Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Banks Are Coming: Why Building Custodial Trust is Imperative
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers. Communicating the information
- 0:07superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps and off ramps.
- 0:11Bitcoin is worthless, artificial.
- 0:14Gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of money? Does is it creates a single
- 0:27network which can do a microtransaction to a giga
- 0:33transaction. The Internet is going to be one
- 0:38of the major forces for reducing the roller gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that will soon be developed is a
- 0:46reliable E cash. Welcome back to Final Settlement
- 0:53everyone. Today is February 11th.
- 0:56It's a Tuesday, gentlemen. How are we doing?
- 1:00I'm joined by my Co host Michael Tanguma and Liam Nelson and
- 1:03special guest today, Mitch Kochman, Chief Revenue Officer
- 1:08at On Ramp. Very happy to have you on the
- 1:10show today. Lots of lots of topics to get
- 1:13through, but how are we doing boys?
- 1:16Doing all right, all all things considered flooding down here in
- 1:19Texas, How to move location so the Internet could work.
- 1:22It looks like bitcoin's prices flooding and bleeding out as
- 1:25well. We're down to we're in a bear
- 1:26market at 95,000, crashed to 95,000.
- 1:29Dollars per coin. Yeah.
- 1:32So things, things are rough. These are always a good time
- 1:36historically though, so you know I'm shop.
- 1:38Solidation exactly a good time to add.
- 1:41Exactly if I. If I had any Fiat to add, I
- 1:44would get in. Here, Yeah, when things are
- 1:47quiet, it's generally a good sign too.
- 1:50Don't want too many hyper bullish headlines all across the
- 1:53news. People need some time to digest.
- 1:56So yeah, all is good. Just kind of keep on chopping.
- 1:59I'm excited to have a Mitch on because Mitch has been talking
- 2:03my ear off or our ear off for over a year now about SAB 121
- 2:07being repealed. And hello, the banks were
- 2:09rugging the industry and once the the banks, you know, had the
- 2:13handcuffs taken off that we were going to go and up only.
- 2:15So I want to, I want to see if it's going to actually play out
- 2:19in that direction and what the latest is.
- 2:21Yeah, I'm pretty sure banks are going to want to make money.
- 2:23So I'm, I'm pretty bullish about leveraging them to, to access
- 2:28new, new pools of liquidity for this industry.
- 2:30I don't know how much banks actually like making money.
- 2:32I was listening to yesterday. Bank of America, I guess, has
- 2:36$100 billion like on the books and losses.
- 2:39Is that right from the? In what?
- 2:42From the the bonds that they hold, yeah.
- 2:46That tracks. Yeah, I mean they're.
- 2:47Making. Money, but that's just generally
- 2:49been the wrong trade for them because they back in 2021, the
- 2:55move to get like marginal extra yield was to go out and buy 3330
- 3:01year assets rather than, you know, one to three or one to
- 3:05three month bonds that were yielding nothing.
- 3:07And so they wanted to make money that way and they really like to
- 3:10make money. They just are caught on the
- 3:12wrong side of that trade. We will get to the repeal of SAB
- 3:16and all its implications, but to kick things off, wanted to go
- 3:21through some news over the past couple weeks, some topical
- 3:26headlines and deals that I think are worth covering.
- 3:30The first of which I'll pull up on screen here was Stripe
- 3:35acquiring a stable coin API bridge for 1.1 billion.
- 3:42I think this is sort of just, you know, reminiscent of of what
- 3:47we've been talking about for the past several weeks of, you know,
- 3:50because this new administration, Trump and his team is digital
- 3:54asset working group are are seemingly very much leaning into
- 3:58stable coins. And that being, you know, the
- 4:02vehicle or the avenue by which we really spread dollar
- 4:06dominance across the world. And, you know, sort of walk this
- 4:10fine line of continuing to kick the can down the road, devaluing
- 4:14the currency, but still maintaining reserve status by
- 4:17just spreading stable coins all over the world.
- 4:20And so now you're seeing the stripes of the world, I think
- 4:24see the see the sort of posturing from the
- 4:26administration and say, you know, we need to lean into this
- 4:29area. So any thoughts from you guys on
- 4:33this move from Stripe or the deal terms or anything else?
- 4:38I mean, I think the, what I'm curious to hear like, because I
- 4:43haven't fully thought out the position other than it's super
- 4:46bearish for like all the Bitcoin companies that try to create
- 4:50cross-border products and solutions.
- 4:52Because at the end of the day, those were built to move Fiat
- 4:56independent of what the movement of like Bitcoin is doing.
- 5:00They're trying to get dollars from one place to another.
- 5:04And it, this is kind of ties into the last week's news with
- 5:09the tether rolling over lightning or whatever.
- 5:13But it's this notion of, well, if the rails already figured out
- 5:16from bridge, I would imagine has relationships cross-border,
- 5:21they've done compliance with different banks.
- 5:24There's already plumbing with the existing system.
- 5:26And how do you transfer into stables on whichever blockchain?
- 5:31And there's a standard being formed, which Mitch, you said on
- 5:34the other side of this on like an infrastructure perspective.
- 5:36It's really hard enough to go and explain this stuff, the
- 5:39legacy institutions, but they can, if you can again, help them
- 5:41make money, they'll buy into it. But then to have to go and
- 5:44explain why you need to do this on Bitcoin, a different protocol
- 5:46with a different prop, you know, it just doesn't feel it feels
- 5:50like it, it takes out the air with a lot of these like
- 5:53pitches. And so I'm just curious, like
- 5:55Liam, I know you looked at a lot of deals even at your previous
- 5:57life, just, you know, being a student of the industry and how
- 6:01is that take make sense? Or do you think there's a
- 6:03different angle why people would use lightning from a
- 6:05cross-border remittance perspective?
- 6:07Yeah, I think a lot of times too people are just, they already
- 6:12have enough issues with respect to tax, getting money across
- 6:15borders that they don't want another volatile currency to be
- 6:18involved as well at a very broad sense in terms of all companies.
- 6:25So I think a lot of Fiat companies that just want to have
- 6:29dollar treasuries will want to use this product and it's also a
- 6:33need for them. You know, I think there is a use
- 6:36case for some Bitcoin only companies that really want to
- 6:39have, you know, their entire treasury and Bitcoin to get
- 6:43across borders. But at this point, it's just a
- 6:45little bit too early for mass remittances of Bitcoin across
- 6:49countries. I, I broadly think that, you
- 6:54know, when you've got large players like Stripe building on
- 6:59other chains, I think it, it is going to be harder to build
- 7:02these solutions on Bitcoin, at least initially.
- 7:05That said, when you know, over the medium, long term, when, you
- 7:10know, let's say stripes hold on Etherium here, you know, if
- 7:14usage of Etherium is going down, they're going to find themselves
- 7:17forced to, to go migrate to somewhere else.
- 7:20And ultimately Bitcoin, you know, we're picking a market
- 7:24dominance, picking up, you know, usage, you know, it's the same,
- 7:28you know, similar to, you know, my background, the
- 7:31infrastructure world, you know, do you want to keep hopping
- 7:33vendors or do you want to go with, you know, the strongest,
- 7:36most resilient one that you might have to pay a bit more,
- 7:39You might have to, you know, might move slower, you know, in
- 7:43some cases. But you know, do you trust that
- 7:46your money's going to get there? And, you know, so I this can be
- 7:50a cost benefit analysis for all these firms.
- 7:53I'm not surprised that, you know, they're going on another
- 7:57chain first, but now I'm pretty I'd say in the short term,
- 8:02pretty bearish with this stuff happening on Bitcoin, at least
- 8:05the major players going to Bitcoin, but in the medium long
- 8:09term, very bullish. I think it's in general though,
- 8:14you know, firm and this is what I'm going to probably get into a
- 8:17little bit on Saab, but firm like Stripe that you know, what
- 8:21are you looking for? I'm looking to acquire.
- 8:24I, I don't have, you know, the skills as much to, you know, the
- 8:27proof of work that I've gotten done this.
- 8:29I'm looking to acquire, you know, knowledge, resources,
- 8:33technology that have proven out that they can, they can move
- 8:38this money. This traditionally has not
- 8:41happened, you know, stables on Bitcoin prior.
- 8:43So if I'm going to go acquire a firm, I'm probably going to
- 8:46acquire one that's doing doing this on Ethereum or Salon or
- 8:48whatever it is today, which is why I think they go in a
- 8:52direction like this. Yeah, I think that's all right.
- 8:55I mean, I think the reality of the situation is that the vast,
- 8:59vast majority of stable coin volumes and flows on these other
- 9:05chains like Tron and Ethereum. And to your point though, Mitch,
- 9:10like I do think there's a medium to long term rationale for
- 9:14trying to build stable coins on Bitcoin.
- 9:18You know, we've seen early iterations and attempts at that
- 9:22and the the thinking really being like, you know, do you
- 9:25want to build these dollar based payment applications on a sound
- 9:32foundation that you know is going to be here in 50 years or
- 9:35do you want to do it on the most popular one right now that might
- 9:38not be that in 10 or 20 years. Like that is, I think the real
- 9:41crux of the question and it particularly if these guys are
- 9:44just going to go buy a player like this, you know, with it
- 9:48like a deal like this, then obviously you're going to go the
- 9:51route of a shorter term. Like where's the volume today,
- 9:55right? Like, I think because that's,
- 9:57that's how you justify a a billion dollar purchase of this.
- 10:00This company is by saying, well, this is where all the volumes
- 10:02are and we're going to build out capabilities to to service these
- 10:05people today. Yeah, I think like the value
- 10:10accrual. We're straight.
- 10:12We're. Bridge I think is interesting is
- 10:15like they have like regulatory framework on ramps, all of the
- 10:19plumbing for it, different institutions like it's a, it's a
- 10:24like a liquidity game. So the more people that pipe
- 10:27into their AP is you get more access points from bringing in
- 10:30dollars and then it's a creative to the network.
- 10:32So I think that's interesting today because a lot of people
- 10:35haven't done it. But what I think is more
- 10:37interesting on the stable coin side is at the end of the day,
- 10:40the value is not where the protocol it's being sent on
- 10:44because it's actually the database that it's being
- 10:47referenced because the protocol can just be turned off and you
- 10:49can move over the database to whichever 1.
- 10:51So I think the question is like less or the thing I'm less find
- 10:54interesting is what the rails that are being used.
- 10:58It's actually the mechanics and the integrity of the underlying
- 11:01asset And how do you, what makes circle tether or if on ramp or
- 11:07whoever spins up a stable coin that delivers some kind of like
- 11:10additional yield in like passing through treasuries?
- 11:13And then if something gets dislocated, what's backed up by
- 11:16BTC, maybe offers BTC on an annual basis to those wallet.
- 11:20Like that's how I think who wins?
- 11:23Because that's a, that's a, a brand recognition and trust
- 11:26game, because that's why you're using those stables, not because
- 11:30of the rails that are used, because any of those, including
- 11:33lightning, something could happen to a channel, but the
- 11:35assets are still a counterparty or the counterparty still the,
- 11:40the issuer. And so I think like that's the
- 11:43real interesting aspect of who can accrue the most value is who
- 11:47builds the brand around stables that has integrity and forward
- 11:50thinking on how do you bring in more liquidity so you can issue
- 11:53more stables which you can get passed through more revenue.
- 11:57And when that I think is like the next version of Staples and
- 12:00why I would want to use one as I would look at who has the best
- 12:03kind of economics around it. Economics risk, I think we're
- 12:07we're very early into that the productization of this step.
- 12:12Yeah, I think that that'll make sense.
- 12:14I mean, if you look at like, like, Michael, what you're sort
- 12:18of alluding to is like the integrity of the underlying, IE
- 12:24for all these stables, like if they're just buying U.S.
- 12:26Treasuries. And then, you know, if you look
- 12:30at Tether, like they haven't historically passed along that
- 12:33yield, right? Like they're just keeping that
- 12:35themselves as profits, rolling a lot of it into BTC.
- 12:39What is your assumption that people will pass along whatever
- 12:44those you know those yields are with respect to the Treasuries
- 12:48that they're holding as the underlying?
- 12:51Yeah, I mean, I guess going back to like the bridge, I guess
- 12:54their value comes because the people using them most likely
- 12:57have no idea who Circle or Tether are or understand have
- 13:02done a lot of the diligence maybe somewhat.
- 13:04But it's really like bridges their interface into accessing
- 13:07this and thinking through their capital movement in the same way
- 13:10that like they would go to Stripe and then plug in their
- 13:13bank accounts and they can move funds.
- 13:14They're getting access to that platform and the they'll be
- 13:20agnostic to what chain it's being used.
- 13:21Like whether it's Salon or theorem, they probably don't
- 13:23even know to be honest. So I don't, I'm like less
- 13:27interested or even like, maybe it does end up on Bitcoin
- 13:29because of the integrity over time, the pipings there, it's
- 13:32just not there yet. So like all that, I can almost
- 13:34guarantee bridge is not probably have integrations with anything
- 13:37Bitcoin related. And if it is, it's probably very
- 13:40like not a lot of liquidity. But the other thing that's
- 13:44actually more interesting because if you're, if the AP is
- 13:46and that plumbing can continue to grow, well then like what's
- 13:49the mode around that? And there's something there.
- 13:52But then there's also how do you create a real mode around the
- 13:56integrity of the, the stable coin?
- 14:00And it has to start looking differentiated because right now
- 14:03tethers making acts billions of dollars, there's not a lot of
- 14:05competition. But what happens when somebody
- 14:07gives back X percentage of those billions back to the end holder,
- 14:12passes it through the other digital wallet and then also
- 14:15anchors a portion of the their holdings into BTC.
- 14:20So it helps with if there's any like dislocation, there's a run,
- 14:24right? We saw what happened with SVB in
- 14:25circle like two or three years ago where the price started to
- 14:28dislocate. Well, if you have the Bitcoin
- 14:30back in it up now you have higher integrity and and it goes
- 14:33back to like the free banking style of different banks will
- 14:36have different custodial relationship or custodial models
- 14:39also have different stable models.
- 14:41And so if we're going to live in a dollar denominated world for
- 14:44at least a while, you may need those dollars and you're maybe
- 14:49you're whipping them around online.
- 14:51But if one's paying less interest or one's potentially
- 14:54seized or the counterparty that issues that stable, there's
- 14:57assets are encumbered, right? Like it starts to look like,
- 15:00well, what are my dollars? Who's being held in this world,
- 15:03this digital native world? And that's what's kind of
- 15:05interesting because now you have an opportunity to to
- 15:09differentiate in the financial services and the stables that
- 15:12you offer. No, that all that all makes a
- 15:15lot of sense. I think pivot to the next deal a
- 15:20a strong departure from what we were just talking about where
- 15:23there's real demand for for U.S. dollar stable coins.
- 15:28This is a deal where, you know, I, I don't think there's
- 15:31actually a ton of demand for, for what this company, Tapper
- 15:34Wizard is trying to do. They raise 30 million.
- 15:38And if you're not familiar, Tapper Wizards has sort of
- 15:44pioneered or worked on Bitcoin inscriptions, which is
- 15:47effectively a form of, of NFT on the Bitcoin blockchain.
- 15:53And a lot of also sort of the undercurrent of what this group
- 15:59and and others have been pushing is, is effectively vouching for
- 16:05advocating for a Bitcoin improvement proposal called
- 16:09OPCAT, which would enable a lot of different things, including,
- 16:16you know, what they want to do basically with these ordinals
- 16:19and NFTS and making them more usable, better user experience,
- 16:23things like that. What what do we make of this?
- 16:27I, I also wanted to pull up here just to look at the volume of
- 16:34ordinals over the past several months.
- 16:36But while I pull that up, any any thoughts on this deal guys?
- 16:40It's pretty easy to say, but raising money to with guarantees
- 16:46or or soft guarantees of a change to the Bitcoin protocol
- 16:50is probably not a viable strategy long term.
- 16:54I it seems like a promise that they can't make.
- 16:58And so it's going to be very difficult for them and their
- 17:01investors to, to monetize this kind of on a hope.
- 17:05It's definitely something that I would want to stay away from
- 17:08personally, but we'll we'll see how this plays out.
- 17:14Yes, I I have pulled up here just inscriptions over time.
- 17:17You can see there's a good amount of activity back in 23
- 17:21and then really fell off for most of of 24.
- 17:25Slight, slight blips over the past couple of months, but not a
- 17:30not not what I would deem sustainable demand for ordinals
- 17:33and inscriptions. And even just to carry a
- 17:37piggyback off of that, like, yeah, you can see how fall, how
- 17:42far these inscriptions have fallen.
- 17:44And it's kind of just the same thing that we're seeing with the
- 17:47proliferation of all these different meme coins being
- 17:49raised, which is essentially there are so many different ones
- 17:53at the moment that you can gamble on which ones are going
- 17:57to go up short term. But in the end, it's mostly a 0
- 18:00sum game. And essentially back in 2017
- 18:05with like the mass adoption of Icos and a lot of these mean
- 18:10coin craze. And when that started back then,
- 18:13there's been kind of a bit of a decline in all these other coins
- 18:18just because people now have a better way to bet on leveraged
- 18:23Bitcoin, which is essentially through the public markets,
- 18:25which is significantly easier buying micro strategy or buying
- 18:31calls or puts on micro strategy, which just have like massive
- 18:34amounts of volatility, which I think is mostly the demand for
- 18:37all of these different things like Bitcoin Ordinals and all
- 18:41these different meme coins. And so I see a lot of demand for
- 18:44all of these different products declining long term.
- 18:47But I'd be interested to hear your guys opinions as well.
- 18:52Yeah, I don't follow, you know, the ordinals and and all this
- 18:55stuff very much. But like, you know, I didn't
- 18:58pull this data, but I can always guarantee you that that is
- 19:02easily a top five single funding or top ten and probably top five
- 19:06single funding round for a theoretical Bitcoin company.
- 19:10There's no shortage of affinity scams that tie to Bitcoin that
- 19:13happened for since its very existence.
- 19:16And when you see somebody invest $30 million in something like
- 19:20that, it's ultimately telling you that they've gotten some
- 19:22economics on the next altcoins that are going to get spun up.
- 19:28And how do they get access to. It's just similar to like what
- 19:32we've seen in the altcoin space with Multi Coin and these other
- 19:35VC firms that they're investing because they're going to get
- 19:38access early to these altcoins that they're going to be able to
- 19:40dump on retail. Yeah.
- 19:45I think that's, I think that's well put the sort of what you're
- 19:50alluding to around the perverse incentives of something like
- 19:53this, where in order to really profit from it, you need to be
- 20:00effectively the earliest to it and then basically capitalize on
- 20:04the late liquidity and and dump on real retail.
- 20:07So we've seen that with all coins, with meme coins, with
- 20:10NFTS and with inscriptions. It's kind, it's kind of the same
- 20:13story. So I mean, to, to just looking
- 20:18at the fundraising round a bit, you know, they're building
- 20:21probably applications to go build, you know, and interact
- 20:25with this stuff. So, you know, it's probably, you
- 20:29know, they're trying to build the pickaxes to, you know, to go
- 20:32create this world, which, you know, feel there will be plenty
- 20:36of, you know, rugging retail and early investors that are making
- 20:39money on it and what not. But I think they're trying to
- 20:42build the applications here. My stance on this stuff is like,
- 20:46I don't pay attention to it, but I'll defend the right to do it.
- 20:49And some, you know, open source protocol that, you know,
- 20:53probably they can use it as they wish.
- 20:56I don't care. It's not what I want to focus my
- 20:58time on. As long as the we're not seeing
- 21:01the network getting, you know, flooded with DDoS.
- 21:05Attacks, but I think that's pretty much where I land on it
- 21:07as well. Like I, I don't have like a
- 21:11super fundamental issue with it because I am sort of a free
- 21:14markets maximalist of people want to get rugged on these
- 21:18things, go for it. But raising 30 million on this
- 21:23idea I I struggle with, I mean from an investment.
- 21:27Perspective So I mean, it's once again, it's not my cup of tea.
- 21:31But that said, you know, the president just launched a meme
- 21:36coin like there's there's a market for this stuff,
- 21:40unfortunately, for better or worse.
- 21:42And, you know, people are always going to be after or seemingly,
- 21:46you know, environment that we're operating in, you know, where,
- 21:49you know, inflation is ruining, you know, they're buying power.
- 21:51They're going to be after that 100 X return, unfortunately.
- 21:55You know, we try leading them in and informing them to go a
- 21:58different way. But until that mechanism changes
- 22:03where, you know, inflation isn't attacking their buying power,
- 22:06like there will be something in human nature that's going after
- 22:09that return that's looking to gamble and, you know,
- 22:12unfortunately like, but these people are building the
- 22:16infrastructure to go to go provide that.
- 22:19I think that's what this is. Yeah, but I think what's more
- 22:22nefarious is that again, it goes back to the affinity scamming on
- 22:26Bitcoin because we saw this with the layer 2 stuff that he gets a
- 22:29pass because, you know, he worked with the president or
- 22:31whatever. But Bailey and all those guys
- 22:34just like investing in all this layer 2 crap that is effectively
- 22:37has a token that's not needed to dump on retail.
- 22:40This is a cousin of that. Stacks is another great example
- 22:43where we talk with clients that would never touch quote UN quote
- 22:45altcoins, but then are happy to invest in Stacks because they
- 22:48believe there's some fundamental utility token around that.
- 22:51That's where the problem with this arises is like OPCAD,
- 22:54Bitcoin, whatever you're going to derive from it.
- 22:57Liam showed the, the, the not really the volatility, but
- 23:02ultimately, like, it's like all altcoins, it gets heavy when the
- 23:06market's out there. Similarly, like step in, it's
- 23:08just my favorite because you know, when everything's hot, the
- 23:12price is up, and then when liquidity goes out of the
- 23:14market, it's just dead. It's zombie zone.
- 23:16And so that's what you're banking on in a $30 million
- 23:19investment is to get access to when the price is running so you
- 23:23can dump and then you can effectively get your bags packed
- 23:25from whatever the investment was.
- 23:28The next one more one more piece of news before we we jump to the
- 23:32next thing. But I thought this one was
- 23:35interesting just in the sense of so so SoftBank made an
- 23:43investment in cipher mining. And so why I thought this was
- 23:48particularly interesting was so SoftBank.
- 23:52They've made some other Bitcoin and crypto related investments
- 23:55in the past, most notably in 21 believe they invested in Digital
- 24:01Currency Group, DCG and, you know, the parent company of
- 24:06Grayscale Trust. And then they also invested in
- 24:10FTX, which which they wrote to 0.
- 24:13And so this I think is the first time since that FTX investment
- 24:16that they've gotten back into the space with an investment.
- 24:19And I think it's particularly, you know, interesting that they
- 24:24decided to invest in a Bitcoin mining company as opposed to
- 24:26something in broader crypto. And any thoughts on this guys?
- 24:33I can jump in. I do agree.
- 24:35You know, it's a sign of things to come.
- 24:38You know, you look at a firm like SoftBank, what are they
- 24:41typically after they've, you know, extremely long time
- 24:44horizons when the mining space, you know, in the short term,
- 24:52even medium term, you know, you've got countries mining,
- 24:55you've got actors that are not primarily focused on economics
- 25:01that are getting into the mining space.
- 25:02It's an extremely competitive area in the of, of our, of our
- 25:06industry. But that hash rate, you know,
- 25:10when you look at the medium long term, when blocks, you know,
- 25:13blocks begin to fill up again, you know, that's, you know, it
- 25:19is absolutely worth something to be able to, you know, be able to
- 25:24guarantee the fact that you, you know, you've got to stay some
- 25:27blocks, you know, should, you know, you win the, the block
- 25:30board. So I, I, I'm not shocked, you
- 25:35know, folks at SoftBank are, are looking at the mining space
- 25:39with, with that long term time horizon, it definitely matches
- 25:41up to, you know, how they typically invest.
- 25:44Yeah, I also wouldn't be surprised if like they have
- 25:48their ears to the ground all across the world and, and
- 25:51understand what's going on with hash rate and understand that
- 25:54there are likely nation state level hash rate accumulation
- 26:00going on right now. So I, I, you know, in the in
- 26:03that sense, I think this this deal and investment make a ton
- 26:07of sense if, if that's what they are seeing on the ground, which
- 26:09is, you know, what we've heard anecdotally and is, is sort of
- 26:12rumored to be the case right now.
- 26:15So in that sense, it, it makes total sense that the most
- 26:17positive signal to me was that they're not investing in
- 26:20something like crypto company, like they're getting into
- 26:22Bitcoin mining. So it it does seem like a shift
- 26:24from where they were two years ago basically.
- 26:27And another thing is this is also kind of going into taking a
- 26:33step back. SoftBank also was one of the
- 26:36investors in the Stargate program, which was the 500
- 26:39billion AI data center program, essentially trying to build out
- 26:43the infrastructure of data centers that is needed to host
- 26:48all these data centers to run the AI programs for these
- 26:53companies. And I believe that they they're
- 26:56part of their investment in Cipher is just understanding,
- 26:59OK, they are a massive data center company that has a bunch
- 27:03of cheap power and potentially they are looking to drift them
- 27:10to skew a little bit more into AI rather than pureplay Bitcoin
- 27:14mining because a lot of demand for that pretty much all across
- 27:18the world. They as companies look at the
- 27:22Stargate program, which is essentially building out a ton
- 27:25of data centers that are competing with Bitcoin miners to
- 27:28get the same low cost electricity contracts.
- 27:33They are increasingly going to run into wait, why does this
- 27:38industry consume so much power? Are they actually generating any
- 27:41economic returns that make sense from this?
- 27:44And will we be? Does it make sense to really
- 27:48focus as much on investing in data centers to help run
- 27:53services for AI, or will there be a benefit to just mining
- 27:57Bitcoin with that excess power if we're not using all of it?
- 28:01I think we're just going to see some more industry leaders
- 28:04become a little bit more familiar with the industry as a
- 28:07whole and dip their toes into the industry as well.
- 28:11Yeah, I think that's exactly right.
- 28:12I think with the nuance a little bit flip there is they have the
- 28:15downside protection of mining as long as they make the right
- 28:17investment. And then it's a call option on
- 28:19the acquisition because everything I've seen and I'm not
- 28:22close to mining, but is that the Co location or acquisitions?
- 28:26It's more economically, it makes more economic sense to turn off
- 28:32the miners and actually Co locate to run models.
- 28:36And so it ties into like Bitcoin mining being like the Canary in
- 28:40the coal mine for cheap cost of energy because it's a lot
- 28:44easier. It's more modular to go into the
- 28:47darkest, deepest corners of the earth to find low cost energy.
- 28:49And once you've proven that out, now you can actually Co locate
- 28:52and start to put GPUs to to run the data sets for LLMS.
- 28:59And so I think that's the trend we've kind of seen with like
- 29:01Core and some other firms. And that could be an angle like
- 29:04you're referencing that they're in Stargate, they have to start
- 29:07looking for more power sources to go and deploy these GPUs.
- 29:11And Cipher could be like one of the first parts of that play.
- 29:16It's a really good point. It feels like that Co location
- 29:21and sort of blending these two industries of Bitcoin mining and
- 29:26and AI data centers is certainly a trend that's occurring and and
- 29:29this could almost be viewed as like a two birds one stone
- 29:32situation effectively. OK, well, that's all I had.
- 29:36For one thing, you. Can't give SoftBank too much
- 29:41credit on that because I mean, they're like wild in the sense
- 29:43that they can produce these crazy returns.
- 29:45But then also we've seen their their write offs or their
- 29:48investments been their write offs there.
- 29:50But then also like, I don't know if you remember they bought a
- 29:52shit ton of Bitcoin back in like I want to say 2020 and then sold
- 29:55it all like in 21 right before the run up something crazy like.
- 29:59So they don't have a fundamental grasp on like at least
- 30:02previously on what was happening in this industry.
- 30:03So you got to take everything they do with the grain of salt.
- 30:05Yeah, if you look it up, you'll see there you can kind of track
- 30:09it. Interesting.
- 30:11I didn't realize that. OK.
- 30:14Switching gears a little bit, Mitch, Chief Revenue offers
- 30:20Officer at on Ramp. You joined us, how long ago is
- 30:24that again? About a year, yeah, from
- 30:27previously bit go and and IBM before that.
- 30:30You've been on some of our pods in the past, but it's been a
- 30:33little while. So maybe for the audience, it
- 30:36would be helpful just to to walk through sort of your background,
- 30:40what you've done in in tech and infrastructure and then
- 30:42ultimately crypto and Bitcoin and and really what led you to
- 30:46on ramp. I think that would be a helpful,
- 30:47helpful place to start for folks.
- 30:50It feels good to be back. I've had a baby 16 months ago
- 30:53and dusted off the mic for the first time since baby was born.
- 30:59But my background came from IBM spent 11, little over 11 years
- 31:03there largely servicing major banks helping them with their
- 31:08infrastructure. My last role there was I LED IB
- 31:11miss relationship with JP Morgan and so under the covers, you
- 31:16know, massive infrastructure stack, sporting Chase Bank and
- 31:20JP Morgan operations. Had a moment where I looked at
- 31:24my son and said, do I want to be helping Jamie Dimon automate
- 31:27jobs or am I? Do I do I want to, you know,
- 31:31inspire you and you know, be a better example.
- 31:34So I went to Bitco and spent almost, I'd say almost two years
- 31:39over there, but came two months before FTX and that two years
- 31:45was largely spent helping, you know, I'd say nearly every
- 31:50Bitcoin company and a number of crypto companies as well make it
- 31:55through all the challenges of 22 and 23.
- 31:58It started with FTX, but then went to Silvergate, went to
- 32:02Fortress Trust, Prime Trust, you know, in Bico being safe harbor
- 32:07for, for many exchanges, you know, during, during that
- 32:12tumultuous time, August 2023, Michael came to Bitco with the
- 32:18idea for multi institution custody.
- 32:21I'd say 5 minutes into the discussion, I, I knew right
- 32:23away, this is, this is something that number one, Bitco had to be
- 32:28a part of something #2 that our industry needed because it's a,
- 32:33the single party custody system had failed.
- 32:37And then my primary part of my job was, you know, you know,
- 32:41being safe harbor, you know, for, for, you know, the
- 32:44situations when it didn't fail, but you know, very much knowing
- 32:49that we needed some sort of, you know, better resiliency for our
- 32:52industry if we're going to get the adoption that we all hope,
- 32:56you know, to to come here. So, you know, I grokked up
- 33:01pretty quick and I went to Mike Belshibico CEO said there's
- 33:06something we've got to be a part of.
- 33:07So we met for a couple days, talk through sort of disruptive
- 33:11forces here, but painted the picture of, you know, if multi
- 33:16institution custody is the future that, you know, our
- 33:19industry is moving towards Biko being the best key agent
- 33:23possible in this model, you know, ends up being very
- 33:27fruitful for Biko when there's more copycats, you know, for
- 33:30multi institution that, you know, come into the industry.
- 33:34BICO having the reps, you know, that they've done this before.
- 33:38You know, they'd be the first client, our first key agent that
- 33:41that they would jump to, you know, as A to set up a new new
- 33:45instance, a new custodian got on board.
- 33:49I spent six months standing up anything from onboarding to
- 33:54legal agreements and, you know, getting BICO where where we
- 33:58needed to be from a sport perspective and ultimately had
- 34:01the choice of, you know, if I knew in my heart of hearts,
- 34:05multi institutions, what you know, the impact that I I know
- 34:11I'd say what I wanted to work on to go make this industry more
- 34:14resilient to, you know, make my time well spent.
- 34:18I could have went to onrap and ultimately made us and I did I
- 34:25guess the the Notre Dame in multi institution make this a
- 34:28success so that other firms key agents, you know, capitulate
- 34:34income into the model other you know, there are copycats, you
- 34:37know on their way, but you make this a success more come or I
- 34:42could have sat there a bit go and tried to drum up interest to
- 34:45to go be, you know, to create more on ramps.
- 34:49Ultimately success is going to bring followers.
- 34:52So came to Onrap, spent a year here, you know as Chief Revenue
- 34:56Officer. Broadly what I do on a
- 34:58day-to-day basis is we've got this multi institution custody
- 35:01framework for how to hold keys and it's building products and
- 35:06services around it for you know the three demographics that we
- 35:09largely serve individuals and building products around that
- 35:13being IRA lending trade. They're institutional clients
- 35:18that are enterprise offering probably creating products and
- 35:22services for those client bases. So that's what I've been
- 35:26spending my time for the last year.
- 35:28Awesome. Appreciate you walking through
- 35:30that. I think if you could go back
- 35:34like and think back to the time at Bitco and cleaning up the
- 35:39messes of the FC XS of the world, like, and this is, you
- 35:44know, this is before the idea of multi institution custody had
- 35:47been incepted into your brain. Like at that point, what did you
- 35:52think was best in breed, right, in terms of custody and
- 35:55security? You know, we had this there's
- 35:58this notion of qualified custody, which I think sort of
- 36:02got blown up in the sense of there were quote UN quote
- 36:05qualified custodians who didn't fulfill their obligations to to
- 36:09a certain extent or something went wrong.
- 36:12And so how did your view of custody and security sort of
- 36:18evolve from the time of cleaning up FTX to to realizing there was
- 36:22another another way with multi institution distributing
- 36:25counterparty risk, reducing single points of failure?
- 36:27But like, what is I guess, you know, putting yourself back in
- 36:32those shoes, like what was the most secure custody at that
- 36:36point? And what was like the big unlock
- 36:38for you being like, OK, there's a whole nother way to do this,
- 36:41basically. Yeah.
- 36:44So I'd say at the time, you know what was best custody, it was it
- 36:50was making sure you you were in deep cold storage market proved
- 36:55over number of years that if you've got a hot key, it
- 36:59ultimately will be exposed through some sort of security
- 37:02vulnerability. So that was, you know, certainly
- 37:06a perk to bit go slower withdrawal process.
- 37:09But broadly, you know, that help keep keep funds there.
- 37:14You know, strong balance sheet. It does protect against risks
- 37:18like that, which is why, you know, your Coinbase, your
- 37:22Fidelity's, your bit goes of the world Anchorage as well tend to
- 37:27do better here. But I'd say that and and really
- 37:32track record. But that said, you know, if
- 37:35you're looking, you know, at a, what a, you know, like post SAP
- 37:392121 repeal, what that means for the industry, if we're just
- 37:44looking at single party custody, you know, all that is, you know,
- 37:48stuff that the banks are going to catch up to.
- 37:51You know, they've got the balance sheet.
- 37:52You know, they're going to, you know, having a, you know, speed
- 37:56is not necessarily, you know, a requirement by the US banking
- 37:59system. You know, deep cold storage is
- 38:01going to be the way that they go here, you know, whether they go
- 38:05build themselves over, you know, period of time or much, much
- 38:08more likely, you know, moving to a, you know, acquiring, you
- 38:14know, the talent and services like that's banks.
- 38:19If, if, if sitting in those shoes in 2223, that's where this
- 38:23industry was going. And it was the the change was,
- 38:28you know, the eye opening model of it didn't need to be this
- 38:31way. Yeah, I've, I was talking to, to
- 38:34major, major, you know, firms that are holding, you know,
- 38:38largest Bitcoin holdings in the world.
- 38:40And their methodology for for choosing custodians was go after
- 38:43the biggest balance sheet and write terms in the language that
- 38:46say should you go under? You know, my claim is 1st.
- 38:50And or, you know, you're backstopping me with you with
- 38:53your funds, not, you know, what's in trust.
- 38:55That's not a way that, you know, this industry sustained.
- 38:59You need something better because this is the first
- 39:04industry where fundamental loss of the asset means it actually
- 39:07goes away. It's not just installing a row
- 39:09in the database. So you know, that's why multi
- 39:13institution was so high opening. It's because you know all these
- 39:16losses, you know they're the reason why our industry does get
- 39:20a bad name. You know why there is
- 39:22resistance, you know, from those who are just following the
- 39:25stories on, you know, FDX and reading major news headlines
- 39:29that not necessarily even seeing things like ETF inflows that we
- 39:32see every day. You build trust by not having
- 39:37these events happen, by improving work and time that,
- 39:41you know, between, you know, losses.
- 39:45So, you know, on the other side, what that looks like is, you
- 39:49know, we can have firms go bankrupt and customer funds
- 39:52don't get impacted. That's the world I wanted to go
- 39:54build and what I didn't think was possible in 2223, you know,
- 39:59outside of just having a major, you know, a large balance sheet,
- 40:01secure this stuff. Yeah, that that's, that's a good
- 40:05way to summarize it. It's effectively, you know, how
- 40:07I talk about the unlock of of multi institution custody is it
- 40:11adds fault tolerance and redundancy to a custody setup
- 40:16for really the first time outside of what you just
- 40:18described of like you hope their balance sheet is big enough.
- 40:21You hope you have some language in the contract that could cover
- 40:24your ass in in basically a a single point of failure being
- 40:28exposed. But like that doesn't scale.
- 40:32It doesn't work for the average person.
- 40:33Like not everybody you know has has the ability to negotiate
- 40:36those types of contracts. So like you did just need a
- 40:38fundamentally different architecture for the setup.
- 40:42And I'm glad that I'm glad that you latched onto that idea early
- 40:46with with conversations with Michael.
- 40:48And it's been it's fun. It's been fun to build out sort
- 40:51of what this looks like in real time.
- 40:54You sort of alluded in there to what we've referenced a couple
- 40:58times around SAB 121 being repealed and this idea of banks
- 41:03getting involved in custody. I guess opening up to the group
- 41:08broad thoughts on what that looks like.
- 41:11Do banks build this themselves? The, you know, the expertise
- 41:15needed to custody private key material is very different from
- 41:20any other asset they've ever custodied.
- 41:22So do they go hire people to do that?
- 41:24Do they outsource it? You know, like we saw basically
- 41:27with with the ETFETF issuers just saying, hey, we're just
- 41:30going to hand this to Coinbase. Do they do something like that
- 41:35or do they just outright buy some players?
- 41:38What what are the thoughts there and, and sort of what is the
- 41:41trajectory here for banks to really get involved in a, in a
- 41:45material way in any of your views?
- 41:49Yeah, I would love to hear Mitch's opinion here because
- 41:51he's obviously got a lot of experience here.
- 41:54But but also love to hear especially on your view of like
- 41:57what, what you think they'll get right, how you think they'll do
- 42:00it. And more importantly, do you
- 42:02think that they'll learn from any of the mistakes of the 2021
- 42:06cycle? Because people really have short
- 42:08memories and even like Mount Gox is very distant memory at this
- 42:13point. So I was just curious on your
- 42:15thoughts there. Yeah, there's a ton.
- 42:19Of maybe before you go, Mitch, because I want to hear that.
- 42:22But I think before going into that, just I think laying the
- 42:26scene for what is available for banks because it's actually a
- 42:31very small window if they have to establish a position, right?
- 42:36They're kind of caught flat footed because historically they
- 42:39were told not to touch this. And if you have kind of had
- 42:42research groups are built in house things, but they haven't
- 42:44been able to turn them on. So if you can lay out like what
- 42:48are even the players that could opportunity like could
- 42:51opportunistically partner? And then how do they think about
- 42:54build versus buy before even going into like, I think that's
- 42:58also important how to think about, you know, counterparty
- 43:00risk. But that'd be helpful just to
- 43:02like lay the scene, lay a little bit of the scene of like what's
- 43:06going on in the space and what are their options?
- 43:11Yeah, yes, I've worked with banks for quite a while.
- 43:15You know, fundamentally who who's involved in it was vital
- 43:22for the thumbs up, thumbs down of and whether a business gets
- 43:26approved, it's the risk department.
- 43:27It's always risk. And you know, if I'm sitting, I
- 43:34can imagine the conversations right now.
- 43:36You know, you've got all all these banks do employ people,
- 43:41you know, on the digital asset side, where they've got these
- 43:46teams that have been researching and, and doing the work on your
- 43:49diligence on companies, diligence on chains and you
- 43:53know, where they may want to be. What these people haven't been
- 43:56doing over the last couple years is moving money, holding key,
- 44:00holding keys. If I'm a risk department and
- 44:04I'm, you know, going to turn on Bitcoin custody, crypto custody,
- 44:10do I feel comfortable with a framework that is not battle
- 44:15tested, that is not actually custody Bitcoin that is not
- 44:21people who have not been in the trenches on boarding and, you
- 44:25know, doing these these these asset transfers?
- 44:29That's a scary thing if I'm sitting, you know, in a risk
- 44:32department right now. So what do I expect to see?
- 44:37You know, there, there's been some M&A in the space broadly,
- 44:41you know, some of these banks, Oregon custodians buying wallet
- 44:44technology. I think that's going to
- 44:47massively, massively increase. You know, look, even just
- 44:52looking at like the, the Stripe acquisition, you know, the, the
- 44:56economics of, you know, what it costs to go buy some of this
- 44:59stuff compared to what that could mean to, to these banks
- 45:03from a revenue perspective. There's a mismatch there.
- 45:06You know, it's, it's not there. There's certainly economies of
- 45:09scale that they pick up because you know, the, the access that
- 45:14Bitcoin firms and you know, well, you know, some of these
- 45:17numbers are big as far as reach to, compared to like major banks
- 45:22and even some of the regional banks.
- 45:24You know, it's, it's the, the scale is hard to comprehend.
- 45:28And I've seen those numbers on the IBM side.
- 45:31So I think we're in for massive MNA.
- 45:36I don't think, I think you'll see some products that roll out
- 45:38Q1Q2 stuff that's been cooking up.
- 45:41But you know, I, I think it's probably end of 2026 before,
- 45:47before these banks do have the, the comfort to offer the
- 45:51products that ultimately like need to come.
- 45:54That said, once that does happen, goodness, are they going
- 45:57to be formidable players, You know, from the balance sheet,
- 46:01from the relationships that they have, you know, with wealthy
- 46:04people, with, you know, really every, you know, everyday people
- 46:08too, you know, trust that they've built up.
- 46:12But that said too, like, you know, as we've seen with the
- 46:17ETFSI think many of them are going to, you know, first see
- 46:21this as a revenue opportunity, but then also a potential
- 46:25opportunity to go gain new clients.
- 46:27And, you know, they're pretty ruthless on the competitive
- 46:29landscape. So I do think on the technology
- 46:33side, on the strategy side, they're going to be, you know,
- 46:36looking for the cheap strategy credits to differentiate, to
- 46:39pick up new clients. So I'm, I'm, I'm fascinated to
- 46:45see what plays out over the next two years.
- 46:47I said it's going to be a ton of M&A.
- 46:49The deep pockets of this industry is it's, it's hard to
- 46:52fathom, you know, I've seen software deals, you know, for,
- 46:58you know, a year run rate run a lot more than, you know, some of
- 47:01what these acquisitions are going to cost.
- 47:03So, you know, I, I do, you know, I, I, I just, I think the access
- 47:11that they have is going to, you know, totally blow away the
- 47:16valuations of some of these firms because the tax can be so
- 47:19important to, to gain. It's an interesting dynamic that
- 47:23probably naively I didn't think about.
- 47:25It's like there's only so many players you can partner with if
- 47:28you want to custody. But ultimately, if they buy
- 47:31somebody, they're just good. It's going to be like their
- 47:34custody offering to the market, which is kind of a problem when
- 47:38you think about specifically from like community banks and
- 47:41other banks that have been disintermediated by the big four
- 47:44or five banks. Now you have to use them for
- 47:47custody of assets, which is just like an interesting dynamic.
- 47:51And then to your point, Mitch, that's a very like interesting
- 47:56acquisition framework when you have like a bit go that has over
- 48:00100 billion in AUM. Coinbase just came out with over
- 48:04700 billion in AUM. So there's like 2 angles.
- 48:07You're like acquiring the assets and it's like venture on assets
- 48:10because the assets grow because it's asset class is growing.
- 48:14So that's an economical like you got to like model that out.
- 48:17But then you're also buying like to your point, there's only so
- 48:20much talent in the space because you need the tech, but the tech
- 48:24doesn't actually matter if you don't have the operational
- 48:26excellence in understanding how to manage this.
- 48:29So it's like a it's a very, it's super fascinating.
- 48:33I think 2026 is kind of ambitious as we know how slow
- 48:37they may like force this stuff, but there's just so much
- 48:40complexity that you have to layer in.
- 48:43So yeah, it's it's wild. I.
- 48:46Think they're going to be forced though, like when one of them
- 48:50comes out with a Bitcoin product, there's going to, if
- 48:54they're going to lose clients because they don't have a
- 48:57Bitcoin product. So I, I think they're, you know,
- 49:02it's weighing the risk of actually, you know, offering it
- 49:08and not having the chops to necessarily do that versus, you
- 49:12know, the FOMO and, you know, the real business drivers of,
- 49:16you know, we're losing clients. This is stuff we're going to
- 49:18have to, you know, be talking on our earnings report calls, you
- 49:22know, that, that we need to go bring a product to market here.
- 49:25So I, I think you're going to have both sides of the coin,
- 49:27which is why, you know, I, I think acquisition is absolutely
- 49:30the way they go, because you can instantly get the credibility
- 49:33and instantly, you know, you know, like I I don't I, you
- 49:38know, you referencing a bit go, you know, 11 years of battle
- 49:42Festivala technology is a much different, you know, animal
- 49:45than, you know, to, for a risk department to go digest then,
- 49:50you know, zero, we're starting up.
- 49:52So I, I think that's that, that's the only way that I, that
- 49:58I see, you know, firms actually, you know, these larger banks
- 50:01going. Yeah, it's a.
- 50:04It's a good way to frame it in that there's risks of you want
- 50:10to do this stuff right and you also don't want to necessarily
- 50:15overpay for assets that are going to be bid up because
- 50:18there's only a few basically players versus there's also
- 50:23probably clear benefits to being early and being a first mover in
- 50:27offering a product or offering different services.
- 50:31So that that will be a balance. I mean, I, I personally expect
- 50:34that kind of deal activity like end of this year to really
- 50:38start. Like I would be surprised if it
- 50:39if it doesn't start until 26. Well, he's just the way, yeah,
- 50:47yeah, yeah, I, I thought he was talking about just like the
- 50:49deal, the M&A activity in general.
- 50:52I I think we could start to see that the other summer.
- 50:55I think we see it now. It's truly the discussions are
- 50:58happening 3:00 to. Six months, yeah, I'm sure
- 51:01they're they're happening now, but everyone's trying to like
- 51:07I'm sure it started in November. They knew this was coming and
- 51:11it's frantically working on the plan of you How?
- 51:14What does phase one look like and what is our strategy for the
- 51:17long term? Which is all it's, it's very
- 51:20interesting on the timing, right.
- 51:22So like, if you if you assume deal making happens throughout
- 51:26this year and maybe they go live with products in 26, it could
- 51:32just be very interesting timing. Depending on like if, if Bitcoin
- 51:35cycles continue in the fashion they have, that could be right
- 51:40around the time that, you know, things are selling off and
- 51:42they're launching a Bitcoin product.
- 51:43Do they then, you know, does it, do we repeat what happened a few
- 51:46years ago where everyone then pulls back from whatever they
- 51:49were about to launch? That could just be interesting
- 51:53timing or there's no such thing as cycles anymore.
- 51:55And it's a super cycle, boys. Yeah, I don't think that it's a
- 51:58super cycle. I think we honestly, the
- 52:02industry has a lot more credibility than it has in the
- 52:05past just because of the timing of the ETS.
- 52:07And the people have made like 100% plus returns if they bought
- 52:12like immediately when they launched.
- 52:14And both like big financial institutions are making money
- 52:19and their consumers are making money.
- 52:20And so it could be really bad timing if the banks launch right
- 52:27into a bear market or at the very top of the bull market.
- 52:30But I think the ETFs have legitimized this asset class for
- 52:35the foreseeable future. So I mean, at the risk of, you
- 52:41know, saying the Bitcoin cycle is, is that because I, I don't
- 52:43necessarily think it is at all, but thinking about the reach
- 52:48these banks have when these banks turn on custody, it's not
- 52:53that's not the bottom of like the top of a cycle.
- 52:56It's, you know, the ability to go like this is the supply and
- 52:59demand game. And when you know that when
- 53:03demand or you're going to have so much new demand that then
- 53:09feels comfortable, you know, with the idea of buying Bitcoin,
- 53:13holding Bitcoin that their marketing machines.
- 53:18We saw with ETS turning on and pushing these Bitcoin products.
- 53:23There's no way that's the top, you know, and we could
- 53:26experience the top beforehand and you know, we get pushed up.
- 53:29You know, I'm not here to make price predictions what not, but
- 53:32you know, we saw with the ETFs of, of what happens when new
- 53:36demand gets turned on and we, we, we were going to see that
- 53:39again, you know, with the, with the bank industry.
- 53:42Yeah, And there's a confluence of things happening here.
- 53:44Like there's the natural stuff around Bitcoin being
- 53:48destigmatized and all of that. But then there's this reality.
- 53:51And I know there's a lot of bearish people on gold, but
- 53:53like, inflation is going to be persistent.
- 53:56There's a lot of things that have to happen to get out of
- 53:59this situation with, you know, the Treasury, Trump, all the
- 54:02things that we know, like the writings on the wall that
- 54:04inflation runs and so scarce assets, you know, the 6040 is
- 54:09going to is up for grabs and like, what does that look like
- 54:12in the future? So these banks are going to
- 54:13naturally have to think about new structures as far as how do
- 54:17you custody a model portfolio. And so Bitcoin's obviously part
- 54:20of that. I think gold will also be a part
- 54:22of that. Obviously, we're seeing what's
- 54:23going on with the gold markets and there's going to naturally
- 54:25need to be better consumer products for gold because people
- 54:28just don't. I think that's the thing we just
- 54:29forgot about. It's like not everybody just
- 54:31apes in. It's like Bitcoin's the thing.
- 54:33I'm 100%, what if you're 70 years old?
- 54:35What are you going to do? Like put 20% in Bitcoin and then
- 54:39deal with, you know, negative yielding bonds?
- 54:40Like, sure, some people are going to do that.
- 54:42Maybe they want to buy gold, but they're going to naturally need
- 54:43a better product for that where they can get better protection,
- 54:47they can get better visibility. So I think there's just
- 54:50structural changes happening to the financial landscape when it
- 54:52comes to like assets and wealth preservation that these banks
- 54:56are going to have to catch up to.
- 54:57So like kind of fits into both what Brian and Mitch was saying
- 55:00is there's like a, there's going to be this natural persistent
- 55:02bit. I think independent, like we'll
- 55:04still get the volatility of cycles, but they're just going
- 55:06to be higher. We're going to be at higher
- 55:08bases in the low and the high. 100% and it's this idea of just
- 55:15like additional passive flows coming into Bitcoin that are
- 55:18just going to be kind of set it and forget it.
- 55:20Either some additional money going into your Roth IRA or any
- 55:26type of IRA just going into Bitcoin, whether it's the ETFs,
- 55:29if you can have it directly with banks.
- 55:31So it's just going to be a kind of passive bid that typically
- 55:35happens with S&P or any other similar financial products that
- 55:39will, I'm, I'm not saying this is the death of cycles.
- 55:42So I could see one where there's potentially one that's not 80%
- 55:47drawdown if there's more of a passive bid for a long time with
- 55:51these ETFs and banks that are custodying it and just like
- 55:55doing the marketing of Bitcoin for it.
- 55:58That passive bid could also just dampen volatility in general,
- 56:02though, because of rebalancing that would occur, you know, when
- 56:05asset prices increase. Yeah.
- 56:08I also think like we're, we're trying to compare this to like
- 56:11what we saw in 24 with the ETFs, but like, I think the magnitude
- 56:16and scale is just going to be entirely different.
- 56:18Because even just looking at ETF flows, like yes, they are the
- 56:23most successful product launches of all time, but like they're
- 56:27barely even turned on at a lot of financial entities and wire
- 56:30houses. And, and so I, you know, we're
- 56:34genuinely just scratching the surface of like those untapped
- 56:37pools of demand that want exposure either through a
- 56:40product like an ETF or they want direct exposure custody by, you
- 56:44know, their bank. I think when that really gets
- 56:48turned on, whether it's end of this year 26 like I, I think
- 56:54it's hard to, it's hard to compare what we've seen with the
- 56:57ETFs to like what the magnitude of, of demand and capital flow
- 57:00could be from that actually being like fully turned on.
- 57:04There is a a crazy amount of anxiety and I personally feel
- 57:07because like you kind of know the future because we've already
- 57:12lived through it. Like everybody even in Bitcoin
- 57:16that we're in early. I've seen the volatility, the
- 57:18cycles when we talked about Ordinals earlier, like that
- 57:20stuff's existed in Bitcoin forever.
- 57:22You just have to like rinse and repeat and it comes in a
- 57:24different narrative. In the same way counterparty
- 57:27risk and education doesn't just, you know, there's only proof of
- 57:30work. You can only get it by either
- 57:32learning from somebody and accelerating that or ultimately
- 57:34having to touch the stove and go through it.
- 57:37So it's like the anxiety comes from where we know it kind of
- 57:39where it goes. We know what we're building.
- 57:41We know what the, the, the consumer, the individual wants,
- 57:44which is important because that's who holds all the
- 57:46Bitcoin. But then we also know how Wall
- 57:49Street and individuals are going to build and how they understand
- 57:51omnibus structures. And we've seen this with like
- 57:53the ETFs and the products and solutions they do.
- 57:55And they're going to be ripe for gaps and, and losses.
- 57:58So we just have to like you kind of like kind of know
- 58:01directionally how this all goes. And then in the meantime, you
- 58:04just have to like sit around and stay alive and help as many
- 58:08people get it right until it gets to the other side.
- 58:13And maybe that maybe you guys have different opinions, but
- 58:15just like all the conversations we have, everything I've seen,
- 58:18you just there's too much of a gap in what we know and what
- 58:22we've seen and then what the rest of the market doesn't.
- 58:25And you can isolate that to Bitcoin and everyone listening
- 58:28or here on the pod knows like you go pitch somebody brand new
- 58:31and they're like, well, what about, you know, Quantum or
- 58:33whatever? It's like, you know, what's
- 58:34going to come up or you just, you know, the rebuttals, you
- 58:37know the things and everyone has to go through that progression
- 58:39in the same way. Like most institutions and most
- 58:41firms are going to naturally have to go through that until
- 58:43standards are formed. And so like, it's just a it's a
- 58:47interesting situation to be in to know that like what Mitch
- 58:49said is coming and it's true, but at the same point, it's
- 58:52going to leave a lot left. And that's effectively what this
- 58:55podcast and you know, the education is about is like, not
- 58:57only what we do, but then if you're wanting to build in the
- 59:00space and you understand the space deeply, that's the the
- 59:02alpha or the gap is understanding Bitcoin, but then
- 59:05thinking through what is commercially viable products
- 59:07that the market will absorb. Because our stance is the
- 59:11market's not going to absorb people holding, you know,
- 59:14plastic devices under their mattress for a very long, and it
- 59:16also isn't going to be JPMC holding all the Bitcoin.
- 59:19And so if those two shouldn't be like very controversial, but
- 59:23they kind of are that Bitcoin's going to be 500 K or $1,000,000
- 59:26and everyone's going to be fine with their inheritance plan with
- 59:29the treasure map. And so now that it's like, well,
- 59:31what do you do? How do you build around that?
- 59:34I, I think with the, with the anxiety that you speak of, you
- 59:39know, I'd say if we've learned anything, it's that this world
- 59:44we speak of, it's all playing out faster than I think any of
- 59:49us could have anticipated. And, you know, if that continued
- 59:53that cycle and, you know that perspective continues, what does
- 59:58that mean, you know? Obviously banks are going to be
- 1:00:01getting into this industry. Obviously they're going to have,
- 1:00:04you know, larger, you know, these are large exposure points
- 1:00:07and there will be a tax, you know, from we got massive
- 1:00:11honeypots of Bitcoin and client data.
- 1:00:14You know, there will be there will be losses, there will be
- 1:00:18issues there, you know, or, you know, potential attacks, you
- 1:00:21know, may not, may not be successful, but the the vectors
- 1:00:24are going to be there. You know, So what, what do what
- 1:00:28do we do now about it? You know, that's that's what
- 1:00:30we're doing every day of, you know, there's 21 million of
- 1:00:33these things and it's helping clients go secure it and secure
- 1:00:38it for their families. And, you know, create a fault
- 1:00:41tolerant solution that, you know, if we can get clients to
- 1:00:46demand something like multi institution, something like
- 1:00:49having, you know, on chain addresses that parent.
- 1:00:55The more that becomes the norm, the more we prevent issues like
- 1:01:00this playing out and ultimately people getting hurt.
- 1:01:02So, you know, it's credence to to what we do it on ramp.
- 1:01:06It's what I want to be spending my days doing is, is, you know,
- 1:01:11ultimately helping people secure their wealth and, you know,
- 1:01:14creating the systems that ultimately, you know, lead this
- 1:01:19industry, that, you know, we end up in a better place and
- 1:01:23hopefully feel less of the pain that we know ultimately will
- 1:01:26come because we've experienced them before.
- 1:01:30Yeah. And maybe even worth taking a
- 1:01:31step back because we kind of glossed over the fact that I
- 1:01:36might be wrong here. But I think the majority of the
- 1:01:38banks are going to like end up adopting some kind of
- 1:01:40proprietary like multi party computation system whether they
- 1:01:43like acquire or set up an incidence.
- 1:01:46And they'll do that for a number of reasons.
- 1:01:49One, because a lot of them been commercialized to sell to banks,
- 1:01:51but two, because this ties back into the education of like banks
- 1:01:55are going to look at diversified basket of crypto currencies and
- 1:01:59digital assets and they're not going to be able to leverage
- 1:02:01multi sig for all of that. And so they're naturally going
- 1:02:04to turn, you know, draft towards what is the all-encompassing
- 1:02:08solution. We all know if anybody's done
- 1:02:10any diligence, like it's an inferior solution, it generally
- 1:02:12gets thrown out with the bath water when you secure Bitcoin in
- 1:02:15that environment. So that's like a whole thing in
- 1:02:18itself that we're going to have like that's just going to be a
- 1:02:20thing where banks are going to adopt an inferior custody
- 1:02:22solution and offer and also adopt all these cryptocurrencies
- 1:02:26and have to figure out how to sell to them, explain them,
- 1:02:28educate them. And it's kind of like a crazy
- 1:02:30situation because like Leishman's posted about this a
- 1:02:33lot the past two weeks about like, you know, they've like
- 1:02:36Coinbase and these other firms, they've already done and played
- 1:02:39this out. They're not going to learn from
- 1:02:40it. It's like Coinbase has a problem
- 1:02:41because what was the coin like? I feel like this past weekend
- 1:02:44got as as quick as it pumped and they try to get it listed, It
- 1:02:47was already like just bleeding out.
- 1:02:51There's so many, but it was like some it was like something.
- 1:02:53It was you, yeah. I think it was like gel coin
- 1:02:58from like. Yeah, exactly.
- 1:03:00Exactly. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:03:01Kraken had that next day so like like which which is the perk you
- 1:03:08can do at MPC. It doesn't work on the multi six
- 1:03:10side. But that said, you know, if, if
- 1:03:14that's where they think the money is, they're they're in for
- 1:03:18a very rude awakening because that's where the short term
- 1:03:20capital is. But you know, when you're
- 1:03:24talking to serious people, they're looking for true cold
- 1:03:28storage, they're looking for the actual auditability that you get
- 1:03:33with multi sick. So look, I, I do think
- 1:03:38ultimately though, because some of the M&A we've seen very early
- 1:03:43has been on the MPC side. But I, I, I definitely think,
- 1:03:48you know, there will be, there will be plenty of voices at
- 1:03:52these firms that, that demand, you know, both on the client
- 1:03:56side, but also on, you know, the actual, the talent of the
- 1:04:00banking, you know, banking industry employees, they're
- 1:04:05going to demand multi 6 solutions.
- 1:04:06So I not naive to think that that that they don't come, but
- 1:04:10off that off the jump it may not.
- 1:04:12Right. I'm curious like because like
- 1:04:14there's one thing on the the technology, but even ahead of
- 1:04:18that is the education. We talked about focusing on
- 1:04:21education. Well, it sounds like the softest
- 1:04:24value prop is actually the hardest because it's hard to
- 1:04:27distill these concepts. But then ultimately if you have
- 1:04:30an educated client, it's, it's a client that you taking care of
- 1:04:33and all the things associated with it.
- 1:04:35If these firms are selling all this stuff that their clients
- 1:04:39are losing funds on, it's to Mitch's point, short term, it's
- 1:04:45short sighted. But if you're building a long
- 1:04:47standing institution and originally I asked you, Brian,
- 1:04:49is because you were at a previous private bank that was
- 1:04:51around for I believe over 100 years, that you can only get
- 1:04:54away with so long selling this stuff and being wrong before you
- 1:04:58leave. Because usually people are exit
- 1:05:00liquidity in the space and they're not getting educated.
- 1:05:03And the best analogy I have is because it's not perfect, but
- 1:05:05it's like if you were trying to build Instagram or a photo
- 1:05:08application in a digital environment, you went to Kodak.
- 1:05:12It would be nonsensical. I almost feel it's very similar
- 1:05:14if you're going to go to a traditional bank to try to get a
- 1:05:20specified or specialized asset management with a bank because
- 1:05:24it's fundamentally different asset across the board.
- 1:05:28Yeah, I mean, I think that's right.
- 1:05:29I think my, my prior firm, Brown Brothers, would, you know,
- 1:05:37they've been so reluctant even when I was there and, and since
- 1:05:40I still, you know, I'm in contact with some, some buddies
- 1:05:43there, like they, they haven't moved anywhere effectively in
- 1:05:47turn in terms of digital assets or Bitcoin.
- 1:05:51And I think that they will be last to move effectively.
- 1:05:54But it, it comes back to what you're describing of like this
- 1:05:57is a, a firm that was founded in 1818.
- 1:06:00They've built their entire reputation and business around
- 1:06:03being a trusted long term oriented partner for their
- 1:06:09clients and offering a a basket of crypto currencies that go to
- 1:06:15zero against Bitcoin is how you like destroy trust in a pretty
- 1:06:20rapid fashion. So I think the Brown brothers of
- 1:06:23the world, I think will be late movers to all of this.
- 1:06:29I'm hopeful that some of those folks, institutions like that,
- 1:06:34we'll take a more principled approach and before they do
- 1:06:37anything educate themselves or at least attempt to and get to a
- 1:06:42place where they're going to offer something.
- 1:06:46But it's not going to be, it's not going to be enabling a
- 1:06:50casino effectively. Which I think if the, the, the
- 1:06:55risk that some of the, you know, the existing stratified players
- 1:06:58run today is they try to move quickly and they offer something
- 1:07:03that is effectively, you know, a skin on Coinbase, if that makes
- 1:07:10sense. Of you're offering a basket of
- 1:07:15crypto currencies, various exposures, and you're not really
- 1:07:19providing any expertise or knowledge around what
- 1:07:22differentiates all these different assets.
- 1:07:24And you're just, you're just opening up the, the floodgates
- 1:07:28effectively, it's very, you know, short, short term oriented
- 1:07:33and runs the risk of, of destroying credibility over the
- 1:07:36medium to long term. So I think that's, that's
- 1:07:39exactly right. And it'll be interesting to see
- 1:07:41how these different banking players play this effectively
- 1:07:45like which how do they how do they sort of balance these
- 1:07:49different trade-offs and, and enter this market in a way that
- 1:07:52doesn't destroy their reputations in the way a.
- 1:07:54Couple years. The way I explained it to an RA
- 1:07:57yesterday was we're like in mid 1990s.
- 1:08:00This isn't perfect apples apples, but it's like we're
- 1:08:031990s and you have an opportunity to get your clients
- 1:08:05in Amazon or you can decide to get them in Amazon with also a
- 1:08:09bunch of other things. And when the blow off top
- 1:08:11happens, because I kind of feel like that's where at we're pre
- 1:08:13like 2000 bubble. I think this next cycle will be
- 1:08:16that and then we'll kind of come out the other side with a chip
- 1:08:18and then we'll still have, you know, Ponzi's, but it'll be like
- 1:08:21less temporary. The standard will be established
- 1:08:23around having custody, but between now and then you try not
- 1:08:27to rug yourself and go into pets.com and whatever else was,
- 1:08:30was part of that fraud. And so like, it's like you guys
- 1:08:33get to make the decision, but we're letting you know like
- 1:08:36there's a fundamental difference between Amazon and these stocks
- 1:08:39in the same way there's a fundamental difference between
- 1:08:40Bitcoin and the rest of these cryptocurrencies.
- 1:08:44Make no mistake, 80 to 90% of these firms are going to offer
- 1:08:51every dog coin and whatever the heck they can make money on.
- 1:08:56They will and ultimately it'll be the reputations on the line
- 1:09:03years later. People don't forget, you know
- 1:09:05these decisions, but they're going to go grab the money
- 1:09:09because because it's certainly there.
- 1:09:12It's the reason why a lot of these crypto exchanges offer,
- 1:09:15you know, gel stool coin too like.
- 1:09:20What's that old? Demand's going to be there your.
- 1:09:23Reputation's my margin. Love it.
- 1:09:30Look, we're going to see a play out.
- 1:09:32They're going to make the same mistakes.
- 1:09:35So, you know, I just be prepared to go see a Dogecoin logo on
- 1:09:41Bank of America, you know, whoever else turns this stuff on
- 1:09:46because it's, it's, it's going to be there.
- 1:09:49Mitch has been trying to get us to support Ethereum, hence hence
- 1:09:52the hence the bull. Hence the bullishness for for
- 1:09:55all coins. I'm not, but Bitcoin dominance
- 1:09:58is like, you know, I, I I throw that, that that chart to, you
- 1:10:02know, anybody, you know, my my former peers at Bitco, you know,
- 1:10:08it's very clear that serious people are are seeing through
- 1:10:14the noise, you know, and the strategic reserve news, you
- 1:10:18know, certainly, certainly helps our case too.
- 1:10:20There's front running that's certainly happening.
- 1:10:23Yeah, that definitely I think fuels the Bitcoin dominance
- 1:10:26case. But you know, I'd say serious
- 1:10:30people understand it. The question is, you know,
- 1:10:34what's are, you know, what is going to be the motivation that
- 1:10:39that drives, you know, these bank, this banking behavior?
- 1:10:41Is it are we building the products for the serious people
- 1:10:44or are we maximizing short term revenue?
- 1:10:46And you're both those answers could be the same.
- 1:10:49I'm not sure. I'm not sitting in their shoes,
- 1:10:51but you know, I excited to see who does make the decision for
- 1:10:56Bitcoin only or or nearly Bitcoin only compared to, you
- 1:11:01know, ultimately the rest. Yeah.
- 1:11:06It's an open question, but I think it's the right one.
- 1:11:09We're a little, we're a little over an hour here, boys.
- 1:11:11Anything. Anything else anyone wanted to
- 1:11:14to raise or bring up before we RIP it?
- 1:11:17I was just looking through any notes to see if there's any, any
- 1:11:20topical things. I think, I think the only thing
- 1:11:24without, you know, sharing too much on our plans is like, at
- 1:11:27the end of the day, the, the biggest insight for me, and it
- 1:11:30kind of ties into this and the strong feeling of, of where this
- 1:11:35goes is because Bitcoin's an emergent asset, you have the
- 1:11:38most, the majority of individuals holding it, so
- 1:11:40roughly 70%. And that's ties into what Mitch
- 1:11:44is sharing about like having the right financial products, the
- 1:11:47right things built. Individuals that have carried
- 1:11:52the asset for that long have figured out something out, which
- 1:11:54is you have to keep it offline, severed from the Internet.
- 1:11:57But the and so ultimately, the only way to get them to
- 1:12:00differentiate or change that position means that has to be a
- 1:12:04step function improvement. So not only do you have to
- 1:12:06improve on the custody layer and provide redundance and
- 1:12:09resilience, but then you also have to be able to provide
- 1:12:11financial services. Because unless you're holding
- 1:12:13this asset till you die and pass it on, you may want to get
- 1:12:16access to inheritance, which is a part of that or lending or
- 1:12:19trading or, or just there's a whole slew of other things that
- 1:12:22you would need. And so the banks and the firms
- 1:12:25that build that are going to be able to win those clients.
- 1:12:27So it's going to be a market driven approach from the bottom,
- 1:12:30not the top, which is historically completely opposite
- 1:12:32of everything we've ever seen. So it's even hard for us to wrap
- 1:12:34our heads around it. But that's how I think we all
- 1:12:37see this playing out. And that's the opportunity for
- 1:12:40individuals building the right way is because B&Y can turn
- 1:12:44something on, but doesn't mean people are going to go move
- 1:12:45their Bitcoin there. There will be because of their
- 1:12:47brand and their name, but they're still going to be large
- 1:12:50holders are still going to be people.
- 1:12:51And then when counterparty risk happens, those holders are going
- 1:12:54to flee because it doesn't matter if it's BNY, Bitco,
- 1:12:56Coinbase and you can put a whole slew, they don't know the
- 1:12:58difference between their custody FTX or another firm.
- 1:13:01So when all that goes bid and counterparty risk people flee.
- 1:13:04And so that's when you know better products establishes,
- 1:13:07standards are established. So I think that's like the
- 1:13:09caveat to all of this is the banks won't drive this.
- 1:13:12They won't have the nimbleness or the the the taste for what's
- 1:13:17needed in the market. And so that opens up a huge
- 1:13:19opportunity that I don't think we've ever seen before.
- 1:13:21Usually assets are driven top down or financial products are
- 1:13:25and that's a huge opportunity. You mentioned a point that I
- 1:13:30hadn't really thought of on the banking side, and it's something
- 1:13:32that, you know, for better or worse, you know, something we've
- 1:13:35took advantage of here at Onramp is most of your single party
- 1:13:40custodians, your big goes coinbases, anchorages.
- 1:13:43They build products for probably the institution space,
- 1:13:47institutional space. And and why is that?
- 1:13:49It's because everything besides Bitcoin, primarily the largest
- 1:13:54allocations sit with institutions.
- 1:13:56They seed, you know, many of these token projects early on.
- 1:13:59They, you know, over the long term dumping on retail, but they
- 1:14:03build their products big go, you know, Coinbase Anchorage, they
- 1:14:05building their products for, you know, for the institution.
- 1:14:11It was a business driven decision.
- 1:14:13But at on ramp, our first use case was the individual.
- 1:14:16Why 7 The chart that Michael just showed 70% of that Bitcoin
- 1:14:20sits with the individual made sense to go building products
- 1:14:22and services, you know, so while it's 10X better than, you know,
- 1:14:27the existing, you know, single party custodial landscape, many
- 1:14:31of the clients we're talking to, you know, have never talked to a
- 1:14:35custodian before. They are either sitting on
- 1:14:37exchanges, sitting in collaborative custody setups or
- 1:14:40sitting on single party single, you know, Ledger treasure, you
- 1:14:43know, cold card setups. They've never been talked to
- 1:14:47about risk. They fear everyday with, you
- 1:14:50know, things like inheritance, things like, you know, loss of
- 1:14:53funds, you know, things like, you know, their personal safety
- 1:14:58risks. And that, you know, a lot of the
- 1:15:01success we've had is because we're actually, you know,
- 1:15:03reaching these clients that that have very much have these needs
- 1:15:07that, you know, they they've never been spoken to.
- 1:15:10You know, that by by anyone in the custodial landscape, which
- 1:15:14you know, going to the banking side.
- 1:15:17This is what they've lucked into is, you know, primarily, you
- 1:15:21know, they've got plenty of, you know, entity clients of course
- 1:15:25as well. But you know, banks have the,
- 1:15:28the, the individual relationship, they're going to
- 1:15:30build products for the individual.
- 1:15:32I think they're going to end up in, you know, just by nature of
- 1:15:36the relationships that they have, Like they, they've got a
- 1:15:39gold mine here and an opportunity to, you know, reach
- 1:15:43a client base that is not like the same success we've had it on
- 1:15:46ramp is reach a client base that has not been spoken to.
- 1:15:49So I'm really excited to watch products for individuals in this
- 1:15:55industry develop and and be creative because quite frankly,
- 1:15:59you know, that's where the Bitcoin sits, but you know, a
- 1:16:01lot of the innovation has not been there.
- 1:16:04Yeah, it's very well said. If anyone wants to learn more
- 1:16:09about what we're doing in on ramp, our products, our
- 1:16:11services, please reach out to any of us or visit our website
- 1:16:15to schedule a consultation to learn more and see how we can
- 1:16:19help you. But with that, wrap it for this
- 1:16:23week, boys. Thank you, Mitch, for joining us
- 1:16:26and see you guys in a couple weeks.
- 1:16:28Thanks. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:16:31week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:16:33valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:16:36rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:16:38All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:16:40notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:16:43reminder that On Rat Media is for informational and
- 1:16:45entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:16:48investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:16:51your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:16:54Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:16:58one of our private client advisors.