Latest / The Vegan Report / Uh Oh Canada! Animals Need Your Vote. With Liz White | Ep. 72
Transcript
- 0:00Baby chicks mailed by the National Postal Service.
- 0:05Animal testing lab whistleblowers getting threatened
- 0:08by mysterious powers. Polar bears allowed to
- 0:13be hunted despite being in danger of extinction.
- 0:18This is Canada in 2025 as it faces what could
- 0:22be the most consequential election in its history,
- 0:27fighting an economic war with Trump's United
- 0:30States. In today's episode, I am joined by the
- 0:35inspiring Liz White, leader of the Animal Protection
- 0:39Party of Canada, for one of the few conversations
- 0:43exploring what is at stake for the billions of
- 0:47animals whose fate will soon be decided at the
- 0:52ballot box. You know, we live in unusual times
- 0:57and people are very afraid of what's going to
- 1:00happen. We have no idea what Mr. Trump south
- 1:03of the border is going to do at any given time.
- 1:06And so things are kind of in somewhat of a chaos.
- 1:11And so, you know, we're looking at unprecedented
- 1:15times in many ways. I don't think in all the
- 1:17years that I've been in politics since the 70s
- 1:20that I've seen anything like this, but I would
- 1:24say I think we have a very real opportunity here
- 1:28to separate ourselves out and to redefine ourselves
- 1:32in a way that makes us very, very different from
- 1:36the United States. I think we are very different,
- 1:38but I want to focus on the animal issue. In a
- 1:43way, we're different because, say, for animal
- 1:46agriculture, The size of the farms are much smaller
- 1:50than the United States. And we have, I think,
- 1:54probably stricter rules about how farmed animals
- 1:58are handled, but those aren't always followed
- 2:01or enforced. And so, you know, we have very difficult
- 2:07situations with farm animals in Canada, but to
- 2:10a much lesser extent than the United States.
- 2:12And then that gives us a very real opportunity
- 2:15to begin to pivot away from animal agriculture,
- 2:20particularly intensive animal agriculture to
- 2:22begin with, and then to pivot away from animal
- 2:25agriculture altogether as our commitment to impart
- 2:30reducing our contribution to global warming and
- 2:34our contribution to animal rights and animal
- 2:37welfare in Canada. And I think we have a very
- 2:40real opportunity to do that because many of our
- 2:44animals go to the United States. pigs, pork goes
- 2:50to the United States. All sorts of animals are
- 2:53transported to the United States. Sows that no
- 2:55longer give birth are transported to the United
- 2:57States for slaughter. I mean, all kinds of things
- 3:00are happening in this particular situation. And
- 3:04again, on the chicken side, all kinds of chickens
- 3:08that are from forced molting and egg laying farms,
- 3:17spent hands, are shipped up to Canada for slaughter
- 3:23and none of that really needs to happen. We can
- 3:26say with regard to the terrorists, no, we're
- 3:28not gonna do that anymore. And I think we begin
- 3:31to redefine how we do animal agriculture in Canada.
- 3:34So I think we have a very real opportunity. With
- 3:37regard to animals and research, I don't see anything
- 3:42really changing substantially in that regard
- 3:44under the current circumstances, but maybe with
- 3:48the turmoil that it has caused, with the inability
- 3:51for research to continue as it was in the United
- 3:56States, we may have an opportunity to change
- 3:59that as well. So I look on it with dread in some
- 4:03ways and with opportunity in other ways. And
- 4:08what about the activism scene? Do you feel or
- 4:13think that the animal rights activism scene in
- 4:18Canada is less developed than in the US or more
- 4:25so? Can you also differentiate those two worlds
- 4:30of activism? From my point of view, The work
- 4:37that people do covertly in labs makes it very
- 4:42much harder to get information out about what's
- 4:45happening. I've done multiple freedom of information
- 4:50at the federal level, the AATIP program, but
- 4:54predominantly in Ontario because they have an
- 4:57Animals for Research Act, and the Animals for
- 5:02Research Act is under the FOIP. freedom of information
- 5:06process, so I can do freedom of information for
- 5:10that. The standard line for denying me any information
- 5:15is the threat of violence against researchers,
- 5:19research laboratories, their homes, their families,
- 5:22and so most of the information that would be
- 5:26very helpful in fighting to get an end to this
- 5:29process is completely denied and it makes it
- 5:33very very difficult to actually get at the problem.
- 5:38The rest of Canada is a serious problem because
- 5:41they do not have any act that governs them. They're
- 5:44under the Canadian Council on Animal Care which
- 5:47is a voluntary body and frankly not much help
- 5:50when even we know that there's issues going on
- 5:54within a particular facility or within a particular
- 5:57government agency and we lay a complaint Those
- 6:01are, as far as I can tell, are never really dealt
- 6:04with. So we have a very difficult road to hoe.
- 6:09I think it would be difficult anyway, but the
- 6:12difference in the United States is that they
- 6:14have sunshine laws. And so they're able to get
- 6:17much more information about what goes on, for
- 6:21example, in research laboratories and then be
- 6:27able to expose them. to the public and there's
- 6:30an assumption that all of that information in
- 6:33the United States should be public really. I
- 6:36don't know whether that's the case right at the
- 6:38moment because they're in the process of dismantling
- 6:40some of the research facilities and their work
- 6:44but in the end there has been a long history
- 6:48in the United States of getting that information
- 6:51out where you know it's kind of opposite where
- 6:54in Canada it's almost impossible to get information
- 6:57out about what's going on in research laboratories.
- 7:01Now, when it comes to animal agriculture, which
- 7:03is another biggie, right? Those are two big,
- 7:06you know, confinement issues and end of life
- 7:10issues and so on. The the farms in the United
- 7:17States have or some of the states in the United
- 7:21States have, of course, passed ag -gag laws and
- 7:24some of those have been challenged and overturned.
- 7:26In Canada, of course, in Ontario, the provincial
- 7:31government here implemented an ag piece of legislation.
- 7:35It's currently going through the courts. We are
- 7:39there as interveners, animal justice leading
- 7:42it, but we're there as interveners. And so we'll
- 7:45see what happens with that particular situation.
- 7:48but I think part of the law has already been
- 7:51struck down and I suspect that other part of
- 7:54the law might in fact be struck down as well.
- 7:56I think we have a very strong argument. So slowly
- 7:59we're picking away at it but it's extremely difficult
- 8:03in Canada to get information about what is actually
- 8:06going on. Not in an overall general sense because
- 8:11the CCAC provides us with that but in a research
- 8:15facility by research facility. In the FOI material
- 8:20that I got from the Ontario Ministry of Agriculture,
- 8:24Food and Rural Affairs that governs the Animals
- 8:27for Research Act, I was able to get heavily redacted
- 8:32information from each research facility in Canada
- 8:36and the inspection reports that took place in
- 8:38those facilities. And the inspection reports
- 8:42showed that in many cases, the research facilities
- 8:46were in non -compliance with the regulations
- 8:48that were set out in the Animals Research Act
- 8:52and in fact some were in violation of those not
- 8:57just in non -compliance but in violation of those
- 9:00and so you wonder if that is what you're seeing
- 9:05out of a heavily redacted document what's actually
- 9:08going on in those facilities and so far we haven't
- 9:11been able to find out. Yeah, so one of the interesting
- 9:14examples of how hard it is to get information.
- 9:18We had a situation where a student or students
- 9:21entered our KEL research facilities, which is
- 9:25at the University of Guelph. And they do research
- 9:29on farmed animals, basically. And they found
- 9:33that the door was open and nobody was inside.
- 9:35except the animals, of course, who are somebody.
- 9:39And they went through and documented the condition
- 9:43of the animals, which were pretty grim, and I
- 9:46think pretty much unacceptable for a research
- 9:49facility in Ontario under the Animals Research
- 9:51Act. So they posted, they took pictures, they
- 9:54posted on Facebook, I reached out to them and
- 9:56asked if I could lay a complaint based on their
- 9:59photos and their information. They agreed. I
- 10:02laid complaints to the university, Omafra, and
- 10:07at the federal level, and was denied all information
- 10:12about what was going on there, even though, you
- 10:15know, the chickens were in really terrible condition
- 10:20and the pigs were. And why we were denied that
- 10:24information is beyond me, but it just goes to
- 10:27show you how difficult it is to get any information
- 10:29out about what's occurring to these animals.
- 10:32So You know, when we get good examples like that,
- 10:36we continue to build on the pressure to the research
- 10:39facilities, to the farm animals to get changes.
- 10:43You mentioned how researchers get threatened.
- 10:48Did I hear that correctly? And, you know, who
- 10:53is doing the threatening? Well, that's the interesting
- 10:57thing, Rayyan. I get denied information based
- 11:02on one -liner, you know, threats of violence
- 11:06and intimidation. So I've written to the IPC,
- 11:12to OMAFRA, to the CCAC to please tell me what
- 11:16are the incidents and who's doing it. And they
- 11:21won't tell me. So I know, but I know from doing
- 11:24a freedom of information request to St. Mike's
- 11:31Hospital, because they use animals there, that
- 11:36they challenged my request based on being persecuted,
- 11:45intimidated, and worried about violence. And
- 11:49so I dug around a little bit and actually in
- 11:54their report they said that outside of the facility,
- 12:00which they not list on list the address where
- 12:03the animals come in. They do all that's all that's
- 12:06public. And yet they're afraid because somebody
- 12:08wrote in chalk on the sidewalk. What was it?
- 12:15Something about animals dying on level eight
- 12:17of the facility and. that was what they used.
- 12:21And a reporter came to their door to ask for
- 12:23more information about what was going on to the
- 12:25animals. And that's what they used as intimidation.
- 12:29And so I have not been able to get an answer
- 12:32since then as to who's doing the intimidation
- 12:34and what's the level of the intimidation. So
- 12:38we don't really know. That's crazy. Crazy. Yep.
- 12:44Yep. You're not allowed to know what's going
- 12:46on in the research laboratory, who's doing it.
- 12:49where the animals are coming from, what they're
- 12:51subjected to, and if there is a threat, what
- 12:55kind of threat there is and who's doing it. You
- 12:57can't have any of that information. I guess in
- 13:01there, there's an implicit confession of, you
- 13:07know, there's an implicit understanding that
- 13:09if you had access to that information and you
- 13:13were able to expose it and present that to Canadians,
- 13:19then they would side with you and make those
- 13:24practices stop. Isn't there, you know, this implicit
- 13:30understanding? I think the interesting information
- 13:35about this particular issue, and maybe even farmed
- 13:38animals, those are the you know, really big,
- 13:40or the big numbers are that certainly with the
- 13:46research issue, Most people just don't believe
- 13:49it's happening. I mean, it is a huge barrier
- 13:52to get over. We went from a broader campaign
- 13:57to a much narrower campaign talking about pets
- 14:01going to research, animals that end up in ponds
- 14:04and shelters are requisitioned by research facilities
- 14:08and they get the animals and they do research
- 14:10on them. And people just cannot believe that
- 14:14that happens. And yet the statistics from the
- 14:18Canadian Council on Animal Care show large numbers
- 14:21of pet animals, companion animals are sent to
- 14:29research. And in fact, some of the most painful
- 14:32research is done on them. And yet, you know,
- 14:35trying to get people to understand that actually
- 14:38happens and how it happens because it's so secretive.
- 14:43is really impossible. And so it makes going after
- 14:48change in these situations a challenge. So years
- 14:55and years ago, I was an activist for an organization.
- 15:00I was volunteering for them on a campaign about
- 15:04tax heavens. I learned a lot about tax heavens
- 15:08and how different countries are different kinds
- 15:11of tax havens for different industries. And I
- 15:15guess my question is, is Canada like a special
- 15:20place for the ag or animal exploitation industry?
- 15:24Like, if you are in in, you know, big pharma,
- 15:28and you want to you know, experiment on on animals
- 15:34and do some of the worst experiments out there.
- 15:38Is Canada one of the best place to to do so because,
- 15:42you know, of that barrier to access of information
- 15:48and, and, you know, how they are allowed to be
- 15:53because I feel like they're really empowered
- 15:55here. I think partly that's the case and partly
- 16:01It's just how the research community worldwide
- 16:06works. As long as you can shut down any conversation
- 16:10about it, they are less exposed to what they're
- 16:14doing and less having to have a conversation
- 16:16that maybe they should change, that maybe they
- 16:20might want to look at NAMs, the non -animal alternatives,
- 16:24of which there are many in... in place now and
- 16:28many that are being developed by people who are
- 16:30doing alternative science in that regard. I think
- 16:34where Canada becomes a haven, and it's not really
- 16:37a haven, I think it's sloppy work on the part
- 16:40of our government and maybe that makes us a haven,
- 16:43but I think a good example of that is the trade
- 16:47-in long -tailed macaque monkeys from Cambodia.
- 16:55under the CITES, the Convention on the International
- 16:59Trade in Endangered Species, if you're going
- 17:01to use monkeys for research, you have to have
- 17:04them from a breeding facility, not from the wild.
- 17:10And of course, with things like COVID and other
- 17:14viruses floating around, and they're used for
- 17:16that kind of research, there is huge pressure.
- 17:22to get more and more macaque monkeys. And so
- 17:25Charles River, which is one of the largest facilities
- 17:27in the United States, and I think one of the
- 17:30only that imports macaque monkeys, was under
- 17:33investigation by the U .S. Fish and Wildlife
- 17:38Service, and in fact they found that they are
- 17:41alleged to have imported monkeys from the wild,
- 17:46and so they have been denied bringing any monkeys
- 17:48into the United States. So Charles River who
- 17:50has a company here, simply move their import
- 17:53into Canada. And Canada's become the largest
- 17:56importer of long -tailed macaque monkeys into
- 18:01Canada. And the more than a suspicion, I would
- 18:06say, exists that these animals came from the
- 18:09wild, not from a breeding facility, because If
- 18:13you look at the number of females in a breeding
- 18:14facility, the length of time it takes for them
- 18:17to have babies, the length of time it takes them
- 18:19to raise them so that they can be used for research,
- 18:22the numbers of monkeys that are coming through
- 18:24simply outpace what a breeding facility or breeding
- 18:29facilities can produce. So we know they're caught
- 18:32from the wild and that's the issue and CITES
- 18:35is taking a look at it, but it makes you feel
- 18:38like Canada has become a safe haven that in fact,
- 18:44our folks in the Ministry of the Environment
- 18:49are not really looking very hard at the documentation
- 18:53of these monkeys and where they came from. And
- 18:55then I guess, like you alluded to, is it, you
- 19:02know, wilfulness from them? Or is it just sloppiness?
- 19:07Is it just incompetence? Are they really understanding
- 19:11the issue and turning a blind eye on purpose
- 19:15because they have been captured by this industry?
- 19:19I think they're looking just looking at the paperwork.
- 19:21The paperwork says captivity. And we know, you
- 19:25know, I mean, the difficulty is this issue of
- 19:29reliability of information from Cambodia. And
- 19:33so, you know, what the U .S. Fish and Wildlife
- 19:37has alleged to have found is that those documents
- 19:41were not true. And when they asked Charles River
- 19:49to prove where these animals came from, Charles
- 19:54River stopped importing into the US and brought
- 19:56it into Canada. So, you know, you think down
- 20:01there, I think, interestingly, before Trump got
- 20:04him. The U .S. Fish and Wildlife Service did
- 20:08a good job at actually taking it on, investigating
- 20:11it, looking at it. I mean, PETA was actually
- 20:14involved in producing some of the information,
- 20:17but the U .S. Fish and Wildlife Service actually
- 20:21did a sting operation and all that sort of stuff.
- 20:25So I think they did their due diligence. I think
- 20:27Canada just looks at the paperwork and says,
- 20:30OK. To continue on this comparison, between the
- 20:34US and Canada. Something the US has that is an
- 20:41envy, I guess, for me, is freedom of speech.
- 20:48And, you know, it's a constitutional right. It's
- 20:53there, I think, First Amendment. But we don't
- 20:57really have something like that in Canada. And
- 21:03what is the impact of that for activism and for
- 21:08animal rights activists in Canada? Well, I think
- 21:11the ag -gag legislation that's being challenged
- 21:14in court in Ontario is a good example of, you
- 21:19know, it's going to probably have to go to the
- 21:21Supreme Court. You know, whether the Supreme
- 21:23Court actually agrees to look at it is a whole
- 21:25other thing. But if they do agree to look at
- 21:28it, then you know we may be able to lay a marker
- 21:32through the constitution about free speech and
- 21:36about the ability of people to actually document
- 21:40the condition of animals and how they're treated
- 21:46legally and and not be constantly harassed and
- 21:50thrown in jail. You know the the farmers argue
- 21:53that if people go into the barns it contaminates
- 21:56the animals But when you look at the actual facts
- 21:59of the case, none of those animals are discarded.
- 22:03They go to slaughter and they're eaten. So there's
- 22:06clearly not a problem with contamination of the
- 22:09animals or spreading disease. And so, you know,
- 22:13their argument for doing that is out the window.
- 22:16So we'll see what happens. And that may have
- 22:21winning that case. in total may have a substantial
- 22:27impact on the ability of people to talk out about
- 22:30things and to actually document things. But that's
- 22:33just Ontario. Now, you know, as the courts function,
- 22:39they often refer to cases that are outside of
- 22:43their jurisdiction. You know, something comes
- 22:45up in Alberta and there's a challenge about free
- 22:48speech. Somebody may use the issue from Ontario
- 22:52to bolster their case. But, you know, it largely,
- 22:56I think, affects Ontario. It may affect beyond
- 22:58that. I'm not a lawyer, so I don't really know.
- 23:03Talking about contamination, I followed closely
- 23:10the work of activists in the US who documented
- 23:15what's happening on the avian influenza front
- 23:21and that epidemic and how it affected and still
- 23:25affects the industry. Have we been impacted by
- 23:36this epidemic? Because I did not see news outlets
- 23:42covering the price of eggs in Canada or something
- 23:46like that. B .C. was the hardest hit. And we've
- 23:55killed, I think, a million chickens in Canada.
- 23:58I'm not sure exactly of the number, but it's
- 24:00huge. And of course, that wouldn't take a long
- 24:04time to come because many of the barns have 40,
- 24:0650, 60 ,000 chickens in them. And it depends,
- 24:12I guess, on whether they're egg layers or whether
- 24:16they're raised to be eaten quickly, broilers,
- 24:19they call them. they've had to kill many, many,
- 24:27many chickens. It's affected a number of barns
- 24:29in BC. And they had to hire contract out people
- 24:37to do the killing in some of the barns because
- 24:40the CFIA, Canadian Food Inspection Agency couldn't
- 24:43handle it. And what they found was that those
- 24:46people who are not particularly trained in doing
- 24:50this job, were contaminating non -contaminated
- 24:57barns when they traveled from barn to barn and
- 25:00spreading the virus. So there was a report about
- 25:03that. So it was not particularly well done and
- 25:06we really don't have the facilities to do it.
- 25:09And beyond that, it is one of the cruelest way
- 25:12to kill animals. They basically suffocate them.
- 25:16They often use foam to suffocate them. you think
- 25:21about what those birds go through, you know,
- 25:26not because of their fault, but because of the
- 25:28fault of people around them and the way in which
- 25:30they're raised and so on. And the cruelty is
- 25:35incredible. And try to get information out about
- 25:39how that takes place, what it looks like. Do
- 25:41they have pictures? It's a no -go. This is a
- 25:47very niche question, but What do you make of
- 25:52this new trend? Maybe it's not new, but it feels
- 25:58like it's a new trend in the past years of having
- 26:04backyard chickens. There were laws passed in
- 26:09many Quebec cities here that authorize people
- 26:15to keep chickens in their backyard. Don't you
- 26:20think that there is a risk of contamination with
- 26:23this whole, you know, even influence a thing?
- 26:27Are we playing with fire with, you know, by allowing
- 26:31people to keep chickens in their backyard? I
- 26:35actually think we're playing with fire. Yes,
- 26:38we were able to get the city of Toronto to back
- 26:40off the bylaw that we're allowing chickens in
- 26:44the backyard. It was a big fight because people
- 26:46wanted those chickens. and you know it's like
- 26:49you think about it just you rent them. You don't
- 26:53think you know you rent your these little animals
- 26:56and you rent the housing for them and you stick
- 27:01them in your backyard and you love them for a
- 27:03few months until they stop laying then you send
- 27:05them back and nobody knows what happens to them.
- 27:08The the owners of some of the rented chicken
- 27:10facilities say oh well you know we take care
- 27:13of your chickens and love them and you'll get
- 27:16your same chickens back but nobody really knows
- 27:19and you know and beyond that what is also shocking
- 27:25to many people is that we mail chicks out to
- 27:30people who want backyard chickens so we put them
- 27:33in Canada Post and mail them and you know you
- 27:37look at this whole situation not only is it cruel
- 27:42and ridiculous, because the eggs cost about $2
- 27:45an egg, it is also the cruelty and the insanity
- 27:52of it, but yes, you're playing with fire. It's
- 27:55like that avian influenza is very, very contagious,
- 28:01and you can't stop other birds from coming into
- 28:05your backyard with the chickens. And, you know,
- 28:08and that's how the contamination happens. So
- 28:10the City of Toronto decided to ban it altogether,
- 28:13which was great. But many other communities are
- 28:16going on as though nothing's happening. And,
- 28:21you know, the problem with avian influence is
- 28:23it's transmitting to other animals and it's been
- 28:27transmitted to people from animals. It hasn't
- 28:32transmitted from people to people yet. But this
- 28:35is a virus that is evolving. And somehow we think
- 28:39that it's all good and that nothing's going to
- 28:44happen. And, you know, we could be in a situation
- 28:48like COVID all over again and much more serious
- 28:52because there are no vaccines for it. And I think
- 28:56we're just playing with fire. So, yeah, I would
- 28:59recommend every community in Canada ban backyard
- 29:02chickens. What do you mean by mailing chicks?
- 29:13Well, they put them in a box. They seal the box.
- 29:16They put a stamp on it and they put it in Canada
- 29:19Post. Chicks. Live chicks. And is it only an
- 29:26Ontario thing? Like, is there a limit to how
- 29:29many days? It's Canada Post. Canada Post does
- 29:32it. Required to do it. And they could spend days
- 29:36in that box. Well, they indicate that there's
- 29:41something live in the box. So it's supposed to
- 29:47get moving, but you can imagine we had a strike.
- 29:51It happened at a time when the chicks probably
- 29:53aren't moving, but we had a strike. If that had
- 29:56happened in the summertime, the chicks would
- 29:59have died. They would have simply starved to
- 30:01death or suffocated. And so, you know, you look
- 30:08at this thing and you think, that's just cruelty.
- 30:12There's no way around it. You can't do this.
- 30:16And yet it's accepted as a standard way to get
- 30:22chicks. We've tried to fight it, but we haven't
- 30:27been successful at this point. It's pretty shocking
- 30:31what we do to animals, isn't it? I'm I'm I don't
- 30:36know what to say. I think I've been vegan for
- 30:40the last 10 years. I'm still shocked by the level
- 30:43of cruelty and and what it means really what
- 30:47it means to treat people sentient beings as as
- 30:54objects. Yep. Yep. Well, you know, our standards
- 31:00at least in the United States are lowering because
- 31:03we're allowed to steal people off a sidewalk,
- 31:08send them to a detention center, and then ship
- 31:10them to another country to their prison system.
- 31:16So, you know, you look at that situation and
- 31:19you think, you know, what we're doing, if what
- 31:22we do to human beings is acceptable, our own
- 31:26species, Why do we think it's going to be different
- 31:29for species that look different from us, behave
- 31:34differently, communicate differently? People
- 31:37look at them and don't know what to make of them.
- 31:42And we're lucky in the sense that we have a fairly
- 31:48large community of people who are compassionate
- 31:52and want to make a change. And so we need to
- 31:59keep working at that. We have to get up out of
- 32:02bed every morning, even if we don't want to face
- 32:04the day and face the awful situation that animals
- 32:07go through. But we have to do it so that we never
- 32:11give up on this issue. And we never give up on
- 32:14trying to protect the animals that we know are
- 32:17subjected to abuse, misuse, cruelty, whatever
- 32:21you want to call it. Yes, I think the difference
- 32:27is when we talk about human rights, there's a
- 32:32much larger network of people and organizations
- 32:36and so much funding dedicated to shedding light
- 32:41on those issues. But, you know, you could be
- 32:46a vegan of 10 years living in Canada and not
- 32:49even be aware that there are chicks being mailed
- 32:55by Canada Post, you know, the, the information
- 33:01that how, you know, it is all done in darkness
- 33:05and silence. It's an indifference of the public.
- 33:12It's, that's, I think, the real difference between
- 33:17human rights and animal rights. I think that's
- 33:22why the Animal Protection Party of Canada is
- 33:24so important. It's the only animal protection
- 33:28party in Canada and we've been around since 2006
- 33:34and it's small because we live in a first -past
- 33:39-the -post system. But if you look at Party for
- 33:42the Animals in the Netherlands, where they have
- 33:45proportional representation. They've actually
- 33:48elected representatives to the European Union,
- 33:52to the European Parliament. They have elected
- 33:56officials to their national government and all
- 33:59the way down to local governments. It's done
- 34:01differently than we do here. But they have been
- 34:06able to expose and have documentation that they
- 34:13have access to. They get government money because
- 34:16they're a political party and they have representatives
- 34:18elected. And they've begun a real active, aggressive
- 34:22debate in the Netherlands about animals and the
- 34:26environment and the cruelty. And we have a real
- 34:30opportunity to do it here. And that's why the
- 34:32Animal Protection Party is participating in another
- 34:37challenge, charter challenge. which is the proportional
- 34:42representation. Fair Voting BC and Springtide
- 34:45are the two entities that are leading the charge
- 34:48on that. We've participated by donating to the
- 34:51cause and we're going, when it gets to the Supreme
- 34:55Court, if it does, we will ask to be interveners
- 34:58as the only political party that's fair talking
- 35:01about this issue, if you can imagine. I think
- 35:05that's the, you know, if we want to close that
- 35:08conversation about the difference between the
- 35:10US and Canada, I think that's what the US will
- 35:14never have the hope of a proportional democratic
- 35:17system, where an animal protection party can
- 35:24reach power. But but we do have that hope. And
- 35:28if, if we can get there, I do think it's you
- 35:33have convinced me that it would be, you know,
- 35:36checkmate. and we could make a really huge impact.
- 35:42Yeah, we're the just for an example, in this
- 35:45election, Pierre Poliev says he's going to open
- 35:49up the seal hunt again. No markets know anything.
- 35:53They're talking about grinding them up for fertilizer.
- 35:56And we're the only party that has a position
- 35:59on it. Other than the conservatives who want
- 36:04to increase it. So I think we are able to participate
- 36:09fully in the election. We can take out ads and
- 36:14talk about the seal hunt and so on. So we're
- 36:17able to actually on the ground during that very
- 36:21critical time when people are more actively looking
- 36:24at alternatives, we're there to provide that
- 36:29alternative if they so choose. And so I want
- 36:36to spend a moment talking about wildlife You
- 36:40mentioned Seals which is you know, I've been
- 36:44hearing about talent long before I was even vegan
- 36:47People don't want to see that they don't want
- 36:51you know seal hunting Seals are just those the
- 36:57cutest creatures out there And and the way they
- 37:01hunt them is just the most you know, barbaric
- 37:04thing you could ever watch, you know, the footage
- 37:07of that. So how is it that it's not, you know,
- 37:13more of a popular political issue? I feel like
- 37:18political parties could, you know, make it an
- 37:22issue and gain lots of popularity with voters.
- 37:28Well, there's a couple of things. This issue
- 37:32has been going on for a very, very long time.
- 37:35And a colleague of mine, Stephen Best, worked
- 37:38on, and Barry Mackay worked on the initial fight
- 37:42and it was a big issue. It was huge, huge debate.
- 37:46And ultimately they want to ban on the import
- 37:50of white coats, the very, very, the babies of
- 37:55the seals. And that's what they were after originally
- 37:57taking the the white coats because that was the
- 38:00most sought after fur. Once they're past the
- 38:04white coat stage, which is about two or three
- 38:06weeks, they become what they call beaters and
- 38:09their fur is very stiff, silvery, blotchy, not
- 38:15really the kind of fur that's going to really
- 38:20be acquired by people who want to wear fur coats.
- 38:25They then became, when that happened, the seal
- 38:29industry went down the tubes for a while. And
- 38:32then under the Liberal Party, it came back in
- 38:35a huge way. They set the kill at 340 ,000 seals,
- 38:42I think. And they never reached that amount,
- 38:45but they took an awful lot of seals out of that.
- 38:48And that's again when they went to the European
- 38:50Union, European Parliament, to say, would you
- 38:54consider this is too high a number you know it's
- 38:57affecting the seal population global warming
- 39:00is happening the seals need ice to to to have
- 39:03their babies on and the ice is disappearing could
- 39:06you ban the import of seal products into the
- 39:11european union and in fact they did and that
- 39:14brought the seal hunt down again there is a challenge
- 39:19at the european parliament as to whether they're
- 39:22going to reopen and consider retaking the seal
- 39:27products. But I think there's enough opposition
- 39:31in Europe that that's not going to happen. So,
- 39:35you know, these animals are being killed because
- 39:38there's no market. And if Poliev opens the market,
- 39:41there'll be more animals killed and there's no
- 39:43market. The last time, not the last time, but
- 39:47the time before The first time he appeared on
- 39:52the show, we talked about also the bears and
- 39:56the market for, you know, hunting bears and how
- 40:00it was even international. We have people from
- 40:03all over the world, mostly the US coming to Canada
- 40:07to hunt bears. Has there been any evolution in
- 40:14that regard? And do you think that with a conservative
- 40:18government? Um, hunting bears and hunting in
- 40:21general, um, would be, you know, um, more open
- 40:26and less restrictive and, um, more, you know,
- 40:31indifference to animal welfare. Um, under the
- 40:36conservative party, really they haven't done
- 40:40a lot of changes to the fish and wildlife conservation
- 40:44act. The only thing that they did, which was
- 40:48egregious, totally egregious, is that the fishermen
- 40:53don't like cormorants. So cormorants are big
- 40:56black birds that, you know, dive in the water,
- 41:00eat the fish, and then they come out, they nest
- 41:04in trees, their guano kills the trees. So they
- 41:06changed the topography of the area that they
- 41:10are in. In Toronto, we have the largest cormorant
- 41:14colony in North America, right at the bottom
- 41:18of the city near the lake. And we've been able
- 41:24to protect those, but in the province itself,
- 41:28the provincial government opened up hunting.
- 41:31Nobody eats cormorants, nobody. So when they
- 41:34shoot cormorants, they have to waste them. So
- 41:36they had to amend the act to allow people to
- 41:40just shoot them and leave them there. If you
- 41:42had to bear, you can't waste that animal. You
- 41:44have to use the pelt, use the meat, all that
- 41:48sort of stuff. Same with deer and so on. But
- 41:52we had a massive victory in Ontario in quite
- 42:00a while ago. they prohibited bear hunting in
- 42:07the spring. And the problem with spring bear
- 42:09hunting is that often mother bears are killed
- 42:12and the cubs are left to be orphans. So they,
- 42:17you know, more than one bear dies, of course,
- 42:19and of course it's cruel and all that sort of
- 42:22stuff. So they decided at that point under Mike
- 42:25Harris, actually, another conservative government
- 42:27to ban the spring bear hunt, which they did.
- 42:30And then under Kathleen Wynne's government, they
- 42:34decided that they needed more northern volts
- 42:36and so they opened up the spring bear hunt again.
- 42:39So we lost that all together and so spring bear
- 42:43hunts continue. You can't hint any other animal
- 42:47in the spring because they consider it to be
- 42:49cruel, but bears are okay. And so bears are killed
- 42:55in the spring and in the fall. The government
- 42:58doesn't really collect, you know, they used to
- 43:01collect great detailed information about what
- 43:04type of bears were being killed. How old were
- 43:06they? Were they male and female? Was one a lactating
- 43:10female? You know, all that sort of stuff. The
- 43:14other thing that they allow is baiting. So you
- 43:17put out a pail of donuts and honey and all sorts
- 43:20of things that smell good to a bear to attract
- 43:23them to the bait site. And then they have to
- 43:25reach up to get the food out of the drum. And
- 43:30then the hunters say that they can tell what
- 43:33the sex of the bear is so they don't shoot females
- 43:35but that is in fact not the case and of course
- 43:39there are lots of females shot and some of them
- 43:44lactating. So you know the whole thing and that's
- 43:49pretty true across Canada and of course in Alberta
- 43:53we're talking about also hunting grizzly bears
- 43:55which are small in number. And that's in order
- 44:03to attract people from the United States to come
- 44:05up and hunt trophy hunting. So, you know, from
- 44:09an animal protection point of view, it's pretty
- 44:15wicked out there for any wild animal. They tend
- 44:22to be persecuted by some group or other, and
- 44:25often hunted by some group or other. You know,
- 44:30it's very, very difficult to get it stopped.
- 44:34What about the use of poison to kill wildlife?
- 44:40So we started that campaign quite a long time
- 44:47ago. In fact, it was right at the very beginning
- 44:49of Animal Alliance that we took on British Columbia
- 44:52because they were using poisons to kill wolves
- 44:54and stuff. and they actually put a pause on that
- 44:57and the pause has continued to this day. So the
- 45:00only province now, and then it used to be Alberta,
- 45:04Saskatchewan and Manitoba, we've been able to
- 45:09get stuff, strychnine that they were using to
- 45:12kill Richardson's ground squirrels, which they
- 45:14don't like in animal agriculture business, stopped
- 45:18and the use of of other poisons we've been able
- 45:23to stop. So we're now down to Alberta. Alberta
- 45:27used to use compound 1080 or monosodium fluoroacetate
- 45:32or strychnine to kill wolves and to protect caribou
- 45:39and to kill wolves and coyotes to protect agriculture,
- 45:45animals, farmed animals. and we managed to get
- 45:48the strychnine banned. So we're now down to one
- 45:52province, one poison, and we're in the process
- 45:56of building a campaign to get that eliminated
- 45:58as well. It's, I mean, I don't know whether anybody's
- 46:03looked at videos of this stuff, but you know,
- 46:06in other countries they often use things like
- 46:09strychnine and Compound 80 to kill animals in
- 46:12cities where they've become nuisance and people
- 46:16have taken videos and when you look at what the
- 46:19animal goes through after eating compound 1080
- 46:22or strychnine it's just heart -wrenching and
- 46:26you know things you can't erase from your mind
- 46:28and so the faster we get this done the better
- 46:32but we've made very real progress over the last
- 46:3510 or 15 years. And a complex question I've had
- 46:43in mind for a long time now is what do you make
- 46:49of the argument from hunters that say, hey, there
- 46:54is an overpopulation of this or that species
- 46:57in the wild. And so we need to reduce their numbers.
- 47:02Is there any validity to that? We're just doing,
- 47:08we've just been working on this issue of overpopulation.
- 47:14And, you know, what the hunters, and in fact,
- 47:18some government agencies, the Ontario government,
- 47:22I believe the Quebec government at some times,
- 47:24and that our national park system often deem
- 47:29animals as being hyperabundant, overabundant,
- 47:33overpopulated are the various terms that they
- 47:35use. And you say, okay, we're looking at a dynamic
- 47:42ecosystem. We're looking at global warming and
- 47:48dynamic changes to the ecosystem. And by what
- 47:52measure are you determining something to be overpopulated
- 47:55or hyperabundant? And it's strictly based on
- 48:01their opinion about what a particular area is
- 48:05to look like. So with the cormorants, on Middle
- 48:09Island, which is in Lake Erie in Ontario, Parks
- 48:14Canada deemed them to be hyperabundant on Middle
- 48:18Island, one island, one island in the middle
- 48:21of a bunch of islands in Lake Erie, an island
- 48:24that nobody can go to. It was bought up by and
- 48:30Parks Canada or the groups that bought it transferred
- 48:34it over to Parks Canada under Point Pelee National
- 48:37Park. They determined the cormorants to be hyperabundant
- 48:41and since 2008 have conducted culling programs
- 48:45on Middle Island so that the vegetation looks
- 48:49the same as it did before the cormorants came.
- 48:54So there's no sense of evolution In an ecosystem,
- 49:01there's no sense that there has to be space for
- 49:05animals that change topographies and ecosystems.
- 49:09You know, these are the type of animals that
- 49:12are change makers, right? That they go in and
- 49:17they change the environment. And people don't
- 49:20like what they see, so they want them gone. And
- 49:24what we've managed to do with a large population
- 49:27in Toronto and I invite people in the summertime,
- 49:32spring and summertime to come and go to Tommy
- 49:35Thompson Park and revel in the amazingness of
- 49:39this water bird colony in a highly dense urban
- 49:43environment and they're thriving but they agreed,
- 49:47the people managing them agreed to do an alternative
- 49:49approach so they They want to keep trees in certain
- 49:53areas. They don't care about trees in other areas.
- 49:55So they chase the cormorants out of the treed
- 49:58areas into the areas where they want them. They've
- 50:01encouraged ground nesting as opposed to tree
- 50:05nesting. And I think 75 % of the colony now nests
- 50:09on the ground. And so it's been a tremendous
- 50:12success. So it shows you that you can do things
- 50:15differently. But the go -to in most of these
- 50:18situations where they claim hyperabundance is
- 50:21killing. And we don't really hear that much about
- 50:28underpopulation in certain areas. We have growing
- 50:35cities that are eating more and more territories,
- 50:42ecosystems, and nobody is talking about how in
- 50:47those cities there's no biodiversity, there is
- 50:52no where all of the species that were supposed
- 50:57to to live there. And now it's all grades, all
- 51:01as felted, it's all Yeah. Yeah. The interesting
- 51:07thing about the city of Toronto is that it's
- 51:10highly dense, for sure. But we have lots of ravine
- 51:15systems and and places where wildlife can hang
- 51:20out. And so we actually have a very rich mix
- 51:25of animals that can coexist with human beings
- 51:29and feel comfortable there. The issue becomes,
- 51:36of course, can human beings be comfortable with
- 51:38the animals? And in fact, we have one issue right
- 51:42now. where there's a lot of in -dust development
- 51:48going on in along the lake in very, very dense
- 51:53communities already, but Ontario Place, they're
- 51:56redeveloping. It was a great piece of land with
- 52:00trees and hardly anybody there. And so there
- 52:03was a lot of wildlife there. They have been disturbed
- 52:06and have moved into this highly dense area. particular
- 52:12is coyotes particularly that have done this and
- 52:14they are now you know uh conflicting with the
- 52:18residents there who want to have their dogs off
- 52:21the leash let them run around you know, do all
- 52:24that sort of thing, which is really great for
- 52:26the dogs, except that if there's a coyote in
- 52:28the area and the dog is little, it may be that
- 52:31the coyote will try and take that little dog.
- 52:34And if it's off leash somewhere away from you,
- 52:37you can't protect it. So we're going through
- 52:39a massive discussion about living coexisting
- 52:44peacefully with coyotes and our animal services.
- 52:50folks are doing a really, really good job at
- 52:53mitigating, trying to mitigate some of the conflicts.
- 52:57But the residents want the coyotes killed and
- 53:01removed. So we're into that kind of discussion.
- 53:04So we'll see how it evolves. But we, you know,
- 53:07if we can get over this hurdle, we can learn
- 53:12to live with coyotes. in the area and in fact
- 53:15in other communities it's been done in other
- 53:18parts of Toronto it's been done but for some
- 53:21reason we're into a real fight on this one so
- 53:24these are important fights where you lay down
- 53:26the line and you say no we're going to fight
- 53:28this if we lose we lose but you know we won't
- 53:31don't want to agree that the coyotes should be
- 53:33removed lethally removed out of this area because
- 53:37the residents don't want to put their dogs on
- 53:39a leash. So, you know, in the long run, I think
- 53:46it's really important that urban areas learn
- 53:52to attract, accommodate, enjoy, live with, leave
- 53:59alone wildlife, because we are, as you say, chewing
- 54:03up what would be their wild territory and putting
- 54:09housing all over the place. So if we can build
- 54:13the community in a way that allows corridors,
- 54:16you know, forested corridors through the communities
- 54:20so that the animals can travel safely, they don't
- 54:23have to go on the road. If we can have ravines
- 54:26and large parks with areas that are protected
- 54:30from people, we can accommodate wildlife nicely
- 54:34and increase the diversity in our own communities.
- 54:38and become ecologically friendly kind of a weird
- 54:42question but do you do you think that environmentalists
- 54:47are our allies no absolutely not please expand
- 54:55isn't one environmental group that i know of
- 54:57that has spoken out about the cormorants and
- 55:01we've been uh fighting this thing for 20 years
- 55:06Culling Cormons on Middle Island began in 2008
- 55:09and, you know, we're close to 20 years, 18 years
- 55:13or so. So nobody has spoken out about it. In
- 55:17fact, you know, the groups that got together
- 55:21to buy Middle Island and then donate it to Parks
- 55:24Canada have not spoken out about it. In fact,
- 55:28some of the groups want the call. They want the
- 55:31vegetation. They don't want the birds. And, you
- 55:34know, cormorants were persecuted were down to
- 55:37about a thousand individuals because they were
- 55:42so persecuted and they've made this uh and then
- 55:46they were you know that they were the persecution
- 55:49stopped but then ddd came around and they were
- 55:51hit with that and so they've now made this miraculous
- 55:55comeback an amazing comeback into you know a
- 55:59couple of million birds not a lot um and and
- 56:03they seem to be thriving and yet what do we want
- 56:06to do we want to persecute them and kill them
- 56:08again i mean you know i i don't find environmental
- 56:13groups standing up for these sort of things no
- 56:17and you mentioned how the animal protection party
- 56:22is the only party wanting a proportional democratic
- 56:29system. So that means that excludes the Green
- 56:32Party. The Green Party, I don't know what the
- 56:38position is. The provincial Green Party used
- 56:41to have a position on partial representation.
- 56:44And then I don't I think they don't now. I'm
- 56:46not sure. But I'm wrong on that. Actually, I
- 56:49think they they do support proportional representation.
- 56:52I don't know about the federal party. But they're
- 56:55not participating in the court case. There's
- 57:00not one party other than ours that have participated
- 57:02in the court case. So you've got to ask yourself,
- 57:06what is it going to take to... If Trudeau, who
- 57:13promised to bring in proportional representation,
- 57:16didn't do it and other elected officials are
- 57:21not particularly supportive of the idea, Then,
- 57:25you know, how do we get it to happen? And, and,
- 57:30you know, I don't know that the Greens have been
- 57:32that active in this whole, this whole fight.
- 57:36Well, you know, I don't care what they say. I
- 57:40want to see action. Why are you not on the front
- 57:43line of this legal fight? Yep. Yep. I think,
- 57:47you know, when you when you think about it, if
- 57:51we had one person, in Parliament. Let's just
- 57:54say one. We would not be able to talk very much,
- 58:02but we would be able to talk, we would be able
- 58:04to ask questions, but we would be able to logically
- 58:07dig for information out of the party, right?
- 58:13Out of the government. So we could dig away at
- 58:18situations around the CFIA, around the expenditures
- 58:22and calling it Parks Canada, the research issue,
- 58:27the funding for research through the various
- 58:32entities that fund research in Canada. We could
- 58:36do all of that. We could start getting the information
- 58:39out publicly on those issues, even just having
- 58:43one person in Parliament. And so, you know, you
- 58:48have to ask yourself, even in our movement, the
- 58:52animal rights movement, why are we not more electorally
- 58:58and politically engaged? Because they're the
- 59:01people who make the decisions. Who lives, who
- 59:04dies, who suffers, by how much, how often, all
- 59:08of those issues are decided by governments. And
- 59:13we seem to think that If we just show governments
- 59:18how bad it is, they'll do something about it.
- 59:21But that's not how politics works. You know,
- 59:24they look at the agricultural community, the
- 59:27number of votes there. They look at our movement.
- 59:32They look at the people that are in the movement.
- 59:36They have no idea how they're going to vote.
- 59:38And so what's the political upside to doing anything?
- 59:43And, you know, the first past the post just continues
- 59:46to make sure that that whole idea and consideration
- 59:52stays in place. Going back quickly to the environmentalists.
- 59:59What is their agenda exactly? Because at first,
- 1:00:04you know, I was very much, you know, aligned
- 1:00:08with them and I'm talking before becoming vegan.
- 1:00:13But then I had an evolution in my thinking and
- 1:00:17I felt strongly that becoming vegan was the best
- 1:00:21thing to do for the environment. And that's when
- 1:00:25I felt kind of a separation with the environmental
- 1:00:31movement and felt like they were not making lots
- 1:00:36of sense. And now I'm just confused, you know,
- 1:00:40what are they about? Well, you know, it's not
- 1:00:45that they're all bad. They fight, you know, they
- 1:00:51fought to protect the green space north of Toronto
- 1:00:55that Ford wanted to develop houses on. They fight
- 1:01:00for parks and for woodlots, protection of woodlots.
- 1:01:06And a lot of them do that kind of work very,
- 1:01:10very well. And that's really important because,
- 1:01:13of course, animals need a place to live. And
- 1:01:18the more of those places that we have, the better.
- 1:01:21But in a way, it's kind of like you defend the
- 1:01:30maintenance of an apartment building, but you
- 1:01:32don't defend the occupants. Do they allow hunting
- 1:01:39in these areas? What do they allow? And in some
- 1:01:44cases, they absolutely allow hunting in the wood
- 1:01:47lots that they've protected. They absolutely
- 1:01:51support Parks Canada and its culling programs.
- 1:01:57They support hunting in provincial parks by First
- 1:02:02Nations. So in a way across Canada, there is
- 1:02:07not a single area or much of a single area that
- 1:02:11animals can be in and safe. And so I think you've
- 1:02:17got to ask yourself the question. You know, it's
- 1:02:20great, it's wonderful, absolutely fantastic to
- 1:02:23save the geography, but you also have to protect
- 1:02:28the occupants of the geography to make a full
- 1:02:32-blown ecosystem work. And so I think that's
- 1:02:35where they fall down. I love the image of defending
- 1:02:41the apartment block, the building itself, but
- 1:02:44not the occupants. I think it's, you know, exactly
- 1:02:47that. And what do you make then of environmental
- 1:02:53causes that have to do with protecting some subspecies
- 1:03:00of vegetation? Like I care about it. I will care
- 1:03:04about it if it has an impact on the fauna, like
- 1:03:11an insect, a butterfly, something like that.
- 1:03:14But if it doesn't, then why should we care? I
- 1:03:19think we should care about plants. They're super
- 1:03:25important. in terms of the evolution of an ecosystem
- 1:03:29the provision of food and shelter and all that
- 1:03:34sort of stuff to species that we don't even know
- 1:03:37about like various types of insects and stuff.
- 1:03:41So I think it's really important where it becomes
- 1:03:43a problem is the where animals have been indigenous
- 1:03:49in the area and plants have been indigenous in
- 1:03:53the area and the area is evolving. an unmanaged
- 1:03:57ecosystem just evolving on its own, and the animals
- 1:04:01eat the plants, I think that's the way it is.
- 1:04:05But you see on Middle Island, Middle Island is
- 1:04:09part of a broader ecosystem that doesn't include
- 1:04:14most of Canada. It's just we're on the edge of
- 1:04:16it, the Carolinian biosphere. And so the plants
- 1:04:20on Middle Island are Carolinian. And Canada considers
- 1:04:25them endangered because they're in Canada, and
- 1:04:29they're not considering them as part of the biosphere.
- 1:04:32If you looked at the plants that they are trying
- 1:04:34to protect from the cormorants in the biosphere,
- 1:04:36they're not endangered at all. And so why are
- 1:04:39we going through this massive, cruel killing
- 1:04:43program to save plants that are not endangered?
- 1:04:46And I think we have to figure out now how we
- 1:04:51look at an evolving ecosystem. Because plants
- 1:04:54are going to disappear. We're talking about,
- 1:04:57you know, the planet warming. We're talking about
- 1:04:59fires. We're talking about, you know, floods.
- 1:05:02We're talking about huge ice things, wind, you
- 1:05:05know, tornadoes and stuff. All of our ecosystem
- 1:05:08is going to evolve and change. And we need to
- 1:05:12allow the plants and the animals to begin to
- 1:05:17change what they need to change in order to survive
- 1:05:20the warming planet. and instead you know we say
- 1:05:23no this plant we have to protect these birds
- 1:05:27we have to kill these deer we have to get rid
- 1:05:30of you know these coyotes have to go all that
- 1:05:33sort of stuff and without recognizing and without
- 1:05:37even acknowledging this tremendous change that's
- 1:05:40beginning and coming and you know going to be
- 1:05:44overwhelming to many species and you know the
- 1:05:47species that can accommodate to it are the species
- 1:05:50that are going to survive. Yeah, we're still
- 1:05:52killing polar bears. They're still, you know,
- 1:05:56you can go up and kill a, you have to go through
- 1:05:59a process, but you can kill a polar bear when
- 1:06:02we know that their ecosystem is going. Are they
- 1:06:08going to survive or not? We don't know, but we're
- 1:06:11not giving them the best chance possible to try
- 1:06:13and survive through that because we think it's
- 1:06:15okay to take them and use their pelts. So I sort
- 1:06:19of think we have not in any way engaged in the
- 1:06:22reality of global warming, changes to the ecosystem,
- 1:06:27impacts on animals that we don't like and animals
- 1:06:31that we do like. I don't know. I just think human
- 1:06:35beings have to wake up and begin to be more inclusive
- 1:06:41and sensitive to broader species in the world.
- 1:06:46Yes. right on. And I guess to close this conversation
- 1:06:50about wildlife, there are parks, national parks
- 1:06:56in Canada that are protected. But nowadays, you
- 1:07:02know, I'm wondering if that protection is really
- 1:07:06that established? Like, what does it mean that
- 1:07:10this piece of land is protected? And am I right
- 1:07:15to be to be skeptical and I guess I could, you
- 1:07:18know, tell the story of the place where I live.
- 1:07:23There was a wetland, you know, location and it
- 1:07:30was understood that this place was protected,
- 1:07:34but yet, you know, there was a vote with the
- 1:07:37city council and they changed the status of that
- 1:07:42land. And now they're building apartment complex
- 1:07:46on on on those wetlands. And so is it really
- 1:07:51protected? And federally, it's legislatively
- 1:07:57protected. That doesn't mean that, you know,
- 1:08:03it's how you interpret, interpret the protection.
- 1:08:06But generally speaking, the the parks that have
- 1:08:10been the parks and Reserves are generally protected
- 1:08:15from things like development, encroachment, all
- 1:08:19that sort of stuff. There was a discussion, in
- 1:08:21fact, in Jasper, around Jasper National Park,
- 1:08:24there was a possible ask of the federal government,
- 1:08:30could they build in the park and replace the
- 1:08:33houses that had been burnt down in the fire that
- 1:08:36went through last year? And as far as I can tell
- 1:08:39so far, the answer has been no. and it won't
- 1:08:42happen but you look at you look at those two
- 1:08:46major parks in Alberta and they have a golf course
- 1:08:50and they have hotels and they have this and I
- 1:08:54think they were probably taken over early on
- 1:08:57in the whole process trying to protect from further
- 1:09:01development which they've been able to do but
- 1:09:05you know I think they're probably protected where
- 1:09:09it isn't protected. Wetlands are a real issue
- 1:09:12across the country. And they're the lifeblood
- 1:09:15of our ecosystems. And they, of course, house
- 1:09:21many, many, many wild animals, wild insects,
- 1:09:26wild everything. And they're critically important
- 1:09:29to the health of the ecosystem. And yet they
- 1:09:34are considered to be Swamps is what we used to
- 1:09:38call them and to be drained and to and to be
- 1:09:43used for development and you know, that's happening
- 1:09:46all across the country. There's a wonderful person
- 1:09:51in Alberta whose name just escapes me at the
- 1:09:54moment. I'll think about it, but she have of
- 1:09:56course advocates for wetlands and advocates for
- 1:10:00not trapping beaver to allow the wetlands to
- 1:10:03occur and And so, you know, it's just an indication
- 1:10:08about how critical it is and how often communities
- 1:10:13ask for a redefinement of what a wetland is so
- 1:10:16that they can develop it. And I have to say,
- 1:10:24many of the environmentalists are on the right
- 1:10:26side of that issue and have fought hard to protect
- 1:10:29wetlands. We worked on one with the city of Montreal
- 1:10:35a while ago, and the city bought the land, ultimately,
- 1:10:42and so that part of the wetland is protected,
- 1:10:43but I think there's development occurring in
- 1:10:46other parts of it, so who knows how that will
- 1:10:49ultimately end, but I think the more parks we
- 1:10:54get, the more land we get under control of the
- 1:10:58federal government, And we'll see what Carney
- 1:11:02does, but I think the more land will actually
- 1:11:05have protected. Not not perfectly, but better
- 1:11:10than just sitting there. So Liz, we mentioned
- 1:11:15how your work is important and this is something
- 1:11:19I, you know, since the first time I met you and
- 1:11:23we had the conversation, my my thinking of animal
- 1:11:28advocacy. and how to best help animals and stop
- 1:11:33this madness has evolved. And now I'm on the
- 1:11:38same page as you are about the political stuff.
- 1:11:44And, and so, you know, what can we do to support
- 1:11:49your efforts? What can we do to support the efforts
- 1:11:52of the animal protection party? Yeah. I guess
- 1:11:59there's a couple of things. I would, once the
- 1:12:05election, let's say the election, okay, so we'll
- 1:12:08deal with the election first. I think you should
- 1:12:10go and meet with the candidates in your area
- 1:12:14and introduce yourself and say you're gonna be
- 1:12:17back. You wanna talk to them about animal issues
- 1:12:19and you're hoping that as it goes along that
- 1:12:23they would be willing to actually introduce.
- 1:12:26a private members bill or actually if they're
- 1:12:28in the government get the government to introduce
- 1:12:30a bill on whatever issue you want to talk about.
- 1:12:34If you want a little bit more support in that
- 1:12:37area you might want to go out and do a bit of
- 1:12:40canvassing for a candidate of your choice. Even
- 1:12:44if they're not the animal protection party, which
- 1:12:46they won't be because we're not bringing that
- 1:12:47many candidates, it's really important to get
- 1:12:50a feel for how politics works. what's the wheeling
- 1:12:54and dealing behind the scenes, who owes what
- 1:12:57who to whom, all that sort of stuff is important
- 1:13:01and making that personal connection with the
- 1:13:04person who gets elected in your area so that
- 1:13:06when something comes up you can phone that person
- 1:13:09up get a meeting with them and talk to them about
- 1:13:12your concerns about whatever the government's
- 1:13:14doing or your support about whatever the government's
- 1:13:16doing. So that I would It's four years, it'll
- 1:13:22be four, if we get a majority government, it'll
- 1:13:24be four years till the next election. I would
- 1:13:27urge people who are vegetarian and vegan across
- 1:13:31the country to begin to do a little bit of research
- 1:13:34into how to become a candidate. It's our goal
- 1:13:40to run more candidates. We've been up to about
- 1:13:4420 at one time. um but uh you know it was quick
- 1:13:49this time so it was we were unable to get to
- 1:13:51that number but if we have time to plan um to
- 1:13:55consider running for the party it's a fantastic
- 1:13:58way you get go to all candidates meetings you
- 1:14:01get to talk about your issue nobody else at the
- 1:14:03count candidates meeting is going to talk about
- 1:14:05your issue but you can i have one on um mid -april
- 1:14:10uh that i'm going to go to and you know I'm going
- 1:14:13to talk about all the animal issues and you know
- 1:14:16because the liberals in a way did a pretty good
- 1:14:18job low -hanging fruit but you know they did
- 1:14:22it they got the cosmetic bill through and they
- 1:14:26did and some of the pesticide stuff we got through
- 1:14:29so they did some really good stuff but it wasn't
- 1:14:34clearly enough. It's obviously, you know, when
- 1:14:37you start digging into animal issues, it's a
- 1:14:39tsunami of issues to try and deal with. So looking
- 1:14:43at the issues that are most important and moving
- 1:14:48those forward, you know, it's harder to talk
- 1:14:51about the animal agriculture because of the size
- 1:14:53of the industry, but there are alternative groups
- 1:14:58out there. There are vegan environmental agriculture
- 1:15:02people. And so we can begin to talk about how
- 1:15:07to, as a party and as a candidate, how to shift
- 1:15:11from the very damaging and cruel animal agriculture
- 1:15:16to a vegan agriculture. And it's much kinder
- 1:15:22to the land. You don't have to use as many pesticides
- 1:15:25and all that sort of stuff. the party and the
- 1:15:29platform, which I think is pretty fulsome, to
- 1:15:32advocate the issues that you are interested in.
- 1:15:36And if you would be interested in being a candidate
- 1:15:38for years coming, maybe do some research on on
- 1:15:42how to do that. A lot of people find it pretty
- 1:15:45intimidating. And then it is because you got
- 1:15:48to get up and talk to an audience that isn't
- 1:15:50particularly sympathetic about your issues. But
- 1:15:54it's a really, really, really good test. about
- 1:15:58how well you are able to put your issues forward
- 1:16:01and whether you can convince people in the audience
- 1:16:04that you have a case. Let me ask you a question.
- 1:16:09I actually wrote an article about social media
- 1:16:12and how social media should not become the centerpiece
- 1:16:19or the focus of animal, you know, animal rights
- 1:16:25activists. And, you know, I actually took as
- 1:16:30an example, the Animal Protection Party of Canada,
- 1:16:34you have, you know, hundreds of followers on
- 1:16:37social media, yet it is difficult to transform
- 1:16:42that and to convert that into candidates in the
- 1:16:48field. So maybe I would love to hear your thoughts
- 1:16:54on that. Why is it so difficult to get people
- 1:16:59who are sympathizers to animal protection organizations
- 1:17:05to do something out of the social media world?
- 1:17:12I think it's become a world where you don't have
- 1:17:19to do a whole lot of work. And you see something,
- 1:17:23you post it, and you get a bunch of people commenting
- 1:17:27on it, and you comment back. And you know, you
- 1:17:30can, it's very passive, you can do it. Doesn't
- 1:17:33take a whole lot of work or thinking. And that's
- 1:17:38why I think it's really difficult for people
- 1:17:40to understand, how do you get legislation changed?
- 1:17:47from the outside and from the inside. How do
- 1:17:50you do it? What is the mechanism by which you
- 1:17:54lobby? Who do you talk to? How often do you go
- 1:17:57there? How much do you pressure those people?
- 1:18:00What kind of information do you put in front
- 1:18:02of them? If you're going to promote an issue,
- 1:18:05you better have it to a politician, you better
- 1:18:07have it well researched because if you present
- 1:18:10them with something like, I don't like what somebody's
- 1:18:13doing, that's not going to cut it and you will
- 1:18:16probably be ignored and you'll wonder why. And
- 1:18:21you need to make, I think you need to make, and
- 1:18:24this may be difficult for people, but I think
- 1:18:26you need to make a really deep commitment to,
- 1:18:30if you're interested in an issue, to doing the
- 1:18:33proper research, to getting all of the scientific
- 1:18:36information lined up, to do all that kind of
- 1:18:39work so that when you go, if you decide to go,
- 1:18:43to your member of parliament or member of provincial
- 1:18:47parliament to present your case that you have
- 1:18:52it well prepared and you're you know skilled
- 1:18:56and the person can see that you know what you're
- 1:18:59talking about and that takes a lot of work and
- 1:19:04often people don't either want to do that feel
- 1:19:08inadequate for doing it. I don't quite know.
- 1:19:11But I do know we've had we have a couple of candidates
- 1:19:13that have just jumped in. They've just decided
- 1:19:16I'm going to do it. One in Newfoundland and one
- 1:19:19out in BC. And it's a hard you know, you can
- 1:19:23imagine being an animal rights person in Newfoundland
- 1:19:27where they have the seal hunt, how difficult
- 1:19:29that is. And, and yet, you know, he's going to
- 1:19:34do it. and so I think you just and and he's and
- 1:19:37they're learning they're both learning really
- 1:19:39fast you know what arguments to put forward what
- 1:19:42not all that sort of stuff and of course myself
- 1:19:45and my colleague Barry Mackay are there to help
- 1:19:47them um but uh it means that these are people
- 1:19:52who are willing to actually do the work and I
- 1:19:55think that makes all the difference in the world
- 1:19:57and we need more people like that And I don't
- 1:20:01know what it takes to get people out of Facebook
- 1:20:03and TikTok and Snapchat and whoever else they're
- 1:20:07on to actually begin to do the kind of work that
- 1:20:12needs to be done to change the legislation because
- 1:20:14that's where the change is going to happen. What
- 1:20:17about donations? How much can we give? I think
- 1:20:22there is a ceiling to political donations. Yeah,
- 1:20:27there's a ceiling. Yeah. It was, it's like $1
- 1:20:31,725 to $1 ,750. I'm just not quite sure it changes.
- 1:20:37It goes up by $25 every year. So you could become
- 1:20:42a month, people could become a monthly donor
- 1:20:44and make it the $1 ,700 and whatever it is over
- 1:20:49a 12 month period. So it isn't onerous. Some
- 1:20:52people just write us a check for the entire amount.
- 1:20:55You get a very, just for people who need tax
- 1:20:58receipts, you get an extremely good receipt from
- 1:21:03Elections Canada for donating to our party. And
- 1:21:08the sweet spot, if you give $400, you get $325
- 1:21:11or $350 back. I can't remember, but most of the
- 1:21:15donation you get back directly off your income
- 1:21:18tax. So it's a really good deal. Yeah, anybody
- 1:21:23who wants to join the Animal Protection Party,
- 1:21:25please come forward. We'd love to talk to you.
- 1:21:28I'll probably call you personally if you give
- 1:21:30a donation and it would be fantastic. And do
- 1:21:35we have to be Canadian to make a donation? You
- 1:21:38have to be a Canadian citizen or there's one
- 1:21:42other landed immigrant or something. I think
- 1:21:46you have to be a Canadian citizen to to vote.
- 1:21:52I don't think you have to be a Canadian citizen
- 1:21:54to join the party. No. So, Liz, I think we covered
- 1:22:00well the topics at hand, the issues that needed
- 1:22:06to be addressed surrounding this election and
- 1:22:11the state of animal rights in Canada. Did you
- 1:22:16want to add something before we stop the recording?
- 1:22:20Yeah, I would just say to everybody who's listening
- 1:22:23I understand how hard it is to do this work to
- 1:22:28look at the images and to not get discouraged
- 1:22:32and not feel angry and not You know feel unable
- 1:22:38to do anything and I just ask you to sit back
- 1:22:42a little bit and Reconsider the animals that
- 1:22:45you watched had to undergo that kind of cruelty
- 1:22:50But if they encouraged you to become part of
- 1:22:57the movement and to fight hard for animal rights,
- 1:23:01then they didn't die in vain and I would urge
- 1:23:04you to sit back, reconsider and join the movement
- 1:23:08and join the party. Whichever you want to do
- 1:23:11and fight for the animals because they sure need
- 1:23:14our help. Thank you everyone for listening. I
- 1:23:18kindly invite you to share this podcast with
- 1:23:21the vegans you know. Let's encourage more people
- 1:23:24to take action. Again, thank you so much for
- 1:23:27caring and I will see you next Tuesday for a
- 1:23:31new episode.