Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Lessons - How to Make Decisions Without Bias, Denise K. Shull - Founder of The Rethink Group
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, it's Scott here.
- 0:10On these lessons, episodes of my podcast, I'll be selecting my favorite lessons from various
- 0:16guests and episodes of success story.
- 0:19Today, you're going to hear from Denise K. Schultz.
- 0:22She is an internationally recognized leader in the market investing and trading psychology
- 0:28space.
- 0:29Her expertise in neuro-economics, the mental game of trading, and markets themselves make
- 0:35her an extremely popular speaker and educator at Wall Street conferences.
- 0:39She has coached hundreds of portfolio managers on the psychological game of trading and
- 0:45educated thousands more in what neuroscience is revealing about how we truly process
- 0:51risk decisions.
- 0:53Her clients span four continents and ten countries.
- 0:56She has an MA from the University of Chicago in Neurocycle Analysis.
- 1:00She formerly ran trading desks in proprietary trading shops and she is the author of market
- 1:06mind games, which has been reviewed as the Rosetta Stone of Trading Psychology.
- 1:12She has appeared in the media numerous times, in particular her appearance on CNBC's
- 1:16Squawk Box in both the USA and Asia received rave reviews.
- 1:21She has been profiled by financial times and Wall Street Journal and today she is going
- 1:26to speak to you about how to make decisions without any sort of bias.
- 1:34What do you recommend people after you show them the light so to speak and they start to
- 1:39understand that every decision that they make has all these biases attached to that decision,
- 1:46then how do they go through life?
- 1:49So the question to learn to ask yourself and to answer accurately, those are two-step
- 1:56tasks, but is what am I feeling and why am I feeling it?
- 2:01And you want the answers to be the truth.
- 2:05Now that's easier said than done.
- 2:08A lot of my coaching is like helping people get the accurate answer because what they think
- 2:12they're feeling or why they think they're feeling this generally not what it is.
- 2:17This will, by the way, circumvent the cognitive biases.
- 2:22So a thing in the behavioral findings, cognitive bias, confirmation bias, recency bias,
- 2:29the literature is way bad, your human brain is biased, and there's nothing you can do
- 2:33about it and you're stuck with that.
- 2:38It's not true.
- 2:41It's based on the wrong model of the brain.
- 2:43I mean, it's called behavioral finance or cognitive behavior because it's like thinking
- 2:47and doing, thinking and behaving, you know, like the juices in the feeling.
- 2:54The cognitive behavior world doesn't get that.
- 2:56So like confirmation bias, when you see the thing you want to see, well, everyone talks
- 3:02about how difficult it is to circumvent that or to a verdict, well, all you have to do
- 3:08is realize what's that feeling and what that feeling is usually like, if you, and this
- 3:13happens all the time with hedgemen managers, I mean, I had a relatively new client yesterday
- 3:18talking about like he went to his investment committee and he stated like his viewpoint
- 3:23and he's in commodities, you know, and so this is my viewpoint of how commodities are
- 3:27going to play out.
- 3:29And then he said, you know, if he starts to look like he's wrong, you know, he doesn't
- 3:33really want to go back to the investment committee and say, you know, I'm the second thought
- 3:37I never mind.
- 3:38I was wrong.
- 3:39Because why?
- 3:40Because it's embarrassing.
- 3:41You know, he's afraid he'll react negatively.
- 3:46So people behave in what looks like confirmation bias, either they only see the data that supports
- 3:55whatever their viewpoint are against, not because they're just programmed to do that because
- 4:02at the moment that they're seeing conflicting data, they're predicting this future of motion
- 4:09that, you know, that's unsafe, right?
- 4:11They're going to be embarrassed.
- 4:12Their boss is going to be mad at them.
- 4:15And they're basically trying to avoid that scenario.
- 4:17Well, the truth is if you face that scenario earlier in your process, whatever, the chances
- 4:27that you end up with the embarrassment go down.
- 4:32Because like, when you, you've stated some, you know, prediction to your firm, whatever
- 4:36it is, I don't care, sales and investment, I don't care whatever it is.
- 4:41And you start to get information that's not working out the way you thought.
- 4:45Well, the sooner you get that and sooner you change course and address, you know, the
- 4:49better the odds of a better outcome, right?
- 4:53But if you delay, because you don't really realize you're predicting this future of embarrassment,
- 4:59the outcome is probably worse.
- 5:01But like, people have no cognitive ability to override that underlying prediction of embarrassment,
- 5:11except to use their thinking to address, wait a minute, I'm really worried.
- 5:17You know, I don't want to try to be wrong because I have sounded like an idiot.
- 5:20It's going to be embarrassing.
- 5:21And they've no way to lose my job just because people have tendency to catastrophize.
- 5:25But the truth is, the earlier an incident that you can face, you know, alternative data
- 5:31that shows your prediction may not be turning out to be like, chances are you can course
- 5:36correct earlier.
- 5:39But it requires knowing that you're feeling like you're predicting this future problem.
- 5:45That's going to give you, it gives you the space to navigate.
- 5:50They don't have, if you're just like torturing the data to prove that your original prediction
- 5:56is correct while you're crossing your fingers and hoping and experiencing all the same
- 6:00side, I don't know, I hope I try to do that, you know, when you say, when you, when you
- 6:06lay it out, it actually makes a lot of sense.
- 6:08But you, I guess, so the issue that we're sort of uncovering is a little bit of, like
- 6:13you mentioned, like we have biases, but after a certain point, there's ego involved.
- 6:18You just don't want to be embarrassed.
- 6:20So when, when you speak to people that operate at this level, the things that are fears,
- 6:27are they valid fears?
- 6:28Like in my opinion, they would be valid fears.
- 6:31Like if I make a sales prediction and it's totally off at any point when I bring that
- 6:37up with my board, they're probably going to have some level of, there's going to be
- 6:44some thought like as to whether or not I'm competent.
- 6:47That's it.
- 6:48Yeah.
- 6:49Of course.
- 6:50Right.
- 6:51Right.
- 6:52Like if you walk through the scenario, it's like completely logical, right?
- 6:56Like, so this is the thing, like an emotion, particular fear, has a totally bad rap,
- 7:03right?
- 7:04Like you're not supposed to feel, feel fear or give into fear or whatever.
- 7:10And like, it's not true.
- 7:13Like if it weren't for fear, there's a lot of accomplishments we all have that we wouldn't
- 7:19accomplish.
- 7:20Like who would really graduate from college if it weren't for fear?
- 7:23Right.
- 7:24You'd do all this other stuff, you know, but you're afraid of the outcome of only partying
- 7:31and not getting the actual degree, like so you'd do the work, you know, you really do
- 7:37the work just because you want it to work, right?
- 7:39Like you do the work because you're afraid of what will happen.
- 7:41Like in their pure form, fear, frustration, disappointment, have information for us.
- 7:50So we've got two problems.
- 7:51We've been told not to recognize any of them and we've certainly been told not to focus
- 7:56on this so called negative ones.
- 7:59When they're in their pure form, they're actually trying to help us.
- 8:01They're trying to keep us safe, trying to help us get what we want.
- 8:04Like frustration is something's going wrong.
- 8:07Take the extreme form of frustration, well, the extreme form would be like rage, but
- 8:11let's take an interim anger.
- 8:13Why do people get angry?
- 8:16Because they feel as if something's wrong.
- 8:20So sometimes it is and sometimes it's their own personal expectation and that's like
- 8:28the next layer of this, what part is real and what part is your own personality, but
- 8:31we can come back to that.
- 8:33And it's core.
- 8:34Like if you're angry with something, your psyche is telling you that something isn't the
- 8:37way you think it should be and maybe you should try to research yourself and find out
- 8:42what that is.
- 8:43This is supposed to say I shouldn't be angry because what the research actually shows is
- 8:47you suppress those emotions, particularly the negative ones, the voice in your psyche
- 8:52gets louder.
- 8:53So they become more disruptive, not less disruptive.
- 8:58And the way it shows is if you suppress it, I mean, there's, you know,
- 9:03I mean, the truth is, you know, in psychology research, you can probably find research to
- 9:08show whatever you want, but there is a good body of research that shows that understanding
- 9:18your negative emotions, acknowledging them leads to better outcomes, particularly
- 9:25that matters to you.
- 9:27When I first heard of this research, it was probably 2008 and I met this woman who at
- 9:33that time was like a postdoc PhD and she had done this research project to show that
- 9:40reframing, you know, situations was a net positive.
- 9:47And to her credit, her research showed that wasn't true.
- 9:51But if you reframed, in other words, you know, took a positive viewpoint or something,
- 9:56on something that didn't matter that much to you, it worked.
- 10:02But if you did it on something that actually really mattered to you, your anxiety levels
- 10:06went up and it didn't work.
- 10:09Why?
- 10:10Because your psyche, like, your psyche really is trying to keep you safe and that kind
- 10:16of includes more than safe, like, it includes thrive.
- 10:21So if you have some unpleasant feeling, it's like, you know, I'll send you, like, feel
- 10:28this horrible pain in your leg and you look down and you know, you've got to gash in
- 10:33your chin for whatever reason, you know.
- 10:37Like, what's the point?
- 10:38The point of the physical pain is like, so that you do something about it.
- 10:42Why is it any different with emotional pain?