Latest / The Vegan Report / The Chimps & Monkeys of Fauna Sanctuary Need your Love! With Dr. Mary Lee Jensvold | Ep. 01
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:05If you're vegan for the animals and you care to do more for animal rights, but you're not sure
- 0:12where to start, then this podcast is for you. Every week, let yourself fall in love with
- 0:18passionate animal rights leaders who will inspire you to find your voice, your own special
- 0:25contribution to the animal rights movement, however small or big it is. Today we are going
- 0:32to talk about compassion and how to extend our compassion not only to fellow homo sapiens,
- 0:40but also to other primates like chimps or monkeys. I have with me Dr. Mary Lee Jensvold.
- 0:48Mary Lee Jensvold is a primate communication scientist and associate director at Fona
- 0:54Foundation. I invite everyone to visit the Fona Foundation website at fonafoundation.org.
- 1:02You can find more details in the description below. She has spent her career working with
- 1:08the signing chimpanzees, Waxu, I think that's how you pronounce the name, and her family. Mary Lee
- 1:16is the former director of the Chimpanzee and Human Communication Institute at Central Washington
- 1:22University. Her interests in chimpanzee sanctuaries include care, practices, behavior, design,
- 1:30and welfare. Her expertise is in chimpanzee behavior and communication. She's a senior
- 1:37lecturer in the primate behavior and ecology program and anthropology department at Central
- 1:44Washington University. She has numerous publications in journals and books. Thank you very much,
- 1:52Mary Lee, for being a guest on this podcast. Well, thank you for having me. I'm looking
- 1:59forward to it. It's so great that you're featuring Fona Foundation. Amazing. You are an expert in
- 2:08primate communication. And one of the most mind-blowing thing I have ever watched is a
- 2:14chimpanzee using sign language. And it is so astonishing that you wonder, is it real?
- 2:22Do great apes who are, I think, the only primates who can learn sign language, do great apes really
- 2:31have a grasp of language? Or is it just a conditioning trick, like a parrot saying a word
- 2:38to get a treat? Well, we find over the years, it's interesting it remains so controversial because
- 2:49it rattles the foundation of who we are as a species. And some of the chimps were raised
- 3:00like human children. And they acquire signs in that environment. So they acquire them in patterns
- 3:10that resemble human children. They use them to initiate conversations. We've looked at, well,
- 3:21they have hundreds of signs in their vocabulary. They use them flexibly. They use them appropriately.
- 3:27They use them spontaneously. They use them with each other and with humans. They initiate
- 3:37conversations. They repair misunderstandings. So all of the decades of research show that there's,
- 3:46it's far more than just a parlor trick. If it were just conditioning, if they were just imitating,
- 3:52they wouldn't be signing to each other. And they wouldn't be initiating the kinds of conversations
- 3:59that they're initiating. Some just simply to comment on the world or start activities or that
- 4:05kind of thing. So yeah, it's more than just a trick.
- 4:11I think, and you said that in your answer, but I think part of the reason why observing a chimpanzee
- 4:21communicating with sign language is such an astonishing vision is because we don't expect
- 4:27that from animals. I think we are brought up to think of animals as objects and it is reflected
- 4:34in our laws. You know, most animals have the legal status of a piece of property and many people don't
- 4:41even think of animals as sentient beings. Yet humans and animals share a lot in common. In fact,
- 4:50we are animals. We are part of the animal kingdom and it is particularly true in the case of primates,
- 4:59which is the evolutionary family to which homo sapiens belong. So could you tell us more about
- 5:06primates and what traits do human beings share with primates?
- 5:10Well, as you've pointed out, we are a primate and so the traits that we all share, we primates,
- 5:22the things that separate primates from perhaps canines or felids or other orders of animals.
- 5:35We all have very large brains. I would say with humans, it's particularly large, the cortex,
- 5:44the outer region of the brain is particularly large. We all rely on vision. So vision is
- 5:54something that we're highly adapted to use. Primates have, even if you look at their
- 6:02sort of the bony structure around the eyes, eyes are in sockets, inside of a socket, so they're
- 6:12very well protected. There's a lot of redundancy in the wiring. There's a lot of the brain
- 6:19devoted to a visual cortex as opposed to maybe a dog where there's more parts of the brain that
- 6:26are going to be devoted to olfaction. So we've got this vision. We have to go along with that. We're
- 6:34highly social, so almost all primates live in social groups. Then if you think about living in
- 6:45a social group, all critters have to communicate. So we have to be very, very careful about that.
- 6:55All critters have to communicate, but we're communicating primarily visually. So then we
- 7:02have adaptations for that. The face is hairless. We have a huge amount of musculature in our faces
- 7:15so we can make different facial expressions. We communicate with body postures and with gestures.
- 7:22So gestures are not just used in American sign language. They're used in many languages of
- 7:29deaf cultures across the globe, but also non-human primates use them, use gestures to communicate as
- 7:40well. So with that, we all primates have hands as opposed to like a hoof or a claw.
- 7:50The fingers are independent digits so they can grasp. We have nails instead of claws.
- 8:04I think sometimes when people look at little monkeys with their little faces and they have
- 8:10these tiny little hands, we all have hands. We have free moving limbs so we can swing our arms around.
- 8:21Humans actually can do that less. If you think about an orangutan, their hip can rotate as much
- 8:28as we can rotate our shoulder. And let's see, some of the other characteristics then we have
- 8:35most primates have a tendency towards single birth rather than having a litter or a whole bunch of
- 8:44babies. And if you think about parental investment, the investment is in trying to ensure that that
- 8:52individual survives rather than if you think about a salmon, their strategy is they just lay
- 8:59thousands of eggs and then they die. So their investment is in sort of creating all of those
- 9:09eggs, whereas primates tend to have a single birth. The growth spurt, all organisms have a growth
- 9:19spurt and in primates it's delayed. We call it adolescence, but that occurs across primates.
- 9:25And so that allows for this longer period of dependency and it's a period of time where this
- 9:33infant and later child with this big brain that's communicating visually is starting to learn
- 9:40information from the individuals in their group, including mom. So that is another sort of hallmark,
- 9:49is this single birth that tend to be spaced out and this kind of heavy investment in those
- 9:57individuals to make sure that they survive. So those are the general characteristics that
- 10:03all primates share. And what about the differences? Because there's a lot of diversity
- 10:11under the umbrella of the term primate. Could you tell us what is the difference between a
- 10:19chimpanzee and a monkey? Yeah, so there's within the order of primates, there are sort of three
- 10:27large groups that you can think of. One is apes, but I'll start at the other, another group that
- 10:38is sort of less related to us. And when I say that we can think in terms of evolution and how long
- 10:45ago we shared an ancestor with certain organisms. Not that those organisms stopped evolving because
- 10:53we're all evolving. Some people have this misconception that humans are more evolved
- 10:59than other species, which is so arrogant. If you are not evolving and adapting to your environment,
- 11:08then you're extinct, which is part of the issue with climate change. So with lemurs, that's
- 11:17the group that diverged the furthest ago. And those are lemurs, other kinds of prosimmians.
- 11:28And then there's monkeys. Monkeys tend to have tails. They occur both in the Americas and also
- 11:41Europe, Africa, and Asia. So I think there's work to change the name, but there's new world
- 11:48primates and old world primates. And they're smaller than apes and they have tails. And then
- 12:01with apes existing today, there's humans. There's a group called pan, which includes
- 12:11pantroglodytes, which are chimpanzees, and then panpaniscus, which are bonobos.
- 12:16And then there's gorillas and there's orangutans. So the orangutans occur in Asia. They
- 12:24diverged first from this African lineage, I guess you would say. Then gorillas split off.
- 12:34And then the pan group split off from homo. And actually, we're
- 12:42more closely related, these two groups, than African and Asian elephants are related to each
- 12:49other. So we're really, really sibling species. And then after that split, that's when bonobos and
- 12:56chimps split off from each other. So chimps and bonobos are more closely related to humans than
- 13:04they actually are to gorillas. So that's a quick run through of the different groups of primates.
- 13:14That's impressive. And if I asked, do primates experience sorrow in terms of social behaviors?
- 13:27Do they experience sorrow? Can they experience humor? Things that we generally think of them as
- 13:37being exclusive experiences to humans. Would you accuse me of anthropomorphizing
- 13:46primates? Or is it something that we could go ahead and make that assessment?
- 13:52Yeah, it's funny. Anthropomorphizing is such a bad word. And I put that in quotes. Because
- 14:03as a culture, and I think science has made more steps towards talking about emotions.
- 14:13In non-human animals, certainly with the signing chimps, you can see examples of it because they
- 14:23can, I mean, Tatu can tell me if she's sorry about something and she can apologize. And we
- 14:30have witnessed grief, if that's what we know. And so I think that's a good example of what
- 14:39we have witnessed grief. If that's what we mean by sorrow, we definitely see that. And humor,
- 14:53you can see chimps engaging in activities and they've got big play faces and they're laughing.
- 15:01And with the signing chimps, they can tell us if something is funny. So we definitely see
- 15:10these range of emotions. And as you know, probably that we're reluctant to assign those.
- 15:21Because what does that mean about how we're treating them? That's really the bigger picture.
- 15:29Yes. Are we ready to go forth with those, to accept those observations and then question
- 15:37our culture and the way we have positioned the status of non-human animals in our world?
- 15:48It's all very fascinating. And you just made quite a case on how complex creatures primates are.
- 15:55And many biologists and ethical philosophers argue that primates should be treated like people,
- 16:02basically. And I mentioned the law earlier and I wonder, does the law in the US, Canada,
- 16:10and elsewhere recognizes that complexity, even the personhood or the sentence of primates?
- 16:18No, we don't. Well, this question of personhood, I'm not a lawyer, but assigning personhood,
- 16:29which the Non-Human Rights Project headed up by Stephen Wise has made huge steps in that regard.
- 16:38And it is on the basis of assigning personhood. He began that with chimpanzees, but has since
- 16:50expanded it to elephants and cetaceans, because they also share many of these characteristics of
- 16:59long life and social complexity and the things that long life and social complexity are not the
- 17:09reasons for personhood. So I think it's more in terms of agency, but it basically moves them out
- 17:20of the, stops them from being an object. There are countries, I think New Zealand, Argentina,
- 17:32that have assigned personhood. There have been cases where there was an orangutan that had to be
- 17:42released from the zoo that she was in. She now lives at a sanctuary in Florida,
- 17:50because it was found that she had that status of personhood. So we're slowly coming along, but
- 18:02there's a long road ahead of us. I think it's going to take a long time for this kind of thing to
- 18:17happen. I think in terms of recognizing the complexity and the sentience, I do think in
- 18:25regard to sentience, we're coming along. You'll see news articles now where people are talking about
- 18:36lobsters feeling pain and there are organisms that are just so far divergent from us, but they're
- 18:44having experiences. Look at all the hoopla about octopus. So we are recognizing
- 18:55that there's a lot going on with other species. One of the things with starting with apes is because
- 19:10it's kind of easy to slip that one in on people because, well, first they can talk to us with
- 19:17signs and people begin to see that similarity, but I feel like once people recognize the similarity
- 19:26between humans and our next of kin, essentially chimpanzees, then they start to wonder about other
- 19:35groups of animals and, well, what about monkeys? What about rats and sea urchins and all those kind
- 19:47of things? I do think things are... There's movement. It's just when you think about
- 19:57the thousands and thousands of animals that are in laboratories and that are on people's plates,
- 20:06that's where it's one thing to think that, oh yeah, my dog can feel things. It's another when you
- 20:13think that the hamburger on your plate might've had a pretty miserable experience before it got there.
- 20:20Thousands, more like billions. Yes, right. Sorry, right.
- 20:28But in the case of, for instance, chimpanzees, I feel like it's not a big concession to make.
- 20:35They have, like you said, they have faces and we can communicate with them using sign language.
- 20:41Why is it so difficult to grant them with personhood status? Why is it so difficult to grant them with
- 20:49personhood status in the laws? And I know you're not a lawyer, but do you know what is that
- 20:58obstacle that stops us from granting that legal status? It's a slippery slope. It's a good slippery
- 21:08slope, but I think it's that sense of if we give an inch, then they're going to take a mile.
- 21:16So if you start with chimps, then what? Now then you're going to make a legal case to get an elephant
- 21:26out of a zoo or work out of a marine park. So it's exactly that. And that was the worry with when
- 21:39biomedical research ended for chimps in the U.S. You know, the worry was, well,
- 21:49what are they going to come after monkeys next? It's like, yeah,
- 21:54yeah, we are. It's going to be another long haul, but that's going to happen. And
- 22:02I think it's just that. It's just a slippery slope. What next?
- 22:06I don't want to ask this next question, but I think it's an important one to ask. If primates
- 22:15are not well protected by the law or not even protected by the law, they must be a prey to a
- 22:23number of abuses. What kind of abuses primates face across the world?
- 22:28Well, I'll just start with, you know, with home. So monkeys are used extensively in biomedical
- 22:37research in Canada and the U.S. We both countries continue to import them. You know, there's a
- 22:49recently was a whole ring that's been involved in illegal. Basically, they're bringing monkeys in
- 22:59that were, you know, so they have these, well, another air quote here, farms in Asia for like
- 23:10long tail macaques. So they're used really heavily in research with COVID. There was a big push, you
- 23:20know, the industry can sound the alarm. Oh, my gosh, you know, now we got to rev things up because
- 23:27we've got this disease that we have to do research about. So, you know, there's such a huge demand.
- 23:35There's a higher demand for monkeys. We don't import them from China anymore. So that was kind
- 23:44of a big source was cut off there. And these this smuggling ring, they're there while they claim
- 23:54that they're breeding chimps for export from Cambodia. But I think that's a big source.
- 24:03So they're not in Cambodia. But it turns out that also wild caught ones were being supplied to these
- 24:11places. And then when they arrive here in the Americas, they're not you can't tell which is
- 24:18which. So that is quite a quite a thing to the point that long tail macaques now are becoming
- 24:29endangered. There's so much of that going on. You know, life in a laboratory is a pretty
- 24:36miserable thing. Often they're living alone in an enclosure, they're subjected to all sorts of
- 24:42different procedures based on what research protocol they're in. You know, just for an
- 24:52organism that's a critter that's so socially complex, being alone or even in a pair is not
- 25:01not a good life. And, you know, they they have a sense of, of what's happening. I wouldn't
- 25:11argue that it's any worse, though, for for a monkey than it is for a pig or dog. So,
- 25:18yeah, so that's, those are the kind of things. And then of course, you know, there's, as I,
- 25:24as I mentioned, in the in the wild, you know, there's threats to habitat, that sort of thing.
- 25:30But really, the main thing it's, it's, is, is biomedical research monkeys are really used
- 25:39heavily in that heavy, heavy, big time. And
- 25:43are there any like guardrails? Like, are they using while experimenting on primates? Are they
- 25:53using like anesthetics or any kind of, you know, painkillers? Are there some rules about, you know,
- 26:04the cage in which they are like, should it be that big? Or it's at the discretion of the of the lab?
- 26:15Or is it just, you know, the wild?
- 26:19Yeah, there are, there's the Canadian Research Council and in Canada that has it's not laws.
- 26:26In Canada that has, it's not laws. They're sort of best practices, if you will. And you do have
- 26:37to treat them humanely. I'm not sure if there's a specification for cage size. My guess is probably
- 26:45yes. In the US there is. It's big enough to make normal postural adjustments. And then they,
- 26:54it's actually specified in the US, which usually lags behind in animal welfare and protection.
- 27:02It is a law. There's the Animal Welfare Act is a law. In Canada doesn't have this same level of
- 27:10protection, which is, which is a real surprising issue because Canada is often, you know, up there
- 27:17with Europe in terms of animal protection, but not necessarily in labs.
- 27:21And, you know, there's stipulations for providing enrichment. You are supposed
- 27:26to provide for anesthesia and pain control and that, and that kind of thing.
- 27:33So, so that's there, but I still would argue that, you know, I mean, the kinds of things,
- 27:42I mean, they're doing mutilations and all sorts of things that will,
- 27:45it's, it's just, it's just too much. You know, I mean, it's even, even if you ended the research
- 27:56itself, just the enclosures and the way that they're living is so, is so awful.
- 28:02And such a, such a lack of, you know, living in a sterile cage, you know, such a, such a lack of
- 28:15variety and enrichment and that, and that kind of thing. But I'm, I also feel like captivity for
- 28:21apes is not, it's really impossible for us to, to, to be able to do that.
- 28:27And I also feel like captivity for apes is not, it's really impossible for us to provide for them
- 28:36as compared to what they could potentially live in the wild, if that's where they were born.
- 28:44So even in the very best sanctuaries, they've got a, they've got a, a good life, I put that in quotes.
- 28:54It's still captivity. It's a, it's a good incarceration. And I think it's important for us not to,
- 29:01to sugarcoat and think that it's, well, if they're in a sanctuary, it's okay. It's, it's,
- 29:08it's still not okay. I think we need to be moving to a place where that just doesn't happen.
- 29:16Yes. And we're using a lot of euphemisms, but we're talking about torture here,
- 29:20torture with guardrails. And it is the law, but it is not the most well enforced law in the land.
- 29:31So, so yeah, we should be aware of that. Yeah.
- 29:37Now, to be more negative, positive. Now, there are a few heroes like yourself, who stand up for
- 29:47welfare of animals and who have welcomed in their circle of compassion, not just humans,
- 29:54but other animals. And you on orders have created a special place, a sanctuary called
- 30:02Fonor. And I'm so glad that such a place exists. Could you tell us more about what is Fonor?
- 30:10How did it come to exist? And what is its mission? Yeah. So Fonor is the only chimpanzee sanctuary
- 30:18in Canada. It came into existence Gloria Grow as our director and founder. And she and I actually
- 30:30met in the mid nineties. She came to the chimpanzee and human communication Institute where we had
- 30:38the sign language project. And we invited people to come and help us with our research through
- 30:44Earthwatch program. And in that, in educating the folks that came, we talked about biomedical
- 30:54research. And so when Gloria learned about that, she decided she wanted to start her, her own
- 31:02chimpanzee sanctuary. And so she lived in Caringham. So that's where she started her sanctuary. And
- 31:12LEMCIP was the laboratory for experimental and medical surgery and primates. They were doing
- 31:19vaccine research. They were infecting chimps with hepatitis C, HIV, and Gloria
- 31:27wanted, you know, then LEMCIP decided that it was going to stop doing that and divested itself of
- 31:37their chimps. And so Gloria took, she took 15 chimps from LEMCIP. And then over the years,
- 31:48other chimps came there, other chimps from zoos in Quebec. So Park Safari, there was a zoo in
- 32:02Saint-Félicien, excuse my accent, or lack of accent. And also the Quebec City Zoo. So
- 32:13other chimps came. And then Tattoo and Lulis also came from the US when the Chimpanzee and Human
- 32:20Communications Institute closed. So there also have been monkeys. We have one monkey now, Newton, and
- 32:31monkeys have come to fauna from biomedical research on other chimps. And so they have been
- 32:39fauna from biomedical research, and also the pet industry. And so our mission, that's how fauna
- 32:49came to exist. And the mission is to provide sanctuary, also to provide education about
- 32:58chimpanzees and our other fellow beings, and also conservation. So fauna sits on about 300 acres of
- 33:08green space just outside of Montreal in an area that's being heavily developed. So the original
- 33:19intention was to create a buffer around the chimps, but it's come to be a place that attracts all
- 33:27sorts of wildlife. And there's endangered species there, migratory birds. And so that also is part
- 33:35of our mission. Wow. And you also have, you know, farm animals, I believe. Yes, fauna started as a
- 33:43farm animal sanctuary. The only farm animals that are left at fauna now are, it's a flock of domestic
- 33:52geese. And fauna is no longer doing any active rescuing. We're really hitting the the sunset
- 34:01of our mission and just providing the best care to the chimps that are there and Newton, the monkey,
- 34:09and the geese. There's no other chimpanzees in all of Canada. There are orangutans and gorillas
- 34:19and zoos, but there's no other chimps. So there's really no one to come to us.
- 34:27So that part of the mission is that we're just riding that one out, so to speak. But it may take
- 34:36a long time because chimps live a long time and we've still got a full house of
- 34:46wonderful beings. Yeah. So that's... And it's their home now. And by the way,
- 34:54you're the last person who should apologize about an accent. I mean...
- 35:01So I would love to know more about, you know, you named some of them like Newton. I would love
- 35:08to know more about some of fauna's residents. Who are they? What is their life story? And
- 35:16what is their life currently at fauna? Yeah. So our main tree, our oldest resident,
- 35:25Sue Ellen, I think Sue Ellen is 56. And Sue Ellen was originally a sidekick in a circus when she was
- 35:40little. And then when she got too big, she was dumped at LEMSIP and spent 15 years in biomedical
- 35:50research and was infected with the HIV virus. It turns out chimps don't get AIDS or don't develop
- 35:57AIDS. So that just goes to show that they're not good models for that. And often, you know,
- 36:07the industry claims that we need these models, but often they're not, you know, we get erroneous
- 36:14findings. So anyway, then Sue Ellen came to fauna as part of the older group of chimps. She's...
- 36:27about six years ago, she lost the use of her legs. And we never figured out what caused it.
- 36:40But it took her years, you know, she could use her arms to move around. And we sort of tricked out
- 36:50her enclosure with straps and bars and so that she could have some mobility. And, you know,
- 37:01many places would have euthanized her, but not at fauna. And she has regained her ability to walk.
- 37:12And, you know, she's always keeping watch. She likes to watch all the guys that work at fauna.
- 37:23She's particularly fond of men. So that's Sue. She often will wear a little kind of a tutu or
- 37:32something like that, which on one hand, it's, you know, I mean, it makes for a great picture.
- 37:40But on the other hand, it reminds us of, it probably is some kind of a throwback in her
- 37:46mind from when she was in the circus. Another one of our residents, Rachel, Rachel was raised
- 37:58in a human home for the first three years of her life, like a pet. And then she was dumped at
- 38:04and then she was dumped at LEMCIP. And then Rachel came to fauna along with the other LEMCIP
- 38:12chimps in 1997. Rachel has a diagnosis of PTSD. And she still, she still, you know,
- 38:28is still suffers with that. And it's not as bad as it was in the beginning when she first arrived,
- 38:39but she still has that. So, you know, even when we bring
- 38:46chimps to sanctuary, there's still this, you know, sort of train wreck that they're,
- 38:53that they're carrying around different individuals of different levels of regret.
- 38:57Sue Ellen is not like that at all. She's a super strong personality, but Rachel really, really
- 39:06suffers. But she's very into her, she loves her caregivers. And she carries around these little
- 39:19stuffed gorillas, which Binky has recently, Binky is another one of the chimps from fauna. He's
- 39:25recently been taking her little stuffed gorillas, you know, kind of like a brother and sister sort
- 39:34of a thing there. So those, those are some of the residents there. Yeah. And then we have Tatu and
- 39:43Lulis who sign language. Tatu was raised like a human child, as I said. And again, that research
- 39:54never to be repeated in no way ethical. But, you know, the chimps are stamped with this and
- 40:04sort of this indelible mark that they can talk with their hands now. And then Lulis,
- 40:11he learned his sign language from other chimpanzees. So, so that's, that's, that's those two.
- 40:20That's amazing. He learned that just from being in contact with some chimpanzees who had
- 40:27that knowledge. So there was like a schooling, like education, basically.
- 40:33Yeah. I would say it's more like the way that we learn, learn our first language. You know, I,
- 40:43you can in school, actually, that's like the worst way to learn a language,
- 40:47unless you're in an immersive classroom. But the way that you learn and acquire languages is really
- 40:55being immersed in that environment. And so Lulis was, his mother was Washo. So the first Washo
- 41:04adopted Lulis. And then in that research, no humans were allowed to sign around Lulis. So
- 41:09his only input was from Washo and other signing chimps. And he began to sign in a week.
- 41:16You know, it's like super amazing. But it, it, it turns out that when we look at what is going on
- 41:25in the wild, of course, we didn't know on this level back in the seventies when this research
- 41:31was going. But now we know that chimps in the wild use gestures, they use gestures that are specific
- 41:38to their community. So, you know, they're, it's, they're, they're acquiring the sort of vocabulary,
- 41:46if you will, of that, that community, so they can, we're seeing, you know, differences amongst them.
- 41:56These, again, the gestures are learned. That's what little chimps do. They
- 42:01acquire the gestures of the humans around them, just like little humans do that as well. So,
- 42:09yeah, so it's, it's that experiment is happening in the wild every day, so to speak.
- 42:15That's amazing. That's truly amazing. My last question for you, Dr.
- 42:21is, why is it so important to be compassionate? And how can listeners make a difference? I thought,
- 42:31I told them, you know, you can visit for our foundation.org. I think there, they can learn
- 42:37more about the residents on the website, there's even a program called Adopt a Chimp, which is
- 42:45amazing. But, you know, if we take a few step backs, and we talk about what is at the heart
- 42:54of this conversation, you know, compassion, why is it so important to include animals in our
- 43:02circle of compassion? Yeah, I let that question, you know, open like that. So, answer that question,
- 43:11you know, open like that. So, answer the way you want. Yeah, well, and so I, I would take it a
- 43:21little bit further. And I think if we view, you know, everything on the planet with sort of that
- 43:33awe and wonder that comes with compassion, I, I, well, imagine how we would treat our fellow humans,
- 43:46if we were able to extend our circle of compassion. And, and, you know, it, it's, it's just, I guess
- 44:00it's the, the characteristics that, that come with having a wider circle of compassion are ones that
- 44:09are, ones that everybody could use. I have a kid, a teenage kid who spends a lot of time watching
- 44:17these Karen videos, and it's like, it's so toxic, but this is true. This is the way people are.
- 44:23And sort of the opposite of that is being compassionate and being humble and asking
- 44:28what it is that other individuals bring to the table and realizing that, you know, everybody,
- 44:38whether you're human or, or you're a chimp or whether you're a monkey or whether you're an oak
- 44:46tree, everybody's just trying to get through the day. And that, you know, just realizing that
- 44:54that's what we have in common. I think it makes people kinder, doesn't it? I wholeheartedly agree.
- 45:03And I would add, it makes life so much more pleasant, you know, it's just, you know,
- 45:10pleasant to be compassionate to others, including animals to be generous with your compassion.
- 45:17And it just makes your life more peaceful, more, more happy life. Yeah. And I just want to interrupt
- 45:30you because you said something that struck a chord when you said generous. And I agree with you
- 45:36because we won't run out. It's not like I'll only have so much compassion in my bucket.
- 45:42Yes, exactly. Why not? I mean, it's not, we're not spending money here.
- 45:52Yes, I'm happy that we agree on that. Would you like to add something before we end this conversation?
- 46:01Yeah, well, I think, you know, what can people do? I, you know, I'm always urging people to pay
- 46:08attention to what is going on in the biomedical industry and what, you know, there's labs all
- 46:17over the place. You wouldn't know it, but they're all over the place. They keep pretty on the low
- 46:23down. And yeah, read, educate yourself. I think the more that we know, the easier it is to have
- 46:34compassion. The more you understand what's going on in our world and educating ourselves.
- 46:42Amazing. Again, thank you so much, Mary Lee for taking the time to answer my question.
- 46:51Well, thanks for featuring Fana and thanks for doing this podcast because this is people
- 46:57listening is one other way that we can change ourselves and hopefully change everybody.
- 47:05Of course, it's my pleasure. Thank you everyone for listening. What an honor to have met Dr.
- 47:11Jens Vold. Go support the Fana Foundation. I left a link to their website in the description below.
- 47:17Share this episode with family and friends and spread the word about experiments on primates.
- 47:23I'm very excited for next week's episode. You are going to hear me talk with Colin,
- 47:30who used to work for the animal industry like ranches and slaughterhouses, but he's now vegan.
- 47:37It's a fascinating conversation and Colin's journey to veganism is very inspiring. So subscribe now
- 47:46and don't miss out on next week's episode. If you like this podcast, take the time to leave
- 47:52a good review. It would mean a lot. I'm also on Instagram if you want to reach out at veganreportpodcast.
- 47:59Thank you again for listening. Take care and see you next week.