Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / ⚠️ Circle (CRCL): A Valuation Beyond Perfection ⚠️
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back everyone to the Deep dive.
- 0:01Great to be here. Today we're really digging into
- 0:04a company that's right at that interesting intersection of
- 0:07fintech and crypto. We're talking about Circle.
- 0:10You probably know them as the issuer of the USDC stablecoin.
- 0:14That's right, a major player. Exactly.
- 0:16And our mission really for you today is pretty clear.
- 0:20We're going to unpack a full financial analysis of circle.
- 0:23We want to pull out the key Nuggets, the most important bits
- 0:26so you can get up to speed fast on their business model, how
- 0:29they're performing financial, the risks and there are some
- 0:31significant ones and yeah, what a lot of you are probably
- 0:34wondering about valuation. And this isn't just guesswork.
- 0:37We're drawing on, you know, detailed financial reports, one
- 0:40filings, industry insights, trying to get a really solid
- 0:44picture of what's going on with this company.
- 0:45They're definitely making waves. OK, let's jump in.
- 0:47First off, Circle Internet group ticker CRCL.
- 0:50What exactly is CIRCLE at its core?
- 0:52Well, fundamentally it's a fintech company.
- 0:54And yes, they're primarily known for issuing USD coin USDC.
- 0:57That's the stable coin pegged 1 to one with the US dollar.
- 1:00To stable value. Supposedly, yes, and their
- 1:02platform is built to help businesses use these digital
- 1:05currencies, use blockchain, you know, globally for payments,
- 1:09commerce that sort of. Thing and you mentioned how they
- 1:11make money it's kind of surprising right the source it.
- 1:13Really is that's what you call the 99% rule and it's spot on.
- 1:17Based on their 2024 numbers, almost all 99% of the revenue
- 1:21came from interest income. Not fees for using USDC.
- 1:25No, not primarily. It's interest earned on the
- 1:27reserves that back the stable coins, mostly USDC.
- 1:31Think about it, for every USDC out there, Circle holds a
- 1:35corresponding dollar in reserves and those reserves they're
- 1:39invested mainly in very safe short term U.S.
- 1:42Treasury bills and also some cash deposits.
- 1:45This is crucial for maintaining that one to one peg.
- 1:47Right, I got to have the backing.
- 1:48Exactly. So operationally, you can almost
- 1:50think of them like a kind of wholesale money market fund.
- 1:52They take the reserve cash, invest it safely, earn interest.
- 1:56And keep it all. Well, not quite all.
- 1:58They share a slice of that interest yield with partners.
- 2:01Coinbase is the big one mentioned as distribution costs.
- 2:04What's leftover is their main source of income.
- 2:06So if 99% is interest, what's happening with that other 1%?
- 2:10Are they trying to build other businesses?
- 2:11Diversify. They are definitely trying that
- 2:13small slice. The other 1% comes from fees on
- 2:16services like Circle Mint. That's their platform for
- 2:19institutions, banks, exchanges, fintechs to mint and redeem USDC
- 2:23directly. They have about what, 1800
- 2:26customers there? OK, institutions.
- 2:28Right. And then there are newer things,
- 2:29still pretty nascent developed help.
- 2:31Our AP is some tokenization services.
- 2:33They've been quite open about wanting to diversify to build
- 2:36more fee based revenue. They mentioned a Circle payments
- 2:38network launching in 2025, for instance.
- 2:40Which makes sense, right? Reducing that reliance on
- 2:42interest rates seems critical. Absolutely.
- 2:44It's a key strategic goal for them, building a more resilient
- 2:47revenue base for the long haul. OK.
- 2:48So the customers using Circle men are institutions?
- 2:51What about regular folks using USDC?
- 2:53And how big is USDC now? Yeah, the direct customers are
- 2:56the businesses, the fintechs, the exchanges.
- 2:59Those 1800 or so using Circle meant the end users, you know,
- 3:03there's someone trading on exchange or sending money.
- 3:05They interact via those intermediaries, not usually
- 3:07directly with Circle. As for size, USD CS growth has
- 3:11been pretty dramatic, over $60 billion issued cumulatively and
- 3:15the current supply in circulation is around $61
- 3:17billion. That's actually an all time
- 3:19high, higher than the 2021 peak. Wow, an all time high now after
- 3:23the crypto winter? Yeah, it shows a strong recovery
- 3:25after that dip in 2022 and early 2023.
- 3:28Remember the market downturn and then that temporary DPEG during
- 3:32the Silicon Valley Bank issue in March 20?
- 3:33Three. Oh yeah, I remember that
- 3:35stressful time. For sure, but it's bounced back
- 3:37strong in the overall stable coin market, which is maybe
- 3:39around $250 billion total. USD CS, the second biggest who's
- 3:43number one still Tether, USDT, they're dominant.
- 3:46USDC has roughly say 24 to 26% market share.
- 3:49But the key take away for Circles business is clear.
- 3:52More USDC in circulation generally means more reserves,
- 3:55which, if interest rates cooperate, means more revenue.
- 3:57Assuming favorable interest rates.
- 3:59That's the big if, isn't it? Especially now.
- 4:01That must be one of the big worries keeping management
- 4:03awake. What are those major headwinds?
- 4:05The risks. Oh absolutely.
- 4:07Short term, the number one risk is the interest rate environment
- 4:10with 99% of revenue tied to it. Falling rates are a direct hit
- 4:14to their income and well, the Fed is expected to start cutting
- 4:17rates eventually, right? If rates went back near 0.
- 4:20Yeah, that would. Hurt, it would significantly
- 4:22impact our main revenue stream. Then there's crypto market
- 4:25volatility. We saw it in 20/22/23.
- 4:28Downturns mean less demand for stable coins sometimes.
- 4:30And specific shocks like that SVB incident you mentioned, that
- 4:34must have been nail biting. USDC actually D pegged for a
- 4:36bit. It did briefly because they held
- 4:39some reserves at SDB. So events like that banking
- 4:42stress can cause temporary dips in circulation, maybe affect
- 4:45revenue short term, and then there's regulation.
- 4:46Always regulation in crypto. Always there's progress maybe on
- 4:50AUS stable coin bill, which could be positive, but delays or
- 4:54unfavorable rules coming out in the meantime that could
- 4:56definitely slow down their growth plans.
- 4:58These are the sort of more immediate bumps in the road.
- 5:01OK, those are short term. What about bigger, maybe more
- 5:05existential long term risks? Things that could really change
- 5:08the game for them? Well, long term regulatory
- 5:11changes remain a huge one. Think about new laws that might
- 5:14heavily restrict private stable coin issuers like Circle or the
- 5:18really big one, a central bank digital currency, ACBDC.
- 5:23A digital dollar from the Fed. Exactly.
- 5:25If the Federal Reserve launched its own digital dollar, widely
- 5:28adopted, well, that could fundamentally challenge the need
- 5:30for private stable coins like USDC.
- 5:32It's a major overhang. Yeah, that's a big shadow.
- 5:34What else? Competition.
- 5:36Tether isn't going anywhere. They have that huge market share
- 5:38and you have to wonder, once the regulatory picture is clearer,
- 5:42will big tech companies jump in or made traditional banks?
- 5:45They certainly have the resources.
- 5:46Right, The Google coin or the JP Morgan coin?
- 5:49That could definitely shake things up.
- 5:51It could. Another risk is just adoption.
- 5:54What if stable coins don't breakthrough to the mainstream
- 5:56as much as hoped? What if they remain kind of
- 5:59niche, used mainly within the crypto ecosystem?
- 6:02Or maybe some other technology comes along like faster
- 6:05traditional payment rails that bypasses the need for stable
- 6:08coins on a blockchain. Interesting point.
- 6:10And finally, circling back to where we started, that revenue
- 6:13concentration relying so heavily on USDC interest income is an
- 6:18inherent long term vulnerability.
- 6:20Management knows this, they're investing in diversification,
- 6:23but will those new ventures like the penis network actually gain
- 6:26enough traction? That's a big question mark for
- 6:28the long term story. Lots to navigate there.
- 6:31OK, let's pivot then let's talk financials.
- 6:33How does their cost structure work?
- 6:34How do they actually make a profit from that interest
- 6:36income? OK.
- 6:37So their costs have two main parts, variable costs tied
- 6:40mostly to USDC and fixed operating costs.
- 6:43The big variable cost line item is distribution and transaction
- 6:46costs. That's the money shared with
- 6:48Coinbase and others. Primarily, yes, the revenue
- 6:51share paid to partners for helping issue and distribute
- 6:53USDC in 2024, that was about $1.01 billion.
- 6:59It scales up and down pretty directly with revenue.
- 7:01We saw in Q12025 revenue was up 55% year over year, but those
- 7:07distribution costs jumped even more, up 68%.
- 7:10It looks like roughly half of every dollar of reserve interest
- 7:13revenue goes out the door to these partners.
- 7:15Wow, half. That's significant.
- 7:16What about their own internal costs?
- 7:18Staff, R&D, keeping the lights on, right?
- 7:21Those are the fixed operating expenses.
- 7:22Think personnel. They have around 900 employees.
- 7:25Research and development compliance, which is huge for
- 7:27them. Marketing, general admin,
- 7:29basically SG and A that bucket was around $182 million in 2024.
- 7:33OK, much smaller than the distribution.
- 7:35Cost much more and crucially, it grows slower than revenue.
- 7:38This creates what they call operating leverage.
- 7:40It's a double edged sword though.
- 7:41How so? Well, when revenue surges like
- 7:43it did by 87% in 2023, those fixed costs don't jump nearly as
- 7:47much. So profitability can really soar
- 7:50high incremental margins. But if revenue falls sharply,
- 7:53say if interest rates plummet. Those fixed costs are still
- 7:55there. Exactly.
- 7:56They can't cut them as quickly as revenue might fall, leading
- 7:59to potential heavy losses. High leverage works both ways.
- 8:02So how did they actually do in the latest quarter?
- 8:04Q12025 Did that leverage help or hurt?
- 8:08Q12025 looked pretty strong on the top line.
- 8:11Revenue hit about $557 million, up 55% year over year.
- 8:16That was driven by a, you know, higher USDC reserves and
- 8:19interest rates staying elevated. But you said distribution costs
- 8:22jumped even more. They did up 68%.
- 8:24So that did compress margins a bit even with the strong revenue
- 8:27growth. But the key thing is they were
- 8:29still profitable in Q1. They continued the profitable
- 8:32trend they established in 2023. Good to hear.
- 8:35Are they just banking the profits or investing?
- 8:37Management's emphasizing continued investment, things
- 8:39like pursuing that U.S. National Trust Bank charter that
- 8:42takes capital and effort and expanding USDC use cases in
- 8:46traditional finance like the work Visa is doing to use USDC
- 8:49for settlement. They seem focused on building
- 8:51for the future. OK, building for the future.
- 8:53Let's talk about the builders. Who's leading Circle?
- 8:56The management team? Their alignment with investors?
- 8:58The face of circle is definitely the Co founder, chairman and CEO
- 9:02Jeremy Allaire. He's been leading it for over 11
- 9:05years. Very prominent figure often out
- 9:08there talking about regulation, engaging proactively, and.
- 9:11Does he have skin in the game? Oh yeah, significantly.
- 9:14According to the filings around the IPO, Alaire owns about 7.5%
- 9:18of Circle at the current market cap.
- 9:19That's where it's somewhere around $3.1 billion.
- 9:23So yeah, his interests seem very much aligned with shareholders.
- 9:26That's a serious stake. Anyone else notable on the team?
- 9:29Definitely, they brought in some heavy hitters, especially on the
- 9:32legal and compliance side. Keith Tarbert is president and
- 9:35chief legal officer. He's a former chairman of the
- 9:37CFTC, the US commodities regulator.
- 9:39Wow, OK, that's relevant experience.
- 9:41Hugely relevant and Jeremy Fox keen is the CFO.
- 9:43Having that kind of seasoned expertise, particularly in legal
- 9:46and regulatory affairs, is absolutely critical in this
- 9:49space. It signals they're serious about
- 9:50playing by the rules, or at least navigating them
- 9:52effectively. And their track record, you
- 9:54mentioned they successfully went public in 2025 after a failed
- 9:58SPAC attempt earlier. Does that show resilience?
- 10:01Transparency. I think it shows persistence,
- 10:03certainly. And on transparency, they do
- 10:05have a history. They got one of the first bit
- 10:06licenses in New York back in 2015.
- 10:09They published monthly reserve attestations showing what backs
- 10:12USDC. That's important for trust.
- 10:14It is, and during that SVB crisis in March 2023, Alaire was
- 10:19very quick to disclose their exposure that open handling even
- 10:22of bad news likely help stabilize things and get USDC re
- 10:26pegged quickly. The S1 filing itself was pretty
- 10:29upfront about risks, including that 99% revenue concentration.
- 10:32No obvious signs of hiding major issues from what we can see in
- 10:35public sources. OK.
- 10:36So management seems aligned and relatively transparent.
- 10:39What about the big outside investors who backed them?
- 10:41Well, besides Alaire and other execs having equity, the
- 10:44shareholder list at the IPO included some big names, top
- 10:47venture capital firms like Excel, General Catalyst and
- 10:50major asset managers like BlackRock Infidelity.
- 10:52So serious institutional backing.
- 10:54Haitian capital usually. Typically, yes.
- 10:56VCs and large asset managers often look for long term growth
- 10:59and appreciate companies building compliant
- 11:01infrastructure. And Blackrock's involvement is
- 11:04particularly interesting because they also managed a significant
- 11:06portion of the USDC reserves. That's a strategic partnership
- 11:09that suggests a strong belief in circles long term future.
- 11:13Interesting dynamic with all that backing are, are they doing
- 11:16share buybacks now that they're public returning capital?
- 11:19No, not currently. They just raised about $1.1
- 11:22billion gross from their IPO in June 2025.
- 11:26As a newly public growth company, the focus is squarely
- 11:28on using that cash to invest in the business, product
- 11:31development, getting that bank charter capitalized, maybe
- 11:33acquisitions down the line. Buybacks would really run
- 11:36counter to that growth narrative right now.
- 11:38Makes sense. OK, let's get to it.
- 11:40The $1,000,000 question or maybe the $185 question.
- 11:42Given the current stock price valuation, is Circle stock a
- 11:47buy? How do we even approach valuing
- 11:49this? Right.
- 11:49This is where the rubber meets the road, as they say.
- 11:52We try to look at it using a classic value investing
- 11:54approach, a discounted cash flow or DCF analysis focusing on free
- 11:58cash flow, what Buffett might call owners earnings.
- 12:01And using conservative assumptions I assume.
- 12:03Yes, very much so. We used a discount rate of 10%
- 12:07to 15% reflecting the risk apply to margin of safety maybe 30% to
- 12:1150% and assumed pretty low terminal growth rates long term.
- 12:15Try not to get carried away by hype.
- 12:16OK, so walk us through a conservative scenario if things
- 12:20don't grow much from here. All right.
- 12:21Let's say free cash flow just stays flat 0 growth the next
- 12:24five years, then maybe grows at just 2% indefinitely after that,
- 12:28basically inflation. Using those assumptions, our DCF
- 12:31model spits out an intrinsic value of roughly $11.80 per
- 12:34share. 1180. Now if you apply a 30% margin of
- 12:38safety to that, you'd be looking for a buy price around $8.30.
- 12:41$8.30 compared to a market price of $185.
- 12:46Exactly. It's, well, it's a massive
- 12:47disconnect. The market price is over 15
- 12:49times higher than even that conservative intrinsic value
- 12:51estimate. Wow.
- 12:53OK, that's dark. What if we're much more
- 12:54optimistic? Assume they execute really well,
- 12:56capture a lot of growth? Let's try that.
- 12:58Let's assume free cash flow grows at a really strong clip,
- 13:01say 30% per year for the next 5 years.
- 13:03That's aggressive growth. Then maybe it slows down to 5%
- 13:06for the five years after that and then settles into 2.5%
- 13:09terminal growth. Still pretty optimistic
- 13:10assumptions. Very optimistic.
- 13:12Yes. Even with those assumptions, the
- 13:14calculated intrinsic value comes out to around $43.70 per share.
- 13:184370, right? Apply the 30% margin of safety
- 13:21again and you're looking at a potential buy price near $30.00.
- 13:25So even being quite bullish on growth, the current market price
- 13:29of $185 is still more than four times higher than our optimistic
- 13:32intrinsic value. So what does that imply about
- 13:34what the market is thinking to justify 185 dollars?
- 13:37It implies the market is pricing and truly extraordinary
- 13:39sustained growth for a very long time.
- 13:42Or perhaps more realistically, our analysis suggests that to
- 13:45get to $185 today, investors are implicitly accepting a very low
- 13:50expected annual return going forward, maybe somewhere in the
- 13:53range of only 5% to 8% per year. Which sounds low for a crypto
- 13:57related stock with all the risks we discussed.
- 14:00It seems quite low, yes, Especially given the regulatory
- 14:03uncertainty, the competitive threats, the interest rate
- 14:06sensitivity, you typically expect a higher potential return
- 14:09to compensate for taking on those kinds of risks.
- 14:12So wrapping this all up, what's the bottom line here, circle the
- 14:15company versus circle the stock? Yeah.
- 14:17That's the key distinction, isn't it?
- 14:19From everything we've looked at Circle, the company appears
- 14:21pretty solid. It's high growth, it's becoming
- 14:23profitable. It has a strong balance sheet
- 14:25post IPO, strong management team that seems focused on compliance
- 14:30and transparency. They're positioning themselves
- 14:33well as a leader in the regulated, stable coin space.
- 14:35Circle the stock. Circle, the stock seems priced
- 14:38for perfection and then some. The current valuation you
- 14:41mentioned a PE ratio over 600 based on trailing earnings.
- 14:44Those kinds of multiples reflect a level of market exuberance
- 14:47that's really hard to justify with traditional valuation
- 14:50metrics, even optimistic ones. It really highlights that
- 14:53crucial difference, doesn't it? A great company isn't always a
- 14:56great stock, especially at any price, particularly in a fast
- 15:00moving, still developing area like stablecoins.
- 15:02Absolutely. Which leads to the final thought
- 15:04for you, the listener, to chew on circles.
- 15:07Doing a lot right operationally, strategically navigating
- 15:10regulation. Is the markets incredibly high
- 15:12valuation, just getting ahead of the curve, betting on an
- 15:15inevitable future? Or is it truly a sign of, well,
- 15:19irrational exuberance? And maybe more personally, what
- 15:22specific milestones or changes would you need to see to feel
- 15:25comfortable if there's enough margin of safety to consider
- 15:28investing in circle? Definitely something to think
- 15:30about and just a reminder to everyone listening.
- 15:32All the analysis we share today is based on publicly available
- 15:35sources as of our recording date.
- 15:37Things can change and interpretations can differ.
- 15:39That's right, and this is purely for educational purposes.
- 15:42It is absolutely not investment advice.
- 15:44Please always do your own thorough research and due
- 15:46diligence before making any investment decisions.
- 15:49Couldn't agree more. Thanks for joining us on the
- 15:52Deep Dive. If you found this helpful,
- 15:54please like subscribe, follow us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or
- 15:58our YouTube channel. Deep value investing.
- 16:00And don't forget to check the episode description for a
- 16:03curated book list on value investing.
- 16:06If you'd like to support the channel and our project to
- 16:08develop a Buffett Indicator app, there's also a Go Fund Me link
- 16:11in the description. Thanks again for tuning in.