Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How To Ask For a Career Reference When Youve Had Multiple Short Stints
Transcript
- Lucas: Alright, today's question comes from a listener who is staring down a job application and realizes their resume looks like a game of musical chairs. Three jobs in five years. Not because they got fired — each role was a genuine step, but each one was under two years. Luna: And the application asks for professional references. That's the part where the anxiety really kicks in, because you wonder — is anyone going to say yes? Lucas: And if they do say yes, what are they going to say? Because the standard advice is always 'pick someone who knows your work well and can vouch for you' — but when you were only at a company for 18 months, and it's been two years since you left, 'know your work well' is a stretch. Luna: It's also an awkward ask. You're basically calling someone you haven't spoken to in years and saying 'hey, remember me? Can you spend 20 minutes on the phone with a stranger and tell them I'm good?' Lucas: And if we're honest, that is exactly why some listeners avoid applying to roles that require references altogether. They self-select out because they assume no one will say yes — or that the reference will be lukewarm because the tenure was short. Luna: Yeah, and that's a real loss. So let's talk about how to actually do this. Because I think there's a smarter way to ask, and it starts with who you ask. Lucas: Before we dive into the who, let me just say — and I know this is a little meta for a careers show — but if you've ever been in this exact spot and found yourself stuck, we actually hear from listeners a lot who say this podcast helped them think through a tough career move. And that's why we keep making these episodes, ad-free, five days a week. A small group of listeners chips in to keep it going at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo — and that support is what makes it possible to do deep dives like this one. Luna: It's true. And we don't put anything behind a paywall, so it's entirely listener-funded. If it's been useful, that's the place to find us. Lucas: Alright, back to references. So Luna, you said it starts with who you ask. What's the mistake people make? Luna: The biggest mistake is thinking you must ask your most recent direct manager. That's the conventional wisdom — ask your current or last boss. But if you've had multiple short stints, your most recent manager may not be your strongest advocate. They only saw you for a year. Lucas: Exactly. And they might also be the person who is most likely to say something like 'she was good, but she left after 14 months' — which is a subtle negative. Instead, I'd argue you should look for the person who saw you at your best, even if that was two jobs ago. Even if it's a skip-level — your manager's manager — or a peer who became a friend. Luna: Or even a client. If you worked with an external client for six months on a project, and you delivered something tangible, that client can speak to your work ethic and results — and they have zero investment in the short tenure narrative. Lucas: That's a great point. And here's the key: when you ask someone, you need to acknowledge the short tenure head-on. Most people try to dance around it. They say 'I know I wasn't there long, but...' and that apologetic framing immediately puts the reference on the defensive. Luna: So what's the alternative? How do you frame it? Lucas: You frame it as a positive. You say something like: 'I know I was only on the team for 18 months, but in that time we accomplished X and Y, and I felt like we hit a really good rhythm. I'm applying for a role where I think that experience is directly relevant, and I'd be honored if you'd be willing to speak to that period.' Luna: That's interesting — you're owning the short tenure without apologizing. You're saying 'I know it was short, and here's why it was still impactful.' Lucas: Exactly. And you're making it easy for them to say yes, because you've given them a script. You've reminded them of the specific accomplishments they can point to. That's the difference between a reference who says 'yeah, sure, I'll do it' and a reference who says 'I don't really remember much, but I guess I can.' Luna: And what about when the company policy restricts what references can say? Some HR departments only confirm dates and job titles. Lucas: That's a real issue, especially at larger companies. In that case, you don't ask the HR person. You ask a person who is willing to speak off the record, or you ask for a personal reference rather than a professional one. Or you ask for a written recommendation on LinkedIn that doesn't go through the formal HR channel. Luna: And you can also ask the reference to be specific about what they can say. Like, 'Hey, I know your company policy may limit you, but would you be comfortable saying I was a strong contributor and that you'd work with me again?' That's a safe phrase for most managers. Lucas: And it's actually one of the most powerful phrases in a reference check. When a hiring manager hears 'I'd work with them again' — that's gold. It's short, it's honest, and it doesn't require a detailed performance review. Luna: So let's talk about the actual ask. What's the email look like for someone who hasn't spoken to a former boss in two years? Lucas: I would send an email that does three things. First, a warm re-introduction — remind them who you are and when you worked together. Second, a specific accomplishment that you're proud of from that time. Third, a clear ask: 'Would you be willing to speak briefly with the hiring manager about your experience working with me?' And then make it easy by offering to send a bullet-point list of what you did. Luna: And what if they don't respond? That's a common fear — that the person will ghost you. Lucas: Then you follow up once, politely, after a week. If they still don't respond, move on. But here's the thing — if someone doesn't respond to a reference request, they probably weren't going to give a glowing reference anyway. So it's a filter. Luna: Yeah, better to know that upfront than to list them and have them say something neutral or negative during the actual call. Lucas: Exactly. And if you're really worried about someone saying something negative, you can ask them directly: 'Is there any reason you might not be able to give a strong recommendation?' That's a tough question to ask, but it saves you from a bad reference. Luna: And if they say 'I don't feel comfortable,' you thank them and move on. No hard feelings. Lucas: Right. Now, another angle here — what about using a reference from a short stint at a startup? That can be powerful because startup references often see you wearing multiple hats. A two-year stint at a startup can produce a reference that talks about how you handled growth, pivots, and uncertainty — which is actually more impressive than a five-year stint at a big company where you did one thing. Luna: That's a good reframe. Short stints can be reframed as evidence of adaptability, not flakiness. And a reference who can speak to that adaptability is gold. Lucas: One more practical tip: when you provide the reference's contact info to the hiring manager, include a brief note about your relationship. 'I worked with Sarah at Company X from 2022 to 2023 on the Y project, and she oversaw my work on Z.' That gives the hiring manager context and makes the reference call more productive. Luna: And it also signals to the reference that you've prepped the ground — they know what's coming. Lucas: Exactly. So to wrap it up: if you have multiple short stints, don't default to the most recent boss. Pick the person who saw you at your best, even if it was two jobs ago. Acknowledge the short tenure directly, frame it around accomplishments, and make it easy for them to say yes. And if company policy is an issue, ask for a personal recommendation or a simple 'I'd hire them again.' Luna: And if you're the one being asked for a reference — try to say yes, even for short-tenured colleagues. You never know how much that one call can change someone's career trajectory. Lucas: That's a great note to end on. Next episode we'll tackle a listener question about whether to include short-term contract roles on a resume at all. Spoiler: the answer is not always yes. Luna: Looking forward to that. Thanks for listening, everyone.