Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / What Keeps People Coming to Church: A Conversation with Pastor Gary Sandberg
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on the Together for Good podcast, I'm finally
- 0:04interviewing Pastor Gary after a long podcast hiatus and I wanted
- 0:09to ask him the question I've been asking everyone these days,
- 0:11which is why are you still here? Why are you still involved in
- 0:13church? He is a man of many stories.
- 0:16I'm looking forward to this. Here we go.
- 0:19Welcome to the Together for Good podcast, a podcast created by
- 0:22Bethany Lutheran Church in Cherry Hills Village, Co and
- 0:26hosted by me, Pastor Nate Pricinger and Together for Good.
- 0:30Our goal is to provide practical, engaging content that
- 0:33supports you without expectations.
- 0:36Whether you're feeling disconnected from traditional
- 0:38religion or simply exploring what faith means in your life,
- 0:42we are here to walk alongside you.
- 0:44No matter where you are on your journey of faith, we're glad
- 0:47you're here. Welcome to Together for good.
- 0:50Well, Pastor Gary, welcome. Long time no.
- 0:53See, he's faster, Nate. In fact, I can't remember the
- 0:56last time we were in studio or if we were in the car.
- 0:59Driving in the car, eating coffee, it has been far too
- 1:02long. I apologize.
- 1:04That's on me for not booking you sooner.
- 1:06But this is the perfect time to bring you in because as you
- 1:09know, we've been doing this whole series talking with people
- 1:12about why they chose to stay in church just because I feel like,
- 1:15I mean, in I'm guessing you see it the way I do too.
- 1:19I feel like we hear so much as pastors about people leaving the
- 1:22church, right? And there's so many books being
- 1:24written and so much research and articles and well, I mean, it's
- 1:29kind of depressing and and sort of annoying too, because I don't
- 1:32feel like that's our reality here at Bethany, right?
- 1:34In a lot of ways. How do, let's just start there?
- 1:37Like, how do you do? Do you notice that as well?
- 1:39Just this constant narrative that everyone's leaving.
- 1:42There are certainly is because people keep also talking about
- 1:45trend lines. And so some people are looking
- 1:47at a trend line and they even saying 2052 is the year that no
- 1:51one will go to church anymore because they, you know, they
- 1:53assume this trend won't have a breaking point.
- 1:56Yeah, that's not true about trends.
- 1:57All trends have a bottom and they have a cycle backup.
- 2:00Yeah, no kidding. So we're in a downward trend
- 2:02right now, no doubt about it. But not only do we hear it in
- 2:05church, but you know that I also.
- 2:07Well, we both have worked at seminaries and we've worked in
- 2:09admissions and I worked in mission support for the
- 2:12seminaries, and you get that same narrative too.
- 2:16And we know that it's been a difficult time for our
- 2:18theological schools, but that also just continues to create
- 2:24more and more around the narrative.
- 2:25Not only is no one coming to church, but no one's going to
- 2:27seminary. Congregations have people to
- 2:30serve them. It's a, it feels like a constant
- 2:33plot of a narrative that comes. And yeah, it's not our daily
- 2:38reality. No Rally of God is very, very
- 2:42real and relevant. Absolutely.
- 2:44And here's what I'm curious about.
- 2:45You knew I was going to get in a dig about your age at some point
- 2:48during this. Like you've been a pastor for a
- 2:50long time. Has this like occurred in other
- 2:55seasons of your ministry career where they've there's been this
- 2:58narrative like look at the trend lines, it's all dropping or is
- 3:01this sort of a newer phenomenon? I think this is newer today.
- 3:05I do think that some avenues that came along have increased
- 3:12the the sort of the trend line down.
- 3:15You know, we all know the forces of Sunday morning activities
- 3:19which were really offline at a certain point.
- 3:22And I always go way back, and I attribute it to the fact that at
- 3:27one point when I served in Minnesota, somebody realized
- 3:30that ice time for youth hockey was cheaper on Sunday mornings.
- 3:35And that started the whole whole expression.
- 3:38That's very, very simplified, but it's also very true.
- 3:41Yeah. But it's that it's the sense of
- 3:46what happened with the Internet. It's a little bit of just
- 3:49people's lives in general. Busyness has taken over.
- 3:53And I think the church was late in the game of commitment.
- 3:58The other places really had commitment.
- 4:00You had to commit paying money to play hockey.
- 4:04So you were there or soccer or now it's even with band and band
- 4:08camp and so many things like that.
- 4:10There were a lot of commitments that weren't usually made that
- 4:14now other outside forces have made.
- 4:17I mean, I, I played in band and high school.
- 4:19I don't remember having a fee. No.
- 4:22In the band, but me either. When you realized you had people
- 4:25pay a fee now, that created a certain commitment, and I think
- 4:29the church was a little late in that.
- 4:31Yeah, and thinking about it, I was talking with people about
- 4:34this just the other night, talking with some friends in
- 4:37that it seems like people want that commitment in different
- 4:43ways, that it gives their life meaning and purpose.
- 4:47You just like you. You hear about these parents who
- 4:49do all of this getting their kids to all sorts of different
- 4:53sports events and, and travelling all over the place.
- 4:57I was playing basketball on Friday morning and I overheard
- 5:00two people that I was playing with and they were talking like,
- 5:03hey, where were you last week? And the guy's like, I was in
- 5:04Chicago. Like, why are we in Chicago?
- 5:06It's like my son had a basketball tournament and the
- 5:09guy replaces like, don't they have basketball teams in
- 5:11Colorado? And the son's probably 8.
- 5:14Correct. Yeah, but there's just something
- 5:18about all this and, and I don't think folks even really
- 5:20necessarily question is like, oh, this is just what we have to
- 5:22do. This is just what it means to
- 5:25raise children in America right now as you get them involved in
- 5:29all of these travelling sports leagues and, and, and that does
- 5:32give your child purpose and direction, as does the families.
- 5:37Like, no, like this is what we do when we're going to Toledo
- 5:39this week because that's where the tournament is.
- 5:41Right. And I'm not even saying that's a
- 5:42bad thing, but it does affect, yeah, it affects the family.
- 5:46It does affect the church. It creates nuances that we
- 5:50either catch up to or or ignore, right.
- 5:54And ignoring them is not going to benefit the church in the
- 5:57long run. No, and it's I I like your point
- 5:59that the church hasn't really gotten on board with this idea
- 6:05of commitment right as quickly as a lot of the other avenues of
- 6:09life and areas of life. We could get rid of that whole
- 6:12grace thing, but that wouldn't change the narrative.
- 6:16We're always going to go with it.
- 6:18Yeah, I think that's part of the problem, not the problem.
- 6:22Like grace is the best thing that church has going for it.
- 6:25Exactly. And it, it sounds weird, how do
- 6:28you hold this intention? How do you talk about commitment
- 6:31and preach about grace at the same exact time?
- 6:34Right? Do you have an answer to that?
- 6:38I don't know if I have an answer to it, but I do think there is
- 6:43something about commitment that parents will catch on to.
- 6:48That a commitment to the church is going to put something in
- 6:50their kids lives that's different than anything else
- 6:52can. And that I think is really as
- 6:56much as it is a part of who we are, it also maybe is a part of
- 7:00our marketing. We do have to let people know
- 7:04that your kids will get something different.
- 7:06And the challenge is what they're getting is not a
- 7:10guarantee that they will have the perfect moral life, right?
- 7:14You know, And that, I think, was also a false pretense of the
- 7:18church. At some point, there was this
- 7:20guarantee that if your kid went to church, they would never
- 7:23experience any kind of moral lapse or anything difficult
- 7:28happening in their lives. Instead, we should have been
- 7:30telling people that when this inevitably happens, there will
- 7:35be a structure that they can ground themselves on.
- 7:38That's really good. I really appreciate that because
- 7:41I think that that's, yeah, that's a part it.
- 7:45It will inevitably happen, right?
- 7:47And because that is the Bible, these are the Bible stories.
- 7:50Right. That they're going to hear and
- 7:52be Yeah, even great King David had his lapses in judgement.
- 7:56Yeah, that's I think that that's really interesting.
- 7:59And it and yeah, the way to market what the church is trying
- 8:03to offer to people, right. Because what?
- 8:05But how do you think people, you know, this is kind of moving
- 8:09into the the direction of the conversation or I thought we
- 8:12were going. Why do you think people are
- 8:16moving away from church? Why are the trend lines going in
- 8:19that way? And is it related to the way
- 8:23that people think about church and the way that it gets
- 8:25marketed? I think those are the challenges
- 8:29that most churches are looking at because we still have out
- 8:32there this this notion that churches didn't keep up with
- 8:37society. Our our music lapsed and we
- 8:40didn't have the same music, our preaching lapsed.
- 8:43We weren't relevant to where people's lives were.
- 8:45And some of those might actually be true, but those certainly
- 8:48were real factors that happened. But I do think another part of
- 8:54it was that we took for granted as church leaders that people
- 9:00would understand what church means in their lives.
- 9:03Yeah, I, I think and, and what's so difficult about that is, is
- 9:07we know what it means for our lives.
- 9:09And the assumption was that everybody else would understand
- 9:14it, right, Without maybe taking time to ask people the really
- 9:20difficult questions about where are the challenges that you're
- 9:25facing? What does?
- 9:28And part of it is we're asking the question, what does church
- 9:31do for you? But maybe we really should just
- 9:34be asking the first question, where do you need God?
- 9:39Because we can also water it down to what kind of spiritual
- 9:44grounding do you want. I can open up to so many wide,
- 9:48wide, wide things. I do think there is a question,
- 9:50where do you need God in your life today?
- 9:53And then to find out, can the church actually remind you that
- 9:58God is there? In your experience is that, I
- 10:03mean, right? Could you're still here and part
- 10:06of church because in some way it did that for you?
- 10:09Oh, I think absolutely it did. Throughout my life, there was
- 10:14always a sense that, that there was a sense that God was present
- 10:20even when spirituality wasn't. Yeah.
- 10:24And so that was a part, though, of my upbringing.
- 10:27And again, as, as we know it, it's been part of our
- 10:30profession. And so it's it makes it easier
- 10:34not to be pulled away from it. But we both had experience in
- 10:38our lives where no one was forcing us to a Sunday worship
- 10:43service When I was connected to the seminary and then when I was
- 10:47connected to Capital University, there was Sunday mornings where
- 10:51there was no, I had no commitment to be at worship.
- 10:54I don't think in that 11 year period outside of traveling or
- 11:00you know, being away on vacation at a time or something like
- 11:02that. But on a typical Sunday morning,
- 11:04there's probably not more than a handful of them in 11 years
- 11:08where I still wasn't in worship because there was something
- 11:11there that I understood would create meaning for my life.
- 11:17And not just my job. Create meaning for my life.
- 11:20Yeah, so and and keep going on that because you, you, you said
- 11:25before that you saw it as like the presence of God being
- 11:30different than a spirituality. Did I get that phrasing more or
- 11:33less right? And in the same sense, I think a
- 11:35lot of people see going to church as a spiritual practice.
- 11:40So I'm curious just how you're compartmentalizing this in your
- 11:42head. That's.
- 11:43Interesting what you talked about in your podcast before
- 11:48about that presence of community, the singing, the
- 11:50breathing, all those things I think are really important.
- 11:52Those are such such dynamic ways to think about it.
- 11:56But there are times in my life where I haven't felt very
- 11:58spiritual. And, and so there's this sense
- 12:01that we have to find a spiritual sense.
- 12:04And even the church is sometimes caught up in that language that
- 12:07you don't really have to go to church.
- 12:09I, I find myself being spiritual in the mountains or whatever.
- 12:13And what I would say is I experience God differently in a
- 12:17church community than I do on my own.
- 12:20And so when I show up in a community, that's where I'd say
- 12:25I experience God's presence, even if I don't feel very
- 12:28spiritual. And so.
- 12:31Yeah, I get that. People might might find that a
- 12:34nuance or they don't know the difference in it.
- 12:37But there is something about inserting yourself in a
- 12:40community where I realized that sometimes, you know, in my world
- 12:46at leading worship or preaching, that there are times when I can
- 12:49bring a word of God to people even though they didn't want to
- 12:52hear it. And so sometimes I would show up
- 12:55at worship, I'd show up at a church because I knew that God
- 12:59would be present and it was important for me to be there.
- 13:03And even if it wasn't important for my own sake, I just assumed
- 13:06it was important for God's sake. And that was enough some days.
- 13:11And Mark Powell, Mark Allen Powell talks about this really
- 13:13well when he says that he goes to worship because God is worthy
- 13:18of worship. And if we start there, don't
- 13:22expect I'd, I don't go to church to expect to be spiritually
- 13:26filled. I go to a church to expect God
- 13:30to be worshipped. Yeah, well, and that's enough
- 13:32sometimes. I yeah, I'm glad you took that
- 13:34turn at the end too, because one of the things that I was
- 13:36wondering about, and I'm guessing you'd kind of give them
- 13:39this same answer, but like if you hear from someone who says I
- 13:42don't experience God in worship, right?
- 13:44Because that's what you were saying.
- 13:45Like I experienced God differently in worship than on
- 13:48the mountains. And I think that's a great
- 13:50point. And I love them both.
- 13:52Yeah, absolutely. I think there's there's need and
- 13:54call for both of those experiences.
- 13:56And you what I hear you saying, too, is that, yeah, like
- 14:00experiencing God and worship also might just be showing up
- 14:04and knowing that God is worthy of worship and that's why you're
- 14:06there. Right, right.
- 14:07And if I leave after a day saying music didn't speak to me,
- 14:12the preaching didn't speak to me, and I didn't pay much
- 14:15attention to the words of liturgy.
- 14:18But I do know God was worshipped and God is worthy of worship.
- 14:21That was enough. I've told this on the podcast
- 14:23before and I know I think I told it to you too, but it's it was
- 14:26my experience going to my home church when I was visiting my
- 14:30mom while she was on Hospice care.
- 14:33And yeah, I went, I just like, I just need to go to church this
- 14:36morning. And I went and I sat in the back
- 14:38and the music wasn't great and the preaching wasn't great.
- 14:41And it meant so much to me. And I can't even fully explain
- 14:44it, but I remember I came back and I told you and Deacon
- 14:47Endeavour that too. I'm like, maybe we don't need to
- 14:49try so hard. It is a good reminder for us as
- 14:55leaders to like and well, we put so much effort and
- 14:58intentionality into everything we do at Bethany, and I really
- 15:02am proud of that. And it's also nice.
- 15:04Just like, yeah, grace abounds, right?
- 15:05Like, God's. God's going to work with this
- 15:08even when there's a typo on the slides or in the bulletin or
- 15:13yeah, it didn't quite go the way we had planned it out in our
- 15:16meetings and in that. Case for you.
- 15:18That was a place of comfort and grounding.
- 15:21Yeah. And the.
- 15:23And I think there's really deep purpose to that.
- 15:26And so for people who've been a long time in a church community,
- 15:29they really feel that. And some people will feel that
- 15:32if they've been away and all of a sudden they end up at a
- 15:35Rockies game and like, wow, I used to go to baseball games a
- 15:37lot and they start going away. And now they show up at A, at a
- 15:41Rockies game and they just immerse themself in it and they
- 15:44feel like, oh, this feels so good to be back to a place that
- 15:48had importance to me. And I think that what we need to
- 15:53create somehow in a, in a church setting, a worship setting even,
- 15:59is how do you create something that feels like home for people
- 16:03who are new to it? And that I think is one of the
- 16:06challenges that we face is what drives or what will make people
- 16:14one come to worship if they hadn't really thought about it
- 16:18before. And when they're there, what
- 16:20will they experience that will let them say, wow, that felt
- 16:24like home even though I didn't know what home was?
- 16:27Yeah. And, and it's so interesting
- 16:30that I love the way you're you're framing this whole
- 16:33conversation because one of the beautiful gifts of the Lutheran
- 16:38Church is the liturgy, which is thousands of years old.
- 16:43And but my joke with the liturgy, you've heard me say
- 16:46this before, the only way you learn to love the liturgy is you
- 16:50do it for 30 years. Exactly like on its surface.
- 16:55And there's, I think there's a lot in worship that is deeply
- 16:58intentional and like biblically rooted.
- 17:01There's so much behind why we do what we do.
- 17:04But if you're new to it, you have no idea.
- 17:07And it's so ancient that it'll likely just go over your head
- 17:11and be like, this is weird. Like Gary, he's up there
- 17:14chanting and he's in a Snuggie. Remember Snuggies blankets with
- 17:20sleeves? Yeah.
- 17:22Like, I don't. I think that that's the real
- 17:25challenge for a liturgical church like ours is trying to
- 17:29figure out how can we make this like, because it is beautiful
- 17:33and it's it's such a gift. And it's not that we need to
- 17:35just throw it all out, right? But we also have to be honest
- 17:39and say, and this doesn't feel like home unless you've done it
- 17:43for 30 years. Exactly.
- 17:46Outside of the fact that sometimes you realize everybody
- 17:51around me is immersed in this. Yeah.
- 17:54So your first time at a professional baseball game, you
- 17:58may have no idea what Take Me Out to the ball game is or what
- 18:02a 7th inning stretch is. But all of a sudden you're
- 18:05standing and you're hearing the crowd sing and you're thinking
- 18:10something's happening here. That's good.
- 18:12Yeah, yeah, yeah. Has some kind of importance to
- 18:15it. And so the next time you go,
- 18:18that happens again because you might think that was a one off,
- 18:21you realize, and then you'll you'll say to somebody, does
- 18:23this happen at every ball game? You know, professional?
- 18:26Yeah, it doesn't happen at my church softball league games.
- 18:29We don't take a 7th any stretch there.
- 18:31Probably should. We might, but but you start
- 18:35realizing there's something here that's communal that people have
- 18:40immersed themselves in. So I also think that all we need
- 18:44to, not all we need to do, but something we can do as a way of
- 18:49creating importance is to let people know there are things
- 18:52about worship that might feel new to you, but look around
- 18:56because they have enough meaning that we keep doing that.
- 19:00And I think that is important, yeah.
- 19:03And there's I, I like that too. I think you're right that people
- 19:06will start to catch the vision for it.
- 19:07And, and I think in our in our world, that just is so
- 19:12fast-paced and you're just relentlessly bombarded with
- 19:17things to be worried about more so than generations ago.
- 19:21Oh, I think that's clear, yeah. We, we talked about that the
- 19:24other day too, just like they're, we are just so exposed
- 19:27to all the tragedy and terror of the world.
- 19:30And that's, it's, it's always been the case.
- 19:32Actually, this is one of the more peaceful times in human
- 19:35history, but we're just so much more aware of it because of the
- 19:3824 hour news cycle, because of our access to information from
- 19:42across the globe in an instant. And, and living in that world is
- 19:47just relentless and difficult. And so how can we invite people
- 19:52into what the what the church has to offer is to help them
- 19:56understand and see God and experience God even in the midst
- 19:59of tragedy, pain, suffering, and hopefully find a place of peace
- 20:05and hope. Like I, I think that's how would
- 20:07you describe it actually. I mean, I've named the problem
- 20:10here, but how would you say like what does church, what, what
- 20:12does church have to speak to that reality?
- 20:14What we really need is faithful proclamation.
- 20:18We need people to be able to stand up and say God is present.
- 20:22And unfortunately, we as people of the church sometimes don't
- 20:29take enough opportunity to say God is present, not God is
- 20:35responsible. And there are plenty of people
- 20:38out there who would like to say God is responsible and they'll
- 20:42use it to whatever advantage they want, whether it's social,
- 20:46political or personal or whatever it is.
- 20:50They can use the when I say they and you know, it's always a
- 20:53pejorative term, but that that some people will choose to speak
- 20:58for God in a way that I don't believe God would ever speak.
- 21:02Right. And so the church needs to talk
- 21:06about what does it mean for God to be present and not what does
- 21:09it mean for God to be responsible, especially when it
- 21:13comes to human tragedy. But we do hear it, you know, at
- 21:18at a certain time. It's oh, because that community
- 21:22accepted these people or they, you know, in today's world, you
- 21:26could say a community wouldn't allow the ice people in.
- 21:30And so now that that's going to be drug up when, when anything
- 21:33tragic happens in that town or that community welcomed these
- 21:36people in or didn't welcome these people in, that's such a
- 21:40misuse of where God is. And in some ways, I think this
- 21:47is relatively new to how how much airtime people get for
- 21:55those kinds of comments. I think people might have had
- 21:57those comments before, but nobody was putting them on the
- 21:59air. And now it's so easy to get
- 22:02airtime that as church people, and particularly as church
- 22:08leaders, we're catching up to what does that mean?
- 22:10How do we bring a message of God's love and grace in the
- 22:15midst of a world where just a few people can be the ones who
- 22:19dominate the air? By talking about God's judgement
- 22:23and God's wrath? Because it just just not the God
- 22:26we proclaim. Right, So what?
- 22:29And yet I think you what you're naming is a strong reason why so
- 22:33many people have chosen to move away from church.
- 22:36I think it is. Because they see the airtime all
- 22:39the time of yeah, like, oh, if that's what church means, if
- 22:42that's what Christianity is all about, like, I don't want any
- 22:44part in that. Right.
- 22:45I, I talk to people all the time who will say what God is doing
- 22:51and and they'll say, how can you worship a God like that?
- 22:55And my answer is I don't because I don't think that's what God is
- 23:00doing. Somebody has Co opted God's
- 23:03message in a way to serve them. I hope my my greatest desire is
- 23:10to proclaim a message that serves God as God is not in a
- 23:16way that I would want to mold God.
- 23:18So then what? What do you think, church?
- 23:22You've answered it a little bit, but I want you to get more
- 23:24specific of what? What does church need to look
- 23:27like in order to meet people in these types of spaces?
- 23:32Like you were talking about helping people see that God is
- 23:35present, not necessarily that God is responsible, but how do
- 23:40you. Yeah, how?
- 23:42How, given how much airtime and everything else that happens out
- 23:45there, how do you, how do we position ourselves as a church
- 23:48that that does that and shows itself in that way to people who
- 23:52are looking for hope and peace in a way to manage the chaos of
- 23:572025? And I think part of that is to
- 24:01remind ourselves of why people still are here.
- 24:04So that's why I love the conversation that you're having,
- 24:08is that the more that people can understand why people are still
- 24:13in communities, faith-based communities, I think that's
- 24:17really the strong point of it because they will realize that
- 24:22they are listening to and turning around and responding to
- 24:27a God that is not a God that is depicted negatively in the
- 24:31media. They're responding to a God that
- 24:34is creating something new in their own spirit.
- 24:39And I do think that's why people come.
- 24:42So part of that for us is to remind people of why people are
- 24:47here. It's it's more challenging to
- 24:50convince somebody who has no reason to be in church why they
- 24:53should be here. But I think part of what we
- 24:56promote is why people are here, because they're here for really
- 25:00good reasons. And they're not all, they're not
- 25:05all so filled with theological doctrinal principles.
- 25:11They just know that somehow in their life God is moving and
- 25:15making a difference. Yeah.
- 25:17And that really is the message of the church.
- 25:20It always has been. Yeah.
- 25:22I mean, it's as it's as old as Follow me with Jesus shares with
- 25:26his original disciples. They didn't know why, but they
- 25:28knew they were going to make a difference.
- 25:30I got to believe that. I think Peter, Andrew, James and
- 25:32John knew that when they choose and chose to follow Jesus that
- 25:37they were going to make a difference.
- 25:39Now, they actually knew what the next three years was going to
- 25:42bring. They might have said no, right?
- 25:44But part of that is just just coming along and seeing so.
- 25:51I, I like that too. I mean it, it's such a good way
- 25:53to frame what we try to do here is like, how can we, how can we
- 25:58create our programming in such a way that people can really see
- 26:03how it makes a difference, right?
- 26:05And I think, I think that's what everyone wants, that that's why
- 26:09you do anything is it makes a difference.
- 26:11You know, you send your kid to the the soccer clinic and it
- 26:14makes a difference. And now she's a better player.
- 26:17Right, yeah. And you hope that she got
- 26:19friends along the way and other things happened and some kind of
- 26:23discipline and they were able to feel good about them self.
- 26:27All famous things is what you want.
- 26:28And I think it comes back around to what we were kind of talking
- 26:30about earlier too, is that people come to church one time
- 26:35and they feel like it doesn't make a difference.
- 26:37They didn't experience God in this place or it didn't
- 26:40immediately fix, yeah, whatever what they were struggling with.
- 26:43So, so, So what do you say? Or or yeah, how how would you
- 26:46respond? I do this a lot with couples
- 26:49that I talked to is they're going to get married, OK?
- 26:51Because I've learned that when people get busy in that stage in
- 26:54their life, there's so many of them say I've fallen away from
- 26:57church and they're all embarrassed about it and all
- 26:59this. So I was telling the story that
- 27:02when one of my cars was coming to the end of its life cycle
- 27:05that I realized I was going to need to get a new car or get a
- 27:10newer car to me. And it was a used car.
- 27:12So I went to a dealership and I test drove a car and I realized
- 27:17when I got in, the seat wasn't all that comfortable and the
- 27:20buttons were kind of in the wrong places.
- 27:22You know how that like the wipers can be on the right or
- 27:24the left and where your lights were and where that little red
- 27:29triangle for your hazard was, you know, can you find that?
- 27:33And, and I drove that car and I got out of it and I went, it
- 27:36just wasn't very comfortable. And so I decided, you know what,
- 27:40I'm just going to walk everywhere.
- 27:42I'm not going to have a car after all.
- 27:43And they look at me like really? And I go, no, I went test drove
- 27:49another car and then I that's really good other one.
- 27:54And I was like, oh, it's like the steering wheel had the right
- 27:58feel to it and the buttons were in the right places and the seat
- 28:01adjusted in a way. And I got out of it and I went
- 28:04that was really comfortable. That's kind of like
- 28:07congregations is that you know what, try 1 and it wasn't
- 28:12comfortable. Decide that.
- 28:14Oh, well, I guess church isn't for me.
- 28:16You find one that fits because there is one out there that will
- 28:20fit. Yeah, and and not that it's all
- 28:22about being comfortable all the time, but you're right.
- 28:24Like you do walk into a place and you're like, this just
- 28:27doesn't this isn't me that right.
- 28:28Like this just doesn't fit. But yeah, but you don't then
- 28:32walk everywhere rather than buying a car.
- 28:34Yeah, that's a great analogy. That's a really great analogy.
- 28:37So with with all this too though, Gary, why do you think
- 28:41you ended up like, I know you grow up going to church and
- 28:45you're from a family that really prioritized all of this.
- 28:49What do you think it was about it that made it really click for
- 28:52you as something that you wanted to consistently keep as a part
- 28:55of your life? Obviously this is well before
- 28:58you went to seminary. Right, right.
- 28:59Right. Yeah.
- 29:00And so I've told this story quite often that, you know, I
- 29:03grew up in a family of four, one sister who at that time in the
- 29:08church couldn't be a pastor. So she kind of had the free
- 29:11past. But then of three boys, when you
- 29:13see him in church every Sunday, everybody kind of said one of
- 29:15them has to be a pastor. You know, that was just sort of
- 29:18the realm I lived in in those days.
- 29:21And and as I went along, there was just something about
- 29:25participating in church that to me was really formative to to
- 29:30serve as an acolyte to me. I felt like an instrumentally
- 29:35important role that I had in the church and then in my church, as
- 29:40you got a little bit older, then you could serve as crucifer, you
- 29:43could carry the cross in. And that to me was just a, that,
- 29:47that, that just felt like a milestone that was so important
- 29:51that somebody would deem me worthy of, of carrying in the
- 29:55cross and, and recessing with it.
- 29:59And so there were people along the way that said to me, Oh, you
- 30:02should think about being a pastor.
- 30:03You should think about being a pastor.
- 30:05And, you know, of course I was going to.
- 30:07I was in church a lot, and not just on Sundays, but, you know,
- 30:11volunteering and confirmation classes.
- 30:14And then I tell the story of one day when I served as Crucifer
- 30:16walked in with the cross. I walked out of it.
- 30:18And a lady in the congregation who'd been a good family friend
- 30:23and all that came up to me and said, every time you participate
- 30:27in worship, it makes me so happy.
- 30:30To me, that was like a flipping point for me about what it would
- 30:35mean to actually serve in the church.
- 30:36Wow. And so I tell people all the
- 30:38time, if you think somebody would be a good pastor, don't
- 30:40say to them you should think about being a pastor.
- 30:43Tell them how they make you feel.
- 30:44It was her saying every time you participate in worship that
- 30:48makes me so happy in my life. I thought, well, I kind of want
- 30:53to make people happy. I'm really committed to the
- 30:55church. Serving the church seems like a
- 30:58natural way for me to live out that what I really want deeply.
- 31:04And and what's funny is people go, oh, well, then you must have
- 31:07been, you know, such a natural speaker and all that.
- 31:09I was terrified to stand up in front of people.
- 31:11I never and that never entered into my head about what it would
- 31:14mean to be a pastor to be able to do that.
- 31:16But somehow that kind of worked out and I worked.
- 31:19Through that I just think it's funny that right if you this
- 31:23woman says like you when you when you do that, you make me so
- 31:26happy and as we well know, like being a pastor is hearing how
- 31:30upset you've made people all the.
- 31:33Time, right? Not all the time, but all the
- 31:36time. It's it's a big part of the job.
- 31:41So that was really my that was my coming.
- 31:44And then once I decided I was going to be a pastor, then other
- 31:48other parts of my life fell in place and I didn't feel like I
- 31:52had to be special or set apart in any way.
- 31:55But I wasn't try about letting people know that either.
- 31:58That that was what I plan to do with my life.
- 32:01And, you know, and I look back now and I think it's worked out
- 32:05well for me and my family and I hope the congregations I serve.
- 32:08Yeah, absolutely, absolutely. I mean, I think it, that's the
- 32:12thing about our work is that it is just, it's really rewarding
- 32:16and really unique and it's a really, I mean, you know, it's
- 32:23yeah, people complain. People complain in every job.
- 32:27Like it's such a good job. That's the thing that I keep
- 32:30coming back to when people ask me about like, what's it like?
- 32:31I'm like, it's so good. Like it's just such a, it's so
- 32:35unique and it's so different everyday and there's so many
- 32:39like facets to it that are just, I don't know, I, I don't know
- 32:43how you feel about it, like at this stage in your career, but
- 32:47that's where I'm at with it too. I'm like this.
- 32:49There's nothing like it in all the world and I wouldn't have it
- 32:53any other way. I don't come across many
- 32:56professions that have the same I don't even know how to not the
- 33:03same responsibilities and so forth to it.
- 33:06But maybe that is maybe it is in a way the same responsibility to
- 33:10it in that no matter what day you have, no matter the joys,
- 33:17the challenges, the responsibilities, is that it
- 33:22really comes back to that same idea of why would I go to church
- 33:26on a day I really don't feel like it.
- 33:28And the the answer is, is because God is present there.
- 33:32And so that is maybe one of the differences I do get to say
- 33:36about my job. No matter what happens when
- 33:38people are happy, when people are upset, when, when, when
- 33:42people are apathetic, no matter what, God is still present.
- 33:47So being able to be in a job where I get to be reminded of
- 33:50that daily, that is something that I think is unique and
- 33:55special. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 33:57Yeah. And it's and the diversity of
- 34:00ways that you're reminded. That God has present.
- 34:04Right, like, 'cause it's not just in worship.
- 34:06No, it's also Bible study. It's also premarital counseling.
- 34:10It's also funeral preparations. Yeah, there's so much to it.
- 34:16Yeah. And it's.
- 34:18Yeah, there's nothing like it. We both worked at seminaries.
- 34:21You should go to seminary. If you've been thinking about
- 34:25it. This is your sign.
- 34:26God is present. So, yeah, if you had to kind of
- 34:34you paint a really good picture of your experience growing up,
- 34:38why, if you had to like really summarize it in in something
- 34:41kind of succinct, a nice sound bite for us, Yeah.
- 34:44Why are you still here? Like what?
- 34:46Why is church still important to you?
- 34:48Yeah, I think the church is still important to me and this
- 34:52would come from more of a mainline perspective.
- 34:55So I think other the denominations or non
- 34:58denominational churches will have a different bent on this.
- 35:02But what's so important to me is that I walk into a worship space
- 35:07and there's an altar there. There is a place where God
- 35:11offers the very presence of God to me and to me.
- 35:16I will never, I don't think I'll ever get over how humble I feel.
- 35:23Whether I'm standing at the altar presiding, or whether I'm
- 35:26simply walking up and receiving the sacraments is that there is
- 35:32a place where I can always know that God chooses to do something
- 35:38for me. And I think that might be the
- 35:41most succinct way of saying, why am I still here?
- 35:45It's because God still desires to give me something freely and
- 35:53I can't imagine a life where I wouldn't want to be in a place
- 35:57to accept it. Yeah, yeah.
- 36:00Or where you'd want to miss out on that.
- 36:02Yeah, to not be participating in this freely given gift.
- 36:07Right. Week after week.
- 36:09And and it ties so well into kind of our earlier part of this
- 36:12conversation about like, you know, as the world, it just
- 36:16seems so overwhelming at the moment to receive that week
- 36:21after week, that reminder of God's freely given presence with
- 36:26us. Right.
- 36:27Yeah. I mean, I remember and a friend
- 36:30growing up who was talking about receiving communion and he said
- 36:34he's like, I every week after I receive it, I just take such a
- 36:38deep sigh because it's like, OK. And it's always stuck with me.
- 36:43And I feel like I've adopted it for myself in a lot of ways too.
- 36:45Just like, yeah, like something bigger than my current little
- 36:50problems just happened here. Right.
- 36:52Yeah. And and then the flip side of
- 36:55that is I've realized part of my own spirituality is centered
- 36:59around generosity. And so church is also the place
- 37:03where I can freely give. And I think that draws me closer
- 37:07to God. I think God provides an altar
- 37:11where the very essence of God, the presence of God, is freely
- 37:15handed over to me. And God provides a vehicle for
- 37:19me to freely hand over some of my resources to the the church
- 37:26or to any God pleasing ministry. And that that really is an
- 37:31opportunity that that I've never given an offering that has taken
- 37:37something from me. Every time I give an offering,
- 37:40it gives something to me. And so I think that really the
- 37:47Church is still one of those few places where you are given over
- 37:53and over and over again, You're giving grace, you're given the
- 37:56sacraments, you're given the opportunity to draw closer to
- 38:00God through generosity. The the Church is absolutely
- 38:03filled with places for you to become more of who you are.
- 38:07Yeah, and the fascinating thing is it's the only place where you
- 38:12don't have to pay a membership fee.
- 38:13No, no, right. Like.
- 38:16Exactly right. It it is more out of your own
- 38:19sense of like being moved by all that's happening that you
- 38:23respond with these gifts, but you think about literally
- 38:27anything else of all the things we've mentioned of the hockey,
- 38:29they have the ice, the ice, the ice fees, right the soccer
- 38:34clinics, any of these things you mentioned country clubs, all of
- 38:37it. There's always a membership fee.
- 38:38There's always a cost, there's always an expectation of like,
- 38:41hey, this is what it, this is what it will require of you to
- 38:44be a member of this space. And and yet all those places
- 38:51have way more involvement, I would guess, than churches.
- 38:55I don't, I mean. Interesting, right I?
- 38:58Don't know if that's true. It it's, yeah, it is really
- 39:00interesting of just like, what in the human psyche these days
- 39:05makes that more appealing or right?
- 39:07Like there's something interesting to explore within
- 39:09that. And I don't have a lot of
- 39:10answers. That's it maybe a matter for
- 39:11another podcast, but yeah, just that that we seem drawn to that
- 39:16when God is freely giving of God sell week after week.
- 39:21It's like, well, you know, and. Part of that is as human beings,
- 39:25we're so accustomed to thinking about what's the catch or what
- 39:33is really expecting of me and you and you talked about it
- 39:36recently in a podcast about the bombardment of advertising that.
- 39:40Takes us. And it, it constantly tells us
- 39:44that we're not enough, right? And so then, you know, I have
- 39:483000 messages in a given week that tell me I need something to
- 39:53be enough. And then I got one that told me
- 39:56that God loves me unconditionally.
- 39:58Yeah, that's a hard. That's a hard message to
- 40:04breakthrough the other 3000. And, and not every church is
- 40:11giving that message. That's true too.
- 40:13A lot of churches, that is a place you go to hear again that
- 40:16you're not enough. Yeah, it just in different ways.
- 40:19Exactly. Yeah, that's true.
- 40:21Yeah. And it's hard.
- 40:22That's hard for people of grace to understand that that's the
- 40:27essence of God to hear. God.
- 40:31Spoken in terms of if you stay here long enough, if you're here
- 40:36that that this congregation or this community can fix you and
- 40:40make you worthy in God's sight, right?
- 40:42Rather than I come because I already know I'm worthy in God's
- 40:47sight, and therefore I want to be where that message is
- 40:51proclaimed, right? Yeah.
- 40:53Right. And why amidst this flood of
- 40:57negative advertising, you're not enough?
- 41:00Why wouldn't you want to at least, like, have an hour a week
- 41:03where you can hear something different?
- 41:05Like, that's my sense of this, to tie it all together too.
- 41:10Well, Hey, anything more you want to say to our listeners?
- 41:12Because it might be another three years before I get you
- 41:14back on. Maybe.
- 41:16This is that there are people who go to church because they
- 41:20need the answers and, and, and sometimes they don't even care
- 41:23how simple or how profound the answer is, they just want an
- 41:27answer. Bethany's probably not a great
- 41:30place for that, but if you come with questions, we absolutely
- 41:35will deal with those, right? So that's another part of, you
- 41:38know, deciding what kind of car you want to sit in.
- 41:41You know, some people want to sit in a car that has a lot of
- 41:45gadgets that do a lot of the work for them.
- 41:47And a lot of people want to do the work themselves and they
- 41:49don't want to feel like. They want manual.
- 41:51Transmission. That's right.
- 41:53Yeah, I went for several cars or manual transition.
- 41:55I loved it. But that there are places that
- 41:59will give you the answers if that's what you need.
- 42:02And there are places where your questions will be so warmly
- 42:07accepted. And you won't be given
- 42:10necessarily answers to your questions, but you'll be given
- 42:14an opportunity to explore your questions.
- 42:18And to me, exploration is far more life giving than asking a
- 42:23question, getting an answer and moving on.
- 42:25So I, I think also what continues to keep me coming back
- 42:30and keep me interested is that I still have questions and there
- 42:34are people who are going to be thoughtful about my questions
- 42:38even though they don't want to answer them, but they want to
- 42:42still engage them. I would.
- 42:45I really hope that what we can do as a church like Bethany is
- 42:49engage people's questions and then if answers come, an answer
- 42:55that comes through engagement is so much better than me just
- 42:57giving them an answer. Like yeah, exactly.
- 42:59Like the the journey is more important than the destination a
- 43:02lot of the times. That can definitely be the case.
- 43:04And we all learn so much more along the way through the
- 43:08engaging, the sharing of questions than if it's just
- 43:10like, not like, hey, stop asking that this is this is the way it
- 43:15is. Right, right.
- 43:17Yeah. And the more of that that we can
- 43:18do and I I think we do a good job of trying to createspace for
- 43:22that in a variety of settings. And, and one thing we know is
- 43:25that people who left the church left because they didn't have
- 43:30engagement, right. And you know, part of that is.
- 43:34And participation like your, your story about how how
- 43:36formative the participation piece was for you, I think is
- 43:39really instructive. Uh huh.
- 43:42It's just like the you get out of it what you put into it.
- 43:45Right. Yeah, church is not a passive
- 43:46activity. Yeah, it's it's not.
- 43:49And letting people know that and engage in it, I do think is an
- 43:54important part of what we continue to do.
- 43:56So that really does continue to bring me back, you know, just
- 44:01say, why do you still go? Why after all these years, do
- 44:03you still go? Because it's still engaging.
- 44:06Yeah. That might be the very, very
- 44:08simple answer, but but it is what brings you, yeah.
- 44:15Yeah, there's always more to do, more to engage with.
- 44:18Well, Pastor, thanks. We should do this again much
- 44:23sooner than than the long hiatus.
- 44:26It was not intentional. I apologize.
- 44:28I apologize to the listeners. He's really good.
- 44:30We should get him on more often. Thanks for being here, being a
- 44:33part of this, as always. And thank you, dear listeners,
- 44:36for listening. Stay in peace every.
- 44:38Thank you for listening to the Together for Good podcast.
- 44:41If you'd like more resources for your walk of faith, please visit
- 44:44our website bethany-denver.org or download our mobile app by
- 44:49searching Bethany Connect in your phone's App Store.