Latest / Film And Whiskey / Casablanca (1942) / Elijah Craig Small Batch
Transcript
- 0:00In 1942, director Michael Curtis and star Humphrey Bogart gave
- 0:05the world a love story that was never meant to be.
- 0:10In 2025, we try a whiskey that continues to be great as time
- 0:15goes by. The film is, as Ben Mankiewicz
- 0:18would say, Casablanca. The whiskey is Elijah Craig's
- 0:24small batch. And we'll review them both.
- 0:27This is the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 0:49Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 0:51review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:55I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 0:58And this week, it really is Brad, the granddaddy of them
- 1:02all. I mean, there's there's a very
- 1:03short list of movies that are like, Oh my gosh, I can't
- 1:08believe we're actually talking about this movie.
- 1:11I mean, it was Citizen Kane, The Godfather, Gone with the Wind,
- 1:15and this, like, I just don't think there's anything else even
- 1:17in that echelon. I mean, when your lead actor's
- 1:20name is Humphrey Bow Daddy, I like, yeah.
- 1:23What do you expect? I mean, I mean a true daddy
- 1:26also, am I right? I mean just talk about the man
- 1:31who who launched 1000 ships with his swagger in this movie.
- 1:35So good dude, I thought. You were going to comment on
- 1:38his? That is a euphemism and I will
- 1:40not take it back. Are you trying to say that
- 1:44Comfrey Bunker got around in Hollywood?
- 1:47I mean, who's to say? Who's to say, man, we're talking
- 1:52about Casablanca. It is perhaps my favorite movie.
- 1:55It's darn close. It's a movie that I've seen
- 1:58probably no exaggeration 50 times.
- 2:01And it is a movie that I have to take larger and larger breaks
- 2:05from in between viewings now, because I feel that like it is
- 2:09so familiar to me. It's so ingrained and I, I know
- 2:13every line of this movie so much that it's become like really
- 2:17hard to assess. It's like when you get obsessed
- 2:19with an album and you play it to death and then you have to take
- 2:23like a 567 year break from listening to that album before
- 2:26you can come back to it and hear anything new again.
- 2:28I'm, I'm kind of at that point with Casablanca and Brad,
- 2:31unfortunately, I'm going to run it right back into the ground
- 2:34again because I was bored on an airplane about two months ago
- 2:38and I was like, I'll watch it now.
- 2:40We're going to talk about it soon enough.
- 2:41I didn't realize there was two months in between.
- 2:43So I watched it two months ago. I watched it today and then I
- 2:47just found out that they're showing it at Regal Cinemas
- 2:50across the country tomorrow. And your boy's an unlimited
- 2:53member, so I'm going to see it again tomorrow.
- 2:55So why not man? It makes sense to me, man.
- 2:57This is the kind of movie that like seeing it three times in a
- 3:02week. A It's not quite a 90 minute
- 3:04film, Bob, but it no, it's just it's close.
- 3:07Just beyond a 90 minute film, it's close.
- 3:10So you're not going to spend like 9 hours like you did with
- 3:12Oppenheimer watching it 50 times.
- 3:15True. And secondly, this is an all
- 3:18time classic dude. It's so good, man.
- 3:21And, and Brad, I've my big worry with an episode like this is
- 3:25that we just come in and say things that people have said
- 3:27about this movie for what, 82 years now since it's been
- 3:31released and some change. And I don't want that like it
- 3:35is. It's one of the most highly
- 3:36regarded films of all time. What is there to say about it?
- 3:40Question mark? That's why we brought in a guest
- 3:42today. It's our friend joining us, I
- 3:44think for the third time now, Vince Mancini.
- 3:47Vince, how are you, man? Good to see you again.
- 3:49I'm great, good to see you guys too.
- 3:50I actually registered my website on bodaddy.com, so I'm very
- 3:56excited to talk about this movie means a lot to me.
- 4:02Bowdaddy is is much cheaper than GoDaddy.
- 4:05It's Bulgarian GoDaddy, right? Yeah.
- 4:08Sometimes I'm also with my friend and my friends and I'm
- 4:10like, hey man, don't bowdaddy that joint.
- 4:13Pass it around, you know? This is why we bring Vince on
- 4:16off the cuff. It is, but it is.
- 4:18It is weird like the term Bogart like I didn't like.
- 4:23It's hard for me to make that connection.
- 4:24I didn't immediately. I still don't entirely
- 4:27understand where that came from, but I guess.
- 4:29It's, I mean it has to be from him, but like why is he
- 4:31associated with being stingy? I don't, I don't get it.
- 4:34I don't either I, I, I guess it's, I think I've looked this
- 4:37up or tried to figure out why that is at some point.
- 4:40And I guess it's just that he's kind of got that like
- 4:41domineering personality. I guess that's the idea.
- 4:45ChatGPT knows. Yeah, well, ChatGPT can make a
- 4:49guess, that's for sure. All right, guys, I want to dive
- 4:52right in. But I want to start with Vince,
- 4:54because like with all of our guests, we send a list of the
- 4:57movies for the season out ahead of time and say, pick a movie.
- 5:00And Vince, I mean, there's kind of obvious reasons that somebody
- 5:03would want to talk about Casablanca because it's just a
- 5:05freaking great movie. But in particular, like, why
- 5:09this movie from the list that we sent you?
- 5:11And hopefully it's not because you secretly hate it and this is
- 5:14like a hot take fest for the year.
- 5:16Not at all. And it's like it's one of my
- 5:18favourites. Unlike you have only seen it
- 5:21maybe like 2 to 4 times or something like that.
- 5:24And being, you know, being a film critic for as long as I
- 5:27have, people are always telling you like or expecting you to
- 5:31have seen like every classic or like, oh, you must really like
- 5:35Kurosawa or like Fellini or, you know, pick your pick your movies
- 5:39on like the AFI top 100 that they expect you to like worship
- 5:42all of them. And like most of the time, like
- 5:44most of those movies on those all time lists, like I don't
- 5:47really care that much about I've seen Citizen Kane like multiple
- 5:52times. It doesn't do that much for me,
- 5:54to be honest. And then Casablanca is, I mean,
- 5:58it's, it's like I, I, it's, it's fine.
- 6:00It's good. I like, I, I get it, but it
- 6:02doesn't, it's, it's not, it doesn't hold like a special
- 6:05place in my heart. It doesn't like make me feel in
- 6:08the way that like a movie that I love should make me feel.
- 6:12Casablanca. I've only seen it a couple
- 6:14times, but like I had already absorbed all of the things that
- 6:19have filtered out into pop culture.
- 6:20And there's so many like, you know, the the song, the here's
- 6:24looking at you kid, play it again.
- 6:26Sam what she doesn't actually say, but you know, we still get
- 6:29the idea. Like those that all filtered
- 6:31down to me before I ever saw the movie.
- 6:34And then I feel like I saw the movie and it actually delivered
- 6:37in a way that I found super surprising.
- 6:41And then I do the thing where like I, I have a memory of how
- 6:47good it is in my mind. And then, and then each time I
- 6:50rewatch it, I expect it to be not as good as I remember.
- 6:53And every time it's like better than I remember.
- 6:55I'm like, God damn, this movie is just like, it's, it gets
- 6:58better somehow. It's each time I think that I
- 7:01lied to myself the last time. Like I realized like no, it's
- 7:04actually that good. Dude, you know.
- 7:06Vince like popping in like a Blu-ray and being like, let's
- 7:10test that theory right now. Yeah.
- 7:13Also, before before Brad, I don't mean to cut you off, but I
- 7:15love that Vince started by saying this is not going to be a
- 7:19hot take fest and then within 30 seconds was like, Citizen Kane
- 7:22doesn't really do it for me, man, you know?
- 7:24I mean, it's, I like it. It's just like, you know, I to
- 7:28me, it's not like, OK, this is the greatest movie of all time.
- 7:30I'm like, OK, sure, you know. I I was just saying when it
- 7:35comes to Citizen Kane a it is probably the greatest movie of
- 7:41all time and BI think the thing we walked away from.
- 7:45But and Bob, you can correct me if you're if I'm wrong.
- 7:48I feel like we walked away saying we understand 100% why
- 7:52this is in the conversation, whether or not we feel like it
- 7:55is I. Citizen Kane, you mean?
- 7:57Yeah, I was Citizen Kane. Sure.
- 7:59Yeah, No, I I would agree with that.
- 8:01Like it's, you know, it's, it's innovative and you can sort of
- 8:05see that like when you watch it. Yeah, no the.
- 8:09For me, it's like, why? Why the hell is this even in the
- 8:12conversation? What are we doing?
- 8:14The movie for me that I was come back to and I'm surprised by how
- 8:17much I love it and I always expected to get worse is the 6th
- 8:20sentence. Every single time I come back to
- 8:23that movie, I'm like, how is this movie so freaking good?
- 8:28Perfect movie, yeah. And and Brad, I think that this
- 8:32might be a good place to transition into our first
- 8:34segment of the day, which we call, Brad explains.
- 8:37Brad's going to give us the movie plot with only 60 seconds
- 8:41sticking on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with
- 8:44this little segment that we call Brad explains.
- 8:47Brad Explains is the part of the show where Brad breaks down the
- 8:50plot of the movie that he has just seen, at least for the
- 8:54second time this season. Brad the the $1,000,000
- 8:57question. Have you watched Casablanca
- 8:59between season 1 and our revisit today?
- 9:02I might have watched it with a group of friends a few years
- 9:05ago. I I feel like I feel like I
- 9:08forced them to watch. I did.
- 9:09I made them watch Casablanca and I made them watch It's Wonderful
- 9:12Life because they hadn't seen it.
- 9:15Because Jordan is in is in dumb dumb and doesn't like watching
- 9:19black and white films. Yeah, cosign for sure, Jordan
- 9:24catching strays on the Film and Whiskey podcast today.
- 9:26You know who you are, Jordan. See, I've never seen It's a
- 9:29Wonderful Life. This is exactly like a perfect
- 9:31point of comparison. My gosh, dude, first of all, I
- 9:34thought you were going to say I've never seen Jordan, but I
- 9:36agree with you guys, which I think would have been the
- 9:38correct thing to say. But Brad, I I've transitioned us
- 9:42into Brad explained so quickly because of something that Vince
- 9:45was talking about, which is the the pop culture bleed of this
- 9:49movie. You know, over the years, it
- 9:52developed such a reputation as perhaps the greatest script ever
- 9:54written. And certainly I would say like
- 9:56in the top five most quotable scripts ever written when you
- 10:00think about the way they've just permeated culture.
- 10:02But it's one of those movies where like, you've never seen it
- 10:06and then you sit down and watch it and you're like, Oh my God, I
- 10:09found the Rosetta Stone. You're like, like, there are so
- 10:13many references that I can remember from my childhood
- 10:16growing up watching like Animaniacs or whatever it might
- 10:19be that would make these sly references to Casablanca.
- 10:23And as a kid, you're like, I get that this is referencing
- 10:25something and now I, I've logged here's looking at you kid in the
- 10:28back of my head. But like, once you see it on the
- 10:31screen, it's like, I, I can't think of many movies besides
- 10:34maybe The Godfather that have had such a widespread cultural
- 10:39impact that it affects media globally that they're
- 10:43referencing it in movies on, you know, on other continents that
- 10:45they're referencing it in like children's animation.
- 10:48And I'm wondering. If we have like anti anti piracy
- 10:51ads with Casablanca, yeah, that was my first exposure to
- 10:58Casablanca was those anti piracy ads.
- 11:00I've I forgot about that? I, like, I was trying to
- 11:03remember all the things that they've used the musical cue
- 11:06for, and I honestly can't. Like, was that the TCM, like
- 11:11bumper music for a while? Like I know, yeah.
- 11:15I remember when I was like, right before I saw it, I was a
- 11:17teenager and I recognized like, these are images from
- 11:20Casablanca. There was a commercial for Diet
- 11:23Coke where they were drinking a can of diet.
- 11:26And first of all, they don't sell cans of Diet Coke in the
- 11:28movie theater, but they're in a movie theater cracking open a
- 11:31Diet Coke mid movie. And it's when Ingrid Bergman is
- 11:35is like, you wonder why there is no other man in my life.
- 11:38And then that the music swells and they sip the Diet Coke and
- 11:41I'm like, wow, what? That movie looks amazing.
- 11:43Then you see the movie and that scene ends with her being like
- 11:47there was and he's dead. It's like, oh now I know why
- 11:51they cut right before that the the close of that line.
- 11:53Also, you watched it and you were like, why is there no Diet
- 11:56Coke in this movie? Yeah, exactly.
- 12:00It it feels like one of those albums where you're like, wow,
- 12:05this had all of these hit singles on it.
- 12:07It's like there's so many, there's so many different
- 12:10moments that have become pop culture staples in it, and you
- 12:14think it's just one, but then you realize it's like 5 or 10
- 12:18different things. Is this movie The Abbey Road of
- 12:22American cinema? That's what.
- 12:23That's the question before us today, Brad.
- 12:26And I bring all this up because I want to know.
- 12:28Like when you first sat down and watched Casablanca, did you have
- 12:32that moment of like, oh, OK, like I recognize now where all
- 12:37these references came from? Or because you lived the
- 12:40sheltered childhood among the two of us, Was that still still
- 12:43lost on you? I, I would say it was mostly
- 12:46lost on me. I, I don't think there was
- 12:48anything in Casablanca that I was like, oh, that's where it's
- 12:51from. There's been a few movies like
- 12:55that throughout the podcast. I mean, heck, This is Spinal Tap
- 13:02is one of them where you're like, oh, yeah, this is the
- 13:05entire, any docu mockumentary of the 2000s.
- 13:09It all came from here. So there, there's been a few
- 13:12movies that did that. I think.
- 13:14I didn't need all that, Bob. It's just a great movie, right.
- 13:19Yeah. Like I didn't, I didn't need to
- 13:21have any of those references to be like, oh, this is where it
- 13:23came from. I I just got to watch it and see
- 13:26where all of those things came from.
- 13:28I guess when I compare it to other movies that are on that
- 13:31list, like there's other movies that you watch, you know, like
- 13:35Birth of a Nation, Like I watch it and I'm like, OK, I can see
- 13:38why this is innovative and it is like an important landmark in
- 13:43film history, but it doesn't necessarily do anything for me
- 13:46like emotionally, whereas. This one, Vince.
- 13:50Yeah, yeah, in that case, defer for obvious reasons.
- 13:54It's a very good thing. Yeah, in that case.
- 13:57But you know, I like, you know, extrapolating from that example,
- 14:01like there's other movies that you can recognize are
- 14:04groundbreaking in their own way, but they're not necessarily like
- 14:07they don't hit you on an emotional level.
- 14:09And I feel like Casablanca is the ultimate counter example to
- 14:13that. Cause every scene that I
- 14:14remember being like, oh man, this was such a huge emotional
- 14:18moment. And then I wonder like, oh, was
- 14:20I just in a weird place when I saw that?
- 14:22And it's like you said, like it's other people have noted all
- 14:25of those moments before you. And even even with that, like
- 14:29going up against that like level of, you know, like that bar,
- 14:36even at that bar, like they still hit every time somehow.
- 14:38I don't know, it's crazy to me. Well Brad, now that the bar has
- 14:42been set for you, you have 60 seconds on the clock to break
- 14:46down the plot of this movie. Filled with spoilers on this 83
- 14:50year old film. So folks, if you have not gotten
- 14:52around to Casablanca yet, now's probably the time.
- 14:56Let's let's hit pause. Let's go watch Casablanca.
- 14:58I do recommend, think it's a pretty good movie, Brad.
- 15:01It's it's decent. And then come back and join us,
- 15:04Brad, one minute and go. Casablanca is a film that
- 15:09follows Rick Blaine as the owner of Rick's Cafe in the titular
- 15:14city of Casablanca. It is set up as a crossroads of
- 15:18sorts where multiple different characters are kind of meeting
- 15:22in this launching point where many people are trying to escape
- 15:26Nazi Germany to get to Lisbon, which will eventually take them
- 15:30to America. Things really kick off when Rick
- 15:34is given letters of transport that will allow anybody to leave
- 15:38the city. His former lover, Elsa Faust,
- 15:42returns to the city with her husband, Victor Laszlo.
- 15:46Hold on. I got.
- 15:46I got hit. Pause.
- 15:47I got it. Elsa Faust is Mission
- 15:50Impossible, I think. That's true.
- 15:53Ilsa Lund. That's a good thing, Ilsa.
- 15:55Lund Faust. It's.
- 15:57Always German. It would be pretty dope if Ilsa
- 15:59was also an assassin. I'm not gonna lie, that might
- 16:02actually improve this movie. It's like the Marvel what's
- 16:05what's the gal that Captain America falls in love with
- 16:07Peggy? Oh yeah.
- 16:09Yeah, Also a secret agent. Also a secret agent.
- 16:12Elsa Lund. Is it Lund?
- 16:16Lund. All right, Elsa Lund comes to
- 16:19Casablanca with her husband, Victor Laszlo, who is a
- 16:22important resistance leader. There is a love triangle between
- 16:26the three of them as Rick determines if he's going to help
- 16:29them escape or try to escape with his former lover.
- 16:34Boom, I don't. I'm sorry for derailing, Brad
- 16:36explains. But that's I feel like now the
- 16:39worst part of this is that my love for Ingrid Birdman from
- 16:44this movie has forever been way up here.
- 16:47And I think I may have just unlocked like the only thing
- 16:50that I would have enjoyed better about Casablanca is if it was
- 16:53actually Rebecca Ferguson as Elsa Lund in this movie or as
- 16:58Elsa Faust in this movie. They.
- 17:00Both have some lice grams, you know, and that's what's that's
- 17:02what's. Important.
- 17:03Sure do. I feel like the like The funny
- 17:05thing about Casablanca is like at least growing up not having
- 17:09it, not having seen it when I was a kid or not having it being
- 17:13part of my like cultural repertoire.
- 17:16Like it's sort of filtered down to me as like one of these like
- 17:19romantic movies. You know, it was like, oh, Gone
- 17:22with the Wind and Casablanca and whatever other like insert
- 17:26famously romantic movie here. And then you watch it and you're
- 17:29like, this is not romantic at all.
- 17:31It's kind of like a bromance movie if anything.
- 17:33Like it's about 3 dudes that are kind of like figure out how to
- 17:38just like put their put their bromance above their petty
- 17:42jealousies. Put their bromance above the
- 17:45Nazis. That's what we're all called to
- 17:47do, I think. Right.
- 17:49So, yeah, I was before Nazis. That's that's how the the phrase
- 17:54goes. Yeah.
- 17:54I think as I look back on this movie, I'm with you, Vince, in
- 17:57that like, it's always regarded as the greatest romance movie of
- 18:02all time. And it certainly is when you
- 18:04think about the sacrifices involved of the characters.
- 18:07But it's much more of an intrigue movie.
- 18:10It's much more of a political movie than I remembered it
- 18:12being. And I think, guys, if we can
- 18:15start, just kick things off with the performances here because
- 18:18they are obviously all iconic performances.
- 18:21I want to start at the top with Humphrey Bogart.
- 18:23Brad, we've done quite a few Bogart films on the podcast.
- 18:26This by far is his most famous performance, I think for good
- 18:29reason. You know, the image of him in
- 18:31that white dinner jacket is like, like, it's film
- 18:34iconography at this point. Like, it is it.
- 18:37You could just cut the silhouette out of it and you're
- 18:39like, Oh yeah, that's Bogart in Casablanca.
- 18:42I think what I forgot about this movie isn't just that Rick is
- 18:47such a anti hero. He's a really early example of
- 18:51what you would come to be known in in 50s literature as the anti
- 18:54hero, but that he's just legitimately like a huge asshole
- 18:59to everyone for most of the movie.
- 19:02To the point where like still 10 minutes from the end of the
- 19:05movie, you're like, Oh my God, this guy's gonna sell out some
- 19:08guy to get sent to a concentration camp.
- 19:11Like there's, there's no redeeming qualities to Rick.
- 19:14Yeah, to to be clear, get some tail and get back to New York
- 19:18'cause he misses it there. Like, this guy is a Dick.
- 19:23And, and I just didn't remember it.
- 19:25I remember him being like a hard shelled soft candy, you know, a
- 19:28hard candy shell soft interior kind of guy.
- 19:31No, not at all. Like he is just the worst for
- 19:35most of this movie and I don't know why I remembered it
- 19:38differently, but Brad, I'd love to hear your opinions on Rick
- 19:41Blaine the character. You mean your first 49 times you
- 19:45got it wrong and this time around hold?
- 19:47On. See, I honestly, I don't take
- 19:51him that way at all. I take him as extraordinarily
- 19:54bitter and angry at his life that he had his one love and he
- 20:00didn't trust his gut to go get her in in Paris.
- 20:04He trusted her to come meet him at the station.
- 20:06And he's been regretting it ever since.
- 20:08And like, the only thing keeping him alive is Sam.
- 20:12So I to me, it didn't come off as just like, he's a giant D
- 20:16It's more of just like, yeah, he's super wounded and.
- 20:19Can't handle his emotions 'cause he was born in like 1890
- 20:22something so. And the fact that he's
- 20:25surrounded by like people that might be trying to kill him at
- 20:28all times. Totally.
- 20:29I've, you know, like he's he's a former guy who's run arms to The
- 20:34Ethiopians and has fought for the Republic in Spain.
- 20:39And now he's like surrounded by Nazis and French Nazi
- 20:43collaborators. So, but like, yes, it's funny
- 20:47because it's like he is that ultimate example of like every
- 20:5250s and you know, every 50s antihero where he's just like
- 20:56outwardly a Dick and he only speaks in like cryptic riddles.
- 21:02Like he's he's refuses to to be honest to a fault.
- 21:07Like he can't even like, tell you what the weather is that
- 21:09day. I I mean the, the line about
- 21:12like, how did you get here? And he said I came to Casablanca
- 21:15for the waters. Quad Rings is like for my help.
- 21:18We're in the desert. He's like, I was misinformed and
- 21:20that's it. He doesn't say anything else.
- 21:22Great. Classic, like 30s, you know,
- 21:26pitter patter dialogue. But like, he really makes it
- 21:30work. There's a quote from one of the
- 21:33brothers that wrote the screenplay that it has more corn
- 21:35than in the states of Kansas and Iowa combined.
- 21:38But when corn works, there's nothing better.
- 21:40And like, that really does sum up the movie.
- 21:42Like, it is very corny. All these things were either
- 21:45tropes at the time or have become tropes.
- 21:48You know, Humphrey Bogart's character probably most of all.
- 21:51But like when he delivers a monologue, like it hits every
- 21:55damn time. I feel like that needs to be the
- 21:59the tagline for Mellow Corn. When corn works, there's nothing
- 22:03better. One of our favorite whiskeys,
- 22:07Brad. Yeah.
- 22:09I'd love to hear a little bit more about what you guys think
- 22:11of the performance. Like obviously with some of
- 22:14these older stars, and I think Bogart's among them, like when
- 22:17you're watching a Humphrey Bogart movie, you're getting a
- 22:19Humphrey Bogart performance. Same thing with like James
- 22:22Cagney. Like you're not expecting too
- 22:24much outside the wheelhouse of a typical James Cagney.
- 22:27I would say Brad, for us, the one that we've watched of
- 22:29Bogart, that was kind of the biggest departure was The
- 22:33Treasure of the Sierra Madre, which I think he's probably
- 22:35better in than in this. But I, I think he or he has to
- 22:39kind of modulate his tone, his rhythm, his emotions in a much
- 22:44smaller register. Because obviously of the
- 22:47character repressing and suppressing all of his actual
- 22:50guilt and shame and everything else.
- 22:52And when to Vince's point, when you see him in the darkened
- 22:57saloon on that first night doing the, you know, of all the gin
- 23:00joints monologue, I it's some of the best acting of his career.
- 23:03It's so good, man. Yeah, he plays dark and brooding
- 23:08so incredibly well. And the the first time that Elsa
- 23:12comes back to see him in at night and he just rips into her
- 23:17and basically calls her a whore. Like Also, this movie has a lot
- 23:24of stuff you do not expect out of a 1942 film.
- 23:29Like, Claude Raines is sleeping with underage women.
- 23:33He flat out calls Elsa a whore. And there's like three or four
- 23:39other moments that I was, like, blown away by the content that
- 23:43they're putting into this movie in the 40s.
- 23:45Yeah. I think that one of the reasons
- 23:47Bogart works so well is because he is kind of a a boulder in the
- 23:55film that everybody else is trying to chip away at and
- 23:58figure out who he is. And you can see him emotionally
- 24:02on his face just like keeping everybody out until the few
- 24:06moments of the film where he lets people in, which is when he
- 24:10calls Elsa whore. He he lets her in and tells her
- 24:13what he's really thinking at the end of the film when he says one
- 24:17of the best closing lines of all time to Claude Raines.
- 24:20Like there's, there's a few moments throughout the film
- 24:23where he actually lets himself be seen.
- 24:26And it it that transition from like, you're not getting
- 24:30anything out of me to like, here's what I really think.
- 24:33Bogart just nails it. Yeah, I think it was the
- 24:38director of Killing Them Softly was talking about Brad Pitt and
- 24:42how like he kind of only can play this like iconic, like
- 24:46larger than life type character because he just has that quality
- 24:50to him. Like he, he doesn't play like a
- 24:52regular average Joe very well, I think.
- 24:56Yeah, Humphrey Bogart has that same thing.
- 24:59And it works. His persona works in this movie
- 25:02because like, he is always, his staginess works 'cause he's sort
- 25:06of always doing a performance in his status as like the biggest,
- 25:10you know, bar owner in this town that's like filled with intrigue
- 25:15and, and spies and people trying to kill each other.
- 25:18So it's like he's given a performance, but he's also
- 25:22playing a guy who's giving a performance.
- 25:24And then, yeah. And then you sort of live for
- 25:26those moments where he drops the facade a little bit and becomes
- 25:32like a wounded little boy or, or, you know, this earnest,
- 25:36earnest, romantic type person. I want to talk about Ingrid
- 25:40Bergman, but in order to kind of intro that, I kind of have to
- 25:44talk a little bit about the the structure of the movie itself.
- 25:47Because they don't actually start that flashback to Paris
- 25:52until about the 45 minute mark of the movie.
- 25:55And everything before that happens in one night in one
- 25:59location, which there are very few movies that can sustain that
- 26:03much of their movie unless they're, you know, like a based
- 26:06on a stage play that happens in one location.
- 26:08But, you know, it reminds me a lot, Brad, of The Godfather,
- 26:11like that opening wedding sequence where you spend the
- 26:14first like 40 minutes there with Don Corleone.
- 26:17Like, I forgot how much of the setup of the characters.
- 26:20You know, the inciting incident with the letters of transit, the
- 26:24intrigue, you know, the the politics between parties at the
- 26:28cafe leading into of all the gin joints.
- 26:31And then finally, like the flashback where you finally
- 26:34understand, like, what the hell is going on with this character?
- 26:37It's a solid 45 minutes. And I think it's really
- 26:40masterfully set up, not just by the script, but also by the
- 26:43director, Michael Curtis, that when Ingrid Bergman walks
- 26:46through the door at like the 30 minute mark of the movie, you're
- 26:50like, oh, who's this? And, and you're not even
- 26:53thinking about the fact that like, oh, now the movie's
- 26:55starting because it never seemed like they were bidding their
- 26:59time. She just comes in.
- 27:01But you've had tons and tons of plot get set up before then and
- 27:05never got bored with it. I don't think we even see Rick's
- 27:08house, right? Like we don't see where he like,
- 27:11lives at any point, no. I does he just live above the
- 27:14bar like where he where he has her that one night?
- 27:17I don't remember. I think so, yeah, I guess, yeah,
- 27:19I guess that counts. Yeah, that's true.
- 27:21But I think, yeah, I think that, yeah.
- 27:23I was going to say the opening of the film is incredible
- 27:25because it's a it's like a little bit ham handed, but they
- 27:29just set up. Rick is a guy that doesn't stick
- 27:32his neck out for anybody. There are there is a French
- 27:36underground resistance in town. There's another cafe owner that
- 27:41like if you want to do get down and dirty, you can go to him.
- 27:44But Rick plays by his own rules and they set all of that up in a
- 27:49way that like feels a little bit obvious, but it's compelling,
- 27:54interesting movie telling where you also get to see the
- 27:57brutality of the the Reich and the the French that are friendly
- 28:03to the Third Reich. Like you get so much jam packed
- 28:08into that that when you hit Elsa walking in, it feels like almost
- 28:13like a mic drop. Like like, oh, we already had
- 28:16all this happening and now this stunning, gorgeous woman walks
- 28:21in and she was in love with Rick.
- 28:23Like, it's just a great like flow into what the movie is
- 28:28actually about. It kind of works the way good
- 28:31pulp tends to work. Like there's that opening scene
- 28:33with the pickpocket and like the most of the openings in this are
- 28:37like a little clunky and like a little stagey.
- 28:41And like that ends up working really well because it it comes
- 28:45on clunky and stagey at the moment when you're most willing
- 28:50to suspend disbelief. And so you're like, OK, let's
- 28:55see where this is going. And then it's sort of like it,
- 28:58it gradually it lowers your defenses for all of the like
- 29:02corn that works so well because like it's gets, it gets
- 29:06gradually, it reveals layers of realism.
- 29:09Like once you've already like suspended it, it's not doing it
- 29:12the opposite way where you know, you're expecting a grounded
- 29:15reality. And then suddenly it starts
- 29:16hitting you with like the, the, the, the stagy stuff.
- 29:19It's, you know, it, it, it lulls you into like a, it lulls you
- 29:25into accepting everything that it's doing.
- 29:28Can I just say while, while we're here at the start, the the
- 29:32the pickpocket who like goes to Rick and he's as he's getting
- 29:37arrested, he's like rank, help me rank.
- 29:40Yeah. Every time I see Ugarte, all I
- 29:45can think about is Robin Williams in Aladdin when he's
- 29:49talking to Aladdin about the rules he got and he goes, I
- 29:52can't bring you back from the dead.
- 29:54Is that is that the connection? Yeah, so that's again.
- 29:57So the actor's name is Peter Lorre, who became very famous
- 30:00for his look and his sound. He was a German actor.
- 30:04One day we'll get around to watching.
- 30:05He made a a film in Germany with Fritz Lang called M that is like
- 30:09just one of the best movies of all time, Brad, and he's the
- 30:11star. Of it, I've even heard of it.
- 30:14All right, there you go. We, you've heard of the letter M
- 30:17We're, we're, we're well on our way, Brad.
- 30:19That first season of Sesame Street paid off handsomely.
- 30:23So yeah. Then he comes over to America.
- 30:25He does a lot of character work. He had worked with Bogart the
- 30:28year before this in the Maltese Falcon and he's in tons of like
- 30:33Looney Tunes cartoons. They do Peter Laurie characters.
- 30:36It comes up in Aladdin. So yes, there you go.
- 30:39Same, same guy I love. A bug eyed little freak.
- 30:42I'm like a big. Man.
- 30:43Yeah. Yeah, if you're remaking this
- 30:46movie, like this is clearly the Steve Buscemi performance,
- 30:50right? Like, I don't think there's
- 30:51anybody else you can really slot in here.
- 30:53Oh, I could do like a Barry Kogan if you're.
- 30:56Going modern Modern. I'm OK with that.
- 30:59I mean, if we're talking bug eyed freaks like he's
- 31:00definitely. Are are you throwing Brad Pitt
- 31:02in for Humphrey? No.
- 31:06I don't think he's that. I don't think he's quite the
- 31:08actor that Humphrey is. Oh, I've got a hot take.
- 31:14Did you see the new Wes Anderson movie, Brad?
- 31:17I have not. The Phoenician scheme.
- 31:21I like Vince, I liked it a lot. But I watched that movie and I
- 31:24was like, I think Benicio could pull off the Humphrey Bogart.
- 31:27Character. He's got the look and the like.
- 31:31He stoicism to him, you know, he's I think that's the only guy
- 31:36I would recommend from from like today's crop of actors.
- 31:39I don't know who else could do it.
- 31:41Well, Humphrey Bogart looks like he lives hard, which is like a
- 31:43rare quality among modern actors.
- 31:48For sure. Speaking of bug eyed freaks,
- 31:51guys, let's get back to Ingrid Bergman, am I right?
- 31:53So I want to talk a little bit about Ingrid Bergman.
- 31:58And I think that I, I wanted to do that set up because they do
- 32:00such a good job of burying the lead with her character because
- 32:03like, she comes in and as she comes in, the rest, you know,
- 32:06the Cafe, you're only familiar with her character as the wife
- 32:10of the guy they've been talking about this whole time.
- 32:12Like they've been building up Victor Laszlo.
- 32:14And you're like, oh, Ingrid Bergman, maybe Humphrey Bogart
- 32:16will try to like, you know, swoop in on the side 'cause he
- 32:19seems like a devious guy. You have no idea that they're
- 32:22going to have this back story that they share.
- 32:25And then she mentioned Sam and then she starts talking to Sam
- 32:28and then you're like, Oh yeah, there's something going on here.
- 32:31And I just love the way that as an audience member, you're left
- 32:35completely in the dark way up until that that first flashback.
- 32:39And there's only a few times, Brad, that we've experienced
- 32:41that with films we've watched for the podcast.
- 32:43I think the Matrix is a good example where I think in the
- 32:46Matrix I talked about like at that 45 minute mark, you're
- 32:50almost getting frustrated with like, I need answers like this
- 32:53is getting I I need to know what's going on.
- 32:55And then they finally reveal like the plot of, you know,
- 32:58what's going on in the Matrix. It's kind of similar here, but
- 33:02in order to get there, you have to go from not knowing who
- 33:06Ingrid Bergman is to having the entire like onus of this past
- 33:11relationships emotional weight put on her.
- 33:14And the way they accomplished that is as Dooley Wilson starts
- 33:19singing as time goes by, Michael Curtis is like, let's leave the
- 33:23camera on her face in an unbroken shot for like the first
- 33:272 verses of this song for like a solid minute.
- 33:30And all you see is like her eyes slowly move this way and and a a
- 33:35single tear starts to form here and you're watching her
- 33:38remember. And for somebody, yes, she's
- 33:42gorgeous. She's a very beautiful woman.
- 33:44But to be able to hold the camera for that long, doing that
- 33:48little, is an incredibly impressive acting feat.
- 33:53Dude. Like one of the one of very few,
- 33:58what I would call perfect shots, like just everything the movie
- 34:04needed and like transcendent in the history of cinema where like
- 34:10you could put that down in front of almost anybody and just let
- 34:14them sit there with that shot and feel the weight of the
- 34:17emotion and what's happened. Like I I would put that up
- 34:22there. I'd put that up there with, is
- 34:26it gold rush where, where Charlie is standing there and
- 34:30everybody else goes out and he's it's just a, it's a perfect
- 34:33shot. I'd put it up there with Darth
- 34:36Vader's mask coming on for the very first time.
- 34:39Like, like. Just wow you you'd really put it
- 34:42up there with Star Wars. That's.
- 34:43Crazy. I I sure would.
- 34:45Who knew? Sorry, here's here's my hot
- 34:48take, Bob. I think that the flashback scene
- 34:53is unnecessary. I I think it kind of ruins the
- 34:59one shot of Ingrid Bergman. Like, I think that shows you the
- 35:04emotion. Yeah, it's making, it's making
- 35:07you create whatever happened between them in your mind.
- 35:10And then you get this weird, like Fellini fever dream,
- 35:13whatever the fuck that flashback is.
- 35:15I kind of agree with. I I was reading the Wikipedia
- 35:17and apparently, like the director, like Curtis Curtis was
- 35:20the one pushing for that for for whatever reason.
- 35:23Oh, interesting. Yeah, I don't, yeah, it doesn't
- 35:25do anything. It doesn't like hurt the film to
- 35:27me, but I could. I feel like yeah, I could easily
- 35:30imagine it without it. For for me, it almost like
- 35:34betrays the beauty of that shot. It's like, OK, we understand the
- 35:38emotional stakes because Bergman knocks it out of the freaking
- 35:42park. Yeah.
- 35:43And then you kind of like put in this.
- 35:45It's like the joke that you make someone create in their head is
- 35:48going to be better than any joke that you actually tell word for
- 35:52word. And like the, yeah, the
- 35:54flashback scene is like they're just telling you like we had, we
- 35:56created it in our head like this beautiful, whatever this
- 35:59beautiful relationship was. Yeah, and, and all you need is
- 36:05for him to in talking to her when he's calling her a whore,
- 36:09which apparently we're talking about a lot tonight, like in
- 36:12that moment. That word a lot more than in any
- 36:14other episode of our podcast. I mean, plus the whole thing is
- 36:18about the inability to recapture a moment, which, you know,
- 36:21that's sort of like The Great Gatsby too, but it's like the,
- 36:24you know, that's the whole theme of the movie.
- 36:26So like when you actually do a flashback to that moment, you're
- 36:29like, yeah, probably could have done without that.
- 36:31Yeah, that's fair. I I think all you have to do is
- 36:34have Bogart angrily describe what it was like waiting on the
- 36:38train platform for her, and I think that would have been way
- 36:41more effective than actually showing the scene.
- 36:44My defense for it and I'm actually with you guys like if
- 36:48they had cut it, I think it's still a great movie, right and
- 36:51and. Then it would be it would be a
- 36:5290 minute film then. That's true.
- 36:55I only know this movie with the flashback in it so it's really
- 36:58hard to imagine it without. But like to see them go from
- 37:02Humphrey Bogart like slunched over a bottle of bourbon to a
- 37:06flashback where you see him smiling for the first time in
- 37:09the whole movie and you're like, this is a completely different.
- 37:11Drive in a convertible like bears in the world.
- 37:14Just right out into the French countryside.
- 37:17He doesn't care. Also and his smile is not great
- 37:20he like barely shows. Yeah, well, his face is all
- 37:23jacked up. He just like, shows a a few of
- 37:26his top teeth that are all like wonky, Yeah.
- 37:28He's got bad. Teeth.
- 37:29So I mean, it is what it is, man.
- 37:31You have a beautiful smile and I don't now I feel offended by
- 37:34this. So what are you really talking
- 37:36about here? I guess is what I'm saying.
- 37:37I mean I miss real teeth in movies like.
- 37:40Yes. I mean.
- 37:42That's always like when when an actor hits the age where you see
- 37:45that they've gotten like veneers or dentures put in.
- 37:48Like when Clooney hit his denture phase.
- 37:50I was like, no, Clooney's actually old now.
- 37:53I was just going to say, like I, I did a re watch of the Mission
- 37:57Impossible franchise before the new movie or right around the
- 38:00time that came out. And then like, like there's a
- 38:02distinct difference between Tom Cruise up until Mission
- 38:06Impossible 2. And then he got some, some like
- 38:09major dental work done between 2:00 and 3:00 to make it look
- 38:12quote UN quote better. But it's like the fact that he
- 38:15had like teeth that had a little bit of character made him more
- 38:19handsome. And like, you take that away,
- 38:21it's like, you know, it's, it's, it's sanding down one of the
- 38:24idiosyncrasies that sort of made him interesting.
- 38:27You know who I bet never had anything done on his teeth?
- 38:30Steve Buscemi. I'll bet you he's just rocking.
- 38:34Whatever man of character right there, Steve Buscemi and then
- 38:37you know, Willem Dafoe has enough teeth for both of them.
- 38:40So that's it's perfect like. And they're more handsome
- 38:42because of it. I love it man, both of them.
- 38:46I forget what movie he was talking about, but I interviewed
- 38:48Ben Foster about some movie that he did.
- 38:50I think it was some sort of movie where he was in combat or
- 38:55something. And like the rumor was that he
- 38:56like ate dirt on the set of whatever movie.
- 38:59And he was like, so I when I was asking him about it, I was like,
- 39:03oh, is this true? Like, what was the story behind
- 39:05that? And he's like, you know, I was
- 39:05just looking around and I see all of us pretty boy actors with
- 39:09our caps teeth, like looking like we just got out of like
- 39:12whatever, you know, like looking like we just came from the the
- 39:16dentist and we're playing this war scene.
- 39:18And it didn't feel right for me. So I like started eating.
- 39:21He put dirt in his mouth to try and make it, you know, a little
- 39:24more realistic. I don't think I've ever heard a
- 39:27better description of actor brain that they're like, how do
- 39:30I make my teeth look like the peasants again?
- 39:34They eat dirt, right? This is what you people do,
- 39:37right? Oh man, guys, we've we've talked
- 39:42about teeth and bug eyes and very little about the acting
- 39:45performances in this movie like. I think the movie doesn't work
- 39:49with that. Sorry.
- 39:50Go ahead. 100 No, I I completely agree with you.
- 39:52Like, you have to have these characters in the movie and you
- 39:55know, we'll touch on some of this, but there's so much lore
- 39:58of like, you know, the the Lamar Sayaz scene is stocked with all
- 40:03of these extras. Many of whom were like
- 40:05legitimate war refugees from Europe.
- 40:08And they said California made this in 1942.
- 40:11Was so insane to me. Like the movie, I mean sorry,
- 40:14the war had like just kind of started like it like movies take
- 40:17a while to make. Like they made a such a perfect
- 40:20World War 2 movie. Like in the middle of it.
- 40:23Like the Nazis were still very much winning at this point.
- 40:27Yeah, like I, I don't have the Wikipedia pulled up, so I'm
- 40:29trying to figure out like, exactly when they filmed the
- 40:31movie. But you have to think that it
- 40:32was at least in production, like when Pearl Harbor was happening,
- 40:37right? It came out at the end.
- 40:38It happened, it happened. They released it just after the
- 40:43Allied invasion of North Africa. So I think it is like before
- 40:47D-Day still like when it comes out like there was, I, I guess
- 40:51there was discussions about whether to try and fit like the
- 40:57invasion of North Africa into the movie.
- 40:59And then they were like, no, we can't do that.
- 41:01I'm so glad they didn't. And like, it's not like it's a
- 41:03very complicated metaphor, like Rick as this picture of American
- 41:07isolationism. But like, there's one small
- 41:09moment where Claude Rayne says something, you know, he says, I
- 41:12stick my neck out for nobody. And then Claude Rayne says a
- 41:15wise foreign policy. And, you know, the entire arc of
- 41:19his character is like, what's going to be the thing that makes
- 41:22him stick his neck out? Because even as that Marseilles
- 41:25scene starts, he's been talking with Victor Laszlo upstairs.
- 41:29They come out onto the balcony and they look down and Rick
- 41:32doesn't do anything. Like Rick is just letting this
- 41:34play out kind of, you know, blowing with the wind and seeing
- 41:37where where fate takes this. And it's Victor Laszlo that's
- 41:40like, screw this, like go down and confront these guys.
- 41:44And throughout the whole movie, you know, yes, we're we're
- 41:47familiar with Rick because he's the protagonist of our movie.
- 41:50But like, Victor Laszlo is the better person throughout the
- 41:54movie. And, like, the guy who's
- 41:55actually has principles and stands on something.
- 41:58And so the question is, is Rick ever gonna get to the point
- 42:02where he could be worthy of Ingrid Bergman's love and worthy
- 42:05of the kind of guy that he used to be?
- 42:08And it's such a great little metaphor for like, hey, we just
- 42:12got bombed by the Japanese. Like, are we gonna, like,
- 42:14finally get into this fight that people been begging us to get
- 42:17into? That seems like such a perfect
- 42:19example of this movie where it's like, you could describe that.
- 42:23Like you could put that on paper.
- 42:25Like, OK, these Germans are singing their song and then they
- 42:27come in and they sing the Marcias and they they drown them
- 42:30out like on paper. Like that does nothing for me.
- 42:33I'm like, OK, whatever, that's stupid.
- 42:34And then you watch it and you're like, yeah, I want to like run
- 42:37through a brick wall, brick wall right now.
- 42:38I'm fucking pumped. Like and, and I will think that
- 42:43about that scene and I'll think it can't possibly make me feel
- 42:46that way again. And then every time I watch it,
- 42:48it's the same damn thing. And I'm like, I don't.
- 42:50You're like standing up with with Laszlo, Yeah.
- 42:53I don't know the words, I don't know what the I don't know what
- 42:56the Marseilles is about. I don't even know the melody.
- 42:58But like, I don't know, just the way he shoots that scene with
- 43:02the final shot of Yvonne, who by the way, like when she first
- 43:08enters, I'm like, why is Rick throwing this hot chick out of
- 43:10his bar? I don't really get it.
- 43:12What's his like? Why does he hate this super hot
- 43:14chick so much? And then angry Bird.
- 43:16Vince's character, if he was in the movie, would be Claude
- 43:19Rains. Yeah.
- 43:21Yeah. Angry Bergeron shows up and I'm
- 43:22like, OK, this is the one you're in love with.
- 43:24All right, whatever. But then it works like
- 43:25everything else in the movie, where at first you're kind of
- 43:28you're sort of like you have your hackles up a little bit and
- 43:31then it it, it gradually lowers your defenses until you're like,
- 43:35OK, just let this movie into my heart.
- 43:38Well, and then you get that story of like Michael Curtis
- 43:40specifically stocking Ricks with extras from Europe who have fled
- 43:45the war. And you know, I've heard it said
- 43:48like 1000 times, but it's true. Like watch anybody in the
- 43:51background in that scene and there are people weeping and
- 43:56it's real because they're like, they have just escaped
- 43:59atrocities in Europe and they're coming to make this movie in
- 44:01America. It's it's one of those stories
- 44:03from Hollywood that's like too good to be true, but it's
- 44:06actually one of the true ones. And I think like maybe another
- 44:10great example of this, Brad is the guy who plays Major
- 44:13Strasser, Conrad Weit again, he was a famous German actor.
- 44:17There's a really like he's. So on metal looking.
- 44:21He's that dude. No one has ever looked more like
- 44:24a Nazi than Conrad. Bike in this movie, his eyes.
- 44:28He was like the most popular actor in Germany in the early
- 44:32days of film. And there's a landmark silent
- 44:34movie called The Cabinet of Doctor Caligari that he starred
- 44:37in. He comes to America.
- 44:39He. He.
- 44:39Silently played the cabinet right.
- 44:41He was the Cabinet, yes. What range on this guy, Right.
- 44:46The sound pictures hit. He has to go back to Germany
- 44:49because he has this thick German accent.
- 44:51But he arrives back in Germany at the same time that the Nazis
- 44:55are coming to power. And he's like these.
- 44:57These guys certainly seem to suck.
- 44:59And what ends up happening is he marries a Jewish woman and right
- 45:03around the time he gets married, they start sending out these
- 45:07kind of like census documents that are like, you have to
- 45:09declare what race you are. And he wasn't Jewish, but his
- 45:13wife was. And he knew it was going to
- 45:15happen. So he wrote down that his race
- 45:16was Jewish on this thing just as like a fuck you to the Nazis and
- 45:20then took his wife and fled to America.
- 45:22And Brad, I've got some facts pulled up about Conrad Bite.
- 45:26He agreed to play Nazi characters in Hollywood films
- 45:29with the stipulation that they must always be portrayed as
- 45:31villains. It was a contractual demand he
- 45:34enforced to ensure that the roles that his roles undermined
- 45:37the Nazi 'cause he fled Nazi Germany with his Jewish wife,
- 45:41supported his ex-wife and daughter in their escape from
- 45:44Germany, demonstrating his commitment to fighting the
- 45:46regime. He donated his life savings to
- 45:49the British government to aid the war effort.
- 45:52When he first fled Germany, he went to England and bought 2000
- 45:58different packages of candy to deliver who to kids whose houses
- 46:02were bombed in the bombing of London, and then continued to
- 46:05give his salary from every movie he made back to the war effort
- 46:08just to fight the Nazis. Dude was a bad ass.
- 46:12That's insane. Yeah, man.
- 46:14Like that's and it's like, you know, people make Movies Now and
- 46:17yes, they have the power to go along with it, but it's like,
- 46:20how often do you get a story about to your point, Vince, this
- 46:23was happening as the war was going on and the people in the
- 46:27movie were part of it overseas. And now they're coming here to
- 46:32make this movie. Every time I watch it, like I
- 46:34can't figure out how they made the timeline work that well,
- 46:38'cause I'm like trying to imagine, like the best War on
- 46:42Terror movie coming out in 2003. Like it's just it's yeah, it's
- 46:48crazy. Also, what's what does that
- 46:50casting call look like? Are you recently escaped from
- 46:54Europe? We need.
- 46:56You. It's like a shady lawyer, like
- 46:59what the guys that now would be doing.
- 47:01Like were you hurt in a car accident?
- 47:03Like did you escape atrocities in Nazi Germany if so?
- 47:06What are? What are?
- 47:07Your 1800 Hollywood. Cause in California we have like
- 47:103 everybody knows like the three dude billboard lawyers, like we
- 47:15have Anne Fong, we have sweet James What, what are your and
- 47:20and and accidentes? What are your guys?
- 47:22You know who I'm thinking of? Tim Nisney.
- 47:26And I'll make them pay. There's a guy named Tim Mizney
- 47:30who looks like knock off, like great value, Mr. Clean, very
- 47:34bald. And his thing is that like,
- 47:36yeah, he his commercial, he would buy 5 second airtime
- 47:39commercials and he would just say I'm Tim Mizney and I'll make
- 47:43them pay. That's it.
- 47:45And he's very. So famous in Cleveland now that
- 47:47like he he owns like every billboard in Cleveland.
- 47:50And it would used to say Tim Mizney make them pay and he
- 47:53would be like cock in one eyebrow like the Rock.
- 47:56And now they've made it so that he the iconography of Tim Mizney
- 48:00is so legendary in Northeast Ohio that the Billboard is just
- 48:03an extreme close up of his eyes doing this.
- 48:06And there's no text. It's just Tim Mizney's eyebrow.
- 48:09He's like Mark I've. Jordan one that just says, you
- 48:12know what I'll do? Which is so threatening.
- 48:17We have a guy named Sweet James, which is disconcerting.
- 48:20Like if you saw the guy's face, he does not look like a sweet
- 48:23guy. He looks like a very.
- 48:25He's just a very ugly man. I feel like sweet.
- 48:28James was in some like it hot and he was like a hit man trying
- 48:32to kill. Yeah.
- 48:34Right. It's just like a creepy name.
- 48:35It doesn't fit the guy. Like you wonder if he chose it
- 48:38because he knew people would be like what the hell?
- 48:40Why is this guy calling himself Sweet James and then apparently
- 48:42like he is Mary or he's the ex-husband of someone who was on
- 48:46one of the Real Housewife type shows?
- 48:48So. And he's a very shady character,
- 48:51yeah. When when they're like reading
- 48:53the, you know, the who's in court into record.
- 48:57It's like and counsel for the defense.
- 48:59Sweet James. Full legal name.
- 49:04Sweet James. Guys, I think this is a good
- 49:07place for us to hit pause, Brad. I've been really excited to dive
- 49:11back into not just this movie, but our whiskey for the day,
- 49:13which is Elijah Craig Small Batch.
- 49:16Vince is actually going to join us for this review.
- 49:18He's got a bottle in front of him.
- 49:19What do you say we get into this review, Brad, dude?
- 49:21I'm ready for it. Let's go.
- 49:30All right, so today we are checking out Elijah Craig, Small
- 49:33Batch Brad, one of the first whiskeys.
- 49:37I think that made a big impression on us as we recorded
- 49:40this podcast. Not necessarily 'cause it was
- 49:42like the best thing we'd ever drank, but it became a really
- 49:45good baseline for us where, OK, it's not benchmark, it's
- 49:49definitely like the second shelf up.
- 49:51And then I think everything in that price point for a long time
- 49:55we compared to Elijah Craig, like, is this as good as Elijah
- 49:58Craig, yes or no? And that was like how we
- 49:59determined value on stuff. Yeah, I, I think that Elijah
- 50:04Craig really set the standard for us.
- 50:07It's been so long since I've returned to it, Bob.
- 50:10I like, I have not drank this probably since we had it, maybe
- 50:15once since. So I, I've already drank it.
- 50:19I'm still drinking it, as you can see.
- 50:22I'm really excited to get into it, man, because it's been a
- 50:25while. I've been trying not to drink
- 50:28too much while we record this and it's very hard.
- 50:31No, we prefer it the other way. You trying to drink as much?
- 50:34Conversations are it's right here.
- 50:36Conversations are much better if you're drinking it throughout
- 50:38the whole thing. Tempting me, yeah.
- 50:41Vince, do you have any history with Elijah Craig Small Batch?
- 50:45You know, like I actually don't it was not one of my, you know,
- 50:51go to favorites in the past. Like I'm very much a Wild Turkey
- 50:56person. I'm very yeah.
- 50:58So I like that, that that's sort of like my baseline go to and
- 51:02that sort of speaks to me for whatever reason.
- 51:05But I'm very much enjoying it this time.
- 51:07And fairly, it's like it feels like it hits super oaky.
- 51:11It's like like a big oak caramel punch.
- 51:14And it makes me want to keep going back to it.
- 51:17And I will probably get it again after this.
- 51:20There you go, Brad, Some statistics that we should get
- 51:23into here before we start the review.
- 51:25This is a Heaven Hill whiskey. We just visited Heaven Hill for
- 51:29the first time this past summer. Incredible operations going on
- 51:33down there at the Heaven Hill distilleries.
- 51:35The mash bill on this one is 78% corn, 10% rye, 12% malted
- 51:40barley. So the rye is very low in the
- 51:42mash bill. It should be a really easy one
- 51:44to drink. I was surprised to find out that
- 51:47the all the barrels that this is aged in are only charred to a #3
- 51:51char instead of that #4 alligator char.
- 51:54And again, I think it just kind of plays into the fact that this
- 51:57is going to be like a little bit more of an approachable softer
- 52:00whiskey for you, especially at the 94 proof point that we have
- 52:04here, Brad. And I, I will say, if you're
- 52:06going to come under 100 and not go all the way down to 80, I
- 52:10think that mid 90s proof point is a really great spot where you
- 52:15have a decent amount of flavor that comes through and yet
- 52:19you're not hitting this high proof 110 plus blasting you out
- 52:23of the water. And Bob, I'm not going to lie,
- 52:26man, the more we've Drake whiskey, the more you realize
- 52:29you're like, I can drink a decent amount of 94 proof
- 52:33whiskey. You hit one O 4110 like yeah,
- 52:37it's a lot. Quicker, dude, it it sure does.
- 52:40But yeah, that's for sure. And I see Vince is drinking this
- 52:42on a big old rock. Brad, I'm trying this neat in my
- 52:44little mini Glenn Cairn here. Let's go ahead and dive in,
- 52:47guys. So Vince, the way this works is
- 52:49we'll assess this across a couple different categories.
- 52:52The nose, the taste, the finish, the overall balance, and then
- 52:56we'll talk about the price of it and determine the value.
- 52:58We'll give scores out of 10 on each of these.
- 53:01Brad, what are you picking up on the nose of this Elijah Craig?
- 53:05Dude, the nose is just like the platonic ideal of what you want
- 53:11from a bourbon. There is caramel, there's brown
- 53:14sugar, there's vanilla. For me, it gets a little bit
- 53:17nutty, a a hint of banana kind of going on.
- 53:22But those are like the the effervescent kind of extras you
- 53:26get. This is bourbon.
- 53:29This is everything you want out of a bourbon.
- 53:31I I don't think it's like transcendently great, but I
- 53:35think it's really good. I'll give it a 7 1/2.
- 53:39Yeah, I'm going to give it a nine out of 10 because I'm with
- 53:41you. It's not like a transcendent.
- 53:42It's it's all of the notes that people say they smell when they
- 53:45smell bourbon. So it is kind of like the
- 53:47quintessence of burfin. It's not like blowing me away,
- 53:51but you're right, it's caramel, it's vanilla.
- 53:53It's there's tons of oak on this, but the oak presents is
- 53:55like really spicy black pepper, cinnamon, nutmeg.
- 53:59I get a lot of Maple on this. It's just a damn good nose for a
- 54:02bourbon. Brad.
- 54:03I'm going to give it a nine out of 10.
- 54:06Vince, any thoughts on the nose here?
- 54:09Yeah, I think I agree with you. I'm, I was surprised at how low
- 54:12the rye was in the mash bill too, because when I taste it,
- 54:17well, I mean, I know we're talking about the nose, but when
- 54:19I taste it, it has that like pepperiness and there is that, I
- 54:23don't know how to describe it. It's like a sparklingness like
- 54:26on my, when I on the nose, like there's like that punchy, like
- 54:32oaky, it's like a spicy peppery thing.
- 54:35But then it's very much balanced by, like you said, all the
- 54:39things that you expect from bourbon, like like this smells
- 54:43like what like a, a, like the bourbon soap that I that I've
- 54:46bought like from the hardware store smells like, it's like,
- 54:49it's what the, the people who create like the the sense draw
- 54:55from basically. I could just see Vince's wife
- 54:58being like, honey, why don't you use the the body wash that I
- 55:01bought? You're like, no, no, I'm sorry.
- 55:03I buy bourbon soap from the hardware store.
- 55:05Yeah, yeah. The the place that I go to smell
- 55:08all my nuts and bolts, I also need soap from there.
- 55:10I want to smell like my drink. Dude, I'm not going to lie, one
- 55:15of my buddies, like kind of as a joke for a Christmas gift got me
- 55:19one of those like whiskey soap pack things and it has a tin of
- 55:27like a solid Cologne that's supposedly like Buffalo Trace
- 55:32bourbon. Smells incredible, dude.
- 55:35It it is, they figured out pumpkin spice.
- 55:39Yeah, that's exactly what. It is as we get into the taste
- 55:45here, I think pumpkin spice might actually be a good lead in
- 55:47here because there is a ton for me.
- 55:49There's a ton of baking spice on this, Brad, I will say like it's
- 55:52everything you want in a bourbon.
- 55:54But as I kind of kick it to the back of my palate, there's like
- 55:561 little note that across my palate, it was like pink bubble
- 56:00gum. But as it got to the back of my
- 56:02palate, it turned a little bit like aspartamey, like it has
- 56:05almost like an artificial sweetness to the back of the
- 56:08palate and into the finish. So I don't know, I guess I'll
- 56:12Ding it for that here instead of the finish.
- 56:13But I'm going to come down to like a 7 out of 10 on the taste
- 56:16here. I mean, for me the the palate
- 56:20sat with a lot of like burnt sugar.
- 56:23It got a little bit peanutty. The caramel and vanilla were
- 56:26there that had like a sugary sweetness, like a frosting, and
- 56:30it had that oaky spiciness going on.
- 56:33It's not like wildly complex, but there's a lot of flavor
- 56:38going on here that once again, I really like it.
- 56:40It's really solid. I'm sitting at a 7 1/2 out of 10
- 56:44on the palate. But I just switched.
- 56:45I switched to tasting it neat and like it is different.
- 56:49I get less oak, and I know what you mean by the sort of
- 56:53artificial sweetener flavor. For some reason I wasn't getting
- 56:58that as much like with a big ice cube in it.
- 57:01I was getting more of the oaky, like leathery notes.
- 57:06But yeah, I I agree with that. It's sort of like it has a
- 57:10syrupy quality to it that cuts the pepperiness in a way that it
- 57:18makes it approachable. But I don't 100% love.
- 57:21So yeah, I would say it's like a 8 for me, yeah.
- 57:25Yeah, Brad. And then on the finish, I
- 57:26actually, since I dinged it for that note on the pallet, I'll
- 57:29kind of come back up a little bit on the finish.
- 57:32Super warming. Like you feel it in your chest.
- 57:34Like to your point, that 94 proof is just high enough that
- 57:37you're like, all right, this has a backbone to it.
- 57:39This would stand up and really great in a cocktail.
- 57:42I think this would make a killer old Fashioned because there's
- 57:44just enough of that burnt sugar flavor you were talking about
- 57:48and quite a bit of oak on this. I'm going to come up to like and
- 57:528.5 on the finish. Dude, you are all.
- 57:56Over the place with your scores. I love this man.
- 57:58Yeah. I am just consistent throughout
- 58:03man. I think this is okie peppery.
- 58:06The vanilla is like the main sweet flavor that sticks around
- 58:09for me. Once again, I'm going to give it
- 58:12a 7 1/2 I'd like. I think this is a really solid
- 58:16example of what you should expect from a bourbon.
- 58:18I will go 8 1/2 because I don't know what it's hard to define
- 58:22like a thing that makes you want to continue drinking it.
- 58:25I tend to judge bourbons by like how long they hang around in my
- 58:30liquor cabinet. Like, you know, I can say what
- 58:32you want about it. Like this is good.
- 58:34This has this note that says that note, But it's like there's
- 58:36my three-week bourbons and then there's bourbons that have been
- 58:38in there for four years and this.
- 58:42I have a term. I have a term for you.
- 58:44Are you ready? What's that crush ability?
- 58:47Crush ability. Yeah, the the craft beer guys
- 58:50love that one. And I don't know, maybe it's my
- 58:54opinion of craft beer world, but no, like, this feels more like a
- 59:00three-week bourbon than it does a 2 year bourbon for sure.
- 59:04Yep, Yeah, it's versatile. I think you could throw it into
- 59:07any sort of cocktail or you could drink it neat.
- 59:10And I think that that's why on balance, you know, Vince, we
- 59:14judge balance especially by like how consistent was it across
- 59:17those first 3 categories that it kind of do this a little bit.
- 59:20And for me, I do think the taste, I had to Ding it a little
- 59:23bit. But overall, Brad, I think this
- 59:24is still a really well balanced whiskey, especially when you
- 59:27consider that this is like the baseline offering and that
- 59:31they're cranking out how many thousands of barrels of this a
- 59:34year for like the the name brand middle shelf product that this
- 59:41is. This is like an 8 out of 10 on
- 59:42balance for me. I'm I'm with you man, 8 out of
- 59:4510 on balance that the mixture of flavors is really beautiful.
- 59:50It's peppery but not overly oaked.
- 59:53It's sweet, but not it doesn't like dive into this wildly rich
- 59:58cloying, like way too much sweetness.
- 1:00:01So yeah, I I think I'm sitting in an 8 out of 10 on balance as
- 1:00:04well. I'll go with that.
- 1:00:05It's all B plus. No, it's very, I would say
- 1:00:07balance is probably its main quality like it's most like most
- 1:00:14memorable quality, like it's just got all of the elements
- 1:00:18that you expect in a bourbon and they're all there and they're
- 1:00:21working together. Yeah, I think if I can be like
- 1:00:25draw some crude boundaries here, Brad, like bottom shelf whiskey,
- 1:00:30you almost want it to announce itself as little as possible
- 1:00:35because like if any notes are going to come out from bottom
- 1:00:37shelf whiskey, it's going to be. They're not going to be good.
- 1:00:39And then you, when you work your way up to this kind of middle
- 1:00:41shelf where it's this and Woodford and maybe, you know,
- 1:00:45Wild Turkey one O 1 or anything in in that realm, like you're
- 1:00:50finally getting into, Oh, I want this to stick around and I want
- 1:00:54it to feel like I can't believe I got it for only 30 bucks.
- 1:00:58And I think that that this is still to me, kind of like the
- 1:01:01platonic ideal of that shelf. So as we get into value here,
- 1:01:05Brad, I actually don't know what this is selling for in the state
- 1:01:07of Ohio. Now.
- 1:01:08Have they raised the price on it?
- 1:01:10This is $35. I think it's damn good, man.
- 1:01:13If it was 30, it'd be a 10. I think it's 35.
- 1:01:16I'm still going to give it like a nine.
- 1:01:18This like I would probably buy this before I bought Woodford
- 1:01:24and I like Woodford a lot so. That's where I'm at with it.
- 1:01:27Yeah. I, I would say I think I'm still
- 1:01:30a Woodford guy at that $35 price range.
- 1:01:33I still think this is an 8 out of 10 on value, that this is a
- 1:01:36really, really good whiskey. And anymore, man, it just, it
- 1:01:42feels like it's hard to find great whiskey in that 32 to $36
- 1:01:46range. So I I'm all in on this.
- 1:01:50Yeah, I have a bottle of wood Woodford in my liquor cabinet
- 1:01:53right now and I think this would go faster than the Woodford if
- 1:01:58I'm OK being honest. Yeah, like for me, if we're
- 1:02:01talking about that, I don't know what like the Wild Turkey one O
- 1:02:041 is going for. If that's the same price point
- 1:02:08to me that's like that. I'd probably put that like a
- 1:02:10little bit higher, but that's more just like a sense memory
- 1:02:14than a thing that I'm evaluating like one, one to one.
- 1:02:17It's just sort of like probably just like based on good vibes I
- 1:02:20have with that for whatever reason.
- 1:02:22But yeah, this feels like a very solid whiskey for 35 bucks.
- 1:02:27Now I will say Wild Turkey one O 1 in the state of Ohio, 2499,
- 1:02:32yeah. Oh man, that's good value.
- 1:02:35That's a really good value man. I think for me, Brad, if I'm
- 1:02:38like, if I have to grab 2 bottles off the shelf, off this
- 1:02:40shelf at the liquor store, it's probably this and it's Maker's
- 1:02:43Mark so that I can get a good weeded bourbon.
- 1:02:45I like Maker's a lot. But yeah, I'd probably put
- 1:02:49Coopers Craft 100 up there. No, that's in there too.
- 1:02:52That's yeah, we're gonna sneak 1/3.
- 1:02:54Because Makers is like a completely different experience
- 1:02:56than this in my my mind. I like also, but like, I don't
- 1:03:00know, we did. We did bourbon.
- 1:03:01It's great. It's just like a completely
- 1:03:03different experience in some ways.
- 1:03:05Brad, I'm coming out to an extraordinarily high 41.5 out of
- 1:03:1050 on this. Whiskey deal.
- 1:03:11I was going to say, dude, you were you were given some some
- 1:03:14capital S scores to this whiskey man.
- 1:03:18It's. Not crazy is like the Elijah
- 1:03:21Craig barrel proofs that people like stand in line for.
- 1:03:25I think that pound for pound, I like this better than the barrel
- 1:03:29proof version. I think it's every once in a
- 1:03:31while you just have to have a really good cocktail bourbon and
- 1:03:34this is that for me. Yeah, I mean, I I'd like this a
- 1:03:38lot. I will recommend you go buy it.
- 1:03:40You can try it. You can do whatever you want.
- 1:03:42Spend your money on it. It's good stuff.
- 1:03:44I'm coming out to a 38.5 Bob. That is, it's a good score.
- 1:03:50This isn't a. 40 plus whiskey, dude.
- 1:03:52Well, that's where you're wrong, my friend.
- 1:03:55I'm just Vince is going to come in and give it a perfect 50 out
- 1:03:57of 50, right? Man, I was supposed to be doing
- 1:03:59math this whole time. I have no idea.
- 1:04:01I was just enjoying bourbon. I'm going to give it a 40.
- 1:04:04Let's say there it is. Guess what Brad, Guess what?
- 1:04:07Guess what we come out to on average anyway, between our 2
- 1:04:10scores, we come out to an 80 out of 100 or a 40 out of 50.
- 1:04:14Boom. So this is hitting that like
- 1:04:17rarefied air. There's only been a few whiskeys
- 1:04:20that are like in this price point that hit this, and it's
- 1:04:22usually because they're not knocking our socks off, but they
- 1:04:25are like just exceptional values.
- 1:04:28And I think this one still belongs in that category.
- 1:04:30Yeah, absolutely. Like I, I think I would have
- 1:04:33been at like 2028, I want to say before out of 40 for the taste
- 1:04:43categories. So yeah, I did.
- 1:04:46Dude. Elijah Craig is really, really
- 1:04:47good. It's not knocking my socks off
- 1:04:49the way it is for you. But if you want a classic
- 1:04:52bourbon experience, something that will give you everything
- 1:04:55you want out of a bourbon Dude for 35 bucks, Elijah Craig is so
- 1:05:00so good. Yeah, I think I may just be
- 1:05:03colored by the fact that we're also talking about, like, one of
- 1:05:06my favorite movies here today. So let's just carry these good
- 1:05:09vibes back into our conversation on Casablanca.
- 1:05:12Brad, what do you say? Let's get to it.
- 1:05:18All right, that was Elijah Craig's Small Batch, a 94 proof
- 1:05:22bourbon that got a 40 out of 50 from us on average.
- 1:05:25Brad, you need to stop resisting.
- 1:05:28It's a damn good whiskey for what it is.
- 1:05:30I. I I would use the exact same
- 1:05:33words to describe it, but not give it a 41 1/2 out of 50.
- 1:05:39The The numbers don't lie, my friend, much like they don't lie
- 1:05:43about this season's game, which we call 2 facts and a falsehood.
- 1:05:47Brad is going to try to stump your ball. 2 are right and what
- 1:05:53is wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 1:05:57and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me
- 1:06:00with three items as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 1:06:04which is a complete lie and your boy is doing terribly this
- 1:06:08season. Now we're coming off of a a
- 1:06:11couple bad weeks for me, including one where Zach
- 1:06:14Johnston led me astray and I got 2 losses on that week because I
- 1:06:18listened to our guest. Vince, I know we're springing
- 1:06:21this on you here. You were.
- 1:06:22We're playing a big game of two truths and a lie, and we're
- 1:06:25gonna tap you to give some expertise here.
- 1:06:29If if you and I decide on an answer and I go with that, if I
- 1:06:33win, I only get one win in the in the win column.
- 1:06:36But if I lose, I get 2 losses. So there's a lot of pressure on
- 1:06:39you to deliver here today, man. Yikes.
- 1:06:41OK, I'll see. I'll do my best.
- 1:06:43No promises, no refunds. That's my personal motto.
- 1:06:47How slyly can you Google off camera while Brad's reading
- 1:06:51these? Pretty good.
- 1:06:51I mean, you'll probably see my eyes moving around to the left.
- 1:06:54Yeah, that's alright. That'll be the tell.
- 1:06:56It's weird. Vince turned his camera off.
- 1:06:57Real. Quick, why does Vince keep
- 1:07:00talking to Siri? I don't understand what he's
- 1:07:02like. Brad, hit me with your two facts
- 1:07:05and a falsehood. All righty fact #1 Because the
- 1:07:09film was made during World War 2, the production was not
- 1:07:11allowed to film at an airport after dark for security reasons.
- 1:07:15Instead it used a sound stage with a small cardboard cut out
- 1:07:18airplane and forced perspective to give the illusion that the
- 1:07:22plane was full-sized. They used little people to
- 1:07:24portray the crew preparing the plane for take off.
- 1:07:29Fact #2 The piano Julie Wilson played as Sam on set was rented
- 1:07:34from a Los Angeles Music Hall for $25.
- 1:07:37A week after filming ended, Warner Bros sold it off at
- 1:07:41auction for a negligible sum. Decades later, however, the same
- 1:07:45piano resurfaced in a private collection and was authenticated
- 1:07:47by a surviving prop master and eventually sold at Sophie's for
- 1:07:512.3 million. Fact #3 The difference in height
- 1:07:56between Humphrey Bogart and Ingrid Bergman changes
- 1:07:59throughout the film. This is because Bergman was
- 1:08:01actually one to two inches taller than Bogart.
- 1:08:04To create the illusion that it was vice versa, Michael Curtis
- 1:08:07had Bogart stand on boxes and sit on pillows and some shots,
- 1:08:10or had Bergman slouched down as when she sits on the couch in
- 1:08:14the franc for your thoughts scene.
- 1:08:16All right, Vince, I'm going to give you my initial thoughts and
- 1:08:19tell me if I'm crazy. I've I've heard the anecdote
- 1:08:24from fact number one about the little people and the plane 100
- 1:08:28times. So like I know that.
- 1:08:30That's where they got the word deplane.
- 1:08:31Deplane. Like it's I don't know how true
- 1:08:37it really is, but it's Hollywood lore.
- 1:08:38So like, and know that it's in the IMDb facts on this #3 I also
- 1:08:44know that they had Bogart stand on boxes like throughout this
- 1:08:47movie. So it it kind of, I want to
- 1:08:49circle #2 as the falsehood. But I also know that this is a
- 1:08:54movie where like yes, a prop from this movie could fetch
- 1:08:58$2,000,000 at Sotheby's. So I don't know man, where are
- 1:09:01you on this one? Yeah, 2 sounds plausible, but
- 1:09:03one and three I'm like 90% sure. I'm kind of in the same spot.
- 1:09:07Brad's smiling, and usually when Brad's smiling, it means that
- 1:09:09he's gotten us somewhere. Now there have been a few.
- 1:09:12I was just thinking about Zach last.
- 1:09:15Week you shut your mouth, Sir. Now.
- 1:09:19There have been a few instances where Brad has snuck in like a
- 1:09:22clause into a sentence that was incorrect, and I'm wondering if
- 1:09:27it was true. If if if she's only like 2
- 1:09:30inches taller than him, or if it's actually if the exact
- 1:09:33amount is actually like more or less.
- 1:09:34I will defend my honor here. I'm usually not that petty.
- 1:09:39Usually, usually every now and then, the pettiness creeps
- 1:09:43through. Brad, I, I just my gut reaction
- 1:09:46said 2 was the falsehood. I'll go ahead and lock into as
- 1:09:49the falsehood here and just hope and pray that I claw back one
- 1:09:52victory. Bob, you are 100% correct.
- 1:09:56So I've I made-up the piano fact and then I looked up to thank
- 1:10:02you. I appreciate that.
- 1:10:04I looked up to see if it actually had been sold.
- 1:10:09The Flashback piano was sold for $602,000 in 2012.
- 1:10:16The actual Rick's Cafe piano was sold in 2014 for $3.413 million.
- 1:10:25That's insane, man, that's insane. 3.4 mil all.
- 1:10:32Right. Well, Zach, I'm not paying.
- 1:10:34For a piano, but that's just sweet.
- 1:10:37Zach Johnson, if you're listening, we are doing the work
- 1:10:39here to dig out of the hole that you clawed for us.
- 1:10:43So Vince, thank you so much for that guys.
- 1:10:46I think that we should talk a little bit about Claude Rains,
- 1:10:50the only person really in in the top tier of this cast that we
- 1:10:53haven't talked about yet. I just rewatched the end of Mr.
- 1:10:57Smith Goes to Washington on TCMA few weeks ago.
- 1:11:00My kids were in the room and they wanted to see it cause
- 1:11:02like, I think they're at the age where they're starting to know
- 1:11:04what government is. And so they're like still very
- 1:11:06idealistic and they're like, wow, this is how it works.
- 1:11:09And, and watching Claude Raines in that movie, I'm just like, Oh
- 1:11:13my gosh. Like I know that he's regarded
- 1:11:16as one of the all time best character actors and supporting
- 1:11:19actors, but damn it if he's just not an S tier Hollywood actor
- 1:11:26that doesn't get the credit. I was trying to figure, yeah,
- 1:11:30one of my main questions, you asked the question of like, who
- 1:11:32would you recast Bogart with? And Claude Raines was like the
- 1:11:36first guy that came to mind of like, who was, who would I
- 1:11:39recast as Claude Raines, by the way, if I was going to recast
- 1:11:43Rick? I feel like if you just like,
- 1:11:46levelled up his acting a little bit, I feel like Gerard Butler
- 1:11:49could, could, could do, could do Rick Boy.
- 1:11:51I kind of want to see Gerard Butler play that role for
- 1:11:55whatever reason 'cause he's a guy that always looks on.
- 1:11:57Levelling up his acting? Yeah, give, give, give me Gerard
- 1:12:00Butler at current acting levels. Let's see 'cause.
- 1:12:03It's like he's not a good actor. Like he's not a great actor.
- 1:12:06I would say he's a he's a OK actor, but he always looks
- 1:12:09hungover and I kind of love that about him.
- 1:12:12Yep. But Claude Rains, like there's
- 1:12:14there's got to be like a lot of people that could play that like
- 1:12:18obsequious weasel character. And, and The thing is like, he's
- 1:12:24just enough of like a dandy and and brings like just a slight
- 1:12:27effeminate thing to everything he does.
- 1:12:30Where like, and Mr. Smith goes to Washington, he is like the
- 1:12:33entrenched Eastern Seaboard senator that has the
- 1:12:37transatlantic accent and it makes perfect sense there.
- 1:12:40And here he's playing like the French philanderer.
- 1:12:43And you're like, yeah, like I I totally buy it here as well
- 1:12:46because he has this mannered thing about him.
- 1:12:49I just, I don't know who it would be in today's Hollywood,
- 1:12:52Brad. I know who it is.
- 1:12:53Who? Stanley Tucci.
- 1:12:57I could. I think Stanley could nail that.
- 1:13:01I could see that. It's like, but Stanley Tucci is
- 1:13:08he's an ethnic white, you know, like he's like, like he and I
- 1:13:12can say that as an Italian and Armenian person, like, you know,
- 1:13:16like we don't object when when ethnic whites get cast as other
- 1:13:22ethnic whites. Like sure.
- 1:13:24Like no one, no one objects to no one objects to what's his
- 1:13:29name? Adam Driver playing Italian for
- 1:13:31the 50th because why not? Like he reads ethnic white even
- 1:13:36even though he's not like I, I don't know.
- 1:13:39I, I don't, Yeah. Claude Raines doesn't read
- 1:13:42ethnic white to me in that way that like some of our cherished
- 1:13:46ethnic whites do like. And Stanley Tucci is definitely
- 1:13:48on like the list of cherished ethnic whites.
- 1:13:51I think that's that we need to just leave the conversation
- 1:13:53right there. That needs to be the last word.
- 1:13:58Sorry, I'm going to retitle this episode, this episode, Vince
- 1:14:02Mancini on ethnic whiteness and just see.
- 1:14:05We change this here. We can already podcast.
- 1:14:10Oh, man. All right.
- 1:14:10When we were on break, I asked the guys, what do we still need
- 1:14:13to talk about? And Vince said, you know,
- 1:14:15phrenology. And then he also said, let's
- 1:14:17talk about the ending of the movie, because he has.
- 1:14:20Some stuff categorizing everyone racially.
- 1:14:23Sure. I was like, what about the
- 1:14:24ending? I want to turn the floor over to
- 1:14:27you because it sounds like this may be hot take #2 from you
- 1:14:31today. What did you want to get across
- 1:14:33about the ending of the film, Vince?
- 1:14:34So no, it wasn't. It's not a hot take so much as I
- 1:14:39didn't realize that because of the the codes that were in place
- 1:14:45for films at the time, like there was no situation in which
- 1:14:51Ilsa could have left her husband and gone off with Rick.
- 1:14:54Like that was like that. Like at the time, that was not a
- 1:14:57possibility for the ending 'cause they couldn't show that
- 1:15:00on film. So like to me when I watch this
- 1:15:03at a modern remove, like it maybe there is a lot more
- 1:15:08ambiguity or like, I don't know, I, I didn't know what was going
- 1:15:12to happen at the end. So to me, like the ending sort
- 1:15:15of comes as a twist that, you know, Rick says, you know, you
- 1:15:21got to go off with Laszlo. Like, like, like it makes it a
- 1:15:24great ending to me. So I didn't realize that that
- 1:15:27would have been expected or predictable at the time.
- 1:15:31Yeah, no, it's funny because I, I was trying to watch this movie
- 1:15:35this time just through Rick's character arc perspective,
- 1:15:40because it, it really isn't much like he goes from being a
- 1:15:43wounded person to doing the right thing.
- 1:15:45But when does the switch get flipped?
- 1:15:48I think is what I was looking for in the movie.
- 1:15:50And when you've seen it 50 times, right?
- 1:15:52Like, it's, it's a lot easier to to know where he's going with
- 1:15:55that plan and who he's tricking into going along with the plan
- 1:15:58at the end of the movie. So initially he tells Captain
- 1:16:01Renault, Claude Raines, I'll deliver Laszlo to you.
- 1:16:06You can put him in a concentration camp.
- 1:16:07Let me run off with his wife, by the way, Don't bring any other
- 1:16:12Nazis around, like, just us, OK? And he's like, all right, sure.
- 1:16:15So then he tricks everybody in the bar into thinking that he's
- 1:16:19handing them over. But then, surprise, surprise, he
- 1:16:22pulls a gun on Claude Rains. He's like, take us to the
- 1:16:25airport. And then they get to the
- 1:16:27airport, and he surprises Ingrid Bergman again by sending the two
- 1:16:31of them off together. And it's like, oh man, You hear
- 1:16:33all these stories about how we had both endings written and
- 1:16:38even the people on set didn't know which one we were going to
- 1:16:40go with. And, and the more I watched the
- 1:16:42movie, a few things have been made apparent that that is
- 1:16:46complete BS. One of them Vince being, yes,
- 1:16:48the Hayes code just would not have allowed that other ending
- 1:16:51to ever happen. But if you're paying attention
- 1:16:54to Bogart's character arc, that other ending couldn't have
- 1:16:58happened anyway because like. Yeah.
- 1:17:00He's such a Dick through the whole movie.
- 1:17:02And you know, Brad said many times, like, he's practically
- 1:17:05called Ilsa a hooker many times. He's just abused everybody
- 1:17:10around him. He sticks his neck out for
- 1:17:12nobody. And then what?
- 1:17:14He's going to give up this paragon of goodness to go to the
- 1:17:17concentration camp and then run off with his wife at the end of
- 1:17:20the movie? That would never happen.
- 1:17:22Like, there's just no way this movie can end any other way than
- 1:17:26it does. Well, I honestly go ahead, Rick,
- 1:17:30are both like trying to be the better man in this situation.
- 1:17:33They're almost like competing for who's going to be the better
- 1:17:35man. Like I, I feel like I, I could
- 1:17:37see a world where Lazlo's like, hey, you know, you guys clearly
- 1:17:43had a thing like she, she clearly like prefers you.
- 1:17:46I don't want to lock her down. I don't want to lock her down in
- 1:17:50a forever relationship where she's not 100% into it.
- 1:17:53Like, I guess I could, I feel like they could have sold that.
- 1:17:56But yeah, I, I which. Is the the American in Paris
- 1:17:59ending Brad right like a. 100. Percent.
- 1:18:02He's just like, yeah, I can see that You love Gene Kelly.
- 1:18:04And then that's how the movie ends.
- 1:18:06I like, I like the idea of the two of them, Bogart and Paul,
- 1:18:11Hon Reed just arguing back and forth like, no, you go, no, you
- 1:18:14go. And then she just sneaks off and
- 1:18:16goes by herself. And then that's how the movie
- 1:18:18ends. That, I think that's the that's
- 1:18:20the plausible third ending that we didn't get.
- 1:18:22With with Claude Rains, the two of them.
- 1:18:25Yeah, but I feel like the, the, the fact that I mean, you
- 1:18:29usually see like these movies that are regarded as these, you
- 1:18:32know, pillars of the romantic movie.
- 1:18:36Usually the theme of all romantic movies and ROM coms
- 1:18:40and, and great love stories is that love conquers all.
- 1:18:44And like the, the entire sort of point of Casablanca is like, no,
- 1:18:48love doesn't conquer all. There's there's some things that
- 1:18:51are more important than that. And that still feels novel even.
- 1:18:57What did you say? 8083 years removed from when it
- 1:19:01came out. It's crazy that that still comes
- 1:19:04off as novel, but it really does, at least for me.
- 1:19:07When I watch it, it's still there's still it feels like a
- 1:19:09surprise or A twist. I mean, it makes me think about
- 1:19:13Saint Augustine a little bit and like properly ordered loves
- 1:19:17that. Like it's not that love doesn't
- 1:19:18win out, it's love for something greater than a relational love.
- 1:19:25And I, I think that's what makes the movie have eternal enduring
- 1:19:31qualities is because as humans, we kind of recognize that like,
- 1:19:35yes, relational love is one of the highest things we ought to
- 1:19:41aspire towards, but there's times in our life where duty and
- 1:19:45responsibility calls us even higher than that relational
- 1:19:49love. Right.
- 1:19:51And it's and I feel like movies that have staying power that
- 1:19:54sort of stick with you have that sort of note of ambiguity.
- 1:19:58So like I go back and forth between what you just said, you
- 1:20:02know, about the different kinds of love and the romance of a
- 1:20:10romance of a relationship that has a natural endpoint.
- 1:20:13Like they're like, they have this romance and it means a lot
- 1:20:17to them because it is. It's it has an end point, like
- 1:20:22they're always going to remember this period, but it's also this
- 1:20:26thing that they can't recapture. And like that is part of romance
- 1:20:31in some ways, that it's this thing that like just can't last
- 1:20:35for forever. And again, I feel like, I feel
- 1:20:39like that's another point that still feels fresh even watching
- 1:20:44it like 83 years later. Well, and the the thing for me
- 1:20:47that sticks out about, you know, Rick's character arc is that he
- 1:20:52sells the cafe and kills Strasser and, and does all this
- 1:20:58knowing that he's going to send Laszlo and and Ingrid Bergman
- 1:21:04off, that he's going to be stuck there, Which shows that in his
- 1:21:07mind, that conversation he has with with Cloud Raines at the
- 1:21:10end of like, hey, I think I'm going to go back into gun
- 1:21:13running or fighting for Free France or, you know, whatever
- 1:21:17they insinuate he's going to go do has been in his mind.
- 1:21:20Like now that I've received consolation and closure around
- 1:21:28this relationship with Ingrid Bergman, I'm going to go back to
- 1:21:31fighting for the things I believe in because this wound
- 1:21:34has been closed up. And I, I think like that's the
- 1:21:37thing that for me this time around, I caught that I didn't
- 1:21:40necessarily before was those last few lines where he's like,
- 1:21:44yeah, I'm going to head down and get into a few scraps and, you
- 1:21:48know, start start doing what I used to do.
- 1:21:50And that's like, that's the power of the final line of the
- 1:21:53movie. I think this is going to be a
- 1:21:54long and fruitful relationship because they both are fighting
- 1:21:57for something bigger than their vices that have been displayed
- 1:22:01throughout the movie. Yeah, I mean, you know, it's
- 1:22:04your point about ordered loves too, right?
- 1:22:06Like, this got him back in the game and he could have gone off
- 1:22:09with Ingrid Bergman and kind of gotten back in the game that
- 1:22:11way, gone back to the person that he gone back to the person
- 1:22:15he thought he was in Paris, right?
- 1:22:17But he recognized like a it's the right thing to do.
- 1:22:20And, and he even says at one point, like when he saw her
- 1:22:24willing to do whatever it took to get those letters of transit
- 1:22:28back like that unlocked for him, like she really loves this guy.
- 1:22:31And, and he deserves her way more than I do.
- 1:22:34And the thing that I'm made to do that I should be doing is
- 1:22:38what I was doing before, which is helping the.
- 1:22:39Being a gun runner. I do love, there's a couple
- 1:22:43things about the ending that I love to your point, Brad, that
- 1:22:46like they're just having this casual like, yeah.
- 1:22:48So what are you going to do now after he he shot a man in the
- 1:22:52heart 36 seconds earlier, and he's just laying there bleeding.
- 1:22:56And they're like, yeah, so what's what's next for old
- 1:22:59Humphrey Bogart? Super casual conversation.
- 1:23:02And then there's also this great moment where he sends them off
- 1:23:07on the plane. Victor Laszlo shakes his hand
- 1:23:10and says, like, welcome back to the fight.
- 1:23:12And he's like, yeah, yeah. One more thing, I just need you
- 1:23:16to know I banged your wife last night, and I really need you to
- 1:23:20understand. And Victor Laszlo's like, OK, I
- 1:23:23understand this is how things work in war.
- 1:23:24And he's like, no, no, no, listen, she really wanted to
- 1:23:28pretend she was. She was in love and super hard
- 1:23:31like she was. Her leg was quivering that
- 1:23:34entire time like it was it was crazy, but I know it didn't mean
- 1:23:37anything. It was just listen.
- 1:23:39I need you to understand. It's just this animal sexual
- 1:23:41thing that we have between us. Like we just cannot keep our
- 1:23:45paws off each other. We're like practically connected
- 1:23:48at the crotch. And I just, I know, you know,
- 1:23:51aside from just like the wetness and the fluids that we shared,
- 1:23:54like that is not the mature kind of love that I know you guys
- 1:23:57share. So like you guys, you you
- 1:23:59should, you should go off together.
- 1:24:02I know that I'm never going to see you again.
- 1:24:04This is not really necessary. I just need you to know for my
- 1:24:07own sake of just cleansing it, getting it off my chest.
- 1:24:11Best sex I've ever had. Have a good.
- 1:24:13Trip What? What a Lay, What a?
- 1:24:16Lay it. Is, I mean, I like that it's
- 1:24:18sort of this ode to personal growth.
- 1:24:22You know, like, like most movies like this or most movies in
- 1:24:26general, they sort of like the, there's an idea of like
- 1:24:30redemption and getting back to the person that you always were
- 1:24:33or that you that you're individuality is like a
- 1:24:38constant. And this is kind of like cutting
- 1:24:41against that in a little way where he's like, he's he's
- 1:24:44leaving this chapter of himself behind in a way and he's OK with
- 1:24:48that. And it's like it's a kind of a
- 1:24:50thing that you don't see in a lot of movies, I would say.
- 1:24:53Yeah, yeah. And it's for me, it's not just
- 1:24:56that, it's that he's also recognizing like the the
- 1:24:59chapters closed, but there's actually somebody better for her
- 1:25:03than me. And I have to be mature enough
- 1:25:05to recognize that specific thing despite how badly I want that.
- 1:25:10And that's that's a really natural segue for me to get into
- 1:25:13our last segment of the day, which we call let's make it a
- 1:25:16double. We're near the end of the
- 1:25:18episode, so thanks listening to the film and Whiskey show.
- 1:25:21Let's pair another film with this one, even if it's
- 1:25:24struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 1:25:25day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:25:27Let's Make It a Double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 1:25:29movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 1:25:33feature. Vince totally forgot to mention
- 1:25:35this to you, so we'll let. You go last.
- 1:25:36Year totally forgot to come up with an answer for this.
- 1:25:40There's been some really good ones thrown out here today.
- 1:25:42Vince, you mentioned The Great Gatsby earlier, and I think that
- 1:25:45would be like a fantastic pairing, kind of going the
- 1:25:48opposite direction from this one, though.
- 1:25:51I think based on the theme that we've hit on here of being a
- 1:25:54grown up about love and recognizing when closure needs
- 1:25:58to happen and how you can't recapture a moment in the past,
- 1:26:02I started thinking, Brad, about past lives, one of my favorite
- 1:26:04movies, but to keep it more chronologically close to this
- 1:26:08one, I'm going to pair it up with the other movie that we've
- 1:26:11talked about on that subject, and that is Brief Encounter, one
- 1:26:15of our very favorite movies from the World War 2 era.
- 1:26:18Just a great romance movie in which people have to be
- 1:26:22grown-ups and recognize when a relationship is over.
- 1:26:25And I think it kind of hits those same notes as Casablanca,
- 1:26:27Brad. Dude, I, I, I need to come back
- 1:26:31to brief encounter that the, the line where I think it's a
- 1:26:36narration line where she says like, it's so easy to lie when
- 1:26:41you're so deeply trusted, so easy and so very degrading.
- 1:26:47Just that one has stuck with you man.
- 1:26:49Oh, what a great. I think it's one of my favorite
- 1:26:52lines of any film. It's so freaking good.
- 1:26:56Brief Encounter, good movie. I am going to go in the
- 1:27:01direction of prescient films that were like really bold in
- 1:27:08calling out the Nazis for what they were.
- 1:27:11I'm going to go with 1939's The Great Dictator.
- 1:27:16A movie that you didn't love, by the way.
- 1:27:18Not my favorite but still one of my absolute favorite like gags
- 1:27:23of all time. With the the typewriter and he
- 1:27:28says one word and she types for like 2 minutes straight and then
- 1:27:32he talks for like a minute straight and she types 3 words.
- 1:27:38Absolutely the greatest gags of all time.
- 1:27:41All right, Vince, you're up, man.
- 1:27:42Did you? Think of something I can't.
- 1:27:44I was about to say the great Dictator and now I'm like lost
- 1:27:48trying to think of like another just like stridently anti
- 1:27:53fascist film that's also great. Like, there's not that many of
- 1:27:59them, are there? That's kind of sad, I.
- 1:28:02Mean. I'm sure there are.
- 1:28:03I'm just not thinking of them off the top of my head, man.
- 1:28:08It's also, yeah, like the things that stick out in my mind is,
- 1:28:12you know, like that it was such like a an anti fascist movie
- 1:28:19that is also prescient like that.
- 1:28:22It came out at a time when that was still like, an open
- 1:28:26question. Oh man.
- 1:28:29Team America. World Police.
- 1:28:31Yeah. There it is.
- 1:28:33That's the one I don't know, Vince, like I hey, I think
- 1:28:36you're you're allowed to share yours with Brad.
- 1:28:38We've had the same one many times.
- 1:28:39But I do think that Gatsby would be a fantastic pairing with
- 1:28:43this. Like just thematically.
- 1:28:46Like when I think, yeah, like the book for sure.
- 1:28:48But like, does the movie hold up to to to this one?
- 1:28:51Probably for something like Doctor Strangelove, yeah, you
- 1:28:55know, a different war, but. Vince, this is an audio based
- 1:28:58format, man, you got to. Pick.
- 1:28:59I know I'm trying. I'm trying to.
- 1:29:00Well, like I had the, I had the Great Dictator in mind, and now
- 1:29:03I'm trying to think of another one.
- 1:29:06Yeah, I got nothing. All right, so I'm, I'm going
- 1:29:09with Brief Encounter. Brad and Vince are both going
- 1:29:11with The Great Dictator, which would make just a really, really
- 1:29:15good triple feature of movies from that 1940 to 1942 range.
- 1:29:20Guys, it's time for us to get into final scores on Casablanca,
- 1:29:23the kind of movie that it doesn't seem necessary to talk
- 1:29:26about final scores with. But shockingly, back in season
- 1:29:301, Brad gave this movie a 9.5 out of 10, the lowest score
- 1:29:35Casablanca has ever received from anyone.
- 1:29:38So I guess the real question here, I'm giving it a 10.
- 1:29:41Brad, have you come up to A10 or are you still sitting at a sub
- 1:29:4510 score here? I have been thinking about it
- 1:29:49all day. I, I got up at 5:15 this
- 1:29:53morning, starting it off with a bang.
- 1:29:57Yeah, I watched Casablanca and I, I was thinking throughout
- 1:30:03because, Bob, you and I would both agree.
- 1:30:05Like, for a movie to be 10 out of 10, it doesn't have to be a
- 1:30:09perfect movie because, like, there is no such thing as a
- 1:30:12perfect movie. And so it really took me down
- 1:30:15this rabbit hole throughout the day, just percolating in my
- 1:30:18brain of like, what makes a movie a perfect movie for me, I
- 1:30:25would say that Casablanca has a few stumbles.
- 1:30:29It has the flashback scene that I don't love.
- 1:30:34It has a few lines from Claude Raines, especially early in the
- 1:30:37film that feel very stilted and like he he just kind of rushes
- 1:30:43through his lines that I'm like, you could have just had one more
- 1:30:45take and he he probably would have gotten it.
- 1:30:48But aside from those things and and Vince, like you said, a lot
- 1:30:52of the setup at the start of the film is kind of wooden and it's
- 1:30:56the corn that you kind of want to like spit out until you get
- 1:30:59to the corn that you really enjoy.
- 1:31:02I think that the the eternal enduring themes of what
- 1:31:08heartbreak can do to a man, of what closure can do to for
- 1:31:13anyone, of fighting for something larger than your own
- 1:31:17personal desires. I think this is a 10 out of 10,
- 1:31:21Bob. We did it.
- 1:31:23Yeah. Can I go back to make it a
- 1:31:27double? Sure.
- 1:31:29I have I have answers now. Speaking of not not knowing how
- 1:31:33to deal with closure, Vince Mancini, let's do it.
- 1:31:35Exactly. OK, so my choices on the subject
- 1:31:40of sort of like the temporariness of love and and
- 1:31:44the idea of like having a relationship that can only exist
- 1:31:48in this one certain circumstance.
- 1:31:50And that's part of the beauty of it.
- 1:31:52I'm gonna go with eternal sunshine and or call me by your
- 1:31:56name. I feel like they like those are
- 1:31:59sort of about like romances that can only exist in like a very
- 1:32:03specific time or place. And I feel like that is, you
- 1:32:07know, if not the main theme of Casablanca, like one of them.
- 1:32:13And yes, this is easily a 10 out of 10 for me. 10s across the
- 1:32:18board from us here on film and whiskey, but we like to know
- 1:32:22what you guys think. Is Casablanca an all time 10 out
- 1:32:25of 10 for you? How many times have you seen it?
- 1:32:27That's what I'd like to know because I feel like once people
- 1:32:29see Casablanca, they become repeat watchers of Casablanca.
- 1:32:34You can let us know on any of our social medias, Facebook X
- 1:32:38Twitter, Instagram, TikTok at Film Whiskey.
- 1:32:43Or you can join the conversation on our Discord.
- 1:32:45We are on there every single day talking to you guys, fans of the
- 1:32:48Film Whiskey podcast. If you want to join the
- 1:32:50conversation, you can find a link to our Discord at the end
- 1:32:52of every single one of our show notes.
- 1:32:56We want to say thanks again to Vince Mancini for joining us
- 1:32:58today. Vince, where can we find you?
- 1:33:00What have you been working on lately?
- 1:33:03I will have by the time this goes live.
- 1:33:06I have a big piece in GQ about the Smashing Machine
- 1:33:10documentary, not the Dwayne Johnson version.
- 1:33:14Check that out and you can find me at vincemancini.substack.com.
- 1:33:19All of my movie reviews and writings are there and my
- 1:33:23podcasts are at patreon.com/fraud Cast.
- 1:33:27We do a prestige TV rewatch podcast.
- 1:33:31It started as Pod Yourself a Gun, which was a Sopranos
- 1:33:34rewatch, and we have since rewatched The Wire and we are
- 1:33:38currently on to Mad Men. We're calling that season Mad
- 1:33:42Yourself a Man, but that is at patreon.com slash.
- 1:33:45Oh man, I love it. I'm looking forward to that GQ
- 1:33:47article for sure next week, Brad, we are getting into some
- 1:33:51weird, dicey, controversial territory as we look at the 1999
- 1:33:56Best Picture winner American Beauty.
- 1:33:59So join us for that one. But until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:34:03I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.
- 1:34:30Music.