Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / The Rise of Quiet Quitting in Schools- Why Passionate Teachers Stop Caring
Transcript
- Ilana: You can feel it in schools right now. who used to lead everything are pulling back. Staff ⁓ used stay late are leaving contract time. People are calling quiet quitting. I think teachers are are ⁓ exhausted. What are your Let me know in the comments. quiet quitting actually Is doing only your description ⁓ unhealthy ⁓ healthy? why are so teachers emotionally Welcome back to Pedagogically Speaking. My name is Alana Hoffer and I started this podcast so you would have a place to go to talk about the realities of teaching these days. know, so many of us got into it because ⁓ loved our teachers ⁓ we had such a time in school ⁓ that we wanted to give other ⁓ children the same ⁓ That wasn't so much for I actually really had a hard time in school. And I got into teaching give students that were like me ⁓ an opportunity to have access points to learning. created this podcast so we have a community because it feels like teaching communities are being driven out of ⁓ with our collaboration time being completely reduced non existent. ⁓ Also, so that we could talk about the kind of teaching that you do not learn about in those textbooks. so ⁓ episode is one that I think a lot of teachers are feeling, even we're not always saying it out loud. Because there this phrase that's been, ⁓ you know, for a little bit lately: ⁓ quiet quitting. in education, are using it to describe teachers who stop volunteering, you know. It's track season. They can't get enough teachers out there to their lunch breaks or their time after school for that. Quiet is about teachers who all of a sudden stop staying late. ⁓ Stop emails late into the evening. Stop sacrificing every ounce themselves for this job. And honestly, I think we really need to talk about what's here. Because from outside, sure, quiet quitting can look like laziness ⁓ like teacher just doesn't care about their students. ⁓ It can also look like disengagement. I don't ⁓ think most teachers stopped caring. I ⁓ many became emotionally ⁓ exhausted. think are ⁓ overwhelmed and think realize that the pace and the expectations put them ⁓ were unsustainable. And so teachers Aren't willing to destroy themselves anymore just to prove that they're committed teachers. that's ⁓ very different conversation. So I really want to unpack what quiet quitting is and looks like in teaching and why happening. And also I want to touch on the the difference between burnout ⁓ and boundaries. we also really need to unpack why often reward ⁓ over functioning teachers and what it would take to re-engage in meaningful ⁓ and sustainable ways. Because genuinely this conversation not for teacher retention burnout. But for the future of education itself, ⁓ lot of us were inspired to become teachers because of the teachers we had in our lives, because of how were able to ⁓ inspire or build community, what is going to be like for the students who are witnessing teachers having to too much, too much of education actually being not in front of the students at all? Teachers who are undermined every day. how we going to have more teachers? ⁓ How we going to inspire those students ⁓ when see that Teaching is an unsustainable profession. Let's dive into this. it's really because quitting like like we talked about before, it's just this idea that you only do exactly what your contract says. And, know, I think ⁓ really hard for teachers to do that. ⁓ So it's interesting now that more and more teachers quiet quitting. So, you know, it's not actually quitting, we understand that. It's doing what role requires and nothing beyond. And for teachers in the school system in their classrooms That is leaving at contract time. It's not staying late. You're not volunteering for extra committees, ⁓ You're running those clubs. You're not answering emails all evening and into the into the night. ⁓ You're taking work home every night. And you're not ⁓ constantly yes to extra ⁓ responsibilities. ⁓ think is really hard for who have ⁓ always done that. The teachers who always ⁓ run clubs before at lunch and after school for teachers who have always made sh knew that if they didn't do it no one else would and the students know wouldn't get those opportunities. ⁓ for those teachers to not do it anymore, obviously quite a big ⁓ rift they're getting a lot of shame towards them. Well you used to always do this. If you don't do this, no one else will do this. And that's unfair ⁓ because essentially everyone is recognizing and verbally saying this institution of education relies heavily on free work and if you can't do this free work then this part of the education will crumble. ⁓ well, ⁓ know, maybe we need to start paying people for this if it's so integral, which it is. And think it's also really hard for new teachers ⁓ who just making not enough money to pay their bills pay off their ⁓ debt. then want come across they care. They want to make sure everybody knows who they are. They want, to fit into the community, but it's absolutely unsustainable. ⁓ Whether that teacher is or is not working ⁓ extra job or two to pay the bills, whether that teacher does or does not have family obligations, it is still really hard to want to belong in a community, but the way of belonging is work and you can't do that. You know, new teachers are exhausted. And quite frankly, ⁓ when was a brand new teacher, I got sick all the time. I used more sick days than I was allotted. So I was not getting paid for the days that ⁓ I wasn't because I was sick. And I had no time to do anything because I was just like you just get especially maybe it's different for high school teachers, but when you start off in like kindergarten or or in in an elementary school, you know, you're exposed. There's so many kids just sneezing in your face and I am very short. So they are sneezing in my mouth, unfortunately. and so there's just so much going on. Back to quiet quitting. So what's interesting is that in almost any other profession, quitting would really just be called ⁓ your job. ⁓ you know what I mean? Like, ⁓ if are like ⁓ people an expense account. ⁓ So if buying things for or client meetings, if you're buying, you know, ⁓ food or different like that, that would all be compensated. ⁓ But teachers don't get compensated for that. So in teaching, the behavior often gets interpreted as disengagement as soon as you stop doing that extra thing. yeah, that really does say a lot about the culture of education right now because teaching normal ⁓ normalized overextension. ⁓ idea if you're a teacher, you have to go above and beyond and do all of this free work. It is completely normalized and has been For so long that healthy boundaries now feel abnormal. feels wrong teachers to have ⁓ healthy and be able to say ⁓ goodbye work and hello ⁓ to life outside of work. And ⁓ know, has really this profession has been built on martyrdom ⁓ because it praised. Exhaustion gets rewarded. And self sacrifice gets framed as passion. I really want that to sink in, Because so many teachers are like, I'm passionate about my students, I'm passionate about teaching, I'm passionate about this. But lot of that is the sacrifice that's getting put in ⁓ in those teachers' personal lives. And we really need to think about the language that we use in education that we use as teachers and for teaching, right? phrases, we do it for the kids. Teaching a calling. You have be passionate. Good teachers go above and beyond. listen, ⁓ deeply about students is beautiful. I care deeply about all of the students that teach. I actually ⁓ genuinely like kids and so I care a lot about all the s the kids You know, my my daughters in dance. ⁓ I cried ⁓ I'm ⁓ I cried and clapped so hard ⁓ her recital all the students. And for her piano recital, because the the students that were doing the piano and the flute were just amazing. deeply Passion matters. somewhere the way, ⁓ it ⁓ it all twisted. passion became tied to ⁓ self-abandonment. And I think that's where things really started to become dangerous for teachers. Because when a system depends on people consistently over functioning to survive, will burn out. And also the system requires to use own money to decorate their classrooms, to use their own money ⁓ for actual to use to raise money for for field trips ⁓ ⁓ have students who get anywhere without ⁓ ordering bus. ⁓ When these things become contingent on what the teacher can do, then ⁓ Not only does the system fall apart, but then the system relies on that. how you then ⁓ I negotiate parts of to become covered by your school or your school district, or you know, ⁓ the governing body ⁓ of funding for wherever you're teaching, you know, because up until point it's all been coming from those ⁓ So quiet quitting also I think looks like a lot of teachers ⁓ taking down all of the things that they've paid for in the classrooms and people exactly ⁓ what funded system really looks like. And that can be both very, very powerful and v I think very depressing for people. teachers are the frontline workers. So hear about it very fast. If you're overextending it's just to survive, ⁓ you're gonna burn out. ⁓ When teachers start pulling back to survive emotionally, self All right, let's talk why teachers are pulling back. ⁓ I know we've been doing the whole time, but I think one of the biggest ⁓ is people assuming that teachers suddenly became less resilient. You know, like teachers are so resilient. look at what they can do with ⁓ But it's not nothing, right? It's it's us. We're burning out because this idea that teachers can survive on nothing. ⁓ No, we can't. We're surviving on ourselves and now we're burning out. So not that teachers have their resilience. That's not true at all. Teachers have been carrying impossible loads for years. ⁓ And eventually everyone's gonna hit their capacity. Because look what teaching has become. Okay? Teaching ⁓ is not anymore about solely about the curriculum, solely getting s making students go from ⁓ where they're reading at to grade level or beyond or math or you know, all of the learning. Teachers are now managing increasing behavioral complexity with no training in it. are now managing mental concerns, ⁓ once with ⁓ no Academic gaps are becoming larger and larger, ⁓ class sizes are ⁓ full or over full, administrative demands. documentation, constant curricular shifts, shifts in how we ⁓ to to parents. There's extracurricular expectations. ⁓ Even you're not running a club, are you expected to go to ⁓ the ⁓ There's concerts teachers are expected to go to. And then also the emotional labor that never ⁓ ends because we do care about our students that has never stopped. So it n it's not about it's not just about inspiring students' love of learning and teaching the curriculum. There's so much more to teaching right now and teachers are doing this while also trying to create engaging, ⁓ learning experiences every day. So enormous. And yet schools often continue adding without removing ⁓ just getting on. And I think people outside of education fully appreciate that, where very little gets taken off of teachers' plates and more and more is added on it. you know, there's new literacy initiatives, there's new literacy screening tools that gets changed every ⁓ every it seems. ⁓ There's assessment practices, new technology platforms, ⁓ new restrictions as well that we need to start implementing. there's new behavior systems, reporting expectations There's new ways that we need to track intervention. more meetings and teachers you expected to absorb all of it ⁓ while functioning at your maximum of emotional capacity. At some the human nervous system ⁓ it pushes And I think many of you, quiet quitting is actually nervous system protection. It's saying, I physically cannot keep operating at this pace. know, and there's another layer to this too: this like moral injury. You know, a lot of teachers they entered ⁓ they became a teacher ⁓ ⁓ know, you care deeply. You want to help, ⁓ want to support kids. But you repeatedly just feel unable to meet the students' needs ⁓ because underfunding or systemic limitations is just a lot of emotional distress, right? there are things that you cannot change. When you care deeply but you feel powerless over and over again every day, you know, that really does change us. I think eventually teachers emotionally detach because you have keep yourself safe. Caring at full intensity is ⁓ is painful. it's not you're a bad teacher and it's not because you stopped ⁓ loving the students. It's because ⁓ chronic emotional overload the way that we function. You We can't keep going home crying, what got into, wondering how you're to create relationships. I think been that's the biggest eye opener for me is that you know, I had a teacher this year say, I'm great at creating relationships. ⁓ That's one of my superpowers. I know what to do in case. And yeah, I agree. Like, also ⁓ ⁓ relationships, ⁓ usually find it it be easy, ⁓ but people tell you, ⁓ well, you just need a relationship with that person, and they are completely ignoring the fact that it took them over four to have a good relationship with someone ⁓ and they you to make it in two weeks, that's impossible. And I think that's that's a topic for another episode. Because while community is extremely important in teaching and creating a classroom community is really important where you have safety so students can take risks. you talk a lot about growth mindset and you talk a lot about having each other's backs and all of that thing, and that is important. ⁓ also does need to be a certain amount of of that goes into this, like not I you to respect me because ⁓ you admire me, but okay, I need you to respect that the teacher and we're working together towards a common goal, which is of, you know, your learning. So yeah, really can change ⁓ way you function ⁓ the way that you see yourself and the way that you are emotionally capable ⁓ of the classroom. And think a lot of schools are full of teachers surviving ⁓ not thriving. So talk burnout or boundaries. And this is the part of the conversation I think gets really but we love nuance on this podcast. You know, not all quiet quitting is burnout. I it's a lot of it it can be ⁓ can boundaries because I actually think ⁓ we to start separating burnout and boundaries, carefully. You know, ⁓ leaving work contract time is not inherently unhealthy. ⁓ answering emails late into night is not ⁓ laziness. ⁓ not volunteering for extra unpaid roles does not make someone less committed to their students or to teaching. doesn't mean you're not passionate. ⁓ It's that I think education has become accustomed to unpaid labor ⁓ that basic boundaries Now seem like a radical concept. And I think a lot of teachers are waking up to this idea. I cannot build a sustainable life my career ⁓ ⁓ of me. ⁓ know, ⁓ realization does not make you ⁓ from teaching, it makes you human. And I think younger ⁓ teachers, Are questioning these systems that older generations have normalized. And I understand that what if you were teaching in the eighties and the nineties, a lot of that work kind of was compensated in other ways. You did have collab time, you did have time to take from the day ⁓ order to run these things. When I was growing up, ⁓ the sports, you can tell how athletic I am. ⁓ you know sports games were actually during the day. It wasn't after school. so you're getting for and But now ⁓ Athletic games, basketball, you know, rugby, they're after school. Sometimes they're over an hour away where you have to travel then come back. And if the game doesn't even start until six o'clock seven, when are you home? And then you have to go to work the next day. it's just so much now. ⁓ I think young teachers are asking. Why is burnout considered dedication? Why is overwork celebrated? are you why are teachers expected to martyr yourselves? I think those are the questions that are really going to see change the education system. Because we can all get on board that actually unpaid labor should be seen as something extra and not seen as a pillar holding up the institution of I think we might actually get somewhere with ensuring that funding gets increased that these things can keep happening. ⁓ Because if a profession can only function people are consistently sacrificing their mental health and well being, that system's already unstable. Now do think there's a difference between healthy boundary setting and, ⁓ shutdown. are not the same Healthy sound like I care deeply students. ⁓ prioritize my rest. It's can be effective without overworking It's really understanding your worth is not tied to your productivity. Okay. Burnout, so those are boundaries. sounds is more like emotional numbness, ⁓ chronic exhaustion, being cynical about work. ⁓ this hopelessness, a of being detached from your students or your And I think ⁓ and ⁓ ⁓ ⁓ know, often the two because as teachers setting boundaries, they want to be in game showing up feeling healthy and they want job as a teacher to be sustainable for long term. And think that's more important than the teacher who's staying ⁓ till PM every night or five PM and then getting there at seven A. But I unfortunately Education often reward ⁓ rewards over functioning, right? And that's the teacher who does answer the emails instantly because it comes up on their watches or their phones. It's you know, they they reward teachers who are constantly volunteering for everything, ⁓ the teacher never says no, ⁓ who sacrifices personal time ⁓ constantly, ⁓ in mornings and weekends. ⁓ You know, those teachers are praised if they're quietly drowning. And think meanwhile, ⁓ the who is protecting their mental health, you know, their mental health can viewed ⁓ as committed. that's a That's a culture in education and and it can be changed and ⁓ because that negative has consequences. Okay. And I think schools quiet quitting, you thing right now, schools are seeing shift. And ⁓ And it's not because students became apathetic. think schools are seeing a shift. And it's not because teachers are all of a sudden apathetic. People depleted. ⁓ Because teaching is a creative profession. creativity requires ⁓ know, collaboration requires Innovation ⁓ requires ⁓ safety. exhausted nervous they can only prioritize ⁓ And that's why burnout can r really these very transactional environments ⁓ teachers are thinking, Okay, what do I absolutely need to do to get through the day? You ⁓ Teachers are functioning in a conservation mode. another thing we don't talk about is this idea of ⁓ emotional masking. ⁓ know, there are teachers who appear ⁓ functional externally, but ⁓ are depleted. They're still ⁓ teaching very smiling, ⁓ showing ⁓ getting things done, ⁓ the ⁓ are fantastic. emotionally, you there's a disconnect. And I some teachers are grieving. I think teachers, not older, but teachers been doing this for a little while, ⁓ maybe ⁓ pre COVID, grieving education used be, used to like. ⁓ grieving and I think younger teachers are grieving teacher that they thought they would be ⁓ what they thought teaching would be. And think all teachers are grieving the joy that you once had. And I think that grief really matters. know, because it's teach it's telling us that have really shifted. And when people stop believing that their effort ⁓ changes everything, when you're passionate teacher and you no longer feel like you can inspire your students, yeah, disengagement can Okay, so like what can we do, right? What actually re engages teachers? are your thoughts? ⁓ know, ⁓ I think I ⁓ we need to turn it into ⁓ think that questions really continue to put the onus on teachers and teachers are already burnt out and teachers are already ⁓ wondering they've gotten themselves into, wondering if can if this is a sustainable career anymore, wondering what you could do with your teaching ⁓ So I think we need to start ⁓ putting the questions to ⁓ how do we support teachers? ⁓ How does the education system support teachers? How can admins start supporting teachers? know, and it's not motivational which is funny that because that's also something that's really hyping up right now. Like ⁓ so people are like, ⁓ like what do you put on your walls to motivate you? And ⁓ don't I just think you can't guilt ⁓ exhausted people into passion. Okay, because What happens? You look at those motivational slogans and you don't feel motivated and then you feel shame. You feel guilt, right? You cannot guilt exhausted people back into passion. You can't you can't put up so many wellness posters you feel like you've moved out of systemic burnout, right? Teachers, do not need more resilience training while you are working in unsustainable conditions. What do need? I think need a manageable workload. They ⁓ protected increased prep time. They need expectations, autonomy, psychological safety, meaningful ⁓ and that actually ⁓ We need less ⁓ leadership and more ⁓ ⁓ truly creates ⁓ where you what people doing on the time that they have. ⁓ Teachers, including myself, you absolutely need to feel trusted again burnout destroys professional agency. When teachers constantly are micromanaged, ⁓ criticized, or overloaded, your investment will naturally decrease. But we that when you feel respected, empowered. ⁓ When you have time to collaborate with people who you feel it a good match, and when are supported, engagement ⁓ all a returns. You know, if it happened tomorrow, might not return right away, but it would return gradually. And so I think schools need to normalize boundaries. Sustainable teaching careers shouldn't require you to self-destruct. It shouldn't require you to work yourself into the ground. should want teachers to have healthy outside of work, be able enjoy hobbies, their families, ⁓ be able enjoy ⁓ rest. ⁓ I think everybody should want teachers to have energy and joy. That shouldn't be controversial. of the best teachers I know are the ones who learn to sustain themselves, not ones running themselves into the ground. And I the biggest thing I want people to take away from this episode is, okay, maybe quiet isn't actually about teachers not caring. I think ⁓ it's ⁓ It's that we listen to. ⁓ Because happens when passionate people operate in systems that ask more than a human can sustainably give? ⁓ So maybe the solution isn't demanding more from teachers. finally building the systems ⁓ teachers don't to sacrifice themselves to survive. Okay? ⁓ Education not benefit when you emotionally numb. ⁓ And if want passionate, engaged teachers, then sustainability has become part of the conversation. ⁓ Thank you so much for listening to this episode of Pedagogically Speaking. If you're listening on Spotify or Apple, please give me five stars. If it's YouTube, please subscribe. If this conversation resonated with you, I'd love for you to share the episode, tag me on Instagram, or send it to another teacher who's been feeling this too. as always, ⁓ care of yourselves, ⁓ care of each other, and I'll see you next time.