Latest / ZulfTalks: Working For Yourself / Renting vs Buying in 2026 Who is Actually Winning S18ep9
Transcript
- 0:00Renting versus buying in 2026, Who is actually winning?
- 0:06There's a lot of dead money in the market at the moment.
- 0:09We've been told the same lie for 40 years.
- 0:15Renting is just paying someone else's mortgage.
- 0:18In the 90s that was probably true.
- 0:23In 2026 with the interest rates where they are and house prices
- 0:29stagnating me, the math has changed.
- 0:32For someone with a mortgage, is it a wealth builder?
- 0:37For others, it's a 35 year trap. I've recently purchased so I'm
- 0:43kind of familiar with this area now.
- 0:44Today we're doing a 2026 housing audit.
- 0:47I've pulled data from right movers, Zoopla, and the house
- 0:51price index. We're going to look at the real
- 0:57cost of owning versus renting and I'll show you why getting on
- 1:02the ladder might be the worst financial move you make this
- 1:06year or the best. Let's think about this.
- 1:09We've got Tom the buyer. We've got Sofia the renter.
- 1:15Tom finally 1. He bought a 2 bed semi with
- 1:18about 5% deposit. He's proud.
- 1:21He's happy for his mortgage. Maintenance and insurance take
- 1:25up 50% of his pay. He is anchored.
- 1:34He's there now he's in the business.
- 1:36Sophia rents a similar place size wise.
- 1:42She pays more in monthly rent than Tom pays in his mortgage,
- 1:48but she has zero maintenance costs and she invests the 40K
- 1:53deposit she didn't spend into her oyster.
- 1:58She has a sale a year later. Both move for a dream job in a
- 2:06different city. Tommy's stockmate Sophia is gone
- 2:10in 30 days, Packed up, moved out.
- 2:13We'll look at the freedom math in a second for this, but the
- 2:172026 market reality the house price index Jan 2026 Zoopla
- 2:24rental market report I looked at.
- 2:26So the average UK price in early 2026 is sitting at roughly
- 2:32290,000 lbs depending on the region, while the average rent
- 2:36has hit a record high of £1300 a month mortgage rates, with the
- 2:41Bank of England base rate hovering about 4.25%.
- 2:45A typical 90% loan to value mortgage is costing homeowners
- 2:49roughly 5 or 6% in interest, so you need a reality check here.
- 2:55If you have £250,000 mortgage at 5.5% you are paying something
- 3:01like £1200 a month just in interest. 1000 £145.00 a month
- 3:11just in interest. That is like money that doesn't
- 3:15go towards your house. It's dead money to the bank.
- 3:18Exactly like rent. So is mortgage like a rent
- 3:21payment? There's unseen 1% here.
- 3:25So the British Insurance Brokers Association BP Home serve
- 3:30maintenance index. The hidden cost of owning a home
- 3:34is estimated at 1% of the property value per year for
- 3:39maintenance insurance. You know that service charge and
- 3:43stuff On a 290K house? That's £2900 a year or £240 a
- 3:48month that renters never pay. When people compare rent to a
- 3:54mortgage they always forget the boiler, the roof, the building
- 3:57insurance and the grand rent. In 2026, the ownership tax is
- 4:02higher than ever. But then again, I've also heard
- 4:06the nightmares about tenants trying to get stuff repaired and
- 4:08the homeowners just taking ages. There's a 5% rule here as well.
- 4:14So I want you to run this math. Take the value of the house.
- 4:20Let's use your example of if you're buying a house or
- 4:23renting, but take the value of the house you want to buy and
- 4:25multiply it by 5%. Then divide that by 12.
- 4:33It's that number. If the number is lower than the
- 4:38monthly rent for a similar house, buying makes more sense.
- 4:42If it's higher, you are actually better off renting and investing
- 4:47the difference. We need to think about this a
- 4:49little bit differently. This accounts for like the
- 4:52opportunity cost for your deposit and the cost of
- 4:55maintenance. So on a 300K house the 5% rule
- 4:59number is like 1250 lbs. If you can rent that same house
- 5:04for £1100. The mat says buying is liability
- 5:13not an asset. SO300K house, 5% rule 1250 back
- 5:21and rent for cheaper. But there's the age-old argument
- 5:26that I'm buying a mortgage, so I'm actually paying for the
- 5:31house, going to be mining at some point.
- 5:35But the freedom of movement like in our example there is
- 5:39interesting, is interesting. There's identity trap here as
- 5:41well because what happens is the sunk cost of status.
- 5:46In the UK, we treat home ownership like an adult merit
- 5:50badge. We are willing to be house poor,
- 5:55eating beans and never going holiday just so we can say we
- 5:59own. But owning 10% of a house and
- 6:0290% of a bank's debt isn't freedom.
- 6:08Which part are you in? Are you renting?
- 6:09Are you buying? If you were lucky enough to buy
- 6:15at a time when the house prices were better and you're paying
- 6:17off, you're all right. But currently you have to think
- 6:20about this differently. The market's changed.
- 6:23It was easier to buy in the past, you were getting salary
- 6:26and house prices were kind of not too far off.
- 6:29Now if you think about this, multi people don't buy homes as
- 6:35their first priority. They buy like income producing
- 6:38assets. If your house is your only
- 6:41investment, you aren't an investor, you're just a tenant
- 6:45of the bank who has a fix on their own toilet.
- 6:51Oh my days. Fix your own toilet, fix your
- 6:53own shower fixture, everything. So let's think about this.
- 6:57If you were to be in a position where you could buy or rent, you
- 7:02got a healthy deposit. Are you going to get more money
- 7:04with that deposit being saved? And you're going to be getting
- 7:06interest. And if anything goes wrong, you
- 7:08call the landlord. If it's a good, good landlord,
- 7:10you get a repaired on. You don't have to worry about
- 7:13it. You got a job in another
- 7:14country. Do you want it?
- 7:16Depends what mindset you are. You want to put your roots down?
- 7:18Do you want to be free to move around?
- 7:22So Tom, our original buyer found out his house value dropped 2%
- 7:26this year. Combined with his interest
- 7:28payments he actually lost £15,000 in net worth.
- 7:32Prices of houses can go up and down but Sophia the renter so
- 7:36her eyesight grow by 8%. She now has a bigger deposit
- 7:41when the market actually makes sense.
- 7:44This is my example but it could be in either way you can have
- 7:46it. The ISO could go down in value,
- 7:49property goes up. It's just what is.
- 7:52Swings and roundabouts. A home is a place to live, an
- 7:57investment is a place to grow money.
- 8:02Don't confuse the tube just because your parents told you
- 8:05renting is a sin. Build your wrath, get a decent
- 8:11part together, then buy your walls.
- 8:15I'm so fun. This is the Money Scorecard
- 8:17series. I'm enjoying looking at these
- 8:19reports and actually looking at what's going on here because
- 8:22it's interesting. The home ownership audit trap.
- 8:25A lot of people are stuck here. This was episode 7.
- 8:28It's a little dive. Just to give you an idea of
- 8:30what's going on and what I'm thinking.
- 8:32I did a full breakdown on season 15.
- 8:34Homebuyers go through the process of how much of a
- 8:37nightmare it was selling my house and buying a house and all
- 8:41the steps I went through in the stagents and all of that la di
- 8:44da di da. But then again, people that
- 8:46rent, I'm hearing stories is very difficult to rent now.
- 8:48They ask for all sorts of cheques and references.
- 8:51So it's hard to rent as well and even getting a place to rent
- 8:54where you want it. So how are you finding this
- 8:56journey? Hmm, What are we looking at
- 8:58next? In the next episode?
- 8:59I'm thinking we're going to look at the, it makes sense to look
- 9:03at the locality because this may not apply to everybody.
- 9:05Depends where you are geographically speaking.
- 9:08There's like a big gap in different markets.
- 9:11Where do you want to be? Everybody wants to be where it's
- 9:13kicking off, but I'm gonna cover that in the next episode, so
- 9:16I'll see you on that. What's one question you're stuck
- 9:21on right now? Contact me on softtalks.com.
- 9:26You can drop me a message and install. e-mail me there if you
- 9:29want. You could even put your answer
- 9:31below this episode in the comments section.
- 9:34I read through every single one and it helps me shape the shows,
- 9:38so it'll be good to hear from you.
- 9:41It would be really good if you can leave a review wherever
- 9:43you're listening to this. The show resources are available
- 9:46at zolftalks.com. You can also sign up to the
- 9:48mailing list there which would allow you to get information to
- 9:51help you on your journey working for yourself.