Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / Why a Smaller Deficit Does Not Lower Interest Costs
Transcript
- Lucas: So the Treasury just closed the books on fiscal 2025 with a deficit of roughly one point seven seven four trillion dollars — that's actually about forty one billion dollars narrower than the year before. Sounds like good news, right? Luna: Narrower by forty one billion on a one point eight trillion hole. That's a rounding error in the grand scheme, but it's at least moving in the right direction. Lucas: Exactly. And the headline is 'the deficit is shrinking.' But here's the tension: even as the red ink got a little less deep, the government's interest costs almost certainly went up. And not by a small amount. Luna: Because yields have been climbing. The ten-year is at four point seven one percent today, the thirty-year above five point one seven. That reprices all that debt rolling over. Lucas: Right. The federal debt is now about thirty nine trillion dollars. The average interest rate on that debt is somewhere around three percent, give or take. But new issuance is coming at much higher rates. So the weighted average is rising. Luna: Every fifty basis points of increase on thirty nine trillion dollars adds roughly one hundred ninety five billion in annual interest. That dwarfs the forty one billion deficit reduction. Lucas: That's the math. The deficit narrowed primarily because tax revenues grew faster than spending. But interest expense is one of the fastest growing categories. The Congressional Budget Office has been projecting interest costs to exceed one trillion dollars by 2028. With yields where they are now, that might come sooner. Luna: So the headline 'deficit falls' is real, but it masks the fact that the underlying interest burden is getting heavier. And that's not a one-year effect — it compounds. Lucas: It locks in. The Treasury is issuing more short-term debt — bills with maturities under a year — which are currently yielding around three point nine five percent. That's actually above the fed funds rate of three point six three percent. So the government is paying more to roll over its short-term paper than banks are paying to borrow from each other. Luna: That's a strange inversion in its own right. Short-term Treasury yields are higher than the policy rate. Normally you'd expect them to be lower because Treasuries are risk-free. Lucas: Right. It's a signal that the market expects rates to stay higher for longer, or maybe even rise further. And it means the Treasury's refinancing costs are rising across the curve. The two-year is at four point three seven, the ten-year at four point seven one, the thirty-year at five point one seven. Every maturity is repricing upward. Luna: And because the Treasury has been issuing a lot of short-term debt — I think about a third of marketable debt is in bills now — those maturities hit quickly. So the hit to interest expense shows up faster than if it were all long-term bonds. Lucas: Exactly. That's why the interest cost numbers are rising so rapidly despite a deficit that improved slightly. The average interest rate on the debt is climbing by a few basis points each quarter. It might not feel dramatic month to month, but over a couple of years it adds up to hundreds of billions. Luna: And then there's the debt to gdp ratio. It's at one hundred twenty two point six percent, basically flat from last year. But if interest costs grow faster than nominal GDP, that ratio starts rising again. We're not out of the woods. Lucas: No, we're not. And that's the core tension: the deficit is down modestly, but the cost of financing the debt is up substantially. The next Treasury refunding announcement in August will be very closely watched for how they plan to manage this. Are they going to shift more issuance to the long end to lock in current rates? Or keep short to minimize cost now, but take refinancing risk? Luna: It's a hard trade-off. Lock in a five percent thirty-year yield for thirty years, or keep rolling short-term at four percent and hope rates come down. Lucas: And the market's telling them that short-term rates might not come down soon. The yield curve has steepened — the spread between the ten-year and two-year is now thirty six basis points, up from basically zero a year ago. That steepener usually happens when the economy is expected to grow, but it also increases term premium, which pushes long-term rates up. So borrowing long is expensive and borrowing short is risky. Luna: Which brings us back to the deficit improvement. It's a good sign that revenues are holding up, but the spending side — especially interest — is a growing burden. If the economy slows, revenues dip, and the deficit widens again. Lucas: Exactly. So the one year improvement is welcome, but it might be temporary. interest costs are structural — they don't go away unless the debt shrinks or rates fall. And neither seems likely in the near term. Luna: And that's the kind of thing that makes listeners want to understand this stuff better. Speaking of which, if you're finding these conversations helpful — like having a clearer picture of why the deficit number doesn't tell the whole story — there's a way to support the show and keep it ad-free. Lucas: Yeah. We don't run sponsorships, so listener support is what keeps this podcast going. If you've gotten something out of walking through the economy with us, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's all one word, fexingo. It's a simple way to chip in, and it really helps. Luna: And we appreciate every single contribution. It allows us to keep digging into these fiscal dynamics without any outside pressure. So thank you. Lucas: Alright, back to the numbers. So we've got a smaller deficit but rising interest costs. Let's put some numbers on what that means for the fiscal outlook. The CBO's baseline from earlier this year showed interest costs hitting about one point two trillion by 2030. With yields now above five percent on the thirty-year, that projection is probably too low. Luna: And that's before any new spending initiatives or tax cuts. The fiscal 2025 deficit improvement was partly due to the expiration of some pandemic-era programs. But mandatory spending on Social Security and Medicare continues to grow as the population ages. Lucas: Right. So the deficit might have tightened this year, but the medium-term trajectory is still rising. The real test will be what happens to yields over the next twelve months. If they stay high, the interest burden becomes the dominant force in the budget. Luna: And that raises a bigger question: at what point do markets start demanding higher yields to hold U.S. debt, creating a vicious cycle? We saw a bit of that last year when the thirty year spiked above five percent. Lucas: Exactly. That's the fiscal sustainability conversation. The U.S. has always been seen as a safe haven, but the debt to GDP ratio is above one hundred twenty percent, and the interest cost to GDP ratio is climbing. If investors start to demand a bigger risk premium, the cost of borrowing goes up, which makes the deficit worse, which pushes debt higher. It's a feedback loop. Luna: So the takeaway here: don't be fooled by the headline that the deficit shrunk. The underlying cost of the debt is still growing, and that's the number to watch. Lucas: And that's why we do this show. The national debt isn't just a number on a ledger — it affects everything from mortgage rates to federal spending priorities. Understanding the dynamics helps you make sense of policy debates. Luna: Next episode we'll look at something a bit lighter — the bond market's betting on a recession? Actually no, let's stick with fiscal math. Thanks for listening.