39:13how much, how effective they are. And I thought
- 39:17this was quite an interesting thing. They do
- 39:21the same, but definitely to try and keep them
- 39:25out of specific spaces that could be something
- 39:28to think about. And then I think continuing to
- 39:31do this work, monitoring, exposing. And also
- 39:35I think in terms of the messaging, we still do
- 39:39a lot of myth busting that doesn't work because
- 39:42we are repeating their framing and their messaging,
- 39:46just trying to basically explain why it's not
- 39:50evidence -based. We really need our own narrative
- 39:54and I don't think that we're doing as well as
- 39:57we can right now. And I think really from Amnesty's
- 40:02perspective, from a human rights perspective,
- 40:05just making sure that people understand that
- 40:08human rights are universal. So that means that
- 40:10if one set of rights, the right to health is
- 40:13taken away, then all your rights are jeopardized.
- 40:16And if the rights of a minority are taken away,
- 40:18then that has repercussions on everyone. So I
- 40:25think it's challenging because people see, they
- 40:28might not know a trans person in their life.
- 40:30They see this as a very politicized marginal
- 40:35issue to their lives. What many people don't
- 40:37even think about it. That's the point. This is
- 40:39like a whipped up moral panic. But yeah, just
- 40:45trying to educate people on like why this matters
- 40:49for us, for everyone, I think is also really
- 40:52important. And then keep being in dialogue. You
- 40:55know, I think also with COVID, we lost a lot
- 40:58of like in -person convening. And of course it's
- 41:01very convenient to have online convening, but
- 41:03I think having spaces to strategize and think
- 41:07together and like, you know, grow a relationship
- 41:09and strengthen the movement is also really, really
- 41:11important. That being said to the online community,
- 41:17but absolutely very, very important. It's interesting
- 41:20that you mentioned kind of the the difficulty
- 41:23with that kind of fact checking, um, you know,
- 41:27counter argument steps. So we actually had a
- 41:29talk on that last two weeks ago, um, by Elliot
- 41:32Higgins, spelling cat founder and Cornell University's
- 41:34Dr. Claire Wardle about the rise backlash and
- 41:38future of counter disinformation. If you missed
- 41:39that talk, you can listen back to it. It's all
- 41:42about kind of the decline in effectiveness of,
- 41:46of kind of verification methods and that kind
- 41:50of counter argument with facts and how that's
- 41:53kind of becoming harder and harder as kind of
- 41:56political views become more entrenched across
- 41:59social media. A lot of people in the comments
- 42:02have suggested on the question you just answered,
- 42:06perhaps targeting the money, particularly from
- 42:08overseas might be a way to do it. Somebody shared
- 42:12a telegraph link that was about ministers cracking
- 42:15down on foreign political donations. Is kind
- 42:18of cutting off their supply of cash a route to
- 42:21this? Is that why also that you decided to look
- 42:23into the financial structures here? Yeah, absolutely.
- 42:27And I think, again, the point I was trying to
- 42:29make is that these issues of gender are still
- 42:34seen as marginal, as niche issues, but they fit
- 42:39in a bigger picture of, you know, a lot of money
- 42:42in this case. Democracy for Sale has done a lot
- 42:46of work on this looking at the foreign influence
- 42:50on UK politics, including political parties.
- 42:56So I think that measures that might appear to
- 43:00be sort of like in broader terms or universal
- 43:04measures around reducing the influence and the
- 43:08amount of money that circulates in the system
- 43:10would also be beneficial for this. So that's
- 43:13why I'm saying we need to take an intersectional
- 43:15and universal approach and not be siloed or siloed
- 43:23ourselves. Sometimes I think unfortunately even
- 43:26in human rights movements and social justice
- 43:28movements, issues of gender and bodily autonomy
- 43:33are considered marginal, but really they are
- 43:36the canary in the coal mine. And you can see,
- 43:40you know, in every, well, in the US, of course,
- 43:42but in other contexts as well, where bodily autonomy
- 43:47protection has been weakened, that then leads
- 43:50to further weakening of protections. So definitely,
- 43:55I think, you know, It's also important to kind
- 43:58of like keep an eye on what's coming. I think
- 44:01often we are on the back foot because we don't
- 44:04necessarily understand what their strategies
- 44:07are. So for example, in the UK with the anti
- 44:11-trans gender critical movement, one thing that
- 44:15they've done really successfully is to go through
- 44:17employment tribunals. And this is not something
- 44:20that Amnesty normally would look at. But in this
- 44:23case, it will be looking at the money that goes
- 44:26into those cases and how those cases are kind
- 44:32of framed, how they are represented, how they
- 44:36are won. That's really, really important. So
- 44:39sometimes it's something maybe in your periphery,
- 44:42but trying to kind of... Yeah, think outside
- 44:46the box and have a look at what's happening that
- 44:48you might not expect. And of course, following
- 44:50the money in that is really important as well.
- 44:54How much control do we have over our own kind
- 44:58of political stances? Bone Blue Mast, some nations
- 45:03require its military members to complete training
- 45:05that is exclusively delivered in the UK, whose
- 45:07facility policies may restrict transgender personnel's
- 45:11equal access. Is anyone actively examining this
- 45:14issue? Have you, on that single point, are you
- 45:17aware of anybody looking into transgender representation
- 45:20in the military and cross -border policies on
- 45:24that? And also how much control do we have over
- 45:28making sure that our laws and our policies are
- 45:33followed within our country if the people influencing
- 45:37them are from different cross -border organisations?
- 45:44Yeah, on this first point, I'm not aware of anything
- 45:50related to this in terms of an issue that the
- 45:54anti -trans movement has taken up. I haven't
- 45:58heard about this so far. In terms of the influence,
- 46:07we do have influence in the UK, you know, MPs
- 46:12are listening to their constituents. So critical
- 46:16mass when it comes to lobbying your own MP is
- 46:19really important. But I also think it's about,
- 46:23you know, resistance and kind of strengthening
- 46:26the fabric of our communities. It's quite interesting
- 46:30that, you know, for example, on trans rights
- 46:32issues, the UK Parliament, Westminster has not
- 46:36voted on anything, you know, over the past seven
- 46:41years. But the erosion of rights has happened
- 46:45and trans people have become this political football.
- 46:49So sometimes it's not in parliament that we have
- 46:52to look, it's a community level, it's in our
- 46:56workplaces where we need to have inclusion and
- 46:59equality and respect. It's in our schools. The
- 47:05anti -rights movement is really good at going
- 47:07through these sort of like side and less kind
- 47:10of maybe observed or monitored routes. So I think
- 47:15that now putting all our influence on MPs is
- 47:19really important. And I think here there is like
- 47:25US tactics are coming in. For example, trying
- 47:28to influence schools boards and school governance
- 47:30has been something that we've seen. We amnesty
- 47:34also has a big human rights education program,
- 47:38we work with teachers and we have seen over the
- 47:41past few years increase, not everywhere of course,
- 47:47but noticeable increase of parents, parents kind
- 47:52of contesting relationship and sex education,
- 47:55contesting LGBTI inclusion in schools. So I think
- 48:01the micro level of what surrounds you is really,
- 48:06really important. And sometimes as campaigners
- 48:07who are very concentrated on parliament. But
- 48:12what is happening locally is really important
- 48:14because before it goes to parliament, a lot has
- 48:16happened already. So you need to start looking
- 48:20very close to you and to your sphere of influence.
- 48:24Absolutely. We often talk about the kind of the
- 48:26legal landscape really defining what happens.
- 48:30Yeah, it's a whole societal view that we need
- 48:33to have to understand the wider scope of the
- 48:36problem. Sonny asked, first of all, I want to
- 48:39thank you for your work, Kiara. Here's my question.
- 48:42Since this US -UK network is also very openly
- 48:45influencing EU far -right groups, I wanted to
- 48:48ask you if in your opinion, the EU is better
- 48:51prepared to deal with this on an institutional
- 48:54level. Thank you so much. Any thoughts on that?
- 49:03That's a good question. I don't know if the rules
- 49:08are stronger. I think the situation is different
- 49:15in the European Parliament because you already
- 49:17have far -right parties represented. I wouldn't
- 49:21say that there is something that is so different
- 49:25in the EU that it kind of insulates them more
- 49:29than in the UK. But just to give you an example,
- 49:34this is last week, the Parliamentary Committee
- 49:38of the Council of Europe was voting on a resolution
- 49:43around the conversion therapy and Sex Matters
- 49:48basically emailed, I mean, like, have you seen
- 49:52their newsletter? So they even support us to
- 49:55say, we're opposing these and we're working with
- 49:58this sister organization in the EU. Please contact
- 50:01your MP, your representative. So there is collaboration
- 50:06and that's why I think there should be also more
- 50:09collaboration between MPs and NEPs and politicians
- 50:12in different countries because it is really happening
- 50:17across the board. Of course, it's very context
- 50:19specific, but it's also global. So I think it's
- 50:25about relationship. I wouldn't know exactly that
- 50:28there is something that insulates the EU more
- 50:30than the UK parliament, for example. Final few
- 50:36questions as we're marking the 10 minutes to
- 50:40go mark. How would you characterize public awareness
- 50:45of this anti -rights movement? in general aware
- 50:49of the fact that there is this kind of overreaching
- 50:53movement called the anti -rights movement? Is
- 50:57that broad understanding or is it still kind
- 50:59of a niche concept when you've looked at reception,
- 51:02for example, for your report or any campaigning
- 51:06that you've done? Yeah, I would say it's still
- 51:11quite niche, like one of the main goals with
- 51:15the report was raising public awareness. So if
- 51:17you go to the page, you will see that at the
- 51:20top, we have done this video for social media
- 51:25with Deborah Francis White, who is a comedian
- 51:27and a podcaster, feminist podcaster. And the
- 51:31whole story behind it was, you know, they're
- 51:34trying to take us back to the 50s, as she stresses,
- 51:36like 1950s housewives, they're trying to take
- 51:39away our right to contraception, the fact that,
- 51:43you know, women are protected from domestic violence,
- 51:46et cetera. And when we shared these, we found
- 51:50that the narrative of the U .S. is trying to
- 51:55influence us and is trying to, you know, take
- 51:57us back and remove our rights really resonated.
- 52:00So I think people still think that the people
- 52:04who are aware, which I would say is a minority,
- 52:08but the understanding that people have is really
- 52:14the US is coming here and they're trying to influence.
- 52:16Of course, bans on abortions and the erosion
- 52:20of LGBT rights are much more stark in the US
- 52:24and also the US is so... ever -present in our
- 52:28media and political discourse. So I think that
- 52:32narrative really resonated. One of the things
- 52:34that I try to do when I'm asked to speak about
- 52:38this work with the media is to say that we really
- 52:42need to be aware that this is also UK domestic.
- 52:46We are deluding ourselves if we just think this
- 52:49is a US influence. Of course, the US influence
- 52:51is there and it's huge. It's money and organization
- 52:54registered in the UK. But there is an ecosystem
- 52:58that is, you know, was already there. So I think
- 53:01that, yeah, it's interesting because the US narrative
- 53:05can be used to raise awareness, but at the same
- 53:08time, you want people to understand that this
- 53:10is not just something that is happening, is coming
- 53:13from the US, and this is not something that is
- 53:15new. So, yeah, so I think that there is still
- 53:21work to do. But I think, you know, putting information
- 53:24out there is really important I've seen the graphs
- 53:30and our social media being shared. They were
- 53:33some of the best performing we had last year.
- 53:36And I think it's because people really want evidence.
- 53:39They have this feeling that, you know, this is
- 53:41happening and our rights are being reduced, etc.
- 53:46It's true. We have this feeling, but really it's
- 53:49true. And this is the evidence. So I think that
- 53:51is a powerful tool for people to have, even when
- 53:54they have conversations with their families or
- 53:57colleagues, et cetera. Maybe linking to that
- 54:02point then, you're speaking to a room of researchers
- 54:05and journalists. What would be the key gaps in
- 54:11research that you think should be focused on?
- 54:14Where would you put? the people in this audience's
- 54:17eyes, for example, over the next five years.
- 54:21What are the danger zones that we're under reporting?
- 54:24What should we be looking at? Yeah, thank you
- 54:28for this question. So one of the things I wanted
- 54:30to flag is crisis pregnancy centers. So these
- 54:35are across the country. There's been a BBC Panorama
- 54:39episode in 2023 where the journalists went undercover.
- 54:45to expose the centers. But since then, I haven't
- 54:48seen anything. And according to our analysis,
- 54:51their expenditure has been growing substantially.
- 54:54So they have more funds. So definitely, please
- 54:58look into that. There's also other research done
- 55:04that I really recommend that people have a look
- 55:06at, done by the European Parliamentary Forum
- 55:12on Section Reproductive Rights. And they've been
- 55:14tracking these movements more in Europe rather
- 55:18than the UK for a while. And one of the interesting
- 55:21things they highlighted in their latest report
- 55:25was that in addition to strategic litigation
- 55:28and lobbying, which are kind of like the long
- 55:31-term strategies that these groups have, the
- 55:35provision of services has increased. So what
- 55:38they call anti -gender services. So for example,
- 55:40crisis pregnancy centers as others are. you know,
- 55:44for example, well, yeah, like third party organizations
- 55:48that are going to school to explain, to promote
- 55:53abstinence education rather than, you know, fact
- 55:55-based sex education. So I think that, yeah,
- 55:59that is an interesting thing to look at. Some
- 56:01of these are charities. So we found evidence
- 56:04that they got some money from National Lottery.
- 56:06and from the government, especially from a COVID
- 56:10fund that was supposed to help organizations
- 56:12kind of keep the doors open during the pandemic.
- 56:16There are small amounts of money, but they shouldn't
- 56:20be able to get money. And also we have seen one
- 56:25of them being contracted by a women's prison.
- 56:30to provide the services there. So this is also
- 56:33really concerning. So yeah, definitely look into
- 56:37that. I think if anyone is able to track the
- 56:40money on an ongoing basis, also look at income.
- 56:45That is also always really important. And I think
- 56:49now that, let's say big, big in the sense of
- 56:54very influential, not in size. anti -trans charities
- 56:58are going to start having accounts. I think really
- 57:02looking into those is really, really critical.
- 57:04I'm just, you know, we're waiting. I think everyone
- 57:06is waiting to see this sex matters account. Amazing.
- 57:14Thank you so much for those tips. really important
- 57:18and really clear things to look into for the
- 57:21next few years. If you're interested in some
- 57:23of these topics within the Discord server, we
- 57:25do have spaces called anti -LGBTQ plus monitoring,
- 57:31which is looking at a lot of the anti -trans
- 57:34movements. We also have obviously a space dedicated
- 57:37to the EU and the UK as well where you can share
- 57:39news. And we have a space for far right monitoring
- 57:44and also disinformation and propaganda, which
- 57:48are slightly out of the remit of this talk, but
- 57:51may still be interesting to those who've attended
- 57:54it. Do check those spaces out. Oh, I also forgot.
- 57:59We also have a space that covers ableist monitoring
- 58:04as well, which I can't find at the minute, but
- 58:07I will link in the chat in a second. Thank you
- 58:11so much, Kiara, for your time today. We are coming
- 58:14to time, so I want to make sure that we finish
- 58:16on the hour. If people want to get in touch with
- 58:19you, perhaps they want to follow up on your research
- 58:22or have more questions that they didn't manage
- 58:25to ask today. What's the best way of getting
- 58:27in touch with you or your team? Yeah, thank you.
- 58:30I'm just going to pop my email in the chat. Please
- 58:33feel free to get in touch. There's also some
- 58:36information that I'm happy to share that is not
- 58:40on the website. So if there's anything you want
- 58:44to know, you have further questions, please get
- 58:46in touch. I just popped my email in the chat
- 58:49right now. Amazing. And for those listening back
- 58:51to the podcast, I'll make sure to include that
- 58:53as well. All right, thank you everybody who has
- 58:57joined today. We'll be back in two weeks time
- 59:00with another stage talk. But for now, thank you
- 59:02so much, Chiara, for your time and for your amazing
- 59:05research. Can't wait to dig into it a little
- 59:08bit more in my own time. And yeah, thank you
- 59:11everybody for joining. Thank you so much. It
- 59:14was a pleasure to be with you. Bye, everyone.
- 59:17Thank you for listening to the stage talk. If
- 59:20you'd like to catch a stage tour live where you
- 59:23can ask the guest questions, join the Bellingcat
- 59:26Discord server by visiting www .discord .gg slash
- 59:32Bellingcat. The music you've heard is titled
- 59:35Dawn by Newer Self and is courtesy of Artlist.