Latest / True Nightmare Stories
She Came Home at 2 AM: The Mustache and the Magnum
She Came Home at 2 AM: The Mustache and the Magnum
A seventeen-year-old girl who survived unimaginable violence walked home at 2 AM and knocked on her own front door - alive and able to describe a small mustache and a red Dodge Magnum with "Magnum" stitched into the seat. Ten women were killed in eight months around Nebraska Avenue in 1984, and one survivor's details led investigators to a man no one had suspected. How did decades of crimes stay invisible until that night?
In this episode, we follow the timeline of disappearances on Nebraska Avenue and the surrounding Hillsborough County…
The skinny
The skinny isn't ready yet — notes appear once the transcript is processed.