Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Curious Case of the Electric Car: Why Efficiency Took a Century to Win
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Deep Dive. We sift through the information
- 0:02overload to bring you what really matters.
- 0:05Today, we're tackling a really fascinating historical puzzle.
- 0:09It's all about electric cars versus, you know, the
- 0:12traditional gasoline one. Everyone talks about EVs now,
- 0:14their efficiency. But here's the big question we
- 0:17want to get into. If electric cars were so
- 0:19efficient even way back, why did gasoline cars completely
- 0:24dominate for, like, over 100 years?
- 0:28There's some surprising twists here.
- 0:30OK, let's unpack this. So to really set the scene for
- 0:33this mystery, let's let's start with the raw numbers, the
- 0:36difference in just basic energy efficiency between electric
- 0:39motors and gasoline engines. It's kind of mind blowing, isn't
- 0:42it? Oh, it absolutely is.
- 0:43Stark contrast. Think of it like this.
- 0:45An electric motor, it's super efficient.
- 0:47It takes about, say, 80 to 90% of the energy stored in the
- 0:49Barry, 80 to 90. Yeah.
- 0:51And turns that directly to making the car move.
- 0:53Most of the energy does the actual work.
- 0:55Now the internal combustion engine, your tyical gas car,
- 0:58much, much lower. We're talking maybe 30 to 40
- 1:01efficiency. Wait, so only 30 or 40 actually
- 1:04moves the car? Where does the rest?
- 1:06Where does the other 6070% go? Well, that's the thing, it's
- 1:09mostly wasted. Dispersed is heat, you know.
- 1:11The engine gets hot, the exhaust gets hot, and also lost to
- 1:15mechanical friction within the engine itself.
- 1:17Only a fraction actually propels a vehicle forward.
- 1:20Wow, so feeling a hot engine is literally feeling wasted energy.
- 1:24Pretty much, yeah. And you can see this in
- 1:27practical terms, like fuel consumption.
- 1:29An EV might use around, let's say 20 kilowatt hours of energy
- 1:33to go 100 kilometers. A kWh is just a unit of energy,
- 1:37like a gallon of gas is a unit of fuel.
- 1:39OK, 20 kilowatt hours. Right now, an equivalent
- 1:42gasoline car to travel that same 100 kilometers would burn
- 1:46through the energy equivalent of about 100 kilowatt hours A. 100
- 1:49compared to 20. Exactly.
- 1:50So the EV is roughly, you know, four times more efficient in
- 1:54just using the energy it carries.
- 1:55There was actually a study, University of Pisa, I think that
- 1:58put it at about 3.5 times more efficient for an EV compared to
- 2:03a similar gasoline car. So yeah, consistently much
- 2:05better, OK. Those figures are really
- 2:07compelling, but efficiency isn't always the whole story.
- 2:11Historically speaking, what does this efficiency mean for the
- 2:14bigger picture? Like environmentally, that's
- 2:16obviously a huge focus now, right?
- 2:19And here's where it gets really interesting.
- 2:21Beyond just how it uses energy while driving, the advantage
- 2:25holds up across the whole life cycle.
- 2:27So you factor in manufacturing the car, making the battery,
- 2:30generating the electricity, even recycling at the end.
- 2:33Even with all that, an electric car produces almost four times
- 2:37fewer greenhouse gas emissions over its entire life compared to
- 2:41a gasoline car. Four times less, even including
- 2:44battery production. Yes, even accounting for that.
- 2:47So the environmental edge is pretty significant, not just a
- 2:49small difference. OK, so efficient, cleaner.
- 2:53It seems like a slam dunk. Which brings us to the the real
- 2:56head scratcher, the plot twist in car history.
- 2:58If Ev's were this good on paper and actually existed early on,
- 3:02how did gasoline cars end up ruling the road for well over a
- 3:05century and 1/2? It just doesn't seem logical at
- 3:07first glance. It's a fantastic question, and
- 3:09yeah, it is a major twist because back at the turn of the
- 3:1320th century, late 1800s, early 1900s, electric cars were
- 3:17actually very promising, especially in cities.
- 3:19People liked them. They were simple to operate,
- 3:22quiet. No noisy engine, no fuel.
- 3:24Exactly. And less maintenance, you know,
- 3:26no oil changes, fewer moving parts.
- 3:29And get this, between about 1900 and 1910, there were lots of
- 3:33electric cars driving around, even electric taxis, in big
- 3:37cities like New York. Electric taxis?
- 3:39Wow, so they had infrastructure too?
- 3:41Charging they did. There were targeting stations
- 3:43popping up in cities. It wasn't like today's network,
- 3:45obviously, but the basic idea was there.
- 3:47They had a real foothold. OK, so they had the tech
- 3:50advantage, early adoption, some infrastructure.
- 3:53So what went wrong? What was the big roadblock?
- 3:55The main issue, the real Achilles heel, was the battery.
- 3:58The technology just wasn't there yet.
- 4:01Early lead acid battery, well, they were heavy, really heavy,
- 4:04and they didn't hold much charge.
- 4:05So the range was very limited, maybe 30-40 miles if you're
- 4:08lucky. Not great for trips.
- 4:11Not at all, and recharging took a long time, hours and hours.
- 4:15So fine for short city hops maybe, but totally impractical
- 4:18for longer journeys or if you lived out in the countryside
- 4:21where electricity wasn't even common yet.
- 4:23OK. Battery limits makes sense.
- 4:25Any other factors pushing gasoline forward?
- 4:28Definitely. External events played a huge
- 4:30role. World War I, for instance.
- 4:32The war really pushed the development of internal
- 4:35combustion engines. Armies needed vehicles they
- 4:38could refuel quickly anywhere. Vehicles with better performance
- 4:41and ruggedness. Logistics.
- 4:43Quick refueling beats slow charging in a war zone.
- 4:46Absolutely. And those wartime improvements
- 4:49then filtered down into civilian cars, making gasoline vehicles
- 4:52even better and more reliable. And wasn't there one specific
- 4:55specific invention around that time?
- 4:57Something that made gasoline cars way easier to use?
- 5:01Something about starting them? Yes, you're spot on.
- 5:03That was a killer blow. Really.
- 5:05The invention of the electric starter motor for gasoline
- 5:07engines. That was around 1916.
- 5:09Before that you had to hand crank them right?
- 5:11Exactly. A big, often difficult,
- 5:14sometimes dangerous crank handle on the front.
- 5:16You had to physically turn the engine over to get it started.
- 5:19I can't even imagine doing that everyday.
- 5:21Right, it was a hassle. The electric starter made
- 5:24starting a gasoline car as simple as pushing a button or
- 5:27turning a key. Suddenly it was just as
- 5:30convenient to start as an electric car.
- 5:32Ah, so it eliminated one of the EVs key convenience advantages.
- 5:35Precisely. But the gasoline car still had
- 5:38much better range, and you could refuel it in minutes almost
- 5:41anywhere. This raises an important
- 5:43question for buyers back then. Why put up with the short range
- 5:46and long charging times of an EV if the gasoline car is now just
- 5:50as easy to start and offers so much more freedom?
- 5:53Yeah, the convenience factor is huge, and I guess the economics
- 5:56started shifting too. Totally.
- 5:57It became a sort of perfect storm favoring gasoline.
- 6:00First, gasoline itself was cheap, really cheap, back then.
- 6:04Second, mass production pioneered by people like Henry
- 6:07Ford with the Model T, drastically lowered the purchase
- 6:10price of gasoline cars. They became affordable for
- 6:13ordinary families. The Model T effect.
- 6:14Right And 3rd, crucially, the infrastructure for gasoline
- 6:18exploded. Gas stations started popping up
- 6:21everywhere, along roadsides, in towns across the country.
- 6:24Refueling became incredibly easy and accessible.
- 6:27While the electrical grid was still lagging behind.
- 6:31Exactly. Electricity generation and
- 6:33distribution were much less developed, less widespread,
- 6:36especially outside major cities. There just wasn't a comparable
- 6:39network for easily charging electric cars on a large scale.
- 6:43So you had cheap fuel, cheap cars, and fueling stations
- 6:46everywhere for gasoline. EVs just couldn't compete on
- 6:49that practical infrastructural level despite their efficiency.
- 6:52Which explains that century of dominance.
- 6:55OK, So Fast forward to today, we're seeing this huge EV
- 6:58comeback, this resurgence. What's changed?
- 7:00What's finally allowing EVs to kind of leverage that inherent
- 7:03efficiency they always had? Well, if we connect this to the
- 7:06bigger picture, it's basically that those historical roadblocks
- 7:10are finally being dismantled. The EV revolution we're seeing
- 7:12now, it's happening because the technology finally caught up to
- 7:15the potential. We've had massive, and I mean
- 7:18massive recent progress in battery technology.
- 7:21Lighter batteries, more energy dense.
- 7:23Exactly. Addressing those core historical
- 7:25Oracle problems, Much better range, lighter weight, which
- 7:28improves the car's performance, and crucially, faster charging
- 7:32times. We're talking minutes now for
- 7:34significant range, not entire nights.
- 7:37And the infrastructure piece? That's catching up, too.
- 7:40Governments and private companies are investing heavily
- 7:42in building out charging networks.
- 7:44It's still developing, but it's becoming far more viable to own
- 7:47and operate an EV for most people.
- 7:50So really only now, with these recent breakthroughs and
- 7:53batteries and the build out of charging infrastructure, is the
- 7:56electric car truly entering a new phase where it can compete
- 7:59effectively on a large scale and finally capitalize on that
- 8:02efficiency edge it had all along.
- 8:04So what does this all mean? We've traced this really winding
- 8:08path from EVs being surprisingly efficient and even popular early
- 8:12on to being completely sidelined by gasoline cars for over a
- 8:16century. And it wasn't just about which
- 8:17engine was better in isolation, was it?
- 8:19It was war, economics, the electric starter and,
- 8:22critically, infrastructure. Now innovation is finally
- 8:25tackling those old problems and EVs are back in a big way.
- 8:28Yeah, I think the big take away is that inherent technological
- 8:31superiority, like efficiency, isn't always enough on its own,
- 8:35not by a long shot. For a technology to truly
- 8:38succeed and become widespread, the surrounding ecosystem, the
- 8:41infrastructure, the economics, the user convenience, it all has
- 8:44to mature alongside it. They have to evolve together.
- 8:47The story of the EV is just such a powerful example of that
- 8:51interplay. Absolutely.
- 8:53And maybe a final thought for you listening, think about what
- 8:57are the technologies might be out there, Maybe older ideas
- 8:59that seem poised for a comeback, not because they're suddenly
- 9:02brand new, but because the things that held them back
- 9:05historically. Maybe battery tech or network
- 9:07speed or material science are finally being overcome.
- 9:11What is this long complex journey the electric car Tell us
- 9:13about spotting future trends and understanding how today's
- 9:16solutions might unlock yesterday's forgotten potential.
- 9:19Something to think about.