Latest / Calibrated Taste / Kaley Mullin: Cool Shiny Insights
Transcript
- speaker-0: I'm Kayleigh Mullen. I'm the co-founder of Cool Shiny Insights. I'm a sociologist and market researcher. speaker-1: First of all, just wanted to talk a little bit about about Cool Shiny. I love what you're doing. I love your newsletter because it is about culture and it's all the things that you've done professionally. First question What are some things that you feel like have been dead on in your calls when you're like, Hey guys, pay attention to these things? speaker-0: I love this question because I do love predicting things. I know that it's a bit of a divisive stakesy topic in terms of trend prediction and trend forecasting, but I think it's fun and I don't know, I think the stakes are pretty low. But so I think like one of my favorite calls ever was pickleball becoming big. You know, our old friend at YouTube looked at pickleball when I told him that and there was only about like ten hundred or ten thousand uploads of of pickleball content that year. And he's like, no, I'm not sure. She's right. And then it exploded into mainstream culture. So that was a good one. I also saw Chapel Roan at Coachella and was like, she's going to be gigantic. So I think I'm pretty good at like buying stock in different people before they blow up in culture. speaker-1: Love that. I love that you're just like the stock picker of culture. That's that's amazing. speaker-0: Yeah, but without the toxic mm wall food style. speaker-1: Yeah, exactly. Without without ruining lives. You get to pick what's cool, which is fun, more fun. I'm speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: actually curious, let's dig in with pickleball. What is it about those early signals that you were like? Those are those are it. Come on. speaker-0: yeah, I think with Chapel Brown it was there's just a Genese qua X factor that was undeniable to me. that, you know, it's like probably anyone that was paying attention could could say that she was going to be successful. But I think that partly you have to be paying attention. And I do dedicate myself to paying attention and to going to places where they have emergent artists and emergent culture and and you know finding those people earlier. Pickleball, I think it it was also about listening to signals from various places. So the first time anyone told me about pickleball was my hairstylist in LA. and it's like she's like, my girlfriend just asked me if I wanted to go play pickleball. And I was like, what what are what the hell is that? And and so I I think one of the important things about cool site cool shiny insights is that we we don't just do like social media listening. We do like listening, cultural listening across all different areas of culture and all different inputs. So including real life conversations that we're having with our friends and family and, you know, podcasts and in books and social media, of course, but more than that too. Yeah. speaker-1: I am very curious though, because you worked at YouTube with me. It was beautiful golden time. And I love talking to you because you you do to your point, you have to listen. How does someone become a better note listener? How does someone who says, Hey, what Kaylee does is so cool. I want to do what she does. Over the course of your career, how did you evolve? How did you continue to tune your ear for these moments? speaker-0: Yeah, I think there's maybe two different questions. One is what would I tell other people? And then a self-reflection. So let's take the what would I tell other people? I think a lot of people if they're at a period maybe motherhood, or if they're in a period like college, or I don't know, just a period where they have lost touch with culture, that it's like a, steaming freight train that it's really hard to get back on or to get on if you never have been on before. And so I think partly I just encourage people to not let that intimidation factor get in the way from consuming more culture. And then I think like it is about consumption. And I think there's obviously a lot of discourse about overconsumption and the health of that. And I think there are risks to that for sure for cultural strategists. But I don't think I could do this work if I wasn't naturally kind of a voracious, nervous consumer of everything all the time. And like very curious about people, very very oriented to novelty. I just want to know about new things and learn about new things and see what people are passionate about and things like that. So I think telling people you gotta consume more, you gotta be on these platforms. You have to treat it like a hobby before it becomes a job, I think. And then I think the next thing is like lear it's it's pattern recognition. A lot of it is pattern recognition and triangulation. And I think learning to be a pattern recognizer and and then also question those patterns and say is that just an algorithmic thing? Is that just blue car theory, which is like if you notice a blue car, then you're seeing blue cars everywhere. It is like ultimately pattern recognition and then you triangulate to figure out is this real? Is this big? Is this breaking containment across different audiences? Things like that. So that's what I would tell people if they're interested in this work. I have a traditional market research background too, which I think is incredibly useful because a lot of qualitative and quantitative research being like focus groups and interviews and surveys. It is about devising tools to ask people questions about themselves. And I think that like that that toolkit is really important for this kind of work too. So okay, so that's what I would tell other people. When I think about my own taste and judgment, I actually think that I've had a very solid core that has been pretty unchanging and If I was not doing this for paid, I would be doing this for free. I think about back in freshman year of high sch of college in the dorm rooms, I used to flip through the printed TV guide. This is me being old, and like look at the content, the TV shows that I wanted all my other friends in the dorm rooms to watch. And I printed that out and pasted it onto the back of a remote control. And now my job is to curate a cultural calendar of cultural moments. And it's like I've just been doing this work for free for so long because I'm like an evangelist. I am like a cultural maven that wants to get other people to like what I like. That is my secret that's my secret driving, motivation is that I really, really like things and I want other people to really, really like them too. I think that has been very s core to my like identity. So I I do feel like I've just fallen into a a really fitting line of work. speaker-1: Yeah. And I think for anybody who is listening, they definitely need to subscribe to Cool Shiny Insights because I love your newsletter for that. This is your new TV guide, you know, on the back. It's and I think the thing too is that because you do micro research for a lot of businesses and brands, you know, to understand their audience. I love the advice you give to others and then the ways that you reflect on yourself. You talk about triangulation. How does someone get better at triangulation? You have a core to what you like. So how do you honestly break out that may not be in your core and help understand something, another audience, another bubble, right? Because a lot of things do feel very fragmented. So how what's to you, as you parse through all this stuff, how do you find that little gem, right? Among all the noise and signals. speaker-0: Yeah, I think part of it is like what hat am I wearing? If I'm wearing my cool shiny culture substack hat, which is very much like this is a free thing for my friends and family and people that like culture, I can put a lot of my personal taste into it. And that is where I'm like, I want people to watch Widows Bay because I'm watching Widows Bay. If I'm doing this work like for a brand, I think that is where I try to put my personal taste a little bit to the side, I will still I will still, bring along the the strong instincts I have for where people are passionate about things and what that might be signaling, but my own personal taste might need to go to the side. But in terms of building a practice of triangulation, this is where a lot of different data inputs are really valuable. I personally really quantitative data as a like grounding checkpoint. Of this might not tell me something new, but it it's often very validating to see the top 100 YouTubers or TV shows or musicians. And again, that's not maybe gonna tell me where culture is headed, but it's a helpful just anchor point. See, and then I think for the work that I do and that Megan, my co-founder and I are more interested in, we are trying to look at the more emerging signals, and those tend to be less quantitatively backed up and more small different pockets of subcultures and like the more interesting edges of culture talking about things. And we often will keep an eye on something and see if it's breaking containment. So is it breaking containment from the small niche audience that started talking about it? Is it breaking containment from TikTok to see are you seeing it on threads and X and Reddit and everywhere? So that's like an important signal for us. Yeah, I would say those are a few of the ways that I triangulate. speaker-1: Love that. I okay. So I have a rather big question for you. And I don't and this is this is very existential. I find it fascinating because as we we talked about, right? You have the quantitative, the qualitative, you have your conversations that you're having in real life, you know, and that's it all tells you something. Have you been able to see a pattern of what breaks containment? Why do you think sometimes within a small bubble, for example, you know, doing Due diligence on you. You did a master's thesis, right, on women's role of dirty derby and subculture. What about certain subcultures and things breakthrough? Do you do you feel like there's something that has that jeunesse qua that you say? What what do you think that could be? speaker-0: Yeah, I think one of the things that I look for is real authentic passion for things. Because I don't think that a lot of things become mainstream dominant trends if they don't actually have like a core fan base. And that doesn't have to be like a fan army like Taylor Swift, but like just people that like it and recommend it and buy it over and over again, or like just are general fans of it. I think that is definitely something I look for, look for a strong passion. But I also do try to just accept that some of the things that I'm looking at are going to the fringe and niche forever. women's roller derby has not broken into the mainstream. But I think there were aspects of that subculture that have become like less culturally emergent and have become more culturally dominant. Like I think that back when I was doing this fifteen years ago or whatever, they had a very like cutting edge presentation of modern femininity that I think is pretty much now mainstream femininity, where they had a very fluid way to move through traditional feminine things and very traditional masculine things. And the the title of it was neither butch nor Barbie. And it was like there was just a real comfort and fluidity with not like code switching between femininity, but just speaker-1: Just speaker-0: being doing that. flow. Yeah. And I think I think that I've seen like mainstream feminist culture kind of move f in in that direction too. So so yeah, it's like that subculture didn't necessarily break through, but there's things about that that have become culturally dominant over time. And, you know, that took a long time. Like again, it's been 15 years. And I don't know that I think that's not even fully true for a lot of people, but I see, you know, a lot of like more of the trends setting women that I look at at being able to flow through the gender presentation in a in a more cool, fluid way. speaker-1: In terms of brands, companies, and we worked at YouTube, right? There's social media happening all the time. And I'm sure brands are coming to you to be like, Kaylee, tell us, what should we do? What do you think brands get wrong about trends? Because all the brands are like, we don't chase trends. We make trends. Is that even possible for brands to do that? speaker-0: I do think it's I think it's dismissive to say we don't chase trends. I would say a lot of brands are not chasing trends or making trends. They're just putting out products and not even trying. Part of the cool shiny founding ethos is and why we are called cool shiny is because we are trying to push back against people dismissing trends and like new things, especially when they come from underrepresented voices or women especially as frivolous and unimportant. And the cool shiny thing is a derogatory, dismissed thing. And we want to say, no, there's actually value in looking at trends. There is value in understanding every trend, even if it's not something that your brand ultimately executes on. So I think understanding trends and having like a cultural insights practice is different than chasing trends. I think Chasing trends is trying to do a reactive post on social for every trending discourse that happens. That would obviously not be the right strategy. But having a cultural insights practice where you are talking about trends, you're tracking and unpacking trends, I think is valuable. I don't really see the downside of that. I think there there are some brands, I don't know, maybe in the fashion space that are just purely cool or music, maybe. But for most brands in most spaces, you're not going to be able to create cultural trends unless you understand culture and where you are on the cultural curve and how culture is flowing and your position with your audience and and all of those things. So yeah, I think I kind of do push back to the sentiment of like, we're not chasing trends. Part of me is like, Well, then you're just not listening a little bit. But that's an oversimplification, of course. speaker-1: Yes, I love the oversimplification because it's true, right? It's if you're not it's not about chasing, it's about listening, right? That's the that's the end goal. The whole even idea of cool and how cool, shiny, can be dismissive. okay, it's just a cool, shiny thing. And it's important to understand as a brand, right? How you're perceived. But in terms of cool, that can feel very loaded too, right? It's this is cool. This is edgy. And then on the other spectrum, it's cringe. So what's your take on that? How what if someone's I just want to be more cool. You said you have your own subjective taste. What makes something cool, something cringe, right? Yeah. What what have you anthropologically have seen, right? speaker-0: Well, I would say that there's not a wide chasm between cool and cringe. It's actually a very thin dividing line and a lot of cool people had to be cringe for a long time before they became cool. And I think speaker-1: Hopefully I have hope, Kaylee. speaker-0: You still have a chance. We still have a chance. speaker-1: I have a shot. speaker-0: I think I think that that is partly why I'm drawn to subcultures. I like weirdos that are really passionate about things. And that is cool to me. Cool isn't one thing to one person, but it is a a vibe and a like a orientation, like a positioning. Like it's a, it's a confidence to being cool, I think, and a self-assuredness. And I think that is like what we want to help brands do is like get to a posture where they're like, What we're doing is cool. What we're putting out into the world is cool. And that doesn't necessarily mean the most popular thing. Popular and cool can be very, very different, but cool is also it when you see it. it feels it feels cool and it feels like something that you want to be close to. So that's what we try to help brands do. speaker-1: I okay, I'm really curious then what is popular but not cool? speaker-0: My God, so many things. speaker-1: Just a few off the top. speaker-0: okay, what is popular but not cool? I would say I don't know, Kevin Hart, a lot of the people that you see, I think culture, prediction markets, I think a lot of hugely dominant culture does lose its coolness often because it's, diluted for the masses and less novel. And I think there is a component of novelty to to coolness. Popular but not cool. speaker-1: Do you feel like also that there's some things that people think are cool, right? And then become popular and you're like, I don't get it. why did that become why do people think it's cool? How did that get popular? speaker-0: The first thing that comes to mind that I've debated with people a lot is Tate McCrae. She's someone that I was just like people were going, gagging for and I was like, I I'm just not seeing it yet. She doesn't have that Janessa qua for me. But then I loved the song Sports Car. So, I do adapt eventually, but I'm also really looking for those almost generational talents. coming after Chapel Tate McCrae was not it for me. I don't really get the Love Island fruit AI thing. Bananja Yeah, but but I think the thing that we try to do is always understand we basically try to humanize trends and what do real people like about the thing. So instead of being like unpacking what is happening in those Love Island AI things, like it is more just why do people tune into and like what is that giving to them and what does that mean about where we're at in culture and things like that. The other thing that I would say that my own personal taste has changed on is K pop and reggaeton and global music. I think that I did have a maybe a slightly more narrow minded approach to non English language music because I was like, I like to know what I'm listening to and the lyrics. And so I'm really happy that my taste has broadened and that, you know, now it's been expanded to more like global music, even if I don't understand all the lyrics. speaker-1: I love that. And I on that same note then you broadened your taste, right? And it it does change over decades. What do you how would you recommend people broaden their taste? is it just exposure? How would you recommend someone else approach it? I speaker-0: I think it is just taking a more open minded, expansive consumption approach. So just dabble in it. you don't have to go to a concert or buy, you know, a full wardrobe of something. Like just dabble in it and broaden your horizons and continually try to seek out novelty. I think like novelty is really good for the brain. Yes. And good for staying youthful. And I think that like it's important to continually I don't know, change with the times and evolve and and yeah, just like try new things. So I think that is something that I really obviously encourage people to do all the time. speaker-1: Oftentimes as youth, Gen Z. Now, as a parent of a Gen Alpha, a lot of us are like, What what is happening? What are some of the things that you're seeing with Gen Z, with Gen Alpha? What are some of your early predictions? Tell tell some of the millennial cringe parents what we should do with Gen Alpha. speaker-0: All right, well, let me take Gen Z first. I think the the first thing to know is just that they are older. They're almost entering 30 at the oldest now. So I think our cultural awareness of them still tends to be that they're quite young. But I think it is a very broad age group and a lot of different life stages covered there from going to prom, graduating, going to college or not going to college, going to trade schools. Maybe being unemployed and being still at home, maybe buying a new house and getting married and having kids, there are a lot of Gen Z parents now. So I think that a lot of what we talk about with generational research is not thinking about the cohort in its entirety and thinking about life stages. And I think partly what we often recommend to brands is to focus on a life stage because even as your generational cohort that's in that life stage now gets older, it's it's important to focus on one different band. And and I think often life stage matters a lot more than generation. That said, there are generational cultural shifts. And I think that one of the ones that's very apparent to me for Gen Alpha is how much technology and they are consuming and how much gamified stuff they are consuming. From everything that I see with Gen Alpha is gamified and is through the lens of games. And so We're just putting out a piece next week about GTA Six, Grand Theft Auto Six coming soon, and how that will probably spark some new cultural artifacts and new cultural trends and things. And I think every big new game it does that. And games are partly where culture is now like mediated and like gen alpha is like getting introduced to culture. So this this summer, my niece and nephew were playing Fortnite and they were like, reskinning their avatar and into the Punisher from Spider-Man, which which they'd just seen in in theaters. And then they were like doing the emote of Zara Larson's Midnight Sun on the Punisher. And all of this culture was like coming together for them and exposed to that culture. And they were experiencing that culture through the game. And so I think that is like just will become increasingly more true for Gen Alpha. And they are spending like more time in digital worlds and getting a lot of value from these metaverse light experiences. speaker-1: Mm, which is like a sandbox and and play and all of those things. That's so interesting. For people who are artists and creators and those who are making, what would you say to them? There's this tension point, right? Of people who are in the creative arts, their own perspective. But then really, I really want to hone in on the word cultural artifact. What about a person who's I want to just impact culture? What would you say to them in all your years of research? What works, what doesn't? Or would you say it doesn't matter? Just do it. speaker-0: I think it depends what your goal is. it's not important for every brand to be cool cool, like I said. It's maybe not important for every creative to be cool. I think a lot of creatives are cool because they are doing their own niche thing and maybe the cultural currents swim their way and make them into more of a mainstream thing. So I think that is valuable important. If your goal is to Breakthrough. I think Zara Larson has a really interesting case study of that because she basically saw on TikTok that her old song was turned into a meme. She changed her entire aesthetic to relate to that meme and then built this internet lore with these followings and her fandom on TikTok. And and then she did this choreography to this song and then just repeated that. over and over every single day on TikTok until it became a meme. And then people went to her concerts and filmed them doing that. And kids learned that dance and Fortnite brought it into the game. And that was very in tune culturally because she understood that it takes a lot of repetition, a lot of devotion and also like being in tune to what is culturally happening for her as a brand. in that time where it was, this song is popping off and it's a meme and people are really drawn to these Lisa Frank colors. Maybe I should lean into that. So I think being culturally aware and flexible and sometimes leaning in can be a way to curate like cultural relevance if that's what you want as a creative person. Yeah. speaker-1: I love that. Okay. I could talk I feel like I could talk to you for five hours because there's so many things I could do. But I do want to end it with. Since we started with the predictions that you hit. speaker-0: Mm-hmm. speaker-1: What are the other predictions? What are some things that you're like people are not talking about this enough? speaker-0: think the internet is is good at finding the other people that are talking about that thing. So speaker-1: What do you personally want to evangelize then? Is there any show or book or thing you're like, I if you could pick a few things off of Kaylee's taste, give us the TV guide of the evangelist Kaylee's content. What would you say? You you mentioned Widows Bay as one, which I heard a lot of great things about. Anything about speaker-0: Which has been totally validated by one million Emmys going their way. So, you know, that's not really even a cutting edge thing to say anymore. I actually am really liking a lot of Apple TV these days, and that's a departure from where I've been in the last like few years. so we're watching Slow Horses and we loved Widows Bay. and then the other thing that I've been really into, like in the last two weeks, has been The New York Times list of hundred best TV shows and just going back and talking about those. And I love the debate of that and picking my favorite shows and thinking about like why I so deeply loved Flea Bag and things like that. The other area of culture that I'm like just always into is romance and romance novels. And I feel like culture is into that right now. So it's been very validating and very fun. And I think like seeing culture be so excited about heated rivalry and off campus and now the most recently the Love Hypothesis movie on Amazon has been really delightful. I haven't had a super strong hyperfixation for a minute. Sadly, I was thinking about this last night where I was like, what have I been really, really into? And sometimes there are just periods where it's like, I'm looking for my next hyperfixation. speaker-1: Can't wait. speaker-0: Yeah. But I think one of the things that I've been really into lately, which feels maybe feels niche, but I don't know. It might be in tune with culture as well, in that I think people are looking to touch grass a bit more. I've been l listening to a lot of plant and animal bestiaries and zoological encyclopedias and like I I'm reading this book called The Light Eaters right now about like plant intelligence. And I don't know, I think that that's not like probably going to ever become a mainstream thing, but I'm pretty into that right now and I'm kind of rethinking my relationship to the natural world. And I think that a lot of people are starting I mean, are doing that because of AI and, you know, general things, speaker-1: Thanks speaker-0: climate change and hellscape dystopia that we're living in. I just speaker-1: Love the idea of light eater. What a delicious way to describe plants, you know. speaker-0: I know. It's so badass. It's fascinating. It's fascinating. And I was reading this other book called Vanishing Treasures, all about different animals that are going extinct. Incredibly fascinating. This guy's voice that is narrating it is so beautiful and lovely. I'm falling asleep to it every single night. So yeah, that's something I've been a little hyper fixated on. I just keep replaying this one book over and over and I'm learning a lot about Greenland sharks and narwhals and wombats. speaker-1: I'm gonna hyperfixate on this too. Kaylee, I gotta do a part two or part three with you. This just you know, but thank you again for sharing your cultural knowledge. So thank you. speaker-0: Thanks so much. This has been really fun. Yay.