Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / One Night of Love (1934)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. Today we're covering One
- 0:23Night of Love, but it took you two tries to say
- 0:25it. Yeah, well, third time is the charm. So let's
- 0:29take it again. We're talking about One Night
- 0:31of Love, and how do you feel about opera? So,
- 0:35I'm... Art, right? I try to be like, man, I support
- 0:41the arts and all of this. You did the absolute
- 0:44cinema pose, but said art. Art. I try to be very
- 0:49supportive of just like all forms of art and
- 0:52that's it, just art. Opera I struggle with a
- 0:56little bit. I think I can appreciate the skill.
- 0:59behind it but i think it's one of those things
- 1:01where maybe if i'm in person and i'm sitting
- 1:03in the audience i can really kind of lock in
- 1:05and be like okay here's the the set the costumes
- 1:08the the performers and everything but as a whole
- 1:11i would say you know it's not really my bag what
- 1:14about you uh i like fraser i don't even know
- 1:17what that means fraser is a fan of the opera
- 1:20um okay i uh It's tough, because I don't want
- 1:25to do the Timothee Chalamet ballet is stupid
- 1:28thing. No, yeah, yeah, yeah. Which I don't think
- 1:30is his... I'm paraphrasing. I don't think that's
- 1:31what he said. That's close. But I never really
- 1:35understood it. I mean, I get it. I understand
- 1:37what the intention is, but in terms of enjoying
- 1:41it and going to the opera and seeing this, over
- 1:45time... Taylor and I have this running joke about
- 1:47like going to the Grand Canyon and you stand
- 1:50on the edge of the Grand Canyon. You're looking
- 1:51down and around and you're there for 30 seconds
- 1:54and you're like, is this it? Is this just all
- 1:58we're supposed to do? And that's kind of the
- 1:59opera to me where it's like, oh, this is what
- 2:02this is. You know, I think something that I forget
- 2:06and I'm going to assume that a lot of people
- 2:08forget is that opera is kind of like a cultural.
- 2:11Art form. Sure. In the same way, I watched that
- 2:14movie last year, Kohoku, I think it was Kohoku.
- 2:18I can't remember. Oh, yeah. What about the Kabuki
- 2:20theater? Yes. And I guess it's kind of similar
- 2:23to that where it is like this culture has their
- 2:26own performance style art. And while it, you
- 2:30know, Kabuki theater isn't my thing either. I
- 2:33don't think there's anything wrong with saying
- 2:34it's not really my thing. But for that culture
- 2:37and for the people that are very invested in
- 2:39that, I mean. Some of the most talented singers
- 2:42come from opera. Do you think that there's, like,
- 2:45new operas being made, like, today? There must
- 2:47be. There must be. And not just, like, not a
- 2:50rehash, but, like, you know, they're doing another
- 2:52edition or run of a previous opera. No, I'm sure
- 2:56they're coming out with new operas. There's gotta
- 2:58be. Somebody out there is writing stuff. You
- 3:01know, and it's people whose, unfortunately, names
- 3:04I'll probably never know. Sure. Just because
- 3:06I'm so far out of that wheelhouse. And they would
- 3:08look at... me and you and what we're doing here
- 3:11and be like yeah well and that's i i unfortunately
- 3:14i think that's what um an idea of well i think
- 3:18it'd be even worse and they'd be like who right
- 3:20i think that there is uh There's certainly a
- 3:24talent for it. It's not like a talentless production.
- 3:27There's a lot of talent that goes into it. I
- 3:29think it's just something that doesn't grab me
- 3:31specifically. And I think that for people overall,
- 3:34they would kind of look at opera as like, oh
- 3:37yeah, it's just so not my bag. I can't do it.
- 3:39I don't think opera by any means is like a pop
- 3:41culture art form. Sure. It's very niche. Yeah,
- 3:45that's kind of the... Love a phantom. I was going
- 3:48to say, big fan of its phantoms, but that's about
- 3:50all I really know. Well, and the reason we talk
- 3:53so much about it is not only is that the topic
- 3:55of the film today for One Night of Love, but
- 3:58also it's a big entry point for Grace Moore.
- 4:01Grace Moore, who is the lead in One Night of
- 4:04Love, was prior to this first known as an opera
- 4:07singer, a very renowned opera singer. So it makes
- 4:11sense, you know, that this is going to be a very
- 4:13popular topic for today. So let's hop right in.
- 4:19We'll talk about the nominations for One Night
- 4:20of Love. We have Film Editing, which was for
- 4:23Gene Milford. Sound Recording. which was John
- 4:27P. Lividary. And that was recorded at Columbia
- 4:30Studio. I'm not sure how much that factored into
- 4:33it, but I mean, John definitely ran that. Music
- 4:35scoring, popular one we'll talk about here. That
- 4:38was Louis Silvers. Director, that was for Victor
- 4:41Scherzinger. Actress in a leading role, Grace
- 4:44Moore, as I mentioned. An outstanding production
- 4:47on behalf of Columbia Pictures. Yeah, which is
- 4:50cool. We talked about Columbia Pictures being
- 4:52like poverty road pictures. This is their second
- 4:54best picture nominee from this year. So of all
- 4:57of the Poverty Row studios, this is the one that's
- 5:00really like bringing in heavy hitters. Yeah.
- 5:03And this was no different. You know, we talked
- 5:05a lot about Frank Capra and how much he helped
- 5:07Columbia Pictures, but this one was very popular
- 5:09as well. I mean, opera was something that was
- 5:11thriving at the time. So having a famous opera
- 5:14singer in Mary, sorry, Grace Moore. Yeah. Having
- 5:18an opera singer as famous as Grace Moore lead
- 5:20this film did a lot for Columbia Pictures and
- 5:23it did do very well in the box office. Yeah.
- 5:25And it's, It's really interesting and cool to
- 5:28me that, like, they got an actual opera singer.
- 5:32Yeah. Because I feel like if they do a movie
- 5:33like this today, they just get, I don't know,
- 5:36Emma Watson, throw her on the screen, and then,
- 5:38you know, add some other opera singer doing the
- 5:41work. That's true. I mean, or have, you know,
- 5:44have an actress who can perform the role, and
- 5:48then when it comes time to sing, dub or something.
- 5:50But back then, as we know, dubbing, really not
- 5:53that possible. Right, because they would film
- 5:55different versions of the movie in different
- 5:57languages. Unless they're doing Wallace Beery
- 5:59playing the guitar. Wow, maybe at this point
- 6:03it was then. Maybe it was. So you ran through
- 6:06a couple of these names going into this, but
- 6:08the film was directed by Victor Schertzinger.
- 6:11Grace Moore starred as Mary Barrett, the opera
- 6:13singer. Tulio Carminati played Julio Monteverde.
- 6:17And Lyle Talbot played Bill. He's got a last
- 6:21name, but I can't remember. We have some questions
- 6:23about his last name, because I can't believe...
- 6:25At one point, I heard Mr. Riley is here to see
- 6:28you, and I just can't believe that he's Bill
- 6:29Riley, but we'll see. Yeah, I don't know what
- 6:31happened there. And then Mona Barry as Lally.
- 6:33That's right. Also have this written by S .K.
- 6:36Lauren, James Gow, and Edmund H. North. Interesting
- 6:40thing about this, this was... based on an unpublished
- 6:43and unproduced play called Don't Fall in Love.
- 6:46That was written by Dorothy Spear and Charles
- 6:48Bien. Let's dive into the synopsis here from
- 6:52One Night of Love. Mary is an opera singer, and
- 6:55she is doing well enough at home. But she decides
- 6:58that she wants to really go off and make it big
- 7:00in Italy. She is excited to go do this. And there
- 7:03is a scene, don't know if you felt this way,
- 7:06it felt very Beauty and the Beast of Belle, like
- 7:09just kind of singing. at her townspeople, and
- 7:12everyone was like, yeah, let's get it, girl.
- 7:14There goes the baker with his tray like always.
- 7:17Yeah, it was a whole scene like that. Very funny.
- 7:20Very good, but very funny. She lives in a little
- 7:24town where there's a bunch of singers. Quiet
- 7:26village. A quiet village with a lot of musicians
- 7:30and singers, and she, of course, starts singing
- 7:33over them playing, and they all play together.
- 7:35And this is where she starts getting a little
- 7:37noticed, and she starts working. with a famed
- 7:41compote note tutor. Yeah, I think he's like an
- 7:46instructor, a teacher or something of the art
- 7:49of opera singing. Right. And this would be Julio
- 7:51Monteverde. And it's clear he's very strict and
- 7:55he is very adamant about what it takes to survive
- 7:58in the world of opera. And this little tense
- 8:02back and forth between them. Bud's a little bit
- 8:05of a romance. It does. And the majority of the
- 8:07movie is them navigating this professional relationship
- 8:09while also navigating their personal feelings.
- 8:12Yep. And a majority of this movie consisted of
- 8:14me going, really, Mary? In terms of her interest
- 8:18in Julio? Yes. 100%. Yeah. Yeah. There's a lot
- 8:21of like, you know, I didn't pair this with this
- 8:23movie. I probably should have. There's a little
- 8:25bit of a baby girl in this movie. Oh, interesting.
- 8:29Of like Julio Carminati, sorry, Julio Carminati.
- 8:34Oops, missed some names. Julio Monteverde, mixed
- 8:37up the actor and the character here. Monteverde
- 8:40is very strict about what she can and can't do.
- 8:44Yeah. And this goes in and out of their training
- 8:47when she's singing, right? Like when she's eating
- 8:50meals, there's a lot of like, nope, she'll have
- 8:53this. She's going to eat this without running
- 8:55it by her. Yeah. To me, we'll go ahead and lay
- 8:59our cards on the table. I couldn't get into this
- 9:02because the romance aspect of this movie, to
- 9:05me, is based on him domineering her. And this
- 9:09isn't like, we've talked about something previously
- 9:11where there's like flirtation walk, where there's
- 9:14clearly some like, or no, I'm sorry, not flirtation
- 9:16walk. It happened one night where clearly Claudette
- 9:19Colbert's character is like someone of privilege,
- 9:21someone of power, and she needs to be brought
- 9:24back down into reality. There's not an aspect
- 9:27of that with Grace Moore's performance here,
- 9:29where it's like, hey, I'm stuck up. I'm rich.
- 9:32Like, I need to be brought down a peg. And he
- 9:34helps her do that. If anything, let me be so
- 9:37real with you. This is one of the downsides of
- 9:38bringing in a famous opera singer like Grace
- 9:40Moore. When she comes in and they're like, hey,
- 9:42you really need some tutelage to get better.
- 9:44I'm like, does she? She's pretty great. Yeah.
- 9:48She's pretty amazing. And by the end of this
- 9:49movie, you're like, yeah, you're... you're as
- 9:52good as you were in the beginning like you're
- 9:53great there isn't like that level of ascension
- 9:57that we've seen from her tutelage with him outside
- 10:00of just their relationship and how happy she
- 10:02is with him somehow yeah but i mean a lot of
- 10:05that is like you you've got to just follow the
- 10:08plot and the narrative and kind of be in the
- 10:10movie and just assume like, yes, she sure has
- 10:12improved, even though she's singing at the same
- 10:14caliber from beginning to end. Which to me is
- 10:18a failure. That's like a negative against the
- 10:21movie when you can't see that progression. So
- 10:23you think at the beginning of the film, when
- 10:25she was singing the Beauty and the Beast. bell
- 10:28thing, she should have been like, there goes
- 10:30the major with his tray. I do! Because if it's
- 10:33to show that she literally learned how to be
- 10:37a better opera singer from Monteverde, then I
- 10:40kind of need to see that progression. And to
- 10:42me, there's no progression in that. And that's
- 10:45nitpicking, but also that wouldn't be needed
- 10:48in my side if you bought the relationship. And
- 10:51it sounds like neither of us really bought the
- 10:53relationship that much. Well, I'm going to be
- 10:55honest with you. When you brought a baby girl,
- 10:58I was like, oh, wait a minute. Oh, you get it.
- 11:01I can see, like, I think I forget that sometimes
- 11:05there are different types of relationships than
- 11:08to the ones that I have held in my life. And
- 11:11I'm like, maybe Mary's into this. You know, maybe
- 11:14that's her thing. I don't know. Certainly, this
- 11:17is not what is being presented in 1934. Sure.
- 11:21You know, they're not like, drink the milk, girl.
- 11:24I think that that does kind of open up to a modern
- 11:27audience like, OK, well, you know, maybe this
- 11:30is how their relationship is going to be successful
- 11:32because this is the power dynamic that they're
- 11:35both kind of interested in. Yeah, it's. I don't
- 11:39know. It's a tough beat because you're right.
- 11:41There's multiple types of relationships. And
- 11:45this one's just not a ton of fun to watch because
- 11:47Monteverde isn't playing the Clark Gable kind
- 11:51of like, I think she needs to be brought down
- 11:53a peg, but ultimately this is how I feel about
- 11:55her. It's more like, to me, Monteverde, and I
- 11:59don't know if this is more in the character or
- 12:01in the performance, I can't say just yet, but
- 12:03with Monteverde's... it doesn't become clear
- 12:07that this is like, oh, this is what she needs
- 12:09and I'm going to be tough on her. It's kind of
- 12:11like, this is who I am. And sorry if this rubs
- 12:13you the wrong way. This is how I train everybody.
- 12:15So when it comes time to be like, oh, hey, I'm
- 12:18actually in love with you. It kind of comes across
- 12:20more as like my golden goose. Like I can't let
- 12:24my golden goose go. Why is she leaving? But then
- 12:27ultimately like that. You kind of read between
- 12:29the lines because he does a lot of like playing
- 12:31with her of like, oh, yeah, OK, I'll bring in
- 12:34Lally instead of you. So no worries. And then
- 12:37he expects that she'll come running back. Right.
- 12:39So it's more like we kind of have to be told
- 12:42that he feels this way more than we see him feel
- 12:44this way. So to me, the romance angle of this
- 12:47just did not work. And it wasn't something that
- 12:49kept me very interested throughout. I think one
- 12:52of the bummers, too, is that when you're first
- 12:54introduced to Monteverdi, he's. Coming out of
- 12:58a relationship with the previous student. Correct.
- 13:00And he's like, oh, I'm never doing that again.
- 13:02Because when you fall for a student, you become
- 13:05the student. And, you know, obviously that has
- 13:08been a contentious relationship. But that setting
- 13:11up like, okay, so this is just what this guy
- 13:13does. Yes. He falls for his students. So it doesn't
- 13:17really feel like there is a passionate romance
- 13:19there. It's more, he's kind of a player. It's
- 13:23a little Stockholm Syndrome. Of like, you're
- 13:25only going to see me. You're going to be here.
- 13:27This is what you're going to do. You're going
- 13:28to eat this. You're going to perform this way.
- 13:31And it just, it doesn't really feel earned. I
- 13:34will tell you the scenes that I actually liked
- 13:36a lot were when he's actually training her to
- 13:38be like a better opera singer. And it's like,
- 13:40well, you have to like push with your diaphragm.
- 13:42And well, here, actually do this exercise where
- 13:45like you're laying down and you have the books.
- 13:47You do the crucible exercise. Yeah, exactly.
- 13:49Oh, wait. Do the voice. And you have to like
- 13:52lay down and put the books on your diaphragm
- 13:55and then like sing from there. And there's like
- 13:57cool experiments where I'm like, this works pretty
- 13:59well. And then Bill comes in and sees them like,
- 14:01you know, rehearsing in this time period. It's
- 14:04fine. It just, I was so kind of like, I really
- 14:07don't want to use the B word here because it
- 14:09feels kind of boring. Not that one. Bored. I
- 14:12was just a little bored, like halfway through
- 14:13this movie. It's only an hour and 20 minutes.
- 14:16And yet still, I was like, what time is it? Like,
- 14:19and that sucks to feel that way sometimes. But
- 14:22yeah, maybe it was like the subject matter of
- 14:24like all this leaning around opera, something
- 14:26I'm not totally into, which I don't think you
- 14:28have to be into to enjoy a movie about the opera
- 14:30by any means. But this one leaned pretty heavily
- 14:33into it. And it just, it also felt very long
- 14:36towards the end. I feel like there's like multiple
- 14:38endings. That's probably my biggest complaint
- 14:41with it is as you get towards the ending, it
- 14:43does feel like that's all folks. Yeah. Just kidding.
- 14:46Here we go. And that, that got really. repetitive,
- 14:50for sure, towards the end. But I kind of have
- 14:53a different, or I had a different enjoyment of
- 14:56this movie. Going into it, I was like, oh, it's
- 14:58about opera. Okay, here we go. Thinking that
- 15:03it was going to be very dull, very dry, very
- 15:05miserable. But it did kind of hook me, and mostly
- 15:09for the music, which I was surprised for. Yes.
- 15:11Well, I didn't love their relationship, although
- 15:15thank you, Nicole Kidman, for kind of... Changing
- 15:17my mind a little bit about a potential reason
- 15:21behind it. The music itself, of all the musicals
- 15:24we've watched, common complaint we've had is
- 15:27that other than Ernst Lubitsch musicals, most
- 15:30of the musical is saved for the back end of the
- 15:34film. This has pretty consistent music littered
- 15:38throughout. Yeah, I'd say... I'd say it's more
- 15:41on the back end, but that's just natural because
- 15:43she's training to be—her ultimate goal is to
- 15:46be performing at the Metropolitan Opera. Right.
- 15:49So, of course, there's going to be more performances
- 15:51towards the end, but you're right. It's littered
- 15:53a little bit more. Yeah, I mean, it opens up
- 15:55with her performing. She's entering a contest
- 15:58to— ultimately be trained by Monteverde. Yes.
- 16:02She does lose that contest, but when it opens,
- 16:04we see her singing. So right off the bat, you
- 16:06know, you're being introduced to the opera and
- 16:09the music that's going to be present in the movie.
- 16:11Right. Following that, though, is when we get
- 16:13the bell in the quiet little village song, which
- 16:17was a lot of fun. Like you said, it's her singing,
- 16:20and then everybody starts opening their windows
- 16:22and playing various instruments along with her.
- 16:26And it does have kind of that Disney musical
- 16:28vibe to it. But really, the music just keeps
- 16:31showing up throughout the movie. I really like
- 16:33the one where she was playing at the club. Yes.
- 16:36And everybody starts singing along with her.
- 16:38I think that was the moment I went from, oh,
- 16:41the music's actually pretty good in this, to,
- 16:44yeah, let's party with Grace Moore. Let's do
- 16:50it. It's interesting that we bring up the music
- 16:53here, because I think one question that some
- 16:56people are going to have is like, oh, so is it
- 16:57a musical? And it's interesting because music
- 17:00is certainly performed in this, but I don't know
- 17:02if I'd call it a musical because it's less that
- 17:05like multiple, I mean, you bring up people are
- 17:07singing with her, but it's no different than
- 17:09like calling a concert a musical, right? Sure.
- 17:12Yeah. All of the musical moments in this are
- 17:16performances. Yes. Like four people in the movie,
- 17:21not just us. So to me, it's tough because I think
- 17:25you could say like, in that sense, i don't know
- 17:28drive is a musical because there's music being
- 17:30performed and people hear it but like that's
- 17:33not right so to me this isn't so much a musical
- 17:36as it is just like a movie about music uh i don't
- 17:39know i i would call it a musical would you there's
- 17:41just so much music and it in the same way that
- 17:4542nd street is like every time they're singing
- 17:47they're performing they're showing you a piece
- 17:49of the final performance they're going to be
- 17:51playing at the end of the movie it's it's not
- 17:54a musical in the sense of like the love parade
- 17:56where they just randomly breaking a song. There's
- 17:59not chorus lines, like you said. It is a focus
- 18:02on just individuals, but at the same time, our
- 18:05Ernst Lubitsch performances are very similar
- 18:07to that, where you have Maurice Chevalier and
- 18:10Jeanette MacDonald, and that's it. You know,
- 18:13there's not a chorus line behind them. That's
- 18:16true. I only paused because I was trying to think
- 18:18of how to say Maurice's last name. I was like...
- 18:20How do we do it again? I panicked. Yeah, no,
- 18:24I'll be bringing him up later. So I want to make
- 18:27sure I got that right. Oh, excellent. Yeah, you
- 18:28know, it's interesting. I was talking with Ashton,
- 18:31listener, lover, friend of the pod. She is thinking
- 18:35specifically about like, she was watching Flirtation
- 18:37Walk. And she was saying like, you know, I just
- 18:40I can't wait for musicals to kind of become what
- 18:42we know musicals to be now. Yeah. And I think
- 18:46her... I'm paraphrasing a little bit of what
- 18:49she said, mostly just one word. But she said,
- 18:52I just want people exploding into emotions and
- 18:54singing about their feelings, damn it. And that's
- 18:56not this. So it's funny. She's right. Musicals
- 19:00kind of became something after a while. And now
- 19:02I think we have an understanding of what a musical
- 19:04is and looks like. In 1934, that's not what,
- 19:09musicals were still finding their footing of
- 19:10like what a musical could be. So you're probably
- 19:13right that this is considered a musical. It's
- 19:15just very different because we think now of musicals
- 19:19as, you know, some kind of mixture of what we're
- 19:21seeing here, but then also what we're seeing
- 19:24in One Hour With You or any of the other Maurice
- 19:28Chevalier. Nailed it. Nailed it. Movies. Ernst
- 19:33Lubitsch movies of how they break into song,
- 19:35but also more of the 42nd Street, Busby Berkeley
- 19:38type of the choreography going into it. So in
- 19:42the three of those, there's a bit of a combination
- 19:44of what musicals tend to look like in the future.
- 19:47So I think that's a little bit more of my limited
- 19:51thought of what musicals can be. And I need to
- 19:53open that up more. So you're right. This is more
- 19:56of a musical in that sense. And it's worth bringing
- 19:59up because not only is this a pretty big deal
- 20:02for One Night of Love, this is the first year
- 20:04where music scoring was one of the nominations
- 20:07for the Oscars. But on top of that, it actually
- 20:09won. So it is the first film, One Night of Love,
- 20:12to win the Best Music Scoring Academy Award.
- 20:16Yeah, which is obviously a huge deal. Huge deal,
- 20:19because now it's almost like a... And it's almost
- 20:22like a checkbox for me of like, okay, is this
- 20:24an all time great movie? What's the score like?
- 20:26Right. Does it feel like that movie? Is it inherently
- 20:28that movie? And I don't think this is a proof
- 20:32of the pudding type thing with this category,
- 20:34like this movie specifically of like, oh, this
- 20:35movie has its own scoring. This movie has its
- 20:38own like distinct style. Because a lot of the
- 20:41songs that you hear in it are like, you know,
- 20:42from Madame Butterfly or from... Oh, what's the...
- 20:46Carmen. Carmen, thank you. So well -known and
- 20:49established like operas and pieces. Right. So
- 20:52it's not the, well, we come back to Hamnet of
- 20:56this existed before. Right. But yeah, it is a
- 21:00really good score. You're right. And it's really
- 21:03important of a start in what movies kind of tend
- 21:07to be, not just musicals, but otherwise moving
- 21:09forward. Yeah. Going back to like the style of
- 21:13musicals you were talking about, I think, There
- 21:15are two types of musical in my mind. There is
- 21:20where the characters live in this world where
- 21:23people can just break into song, which is kind
- 21:25of the Lubitsch we've been covering. Like a Mamma
- 21:27Mia kind of thing. Or Disney movies, really.
- 21:29Follow that formula. And then you have what we're
- 21:33calling the backstage musicals. Like A Star is
- 21:36Born. Yeah. 42nd Street, Gold Diggers of 1933,
- 21:40where there is music because these characters
- 21:43are... living a life that requires music you
- 21:48know i think there's a combination of something
- 21:49like that too because that's kind of white christmas
- 21:51like white christmas singing in the rain there's
- 21:53a little bit of like well hey here's our now
- 21:55like we're rehearsing for this and here's one
- 21:57of our performances of what we're going to be
- 21:59doing and then like it'll cut to them kind of
- 22:02just like singing on their own or dancing on
- 22:04their own so there's a combination yeah of these
- 22:06two but you're right those really are kind of
- 22:08like the beginning and end yeah but that being
- 22:11said the the type of music musical where Oh,
- 22:15we're performing music because that's what our
- 22:17job or whatever requires. That's what this is.
- 22:20And it's similar to the Broadway musicals that
- 22:23we've covered on the show. It's just that the
- 22:26style of music has changed. You have your Broadway
- 22:30musicals that also require the intense choreography
- 22:33and the big set pieces and things. Whereas this
- 22:37is focused on opera. So it's not. really the
- 22:41the movie's fault for not having like massive
- 22:44choreography it's that opera itself doesn't really
- 22:47include massive choreography it's less a miss
- 22:50and more just it's not that type of movie yeah
- 22:52and uh i don't want to say like it got me interested
- 22:56in in checking out opera but i i did enjoy watching
- 22:59grace more perform and i think they they also
- 23:03include scenes where they are performing these
- 23:06opera pieces in really fun and interesting ways.
- 23:09One of my favorite scenes in this movie is when
- 23:12they are at Grace's home and the landlord is
- 23:15about to come up to collect rent. And they're
- 23:17like, oh, well, we don't have it. What do we
- 23:19do? The landlord ends up being a, maybe like
- 23:22a hobby opera singer, I think. I don't know if
- 23:26she was like a previous opera singer, but they're
- 23:27like, let's start rehearsing. And then when she
- 23:30comes up, be like, oh, we need someone to cover
- 23:33this. part the the tenor part or whatever and
- 23:36they do and she comes in and she's just really
- 23:38getting into it and being very uh super performative
- 23:41right uh and it's a lot of fun because you see
- 23:44like who is it lally playing uh the piano with
- 23:47bill i think and and they're both listening to
- 23:50her sing and they're just like man she's she's
- 23:53going nuts like just making the funniest faces
- 23:56it was a lot of fun and i'm glad that they took
- 23:58instead of just having opera performance opera
- 24:00performance they had these unique things Her
- 24:03playing with all the musicians outside of her
- 24:05window, them performing with the landlady, everybody
- 24:07singing together at the bar. That added a little
- 24:10bit of something to pull in, I feel like, your
- 24:13average audience member. Yeah, you're right.
- 24:17To me, it felt a little rollercoaster of ups
- 24:20and downs. Because you're right. Those pieces
- 24:23you're talking about were clearly the ups. Although
- 24:25I have to tell you that if I was a landlord and
- 24:28I had a hobby of opera singing and they brought
- 24:31me in and were like, hey, you should perform
- 24:32this. I'm like, hey, great call. And we sing.
- 24:34We have a great time. They're like, where's my
- 24:36money? Yeah. So it wouldn't be me like, ah, you
- 24:40kids, give me until tomorrow. It's like in Spider
- 24:42-Man. He like shows up and he does this whole
- 24:44thing. He's like, hello, my baby. Hello, my darling.
- 24:47Where is my money? You can't talk to my daughter
- 24:51one more time until you pay your money. Yeah.
- 24:53Just like in between both. You're right that
- 24:58those are the most interesting parts of the movie.
- 25:01And I think that that is ultimately good for
- 25:04a musical. Not so great for a narrative. Because
- 25:07as we get towards the end of this story, it becomes
- 25:11clear that there is a codependency. Not so much
- 25:15on Monteverde's side, but more on Mary's side.
- 25:18Yeah. Where Mary can't even perform specific
- 25:21songs without her specific tutor. And this is
- 25:25not what a tutor is supposed to do. A tutor is
- 25:27not supposed to be or a mentor isn't supposed
- 25:29to be at every performance they have for you.
- 25:31And now he's the conductor. Right. Right. So
- 25:33now we've proven twice that he is the conductor
- 25:37is the reason why she's able to perform as well
- 25:39as she is. So it's almost like they've created
- 25:42this very like parasitic relationship of like,
- 25:45it's not just that you're a good performer. It's
- 25:47that you're a good performer if he's there. Right.
- 25:49And he's not doing the most dramatic, like, you
- 25:51know, he's not conducting the orchestra, he's
- 25:53conducting her. And it just, it felt kind of
- 25:57strange to me. And it's very possible that this
- 26:01is, I would say almost extremely likely, that
- 26:03this is a 2026 lens of like... I don't know if
- 26:07this is how a relationship should work, man.
- 26:09And in 1934, very different expectation of that.
- 26:13But for me, it was weird. It just felt like a
- 26:16weird relationship. And if it felt earned, and
- 26:19if it felt like, hey, I really love this girl,
- 26:21so I'm going to do whatever it takes, and also
- 26:23she loves me, cool. You don't get to see a lot
- 26:26of that. No, no, no, you don't. And it's really
- 26:28frustrating, too, because she gets booked for
- 26:31the, what is it? The big one at the end. Oh,
- 26:34at the Metropolitan Opera, it's the Madam Butterfly.
- 26:36Yeah. Yeah. And Monteverde is like, she's not
- 26:40ready. So it's not like he's a supportive partner
- 26:42or anything. He's awful. He's so toxic to her.
- 26:46You're totally right. And this is what factors
- 26:48into the multiple endings for me because she's
- 26:50like, hey, I'm not going to go perform today.
- 26:52I'm not doing that. And he's like, okay, well,
- 26:55I'll get Lally. Don't worry. You're going to
- 26:57marry Bill. That's so cool. I'll bring Lally
- 26:59in. Don't worry. We'll make it happen. And I
- 27:02can't remember if this is Carmen or not. I think
- 27:04this was a different thing. But he tells her,
- 27:06Lali's going to do it. And Lali, sorry. Lali's
- 27:09going to do it. And then she's like, well, that's
- 27:12absolutely not going to happen. I'm going to
- 27:13go take care of that. Shows up, and she's like,
- 27:16where's Lali? And he's like, I don't know, probably
- 27:17in the front row or something, waiting to watch
- 27:19the performance. Because I knew you were going
- 27:21to show up after all. And she's like, well, how
- 27:24could you do this? I can't believe, well. Actually,
- 27:26it's my time. Okay, let me hop on. Right. And
- 27:28she performs. And you're like, okay, well, this
- 27:30is the end of the movie. Like, he's kind of called
- 27:32her bluff. She's revealed how she actually feels,
- 27:35and this is the end. And instead, it leads to
- 27:39what you're talking about, where someone's like,
- 27:40hey, oh, my God. I cannot believe how good you
- 27:43are. You've got to perform in the Metropolitan.
- 27:45And she's like, yeah, totally. And he's like,
- 27:47nah, she's not ready. Yeah. And not even she's
- 27:50not ready, but like, I won't let her do that.
- 27:53Right. And you're like, oh, no. This movie is
- 27:56not over. Like, this is a terrible idea. So then
- 27:59you kind of just accentuate, or not accentuate,
- 28:02but extend the same thing that we saw before
- 28:05and know that it's just going to end the same
- 28:08way of, well, I can't allow you to do this. Great.
- 28:11Well, I'm going to go do it on my own. And she
- 28:13does. But she freezes in Madame Butterfly because
- 28:16she feels like, well, I can't perform. My rehearsals
- 28:19haven't gone well. I can't be the best version
- 28:21of myself for some reason. What could it be?
- 28:24And it's him. And out of nowhere, during Madame
- 28:27Butterfly, he shows up. He pops up from beneath
- 28:30the stage. Yeah, he just is there. I think it's
- 28:34not even the pit. It's an awning in front of
- 28:37the pit where only the stagehands and actors
- 28:41can see him. And, or performers. And it's then
- 28:45when like she can give this incredible performance
- 28:47and the movie ends on that performance. So we
- 28:50don't see their embrace or anything, but you
- 28:52just understand, okay, they're back together
- 28:54and clearly they need each other. I don't know
- 28:56how clear it is that he needs her. Right. I think
- 29:00it becomes one of those things where he's like,
- 29:02oh, I knew she was like destined to be the greatest
- 29:06opera singer of all time. Yeah. I've never told
- 29:09her that. And I don't know that I ever will,
- 29:11but that's what I need. Like as a teacher, he
- 29:14needs the best. And maybe he needs to be the
- 29:17one that created the best. So it's still a very
- 29:21toxic relationship. But I think that's kind of
- 29:24what his character is, where he's like obsessed
- 29:26with the art form. And since she is the peak
- 29:30of that art form, that's why he's drawn to her.
- 29:33I told you previously on the pod. And you listening
- 29:37at home, I've told you this before, too. I don't
- 29:39read synopses of movies anymore, because I'm
- 29:43always worried it's going to be a woman can't
- 29:44perform Madame Butterfly, so her toxic partner
- 29:47shows up and teaches her better. And then Bill
- 29:49leaves. And then Bill leaves, yeah. And boy,
- 29:53does Bill leave. completely can we just like
- 29:56i'm gonna interject my own thought real quick
- 29:58bill almost as uh hard as who are we talking
- 30:03about flirtation walk when he's like hey we're
- 30:05getting married buzz off and then 30 seconds
- 30:08later we broke up but i wish you the best right
- 30:10um there's a lot of that with bill where bill's
- 30:13like hey girl great job you killed it look i
- 30:16know we're gonna get married but i'm going to
- 30:17new york in like an hour so um Ring me sometime.
- 30:20And just leaves. So it's almost as if the writer
- 30:23was like, we got to get Bill out of here. We
- 30:26got to make this relationship make more sense.
- 30:28It's almost like Bill was saying, this movie's
- 30:30getting long. I don't want to be a part of that.
- 30:34I'm out. Yeah. Yeah. So Grace Moore's a big deal.
- 30:37Obviously famous opera singer before this film.
- 30:39In terms of the performance of the movie, she
- 30:42does really well. It's one of those things where
- 30:45you're worried, okay, you're a great opera singer.
- 30:48How good are you as an actor? And she's great.
- 30:51I have zero issue. In fact, I was kind of surprised
- 30:54doing some research here. Maybe on the second
- 30:56performance she does, I'm like, is she an opera
- 30:58singer? And I looked into it. The movie hypes
- 31:01her up. In the very beginning, it says Miss Grace
- 31:04Moore as Mary. So they are really hyping her
- 31:08up, and for good reason. She's great in this.
- 31:10But with Grace Moore, there came a couple complications.
- 31:13Specific, not complications, but some interesting
- 31:15behind -the -scenes stuff. Nothing that made
- 31:17the movie unfavorable behind the scenes. So this
- 31:20was a Columbia film. And after this came out,
- 31:22and certainly after her nomination for Best Actress
- 31:25in the Leading Role, MGM. Metro -Goldwyn -Mayer
- 31:28tried to steal her from her Columbia contract.
- 31:31So they specifically offered her a starring role
- 31:34alongside Maurice Chevalier. Ooh. And sharing
- 31:39top billing with him. This is not something he
- 31:42did. He was always like, well, this is like Maurice
- 31:44Chevalier with this person. But instead, this
- 31:48was going to be more like a Ginger Rogers, Fred
- 31:50Astaire, like the two of them together are the
- 31:52lead. Sure. Right? And it was going to be Grace
- 31:54Moore and Maurice Chevalier. And Maurice said,
- 31:58what on earth are you talking about? What do
- 32:00you mean? There is no way you can do that. Wow.
- 32:02He would never concede this to anyone. So certainly
- 32:06with Grace Moore, who had one major film under
- 32:09her belt. right, like this nomination, he was
- 32:11like, no, not going to concede to that. Wow.
- 32:13So the film wasn't made because of this. And
- 32:16not only because of that, or not only that, but
- 32:19Chevalier was so put off by this offer that he
- 32:22actually shortly after quit Hollywood. There's
- 32:26never like a one -to -one that says this is specifically
- 32:28what did it. But like shortly after this controversy,
- 32:31he was like, I'm not acting again. Wow. So there
- 32:33was a lot of like... The studios tried to change
- 32:36what musicals looked like because of this. Or
- 32:39not musicals, but like movies in general. And
- 32:42I mean, Maurice Chevalier is a huge name, not
- 32:44just for the Academy, but also for us and what
- 32:47movies we talked about. So it's tough to see
- 32:51something like that happen. But also I think
- 32:52it speaks a little bit to the egos that existed
- 32:55in the 1930s. Yeah. With Hollywood. That's wild
- 32:59to just be like, oh no, but I loved him. Oh,
- 33:03that's why he left? Well, good riddance. I will
- 33:06say, though, he does return to acting. I don't
- 33:09know exactly when, but he does show up in a film
- 33:11we'll talk about in 1961 called Fanny. Which
- 33:14is, so what was the, was it like 1934 to 1961
- 33:18he didn't do films? No, I don't think it was
- 33:21that long. I don't believe his exit from Hollywood
- 33:26was really all that long. Because I do see just,
- 33:29I'll show you my letterboxd here. One night.
- 33:32With you. Uh -huh. Or One Hour With You is here.
- 33:35And then there's a good bit of maybe 20, 24 movies,
- 33:40maybe 30 movies before you get to Fanny. Okay.
- 33:43So I don't know how long that exit was. Got it.
- 33:46So it was more an exit, but he did return. Yeah.
- 33:48And we will definitely talk about him in three
- 33:51years. Oh. So, you know, right around the corner.
- 33:54Well, hold on. Three years. Not three years for
- 33:56us. That'd be three decades. So three months.
- 33:58Three. No, 1961. Three years. Oh, yeah, three
- 34:02years. No, you're right. Okay. It'll be 2030.
- 34:04Oops. It'll be fun. That'll take a little while.
- 34:08So with Grace Moore, there came some really high
- 34:13highs in her performance and in her performance
- 34:16of her singing as well. I don't know if I would
- 34:19say that this role of Mary is like... an Oscar
- 34:25-winning performance. It is good. And I'm not
- 34:28going to downplay how effective it is in the
- 34:30movie itself. But when we talk about what's come
- 34:33before this, it's not really what stands out
- 34:36to me in that. Now, I think the one -two punch
- 34:39and the reason why this nomination happened is
- 34:41that she is that good of a singer. Right. And
- 34:43the opera performance is the other side of it.
- 34:46So I think there's an interesting... Okay, yeah,
- 34:49there's an Emmy or a Grammy maybe in there for
- 34:51you. Not an Emmy. Right. There's a Grammy potential
- 34:53in there for you, but I don't know about Oscar.
- 34:56But certainly the nomination was a big deal.
- 34:58And I thought she did really well in it for someone
- 35:00who did not start as an actor. Yeah. In Hollywood,
- 35:03at least. I definitely agree with you. Like her
- 35:05performance of the opera music is like the drive
- 35:09behind her Oscar nominee or her. academy award
- 35:12nominee we weren't calling them that's right
- 35:15which doesn't really matter but i feel like maybe
- 35:18it's a big deal that i want to drop when we get
- 35:20to that point yeah um but regardless there's
- 35:24a reason we're saying the sixth and eighth i'm
- 35:27not doing the thing right academy award ceremonies
- 35:30rather than oscar yeah yeah and for copyright
- 35:33i don't need them coming after me i've got enough
- 35:36of that going on behind the scenes can we not
- 35:37say oscars i don't know i hope we can because
- 35:39it's the name of the show So fingers crossed.
- 35:42I feel like we can. However, her performance,
- 35:46though, I do think she is funny a lot in this
- 35:49movie. She is. Especially during her training
- 35:51scene. Actually, when she first meets Monteverde
- 35:53and he starts criticizing her performance, she
- 35:57doesn't know who he is yet. And he's this is
- 36:00really when he's like prime jerk. He's. getting
- 36:04kind of handsy with her and and not in like a
- 36:06gimme gimme kind of way she goes to walk away
- 36:09because he's bothering her and he'll like grab
- 36:11her arm and pull her back and be like do not
- 36:13walk away from me and you're like chill out man
- 36:15he's into it buddy but uh she does have some
- 36:17funny lines where or snarky lines there that
- 36:20i think helped me enjoy her character beyond
- 36:24just the oscar performance uh excuse me the opera
- 36:27performance but then when she's training and
- 36:29stuff too she's she's very Funny and goofy. I
- 36:32can't remember specific lines there, but she's
- 36:35kind of giving Monteverdi a hard time. The piano
- 36:39player, while she's training, he's making like
- 36:41funny faces while he's playing the piano and
- 36:44she's doing a breathing exercise or a head tilting
- 36:47exercise. She starts giggling at that. And I
- 36:49don't know. I just thought she, her performance
- 36:53outside of the singing is not enough for the
- 36:57nominee, but it was enough to like. intrigue
- 37:00me in her character be memorable yeah yeah so
- 37:03i'm glad that she was able to perform at least
- 37:07to that caliber yeah i mean it's she is very
- 37:11good in it there's absolutely nothing wrong with
- 37:13the performance itself i think it's more the
- 37:16character i think it's the character and the
- 37:18journey that she goes on or lack thereof in my
- 37:22opinion tbh so it's less her performance and
- 37:26it's more just the material that I think is,
- 37:28like, it doesn't feel like an Oscar -winning
- 37:30character to me. But that's okay. That's more,
- 37:34again, a nitpick. I do want to bring up, when
- 37:36we talk about musicals, that there's something
- 37:38that Columbia did here that was a little different.
- 37:41Columbia, obviously, nominated for sound recording,
- 37:45right? On top of John P. Lividary, Columbia Studio
- 37:49was recognized for best sound recording here.
- 37:52And one thing that they did was, it's actually
- 37:54called, and I'm... hoping you know a little bit
- 37:56about this, vertical cut recording. Your eyes
- 38:00just got so big. It was an early method of audio
- 38:03recording. So this was something that was seen
- 38:05as not revolutionary. I think it has existed
- 38:08prior, but that style of recording definitely
- 38:10helped their nomination here. How did you feel
- 38:15about the sound here? Because obviously, you
- 38:17know, we're pretty like, what, six years into
- 38:19the sound recording. So how... How did you feel
- 38:23about like the quality, not just this movie,
- 38:25but like of this year so far that you feel like
- 38:28where we are with sound recording? I think that
- 38:30having recently had to tweak sound on my computer
- 38:33myself and just dealing with, what do they call
- 38:35them? When it's too loud and it just breaks.
- 38:38Oh, peaking. Yeah, peaking. This is a movie that
- 38:41has so many opportunities for that to happen
- 38:44with Grace Moore singing. And I thought for 1934,
- 38:49this was pretty crystal clear. Yeah. And I think
- 38:52this being a musical and specifically an opera,
- 38:55like to make this sound good on film and not
- 38:58just when she's performing in front of the camera
- 39:00for the crew members, that alone is worth the
- 39:03nomination. Yes. No, absolutely. And it's almost
- 39:07one of those things where it's so good that you
- 39:10don't notice it. Yeah. Right? We've come very
- 39:13far. in our journey of movies even uh the viva
- 39:17via i think there were some moments where i was
- 39:19like oh the sound recording isn't the absolute
- 39:21best here but it is wide and uh very large in
- 39:25scope they're outside there's a lot of like horses
- 39:27running around it's no in old arizona right right
- 39:31but you can tell it's like limitations with this
- 39:35it's in a theater there's a large stage of people
- 39:37on screen And yet everything comes across so
- 39:40clearly. And even though my closed captioning
- 39:43on, I don't really know if I want to say it,
- 39:45Jeff Bezos' streaming platform, even though the
- 39:50closed captioning on that is not linked to the
- 39:52correct movie, and if you do rent it on that
- 39:54platform, the closed captioning will give you
- 39:56that captioning for another movie. It's crazy.
- 39:58Don't know what's going on with that. I didn't
- 40:00need it. And it was nice to be able to kind of
- 40:03watch another movie like this and not necessarily
- 40:05need it. Now, would I have loved it for some
- 40:08of the opera singing? Sure. Because I don't know
- 40:10a lot of the lyrics in that. But otherwise, I
- 40:12could make out the majority of everything else.
- 40:14And that's a testament to the sound recording.
- 40:16The music is obviously a very large portion of
- 40:19that, because it's not just the score, but it's
- 40:21an actual performance of that song. So it is
- 40:24a big deal. I mean, you know, you can say whatever
- 40:27you want about this movie, and I certainly have,
- 40:29and I will continue to do that. But you can't
- 40:33knock the nominations and the wins here, because
- 40:35not only did it win for best music scoring, which
- 40:38we talked about, it won for sound recording as
- 40:40well. And it should have, because it is doing
- 40:43something really remarkable here. So it is more
- 40:46of a technical achievement than it is a narrative
- 40:48achievement in my eyes. But... Very cool to have
- 40:52this kind of invigoration, like a kickstart into
- 40:55something that is a very big deal. Probably one
- 40:57of my favorite awards to see at the Oscar ceremonies.
- 41:01The sound recording award? Well, sound, score.
- 41:05Oh, score. Gotcha. Yeah. I do like sound, but
- 41:08I'm not going to be like, oh, it's sound. Everyone
- 41:10be quiet. You were big on F1, so. No, hold on.
- 41:12There's that. I was adamant about F1. I wasn't
- 41:15big on F1. I was just, I knew that over one battle
- 41:20after another in Sinners, even though the music
- 41:22was a big part of it, vroom vroom was going to
- 41:25be the thing that won sound. That's fair. I do
- 41:27think, like, it was obvious that the first musical
- 41:31scoring was going to go to a musical. Of course.
- 41:34The award, I mean. And then to have it sound
- 41:36just going hand in hand with that, this makes
- 41:39sense. the winners of those categories were certainly
- 41:43always going to go to a musical. And I think
- 41:46that this year, One Night With You, the only
- 41:49other comparison we have is Flirtation Walk,
- 41:51and I do think that this outperforms that easily
- 41:54on every level, which is weird because Ruby Keeler
- 41:57and Dick Powell, like, we enjoyed them so much
- 41:59in 42nd Street. It's just, I don't know, maybe
- 42:02Borsiggy letting us down, but... It's funny.
- 42:05I feel like you can pick and choose. Somewhere
- 42:07between this and Flirtation Walk, I think you
- 42:10can take the casting of Ruby Keeler and William
- 42:12Powell, or maybe the chemistry of William Powell
- 42:14and Ruby Keeler, and I think you can have a better
- 42:17overall movie. hear in this but you're right
- 42:21one thing i want to push back on and i don't
- 42:23think i'm pushing back too much it's just more
- 42:25clarifying for the audience because i think you
- 42:26feel this way is that it's not just that a musical
- 42:29was going to win this and you're right of course
- 42:31they are but like we've seen musicals in prior
- 42:34of like the broadway melody and different things
- 42:37flirtation walk even and you'd be like yeah it's
- 42:40a musical but I don't think it really deserved
- 42:41it. This one does like for the music and for
- 42:44everything. Like it feels like those are earned.
- 42:46It's not just, yeah, of course it was always
- 42:48going to be musical. It's like, yeah, this one,
- 42:50like it, of course it's a musical, but like this
- 42:52one did do it. Yeah. Yeah. And as we know, it
- 42:55did. Because it beat Flirtation Walk in pretty
- 42:58much every category. It did. And it's funny because
- 43:01you see two nominations like this and you're
- 43:02like, oh, man, you guys are kind of sweeping
- 43:04the Oscars a little bit, huh? And we'll talk
- 43:06about that. But it was not the movie that everyone
- 43:09was talking about at the end of this ceremony.
- 43:11No, it wasn't. That's for sure. No, it wasn't.
- 43:13The last category I want to touch on real quick
- 43:15is also a new category for this year's Academy
- 43:19Awards, and that's editing. Yeah. And I can't
- 43:22remember if any of the movies we've covered.
- 43:25This year so far, we've talked about editing.
- 43:27So this might be the first one. Forgive me. I
- 43:29forget. But I kind of wish that I would have
- 43:32focused more on that for this movie. But there
- 43:35was really so much going on with sound, which
- 43:37it won for, that I wasn't locked in to focus
- 43:42on that editing. I don't think I was either.
- 43:45I mean... At the end of the day, editing is something
- 43:48that you should feel and not notice. Sure. Right?
- 43:52I think score is a similar way, too. I mean,
- 43:54score should be a little more memorable, ideally
- 43:56for me. But for editing, it's more the way that
- 44:00the movie is paced and moves forward in the story
- 44:03and the scenes feel cohesive. Yeah. And I can't
- 44:05say that I felt that way about this. Well, we
- 44:08talked about... Viva Via last or a couple episodes
- 44:12ago and how disjointed that felt due to the multiple
- 44:15directors on that. This never felt disjointed
- 44:19to me. So it was presented in like a very tight
- 44:23narrative. It felt forward moving. Yeah. It obviously
- 44:27towards the end, we both agree that it just the
- 44:29plot itself kind of meandered and went back and
- 44:32forth with the same theme over and over again.
- 44:35But as far as the editing went. While it doesn't
- 44:37stand out to me, I agree. It kind of just worked
- 44:40properly. Right. This didn't win for editing,
- 44:43so maybe it's not the perfect example for this
- 44:45first showcase of the editing nominees. So I'll
- 44:50be curious when we get to the film that won,
- 44:52how we'll talk about it more. So we have not
- 44:56had the opportunity to talk about film editing
- 44:58yet this year. So I'll tell you what. There were
- 45:02three nominated. We're covering two of them.
- 45:04The winner, we won't be watching. Interesting.
- 45:07Yeah. So we'll be able to talk about that in
- 45:09a little more detail in the ceremony episode,
- 45:10I imagine. Yeah. Yeah, this was an interesting
- 45:13one, man. I mean, it's one of those where my
- 45:17rating isn't going to be super favorable on this.
- 45:20And ultimately, this did not cause any harm.
- 45:22This was not a movie that is trying to wish ill
- 45:25will on people, and it's not actively hurting
- 45:26anyone. It's just something that I could not
- 45:29engage with. Technically speaking, with the technical
- 45:33aspects, sound recording and music score, you
- 45:35can't overlook something like this and what it
- 45:38brings on moving forward. But it just felt narratively
- 45:41very, I would say, disjointed. Not so much in
- 45:45the editing, but I feel like just in the performances.
- 45:48I felt like I couldn't see the connection in
- 45:50the characters. And maybe it's more of a screenplay
- 45:52issue than it is the performances of these characters.
- 45:55Again, I thought Grace Moore did really well.
- 45:56I liked Tulio Carminati. as monteverde fine it's
- 46:02just his character himself that i i really wasn't
- 46:04rooting for right yeah for at least 90 of the
- 46:09movie maybe more sure sure but and that's really
- 46:12just the end and i think it's now funny in retrospect
- 46:15but at the time i was confused with lyle talbot
- 46:17as a bill when he's just like yeah i'm just gonna
- 46:20i'm gonna duck out see it um funny now thinking
- 46:23about by the time i was like what is that just
- 46:26There wasn't a scene where Bill looks over and
- 46:28sees their look, and he's like, I should probably
- 46:30just get out of here. Something to connect that.
- 46:32And yeah, the ending, it felt somehow simultaneously
- 46:37rushed, but also too long. Yeah. Which I don't
- 46:41know how you do that, but it definitely felt
- 46:42like both. Do you want to get into ratings? Yeah,
- 46:44yeah. So I gave this two stars. Okay. Yeah, for
- 46:47all the reasons you said, but specifically the
- 46:50ending, I was enjoying this movie. The relationship
- 46:54was... kind of rough to watch although again
- 46:57you've kind of sparked something in my brain
- 46:59to be like well wait a minute maybe there's something
- 47:01there different way to look at it yeah but the
- 47:03ending really i was just like oh this is too
- 47:07much this is too much and with ending do you
- 47:09mean like the last like 15 minutes or like the
- 47:11final i mean like the last 20 minutes or so i
- 47:14think this movie should have been right around
- 47:16the 60 65 minute mark the she done him wrong
- 47:20angle yeah it that multiple performances and
- 47:23the going back and forth of, well, I can't do
- 47:26this, but I want to do this, or you can't do
- 47:28this, but I'm going to make you do this. It just
- 47:30was exhausting by the end. And that really took
- 47:32what I thought was going to be a rewatchable
- 47:35movie for me. That's how much I was enjoying
- 47:37it up to that point and turned it into, oh, this
- 47:40might be a one and done for me. And I gave it
- 47:42two and a half stars. So I enjoyed it a little
- 47:45more than you. But that ending killed it for
- 47:47me. Yeah. To me, the last 20 minutes, the pacing
- 47:49is just completely off. Third act, I think, is
- 47:51a better way to say it. Sure. Yeah, totally.
- 47:53I do want to point out there is one scene that
- 47:55I thought was not so much clever, just memorable,
- 47:59in which Mary is convincing Monteverde that she
- 48:03is sick and lost her voice and can't perform.
- 48:06Oh, yeah, yeah. And he comes in and then bothers
- 48:08her and makes her scream. It's so angry. And
- 48:11she screams. And he's like, great, your voice
- 48:13is good. I'll see you outside. Yes. I guess in
- 48:16maybe a different actor or in a different like
- 48:19characterization, this would be a cute little
- 48:21like Maurice Chevalier. You did it to me again.
- 48:25This would be a cool little like Maurice Chevalier
- 48:27moment of like him kind of like getting the better
- 48:29of her and him knowing this is always going to
- 48:31happen. And it's just more like, ha ha, gotcha.
- 48:34But instead, like something about Monteverde
- 48:37and his character, it feels more like. I am the
- 48:40master of my domain and how dare you like question
- 48:42me like you're going outside. And it doesn't
- 48:45feel as playful. No, it all feels mean. Everything
- 48:48he does. It does feel mean. Yeah. So like he
- 48:50knew that and he knew what was happening. But
- 48:52instead of playing it very like cutesy, it's
- 48:55very like, don't dare do this to me again. Yeah.
- 48:58And it feels like dangerous. It does. It does.
- 49:00He's really not a likable character in this at
- 49:02all. No. Grace Moore, though, in that scene,
- 49:04when he's like, the doctor says, say on, she
- 49:06goes. Very funny. I laughed pretty hard. Again,
- 49:10I think there's a reason we're seeing her nomination
- 49:12and not his. Yeah, totally. And again, I don't
- 49:15want to dog on Tulio Carminati. I think it might
- 49:18just be the way the character is written. Sure.
- 49:20And I think it's less his performance. I have
- 49:22a sneaking suspicion that's what it was. Yeah.
- 49:24Because that's kind of my issue with the movie
- 49:26and Mary's character as well. I think it's the
- 49:28writing. Which is funny. Whenever you see more
- 49:31than two writers, you're always like... Too many
- 49:33hands in the kitchen? Maybe. Too many cooks in
- 49:34the kitchen, maybe? Maybe. We'll see. Let's get
- 49:36into double features. Double feature, baby. So,
- 49:38the more I think about it, the more I probably
- 49:40should have just rent with a baby girl. Because
- 49:42that explains the relationship itself. Sure.
- 49:45To me. I don't think that it's leaned into as
- 49:47much of like the Nicole Kidman side with Grace
- 49:49Moore of like, oh, this is kind of working for
- 49:51me. Right, right. But I think it makes sense
- 49:53why she's coming back. What I instead did was
- 49:56I leaned into the aspect of a relationship within
- 49:58the music. And I chose the 2007 Music and Lyrics,
- 50:02which was directed by Mark Lawrence. This is
- 50:05a Hugh Grant, Drew Barrymore movie of Lionel
- 50:08and John fame. And nothing. Okay, well, not even
- 50:13a smirk. I didn't get the joke. I'm sorry. I
- 50:15made a John and Lionel Barrymore reference. Oh!
- 50:18It's fine. We'll cut that. I anticipate it won't
- 50:21be cut. I was also writing down your thing. You
- 50:24were. No, I was looking for a smirk or something.
- 50:27No, it's okay. Take two. I'm just going to jump
- 50:28off a cliff. That laugh was way worse. So, directed
- 50:35by Mark Lawrence, this is a Hugh Grant, John,
- 50:36oh my God, Drew Barrymore movie. This movie has,
- 50:42he is a, Hugh Grant is a pop star. Have you seen
- 50:46this? No. He is an 80s pop star, and he's not
- 50:50as relevant now in the 2000s. And he finds a
- 50:53music producer in Drew Barrymore's character,
- 50:56and she helps him come up with songs and music
- 50:59that, lyrics and music, if you will, that help
- 51:02him. become a little more relevant. And of course,
- 51:05in this, they fall in love. There's one huge
- 51:08reason to see this movie in my eyes, and I'm
- 51:10trying to make this pitch not just to you, but
- 51:12to the general audience. Sure. There's a song
- 51:15that opens this movie, and it's a music video
- 51:17of what Hugh Grant and his boy band he was in
- 51:20was most popular for. And it's a song called
- 51:22Pop Goes My Heart. And this song is the catchiest
- 51:26thing. It is like that thing you do level of
- 51:30like, you didn't have to go this hard for this
- 51:32movie. And the movie is not justified in this.
- 51:36But the song is like so good. I will play it
- 51:39for you afterwards. But I implore everyone to
- 51:41go listen to Pop Goes My Heart and see this movie
- 51:43and watch the opening credits. You probably turn
- 51:45it off shortly after. But that song is so catchy.
- 51:49And you have Hugh Grant doing his Love Actually
- 51:52dancing around the screen and singing. a song
- 51:55like this so uh music and lyrics is gonna be
- 51:57my double feature for one night of love very
- 51:59nice i like it i'm gonna be annoying right now
- 52:01i wrote down right now yeah just right now uh
- 52:05watch your tone i had maybe understand my john
- 52:08and lionel barrymore jokes distracted and i'll
- 52:11uh i'll be kinder i'm gonna edit in the biggest
- 52:13laugh for that you should put a studio applause
- 52:15everyone like exactly Like Ross and Rachel getting
- 52:20together for the sixth time. It's going to make
- 52:22no sense. So I had written down one film. Halfway
- 52:26through the recording, I was like, oh, no, no,
- 52:27no. I'm going to go with this. This is better.
- 52:29And then right towards the end, I was like, no,
- 52:31no, no, no. So originally I went with Maria,
- 52:33the Angelina Jolie film where she's an opera
- 52:35singer. That just came out. 2024 it came out.
- 52:38Yeah. Oh. Oh, but it was in the 2025 Oscars.
- 52:41Yes. That's right. Yeah. I enjoyed that movie.
- 52:43It is a prime example of. Hey, we got an actress
- 52:46who is not an opera singer and we just dubbed
- 52:48over it. Pretty divisive from what I saw in the
- 52:50letterbox. But then I said, no, no. I like the
- 52:52idea of Monteverdi training Mary. I'm going to
- 52:57go with my favorite example of someone training
- 53:00somebody in the masterful art of something else.
- 53:04The next Karate Kid with Hilary Swank. But then.
- 53:08I credit you for this choice. Honestly, I did
- 53:11decide to go with Baby Girl because I think it
- 53:14opens up such an interesting thing for us on
- 53:18this podcast of being able to look back at these
- 53:21films that are almost 100 years old and step
- 53:24outside of like what we're being shown on screen
- 53:27and really coming up with like our own theories
- 53:30and things. And I think that relationship that
- 53:34is kind of like a sub dom. relationship right
- 53:38that adds so much more to this movie and it takes
- 53:41what is on a first viewing for me just kind of
- 53:45like a gross toxic relationship and turns it
- 53:48into something that could be romantic if viewed
- 53:51from the appropriate lens and i think that was
- 53:53really cool i love that you brought it up and
- 53:56it It did affect my view on the entire movie.
- 53:59Yeah, I wonder looking back now, if I watch it
- 54:02a second time, if that changes things. My initial
- 54:04thought is it doesn't because you don't see Grace
- 54:07kind of understand. Well, I say Grace, Mary.
- 54:09You don't see Mary kind of understanding that
- 54:12this is what she's into. And like, oh, well,
- 54:14I think that's what I like in a relationship.
- 54:16And you see it more of a he's playing it as like
- 54:20a Dom sub kind of relationship. And she's playing
- 54:23it more as the common trope that we now know.
- 54:26romantic comedies of like oh he just makes me
- 54:28so mad there's no one in the world that makes
- 54:30me more mad than him so i was like you want to
- 54:32kiss him so badly right and there's kind of a
- 54:35combination of those two and i think on her side
- 54:37it's more the uh he makes me so emotional which
- 54:41makes me tap into my anger but in reality i feel
- 54:44this way about him and with him he's more like
- 54:46well no you're into me because i'm dumb i'm dominating
- 54:49you right and that's i don't think He feels a
- 54:52different way than she does. Or sorry, he wants
- 54:54a different relationship than she does, but they
- 54:56still end up together. So to me, it doesn't feel
- 54:59quite like the baby girl of it. Sure. That's
- 55:02my recollection of a movie that I saw two days
- 55:04ago. So that might change as I watch it a second
- 55:07time. My question for you, do you think if you
- 55:10watch it again and find more of that, that changes
- 55:11the rating for you? If anything, it might bump
- 55:14it up a half star for the display of the relationship
- 55:17with that dumb sub. Right. But the ending is
- 55:21still the ending. Sure. The third act is still
- 55:22the third act. But I just like the idea of being
- 55:26– like this movie is never going to come out
- 55:28and be like, here is a dom, here is a sub. Yes.
- 55:31Didn't exist back then. Exactly. Well, not on
- 55:34screen. The labeling. Right. Sure. But I just
- 55:38think it's cool to be able to interpret these
- 55:41movies with a modern lens. I think it makes them
- 55:44more accessible. Not only to us, but to people
- 55:46watching along with us. I mean, we talked about
- 55:49Farewell to Arms, a Farewell to Arms, and like
- 55:52the queer undertones between Adolph Manjoo and
- 55:56Gary Cooper. I was going to say Cary Grant. Gary
- 56:00Grant. Exactly. But, you know, in that movie,
- 56:04they're never going to dive into that. And the
- 56:05source material doesn't really present their
- 56:08relationship. in like a queer context but i think
- 56:11it's cool to be able to approach that and be
- 56:14like oh well maybe this adds a little bit something
- 56:17and it it gives you a way to enjoy the movies
- 56:21and engage with the movies it's nice to play
- 56:22therapist with these movies right because i think
- 56:25that there's a little bit of like well no i didn't
- 56:27like if you ask borzegi he's probably like well
- 56:29i didn't intend that was not an intentional thing
- 56:31sure yeah but it was there right And it's not
- 56:34like us leading the witness. Like it's more like
- 56:36it was, it's present in the text and maybe it's
- 56:39subconscious. Maybe it's, it's less, well, that's
- 56:41what I meant to do. And more like, I think it's
- 56:43consciously, I think that's what I meant to do.
- 56:44Cause that's how I'm writing characters. So it
- 56:47is really interesting to think about things a
- 56:48little more like deep, not deeply, but like.
- 56:50beyond what they intend and maybe it was like
- 56:53not even their attention but certainly present
- 56:55on screen so i'm happy to lean into that uh this
- 56:58is something that kind of stood out to me immediately
- 57:01of the movie not saying it so much but you can
- 57:03kind of read it yeah i i just think that's so
- 57:06cool i think it breathes new life into movies
- 57:10that people have started to dismiss Pretty heavily.
- 57:13That's true. And I don't mean to dismiss this
- 57:15one. It's just it did not work for me specifically.
- 57:17I wasn't referring to you. I just want to make
- 57:19it more clarifying for the audience. Sure. But
- 57:22awesome. I'm so glad you brought up Baby Girl.
- 57:24And great with music and lyrics. Great double
- 57:27feature pick as well. I'll try to bring up Baby
- 57:28Girl with more movies. Please do. Maybe we'll
- 57:31get a Baby Girl soundboard that we can just play.
- 57:35I'm terrified of what the audio clip is going
- 57:37to be. But I will be thinking of ideas for you.
- 57:41Perfect. Perfect. Maybe it's just lapping up
- 57:44milk from a sausage. Oh, God. I don't want that
- 57:47sound. I can get it out in the hallway real quick.
- 57:51I'll just find one of the cats and we'll just
- 57:53like double it up. I'm glad you said one of the
- 57:54cats. And you're just like, I got you, bro. It's
- 57:58the cats don't want to do it. I'm like, well,
- 58:00I'll do it myself. You put on the gauntlet, have
- 58:03nothing to do with your hands. And you're just
- 58:05like, well, I'm fine. That's my thing. You know
- 58:08what's so true? That is my Thanos moment of like.
- 58:11putting on the glove and be like fine i'll do
- 58:13it myself and just yeah just milk get down and
- 58:17this took a turn i regret you bringing up baby
- 58:21girl now well yeah as soon as you paid a compliment
- 58:23i was like he'll regret that so anyway that's
- 58:26one night of love and i would love to hear me
- 58:29in the milk sauce oh god We would love to hear
- 58:32what you thought of this movie if you sat down
- 58:34and you watched it and kind of how you I think
- 58:38the big takeaway for me in this episode is the
- 58:40being able to add context from 2026 into older
- 58:45films. Definitely. So if if you do that with
- 58:47this film or any other movie that we've covered
- 58:50on the show, I would love to hear about that.
- 58:51You can shoot us an email. Are you doing like
- 58:54a Claudette Colbert showing me your leg right
- 58:56now? I'm working on my knee. Oh, that's OK. I
- 58:59was like, yes, sure. We're going down a deep
- 59:02rabbit hole. No, I'm leaning into the baby girl
- 59:05a bit. But you can shoot us an email at OUTAOPodcast
- 59:08at gmail .com. My voice just did something really
- 59:11weird there. Also, if you're interested in supporting
- 59:14the show, we just did our watch party for the
- 59:17month. It was fantastic. If you want access to
- 59:19that watch party and any other perks like the
- 59:24Discord, our special... horror themed bonus podcast
- 59:29horror of the overlooked check out patreon .com
- 59:32slash o -u -t -a -o podcast also there's some
- 59:35exciting stuff happening with the podcast here
- 59:38shortly that I'm really looking forward to like
- 59:41revealing and talking about. So stay tuned for
- 59:43more of that. And I think it would also be beneficial
- 59:47if everyone followed us on Instagram, because
- 59:49I have a feeling that the opportunity you're
- 59:51talking about, it's going to come with a lot
- 59:52of great footage. I think so. So I would suggest
- 59:55that you follow us on Instagram so you can follow
- 59:57along with us as we make that journey. Yes. Thank
- 1:00:00you for plugging that. All of that information
- 1:00:02is down in the show notes as well. So check all
- 1:00:05of that out and give us a follow next episode.
- 1:00:07we will be covering Here Comes the Navy, which
- 1:00:10means we get to talk about James Cagney. I'm
- 1:00:12so excited. Yeah. We're also, you know, how rare
- 1:00:15that we get to talk about a military institution
- 1:00:16in a movie. This is true. Very excited for that.
- 1:00:19I'm also going to do my best not to do the village
- 1:00:21people in the Navy in the middle of this. So
- 1:00:24Godspeed. Please have your blessings up for me.
- 1:00:27Good luck. This is available video on demand.
- 1:00:29So if you want to rent it, you can check it out
- 1:00:31there. The movie. Yes. Yes. I was like, me comparing
- 1:00:35it to village people. Ryan doing all kinds of
- 1:00:38things for you folks at home with this episode.
- 1:00:41Yeah, I'm worried I'm going to be doing that.
- 1:00:43But stay tuned for that episode. As always, I'm
- 1:00:46your host, Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see you
- 1:00:48at the movies.