Latest / The Vegan Report / Abortion and Animal Rights. With Michael C. Dorf | Ep. 73
Transcript
- 0:00Back in 2016, Jerry Kolb and Michael Dorff published
- 0:05one of the most thought -provoking book in the
- 0:09animal rights world. It is called Beating Hearts
- 0:12and it attempts to resolve a challenging question.
- 0:16How can you condemn hunting, animal farming and
- 0:19animal experimentation while also favoring legal
- 0:23abortion, which is the deliberate destruction
- 0:26of a human fetus? If you are someone like me,
- 0:30who thinks abortion should be legal, but goes
- 0:33as far as not to even kill mosquitoes, then this
- 0:38issue hits home. But more than that, this book
- 0:41is the proof that the secular vegan philosophy
- 0:44and intellectual tradition has enough depth to
- 0:48tackle and appropriate itself some of the most
- 0:52complex and sensitive moral hot button issues
- 0:55of our time. To discuss the book, I have the
- 1:00honor to welcome the author himself, Michael
- 1:03Dorff, a Robert S. Stevens Professor of Law at
- 1:07Cornell University and long -time animal rights
- 1:10activist. Check out the episode notes for more
- 1:13details. And if you appreciate this conversation
- 1:17and my independent reporting of the animal rights
- 1:20world, then please share this episode with your
- 1:24fellow vegans. asked me before we started recording
- 1:29to talk a little bit about Sherry Kolb, who is
- 1:32my co -author on this book and who passed away
- 1:36in 2022. The book was published in 2016 and I
- 1:42thought I'd say a little bit about Sherry's work
- 1:44in animal rights. So first, both of us were trained
- 1:50as lawyers. We were colleagues for many years.
- 1:55and but also married. And we became vegans in
- 2:032006, but had been sort of moving in that direction
- 2:07in the way that a lot of people do over the better
- 2:10course of a decade in stages. Initially, we did
- 2:18so as a kind of personal choice. And over time,
- 2:25it became woven into our respective work. I would
- 2:28say more initially for Sherry than for me. If
- 2:33I think about the roots of Sherry's activism,
- 2:38she always loved animals. We had dogs, and she
- 2:41was very fond of animals as a kid. She actually
- 2:45is, I think I can say this, she's responsible.
- 2:50for a line in a Supreme Court case in 1993, long
- 2:54before she became vegan. So when Sherry was a
- 2:57law clerk for Justice Harry Blackmon on the U
- 3:00.S. Supreme Court, there was a case before the
- 3:02court called Church of Lakumi Babalu -I against
- 3:05Aylia. And the case posed the question whether
- 3:10a local law that forbade ritual animal slaughter
- 3:15was targeted at practitioners of Santeria. whether
- 3:18that law violated freedom of religion. And the
- 3:22Supreme Court unanimously said, yes, the law
- 3:25was unconstitutional because it singled out ritual
- 3:28slaughter as opposed to being a kind of general
- 3:30purpose anti -cruelty law. Justice Blackmun wrote
- 3:35a concurrence saying that, well, it would be
- 3:38a very different case if this were a law that
- 3:40was going after slaughter more generally on the
- 3:44grounds that it was inhumane. In that case, the
- 3:48government would have much stronger interest.
- 3:51He wrote that because Sherry pushed him to write
- 3:54it. And it's, you know, it's one of the very
- 3:57few expressions of what you might think of as
- 4:00animal welfare in the US Supreme Court case law.
- 4:04So I think Sherry was kind of a proto vegan.
- 4:06already. But what sort of pushed her and therefore
- 4:12me into veganism and then the animal rights movement
- 4:15was that she was for many years colleagues with
- 4:18Gary Francione at the Rutgers law school. And
- 4:24Gary is of course a well -known author and animal
- 4:30rights activist. He wasn't that, I would say,
- 4:35much of an advocate with his colleagues, I think
- 4:37because he didn't think there was much of a hope.
- 4:41But Sherry was sympathetic to him from the beginning.
- 4:43She started working there in 1995. And one way
- 4:48you saw it was she would sometimes bake cookies
- 4:51for the faculty. And because she wanted to include
- 4:55Gary, she always made them vegan, too. And that,
- 4:59I think, planted a seed. There was no exact turning
- 5:05point for veganism, but we sort of, as I said,
- 5:08gradually got there in 2006. And then after we
- 5:11moved to Ithaca, we sort of joined the local
- 5:15vegan community, which included a number of very
- 5:18prominent people. So Colin Campbell, who's most
- 5:22famous for the China study, lives in Ithaca.
- 5:27There's a farm sanctuary is a 40 minute drive
- 5:31away in Watkins Glen. The filmmakers, James Labeck
- 5:37and Jenny Stein live here. A friend of ours,
- 5:41Amy Hamlin, who runs something called the Coalition
- 5:44for Healthy School Foods, which promotes plant
- 5:47based foods in public schools. lives here. So
- 5:50we became friends with all of these people. And
- 5:52one of the things they encouraged us to do was
- 5:54to go to something called Vegan Summerfest. At
- 5:57the time, it was called Vegetarian Summerfest,
- 5:59although it was purely vegan. And there, we were
- 6:03exposed to just many more people in the movement.
- 6:08And that led Sherry to decide she wanted to offer
- 6:12a class in animal rights. A lot of law schools
- 6:15offer classes in animal law. But Her view at
- 6:20the time i think this was true for her throughout
- 6:22her life was that the law was not a very powerful
- 6:25instrument for bringing about change for animals
- 6:29mostly because. It's very difficult to enforce
- 6:33laws that go very far beyond where people are
- 6:38in their own social attitudes and so she thought
- 6:41that if you wanted to make real progress you
- 6:43had to at least start with working on people's.
- 6:47viewpoints. And so she taught this class in animal
- 6:51rights for many, many years. She brought in guest
- 6:54speakers, many of whom we met at Summerfest.
- 6:58And, you know, they had a lot of various perspectives.
- 7:02We met lots of interesting people in the movement.
- 7:05And that led to Sherry's first book, which was
- 7:09not her first book, but her first book on animal
- 7:10rights, which was called Mind If I Order the
- 7:15Cheeseburger. and other questions people ask
- 7:17vegans and what that book does in uh 13 chapters
- 7:21is it poses questions that people commonly ask
- 7:25like you know where do you get your protein um
- 7:29uh isn't it you know if other animals eat animals
- 7:32why is it wrong for humans to eat animals these
- 7:34sorts of things some of which are often posed
- 7:37as gacha questions or not in good faith but the
- 7:42point of her book was to take these questions
- 7:43seriously to treat them, regardless of how they
- 7:46might be asked any given person, as though they
- 7:50were being asked in good faith, and then really
- 7:52grapple with them. One of the questions that
- 7:56was posed in that book is, are you pro -life?
- 8:01Because that was a question we had encountered
- 8:03from i think some people who were pro -choice
- 8:07on abortion and wanted just sort of wanted to
- 8:10know well is does your theory lead to this other
- 8:12position and some who were in fact pro -life
- 8:15on abortion uh but were part of the animal rights
- 8:19movement so uh you can think of someone like
- 8:21matthew scully i mean he wasn't the actual person
- 8:23who posed that question to sherry but other people
- 8:25did and um she has a kind of uh the kernel of
- 8:31the argument that we would unpack at greater
- 8:35length in Beating Hearts in that chapter of Mind
- 8:39If I Order the Cheeseburger. In addition to the
- 8:43chapters in Mind If I Order the Cheeseburger,
- 8:45Sheri had all sorts of interesting ideas about
- 8:48veganism and animal rights, which she wrote about
- 8:50both in academic work that appears in scholarly
- 8:55journals and in more popular work. She and I,
- 9:00for many years, I still do this. publish a bi
- 9:03-weekly columns first in something called Find
- 9:06Law and for the last 15 years or so in a journal
- 9:11called Verdict. And in addition to that, I have
- 9:15a blog for which I write two or three times a
- 9:20week, and Sherry used to write every other week.
- 9:22So she would explore almost all sorts of things.
- 9:25She had a number of interesting essays about
- 9:29the relation between various religious practices
- 9:33and veganism. She was quite interested in how
- 9:39different movements responded and worked together.
- 9:44So she would draw parallels between the LGBTQ
- 9:48rights movement and animal rights. And so she,
- 9:53you know, I think she sort of covered the waterfront
- 9:56during the period in which she was actively thinking
- 10:00and writing about animal rights. Admirable. Thank
- 10:04you so much for sharing that about Sherry. And
- 10:08I'm impatient to get into the topic of the book,
- 10:12Beating Hearts. But first, I want to have maybe
- 10:17your opinion as a lawyer and as a professor of
- 10:20law about the expression, the term animal rights.
- 10:25I'm meeting more and more activists in the animal
- 10:29rights animal liberation space who are taking
- 10:32their distance away from that expression and
- 10:35who would rather prefer to use vegan or veganism
- 10:40instead of talking about animal rights because
- 10:44they feel you know it's a bit too much detached
- 10:48from the reality of people and that maybe there's
- 10:52Like you said, no future in advancing the animal
- 10:55cause on the legal front. What do you make of
- 11:00that and of the term animal rights? Yeah. So
- 11:06I want to answer that question in a second, but
- 11:08first I want to just clarify. I don't think there's
- 11:11no future in advancing the cause of animals through
- 11:14the law. I think that I would qualify that in
- 11:17two ways. So the contention, which was Sherry's,
- 11:20but I largely share this. is that it will be
- 11:24difficult to make a whole lot of progress now
- 11:27through laws that do what we really want them
- 11:30to do, because to get those enacted, you would
- 11:33need much more support than they currently have.
- 11:35But I think there are at least two ways in which
- 11:38law can be useful. One is we can think long term
- 11:41that eventually, once people's hearts and minds
- 11:44have been changed, it might be possible to enact
- 11:47laws that do have serious teeth. And the second
- 11:52is that, you know, I don't think of legal reform,
- 11:56whether through legislation, referenda, or court
- 12:00cases, as operating separate from social and
- 12:06political activism, so that litigation or a campaign
- 12:11for legal change can be a kind of social activism,
- 12:16so that even if what you're seeking is relatively
- 12:19modest, You know, getting rid of battery cages,
- 12:23for example, or as in the case of litigate the
- 12:27litigation, you're just trying to have this these
- 12:29particular elephants moved to a sanctuary rather
- 12:32than kept in a zoo or other form of captivity.
- 12:35And even if you fail, the campaign itself can
- 12:40move the needle by changing people's minds and
- 12:45therefore Laying the foundation for further change
- 12:49so I should say that about about the law coming
- 12:52directly to your question I Don't have a strong
- 12:57view about the nomenclature You know the Until
- 13:05very recently I and and you know for a while
- 13:08now I've heard people not want to use the word
- 13:10vegan because they fear that it turns people
- 13:14off I don't love the word the term plant -based
- 13:17only because it's misleading. So my friend and
- 13:21fellow activist, Victoria Moran, likes to use
- 13:26the term plant -exclusive rather than plant -based
- 13:30because it's more accurate. Because I've seen
- 13:33products labeled plant -based that contain some
- 13:36animal products. It's like, well, the base is
- 13:38plants. It's then the additional thing. So I
- 13:40think any term one uses, whether it's vegan,
- 13:44animal rights, plant -based, or something else,
- 13:49is going to potentially have two problems. One
- 13:53is that it might not be exactly accurate in capturing
- 13:56everything that the people who want to use it
- 14:00want to project to the term. And the other is
- 14:04words can take on a kind of guilt by association,
- 14:10so that if there are negative attitudes towards
- 14:12a term, even if it's inherently unproblematic,
- 14:16there might be tactical or strategic reasons
- 14:19to move away from it. You see this sometimes
- 14:21moving outside of this particular realm. You
- 14:23see this sometimes with the way in which the
- 14:26preferred term for a group that suffers some
- 14:29form of systemic discrimination or subordination
- 14:33will want to change the name because A stigma
- 14:37becomes associated with the term, even though
- 14:39the term is not inherently offensive. It becomes
- 14:44offensive because a lot of the people who are
- 14:46using it at a particular time have discriminatory
- 14:51attitudes about it. And so that might be some
- 14:53of what's going on with animal rights versus
- 14:55something else. My own preference would be to
- 14:59use whatever term is going to be most effective
- 15:02at building support for the shared goals of the
- 15:06movement. Okay, let's get to the book now. I
- 15:12before reading your book, I have to say I never
- 15:16really thought a lot about abortion and the debate,
- 15:22you know, pro choice, pro life. Um, I live in
- 15:26Canada. I live in Quebec. Uh, this, this is not
- 15:30part of the, uh, political culture here to, to
- 15:34debate this. Um, uh, and so I never, this was
- 15:39never top of mind, not like in America, but I
- 15:44always got, you know, the impression that this
- 15:46was very, um, um, you know, this rattles people
- 15:53and, uh, you know, triggers lots of reactions.
- 15:59So I guess my first question about the book is,
- 16:03did you have conversations about maybe hesitations
- 16:07about not publishing the book in fear of the
- 16:12kind of reception you would get from publishing
- 16:15this book touching to this turled rail issue?
- 16:20And also, what kind of reception did you get
- 16:23once you published the book? Yeah. So the short
- 16:28answer is no, not really. I mean, we're both
- 16:32academics and I think we we consider ourselves
- 16:37activists, but we're careful in our scholarly
- 16:41work to make claims that are backed by good arguments
- 16:48and good citations and what have you, and that
- 16:53sometimes will lead me, and this was true of
- 16:56Sherry as well, to take positions that might
- 17:00not be especially popular with our friends as
- 17:04well as with people with whom we more often disagree.
- 17:10So we didn't really worry too much about that.
- 17:14I have also I had written about abortion in my
- 17:20scholarly work as had Sherry and a lot of different
- 17:23articles and so forth and I think that no one
- 17:29who knew us would be surprised that this was
- 17:33an issue we were discussing. We did have a worry
- 17:36a little bit about whether it made sense as a
- 17:41kind of uh... tactical matter if we're thinking
- 17:44of ourselves as advocates for animals or advocates
- 17:49for whatever position we're going to be proposing
- 17:51on abortion to combine the two because you know
- 17:54it's a little bit like uh... you know you take
- 17:57a controversial subject and you what you normally
- 17:59the way you wanna persuade somebody of your view
- 18:03is to find an area of agreement and then show
- 18:07how their agreement on Here, we're taking y and
- 18:14saying, well, here's something else you don't
- 18:15agree with us on, potentially. And so that seems
- 18:17kind of backwards as an advocacy strategy. But
- 18:20I have to say, we really didn't think about it
- 18:23as advocacy. As far as the reception goes, I
- 18:29think it was generally quite positive. I have
- 18:34two caveats about that. One is we didn't think
- 18:39about it We went back and forth with the publisher
- 18:41over the cover illustration because the the cover
- 18:46illustration includes a human baby not like a
- 18:49fetus or an embryo and I think that led some
- 18:53people who didn't read the book to think that
- 18:55this was a sort of strongly anti -abortion book
- 18:57which it is not and so I actually had one conversation
- 19:01with somebody who was who had that view and i
- 19:04tried to you know explain to her no no that's
- 19:05not what's going on there and um but the the
- 19:09the marketing people persuaded us that this was
- 19:12better than any of the ideas we came up with
- 19:14for cover illustrations um i would say that people
- 19:20who are sort of uh whose first commitment is
- 19:24to animals and like you you might have thought
- 19:28about abortion issue might have some position
- 19:31about it but it's not something that is sort
- 19:32of an animating issue for them really like the
- 19:36book they thought oh this is interesting you're
- 19:37shedding interesting light back and forth for
- 19:40people who um came to the book with um i think
- 19:46strong views about abortion if they were pro
- 19:51-choice i think they were initially a little
- 19:56bit put off but then generally came around and
- 19:58sort of liked our arguments. And I think the
- 20:01opposite is true of people who are pro -life.
- 20:02That is, I think people who are pro -life, there
- 20:06were a few who I thought took, who said, and
- 20:10I appreciated this, well, I don't agree with
- 20:12you, but at least you're giving our argument,
- 20:17you're taking our argument seriously and you're
- 20:19not responding to a straw man version of it.
- 20:22And, you know, that to me is about what I would
- 20:25expect. So I didn't expect that we would persuade
- 20:30anybody who was strongly opposed to abortion
- 20:32to change their view about that from this book.
- 20:35But it was our hope that we would sort of feel
- 20:40the force of arguments on all sides of their
- 20:43respective issues. I should say, all sides, I
- 20:48actually don't think there are any very good
- 20:49arguments against the animal rights position.
- 20:53So I'm open to feeling the force of contrary
- 20:56arguments. I just didn't see any here that I
- 20:59don't find. I tend to find that people who are
- 21:03opposed to the kind of, you know, sort of minimal
- 21:06rights for animals are engaged in rationalization
- 21:09rather than, you know, building serious arguments.
- 21:13I agree with what that person said about the
- 21:19straw man argument. I really feel like in your
- 21:22book, you're making the best pro choice argument
- 21:25because you are addressing the real arguments
- 21:29coming from the pro -life people. You know, you
- 21:34take them seriously, yes, but what's most important
- 21:38is you represent their argument well. And I really
- 21:44realized, you know, from reading the book that
- 21:46I had been fed a caricature version of what was
- 21:52a pro -life person. I really had, and that's
- 21:58the best word for it, a caricature in my head
- 22:00of, you know, who, like in the beginning of your
- 22:04book, you talk about how most pro -life people
- 22:08are pro -life for religious reason, and they
- 22:11have nothing to do with, you know, they have
- 22:13not thought about the question of sentience.
- 22:15And that's what I had in my mind, you know, someone
- 22:18like deeply religious or fanatic who hates women.
- 22:24And that's what, you know, gets you to believe
- 22:30that pro -life is a good stance. But yeah, you
- 22:36really represented well. We should clarify. What
- 22:40is your position on abortion? So The view that
- 22:45Sherry and I defend in the book is that abortions
- 22:50before fetal sentience which is that you can
- 22:56There is a range of legitimate scientific argument
- 23:00about when exactly fetus is attained sentience,
- 23:02but it's it's certainly well past the point at
- 23:06which about 90 % of abortions in North America
- 23:09occur. But our view is that abortions before
- 23:13fetal sentience do not raise serious moral questions.
- 23:19Abortions after fetal sentience do raise serious
- 23:24moral questions and that therefore someone deciding
- 23:28whether to have an abortion of a sentient fetus
- 23:33uh first of all has a kind of moral duty to try
- 23:35to make that decision before fetal sentience
- 23:37but you can't always sometimes there are circumstances
- 23:40that arise late in pregnancy but that there is
- 23:44a kind of personal moral duty to give serious
- 23:49weight to the fetus's interest if one is going
- 23:52to have an abortion after fetal sentience but
- 23:57that still doesn't answer the question of what
- 24:00position the law ought to take on abortion because
- 24:04there are many things, there are many areas of
- 24:07life where one has a moral duty to take seriously
- 24:11some matter, but if one takes it seriously or
- 24:16even if one doesn't take it seriously and makes
- 24:18a kind of moral mistake, we don't necessarily
- 24:21think that justifies the state in intervening.
- 24:25So our view is that in general abortion up until
- 24:33fairly late in pregnancy ought to be legal, but
- 24:37that people ought to take seriously their moral
- 24:40duties with respect to abortion of sentient fetuses.
- 24:45So when you say sentience, what do you mean by
- 24:48that? Yeah. So sentience is the ability to have
- 24:55and the having of subjective experiences such
- 24:58as pleasure, pain, excitement, thoughts, etc.
- 25:04It's the difference between something and someone.
- 25:08It's a sort of a first -person subjective consciousness.
- 25:11It's a synonym for rough synonym for consciousness.
- 25:14The reason I prefer the term sentience although
- 25:16maybe I shouldn't because a lot of people who
- 25:18aren't in the animal movement don't know the
- 25:21word but the reason I prefer sentience is that
- 25:23consciousness I think tends to signify more of
- 25:28a kind of rational thought process and a being
- 25:31need not be rational in the way that you know
- 25:34we think of like a you know a philosophy professor
- 25:36uh in order to be sentient so um it's basically
- 25:41what distinguishes most animal life from you
- 25:46know, just about all plants, as far as we're
- 25:48aware, all plant life and inanimate objects.
- 25:52Okay, so you mentioned how sentience is, yes,
- 25:56a very well known popular word used in the animal
- 26:01rights world. How did you tie this term of sentience
- 26:08to? What is the link between that to, you know,
- 26:15abortion, or since we're talking about abortion,
- 26:18how did you tie that, you know, concept of sentience
- 26:22to, you know, talking about the fetus to animals?
- 26:27Sure. So the first thing to note right is that
- 26:35this is the Using sentience as the basis for
- 26:40rights is hardly something we came up with, right?
- 26:42This is a common view among people who support
- 26:45animal rights, and it goes back quite far. If
- 26:51you think about Jeremy Bentham's famous line,
- 26:55the question is not can they think, but can they
- 26:57suffer? And it's a little weird to think about
- 27:01animal rights and then talk about Bentham because
- 27:03Bentham was a utilitarian who famously derided
- 27:06the whole idea of rights as nonsense on stilts.
- 27:09But nonetheless, Peter Singer is also a utilitarian
- 27:12and he's associated with the animal rights movement
- 27:14as well. And so the idea is that beings who are
- 27:22capable of suffering should not be unnecessarily
- 27:27made to suffer. That's the sort of, I think,
- 27:29the core of the animal rights idea. It's also,
- 27:33you can find it in many religions. It's most
- 27:38clearly in the idea of Ahimsa and the Indian
- 27:42religions. But it doesn't have to be a religious
- 27:45idea. It could just simply be, if there's any
- 27:48kind of moral principle, you shouldn't unnecessarily
- 27:51inflict suffering on a being capable of suffering
- 27:54and and this takes an additional logical step
- 27:58which we can talk about later um likewise a being
- 28:02capable of experiencing pleasure or pleasurable
- 28:05experiences or or deriving something positive
- 28:08out of its life shouldn't be deprived of its
- 28:11life either and both of those principles i think
- 28:15are in play not only with respect to the duties
- 28:20we humans owe to animals but also with respect
- 28:23to whatever duties we owe to human fetuses. After
- 28:27all, a human fetus that is capable of experiencing
- 28:33pain or is capable of having subjective experiences
- 28:38more generally seems to have the same kinds of
- 28:41interests in both avoiding the painful experience
- 28:44and in continuing to exist as would a non -human
- 28:48animal like a chicken or a pig or what have you.
- 28:52So it seemed to us just quite logical that these
- 28:55ought to be connected. And we also noticed that
- 28:59a lot of the pro -life advocacy that aims at
- 29:05people sort of in the middle, that is to say,
- 29:07not people who have strong religious commitments
- 29:11that they believe in the insolment of a zygote,
- 29:15but people who, you know, just sort of don't
- 29:18think about it much, that a lot of the the argument
- 29:21aimed at them works in this register of avoiding
- 29:27inflicting suffering. So one of the things that
- 29:31we saw in the United States over the course of
- 29:34several decades were campaigns to enact laws
- 29:42and also to public information campaigns about
- 29:47fetal pain. Right? So there was legislation in
- 29:53various US states. There was a bill introduced
- 29:56in the National Congress to ban, quote, pain
- 30:01-capable abortions. That is to say, abortions
- 30:04of fetuses capable of experiencing pain. And
- 30:08I think that reflected a recognition that, at
- 30:12least for a lot of the audience for the debate
- 30:15about abortion, people cared about abortion or
- 30:20didn't care about abortion, whether or not they
- 30:22imagined the infliction of pain or other suffering
- 30:26on a fetus, right? And so it does seem to us
- 30:31that putting aside distinctly religious views,
- 30:36the secular argument against abortion looks very
- 30:41much like the argument for respecting animals.
- 30:48If I had to summarize what you just said, um,
- 30:54you looked at people who cared about, uh, you
- 31:00know, fetus abortions, all of that, since we
- 31:04are humans, uh, since, uh, they are Americans.
- 31:08Um, and you explain why they care about it by
- 31:14talking about sentience and then you tie it to
- 31:20the animal rights movement for them. Is that
- 31:24a good summary? Yeah. So I think that's right.
- 31:27With the possible exception of that, I don't
- 31:31know that that's why all of them care about it.
- 31:34I'm sure that's not why all of them care about
- 31:36it. As you were saying, you know, many people
- 31:39might hold these these views simply because that's
- 31:41what their religion tells them. But I think that
- 31:45it's certainly true that some of them have a
- 31:48this view for that reason and certainly you see
- 31:51it in the kinds of arguments that they make and
- 31:53so again much like you know sherry's book on
- 31:57um you know mind if i were the cheeseburger right
- 32:00the goal here is to take this seriously and respond
- 32:04to what is sometimes called the steel man as
- 32:07opposed to the straw man version of the argument
- 32:09by the way i should say that here in quebec uh
- 32:14abortion is legal up until nine months. So kind
- 32:19of a strange situation. What do you make of those
- 32:23people? And you touched on that in the book,
- 32:27who believe that humans are special, their own,
- 32:33our own kind, you know, it is, they justify it,
- 32:38their views with religion. And so, yeah, humans
- 32:45are special, they are unique, and we should not,
- 32:50you know, mix that with the rest of the animal
- 32:53kingdom. Basically going against what Darwin
- 32:58was saying about humans and the rest of animals,
- 33:02you know, there's a difference of degrees and
- 33:04not of nature. Well, those people say there's
- 33:06a difference of nature. What do you make of that?
- 33:10Yeah, so I mean, I think that if somebody is
- 33:15asserting that as a matter of religious doctrine,
- 33:21there are really two kinds of responses one can
- 33:24make. One is somebody who falls within the same
- 33:30religious tradition, I think can usually point
- 33:33to resources within that religious tradition
- 33:36for why this is a mistake. So that in just about
- 33:42every religious tradition, there are resources
- 33:48for showing kindness to animals. It's very, very
- 33:52clear in the Eastern religions, especially those
- 33:56that believe in reincarnation and the possibility
- 33:58that one's soul could have come from or end up
- 34:01in a non -human animal. It's within the Christian
- 34:06tradition. The current pope, Pope Francis, took
- 34:12his name from Francis of Assisi, who is known
- 34:15for his kindness to animals. In both Judaism
- 34:22and Islam, the rules around slaughter of animals,
- 34:27both permit slaughter of animals, but both kosher
- 34:31laws and halal are thought to be partly about
- 34:37reducing cruelty to animals. And so even if one
- 34:43begins with a sort of strongly religious basis
- 34:48for one's morality, that's not a reason to unnecessarily
- 34:55harm animals. In fact, it's the opposite, right?
- 34:58So that's one kind of an argument within that
- 35:03area. And then one can say, look, we're not saying
- 35:07that necessarily that non -human animals are
- 35:10the same as humans in all respects, and maybe
- 35:14not even in what you think of as the most important
- 35:16respect, but just in one respect that you care
- 35:20about. And so the same sort of compassionate
- 35:24motives you might have for being against abortion
- 35:27can apply to not participating in various forms
- 35:31of animal exploitation. The other thing one can
- 35:35do, and this, I think, is going to be more or
- 35:38less effective, depending on one's audience,
- 35:42is to say something like, well, look, we live
- 35:45in a religiously diverse society in which people
- 35:49come from a variety of faiths or no faith at
- 35:52all. And so if we're going to have a public debate,
- 35:56we have to restrict ourselves to what John Rawls
- 35:59called public reason. And that means particularly
- 36:02sectarian arguments are out of bounds, at least
- 36:06as a basis for public regulation. Although, of
- 36:10course, they could be a basis for particular
- 36:12as individual moral choices. And so therefore,
- 36:17let's bracket those. If I can, I want to make
- 36:24one analogy, which is I think that some of what
- 36:29you're talking about, the idea that it's almost
- 36:31offensive from a religious person's perspective
- 36:34to be talking about the rights of fetuses in
- 36:38the same breath as the rights of chickens or
- 36:40cows or pigs. I think that is a kind of reaction
- 36:45that one sometimes sees in other forms of animal
- 36:50advocacy that compare the treatment of non -human
- 36:55animals to historic injustices against human
- 36:58beings like slavery or the Holocaust or what
- 37:01have you and I understand why as a tactical matter
- 37:07therefore one should be very careful about drawing
- 37:11such analogies but I think the people who are
- 37:16taking offense are misunderstanding the way in
- 37:21which the argument is being made right when if
- 37:23somebody says that what's happening to animals
- 37:28on farms and slaughterhouses is comparable to
- 37:35slavery or the Holocaust. They're not trying
- 37:36to minimize slavery or the Holocaust. They're
- 37:39not trying to say that people who were enslaved
- 37:42or people who were victims of genocide were as
- 37:48worthless as animals. It's because the people
- 37:51making this comparison think of non -human animals
- 37:54as having great worth that we think of it as
- 37:58comparable. So to my mind, there is at best a
- 38:02tactical reason to avoid drawing these sorts
- 38:05of analogies because it's not effective advocacy
- 38:08to offend people, even if people ideally shouldn't
- 38:12be offended by the argument you're making. I
- 38:15agree that you don't want to start a conversation.
- 38:20Well, it's difficult to have a conversation if
- 38:22you start with something. Judge offensive, but
- 38:26at the same time Don't you want to get personal
- 38:33right away with people and you know Get at the
- 38:38heart of it and and the best way to do it is
- 38:43Really to touch on some issues such as abortion
- 38:47I Guess my question is uh, if done in a thoughtful
- 38:55manner, um, shouldn't more activists not shy
- 39:01away from, um, addressing, you know, um, doing
- 39:05your argument, the argument you're making in
- 39:07the book and talking about abortion, um, or discussing,
- 39:12um, you know, the Holocaust as it is done in,
- 39:16um, the book, uh, an internal Treblinka, um,
- 39:23because they would catch the attention of people
- 39:26much more quickly and get them to think maybe
- 39:30more profoundly on those issues. Or is it a miscalculation
- 39:37on my part? Yeah. So I don't think there, you
- 39:41know, there's a lot of research now being done
- 39:45by people in the animal rights movement about
- 39:47what kinds of advocacy are most effective. You
- 39:51know, one thing we learned is that something
- 39:53I wouldn't have thought turns out to be true,
- 39:55which is that showing people really graphic imagery
- 40:00of, you know, what happens in a slaughterhouse
- 40:03is pretty effective, at least in the short run,
- 40:09at sort of shocking people. And, you know, I
- 40:14looked at that data and I, you know, I have to
- 40:16confess I think it's right that that probably
- 40:19does work. I don't know that there has been similar
- 40:24research backing up the kinds of what people
- 40:28think of as provocative analogies. There was
- 40:32a case about a decade ago in Germany in which
- 40:37the German branch of PETA had these billboards
- 40:40that said Holocaust on your plate. And they were
- 40:44actually prosecuted under, you know, because
- 40:47Germany has very strict laws about Nazism and
- 40:53so forth. And of course, it was a complete misunderstanding
- 40:56of what PETA was trying to do. But it might not
- 41:00have been very effective advocacy for PETA in
- 41:04Germany then. So I don't think that there is
- 41:11a Definite answer to your question at this point
- 41:15I think some people are going to find that kind
- 41:18of advocacy more effective or less effective
- 41:20with particular audiences You know certainly
- 41:25One wants to reach people at a personal level
- 41:30and one way to do that is to find some personal
- 41:33connection It could be through an issue that
- 41:36your interlocutor cares about if that's abortion
- 41:40for example but it could be through something
- 41:43that you know some other shared view like you
- 41:45know person who has a companion animal like a
- 41:47dog or a cat and will almost invariably you know
- 41:52sympathize and empathize with dogs and cats and
- 41:56so that's often a gateway in Now, how far it
- 42:00gets you is not entirely clear. But again, this
- 42:03is an area that I haven't studied directly, but
- 42:06I have seen some of the studies. And I think
- 42:08they're somewhat inconclusive. But there's an
- 42:12emerging picture. And I would urge any advocate
- 42:16who's comfortable in adopting a variety of tactics
- 42:19to look at the data we have and sort of see what
- 42:22they think they can be most effective doing.
- 42:25Yeah, I think that's what's lacking. the desire
- 42:28to even explore that, because I guess even activists
- 42:33putting themselves out there don't want to be
- 42:36in that discomfort, this very, yeah, uncomfortable
- 42:41situation of having to talk about abortion or,
- 42:46you know, drawing parallels with the Holocaust.
- 42:49Like, yeah, and I would understand that, you
- 42:53know, the how this tasteful, it sounds for certain
- 42:59activists or volunteers to organizations to to
- 43:02go there. And right. No. So again, I mean, I'm
- 43:07sometimes when I'm asked this kind of a question
- 43:11and I've done presentations on effective advocacy,
- 43:14which I sort of try to summarize what the latest
- 43:17data say is I sometimes end by telling people
- 43:21in the end, you don't really need to worry about
- 43:24it too much because like any movement, the animal
- 43:29rights, animal protection, animal welfare movement,
- 43:33as a very wide array of people with both with
- 43:38respect to what they think the goal is and with
- 43:40respect to what they think the means of achieving
- 43:43that goal are. And so it's not like there's some
- 43:48central command that's now telling all the activists,
- 43:52okay, this is the way we're going to make our
- 43:54arguments. people will end up doing a variety
- 43:59of things. I guess I don't know that drawing
- 44:05these analogies is necessarily helpful, but if
- 44:08someone's comfortable doing it and they think
- 44:10it's going to be effective, that will be a reason
- 44:12to go ahead. I should say that, again, we didn't
- 44:16write that book because we thought that bringing
- 44:20up abortion was an especially effective means
- 44:24of advocating for the rights of animals. I think
- 44:27we did have in mind that some people who had
- 44:31an interest in the abortion issue would read
- 44:33our book and they might or might not come away
- 44:36convinced about anything we said about abortion,
- 44:39but might in the process have learned something
- 44:41about the treatment of animals and that might
- 44:42affect how they thought and behaved with respect
- 44:44to animals. But it was not primarily conceived
- 44:48of as a way of leveraging the abortion issue
- 44:52to Make a bunch of points about animals. Certainly
- 44:56not. And, uh, yeah, I guess my point is, um,
- 45:00it's in your arsenal, those, you know, beating
- 45:02hearts exists, dominion exists. And you know,
- 45:06there are, this is part of your arsenal as an
- 45:10activist. Um, and you should be aware of them
- 45:12because I have now mentioned your book to many
- 45:15people. Thank you. Of course. Uh, and you know,
- 45:21it surprises me how there are, you know, street
- 45:24activists who have done this for the last 10
- 45:26years who have not read beating hearts. And,
- 45:30um, yeah, it's like, it's in your arsenal. You
- 45:33should know the argument about abortions and,
- 45:36and, you know, uh, yeah. Um, okay. Now you mentioned
- 45:43that, um, uh, how, you know, the footage. of
- 45:49animals being slaughtered was effective in getting
- 45:53people interested in the cause and in becoming
- 45:56vegan. Now, it is also a strategy used by pro
- 46:01-life people. And this is my favorite part in
- 46:05the book, how you draw those parallels between
- 46:09pro -life activists and animal rights activists.
- 46:12And I would love if you could... draw some more
- 46:17of those parallels and talk about why is it important
- 46:20to to explore that? Sure. So just for those for
- 46:26people who haven't read the book, or aren't familiar
- 46:29with it, it's divided into two parts, what I
- 46:31would call sort of philosophy, which is the first
- 46:3460 % of the book, and then some strategy, which
- 46:38is the remaining 40 % or so of the book. And
- 46:42so the philosophy part is all about, you know,
- 46:46How do you reconcile various views about abortion
- 46:49with various views about animal rights? What's
- 46:52the relevance or irrelevance of belonging to
- 46:55the human family as opposed to some other species?
- 46:59But then we turn in the back half of the book
- 47:03to noting ways in which there are similar advocacy
- 47:11challenges for Both the pro -life and animal
- 47:16rights movement and that's a that's a switch
- 47:18because for the most part in the first part of
- 47:20the book we are Although we analogize at first
- 47:25the pro -life position to the animal rights position.
- 47:28We end up ultimately inverting that and defending
- 47:31a Pretty pretty conventional pro -choice view
- 47:34and reconciling that with animal rights, but
- 47:37but the the parallels in tactics do correspond
- 47:44with pro -life movement and the animal rights
- 47:46movement. And there are two main ones that I
- 47:49would focus on, one of which is the one you mentioned,
- 47:52which is it is notoriously true that the anti
- 47:58-abortion movement will, in various circumstances,
- 48:03either hold up or otherwise display or publicize
- 48:06pictures of aborted fetuses. And these are meant
- 48:10to be very disturbing images. And likewise, some
- 48:16people in the animal rights movement will either
- 48:18hold up pictures or try to get people to watch
- 48:21videos of what happens to animals during slaughter
- 48:26and other processes. A couple of things I'd say.
- 48:31So first, you know one of the problematic aspects
- 48:35of the way in which that is leveraged by the
- 48:38anti -abortion movement is those are typically
- 48:41pictures of late -term abortions but the movement
- 48:46aims to ban abortion from the very beginning
- 48:49of pregnancy and so there's a a bit of dishonesty
- 48:53i think in that it's not you know i think those
- 48:56images would be appropriate as a part of an argument
- 49:01for addressing later term abortion, but less
- 49:04so for the sort of broad ban on abortion. And
- 49:08I don't think that's true of the footage with
- 49:10respect to animals. Second thing I want to say
- 49:14about images is there is, I think, a kind of
- 49:22prima facie moral question, which is that people
- 49:26are going about their business and they've got
- 49:29you know everyone's got complicated lives they've
- 49:32got their own challenges and then as an activist
- 49:35you know you you confront them with something
- 49:37extremely upsetting and you're doing harm when
- 49:41you do that uh and so i think you have to have
- 49:44a good reason to do that kind of harm um you
- 49:48know in the same way that i think it's wrong
- 49:51to unnecessarily harm non -human animals well
- 49:54humans are animals too if i'm harming a human
- 49:56by upsetting them then I need a good reason to
- 49:59do that so the good reason has to be well they
- 50:04are participating in a very harmful activity
- 50:08themselves and I'm hoping that by doing them
- 50:13this short -term harm I'm going to change their
- 50:17mind and thus change their behavior so but there
- 50:19is that kind of a sort of moral calculus there.
- 50:23And I think that that's a, you know, something
- 50:26that you have to take seriously. Again, the data
- 50:33I know of about the efficacy of showing people
- 50:38graphic imagery, post dates when we wrote that
- 50:41book. So I think if I were to revisit that chapter
- 50:45today, I would come down more firmly in favor
- 50:50of saying, yeah, this is something that it's
- 50:52fine to do, not because you're not doing harm
- 50:54to people by upsetting them, but because it's
- 50:57more justified because it's efficacious, right?
- 51:01The fact that you have a noble cause isn't a
- 51:03sufficient reason. It's got to be that you have
- 51:04a noble cause and it's likely to have some sort
- 51:06of an impact. So that's with respect to images.
- 51:11I can stop there and ask if you have follow up
- 51:13questions about that, or I can talk a little
- 51:15bit about violence if you want. No, please go
- 51:18ahead with violence. Okay. So the right. So the
- 51:20other parallel is the question of what role,
- 51:25if any violence plays in these respective movements.
- 51:29Um, because, uh, critics of both the pro -life
- 51:34movement and the animal rights movement, uh,
- 51:37have argued, uh, with varying degrees of accuracy
- 51:42that these are extremists who are, you know,
- 51:46causing serious harm and so one of the things
- 51:49we do purely for the sake of argument before
- 51:52we get into that is to ask the question well
- 51:55is violence morally justified uh that is to say
- 52:00you know if currently someone were doing to humans
- 52:06what happens routinely to non -human animals
- 52:09you know throughout the world uh i think most
- 52:13of us would say it is morally justified at the
- 52:17very least to violate property rights and to
- 52:21cause some you know property destruction to rescue
- 52:25as many humans as one can from that kind of horrible
- 52:30treatment and eventual death and so if you're
- 52:35a serious you know animal activist why not do
- 52:39that isn't it morally justified even if you don't
- 52:41want to go to prison? And so you might not do
- 52:43it for pragmatic reasons. And likewise, you could
- 52:46ask the same thing about an anti -abortion activist
- 52:49who believes abortion is morally equivalent to
- 52:52murder. You would take many steps, including
- 52:56physical intervention, to stop someone from committing
- 53:01murder of a fully -born, living human being.
- 53:04And so just as a logical matter, right, it does
- 53:08seem like if one accepts the premises then violence
- 53:13is morally justified even if it might not be
- 53:15legally justified. We don't really engage with
- 53:20that on the anti -abortion side because we don't
- 53:22think that the we don't accept the the argument
- 53:28and even with respect to sentient fetuses we
- 53:31think that there are Various reasons why the
- 53:34moral choice should rest with a pregnant person
- 53:36rather than with some third party or the government
- 53:39but we do wrestle with it for animal activists
- 53:44and The conclusion we reach is that in order
- 53:50to justify the use of physical force whether
- 53:54it's to commit property damage or, even worse,
- 53:59loss of human life, right? You need to not only
- 54:04think that the moral wrong of what's being inflicted
- 54:11on the animals is very, very serious, which we
- 54:14do think it is, but you also need to think that
- 54:17your act of violence is going to actually benefit
- 54:22those animals. And we have two reasons for thinking
- 54:26that's not true. One is that there are just so
- 54:33many animals in this system. And if there is
- 54:40one thing that sort of unites the general public
- 54:42against the cause, it's acts of violence. Even
- 54:46property damage is very bad publicity. And so
- 54:51it's likely to be counterproductive to the movement.
- 54:54Second reason is that there are so many things
- 54:58one can do short of violence to rescue individual
- 55:03animals that if your concern is, well, at least
- 55:06I've saved that one animal, you can save that
- 55:08one animal from using various other non -violent
- 55:12methods. So at the end of the day, we come out
- 55:16pretty strongly against it. We also entertain
- 55:21the idea that you might associate with Gandhi
- 55:27or Thoreau or Martin Luther King Jr. that violence
- 55:31is never an appropriate means towards achieving
- 55:35a peaceful goal. I'm generally sympathetic to
- 55:43that view, but I don't think that that's the
- 55:45core of our argument. That's really interesting.
- 55:48have spoken many times with one of the officer
- 55:52of the animal liberation front press office about,
- 55:57you know, the actions of the animal liberation
- 56:00front. And so I guess my question is, what do
- 56:04you make of acts of violence, such as what they
- 56:09did in Iceland where they are wrecked to whaling
- 56:14ships and, you know, basically put a stop to
- 56:20a very lucrative economic activity in Iceland.
- 56:25Are there some exceptions to that? Some acts
- 56:28of violence of property damage that could be,
- 56:34you know, very impactful if enacted? Yeah, so
- 56:42first I'd say that, you know, I think with a
- 56:45few exceptions ALF and Sea Shepherd are less
- 56:51what we had in mind we were we were more focused
- 56:54on acts of violence with respect to domestic
- 56:58farming but you know the argument I just laid
- 57:03out right is ultimately depends on a kind of
- 57:13predictive and empirical question. Whereas one
- 57:18can save a cow without breaking into a farm,
- 57:22harder to save the whales through some other
- 57:27means. So I guess I understand how one could
- 57:30reach a contrary conclusion with respect to free
- 57:33living animals in the ocean. I had in mind, I
- 57:38mean, you know, one of the things that I think
- 57:43about sort of a group like Direct Action Everywhere
- 57:45or DXE, and they are very much against doing
- 57:51even property damage. I mean, the most kind of
- 57:54property damage they might do is they might like,
- 57:55you know, cut a wire or something that prevents
- 57:59someone from getting to an animal, but they're
- 58:00not doing any kind of serious economic damage.
- 58:03And the defense is typically that the animals
- 58:06that are rescuing had zero or even negative economic
- 58:10value to the farmers. And so to my mind, the
- 58:17question for them is the stakes are lower because
- 58:23you're not causing serious property damage. You're
- 58:26certainly not causing serious harm. There is,
- 58:30of course, always a risk That there could be
- 58:34violence more likely against members of your
- 58:36own group if there happens to be a. Guard there
- 58:40some or someone i you know this is not activity
- 58:42in which i engage so i don't i don't know how
- 58:45to weigh all of those factors. What you know
- 58:50i i i i talk to wayne shung after he was in prison
- 58:56when of course founder of the xe no longer with
- 58:59the xe but you know so still. very much involved
- 59:01in this sort of movement and you know he had
- 59:05said before and after he went to prison that
- 59:09he thought that his going to prison would be
- 59:12good for the movement right so that um when we
- 59:15say we're against violence we're not against
- 59:19civil disobedience but it's civil disobedience
- 59:22in the sort of throw gandhi king tradition in
- 59:27which part of the dramatization of the seriousness
- 59:32of your cause is your willingness to go to jail.
- 59:37I do think it takes a lot of creativity to go
- 59:44and try to see the parallels between pro -life
- 59:48and the animal rights movement and try to learn
- 59:51from other social movements that are not looked
- 59:54upon as being adjacent to the animal rights movement.
- 59:59I always hear activists talk about the animal
- 1:00:03rights movement as a social justice movement
- 1:00:05or something akin to that. But I really like
- 1:00:11the idea of getting inspired or studying at least
- 1:00:16other social movements and you know, learning
- 1:00:21from from what they have accomplished. Now, we
- 1:00:26should maybe touch briefly on on this topic.
- 1:00:29But the pro -life movement has been successful
- 1:00:32in the US in reaching their goals. What do you
- 1:00:39make of that success? So I'm not sure they've
- 1:00:45been successful. They've been successful in making
- 1:00:47abortion illegal in about half the country. I
- 1:00:52don't think they've been successful in reducing
- 1:00:54the number of abortions. There's actually evidence
- 1:00:58that the number of abortions has actually increased
- 1:01:02in the now nearly three years since the Supreme
- 1:01:06Court overruled a constitutional right to abortion.
- 1:01:10Part of that is because of the availability of
- 1:01:15abortion pills, whether legal availability or
- 1:01:19illegal availability. Part of it is because of
- 1:01:24pushback. And one of the things you've seen in
- 1:01:28the US is, I think, a shift in public opinion,
- 1:01:32so that as a consequence of their success in
- 1:01:36the courts, their views have become less popular,
- 1:01:41so that when abortion has been placed on the
- 1:01:45ballot in states, even in most of the fairly
- 1:01:49conservative states, it's generally lost. And
- 1:01:52when it has won, like it did in a state like
- 1:01:54Florida, it was only because the threshold was
- 1:01:57a sort of super majority threshold. So I think
- 1:02:01there's a question of how you measure success.
- 1:02:03Having said that, yes, the campaign to change
- 1:02:08the law was very effective, and I think that
- 1:02:14was partly because they were able to rally their
- 1:02:22voters around particular issues to the exclusion
- 1:02:28of other issues. That is, there are a lot of
- 1:02:32voters in the United States who might have a
- 1:02:36whole variety of views on a great many uh issues
- 1:02:39but will only vote uh for a candidate if they
- 1:02:44are anti -abortion to a lesser extent that's
- 1:02:47true of people who are pro -choice but but there's
- 1:02:49some of that and so it's it um uh i think part
- 1:02:54and the reason i'm focusing on voters even though
- 1:02:57the big change took place in the supreme court
- 1:03:02is because the way that you got a supreme court
- 1:03:06that was going to overturn the abortion right,
- 1:03:11was through presidential appointments, which
- 1:03:14were based on campaigns which included abortion
- 1:03:17as one of the central issues, despite all sorts
- 1:03:21of other things going on. Now, I happen to think,
- 1:03:25putting aside my animal activism hat, I happen
- 1:03:28to think that's not healthy for a democracy to
- 1:03:31have elections turn on you know this one issue
- 1:03:34which you know to people on both sides is an
- 1:03:36important moral issue but there are you know
- 1:03:38literally hundreds of other uh also important
- 1:03:42issues that get sort of submerged and sort of
- 1:03:45washed out as a consequence um but i think that
- 1:03:50one thing that we could learn from the that is
- 1:03:56number one two things i'll say number one is
- 1:03:58patience This was a campaign over the course
- 1:04:01of about 50 years. And they were persistent.
- 1:04:06And even though they had setbacks, they eventually
- 1:04:08won, at least as measured by the legal change.
- 1:04:13And the other thing, I guess, is the importance
- 1:04:18of having a core of passionate supporters. So
- 1:04:23there are. people who care passionately about
- 1:04:27the animal issue. And then there's a lot of what
- 1:04:30we might call diffuse support. So I think that
- 1:04:34one of the things that could be really effective
- 1:04:38is turning some of those diffuse supporters into
- 1:04:41passionate supporters, the sorts of people who
- 1:04:43would go out and sort of vote and make this a
- 1:04:46campaign issue. It isn't there yet. So the highest
- 1:04:52profile uh... vegan politician in the united
- 1:04:56states uh... was in the news lately that's uh...
- 1:04:59united states senator corey booker who just you
- 1:05:01know spoke uh... continuously on the senate floor
- 1:05:04for twenty five hours he is quite open about
- 1:05:07the fact that he's a vegan and it's important
- 1:05:09to him um... there's an hour now another vegan
- 1:05:12in the u .s. senate adams chef and these are
- 1:05:14the both important players in the democratic
- 1:05:16party it's not as though there's a kind of vegan
- 1:05:20lobby or, you know, that the vegans are a powerful
- 1:05:24voice that politicians have to take seriously.
- 1:05:28So, you know, that's something you can build
- 1:05:31over time. Yes, I read Matthew Scully, and, you
- 1:05:38know, he mentioned how he would never support
- 1:05:42a political candidate who was not pro -choice,
- 1:05:46pro -life rather. And yeah, I have seen that
- 1:05:53how they are one issue voters, you know, the
- 1:05:56pro -life people. And I've looked at it a bit
- 1:06:00with envy, I have to say, you know, putting the
- 1:06:02question of democracy aside, I wish that there
- 1:06:05was more of that in the animal rights movement,
- 1:06:09you know, people prioritizing animals over other
- 1:06:14uh social issues um because if we don't do that
- 1:06:19then who else is going to put them forward but
- 1:06:23um so so you did cover that but i guess my my
- 1:06:29other question regarding that is should we put
- 1:06:33more the emphasis on uh politics instead of anything
- 1:06:38else um in regard to you know advancing the animal
- 1:06:43rights agenda. I often talk with Liz White, who
- 1:06:50is the leader of the Animal Protection Party
- 1:06:53of Canada. And every time she comes on the show,
- 1:06:57she says, you know, everything is political,
- 1:07:02politicians decide everything, you know, who
- 1:07:04lives who dies. And how are things done in terms
- 1:07:09of, you know, exploitation of animals. But we're
- 1:07:15not, you know, I feel lots of animal rights activists
- 1:07:20are not very political, are not inclined to make
- 1:07:26their activism more political. Do you think we
- 1:07:29should go more in that way, get inspired by the
- 1:07:33pro -life crowd and get more political? Where
- 1:07:40possible, sure. I think you can do that on issues
- 1:07:49where you can build coalitions with people who
- 1:07:53are not fully on board the animal rights movement.
- 1:07:55So for example, there are a number of towns in
- 1:08:01Massachusetts now that have banned the sale of
- 1:08:04fur. was a ballot initiative in Denver to close
- 1:08:12a lamb slaughterhouse, right? There are initiatives
- 1:08:21involving the treatment of horses. You can do
- 1:08:24things about companion animals. Given though
- 1:08:32that somewhere between 95 and 98 % of The people
- 1:08:38in our countries are. Eating and wearing animals
- 1:08:43on a daily basis. Who let politics and the law
- 1:08:49are not going to be a means of achieving very
- 1:08:54dramatic changes in the short run right not a
- 1:08:59reason not to do it right where you can not even
- 1:09:01a reason not to swing for the fences even though
- 1:09:04you know it's futile because you. who raise people's
- 1:09:07awareness. But I don't think that can be certainly
- 1:09:10the exclusive strategy. I sometimes hear people
- 1:09:13both in the animal rights side and the environmental
- 1:09:17justice movement or environmental movement say
- 1:09:21things like, well, these are systemic problems.
- 1:09:23They can only be addressed systemically by government
- 1:09:25and so forth. And I agree they're systemic problems,
- 1:09:28but systems are composed of individuals. And
- 1:09:31so there's no reason why you can't attack a problem.
- 1:09:35both at the systemic level, and at the individual
- 1:09:39level. And in fact, those things will often work
- 1:09:42complementarily. And I should differentiate the
- 1:09:46political system in Canada versus America. In
- 1:09:50Canada, we have the hope of a proportional democratic
- 1:09:53system, where parties like the Animal Protection
- 1:09:58Party can vote into, you know, MPs into the Parliament.
- 1:10:07So that's something that Americans do not have.
- 1:10:14We will never see an animal party in America
- 1:10:19doing impactful work like we see being done in
- 1:10:24the Netherlands or in New Zealand. Yeah, I think
- 1:10:29that's right. And I mean, I would include the
- 1:10:33Greens in in much of europe they're not explicitly
- 1:10:37animal rights party but a lot of people who are
- 1:10:40active in in green the green party have uh animal
- 1:10:44rights commitments along with their environmental
- 1:10:46and other commitments uh yeah it is a it is a
- 1:10:50problem with um district by district elections
- 1:10:54and you know no no no proportional representation
- 1:10:57that you're not going to have representation
- 1:10:59of that it's just a call to mind if i I don't
- 1:11:02know if you're familiar with the Graham Greene
- 1:11:04novel, The Comedians, which is a novel about
- 1:11:08basically the horrors of the popadoc regime in
- 1:11:13Haiti. But there's a character in the book who
- 1:11:19is referred to as the presidential candidate.
- 1:11:22And you learn that he ran for president of the
- 1:11:25United States on the vegetarian party platform,
- 1:11:28which, of course, is made up. And he's a somewhat
- 1:11:32ridiculous character. But it was hopeful to me
- 1:11:36that, oh, there was a vegetarian party, at least
- 1:11:39in fiction once. Yeah. I mean, we're grasping.
- 1:11:47Right. Yeah. I mean, again, going back to democracy,
- 1:11:55Sure, America does not have the hope of a proportional
- 1:11:59democratic system. But you have the First Amendment,
- 1:12:04which is freedom of speech. And, you know, the
- 1:12:07the ALF press office could not exist in Canada,
- 1:12:13but it can exist in in the US. So that's something
- 1:12:17beautiful and a big win for a great environment
- 1:12:22for activists in the animal rights space. Yeah,
- 1:12:25I think that's right, at least as their US citizens,
- 1:12:28because increasingly people who are not citizens
- 1:12:30are being punished for their freedom of expression.
- 1:12:33So, you know, I hope that turns out to be a temporary
- 1:12:38anomaly. You know, and there are there are other
- 1:12:44ways in which people can be influential. in politics
- 1:12:50right again um you can you can have these coalitions
- 1:12:54with other other movements so just to give another
- 1:12:58example so i'm i on most issues i find myself
- 1:13:02on the other side of people who call themselves
- 1:13:05libertarians but there is a libertarian organization
- 1:13:09in the united states called white coat waste
- 1:13:12which lobbies again very strongly against uh...
- 1:13:17medical research and and and and experimental
- 1:13:21uh... laboratory research on an on animals there's
- 1:13:24a federal law that requires that all the drugs
- 1:13:26be tested on animals and this libertarian organization
- 1:13:29lobbies against it on the ground this is a waste
- 1:13:31of money because the animal testing doesn't do
- 1:13:35any good uh... and it turns out that some of
- 1:13:38the people who are involved in it do actually
- 1:13:41care about the animals to so there's an opportunity
- 1:13:43to work with a potentially more powerful constituency.
- 1:13:47So I'm all for building coalitions with groups
- 1:13:52who might not share my views on any range of
- 1:13:57issues. So long as we can make common cause on
- 1:14:00this particular one, especially when it's one
- 1:14:03of those animals. I guess to close this topic
- 1:14:08of politics, and why do you think that Spartacus
- 1:14:14Curry Booker is not more, you know, pro animal
- 1:14:18more, you know, outspoken about his veganism.
- 1:14:24I'm always, you know, I find myself asking this
- 1:14:27question, because if I put myself in his place,
- 1:14:31I feel like I would be the first, you know, most,
- 1:14:34you know, driven on this issue and would put
- 1:14:41all of my time. So yeah, why do you think people
- 1:14:47like Cory Booker, you mentioned Adam Schiff,
- 1:14:50I think Bill Clinton was vegan for a long time.
- 1:14:54Not for the animals, though. For health reasons,
- 1:14:57I suppose. Yes. Anyway, he was never fully vegan.
- 1:15:00It was only for health reasons. Yeah, so why
- 1:15:05are those people and I guess more liberal politicians,
- 1:15:09because they must know vegans in their family,
- 1:15:13in their circle of friends. Why don't we see
- 1:15:16more of them being proactive in terms of, you
- 1:15:20know, animal rights? Right. So I think it's simply
- 1:15:24because we're a very small minority of the population,
- 1:15:27right? It's not. And and we are not seen as oppressed.
- 1:15:31We're seen as annoying. Right. Even though, of
- 1:15:33course, we don't want to be He's seen as a press.
- 1:15:35You want them to see the oppression of the animals.
- 1:15:39Again, it's just a matter of what's politically
- 1:15:42possible. So I think Cory Booker is actually
- 1:15:45pretty good about speaking up compared to what
- 1:15:49the possibilities are. You know, New Jersey,
- 1:15:52which is the state he represents, includes a
- 1:15:55lot of dairy farmers. So there are industries
- 1:15:59that would oppose him if he made his Veganism
- 1:16:04more of a voting issue. I think you notwithstanding
- 1:16:07that he does typically come out What I regard
- 1:16:09as the right way whenever one of these issues
- 1:16:11comes up, but you're you're absolutely right.
- 1:16:13He's not out They are pushing for you know a
- 1:16:16ban on You know animal slaughter or dairy or
- 1:16:20anything like that and I think that reflects
- 1:16:23a kind of political Reality, I just don't think
- 1:16:26it's realistic to expect somebody who has to
- 1:16:29stand for reelection to be proposing laws that
- 1:16:34are going to ensure that they don't get reelected.
- 1:16:38So, you know, that's, again, it's, it's simply
- 1:16:41a, to my mind, it's simply a numbers game. But
- 1:16:43again, you can make progress on smaller issues
- 1:16:46where you can form coalitions with people who
- 1:16:49have much less ambitious goals. Yeah, an argument
- 1:16:54for putting limits to mandates, political mandates.
- 1:16:59Okay, I guess my last question for you, and thank
- 1:17:03you so much for your time, we went over time.
- 1:17:06It's okay. Is you finished the book by mentioning
- 1:17:10a book I did not get to read yet called Zootopia.
- 1:17:16And you describe what it would be like to have,
- 1:17:20you know, more of an ideal world for animal and
- 1:17:26human relationships. And I guess that's one of
- 1:17:31the best if not the best description of a world
- 1:17:36where the animal rights movement succeeds, that
- 1:17:40I have read, you know, what it looks like if
- 1:17:42we succeed. So I would love if you could maybe
- 1:17:46as parting words to to talk about that about
- 1:17:50a zoo utopia. Sure. So so that's a book by Will
- 1:17:56Kimlicka and Sue Donaldson, and they're Canadians,
- 1:17:58by the way. So I think they're at Queen's University
- 1:18:02in Kingston, Ontario. And we actually presented
- 1:18:07a version of that chapter there before we published
- 1:18:11the book. After the book, there was a nice panel
- 1:18:16on it that Peter Singer hosted at Princeton.
- 1:18:19But that issue didn't come up. So giving credit
- 1:18:22to will ensue, what they say in their book is
- 1:18:27they imagine sort of three categories of animals,
- 1:18:33what they call sort of sovereigns, and these
- 1:18:37are free -living wild animals, and there the
- 1:18:42idea is to just let them be. Denizens, who are
- 1:18:47animals who live among us but are not Really
- 1:18:51part of our society. So think about like rats
- 1:18:54and pigeons and so forth and then citizens and
- 1:18:59The idea that I think I find most intriguing
- 1:19:01is their idea of citizens So these are you know,
- 1:19:03these are basically the most domesticated animals
- 1:19:07Think of dogs sheep, etc who With whom we have
- 1:19:16we could they imagine have a kind of mutualist
- 1:19:18relationship And I want to think that's possible.
- 1:19:25And I think I live with three dogs. I think on
- 1:19:28our good days, we have a mutualist relationship.
- 1:19:32If I'm playing frisbee with one of my dogs, I
- 1:19:37throw the frisbee. And he's clearly enjoying
- 1:19:39going after it and occasionally catching it,
- 1:19:42usually picking it up after it lands, and then
- 1:19:47bouncing back to me with the frisbee. He's enjoying
- 1:19:50it, and I'm enjoying it. And that is, I think,
- 1:19:53characteristic of a good deal of our relationship.
- 1:19:56You see anybody who lives with an affectionate
- 1:20:00companion animal, they lie on their back to get
- 1:20:02a belly rub or something like that. That's a
- 1:20:04sort of mutually satisfactory relationship. I
- 1:20:07think that's possible. But I also think it's
- 1:20:11fraught. That is to say, even for our most beloved
- 1:20:15animals, we are controlling their lives. in ways
- 1:20:19that I think are suboptimal. I would be very
- 1:20:24sad if that were to stop being the case. I don't
- 1:20:27think there's any risk of it stopping. I mean,
- 1:20:30I adopted all my dogs from shelters. I'd continue
- 1:20:33to do that. But in an ideal world, people aren't
- 1:20:38breeding these animals. What Will and Sue say
- 1:20:42is, well, they would breed on their own and there'd
- 1:20:44be these animals, you know, and they would come
- 1:20:46in. And so, you know, maybe I think it might
- 1:20:48look a little bit like the relationship between
- 1:20:50humans and the first dogs, which were sort of
- 1:20:53friendly wolves that came around the campfire
- 1:20:55of their own accord. I do think, though, that
- 1:20:59the kind of ideal future is also going to have
- 1:21:03to include just a lot more wild spaces that humans
- 1:21:07don't enter. Right. And so a An enormous reduction
- 1:21:12in the consumption of animal products will facilitate
- 1:21:15that because it will mean we just need much less
- 1:21:18land to grow food. That is also facilitated by
- 1:21:26the decline in human population, which is likely
- 1:21:29to begin 20 years or so, right, that his birth
- 1:21:32rates worldwide are declining almost everywhere.
- 1:21:36We will eventually reach a point of population
- 1:21:38decline and then presumably at some point stability
- 1:21:41at a much lower level where it's possible for
- 1:21:44there to be these wild spaces Assuming we get
- 1:21:46there before you know, we the complete ecological
- 1:21:49disaster And so I think the relationship that
- 1:21:53the ideal relationship I'm imagining is one in
- 1:21:57which you know for the most part we just leave
- 1:22:00the animals alone But you know I would like to
- 1:22:06think that there will be these citizens or perhaps
- 1:22:09denizens with whom we have friendly relations.
- 1:22:13But, you know, I doubt I'm going to see any of
- 1:22:15that in my lifetime. So right now, my main goal
- 1:22:19is just to sort of minimize the harm. Wonderful.
- 1:22:24Mike, thank you so much. Thank you for your work.
- 1:22:28I really consider your book as a classic of animal
- 1:22:33rights. books and you know, it's really up there
- 1:22:37in my list. So thank you for the book. Thank
- 1:22:42you for your activism and your work in the space
- 1:22:46of animal rights. And a big thank you for having
- 1:22:50taken the time to answer my questions. It was
- 1:22:53my pleasure. This was really a fun conversation.
- 1:22:56Thank you everyone for listening. I kindly invite
- 1:22:59you to share this podcast with the vegans you
- 1:23:02know. Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:23:06Again, thank you so much for caring and I will
- 1:23:09see you next Tuesday for a new episode.