Latest / The Goats of Growth / Why PayReady's All-AI Rollout Failed, and the Human-in-the-Loop Fix That Worked
Transcript
- Jay Webb: What's good, everybody? Welcome to another episode of The Goats of Growth, where I interview go-to-market leaders and founders at tech companies to learn how they've been adopting AI in the effect positively or negatively, by the way, it's having on go-to-market operations. Not sponsored by anyone yet, but speaking of negative impacts, AI might be having, if it's making it harder to stand out in a sea of AI-generated content like emails and Facebook posts or LinkedIn posts, etc. And decision makers aren't answering your reps calls anymore, then please reach out to me, J at thegoats of growth.ai, to find out how you can sponsor this podcast, which will help you break through the noise and have me read read your ads live throughout these episodes in front of go-to-market decision makers like today's guest, who happens to be Dustin Schwarz, an operations and customer experience leader who spent 15 plus years building scalable service delivery inside multifamily and the prop tech world. With senior leadership roles at companies like Railpage, Rainmaker Group, and LiveCorps. Today he's the chief customer officer at Payready, the multifamily SaaS platform behind AI driven rent collection, resident and payment portals, and CRM tools serving three and a half million plus units. Dustin, welcome to the Goats of Growth. Dustin Schwarz: Thank you very much, Jay. glad to be here. Jay Webb: Yeah, absolutely. So tell me a little bit about what what I just ended with, which is pay ready. Talk to me about the value prop there in your role there's chief customer. Dustin Schwarz: Certainly, yes. So our value profit pay ready is around reducing bad debt for multifamily operators. Right. We find that they're the most effective when they're focused on serving their customers and leasing and things that drive value. but it is, you know, a meaningful and real part of the business that, you know, sometimes when people move out or, you know, they incur balances and that there bad debt to recover. So we have a series of tools available to help them with that venture, starting with when they're a resident, Payment portal options, making it easier to pay and interact with AI to overcome obstacles to pay rent. you know, we we move into the CRM space for these multifamily operators, especially around move out. So if they want to track residents and interact with them through our systems, they're able to do so. And then we also have, you know, some third party vendors that we work with and our new proprietary AI tools that we can use to interact with people through that move out process to help you know. Just help people that want to pay pay in a more human way, right? I mean, there's always been third party collections out there, right? And that will continue to exist. But personally and at pay ready, we don't believe that that's where things should start. Right. So this is a softer, non punitive approach, right? No late fees, no interest, none of those penalties, you know, for the people that are really just trying to do the right thing. Jay Webb: Tell me about when AI, and thank you for for that breakdown. Tell me about when AI was introduced to your service offering and and the journey that that you took, right? Because obviously, old school sort of way of doing business right, I'm sure, in terms of rent collection and that type of stuff. So I think education internally for you guys, but then also for your customers. Tell me about that. Dustin Schwarz: Yeah, certainly. So we've always been interested. Our CEO, he's on the bleeding edge and always, you know, trying the new things. But, you know, we were a legacy business, right? We had established customers, processes, employees. So, I mean, it's probably about a year and a half ago now. We went out and acquired a company called Buzz.ai. And what was special about Buzz to us was that this was AI trained on multifamily property management behaviors. Right, not just trying to take generic AI and fit it into your box, which I think a lot of companies have done. You know, we spent the extra resources to go out and find something built in our space. It was built by an actual property management company. So we were very comfortable that they were familiar with the space. And so that was our our jumping into the pool with both feet moment. Right. So Jay Webb: Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: we inherited their customers, their product. they were serving current residents in a lot of different ways. And we've really expanded that through the move out process and used their technology. as a foundation to offer different product lines with AI. Jay Webb: In w when you started rolling it out to your customers, what was the the the response? Dustin Schwarz: every possible side of the spectrum that that you could think of, right? traditionally, multifamily housing has not been a leading adopter in technology adoption. Just generally, Jay Webb: Mm. Mm. Dustin Schwarz: I think it's a more conservative industry from the risk appetite aspect. when I worked for a property management company right immediately before I came to Pay Ready, AI was kind of a hard stop, right? Like we're just not interested due to consumer and reputational risks, legislative risks, particularly anything tied to money. So, you know, my former employer, of course, is one of our customers, right? So that started a lot of of really challenging discussions of working through how do you make your customers feel better about this, right? People who, you know, aren't all in on AI and and are concerned about these things. And so we really had to understand where their concerns came from and build safeguards into everything that we do, be the contracts that we sign, right? Like like how do we structure things, the workflows, when do humans get involved? That was the big one, I think, right? I think a lot of customers understand this is the way the world is going. But as of now, a lot of people, and and I think rightly so, honestly, believe that you do sometimes need a human for the complex situation, for the escalation, for the problem. And so, you know, making people feel better about that, building those processes, that was the key because originally we tried to just launch it as a fully AI solution. So we rolled out some of our customers, completely replacing our legacy concierge offering that we had, which was kind of that soft touch human outreach. And AI was just not as effective. So now we had the concerns with Performance added in along with all of these other concerns about, you know, this AI is our brand, you know, basically putting in front of everybody. So through the past, you know, year or so, a little less than a year, we've built those human and the loop processes you know, to really bring it in. And that's on our our customer side where we're doing outreach as well, just Jay Webb: It's it's just Dustin Schwarz: internally, like our own support team, right? Just applying all these same principles internally where Routing and simple conversations can be done in an automated way, but you've still got that human backup for the things that are a little bit more complicated or heated. Jay Webb: Man, there's a lot there that you said. I'm trying to pick which one I wanna sort of tug on a little bit here. Let me just start with one of the things you said most recently, which is not as effective. AI was not as effective as as what it you thought it may be, so to speak. Give me an example of of where you thought it would be better, I s so so to speak, and and maybe the the surprise that that it that it wasn't as as effective as you wanted. Dustin Schwarz: certainly. So, you know, I'll I'll use our, you know, sort of that concierge soft outreach post-move-out process. Jay Webb: Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: in theory, right, automation is going to be more effective at our scale, right? We have millions of units, you know, hundreds of thousands of move outs, you know, occurring on a monthly basis. And you don't reach somebody every time you try to call right? So like having a human trying to reach people to talk about these things, It's just it doesn't feel scalable. So the idea that you can you can hit a voicemail drop theoretically on every person every day if you really wanted to. So so it just felt like it can't possibly result in less true connections and resolutions, right? and I and I just did not experience that, right? So these touch points might have been there, but this Jay Webb: Mm-hmm. Dustin Schwarz: is a sensitive discussion, right? This is, you know, perhaps. I don't agree that the oven wasn't clean enough when I moved out or that there was a stain on the carpet, right? It's not just as simple as send someone link, deposit money in account, right? And so these highly skilled humans that built this skill set over a period of years might not be able to speak with everybody every day, but they have so much of a higher completion rate or success rate when they have that discussion that the net result was higher. So that was you know, learning experience, right? But you don't know until you try. We learned exactly where the gaps were. You know, so this was a a known and calculated risk, right? To jump in with both feet on this. we learned where the gaps were and went out and built a hybrid process where, you know, escalations or people that aren't being responsive, right? They're the ones that are gonna get that human touch. If people have a question that trips up the bot. Right. They go into a certain queue that goes to a a highly skilled person who's dealt with exactly that kind of thing before. Right. So now with automation, and I think this is another key thing that I like to hit on is we're all using AI, I think, as a an all-encompassing buzzword for all of the efficiency gains and improvements that we're making right now. But it's it's not just LLMs and their power or agents, right? the development in data science and other types of automation and low-code automation, like I'm talking well n8n and zapier some that we've used. I know there's a ton of other tools there. it's just transforming how you can do this stuff, right? So we can literally take a discussion if a person says a certain keyword, for example, and that can go to a certain human who's a specialist in that keyword, right? It's just a a level of automation that was not possible just probably two years ago. Jay Webb: Do you s let's let's move forward two years from now, actually. Do you see a world where in two years your team has the capability or in the agent, frankly, is capable of of of learning even more and being more effective and maybe removing the human from the loop? Let's say let's say human in the loop is maybe you have the number here, but let's call it like thirty-five percent, right? Do you think maybe in two years it can get down to say the human in the is in the loop? Fifteen percent, right? Do you see that? As a as a possibility? Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: Absolutely. It's the worst it's ever going to be today. Right. if Jay Webb: Yeah. All right. Dustin Schwarz: we're looking forward, I think that's, you know, our chief product officer, I've heard him say that multiple times. and and I believe it to be true. So, so absolutely. I mean, we're using these examples to further train. And you know, at some point, business is all about judgment, right? And at some point, it's just worth it to accept that, right? So even if we get to a point where You know that automation is only, I mean, I think 15% is the number you said. So let's say it's 85% as effective as a human. As a business leader, some companies are just going to decide that's good enough, right? And they're going to go ahead with that 85%. And that's how a lot of businesses will be run. that's not how I operate. You know, I have been my own customer, not in the same time, but like I've been a multifamily property operator. I know that experience. So my goal in my job. is to deliver 100% of the efficacy to them and or more than 100%, right? As we get that automation. And so I think that some companies will pull that trigger and two years from now that's where we'll be. I expect there will be still some meaningful human involvement, at least in what I'm doing. Jay Webb: Tell me about the legislative risk that you alluded to. Tell me and and what was the how did you overcome that obstacle? Dustin Schwarz: th that's becoming more challenging with the lack of Jay Webb: Mm. Dustin Schwarz: federal oversight in these spaces. Jay Webb: Hmm. Hmm. Dustin Schwarz: you know, so in the space where we operate, right, there's multiple different angles that we have to be watching. So there's the AI specific angle, right? So that just ties into AI communication. I think that there's some traction around job loss legislation, around call centers specifically, right? Jay Webb: Mm. Dustin Schwarz: And so like there's that internal facing angle. That we have to be conscious of, right? If we go to 100% automation and all of a sudden there's a law that, like, no, nope, actually, we care about call center jobs, we can't do that. Right. You have to hedge against that. There's also the consumer side, right? Which is if everybody can do all of this, you know, calling and voicemail dropping with AI all of the time, the inbound traffic to people like you and me and everybody else in the country will be just so overwhelming that that's going to be limited. That's further limited by Anything related to collections. So although I said the beginning of the call, I don't think things should start with collections, sometimes they end up there ultimately, eventually, in the process. That's heavily regulated you know, around Jay Webb: Mm. Mm-hmm. Dustin Schwarz: these kinds of communications. To make that even more challenging, we now have state and even municipality level rules and laws around how often can you call somebody, how many total times can you contact them in a seven-day period that's rolling? if you actually Talk to them, when can you talk to them again? Right. So like this becomes really hard to track. And it's an area where we've done the best that we can, but we're we're struggling to keep up with because again, you know, housing is so sensitive. There's a lot of discussion around junk fees as well that picked up in the Biden administration, but I don't think it's completely gone away. And so, you know, again, that's subjective. What is junk, right? But ultimately, whatever you're charged when you move in or while you live there. when you move out, if that's part of your balance, that is also a discussion. And so I'm hopeful that there's some federal level simplicity that comes of this, because right now it's a patchwork that we're struggling with. Jay Webb: kind of alluded to it just a bit there, but how do you keep up with the all of the, you know, regulations and compliance and and and all that? Like it's just I'm assuming as a as a team you guys must have some something going on there. Tell me about it. Dustin Schwarz: y yes. we we have we brought in a heavy hitter as chief risk officer. Jay Webb: Mm. Dustin Schwarz: forgive me if that's not his exact actual title, but we brought in, you know, an industry veteran who's also a lawyer and that really just helps on making the judgment calls, right? So to make this even more confusing with these laws, there's often contradictory rulings. So the law Jay Webb: Right. Dustin Schwarz: is one thing, but then you see this ruling in practice and there's things and you're like, wait, this doesn't make sense, right? And so that It again, it comes down to judgments. So we brought in an expert to help us with those calculated risks and judgments. you know, and our director of compliance has been with us for a while, so they're doing a lot of work. And then we're using AI, right? You can scrub what's happening much faster and what you care about, right? So we know what we care about. We're we're pretty specific about that. so we're able to get that. And then we've also outsourced a bit of this to vendor partners. So You know, we have a vendor marketplace that you know we're responsible for. And so to participate in our marketplace, one of the responsibilities as a partner is that you are up to speed on all this. So that both A, whatever's happening should be compliant because I'm gonna hold you accountable to it. And then B, I learn from them, right? So I'm holding, you know, dozens of vendor partners accountable. Whatever I'm hearing from vendor partner one, two, three, four, five. I'm able to very quickly roll out. So it only takes one out of dozens to pick up on something before I'm able to distribute it throughout the network. Jay Webb: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. For sure. Yeah, that makes sense. Man, so many moving parts. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Dustin Schwarz: But it's not scientific. You can see the gaps there, right? Like there's there's potential. Jay Webb: Yeah, that's the thing. That's one of the reasons why I wanted to to do these episodes because there's so many moving parts and so many dyn so much d so many dynamics, I guess, to to building with AI, using AI. And I think that frankly, what you just described is is is is more of a moat than I feel like a lot of people have, because you can figure out the legislative part of it and have somebody like you said, the chief risk officer or somebody who is very learned and and and knows this stuff better than most, then you're able to cap your downside, so to speak, or other people who might be listening to this and be like, I'm gonna jump into the prop tech AI stuff too. And and they might be more at risk, right? Which your obviously makes you guys a lot more valuable. Dustin Schwarz: certainly. It's why I believe SaaS isn't dead, right? So there's it's easy to say, but what I think has actually happened is that the SaaS business built on a feature is dead. So like you're no longer Jay Webb: Hm, yeah. Dustin Schwarz: able to sell features because anybody can copy features. But but you're Jay Webb: Yes. Dustin Schwarz: right. I mean, you can still through clever design, through partnerships, you know, you can build a business that has a moat that people can't just go build and copy with AI. Even as we market ourselves as an AI forward business, I'm happy to talk about how we do a lot of these things. Because I'm confident that somebody with Claude Code's not gonna be able to figure it out Jay Webb: Well, the word that I've been using a lot lately is execution, right? So there's the mo there's one moat which is you know, as we talked about legislative and and compliance and all those things, the things that are really the hard blocking and tackling of trying to just get a get the thing going in the right direction. But the other thing is execution. and in particular for this conversation, like go to market execution. And one of the things that you said to the something to the effect of like at some point You know, companies are gonna decide, okay, well, that's you know, good enough, right? In other words, eighty five percent right is is good enough. Question I have is what's under what's the underlying thought there? In other words, why not one hundred percent? and how has how has the adoption of AI impacted the you know, growth for you guys, top line and bottom line? Broadly speaking, of course. Dustin Schwarz: Certainly. Yes. So on on the why is 85% good enough. you know, not not to make this into a political discussion, but I think the incentive structures that many companies operate by, that they are going by metrics that are not around customer satisfaction or l really seriously long tail or long term metrics, right? So a lot of SAS metrics out there to measure efficiency, for example, and in your valuation, right? Who that's running a SaaS company or, you know, whatever, doesn't care about your valuation. So there's metrics in there, like a like a revenue per employee, for example. So that's where it becomes good enough. you can push revenue up. That's really hard and that takes a lot of time. you cut the denominator. That's very fast. It does not take time, right? And so if you can mostly get where you're trying to go, you might be okay if you're, you know, backed by, you know, your financing system is encouraging this kind of behavior. You know, I think that Customers are experiencing this degrading quality. And this isn't a SAS problem. You know, I I think a lot of people, if you ask them like, hey, what's the quality now when you go to the dentist or the doctor or the vet? they might note that it's different than it was 10 or 20 years ago. And so that's where the customer is going to start being fed up, I think, with this good enough approach. And so I believe there is a place for companies like what we're doing, which is we're focused on that 100% for you. And maybe it'll cost a little bit more, but I think people will pay for it. And by the way, I'm not actually sure that it's gonna cost that much more in the long run because AI is not free, right? The amount of computing power required for these very complicated things, you can run up a serious bill. And so I think that that's another angle of it where I'm pretty confident that people that are taking a long-term view and a customer-centric view can still succeed. Jay Webb: One question regarding that. Are you consumption or a com consumption model or or like like monthly annual in terms of how people pay? Dustin Schwarz: we are we have both. So we are incentivized through more people, you know, paying their balance and their rent and and whatever, right? So it kind Jay Webb: Got it. Yep. Dustin Schwarz: of aligns the interest of our vendor partners of pay ready and our customer. We all win together. you Jay Webb: Mm-hmm. Dustin Schwarz: know, that said, we do have some of our products are straight SAS, you know, per ENU per month. so Jay Webb: Mm. Dustin Schwarz: you know, it's it varies. Jay Webb: Yeah, that makes sense. how has it when you sh made that shift, right? And you obviously made that that acquisition, what was the biggest impact when it comes to the health of the business in terms of in like an enormous cost reduction? you know, able to serve more customers at a particular margin that you weren't able to serve before. Like tell me about w where where the biggest impact was when you started building AI into your solution. Dustin Schwarz: Certainly. So from a straight variable margin, I think it was two and a half to three times, you know, somewhere in that neighborhood. So of course, that's an immediate, massive financial impact. Jay Webb: Mm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Dustin Schwarz: that's probably the the largest one, I guess that'd be the simple answer, but there's, you know, a lot more the efficiencies that come from that because we're using AI as our external facing product, but we've also used it internally, right? Like we're able to support Jay Webb: Mm-hmm. Dustin Schwarz: three times as many customers with one support agent than we could before. implementations, you know, we're twice as effective as we were before. So really the number is more than that. The other side of the coin would be, you know, from my job. So although my, you know, my title is a little more customer focused, a big part of my job is responsibility for that vendor network and like our actual operations of our company, our service component. It's allowed me to reduce the number of vendors that I depend upon and just simplify processes, right? And cutting out that noise potential other interests and all of that has just made my job easier. And that also has positive financial implication for us. Jay Webb: Yeah, for sure. What about build verse buy? in terms of how do you go about that and thinking about whether you're gonna have an AI component or or agents operating internally for you or as you were talking earlier, right? Because people can just buy these features or build these features for themselves, it's if it's gonna be more cost effective. So how do you think about that? Dustin Schwarz: i it's tough because you know, again, I think both answers can be right, depending on who you happen to be. The key is is the thing that you're buying, is it real? Right. Right now there's a lot out there, right? And you can with you know, with automated code now, you can build something that like at face value, looks real, operates. Th this is no longer, you know, Visio and you know. a clever designer making a click-through demo that looks real. It is real. You click, it works. There is code on the back end and it actually does a thing. Now you have a real software developer look at it and they'll be like, hey, this is held together with baling wire. And you know this is going to take just as much work to rebuild it. So that's where I believe despite what we're seeing with the ability of low code and the ability of people that aren't as technical to build code, a skilled software developer is still highly valuable and and they're worth the money because You can build something real. So I would say for us in buying Buzz, buy was the right thing. It it saved years of development time for us to be able to find something from our own industry that actually worked and did what it was supposed to do is a no-brainer. but I worked for RealPage previously, right, a little earlier in my career. And their strategy was heavily acquisition-based. I came into RealPage through an acquisition. And Some of those acquisitions I believe were were quite good. I think ours was a successful acquisition, you know, for real page. But I saw some that weren't. And the amount of pain caused by an ineffective acquisition, which isn't even always the fault of the acquired product and party, it can just be how you do it. Also, Jay Webb: Yeah. Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: that that can bring you down. So I would way rather build. So like if I can get an A grade, I'll buy A grade product that I'll buy it. If I'm not getting an A grade product, I think at this point with how fast you can develop stuff. I think build is the right answer for us as a tech company. I think if you're a multifamily property operator who we work with, you know, I think the calculation is is different. I think unless you are the gray star of the world, you know, and and you're absolutely massive, you don't want to inherit the tech debt. You don't want to bother with all of this stuff. So I would still buy, you know, if I was in that seat. Jay Webb: Well, you went by like a whole different level as far as what I was thinking. You were thinking about buying the entire company and acquiring which is which is on a whole another level. Dustin Schwarz: Yeah. Yeah. Sorry, that's what we did, yeah. Jay Webb: that's okay. For sure, for sure. I was thinking about more of, you know, when you have a particular solution, a feature where, you know, you hear like Jason Like as you guys are are are building and and even creating efficiencies, let's just say, within your go to market operation, how do you decide that in terms of okay, we're gonna buy HubSpot or we're gonna build something similar to the hub, you know, that kind of a thing. Dustin Schwarz: Yeah, I I'm still a fan of buy in that situation. Jay Webb: Yeah. Mm. Dustin Schwarz: but i it the world of who you buy from has changed. So we recently made a big change, right? We used the largest support and CRM provider in the industry. Some we had some friends out California, right? And we were using them and we just pivoted to intercom, right? A a more modern, smaller, more nimble provider that aligns to what we're trying to do and allows us to tie what we're doing. into what they're doing in an easy way. I know you can do anything if you if you're using the largest provider, you can do anything with them. If you have your own on staff admin or you're paying a consultant and you know, as a midsized SaaS company, that i is too much, right? And so could we have built our own support and CRM platform instead of, you know, HubSpot and Intercom together? Yeah, we could have. Jay Webb: Mm. Dustin Schwarz: I don't think it's worth it, right? The distraction is is not worth it for what we could have done with the same amount of time, with how effective our developers are now, how much value we can bring to customers, how we can scale what we're doing, I still want to keep the effort on that side. And now that we have a much more affordable solution because of the competitive landscape, I'm happy to buy. Jay Webb: Yeah, for sure. Let me ask you about skill sets that are, you know, necessary today, maybe than they weren't that they you know, maybe skill sets that weren't even a year ago or two years ago, right? As you start evaluing peop evaluating people and and bringing people into the organization, what are you looking for in terms of what they they need to have to use be more fluent in AI to understand maybe some of the stuff that we were just talking about in terms of like, okay, well, should we build, should we buy? Somebody internally that is comes to you and says, you know what, I know you were thinking about the solution, but you know what, I can build this and here's all the specs that are needed. Like tell me about that and and the impact that you hope the people coming into the organization are going to have. Dustin Schwarz: Yeah, it's it's interesting because I've I've really completely pivoted on this to where it you know, and this actually sounds terrible from somebody who's been in the same industry for you know, a really long time and would love to talk about my experience here, but I I value domain experience much less than I have in the past. I'm looking for for character traits and abilities. I would liken it to you know, I'm really into sports. I don't know if you are. I'm a big Jay Webb: yeah. Dustin Schwarz: f I'm a big NFL or NBA fan, right? You'll see Players get drafted that have had no success in college because they have the traits, right? They're they are tall enough, they are fast enough. And the thought being, okay, well, we can get there. We can, we can have them stand in front of a ball machine and have them catch 5,000 balls a day. We'll teach them to catch, but you can't teach that speed, right? Jay Webb: Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: so well, for me, it's not speed, but I want to see people that are creative and adaptable. I think that's the thing, is You you asked the two years out question from a product perspective. I don't know what I will need from you two years from now. I I Jay Webb: Mm-hmm. Dustin Schwarz: don't know how things are gonna run internally. We run so differently now than we did two years ago that I think the biggest, most important things is that you can roll with that. And you're intelligent, right? So an intelligent person who is flexible and willing to figure it out, that's what I'm looking for because you know, I can eventually teach you about multifamily housing. But those things, you know, and and further, we're a work from home company for the most part. So like intrinsic work ethic and and ability to do that, these are just things that you can't really teach. So I'm much more focused on finding somebody who's got a track record of success in their career doing cool, varied things. that's who I'm looking for. So if I want account manager, that I want that. I don't want somebody who, like, hey, I've I've been account managing for 25 years. That's Cool, but we're we're not gonna do it how you've been doing it for twenty five years, so that's less relevant. Jay Webb: Why has it changed though? In other words, and I appreciate that because it makes a lot of sense actually, but why has that changed? Because I feel like let's say four years ago, you could have said the same thing. Other words, I need somebody who's adaptable because I don't know where we're gonna be two years ago or you know, two years from now. Or is that because things are changing so rapidly and things are changing so fast that that's what makes it more important? Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: Yes. It it's it's the pace. I mean, really, as much as we felt like life always changed and it did and things moved forward. you know, if you look at like implementing a SaaS product at many companies in 2000 and in twenty nineteen, you might see a world where they're using Outlook, emailing Excel sheets, you fill out the data, they have somebody come in and, you know, do the data and set up like things really just had not changed. that much. where where now, you know, there there's entire concepts that we didn't even know about five years ago that if you don't know how to do it and handle it, you can't be effective in a technology company. Jay Webb: about the prospects of someone coming in and having not I don't know, gone beyond a chat bot, so to speak, right? They've they've typed in Gemini or chat GPT to give them a list, but they haven't necessarily been as hands-on or, you know, really understand it to a certain level. And maybe not even to the point where they need to be experts, but I feel like you I think you've mentioned you know, creative, right? Curious. It's it's like if you're not curious enough to roll your sleeves up and just even build something for yourself at your home, so to speak. then you know, maybe maybe that's not the person right now. Tell me about what you what you're thinking in in terms of that. Dustin Schwarz: I mean, I I think it just depends on if that desire is there, right? So i is this a I mean, I I hate to give a free pass completely, but is this a victim of circumstance or just because they they aren't as interested, right? If you worked for a a legacy company that didn't do it, you know, I know some companies that still don't have a corporate AI account, you know, things like that. that's that's one thing. So it's all about are you wanting to and do display those other traits. Because I think somebody who displays those traits can pick up how to use AI pretty quickly. Like Anthropic has wonderful online learning for free on how to learn their stuff. Right. And so I think that you can pick it up if you really want to. It's not about how technical the person is. It's about these other skills. And another really interesting skill that I look for now is vocabulary and linguistic skill. Right. So Jay Webb: Hmm. Dustin Schwarz: you're output from AI depends heavily on what you put in. So the ability to articulate complex things in a way that a bot that may not have context can understand. Like you the the people that did well in you know English and language arts in high school, like this is a a big advantage where, you know, the people that are analytically very strong, you know, one one of my things I pride myself on is is analytics. And I'm like, I can ask Claude and get what I used to work all day on in five seconds. That skill Jay Webb: Yeah, yeah. Dustin Schwarz: set is is not as valuable in this situation. Jay Webb: Yeah, for sure. Yep, absolutely. And one of the things, one of the traits that I I'm appreciating more, frankly, is is persisting through the prompts, to be honest with you, right? In other words, because I think that you know what we're what we've been accustomed to, speaking of putting something in the chat GPT or or Gemini, I put something into Claude actually, which is what I use about a month or two ago, and it got the math wrong. And I'm talking about this is Dustin Schwarz: Yeah. Yeah. Jay Webb: pretty basic math and I push back on it and so well wait a minute, this isn't this isn't right, right? And I feel like a lot of people accept what they see at face value, even though it says at the bottom of the thing, like AI can can get it wrong. Like it it you you know, if you're when you're to me, I feel like if you are building enough stuff or just a or even coming at it with a particular domain expertise, right? A particular point of view, that's going to be illuminated even more, right? And so to be able to sort of understand that and then to persist through that and sort of work with Claude, right, as a co pilot, not somebody who's just taking who's just gonna take over and do your work for you, I think is something that that people have to sort of have as well, you know. Dustin Schwarz: Yeah, no, you're you're spot on. I probably should have definitely included that because that is something I care about greatly as well. And it's Jay Webb: Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: the the critical thinking, right, aspect of it and the ability to iterate through. Interestingly though, Claude can also just help you with that. Right? Like Claude can help you pick apart Claude if you just have the patience and and like what you're looking Jay Webb: Yes. Yes. Yes. Dustin Schwarz: for is that persistence to do so. You don't even need to know why Claude is wrong. You can Jay Webb: Right. Dustin Schwarz: sometimes just ask it, like, hey, what are the holes in what you're saying? So so no, Jay Webb: Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: yeah. I'm with you. That is, that is important. But it's again, it's just a different set of skills than was rewarded five years ago. And so the fact that somebody got promoted a whole bunch through the 2010s, you know, may not mean that they're the most successful in the 2020s. Jay Webb: That's right. Yep. That's right. One thing you you obviously talked about some of the shortcomings, one of the shortcomings it had in terms of b it being effective with communicating with you know, your customers in terms of resolving resolving issues and that type of stuff. Is there anything else, before I I just this last question before we get into the rapid fire fight, but is there anything else that that you've put initiative into or that pointed an agent to where it failed. And the reason I'm revisiting this is because I feel like it happens every day with me, to be honest with you. Right. And I feel Dustin Schwarz: Yeah, yeah. Jay Webb: like, you know, there's a lot of AI, I call it AI porn out there where it's like, I my agent did this and I fired my team and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, and all this stuff. Right. And it's like it's just not that easy. Right. Like it's really not that easy. And that's that's why I mentioned that word persistence, right? You gotta persist through it and work through it. with Claude and friggin and figure out what's right and what's wrong and all that stuff. And I feel like I wanna make sure that people understand that, you know, who who who maybe fall into that bucket of they're just using Chat GP to the Ch GPT and they're just using Gemini, that there's so much that goes into it. And even if you build something and it fails or you know, something like that, that, you know, you know it's it's not you're not alone, number one, and just expect that to work through it. So any anything else that may have surprised you or just Dustin Schwarz: yes, I think there's there's three areas where I've seen it consistently fail. the first is people. So people are far too complex for what AI can understand. And so I've seen people try to use it that are in leadership positions. So, you know, h hey, I have a lot of people on my team. I'm gonna use AI to help manage my team or help coach my team or anything related to feelings whatsoever. I would advise not following. the advice that you get professionally and even more so personally, you know, you hear about people using it as your therapist and stuff like I've seen it say such laughably atrocious things as far as advice on what to say in a personal situation that I'm like, I cannot believe anything that you tell me now. So I think that that's a big one. You know, so if you're making a r a riff list, sure you can ask the AI general questions. You cannot ask it who should be on there, right? Like Jay Webb: Right, right. Dustin Schwarz: y you know, so this just like taking the human aspect out and trusting AI to handle that, I think is a mistake. judgment is another thing that it cannot do. so you know, what should I do, Gemini, is not something an executive should make an actual decision based upon. As an executive, you can be like, Hey, what am I not thinking of? What are the pros and cons, right? Like there is a way to use Gemini to help you get to the right decision, but ultimately the skills that have made executives win in the past around that judgment or leading people, managing people, motivating people, those skills I think are still extremely valuable. And so, you know, just because we're excited about what we can do with technology, those things are still very important. There's still a lot of people out there that I think are scared right now. And so I think leadership is is something you cannot outsource. And I think some people are trying. And I don't think that that's going to go very well for them. So I think those are some areas. And the last is hardcore analytics. as far as, you know, you were mentioning the numbers thing. We ha we're plugged into all the numbers within our systems. And I think, yeah, there are still times where it's like, hey, that number can't possibly be right. I mean, until that that used to happen with analysts too. It still does. but until it happens far less with AI, I don't think that you can trust high visibility, high importance things like, you know, I don't know, presenting to your board and stuff like that on on the analytics. I mean, you still need checks and balances. I think those are areas where I'm still hesitant. Jay Webb: People and failing people and failings together, so to speak, judgment and hardcore analytics. That analytics thing actually surprises me a little bit. So you've seen it where the analyti where it's gotten the analytics wrong, essentially, right? Wow. Hmm. Dustin Schwarz: Yes. The the issue is not the math, right? It's always right on the math. The issue is understanding the context and the idiosyncrasies of like what you're really trying to ask. Because I mean, at least I think what most people are trying to do is replace BI, right? So hey, instead of BI that has this canned set of reports that I need, I just want to be able to ask the question and get the answer. That's where it fails. So in in the idea of I want to duplicate what I had with my BI system before. You can build a report and it looks pretty and send it out. AI is great for that. You're that kind of hardcore analytics, I think you can win. It's the, hey, I'm gonna be meeting with my board. Hmm, this thing just happened. What is the financial impact of that? Do do do do do do do do do right? The numbers that I get back from that are that's what is so bad. because it can't Jay Webb: Hmm. Interesting, yes. Dustin Schwarz: it can't process and understand. you know, I don't know, what kind of revenue are you talking about? And and our systems are all messy. It's about the underlying data, right? And so, Jay Webb: Mm-hmm. Dustin Schwarz: you know, it'll it'll miss things. And so that's where I just don't quite trust yet. Jay Webb: Yeah, interesting. I hear that. The quality of revenue, so to speak, right? Just as an example, right? Yep. Mm-hmm. Dustin Schwarz: Right. Like one time, one time versus recurring. And like you can program all of that out if you're very diligent. But I think the casual AI user is not very diligent like that. It's the customer success manager going to talk to a customer soon. Give me the numbers on this customer. How many support tickets do they have? How many were resolved? how much money did they make this quarter? That's where I get scared. Right? It's it's that kind. Jay Webb: Yeah. Yep. Yeah. Makes sense. Makes sense. Awesome. Okay, great. That's a great place to end the the main part of the the interview. But now let's jump into what I call the rapid fire five, where I ask you five questions. You give me five answers, and then we'll we'll get a bonus question from you where need to have you ask the next guest a question that you've thought of. All right. Dustin Schwarz: Sounds good? Jay Webb: Fabulous. All right, first question. what motivates you? Dustin Schwarz: I I grew up on a farm, so work ethic was never optional and that stuck. You know, I don't nothing other than that. Jay Webb: Love it. W name a big goal you have right now and when would you like to accomplish it? Dustin Schwarz: Okay, this one's kind of funny. the Taco Bell fifty K, which I know you're gonna have to Google later and that's okay. but Jay Webb: Yes. Dustin Schwarz: there's there's a a fifty K run with ten Taco Bell stops. And I tried it last year and ended up with a a fairly severe injury. And so I really want to complete it this year without incident. That's my goal. Jay Webb: my goodness. I I have to ask, what what to how many taco bells did you get to before you injured yourself? Dustin Schwarz: un unfortunately all of them. Jay Webb: Okay. Why you say unfortunately? That sounds at least like some plus kind of accomplishment. Dustin Schwarz: You know, you here's the ironic thing. I never liked Taco Bell before. It was a joke, right? This is funny. Jay Webb: Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: It's crazy. It's a joke. I now crave Taco Bell. I I had here's how bad it got. I had surgery. That so my injury was severe enough that I needed surgery after this goofy run. And they they c of course put you under. And I'm getting a ride home from my wife and I'm groggy and coming out of anesthesia and I'm hungry because I haven't eaten all day. And I don't really remember this because I was all loopy. Apparently I demanded that it was Taco Bell. Jay Webb: Ha ha Dustin Schwarz: So like coming out of surgery, you know, I I wanted I don't know, three soft tacos or something. So so I don't know how to explain it. but anyway, need to find somebody. Jay Webb: That's amazing. Yeah. Now I that's why Yeah. Now I understand the context behind unfortunately all of them. That's pretty funny. Dustin Schwarz: Yeah. Jay Webb: my gosh. Okay. number three, what's your most preferred way to learn new information to stay sharp? Dustin Schwarz: human interaction, talking to people like yourself or you know, I have a a valued circle that I've developed through the course of my life that I just like to spend time with people that I think are intelligent and I like their outlook. I learn so much more from them and it's more efficient. I like reading books and and taking courses. I just don't have time anymore. And Jay Webb: Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: so I need to be very targeted. So maybe these discussions might prompt me then to go take a certain course or read a certain book and do something targeted. but I I'm getting it from people and now I'm supplementing that a bit with AI interaction. Right. As I go through the day, I I'm trying to realize where things cause friction and then using AI to identify well, like, okay, I experienced this friction. Where do I acquire the skills so that doesn't happen in the future? you know, so I'd say those two are the more efficient ways for me. Jay Webb: Which I love that. It's one of the reasons why I love doing this podcast because I feel like it's a master class every time I meet somebody. You know, it's like you're always learning something new for sure. And Dustin Schwarz: Yeah. Yeah, Jay Webb: I get to invite people to listen as well. here's a c again a very interesting question that I got from a guest a while ago that I decided to keep as part of the Rapid Fire Five, which is who's your favorite character of all time? And it could be a neighbor down the street when you were growing up, it could be a character in a movie, it could be anybody. Just it's a pretty wide open question. So who's your favorite character of all time? Dustin Schwarz: Okay, so it's it's pretty funny because this answer is goofy too, and I promise I can be serious sometimes. I often am. Jay Webb: Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: but it's it's yogurt from Space Balls. Have you seen the movie? Jay Webb: I saw that so long ago and I can't even necessarily remember it. But yeah, tell me about it. Of course. That's Dustin Schwarz: My last name is Schwartz. I do I really have a choice? Jay Webb: true. That's so funny. I Dustin Schwarz: Yeah, no choice. Jay Webb: love it. my gosh. Yeah, that came out so long ago, Spaceballs. My gosh. Yeah. What is? the sequel? Really? Wow. Jeez, I didn't know that. That's interesting. Wow. Yeah, no Dustin Schwarz: Yeah, eighty eighty something. Sequel coming out next year, I think. The sequel Yeah. Yeah, like thirty years later. I don't know, I guess about Jay Webb: kidding, huh? Some really good sequels coming out next year. Frozen 3, too. actually, no, I think that's in a few years. what's your favorite thing to do when you aren't working? Dustin Schwarz: Anything automotive, restoring classic cars, racing, overlanding. If it's got four wheels, I'm in. Jay Webb: Wow, that's cool. I gotta ask, what's the most what's the last classic car that you restored? Dustin Schwarz: so right now I have well, I I guess I have a sixty-nine Plymouth Roadrunner right now in Jay Webb: Mm-hmm. Dustin Schwarz: color called B5 Blue that I really like and it's a four speed. I didn't do that one myself. I put together an automatic sixty-eight Firebird and I wanted the four speed, so I sold mine and I bought that. But you know, that's kind of my jam is the older muscle cars. And then for racing and stuff, I've got a Hellcat Hellcat Red Eye Wide Body Jailbreak, which is the biggest tongue twister of a name. but but it'll rip. So, you know, those are kind of my g my rigs. Jay Webb: So you race the cars too. Dustin Schwarz: Yes. Jay Webb: That is so cool. That is amazing. I gotta s you gotta send me the the name of that twang twister because I gotta take a look at that, for sure. Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: a hundred percent. Yeah, I'll email that over. Jay Webb: That is amazing. okay, so here is the part where you get to ask a bonus question, so to speak, or the question to the next guest. Unfortunately, I don't have one for you because as you know, I've had some technical issues and a couple of the guests that I had before. I couldn't even get that far into the the episode and the connection broke and they never actually asked the question. So I'm starting here with you, which I believe will be like the fifth episode of this new season, so to speak. So but what question would you like for me to ask the next guest? Dustin Schwarz: Yeah, certainly. So I I like to try to cut through the fluff and get real answers from people. So I'm gonna try to get one that'll get you something good. But I I wanna know like Jay Webb: Yeah. Dustin Schwarz: what's a best practice or belief in your industry or in tech that you believe is wrong and and how do you swim against the stream on that? Jay Webb: Leaf in your industry that you believe is wrong, and how do you swim against the how do you swim against the the green, so to speak? The the current. Dustin Schwarz: The current. Jay Webb: Yeah, the current on that. Okay. very interesting. That's that's a good one for sure, for sure. I can't wait to ask that one. for sure, you're right. And that's what I was saying earlier about POV, right? In other words, you have coming to the table with a a POV, whether it's building AI or whether you're sitting across from a customer, right? You have to have that strong POV. because everybody can just look it up and be like, yeah, this is this is right or this is wrong, whatever, right? So very interesting. fantastic. Well let me ask you this. How what's the best way for people to reach out to you to say thank you for doing this? Maybe they are interested in in pay ready, maybe they're interested in looking for an opportunity there. Tell me what's the best way for people to to reach out to you? Dustin Schwarz: I'm I'm pretty good at LinkedIn right now. So I think that's probably the easiest place to find me. They'll have my correct spelling, you know, on here. just reach out there if you're interested in pay ready, you I'll get you with somebody on our bizdad team. And if you just want to chat, sorry, went horse horse at the wrong time there at the end. you know, but then I can ping people my seller email or whatever, take it from there. Jay Webb: Yeah, and it's Dustin Schwartz with a with a with a Z, no T, just S C H W A R Z. When I was looking you up, trying to pull up your LinkedIn profile, I go, where is he? I go, Yeah, wait a minute, I gotta I gotta get rid of the T. Dustin Schwarz: Matters. Jay Webb: and don't forget everybody to when you you reach out to him to use the goats of growth in the subject line or you know, somewhere very early in the message, so he can pay pay special attention to you because obviously if you heard him on the goats of growth, you are certainly in unique company for sure. So Dustin, I wanna and you and you're growth minded by the way, just by listening to this podcast. so Dustin, I wanna I wanna thank you, A, for your patience and grace. because again, we've had technical difficulties before. So I appreciate that. I appreciate you sharing all of your information that you've had with us for sure. Like I said, I'm certainly gonna be smarter as a result of it. And I feel like people who are listening to this will be as well. for those listening, please go follow Dustin, reach out to say thank you in for this episode and this podcast. Don't forget to subscribe, rate, and review, and of course tell your colleagues, friends and Everybody so that it signals to folks that this is something worth listening to. in the meantime, thank you, Dustin, and goodbye, everybody.